Pertamina vs Karaha Bodas (HPI)

$%&$&$ !#%'$#$!

%:,83/-:,9:39:20203:42543033,9:,85,/,2,9,:,::2 !07/,9,39073,843,

8:8:30 04254 $498:3/,,!:97 $,8,,:#,3 :,3,

4803 :,2,/27:4$

&%$&& &'#$%$!# & 

 !&& ,9,70,,3

::2!07/,9,39073,843,,/,,9072,8:/,,204254::257;,9,703, 203,3:9 ::2 57;,9 2,, ::2 !07/,9, 39073,843, 90780-:9 :, 203,9:7 :-:3,3::2,39,75,/,,28:,9:4397,,392-:/,7::2507,9,3::2 !07/,9,39073,843,202503079,3,30-:,8/,7800/,7:78/8/,,28:,9: 30,7, 03:7:9 $:/,74 ,:9,2, ::2 !07/,9, 39073,843, ,/,, ::2 507/,9, :39: :-:3,3:-:3,3 39073,843, &38:7 39073,843,3, ,/,, :-:3,3 :-:3,33,80/,3,3,/,,/,3,,/,,::2507/,9,3,843,::24397, 80-,,-,,3/,7::2507/,9,202-0-07,5,,8,8,3-0781,9:3;078,805079 ,8,80-0-,8,3-074397,4397,203,980-,,:3/,3:3/,3-,5,7,5,,3 202-:,93, 8079, ,8,8 805,,9 !,7, 5, ,3 907-,9 /,,2 4397, ,9,: 507,3,3 /2,3,8,3/507,3,3200,9-,9,88,9:30,7,/,,2,92-:8:,9:80309, 507:20309,5,39070-/,::.,7,.,7,:39:203008,,380309,90780-:9$,, 8,9::5,,:39:203008,,380309,,/,,/03,3,7-97,80 03:7:9 &3/,3&3/,3 4247  9,:3  9039,3 ,7-97,80 /,3 ,9073,91 503008,,380309,:2:2 ,3/2,8:/ /03,3,7-97,80 ,/,,.,7, 503008,,3 8:,9:80309,507/,9,/:,7507,/,3:2:2,3//,8,7,35,/,507,3,3,7-97,80 ,3 /-:,9 80.,7, 9079:8405,7, 5, ,3-0780309, /,5:3 507,3,3,7-97,80 /,79,380-,,8:,9:0805,,9,3-07:5,,:8:,7-97,80,3907.,39:2/,,28:,9: 507,3,3 9079:8 ,3 /-:,9 5,7, 5, 80-0:2 92-: 80309, ,9,: 8:,9: 507,3,3 ,7-97,80907803/7,3/-:,95,7,5,8090,92-:80309,0805,,9,3,9,:,9:7,3 2,3 ,3 507: /805,,9 /,,2 ,7-97,80 90780-:9 ,/,, 203,3:9 5,3 ::2 .4.041, 5,3147:2.4.041147:2/,35,3/428.4.041/42.0  ,2:3 80,5:3 90, ,/, 50305,,9,3 ,9,8 .,7,.,7, 503008,,3 80309, 90780-:9/,,22502039,83,9/,,2:/,,8,,,32:3.:907:9,2,/,75, ,39/,203072,,8,7-97,80,39,7,,3,/,,203,3:9425090385,7,5, 42509038503,/,357480/:7-07,.,7,2,907 ,3/50780309,,3 8,25, 05,/, /,,080:8/,75:9:8,3,7-97,8090780-:9

0,703,9:,2,,3202-,,820303,,8:8!079,23,20,,3,7,, 4/,8 425,3 ,3 203,7 :39: /-,,8 ,703, ,8:8 3 203,7 :39: /,3,9 80,3,/,3,507,,3,3/,75,,3/,,,340!03,/,3,7-97,80:,,703, 92-:3, ,8:8 90780-:9 9/, 90705,8 /,7 0-,,3 ,3 /,2- 40 !020739, 3/4308, ,3 80-03,73, -:,3 207:5,,3 5, /,,2 507,3,3 909,5 /,25, 0-,,390780-:9202503,7:02,25:,350203:,384397,

 $&$!#%;8#$! ,8:8!488 O

!,,3-0780309,,/,,!079,23,/03,3,7,,4/,8425,3

O

!0780309,,3 ,3 907,/ ,/,, 20303, 507,3,3 80:-:3,3 /03,3 502:9:8,34397,,9,8507,3,30/:,-0,5,

O

$0309, ,39,7, !079,23, 20,,3 ,7,, 4/,8 47547,943  -072:, /03,3/9,3/,9,3,33,507,3,3439507,9434397,.95,/,9,3, 4;02-07  !,/, 9,3, ,3 8,2, !%!07:8,,,3 897 0,7,!/ 8,9: 5, /,3 !079,23, 8079,  5,/, 5, ,3 203,3/,9,3,3 507,3,3 307$:554397,.9$

O

!0780309,,3 3 907,/ /,703,,3 /,,2 507,,3,3 9073,9, 5740 0897,3 /039,3 /,3 /9,3:,3 40 !020739, -07/,8,7,3 05:9:8,3 !708/03 4 9,:3  9079,3,  $05902-07  /,3 2030-,-,3 ,/,, 07,8,2,!079,23,/03,39/,/,5,9/,3:9,3

O

5,/,9,3,57202,8:,3:,9,3,397:07-97,80030, 808:, /03,3 9025,9 503008,,3 80309, ,3 /5 40 5,7, 5, /,,2  !,/, 9,3,  0802-07  7-97,80 030, 202-:,9 5:9:8,3 ,,7 !079,23, /,3 ! 202-,,7 ,39 7: 05,/,  :7,3 0- 80-08,7 &$  9,8 5:9:8,3 ,7-97,80 030, !079,23, 9/, -0780/, 80.,7, 8:,70,20,8,3,,33,

O

!079,23, 20,:,3 :5,, ::2 /03,3 20239, 503,/,3 / $88 :39: 202-,9,,3 5:9:8,3 ,7-97,80 ,3, 8,, :5,, 3 9/, /,3:9,3 /8288 ,703, 9/, /-,,73, :,3 /05489 80-,,2,3, /5078,7,9,3 40 $88 0/07,$:570204:79

O

$02039,7, 9:  90, 20,:,3 :5,, ::2 -07:5, 5072443,3 :39: 50,8,3,,3 !:9:8,3 7-97,80 030, / 503,/,3 -0-07,5, 30,7, / 2,3, ,8809/,3-,7,3!079,23,-07,/,0.:,/3/4308,!,/,9,3,!0-7:,7 203,:,35072443,35,/,&$897.94:7914790$4:9073897.9

41 %0,8 :39: 20,8,3,,3 !:9:8,3 7-97,80 030, ,:  203,:,3 5072443,3,38,2,5,/,503,/,3$3,5:7,/,34343 O

!079,23,20,:,3 :5,,::2-07:5, 5034,,350,8,3,,3 /503,/,3 503,/,3,3/239,40:39:20,:,3080:8!079,23,20,3:9,3 :5,,::2502-,9,,35:9:8,3,7-97,80030,/503,/,33/4308,!,/, 9,3,  ,709  !079,23, 80.,7, 7082 203,:,3 :,9,3 502-,9,,3 !:9:8,37-97,80030,05,/,!,,79,!:8,9:,9,3502-,9,,390780-:9 //,8,7,3 5,/, 09039:,3 5,8,  && 4  9,:3  9039,3 8,7,98,7,9 502-,9,,35:9:8,37-97,8039073,843,,3-07-:3!072443,3502-,9,,3 ,3, /,5,9 /,:,3 907,/,5 5:9:8,3 ,7-97,80 ,3 8:/, //,19,7,3 / 503,/,3

O

,8,3,,8,3 5072443,3 502-,9,,3 ,3 /80-:9 /,,2 5,8, 3 ,7:8 /-:9,3 /03,3 5:9:8,3 503,/,3 5,-, 503,/,3 203,9,,3 -,, ,,8,3,,8,390780-:9907-:9,9,:9/,907-:92,,5:9:8,3503,/,33/,5,9 /:3,,380-,,/,8,750792-,3,3-,,2:39:203,-:,3,9,:2034, 5072443,3

O

,,25:9:8,33,34247!9!899,3,$05902-07503,/,3 007

,,79,

!:8,9

,73,

203,-:,3

:,9,3

!079,23,

/03,3

202-,9,,35:9:8,3,7-97,8039073,843,&%#/030,$88 O

/,5:3-0-07,5,,,8,33,,39,7,,3503,3,9,3,7-9079/,/,:,3805079 ,390,/507,3,3/,39/,/,3,9,7-907,390,/003/,405,7, 5, -07/,8,7,3 507,3,3 802039,7, !079,23, 9/, /-07,3 574507 349.0 20303, ,7-97,80 3 /,3 9/, /-07 08025,9,3 :39: 202-0, /7 ,08 ,7-97,8090,8,,203,187,3147.02,0:70803,20893,!079,23,9/, /,5,9 /239,,3 5079,3:3,,- ,9,8 808:,9: ,3 / :,7 02,25:,33,  8,2539:,087-97,80/,3,590,20,25,:003,33,,703,9/, 203:3,,3 ::2 3/4308, 5,/, , ::2 3/4308, ,/,, ,3 ,7:8 /5,,203:7:90805,,9,35,7, 5,,08,7-97,80,3, 203:3,,3,9 3:7,33,803/7-07/,8,7,350792-,3,30,06:0409-434

3,88  47:2,3-0703,3

47:2 ,3 -0703,3 ,/,, ,7-97,80 030, /,703,,3 0/:, -0, 5, 90, -07805,,9 :39: 203008,,3 80309, 0/:, -0, 5, / 7-97,80 030, -07/,8,7,3507,3,3439507,9434397,.9  !,9,:-:,3

$:,9: ,8:8 ,,3 203,/ ,8:8 ! ,5,-, ,/, 0907-,9,3 :38:7 ,83 14703 0020398 //,,23,,,:5:3 0. !5,/, 573853, ,3,80-,, ,/, 503:3:

,9:-07,9,3/03,3,/,2,3,,3,,3-07,:/,,28:,9:,8:8 .4.041, /,3  :, 503,/,3 2,3, ,3 -07, :39: 203,/ .4.0 41 147:2 ,/ ! 203,,- .4.041, /,3.4.041147:2 

&38:7:38:7,8390780-:9/,39,7,3, $:-0 %025,9507-:,9,3/,:,3 03/07,,5, .4.041,/,,24397,/ ,/ ,8:8 3 207:5,,3 ! /,703,,3 907,3/:3 .4.0 41 ,  /2,3, 503008,,380309,808:,507,3,3/8008,,3/7-97,80030,  ,81,8

,8:839072,8:/,,2,81,8::24397,507,3,380-,-907,/3,,8:8 3/,703,,3502:9:8,34397,80.,7,805,40!079,23,,9,8507,3,3507,3,3 439 507,943 4397,.9  /03,3 5, ,7,, 4/,8 425,3 5,/, 9,3,  4;02-07  ::2,3/:3,,3

:,1,8 ,/,, 503443,3 50789, ,9,: :-:3,3 ::2 0 /,,2 ,/,,/,!/,3::22,907,.,22,.,2:,1,8 O

:,1,8203:7:90147 ,9::,1,8,3//,8,7,35,/,::22,907,,2

O

:,1,8203:7:90.,:80

,9::,1,8,3/,:,3808:,/03,388902/,3,9:7,3,9:7,3808:, 88902 ::2,3-078,3:9,3 O

:,1,880.,7,494342 ,9::,1,8,3//,8,7,35,/,8:,9:507-,3/3,3::2

O

:,1,880.,7,-079,,5 ,9::,1,8,3/,:,320,:-0-07,5,93,9,3,9: O

":,1.,94307890737,/08-07/,8,7,30147

O

":,1.,943099037,/08-07/,8,7,30.,:80

,/ ::2,3/:3,,3,/,,::2$88,703,50,8,3,,3,9,: 147:2,3-0703,3,/,,,7-97,80030,,2:380,7:83,50780309,,3 3/,8,3,,3/03,3203:3,,3::23,843,,9,:::23/4308,,703, ,/,3, :38:7 /428 /,7 0/:, -0, 5, 02507,9,3 9::,3 ! ,3 /93,: /,7 ,9,7 -0,,3 050393,3 ! ,9: 0,/,3 09079-,3 05,89,3 ::2 /,3 0,3.,7,3 507,:,3 39073,843, 07/,8,7,3 , 90780-:9 2,, ,8:839072,8:/,,2:,1,80147 ,703,//,8,7,3 5,/,::22,907, ,2  ,,2,3,,0.,:80203,9:7,90780-:9-,,2,3,,50,8,3,,3, 90780-:9

03039:,3::2,3-07,:0 .,:80-,4397,205:9 !,3::24.041, ::2,3-07,:203:7:904..4397,.9:8 ::2,3-07,:203:7:904.84:9438 ::2,3-07,:203:7:990574507,4190.4397,.9 %02489.,7,.90789..4330.943 07/,8,7,3 0 .,:80 /,,2 ,8:8 3 ,/,, .4.0 41 , ,703, 503,7: /,75,/,/9072,3,80.,7,:2:2-,,-039:1472,/,74397,

 !&%&! 0825:,3

!03/,5,9$:/,74,:9,2,,3202,3/,34397,39073,843,80-,,-,,3 /,7 88902 4397, 3,843, 90, /,: 80-,, /4973 ,,2 4397,4397, -07/203839073,843, 503039:,3 5,3 ::2 .4.0 41 ,  ,/,, 8,3,9 50393 :39:2033/,7,3907,/3,.431.941, 2033,95,7,5,,3907-,99025,9 97,38,8/,388902::2,3907,9-07-0/,-0/,/,3-,,32:33-079039,3,3 ,9,: -070-,,3 ,39,7 8,9: :78/8 ::2 /03,3 :78/8 ::2 ,33, ,,3 80,5:3.4.041,90,/909,5,3/,,28:,9:4397,,9,:507,3,3::2507/,9, 39073,843, 909,5 2038,,3 50784,,350784,,3 203/,8,7 /,,2 574.00/38 8:,9: 507,7, , 3 -07,,7 /,7 507-0/,,3 :,1,8 ,39,7, -07-,, 88902 ::2 507/,9, 39073,843,//:3, ,8:8 3 207:5,,3 50780309,,3 ,39,7, !079,23, /03,3 ,7,, 4/,8 425,3,3/2,3,50780309,,33207:5,,350780309,,34397,,703, ,/,3,502:9:8,34397,80.,7,805,808:,507,3,3147:2,3-0703,3,/,,  7-97,80030,,8:83202:38:7,83/2,3,503008,,380309,3,907/,5,9 / 7-97,80 030, $88 803, ,8:8 3 207:5,,3 ::2 507/,9, 39073,843, :,1,8,8:83,/,,014780/,3,3::2,3/:3,,3,/,,::2$88 ,2:3 /02,3 /,703,,3 /428 0/:, -0, 5, 80,7:83, ::2 ,3 /:3,,3,/,,::23/4308,/,380:-:3,3/03,3,8:8,3207:5,,3::2 4397,,9,:507,3,3/,3-07/,8,7,3/03,3507,3,3,390,/-:,92,,/,,2 ,8:83::2,3-07,:0.,:803,,9:-07/,8,7,35,3::2.4.041 , ,390,/805,,9/,,2507,3,3 439507,9434397,.9 ,39,7,!079,23,

/03,3,7,,4/,8425,3