EL OLIGOPOLIO
ANDRES FELIPE RORODRIGUEZ BRYAN MORALES CAMILO CORTES ESGUERRA JOHAN MARTINEZ VASQUEZ LADY ALEJANDRA RODRIGUEZ ANGEL MEIVER BEATRIZ MELO VILLANUEVA MONICA RALLO PAULA BARRERA
FUNDACIÓN UNIVERSIDAD DE AMERICA INGENIERIA INDUSTRIAL MACRO Y MICRO ECONOMIA BOGOTÁ D.C 2016
EL OLIGOPOLIO E !"#!$!"!% &'(& ()*+",! -"&,& & /!"#! $!!'/ /$!"! -&,&!*&'3. E' 4,5 &'(*4(4*5 & +&*5!% ",4"5 &,(*! & 5 !*+5 & !+$&(&,"5 "+$&*&(5% !,'( !,'("("(4" 4"5 5 $!* $!* 4, #*4$ #*4$! ! $&74& $&74&8! 8! & !&* !&*&,( &,(&' &' 9$*! 9$*!4 4(! (!*&' *&'::-&, &,& &!* !*&' &';; ",(& ",(&* *&$ &$&, &," "&, &,(& (&'' &'(* &'(*5( 5()# )#" "5+ 5+&, &,(& (& 4, #*5, #*5, ,<+& ,<+&*! *! & &+5 &+5, ,5, 5,(& (&'' 9!,'4+"!*&':!+$*5!*&'; &, 5 74& !' !&*&,(&' ("&,&, 4, $!&* & +&*5! '4""&,(& !+! $5*5 "=5* $*&"!' 5,("5&'. C!+! &' 4,5 &'(*4(4*5 !,!*+55 $!* $!5' &+$*&'5' 4574"&* +5,"$45">, & 5' -5*"5 *"5?&' $!* $5*(& *(& & 5#4, #4,! & !' &,(&' &!,>+"!' 54 54'5 !,'&4&,"5' $!'"("-5' ,("-5' &, 5' !(*5' !+$58@5' ! 74& $4&& $*!4"* *&$*&'5*@5' $!* $5*(& & 5' &+$*&'5' !+$&("!*5'. 1 GESTIOPOLIS. Q4) &' 4, !"#!$!"! &, @,&5. (($::.#&'("!$!"'.!+ :74&&'4, !"#!$!"!: "(5! &, & 5?*" & 2016
A#4,5' & '4' $*","$5&' 5*5(&*@'("5' '!, E"'(& 4, ,<+&*! *&4"! & &+$*&'5' /4&*(&'3 5' 45&' ("&,&, & !+","! &, 45,(! 5 $*&"! 5,("5% *&'$&(! 5 5' &+$*&'5' $&74&85'. L!' $*!4(!' $4&&, &'(5* ! ,! "&*&,"5!'. H5 ""4(5 $5*5 &,(*5* &, & +&*5!. U,5 &+$*&'5 $4&& "'+",4"* & $*&"! & '4 $*!4(! $5*5 5(*5&* +K' &+5,5 54+&,(5* '4' ",#*&'!'% & *&'4(5! & &'(5 5">, &$&,&*K & 5 *&5">, & !' !+$&("!*&'. L5' &"'"!,&' & 55 4,5 & 5' &+$*&'5' 5&(5 5 !' *&'(5,(&'. •
• • •
•
CAUSAS DEL OLIGOPOLIO L5' *5!,&' $!* 5' 74& '& $*&'&,(5, !"#!$!"!' '& &,4&,(*5, &, 5' ?5**&*5' & &,(*55 74& &4&, 5 !' !+$&("!*&' +5,("&,&, & !+","! & 4,5' 45,(5' &+$*&'5'. E, & 5'! & 74& 4,5 &+$*&'5 ",(&,(& ",#*&'5* 5 +&*5!% &'(5 ("&,& 74& 74& !,(5 !,(5** !, !, ?4&, ?4&, 5$" 5$"(5 (5 !, !, & ", ", & !#*5 !#*5** !+$ !+$&( &("* "* !, 5' &+K &+K'' &+$*& &+$*&'5 '5'' '", '", '&* &"+ &"+", ",5 5! ! *K$" *K$"5 5+& +&,( ,(&. &. L5' L5' ?5**& ?5**&*5' *5' & &,(* &,(*55 55 & &'(& &'(& +&*5! '!, •
B5**&*5' &'(*5()#"5' L5' &+$*&'5' 74& !,!*+5, &'(& +&*5! (!+5, &'(* &'(*5( 5(&# &#"5 "5'' $5*5 $5*5 5"' 5"'5* 5* 5 5' 5' &+$* &+$*&' &'5' 5' &, *& *&"+ "+"& "&,( ,(!. !. U,5 U,5 & 5' 5' &'(*5(&#"5' 4(""55' &' (&,&* 5 5$5"5 & $*!4">, &&-55% 5 (&,&* &'(5 &'(*5(&#"5 5 &+$*&'5 $4&& &, 4574"&* +!+&,(! (!+5* 5 &"'">, & '5(4*5* & +&*5! !, $*!4(!' &=5,! 5 5 $&74&85 &+$*&'5 !,
$!5 -&,(5=5 !5'"!,5,! 74& &'(5 (&,#5 $!!' ",#*&'!' $!*74& 5 &+5,5 & $*!4(!' '&*K &+5'"5! 5+$"5. •
•
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
•
•
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
+&" +&"! ! & 5 ",-&* ,-&*'" '">, >, &, $4? $4?" "" "5 5 !, !, 4, '!! '!! ", 74& 74& &' #5, #5,5* *&!,!"+"&,(! &, 5 +5*5% 5 &+$*&'5 *&"), ",#*&'55 $4&& !#*5* 5 *&$4(5">, 74& ?4'5% $&*! &'(! (!+5*@5 4, ("&+$! 5*#! 74& & #&,&*5*@5 $&*"5' +"&,(*5' !?("&,& 5 *&$4(5">,.
CONCENTRACIÓ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
SUPUESTOS BASICOS DEL OLIGOPOLIO
•
H5 4, ,< ,<+& +&*! *! *& *&4 4" "! ! & &+ &+$* $*&' &'5' 5' 55' 5' 5*5(&*@'("5' & 5 $*!4">, '4' !'(!'% & +&*5! '>! *&'"'(& 4, ,<+&*! *&4"! & &+$*&'5'.
FIG.1
L5 5,(&*"!* #*5"5 ,!' ","5 74& & +&*5! '!! *&'"'(& (*&' &+$*&'5'% 5 4*-5 D *&$*&'&,(5 5 &+5,5 (!(5% 5 4*-5 D 5 &+5,5 $*!$!*"!,5 45,! 5 2 &+$*&'5' &, & +&*5! 74& *&$*&'&,(5 4, 4!$!"! 5
• •
•
4*-5 1: D &' 5 &+5,5 $*!$!*"!,5 '" 4?"&*5 &+$*&'5'. H5'(5 574@ (!5-@5 5 4*-5 & &+5,5 $*!$!*"!,5 &'(K $!* &,"+5 & 5 4*-5 & !'(! +&"! & 5*#! $5! 9CM&L$;. P&*! '" &,(*5 4,5 45*(5 &+$*&'5% '4 4*-5 & &+5,5 $*!$!*"!,5 D &'(5*K &, (!! +!+&,(! $!* &?5=! & CM&L$% ! 74& & 5*K $)*"5' '"&+$*&. (($::.545&&!,!+"5.!+:+"*!5$+5(&*"5. U, $*!4(! !+!#),&! ! "&*&,"5! E,(*55 "+"(55 L5 &,(*55 5 +&*5! !"#!$!"'(5 &'(K !,""!,55 $!* -5*"5' ?5**&*5' & &,(*55. P!!' -&,&!*&' +4!' !+$*5!*&'. MODELOS
FIG.2
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
E =4&#! &' 4, ("$! & +!& +!&! ! +5(&+K("! +5(&+K("! $5*5 &,(&, &,(&,&* &* 5 (!+5 & &"'">, 5 ",(&*5">, &,(*& 74"&,&' (!+5, 5' &"'"!,&'. Y & +&=!* !,!"! '& 5+5 E "&+5 & $*"'"!,&*!.
FIG.3
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ÓN •
E'(*5(&#"5 +"(5% V5!* &'$&*5!
U, =4#5!* 4'5 4,5 &'(*5(&#"5 $4*5 '" 4'5 5 +"'+5 5">, 5 55 (4*,! & =4&#!. E =4#5!* 4'5 4,5 &'(*5(&#"5 +"(5 '" 5 55 (4*,! &'!#& 5 55* 4, 5">, $5*5 74& 55 5">, '& &'(K 4'5! 4,5 *5">, &(&*+",55 & ("&+$!.
R&$*&'&,(5+!' 4,5 &'(*5(&#"5 +"(5 9! $4*5; & =4#5!* *&#>, $!* 4,5 +5(*" !, 4, '!! *&,#>, 9-&(!* $*!?5?""5; R X X a b c . . . C!, C!, ! +"'+ +"'+! ! ,<+& ,<+&*! *! & &,(*5 &,(*55' 5' 74& 74& *&,# *&,#!, !,&' &'%% &, 45 45 55 55 &,(* &,(*5 55 5 *&$*&'&,(5 5 *5">, & ("&+$! 74& &'(K 4'55 5 !**&'$!,"&,(& 5">, 9! 5 $*!?5?""5 & 4'5* 574& 5">,; !,& a b . . . X 1. U,5 U,5 &'(* &'(*5( 5(&# &#"5 "5 +"( +"(5 5 $5*5 $5*5 & =4#5 =4#5! !** *&,# *&,#>, >, '& *&$*&' *&$*&'&, &,(& (& $!* $!* 4, -&( -&(!* !* $*!?5 $*!?5?" ?"""5 5 '"+" '"+"5 5*% *% $&*! &, !*+ !*+5 5 & !4 !4+, +,5 5 C . P5*5 P5*5 5+?! 5+?!'' =4#5 =4#5!*& !*&'% '% &'(*5(&#"5' $4*5' '!, *&$*&'&,(55' $!* -&(!*&' $*!?5?""5 !, 4, '!! 1 & *&'(! & 5' &,(*55' 0. E -5!* &'$&*5! & =4&#! !, +5(*" & $5#!' P 74& *&'4(5 $!* 5' &'(*5(&#"5' +"(5' R C &' &' 5! $!* e = RPC
E -5!* &'$&*5! & =4&#! &' & $5#! $*!+&"! $!* (4*,! '" 55 =4#5!* 4'5 '4 &'(*5(&#"5 +"(5 &'$&""55 $!* R C &'$4)' &'$4)' & 4, #*5, ,<+&*! & (4*,!'.
•
C*"(&*"! +","+5% P*","$"!' 4,5+&,(5&' & 5 (&!*@5 & =4&#!'
C*"(&*"! M","+5 U, =4#5! =4#5!** 74"&, 74"&, 4'5 & *"(&* *"(&*"! "! +","+5 +","+5% % +","+" +","+"5 5 & 58! & 5 +&=!* +&=!* !,(*5 !,(*5 &'(*5( &'(*5(&#" &#"5 5 & !(*! !(*! =4#5! =4#5!*. *. E' &"*% &"*% 4,5 &'(*5( &'(*5(&#" &#"5 5 >$("+5 >$("+5 '&#<, '&#<, & *"(&* *"(&*"! "! +","+5 &' 4,5 74& +","+"5 & 58! +K"+! 74& $4&& 5&* & !,(*",5,(&.
1 2
P*","$"!' 4,5+&,(5&' & 5 (&!*@5 & =4&#!' C45,! 5,5"5+!' 4574"&* =4&#!% 5&+!' !' '"#4"&,(&' '4$4&'(!' 5&*5 & !' !' =4#5!*&' C55 =4 =4#5!* !* 5 5& 5 5 5 5">, +& +&=!* $!' $!'""?&. C55 C55 =4# =4#5 5!* !* '5?& '5?& 74& 74& '4 !,( !,(*", *",5, 5,((& &'(K '(K (5+? (5+?") "), , 5"& 5"&, ,! ! 5 5"> 5">, , +&=!* +&=!* $!'"?&. ESTRATEGIAS
•
M!&! M!& ! & ! !"# "#!$ !$! !"! "! $4 $4*! *! E, 4, +& +&* *5! 5! ! !"# "#!$ !$! !"' "'(5 (5 ! !'' $* $*!4 !4( (!' !' -&," -&, "!' !' '! '!, , '4' '4'("("(4 (4(! (!'' &, &,(* (*& & & &! !'' +" +"'+ '+!% !% &, &,(* (*& & ! !'' 74 74& & ! !*& *&&, &, 5 5'' &+$*&'5'% $&*! !, $&74&85' "&*&,"5' &,(*& &'(!'% 5 &'(& '& !,!& !+! !+ ! !" !"#!$ #!$!" !"! ! " "&*&, &*&,"5 "5! ! $&*! &, & !" !"#!$! #!$!"! "! $4*! !' $*! $*!4( 4(!' !' -&,"!'' '!, '4'("(4(!' $&*&(!' -&,"! $&*&(!' & 5 !+$&(&,"5% !+$&(&,"5% &'(! 74"&*& &"* 74& ,! 5 "&*&,"5 &,(*& !' $*!4(!' -&,"!'% 4, &=&+$! 5*! &' & & 5
-&,(5 & *4(5' -&#&(5&'% $4&'(! 74& (!!' !' $*!4(!' !*&"!' '!, "#45&'% 5 &'(! !"#!$!"! $4*! '& & $4&& 5+5* 4, !"#!$!"! $&*&(!. •
M!&! & 4*-5 74&?*55 ! +!&! & S&& E' 4, 5'! & !"#!$!"! $4*! 74& '& ?5'5 &, !' '4$4&'(!'% & & *&4">, & $*&"!'% & 54+&,(! & $*&"!'. E, 5'! & 74& 4,5 &+$*&'5 54+&,(& !' $*&"!' & '4' $*!4(!'% 5' &+$*&'5' !+$&("!*5' ,! 5 '"*@5,% ! '&5 ,! "#455*@5, !' $*&"!'% '& +5,(&,*@5, &, !' 5,(&*"!*&'% *&5,! ! 74& '& &,!+",5 4,5 &+5,5 &K'("5.
FIG.4
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
FIG.5 •
•
M!&! & !4'">, !4'">, E +!&! & !4'">, ! 5*(&% &' 45,! & #*4$! & &+$*&'5' & +&*5! !"#!$!"'(5 '& *&<,&, $5*5 5*+5* 4,5 5'!"5">, &, !,& 5=4'(&, !' $*&"!' & !' $*!4(!' !*&"!'% 54+&,(&, '4' #5,5," #5, 5,"5' 5' $5*5 ?&, ?&,&" &""! "! +4( +4(4!% 4!% #&, #&,&*5 &*5+&,( +&,(& & &'( &'(5 5 5'! 5'!"5 "5">, ">, (&* (&*+", +",5 5 (*5,'!*+5,! & +&*5! !"#!$!"'(5 &, 4, +&*5! & +!,!$!@'("!. D!,& &'(5 5'!"5">, &' & +!,!$!"!. E !?=&("-! !?=&("-! & &'(5 !4'">, &,(*& 5' &+$*&'5' &+$*&'5' &' *&4"* 5 !+$&(&,"5 !+$&(&,"5 &,(*& &5' 5 5 $5* 54+&,(5* '4' #5,5,"5'% *&5* 4,5 &'$&"& & +!,!$!"!% & "+$&"* 74& '& *&&, ,4&-5' &+$*&'5' 74& $4&5, 5&(5* '4 +&*5!% (!+5* &"'"!,&' ?&,&""!'5' $5*5 5' &+$*&'5' ",-!4*55'. U, &=&+$! & 4, +!&! & !4'">, &' & $5(! &,(*& 5' ",4'(*"5' $&(*!&*5' 5' #5'!",&*5' 9OPEP; 5 !4'">, '& $4&& $*&'&,(5* &,(*& &+$*&'5' ,5"!,5&' ! ",(&*,5"!,5+&,(&. M!&! & "&*5#! & $*&"!' P!* +&"! & "&*5#! & $*&"!'% 5' &+$*&'5' ! "*+5' $*&'&,(&' &, 4, +&*5! !"#!$!"'(5% 5&$(5, & $*&"! "+$4&' "+$ 4&'(! (! $!* 5 &+$ &+$*&'5 *&'5 !+",5 !+",5,(& ,(& & +&*5! +&*5!%% 5'@ 74& 54+ 54+&,( &,(5,% 5,% +5,("&,&, ! "'+",4&, !' $*&"!' & '4' $*!4(!'% '"#4"&,! & $*&"! "=5! $!* 5 ",4'(*"5 !+",5,(& &, & +&*5!. P!* +&"! & &'(& +)(!!% 5' &+$*&'5' & 4, +&*5! !"#!$!"'(5% '& '"&,(&, +K' 5"-"5!' &, 5' #5,5,"5' *&,(& 5 !(*!' +)(!!' "+$&+&,(5!'. /L"&*5#! & $*&"!' &' !(*5 !*+5 & !4'">, & 5' "*+5' !"#!$!"'(5'. A(45+&,(& &' 4,5 4&'(">, '&*&(5 &,(*& 5' "*+5'. Y 4,5 & 5' "*+5' &' !,'"&*55 !+! & @&* "=5 !' $*&"!' !'5' *&5"!,55'. T!5' T!5' 5' "*+5' &, 5 ",4'(*"5 !"#!$!"'("5 '"*K, 5' *' "=55' $!* & @&*. A74@ ,! 5 $!'"?""5 & !+$&(&,"5 &,(*& & @&* 5' "*+5' ","-"45&'. G&,&*5+&,(& 5 (*&' ("$!' & @&*&' & $*&"! L@&* & $*&"! & ?5=! !'(!% P*&"! @&* !+",5,(&% P*&"! @&* ?5*!+)(*"!.3 T!+5! & 5*(@4! & I*'5 CV% E!,!+"'(5 & 5 U,"-&*'"5 & C5"4(% \(($::4?$5#&'.!+:&45("!,:]5(5*&(&D&*&,(T$&'!O"#!$!
•
M!&! & &+$*&'5 @&* E'(& +!&! &' $5,(&5! $!* S(5&?&*#% &, & 45 '& $*&'&,(5, !' &+$*&'5' 74& !*&&, $*!4(!' !+!#),&!'% 4,5 &+$*&'5 @&* &, & +&*5! !(*5 ',5 &+$*&'5 +K' $&74&85% S(5 S( 5& &? ?&* &* " "& & 74 74& & 5 55 5 4, 4,5 5 & 5 5'' &+ &+$* $*&' &'5' 5' $ $5, 5,(& (&5 5 5 5 5,( ,(" "5 5 $*!4"5% '4' $*&"!' "+$4&'(!' 5 !' $*!4(!'% 5 5,("5 &+5,55 $&*! (5+?"), $5,(&5 74& 5 &+$*&'5 @&*% !,!& !' !'(!' & $*!4">, 74& ("&,& 5 ',5 &+$*&'5% $!* ! (5,(! 5 &+$*&'5 @&* &' 5$5 & 5,(""$5* 5 *&5">, & 5 ',5 &+$*&'5 *&,(& 5 55 &"'">, 74& 5 &+$*& &+ $*&'5 '5 @&* @&* (! (!+&. +&. L5 "&*&, "&*&," "5 5 &, &,(* (*& & &'( &'(& & +! +!& &! ! & +!&! +!&! & !+$&(&,"5 & C!4*,!( &' 74& &, C!4*,!( 5' &+$*&'5' 74& !+$"(&,% ("&,&, 5 +"'+5 -&,(5=5 4,5 '!?*& 5 !(*5% 5 5 $5* ("&,&, 4,5 +"'+5 ",4&,"5 &, & +&*5!% $!* ! (5,(! $4&&, 5(&*5* '4' $*&"!'% $!* ! (5,(! &, &'(5 !+$&(&,"5 5 &+$*&'5 74& -&,5 +K'% &' 5 74& !?(&,*K +K' #5,5,"5'% '", "+$!*(5* & $*&"! $!* & 45 '&5 -&,"!.
FIG.6
E &74""?*"! & +!&! $*&'&,(5! $!* S(5&?&*# '& &,4&,(*5 45,!% 5 &+$*& &+ $*&'5 '5 @&* @&* & &" "& & 5(45* 5(45* !+! 4, +! +!,! ,!$! $!""! ! !? !?'& '&**-5 5 74& 5' #5,5,"5' 74& &'(K, !?(&,"&,! $!* '4' $*!4(!' &' '!! "&*(5 $5*(& & 5 &+5,5% 5'@ 74& &'5 $5*(& & 5 &+5,5 74& 4?*& &' '4 +K"+!' ",#* ", #*&'! &'!'% '% $! $!** ! (5 (5,( ,(! ! $*! $*!4 4" "** +K +K'' "+ "+$ $" "5*@ 5*@5 5 " "'+ '+", ",4" 4"** '4 '4'' ", ",#*& #*&'!' '!'%% "'+",4&,! '4' #5,5,"5'% 5@ &' 45,! 59'; &+$*&'5' '"!*5'% &"&, 5&*'& 5*#! & *&'(! & 5 &+5,5 74& ,! 4?*& 5 &+$*&'5 @&*% #&,&*K,!&' 5 5 $5* 4,5 #5,5,"5. L5 &'-&,(5=5 & &'(& +!&!% &' 74& 5 &+$*&'5 @&* 4(""& '4 -&,(5=5 $5*5 5&* ",4'! &'5$5*&&* 5 5 !(*5 &+$*&'59'; "=5,! $*&"!'% 74& ,! *&$*&'&,(&, #5,5,"5' $5*5 5 &+$*&'5 '"!*5 (5+?"), $4&& !,&-5* 5 74& 5 &+$*&'5 '"!*5
$*!45 +K' 5 +&,!* $*&"!% +5"+"5,! '4 #5,5,"5% (!+5,! (&**&,! &, & +&*5! 5 5 $5* (5+?" (5+?"), ), '& $4&& $*&'&,(5* & 5'! & 74& 5 *&5"5* &'(5 =4#55 5 5 &+$*&'5 @&*% @&*% 5' 5' &+$*&'5' '"!*5' '& 4,5, $5*5 $5 *5 & &** **! !5* 5* 5 &+ &+$* $*&' &'5 5 @@& &**% 5 5' 5'! !"5 "5*' *'& & $4 $4& &&, &, 54 54+& +&,( ,(5* 5* '4 $*!4">,% +&=!*5* 5 5"5% $!,"&,! &, &'-&,(5=5 5 5 &+$*&'5 @&*. EFECTO ECONÓMICO E !"# !"#!$ !$! !"! "! '& "'( "'(", ",#4 #4& & & & +!,! +!,!$! $!""! ! 5 !+$ !+$&( &(&, &," "5 5 $&* $&*& &(5 (5 $!* $!* 5 ",&$&,&,"5 &,(*& 5' 5"!,&' & 5' "'(",(5' &+$*&'5' 74& ! !,!*+5,. E' 4, +&*5! &, & 45 5 +5!*@5 & 5' -&,(5' '!, *&5"55' $!* 4,5' $!5' &+$*&'5' 55 4,5 & 5' 45&' &' 5$5 & ",4"* &, & $*&"! & +&*5! !, '4' $*!$"!' 5(!'. D"5' &+$*&'5' &, #&,&*5 '& 5, 4&,(5 74& '4' ?&,&""!' $!*@5, *&&* '" *&5"5, 54&*!' !, '4' *"-5&'. T5+?"), '& $4&& &4"* &4"* !+! ",(&*&'5,(& ",(&*&'5,(& 5 74& '& !,'("(4&, !,'("(4&, 4,5 & 5' K*&5' K*&5' & 5 !+$ !+$&( &(&, &,"5 "5 &!, &!,>+ >+" "5 5 !, !, +K' +K' "& "&*& *&, ,"5 "5'' & !$", !$","> ">, , !+! !+! (5+? (5+?") "), , &' $*&! $*&!4$ 4$5,( 5,(&% &% $*!$" $*!$"" "5 5 4,5 4,5 #*5, #*5, $5*5 $5*5! !=5 =5 74& 74& $4& $4&& & *&'4 *&'4((5* 5* &, '5, '5,"! "!,5 ,5** 5 !, !,4 4(5 (5 +K' +K' !+$ !+$&( &("("(""-5 5 ! (!& (!&*5 *5** 5 !, !,4 4(5 (5 74& 74& ,! &' !+$&("("-5. S& $!*@5 &"* 74& &,(!,&' 74&% &, '&+&=5,5 '&+&=5,5 !, 5 !+$&(&,"5 !+$&(&,"5 $&*&(5% $&*&(5% & !"#!$ !"#!$!" !"! ! *&'4(5 *&'4(5 $&*,"" $&*,""!'! !'! $5*5 5 '!"& '!"&5% 5% &?"! &?"! 5 &(*5-" &(*5-"> > & &"5 &"5"5 "5 $*!4( $*!4("-5 "-5 "'(*" "'(*"?4( ?4("-5 "-5 74& '& !,'"& !,'"&*5. *5. A'@ +"'+!% +"'+!% '4' &&(! &&(!'' ,(",("-!' !' $4&&, *&'4(5* &""&,(&' & ! 74& *&'4(5 &, & +!,!$!"!% 5 74& ,! &' $!'"?& 5 -&*""5">,% &,(!,&' &"'(&, +&,!' &!,!+@5' & &'55 '& 4(""5 4, '4$&*"!* ,<+&*! & 5"!,&' 5=&,5' 5 $*&"!. S", &+?5*#!% &"'(&, 5#4,!' &&(!' ?&,&""!'!' &*"-5!' & $*!#*&'! (&,!>#"! & 5 $*!4">, &, &'55. ALGUNOS EJEMPLOS DE EMPRESAS OLIGOPOLISTA OLIGOPOLISTAS S SON
•
E+$*&'5' & (&&!+4,"5"!,&' 95*!%+!-"'(5*%("#!; 95*!%+!-"'(5*%("#!;
E "&5 & S+"( &' 74& &"'(5 4, +&*5! & !+$&(&,"5 $&*&(5% !,& 55, +4!' !&*&,(&' +4!' &+5,5,(&'% $&*! 5 '&(!*&' &, 74& &'(! ,! '& $4&& 5*% &' & 5'! & 5 (&&!,@5 (&&!,@5 +>-"% !,& &"'(& &"'(& 4, *&4*'! "+"(5! "+"(5! & $*!$"&5 &'(5(5 9E &'$&(*!; 74& *&74"&*& 4,5' #*5,&' ",-&*'"!,&' & 5$"(5 $!* 5 ",*5&'(*4(4*5 (&,!!#@5 *&74&*"5. P!* &!% &' 74& ,! &"'(&, +4!' -&,&!*&' &, & '&*-""! & (&&!,@5 +>-"% ! 74& ! !,-"&*(& &, 4, !"#!$!"!% &' &"*% 4, +&*5! &, !,& &"'(&, $!!' !&*&,(&' +4!' &+5,5,(&'.
E'& &' & 5'! & C!!+?"5 & +4!' $5@'&' & +4,!% ",4'! &, E'(5!' U,"!'% !,& 5 $&'5* & 74& &"'(&, 4,5 #*5, 5,("5 & !$&*5!*&' &'(5(5&'% '!! !+$58@5' $!'&&, 4,5 !?&*(4*5 &, (!! & (&**"(!*"! ,5"!,5. E, ,4&'(*! $5@'% &"'(&, !$&*5!*&' +>-"&' 74& $!'&&, 4,5 *& $*!$"5 9&, !*&, & 4!(5 & +&*5!; C5*!% M!-"'(5*% T"#! A-5,(& 9*& "DEN;% (!5' &'(5'% &+$*&'5' +4(",5"!,5&'% 5&+K' &"'(&, !(*5' &+$*&'5' 74& '& &,!+",5, !$&*5!*&' -"*(45&'% 74& ,! $!'&&, 4,5 *& $*!$"5 '",! 74& 574"5, 5 ",*5&'(*4(4*5 & !' !$&*5!*&' +>-"&'% &'(!' '!, U^% ETB% _"(!% UNE 94(""5, 5 *& & T"#!;% V"*#", M!?"& 94(""5 5 *& & M!-"'(5*;% &, (!(5 '!, !$&*5!*&' & (&&!,@5 &45* &, C!!+?"5. E'(5 &'5'5 !+$&(&,"5 &-5 5 74& '& (&,#5 74& $5#5* +K' $!* 4, '&*-""! & +&,!* 5"5% &, ,4&'(*! $5@' 5'(5 & +"'+! $*&'"&,(& '& 74&=5 & +5 '&*-""! & 5 (&&!,@5 +>-"% 5(5 & 4,5 +5!* *5">, !,(*! '!?*& 5 (&&!,@5 &45*. P&*! -5+!' $!* ?4&, 5+",!% &'& 5& -5*"!' +&'&'% & M",TIC% M",TIC% 5 S4$&*",(&,& S4$&*",(&,&,"5 ,"5 & I,4'(*"5 I,4'(*"5 C!+&*"!% C!+&*"!% 5 C!+"'">, C!+"'">, & R5">, R5">, & C!+4,"5"!,&' & C!,#*&'! 5, $4&'(! '4' !=!' '!?*& &'(& +&*5! '& 5, "+$4&'(! +4(5' $!* ,! *&$!*(5* & -!4+&, *&5 & 74&=5' 74& $!,&, ! 4'45*"!'% '& $4'! 4, @+"(& +@,"+! &, 5 -"#&,"5 & '5! 9!' +&'&';% '& "+$&+&,(> 5 $!*(5?""5 ,4+)*"5% '& 5-5,5 &, 4, $*!&(! & & &, & S&,5 S&,5! ! $5*5 $5*5 &-"( &-"(5* 5* 5' 5' K4 K4'4 '45 5'' & $&*+ $&*+5, 5,&, &," "5 5 +@," +@,"+5 +5'' &, +5* +5*!' !' *5(!*"!' $5*5 74& !' !$&*5!*&' !+$&,'&, 54(!+K("5+&,(& 5 !' 4'45*"!' $!* 5' 5+55' 5@5'% $5*5 74& $4&5, !+$5*("* ",*5&'(*4(4*5 &,(*& !' !$&*5!*&' !, 5' *&&' & &,&*#@5 &)(*"5. •
E+$*&'5' & G5'&!'5'
L!' !"#!$!"'(5' &'(5?&"!' '4&&, (&,&* 4,5 *&$4(5">, 5-!*5?&. E, +4!' !"#!$!"!' !+! !' !' +&*5!' & ?&?"5' ?&?"5' #5'&!'5' & 4&*(& #5'(! &, $4?""5 5 545! 5 *&5* +5,(&,&* &5(5 5 5 +5*5. U,5 &+$*&'5 ,4&-5 $!*@5 55,5* 5 5' 74& 5 &'(K, &, & '&(!*% $&*! &! $!*@5 *&74&*"* 4, 5*#! $&*"!! &, & 74& !' !'(!' $!* $4?""5 '!, 4&*(&' !' ",#*&'!' '!, ?5=!' U, ?4&, &=&+$! & 4!$!"! PEPSICOCA COLA D!,& ! "5 '"#4&, (&,"&,! 4,5 #4&**5 !+&*"5% &'& 74& P&$'" &, 1`0% 4& *&55 $5*5 !+$&("* !,(*5 '4 #*5, *"-5% C!5C!5. T5,(! 4,5 &+$*&'5 !+! 5 !(*5 '& *&$5*(&, & +4,!% !,& &, 4,!' $5@'&' !+! T!"! ! J5$>, 5 -&,(5 & P&$'" &' +4! +5!* 74& 5 & '4 *"-5% &, !(*!' $5@'&' !+! I(5"5 I,#5(&**5 5 -&,(5 & C!5 C!5 &'(K $!* &,"+5 74& 5 & P&$'". A ",5&' & 10 5 aa#4&**5bb '& (*5'5> 5 5' $5,(55' 45,! P&$'" &+$&> 5 5,5* 5,4,"!'% 5,4,"!'% !,(*5(5,! !,(*5(5,! 5 5+!'!' 5+!'!' & 5 )$!5 $5*5 5* 4,5 +&=!* "+5#&,. E'(5 ?5(55 (&&-"'"-5 '& 5 (*5'55! 5'(5 5 5(45"5% !,& &'(5' !'% '"#4&, 5"&,! 5,4,"!' !, & ", & !,'"* 4, +5!* ,<+&*! & !,'4+"!*&'
E+$*&'5 & &+&,(! &, C!!+?"5 9!"#!$!"! &+&,(&*!; L5' &+$*&'5' $*!4(!*5' $*!4(!*5' & &+&,(! &, C!!+?"5% C!!+?"5% &, &'(& +!+&,(!% '!, (*&' H!"+ 9S4"5;% C&+& 9M)"!; A*#!' 9S","5(! A,("!74&8!; 5 ",4'(*"5 & &+&,(! &' 4,! &,(*& +4!' &=&+$!' & &+5'"55' &'(*4(4*5' & +&*5! & 45,("!'!' $*!4(!' &, C!!+?"5% &'$&"5+&,(& &'$4)' & 5 5$&*(4*5 &!,>+"5 & 10 &, & 74& !' $*"+&*! @5' & '& $*!4=! 4, 54+&,(! & ?4(! & ",4&,(5 "!'% 74& $5'> & 4, $*!+&"! & 1`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` &,(*5 5 +&*5! C&+&,(!' A,",!% 74& 574"&*& 4,5 &+&,(&*5 &, B!5K &, & 200 +!,(5 !(*5 $5,(5 &, B5**5,74"5% !, 5 45 '4$& & ` $!* "&,(! & 5 &+5,5 5 ,"-& ,5"!,5. E, 1`% A,",! '& 4,& 5 5' (*&' #*5, #*5,&' &' 5 &"' &"'(& (&,( ,(&' &' $5*5 $5*5 *&$5* *&$5*("("*'& *'& & +&* +&*5! 5! !!+ !!+?" ?"5, 5,!. !. A,(&' ,(&' & 5 !,'!"5">, & A,",!% &, & 58! 2000% 5 S4$&*",(&,&,"5 & I,4'(*"5 C!+&*"!% 5,(& &-"&,"5' & !4'">, (K"(5 &,(*& A*#!'% H!"+ C&+&% &' 5& "*+5* 4, 5(5 !,& 5' !+$*!+&(& 5 ,! (&,&* $*K("5' *&'(*"("-5' & +&*5!% (5&' !+! 5!*5* $*&"!' 5'"#,5*'& & +&*5! $!* !,5' &, &'& 58! !' $*&"!' &'(5?5, &+5'"5! 5(!'% +"&,(*5' 5 !,'(*4">, 5 &+5,5 & &+&,(! &'(5?5, $*K("5+&,(& $5*5"55'. E, !(4?*& & 200% !+"&,5 4,5 #4&**5 & $*&"!' $*&"!' 74&% '&#<, A,",! A,",! !, '4 +5*5 U,! A% 4& ",""55 $!* 5 !+$&(&,"5 A*#!' !, G5,5&+% C&+& !, S5,'>, H!"+ !, H)*4&' '&#<, A,",! 5 #4&**5 '& ",""5 45,! 5' !(*5' (*&' +5*5' ",-5&, '4 (&**"(!*"! &, S5,(5,&*% B!5K C4,",5+5*5% !,& (&,@5 & 0 $!* "&,(! & +&*5!% $&*! '&#<, )'(5' <("+5'% 5 #4&**5 5 ",""! A,",! 5 ",-5"* '4' (&**"(!*"!' !, '4 +5*5 U,! A. L5 #4&**5 & $*&"!' 4& & (5 +5#,"(4 74& &,(*& !(4?*& & 200 5#!'(! & 200% !' $*&"!' $5'5*!, & 4, $*!+&"! & 22.000 $&'!' 5 4,!' $*&"!' +@,"+!' & 6.000 $&'!' & ?4(! & ",4&,(5 "!' '", 45 (!5' 5' &+$*&'5' $&*"&*!,% 5 (5 $4,(! 74& '& &'("+5 74& &=5*!, & *&"?"* 9! & #5,5*; 200 200 +" +"!, !,&' &' & >5*& >5*&'' &, &'& &'& 5$'! 5$'! !?-"5 !?-"5+& +&,( ,(& & 5' 5' #*5, #*5,&' &' (&,@ (&,@5, 5, #*5, #*5, *&'$5! ",5,"&*! $5*5 5#45,(5* & ?5=!,5! & $*&"!'% !'5 74& ,! $5'> !, A,",!% 5 45 (4-! 74& &,(*5* 5 ,&#!"5* '4 -&,(5 $!* 10 +"!,&' & >5*&' 5 &+&,(!' &+&,(!' A*#!' &, ""&+?*& & 200. U, +&' &'$4)' & 54&*!% !' $*&"!' '5(5*!, 5 12.00 $&'!'% & !?& & '4 -5!* +@,"+!% 4, +&' 5,(&'. D&?"! 5 &'(5 #4&**5% 5 S4$&*",4'(*"5 +4(5% &, !(4?*& & 2006 5 A*#!'% C&+& H!"+ $!* 4, +!,(! & 2.6 +"!,&' +"!,&' & $&'!' 5 '4' *&$*&'&,(5,(&' *&$*&'&,(5,(&' $!* 1 +"!,&' +"!,&' & $&'!' &, &'& +!+&,(! +!+&,(! 5 S4$&*",5," S4$&*",5,"&*5 &*5 5' 54'> & !4'">, ! 54&*!' 74&
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` •
O"#!$!"! & (&&!+4,"5"!,&'
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•
O"#!$!"! & $585&'
S& !,'"&*5 4, !"#!$!"! 5 74& 5 '&* 5' 4&85' & +&*5! & $585&' &, C!!+?" C! !+?"5 5 9T 9T& &,!' ,!'4* 4*%% T&,! ,!74@ 74@+" +"5' 5' 9]" 9]",, ,, U( U(*5( *5(*"+ *"+;% ;% F5+ F5+"" ""5 5 9P& 9P&74& 74&8@, 8@,;% ;% c"+?&* 9H4##"&'; D*$&*' 9B5? S&;;% &'(5' &+$*&'5' &"&, &&-5* !' $*&"!' & '4' $*!4(!' 5 '&* ","'$&,'5?&' &, 5 -"5 !(""5,5 & 5' +5*&' !' $*!4(!' 4,5 ,&&'"5 "5*"5% &?&, &&* 5,(& !' $*&"!'. E'(! *&5! !, & ", & 74& (!!' (&,#5, #5,5,"5' 5,(& 5 #*5, !+$&(&,"5. A(&,(5,! !,(*5 !' +5,&=!' & +&*5! !!+?"5,! 74& '!, 5 ?5'& & !&*(5 &+5,5.
BIBLIOGRAFdA
(($::.&&'$&(5!*.!+:,!(""5':&!,!+"5:&5*(&&!'$5,5&' 5*("4!0`6 (($::.?5,*&$4(4*5.!*#:?55-"*(45:545&(5*&5':&!,!+"5:!+$&(& ,"5'e&e+&*5! (($::.&&*5!.!:&"(!*"5:&5*(&&$5,51616 (($::.?5,*&$4(4*5.!*#:?55-"*(45:&!,!+"5:",4'(*"5(",5:22.(+ (($::.#&'("!$!"'.!+:74&&'4,!"#!$! (($::&'.'"&'5*&.,&(:+*"1:!"#!$!"! (($::.$&!".!*#:C!4*'&':C!4*'&''$:+":+".(+ (($::.545&&!,!+"5.!+:+"*!5$+5(&*"5. (($::.",5,5'.!+:!"#!$!"!' (($'::.!4(4?&.!+:5(-X$E-FYe?7! (($::.&4+&.,&(:4*'&!,:=4&#!':+5"+",.(+ (($::.&"#+&"5.!+:M4,!R&5:S4++5*?.(+ (($'::.45+.&':$&*'!,5e$":&!,!+"5':"554'!:D!4+&,(!':INCER TIDUMBRE202011:E=&*""!'20(&!*"520&20=4&#!'.$ (($'::$*&".!+:!&7???':&&(!'&!,!+"!'&!"#!$!"!:
•
•
• • • • • • • • • • •
•
(($'::.4?&,'5!'.!+:N&#!"!':O"#!$!"!'E, C!!+?"5:220.(+ (($::.$!*(5!"!.!:&!,!+"5:",5,5':+&*5!&+&,(! !!+?"5` (($::&'.'"&'5*&.,&(:?'*(0:!+$&(&,"5+!,!$!'("5!"#!$!"!
•
•
•
