PERBANDINGAN UUD 1945, RIS 49, UUDS 50

!#&&$%%&$#$ ,3&&$ 0183,74 43899:8207:5,,3,,38,3,950393/,3;9,/,,28:,9:5020739,,3/03,3/-07,:,33,/,3/8,,33, 43899:8,3202-039:#05:-3/4308,3207:5,,35079,3/,,30,8-,,30,7,3/2,8:/,380-,,30,7, 43899:843,,3203,230-0-,8,37,,93/4308,:39:2020739,/7803/7:8,,-,38,3/4308,,3207/0,/,3  -07/,:,9:39:202-039:5020739,803/7,38,8079,:8,,203,23,,3,8,2-203039,3503,,:3,,3 0:,8,,3,3,/,5,9/,:,3/,,207,3,30,7,43899843,502-039:,330,7,43899:843,207:5,,3-,,3/,7 :5,,203.,5,0207/0,,3,703,,3,/,,207,3,002-,,,33/,5,9/-,3:32,8,7,,9,3/0247,98 $0,574,2,8,:89:88,25,8,,9390,-07,:9,2,.,2&3/,3&3/,3,8,7/,,2-0-07,5,5074/0,9: !074/0 !074/0 :8 :89:8 9:80802 0802-07 -07   !074/0 !074/0 08020802-07 07  :89:8 :89:8   !074/0 !074/0 ,:89:8 ,:89:8  :   !074/ !074/0 0  : :  8,,9 8,,9 3 3 &&   90, 90, /,2,3 /,2,3/02 /02,3 ,3  $,,9 $,,9 # /574 /574,2, ,2,8 8,3 ,3 5,/, 9,3, 9,3,  :89: :89:8 8   #05:--,7:3-0:22025:3, #05:--,7:3-0:22025:3,&3/,3:3/,3 &3/,3:3/,3,8,7803, ,8,7803,4 40!!5,/,9,3, 0!!5,/,9,3,  ,:89:8/8,,3&& ,:89:8/8,,3&& 80-,, 80-,, &3/,3 &3/,3&3 &3/,3 /,3 ,8,7 ,8,7 705:- 705:-  3/4308 3/4308, , ,3 ,3 909,5 909,5 507:-, 507:-,,3 ,3 509, 50754 507549 9,3 ,3 ,3 ,3 907,/ 907,/ ,39,7, ,39,7, 3/430 3/4308 8, , /03,3 /03,3 0,3/, 0,3/, 90,202-,,/,25, ,3-08,7 ,3 -08,7 743743,3 743743,3 0,3/, 0,3/, /,,2# 2,8 2,8 .::5:,9 /03,3 203.4-, 203.4-, 203/7,30,7, 203/7,30,7, $:2,907,%2:7%0,7,!,8:3/,3/80,,3/03,3:8,,:39:207:39:,3#907,/,7089,:3/,3708 /2,3,,-,9/,79:!203,/,,3/03,, 03,3 03,3 /809::3, /809::3, ,8,8 ,8,8 43107038 43107038 0,:3/, 0, :3/,7 7   5,/,9,3, 5,/, 9,3,  4;02-07 4;02-07  / 03 ,, 2,, 2,, 907-039:, 907-039:,  0,7  0,7, , #05:- #05:-  3/4308 3/4308, , $07,9 $07,9 #$ #$ $0-,, $0-,,2,3 2,3, , /02: /02:,,3 ,,3 40 #.01 #.01    ,7 4310703 43107038 8 90780-: 90780-:9 9 /80 /805,, 5,,9 9  -,,  -,, 0,3/, 0,3/, ,,3 20307,,3 20307,,3 0/,:,9,33,05,/, 0/,:,9,33,05,/, #$,39,7, 0,3/, 0,3/, /,3#$ /,3 #$,,3 ,,3 202-039: 202-039:8:,9::3 8:,9::3 43,7 43,7 /03,3 7,9:0,3/,80-,,5253,382-48#$3907/7/,730,7,-,,3,32,832,8330,7,-,,390780-:9202

8,2,/03,35020739,203:8:3&&#,3,,3203,39&&,3-07,:5,/,8,,99:&&,3/80-,-,3 ,703,-,/,3,3203:8:33,207,8,/73,:7,3705708039,9,1$0,381,93,,3802039,7,5078,2,,3/,39,7,09,3, ,/,,8,2,8,2,&3/,3:3/,3,8,7/2,3,2070,/-:,9:39:203,//,8,7::2-,30,7,/,8,7092,8/,7 0:,8,,3,38,/,78:,9:5020739,,3 $0.,7,&2:2/,709,&&90780-:9/,5,9/,81,8,3/,,2/:,-039:30,7,08,9:,3/,310/07,/2,3,203:7:94 :83,7//,3,72,-7,2507-0/,,3/,39,7,0/:,3,80-,,-07:9  !,/,30,7,10/07,30,7,30,7,-,,33,5:3,003,3:39:202-:,9&&803/7/,3/,5,9203039:,3-039: 47,38,83,2,832,83/,,2-,9,8-,9,8,39/,-079039,3,3/03,343899:8/,730,7,10/07,80:7:3, ,,2,347,38,8/,7-,,3-,,35,/,30,7,30,7,08,9:,35,/,,78-08,73,/9039:,340502-:,9&&/  5:8,97,38,83207:5,,350,8,3,,3/,788902/080397,8,8/,,230,7,08,9:,3,,3-,,,3/,,230,7, 08,9:,3,3,23,/80-:980-,,5745389/,2025:3,003,3:39:202-:,9&&803/7  ,,230,7,10/07,003,3502-:,9&&5020739,5:8,910/07,/9039:,380.,7,9075073.80/,3,3003,3 ,33,5,/,30,7,30,7,-,,3$0-,3,/,,230,7,08,9:,3003,380.,7,9075073.907/,5,95,/,574538  574538/,3708/:54073,,/,5,/,5020739,5:8,930,7,08,9:,3 !07-0/,,3,30-9073./,709,&&90780-:9/,5,9/,9/,,29,-0 !07-0/,,3 &&  43899:8 #$ /,3&&$ 

$!

&&

&&$

43899:8#$ 





$8902,9, !03:8,3 &&



!02-:,,3 907/7 /,7  ,30, /80-:9,3  2,, /8:8:3, 0207/0,,3



2:,/2,907/7/,7 ,30, /80-:9,3 0207/0,,3 /8:8:3 /,,2 8:,9: 5,,2



:,/2, 907/7 /,7  ,30, /80-:9,3 0207/0,,3 /8:8:3 /,,2 8:,9: 5,,2





0303, 039: 0,7, /,3 0/,:,9,3







,07,  0,7,



0-,38,,3 3/4308, 9: /,,2 8:,9: :3/,3:3/,3 /,8,7 30,7, ,3 907-039: /,,2 8:8:3,3 0,7, 3/4308, ,3  -070/,:,9,3 7,,9 /03,3 -07/,8,7 05,/, &&  907/7 /,7 ' -,-  5,8,  ,9:7,3 507,,3 /,3  ,9:7,39,2-,,3 0,7, 3/4308, ,/,, 30,7, 08,9:,3 ,3 -07-039: 705:- 5,8,  ,,9  0/,:,9,3 ,/,, /9,3,3 7,,9 /,3 /,:,3 80503:3, 40!#5,8,,,9 

&&  9/, 2030,8,3 /03,3 9073. 20303, 2,3, 8,, ,, 34308, 9:

30,7, ,3 -07-039: #05:- 0/07,8 30,0 







43899:8 #$ -,9,3 9:-: 907/7 /,7  -,/,35,8,

#$ ,3 207/0, -07/,:,9 ,, 8:,9: 30,7, 4:2 ,3 /0247,8 /,3 -07-039: 10/07,8 /,,25,8,,,9 0:,8,,3 0/,:,9,3 #$ /,:,3 -078,2, ,39,7, 5020739, !# /,3 $03,9 /,,2 5,8, ,,9 #$ 205:9 80:7: /,07, 3/4308, ,9: /,07,-078,2, 

 0,7, 3/4308, %2:7 0,7,

30,7, ,3 -07-039: 0,7, #05:- 08,9:,3,30,0 







,9,39:-:&&$ 907/7/,7-,- 5,8,/,35,8,  503:9:5

#05:-3/4308,,3 207/0, /,3 -07/,:,9 ,,8:,9:30,7,4:2 ,3 /0247,98 /,3 -07-039: 08,9:,3 /,,25,8,,,9 0/,:,9,3#-07,/, /9,3,37,,9/,3 /,:,340  5020739,-078,2, /03,3!#/,,2  5,8,,,9 #05:- 3/4308, 205:9 80:7: /,07, 3/4308,!,8,

!,8:3/,3 9072,8: /897 10/07, ,,79,0,7,,, %2:7 0,7, ,/:7, 0,7, $:2,907, %2:7 8,,3 $0,9,3 /,3 ,-:,3 ,9: 0,7, $:2,907, $0,9,3 



,9 003,5,3  0,7,



,9,,9 003,5,3 30,7,907/7/,7 ,08 !072:8,,7,9,3 #,,9



$,9:,3 030,7,,3 ,3 90, 803/7 ,,%03,,3, 09:3 #,: ,2,39,3 ,7,9 ,, 08,7 ,07, -,3,7 ,2,39,3 903,7, /,3 ,2,39,3 %2:7 !,8, ,9,,9 50703,5,3 30,7, /,,2 43899:8 #$907/7/,7 !708/03



,9,,9 50703,5,3 30,7, /,,2 &&$ 907/7/,7 !708/03 /,3 !708/03

,

03907203907 !708/03

03907203907 $03,9

0,3 #,,9

!07,,3 0,3 #,,9

!07,,3 ,,2,

0,3 7,,9 :3

!07,,3 ,,2, /,3 0,3

0,3!0792-,3,3 :3

:3 3/4308, /,3 0,3 !03,,8 0:,3,3

!03,,80:,3,3

,,2,:3/,3



!030,8,3 ,9,,9 003,5,3  0,7,

,/,3 !02078, 0:,3,3 !#907/7,9,8,349, ,349,!#/9,2-, /03,3:9:8,3/,07,/,3 443,3203:7:9,9:7,3 ,3/909,5,3&&  5:9:8,3!#/909,5,3 /03,38:,7,907-,3,  -078/,380/93,80, /,,29,:3/-:49, 30,7,/,32039,5,3 &&/,3

,,2 43899:8 #$ 9/, ,/,!#

!708/03 !708/03  



!708/03 



!708/03/,3, !708/03/540 !#/03,38:,7, 907-,3,5,8,,,9  $0-0:2 202,3:  ,-,9,3 !708/03 /,3 ,5708 -078:25, 203:7:9 ,,2, ,9,: -07,3 /03,3 8:3:8:3: /,/,5,3 !# ,9,:

%/,,/,!#



!708/03 /5 40 47,347,3 ,3 /:,8,,3 40 5020739, /,07, /,07, -,,3 !,8,  ,,9 !708/03 80-0:2 202,3: ,-,9,3 203,3,9 8:25, /,/,5,3 47,347,3 ,3 /:,8,,3 40 5020739, /,07,  -,,3





!708/03 /,3 ,5708 /5 203:7:9 ,9:7,3 ,3 /909,5,3 /03,3 &&5,8,,,9 !708/03 80-0:2 202,3: ,-,9,3 203,3,9 8:25, /,/,5,3!# !020739, /,5,9 /,9:,3405708/03 5708/03 -07, 202-:-,7,3 !# /03,3 8,7,9 /,,2 ,9:  ,7 ,7:8 /,:,3 502,3  -,7:

,,2 43899:8 #$  3 ,39,7, 5020739, /03,3 5,70203 202 0/:/:,3 ,3 8,2, 03907 8,2, :,9 /2,3,  5020739, 9/, /,5,9 03907203907 



!#5,8, &&  0/:/:,3 ,/,, :,9 5708/03 9/, /,5,9 202-:-,7,33,

03907 

%/,,/,203907

$03,9 

/,9:,3 40  5,70203 /,3 5,70203 5:, 9/, /,5,9 /-:-,7,3 40  5020739,

 -078/,3 /,,2 /0,3 203907 ,3 /5253 40 507/,3, 203907 , -07,,3,3 /,39,3 40 203907 ,3 /9:3: 40 /0,3203907

03907

$03,9 03907203907  -078/,3 /,,2 /0,3 203907 ,3 /5253 ,,2 ,,9 003,5,3 40 507/,3, 203907 30,7, / &&$  , -07,,3,3 9/,,/,803,9 /,39,3 40 203907 ,3 -070/:/:,3 !# :8:8 !# 20, 80:7: $03,9 7,,9 3/4308, /,3 907/780:2, ,349, 0, /,07,/,07, ,3 -08,73, -,,3 809,5 /,07, /909,5,3 -07/,8,7 ,9,8  -,,3 2025:3, /:, 5079:3,3 809,5 ,349,803,9/,3809,5  , 503/:/: ,349, 803,9 3/4308, 202 2030:,7,3 8,9: 8047,3, 8:,7, ! !# %/,,/, !# 20, 80:7: 7,,9 3/4308, /,3  907/7/,7,349, $:8:3,3 /,3 0:,8,,3 



%/,,/,803,9/,,2 ,,9003,5,3 30,7,-07/,87&& 



!# 

$:8:3,3 !# /909,5,3 /03,3 &3/,3:3/,3 5,8, ,,9

! 

$:8:3,3 ! /909,5,3 /03,3 && /0,3 3  -070,-,3 202-07 ,,-,3 ,9,8 5079,3,,3 5708/03 /,3 -07,









203,:,3 :8: ! 05,/,5020739, 

 /,9:7 /03,3 &3/,3:3/,3 %/,,/,

 

! ,,2,:33/4308, $:8:3,3 0,349,,3 9/, /-,,8 80.,7, $:8:3,3 /,3 73. ,3, 0:,8,,33, /,9:7 2030-:9,3 8:8:3,3 /03,3 &3/,3:3/,3 0:,8,,3-,/,3-,/,3 10/07, 0,2,3 9: /,9:7 /03,3&& !





! 



:-:3,3 :,7007



43899:,390







$:,9: -,/,3 ,3 9:,83, 0- -,3, /99 -07,9,3 05,/, 93/,,3 ,3 -0781,9 7057081 !708/03 203,3,9 /:9, /,3 438: 5708/03 203072, /:9,30,7,,3

%/,,/,43899:,390 909,5 20303, !# ,3 202 1:38 ,3 ,257 8,2,





! /,39 /03,3 3,2, 0,3 !03,,8 0:,3,3 8:,9: -,/,3 ,3 9:,83, 0-  -,3, /99 -07,9,3 05,/, 93/,,3 ,3  -0781,9203.0,

! /,39 /03,3 3,2, 0,3 !03,,8 0:,3,3 8:,9: -,/,3 ,3 9:,83, 0-  -,3, /99 -07,9,3 05,/, 93/,,3 ,3  -0781,9203.0, ,8: /,,2 /,3 202:9:8,3 507,3,3 /,3 507809::,3 ,3 ,3, /,:,3 40  5708/03 /03,3 :,8, :3/,3:3/,310/07, 43899:,390 /-039: /03,3 ,,3 202507-08,7!#,3 /5 /,3 $03,9 -,7: ,3 /9:3: 8079,





,8: /,,2 /,3 202:9:8,3 507,3,3 /,3 507809::,3 ,3 /,:,3 40 5708/03 ,3, /03,3 :,8, :3/,3:3/,3 43899:,390 907/7 /,7 80:2, ,349, ,3 -08,73, /909,5,3 -07/,8,7 ,9,8 5079:3,3 809,5

/03,3 43899:,390



!03:8:3





,2,







!079,,3,3  0,7,



&&  7,3.,3,33, 90, /809:: 5,/, 9,3,  :  40 !&! /,3 1472,3,  -07,: 80, /8,,3 40!!5,/,9,3,  :89:8  8,25, 9,3,  0802-07  0,7,-07/,87,3,9,8 09:,3,3  !,8, ,,9 0,7, 203,23 0207/0,,3 9,59,5 503/:/: :39: 2020: ,,2,3, 2,832,83 /,3 :39: -07-,/, 203:7:9,,2,3,/,3 0507.,,,33,9: %,59,5 ,7, 30,7,  -07, /,3 ,- :9 8079, /,,2 :8,,

,349,,349, :,7  -,8, 80-,3, :2, ,349,-,8,2,08









43899:8 #$ 7,3.,3,33, /8:8:3 40 ,, 705:- 3/4308, /,3  507902:,3 :39: 2:8,,7,10/07,

,,2 #$ 9/, /80-:9,3 -,, 30,7, -07/,8,7,3 09:,3,3 %/, ,/, 5,8, :8:8 ,3 203,9:7 ,23,3 -, 9,5 503/:/: :39: 2020: /,3 -07-,/, 203:7:9 ,,2, /,3 0507.,,,33,

0- /80-:9,3 705:- 807,9

85081 9039,7, 3/4308, -079:,8

 , 503/:/: ,7, 30,7, 3/4308, 202 8047,3 , 5,8,,,9 







&&$  3 /7,3.,3 40 5,39, ,-:3,3 ,39,7, #05:- 3/4308, $07,9/03,3#05:- 3/4308,

0,7, -07/,8,7,3 09:,3,3 20 5,8, ,,9 0,7, 203,23 0207/0,,3 9,59,5 503/:/: :39: 2020: /,3 -07-,/, 203:7:9 ,,2, /,3 0507.,,,33,2,83 2,83

3,9,3 !07,3 #05:- 3/4308, -079:,8 203/:3 050393,3

 502-0,,330,7, 





!708/03 /03,3 507809:,:,3 !# 203,9,,3 507,3 202-:,9 507/,2,,3 /,3 507,3,3 /03,3 30,7,,3 !708/03 5020,3 0:,8,,3 ,3 90793 ,9,8   /,3& %/,/0,8,3









$892 !020739,,3



!020739,,3 ,07,





$8902 5020739,,3 !708/039 %/,9075073.,703, /,9:7 02-, /03,3 &&





203/:3 050393,3 050393,3 #$ 5,8, ,,9 !020739, 9/, 203,9,,3 507,3 20,3,3 , 9: /3,340!#/,3 $03,9 !708/03 ,, !,32, 907939039,7,#$

050393,330,7,# 





!020739, , 507: 203,7: 9039,7, /-,, 8047,3 5,32, :2:2 230907 5079,,3,3 /,5,9 /9:3: 207,3,5,-,9,39: $8902 502073,9,,3  5,70203907 0,8,3 80.,7, 73. 20303, ,9:7,3 /,7 30,7, -,,3 /,7 ,,9 003,5,3  50,8,3,,3 5020739,,3 , 0,-,3 ,/23897,8 /





!708/03 9/, 203,9,,3 507,3 20,3,3 , , 9: /3,30-/::40 !# !708/03 2020,3 0:,8,,3 90793 ,9,8 !# ,,2 0,/,,3 507,3  5020739, 203025,9,3 ! /-,, 8047,3  5,32,-08,7

$8902 5020739,,3  5,70203907 %/, /0,8,3 80.,7, 73. ,3, /80-:9,3  -,, 9,59,5 /,07,  -07, 203:7:87:2, 9,3,3,803/7808:, /03,3&&



&3/,3 :3/,3



0:,8,3 507:3/,3 :3/,3,3 /,8,3,,3 ,39,7, 5020739,  -078,2,!#



0:,8,,3 507:3/,3 :3/,3,3 /,:,3 40 !020739,  -078,2,!#/,3$03,9



0:,8,3 507:3/,3 :3/,3,3 /,8,3,,3 ,39,7, 5020739,  -078,2,!#

,19,7!:89,,

,5,309,9072344$0,7,/,3,,79,05/-:/ /3,3::3,8:943857,8!020739,,343899:843,/3/4308,,,79,!:89,,&9,2,7,19 ,7,94030/!/,3:7444948:8,394$0,7,,843,3/4308,',,79,,,!:89,, #.01$0,7,3/4308,4/0734,,79,,/,,/,&3;0789!7088 4 :83,7/ /,3 ,72, -7,2  !03,39,7 ::2 %,9, 0,7, 3/40308, ,,79, !:8,9 $9:/ ::2 %,9, 0,7, &/,3'$3,7,9