Pasien yang Menolak Tindakan Medis
Kelompok VI
03007144
LINTA ISNA H
03008097
FANI SAFITRI
03007152
MARCELIA ANDHITA S
03008102
FERDY
03008006
ADINDA PUSPITA DEWI
03008144
LUSTIKA IMA PRANASARI
03008010
AGRA CESARIENNE P
03008145
LYSTIANA
03008052
AZHARI GANESHA
03008303
SITI NASIRAH T AHMAD
03008053
AZZAHRA AZMI
Fakultas Kedokteran Universitas Trisakti Jakarta, 29 Januari 200
P!"#$%U&U$"
1
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
K$'U'
2
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
P!M($%$'$" K$'U'
3
'kenario I
N S 35 !+., *+!+, (%&+! #( )(.+ #/","# (*+ *(, +, #(/.+, .!+-+ !"*+# *+$+! .+, +"% #("/ S(!"+$ #+/" ",", +# $(%/. *"!&/&, *(,+, -(-+#+" #+!(!(% S(!(/+ *"/+#.#+, $(-(%"#)++, /(,#+$ !(%-+).# #&/&,&)#&$" *"!(-.#+, +*+,+ !.-&% $+*+ *+(%+ #&/&, +, -(,*()+# <()"#+ .%",+%"+ )(",+ -(,(+#+, #()./"!+, +# D!(% -(,+,.%#+, .,!.# *"/+#.#+, !",*+#+, (*+ $(,+,#+!+, !.-&% -(,",+! !.-&%,+ (/.- )((%+$+ ()+% NS *+, #(/.+%+,+ )(!.. )+%+, *!(% *+, -(,+,*+!+,+," ",'&%-(* &,)(,! Pem)a*asan +
T",*+#+, *!(% ).*+ !($+! #+%(,+ )().+" *(,+, )!+,*+% -(*") +"!. -(,(/+)#+, #($+*+ $+)"(, !(,!+, $(,+#"!,+ *+, -(,"+$#+, ",'&%-(* &,)(,! .,!.# *"!+,*+!,+," &/( $+)"(, )(!(/+ -(-",!+ $(%)(!..+, $+)"(, *+, #(/.+%+,+ (%*+)+%#+, .#.- #(*!(%+, !..+, !",*+#+, -(*") +, .!+-+ +*+ *.+ +"!. = 1 M(,(+##+, *"+,&)") ;!.-&% +, -(,(#+, <()"#+ .%",+%"+: 2 M(/+#)+,+#+, !(%+$" ;&$(%+)" $(,+,#+!+, !.-&%: K(-.*"+, )+%+! /(+/ *"/+#.#+,,+ !",*+#+, -(*") +%.) -(,+#.$ !"+ +/ = 1 I>", $+)"(, = (%.$+ ",'&%-(* &,)(,! ;*+/+- #+).) "," *!(% !(/+ -(/+#.#+, !",*+#+, +, !($+! #+%(,+ !(/+ -(,(/+)#+, !",*+#+, +#+, +, *"/+#.#+, *+, $+)"(, )(%!+ #(/.+%+ !(/+ -(,(!..",+: T",*+#+, -(*") +%.) *"*+)+%" $%",)"$ -&%+/ = + ?!&,&-" (,('"(,( N&,-+/('""(,( * @.)!"'"#+)" 2 A/+)+, -(,.%.! "/-. #(*!(%+, = ",*"#+)" -(*") ;*+/+- +/ "," $+)"(, *"!(-.#+, !.-&% +, -(,(#+, ()"#+ U%",+%"+ +, -(%.$+#+, ",*"#+)" *"/+#.#+,,+ $(,+,#+!+, !.-&% -(/+/." $(-(*++,: 4
3 C+%+ +, +#.B )!+,*+% -(,.%.! "/-. #(*!(%+, = )!+,*+% -(*") ;*+/+- # +).) "," *!(% -(,(%+$#+, )!+,*+% $(-(*++, +, )().+": D+)+% .#.- I,'&%-(* C&,)(,!= 1 U,*+,.,*+, ,& 29 !+., 2004 !(,!+, $%+#!"# #(*!(%+, I,'&%-(* &,)(,! +*+/+ $(%)(!..+, $+)"(, .,!.# -(,+/+," !",*+#+, -(*") )(!(/+ *"+ -(-++-" %(,+,+ !",*+#+, !(%)(.! 2 PERMENKES 585B 89 = P(%)(!..+, ")+ )(+%+ /")+,B !(%!./") S(!(/+ $+)"(, -(,*+$+!#+, ",'&%-+)" +, +*(#.+! !(,!+, !",*+#+, *+, '+#!&% %")"#&,+ K(.,++, ",'&%-(* &,)(,! = 1 S(++" .#!" !(%!./") $(%)(!..+, !",*+#+, -(*") 2 M(-+. #(!(/"!"+, *+, #(+!"+!"+, *!(% 3 M(,",#+!#+, $(,+-"/+, #($.!.)+, +, %+)"&,+/ 4 M(,",*+%" $(,"$.+, *+, $(-(%+)+, 5 D!(% !(%",*+% )(+%+ .#.- *+%" #(++/+, +, .#+, #(/+/+"+, S(!"+$ !",*+#+, ",<+)"' +%.) +*+ ",'&%-(* &,)(,! !(%!./") *+, $+)"(, +%.) ).*+ -(-++-" %")"#& *+, ('(# )+-$", D!(% $(%/. -(,(/+)#+, )(+%+ )",#+! *+, (/+) )(%!+ -(,.,+#+, ++)+ +, -.*+ *"-(,(%!" &/( $+)"(, )(-.+ $(%","+, !(%+$" -./+" *+%" $%( &$ )+-$+" $&)!&$ H+/ "," !(/+ *")(.!#+, *+/+- PERMENKES 585 $+)+/ 6 ++ ",'&%-+)" +%.) *"(%"#+, &/( *!(% +, -(/+#.#+, &$(%+)"
Y+, *+$+! -(-(%"#+, $(%)(!..+, ",'&%-(* &,)(,! = 1 P(%)(!..+, &/( $+)"(, *(+)+ +, )(+! -(,!+/ -","-+/ 21 !+., +!+. !(/+ -(,"#+
5
2 @"#+ $+)"(, !"*+# )(+! )(+%+ -(,!+/ *+$+! *"+#"/#+, &/( +/" 3 K(/.+%+ !(%*(#+! "#+ !"*+# )(+! -(,!+/ +!+. (/.- 21 !+., @"#+ *!(% -(/+#.#+, !",*+#+, -(*") ",<+)"' !+,$+ ",'&%-(* &,)(,! -+#+ *",++$ -(,+,"++ M+!(%" +, !(%*+$+! *+/+- ",'&%-(* &,)(,! = 1 P%&)(*.% !",*+#+, -(*") M(,+#.$ = A/+!+/+! +, *"$(%/.#+, +"+, !.. +, !(%#(,+ #(-.,#",+, ,(%" +, !"-./ #(-.,#",+, $(%/.+)+, &$(%+)" ;)(!(/+ &$(%+)" +%. *"(%"!+.#+, #($+*+ $+)"(, *+, #(/.+%+,+: 2 R")"#& +, -.,#", !(%+*" 3 M+,'++! !",*+#+, 4 A/!(%,+!"' !",*+#+, 5 P%&,&)") "/+ !"*+# *"/+#.#+, &$(%+)" "," 6 P(%#"%++, "++ 7 T..+, !",*+#+, -(*") .,!.# !(%+$" +!+. *"+,&)") D+/+- #+).) "," !..+,,+ .,!.# !(%+$" 'kenario II + S++! $(-(*++, *"/+#.#+, *!(% -(,(-.#+, +,+# !(%+*" $(%/(,#(!+, *+,
!(%,+!+ #+%)",&-+ $%"-(%,+ +*+ $+*+ &<+%".- #"%" D"+*+$#+, $+*+ #(,+!++, +, +*+ )++! "!. *+, #&,*")" $+)"(, +, -(/(-+ *!(% )((%+ -(-.!.)#+, .,!.# -(/+#.#+, %()(#)" #&/&, *+, -(,+,#+! &<+%".-,+ !+,$+ #&,)./!+)" *./. *(,+, *!(% &, Pem)a*asan+
K(/&-$ #+-" -(,(-.#+#+, ((%+$+ +/+)+,
$%& *+, #&,!%+ !(%+*+$ !",*+#+, +,
*"/+#.#+, &/( *!(% = P-
K-"T$
6
1 D!(% *"(,+%#+, -(,+,#+! &<+%".- 1 NS !"*+# #&-$(!(, #+%(,+ *+/+- #(+*++, +$+"/+ *" ",'&%-(* &,)(,! !(/+ *"",'&%-+)"#+, !"*+# )+*+% -(,(,+" !",*+#+, /+", +, *"$(%/.#+,
2 D!(% -(,+,#+! &<+%".- !+,$+ ">", *+%"
2 D" ",'&%-(* &,)(,! %()(#)" #&/&, *+, $+)"(, $+*++/ .-.% $+)"(, -+)" 35 !+., $(,+,#+!+, &<+%".- *+$+! *"-+).##+, #( *+, $%&*.#!"' I," +#+, (%$(,+%. ()+% *+/+- #(-.,#",+, $(%/.+)+, &$(%+)"
!(%+*+$
3 D!(% -(-"#"%#+, $%",)"$ (,('"(,( "#+ !",*+#+,
!(%)(.!
!"*+#
*"/+#.#+,
#(-+-$.+,
%($%&*.#)"
D!(%
*"+,+$ -(/+,+% $%",)"$ +.!&,&-"
)((%+ 3 D!(% )(+%.),+ -(-",!+ ">", #($+*+
*"#++!"%#+, #&,*")" $+)"(, +#+, )(-+#", #(/.+%+ $+)"(, +!+. (%#&,)./!+)" *+./. -(-.%.#
*(,+, *!(% &, +, +/"
4 P+)+/ 7 ++! 285 !(,!+, $(%/.+)+, &$(%+)" 4 D!(% "," -.,#", (%#&-$(!(,)" .,!.# *"&/(#+, .,!.# -(,(/+-+!#+, "+ $+)"(, 5 D"/"+! *+%" )(" #($.!.)+, (!"# *!(% -(/+#)+,+#+, (,('"(,( ;.,!.# #($(,!",+,
-(,+,#+!
6 *!(% (%.)++ -(,(+ -(!+)!+)") /(" /+,.! ;(,('"(,(:
#"%"
!+$"
!"*+#
(%(,+, .,!.# -(/+#.#+,,+ #+%(,+ "!. "/++ #&-$(!(,)" *!(% &,
$+)"(,: *+, ,&, -+/('""(,( ;!"*+# -(%."#+, 5 $+)"(,:
&<+%".-
D!(%
-(/+#.#+,
.-+,
(%%&%
S(+%.),+ )(+#!. *"/+#.#+, $(-(%"#)++, ++/ *!(% +%.) .%"+ .+ "," -(%.$+#+, !.-&% -(!+)!+)") *+, -(-(%"#)+ &%+, /+", *")(#"!+%,+ ,+-., *!(% +,+ '.) .,!.# -(,+!+)" #(/.+, .!+-+ +"!. ).)+ AK #+%(,+ +*+ !.-&% 6 (%*+)+%#+, )!+,*+% &$(%+)"&,+/ -(*") *!(% *"+,+$ -(/+,+% #+%(,+ !"*+# *" "&$)" !(%/(" *+./. .,!.# $(-(%"#)++, /(" /+,.! .,!.# -(,(!+." )!+*".- C+
'kenario III
7
S(!(/+ &$(%+)" #&,*")" $+)"(, !+-$+# -(-+"# *+, *!(% )((%+ -(-(%"#+, #(-&!(%+$" )(%!+ $(,",+%+, A#"+! ('(# )+-$", #(-&!(%+$" *+, $(,",+%+, "!. NS -(%+)+#+, $(,*(%"!++, +, /.+% "+)+ !"*+# ")+ -+#+, #+%(,+ )+,+! -.+/ *+, ,(%" +, !"*+# !(%!++,#+, N S /+/. -(,&/+# !(%+$" -(*") *+, -(-"/" $(,&+!+, +/!(%,+!"' Pem)a*asan +
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
Pandangan $gama tentang Terapi $lternati.
8
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kenario IV
P+)"(, -(%+)+ !(%+$" !"*+# -(-(%" -+,'++! *+, -(,"-./#+, +,+# -+)+/+ )(",+ $+)"(, -(,&/+# $(,&+!+, +$+$., *+, -(-"/" !",+/ *" %.-+ P+)"(, -(,+*+%" "*.$,+ !"*+# /+-+ /+" *+, $(,+#"!,+ !"*+# ")+ *"&+!"
Pem)a*asan +
PR? NS
K?NTRA NS
9
1 P(,&+!+, *(,+, #(-&!(%+$" )(/+", )+#"!
1 N S -+)" -.*+ ;35 !+.,: )(+%.),+
.+ -(,(/.+%#+, "++ +, ()+% +)"/,+
!"*+# (%$.!.) +)+ /+"$./+ )(!(/+ &$(%+)"
$., (/.- !(,!. *+$+! )(-. T& ..,
*"/+#.#+, #&,*")" $+)"(, !+-$+# -(-+"#
..,,+ -+,.)"+ +#+, -+!" .+
2 H"*.$ *+, -+!" )+#"! *+, )(-. T.+,
2 M(,&/+# )(-.+ $(,&+!+, -(%.$+#+, +# NS
+, -(,(,!.#+, -+,.)"+ +%.) (%.)++ 3 M(,&/+# )(+/+ -++- $(,&+!+,
3 NS !"*+# -(-"/"#" -&!"<+)" .,!.# )(-.
!(%-+).# .,. *"%" )(+%+ !"*+# /+,).,
4 N S !"*+# ",", -(%($&!#+, #(/.+%+,+
S&/.)" +, *+$+! *"(%"#+, = 1 M(,*(#+!#+, *"%" #($+*+ T.+, )().+" *(,+, + +-+ +, N S +,.! 2 T(!+$ -(,+/+,#+, $&/+ "*.$ +, )(+! 3 P(%+, #(/.+%+ )+,+! *".!.#+, .,!.# -(-(%" -&!"<+)" #($+*+ N S 4 N S *+$+! *"+,.%#+, .,!.# -(,"#.!" %&$ #&,)(/", *(,+, )()+-+ $(,*(%"!+ C+ .,!.# )+/", -(,(-+,+!" *+, -(-(%" -&!"<+)" ++% !(%.) (%#+%+ *+/+- "*.$
TI"J$U$" PU'T$K$
10
M(,.%.! N+!"&,+/
C(,!(%
'&%
C&-$/(-(,!+%
+,*
A/!(%,+!"<(
M(*"",(
;NCCAM: P(,&+!+, +/!(%,+!"<( *+$+! *"#+!(&%"#+, -(,+*" 5 #+!(&%" +, #+*+,#+/+ )+!. (,") $(,&+!+, ")+ -(,+#.$ ((%+$+ #+!(&%"5: = / $lternative Medial 'ystem1 %ealing 'ystem non medis
T(%*"%" *+%" H&-(&$+! N+!.%&$+! A.%<(*+ *+, T%+*"!"&,+/ C",()( M(*"",( ;)(/+,.!,+ *")",#+! TCM: 2/ Mind (ody Intervention
T(%*"%" +!+) M(*"!+)" A.!&(,") R(/+#)+)" P%&%()"' T(%+$" K%(+!"' ").+/")+)" K%(+!"' H$,&!(%+$ N(.%&/",.")!"# P%&%+--", ;NLP: %+", G- *+, + F/&(% R(-(* 3/ Terapi (iologis
T(%*"%" *+%" T(%+$" H(%+/ T(%+$" N.!%")" F&&* C&-",", T(%+$" @.) M+#%&"&!"# T(%+$" U%",( C&/&, H*%&!(%+$
4/ Manipulasi $nggota Tu)u*
T(%*"%" +!+) P"+!BM+))+( A%&-+!(%+$ H*%&!(%+$ P"/+!() C"%&$%+!" Y&+ T(%+$" C%+,"&)+%+/ T(#,"# .!(#&
5/ Terapi !nergi
T(%*"%" *+%" A#.$.,#!.% A#.$%()).% R('/(#)"&/&" C" K., T+" C" R("#" *+, P%+,+ (+/",
%u)ungan %ukum #okter 6 Pasien
H..,+, *!(% *(,+, $+)"(, +*+/+ ..,+, +, .,"# *!(% )(++" $(-(%" $(/++,+, #()(+!+, *+, $+)"(, )(++" $(,(%"-+ $(/++,+, #()(+!+, D!(% +, $+#+% *+, $+)"(, +, 11
++- *!(% +, )(+! *+, $+)"(, +, )+#"!
H..,+, !+,.,++ !"*+# )("-+, "!. -(,(+#+, $+)"(, +, #+%(,+ #(++-+,,+ !"*+# -(,(!+." +$+ +, !(%+*" $+*+ +#!. !",*+#+, -(*"# *"/+#.#+, +/ "," *"-.,#",#+, #+%(,+ ",'&%-+)" *+%" *!(% !"*+# )(/+/. *"-(,(%!" &/( $+)"(,
S(%",#+/" $+)"(, !"*+# -(,(%!" "!. -(,*.+ !(/+ !(%+*" #()+/++,B#(/+/+"+, )(",+ *!(% *"-",!+ .,!.# -(,+,!" #(%."+, +, *"*(%"!+,+ Y+, )(%",#+/" -(,+*" $(,*+$+! +, )+/+ +*+/+ ++ )(!"+$ #()+/++,B#(/+/+"+, +, *"$(%.+! &/( *!(% +%.) -(,*+$+! +,!"%." +#+, #+*+,#+*+, #+/+. +*+ )().+!. +/ +, *"*.+ !(%+*" -+/$%+#!(# -+#+ *"$+#+" &/( $+)"(, )(++" #()(-$+!+, .,!.# -(-+#)+ *!(% -(-++% +,!" %."
P+*+ $(,(,!.+, (%)+/+ !"*+#,+ *!(% *+, $(-++%+, +,!" %." +%.) *".#!"#+, !(%/(" *+./. *+, *"!(,!.#+, &/( +#"- *" P(,+*"/+, M+)+/+,+ *!(% )+,+! %(,!+, !(%+*+$ $./"#+)" )(",+ )(%",#+/" *!(% +, (,+, -(,+*" )&%&!+, *" -(*"+ -+))+ -(-++% #&-$/+", $+)"(, !+,$+ -(/+/." $%&)() .#.-
K()+/++, "," )(%", *")+/+ .,+#+, &/( $+)"(, -(,(+#+, *!(% +#+, -(/",*.," *"%",+ *(,+, (%++" +%+ .,!.# -(,",*+%" .+!+, *+%" $+)"(, S+/+ )+!. +%+ +"!. *(,+, -(,+/"#+, !+,.,++ #($+*+ $"+# #(!"+ +"!. +).%+,)" +!+. (#(%+ (#)!%+ +!"+!" P+*+ "/"%+,,+ $+)"(, .+ +, %." #+%(,+ "++ $(,&+!+, -(,+*" /(" ()+% *+, $+)"(, +, +%.) -(,+,., (+,
S((,+%,+ #()+/++, +!+. #(/+/+"+, *!(% *+/+- -(/+#)+,+#+, $%&'()" -(*") -(%.$+#+, ).+!. +/ +, $(,!", .,!.# *""+%+#+, *+, *"#(!+." &/( $+%+ *!(% $+*+ .-.-,+ +/ "," *")(+#+, #+%(,+ +#"+! #()+/++, *+, #(/+/+"+, *+$+! -(,"-./#+, *+-$+# +, )+,+! -(%."#+, S(/+", -(%.)+# +!+. -(,.%+," #($(%+++, -+)+%+#+! !(%+*+$ $%&'()" #(*!(%+, .+ -(,"-./#+, #(%."+, $+*+ $+)"(, U,!.# -(-++-" +*+ !"*+#,+ #()+/++, +!+. #(/+/+"+, !(%)(.! !(%/(" *+./. #()+/++, +!+. #(/+/+"+, $(/+#)+,++, $%&'()" +%.) *"/(!+##+, (%+*+$+, *(,+, #(+"+, $%&'()" *" )+-$", -(-$(%+!"#+, +)$(# .#.- +, -(,*+)+%" !(%+*",+ ..,+, .#.- +,!+%+ *!(% *(,+, $+)"(, +, (%).-(% $+*+ 12
!%+,)+#)" !(%+$(.!"#
K+/+. *"/"+! *+%" #++ -+!+ .#.- ..,+, +,!+%+ $+)"(, *(,+, *!(% !(%-+).# *+/+%.+, /",#.$ $(%+,"+, ;!%+,)+#)" !(%+$(.!"#: #+%(,+ +*+,+ #()+,.$+, *+%" *!(% .,!.# -(,.$++#+, #()(+!+, +!+. #()(-.+, $+)"(, )(+/"#,+ $+)"(, -(,(!.." !",*+#+, !(%+$(.!"# +, *"/+#.#+, &/( *!(% !(%)(.! P(%+,"+, !(%+$(.!"# -(-"/"#" )"'+! *+, "%" +, #.).) !"*+# )+-+ *(,+, )"'+! *+, "%" $(%+,"+, $+*+ .-.-,+ #+%(,+ &(# $(%+,"+, *+/+- !%+,)+#)" !(%+$(.!"# .#+, #()(-.+, $+)"(, -(/+",#+, -(,+%" .$++ +, !($+! .,!.# #()(-.+, $+)"(, P(%+,"+, *!(% *(,+, $+)"(, !(%-+).# $+*+ $(%+,"+, !(,!+, .$++ +!+. *")(.! ; I,)$+,",)<(%",!(,") : .#+, $(%+,"+, !(,!+, +)"/ +!+. *")(.! ; R()./!++!<(%",!(,") : H..,+, .#.- +,!+%+ $+)"(, *(,+, *!(% *+$+! !(%+*" +,!+%+ /+", #+%(,+ $+)"(, )(,*"%" +, -(,*+!+," *!(% .,!.# -(-",!+ $(%!&/&,+, -(,&+!" )+#"! +, *"*(%"!+,+ *+/+- #(+*++, )($(%!" "," !(%+*" $(%)(!..+, #((,*+# +,!+%+ #(*.+ (/+ $"+# *+, !(%+*" ..,+, .#.- +, (%).-(% *+%" #($(%+++, $+)"(, !(%+*+$ *!(% )(",+ $+)"(, (%)(*"+ -(-(%"#+, $(%)(!..+, !",*+#+, -(*"# ; ",'&%-(* &,)(,! :
D" I,*&,()"+ ",'&%-(* &,)(,! !(/+ -(-$(%&/( .)!"'"#+)" .%"*") -(/+/." P(%+!.%+, M(,!(%" K()(+!+, RI N& 585BM(,#()B1989 +P(%)(!..+, !",*+#+, -(*"# ;",'&%-(* &,)(,!: *+/+ $%+#!"# +,+# -(,+/+-" #(,*+/+ #+%(,+ '+#!&% ++)+ '+#!&% +-$.% !+,+, #(/.+%+ +!+. $"+# #(!"+ *+/+- +/ -(-(%"#+, $(%)(!..+, '+#!&% $(%(*++, #($(,!",+, +,!+%+ *!(% *+, $+)"(, *+, '+#!&% /+",,+
S(+ *+/+- #&,)($ "," *!(% +,+ (%#(+"+, -(/+#.#+, $(/++,+, #()(+!+, *(,+, $(,. #().,.+, *(,+, -(,(%+#+, )(/.%. #(-+-$.+, *+, $(%+!"+,,+ )().+" *(,+, )!+,*+%* $%&'()",+ @+*" S(&%+, *!(% *+$+! *"#+!+#+, -(/+#.#+, #()+/++, +!+. #(/+/+"+, *+/+- -(,+/+,#+, $%&'()",+ +$+"/+ *"+ !"*+# -(-(,." #(+"+,,+ *(,+, +"# +, (%*+)+%#+, #(-+-$.+, !(%!"," +, *"-"/"#",+ )().+" *(,+, )!+,*+%* &$(%+)"&,+/ ;S?P:
P!'!TUJU$" #$" P!"-&$K$" T!%$#$P TI"#$K$" M!#I'
13
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
T..+, *+%" ",'&%-(* &,)(,! +*+/+ ++% $+)"(, -(,*+$+! ",'&%-+)" +, .#.$ .,!.# *+$+! -(,+-"/ #($.!.)+, +!+) !(%+$" +, +#+, *"/+#)+,+#+, I,'&%-(* &,)(,! .+ (%+%!" -(,+-"/ #($.!.)+, (%)+-+ H+# $+)"(, .,!.# -(,(,!.#+, ,+)",+ *+$+! !(%$(,." *(,+, )(-$.%,+ +$+"/+ $+)"(, !(/+ -(,(%"-+ )(-.+ ",'&%-+)" +, "+ $(%/.#+, )(",+ "+ *+$+! -(,+-"/ #($.!.)+, +, !($+! K(#(.+/"+, *+$+! *".+! +$+"/+ ",'&%-+)" +, *"(%"#+, *+$+! -(,(+#+, .,+,+, $)"#") $+*+ $+)"(, D!(% +%.) -(,+*+%" ++ ",'&%-(* &,)(,! -(-"/"#" *+)+% -&%+/ *+, (!"# +, #.+! M(,.%.! A-(%"+, C&//(( &' P)""+,) E!") M+,.+/ $+)"(, +%.) -(,*+$+! ",'&%-+)" *+, -(,(%!" !(,!+, #&,*")",+ )((/.- -(,+-"/ #($.!.)+, (%(*+ *(,+, !(&%" !(%*+./. +, -(-+,*+, !"*+# +*+,+ ",'&%-(* &,)(,! -(,.%.! .#.- $(,+,"+++, #"," +/ "," *"+,+$ )(++" #(/+/+"+, I,'&%-+)" +, *"(%"#+, +%.) /(,#+$ !"*+# +,+ (%.$+ +++, +!+) $(%!+,++, $+)"(, S.+!. ",'&%-(* &,)(,! +%.) -(/"$.!" = 1
D!(% +%.) -(,(/+)#+, $+*+ $+)"(, -(,(,+" !",*+#+, !(%+$" *+, $(,+#"!,+
14
2
P+)"(, +%.) *"(%"!+. !(,!+, +)"/ !(%+$" +, *"+%+$#+, *+, )((%+$+ ()+% #(-.,#",+, #((%+)"/+,,+
3
P+)"(, +%.) *"(%"!+. -(,(,+" ((%+$+ +/!(%,+!"' +, +*+ *+, +#"+! +$+"/+ $(,+#"! !"*+# *"&+!"
4
P+)"(, +%.) *"(%"!+. -(,(,+" %")"#& +$+"/+ -(,(%"-+ +!+. -(,&/+# !(%+$"
R")"#& +, +%.) *")+-$+"#+, -(/"$.!" ('(# )+-$", +, -.,#", !(%+*" *+/+- $(,.,++, &+! +!+. !",*+#+, $(-(%"#)++, *+, &$(%+)" +, *"/+#.#+, %$& %$& 8$" #II"F-M$'IK$" %asil Pemeriksaan
P+)"(, -(-"/"#" +# .,!.# -(,(!+." +)"/ $(-(%"#)++, +, !(/+ *"/+#.#+, M")+/,+ $(%.++, #(+,+)+, $+*+ +)"/ P+$ )-(+% A$+"/+ ",'&-+)" ).*+ *"(%"#+, -+#+ #($.!.)+, )(/+,.!,+ (%+*+ *" !+,+, $+)"(, isiko
R")"#& +, -.,#", !(%+*" *+/+- !(%+$" +%.) *".,#+$#+, *")(%!+" .$++ +,!")"$+)" +, *"/+#.#+, *!(% .,!.# !(%+*",+ +/ !(%)(.! R(+#)" +/(%" "*"&)",#%+!"# *+, #(-+!"+, +, !+# !(%*.+ +#"+! $(,&+!+, )(/+-+ "," +%+, *".,#+$#+, *!(% S(+"+, #+/+,+, (%$(,*+$+! ++ #(-.,#",+, !(%)(.! .+ +%.) *"(%"!+. $+*+ $+)"(, @"#+ )(&%+, *!(% -(,(!+." ++ !",*+#+, $(,&+!+,,+ (%")"#& *+, !(%*+$+! +/!(%,+!"' $(,&+!+, /+", +, /(" +-+, "+ +%.) -(-(%"!+.#+,,+ $+*+ $+)"(, @"#+ )(&%+, *!(% !"*+# +#", $+*+ #(-+-$.+,,+ .,!.# -(/+#.#+, ).+!. $%&)(*.% !(%+$" *+, !(%*+$+! *!(% /+", +, *+$+! -(/+#.#+,,+ "+ +" -(-(%"!+.#+, $+*+ $+)"(, $lternati.
D!(% +%.) -(,.,#+$#+, ((%+$+ +/!(%,+!"' *+/+- $%&)() *"+,&)") *+, !(%+$" I+ +%.) *+$+! -(,(/+)#+, $%&)(*.% -+,'++! #(%."+, *+, +++ +, *"!"-./#+, *+%" ((%+$+ $"/"+, !(%)(.! S(++" &,!& +*+/+ !(%+$" "$(%!"%&"*")-( T(%*+$+! !"+ $"/"+, !(%+$" +"!. 15
&+! "&*".- %+*"&+#!"' *+, ).!&!+/ !"%&"*(#!&-" D!(% +%.) -(,(/+)#+, $%&)(*.% #((%+)"/+, *+, #(%."+, )(%!+ #&-$/"#+)" +, -.,#", !"-./ u:ukan1 konsultasi
D!(% (%#(+"+, -(/+#.#+, %..#+, +$+"/+ "+ -(,+*+%" ++ #(-+-$.+, *+, $(,(!+.+, +, "+ -"/"#" #.%+, .,!.# -(/+#)+,+#+, !(%+$" $+*+ $+)"(,$+)"(, !(%!(,!. P(,+*"/+, -(,+!+#+, ++ *!(% +%.) -(%..# )++! "+ -(%+)+ !"*+# -+-$. -(/+#)+,+#+, !(%+$" #+%(,+ #(!(%+!+)+, #(-+-$.+,,+ *+, "+ -(,(!+." +*+,+ *!(% /+", +, *+$+! -(,+,+," $+)"(, !(%)(.! /(" +"# *+%",+ Prognosis
P+)"(, (%+# -(,(!+." )(-.+ $%&,&)") #&-$/"#+)" )(#.(/( #(!"*+#,+-+,+, "++ #()./"!+, *+, %")"#& *+%" )(!"+$ $"/"+, !(%-+).# !"*+# -(,*+$+! $(,&+!+, +!+. !"*+# -(,*+$+! !",*+#+, +$+$., P+)"(, .+ (%+# -(,(!+." +$+ +, *"+%+$#+, *+%" *+, +$+ +, !(%+*" *(,+, -(%(#+ S(-.+ "," (%*+)+%#+, +!+) #(+*"+,#(+*"+, (%+/+)+, +, *+$+! *"*.+ &/( *!(% K(+*"+, +, +%+, +!+. !"*+# "+)+ .#+, -(%.$+#+, +"+, *+%" ",'&%-(* &,)(,!
16
K!'IMPU&$"
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
17
#$FT$ PU'T$K$
1 S+-$.%,+ .*" Profesi Kedokteran dan Kode Etiknya serta Peran Manajemen Rumah Sakit terhadap kasus Malpraktik. A()) &, @+,.+% 29! 2011 A<+"/+/( +! = !!$=BB'%((()&-B#(#"-+/$%+#!(#B(!"##(*!(%+,!2 P(,&+!+, A/!(%,+!"' K&-$/(-(,!(% A()) &, @+,.+% 29! 2011 A<+"/+/( +! = !!$=BB%.-+(%+/#.&%*$%())&-B2009B02B08B$(,&+!+,+/!(%,+!"'#&-$/(-(,!(% (%)+-.,+1B 3 +"+, K(*!(%+, F&%(,)"# Peraturan Perundang-undangan Bidang Kedokteran @+#+%!+ 1994 4 S+,,&, T&-+) Pengantar Bioetika G%+-(*"+ P.)!+#+ U!+-+ @+#+%!+ 1995
18