UNIVERSIDAD DEL MAGDALENA LECTURA Y ARGUMENTACION
ANALISIS DE SENTENCIAS C-054 - C-820
OLGA LUCIA CASTELLAR cod. 2016143043 DUVAN POVEDA CONTRERAS cod. 2016143142 MIGUEL GARIEL RUI! cod. 2016143165 TA TAYRI "ERLEY SIERR SIERRA A cod. 20161431#3
LIC. DIANA PATRICIA SANC"E!
SANTA MARTA$ MAGDALENA 2016
A%&'()() )*%+*%c(, C-0542016 Numero: C-0542016 Fecha: oo+& D.C.$ d(*/ 10 d* **o d* do) (' d(*c()() 2016. Magistrado ponente: LUIS ERNESTO VARGAS SILVA Aclaran el voto: LUIS GUILLERMO GUERRERO P7RE!$ GARIEL EDUARDO MENDO!A MARTELO$ GLORIA STELLA ORT! DELGADO. Salvan el voto: LUIS ERNESTO VARGAS SILVA Norma demandada. A+9c:'o 2#. C:,%do *' )*%+(do d* ', '*; )*, c',o$ %o )* d*),+*%d*& ): +*%o '(+*,' , <*+*=+o d* co%):'+, ): *)<9(+:. Problema jurídico enunciado por la corte. >E) co<,+('* co% ', Co%)+(+:c(?% ; <,+(c:',*%+* co% *' <(%c(<(o d* ):<*,c9, co%)+(+:c(o%,' d* @:* +,+, *' ,+9c:'o 4 C.P.$ ', %o, d*' C?d(o C(B(' @:*$ ,' d*%( *' +odo d* (%+*<*+,c(?% ,,+(c,'$ d*+*(%, @:* *% c,)o @:* ', d()
3. ', c',(d,d d* :%, d()
Decisión RESUELVE D*c',, EEQUILE ', *=<*)(?% JC:,%do *' )*%+(do d* ', '*; )*, c',o$ %o )* d*),+*%d*& ): +*%o '(+*,' , <*+*=+o d* co%):'+, ): *)<9(+:.K$ co%+*%(d, *% *' ,+9c:'o 2# d*' C?d(o C(B('. Argumento de la decisión Problema jurídico resuelto por la corte E% <(* ':,$ L, Co+* ,dB(*+*$ *% c,(o$ @:* *' +odo ,,+(c,' d* (%+*<*+,c(?% d** *%*%+,)* , B,(,) d(c:'+,d*)$ *',c(o%,d,) +,%+o co% *' d**cFo co%)+(+:c(o%,' coo co% ', +*o9, d*' d**cFo ; ', 'o)o9, co%+*
Argumentos no esenciales. •
•
•
,
!ntervenciones. P"#$AD" %&N&A' D& 'A NA#!"N M*d(,%+* *)c(+o ,d(c,do *% *)+, Co
%o, ,c:),d,$ *% *' *%+*%d(do @:* ', (), J)* *** ,' )*%+(do co%)+(+:c(o%,'*%+* B&'(do d* ', '*; ; %o )(<'**%+* , ): )*%+(do '(+*,'K.
Aclaraciones de votos A#'AA#!+N D& ,")" D&' MA%!S)AD" %A-!&' &D$AD" M&ND"A MA)&'" A 'A S&N)&N#!A #/012345 E% '+(,) o<+,o)
A LA SENTENCIA C-05416 1. E)+o; d* ,c:*do co% ', ,:*%+,c(?% co%+*%(d, *% ', )*%+*%c(,$ ', c:,' :%9Boc,*%+* o'(, , co%c':( @:* *' +odo d* (%+*<*+,c(?% ,,+(c,' *)+&$ *% +od, c(c:%)+,%c(,$ ):<*d(+,do , ', *c,c(, d*' <(%c(<(o d* ):<*,c9, co%)+(+:c(o%,'$ ,)9 coo ,' B,'o %o,+(Bo d* ', C,+, Po'9+(c,. 2. E)+, od,'(d,d d* d*c()(?% )* o)+,, %*c*),(,$ , <,+( d* d()+(%+o) ,:*%+o). E% <(* ':,$ ', )*%+*%c(, ,):* ,c*+,d,*%+* @:* ):)()+*% *% *' od*% :9d(co do) co<*%)(o%*) d*' <*c*<+o ,c:),do :%, o,'()+,$ @:* <o<:%,
', %o, d*,%d,d, +(*%* (d%+(co co%+*%(do ,+*(,' ,' d*' ,*%+o o((%,' d*' ,+9c:'o 48 d* ', L*; 2#0 d* 16$ @:* )* **9, , ', (%+*<*+,c(?% d* ', Co%)+(+:c(?% @:*
•
•
•
D* o+, <,+*$ *' ,c+o ,%(*)+? @:* ', (%+*<*+,c(?% '(+*,' d* ',) *=<*)(o%*) J'*;K$ Jd* ,%*, *%*,'K ; J*=<*)(?% o)c:,K$ co%+*%(d,) *% ', d()
esuelve D*c',, EEQUILE *' ,+9c:'o 25 d*' C?d(o C(B('$ E) c(*+o @:* *' ,+. 25 d*' c?d(o c(B('$ *co%oc* ,' '*()',do$ *% o, *=c':)(B, ; *=c':;*%+*$ ', ,c:'+,d <,, , co% ,:+o(d,d '*;*) o)c:,) atio decidendi: E% *' E)+,do co%)+(+:c(o%,'$ ', (%+*<*+,c(?% <,, , *' )*%+(do d* :%, '*; o)c:,$ d* :%, ,%*, *%*,'$ %o *) :%, ,c:'+,d *=c':)(B, d*' '*()',do$ <:*) +,(% *)+& , c,o d* ', Co+* Co%)+(+:c(o%,' c:,%do )+, **c* *' co%+o' d* co%)+(+:c(o%,'(d,d d* ', '*; ; , *' )*%+(do B&'(do d* ', (), S* d*c',, ', *=*@:(('(d,d <:*)+o @:* *' ,+9c:'o 25 d*' C?d(o C(B(' %o F,c* ***%c(, , @:* ',) )*%+*%c(,) d* ', co+* Co%)+(+:c(o%,' @:* )*H,',% ', (%+*<*+,c(?% co%)+(+:c(o%,'*%+* ,:+o(/,d, d* ', '*; )*, o'(,+o(, ; *):'+* B(%c:',%+* d* ,%*, *%*,' "biter dicta: E% *',c(?% co% ',) ,:+o(d,d*) , @:(% co*)
', :d(c(,' ; ', '*()',+(B, o co% ,:+o(d,d. T,(% d*%o(%,d, (%+*<*+,c(?%
Z81#2016 1250[ S,:*' 'o) +(%o) J'*;K ; Jod*%,(*%+o :9d(coK %o )o% )(%?%(o)$ L, %o, ,c:),d, +,
#oncepto del procurador general de la nación J', *=*@:(('(d,d d*' ,+9c:'o 25 d*' C?d(o C(B('$ co% *=c*
L, (%+*<*+,c(?% *,'(/,d,
