accion reinvindicatoria

c


cc c     c cÔ




ÔÔ cÔ





Ô 
Ôc


cccccc  c

c  ccc c cc  cc cc   c   c

c c c c c c(Sec. 33[2], BP 129; RA 7691)cc c c  c c c  c c c c   c

cc c

c c cc c cc c(Sec. 3, Rule 70)c ccccc c   c c  c c c   c c  c cc c  c ! c   "c c  

c cc c c c  c

cc #cc cc c cccc c  c

c c  cc c    c cc c c ccc   c  c c ccc

c c cc c  c c c c cc c c  cccc c c c c  c(Benguet Corp. Cordillera Caraballo Mission, GR 155343, Sept. 2, 2005)c $ccccc% c  c cc c  c cc  ccc

ccc ccc c c

c

 ccc  ccc

c cc c c

c c c(Valdez vs. CA, GR 132424, May 2, 2006)c &ccccc '   c c  c c c   c

c c   c c c  c

c c c

c c   c  c   c   c c  c

c    c  c c    c

c c  c c  c c c   c

c c   c c c  c c  c c    c c c c c  c(Marino, Jr. vs. Alamis, 450 SCRA 198 [2005])c c c c cc cc 
cc cc cc c c c c cc "%%c%c&'()*+c  c   c !c "#c cc ( "c c cc ccccccccccccccccccccccccc(  c c )*+

+* +,-c c ccccc  c / c +( -c-+.
 c - versus ±c 0 -*+1+ -c c *+02+cc c ( +.+cJJc c cc $cc ( "c ccccccccccccccccccccccccc  c cc + c3c445c ccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc cc cc 6c cc c
c c-c*c cc

0 -*+1+ -cJ"c cc % c2 c cc(  7
8c c c cCertiorari cc&9c

cc c

c c : c c  c c 6 78cc
4c c 444cc   7$8c
;c - c 444c

c c  c

c + c c+,c
(c* c99;5
c cc c  cc  cc  cc c   "c cc -c
4c c
55;c
c c c  c c   c  c  c c    c c % c c%c
cc  c ccc c  c  c+  c
cc c c(  cc 7&8c :c c  c c* c
4&<3c cc cc cc  cc c cc c

cc
&c !ccc

cc  c c =  c
  c % c  c c  c  c  c c  c  c

c  c* c9&<3c c ccccc c

c6 c

c% c cc+ c cc  c c

c c c  c c   c c   c c c  c  c    c 

c7 c   8ccc c  ccc ccc c   c c

c c c c c c cc c c cc  ccc.cc  cc  cc cc c cc0 c c cc  ccc

 c c    c

c c c  c c   c c  c  c  c  c  c c c  c  c   c c c c c ccc c ! c   c c c  c  c c  c    c

c c c  c c c  c   cc0c c cc   c

ccc c  c cc cc

cc c  c c c !  c c cc c  c    cc  c c c  c  c c c ccc  c c c  c cbarangayc  c  c

c =  c
  c% c c c c   c  c  c c c cc2 c c c cbarangayc c

cc c c= c+ cc   c  c c* c
4&<3c cc c c   c c   c  c * c
4&<3c c c c   c c c c   c  c  cccc c ccc   c

cc c ccc

 #cc  cccc c ccc(<4444cc(&4444c  cc  c  c  c    c c c  c c  c

c c  c    c

c c c  c  c  c c  c

c c   c  c   c

c c  c    c  c c

  c  c #c c   c c c c  c  c c c($444444c  c c  c(444444c c > c  c   c  cc  c

c  798c cc   ccc cc' c+ c c> c  c c  c c* c
4&<3c c  c' c+ c  cccccccc c   c c  c c* c
4&<3c c c c cc c c  cc c c c ccc  c c c cc c  c  c

c   c

c c  c    c c c    cc c c c c c:cc c c  ccc c c c c cc  cc c c  c

cc c   c  cc c  c c  c

cc  c c c  c

cc cc c

cc c c  c c c c cc c

c  c  cc  c c c c c c c c  c    c c  c  c  cc c

cc  cc c c c  c cc

cc cc cc34c

cc c

c cc c  cc c c c c ccc c c c7<8c cc   c  c c c ' c + c c c c  c  c c c  c c

c c  c   c

cc c c c c cccc

c
534ccc  c  c c c c  c c  c c c  c  c  c  c  c  c  c  cc0c c  c c  cc c

cc cc c c ccc c c cc' c+ cc c c c   ? c c c  c   c

c c c  c  c c  c  c  c c  cc0cc c  c

c ccc  c c  c cc c cc c

cc  c c c c    cc 738cc cc   ccc  c c c c' c+ cc c cc c c    cc  c cc c   c c c c c c c

c  c c c c c

 c  c   c   c  c c  c c  c  cc c  c

c  c    c c c   ?ccc% c  c> c     cc c c c c
553c cc  cc c c  cc% c  ccc c c c   cc

cc    cccc cc  ccc ccc c c c ! c c  c  c c  c    c c  c  c > c c    c c c > c  c  c  c c c c   c cc@7'8 c  c c c

c  c c   c   c   Ac  c c   c c c c c c @:c c   c  c c  78c  c  c  c Ac c c ! c  c

c c  c    c c c  c  c   cc  ccccc c

cc c cc

cc   ccc cc c c' c+ cc c cc  c cc cc c c

cc c ccc  c c cc ccc c@  c c

c  Acc+ c  c c

c  cc  cc c ccc c c

c   c

cc c c c c c B c cc c   cc c cc +ccc

c c' c+ c  ccc :ccc c  c> c   #c c c c c B c cc c   cc c cc  c

c > c  c  c c c   c c 

c  c  c  c c  c  c  c c   c c c  c  B c  c c c   c c  c c  c c c c   c c c cc($944444c > c  7;8c cc + c  c

c c   >c   c   c  c c c   c c c c c 6 758c c   c  c * c
4&<3c c
c c
555c   c ccc c c c c c    c c c  c c c   c c c c  c   c c 

c  c c

c  ccc cccc c

c(<4444cc(&4444c  cc  c  c  c    c c c  c c c

c c  c    c

c c c  c c  ccc

cc  c

cc  cc cc c  ccc c ccc cc c c c  ccc c cc ccc c c

c(444444c c > c  cc   c  c cc   c c c c c c 6 c  c c  c  c  c c% c c %c 9cc c c  c  :c  c   c  c * c &&$9cc-c5c - c 7
48


555c c c  c  c 6 

c

 cin totocc c c 6 cc-c

  ccc c cc c

c+ c cc c c cc cc cc   > c c  c c  c

c + c  c  :c  c +,c
(c * c 99;5
cc6 c  ccc c c4c'c444

7

8

c+ c c  cc c
4cc

444c c  c

c + c c  c 6 c  c  c c 6  c

c  c c c c c c c   c > c   c c   c  c * c
4&<3ccc c  c c c > c   c  c c c  c  c c  c     c

c  c c c  c  ccc   c c c   c c  c c    c  c  c c  c  c c  c  c c   c c  c  c c  c c c c c

 c c c

c  c  cc   c

cccc  !cc c

c+ c  ccccc c   c cc  c c  c c* c
4&<37
8c cc c{alloc

cc c

c+ c6 c "c cc C0  =- c   c  cc  c !  cc  c c c c c , D *c 62 c -2
c c   c 6 c c - c 5c
555c  c  ccc%c9c

cc c c c

c% c c cî

îÔ  c 

 c
  cc c   c 6 c c c 
c
555c c c c =  c %c

c c   c  c  c c    c

c % c  c cî

 îÔ   c c !  "  #î"! Ô $" î# " % &Ô Ô  Ô
'
(
()   ) 'Accc c D 
6c +*6c
c+
6 cc c cc6


*,c  cî

îÔ c cc +  ccc c

c  c cc  c c  c 'c +  c c  c c c   c  c c  c  c c  c  c  c c  c  c c  cc  c  c cc cc > c  c cc  c c   7
$8c

cc  c6 c

cc  c

c+ cc c c ccc c c cc  cc
;c- c444c cc 0c  c   c , c c   c c

c

c c c
c

c cc  c(  c c 7
&8c c c cc   c  "c cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc ccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc c cc C0 0 c -c *-c 0 c 2*  (+.c  +.c -2c *c  
c%+,2 -c )c %+*0c
c 0+6c 0 c '2
6  -*c -D c 0 c + -*c c '  *c +*6c 6++,
c * . 6c @
-. 6+6c+*+*+*c (.+ * ==c Dc +*  +c
- +c +*6c (
*+ -*c +D +c +*6c +..c ( 
-*
c .+  *,c  ,0
c 2*6 c 0 c6 = *6+*
#c ccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc c cc C0 0 c +c (- -*c-=c (   -* >
c .+*6c *-+0 6c %)c 
(-*6 *c +*c% c -D  6c0-2,0c+*c+ -*c7=-8c '  *cc cc cc cc c  c ccc  c c ccc

cc c c c c

c cccc   7
98c cc +c  c c  c c c  c  c c  c c c 34c

c c  c

c  c
 c
c

c c   "c cc


 -*c
ccâ o may institute proceedings, and w en.cEc
c  c c    c

c c c  c  c c  c  c

c c   c

c c c c   c c c    c c c c c c c  c  c c c c  c ,

c c c 



 c -c  !c . c c . ,c c .- ..!c  .c -c c /   c c    c -c c  ,c c .c 



 c !c 0  c -c  !c  c /

c c . c c c .,.c    0 c c 

,

c -c  !c c .

c 0 c 0 c c c   c !cc !c c  c c1&2c!c-c c c  c c . ,c-c 



 c  ,c c  c ccc  .c .c$   cc c c   c  c    c c   c

c   c c c  c c   c   c cc c c   c

c c   c  c  c  c c   c  c  c cc cc 2 c  c c c c  c c c  c

c   c

c c  7
<8c c  c c c c c c  c  c c c c  c   c  c c   c

c c c c  c c c c cc  c c  c

cc c c c  cc  c

cc c c c  

7
38

c

cc c  c  c   c c   c

c c  c  c   c c  c  c   c  c  c c c  

c c  c

c c  c c  c  c c cc0 c  > c   c c c c c  

c c c  c c c c  c c  c c   c c   c

c c  c  c   c c  c  cc c  c cc c7
;8cc cc +c  c c  c  c  c c   c  c c  c   c  c  c c    c  c  c   c c c  c  c    c

c   cc
c c c  c  c c  c  c c c

c  

> c  c c c  c  c c c c  c 7
58

 c c cc c

cc c  cc  c c 

c

cc C c c c cc c    c

c c  c  c c  c c c

c c  c c  c c c   c c c   748cc c  c c  c  c c    c  c 

c c c

c c c  c c c c c  c c  c  c c c  c c c   c  c c cc c

c  cc   c  c

c c c  c  c c  c c c c

7
8

ccc  c c  c c  c c c c c c

c c   c  c c c c   78c cc  c c ccc  c c c c   c c cc! c   c cc  c c  c  c c c   c c c   c  c c c  c     c

c

 c  

7$8

ccc    c  c  c c c c c

c c   ccCc c

  c   c  c c  c     c

c  c  c c  c c  c  c c  c c  c c c  c c  c  c  c c   c c c  c  c    c cc  7&8c cc c  c   c c > c   c  c c c c   c  c  "c cc $c c 78c c c c c c c

c cc

cc c c  c
 c @FAc% c c  c c c

c 
&c !c  c  c  c. c3c ( +4444<c c  c c c  c  c   c c c  c c  c c

c c* c9&<3c

cc c

c6 c cc c

c% #c cc &c c c c  c c   c c

c c  c  c    c c   c c c 7 c   c c 8c c  c    c 

c c  c

c  c c c  c  c  c c ! c c c c c  c c c

c c c ccc

cc c cc c   c c cc c cc  c#c cc 9c c c c c c  c c c  c   c  c c  cccc c:  c

cc7  cc> 8c  c c   c c  c  c c  c  c c c  c  c c  c c cc  cccc7  cc8#c cc <c c c  :c c 7  c c 8c  cc c  c c c c  c c c ccc c: c c c ccc  ccc 7  cc8c78c c c c  ccc c  c  ccc c cc ccccc c c #c cc 3c c 78c  c  c c  c  c c  c

c c %c  c

c =  c
  c %c c c

c c c c 'c 
c
55;c  c

c  c c c  c c c c 

c  c +c @+Ac c c  c   #c cc ;cc  c

 ccc%cc

c  c c c c c    c c  c  c c  c c c  c c c   c  c = c + c c =c ;c
55;c c c c c c (:c
c
 c (:ccc ccc(:c c  c. c c

c c c  ccccc

c c+c@%A798c cc cc *  c c   c   c  c c  c   c   c  c c  c  c !c  c c c c  c c  c  cc c  c  c c c  c  c c  c c   cc c c c  c cc  ccc

c> c cc c  c c c c  c   c

c cc
c   c c    c c  c  c c c   c c c cc  c cc cc c c c! c cc c c

 c  c c  c c c c  c    cc c c c caccion publicianac caccion reivindicatoriac c c Accion publicianac c c c  c  c  c c  c

c   c  c  c c  c cc c,  .c .c cc   c c c c cc ccc c cc  c  c  c c ccc c

c  c

cc c

c cc c c  c ccc c

cc  c

cc  c cc cc c c c c  c  c   c  c  

c c  c  c  c c c c  c c caccion publicianaccAccion reivindicatoriac c cc c c c   c c c c  c 7<8

 c  c cc c cc c,  .c .c c cc  c  c  

c

cc =c c  c  c c   c c c   c c c   c  c c c   c

c c  c   c c c  c c  c c c  c  c c % c

 cc c c c cc c

cc  c c c  c  cc  c  c  c cc c c cc c  cc c

c   c cc   c  c c  c c   ccc   > c   c

c c  c   c  c c   cc !c c/

cc . c ccc c  > c  c

c   c c c  c   c c c c c /   c c    cc+c  c  c c c c  c c   > c   c

c c  c   c  c  c c c c c c  c   c

cc c  c738cc cc
c c   c c   c  c * c
4&<3c  c  c  c c  c c c    c !  c c c  c c  c  c c  c

c + c  c  c c   c c c c c  c    c c c  c   c c  c c   c c ccc c  c  c c  c c :c

c    c

c c c   c  c * c
4&<3cc cåaresma v. Abellana

7;8

cc c  "c

cc c c   c c c c

c c  c c c    c

c c  c c  ccc c  c

cc  cccccc cc c  c  cc '   c

c c  c c c c c c c

c c  c c   c c c c c  c c c   c c  c  c c  c  c

 c cc c   c cc cc cc

cc cc.:c

c    c

c c  c c c  c c c c c

c c  c  c c c c c c !  c c c c  c   c

c c   cc c c  c  c  c    c c c c

c c  c cc   c c cex mero motuc cmotu propriocc+c c

cc c  c   c ccc #cc c  c c   c  c c c  cc
c c cc c :c  c c c cc

cc (  c   c c  c c  c  "c c   c

c

c c c
c

cc cc  c

cc c ccc c c758cc c c c  c c > c   c c   c  c c  c   ci.e.c  c  c  c c  c  c c c  c c c c c ccc c   cc
c  c c* c
4&<3c cc   c c c c c c c c c c  c c  c c   c

cc  cc c cc c  c

cc  c  cc  cc  c c c ccc  ccobiter dictumcc c  c : cc c c  c c c c c  c

c c 

c c c ccc c cc c    ccc  c

ccc  c c   c

c cc cc  c cc c

c  c  cc c c  ?c

c c  c  c c cc   ccc c ccccc cc â
c c6 c c
4c c 444cc   c c
;c - c 444c

c c  c

c+ c c+,c
(c* c99;5
cccin totocc* c c cc cc%c cc cc cc cc

c%c$
$34c +  c'  c

cc cc cc C c-*2"c cc cc cc $5c63"c +  c'  ccccc   c cc cc cc c$$
c$7cccccccccccc5c#%c$
5c ccccccccccccccccc+  c'  ccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc+  c'  c cc cc cc c%c7c cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc+  c'  c cc cc cc cc cc cc

cc cc cc c cc cccccccccc c  c c c    c c c  c 6 c c c c    c  c c  c  c c cc c

cc   c

cc > c6  c cc cc cc cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc$5c63"c cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc+  c'  c ccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc  c c6  c cc cc cc $$c cc cccccccccc( c c
 c
$c+ cD c

cc    ccc6  c  > c+  c c c c  c c c    c c c  c 6 c c c c    c  c c  c c c cc c

cc   c

cc > c6  c cc cc cc 6c%c75c cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc  c'  ccccccccccccccccc cc cc cc cc cc cccccccccc cc c c c ccccccccccccccc(c
 c -c * c <4c c4c c 445c c c   c '  c  c
c ( c   c +  c '  c   c  c   c  c c +  c '  c c +  c +   ?c c c c

 cc 7
8 cccccccccccccccRollo,cc
49c 78 ccccccccccccccc(cc+  c'  c c
cD c'c c+  c'   c  c'c c
c  cc

c c cc cc6 c  #crollocc5$$c 7$8 ccccccccccccccc cc3c 7&8 ccccccccccccccc cc&;9
c 798 ccccccccccccccc c 7<8 ccccccccccccccc cc99<c 738 ccccccccccccccc c 7;8 ccccccccccccccc c 758 ccccccccccccccc  cc
3
$
c 7
48 ccccccccccccc cc
54
5<c 7

8 cccccccccccccRollocc
4c 7
8 ccccccccccccc cc$$c 7
$8 ccccccccccccc+crollocc
5<c /

7
&8

cccccccccccccRollo, c
&c ccccccccccccc cc
&
;c 7
<8 cccccccccccccValdez, Jr. v. Court o{ Appealsc,c* c
$&&c&cc44<c&;5c
+c$<5c$33$3;c 7
38 ccccccccccccc
 c
cc34c

cc c c

c c 7
;8 cccccccccccccValdez, Jr. v. Court o{ Appealsc c c

cc  cc  c c  ccc  c c c c
cHabagat Grill v. DMC-Urban Property Developer, Inc.c ,c * c
99

4c$
c c 449c &9&c
+c<9$c<34<3
c c 7
98

c $ccc c 8"%%c%c&+'9'*c c&:c:;;)c c 2c c c c c cc'c$
c44
cc c

c+ 7
8c c

cc

cc c c c%c
<c

cc c c  c c* c5344
c  cc      c c=c, ? ccc%cc' c- c'c cc   c

cc c c cc 

 c   c0  c

cD c.  c c -c- c
c
55<c  c' c- c'c - c  c cccGc

c c cc (*(Gc  ccG  c+=,2c Gc c cc  c   Hc4594&c  c c cc.  c%   c  c- c+ c   c   c

c c c- cc c cc c c  ccc  c

:c  c

ccc 78 cc cc  c c

   c c c c=c3c
553cc  c cc c c c

cc c

cReconveyance o{ Possession wit Preliminary Mandatory Injunction and Damages7$8c  c    c c c c+ c   c ccc cc  cc

ccc c  c c-c* c(&&3c c c=c
4c
59
c+c. c c ccc   c

c c  c, ? c c cc c


&;c

c c c c  c=c , ? ccc%c =7&8c c    c cc cc cccc c  c  cc cc c     cD c.  cc c c. ?c c
5$9#798c cc   c c  c c c* c$4c
53<c c c c cccc cc

cc c c

c 7<8 +c. # cc  c c  ccc cc c c c   c

c ccc c c c c  738c c- c
c
55
c   c cc  c

 c   c c c c  cc!  cc   c

ccc cc cc

cc  c c  cc

ccc c c(


<4758c c c cc6 c* c39<97
48c c %c6 c

c* c3c
55;cc c c c c   c  c c   "c C0  =- cc ccc c  c

cc 

c7 c   8cc  cc   c7 c   8"c
c - ccc ccc  c

ccc c!  c cc 

cc c - ccc c c  c c  cc  c 

Hc c  c 

c ccc c cc cc c
-c-6  6c -cc c

c   c cc ccc c c   cc cc"c c c c c cc7c  H8c cCc  ccc

cc c c c cc   c

cc78 ccc  cc cc  cc c cc cc  c

cc  c c cccc c c78cc

c 

Hc  ccc c!  c c  c cc cG cc.  c %   c  c-cccc78c768 c* c39<&c ccc

cD c.  c c c cc ccc:c cc c
c
c cc c. c* c443cc cc c c c. c* c443c cc c c c78c768 c* c
5$$cccc

c . ?c%c.  c c : c c78c768 c* c9&9&c  cc c  c

c ccc ccc  cc78c768 c* c39<9c cccc

c 7 8#cc  c  c0. c  ,c7(;;;;G7

8c  cc   c  c (   c cc cc c

c+ c c

cc c H c   c

cc c

c   c cc cc c -cc  ccc c

c

cc c H c c  ccG c    cc  c c c c  cc c c c     cc c c c    c ccc  c

cc c c cc cc

7
8

c
5$4G c c cc c ?cc ccaccion publicianacc c c  c cc  c

c  cde jure7
$8c c 0cc c  c c c c  cc   c  "c ccccC0 0 c-C* 
0 (c+*6c . c+**-c% c+*c

2 c-c6   * cC0-c0+
c+c %  c ,0c7-8c0 c(- -*c.  ,+ 6#c+*6c c cC0 0 cccc0 c*+2 c-=c0 c+ -*c+
cC ..c+
c0 c'2
6  -*c-=c0 c-2c 6 ( *6c-*c0 c=+
c+
c+.. , 6c *c0 c-(.+ *7
&8c = c   c  cc c

c:c

c   c cc cc cc  c  c c
 c$$c

c% c( c% c
5c c'  c  ? c+c

c
5;4c ccc  c+c* c3<5
c   c cc   c

c   c c  c  c c  cc   c  c c  c c "c cccc c $c/. 0c , .c     c c..c 0 .c 

c c 0.0c .ccc



 c-c.c !cc !c  c cccÔ  c0. c-cc!cc  c c c

c/c !c  c  c17:;;;;%;;2 c c  c  c c c cc c   cc  c cc= c  c c (9444444c c

c  c c

c c: c H c  c   c  cc  "c(  cc c  c

cc cc

c c  ccc

c c c cc ccc  cc

cc c  c  c   cc   c  c % cc c  cc c+c* c3<5
ccc c

accion publicianac c  cc c cc c c 7
98cC cc    c  cc+c* c3<5
c c
55&cc   c

cc  cc  c ccc c c   c c cc   ccc  cc  c cc(4444c(94444ccc c c c c c  cc  cc  c cc c   c   c caccion publicianaccaccion reivindicatoriacccassessedcc

ccc c  c ccc  c  c +  cc   cc cc  cc

cc c c +  cc c 

c ccGc c cc

c c  cc c    c c c c

c cccc c c  c c c  c c ccc c:c c

cc G7
<8c c c cc cc  cc

c(


<4c c c cc6 c* c39<9cc  c   c

cc  ccc c

c   cc c ccc

c(94444c c   cc c  c  c  cc c   c   c

cc  c c c c c c cc ccc c:c  ?c

cc  c c cc ccGc  c  cc7

ccc 8c(94444Gc c c c c c cc c  cc  cc  c c c c  c:c7
38c c c

c  cc   cc

cc c c .:c

c   c c c

c cc  ccc cc  cc c cc cc c cc c c  cc  c cc c c ccc

c c  c  c 7
;8 c ccc c c cc c c cc  c c   ccc c

c:c

c   c  c cc   c c c c c c cc c c c c ccc c

  c c En passant, c c  cc   Hc c

c ccaccion publicianac cc c cc    c

:cc c- c
c
55
caccion publicianac c c c ccc c c   c cc  c cc   ccc   c  c cc cc6 c

c* c3c
55;cccc cc  c  c c c  c c c c c c  cc cc  c c c â
cc  c cc"ccc'c$
c44
cc c

c + c c
c+
6 cc c

c%c

cc c c c

cc c c  c  c* c5344
c cc*2..ccD- 6c c:c

c   c c
-c-6  6c c ±uisumbing, (C airperson), Tinga, Velasco, Jr.,ccBrion, JJc c c c   c

cc(    c
c c  c cc 
cc cc cc

cccc"%%c%c&*'(*;c cc

7  >c cc )*+

+* +,-cJc cccccccccC airperson,c 0 -*+1+ -c D .+
-c'c *+02+cc ( +.+cJJ.c cc

cc"5cc7c  c=c7?c ccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc(   cccccccccccc cc

cc cc

cc

cc

cccccccccccccccc3cversus 3c cc

cc


%c c "%c c c c  !c  c c7  ,c= ,c-cc,  .c .c$ c -c @ A c $ !c # c )+Bc
%c 5c c c  c  !c  c c 7  ,c = ,c -c c .  c .c $ c-c@ A c $ !c # c ':Bc  c c
c c 75c 7c %c c  c c c 1 .!c c ""c %c c  c c %c c  c   c !cc""c%c2c cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc   %c cc

cc cc cc cc 7 .,>c July 22, 2009

/c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3cc3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3/c cc cc$cccccc cc 7cD>c cc

 c   c c   c ccertioraricc c <9c

c c  c

c  c  c c c 7
8

   c

cc c

c+ c +cc
c
9c44$cc'c
c44&c  c c +,c
(c* c3;53;cc cc c cc cccccccccccc  cc c   c cc cccccccccc
 c c 'c 44
c  c    c   c

c    c +   c c D c 6  c

c  c c    c  c  c c

cI? c  c %c &c c   78c  c  c    ccC

c c  c+   c c cAccion ReivindicatoriacI  c

c cc 6 c  c (c c (  c  c  cc( c    c c c c  c  c c % c 0  cI? c  c  c c   c c

($
4444c  c  c c c c

c    c +   c c D c 6  #c c    c  cc c c  c c  c  c c c c c  c

c c c

c c c    c c   c c  cc( c   ccccc  c c  cc c c  cc c  c c c c c   c c    Hc  c  c

c  c c  c c  c  c   cc( c    c c c c c c c c c c  c  c

c c c  #c c    c c c  c c   c

c c  c c#cc   ccC

c cB c  c cc c cccc c  cc H c  c cc cccccccccc(   c c  c c c c   c  c 6  7$8c  c   c cc  c c c c c  c    c c c c c

c c  c  c c c

c    c  c c

c  c   c cc cccccccccccccccc cccc-7&8cc 'c &c 44cc cccc  c  c   c  c c cBatas Pambansac %(cBlg.c
5c  c c c c c  c   c    c

c  c   cccc cccc ccc ccc  ccc

ccccc cc

ccc cccc cc (   Hc  c c   c

c  c-cc'c&c44c c c cc

cccccccccc(   c   c c   c -c c  c c   c ccertiorari  c c  c 798

 c c c

cI? c c%c;3cc0 c c  c6  ccc
4c44$ccc   c c   c  c  c c  c

c   c c c c

c c c (  c 'ccc c   c c c  c  c c c  c  c
 c $$ $c

c  c +c +c * c 3<5
c  c %(c %c
5c ccc c    c c c   c cAccion Reivindicatoria,c c c   c  c

c   c c   c

ccc  c c cI? c  c cc  cc c c(9444444ccc+c  c c   7<8c

cc6 c  c cc   cc c c cc-738cc'c$c44$c cc cccccccccc(   cc c cc c

c+ c c  c ccertiorari,   cc cc c c c c  c c  c

c   c   c  c:c c  c

c    c c  c

 c c   c

c c   c cAccion Reivindicatoria,c c :c

c    c c c ccc cc  c+c  cc
c
9c44$cc+c  cc  c  c   c ccertioraric c  c  c  c    c  c c  c c  c   c

c c c

c cc(   Hc   c c    c

c c   c

c   c  c  c c   7;8cc'c
c44&c cc cccccccccc c   c cc  c  cc c  c

ccc"c cc cc 0 c 0-*-+%. c -2c -=c +(( +.
c + 6c C 0c ,+D c +%2
c -=c 6
  -*c +-2* *,c -c .+Fc -c *c
c 

c -=c '2
6  -*c *c 6 *) *,c0 c (   -*c=-cCERTIORARIc+*6c=-c =+ .2 c -c 
-.D c 0 c

2 c +
6c *c 0 cCERTIORARIc ,+6 *,c 0 c '2
6  -*c -=c 0 c  -(-. +*c  +.c -2c -c +F c -,* 1+* c -=c +c +
c -=cACCION REINVINDICATORIAc cc 0 c 0-*-+%. c (2%. c 
(-*6 *c =+ +c ,-*1+.
+
6+.+c +
c (
6 *,c '26, c -=c c %+*0c ;3c I2 1-*c  )c + 6c C 0c ,+D c +%2
c -=c 6
  -*c +-2* *,c -c .+Fc -c *c 

c -=c
c '2
6  -*c *c 6


*,c 0 c (   -*c =-cCERTIORARIc+*6c *c 
-.D *,c 0+c +c +
c -=cACCION REINVINDICATORIAc
c C 0 *c 0 c '2
6  -*c-=c0 c -(-. +*c +.c-2c cc

0 c 0-*-+%. c (2%. c 
(-*6 *c +*2 .c +-c +
c (
6 *,c '26, c c %+*0c &cI2 1-*c  )c + 6cC 0c,+D c +%2
c -=c 6
  -*c +-2* *,c -c .+Fc -c *c
c 

c -=c '2
6  -*c *c
-c +F *,c -,* 1+* c -=c 0 c -(.+ *c =-cACCION REINVINDICATORIAc *c  D .c +
c *-c 3&$&c * . 6c @0 
c -=c
(
c +(-.-* -c Dc 6 -*
-c +*6c D+.  +*+c6 -*
-c cD
c+*+c6 c,2 +c
+*c( 6-c c+.A758c cc cc ccccccccccc c(  c cCertioraric c

cc  c ccc c  ccc   c cc ccccccccccc cc cc c  c c c c  c c   c

cc+c  ccc c  c   c c  c ccertioraric  c   c c c c &9c

c c  c  c

cc  c ( cc c cPasiona, Jr. v. Court o{ Appeals,

7
48

cc c c c   "ccc

cc ccccccccccccc  c c c   c  c    c c  c c c c

c c +c cc<9c c c  c c c c ccc c c  c c c !c c c c   c

c c c  c  c   c c  c C c !c .!c c    c -c 0 c  c
 Ô
c c  .c '(c -c c  . c -c $ %ccc    c -c 0 c  c
 Ô
c c c  .c  0 .c   c -c
 Ô
c c-ccc!c cc cccccccccccccccc cccccccccccccccccccccccc cccccccccccc
c c c c c c c c  c  c c  c c c  c   c  c ccertioraric c  c c  c Ec   c

c c ccertioraricc c  c  c  c c  c
 c
 Ô
c c

c c

c cc   c-cc. c.c  c c H c c c c  c c H c  c

c c  c c  c c  c -c

c c !  c

ccertioraric c c c c  c  c c c c  c c c !c câc c.c c0 . .c c c c c
 Ô
c ..c c c 0 c -c c , c -c c ,0c  c -c    cc(  H c  c  c  c  cc(  c cCertioraric cc c c ccc  c  c c 7

8  c   c cc

cccccccccc= c c c c  c  c  c c +c  c c  c c c   c c   c ccertiorari  c cc cc   c  cc c ccc

cc  c

ccertiorariccD cc c(  c cCertioraric  c ccc cc  c c ccccccccc

cccccccccc  c cc c c   c c cc  c c c ccertioraricc ccc  cc  c  c c cc  c+c   cc c  c

cccccccccc* c c cccc c cc c  cc c cHeirs o{ Valeriano S. Conc a, Sr. v. Spouses åumocso,7
8 c c "c

cccccccccccc c c c

c   c c c c c   c c  c

c c c  c

c  c  c c  c ! c  c c c  c c   c c c c c   c

c  cc  c@ c c c  c

cc c cc  c  Ac cc cccccccccccccccc cc c c c  c c c c c c  c  c   c 

c c    c c c  c c c c c c

c  c  c c

c  c    c c
 c
5
c

c %(c
5c c c   c  c  c  c c
 c
5 ccc    c c c  c   c c  c  c c c  cc+c* c3<5
c c
55&c ccc c   c    c

c c  c c   c  c c Gc   c   c  c  c  c  c c   c

c c  c c c  c  cc c 



c 0. c -c c !cc  c c c c/c !c  c  c17:;;;;%;;2c c c  0 .c  

c c c  .c c c 



c 0. c  c c /c  -!c  c  c17(;;;;%;;2c/. 0c-c  c, c-c0cD c  !E c - c .  ,  c /

 c  c   %Gc  c c c   c .c  , .c      c 0c   c c c c -c  c 0.0 c F .c c 



 c -c .c !c c  !c  c  Fc c   c &G1:2c -c #%7%c &:Gc c 0 c  cc-  c c  c.0.c  c cc



c0. c -c c .c !c 0.0c  c c  D%c c c  c  c  c G c c  c  : c

c c  c  c  c  c c c  c    c

c  G7
$8c cccccccccc cc ccccccccccc c c c c +c c  c c c c c    c c  c    Hc  c cAccion Reivindicatoriac cc

cccccccccccâcc
c""cc  c cc cc:c

c ccc   c

c c  c

c + c c +,c
(c * c 3;53;c c
c
9c 44$cc'c
c 44&c ccc c c%c cc cc cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc%c7c ccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc+  c'  c cc cc âc$$5>c cc cc cc $5c63"c +  c'  c   c cc cc cc cc cc cc c%c$
$34cccccc7#c=%c$c=%c ccccccccccccccccc+  c'  ccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc+  c'  c cc cc

cc cc c5c#%c$
5c +  c'  c cc cc cc cc c cc cc cccccccccc c  c c c    c c c  c 6 c c c c c    c  c c  c c c cc c

cc   c

cc > c6  c cc cc cc $5c63"c ccc+  c'  c cccc c6  c  c cc cc cc cc $$c cc cc cccccccccc( c c
 c
$c+ cD c

cc    ccc6  c  > c+  c c  c c c    c c c  c 6 c c c c    c  c c  c  c  c cc c

cc   c

cc > c6  c

cc cc cc ccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc6c%c75c ccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc  c'  c cc cc cc c c c 7
8

ccccccccccccccc(cc+  c'  c6 cD    c c+  c'   c' c.c
 c 'cc0: c
c+ c  #crollocc3cJc5c 78 cccccccccccccccRollocc$3&;c 7$8 cccccccccccccccIdcc3;;&c 7&8 cccccccccccccccIdcc55
44c 798 ccccccccccccccc(cc'c= c, ? + #cidcc
5&
59c 7<8 cccccccccccccccRollocc
5<
55c 738 cccccccccccccccIdcc99c 7;8 cccccccccccccccId.cc5c 758 cccccccccccccccIdcc
&
9c 7
48 ccccccccccccc,c * c
<9&3
c'c 
c 44;c 995c
+c
$3c   cIloilo åa Filipina Uycongco Corporationv. Court o{ Appealsc9$5c
+c
3;c 443c 7

8 cccccccccccccIdcc
9

&c  cc   c  c 7
8 cccccccccccccc,c* c
9;

c6c
c443c9&4c
+c
c 7
$8 Idcc
<
;c  c  c c c  c

cc(    c 57c$5c  c = 
c6 D
-*c "%%c%c399:&9c= c:Gc&G+Gc c$%c6c c
c$%c6c   cc  c
%cc%cc7  ,c= ,c$ c-c  c

 c-c# . c# cc
cc%cc74c c7cc   c E. M. Reyes {or petitioner.

Ruben T. Reyes {or respondents. cc 
HcD*c c c  c cc c H c-c c  c    

Hc  c c c c

c c

cc c cc  c

c     cc c c

c   c 

c c  c  c   Hc c c

c   c cc c

cc:c

c    c
c c cccaccion publiciana cc c

cc c c  c   cde jurec c ccaccion reivindicatoriac  c  cc c H c   cc cc c c c c c c c  c   cde {actoc c c c  cc    c

cc  c c c c  c cc c c  c c   c

c   c c   cccc c c c  c  c c (   c c 

c cc c

c=  c  c

c%cc c c+ c
c
5<;cc c c cc c c c! c c cc c  c c c% c
c
  c0  c%c  ccc

c$<;9c !c cc c cc  c

c  c   c c   c&c cccc   c "c cc 

cc  c    c

cc c  c c c cc% c

c
c
  c0  c%cc c c cc  c c

  "c 6   c  c $cc cc cc

 c

c 

ccc  ccc

c c  c
 c c

cc  ccc cc  c  cc

c

cccc   c    c c "c cc  c

c c c c c  c  c

:c ccc    cc c c cc #cc cc  c  c ccccc  c cc  

c c#c &cc  c c=c
5<;c 

cc  c  cc  c  

cc cc

cccc  c  c  ccccc cc  c  c cre{used at t e same time claiming owners ip o{ t e property, and alleging {urt er t at t ey boug t t e same {rom a certain Pablo Aguinaldo;c 9cT at in order to quiet t e title o{ owners ip over t is landcc 

ccc  c c   cc c cc cc  !c c 

c c cc c

c-c  c( c (
44444c(   cc c H c  #c <ccc  cc c c c cc c   cc  c ccc

c 

c c=c
5<;#cc 3cc cc c  c

cccc  c

c= c (9444c( c  cc cc c c c c 

cc 

c c =c
5<;c:c (   c  cc c c  c cc cG c78c ccc  c

cc  c  ccG#c cG  cc  c ccc  cccc  c

c c c c 

#Gc cG  cc  c cc 

c cc cc c

c= c

( c (9444c(   ccc c cc c

 cc  cc

c=c
5<;c cc  c

cc  c c c  c c  c

c 

#Gcc c  c   c ccc c(
44444c H c  cc c  c

c  c 2 c   Hc  c c  cc  c cc ccGc c c c   c c cc

cc c c  Gcccc c  c c   Hc  cG cc c c c c c c  !cc c  c  cc   c c   c

cc   c c c  c Gc c  c   Kc   ccG 

Hc  c c  c

c c! c c c cc!  c

c  c ccc cc  c Gcc  c c c  cc c

c+ c
9c
5<;c  cc  c c  c ccGc

Gcc  cc cG c:c

c   Gc c c c"c +c c

ccc c

c  c cc  c c ccc c

c  c  c c c 

 c  cc c c! c c2 cc c c c c ccc  c

c  cc c    c

cc c c c  cc c cc9c

c  c  cHc c c c! cc c

c

  c c ccc 

ccc c c   cc c c c c c 

 cc   c c  c c c cc c c!  c cc+ c &3
cc*c  c c* c  ccc

c  c  c : ccc  

cccc  c

cc c c!  c   cc c

c c 0cc c  c c cc  c c

cc  c c cc c  c cc     cc c c cc c c c  c  c  c c c  c :c  cGc c  c

c  cc c    c

cc c c c Gc cc  c   c

c  c cc   Hc  c c cc  c

cc c cc c c c  c

c   c

cc c cc c  cccc cc c  c c c( c+  cc c   Hc c cc c c c

c c c c   cc c   de jurec cc c cccc  c

c c  cc  c c

c   c + c cccc  c'  c "cGccc:  c

c  c cc c

c   c

cc c cc
cc c c c  cc c c   caccion interdictalcc cc

c cåey de Enjuiciamiento Civilc c : cc c

c c  c cc c c  c cc cc  c

ccc  #c ccaccion publicianac c c cc c

cc c c  cc ccc c c c  c  c  c cc c

c=  c  #cc $caccion de reivindicacion  c : cc  c

c   c  c

c  c  cc c ccc c  c c c cc  c

c=  c  c9c c cc  ccG c c c c  ccc c  c ccp ysicalc  c

c c c  cc  cc c  ccc c 

cc ccprior   c c    ccc c c  cc  cc c   cCccccc

c  c c  c cc c c c  c  c

c cc cc  cc  c c c c c c c cc c cccc c ccc cc caccion publiciana or accion reivindicatoriac'(   Hc c c cc c c

c  cc  c c c  cc c

c c  c c c

c  ccc c c c

caccion reivindicatoriac c c

c c   c

ccc + c

ccc c cc   c c

cAguilon vs. Bo ol (c   c c cc cGc  c  c c cH   cc!c c ccc  c cc!c c c c Hc c  c c cc!c c cc cc cc c c  c c   c  c Hc c    c'  c  c&94Gcc caccion publicianac ccc  c cc  c  c  c c ccccc c c  c c

c  cc  c  cc   c

cc  c

c=  c  cc c

cc  c  cc  c c  c cGcc c c c

c  c cccc c

 cc c c c  c c

cc c cc c

c cc cc  c  cc  cc   c c  c

ccc (   c c c c caccion publicianac cc c c c  c   Lc  ccc  c  cc cc c c c c cc  c c0 c c c c

c   Hc  c c c  cc c c c

c   c

cc c c   c c c caccion publicianac cc c

c=  c  c c  c c c cc c ccc c   c c cc c  c  cc c ccc cc c c c c c  c cc   c c   c ccc c c c c c ccc   c c c  c   c cc c cc c

c c c c

c   c

cc c*c +-6 *,.)cc ccc  c cc c H c  c c

c+ c
9c
5<;ccc c cc c  c c

c=  c  c c    c c cc    cc cc  c

c cc  cC c  c  c   c c  c c  c c Makasiar, Fernandez, Guerrero, De Castro and Melencio-Herrera, JJ., concur. c  c

cc(    c 57c$5c  c 0 6c6 D
-*c "%%c%c&)&9;9ccccccccccccccc c&+c:;;Gc $ccccc$c6cccc $cc cccc. ccc  c c !c c !3 3 ccc$c(   cc  c #"c77c=6c6c5c$#c c75c$$ccc "5   c 6c cc c
c c-c*c $
$34cD*c


 c cc(  c c  ccc<9c

cc c

c c   cc- cc&cc 443c$4cc443cc$
c- c443ccc%c$c

cc c c c c

c  c c c  c c:c

c   cc  c

c   cc6 c c.  c6 c c6 c+ c c6 c= c6 cc.  c6 c   c   c%  cc'cc
  c c=  c. cc c . c c  c c* c<;<;c (   c c ccc c  c c    cI  c

c cc 6 c  c   c c3cc443c :c c  c c* c<;<;c(   cc c c  ccccc  c

ccc

cc cc c c

c c $ c* c
35$3 c c c c cc c c(   c  cc & c c  c+  c6 c +  c c c   c6 cc  c

c+  c

cc c   c( c    c c c c c' ! c% c c c cc c c c  c

cc c c+  cc   ccccc cc c  cccc cc+  cc c  c cc 9c (   c cc   c   > c  c c3c (   c c cc c c   c cc. cc

c%c + cC c c    c6 cc    c   c   c ccc

cc c cc c  c  c   c c c

c   c +  c c   c   >c  cc c  c  cc c

c  c c> c c

c   c cc c #c cccc c c    >c c cc c c   cc c c c cccc  c c ;  c c c  c c  c(   c  c c c c  ccc  c    c cc c cc c

c(9444444c  c  cc> c  c c

cc c cc c cc c cc c  c

c+ c
5c

cc  c c c 0c  5c(   c : cc ccc  c   c cc c cc c

c(9444444c ccccc cc  cc c c c c c   c c c cc c c= c   c :c c c  c    c(9444444c c > c  c cc> c  c ccc c    c   c ccc   c

cc
4c % c   c c c c ccc cc-cc&cc443c  c    >c  c cc c

c:c

c   ccc c c c+c* c 3<5


c c% c( c%c
5c  c: c cc'  c  ? c+c

c
5;4c c  ccc c   c cc  ccc  cc

cc c  c c(444444c c ccc c cccc

c cc(444444#c c   >c c c cc c c  cc   c

cccccc c  c&cc443c-c"c c c c c   c cc c c ccc c   ccc c c  c c cc(444444ccc   cc c  c 
c (   c cc  c c   c

cc  cc-c  c c   cccc c  c c

c c c c!  c

c #cc c     c c cc ccc c :c c  c  c   c(  > c
$   c  c ccc  c c
 c
cc<$c

cc c

c  c  cc
& c c c! c c  ccc   c

cc c cc-cc$4cc443ccc c   >c  c c   c c cc c c c! c c ccc c( c c c+c* c3<5
c c cc  c c c cc  c c   c cc  ccc  cc

cc c   c c(444444c
cc  cc

c c ccc6 c* c4
9 &;$;
cc c (   c c c c c c c  c c cccccc- c c&cc443cc$4cc443c  c c  cc c cc c c c cc
 c
cc<$c

cc c

c c  ccc c c! c c  ccc  c   c

cccc c ccc c c  c c c  cc c   c

c c c!  c

c ccreivindicacionc cc c  c  ccc

0?

c c c cc c   c  ccc   c

c  c  c

c c c cc c cc  c

c c  
3c cc cc-cc$
c- c443c c   >c  c c cc c   c c  c c cc c

c  c

c  c

c cc c:c

c   c cc c
 c
cc<$c

cc c

c c c   "c
 c
cC cc c  c+c c  cccc c c c c c  c c c  cc

ccc c c c c c  c cc

c c cc cc c  c

c cc c cc  c  c c c c cc!  c

c   c c  c cc cc c

c  c  c c  cc +c c cc  c

cc  c c! c c cc c c c  c  c c  c   c   cc+ c
<43c

cc  c ccc cc cc cc

 ccc  ccc  c c

c
 c
cc<$c

cc c

c  cc  cc  c cc c c c  c c  cc c cc cc  cc c  c cc

c c

c  c c  cc c c ! c c cc cc  cc ccc c c c c+c* c3<5
c  c  ccc c   c cc  ccc  cc

ccc c  c  c cc(9444444c c c cc(444444c cc c 
;cc    cc

cc$
c- c443c-c

ccc "c  c c   ccc c c! c c ccc c70 c   8c c c cc   cc

cc cc(&
444ccc6 c* c4&;$;<c0c c c c    c cc c c c

cc  c    cc  c cc 
5c 0cc c(  cc   c cc c c

"c c C0 0 c-c*-c0 c
(-*6 *c'26, c-  6c,+D c+%2
c-=c6
  -*c *c 6


*,c0 c-(.+ *c-=c0 c(   -* 
c-2c(-( -4c (   >c c

cc c c  c c c cccc c cc cc  c  c c  cccc c  c% c cc  cc c c c c c  c(  c cc c  ccc c c c  c  c cc cc  cc c

c  c c  c   >c  c c:c

c   c c c c cc c +c c c c  c  cc ccc c  ccccc cc c c

c c  cc c  cc

ccc cc c cc c cc

 cc  c cc cc  cc  cc  c

cc   c

cc c  ccc  c c

cc  >c  c c  c
c (   c c c  cc ccc<$c

cc c

c ccc ccc    ccc  ccc  c c

c
 c
cc<$c

cc c

c c

c  cc

c
 c
cc<$c

cc c

c c   ccc   c c  cc cc cc  c c c  c c "c +c c  cccc c c c c c  c c c  cc

c cc c c c c c  c cc c c cc c c c  c

c cc c cc  c c c c c cc !  c

c   c c  c cc cc c

c c  c c  cc  c  c + cc ! c  c  cc  c c c  ccc  cc

c
 c
cc<$ccc c cc  cc
 c
cc<$c

cc c

c c c   c c  c  cc"c +c c cc  c

cc  c c! c c cc c c c  c  c c  c   c   cc+ c
<43c

cc  c ccc cc cc  c  c c  cc

c
 c
cc<$c

cc c

c c  c  c c
cc c c c  c

cc  c  ?cc+  c
$95c c
$<5c

cc  c #c cc c  c! c c  ?cc+  c&3
cc  c #cc $cc c c   c

  c! cc+ c
<43c

cc  c c cc c cc c c c cc   cc  c  c c c  c cc c c cc  c

cc c  c

cc   c

c  ccc

c c cccc  c

c  c c c c c   c cc  c  c cc  cc

c
 c
c c<$c

cc c

c c  c  c ccc c c c

cc'  c   ? c+c

c
5;4c cc c c  c c cc
 c
cc<$c

cc c

c c  c c  c! ccc  c c! c cc c ccc cc  cc cGGcEccc c c!  c

c cGcc cc78cGc c   c c c  ccc c  c c cc   c c c  cGcccc cc c cc  c c c Gcc c

cc cGGc cc c  ccc  c cc cc   ccc    cc   c cc  $c c  cc c  c

cc'  c  ? c+c

c
5;4c cc  cc  cG Gcc  c!  ccc c c c   c   c cc  c  c  c  c c c c  c

cc ccc  cc  c c c(444444c "c
 c$$c'   c

c   c c  c  c c  cc  c  c c   c c  c  M   c c  c  c c  cc  c  c c  c c "c cccc $c  c   c   c cc  c  c c  c c c  c

cc c c c  c ccc  cc

cc c c  c c  c ccc   c c (444444c c c  c  c c c cc c  cc  c c  c= c  c c (9444444c c

c  c c

cc: c > c

 c   c  cc  "cccc  c  c

+ c ccccc  cc

cc c c c c cc6 c* c4 &;$;c  c   c c cc  c

cc  c  c c  cc c   c   c

ccc ccc = cc c c c  c   ccc cc ccc

cc   c  c c

c  c c&c
cc c

cc c c c  c c c cc   c c

cc  cc    c

cc  ccc cc c  c c c c cc c

c c  c cc c c c  c  c  cccc

c ccc c c ccc c  c

cc cc c c c c c  c+c  c c c  c  cc cc c  c    ccc ccc cc c  c c  c #cc   ccc cc c

c cc c c    cc c ccc cc  c

c 9

   cc  c

c  ccc  c

c   c Cccc c c ccc c c cc  c

cc c c c   cc  cc c c c   c cc c c c  cc c c c c    c cc c c c  c c  c c ccc   c c  c <  cc    c

cc  c cc c c   >c  c c!  c

c c c c c   ccc c   c  c ccc c c c c  c  c c c c  !c  cc> c c c

c   c cc c c cc. cc c  cc c   >c c
c   cc cc  cccccc c

cc  c

c c  cc cc cc cc  c

cc c  c cc c     c cc  c c c  c+c c  c cc  c cc c

c  c c cc  cc c

cc c

c c c  cc c   c

c  c

ccc+c  c     c cc  cc c c  c c > c c

c  c ccc c  c 31avvp i1c (   >c  c  c 

 c  c cc c     c'   c c c c c cc ccc

cc c  c, ccc c c c c c c(&
444cccc ccc c   c cc c c cc c cc c c c  cc c

c  c c  c  c c   >c   c c  c c* c<;<;c c:c

c   c + c ccc  c   >c  c c  cc   c   c

cc c ; åaresma v. Abellana   c   "c c c  cccc

cc ccc   c

cc cc ccc c   c

cc  cccccc cc c c c'   c

cc c

cc cc cc

cc c c  c cccc ccc  c c c  cc c c  c cc c   c cc cc cc

cc c .:c

c   c

cc c cc c cc cc

cc c ccccc c!  c ccc c  c

cc  c cc c c c   c cc c

cc c cc  cc cc c c c c  cccc  c  c
ccc c  c   >c  cc c c c ccc c c cc  c cc c c cc c

c  c  c c:c c c

c    c+cc

cc c c cc cc  c ccc  c cc c

c  ccc c c c cc   c c  c c

cc c c ! c c:c

c   cc c

c  c cc ccc c c c c cc  c

cc  cc c cc c  c c ccc ccc c cccc c

  c

cc ccc c c c cc cc   ccc c

c 5  c c c    c* c c   c c c c c  cc c

cc c

ccertioraric *cD Cc-=c0 c=- ,- *,cc  c(  c c6


6cc- cc&cc443c$4c c443cc$
c- c443c

cc c c c

c c c%c$c  cc   c c  c c* c<;<;c  c cc+==  6cc c c c c c  c +*6cc  c

c c c cc  c c c cc c

c c   c c  c   c  c  cc   c
-c-6  6c c c  c

cc(    cc 57c$5c  cc cc  c

cc(    cc
c cc  cc ccc 
ccc c

"%%c%c&*'(*;c cc

7  >c ccc )*+

+* +,-cJcc C airperson,cc 0 -*+1+ -cc D .+
-c'cc cc"5cc7c  c=c7c (   c cc

*+02+ccc ( +.+cJJ.cc ccc ccc

cc ccc 3cversus 3c ccc cc
%c c "%c c c c  !c  c c7  ,c= ,c-cc,  .c .c$ c -c @ A c $ !c # c )+Bc
%c 5c c c  c  !c  c c 7  ,c = ,c -c c .  c .c $ c-c@ A c $ !c # c ':Bc  c c
c c 75c 7c %c c  c c c 1 .!c c ""c %c c  c c %c c  c   c !cc""c%c2c    %c cc

ccc ccc ccc ccc ccc 7 .,>c July 22, 2009

/c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3/cc ccc cc$ccccccc ccc 7cD>c ccc  c   c c   c ccertioraricc c <9c

c c  c

c  c  c c c    c7
8c

cc c

c+ c +cc
c
9c44$cc'c
c44&c  c c +,c
(c* c3;53;cc cc c cc cc  cc c   cc ccc
 c c'c44
c c   c  c

c    c+   ccD c6  c c c c   c c c c

cI? c c%c&cc  c78c  c c   c cC

c c  c+   c c cAccion ReivindicatoriacI  c

c cc6 c  c (c c (  c  c  c( c    c c c c  c  c c % c 0  cI? c  c  c c   cc

c($
4444c  c  c c c c

c    c+   ccD c6  #cc   c c cc cc  c cc c c c  c

c c c

c c c    c c   c c  c( c    ccccc  c c  cc c c c c c

c c c c   c c    Hc  c  c

c  c c  c c  c  c   c( c   cccccccc cc c  c

cc c  #c c    c c c  c c   c

c c  c  c #c c    c c C

c  c B c  c  c c c  c c c c  c  c c  H c  cc ccc (   c c cc cc  c c6  c7$8c  c  c cc ccccc c    c c c cc

cc  c  c c c

c    c  c c

c  c    cc ccc ccc cc-c7&8cc 'c &c 44c cc  c  c   c  c c cBatas Pambansac %(cBlg.c
5c  c c c c c  c   c    c c   c   c c c c  c

cc c

c ccc ccc

(   Hc  c c   c

c  c-cc'c&c44c c cc ccc (   c   c c   c -c c  c c   c ccertiorari  c c  c  c  c c

cI? c  c %c ;3c0 c c  c 6 c798ccc
4c 44$c c c   cc  c  c cc c

c  c ccc

ccc(  c'cc c   ccc c  cc c c c
 c$$ $c

c c+c +c* c 3<5
c  c %(c %c
5c cc c    c c c   c cAccion Reivindicatoria,c c c   c  c

c   c c   c

cc  c  c cI? c  c cc  cc c c(9444444c+c  c c   c7<8c

cc6 c  c cc   cc c c cc-c738c'c$c44$cc ccc (   cc c cc c

c+ c c  c ccertiorari,   cc ccc ccc cc c

c  c  c c:c c c

c   cc c  c c   c

c c   c cAccion Reivindicatoria,c c :c

c    c c c  c c   c +c   c c
c
9c 44$c c +c   c c   c  c   c ccertioraric c  c  c  c    c  c c  c c  c   c

c c c

c c(   Hc   c c    c

c c   c

c   c  c  c c   7;8cc'c
c44&cc ccc  c   c cc  c  cc c  c

ccc"cc ccc ccc 0 c 0-*-+%. c -2c -=c +(( +.
c + 6c C 0c ,+D c +%2
c -=c 6
  -*c +-2* *,c -c .+Fc -c *c
c 

c -=c '2
6  -*c *c 6 *) *,c0 c (   -*c=-cCERTIORARIc+*6c=-c =+ .2 c -c 
-.D c 0 c

2 c +
6c *c 0 cCERTIORARIc ,+6 *,c 0 c '2
6  -*c -=c 0 c  -(-. +*c  +.c -2c -c +F c -,* 1+* c -=c +c +
c -=cACCION REINVINDICATORIAcc ccc 0 c 0-*-+%. c (2%. c 
(-*6 *c =+ +c ,-*1+.
+
6+.+c +
c (
6 *,c '26, c -=c c %+*0c ;3c I2 1-*c  )c + 6c C 0c ,+D c +%2
c -=c 6
  -*c +-2* *,c -c .+Fc -c *c 

c -=c
c '2
6  -*c *c 6


*,c 0 c (   -*c =-cCERTIORARI+*6c *c 
-.D *,c 0+c +c +
c -=cACCION REINVINDICATORIAc
c C 0 *c 0 c '2
6  -*c-=c0 c -(-. +*c +.c-2cc ccc

0 c 0-*-+%. c (2%. c 
(-*6 *c +*2 .c +-c +
c (
6 *,c '26, c c %+*0c &cI2 1-*c  )c + 6cC 0c,+D c +%2
c -=c 6
  -*c +-2* *,c -c .+Fc -c *c
c 

c -=c '2
6  -*c *c
-c +F *,c -,* 1+* c -=c 0 c -(.+ *c =-cACCION REINVINDICATORIAc *c  D .c +
c *-c 3&$&c * . 6c 0 
c -=c
(
c +(-.-* -c Dc 6 -*
-c +*6c D+.  +*+c6 -*
-c cD
c+*+c6 c,2 +c
+*c( 6-c c+.c758cc ccc ccc c  c (  c cCertioraric c 

c c  c  c c c  c  c c c   cc ccc c c c c c  c  c c c c  c c    c

c c +c  c c c c  c   c c  c ccertioraric  c   c c c c &9c

c c  c  c

c  c ( c c cPasiona, Jr. v. Court o{ Appeals,c7
48cc c c c   "cc ccc c  c c c   c  c    c c  c c c c

c c +c c c <9c  c c   c c  c c c c c  c  c  c c c !c c c c   c

c c c  c  c   c c  c C c !c .!c c    c -c 0 c  c
 Ô
c c  .c '(c -c c  . c -c $ %cc    c -c 0 c  c
 Ô
c c c  .c  0 .c   c -c
 Ô
c c-ccc!cc ccc ccccc c
c cccccc c c cc ccc  c  c  c ccertioraric c cc c  c

ccccertiorariccc  c  c  c c  c
 c
 Ô
c c c  c 

c c c

  c-cc. c.c  c c H c c c c c c H c c

cc  c c c c c-c

cc!  c

ccertioraric ccc c  c  c c c c  c c c !c câc  c .c  c 0 . .c  c c  c  c
 Ô
c ..c c  c 0 c -c c , c -c c ,0c  c -c    c(  H c  c  c  c  c c (  c

cCertioraric cc c c ccc  c  c c c  c7

8c cc = ccc c c c cc+c cc cc c  cc  c

ccertiorari  c cc cc   c  cc c ccc

cc  c

ccertioraricD cc c(  c cCertioraric  c ccc cc  ccc

  c cc c c   c c cc  c c c ccertioraricc ccc c c  c  c c cc  c+c   cc c  c

* c c cccc c cc c  cc c cHeirs o{ Valeriano S. Conc a, Sr. v. Spouses åumocso,c7
8  c "c

ccc

c  ccccc  c c c

c c c c

c  c  c c  c ! c  c c c  c c   c c c c c   c

c   cc  c c c c  c

cc c cc  c c cccc cc c c c  c c c c c c  c  c   c 

c c    c c c  c c c c c c

c  c  c c

c  c    c c
 c
5
c

c %(c
5c c c   c  c  c  c c
 c
5 cc    c c c  c   c c  c  c c c  cc+c* c3<5
c c
55&c ccc c   c    c

c c  c c   c  c c Gc   c   c  c  c  c  c c   c

c c  c c c  c  cc c 



c 0. c -c c !cc  c c c c/c !c  c  c17:;;;;%;;2c c c  0 .c  

c c c  .c c c 



c 0. c  c c /c  -!c  c  c17(;;;;%;;2c/. 0c-c  c, c-c0cD c  !E c - c .  ,  c /

 c  c   %Gc  c c c   c .c  , .c      c 0c   c c c c -c  c 0.0 c F .c c 



 c -c .c !c c  !c  c  Fc c   c &G1:2c -c #%7%c &:Gc c 0 c  cc-  c c  c.0.c  c cc



c0. c -c c .c !c 0.0c  c c  D%c c c  c  c  c G c c  c  : c

c c  c  c  c  c c c  c    c

c  Gc7
$8cc c ccc c c c c c +c c  c c c c c    c c  c    Hc   c cAccion Reivindicatoriacc ccc câcc
c""cc  c cc cc:c

c cc   c

cc  c

c + c c +,c
(c * c 3;53;c c
c
9c 44$cc'c
c 44&c ccc c c%cc c

#"c%cc 9)+c$c9:+c cc $>c
   cccc cccc  cc cc  cccc  cc%  cc ccc cc  cccccc

cccccc  cccc  cc

c c  c ccc c c

  c ccc cc c c cc c 

c c c cc  c

cc   c  c cc  c c cc c cc c cc  c c c  ! ccccccccc ccc  ccc c cccc cccc  cc

cccc cccc  cc cc cc c cc cc cc cc

cccc cc

cc cccc2 cc  cc

c  cc cc  cccc cc cccc cc cccccc

ccc  c

cc c cc c

c   c c  cc cc
>c ccc  cccccc ccc  ccc=

ccc ccc ccc ccc c  c

cc c   cc c 

c ccc c c cc  cc

cccc cc cc   cc  cc cc

ccc cc
c!  c c  c  c cc c c c   c

cc cc* cc c

c  c  c ccc

c   ccc  cc  ccc c  ccc: ccc  ?ccc

cccccc cccccc ccc   ccc c c

cc c

c   ccc 

c cc c c c   cc  ccc  c

cc cc cc c cc c c:c   c c c cc=  cc  c

c  c c c c cc c c

cc  ! c cc cc cc c

ccc    c
 c c  c ccc cc cc cc cccccccc

cc  cccccc ccc   c c: c

cc c

cc  c c cccc

ccccc cc =  cccc cccc!  cc  cccccccc   cc cccc c  c c c c cc

cc  cc cc cc cc  cc cc cc cccc cc cc

 cccc ccc cc  cccccc

cccccc cccccccc0 ccc cc c cccc c c c c  cccc cc 

cc:cc cc cccc  cccc cc

cccc c ccc   c

ccc

ccc c c  c  c c ccc c c cc c c  c c c c     c c cc c c c   c cc c  ccccc c

$cc c$cc$ccccccccccc"%%c%c&9:&G+c $%c c=5cH"cIc c$%ccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc7  >c $



 &c

75cD&c î)Ô
'Ô&c 534c 3cc0 cc3ccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc$=c%c "c c $
$34cDDc 75c"6c"c c 4#
c"cccccccccccccccccccccccccccc7 .,>c    c  , c&*c:;;(c /3333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333/c cc$cccccc  cJ."c ccDecision7
8cc
cc c

c+ c cc   c

cc  c c c ccc c c c c

cc c c  ccccc c   c cc c  c c c cc c  c c  c c cc c

cc   c c

c+ >cDecisionc c c   c  cc  c cc cc   c  c   c :c c   c c* c$3<c ccc

cc c%c cc cc  c   ccc

c

c c   c

cc $c c

cc cc c  c

c c c* c $<&<<c$<&<3cc$<&<;c(   c : c: c  c  ?c-> c   c

c c  c  c c  cc-c
c  c c c cc  cc : cc cc   c c $4c c  c c

ccc%c   c  c ccc c    c  c

c  c  c c   cc  c c
 cc cc'  cF cc
 c c    cc! cc c  c c( c cc cc cc c$cc
559cc cc c ccc ( c ccc! cc   c  cc   c cc6c

c+ c
c c
&c'c
55&cc0 c ccc

c ccc  c

c c  ! c cc  !c c cccc   c cc  c c c
$c=c
559c cc cc  cc( c c78c(c c c c c  c c  c

 cc)c ccc cc c&c+ c
55<c cc c  c    c ccc  c c!  cc c cc c  c

c c    c -ccccc c
cc
553ccc

 cc> c c c  c c -c;cc
553c   c cc  c

ccc0 c cc   ccc cc  c

c   c -c$c'c
553ccc ccOrder  c ccc  c c   >c  c

c c c c;cc
553#c c c  c c   cc5cc
5537$8ccc    >c  c c  c c cc ccPetition {or Certiorari wit Injunctionc c cc c

c+ ccc ccPetition {or Reviewccc cccccc c   c c  c c cc c c  ccc  c c c  c c c! cc c c c c c cc  cc  cOrdersc

cccccc c c (   cc

:c c  c cPetition {or Reviewccc&9c

cc c

c ccc   c  c c c c c"c cccc c cc c cc  ccc cc  c c c c #c ccc  c cc  c    cc c c c c c  ?ccc#cc cc   c c  c  cc c cc  c

cc c  c Cc cc  cc cc  c c c   c !c

c c c "c
ccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc-c
cc
553ccccc!  c c

 cc c

ccc cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc-c;c+ c
553c   c cc c

cc  c  c $ccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc-c;cc
553c   c ccNotice o{ Appealc ccc &ccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc-c5cc
553c   c c : c ccccMotion {or Reconsiderationc

cc  c
cc
553c c 9ccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc-c$c'c
553ccc

cc ccOrderc c    >cMotion {or Reconsiderationc <ccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc-c5c'c
553c   c cc c

cc  c$c'c
553cOrderc 3ccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc-c&c'c
553c   c c cc c

c+ c c  c c c  c c

cc
4c c  c c c c c(  c c c

;ccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc-c$4c'c
553c   c c cc c

c+ c cPetition {or Reviewc (   c cccPetition {or Review  c c cc c
9c c ccc c  ?ccc c c c c;c+ c
559ccc

c c

ccc c cc c
$cc
553cc+  c cc cc c c ccc c cc  c c5cc
553c

ccMotion {or Reconsideration c

cc  c cc c

c cNotice o{ Appealcc cNotice o{ Appealcc;cc
553c cc c c

cc  c  c c  c c cc  c c c c cc c

c+ c cc
c 7&8c (   c ccc   c c c ccNotice o{ Appealc c c cc   cccc c:cc   c c c c  ccMotion {or Reconsiderationcc
c

 c c c c cc c
9c c c c c  ccc

c c

cc c c c;c+ c
553ccc c
$cc
553c    c c cComment,798c  ccc  c

cNotice o{ Appealcc;cc
553c c  cc c c c c ccc

cc cc  c

cMotion {or ReconsiderationMotion {or Reconsiderationc cc ccc   ccc ccNotice o{ AppealcccOrdercc$c'c
553c "c  c cc   ccc c cc cc  c c   c   >c  cc c  cc c

cc -c c cc*  c

c+cc  c cc6  c cc;c
553c . : c cc6  c cc5c
553c cc  c c   c    cc*  c

c+c c c cc cc  cc  c c    c c6 * 6c c  c c  c  c( c+c c    c c,+* 67<8c  c c c   c
c cc c

c+ c c c c c c cc c

:c  ?c

c    >c  cc cccc%c  c c  ccccc c c c ccccMotion {or Reconsiderationc cccc  c

ccNotice o{ Appealc c c c   ccc c Kc c&c  cc c

cc c c c cc
c
c   "c   c&cHow appeal taken; time {or {ilingcc+cc  c cc  cc c

ccc c cc c

c  cc   cc cc c  c c c cc c

c + c ccc c c cc:c

c  c cc    c :cc c c

 c  cc c

c(94444c c  cc   cc c c ccc c c cc c

cc  ccc  c cc cc c  c c
9c c  c  c

cc c c cc c c

cc c

c  > c  c cc c c   c

c cc c ccc2 c c  cccc

cc c c

cc :c c c c  ccc c c  c cc  c

ccc cc c



c+ cccc  c c

c c
9c c c  c c c cc  c c  cc* c c c cccc cc c  c cc c c c c c c
9c c
cc c c c c c cccc

cccc   c  cc

ccPetition {or Reviewc cc c

c+ cc ccNotice o{ Appeal cccc0 c c  c c ccc ccc c  c

ccMotion {or Reconsideration cc

  ccc
 c$cc94c

cc c

c c  cc c

cccc c cc c

c c cc  c

cc> c  cc+ c cc cc  c

c cMotion {or Reconsiderationcccc cc

 c c

cc  cNotice o{ Appealc ( cc c

cc c cccMotion {or Reconsiderationcc c cc c  c c c

cc c ccMotion {or Reconsiderationcc+cMotion {or Additional Time to File t e Petition  c : c c cc c

c+ cc  c c
9c c  c c

cc c

ccMotion {or Reconsiderationcccc
4c! c c  c c c ccc    c c cPetition {or Reviewc c c (   c  :c cc c cPeople v. De la Cruz738cc cc  c

cc c c c cc  c c c cc cc  c c   ccc c   c cc c  c c

c De la Cruzc cc  c c cc  c c
 c$cc
c

cc c

c c    ccc c c

cc  cc c

ccc cc  c

ccccc c c c c  c

cc  c

cc cc cccc  c c c cc c

c+ c cc c c

cc  cc  c

cccc
cc  c

cc  c

cc c   c c c  c c c cc  c  c * c cc  cc c  c c cc   "cccComplaintc   cc    c!  c cc c

c c c c  ?cccc cc  c   c c c   c ccc  cc  c

cc c c  c

c   cc
 c c c

ccccc c

c+ c cc c   cc cc  c cc c c c c c c c c c  c"cc c  c  c c  cc   cc c

c  cc c    cc c c #cccc c c c c c  ccc  c c c! c c c c c

c c c Cc c cc c

c+ c c  c c c c  cc   c c  "c cccc

$ccccccccc 

ccc  c

c. c* cc c c ccc* c$<&<
cc c

c 6 c

cc c. c* c
+c c c ccc* c$<&<3c

cc c

c6 c

c c cc. c* cc;<+c c c ccc* c$<&<;c

cc c

c6 c

c c cc c cc c

ccc   c

c  c c c

c  cc c c c+ c@+Ac@%Acc@Ac  cccc cc

#c &ccccccccc c  ?c-c cc  c c c

c  c  #c 9ccccccccc cc  c c c

c  c  c c  ?c-ccc cc   c'c-ccc  c cc  c  c c  c  #c <ccccccccc cc<c
559c 

c cc c  c c  ccc   cc c c c c c  c  ccc

cc cc  c  c  c$4c c

 c c

c  ccc c

c  cc c cc c+c@6Acccc cc 

#c 3ccccccccc  cc ccc  cc  cc  c  c cc  c  c  c c   c  c

c  c  c  c 

cc  c 

c

cc c

c  c  #c ;ccccccccc c c   cc  c

c  c  c  cc 

c 

cc 

c  c cc c

cc c cc c

c(
444444cc c ccc7;8c C c ccccc  ccc

cc c cc c c c c   c

c ccc  c

cc  cccc

cc  c 758c    c ccc  c c ccc   >c  c c   c c cc c cc cc cc  c

cc c c  cc c

cc c c  c  c c cccc c

c+ c cc c

cc c cc! c c! cc  c c c

c c c   cc  c c c ccc cJavelosa v. Court o{ t e Appeals7
48c c cccc c cc  ccc c  c   c

c  c c 

 c c:c cc c c c cc c c!c cc cc c c c cc ccc c c c   c   c  cc 

c cc 

 c  c  c  cc   c

cc 7

8c 0cc cG c   Gc ccc c c  c ccc

c c  c cc cc  c c c c ccc c c c  cc c c c cc cc c c cc 7
8c cRosanna B. Barba v. Court o{ Appeals,7
$8ccccc c c cc c c c   c  c  c 

c c 

 c

% c c c cc c ccComplaintc"c cccc  cc ccc  cc  cc  c  c cc  c  c c  c   c  c

c  c  c  c 

cc  c 

c

cc c

c c   #7
&8c cc 

 c c   cc c c c cc c  c   cccccc c  c

cc  c cc c* c$<&<<c$<&<3cc$<&<;c%c c  c ccc c   cc

c  c

cc   c c c cc*  ccc ccc c    c : cccccc  c  cc   c  cc  c    c

c  c

cc  ccc  c   cc c c

cc c  c c c 

 c cc c

c  c   c c c ccc    c c :c c  ?c cc!  c c c cc c

cRaymundo dela Paz v. Panis7
987
<8c

cc c

c ccc c  c c  c c  c  c cc  c

cc c  cc c

cCo Tiamco v. Diaz7
38c   cc c c c "c%cc   c ccc  c

c
c
cc34c cccc  c cc cc   c

c  c c  ccc c c   c  c c    c

c c  cc  c

c  ccc cc c c c cc  c c

c  c c c cc  c c c c cc   c    c c  c

c c  cc c 7
;8c   c   c  c c cc

cc   c

cc c c   ccc

c c

c cc c c  c cc(   c: ccc c!  c c ccc   c c  c c ccc

cc c c c c    c  ccccc cccc   c cc c c ccaccion reivindicatoria  c cc cc cc   cc  c  c   c c c c cc c

c  cc c cc c cComment,7
58c   c  cc c cc c  c ccc  c(   c cc ccc : c c

c   ccc c

c   c c c c c c

c  c c cc  c cc cc c c  cc   c   c

ccc c   c c  c  c c cc c c  c caccion reivindicatoriac cc c

c   c

cc cc c

 c

 caccion publicianacc c ccc c

c  c c  de jure,ccaccion interdictalde {actocc cc c c c cc!  c

c  c c   c cc c

c   c cc  748ccc c c c  c c  c * cc c c   >c  c cc cc   c c cc    c 

 c c c c  ccaccion reivindicatoria  c c cc  c

c cc c c(   c c c   cc  c cc cc c

c  c c

  c   c

cc   cc: c c c  c

cc c

c c

  cc   c  c c   cc   c

c   >c c   cc c c c c c  c c

cc c c cc c

c c c  cc  c   c

c  c(   c cc c  c c c c c c   c

cc c cccc ccc c   c cc c

cc c c c c ccc

c   c cccc c c c   c c   c cc  c cc  c ccc  c c cc c cc  c

c   ccc c ccc c c c c  c c  c cc

c  c c   7
8c c c cGanadinc c v. Ramos78c cc cc cc c cc c c

c  c c  c cc c

  c c cc cccc cc c  c c c

c c

cc

c cc c  c

c cc!  c

c c c  c c* c+*$9
cc c c c

c c cc c c c cc

ccc

c c ccc  c c  ccc

c  c    c ccc  cc c c c c c cc c cc cc cc  c

c  cc cc cc  cc ccc  c cc

c c B c cc  c ccc  cc cc cc 7&8c cOronce v. Court o{ Appeals,798c c cccc cc   cc  c cc c c cc  c

ccc

c c c  c c

cpacto de retro c c! c  c cc c c  c

c=  c  c c cc c c c  cc cc

cc

ccc  cc 

cc  !cc  cc ccc  c cc c

c

  c  ccc cc  cc c c cc c cc c cc c  c   c c cccc  c  c cc c  !c

ccc

c  ccc c c  ccc c c cc c cc  c c c  c ccc cc c  cde {actocc c  cde jurec c c c c cc c

cTecson v. Gutierrez7<8cc c"c Cc c  c cc c c c cc   c  c

c   c cc c c  c cc c

c  cc c

c  c cc c

c   c c  c  :c c+ c cc c H c  c

c   c ccc c cc   cc c

c

cc c  Hc  c cc c cc c cc c cc c  c   c c cc c ccc c c c c  c  cc c c c c cc ccc c

c   c cc c

cc c:c

cApostol v. Court o{ Appeals,738c c ccc  c c c "c ccc2c
 c&;c

c(  c6c* c
95cc c

c c c cc c c c :c c ccc  c ccc cc c  c cc c c  c ccc c

cc  c

cc c

cc   cc cc  c cc  c c   c cc cCc c cc   ccc c c c

  c cc c c cc c

cc ca quoc c c cc c c c  7;8c C cc  c

cc  c c c  c

c   cc c cc c  cc c  c

c c c cc cc  c c C0  =- ccPetition c,+* 6ccDecisionc

cc c

c+ cc
cc  c c c

cc c *
+ 6cc+==  6c  c  c    c
-c-6  6c c  c

cc(    c 57c$5c  c 0 6c6 D
-*c cc "%%c%cG*&;+c= c&Gc&GG(c $4c=#5ccc  cc  c
%c$5cc77c17$c$c2c c5$c6c   c cc cD*c c c  c c ccc :c c c ccc c

cc c

c+ cc & * c;c
554c cG ? c'cc. cc2  c Gc +,cDc* c
5333c c c :  c  c   c ccc&c
554c c c c c cc ccc   c c c

c  c c  ccc

c

33;9c !c c c c% c,  cc% :c* c. c   c'  c 'cc c

cccc  ccc c c c
534c c2  c c c c cc cc c c c c  c c c   c c c9c

 c

cccc cc cc c cc  cc c

c'c( c  c  c cc  c

c'  c'c c c c  c cc c  cc cc (  c ? c'cc. c ccc

c'  c'ccc c

cc c  c + c c  c cc c c c ccc c

ccc  cc c
5;$cc c c ccccc  c c   c

cccCc :ccc  c ccccc  c c c c  ccc  c cc c c c cc
5;&c c  c cc  c  c c  c cc c c  c

c   c c cG  c

c  c.c. #c c

c(  c c

c2 c  cc6 Gc ( c  c c c+ c cccccccc c c c
5$;cc cc ccc c  c

c.c c .c cc c c c   c

c.c cc  !ccccc  c

c+ c c c * cc
5;$c cc  cc  c cc cc'  c'cccc. c c   c c9c -c+ c

c
5;&cc c c cc c  cc c c c  c c   c  c

cc c H c cc=c<c
5;;c c  c

c  c6c. c  "c C0  =- c(  c  cc cc"c
c6 cc c cc 

cc c cc  cc cc cc c ccc cc c H c  c cc c c

 c
5;$cc cc #c c- c c2  c cc c   cc      c c  cccc c

c c  cc cc  c 

c c 

#c $c- c c2  c c cc 

c ? c'cc. c c   c cc c
<4c c

cc  c c c  c
5;$cc c
5;3c c  c c! c cccc:c c

cc  cc cccc cc c cc c cc c

c c c c c  cc c c  c

c 

#c &c- c c c cc c 

c'cc. cc c

c($;94
;c   cc c   c  ccc  c c c  c

ccc  cc c cc 

#c 9c- c c c cc c 

c'cc. cc c

c($44444c  c Hc c  #c(
44444c c   c  cc(44444c c c c  c  #cc <c6  c H c  c c:c

c c'c

-cc cc c

c+ c c  c cc c c

c   ccc cc c c c c c

c+ c  cc c   c cc c c  cc c cc&c
554c

cc c H c c  c c   "c C0  =- c  c  cc cc  c  cc c c c c+==  6c cc-6 = + -*ccc c  c cc  c c c ccc c c c c  cc c
5;$c c
554c  c   cc(c ccc c   c c c ccc

cc c  H c:c cc   c

cc c c c  c cc c c

c  c*c6  c c     c c!  cc    c

cc c cc  c c c c  c c cc c  c c c     ccc c   c c c  cc c  c  cc c cc   c

c+ c c+c= ccc ccc c c c  cc c   c

c%(c
5c
 c&c cc c   c   c c c  cc  c  cc  c c

c c c c c c c cc c cc c c cc  c c c cc   c   cc  c c)c ( c  H c  c c  cc c c cccc c

c+ c c * c;c
554c  c cc c c  c c cc  cc  c c c c  c c   c c* c
9<;c cc

c   c c  cc ccc  ccc  H c  c c c c cacción interdictalcc c c c  c

c c  cc  ccc c cc c   c c c:c  c  cc  c ccc c c  ccc c c c c c c ccc cccc ccccc c cc c! c c c  cc c  H c  c c
c  c ccc c c cc c cc

c c  c cc c  ccc   cc cc cc  c c* c G
9<;c c c cc c c c c

c   c c cc c c 0c c  c c c c c  H c  ccc c

c+ cc c  ccc c c cc c  c c
cc  c c c  c  c c  c  c c c  cc  c ccc

cc c cc c c c c

c c cc c c

c  c   c *c  c ccc c

c:c

c   c  c ccc c c  c

c  c  c cc  c  c cc   c

cc ca quo c cc c c cc c c cc  c c + c  c ? cc  c

c  c H c ccc c c ccc c c c  c  cc c

cres judicata c c c ( c  c c  ccc c cc  c  ci.ecc c cc c c  c cc c cc   c cc c c  c cc  ccc cc ccc c

c+ c c+c,c
(c* c
9344c cG2  c cc0 c +  cc ? c'Gccc  c c c

c  c cccc c c c c c,c* c;5$
c&;c c  c c  c c c

c c c cc  c cc   c

cc c cc c cc c

c c  c  c c c ccc  c cc  c '   c

cc c cc cc c  c ccc    c ccc&&c c c  c cc c

c  c cc  c&:c +c c c   ccc ccc ccc cc  c c cc&9c% c c &'     cc c   c c c  c c ccc c c   c c &( cc c c c c c ccc c cc   c c c c c  c  ccc

cc  c c c c +c c

cc  c   cc  c cc c c ccc c c c cc

  c

cc  cc c c c

c c c +c c c  c acción interdictalc c c  cccc c  c

ccc  cccc c c c  c

cc c+ c  cc c c

c cacción publiciana ccc c c cc c

c  ccacción reivindicatoriac cc c c c   c c  c c

c  c:ccc &* c:  c

c  c c  c c  c c c c   c c   ccc c  c c

cc  c

ccc c  c c  ccc c c cc  c c  c

cc H c c c c  cc  c

cc c c c  c&+c+cc  c c c cc c   c c c  c c  c c c  cde {actocc c  cde jurecc    c c c c c cc cc=  ccc c cc!  c    ccc c cc cc  c c c c

cc cc

cc &)  c cc c

c c c cc  c c c c  cc   c c

c  cc  c c c c  c

cc ccc c   c c  ccc c cc c ccc   c  cc c cc cc!  c

c

  c ccc c c c   c c c cc c

c  c&Gc  c   c cc   c c c c c  c Acción publicianac ccc c c cc c

c  cc   c c c

c cc cc cc   c c

cc c cc c c c c34c:;c2c  c   ccc c:&ccc c cc c c c::c Acción reivindicatoriac c cc c c c   c  cc c

c  c  c cc c cc c c c (  H c  c c cG  c

c  c.c. #c c

c(  #c c

c :9 2 c cc6 Gc c+ c cc  c cc c

cc c c  c H c  c cccc cc  cccc c ccc  c c c c cGc c c Gc c( 

c : ccc cc

c ccc  cc:c c c   c  c ccc c c   c  c cc c   c cc cc c

c  c c c c cc c c  c c ccc c c  cc cc c cc   cc c  c  c c c c c  cc  c ?c cc&"c

c c c  cc c'  c'cc c2  c c   cccc c c cc D .c.+Cc. +
c*-c *+*)c-c +, 2.2+.c. +
c cc c

c c
ccc cc c cc c  ccc

cc  #c:'c + c c ccc c c c

cc  c cc c c cc c cc  cc  ccc 

cc c cc  cc c cc c c cc

ccc c ccc c ccc  ccc c c
5;$c

c  c

c c cc ccc:(c +c c  c c   cc c

c c  cc c c c c c  ccc c

c  cc cccc

cc c cc  H c     cc c  c c : c  cc  c

c  cc    c cc  c  c cc ccc c c c cc  c cc c c cc  c  c Ccc  c

cc cc c c  c  c c c c   c c c

c  cc  c  c

c  cc  c c ccc  c 

cc c c c  ccc c  c c cG c

c c   Gc c c ccc c   c   c

cc c c  c cc  c

c :*

 c  c c * c ccc c

ccc c c c  c   c ccc cc  c
 c cc!  c

c   c c  c c cc cc  c c  ccc c c c cc c

c c  c c cc   c cc   c cc  c ccc c c c   c cc c c cc  c

c+ c c  c   c ccc c  c c c

c  c+  c cc c  c cc c cc cc  c

c  c cc ccc  c c ccc c

c   c  c c  cc  c cc   c c c c

cc cccccc   c

  c  c cc!  cc  c c c cc c c cc  cc cc c c c c cc  c  c:+c Cc ccc  c cc ccc  c  cc c

c  c  cc  c cc cc c H c  c c c c c c  :cc c   c H c  c cc c

ccc   c c  c( c   c c c c c c    c c cc H c:c

c   c0c  c  :cc H c   c c c

 c  c  c  cc c   c c

 c c  c c c!  cc c   c:)c (   c c  c   ccc c c c

c   c c c c  c  c  c cc   c

cc c cccc  c c : c c c cc :c  c cc H c   c c  c %c c  H c c c

c c c  c c  cc  c :c0c c c    c cc c H c c

cc  c c

c c c0 c  c c  ccc

c   cc  c c ccc cc c cc  c c cc  c c( c  c cc c c :c cc c  cc

ccc cc c cccc :c

c c0c c c   c  c  c  cc H cc

c   c ccc c

  cc c c  c cc  c c c ccc c  c 0cc c c cc c c  c c

c c c c  c c c c"c = cc c  c c c ccccc c cccc  c  c c(6c5&
cc ccc c c 

c c  cc cc c c c cc c

c  c   c cc c c cc c  ?cc c  c cc c

c  c  c   c 6  c c0 c

c
+c39<c  c c   cc c   c c  ccc c cc ccc   c 6 c c6c,?c
c
+c
&&cCc c ccc c  c cc6 c c   c cc c ccc= cc+c c c cc  c   c  !cc  cc  c c  c  ccccc c  c  c c  c cc c  cc c c  c cc cc

c
 c&c

c%(c
5c cc c   c   c c c  c ccc

 c c  c cc  c c

c c  c c  c  c c  cc c c c c c cc c c c cc c c c cc    c   cc  c c  it is already a settled rule t at inasmuc as t e RTC is a court o{ general jurisdiction, w et er a particular matter s ould be resolved by it in t e exercise o{ its general jurisdiction, or in its limited jurisdiction, or in its limited jurisdiction, is not a jurisdictional question but a procedural question involving a mode o{ practice w ic , t ere{ore, may be waived  c c  c.$$;94c'cc
53<#c
 c c% c.$
;9&c
c5c
5;c:Gc  c  c -ccc

cres judicata  cc c  cc ccc c  c c c   c c  c  cc  c cc cc  c c,c* c;5$
c9;cc cc c cccc c  c c ccccc c cc c  c 9& 'c6c. cc c

c+ c c cc  cc  c  cc c  cc c c c c cc  c c c  c  c cc

c  c  c cccc c ccc c c c c   c cc  ccc  c cc ccc  cc c  "c ccccc

c   c

c  c c cc cc  c c cc c c c  c  ccc c

cc c c c c c+c c* c
9<;c c

 c c cc

cc cc c

cc  c c  c c  c c ccc cccc c c cc cc ccc c cc c   c ccc 9:  cc c cc c  c c  c  c c c c  c c = cc  c! cc ccc c

ccc c c c  cc cc c

c   cc cc c

c c c cc c c ccc c

cc   c

c c cc ccc  ccc c c+,c
(c * c
9344cc c cc  c c c

c  c c c  ccc c c  c  ccc  cc  cc cc c   c c cc   c

cc!  c  c99c c ccc ccc c cc  c c c c c

c c cc  c c cc   c ccccc c   c c  c cc  c c c  c c  c  c  cc c  H c:c

c   c

C0  =- cc  c c,+* 6ccc c

cc c

c+ cc * c;c
554c c+c,cDc* c
5333c G ? c'cc. cc2  c Gc c
c +
6 ccc   c ccc&c
554c c *
+ 6c   c  c c  c
-c-6  6c c  c

cc(    c 57c$5c  c
-*6c6 D
-*c cc "%%c%c&:(;((c c9;c&GG)c %c$$c6cc7c$7c  cc  c $5cc77c c75c5c%%c=c cc7%c =c   c cc 4cD*c  c cc  c c c ccertioraric

cc cc c=c5c
55
c & + c  cin totocc c

cc c c c

c( c c c  c c* c<54c  cc ccc H c  c

cc3c
55
c(39c  c c c    cc    c  cc  c'  c c   c

c ccccc

  c  "c cc  c cc* c3c
55
c  cc  cc

c&Nc c c c c  #c ccc

c c cc ccc* c9;3&;c c c c   c #cc cccc

c c

cc c c c  c

cc :  c  c+c=  cc c c  c cc  c c c cc c c c   "c c

cc c cc c (54444444c cc c cc cc c  cc  c

cc c cc c cc c cc c

c: c cc3c+ c3ccc3c
55cc   c c c  cc cG  c

cc-,+,-c  c   c cc c  c  c cc cc-,+, c   c c  c

cc c 9  cc cccc

c c cc c c= c c cc H c c

cc * c9;3&;c c c c  c+c=  cc (  c  cc c   c  c ccc  cc cc  !c c c c c

ccc c  c  c c=c
c
55c+ cc cc* c9;3&;c ccc c  c

cc* c(;99<5c c c ccc

c  c+c=  cc'c

( c   c  !c  cc  c c

c(9c  c  c  c cc
$c
55c c cc cc  c c c "c PROMISSORY NOTE = cc c c  c cc+c=+*
-c +.)c+*6c6 D .-( *c -(-+ -*cc  c c

c c  c= c0c  c( c (94444444c c c c+ c3c
55c c  cccc

c cc &Nc c c c c cc c cc  cc c cB cc c  c  c

c(39c  c  c cB c c  ccc c cc

c   c c  c cc  cc  cB c c+=+*
-c  +.)c+*6c6 D .-( *c-(-+ -*c c  cc c c c  c ccc c cc9
cc ccccc

c&Nc c  c  c c
55c c  c+ c  c    c  c cc  c cc c c

c  c cc c c c c( c c*c c c c   c c   c cc cccc c c c c c c cc c cccc

c c ccccc cc  c  c cc c

c c c= cc cccc c  c

cc  c

cc c c  c

c  c+c=  ccccc c c  cc c ccc c c c c  cc  !c cc  c

cc c+ cc c  c    c ccc  c cc ccc cc c c  cc c   c ccc c+ c  c   c cc c

cc* c (;99<5c c cc  ccc c

ccc c  c c   c

cc c+   c -c6c
5c
55cc c c ccc cc   c  c

c c  c c   "c C0  =- c   c  cc  c    cc cc c c ccc cc c

c   c

c+c=  cc= c 6 c   c cc c c

c c cc c c c  c c c c

ccc* c;99<5c

cc c

c6 c

c ?c c c* c9
c   c c  c   c  c  c 

c

cc  c  c c c  cc  c  c c c cc  c  c c  c H c  ccc c  c c

c ccc c c c  c

c)c   c    cc cc c

c+ c c cc c

cc c cc   cc  c  cccc cccc c c cc c    c cc c c c ccc c c c c c c c   ?cc  c c  c= c cccc  c   c

cc c  ccc

c c c c c c c ccc   c c c   cc+c4;;c

cc  c c

(  c+c=  cc cc  c c   ccc c

c+ c cc   c c  c  ccc3c
55<c0c c  c c c ccertioraric cc

  c  "c C0 0 c-c*-c0 c-2c-=c+(( +.
c  6c *c2. *,c0+c0 c  , -*+.c +.c-2c0+6c*-c'2
6  -*c-D c0 c-(.+ *c= . 6c %)c0 c(   -* c C0 0 c-c*-c0 c-2c-=c+(( +.
c  6c *c2. *,c0+c0 c -*+2+.c6-2 *
c
2%' c-=c0 c *
+*c+
c+ c -*
 2 D c-=c(+2c-

- 2c+
c6 = * 6c2*6 c+ . c4;;c -=c0 c D .c-6 c-=c0 c(0 . (( *
c -cc  c ccc c "c -  cc c

c c cc  c   cc c c c c c     c  c c  c+ c ccc34c

cc c

c  cc c c c c c  ccc c   c

cc    c c  c c  c c c c   c  ccc c  c  c c c cc ccc  c

ccc c  c c cc c c c cc  c c  c

cc  c  c c c   cc c

cc c c c  c   c c, c;
c( c9&#c 6 : c c6   c;5c( c&&c c c c c   c c  cc c c  c  cc  c

cc
cc cc cc  cc ccc c c c c  cc c  c cc c

c=  c  c  cc c c c  c cD c<$c
+c3;c c c cc ccc cc  cc c c  cc
cc c

 cc   cc cc cc c c c c c    c cc c+  cc
 c$$c

c%(c%c
5c  c c   cc c cc c   c   c c  ccc c  c c
c( c :c: c c c+c
c
+c
9&c7
5548cGc Cc :ccc c c c cCcc    cc c c c c  cc   c c accion publicianacc  cc    c c accion reivindicatoriac ccc

 c c  c cc!  c

c  cde {actoc +c c c  c accion interdictalc c c  cccc c  c

ccc  cccc c c c  c

cc c+ c  c c c c

ccaccion publicianac ccc c c cc  c

c  caccion reivindicatoriac cc c c c   c c  c c

c  c:cccc:  c

c  c c  c c   c c c   c c   ccc c  c c

cc  c

cc c c  c c ccc c c cc  c c  c

cc

H c c c c  cc c

cc c c c  c+cc  c c c cc c   c c c c c  c c c   cde {actocc c  cde jurecc   c c c c c  cc cc=  ccc c cc!  c   ccc

c cc cc  c c c c

cc cc

cc cc  c

c c c cc  c c c c  cc   c  c

c  cc  c c c c  c

cc ccc  c   c c ccc c cc c ccc   c  cc  c cc cc!  c

c   c ccc c c c   c

c c cc c

c  c  c  c cc   c c c  c c  c&;c c  c c cc   cccc   c

c  c cc c cc  c  c   c ccc!  c

c  c c "c cc  c

cc c

c

  c c  #c cccc   c

c c   c c(&4444444cc c  c c c  cc  cc cc c#cc ccc   c   c

c c    cc c  c cc  cc  c c c+ c  c+c=  cc c c  cc  "c 9c c ccc

cc c

c39c  c c cc c  cc  c    cc ccc6c

c c cc c cc  c   cc cccc  c cc c  c cc   c 

ccc c cc c  cc6c

c+ c
c c  c

cc  

cc c6c

c
c c c

c c c ccc   c c c+cG+G#c <cc c c c  ?cc c

c6 c  c  cc+ c
cc  c cc 

c c c cc 

cc  c6c

c
c  c cc   c H c c

c c c

c c* c9;3&;c

cc  c

c ?c c

c c c ccccc cc c c +cG%G#c 3cc c    cc c  cc 

cc  c c

c(9c   c cc c   c c  c c&Nc c  #c ;cc  c    c  c ccc  c c  cc cc c

cc  c 

c cc cc+ c6c

c
c c  c  c cc c c c c

c c* c(;99<5c c

c c c  ccc   c c c+cGG#c 5cc c  cc c

cc c c

c c ccc

cc  

c c

c c c ccc   c c c+cGGc 

c cc c

cc  c

cc   cc

cc  c cc   c cc  c  cc  c c c c c cc 

c  c  c  c #c* c cc  c cc  c

c&Ncc c  cc
55c c  cc cc #c
4cc c cc  c

cc  cc cccc  c c  c  ccc  ccccc6c

c
cc c c  c

c 

cc   c ccc cc

c(&4444444cc c cccc   ccc cc  c  c cc ccc  c   c ccc c

c (&4444444cc c c cB c  cc 

c c:c c &&   c

cc  c #c c c c cc  cc  cc  c+c=  cc c  c c  c  ccc c c cc  c  c

cc c c
c  cc c c c  c

c  c

cc  c  cc c c c+ cc cc    c "c c c

cc  c c  c c* c5
cc'  c

cc(c

c 0  c%cc c cc  cc  c c c c   cc   c c c c ccc!  c

c c cc c  c cc  c

cc  c

c=  c
c= cc  c  c

c : cc

cc c cc c c  c  ccc  c  c  cMc c  c c

c ccc

c cc c  c cMc c cc c c  c cc  c

cc  c  c c c  cccc c c cc cc cc  c

c c

cc c  ccc c c c  cc  c

ccc

cc   c  ccc c  c c cc cG c

c  c   Gcc c cc  c  c

cc'  c

cc &: (c c cc c c * cc cc  ccc  c  c cc  c    c cc c

c   c+c=  cc ccc c:c c ccc cc cc  c

cc  c c +c  c c  cc  c c c c c cc   c c c   cc 

c D  cc(c
&$c
+c94c
5;<c c  c cc c

 cc c cc ccc c c c c ccc c c0c c c c c   c cc c cc cc  c D cc D c;c
+c;&3c
5<$#c cc+c  c ccc
+c55
c+ ccccG cc  ccc c c c    c cc  c Gc  H c c c c c ccc

c c c  c c c c c c c ccc

c pactum commissoriumc   cc+c4;;c

cc   c c c   "c +c4;;cc  c c  cc  c ccc cc c c

c  c

cc+c   c cc c ccc c C c c c c!  cc c

ccc c  cc

c(  c  c  ccc  c  c  ccc   c c  ccMc Cc c cc+ c4;;c

cc  c c

cc(    c cc  c c cc

c c   c cc  c c

cc c c c c

cc  c

cc c ccc c ccC c  c. c+ c c 9&c( c$<
c+ pactum commissorium is a {or{eiture clause in a deed o{ mortgagec 0 cc+ c
&&c
+c&94#c cc c

c+ c

c
+c<&
#c c

cc c  c
9<c  c c+ c4;;cc c  c cc cc

c c c c   ?c c c c c   c cc  c  cc  cc cG c   cc  c ccc

c c  c   cc c   ccc cc  c

cc Gc  cc
 c
9c( c&$<cIN SHORT, THE PROSCRIBED STIPUåATION SHOUåD BE FOUND IN THE MORTGAGE DEED ITSEåFc&'c c  c cc  c c c   cc c

c  c cc c cc  c

cc    c c+c4;;c cNakpil v. Intermediate Appellate Courtc&(c c  cc  c

cc   c c cc

c  c c cccc  c cc "c* c c cccc cc cc c c cc cc c c  c

cc  c cc  cc cc c c ccc  c c c c c c pactum commissoriumc  c c"c

ccc  ccc  cc( cc c cc G  c c c c   cccGc c c  c   c c  cD c  ccc  c c c cpactum commissoriumc c c c    cc+c4;;c

cc  c c= cc c cc  c   c

c c ccD?c ccc

c  c

c  c cccc

cc  cT us, contrary to respondent's mani{estations, all t e elements o{ a pactum commissorium were present: t ere was a creditor-debtor relations ip between t e parties; t e property was used as security {or t e loan; and, t ere was automatic &* appropriation by respondent o{ Pulong Maulap in case o{ de{ault o{ petitioner c
 cc c c :c c c    c c  c c c

c c  c c  pacto de retroc  cc cc cc! c  c c cc  cccc c

cc c

cc   c c c+c
<4c

cc*c  c c c 

 c ccc c

c c  c c c cc! c c c c c  pacto de retroc  c  cc  cc   c

 cc ccc c  c c c

c  cc c  c ccc c cc c c c cc  c  cc! c c (  c c cc c cc cc   c cc c   cc  cc c c cc c ccc  cc  c  c c cc c cc  cc
c   ccc   c

cc  c c  c c ccc c c c c c

c   cc  c c c c c c pactum commissoriumc c cc  c c! c   c

cc c c  cc

c  c  c   c cc c cc c

cc  c c ccc c cc &+  c c &)

c cReyes v. Sierrac c c c  cccc H ccc

c  cc  c c c c cc cc  H c  c ccc c c c c c

cc  c

cc c c pactum commissoriumc -  c  ccc

cc  c H cc    c cc c cc   c

cc c c c cc%  c%cc   cc c cc cc c cc c  c  cc c c  c ccc c  c = c

c  c ccc c  c c  c c   c

cc  c cc c c ccccc c c  cc c  c c  c

c c c  cc  c

c+ c4;;c

cc*c  c  c c "c c  c c  cc  c ccc

cc c c c   ccc+c   c cc c ccc c cc

c c c  cc c c c cc c  H c  c  ccc c c c pactum commissoriumc c c  c

c  c c&G c c   c  c cc cccc    c cc  c  c   cc c  c

c  c    c cc  c   c

cc c cc  c c c  c+c =  ccccc

c c c  c  c cc cc c  ccpactum commissoriumcc cc c c

pactum commissoriumc c c c c2c cc c:;  c

c+  c c "c

c    c cc   c    c c  c cc+ c4;;c

c c  c "c +c4;;cc  c c  cc  c ccc

cc c  c c  c

cc c+c   c cc c ccc c c ! c  c   cc c c cc   c c "c
ccc  cccc c c cc c cc c  ccc

c  c ccc

cc  c   #cc cc c  ccc   c cc  c   ccc  c

cc c c c c ccc

c c

cc  c   c  cc c:&  c  c c c  c c cc  c

ccc

c cc c

c c  c+c =  cc cc c  cc* c(;99<5c  cc c c c ccc  c cc cc   c c c  c C0  =- cc c

cc c

c+ c c+==  6c 

c c c  c  H c   c  c  c    c cc ccc    c cc  c  cc  c c cpactum commissoriumcc D 
6c 

c c cccc c cc c    c c c cc c

c6 c

c( c c cc-6  6c c+* .cc* c (;99<5c c c  cc

2 ccc c ccc

c  c    c
-c-6  6c c c $cc 8"%%c%c&:(;((%cc c9;c&GG)


 &%c$5cc 77c c75c5c%%c=c cc7%c=   %c cc$cccccc  *6-1+cJ"c  c c c   c c  c ccertioraric

c c  c c c =c 5c
55
c + 7
8c  cin totoc c  c

c c  c  c  c

c ( c  c c   c  c * c <54c cc ccc > c  c

cc3c
55
c(39c   c  c  c    cc    c  cc  c'  c c   c

c ccccc

  c  "c cc  c cc* c3c
55
c  cc  cc

c&Nc c c c c  #c ccc

c c cc ccc* c9;3&;c c c c   c  #c c c c c c

c c

c c  c  c c  c

c c  c  c+c=  c78c

c  c c c  c  c  c  c c  c c c   "c  c

c c  c  c c  c (54444444c  c c  c c c  c c  c  c c   c

c c  c  c c c cc c cc c

c: c cc3c+ c3ccc3c
55cc   c c c  cc c@  c

cc-,+,-c7 c   8c cc c  c  c cc cc-,+, c7  8c c  c

cc c  cc cccc

c c cc A7$8c= c c ccc > c c

c c* c9;3&;c c c c  c+c=  cc (  c  cc c   c  c ccc  cc cc  !c c c c c

ccc c  c  c c=c
c
55cc+ cc cc* c9;3&;c ccc c  c

cc* c(;99<5c c c ccc

c  c+c=  c7&8c ( c   c  !c  cc  c c

(9c  c  c  c cc
$c
55c c cc cc  c c c "c c

(-

-) *- c = cc c c  c cc+c=+*
-c +.)c+*6c6 D .-( *c-(-+ -*c c  c c

c c  c= c0c  c( c (94444444c c c c+ c3c
55c c  cccc

c cc &Ncc c c c cc c cc  cc c  cB cc c  c c

c(39c  c  c cB c c  ccc

c cc c   c c  c cc  cc  cB c c+c=+*
-c  +.)c +*6c 6 D .-( *c -(-+ -*c  c   c c c c  c  c  c c c c cc9
c c  c c c c c

c &Nc c  c  c c
55c c  cc+ c  c    c  c cc  c cc c c

c  c cc c c c c( c 7<8c c c c   c c   c cc cccc c c c c c c cc c  c c c c

c c  c c c c c  c c   c  c c c c

c c c= cc cccc c  c

cc  c

ccc c c  c

c  c+c=  cccccc c c  cc c ccc c c c  c  c c  !c  c c   c

c c c + c c  c   c    cc cccccc  c cc ccc cc c c  cc c   c ccc c+ c  c   c cc c

cc* c (;99<5c  c c c   c c c c

c c c  c   c  c   c

c c  738c -c 6c
5c
55c c  c  c  c c c  c c    c   c

c  c  c c   "c C0  =- c   c  cc  c    cc ccc c c c c  c c  c

c   c

c +c =  c c +c 6 c    c c c  c c

c c cc c c c  cc c c

ccc* c;99<5c

c c c

c6 c

c ?c cc* c9
  !c   c c c c  c  c c  c  c c    c  c

c    c c  c   c  c  c 

c

cc  c c c c  cc  c  c c c cc  c  c c  c > c  ccc c c c 

c ccc c c c  c

7;8c   c    cc cc c

c+ c c cc c

cc c cc   c c   c   c c c c  c c c c  c  c  c c  c    c c c  c  c c  c c c  c c  c  c  c c  c   ?c c   c  c   cc = c c c c c   c    c

c c  c  ccc

c c c cc c c c ccpactum commissoriumc c c   cc+c4;;c

cc  c c (  c +c =  c c c c   c c    c c c  c

c + c  c c   c c  c   c c c 3c
55<c 0c  c   c c  c c   c  c c

  c  "c C0 0 c -c *-c 0 c -2c -=c +(( +.
c  6c *c 2. *,c 0+c 0 c  , -*+.c  +.c -2c0+6c*-c'2
6  -*c-D c0 c-(.+ *c= . 6c%)c0 c(   -* c C0 0 c -c *-c 0 c -2c -=c +(( +.
c  6c *c 2. *,c 0+c 0 c -*+2+.c 6-2 *
c
2%' c -=c 0 c *
+*c +
c + c -*
 2 D c -= PACTUM COMMISSORIUM+
c6 = * 6c2*6 c+ . c4;;c-=c0 c D .c-6 c-=c0 c(0 . (( *
c -cc  c ccc c "c -  c c  c

c  c c c   c   c c  c c  c  c  c      c  caccion publicianac + c  c c c 34c

c c  c

c  c c  c c  c c c  ccc c   c

cc   c c  c c  c c c c   c  ccc c  c c c c cc ccc  c

cc c c  c c ccc c c cc  c c  c

cc  c  c c  c  cc c

cc c c c  cc   c c, c;
c( c9&#c6 : c c 6   c;5c( c&&cc c c c c   c c  cc c c c  cc  c

cc
cc cc cc  cc cccc c c c  ccaccion publiciana  c c  c

c =  c  c  c c  c  c  c  c  c D c <$c
+c 3;cc c  c c c  c c c c c   c c  c c   c c
c c  c  c c    c c  cc  c c  c  c  c  c  c    c c c  c +  c c
 c $$c

c %(c %c
5c   c  c   c c  c  c c  c   c   c c  ccc c c cc
c( c :c: c c  c+c
c
+c
9&c7
5548758c Cc :ccc c c c ccCcc    cc c c c c  cc   c cc accion publiciana c  cc    c c accion reivindicatoria ccc

 c c  c cc!  c

c  cde {actoc

+c c c  c accion interdictalc c c  cccc c  c

ccc  c c c c c  c  c   c

c c  cc + c  c c c  c

c caccion publicianac c c c  c  c  c c  c

c   c caccion reivindicatoriac c c  c  c  c   c  c  c  c

c   c :c c c c:  c

c  c c  c c  c c c   c c   ccc c  c c

cc  c

ccc c  c c  c c c c  c  c c   c c   c

c c > c  c  c  c   c c  c

c c  c  c c  c +c c  c c  c  c c  c   c  c  c  c  c   c c c   cde {actocc  c   cde jurec c    c  c  c c  c cc c cc =  c c c  c  c c !  c    ccc c cc cc  c c c c

cc cc

cc cc  c

c c c cc  c c c c  cc   c c

c  c c  c c c c  c

cc cccc c   c c ccc  c cc cc ccc   c  cc c cc cc!  c

c   c c c c c c c   c c c cc c

c  c  c  c cc   c c c c c  7
48c c  c c cc   cccc   c

c  cc cc c cc  c  c   c  c c c !  c

c   c  c  "c c c   c

c c  c

c

  c c  #c cccc   c

c c   c c(&4444444cc c  c c c  cc  cc cc c#cc ccc   c   c

c c    cc c  c cc  cc  c c c+ c  c+c=  cc c c  cc  "c 9cc  c c c c

c c c

c(39c   c  c  c c  c  c c  c    cc ccc6c

c c cc c cc c   cc cc c c  c c c c  c c c   c

c c c  c  c c c  cc6c

c+ c
c c  c

cc 

cc c6c

c
c c c

c c c  ccc   c c c+c@+A#c <ccc c c c  ?cc c

c6 c  c  cc+ c
cc c cc  

c  c  c  c c  

c c  c 6c

c
c  c  c c   c > c  c

c c c

c c* c9;3&;c

cc c

c ?c c

c c c cc ccc cc c c+c@%A#c 3ccc c    cc c  cc 

cc  c c

c(9c  c cc c    c c  c c&Nc c  #c ;cc c   c    c  c  c c c  c  c  c c  c c c

c c   c  

c  c c  c c + c 6c

c
c c  c  c c c  c c  c  c

c c * c(;99<5c  c

c  c c  c c c   c  c  c +c@A#c 5ccc c  cc c

cc c c

c c ccc

cc 

c c

c c c ccc   c c c+c@Ac 

ccc c

cc   c

c c    c c

c c  c  c c   c  c c

  c  c c   c  c c c c  c c  

c   c   c   c  #c * c  c c   c c c  c

c &Nc c  c  c c
55c  c  c c  c c  #c
4cc c c  c c   c

c c   c c c c c c   c c  c  c c c  c c c c c 6c

c
c c  c c  c

c  

c c   c c c c  cc

c(&4444444cc c cccc  ccc cc  c  c cc c cc  c   c ccc c

c(&4444444cc cc c cB c  cc 

c c :c c  c

cc  c #7

8c c c  c c  c c  c c   c +c =  c c  c  c  c  c  ccc c c cc  c  c

cc c c
c  cc c c c  c

c   c

c c   c   c c  c  c  c + c c c c    c "c c  c

c c   c c   c  c * c 5
c c '  c

cc (c

c 0  c %c c c cc  cc  c c c c   ccc   c c c c  ccc!  c

c c cc c c cc  c

cc  c

c=  c
cc= cc  c  cc : cc

cc c cc c c  c  cc c   c  c   c Oc  c   c  c

c  c c c

c  c c c   c cOc c cc c c  c cc  c

cc  c  cc c c   c c c c  c  c  c c  c c c c   c c  c

c c  c   cc c c  c  c  c  c c   c

c c c

c c    c  c c c  c  c c cc c@ c

c c   Acc c cc  c  c

c c'  c

cc(c c cc 7
8c * cc cc  ccc  c  c cc  c    c cc c

c   c+c=  cc ccc c:c c ccc cc cc  c

cc  c c +c   c c   c c   c c  c  c c c c   c  c  c   c c  

c D  cc(c
&$c
+c94c
5;<cc c  c cc c

 cc c cc ccc c c c c ccc c cc0cc c c c   c cc c  cc cc  c D ccD c;c
+c;&3c
5<$#c cc+c  c ccc
+c55
c + c c c c @ c c   c c c  c  c  c    c c c  c  Ac   > c  c  c  c c  c c c

c c c  c c c c c c c ccc

ccpactum commissoriumc   cc+c4;;c

cc   c c c   "c +c4;;cc  c c  cc  c ccc cc c c c  c

c c+c   c cc c ccc c C c  c  c  c !  c c  c

cc c c  c  c c 

c (  c   c  ccc  c  c  ccpactum commissoriumc c  ccOc

Cc c  c c + c 4;;c

c c   c  c

c c (    c c c   c c c c

c  c   c cc  c c

cc c c c c

cc  c

cc  c  c c c  c c c C c   c . c + c  c 9&c ( c $<
cc +cÔ ' ''

'c c c --  c . c c c c -c ,,c 0 c c + c
&&c
+c &94#c  cc c

c+ c

c
+c<&
#c c

cc c  c
9<c  c c+ c4;;cc c  c cc cc

c c cc   ?c c  c c c    c c c   c   c c   c c  c @ c   cc   c  c c c

c c  c   cc c   ccc cc  c

cc Ac  cc
 c
9c( c&$<ccc
c
c7$#c75c
5c#c5c c
c""cc%7
&8c c  c cc  c c c   cc c

c  c cc c cc  c

cc    c c+c4;;c cNakpil v. Intermediate Appellate Court7
98c c  cc  c

cc   c c cc

c c c cccc  c cc c* c c ccc ccc cc c c  cc cc c c  c

cc  c c c cc cc c c ccc  c c cc c c ccpactum commissoriumc c  cc"c ccc  ccc  cc( cc c cc@  c c  c  c   c c c Ac c  c   c   c  c   c D c  c c c   c  c  c ccpactum commissorium  c c c   cc+c4;;c

cc  c cc= c c c cc  c   c

cc ccD?c ccc

c  c

c  c c c c c

c c  c c  c  c   > c     c c c  c

c cpactum commissorium c "ccc cc   c   ccc  #cc  c  c  c  c  c c c  #c c c  c   c    c c   c

cPulong Maulap c c

c c

c  7
<8c
 c c  c  c :c  c c    c  c   c c  c

c c   c  c cpacto de retro  cc cc cc! c  c c cc  cccc c

cc c

cc   cc c+c
<4c

c c *c   c  c c 

 c  c c c  c

c c  c  c  c  c c ! c  c c c c cpacto de retro  c cc  cc   c

 cc c cc c  c c c

c cc c  c ccc c c c c c cc   c cc! c c (  c  c  c c  c  c c c c   c cc  c    c c  c c  c  c c c  c c c c  c c   c  c  c c c  c c c  cc
c   ccc   c

cc c c  c c ccc c  c  c  c  c 

c   c c  c  c c  c c  c cpactum commissorium c cc c c! c   c

cc c c  cc

c  cc  c   c cc c cc c

cc  c c ccc c cc  7
38c

c cReyes v. Sierra7
;8c c c  cccc > ccc

c  cc  c  c c  c c c  c c   > c  c  c c c  c  c  c c c

cc  c

cc c ccpactum commissoriumc -  c  c c c

c c   c  > c     c c c c  c c   c

c c  c  c c  c c %  c %c c   c c  c  cc cc c cc c c  cc c c  c  c c c  c  cc = c

c   c  c c c  c   c  c   c  c   c

cc c cc c c ccccc c c  cc  c c c  c

c cc c  cc  c

c+ c4;;c

cc*c  c c c  "c c  c c  cc  c ccc

cc c c c  cccc+c   c cc c ccc c cc

c c c  cc c c c cc c  > c  c ccc  c c c ccpactum commissorium  c c  c

c  cc c  7
58c  c cc cccc    c cc  c  c   cc c  c

c  c    c  c c  c   cc

c c  c  c c   c  c  c   c +c =  c c c c c

c c c  c  c  c c  c c c  c cpactum commissorium. c  c c  c  c

cpactum commissoriumc c  c  c cUy Tong v. Court o{ Appeals748c c "c c    c  pactum commissorium stipulationsc c  c cc+ c4;;c

cc  c "c +c4;;cc  c c  cc  c ccc

cc c c c  c

c c c+c   c cc c ccc c c  ! c   c   c c  c  c pactum commissoriumc c  "c
c c c  c c c c c c  c c  c c c c c c c

c  c c c c

c c   c   #c c c c c  c c c   c c c   c    c c c   c

c c  c c c  c c c c

c  c

c c   c   c  cc  c 7
8c c c   c  c  c c   c

c c c

c c c  c

c  c   c +c =  cc cc c  cc* c(;99<5c  cc c c c ccc  c cc cc   c c c  c â
c c  c

c c  c

c + c c +==  6c 

c  c c   c   > c   c   c   c    c c c  c c c    c c c   c   c c  c c  c cpactum commissoriumc  D 
6c 

c  c c c c c  c  c c  c    c c  c  c cc  c

c 6 c

c( c  c c c -6  6c c +* .cc * c(;99<5c c c  cc

2 ccc c ccc

c  c    c
-c-6  6c

c  c

cc(    c 57c$5c  c = 
c6 D
-*c "%%c%c3')*&:c= !c:+c&G)9c $$c7=cPetitionerc ccc c$5ccc$cc 6c#$
ccRespondentsc cc @54cD*c cc c  c cc  c c c ccertioraric

cc c

cc c

c=  c  c

c.c c  c c * c94$<c  cc c cc c

c:c

c   c cc  cc c c   c    c cc c -c'c$
c
53&cc 

c  c  c c  c  c c  c c  cc  cGI  c

c c cc(  c

cc( cc c

cc6 Gc c c c

c=  c  c

c.c%c cc cc'c,  c  cc  c c c  cGcc 

c cc c ccc  c

ccc

c   cc   ccc

c
&c c c c cc  cc(
&9444c c c % c*cFc c c c cc  c

c. c* c9$5c cc* c4ccGc c 

c! c  cc

ccc c cc
$c
5<$c  cc  c+ cc
  c
P  cc cccc cc c cc cc c  c

c c

c

 cc c c c c c

c c cc c  cc  c

cc   c c c  c  c cc cc cc c  c cc   c c c   G#cGcc 

H c(  c:c cc

c c      c cc  cc cc cc c &4c cc c  c c   cc 

cc ccc c cccc6 c* c
;$

cc 

c

ccc c cc  c  c: cc c  c

cc 

c c 6c5c
5<&ccc  c

cccc c cccc6 c* c
5&;&c  c  c ccc
5<$#ccc  cc c

cc c c c c   cc  c c  cc   c

ccc  c cc$c

cc  c c  cc H c c

c   c

c5;c c c c  c cc cc c c c c  c

cc cccc cc  c  cc  c

c c c c6c
53$c c cc c cc   cc  ccc  

c

cc c  c cc$c

cc  G#cGc 

H cc6 c* c
;$
<c  c c ccbona {idec c

c   ccc  c c c cc
$c
5<$c c cc cc c  c c cc6 c* c
5&;&c

cc #cc  c

cccc c c c G#cGcc  c c c c c cc cc  c c  c

ccc

cc c  c c  c c

ccc  c c c   cc c cc c

c G#ccGcc 

c c c ccc c c  c c   cc c  c

ccccc c ccc  c  ccc 

c cc c

ccc c cc  c Gc   c c3c c c+cc9c cc c c c  cc c=c4c
53&c cc  c c  ccc   c cc cGcc cc cc c c

ccccc

c ccc c  c

c cc c

cc c c
5
 c  c   cc      c cc c -c* c&c
53&cc c cc  c c  c cc "cG ccc c c c    c cc c

cc c c  #cc ccc c c c   c ccc

cc c c    c cc c C c c cc  c cc ccGcc cc

cc  c c cc  c

c. c* c9$5c cc* c4c c cc ccc  c   c c  ccc( c.c+c
 c&c

c  c+c* c
&
c cc   cc H c c  c  cc6  c

c. c cc c  c

c c  c c c

cc c c

c  c c   ccc

cc c

cc c  cc c  c c c!   c

c  c cc  cc ccc
c

c+ cc *c  Hc c cccc6  c

c. c cc   c c  c cc  cc ccGc   cc3c c c+cc
<
3cc c c cc c 

cc c cc   cc c c c

c  cc c cc%c

c.   c cc c + c cc  c cc cccc c

cc 

c c c  ccc  c c c c ccc 

c cc c c'c
53&c c c c cc

 ccc

cc c

c c c c c6c
53$c cccc  cc   #ccc cc  cc c c cc c cc c  c c c c c c cc c

c  c    c cc c -c* c
;c
53&cc 

c cc   c c  c c  c ccc  c  c c   c ccc c c ccc

c  c c c ccc 

c c c c ccc c

c    c cc c ( 

c  c ccc!  c

c c c c  c

ccc cc c c&c c 5c

cc  c c$cc&c

cc cccc

cc

 c   #ccc  ccc c  c:c cc

c c     c cc c cc c  c c cc ccc c cccc cc c  c

ccc c !  c c cc c c #ccc!  c c c c c c c

cc  c c  c cc  c#cccc c c cc  cpublicianac c cc  c c c   c cccc
c c cRallon vs. Ruizc;c
+c$$  c cc c c  c c c6c9c
53&c cc  c c  c-c'c
<c
539c c c c c!  cc 

c ccc  c c c c  c c c c

c  c  cc c-c'c$

539cc 

c ccc  c   c  c c  c c c c c

c   cc ? c  c c c

c     c cc c c c c c   c cc  c c cc  c cc   c  c +cccc c ccc cc cc

cc c

cc  c c cc  ccc c c c#c cc c %cccc  c  c   c cc0  c cc c c  ccc0  c c c cc   c ccc c c  c cc   c  ccc c c c#cc cc  c

cc c c cc  cc  c c c c   c cc

c ccccc  c  c c  c cc c c cc cc 

c -c+ c

c
539cc c cc c  ccc  c  c c c

  "c c c c  ccc 

cc c ?c c cc c  c

ccc c!  cc 

c cc c c c cccc c !  c cc ccccc6  c

c. ccc
c

c+ c c*c  cc   c cc   c

cc cc   c c
 c&c

c  c+c* c
&
cc!  c

c   c  c cc cc c   c cc c c c!  cc cc cc c c c c c c c cc c   c

cc cc c!  c-c c!  c c c c c c   c

ccc c!  cc c c cc c

cc c  c c c   c c  ccc c

cc
c cc   cc3c  c c+cc&9&<c = cc  c c c
c3c
539c c  c c  c c ccc c cc  cGcc0  c c c c   c cc c

cc c cc 

c  c c cc   c  c

Gc c cccGc cc c    c    c

cc c

cc ccccc 

cc c c cc  c c  c cc  c

cc   c Gcc c  c  c cc c cc cc  c cc   c  c c  c  c c0c+c* c4<3;$c 

943c= c c(   c c6 c(  c    c cc c c 

c c c   c cc  c c  c cGcc  c  c c  c c cc c c c cc c c cc

cc  c  c c  c cc c c

  c cc  c c cc  #ccccc

cc c cc%c

c . c c cc cc c c   ccc!  c

c c c c  c

cc c c!  cGc cc c c  a quoc cc  c  c c  c cc cc6c
<c
539  c cc c -c'c
;c
53<c cc 

cc c c cc c cc  c c  c c c c c  cc  c c c c c  c   c c     c cc c c  c cc'c'  c*c%   c   c  cc cccc  c

c'c  c c
c
4c
53<c cc c cc H c  c

cc cc c   c cc c + cc c c c cc cc  c'c' c(c+ c cc

cc'c$c
53;c  cc  c c:c

c   cc cc    c:c c ccc   c cc c c ccc 

  c  cc   c c

c  "c

cc c cc c  cccc c cc c ccc   c ccc c

c   c cc  cc   c  cc cc c  c c   ccc c

cHc c  c  c c

c cc  c  c c cc  c

c
 c$cc
4c

cc c

c   c cc c cc c cc c  cc c c  c   cc cc   c cc ccc c c   c ccc c  c c:c

c   ccc ca quoc cc c creinvindicatoriac c c c   #ccc c c c   c

caccion reinvindicatoriac c  ccc  c

cc c

cc  c   #ccc c c   c  c  c cc c  cc c c c c c cc cc

  c  cc c

c c  cccc  :c

cc c ccc     c cc c % c  cc! c c  c c  c c-cc  c ccc c  c  c c c  cc c cc     c cc  c Ccc cc  ccc!  c

c cc c  c

ccc c c c c c   c  c+c  c

c cccc c  c c  c

c

 c    c

cc c

c c  cc  c c ccccc

c   ccc 

c

ccc c!  cc: c

cc 

H c  c cc

c c      #cc c ccc #cc c c cc c  c  c  cc  c

cc  ccc!  c

cG c c c  c cc   ccc c c c c c  c cc cH

cc c c  c cc   c    c cc c C cc  c  cc  ccc c

c   c c cccc  c  cc c: c

cc  c ccaccion publiciana,cc ccc c

c   c  c ccGc  Gc cc c  Molina vs. De Bacudc
5c
+c59<cG cc  c cc c

c=  c  c

cc   c c  ccc c cc c cc  c

c c c  c  cc  cc c c
#cc cc  cc c c c H    c c! cc c  Hc

cc c cc c

cc ccc c
5&&c' c  c  c c c cc    Hc  ?c  c

c. c
cc cc

c. ccccc c c c+ c  c c :cc c cccc c

c c cc c c  c c c ccc cc  cccc    c cc c c   c c cGc c  ccc c c!  cc c cc c  c  cc  c c c cc
 c&c

cc( c.c+c   c +c* c
&
cc  c c  c

c c c c c c cc6  c

c .   c cc c Cc :c c  cc c  c c cGc  c c cc.c6c

cc   c

c cc  c ccc  c  c c   c c  c   cc cc

ccc    c c c cc ccc cc cc   c  c cc c c   c c cccc

cc cc  c

c   c  ccc ccc    c cc c

cDiaz vs. Macalinaoc
4c( c555c   c   c  c  c c cccc c  c c c c c

c   c c 

cc   ccccccc c c c  cc c

c   cccc cc cc   c ccc  cc c cc  c cc c c     c cc c cReyes vs. Sta. Mariac5
c
+c
<&cc c c! c cc c c  c c ccc c cc c cccaccion publicianac cc c

cc c c  c   c cc c ccaccion reivindicatoriac  c  cc c H c     c c c c c c c cc c c c  c  c  c c c  c :c  cHcc   c

c  ccc    c

cc c c c Hc cc  c   c

c  c cc   Hc  c c c  c

cc c cc c c c c

c   c

cc c cc c c ccc cc ccc  c   Hc   c cc c c c

c c c c  cc c   ccccHc
c c c cD c<$c
+c3;#c. cc c5c( c <
;c cc c
  ? cc  c cc   c  c cc c

c  c   c

c c c c  c  c cc cc!  c

c   c c c cc   c  cc  c c : ccc cc!  c

c cccc c c c

c  c c  ccc  ?c  c

cc c c   ccc  cc   c c c  c c c  c

c ccc c cc c c c  c  c c ?c 'c;c
+c$$#c( c c
c5c( c9#c  c c6c%c
5c
+c59<#cD   c c c c
+c$;9#cc c+c
4
cc
cc c

c c   ccGc  c cc c  c c c c  c   c  Gcc   c  c

cc  c cGI  c

c c cc (  c

cc( cc c

cc6 Gc c cc  c cc c c c c  c ccaccion publicianac c  c c  c c c c c

c

    c cc c + cc  c ccGcc c c  c c c cc   c  ccc   c cc c

c   c ccc c ccc  cc c c  c

cc c

c c c c  c

c-cc  c cc c c c c c    ccc c!  c cc ccc cc  cc c c c c      c cc c c c c c   ccc c c c

c   c cc cc

cc  c c ccc  H c c c c c! c c c c c   c

cc  cc c

c c cc c  c c :cc cc   c  c c c c! c   c cc c 

c c  c c c   c c c c '   c

cc  c c  cc ccc . !  c cc6c%  c c$3c
+c9$9cc c ccc  c ( c c= c

c6 c
c
+c
44cc cc    c cc cc c   c ccc

cc cG'   c

cc c

cc ccc  c ccc cc cc c c

cc    c cc  c

cc  c c c c c c  ccccc  cc  c  cc c

cc Gc . !  c cc6c%  c  csupra  c cc c

c c c c! c   c cc cc cc c ccc

cc c

cc   c  c c c c cc c ccc   c  cc c

c c c

c   c  cc   c  cccc  c c  cc c c  c  c c c   ccc c

cc  c c  ccc

c c

c c c  cc c cc   cc c cc  c ccc  c cc! c c  c cc   c cc   c c

c  cc c c c cc

  c  c+cc c cc  c c  ccc c

c  c cc cc ccc  c  c   cc c c  c c cc c  c c cc cc c cc cccc  c cc

c c ccc cc  ccc c  ccc c

cc   c cc   c c cc c  c c c  c c  c&5c
+c$
5c %  cc   c  c

cc   c  cccc  c c  cc  c  cc c  cc c

c ccc  cG c Gccc

 cc   c  ccG c c

c  Gc ?cc  ?c cc c  c+ ccc

c c    cccc c c cc  c  c c c ccc  cc c c c ccc cc  c  c c c   c   c cc c +-6 *,.)cc  c c c c  c cc  c cc c c cc'c$c
53;c

cc  c'c cccc  ccc c  c c c ccc cc  c

cc   c cc c   c  c c    c cc c
-c-6  6c c c  c

cc(    c 57c$5c  c
-*6c6 D
-*c "%%c%c&);9G'ccccccccccccc c:Gc:;;)c =c#%c$c !cc !3 3c$c4%ccc  c c$c c"c
5"c   c 6c cc c
c c-c*c "cD*c  c cc  c c c c 
ccc&9c

cc
553c c

c  c( c   cc 6 cc  $c

cc c

c+ c c+,c
(c* c5;93ccc c c

 c c  &c

cc c c c c%c;9cI? c c c c  c c* cI 4&9$9;
c cc ccc c cc c   c cc c c  c  c c  cc  9c caccion reivindicatoria c c cc   c  c%c  c cc   cD c1c  c  c   c   c cc,c0 cc  c c :c c  c c* cI4&9$9;
cc 

c c%c;9c

ccc

cI? c c cc  c  ccc cc  c cc  c cc c c
c c&c+ c44$c c  c c c  c cc c  c cc. c&=

c * c$c+ c
cC c=  c(:c
  cI? c c cc c

c($$444444c cc c c   c+  c c  c cc cc;c

c  c cc c  c   c

cc c c  c0 ccc c

cc  c c

c c  c  ?ccc ccc  cc c cc c c

c  c  c+c  c :c  c c c  c c ccc  ccc c  c  > cc  c  c cc c  cc cc0 cc c cc ccc 
-c;c- c44&c  c cc  c c6c6 c  c c c6  c c c  cc  c

c   ccc c

cc  c  c c  c c cc    c c  ccc c ;

  c0 c cc  c c6  c cc cc c c

c  c c c
;c * c44&c  cc  c

c:c

c   c ccc c ccc

cccc   cB c c ccc

c  c  c0 cccc0  cc.c2 c  c% c 0.2%c c   c cc  c c cc c c cc  c cc  c cc cc c

cc   c c cc c  c 

c c c

c   c cc c  c  c cc c  c  c0 cccccc c! c   c cc c

c  c c c c  c c
 c
<cc
&c

cc c

c c cc c  c

c   c cc  c c0 cc cc  c cc  c c

c cc  c cc  ?c  c0 c c  c ccc   cc c cc c cc cc   c c cc  cc  c c  c 5c + c  c cc c cc  c c  ccc cc-  c-
4c c
c c449c c cc  c c  cccccc > c   c c c  ccc   c cc cc c cc  c c  c cc c   c ccccc   c c c c cc cc ! c   c c  c ccc cc  c0 > c  c c  c cc  cc c c! c cc  c c

c c ccc    c

c  c c c cccc  c c c c c  c c c  cex-partec  c  c cc  c0 c c cc c -c
;c+ c449c  c0 c cc c cc cc cc   c

c   c 

cc ccc  c  c c cc   cc   c c cex-partec  c  c c c cc+ c449c  c 0 c cc   c

cc   c c c cc  c

cc  cc  c

cc  c

c cex-partecc  c

cc c

c c  c  c  ccc c

cc c  cc   c  c

c   c c  c
   c

-c
3c'c443ccc cc c  c  c   c c  > c  c  c c  c

c   c  ccc cc c

c c  c  c cc c c c  c

cc 
$c 0 c   cccc cc c

c+ c cc  c  c c c  c  ccc-  c-cc
cc449cc-cc
3c'c443c cc'c    cc cc cc c cccc  c c  c c* cI4&9$9;
cc   c c:c

c   c -c3c
c443cc c

c+ ccc  c6 c c   >c   c c  ccc c c cc  c  c

cccc cc   c

c  > c  c c:c

c   c c  c  cc5c* c443cc  c

c+ c c  > c  c c   c 0cc  c  c cc   c "c
c c cc  c cc  c cc c   c c  c c* cI4&9$9;
#c c cc c   cc c  c c c  ?cc   c

cccc  cc c c  #cc $c    c   c c

ccc<9c  c  c

c  cc cc  cc c  c c  c c  
&c  c  c cc c cc  c cc  ccc  c cc c c   c ccc cc cc  c  cc cc c

c    c cc c   c c cc

cc   c

ccc cc  c

accion reivindicatoriac  c c c  c c    c cc

cc ccc   c

cc cc ccc c  c

cc   cccccc cc c c c'   c

cc c cc c c cc

cc c c  c cccc ccc  c c c cc c
9  c  c cc c   c cc cc cc

cc  c
<

+c  c

c
 c
c

c(  c6c (6c* c
$&& c c cc c

  c

cc0.2%
3c  c   cc  c!   c  c c  c c c cc   c  c  "c
 -*c
c cc c

c  c   c cccc ccc  cc c  c  c  c  c  c c c(  c6c* c593cc* c0  c+  c cc  c   c ccc c  c

cc   c"c +c2 cc c  c  #c %c  c   c ccc c  c cc   c c c    c cc   cc c c cc :c c  #cc c  c   c  c c

c cc  c    c cc c

c   c c c    c c  cc c cc c  c c ! c  c ccc cc c

cc > cc cc   c c  c cc  cc  c c  cc cc c c c  c  c c  c

cc c  c c c cc* c0  c+  c *0+c7 c0.2%8c c  c cc  cc cc c

cc c c  "c

GC0  +
c  c  ccccc c   c  c  c   c B c  ccc c c   cc    c c  cc  c c   c  c c cc   c  c   cc c  c c !  c c cccc  c

c cc c #c C0  +
c  c

c c c c  c  c

c   cc c   c cc   c   cc    c  cc   c c c  c c  c  c cc c c  c c  c  cc cc ccc c cc

c  c

cc c   c  c c

c  c  c c .G
;c c

c ccc c  cc cc c c c c   cc   c

 B  cc c c cc c

cc   c

cc*0+c cc0.2%c c c     c c  cc

cc  c cc  ccc c cc c c   cccc*0+c cc0.2%c c   c c   c c  c  c cc   c ccc cc c c cc  cc   c  c c c c  c cc  c    c c:cc   cccc c  c 
5c Ccc cc c

cccc c c   c cc c c cc  c

cc   c*  c cc  c c cc c c c   cc  c cc cc c  :cc   c

cc0.2%cc c  c cc  c cc  c c cc c c    c

cc c c cc c  cccc

cc   c c cc   c

c c(6c* c593c c(6c* c
$&&c 

c ccc

cc  cc  c

cc 0.2%c c c * c c c cc c

c
c
c(6c* c
$&&c c ccc0.2%> c    c  c  c cbyc   c c c    c c c+ c cc c  cG cc c  Gcc  c   c ccc cc    c  cc  c   c  cc  c c    c  cc  c c cvice versa4c c  c  c ccc  c cc   c ccc c c c  c c   c  c c c  cc  c c    c cc c

cc   c c  c c c :c c  c cc cc cc c  c= cc c

c c  ccc c c c  c cc  c c

cc  c cc c c  c c : c c ccc  c

cc c

cc c c c(  > c  c ccc c c c cc   c cc  cccc  cc   c ccccccc cc c cc c c 
  c0 c  c  > c   c c  c c c c

cc ccc c

c  cc   c

cc c  cc c  c cc  cc   c

ccc cJavellana v. Hon. Presiding JudgecRTC, Branc 30, Manilacc c

cc   c

cc c cc  c caccion publicianacc c

c c cc ccc  c c c ccc c c cc

cc   c cccc c cc  c c cc  c c ccc  ccc c cc   c c ccc c c cc   c c  c c  c c   c cc0.2%c-c  c cc   c c 

 c  cc c cc   c cc ccc c c c c  cc   c c c c  cc c

c(6c* c593cc(6c* c
$&&cc c  c c c   c

cc0.2%$c c c c   c cAntipolo Realty Corp. v. National Housing Aut ority&c c  cc ccc0.2%c c   c c    c   cc  c

cc  c

c

c  ccc c c cc   c cAntipolo Realtyc c c !c c cc  c   cc c c  c cc cc  c

ccc c  c  c  c    c c c c  c   c cc   c  cc  c  c

c cc ccc  cc
 c
cc c

c(6c* c
$&&c cc   ccc   c

cc0.2%c ccc  c cc  cc  ccc c  cc  c

cc  cc    c

cc  c cc c

c 9 c cc(6c* c593 c cc  c c  c c c c cc <   c c c c c  c: ccc c c  c cc ccc   c c ccc cc cc  c cc0.2%c c cc 3 cc  cc c c c   c  c

c  c ;

c c cSuntay v. Gocolay c cc

cc(6c* c593c   cc!   c  c    cc     c c c ccc c

c+ c cc  c  c cccobiter dictumc+ ccc

c cc c cSuntayc cc  c ccc 0.2%c cc c ccc

cc c c c

c  c

ccc c

cc c

c:c

c   c(6c* c593cc(6c* c
$&&cc cc c c  cc c c c  cc    ccc c  cc c c c  :c cc(6c* c
$&&cc c : c  cc  c

c   c

cc c    c c cc  cc  c c ccc  c

c  c   ?ccc0.2%cc
 c
c

c(6c* c
$&&c c c

c+ cccc  c cc c c c c  c

ccc

c c  c c cc  c   c cc  c   ccc c cc   c c  c  c cc

ccc

cc   c  c c  c   c ccc c ccc0.2%c c   c cc   c  cc c c

c cc

cc   c c * cc   c   cc   c c    c c  ccc c

cc 5 0.2% c cc ccccc c

c   ccc  ci.ecc

c c   c B cc   c cc  c c  c c   c cc 0.2%c= cc c c c  cc c   c

cc0.2%cc cc cc c

cc c cc c
 c
c

c(6c* c
$&&$4c* c cSpouses Dela Cruz v. Court o{ Appeals$
cc ccc   c

ccc cc  c c c

cc  c c c

cc   c  cc c cc c c c ccc

cc  c  c c
 c
c(6c* c
$&&c c  c  c  cc c c "c -c cccc  cccc c   ccc* c0  c +  c *0+c cc cc0.2%c c   c c   c cc  cc   c c c c c  c cc  c    c = c cc   c ccc  c

cc c c c cc  c

cc  c c ccc  c

cc  c c c

c   c cc c   c  c cc c c ccc ccc cc0.2%ccc   c c  c c cccc

c ccc   c

cc c cc cc c  ccc  c

cc  c   c

cc c cc 

c c c c  c cc c c

cc  c c c+ cc c  !cc   c

c c c ccc cc cc   c cc cc c c cc  c c   c c  cc!  c

c   c c c cc cc cCc   cc   c

cc c ccc

cc cc c c  cc   c cc  cc c cc  cccc

cc  c ccc  c cc  $c cc  c c   >c  c c  c cc cc

 c  c  cc  cc  cc c c ccc c c c

 ccc

c  c   c c  c cc

c cc c c cc  c  c ccc C0  =- cc  c  c c c c  c c,+* 6ccc6 cc3c
c443cc  cc5c* c443c

cc c

c+ c c+,c
(c* c 5;93cc D 
6cc
c+
6 cc  cc
cc449cc
3c'c443c

cc  c c c%c;9cI? c c c  c c* cI4&9$9;
cc *
+ 6cc  c c c c-6  6c c cc   c cc c  c c* cI4&9$9;
c  c c c  c  c   c
-c-6  6c c  c

cc(    c 57c$5c  c = 
c6 D
-*c cc "%%c%c3');(;c c&;c&GG'c $c=cPetitionerc c
%c"c%ccc7  ,c= ,c# cc$ c -c  c

 c-c4 . c cccRespondentsc #cD*c cc c (  c=  c' c!   c c cc c

cc c c c  cc c c

c c c c  c  cc  c c  ccc cc c

c  c c  c c! c c cc c

cres judicatacCc  cc   c  caccion interdictalcaccion publiciana caccion reivindicatoria  accion de reivindicacion  c cc  c  c cc    c cc c c cc c9c'c
5<$c  c cc   c
 c+  c c. c* c
<&
c  $4;c

cc-  c  c
  c. cF:c-  c c cc6  c.c -

c%c

c. c-  c c
 c c6c
534c cc c c  c    c

cc  c

ccccc c%c% c c   cc  c c  cc  cc c c

c-  c c :c c  c c* c5<c  c c ccc$c c cc ccc 

c ccc cc cc c c  c

cc cc

cc cc. cF:c c

c-  c  c c c c c. c* c
<&
c $4;c

cc-  c  c
  c c
5<
ccc cc c  c cccc   c  ccccc
 c c6c
c
534cc c  c c  c

c 

cc  c c  c  c c cc c  ccc  c cc  cc

c. c* c
<&
c $4;c cc c

c c c c   c

c  c ccF:c c c

c  c  c

c#c  cc c c cc  c 

H c c :c c c ?c  c  cc c c : c   c c  cc 

cc  c  c%.c

%c

c. c  c ccc c  c c c  c c  c

c  c  c

cc c   ccc

c44c !c  c c c c&c cc c -c3c* c
53cc c c

c-  c c%c&c:c  c  c c* c5
c. c c  ccc c!  c cc

 c. c
<&
c

cc 

cccGc9cc6 c

cc c c

c-  c cc cc  c c$4c+ c
53$cccc c

c=  c  c

c1 cc-  c c%c c' $ c  cccc

cc   cc   c

cc c c  cc c  c  c  c c c 

 c c c cccc c!  c c  c ( c   c

c. c* c
<&
c c cc c
 !c c
3c6c
53$c  c cc   c
 c(c* c99&;cc c-  c c

c c* c($95c  c. c* c
<&
c c%c% c c cc  ccc cc  c c  ccc cc cc c  c  cc  c

c c44c !c c c!  c cc c  c c c  c cc c

cc cc c c  c  c c cc  c c  c cc  c cc c -c5c'c
533c c c c c &c c  cc  c

cc  c

c  c c* c5<c   c   cc  c c!  c

c cc c

c  c c c  c%c % cc  c c ccc c

c=  c  c

c1 cc-  c c  :c c  c c* c4$4c c c ccc$c ccc ccc 

c cc c c c c c

ccc

cc  c c. c* c
<&
c $4;c-  c  c
  cccc cc-  c c

c c * c($95c ccc c

c6 c cc  c

c1 cccc
 c c6c
534cc c c  c c cc  c c c6c$c
5<5c cc%c

c. c cc !c c  cc c   cc  c  c

c 

H c   c c

c c44c !c ccc c% *c%+%-.cc cc c *-c-
 c c c c cc c

c c c ccc  cc  c c * !  cccc c cc c  c

c  cc   c c c c  c c  c  c c  c c  cc  c cc c

cres judicatac6 c%c% c c c cc    c cc c c+

c)

c  c-cc3c'c
53; ccc c

c=  c  c

c1 c%c
 c   cc c

c ccc c  c c  c c  H c  c c   c  c cGc0c c  c c c ccertiorari  c cc c (  c  ccres judicata  cc cc  c c cc c c  c

c  c c  c

c ccc  c c  cc cc c c cc  ccc  !c  c c!  c

c c
c cc c  c  c  c c  : cc  c cres judicatac cc c cc  cc c c c c cin personam#c c ccc  pendente litec c c cc c  :cc  c

cres judicatacC cc cc c

c c c   ccc c c  c

c  c

c c cc  c c c c  cc c cc c cc   c

cc c cc  !c c c c!  c

c c c

: c  cc

  c

cc c  c cc c

( c  c c   ccc c  c

c  c cc c  c cc cc  c c  cc c

cc c cc  c c cc c

cc  c c -cc c

c  c

c  c

c cc c  cc c

cc c  c cc   c c  cccc  !c  c c!  c

c c cc c

c c  c c  c   c c  cc cc    c cc c  cc c c cc  cc  res judicata  ccc    c

cc  !c cc

  c!  c c "c
cc ccc cc c #c cc c cc c cc   c cc c#c $cc cc ccc cc   #cc &cc ccc  cc  c  c  c

c  c

c ccc

c   c

c c&;cc c

cc  cc!  ccc  c

c cc cc

c! cc c c0cc c  c  ccc cc  c c * c5
c  cc

c  c

c c c ccc    c

c  c c* c4$4  c cc c (  H cccc c c  c

c  ccc c  c c  c cCcc ccc cres judicata  ccc c! c c c cc c   c  c

c  c&&c c c ccc  c

cres judicata c cccc c  c   c  c cc  !c   c c ccc  ccc c  c  c

c  c  c cc  c cc c cc c c c c cc  c c c c cc cc c c c cc c cc  c c  c c&:c c ccc  cc&9c c
c&5cc cc$5c c

c c   ccGccccc c c c c c ccc c c c c cc ccc ccc c c c c  cc c  cc c   c c  cc c  !c cc c

cc c c  c  c   c cc c cccc c cc cc c Gc c c c cc ccc c c cc c  c  c c cc  c c  c

c%c % cc c  !c cc cc  c

cc  c c0cc cc c c   c  c

cc  ccc c  c%cc c c c  H c ccc c c  c

c  c

c cc  c c * c5
c c c c c cc c c c cG78c c c cc c c  cc c c c c c  c

cc cc c  cde {acto c c  cde jurecc  c c cc cc   c

ccc   c

cc c cc  ccc cc! c  c c ccc cc  cc c c  Gc&(c+cccc cc c c c

c  c c  c c cc !  c

c  cc c cc   c c  c c ccc cc c c

cc

  c

ccc c  c&*c cc c -cc cc  c c* c4$4c c c c cc c cGI  c

c c c c

c(  c c6 Gc c c cc c c ccc

cc ccaccion reivindicatoria c+c&$&c&+c

cc  c cc  cc   c  c  c c* c5<c  c ccaccion interdictalc= cc c

cc  c c  c c* c4$4c 

c  c   c cc  cc c c  cc cc  c ccc  c c cccc cccc cc c  c

c cc &)   c:c

ccc

ccaccion reivindicatoriac c cc c &G

c  c cEmilia v. Badoc c c cc c c c c  c

ccc c  cc c  c cc  c cc c c c  c

c c ccaccion interdictalc c cc c c c  cc detentacioncc c H c  c

cc c c cab initioc cc c c c c c

desa uicoccc H c  c c   c cc c cc ccc  c

c c c c  c c

c c cc c  c cc  ccc

ccc cc c c c

c  ccc  ccc

c cc c c

c c c cc  c  c c c c   c c #c:;caccion publiciana  c ccc c c  c

cc c c  cc c  cc c cc c c c ccc    c c c c cc c#ccaccion reivindicatoria caccion de reivindicacion  c : cc c

c   cc  c jus utendi c jus {ruendi c cc c c c c Accion reivindicatoria caccion de reivindicacion c cc cc 

c c   c

ccc

ccc : c c

c  c c  c:&c c c

c  accion interdictal caccion publiciana c 

cc c

c

ccc c c  c  c ::  c

c c c cc c c  c c* c5
c c c  c0c c  c c* c5
cc cc

cc c c  c c * c4$4c c cc c cGc c c c c Gc

ccc

ccG cc -  c c c

c c* c($95Gcc  c c  c c* c4$4c  c  c c!  c

c   ccc  c  c c  c

c 

H c c

c cc  c   c  cc c c  c c ccc c

c c   c  c c c ccccc c  cc c c c   c

c c c c c  cc c c c cc c

c  ccc c c    ccc c c c c  c

c c cc c c c

c   c:9c cc c +c cc c

cc cEn Banc c±uimpo v. De la Victoriac:'cc ccc  c c * c4$4c cc  c c! c c c  c c   c  c c cc c

c c

c  c c cc  !cc c c  c

c  c

c cc  c c* c5
ccc c

c=  c  c

c1 c%c c c  c c-  c c  c  c c* c4$4cc  c  !c-c c   c

cc  cc D 
6cc
c +
6   c cc c c:c

c c c c ccc  c  c cc c

ca quo ccc c  c cc c

c  c c* c4$4c c c c c c c  c    c cc c
-c-6  6c c