Optical fiber solution for mobile fronthaul to achieve Cloud Radio Access Network
Embedded R esonant esonant
and ModulablE Self-tuning laser cavity for next generation access network transmitter
Philippe CHANCLOU, Anna PIZZINAT, Fabien LE CLECH, To-Linh REEDEKER, Yannick LAGADEC, Fabienne SALIOU, Bertrand LE GUYADER, Laurent GUILLO, Qian DENIEL, Stephane GOSSELIN, Sy Dat LE, Thierno DIALLO, Romain BRENOT, Francois LELARGE, Lucia MARAZZI, Paola PAROLARI, Mario MARTINELLI, Sean O’DULL, Simon Arega GEBREWOLD, David HILLERKUSS, Juerg LEUTHOLD, Giancarlo GAVIOLI, Paola GALLI
Session 9e, 04 July 2013
contact: philippe.chanclou
[email protected] @orange.com
Future Network & MobileSummit 2013
Copyright 2013 ORANGE Labs
Summary:
Context of Cloud Radio Access Network
Which are the main constraints of fronthaul?
Discussion on optical network for the fronthaul
Self-seeded WDM solution
Conclusion
Session 9e, 04 July 2013
Future Network & MobileSummit 2013
Copyright 2013 ORANGE Labs
Summary:
Context of Cloud Radio Access Network
Which are the main constraints of fronthaul?
Discussion on optical network for the fronthaul
Self-seeded WDM solution
Conclusion
Session 9e, 04 July 2013
Future Network & MobileSummit 2013
Copyright 2013 ORANGE Labs
Optical architecture for Mobile fronthaul: Step 2: Distributed base station with « traditional » backhaul
Step 1: Macro M acro base station
RRH ~15kg
RRH
RRH RRH
coax
D-RoF RRU RRU
D-RoF BBU
RRU
RRU: Remote Radio Unit RRH: Remote Radio Head BBU: BaseBand Unit CSG: Cell-Site Gateway D-RoF: Digital Radio oe! Fi"e! #C$R% o! &BS'% standa!d( Session 9e, 04 July 2013
e l m e u t s d y o S m
BBU
e l m e u t s d y o S m
CSG
RRH close to the antenna Energy savings
Space constraints in cell site cabinet
Future Network & MobileSummit 2013
Copyright 2013 ORANGE Labs
Step 3: BBU hostelling with stacking (or BBU centralisation) •
BBU colocalised in secured CO (no need for IPSec)
•
X2 optimisation,
•
Future proof with respect to LTE-A evolutions (CoMP support)
•
Energy and deployment savings (expected 20%), site engineering
•
Feasible today
RRH
Cent!al &..ice D-RoF
RRH
RRH RRH
optical distribution network
BBU
e l m e u t s d y o S m
BBU
e l m e u t s d y o S m
BBU
D-RoF
F!ont/a0l Session 9e, 04 July 2013
Future Network & MobileSummit 2013
e l m e u t s d y o S m
%$)*$+S netwo!k
,
S1
*'SG
Back/a0l Copyright 2013 ORANGE Labs
Step 4: C-RAN (or BBU hostelling with resource pooling) 4 Cs of C-RAN: Centralization, Cloud, Cooperation, Clean
RRH
RRH RRH
Same advantages as step 3, plus Less interfaces to core network (S1 and X2) Simplification of mobility management CAPEX savings due to reduced BBU number Trials ongoing in other countries
RRH
RRH RRH
-
D-RoF
RRH
RRH RRH
optical distribution network
F!ont/a0l
Cent!al &..ice g n d i a c o n a L l a b
,
BBU
e l m e u t s d y o S m
%$)*$+S netwo!k
Back/a0l
RRH might be replaced by Active Antenna Arrays (AAA): new antennas with integrated RRH Session 9e, 04 July 2013
Future Network & MobileSummit 2013
Copyright 2013 ORANGE Labs
S1
Definition of fronthaul and backhaul
RRH
RRH RRH
Central Office g ta - o BBU RRH
RRH
BBU RRH
X2
IP/MPLS network
EPC
e l m e u t s d y o S m
S1 MASG EN BBU
fronthaul Session 9e, 04 July 2013
e l m e u t s d y o S m
Future Network & MobileSummit 2013
CE BIOM
e l m e u t s d y o S m
backhaul Copyright 2013 ORANGE Labs
Summary:
Context of Cloud Radio Access Network
Which are the main constraints of fronthaul?
Discussion on optical network for the fronthaul
Self-seeded WDM solution
Conclusion
Session 9e, 04 July 2013
Future Network & MobileSummit 2013
Copyright 2013 ORANGE Labs
Main constraints of fronthaul for optical network 1/2
typical fronthaul requirements Data rate
Symmetric bit rate Maximum BER 10-12 Multi-rate: CPRI1 = 614.4 Mbit/s OBSAI1 = 768 Mbit/s CPRI2 = 1228.8 Mbit/s OBSAI2 = 1536 Mbit/s CPRI3 = 2457.6 Mbit/s CPRI4 & OBSAI3 = 3072.0 Mbit/s CPRI5 = 4915.2 Mbit/s CPRI6 &OBSAI4= 6144.0 Mbit/s CPRI7 = 9830.4 Mbit/s
Frequency accuracy
+/- 2 ppb (NB. Time & phase synchronization is required for LTEAdvanced; A phase accuracy requirement budget will be allocated to the CPRI link )
Jitter
Jitter values are specified according to CPRI requirements (v5.0 – 2011-09-21)
Session 9e, 04 July 2013
Future Network & MobileSummit 2013
Copyright 2013 ORANGE Labs
Main constraints of fronthaul for optical network 2/2
typical fronthaul requirements Latency vs. reach
LTE-A: 190µs round trip time (about 20km round trip)
Environment condition
RRH is an outdoor equipment (typ. -40 to +85°C)
Network operation
Scope of responsibility (fiber and radio network)
Session 9e, 04 July 2013
Future Network & MobileSummit 2013
Copyright 2013 ORANGE Labs
Fronthaul : scope of responsibility
RRH
RRH RRH
demarcation point demarcation point
Central Office e l m e u s o y S m
RRH
RRH RRH
Mobile operator Session 9e, 04 July 2013
Fiber provider Future Network & MobileSummit 2013
BBU
e l m e u t s d y o S m
BBU
e l m e u t d s o y S m
Mobile operator Copyright 2013 ORANGE Labs
Summary:
Context of Cloud Radio Access Network
Which are the main constraints of fronthaul?
Discussion on optical network for the fronthaul
Self-seeded WDM solution
Conclusion
Session 9e, 04 July 2013
Future Network & MobileSummit 2013
Copyright 2013 ORANGE Labs
Dedicated Fiber RRH
RRH
RRH
B&W* SFP
B&W* SFP
B&W* SFP Fiber Monitoring passive part
PRO’S CPRI
• no extra equipment cost for transmission
When PtP fibres is available Optional fiber monitoring
CON’S • requires many fibers • extra equipment for fiber infrastructure monitoring
Fiber Monitoring Active part part B&W* SFPs
BBU BBU Session 9e, 04 July 2013
Future Network & MobileSummit 2013
Copyright 2013 ORANGE Labs
CWDM : passive solution RRH
PRO’S • few fibers • No active components on passive mux • High MTBF • Suited for outdoor deployment • Low cost point for CWDM technology (cf. • No introduction of transport latency • up to 16 channels per fiber
CWDM Fixed color SFP
CWDM Fixed color SFP RRH
RRH
CWDM Fiber Monitoring passive part
passive devices CWDM
Fiber Monitoring Active part
CON’S • inventory management required to align optic color with RRH-BBU link • not bidirectional (2 fibers per link) • no native OAM
CWDM CWDM Fixed color SFPs
BBU BBU
Session 9e, 04 July 2013
Future Network & MobileSummit 2013
Copyright 2013 ORANGE Labs
RRH
DWDM : passive solution
PRO’S • 44/88/96 channels per fiber • Bidirectional • No active components (passive mux)
CPRI colorless DWDM RRH
Un-mapped traffic Fiber Monitoring passive part
Fiber Monitoring Active part
CPRI colorless DWDM
BBU BBU
CON’S • No native OAM
Session 9e, 04 July 2013
Future Network & MobileSummit 2013
Copyright 2013 ORANGE Labs
Fronthaul : Infrastructure monitoring principle
« Slave » passive box for demarcation point : - no touch of the traffic - optical attenuation 1 à 2 dB - monitor loopback - optical bandwidth : 1260 up to 1610 nm ∼
« master » box offering: - add and drop of supervision wavelength (1630nm) - optical attenuation 1 to 3 dB - optical bandwidth : 1260 up to 1610 nm - deliver alarms and supervision indicators -Power monitoring : per line or per wavelength ∼
1630nm Px1Px2 Tx Rx loop back for only 1630 nm
passive
Session 9e, 04 July 2013
active
Future Network & MobileSummit 2013
Copyright 2013 ORANGE Labs
Central Office
Summary:
Context of Cloud Radio Access Network
Which are the main constraints of fronthaul?
Discussion on optical network for the fronthaul
Self-seeded DWDM solution
Conclusion
Session 9e, 04 July 2013
Future Network & MobileSummit 2013
Copyright 2013 ORANGE Labs
Fronthaul : CWDM solution
RRH
Monitoring wavelength Tx
D e M U X
M U X
Session 9e, 04 July 2013
Px2
Passive device offering filtering loop back
Future Network & MobileSummit 2013
Central Office
Rx
Px1
Active Equipment
X U M
X U M e D
Copyright 2013 ORANGE Labs
BBU
e l m e u t d s y o S m
BBU
e l m e u t s d y o S m
BBU
e l m e u t s d y o S m
Fronthaul : DWDM fronthaul
RRH
M U X / D e M U X
Session 9e, 04 July 2013
Automatic and passive assignment of the wavelength (colorless) Single fiber (bi-directional) architecture
Infrastrusture monitoring wavelength & channels monitor
? Passive device offering filtering loop back
Future Network & MobileSummit 2013
Active Equipment
Central Office
X M e D / X U M
Copyright 2013 ORANGE Labs
BBU
e l m e u t d s y o S m
BBU
e l m e u t s d y o S m
BBU
e l m e u t s d y o S m
Fronthaul : DWDM fronthaul by self seeded (1/3)
RRH
) x T ( A O S R
Automatic and passive assignment of the wavelength (colorless) Single fiber (bi-directional) architecture
) x R ( D P A / N I P
SFP transceiver
M
X
X / D e M U X
M e D / X U M
i RSOA (Tx) d i B
self seeded source Session 9e, 04 July 2013
Future Network & MobileSummit 2013
Copyright 2013 ORANGE Labs
Central Office
BBU
e l m e u t d s y o S m
BBU
e l m e u t s d y o S m
BBU
e l m e u t s d y o S m
Fronthaul : DWDM fronthaul by self seeded (2/3)
RRH
) x T ( A O S R
Automatic and passive assignment of the wavelength (colorless) Single fiber (bi-directional) architecture
) x R ( D P A / N I P
SFP transceiver
M
X
X / D e M U X
M e D / X U M
i RSOA (Tx) d i B
ASE source Amplified self-seeded source Session 9e, 04 July 2013
Sliced ASE by AWG
Future Network & MobileSummit 2013
Copyright 2013 ORANGE Labs
Central Office
BBU
e l m e u t d s y o S m
BBU
e l m e u t s d y o S m
BBU
e l m e u t s d y o S m
Fronthaul : DWDM fronthaul by self seeded (3/3) Amplified Self Seeded
RRH
) x T ( A O S R
Automatic and passive assignment of the wavelength (colorless) Single fiber (bi-directional) architecture standard WDM ODN
) x R ( D P A / N I P
SFP transceiver
M
X
X / D e M U X
M e D / X U M
i RSOA (Tx) d i B
Amplified self seeded source Session 9e, 04 July 2013
Future Network & MobileSummit 2013
Copyright 2013 ORANGE Labs
Central Office
BBU
e l m e u t d s y o S m
BBU
e l m e u t s d y o S m
BBU
e l m e u t s d y o S m
Fronthaul : DWDM fronthaul by self seeded 2,5Gbit/s results 0
ASE
-10
-2
Amplified Self-Seeded
BER@10-3 with FEC
-3
Sliced
-4
-20
-5
22dB
-30
) m B-40 d ( r e -50 w P
Sliced ASE
) R-6 E B ( -7 g o L-8
-60
-9
-70
-10
-80
-11
-90 1531,5
mp e Self-Seeded
ER=8dB
-12 1532,5
1533,5
1534,5
0
1535,5
Wavelength (nm)
•
Optical spectrum centered at 1533.7nm
(CH9 of
•
2
4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 Feeder Optical budget (dB)
19dB of feeder optical budget
AWG)
•
22dB of optical improvement
Session 9e, 04 July 2013
Future Network & MobileSummit 2013
Copyright 2013 ORANGE Labs
Impact on cavity length log(BER)= f(Received power)@2.5Gb/s -2 -3 -4
SS-5km
-5
) R E-6 B ( g-7 o l
-
-8
m
-9 -10 -11 -12 -35
-30
-25 -20 -15 -10 Received power (dBm)
Self-seeded_10m-Cavity
Session 9e, 04 July 2013
-5
Self-seeded_5km-Cavity
Future Network & MobileSummit 2013
Copyright 2013 ORANGE Labs
Impact on cavity length
log(BER)= f(Received power)@2.5Gb/s
log(BER)= (cavity length)@2.5Gb/s
-2
-2
-3
-3
-4
-4
SS-5km
-5
) R E-6 B ( g-7 o l
Amp-SS-5km
-
-8
m
-9
Amp-SS-10m
-10
SS
-5 ) R-6 E B-7 ( g o L-8
-9
-11
-10
-12 -35
-30
-25 -20 -15 -10 Received power (dBm)
-5
Self-seeded_10m-Cavity
Self-seeded_5km-Cavity
Amplified SS_10m-cavity
Amplified SS_5km-cavity
Session 9e, 04 July 2013
-11 -12
Future Network & MobileSummit 2013
0
5
10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 Cavity length (km)
Copyright 2013 ORANGE Labs
Impact on cavity length
log(BER)= f(Received power)@2.5Gb/s
log(BER)= (cavity length)@2.5Gb/s
-2
ER=5.6dB
-2
-3
-3
-4
-4
SS-5km
-5
) R E-6 B ( g-7 o l
Amp-SS-5km
-
-8
m
-9
Amp-SS-10m
-10
SS
-5 Amp-SS
) R-6 E B-7 ( g o L-8
-9
-11
ER=8dB
-10
-12 -35
-30
-25 -20 -15 -10 Received power (dBm)
-5
Self-seeded_10m-Cavity
Self-seeded_5km-Cavity
Amplified SS_10m-cavity
Amplified SS_5km-cavity
Session 9e, 04 July 2013
-11 -12
Future Network & MobileSummit 2013
0
5
10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 Cavity length (km)
Copyright 2013 ORANGE Labs
Impact on cavity length
log(BER)= f(Received power)@2.5Gb/s
log(BER)= (cavity length)@2.5Gb/s
-2
-2
-3
BER@10-3 with FEC
-3
-4
-4
SS-5km
-5
) R E-6 B ( g-7 o l
Amp-SS-5km -
-8 -9
Amp-SS-10m
-10
SS
-5 ) R-6 E B-7 ( g o L-8
Amp-SS
-9
-11
45km-long external cavity
-10
-12 -35
-30
-25 -20 -15 -10 Received power (dBm)
-5
Self-seeded_10m-Cavity
Self-seeded_5km-Cavity
Amplified SS_10m-cavity
Amplified SS_5km-cavity
Session 9e, 04 July 2013
-11 -12
Future Network & MobileSummit 2013
0
5
10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 Cavity length (km)
Copyright 2013 ORANGE Labs
Conclusions
Expected gains from C-RAN (most come from BBU Hostelling)
- Radio Site engineering improvements (footprint reduced, energy efficiency, less operations on site..) - Radio performance improvements to be challenged with alternative solutions - Transport: leverage future-proof infrastructure and concentrate complexity at central office level
Technology short term possibilities
- CWDM: good, simple, cost effective option with additional “passive” fiber monitoring for first mile
Optical architecture perspective
- Self seeded source allows to achieve a colorless DWDM source with - automatic and passive wavelength assignment - single fiber (bidirectional) link - athermal wavelength allocation question : do we have solution up to 10Gbit/s?
Session 9e, 04 July 2013
Future Network & MobileSummit 2013
Copyright 2013 ORANGE Labs
Acknowlegment
FP7-ICT-2011-7
Session 9e, 04 July 2013
ERMES m edded R esonant and ModulablE Self-tuning laser cavity for next generation access network transmitter
Future Network & MobileSummit 2013
Copyright 2013 ORANGE Labs
Fronthaul : Architecture of « passive » solution Automatic fibre protection one link = 2 fibres
RRH
RRH RRH
path 1
M U X
path 2
e l m e u s o y S m
passive
RRH
RRH
X U M
Central Office
RRH
X U M
M U X
Session 9e, 04 July 2013
Future Network & MobileSummit 2013
Copyright 2013 ORANGE Labs
BBU
e l m e u t s d y o S m
BBU
e l m e u t d s o y S m
Fronthaul : short term vs mid/long term solutions #Fibers on last mile
Synchro & latency
Integrated monitoring solution
i!"
Ok
“Passive” (done by extra equipment)
Short term for CWDM
#$% &2 t$ 4'
Ok
“Passive” (done by extra equipment)
Typ. OTN based (CPRI encapsulation)
Short term
(e)y l$% &1 t$ 2'
Ok (Freq. only)
Part of OTN
Passive + active WDM
Passive CWDM + OTN
Short term
#$% &2 t$ 4'
TBC
Passive + part of OTN
Synergy with FTTH
wdm // to gpon or integration in NGPON2
Long term
FTTH infra reused
TBC
PON OAM (OMCI)
CPRI over Ethernet
CPRI I/Q encapsulated in Ethernet
Long term
*edi+m t$ i!"
TBC
Ethernet OAM (MEF)
Name
Description
Avail.
Dedicated fibre
one fiber per RRH per techno
Short term
Passive WDM
Colored SFP (RRH & BBU) cwdm or dwdm
Active WDM
Session 9e, 04 July 2013
Future Network & MobileSummit 2013
Copyright 2013 ORANGE Labs