&1B1 &1B1 >1 89 89B91 B91 3>35@ 3> 35@1< 1< 45 < @
1 (>1 45 B121 B121 )* +@
@JKF @JKFI@ I@FI FI < J @<J, < @_ @ _JF JFF F P < @JKF @JKFI@ I@FI FI < FJ <FJ <FJ P J @EJK@ @EJK@KL KL@F @FEF@J-<@> 'E>F@J-<@>EF EFFJ FJ P LJK< LJK< < CFLE CFLE>LLF, J@>F, JLJ G @GI<>E EE E JLJ KI KI FJ. D< \ < J JK< K< GIF>I< GIF>IYE< >YEFQ >FQ @JKF @JKFI@ I@ GF\ GF\K@K@ E@ h@>E@@ @ I< GIF>II L>I FJ EL\ >\ GF\ GF\K@K@. . *
AJ@>EF AJ@>EF >1 1 45 B121 B121 FE @EK@ >@ P GIF>I GIF>IS SK@K@ HL< P19 6B1>P195 5 K@F K@FE@ >@J J HL< HL\ J< JL>@< JL >@ # =5> G9 J J (+I\J, (+I\J, "@ "@I, I, 1985) P \ \ <<KL <<KLF F LE GI@< GI@F KF L >LEF, EF, GFI F KEKF, KEKF, J FEL FELJ@F J@FE@ >@J J < LE KI KI F HL< P P < F F < @EK< @EKI >IJ< J< JFI< JFI< J\ @JF. @J F. GI@ FI@>@E E 8R >8R5 5, 4(1-2), 65 65, BI< Prismas, R!/%a ! $%)+%a %(!&!ca&, N 6, 2002, **. 123-133.
E "1 Q @2<95 1 9<<175,2 LI@< A>LFE @F JLJ IKJ < EF@J. ' JF@FF>\ GF\K@, GFI JL F, FEF@_ LE @EL< GI@M@<>@F, I<@_E < LE FELIJF < @I_ <@FJ < Y < 1970 JL F GFI FFIJ@,4 AEE@< &I@<><,5 LI@< DLMLEFJ, <@IFE @IFJ, FP SJ@FJ, +IK@F CFLE@JK IEYJ F F < FJ GIK@FJ. +FI FKI GIK<, LEIFE FJ KI FJ JFI< J Y@K\ GF\K@, IIL < @JKFI@ < J @<J P @JKFI@ < J @EJK@KL@FEFJ KFIFE < I<F, < < FJ JF@_F>FJ. +FI\ P IELIF < HL< L
2 3
. A>LFE, "1 Q @2<95 1 9<<175, +I\J, 549 3945>391 <97LB931 45 <1 45=3B1391 =45B>1, BLFIJ@, "1 DQ=3B195 5 <5 @1B9 @<995 (FJ MFc<, "5 C==>95 6B1>P19. E19 4b58>7B1@895 @<995, +I\J, 91 6B1>355, I@, @I, 1978. 6 . DLM95 6B1>P19?, +I\J, PI, 1982. 8 EKI< FKIFJ J@>EFJ < . 124
>cE FF, EL@ < FJ P FJ @JKFI@FI>1<5 \E <<KLF FE I<F LJ, IF FIFJF JFK@IEF, @JK@EKF: FI@_E GIF>I35@1< 45 < @F < FJ @M IL < J GIF<SK@J < ES@J@J < F GF\K@F < FJ I FcE. +I @LJKII F HL< <@FJ, @K<FJ K\KLF @E@K@MF J J@>L@5 5> FB1>35),9 +. E35 45 <1 @<995 =45B>5),10 +. BYE@FL ( "5 13B5 45 )11 F '. DLFEK ( H= 151<9);12 l I5B <1 Q<9> 6B1>P195)13 F B. BQF ( "=9RB5 45 5>9> 4Q=3B195;15 l < \ GF\K@ B5 );17 l I<K@M@_E < @FJF\ < 5).18 9 C. @F5 5> FB1>35, +I\J, "@I, 1982. 10 +. E35 45 <1 @<995 =45B>5, +I\J, +PFK, 1977. 11 +. BYE@FL, "5 13B5 45 , +I\J, %FJY CFIK@, 1973 KIL@_E JK<E: "1 3B>139V>
45< 53B9B. E>1 2B5 5< 145>9=95> 45 > @45B 5 @9B91< <193 5> <1 FB1>391 =45B>1, YO@F, C, 1981. 12 '. DLFEK, H= 151<9, +I\J, "@I, 1976 KIL@_E JK<E: H= 151<9. GQ>59 1@75 45 <1 945<7T1 53>V=931, I@, /LILJ, 1999. 13 . LI5B <1 Q<9> 6B1>P195, +I\J, "@I, 1978 KIL@_E JK<E: &5>1B <1 5<39V> FB1>351, BI<FE, +5>9> 4Q=3B195, +I\J, PI, 1981 KIL@_E JK<E: "1 9>5>39V> 45=3BL931, BLB5 B1 5< E14, BI<FE, FEK< sM@, 1978. 17 . "L, +I\J, "@I, 1980. 18 '. 5 KIL@_E JK<E: F9< 6T1 @1, YO@F, C, 1991. 125
/FJ F EF JK GI IK@F P LE LI FE< J< IK@LE F JF@ P JL I P J< I<< MF < FFLIFJ EF@_E < @JKFI@ FEF \. *** ' @JKFI@ KI@@FE < J @<J < GI<< I GFI @@J HL< P HL< KF>I FE L@F. +F<FJ J<^I GFI F 139V> 45< 49339>1B9. CFEJ@F $ FF J < R@< >LI\J FEJ>IJ @JK@EKFJ LKFIILG@ @EK<<KL < J@>F. +F<FJ IE@ GFI IEXF@J CUK<E@@ HL< P HL< I<QIFJ. A FEKII@F, PFI\ < J FIJ HL< <FJ @KF FEJK@KLPIS@J, GILE GIF<SK@ >F. R. >L 5< 97< I , +L1 45 <1 Q@31 B=L>931, YO@F, C, 1984. 23 . CUK<5 1 #1, I@, A, 1989, KI
126
FE @IFJ <FJ GI 3><1, EF I < GI<1. < IYE 4 B14931<9=5 @89<@895 < . #YMP,24 .-. 51 5 <1 395>35 @<995 45 > 5=@ < . DF FEJLF P LIEo F nIE LE P FEF@F. E JL FI LK (. DI, K@d<, KIQE FI@FJ @JK < KFFJ HL<FJ HL< nFLIIFEo l @JF K@<GF HL<, YILLJK< CFK< F 'F< LIJ J@<GI< @@_E < FJ KF, J@ J_F J< J< HL< F, Kc L
24 . #YMP, "1 FB=19> 4 B14931<9=5 @89<@895, +I\J, 1901-1904, KI35 @<995 45 > 5=@, +I\J, I@E, 1974 (GI@
1950).
K@F. < FGI A @K P BB399=. E F < LE FI JFI< L, 391. 5) E< 9 @<79=. <@E JFI< KFF L K\KLF < I< +IYFK (DFQ), HL< GFI F < J LEFJ L@I < E@FE@JF n<FK@MFo (BIIZJ, +Y>LP), n@EK<>Io (LIIJ), nKFK@KI@Fo (#@KLE @JKFI@ IE PL GI E@<. JKJ @EF <@@IFJ @MKIFJ > 8135> 3= @B5>45B >141 89VB93, 1> 31>4 1@B5>41= =38 45 B1 31. GFIK< < @JKFI@ FE1<94145 @F@ILGFJ JF@@EE JL GFIM
FEKII@F, < LE KI F GILGFJ JF@E@QE EL@@@ < J J@KL@FEL, JFLEFJ <<GFJ < F $ KF $$$? JKFJ <<GFJ GLEKL@_E JFI< < J9414 @ JLI>@@ILI >IEIEEFJ. F GF<FJ FEFIIEFJ, GFI <<GF, FE GI<@IJ< L (GFI <<GF, LEF J< < <FI@ EF J<
27
FI< 8R5, 111112, L@F-@@<I< < 1983, P <>\K@
K@E@ I5B139 P 3= @B5>9. $EKLIJ SJ F FJ, < J @JKE@J, < J JLGd< HL< < @JKFI@FI J< @) @G@ I<FEJKIL@I < FF FF FJ KFIL<@@1B91>5 F N<L@FJ @EILGFJ JF@F, J@ J< FJ@EE. JK @EM
28
' <GK\, FEKII@F < J@GK\, EF @G@ E@E>LE @LEFJ < IF $ GIK@I < "L@QFK. ' <GK\ I 6B=139V> (HL< < > GQ < 391=95> (HL< < > >191>35 4b1B9, @KF >19B5 45 <1 <1>75 @89<@895, +I\J, +, 1969: n' <GK\
@JKFI@ GF\K@ < L< J\ FJ MEF@@F LE@M IL@JK P @E< < @F LE@MI < KI F < LE GIF< ( I<L@_E GIF>I 5< 9>939, P HL< J_F @G@@LI IIF, F FLYJ P F GFGLI) LP I @_E JFI< < GIE FF EK>_E@FJ. ' F P J <KLIJ HL< <@_E HL< LE < IL@LEFJ JFJ GL<< F < LE J@G< B5B>. L< L@IJ< <SJ < >LEJ K
29 30
. ALI, H99B5 @<995 45 <1 Q<9> 6B1>P195, +I\J, AIE CF@E, 1913. JLK\KLF < @IF lnI@>@E
3>51< 45 <1 9451 (. FJ KI FJ < LE\@F 85 F>419> 6 #45B> &<9931< 878 ,31 GIFLI_ JLGFE@JF, GIK@LIFJ FEIEE < I@FJ JN ALJK@E,34 @EEIEd\JK@FJo J@KLFJ E@@@_E FEMIE IF @F JFI< EK>9` KFF F HL< KI JL I @ @JKFI@ FE
31
. @EE419> 6 #45B> &<9931< 878 , CI@><, CI@>< E@M41=5> 45< @5>1=95> @, YO@F, C, 1993, FJ MFc E LE @E K< @JKFIP F @<Jo, H9B 1>4 85B, 7(1), 1969; nF< GIF<J @E K< EPJ@J F GF@K@ KFL>K E K@FEo, &<9931< 85B, 2(3), >FJKF < 1974 (KFF < EcF, E@MF +IF HL@
