Petrozuata Case Analysis

c c c


c

cc  
c

c 

c 
cc c 
c c   cc c
cc c c c c  !c"c #$#%c&'#'cc ("#c)("c*'(+!'#)"cc ,)c&')#ccc ccccccccc!-c.#)c ccc"#&'c&#((c ccccccccc )##.c-#%#"#.c cccccccccc#)%c&%/c-c &'#/c$&'"c

 
c

c0 

1c
c

c c

2c c
c3
 c c c3c c  c
4c2
c
c c  c
c3 c3c c 5 c3
 c 
c3c
 
c c3
 4c

Ê


Ê 
       
     Ê  
      
   
   

   Ê            
    
       ! "     Ê     
       "   
    
#
 Ê           
     Ê



"              
 $ %c R   

   
          
  
      
 
 &c '           
 
                   
               
        
   
         
   
 "            
 $ %c "  
                
    ! &c (       Ê                   
"       
   )  *c Ê

        
#
 +c "            
               R       

c

2
c
c 

6
c  c c3 c c
 c ,4c2cc c
c 

c
 c c ,4c 2c 2 c 
c c ,c 3c c  5 c 2 c 3
 c  
cc
c 
4c

Ê


 ,       $ c  
c ,c   

          

     


   
   
  
    #   
         cc c 7 
c
c            #   
    
    
          !
 
  

"   
  #   #



      
     
       
  

       
   c 8c c   c 
 c                         

   
 "  
  
       -.%+ -*/     

   c "  
                             

 
  $ %c %*/&(%c (9c ' c -(/*#/c )&.c %&)#%* c 0 1 "      
      
     
 01' 0' 2'   (Ê 2#0  "   

      
  
   *33               %345 %%/45 &c :'c! c*($ )#: c)#(c(9c8;7c#&c' c#) c%c) <)  %2      %.36)        8c "    

  
   &&#%#//"c/(+c) #. $ %c-(%c(9c (%/"c=>?8c- )c#)) /c   
       -%+&/
0  
  %3       
   
  -.7*  -.%+c @c c#" %c-)()"cA' c*#&'c+# )c9#//Ë$          
      

 
  

    $c #c %  $  83   #  c c &  $  ,   
   c *c *  $      7  c !c +  $  )
 c ccccccR                0        

  Ê                     Ê                
 
          
 Ê             c c c c c c c

8c


c

 c c  c 2c  c 3c ?Bc 3c c 3 c c 3 c c  5 c 2 c  c  c
c  c  c
c 2 c 
c
4c 2
c 
c c c c c
c

cc  c
c c 5 c
c 
c cCBc3c c 5 c3 4c 
cc;B4c

(/%c ( 
      
     
    735

    
 "     0    

      $ c  735
        099  &75        
               )  &%5 R     45    )   c 735
  Ê'9  
    &376             
      8c 
735
  Ê'9         #     
        

 #   

 @c    
   /35   Ê'9   
        %+46     
      )  Ê'9  %*46 R           
       
             R  
       ;c 

   435    099   &&5      
        )  &%5R

              "  

       2' %c-)(D *c/ $ )#: c&cCBc      
    /35   099      *&5

   
 !   Ê'9       %+46   
          
              ! 

   ) Ê'9 %*46    Ê'9    2' %c-)(D *c/ $ )#: c&c;Bc   
     435 099       &&5
  )   
R       

    )  
    "     
       # 
 
    R   Ê'9               &376        )  
  %*46:  Ê'9       

@c

2
c ,c 3c  c  c  c c c 3 c c 
4c 2
c
c c


c
cc


c3c
c,c3c 4

Ê


       
    ;
%++  <    
"       
%++  $ %c "  
     
7   )
   
 &c  
             *c " (Ê                

     
   +c    
  )   
   -%+

  4c =         
                 


 7c "     
   %.    !                   %345 %%/45        /45 ./45 "                 $ %c
: %*"c! $            
 
      
; 90<  -&33R                
)90      
  &c #%.c             
    
      
   
  
       
R     
    $ c Ê $           
 
   
 

 c 9    c 
     

     c    


     *c /*c(%!&        
     
   

    
                     
  R             

  
  +c / c @@
c (%!&                        
  #  
    
7  R        
   
  (Ê  R     
             

c c c

?


cc3c c c2
c
c c7 c  4c
 c c
 c
c 3 c
c 
c cc
c 3c3 cc?c

(/% 0
 

      &75735
  "  
   
   ) 

   
  Ê           ) 


    

  
    )           '

      )    

  

 p
c cc

c cc


c c cc

c cc

%887 %88/ %88. %888 &333 &33% &33& &33* &33+ &334 &337 &33/ &33. &338 &3%3 &3%% &3%& &3%* &3%+ &3%4 &3%7 &3%/ &3%. &3%8 &3&3 &3&% &3&& &3&* &3&+ &3&4 &3&7

/83*4 .%3&% 7*%%78 7*%%78 7*%%78 7*%%78 7*%%78 7*%%78 7*%%78 7*%%78 7*%%78 7*%%78 7*%%78 7*%%78 7*%%78 7*%%78 7*%%78 7*%%78 7*%%78 7*%%78 7*%%78 7*%%78 7*%%78 7*%%78 7*%%78 7*%%78 7*%%78 7*%%78 7*%%78 7*%%78 7*%%78

-3 %333333 %3&+&88 %&7/&.3 %+43333 %+%%%%% %*/&&&& %****** %&7..47 %%./7%+ %3.787% 8//+.+ .+8447 /44%*/ 778%*/ 47/%*/ ++8%*/ +3%7.8 *+.&+% &4&3*+ %*+++. /4333 /4333 /4333 /4333 /4333 3

@c

c 
c cc

 c cc


 c

@
c

@
c


@c


@c


 c

@
c


 c


@c

@
 c





 c

@
c


c


c

@
c


c


@c

@
c


 c


@@c

@
c


c


@c

@
@c


@c


c

@
c


c


 c

@
c


 c


c

@
c


c


c

@
@c


c


c

@
 c


 c


c

@
c


c

@
c

@
@c


c

@
@c

@
c

@
c

@
c


c

@
c

@
c


c


 c

@
 c


c


c

@
@c


c

@
c

@
@ c


c

@
c

@
@ c


c

@
c

@
@ c


c

@
c

@
@ c


c

@
c

@
@ c


c

@
c

@c


c

@
c

cc

@c


c

@
c

cc

@c


c

@
c

cc

@c


c

@
c

cc

@c


c

@
c

c

&3&/ &3&. &3&8 &3*3 &3*% &3*& &3** &3*+ 

7*%%78 7*%%78 7*%%78 7*%%78 7*%%78 7*%%78 7*%%78 7*%%78 

cc

@c


c

@
c

cc

@c


c

@
c

cc

@c


c

@
c

cc

@c


c

@
c

cc

@c


c

@
c

cc

@c


c

@
c

cc

@c


c

@
c

cc

@c


c

@
c

cc

cc

cc

cc

 "       

  )     c c


c

c


 c

 c c c  c c  c

c 
c
@ c

 (    ) 
   
         &/ &.5   
     %.%85R     )  


  &3&&5 
 
    

  
  435
   099   &&5"      
    435
     
     )  Cc

2 c c cc 5 c4c2 c c cc  c

c
c  4c

c ( 
         &75       &&5    )   0  
    R   
       +5   75 
            "     
 -) 9 )c %$ &%:c %c -)(D *c (%!& c



  '      ) 
      
         
    )  7    
   &%5  
  %.750 '   
 )
  
       :  
 099

  R'    )  
     0 
     
 435       )   )           099 

&&5     )
R'   
   )


>c

2c c
c3
 c c  c3c 5 4c

(/%c Ê 
     
 
              
    735Ê 
      

   $ c R        
                  
   c Ê    
  735 /35  0     
          
     
   
  
      
  8c "                     Ê     
   @c          
              
)    
 
   
   ;c !               
            
     
       
    c