!"#$%$&'"() + )","-"./0$) $&.%$1 2%3,3'"4&5 2/6-"'"0(05 2/6-"'".+5 2%3,3'"4& 0$ 7$&.()5 %$-('"3&$) 286-"'()5 2%32(9(&0( + '3,/&"'('"4& )3'"(-:
D
C%3,3'"4&
C/6-"'"0(0E
" #
(Belch, 2005) (Wells, 1996)
;= $)>
;= ,$0"3) /."-"?(>
;@ A/"=& 7( 0"%"9"0(>
;= 0"#/&0$>
!" $% &''()*+%&*,+ )- .')%" $%" %&.*/*)%)-" 01*+*&*% -$ /-+)-)'( 2%(% -".%3$-&-( &%+%$-" )*+4'(5%&*,+ 6 &'+/-+&*5*-+.' -+&%5*+%)'" % $% /-+.% )- 3*-+-" 6 "-(/*&*'" ' % *521$"%( 1+% *)-%7 !+8$'3% .')'" $'" -$-5-+.'" )- $% &'51+*&%&*,+ *+.-8(%$7 ?- )-4*+- &'5' &1%$01*-( 4'(5% )- &'51+*&%&*,+ *52-("'+%$ %&-(&% )- 1+% '(8%+*9%&*,+=
!$-5-+.'" )- $% "135-9&$% 2('5'&*'+%$7 (Fischer, 2004)
:1)*-+&*%" -;.-(+%" *+.-(+%"7
<(')1&.'= "-(/*&*' ' *)-%7
A-)*'" 5%"*/'" )&'51+*&%&*,+7
B'+"15*)'(-"7
<(')1&.'= "-(/*&*' ' *)-%7
B"2"3 0$ 3%9(&"?('"4& A/$ -( /."-"?( <>3$*&% 6 2(*/%)%7
;B"$&$ (-98& '3).3> ?@7
<(*/%)%7
?@7
C/6-"'".+F
C%3,3'"4& 0$ 7$&.()G
$ %
(Belch, 2005) (Belch, 2005)
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
<>3$*&% 6 2(*/%)%7
E'7
<(*/%)%7
?@7
H$-('"3&$) I 286-"'()
C%32(9(&0(J
K3,/&"'('"4& L )3'"(-
&
(Wilcox, 2001) (Fischer, 2004) ( (Treviño, 2000) '
J1+&*,+ %)5*+*".(%.*/% 01-/%$>% $%" %&.*.1)-" )-$ 2>3$*&'= *)-+.*4*&% $%" 2'$@.*&%" 6 2('&-)*5*-+.'" )-$ *+)*/*)1' 1 '(8%+*9%&*,+ &'+ -$ *+.-(K" 2>3$*&'= 6 -D-&1.% 1+ 2('8(%5% )%&&*'+-" 2%(% &'+"-81*( $% &'52(-+"*,+ 6% %&-2.%&*,+ )-$ 2>3$*&'7 <13$*&*)%) 01- "(-%$*9% -+ 5-)*'" 5%"*/'" )&'51+*&%&*,+ 2%(% )*41+)*( *)-%" 2'$@.*&%" 6 (-$*8*'"%"7 B%52' )- -".1)*' "'&*'$,8*&' 01-;2$'(%
A-)*'" 5%"*/'" )&'51+*&%&*,+ 6 L-((%5*-+.%" )&'51+*&%&*,+ H4'$$-.'"= )*"&1("'"= &'51+*&%)'" )2(-+"%I7
:1)*-+&*%" M5%8-+ -;.-(+%" 2'"*.*/% )- $% H&'+"15*)'(-"I &'52%N@%7 - *+.-(+%" H%&&*'+*".%"= .(%3%D%)'(-"I7
<>3$*&% 6 2(*/%)%7
?@7
A-)*'" 5%"*/'" )&'51+*&%&*,+7
:1)*-+&*%" -;.-(+%"7
M)-%" 2'$@.*&%" 6 (-$*8*'"%"7
<>3$*&% 6 2(*/%)%7
?@
A-)*'" 5%"*/'" )&'51+*&%&*,+7
?'&*-)%)
M+4'(5-" )8'3*-(+'7
<>3$*&%
?@
-"2-&*%$5-+.%01-$$' (-$%&*'+%)' &'+ $% *+4'(5%&*,+= &,5' -".% -" 2-(&*3*)%= .(%+"5*.*)% 6 -+.-+)*)% 6 "1 *52%&.' "'&*%$7