7HSUHILHURDWL &RUtQ7HOODGR
7HSUHILHURDWL 7tWXOR2ULJLQDO 7HSUHILHURDWL (GLWRULDO (GLWRULDO%UXJXHUD6$ 6HOOR&ROHFFLyQ &RULQWR6HOHFFLyQ *pQHUR &RQWHPSRUiQHR 3URWDJRQLVWDV ,xDTXH5ROGDQ\%HED4XLQWDQD
$UJXPHQWR 'RV KHUPDQRV JHPHORV XQR EXHQR HO RWUR QR WDQWR ¢'H FXDO HVWDED HQDPRUDGDHOOD"¢'HOTXHSDUHFtDEXHQRRGHOTXHQR" (OOD XQD VHxRULWD GH VX FDVD \ ORV JHPHORV XQRV VLQYHUJHQ]DV FRQ ODV PXMHUHV¢4XpSRGtDUHVXOWDUGHHVR"
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
&DStWXOR &DStWXOR ³1RWHROYLGHV,xDTXH+R\QRHVWR\FLWDGRFRQHOODSHURFUHRTXHVHUiPHMRU TXHW~SURFXUHVYHUOD1RWHQJRWLHPSRQLSDUDSRQHUXQDQRWD/HGLFHVODYHUGDG TXHWXYHTXHVDOLUGH0DGULGDHVFDSH$VXQWRVGHQHJRFLRV¢0HR\HVRQRPHR\HV ,xDTXH" ³&ODURTXHVL7HYDVGHYLDMH$0p[LFRHVWDPLVPDWDUGHGHQWURGHXQFXDUWR GHKRUDWRGRORPiV¢1RHVDVt"<SUHWHQGHVTXH\RYHDDWXQRYLD\VHORGLJD ³(VRHV ³6HORGLUp ³&RQ VXDYLGDG ¢HK ,xDTXH" 1R VHDV EUXWR 7~ D YHFHV KDFHV ODV FRVDV D OR EHVWLD ,xDTXHGLVWHQGLyORVODELRVHQXQDVXWLOVRQULVDVDUFiVWLFD (UD DOWR \ GHOJDGR GH DQFKDV HVSDOGDV PX\ QHJUR HO FDEHOOR SHLQDGR KDFLD DWUiVFRQODPD\RUVHQFLOOH]/RVRMRVWDQQHJURVFRPRHOFDEHOOR\ORVODELRVUHODMDGRV HQXQDPXHFDLQGHILQLEOH (UQHVWR FHUUy HO PDOHWtQ \ VH YROYLy HQ UHGRQGR (UD H[DFWDPHQWH FRPR VX KHUPDQRFRQOD~QLFDGLIHUHQFLDGHTXH,xDTXHOOHYDEDHOFDEHOORPiVODUJR1DGLH YLpQGRORV VHSDUDGRV HUD FDSD] GH GLIHUHQFLDUORV -XQWRV VyOR VH GLVWLQJXtDQ SRU HO FDEHOOR (UQHVWR HO VHVXGR GH ORV JHPHORV HUD GH FRQWLQHQWH PiV ELHQ JUDYH RFXOWDQGRVXPDODLQWHQFLyQ SRUTXHVLHPSUHODWHQtD EDMRXQDVRQULVDFRQYHQFLRQDO (UDHOKRPEUHQRFWXUQR(OTXHWHQtDIDPDGHJUDQSHUVRQD\HQJDxDEDDVXSURSLR KHUPDQRVLHQHOORLEDQIDOGDVRFRVDTXHSXGLHUDLQWHUHVDUOH ,xDTXHHQFDPELRHUDHOKRPEUHIUtYRORTXHQXQFDWRPDEDQDGDHQVHULRTXH WHQtDGRFHQDVGHQRYLDVDODYH]\DWRGDVGDEDSDODEUDGHFDVDPLHQWR\FXDQGRVHOH GHVFXEUtDHOMXHJRVHTXHGDEDWDQIUHVFR 3HUR QR RFXOWDED XQD GREOH YLGD eO HUD DVt SRUTXH OR HUD \ QR WHQtD SRU TXp GLVLPXODUOR (UQHVWRQRHVWDEDELHQVHJXURGHTXH,xDTXHKLFLHUDELHQVXHQFDUJR 6HVHQWyDVXODGR\ORDVLySRUHOEUD]R ³(VFXFKD PXFKDFKR (VF~FKDPH ELHQ 1R PH DJUDGD HQ DEVROXWR TXHGDU FRPRXQFRFKLQR
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
(UQHVWR KL]R XQR GH VXV OHQWRV PRYLPLHQWRV GH SURWHVWD 0HWLy OD PDQR HQ HO EROVLOORGHODDPHULFDQD\VDFyXQFLJDUULOOR/RHQFHQGLy\IXPySUHFLSLWDGDPHQWH ³3XHGHTXHPHLQWHUHVHPXFKR%HED4XLQWDQD1RORVpGHPRQLRQRORVp(V PL QRYLD ¢QR" < \R QXQFD KH WHQLGR QRYLD ¢1R HV DVt" 6L QXQFD OD KH WHQLGR \ \D FXPSOtORVYHLQWLVLHWHDxRV\ODWHQJRDKRUDHVGHVXSRQHUTXHPHLQWHUHVH¢QR" ³
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
³3HUR\RVR\WXKHUPDQR\DGHPiVJHPHOR (UQHVWRYROYLyDUHtU ³)XH PiV LQWHUHVDQWH D~Q (OOD VH TXHGy DVRPEUDGD FXDQGR QRV YLR MXQWRV 'LMR ¢&XiOGHORVGRVHV,xDTXH"7~GLMLVWH
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
³4XH YD\D D YHU D %HED \ OH GLJD TXH KDV WHQLGR TXH VDOLU GH YLDMH \ TXH QR VDEHV FXiQGR YROYHUiV \ FRPR HUHV WDQ SHUH]RVR QR OH HVFULELUiV XQD VROD FDUWD $xDGLUpVLWHSDUHFHTXHODVPH[LFDQDVVRQPDJQtILFDV ³(UHV XQ EHVWLD ³JULWy (UQHVWR PDOKXPRUDGR³ ¢4Xp WLHQHV TXH GHFLU W~ GH ODV PH[LFDQDV" 3UHWHQGR TXH %HED PH HVSHUH 6t QR PH PLUHV FRQ HVD H[SUHVLyQ IHUR]0HJXVWD'HWRGDVODVFKLFDVTXHWUDWpIXHOD~QLFDTXHQRPHSHUPLWLyTXHOD EHVDVH ,xDTXHDSUHWyORVGHGRVHQHOYRODQWH ³1R«QRODEHVDVWH«¢QXQFD" (UQHVWRVXVSLUy ³-DPiV\HVRHVFRPRXQDHVSLQLWDTXHOOHYRGHQWUR ³'H PRGR TXH W~ HO FRQTXLVWDGRU RFXOWR HO DYH QRFWXUQD HO TXH VH ODV VDEH WRGDVFRQODVFKLFDVHOTXHWLHQHIDPDGHH[FHOHQWHSHUVRQD\HVXQFDQDOOLWDFRQWUDMH GHHWLTXHWDQRIXHFDSD]GHEHVDUDVXQRYLD (UQHVWRVHPRUGLyORVODELRV ³1RIXLFDSD]GHWRFDUOD¢HQWHQGLGR"(VPLSULPHUIUDFDVR\HVRQRORDVLPLOR \RPX\ELHQ7~FRQRFHVPX\ELHQDGRQ)pOL[4XLQWDQD ³6HJXUR\DWtD3HSDWDPELpQ ³1RFRQR]FRDODWDOWtD3HSDQLPHLQWHUHVD ³(VXQDVROWHURQDIRUPLGDEOH ³,xDTXH ³¢4XpSDVD" ³7HHVWR\KDEODQGRHQVHULR1RKDJDVXQDGHODVWX\DV7HSLGRTXHYD\DVD FDVD GH %HED
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
³0H FRVWy FRQVHJXLU XQ SXHVWR OXFLGR HQ OD VRFLHGDG ³JUXxy³ 8QD YH] FRQVHJXLGRGLUpHOUHIUiQ&RJHEXHQDIDPD\pFKDWHDGRUPLU (ODXWRVHGHWHQtDDQWHHODHURSXHUWRGH%DUDMDV ³7XDYLyQHVWiDSXQWRGHVDOLU³JULWy,xDTXH³6DOGLVSDUDGR6LSLHUGHVHVWH DYLyQSHUGHUiVODFRQILDQ]DTXHSDSiWLHQHGHSRVLWDGDHQWL ³(QPRGRDOJXQR³VDOWyGHODXWR\DVLHQGRHOPDOHWtQ\PDOHWDHFKyDFRUUHU GLFLHQGRDOPLVPRWLHPSR³ 1RWHROYLGHV«'LOHTXH\RQRHVFULERQXQFD'LOHTXH HVSHURTXHDPLUHJUHVR«'LOH« /DYR]VHSHUGtD\DDOROHMRV ,xDTXHTXHQRVHKDEtDPRYLGRGHODXWRHVSHUyDOOtVHQWDGRDQWHHOYRODQWHD TXHHODYLyQGHVSHJDUD 'HVSXpV«\DKDUtD\GLUtDORTXHOHGLHUDODJDQD
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
&DSLWXOR &DSLWXOR ³/DYLGDQRHVXQMXHJR%HED7~GHEHVVDEHUOR6LHPSUHWHORGLMHDVt\WUDWp GHGHPRVWUDUWHTXHQRHVWDEDHTXLYRFDGR %HED JXDUGy VLOHQFLR (VFXFKDED (UD XQD EXHQD FXDOLGDG VX\D 6LHPSUH HVFXFKDEDDVXSDGUHDXQTXHDOILQDOQRKLFLHUDQDGDGHFXDQWRpOGHFtD ³1R HV FRQYHQLHQWH SHUGHU HO WLHPSR 1R HV TXH W~ VHDV PD\RU 6yOR WLHQHV YHLQWH DxRV SHUR \R HVWLPR TXH OR SHRU TXH SXHGH KDFHU XQD PXFKDFKD HV GHMDUVH FRUWHMDUSRUXQKRPEUHTXHQRVHYDDFDVDUFRQHOOD ³(O TXH QR VH FDVD HV HO JHPHOR )pOL[ ³LQWHUYLQR WtD 3HSD³ (UQHVWR HV XQ KRPEUHVHULR ³1R PH ItR GH ORV KRPEUHV TXH PDQHMDQ HO GLQHUR FRPR \R OD KLVWRULD \ OD OLWHUDWXUD ³6LHPSUHWHHPSHxDVHQQRYHUSHUVRQDVEXHQDV\FRQH[FHOHQWHVFRQGLFLRQHV HQWRUQRDWL³JUXxyODVROWHURQD ³7~QRVDEHVGHHVDVFRVDV3HSD³VHH[DOWyHOHOHJDQWHFDEDOOHUR³1RWHKDV FDVDGRQXQFD 7tD3HSDQRVHDOWHUyHQDEVROXWR 3HURGLMRFRUWDQWH ³+HWHQLGRQRYLRV \ Vp ORTXH VRQ ORVKRPEUHV $ XQD PXMHU QROH KDFHIDOWD OOHJDUDOPDWULPRQLRSDUDVDEHUFLHUWDVFRVDV ³1R RV HQIDGpLV ³SLGLy OD SUHFLRVLGDG TXH HUD %HED 4XLQWDQD³ 1R KD\ PRWLYRV(UQHVWRHVXQKRPEUHHVWXSHQGR1RHVWR\HQDPRUDGDGHpOD~QSHURFUHR TXHOOHJDUpDHVWDUOR ³3XHVHVORTXH\RSUHWHQGRHYLWDU³DGXMRHOSDGUHVHYHUtVLPR³&XDQGRXQD PXMHU VH HQDPRUD \D QR VDEH OR TXH KDFH /R FRQYHQLHQWH HV HQDPRUDU VLQ HQDPRUDUVHXQR\HQWRQFHVHOWULXQIRHVVHJXUR ³3DSi« ³
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
³£3HSD ³/RGLFKR6LWXKLMDSXHGHSLOODUXQPLOORQDULRQRWLHQHSRUTXpFDVDUVHFRQ XQPXHUWRGHKDPEUHFRPRW~ ³£3HSD ³£7tD ³(VODYHUGDGKLMLWD<W~KHUPDQRQRPLUHVFRQHVHIXURU(VWR\GLFLHQGRXQD YHUGDG FRPR XQ WHPSOR &RQ OR JXDSD TXH HUHV FRQ OR LQWHOLJHQWH TXH HUHVFRQ OR MRYHQTXHHUHV\ORFXOWDSRUTXHHVRVLKD\TXHGHFLUORWRGRGHHVRWHGRWyWXSDGUH HQ DEXQGDQFLDQR HVWDUtD ELHQTXHGHVSXpV GH FDVDGD WH SUHRFXSDUDV GH FRQWDUORV JDUEDQ]RV\HODUUR]FRPRKDFHPRVHQFDVD ³£3HSD ³7HRLJRELHQ)pOL[1RHVSUHFLVRTXHPHFKLOOHVWDQWR$GHPiVXQVHxRUWDQ HOHJDQWH\FRPHGLGRFRPRW~JULWDQGRDVt¢4XpGLUi)HOLVD" ³(UHV XQD PHWRPHQWRGR 3HSD ³VH HQRMy PXFKtVLPR HO FDEDOOHUR³ 1XQFD GHEtVDFDUWHGHOSXHEOR 7tD3HSDFRQWLQXyLQPXWDEOH 'LMRULHQGR ³6LPHGHMDVHQHOSXHEOR¢TXLpQVHKXELHUDRFXSDGRGHFULDUDWXKLMD"1RQRV HQJDxHPRV )pOL[
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
'RQ)pOL[VHSXVRHQSLHGDQGRSRUILQDOL]DGDODFRPLGD ³7HQ FXLGDGR %HED ³GLMR DO GHVSHGLUVH EHViQGROD HQ OD IUHQWH³ 1R PH DJUDGDTXHVDOJDVFRQXQ5ROGiQ ³(UQHVWRHVKRPEUHVHULR³DGXMRODMRYHQ ³/RVHUiQRORGLVFXWR SHUR\RWHGLJRTXHWLHQHGHPDVLDGRGLQHUR\KDFHXQD YLGD GHVRUGHQDGD 9LYHQ VRORV HQ HVH SLVR GH OD DYHQLGD GHO *HQHUDOtVLPR \ OXHJR YLDMDQ SRU WRGD +LVSDQRDPpULFD FXDQGR OHV DSHWHFH 6X SDGUH HVWi HQ 9DOHQFLD FDVDGR HQ VHJXQGDV QXSFLDV \ VyOR VH SUHRFXSD GH VXV KLMRV JHPHORV FRQ HO ILQ GH TXHOOHYHQHOQHJRFLRGHVGHDTXt7HGLJRUHSLWRTXHQRPHDJUDGDQHVDVUHODFLRQHV 8QFDWHGUiWLFRXQDERJDGRXQLQJHQLHUR« ³<DPRULUVHGHKDPEUH ³£3HSD ³¢1RHVDVt"¢4XpVDFDPRVQRVRWURVFRQTXHW~VHDVXQRGHORVPiVDQWLJXRV SURIHVRUHV GH OD )DFXOWDG" 'L ¢TXp" &RQWDU ODV SHUUDV KDVWD HO FpQWLPR &XDQGR D %HEDVHOHFRPSUDXQPRGHORKD\TXHGHMDUHQEODQFRORVFRMLQHVGHOVDOyQTXHHVWiQ GHVJDVWDGRVSRUHOXVR&XDQGRKD\TXHOODPDUSRUWHOpIRQRVHFXHQWDQODVOODPDGDV SDUDTXHODIDFWXUDGHOPHVQRVXSHUHORSUHYLVWR+D\TXHLUDSDJDQGRWRGDVOXFHV\ KD\TXHDQGDUFRQHODJXDUHVWULQJLGD ³3HSD WH GLMH PXFKDV YHFHV TXH QR WH PHWDV HQ HVWR 9LYLPRV FRQ KRQRU \ GLJQLGDG\HVRHVORPiVLPSRUWDQWH <VDOLyVLQHVSHUDUUHVSXHVWD (QDTXHOPLVPRLQVWDQWH)HOLVDODFULDGDSDUDWRGRDSDUHFLyHQHOXPEUDO ³6HxRULWD%HED³GLMRFRQYR]JDQJRVD³ODOODPDQSRUWHOpIRQR ³¢4XLpQ" ³&UHRTXHGLMRGRQ(UQHVWR5ROGiQ ³9R\«YR\HQVHJXLGD³SHURDQWHVGHVDOLUVHYROYLyKDFLDVXWtD³1RGHEHV VHUWDQGXUDFRQSDSiWtD3HSD ³-LML«7XSDGUHYLYHFRQYHLQWHDxRVGHUHWUDVR6LORVDEUp\R %HEDVDOLyFRUULHQGR 7HQtDQ GRV WHOpIRQRV HQ FDVD (Q HO GHVSDFKR GH VX SDGUH GRQGH HQ DTXHO PRPHQWRVHKDOODEDpO\HQHOOLYLQJXQDHVSHFLHGHVDOLWDGHHVWDUGRQGHHOODUHFLEtD DVXVDPLJDV\FKDUODEDQPXFKDVYHFHVFRQODEXHQD]DGHWtD3HSD $HVWH~OWLPROXJDUVHGLULJLy 6HGHMyFDHUHQXQDQFKRVLOOyQ\DVLyHODXULFXODU ³'tJDPH ³£+ROD
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
³£$KHUHVW~« ³¢1RSLHQVDVVDOLUKR\" ³6t³DGPLWLyXQWDQWRDVRPEUDGD³ SHURD~QVRQODVVHLVGHODWDUGH1XQFD PHOODPDVDHVWDVKRUDV ³¢4XpWHSDUHFHVLKR\IXpUDPRVDEDLODUSRUDKt" ³¢$EDLODU"3HUR¢GHVGHFXiQGRWHJXVWDDWLEDLODU" ,xDTXH HQ HO DSDUWDPHQWR GH OD DYHQLGD GHO *HQHUDOtVLPR WDSy HO DXULFXODU \ PLUyGHVRODGRDVXFULDGR ³+HPHWLGRODSDWD0DWtDV ³
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
³%LHQ PHUHFLGR VH OR WLHQH (UQHVWR 4XH QR GHMH D ODV QRYLDV WLUDGDV FRPR VL IXHUDQFROLOODV'LPHGLPH¢VDEHVW~GyQGHTXHGyHQYHUVHFRQHOOD" ³9DVLHPSUHDEXVFDUODDODVVLHWHHQSXQWRDVXFDVDVHxRU ³*UDFLDV(UHVPLJXtD0DWtDV0LJXtD\PLRULHQWDFLyQ ³¢1RHVODPLVPDFRVDVHxRU" ³¢6t"¢7~FUHHV"³GHVWDSyHODXULFXODU³¢$ODVVLHWHHQWRQFHV" ³¢3RUTXpHVDVODUJDVSDXVDV(UQHVWR" ³¢4XpSDXVDV" ³1RVp7HDVHJXURTXHWHHQFXHQWURUDUR ³$ ODV VLHWH HQ SXQWR MXQWR D WX FDVD 1R WDUGHV HQ EDMDU
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
³3XHVPDQRVDODREUD ³6HxRU\R« ³0DWtDVTXHWHGHVSLGR ³6LVHxRU3HUR\RVLJRSHQVDQGRTXHKDFHPRVPDO ³7~QRKDFHVQDGD6R\\RTXLHQOHORKDFH ³
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
&DSLWXOR &DSLWXOR (UQHVWRVLHPSUHXVDEDXQDORFLyQSHFXOLDU0X\PDVFXOLQD0X\IUDQFHVD (ODXWRROtDD(UQHVWR$%HEDTXHHQWUDEDHQDTXHOPRPHQWRHQHO©0HUFHGHVª QRVHOHRFXUULySHQVDUTXHDTXHOKRPEUHTXHVHVHQWDEDDQWHHOYRODQWH\OHVRQUHtD SRGtDVHUHOJHPHORGHVXSUHWHQGLHQWH ³£+ROD²VDOXGRDFRPRGiQGRVHDVXODGR ³£+ROD eOODPLURFRQVXVHQRUPHVRMD]RV ,xDTXHHUDPHQRVVHVXGRTXHVXJHPHOR0LHQWUDVHVWHVDEtDGRPLQDUVH\PLQDU HO FDPLQR KDFLD XQD IHOL] VROXFLyQ YLFWRULRVD ,xDTXH HUD IRJRVR DSDVLRQDGR GLFKDUDFKHUR\WHPSHUDPHQWDO ³(VWDVJXDStVLPD ³¢(K" ³7HGLJRTXHHVWiVJXDStVLPD ³¢6DEHVTXHKR\WHHQFXHQWURPX\YLYR" ³¢9LYR" ³0X\SDUODQFKtQ ,xDTXHHQVXSDSHOGH(UQHVWRVRQULyFRQVXILFLHQFLD ³8QRQRSXHGHUHVLVWLU\WLHQHTXHGHFLUDVXQRYLDORTXHOHSDUHFHHVWi(VWiV JXDStVLPD(VHDEULJRFHOHVWHWHVLHQWDFRPRXQJXDQWH ³3XHV PH OR KL]R PL WtD ³GLMR %HED FRQ OD PD\RU VHQFLOOH]³
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
(UDXQDIDFHWDTXHpOGHVFRQRFtDHQ(UQHVWR6LHUDPiVELHQVLOHQFLRVR¢4XpDUWH HPSOHDEDSDUDFRQTXLVWDUDODVFKLFDV" 'HFLGLyFDOODUVHWRGRORTXH%HED4XLQWDQDOHSDUHFtD ³¢4XpWHSDUHFHVLIXpUDPRVDEDLODU" ³3HURVLQRVDEHV ©$GHPiVHPEXVWHURª ³3HURTXLHURDSUHQGHU³GLMRHQDOWDYR]³1RYR\DSDVDUPHODYLGDYLHQGR EDLODUDORVGHPiV ³6LHPSUHFUHtTXHQRWHLQWHUHVDEDDSUHQGHU (UD XQD PRQDGD ¢4Xp GLUtD (UQHVWR GH VX GHVIDFKDWH] FXDQGR UHJUHVDUD \ VXSLHUDTXH%HEDGHVFRQRFLyODDXVHQFLDGHVXQRYLR" $(UQHVWRQROHLQWHUHVDED%HED GHVHUORFRQWUDULRODDGYHUWLUtDSHUVRQDOPHQWH GH VX PDUFKD \ DGHPiV QR VH LUtD SRUTXHWHQtD HQ VX PDQR HQYLDUOR D pO D 0p[LFR WUDVDGYHUWLUDVXSDGUHTXHpOHVWDEDPX\RFXSDGRHQ0DGULG ³1R YR\ D VDFULILFDUWH WRGD OD YLGD D YHU FyPR EDLODQ ORV GHPiV ³\ VLQ WUDQVLFLyQ³ ¢$O%LRPER&KLQR" ³%XHQR 7RUFLyKDFLDODL]TXLHUGD\HODXWRVHHQFDPLQyDODVLQPHGLDFLRQHVGHOD*UDQ 9tD +DEtD PXFKR WUiILFR SRU DTXHOOD SDUWH \ HO MRYHQ KXER GH KDFHU YHUGDGHURV PLODJURVSDUDDSDUFDU&XDQGRORKL]RVDOWyDOVXHOR\GLRODYXHOWDDODXWR &XDQGR DEULy OD SRUWH]XHOD \D %HED VH GLVSRQtD D EDMDU /D DVLy SRU HO EUD]R FHUUyHODXWR\ODFRQGXMRKDFLDHOOXMRVRORFDO (UD SOHQR LQYLHUQR PHGLDED GLFLHPEUH +DFLD PXFKR IUtR \ ODV SDUHMDV VH DUUHEXMDEDQHQODHQWUDGDSUHWHQGLHQGRKDFHUORWRGRVDODYH] ,xDTXHSDVyXQEUD]RSRUORVKRPEURVGH%HEDSHURpVWDOHPLUyVHYHUD ³6DEHV³GLMRXQSRFRVRIRFDGD³TXHQRPHJXVWDTXHPHWRTXHV (UDRWUDFRVDTXHLJQRUDED ¢&yPR SRGtD (UQHVWR HO WRFyQ SRU H[FHOHQFLD SDVDU VLQ WRFDU D DTXHOOD PRQDGD" 6HUHVLJQy $WUDYHVyMXQWRDHOODWRGRHOORFDO'HUHSHQWHSHQVyTXHVLDOJXLHQORYHtDSRGtD FRQRFHUOR PHMRU TXH %HED \ OODPDUOR SRU VX QRPEUH \ OR FXULRVR HUD TXH D pO OR FRQRFtD WRGD OD MXYHQWXG PDGULOHxD 3HUR VH WUDQTXLOL]y 1DGLH VHUtD FDSD] GH GLVWLQJXLUORVL%HEDQRORKDEtDKHFKR\D\HVWDEDFODURTXHQRHUDDVt ³$TXt³GLMR $OJXLHQJULWyWUDVpO ³,xDTXH
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
6HYROYLy (UD XQD OLQGD FKLFD UXELD PX\ SHULSXHVWD PX\ PRGHUQD FRQ XQD PLQLIDOGD HQFDQWDGRUD ³,xDTXHFLHORPLyD\HUWHHVWXYHHVSHUDQGR\QROOHJDVWH(UHVXQIUHVFR ³/R VLHQWR ³GLMR ,xDTXH GDQGR D VX YR] XQD JUDYHGDG DO HVWLOR GH VX KHUPDQR³7HKDVFRQIXQGLGR
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
³¢&yPRHVSHFLDO" ,xDTXHWUDWDEDSRUWRGRVORVPHGLRVGHDWUDHUODKDFLDVLSHURHOFRGRGH%HEDVH ORLPSHGtD ³¢/RYHV" ³¢4XpYHR" ³4XHQRPHGHMDVDEUD]DUWH ³(UHVXQIUHVFR1XQFDORLQWHQWDVWH+R\HVWiVGLVWLQWR ©3XHVQRVHUpFDSD]GHVHUFRUUHFWR³SHQVy³0DOGLWDVHDQR(VWDFKLFDFDODKRQGR FRQHVRVRMD]RV\HVHSHOR\HVDERFD\HVHFXHUSR«<XQRQRHVFDSD]GHFRQWHQHUVHª ³&XDQGR XQ KRPEUH VLHQWH DIHFWR R VLPSDWtD KDFLD XQD PXMHU QR OH LQTXLHWD HVDPXMHU3HURFXDQGRVHHQDPRUDGHHOOD« ³(UQHVWR«SUHILHURYROYHUDODPHVD ³¢(UHVWRQWD" ³1RVR\GHODVTXHEDLODQRIUHFLHQGRXQHVSHFWiFXOR 1RODVROWy/HTXLWyHOFRGR\ODDSUHWyFRQWUDVL/DVLQWLyWHPEODU ³%HED«PXFKDFKLWD« ³1R«QR« ³¢1R TXp" ³VXVXUUy³ ¢3XHGH XQR HYLWDU VHQWLU DGRUDFLyQ SRU XQD PXMHU FXDQGREDLODFRQHOOD" ³7HGLJR«2PHVXHOWDVRWHGHMRSODQWDGR ³3UXHEDDVROWDUWH ³(UQHVWR«GHWHVWRODVLQFRUUHFFLRQHV ³8QKRPEUHHQDPRUDGRDXQTXHQRTXLHUDDOJXQDYH]UHVXOWDLQFRUUHFWR ³6XpOWDPH%DLODFRPRODVSHUVRQDV eOPHWLyODFDEH]DHQVXJDUJDQWD$VtFDVLSHJDGRDHOODVLQWLpQGRODWHPEODUHQ VXSURSLRFXHUSRGLMREDMtVLPR ³0LUD HQ WRUQR D WL )tMDWH ELHQ %DMR HVD WHQXH OX] D]XORVD \ URML]D WRGDV ODV SDUHMDV VH DEUD]DQ 9LHQHQ DTXt D HVR 1DGLH VH PHWH FRQ HOODV \ SXHGHQ DEUD]DUOH S~EOLFDPHQWH (OODQRHUDGHpVDV /RGLMRFRQIXHU]DXQSRFRWHPEORQDVXYR] ³1RTXLHURVHUFRPROD JHQHUDOLGDG<QRHVSUHVXQFLyQ(VTXHPHUHSXJQD HVHWLSRGHDEUD]R(VPiVELHQVH[XDO ³¢<QRVRPRVVH[XDOHVORVVHUHVKXPDQRV" ³&RQDOJXQDGLIHUHQFLD ³%HEDFXDQGRQRVFDVHPRV
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
(OODHOHYyORVRMRV/RVWHQtDOtPSLGRV1RKDEtDILQJLPLHQWRHQHOORVQLVLTXLHUD FRTXHWHUtD ,xDTXH VH VLQWLy XQ SRFR PH]TXLQR SHUR QR OD VROWy /D GREOy XQ SRFR PiV FRQWUDVt+DEOyHQVXRtGR ³¢4XpSDVD"0HKDVPLUDGRGHXQDIRUPDUDUD (OOD V~ELWDPHQWH VH GHVSUHQGLy /OHYy OD PDQR DO SHOR (UD XQD PDQR ILQD \ VXDYHPHQWHFXLGDGD/HWHPEODEDQXQSRFRORVGHGRV3DUHFtDTXHVXVHQVLELOLGDGVH UHFRSLODEDDOOtVLQUHPHGLR ³%HED« ³3HUGRQD³GLMRDKRJDGDPHQWH³1RSXHGRFRQWLQXDUEDLODQGR <VHJXLGDPHQWHVHGLULJLyDODPHVD 6HVHQWy\PLHQWUDVpOFRQWLQXDEDGHSLHPLUiQGRODSHQVDWLYDPHQWHHOODOOHYy HOYDVRDORVODELRV\EHELyGHVSDFLRXQSRFRVRIRFDGD ,xDTXHVHVHQWy ³¢4XpFODVHGHPXMHUHUHV"7XItVLFRHVPRGHUQR\RGLUtDTXHXOWUDPRGHUQR (VWiVDSXQWRGLUtD\RSRUWXItVLFRGHXVDUODPLQLIDOGD<HQFDPELRWHDVXVWD\WH DEUXPDODIRUPDGHVHUGHOKRPEUHDFWXDO ³1RVR\FDSD]GHDVLPLODUORTXHpOYHFRQWRGDQDWXUDOLGDG ³¢4XHWHRSULPDEDLODQGR" ³4XHPHWXUEHVDVt ³£%HED ³1RORSXHGRUHPHGLDU ³6R\WXQRYLR ³3HURD~QQRHUHVPLPDULGR³URWXQGD eOULy7HQtDXQDULVDGLVWLQWDDODGH(UQHVWR SHUR%HEDHQDTXHOLQVWDQWHQRVH SHUFDWyGHODGLIHUHQFLD ©'HPRGR³SHQVy,xDTXH³TXHHOODLEDDODFD]D$ODFD]DGH(UQHVWRVHHQWLHQGHª ³1R PH GLUiV ³DSXQWy DO WLHPSR GH H[WHQGHU ODV PDQRV SRU HQFLPD GH OD PHVDWUDWDQGRGHEXVFDUORVGHGRVIHPHQLQRV³TXHQRYDVDFRQVHQWLUTXHWHEHVH PLHQWUDVQRVHDWXPDULGR ³(VRHVH[DFWDPHQWH ³/RFXDOPHKDUiSHQVDUTXHHVWiVGLVSXHVWDDFD]DUPH 6HRIHQGLy /RYLRHQVXVRMRVDOHOHYDUORVKDFLDpO(UDXQDPLUDGDIUtD\GLVWDQWH'LIHUHQWH VREUHVDOWiQGROH ³¢4XLHUHVGHMDUORHQHVWHPLVPRLQVWDQWH"³SUHJXQWyFRQKHODGRDFHQWR
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
,xDTXHQRIXHFDSD]GHDVLUVXVGHGRV(OODORVPHWLyEDMRODPHVDORVFUX]yHQ VXUHJD]R ³%XHQR EXHQR ³WUDWy GH DSDFLJXDUOD³ QR QRV GLJDPRV GLVSDUDWHV ¢&yPR YR\DGLVLSDUHVDQXEHFLOOD" ³1R PH DJUDGD MXJDU FRQ ODV SDODEUDV 1R PH DJUDGD HQ DEVROXWR ¢PH HQWLHQGHV"1LTXHVHMXHJXHFRQPLVVHQWLPLHQWRV
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
&DSLWXOR &DSLWXOR 'HMDEDQHOORFDO /D FDOOH VHJXtD DWHVWDGD GH WUiILFR ,xDTXH FRPR SXGR OD FRQGXMR KDVWD HO HVWDFLRQDPLHQWR\DEULyODSRUWH]XHOD $XQTXHSDUH]FDLPSRVLEOHDOJRVHKDEtDURWRHQWUHDPERV1RSRUpOSRUHOOD TXHSDUHFtDSRQHUXQDEDUUHUDHQWUHORVGRV ,xDTXH FHUUy OD SRUWH]XHOD \ GLR OD YXHOWD DO DXWR DFRPRGiQGRVH DQWH HO YRODQWH ³(VWiVUDUD³GLMRPDOKXPRUDGR³1RVR\FDSD]GHHQWHQGHUWH ³(V OR H[WUDxR 4XH QR PH HQWLHQGDV KR\ \ PH HQWHQGLHUDV DQWHV (VWD FRQYHUVDFLyQ OD WXYLPRV D ORV SRFRV GtDV GH VDOLU MXQWRV 4XHGy ELHQ VHQWDGR PL PRGRGHVHU\PLFRQFHSWRGHODPRU\GHORVKRPEUHV7~HVWXYLVWHGHDFXHUGRRDO PHQRV FRQ WX VLOHQFLR DVt OR GLVWH D HQWHQGHU \ GH UHSHQWH YXHOYHV FRQ WXV IRJRVLGDGHV ©(OPX\FDQDOOLWDHVWDEDPLQDQGRHOFDPLQRDOR]RUURª (QDOWDYR]PDQLIHVWy ³1RVHSXHGHYLYLUDWXODGRVDEHUTXHHUHVODQRYLDGHXQR\GHMDUWHSDVDUVLQ UR]DUWH ³(VDHVODFRQGLFLyQ ³¢4XpFRQGLFLyQ" ³/DGHVDOLUFRQPLJR/DGHVHUQRYLRV ³
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
(ODXWRVHGHWHQtDDQWHODFDVDGHODFDOOHGHO*HQHUDO6DQMXUMR %HED 4XLQWDQD GHQWUR GH VX GHOLFDGD IDVFLQDFLyQ DVLy OD PDQLOOD GH OD SRUWH]XHOD&RQVHTXHGDGGLMR ³1RYR\DWXFDVD3HURWDPSRFRSLHQVRLQWLPDUFRQWLJRHQHOVHQWLGRTXHW~OR GHVHDV6LQRHVWiVGHDFXHUGR« ,EDDGHVFHQGHU (OUDELRVRSXHVQRHUDWDQGLSORPiWLFRFRPR(UQHVWRODDJDUUySRUXQEUD]R ³$JXDUGD ³¢3DUDTXp"
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
³6LpQWDWH0DWtDV ³6LVHxRU 3HURQRVHVHQWy ³0DWtDVWHKHGLFKRTXHWHVLHQWHV³JULWy,xDTXHH[DVSHUDGR 0DWtDVORKL]RFRPRVLIXHUDSORPR\FD\HUDGHUHSHQWHHQXQSR]RVLQIRQGR ³0DWtDV ³HPSH]y ,xDTXH FRQ ORV GLHQWHV FDVL DSUHWDGRV³ 7~ FRQRFHV D PL KHUPDQRPHMRUTXH\R ³3XHGHVHUVHxRU ³3XHGHQR HV ³6LHOVHxRUORGLFH« ³0DWtDVGpMDWHGHHQVHxRUHDUPHWDQWR\VpPiVVLQFHUR ³/RHVWR\VLHQGRVHxRU ³1R PH GHVHVSHUHV ¢4Xp LQWHQFLRQHV WHQtD PL KHUPDQR FRQ UHVSHFWR D %HED 4XLQWDQD" ³6R\KRQUDGRVHxRU ³¢&yPR"¢4XpVLJQLILFR\RDTXt"¢1RVR\WDQVHxRU\WDQVXSHULRUWX\RFRPR pO" ³3HUR\RQXQFDGLUpDOVHxRU(UQHVWRORTXHSLHQVD\GLFHHOVHxRU,xDTXH ³0DWtDV TXH HVWiV DFDEDQGRFRQ PL SDFLHQFLD 0H HVWR\ MXJDQGR HO URVWUR HQ HVWR\DOJRPiV<QRHVWR\GLVSXHVWRDMXJDUFRQEDUDMDVSUHVWDGDV6RQODVPLVPDV\ TXLHURFRQRFHUODV ³6tVHxRU ³6tVHxRUQR£PDOGLWDVHD+DEODFODUR0LKHUPDQRWLHQHODPDODFRVWXPEUH GH KDEODU HQ DOWD YR] FXDQGR VH FUHH VROR \ W~ WLHQHV OD PDOGLWD FRVWXPEUH GH HVFXFKDUORWRGR ³6HxRUPHRIHQGHXVWHG ³0DWtDVTXHFRQHVDFDUDGHERERVDEHVW~PiVTXH6yFUDWHV ³¢(OJDWRVHxRU" ³£4Xp JDWR QL TXp QDULFHV 0H UHILHUR DO ILOyVRIR QR D QXHVWUR JDWR 'LPH 0DWtDV¢TXpWHHVWDEDSUHJXQWDQGR" ³'HFtDHOVHxRUTXH\RVDEtDPXFKRVHxRU ³/iUJDWHGHDTXt0DWtDV ³¢&HQDPRVVHxRU" ³¢&HQDPRV"¢4XpPDQtDHVHVDGHKDEODUHQSOXUDO"
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
³3HUGRQHHOVHxRU«&UHRTXH«TXHYDVLHQGRKRUDGHTXHQRVDOLPHQWHPRV ³0DWtDV TXH VHD OD ~OWLPD YH] TXH PH DVRFLDV D WX DSHWLWR ¢(VWi FODUR" < DKRUDSXHVWRTXHQRTXLHUHVGHFLUORTXHSLHQVDPLJHPHORGHVXQRYLD« ³¢'HODGHpOVHxRURGHODGHXVWHG" ³0DWtDVHUHVILHODQXHVWUROHPD ³6tVHxRU ³3XHVVLORHUHVHQHVWHLQVWDQWH\RHVWR\VRORHQHVWHSLVR\WHQJRXQDQRYLD (OSDVDGR«QRFXHQWDFRQPLJHPHOR2PHMRUGLFKRHOSUHVHQWH ³6tVHxRU ³/DUJDQGR 0DWtDVVHDSUHVXUyDGHVDSDUHFHUSDUDUHDSDUHFHUFDVLLQPHGLDWDPHQWH 6HTXHGySODQWDGRHQODSXHUWDFRPRFRKLELGR$OPHQRVpVDHUDVXH[SUHVLyQ SHUR,xDTXHORFRQRFtDORVXILFLHQWHSDUDVDEHUTXHMDPiVVHFRKLEtDDTXHOWXQDQWH ³/DFHQDHVWiVHUYLGDVHxRU ³9R\³SHURLQPHGLDWDPHQWHOROODPy³9HQXQPRPHQWR0DWtDV (O FULDGR IODFR \ GHVJDUEDGR DYDQ]y VLQ SULVDV &RQ HVH UHVSHWR TXH VH DSDUHQWDDXQTXHQRVHVLHQWH ³8VWHGGLUiVHxRU ³¢(VWXYLVWHDOJXQDYH]HQDPRUDGR" ³1XQFDVHxRU ³¢-DPiV" 0DWtDVSXVRH[SUHVLyQGHVRODGD ³-DPiVVHxRU ³%LHQ SXHV\RORHVWR\'HODQRYLDGHPLJHPHORKDFHPiVGHVHLVPHVHV¢7H HQWHUDVELHQ"<QRPHPLUHVFRQHVDH[SUHVLyQLQFUpGXOD(VWDYH]HVHQVHULR
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
³8QFDEOH\OHGLUiVDPLKHUPDQRTXHODVHxRULWD%HED4XLQWDQDKDVDOLGRGH YLDMH FRQ VX SDGUH HQ GLUHFFLyQ« DGRQGH WH SDUH]FD 0X\ OHMRV $Vt QR FDEH OD SRVLELOLGDGGHTXHOHHVFULED ³¢'HERDxDGLUDOJRHVSHFLDOVHxRU" (OURVWURLPSDVLEOHGHOFULDGRFULVSyORVQHUYLRVGH,xDTXH 6HSXVRHQSLHGHXQVDOWR\JULWyHQIXUHFLGR ³¢6DEHV XQD FRVD 0DWtDV" (UHV WDQ FHUGR FRPR PL KHUPDQR 1R QR QDGD HVSHFLDO6LPSOHPHQWHORTXHWHKHGLFKR\F~UVDOHHOFDEOHDKRUDPLVPR ³¢1RUHIOH[LRQDPRVXQSRFRVHxRU" ³¢&yPR"¢4Xp"¢2WUDYH]HOSOXUDO" ³3HUGRQHHOVHxRU ,xDTXHVHUHVLJQy3XVRHVDH[SUHVLyQERQDFKRQDGHOPXFKDFKRERQDFKyQTXH SUHWHQGHVRQVDFDUDOGpELOFULDGR 6HDFHUFyDpOPX\GHVSDFLR/RPLUyDORVRMRV0DWtDVVRVWXYRYDOLHQWHPHQWHOD PLUDGD ³0DWtDVHUHVPLDPLJR ³<VXFULDGRVHxRU ³3HURHVTXHHQHVWHLQVWDQWH\RQHFHVLWRTXHVHDVPiVPLDPLJRTXHPLFULDGR ³6tVHxRU ³(VWiELHQSXHVFRPRHUHVPLDPLJR\RWHSUHJXQWR0DWtDVTXHULGRTXpHVOR TXH SLHQVD PL KHUPDQR FRQ UHODFLyQ D VX QRYLD ¢9D HQ VHULR" ¢3LHQVD FDVDUVH FRQ HOOD"¢(VWiHQDPRUDGR" ³1RPHKDUHIHULGRVXVVHFUHWRVVHxRU ³0DWtDV TXH QRV FRQRFHPRV 4XH PL JHPHOR WLHQH OD FRFKLQD FRVWXPEUH GH KDEODUDOWR\W~ODFRFKLQDPDQtDGHHVFXFKDUGHWUiVGHODVSXHUWDV ³(OVHxRUPHRIHQGHPXFKR ,xDTXH\DQRSRGtDPiV (VWDED LQTXLHWR \ PDOKXPRUDGR < DTXHO VLOHQFLR \ FHUUDGXUD GHO FULDGR OH VDFDEDQGHTXLFLR $EULy OD SXHUWD \ GH XQ WLUyQ HPSXMy D 0DWtDV GH WDO PRGR TXH pVWH KXER GH VDOLUWDPEDOHiQGRVH ³/DFHQDHVWiVHUYLGDVHxRU³LEDGLFLHQGRDWUDJDQWDGR ³&HQDW~\WXSDULHQWHPiVSUy[LPR³JULWy,xDTXHGLULJLpQGRVHDODSXHUWD< VDOLHQGRSRUHOODGLRXQIRUPLGDEOHSRUWD]R 6HYLRHQSOHQDFDOOHPLUDQGRDORDOWR1RVDEtDDGyQGHLU4XLVLHUDSRGHURtUOD YR]GH%HEDDXQTXHIXHUDSDUDGHVSUHFLDUOR
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
$SUHVXUyHOSDVR1HFHVLWDEDDWXUGLUVHDTXHOODQRFKH2OYLGDUVHGHODILGHOLGDG GH0DWtDVGHODPDUFKDGHVXKHUPDQRGHODLQTXLHWXGFRQWDJLRVDGH%HED«
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
&DSLWXOR &DSLWXOR 1R HUD SRVLEOH VRSRUWDU D (XJHQLD QL D /HRQRU QL D FXDQWDV OH URGHDEDQ HQ DTXHOLQVWDQWH6HKDOODEDHQXQFDEDUHW\PDOGLWDODJDQDTXHWHQtDGHGLYHUWLUVH ©4Xp GLDEORV PH SDVD" ³VH SUHJXQWy PDOKXPRUDGR³ (V OD SULPHUD YH] HQ PL YLGD TXHQRPHGLYLHUWRª ¢%HED 4XLQWDQD" 6L SRVLEOHPHQWH WHQtD WRGD OD FXOSD %HED 4XLQWDQD DTXHOOD FKLTXLOODGLIHUHQWHTXHVHQHJDEDDVHUEHVDGDSRUVXQRYLR« ³(VWiVPX\FDOODGLWRKR\DPRUPtR³VXVXUUyDVXODGRXQDOLQGDPXFKDFKD /DPLUyKDVWLDGR 6t GHV~ELWRVHQWtDKDVWtR&RPRVLGXUDQWHDxRVHVWXYLHUDFRPLHQGRSDVWHO\GH UHSHQWHOHHQWUDUDXQDLQGLJHVWLyQ /H URGHDED XQ JUXSR GH EHOODV PXMHUHV &RUUtD HO FKDPSiQ 8QR GH ORV HQFDUJDGRVGHODVDODPLUDEDFRPSODFLGRHOFXDGURIRUPDGRSRUHOIUtYRORPLOORQDULR \ODVPXMHUHVGHGLFDGDVHQHOORFDODKDFHUSDJDUORVJDVWRVGHORVKRPEUHV (VWDEDWDQKDUWR\WDQKDVWLDGRTXHHQDTXHOPRPHQWRKXELHUDMXUDGRQRYROYHU DOOt VL QR VH FRQRFLHUD OR VXILFLHQWH \ VXSLHUD GH DQWHPDQR TXH DO GtD VLJXLHQWH VH ROYLGDUtDGHOKDVWtRDFWXDO 1R REVWDQWH HQ DTXHO PRPHQWR GHFLGLy VDOLU GH DOOt WRPDU HO DLUH SHQVDU VL SRGtD\ROYLGDUVHGHWRGDDTXHOODSRGUHGXPEUH 6XELy DO DXWR GHVR\HQGR D ODV FKLFDV TXH OR OODPDEDQ \ OR SXVR HQ PDUFKD 5RGy SRU WRGDV ODV FDOOHV GH 0DGULG FRPR XQ GHVRULHQWDGR \ D ODV FXDWUR GH OD PDxDQDHQWUDEDHQVXOXMRVRDSDUWDPHQWRGHODDYHQLGDGHO*HQHUDOtVLPR 0DWtDV HQ HO YHVWtEXOR GRUPLWDED VREUH OD PLVPD DOIRPEUD ,xDTXH FHUUy OD SXHUWD \ FRQWHPSOy EXUORQDPHQWH DO FULDGR 7HQtD XQD VLOOD PX\ FHUFD \ GHGXMR D MX]JDU SRU OD SRVWXUD SRFR FyPRGD GHO FULDGR DFXUUXFDGR HQ HO VXHOR TXH VH IXH HVFXUULHQGRGHHOODKDVWDFDHUVREUHODDOIRPEUD 6HTXLWyHOJDEiQ\VHDFHUFyD0DWtDV/HWRFyHQHOKRPEUR (OFULDGROHYDQWyGHVSDYRULGRODFDEH]D ³£(KDK«¢4XpSDVD"³PLUyHQWRUQR³¢'yQGHHVWR\" 'H V~ELWR DO YHUVH HQ HO VXHOR VH OHYDQWy GH XQ VDOWR DOLVy HO WUDMH QHJUR FDUUDVSHy\VHSXVRILUPH ³3HUGRQHHOVHxRU&UHRTXH«³FDUUDVSHy³&UHRTXHPHKHGRUPLGR ,xDTXH FUX]y ORV EUD]RV HQ HO SHFKR &RQWHPSOy DO FULDGR FRQ H[SUHVLyQ HQWUH WLHUQD\EXUORQD ³7HKHGLFKRPXFKDVYHFHV0DWtDVTXHQRPHGHEHVHVSHUDU ³(OVHxRUVH«VHHTXLYRFD
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
³1R FUHDV 0DWtDV ³FRQIHVy EDMR FRQ UDUD HQWRQDFLyQ FDPLQDQGR MXQWR DO FULDGR HQ GLUHFFLyQ DO VDOyQ³ $ YHFHV XQ KRPEUH KHFKR \GHUHFKR FRQ YHLQWLVLHWH DxRV VH VLHQWH HQWHUQHFLGR DQWH XQD GHPRVWUDFLyQ GH FDULxR 8QD VLPSOH GHPRVWUDFLyQFRPRHVODHVSHUDGHXQFULDGRDODVFXDWURGHODPDGUXJDGD¢6DEHV 0DWtDV" 1R FUHDV TXH HVWR\ ERUUDFKR &UHR TXH QR KH EHELGR PiV GH GRV FRSDV GH FKDPSiQ 3HUR KH SHQVDGR 'H UHSHQWH XQR VLHQWH GHVHRV GH SHQVDU \ SLHQVD VLQ UHPHGLR\VHYHDVtPLVPR\VHVLHQWH³¢FyPRWHGLUp"&RPRXQVHUGHVYDOLGRHQ PHGLR GH XQ IUDJRU LQIHUQDO GH SDVLRQHV GH GHVHRV GH IDOVHGDGHV ³VH HFKy D UHtU VDUFiVWLFR³ $O YHUWH DKt DFXUUXFDGR HQ OD DOIRPEUD TXLVLHUD KDEHUWH TXLWDGR ORV SDQWDORQHV0DWtDV\ODEDUED\HOELJRWH
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
PDGUHKD VXELGR DO FLHORª
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
³(UQHVWR ³£2K« ³¢1RVHUHFXHUGDGHPt" ³&ODUR³H[FODPyODVROWHURQDWUDVXQPRPHQWRGHUHIOH[LyQ³7HYLFRQ%HED QRKDFHQLXQPHV$OVDOLU\RGHFDVDHVWDEDLVORVGRVHQHOSRUWDO ³(VRHV ³/RUHFXHUGRSHUIHFWDPHQWH 6XUJLyXQDSDXVD ³'HPRPHQWRFUHtTXHHUDV,xDTXH7HQpLVODYR]SDUHFLGD ³$pO«OHFRQRFHXQSRFRPiVTXHDPt¢QRHVHVR" 7tD3HSDVRQULyDELHUWDPHQWH ³3XHVVt7XYHRFDVLyQGHKDEODUFRQpOFDVLXQDWDUGHHQWHUD(OGtDTXH%HED OR FRQRFLy ³GLMR FRQ QDWXUDOLGDG³ IXH HQ FDVD GH ORV 6DPDQLHJR 8QD SXHVWD GH ODUJR ¢VDEHV"
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
<FROJy (QDTXHOLQVWDQWHHQWUy%HED ³$FDEDGHKDEODU(UQHVWR³GLMRWtD3HSDFRQQDWXUDOLGDG /RVRMRVGH%HEDUHOXFLHURQ3HURVXYR]VRQyGLVSOLFHQWH ³£%DK ³¢(VWiLVHQIDGDGRV"'LMRTXHLEDDHVSHUDUWHDODVDOLGDGHOWHPSOR ³3XHV\DHVWR\DTXt ³
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
&DSLWXOR &DSLWXOR ³'LJD ³£+ROD 8QVLOHQFLR 'HVSXpV« ³£+ROD ³)XLDEXVFDUWHDODVDOLGDGHOWHPSOR1RUH]DEDQ\DODPLVD ³6t ³6t¢TXp" ³(VWR\HQFDVD ³&ODUR
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
³'HQWUR GH XQD KRUD SRU HMHPSOR 7RPDPRVMXQLRV HO YHUPXW FRPHPRV SRU DKt« ³£1R ³URWXQGD³ (Q SULPHU OXJDU \R QR VR\ XQD SRWHQWDGD 9LYR HQ XQD HVIHUD VRFLDO REOLJDGD SRU OD SURIHVLyQ GH PL SDGUH TXH QR YD GH DFXHUGR FRQ QXHVWUDHFRQRPtD1RWHQHPRVPiVTXHXQDFULDGD\KHGHD\XGDUDWtD3HSDDKDFHU ODV FRVDV \ OD OLPSLH]D SDUD TXH )HOLVD SXHGD FRFLQDU WUDQTXLODPHQWH 3DSi HV PX\ H[LJHQWHSDUDODVFRPLGDV3UHILHUHXQDFULDGDTXHVHSDVHUYLUODPHVD\FRQIHFFLRQDU XQDFRPLGDDGRVFULDGDVSDUDODOLPSLH]D ³%HED« ³6L ³¢
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
³4XHULGD ³VXVXUUy \HQGR D VX ODGR \ VHQWiQGRVH -XQWR D HOOD³ 4XHULGD PtD«¢HVWiVOORUDQGR" ³1R«QR« 3HUR HUD FLHUWR /ORUDED 6LOHQFLRVDPHQWH FD\pQGROH ODV OiJULPDV PXGDPHQWH VREUHORVGHGRVFUX]DGRVHQODIDOGD ³%HEDTXHULGDPtD«1RGHELHUDVVHUWDQVHQVLEOH3DUDYLYLUHQHVWDYLGDHQ ODGHKR\«KD\TXHHVWDUPiVHQGXUHFLGR«¢4XpWHRFXUUH" 7HQtDTXHGHFLUOR ¢$VXSDGUH"1RQXQFDODFRPSUHQGHUtD 7tD3HSDVt«6t«HOODHUDPXMHU\TXL]iDOJ~QGtDVHKDEUtDHQDPRUDGR ³1RSXHGRVDEHU%HEDTXHULGD« ³1RVpTXpPHSDVDWtD3HSD³JLPLy%HEDHQWUHVXVSLURV³7HMXURTXHQROR Vp'HUHSHQWHPHSDUHFHTXHHVWR\WUDWDQGRGHQXHYRD,xDTXH ³¢&yPR" ³6tVtQRPHPLUHVFRQHVHKRUURU7HDVHJXURTXHHVWDPDxDQDKDFHVyORXQ LQVWDQWH PH OR SDUHFLy
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
³¢3RUTXpTXp" ³¢3RUTXpGHUHSHQWHVHSDUHFHWDQWRDVXKHUPDQR" ³3RUTXHVRQJHPHORV¢QR"4XL]i(UQHVWRSRUFRQVLGHUDFLyQDWXMXYHQWXGVH GREOHJDED < DKRUD TXH \D WH FRQVLGHUDED VX IXWXUD HVSRVD« URPSH OD GLVFUHFLyQ TXHFRQWHQtDVXVVHQWLPLHQWRV ³0HDVXVWD /DGDPDULy /H DFDULFLy GHQXHYR HO FDEHOOR /H VHFy ODV GRV OiJULPDV TXH TXHGDEDQ HQ ORV YHUGRVRVRMRV ³$QGDGHMDGHSUHRFXSDUWH+DVORJUDGRGHVWHUUDUD,xDTXHGHWXFRUD]yQ6p TXHWHFRVWySHURWXEXHQMXLFLRORKDORJUDGR(VWiVHQDPRUDGDGH(UQHVWR\pVWHQR WHGHIUDXGDUi (OODWLWXEHy 3DUHFtDGHVHRVDGHGHFLUDOJR ³'LOR ³VXVXUUy OD GDPD FRPR SHQHWUDQGR HQ VXV GHVHRV³ 'LOR %HED TXHULGD 1R KDV FRQRFLGR D WX PDGUH \ WX SDGUH WXYR OD EXHQD RFXUUHQFLD GH QR YROYHUVHDFDVDU$~QHVMRYHQ\TXL]iQRVVDOJDDOJ~QGtDFRQXQDGHHVDVSDWDGLWDV TXH WDQWR GXHOHQ 3HUR QR OR FUHR $O PHQRV WHQJR HVD HVSHUDQ]D 7H GHFtD HVWR SRUTXH\R«DOYHQLUDYLYLUFRQYRVRWURVVHQWtDODQHFHVLGDGGHFRQVLGHUDUWHFRPR KLMDPtD'LPHORTXHVHD7~VDEHVTXHVLHPSUHHVWR\GLVSXHVWDDD\XGDUWH ³1RWHKDVFDVDGRQXQFD ³2FXUUHQFRVDVTXHXQDPXMHUQRSUHYp ³¢3RUTXpQRWHKDVFDVDGRWtD3HSD" ³$OJ~QGtDWHORGLUp ³+HWHQLGR\RODFXOSD«¢YHUGDG"1RKDVTXHULGRDEDQGRQDUPH ³1R«QR« 3HURHUDDVt &XDQGR VX KHUPDQR OD OODPy HOOD HVWDED D SXQWR GH FRQWUDHU PDWULPRQLR FRQ XQPDHVWURGHHVFXHOD4XLVRFRUUHUMXQWRDVXKHUPDQRYLXGR(OQRYLRVHRSXVR ©6LPHDPDVGHYHUDV«PHHVSHUDUiV8QPHVGRVQRPXFKRPiVª (OPDHVWURVHQHJyHQUHGRQGR ©2\RRWXKHUPDQR\VXKLMDª ©6yOR SRU XQRV PHVHV (VWiQ VRORV PH QHFHVLWDQ 6R\ OD ~QLFD SHUVRQD TXH SXHGR D\XGDUOHV\%HEDODFKLTXLOODGHPLKHUPDQRVyORWLHQHGRVDxRVª )XHLQ~WLO
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
(OODFRQVLGHUyDTXHOODFHUUDGXUDGHOPDHVWURQDFLRQDOFRPRXQVLJQRGHDPRU HVFDVR6HIXH<FXDQGRWUHVPHVHVGHVSXpVUHJUHVyDOSXHEORDVXHVFXHODHQFRQWUy DOPDHVWURGHUHODFLRQHVFRQODVXSOHQWHTXHHOODGHMy )XHXQGHVHQJDxRGHPDVLDGRKRQGR\WHUULEOHSDUDROYLGDUOR 'HMyODHVFXHODGHILQLWLYDPHQWH\FRUULyGHQXHYRDOODGRGHORVVHUHVTXHWDQWR ODQHFHVLWDEDQ1LVLTXLHUD)pOL[VXKHUPDQRVXSRMDPiVTXHHOODVHFDVDEDHOPLVPR PHVHQTXHUHFLELyVXWHOHJUDPDOODPiQGROD 6HLVPHVHVGHVSXpVVXSRTXHODPDHVWUDSODQWDEDDOPDHVWUR\VHFDVDEDFRQHO KLMRGHOPpGLFRWLWXODU(UDPHMRUSDUWLGR,QJHQLHURMRYHQDSXHVWR (O PDHVWUR FRUULy D HOOD DQVLRVR GH DUUHJODU DTXHO GHVDJXLVDGR SHUR 3HSD 4XLQWDQDHUDGHPDVLDGD3HSD4XLQWDQDSDUDFDHUGRVYHFHVHQHOPLVPRGHVHQJDxR 1XQFDMDPiVTXLVRRWURQRYLRQLSHQVyQXHYDPHQWHHQFDVDUVH ³7tD3HSD ³6t³ULyEDMDQGRGHODVQXEHVKX\HQGRGHDTXHOORVUHFXHUGRV\DLGRVTXHQR GHVSHUWDEDQQLVLTXLHUDUHQFRU ³$OJ~Q GtD PH FRQWDUiV WX YLGD /D RFXOWDV FRPR VL HQ HOOD JXDUGDUDV UHFXHUGRVUHFRSLODGRVLQWHQVtVLPRV ³1RTXHULGD³ULyWULVWHPHQWH³7RGRHQPLYLGDHVYXOJDU3RUHVRQRTXLHUR TXHODWX\DVHDLJXDO'LPHORTXHLEDVDGHFLUPH ³(VTXH«QRPHDWUHYR ³¢7DQSRFDFRQILDQ]DWLHQHVHQPt" ³1RQR«'LPH«WtD3HSD«¢(VPXFKRSHFDGRTXHXQKRPEUH«WXQRYLR³ WHEHVH" ³£2K ³¢/R HV" 'L ¢OR HV" ³\ DSDVLRQDGDPHQWH GHVFRQRFLGD SDUD WtD 3HSD TXH OD FRQVLGHUDED PiV ELHQ IUtD DVtD ODV PDQRV GH pVWD FRQ DQVLHGDG³ 'L WtD 3HSD ¢HV WDQWRSHFDGR" ³¢7~«ORGHVHDVFRQDPRU" ³
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
³(UHV GHPDVLDGR SXUD H LQRFHQWH TXHULGD PtD 7~ PLVPD ORV GLVWLQJXLUiV« FXDQGR ORV UHFLEDV 3HUR SURFXUD KXLU GH HOORV FXDQWR SXHGDV /RV EHVRV VRQ OD LQYLWDFLyQDDOJRPXFKRPiVLQWHQVRTXHVLHPSUHFDXVDGRORU
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
&DSLWXOR &DSLWXOR ³3RU DTXt ³GLMR \ OD HPSXMDED EODQGDPHQWH HQ DTXHOOD WDUGH IUtD \D FDVL DQRFKHFLHQGRHQWUHODPXFKHGXPEUHTXHHQWUDEDFDVLFRUULHQGRHQHOFLQHPDWyJUDIR ³1ROHGLMHDSDSiTXHLEDDOFLQH ³2OYtGDWHGHSDSi³JUXxy,xDTXHHPSXMiQGROD (OODVHGHMyLU 1HFHVLWDEDLU(VWDUDVXODGR2OYLGDUVHGHWRGDVVXVLQTXLHWXGHV ³(VDTXt³GLMRpOHQXQDHVTXLQDRSXHVWDGHOSDVLOOR³4XtWDWHHODEULJR <XQLHQGRODDFFLyQDODSDODEUDODD\XGypO /RKL]RFRQGHOLFDGH]D&RPRMDPiVKL]RFRQQLQJXQDRWUDPXMHUH[FHSWRFRQ HOODDQWHVGHVHUODQRYLDGHVXKHUPDQRJHPHOR )XH FRQ HOOD DO FLQH GRV YHFHV < WDPELpQ OH TXLWy HO DEULJR \ UR]y FRPR DO GHVFXLGRVXVKRPEURV\OHFRVWyFRPRHQDTXHOLQVWDQWHEDMDUODPDQR (OODOHPLUyHQODRVFXULGDG%XVFyVXVRMRV ³'HMD³VXVXUUy³1RPH«QRPHWRTXHV« ,xDTXHEDMyODPDQR ODDSUHWyUXGRHQHOEROVLOORGHODDPHULFDQD 3HURGHVSXpVLQPHGLDWDPHQWHODD\XGyDVHQWDUVH ³4XLWD ³¢(UHVWRQWD"¢1LVLTXLHUDSXHGRDVLUWHGHOEUD]RSDUDD\XGDUWH" 6HVHQWyDVXODGR 6HLQFOLQyPXFKRKDFLDHOOD%XVFyVXVRMRV\SDUDKDFHUORPHWLyODFDEH]DEDMR ODGHHOOD ³'HMD³VXVXUUyDWXUGLGD ³(VTXHQRSXHGR ³7HSLGR« ,xDTXHEXVFDEDVXVGHGRVHQJXDQWDGRV/HTXLWyHOJXDQWHGHXQDPDQR ³7HGLJRTXH«TXH« ³7HWLHPEODODYR] 6HHVWUHPHFLyGHSLHVDFDEH]D ³'HMDWHGLJR ¢3RGtD pO KXLU GH DTXHOORV GHGRV SHUIXPDGRV VXDYHV TXH WHPEODEDQ EDMR VXV ODELRV" ³%HED«
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
³1R« QR KDEOHV ³VXVXUUy HOOD FRQ XQ KLOR GH YR]³ 1RV YDQ D SHGLU TXH VDOJDPRV ³3XHVQRKDEOR ³3HURGHMDPLV«PLV«PDQRV ³(VRWDPSRFRSXHGR ³3RUIDYRU« ³&XDQGRPHSLGHVDOJRDVt«SRUIDYRUPHHQWUDXQQRVpTXp«³OHGLMRHQHO PLVPRRtGR³(VFRPRVLW~\\R«HVWXYLpUDPRVSUHVRVHQDOJRFRP~Q ³&DOOD ³6LQRSXHGRFDOODUQLSDUDU ³3DUD³SLGLyHOODDMHQDDVXVSHQVDPLHQWRV³'HMD«PLVGHGRV 1RSRGtD /RVVX\RVVHGHVOL]DEDQSRUHOEUD]RIHPHQLQR\VHSHUGtDQEDMRODPDQJD(OOD VHDJLWyWUDWyGHHPSXMDUORSHUR,xDTXHVXVXUUyEDMtVLPRVXSOLFDQWH ³'pMDPHWRFDUWH'HHVWHPRGRSHQVDUpTXHHVWiVMXQWRDPt ³/R«ORHVWR\ ³
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
eO OH D\XGy D SRQHUVH HO DEULJR /R KDFtD GHOLFDGDPHQWH FRPR VL GH SURQWR WXYLHUD PLHGR D RIHQGHUOD FRQ VXV GRV PDQRV (OOD FXDQGR WXYR HO DEULJR SXHVWR JLUyXQSRFRODFDEH]D 6XVYHUGRVRVRMRVORPLUDURQODUJDPHQWH ³1RPHPLUHVDVt³SLGLypOFDOODGDPHQWH³1RVpGHORTXHVHUpFDSD] 0XGDPHQWHDVXODGRVLQUHKXLUHOEUD]RTXHVHHQOD]DEDFRQHOVX\RDPERV VDOLHURQDODFDOOH 6DEtDTXHLEDDRFXUULU 3RUHVRFXDQGROOHJyDOSRUWDOWUDWyGHKXLUFRQXQSUHFLSLWDGR« ³+DVWDPDxDQD ,xDTXHODUHWXYRSRUXQGHGR(OODWUDWDEDGHDOHMDUVH ³9HQDEXVFDUPHPDxDQDDODPLVPDKRUD ³$JXDUGD ³(V«HVWDUGH /D SRUWHUD QR HVWDED HQ OD JDULWD &DVL QXQFD HVWDED D DTXHOOD KRUD ODV GLH] \ FXDUWRGHODQRFKH ³3DSiYDDHQIDGDUVH«0HWLHQHSURKLELGROOHJDUWDUGH ³7XSDGUHYLYHFRQYHLQWHDxRVGHUHWUDVR\SHUGRQDTXHWHORGLJD ³7HUXHJR« 1RHUDSRVLEOH+DEODED\DODYH]ODDUULQFRQDEDKDFLDXQDHVTXLQDGHOSRUWDO HQ OD SHQXPEUD (OOD TXH UHWURFHGtD TXHGy GH V~ELWR LQPyYLO SHJDGD D OD SDUHG )XHDOOtGRQGHpOEXVFDQGRVXVRMRVFRPRXQDYDULFLRVROHPHWLyODVPDQRVEDMRHO DEULJR\ODDWUDMRKDFLDVL ³1RQR«³VXVXUUy%HEDGpELOPHQWH 6DEtDTXHQRSRGUtDHYLWDUDTXHOLQVWDQWH(QXQGtDDPDEDPiVD(UQHVWRTXH HQ DTXHOORV GRV PHVHV GH KDFHUVH SUHJXQWDV DO UHVSHFWR D VL PLVPD (UD WRGR PX\ H[WUDxRSHURQRVDEtDRQRSRGtDGHWHQHUVHHQDTXHOLQVWDQWHDSHQVDU ,xDTXH OD DSUHWDED KDFLD VL FRQ HVD KDELOLGDG GHO KRPEUH TXH VDEH FyPR FRQTXLVWDU D XQD FKLFD 1R KXELHUD SRGLGR KDFHUOR HQ VX SDSHO TXH ODV SHUVRQDV IRUPDEDQXQDVGHRWUDVHQVXSDSHOGH(UQHVWRVLTXDSRGtDKDFHUOR %XVFyVXVODELRV (OODDWXUGLGDWUDWyGHKXLUSHUR,xDTXHODSHJyDVXSHFKR\IXHLQFOLQDQGROD FDEH]D EXVFDQGR VXV ODELRV FRQ ORV VX\RV /RV HQFRQWUy DO ILQ ,QH[SHUWRV WHPEORURVRVFRKLELGRV ³%HED«
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
³'HMDGHMD³SLGLyHOODVRIRFDGD³'HMD« 3HUR QR SRGtD KXLU GH pO (UD FRPR VL XQD IXHU]D VXSHULRU OD UHWXYLHUD DOOt GREODGDHQVXSHFKRFRQORVODELRVGH,xDTXHSHUGLGRVHQORVVX\RV ³7HTXLHUR¢VDEHV"³GLMRpOURQFDPHQWH³1RORYR\DSRGHUUHPHGLDU(VOD SULPHUDYH]TXHPHRFXUUH +DEODEDHQVXERFD (OOD VHQWtD FRPR VL HO VXHOR IXHUD D GHVOL]DUVH EDMR VXV SLHV &RPR VL DOJR LQGHILQLEOHODUHWXYLHUDDOOt\VXVODELRVFHUUDGRVVHQHJDUDQVXWLOPHQWHDDGPLWLUOR eOGLMREDMtVLPR ³1RVHDVWRQWD6RPRVQRYLRV«QRVQHFHVLWDPRV ³3HUR«SHUR ³6t\DVp&iOODWHDQGDFiOODWH 6XYRVHUDWHQXH\VXVEHVRVFiOLGRVKRQGRVVLQSHFDGR ³1RVDEHVEHVDU (UDFRPRXQKDODJR(OODVHHVWUHPHFLy\TXLVRKXLUGHVXVEUD]RV ³%DVWD³VXVXUUyVRIRFDGD³%DVWD3RUIDYRU« ³$JXDUGD ³1R«QR0HGDYHUJHQ]D /RHQDMHQDEDDTXHOODWLPLGH]DTXHOODSHQXPEUDHQODFXDOODLQJUiYLGDILJXUD SDUHFtDGHVGLEXMDUVH\DSDUHFHUGHQXHYRQtWLGD\SDOSLWDQWH 3HUR FXDQGR HOOD HVFDSy SRU GHEDMR GH VXV EUD]RV VH TXHGy FRPR VROR FRPR GHVDPSDUDGR ³%HED« (OODVHSHUGtDHQHODVFHQVRU'HFtDTXHGDPHQWHWHPEODQGR ³1R«QR« < pO TXHGy DOOt FRQ ORV EUD]RV FDtGRV D OR ODUJR GHO FXHUSR HO GXO]RU GH ORV ODELRVIHPHQLQRVHQORVVX\RV
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
&DSLWXOR &DSLWXOR SLWXOR ©6LHPSUH OD TXLVH $QWHV GH FRQRFHUOD FRQWDED ODV QRYLDV D GRFHQDV 1R VHQWtD QL XQ UHPRUGLPLHQWRGHFRQFLHQFLD3HURGHVSXpV«QRVHQWtHQPtGHVHRDOJXQRGHFRUWHMDUDRWUD PXMHU 3DUD SUREDUPH PiV D\HU WUDV GHMDUOD D HOOD PH IXL D XQ FDEDUHW 6LHPSUH PH HQWUHWXYR HVWH SXHUFR HVSHFWiFXOR $\HU QRFKH VHQWt DVFR (O DVFR GH XQ KRPEUH PRUDO TXH DFDED GHEHVDU ORV ODELRV SXURV GHXQD PXMHU ODPXMHU TXH GHVHD SDUDHVSRVD (VRHV ORTXH VLHQWRSHVHDPLPDOGLWDIULYROLGDG'HEtTXHUHUOD\DHQWRQFHVFXDQGRHUDVyORVXDPLJR\W~ OD FRQRFLVWH DTXHOOD WDUGH
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
TXHGDVWHFRQXQVRORDPRU
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
³£$K HV YHUGDG ³PLUy D VX SDGUH TXH OHtD OD 3UHQVD UHSDQWLJDGR HQ XQD EXWDFD³£$GLyVSDSi ³1RYXHOYDVWDQWDUGHFRPRD\HU1RPHDJUDGD$GHPiVWHQJRTXHKDEODUWH DWXUHJUHVR ³6tVt ³(VWiV QHUYLRVD %HED ³DGXMR HO FDEDOOHUR JUDYHPHQWH³ \ HVR QR HV FRQYHQLHQWH ³7HDVHJXURSDSi« ³0iUFKDWH ³LQWHUYLQR WtD 3HSD³ 6L KD\ DOJR TXH GLVFXWLU \R OR KDUp FRQ WX SDGUH ³7~\\RQRWHQHPRVQDGDTXHGHFLUQRV³VDOWyHOFDEDOOHURHQRMDGtVLPR³< QRWHPHWDVHQPLVDVXQWRV ³&ODURTXHWHQHPRVTXHKDEODU/RKDUHPRVWDQSURQWRVHYD\D%HED %HEDQRSRGtDGHWHQHUVHDSHQVDUHQORTXHVHGHFtDQVXSDGUH\WtD3HSD/RV EHVySULPHURDOXQR\GHVSXpVDRWUR(QFRQWUyFDORUHQHOURVWURGHVXWtD\IUtRHQHO GHVXSDGUH/HH[WUDxyXQSRFRSHURQLHQHVRSXGRGHWHQHUVHDSHQVDUGHPDVLDGR ³9ROYHUpDODVGLH]³GLMRSUHVXURVD <GHVDSDUHFLy +XERXQVLOHQFLRHPEDUD]RVRHQHOVDOyQ 7tD 3HSD FRQ VX KDELWXDO GHVSDUSDMR VH VHQWy IUHQWH D VX KHUPDQR &RVD H[WUDxD GRQ )pOL[ ³FXDUHQWD \ FLQFR DxRV ELHQ SDUHFLGR GH FRQWLQHQWH JUDYH³ SDUHFLyLQTXLHWR\GLVSXHVWRDVDOLUGHOVDOyQ 3HURWtD3HSDGLMRDOJRTXHORGHWXYRHQVHFR ³7HQJRPHGLDLGHDGHORTXHSLHQVDVGHFLUOHDWXKLMD (OFDWHGUiWLFRTXHLEDDOHYDQWDUVHVHVHQWyGHJROSH ³7~«VDEHV« ³
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
³Ð\HPH« ³/R Vp 6p PXFKDV FRVDV PiV 6p TXH DQGDV OLDGR FRQ XQD PXMHU 1R WHQJR QDGDTXHGHFLUGHHOOD1RVHUiEXHQDSHURWDPSRFRVpVLHVPDOD(VXQDPXMHUTXH SLHQVDVPHWHUHQHVWHKRJDUFRQORFXDO%HED\\RWHQGUHPRVTXHVDOLUGHpO ³Ð\HPHW~«¢TXpWHKDVFUHtGR"¢4XHYR\DUHQXQFLDUDODIHOLFLGDGSRUWL" 3RGUtDKDFHUOR(QRWUDRFDVLyQHOODUHQXQFLyDODVX\DSRUpO 3HUR 3HSD 4XLQWDQD HUD PXFKD 3HSD SDUD PDQLIHVWDU OR TXH VHQWtD \ OR TXH SXGLHUDKHULUDVXKHUPDQRDXQTXHDpVWHQROHLPSRUWDUDKHULUODDHOOD ³
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
%DLODEDQHQ9LOOD5RPDQD (UDQ ODV QXHYH GH OD QRFKH /D SLVWD DWHVWDGD EDMR DQD OX] D]XORVD \ URML]D $SHQDVVLVHPRYtDQ/DOOHYDEDVXMHWDSRUODHVSDOGD\VXPDQRWDQSURQWRHVWDEDHQ ODQXFDIHPHQLQDFRPRHQVXFLQWXUDDWXUGLpQGROD\HQHUYiQGROD 1R SRGtD VHSDUDUVH GH pO 4XLVLHUD WHQHU YROXQWDG SDUD KDFHUOR SHUR \D QR SRGtD/HGDEDYHUJHQ]D1RHUDFDSD]GHUHPHGLDUHOUXERUTXHVXEtDDVXVPHMLOODV FDGDYH]TXHpOODRSULPtDFRQWUDVtODIXQGtDHQVXFXHUSR\OHKDEODEDDORtGR ³&XDQGRQRVFDVHPRV« ³&DOODFDOOD ³¢1RTXLHUHV" ³1RVp ³¢1R" ³%DLOD(VWDPRVSDUDGRV $Vt SRU OR PHQRV GRV KRUDV (O WLHPSR TXH HPSOHDURQ HQ VDOLU GHO FHQWUR \ SHUGHUVHHQODOXMRVDVDODGHILHVWDV 'HUHSHQWH,xDTXHKL]RXQDSUHJXQWD ³¢1XQFDWHEHVyPLKHUPDQR" (OODSDUHFLyVREUHVDOWDUVH 6HVHSDUyXQSRFR(FKyODFDEH]DKDFLDDWUiV ³¢7X«KHUPDQR" ³,xDTXH ³£$K ³¢7HEHVy" ³1RFODURTXHQR¢&yPRSLHQVDVHVR",xDTXHIXHXQDPLJRFDVXDO1XQFDPH SXVHHQUHODFLRQHVVHULDVFRQpO ³¢3RUTXp" ³7~VDEHVPX\ELHQODIDPDTXHWLHQH ³/RTXHGLFHODJHQWH1RSLHQVHVTXHODVFRVDVVRQFRPRVHFXHQWDQ$YHFHV QRVHTXLYRFDPRV ³6LWLHQHXQDQRYLDFDGDKRUD ,xDTXHULyXQSRFRIXHUWHXQSRFRQHUYLRVDPHQWH 1R WHQtD PiV QRYLD TXH HOOD $WRGDV ODV IXH ROYLGDQGR 1R VH SRGtD VDOLU FRQ DTXHOOD IUiJLO \ IHPHQLQD PXFKDFKD \ WHQHU PiV QRYLDV (Q pO QR FDEtD VHPHMDQWH FRVD ³0H«PHRSULPHVPXFKR$GHPiVGHEHVHUPX\WDUGH(QWUHTXHOOHJDPRVD FDVD«
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
³¢0HGHMDUiVEHVDUWHGHVSXpVFXDQGR\RTXLHUR\QHFHVLWR" ³1RQR« ³0HUHVWULQJHVORVEHVRVFRPRDQWHVVHUHVWULQJtDHODJXD ³9iPRQRVDQGD³\VHVHSDUDEDGHpO ,xDTXHYROYLyDDWUDHUODKDFLDVL ³8QSRFRPiV ³&yPRHUHV(UQHVWR &DGDYH]TXHOHOODPDED(UQHVWROHKHUtD6tSURIXQGDPHQWH 3RUHVRQRLQVLVWLy -XQWR DO JXDUGDUURSD OH SXVR OD JDEDUGLQD SRU ORV KRPEURV \ SDViQGROH XQ EUD]RSRUHOORVVHGLULJLyDODFDOOH 8QJUXSRTXHHQWUDEDOHVJULWy ³$GLyV,xDTXH ³(V(UQHVWR³GLMRHOODVLQSRGHUVHFRQWHQHU ,xDTXHVHHFKyDUHtUVLJXLHQGRVXFDPLQRMXQWRD%HED
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
³<PHGHMDV ³(VTXH« ³6pORTXHHV ³(UQHVWR\R«\R« /HWHPEODEDQORVODELRVeOYROYLyDEHVDUOD0XFKRWLHPSR&RPRVLHQHOOROH IXHUDODYLGD&RQORVODELRVDELHUWRVGDQGRWRGRVXVHUHQDTXHOEHVR ³%DVWDEDVWD <VRIRFDGDWtPLGDKX\yGHVXVEUD]RV\VHDFXUUXFyHQXQDHVTXLQDGHODXWR GREODQGRHODEULJRVREUHHOSHFKR ,xDTXHGLMREDMtVLPRDOWLHPSRGHSRQHUHODXWRHQPDUFKD ³¢&XiQGRGHMDUiVGHDYHUJRQ]DUWH" ³1XQFD«QXQFD«1RORSXHGRUHPHGLDU 3RUHVRpOODTXHUtD3RUHVR\SRUTXHHUDXQDPXMHUFLWDPRUDODTXLHQSHVDED FDGDEHVRTXHGDEDDXQTXHORGHVHDUD\ORVLQWLHUDFRQWRGDVODVILEUDVGHVXVHU
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
&DSLWXOR &DSLWXOR 1RWyXQDH[WUDxDFULVSDFLyQHQHOURVWURVLHPSUHERQGDGRVR\DSDFLEOHGHWtD 3HSD %HED VHQVLEOH FRPR HUD KHQFKLGD GH DPRU FXDQGR OOHJDED HQ HO VHFUHWR GH DTXHOORVEHVRVHQVXVHUFUH\yTXHODULJLGH]GHDTXHOURVWURVHGHEtDDVXWDUGDQ]D ³6yORVRQODVGLH]WtD3HSD³VXVXUUyLQFOLQiQGRVHKDFLDHOODKDVWDEHVDUODHQ ODIUHQWH ³1RQRTXHULGD«1RHVHVR ³¢2FXUUHDOJR" ³7XSDGUHGHVHDKDEODUWH(VWiHVSHUiQGRWHHQHOGHVSDFKR /DMRYHQVHHVWUHPHFLy ³1R PH GLJDV TXH SDSi FRQVLGHUD TXH OOHJR WDUGH ³VH DODUPy PLUiQGROD VXSOLFDQWH 7tD 3HSD GXGy XQ VHJXQGR SHUR OXHJR OH SDVy XQ EUD]R SRU ORV KRPEURV OD DWUDMRKDFLDVt\ODEHVyHQHOSHORFRQLQILQLWDWHUQXUD ³9DDGROHUWHORTXHWLHQHTXHGHFLUWH%HEDTXHULGD9DDGROHUWHPXFKR1RVH WUDWDGHWL+D\PRPHQWRVHQORVFXDOHVORVSDGUHVVRQWDQHJRtVWDVTXHVHROYLGDQGH VXVKLMRV\GHODVKRUDVHQODVFXDOHVpVWRVUHJUHVDQDFDVD ³1RWHHQWLHQGR ³1RVHVL\RGHERSRQHUWHHQDQWHFHGHQWHVGHORTXHpOYDDGHFLUWH1RVpHQ UHDOLGDGFXiOHVPLGHEHU ³%HED³OODPyXQDYR]URQFDGHVGHHOXPEUDO /D MRYHQ VH SXVRHQSLH7tD 3HSD TXHGyFRQ HO EUD]R VROR H[WHQGLGR VREUH HO UHVSDOGR ³3DSi ³9HQDPLGHVSDFKR+HGHKDEODUWH /R KL]R DVt D~Q SHUSOHMD 1L OD PiV OHYH LGHD GH OR TXH VX SDGUH WHQtD TXH GHFLUOHFUX]ySRUVXPHQWH ³3DVD\FLHUUD³SLGLyHOFDWHGUiWLFR\HQGRDVHQWDUVHWUDVODDQFKDPHVDGHVX GHVSDFKR³+HPRVGHKDEODUXQSRFRFRQFDOPD ³0H DVXVWDV SDSi ³H[FODPy OD MRYHQ IUDQFDPHQWH DODUPDGD³ ¢+LFH DOJR" ¢7LHQHVDOJRTXHFHQVXUDUPH" ³1R VH WUDWD GH WL ³FRUWy pO WRGR OR DPDEOH TXH SXGR³ (V GH Pt GH TXLHQ YR\DKDEODUWH ¢'HpO"¢4XpOHRFXUUtD"
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
6H GHMy FDHU DO RWUR ODGR GH OD PHVD \ MXJy GLVWUDtGD FRQ XQ SLVDSDSHOHV GH FULVWDOWDOODGR ³&UHtTXHWXWtDWHGLUtDORTXH\RSUHWHQGRGHFLUWH ³1R WXYR WLHPSR ³VRQULy %HED HQFDQWDGRUDPHQWH³ 7~ DSDUHFLVWH HQ HO PRPHQWRHQTXHHOODVHGLVSRQtDDGHFLUPHDOJR ³%HED³HPSH]yHOFDEDOOHURWUDVXQDSDXVDHPEDUD]RVD³7LHQHVYHLQWHDxRV \\DVDEHVPXFKDVFRVDV+LFHGHWLXQDPXMHUFXOWD\FRPSUHQVLYD(UHVLQWHOLJHQWH\ QRFUHRTXHVHDSUHFLVRTXH\RHPSOHHXQVLQItQGHIUDVHVSDUDKDFHUWHFRPSUHQGHUOR TXHSUHWHQGR ³3RU VXSXHVWR SDSi 4XL]i VHD PHMRU TXH PH OR GLJDV SURQWR \ VLQ PXFKDV IUDVHV ³6XSRQJRTXHXQGtDWHFDVDUiVFRQHVHQRYLRTXHWLHQHV ³&UHRTXHVt ³eOWLHQHPXFKRGLQHUR« ³3DSi ³1RQRVLQRWHYR\DUHSURFKDUTXHORWHQJD0HMRUSDUDWL$KRUDFUHRTXH HVWR\FRQYHQFLGRGHTXHWHDPDGHYHUDV8QKRPEUHGHVXWDOOD\GHVXIRUWXQDQR SLHUGH HO WLHPSR SDVHDQGR FRQ XQD PXFKDFKD GXUDQWH YDULRV PHVHV SDUD SODQWDUOD OXHJR ³0HTXLHUH ³(VRHVSHURKLMD(VRHVSHUR&RPRWHGHFtDXQGtDWHFDVDUiV(VVHJXURTXH HOGtDTXHORKDJDVWHOOHYDUiVDWXWtD ³¢$WtD3HSD"³VHDVRPEUyODMRYHQVLQFRPSUHQGHU³3RUVXSXHVWRVLHOODOR GHVHD3HURQRYR\DGHMDUWHDWLVROR (OFDWHGUiWLFRFDUUDVSHy(QFHQGLyXQFLJDUULOOR\IXPyPX\DSULVD ³'H HVR VH WUDWD SUHFLVDPHQWH ³PXUPXUy DO UDWR³ (V SRVLEOH TXH W~ SUHWHQGDV GHMDUOD FRQPLJR SHUR WDPELpQ HV PX\ SRVLEOH TXH HOOD VH QLHJXH D TXHGDUVH ³3DSi VL HV WX KHUPDQD \ WH TXLHUH PXFKR \ UHQXQFLy D VX MXYHQWXG SRU QRVRWURV« ³%XHQR³ULyHOSDGUHQHUYLRVDPHQWH³(VRHVORTXHHOODGLFH ³$OFRQWUDULRSDSi7tD3HSDQXQFDGLFHHVR3HURKD\TXHVHUFLHJDSDUDQR YHUOR\WRQWRSDUDQRFRPSUHQGHUTXHIXHDVt ³2OYLGHPRVHVHDVXQWR$OILQ\DOFDER\RHVWLPRTXHQDGLHUHQXQFLDDQDGD SRUQDGLH'HFLUVtVHGLFHSHURODUHDOLGDGHVGLVWLQWD ³3DSi«UHVXOWDVFUXHODOFRQVLGHUDUDWtD3HSDTXHHVWXKHUPDQD ³1R QR %HED 1R WUDWR GH VHU FUXHO VLQR UHDO $GHPiV QR WH KH FLWDGR DTXt SDUDKDEODUWHGHPLKHUPDQDQLVLTXLHUDGHWLSHVHDSUHRFXSDUPHPXFKR(VWDYH]
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
VR\ XQ SRFR PiV HJRtVWD 3UHWHQGR \D FUHR KDEpUWHOR GLFKR KDEODU GH Pt 0H TXHGDUpPX\VRORFXDQGRW~WHFDVHV ³6LQRYR\DFDVDUPHPDxDQDSDSi )pOL[ 4XLQWDQD \D OR VDEtD 3HUR GH DOJXQD IRUPD KDEtD TXH HQIRFDU DTXHO DVXQWR<FXDQPiVQHJURSXVLHUDVXIXWXURPiVPRWLYRVWHQGUtDSDUDKDFHUORTXH SHQVDEDKDFHU ³3RU VXSXHVWR TXHULGD
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
³1RWHFRPSUHQGR ³¢4XpPiVGD"³\EDMRFRQDPDUJXUD³ ¢&XiQGR«FXiQGR«KDVGHFLGLGR FDVDUWH" ³'HQWURGHWUHVPHVHVMXVWRV ³<ODWUDHUiVDTXt³GLMRVLQSUHJXQWDU ³1R,Up\RDYLYLUDVXFDVD0LHQWUDVW~QRWHFDVHVLUiVDYLYLUFRQQRVRWURV 7~\WtD3HSD ³£1R $TXHOODQHJDFLyQVDOLyGHVXVODELRVFRPRXQGLVSDUR ³%HED« ¢SRU TXp QR" 6R\ WX SDGUH 'HELHUD DOHJUDUWH HO KHFKR GH TXH KD\D HQFRQWUDGRODIHOLFLGDG ³1RYR\DGLVFXWLUHVR&LHUWRTXHQRWHQJRQLQJ~QGHUHFKRDRSRQHUPHSHUR QRPHQRVFLHUWRTXHQXQFDLUpDYLYLUFRQYRVRWURV¢6DEHVSDSi"9R\DWUDEDMDU ³¢7UDEDMDU"¢1RWLHQHVXQQRYLRULFR"$GHODQWDUODIHFKDGHODERGD /RPLUyODUJDPHQWH ³(UHV GH UHSHQWH ³GLMR EDMR³ PX\ HJRtVWD 1R WH GDV FXHQWD GH TXH XQ KRPEUH QR VH FDVD FXDQGR XQD TXLHUH \ WDPSRFR FRPSUHQGHV HQ WX WHUULEOH \ GRORURVRHJRtVPRGHTXHXQDPXMHUQRSXHGHQLGHEHLQVWDUDOQRYLRDOPDWULPRQLR VLpOQRHVWiGLVSXHVWRDFDVDUVHSRUVtPLVPR ³1DGDKD\TXHLPSLGDWXERGD ³+D\XQDUD]yQ0X\SRGHURVDFUHR\R4XH(UQHVWRQRKDGLFKRD~QFXiQGR SLHQVD FDVDUVH \ QR VHUp \R TXLHQ PHQFLRQH HVH DVXQWR 3HUR W~ FiVDWH ³DxDGLy YDOLHQWHPHQWH³ VL pVH HV WX GHVHR 6L OR QHFHVLWDV DVt GHEHV KDFHUOR H LUWH FRQ WX PXMHU
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
³/RVLHQWR%HED³GLMRURQFDPHQWH³&UpHPHTXHORVLHQWR /D MRYHQ JLUy VREUH VL \ GHVSDFLR VH HQFDPLQy GH QXHYR DO VDORQFLWR 3HUR FXDQGRLEDDWUDVSDVDUHOXPEUDOSHQVyTXHQRWHQtDSRUTXpLQTXLHWDUDVXWtD(VWDED OORUDQGR \SUHIHUtDTXHVXWtD3HSDFXDQGRODYLHUDQRVXSLHUDMDPiVHOJUDQGRORU TXHSDUDHOODVXSRQtDODERGDGHVXSDGUH 3RUHVWDUD]yQIXHGLUHFWDPHQWHDVXFXDUWR
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
&DStWXOR &DStWXOR 8Q OHMDQR UHORM WRFDED ODV GRFH FXDQGR R\y ORV SDVRV GH WtD 3HSD D WUDYpV GHO SDVLOOR\HQVHJXLGDVXYR]VXDYH\FDULxRVD ³¢'XHUPHV%HED" +L]R XQ HVIXHU]R 7HQtD ORV RMRV VHFRV \ OD PLUDGD EULOODQWH ORV ODELRV VH SOHJDEDQHQXQDVRQULVDTXHSUHWHQGtDVHUYDOLHQWH ³3DVDWtD3HSD /DVROWHURQDSDVy /H SDUHFLy D %HED PiV GHVJDUEDGD \ GHVRODGD TXH QXQFD 6LHPSUH FUH\y TXH DTXHOODPXMHUOOHYDEDGHQWURGHVLXQGRORURXQSURIXQGRSHVDU&RPRXQDUHQXQFLD LQYROXQWDULDTXHGDxDEDD~QDWUDYpVGHORVDxRV /DHYRFySRUXQLQVWDQWHFXDQGRHOODWHQtDVHLVRVLHWHDxRV7tD3HSDQRHUDOD PXMHU GHVJDUEDGD DOWD \ IODFD (UD SRU HO FRQWUDULR XQD PXMHU EHOOD VLQ DUUXJDV PyUELGDVXVLOXHWD(OHJDQWHVXDQGDUDLURVDVXFDEH]D 7tD 3HSD DMHQD D ORV SHQVDPLHQWRV GH OD MRYHQ FHUUy OD SXHUWD \ DYDQ]y 6H VHQWyVLOHQFLRVDPHQWHHQHOERUGHGHOOHFKR ³7XSDGUHQRKDYXHOWRD~Q ³
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
³1RKDEOHPRVGHHVR<HVFXFKDWtD3HSD3RUIDYRUHVFXFKDHVWR+D]ORSRU Pt 6L KDEOD (UQHVWR FRQWLJR SUHJXQWiQGRWH SRU Pt HQ FXDOTXLHU PRPHQWR QR OH GLJDVQDGDGHFXDQWRRFXUUHQLGHPLLQWHQFLyQGHWUDEDMDU ³3HURQLxD« ³7H OR VXSOLFR 6L pOVH HQWHUD GHTXHSLHQVR WUDEDMDU TXL]i VH YHD REOLJDGR D SHGLUPH TXH PH FDVH FRQ pO \ HVR QR SRGUtD VRSRUWDUOR 6L DOJ~Q GtD (UQHVWR PH KDEOD VHULDPHQWH GH PDWULPRQLR QR VHUi SUHVLRQDGR SRU UD]yQ GH XQ GHEHU TXH pO FUHDVX\R¢0HFRPSUHQGHV" ³3HUR« ³(V HO ~QLFR IDYRU TXH WH SLGR (Q FXDQWR D TXH SDSi VH FDVH ³DxDGLy KDFLpQGRVHODYDOLHQWH³WLHQHSOHQRGHUHFKRDKDFHUOR(VMRYHQ\HIHFWLYDPHQWHHO GtDTXH\RPHFDVHVLOOHJRDFDVDUPHVHTXHGDUiPX\VRORSRUTXH«\RWHOOHYDUp FRQPLJR ³%HED« ³6L VL QR PH PLUHV FRQ HVH DVRPEUR 0H SDUHFH PX\ ELHQ TXHSDSi VHFDVH 4XH IRUPH VX SURSLR KRJDU 4XL]i VHD GHPDVLDGR HJRtVPR SRU PL SDUWH SHUR VLJR SHQVDQGRTXHHVORPHMRUTXHSXHGHKDFHU ³0H DVRPEUDV &UHtD TXH WH HQFRQWUDUtD OORUDQGR \ UHVXOWD TXHHVWiV GHSDUWH GHWXSDGUH ³7RWDOPHQWH ³PLQWLy³ 6R\ KXPDQD \ WHQJR XQ UD]RQDPLHQWR VHQVDWR 7HQJR DGHPiV ODSOHQD FRQYLFFLyQ GH TXHSDSi QR HOLJLy XQD HVSRVD YXOJDU 3DSi QRORHV ³6LQRWHKDGLFKRGHTXLpQVHWUDWD«\RSXHGRGHFtUWHOR$QWHVGHTXHpOPH KDEODUD\R\DVDEtD«7RGRVHVDEH7~QRORVDEtDVSRUTXHYLYHVGHPDVLDGRSDUDWX DPRU ³6R\HJRtVWDDXQTXHQRTXLHUD ³(V XQD FRPSDxHUD &DWHGUiWLFR FRPR pO 8QD SHUVRQD LPSRUWDQWH WLHQH GLQHUR\HVMRYHQ&UHRTXHWUHLQWDDxRVHVFDVRV0X\EHOODPX\GHVXFDVDSHVHDVX SURIHVLyQ ³£$K ³6HOODPD$OLFLD)RQVHFD(VKLMDGHXQIDPRVRQRWDULR ³£$K ³3HUR HVR QR LPSLGH TXH \R VLJD SHQVDQGR TXH FRPHWH XQ GLVSDUDWH 3URQWR FXPSOLUiFXDUHQWD\VHLVDxRV ³(VMRYHQ ³1RHVMRYHQ%HED1RQRVHQJDxHPRVW~\\R« ³'HWRGRVPRGRVWLHQHGHUHFKRDVXSDUWHGHIHOLFLGDG<KDWHQLGRPX\SRFD < HQ DTXHO LQVWDQWH GH V~ELWR GHFtD OR TXH VHQWtD ¢4Xp GHUHFKR WHQtD HOOD D UHFKD]DUQLVLTXLHUDFRQHOSHQVDPLHQWRTXHVXSDGUHWUDWDUDGHEXVFDUXQSRFRGH
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
OD IHOLFLGDG TXHWDQ MRYHQ OH IXHQHJDGD" ¢1R YLYLy FRQVDJUDGR D HOOD KDVWD TXH IXH XQDPXMHU" 6HVHQWyHQHOOHFKR ³0DxDQD PLVPR EXVFDUp WUDEDMR ³GLMR UHVXHOWDPHQWH³ 'HER KDFHUOR DVt \ KDVWDPHFRPSODFHTXHPHREOLJXHQODVFLUFXQVWDQFLDV ³¢<(UQHVWR" ³1ROHGLUpQDGD ³3HUR«¢HVpVHWXGHEHU" ³
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
³(VWi ELHQ ³DGPLWLy WtD 3HSD SXHV WRGR OR TXH KLFLHUD R GLMHUD %HED OR FRQVLGHUDEDUD]RQDEOH³0DxDQDVHORGLUp %HVyDODMRYHQUHSHWLGDVYHFHVPXUPXUDQGR ³(UHVGLJQDGHVHUDGRUDGD6LKLMDVL7~VLTXHWLHQHVYDORUHV $ODPDxDQDVLJXLHQWH)pOL[4XLQWDQDHQWUyHQHOVDOyQKRVFR\IULyRFXOWDQGR HQHOIRQGRGHVXVHUEDMRVXPiVFDUDLPSHQHWUDEOHHOWHPRUDXQDHVFHQD 3HURQRRFXUULyDVt (Q HO FRPHGRU VH KDOODED WtD 3HSD FRPR VLHPSUH VRQULHQWH \ DQLPRVD VLUYLHQGRHOGHVD\XQRSDUDVXKHUPDQR ³%XHQRVGtDV³VDOXGy)pOL[IUtDPHQWH ³%XHQRVGtDV)pOL[7HQJRTXHGHFLUWHDOJR ³1R ³VDOWy pO³ 1R TXLHUR VDEHU QDGD 6XSRQJR TXH %HED WH SRQGUtD DO FRUULHQWH\WHGLUtD\DTXHQRSLHQVDYLYLUFRQPLJR\FRQPLIXWXUDHVSRVD ³¢<WHH[WUDxD"/DFKLFDSUHWHQGHVHULQGHSHQGLHQWH
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
©6L VHUp WRQWD ³SHQVy OD VHQWLPHQWDO VROWHURQD³ 6L VLJXH WDQ HPRFLRQDGR YR\ D OORUDUª 3HUR)pOL[4XLQWDQDPDUFKRVLQPDQLIHVWDUGHQXHYRVXKRQGDHPRFLyQ
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
&DStWXOR &DStWXOR &UX]DED OD FDOOH GH $OFDOi D SDVR OLJHUR DSURYHFKDQGR HO VHPiIRUR DELHUWR FXDQGRVLQWLyXQDYR]LQFRQIXQGLEOH ³%HED 0LURDWUiV (QVXVXQWXRVR©0HUFHGHVªLED(UQHVWR(VWDEDDOOtDGRVSDVRVGHWHQLGRDQWHHO VHPiIRUR ³9HQ³OODPypO³9HQ (OODIXH 7HQtDTXHLU(UDQODVGRFHGHOGtD\UHJUHVDEDGHXQDFDVDSXEOLFLWDULDSDUDOD FXDO XQD DPLJD OH GLR XQD WDUMHWD ,ED D WUDEDMDU (PSH]DUOD DO GtD VLJXLHQWH FRPR LQWpUSUHWH HQ GLFKD RILFLQD /H SDJDEDQ XQ VXHOGR HVSOpQGLGR \ VXV SHQXULDV HFRQyPLFDV VL HV TXH LEDQ D H[LVWLU GHELGR D OD ERGD GH VX SDGUH \D QR H[LVWLUtDQ 3HURQRSHQVDEDGHFLUOHQDGDD(UQHVWR 1R FUHtD VX GHEHU GHFtUVHOR 1L GH OD ERGD GH VX SDGUH QL FXiQWR KDEtD FDPELDGRHQHOSDQRUDPDIXWXURGHVXYLGDHQXQGtD 6XV UHODFLRQHV FRQ (UQHVWR QR HUDQ OR TXH VH GLFH XQDV UHODFLRQHV WRWDOPHQWH IRUPDOHV ([LVWtD SRU PHGLR HO DPRU TXH VH SURIHVDED XQR D RWUR SHUR QR H[LVWtD SDODEUDDOJXQDGHFDVDPLHQWR 6HYLVOXPEUDEDpVWHDODUJRSOD]RTXL]i\HOODSRGtDKDFHUGHVXYLGDSULYDGDOR TXH FRQVLGHUDUD FRQYHQLHQWH VLHPSUH TXH JXDUGDUD OD PD\RU PRUDOLGDG < OD PRUDOLGDGHUDVLQyQLPRGH%HED4XLQWDQD\HVRORVDEtDPX\ELHQ,xDTXH5ROGiQ 6HDFRPRGyDVXODGR 6XV GHGRV OD EXVFDURQ \ FRVD H[WUDxD ORV GH %HED QR OH UHKX\HURQ 6H HQUHGDURQHQORVVX\RVFRQV~ELWDDQVLHGDG ³¢4XpWHSDVD"³SUHJXQWypOEDMRDOWLHPSRGHSRQHUHODXWRHQPDUFKDFRQ XQDVRODPDQR ³1DGD«QDGD« ³(VWiVGHXQVHQVLEOHVXELGR ³7H«WHORSDUHFHDWL ³<SDUSDGHDV (OODULy (UD XQD ULVD VXDYH \ WHQXH /D ULVD LQWLPD GH XQD PXFKDFKD WtPLGD TXH WLHQH PXFKDVFRVDVTXHGHFLU\QRVHGHFLGHDGHFLUQLQJXQD ³(VWiVGLVWLQWD ³¢1R«QRWHJXVWR"
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
³%HED ³3HUGRQD ³6L HVWiV FRTXHWHDQGR FRQPLJR 'LPH GLPH ¢DGyQGH LEDV" ¢2 GH GyQGH YHQtDV" ³'H PLVD ³PLQWLy³ 3UHIHUt GDU XQ SDVHR KDVWD FDVD 0H OODPDQ OD DWHQFLyQ ORVHVFDSDUDWHV«,EDFRQWHPSODQGRVXHVSOHQGRU ³9DPRV D WRPDU DOJR SRU DKt ORV GRV 6XSRQJR TXH QR WHQGUiV SULVD GH UHJUHVDUDFDVD ³/DWHQJR3HUR«YR\FRQWLJR ³3HQVDED OODPDUWH SRU WHOpIRQR KR\ D ODV GRV R DVt ¢6DEHV" 7HQJR TXH LU D 9DOHQFLDHVWDWDUGH0LSDGUHUHJUHVyGH0p[LFRLQRSLQDGDPHQWH\PHUHFODPD'LFH TXHVyORPHHQWUHWHQGUiXQGtD&UHRTXHSDVDGRPDxDQDHVWDUpGHUHJUHVR ³£2K ³/RVLHQWRPLYLGD¢6DEHVORTXHHVWXYHSHQVDQGR"4XHQRVFDVHPRV ³¢&yPR" ³(VRHV3RGHPRVKDFHUORSURQWR'HQWURGHXQPHVGHGRV«¢4XpWHSDUHFH" (OODFHUUyORVRMRV ¢3DUHFHUOH"¢6HUtD«VHUtDPDUDYLOORVR" ³&RPRW~GLJDV ³$PLUHJUHVRGH9DOHQFLDWHQJRTXHGHFLUWHDOJR0XFKDVFRVDV ³%XHQR³GLMRVLQLPDJLQDUVHVLTXLHUDORTXHpOLEDDGHFLUOH ³¢9DVDRtUPHFRQLQGXOJHQFLD" /R PLUy ODUJDPHQWH 1R VXSR SRU TXp UD]yQ OLEUy OD PDQR GH ORV GHGRV PDVFXOLQRV\HOODPLVPDLPSHWXRVDPHQWHIHPHQLQDVHFROJyFRQODVGRVPDQRVGH VXEUD]R ³¢&XiQGRQRORIXLSDUDWL"3HUR¢QHFHVLWDVPLLQGXOJHQFLDGHYHUDV" ³/D«ODYR\DQHFHVLWDU ³7RQWR ³3HUR¢TXpWHSDVDKR\QLxD" ³1RVp4XL]iWHQtDQHFHVLGDGGHHQFRQWUDUWH 'H UHSHQWH HO DXWR GLR XQ YLUDMH 7RUFLy D OD L]TXLHUGD 6LJXLy XQD ODUJD FDOOH VDOLyDRWUD\VHSHUGLySRUODFDUUHWHUDGH/D&RUXxD ³¢$GyQGHYDPRV"³SUHJXQWyHOODVRIRFDGD ³1R Vp £4Xp PiV GD 9DPRV D XQ OXJDU GRQGH SRGDPRV HVWDU VRORV GLH] PLQXWRV ³1R³VHDWXUGLy³1R
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
³1RVHDVWRQWLWD0HJXVWDHVWDUVRORFRQWLJR\EHVDUWH\SHQVDUTXHHVWiVDPL ODGR\WHWRFR ³(UQHVWR ³2MDODVHPXHUD ³¢4XpGLFHV" ³1DGD«QDGD«(VWDEDSHQVDQGR«¢4XpSHQVDED\R"£$KVL4XHGHUHSHQWH PLQRPEUHQRPHJXVWD <UHtDDOHJUHPHQWHGHWDOPRGRTXHHOODQRVXSRFRPSUHQGHUORTXHUHDOPHQWH OHRFXUUtD eO DXWR VH GHWXYR GLH] PLQXWRV GHVSXpV HQ XQ ERUGH GH OD FDUUHWHUD ,xDTXH FUX]yORVEUD]RVHQHOYRODQWH ³¢6DEHV"³VXVXUUyDWUD\pQGRODKDFLDVt³9R\DHVWDUVLQYHUWHGRVGtDV0H YDQDUHVXOWDULQVRSRUWDEOHV(VWDEDUDELRVRSRUTXHSUHVHQWtDTXHQRSRGtDYHUWHKR\ \GHV~ELWRDSDUHFLVWHDQWHPtMXQWRDOVHPiIRUR
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
9HVWtD HOHJDQWHPHQWH \ VX H[TXLVLWH] FDXVy OD DGPLUDFLyQ GH %HED \ VX WtD 7DPELpQ HVWDED DOOt )pOL[ 4XLQWDQD DWHQWR HOHJDQWH VLHPSUH HQ VX SDSHO GH WRWDO JUDYHGDG ³0H DOHJUR PXFKR GH FRQRFHURV ³GLMR $OLFLD³ )pOL[ PH KDEOy PXFKR GH YRVRWUDV ³\ GHVSXpV PLUDQGR DWHQWDPHQWH D OD MRYHQ³ 7HPtD TXH QR VXSLHUDV FRPSUHQGHU«HVWR6DEHUQRHVODSDODEUD ³DxDGLyFRQXQDVRQULVD³ TXHUHUGLUp PHMRU 4XH QR TXLVLHUDV FRPSUHQGHU 3HUR HVWDQGR HQDPRUDGD GH XQ KRPEUH \R FRQVLGHUpTXHWXSDGUHQRWHQtDSRUTXpRFXOWDUSRUPiVWLHPSRORTXHRFXUUtD ³$KRUD HVWR\ GREOHPHQWH VDWLVIHFKD $OLFLD ³GLMR VXDYHPHQWH DVLHQGR VXV GHGRV³
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
(QDTXHOLQVWDQWHWtD3HSDVHOHYDQWy\VDOLyGHOVDORQFLWRFRQHOILQGHGLVSRQHU ODPHULHQGD )pOL[4XLQWDQDGLMRVRQULHQWH ³2VGHMRVRODV4XL]iWHQJiLVDOJRTXHKDEODU$VtRVFRQRFHUpLVPHMRU $OLFLDORGHVHDED1HFHVLWDEDVDEHUPXFKDVFRVDVGHODKLMDGHVXIXWXURHVSRVR ³6LpQWDWHMXQWRDPt%HED'HMDODVURVDVHQXQE~FDUR /D MRYHQ OR KL]RDVt TXHGiQGRVH FRQ XQD DOD TXH GLR YXHOWDV \ YXHOWDVHQWUH ORVGHGRV 6HQWDGDMXQWRD$OLFLDODPLUyGHV~ELWRFRQFRPSODFHQFLD ³¢6DEHV" ³H[FODPy VLQFHUD³ 7HQtD PLHGR FRQRFHUWH SHUR DKRUD SUHVLHQWR TXHYDPRVDVHUEXHQDVDPLJDV ³/DDPLVWDGVLQFHUDGDxDDYHFHV%HED¢4XpWHSDUHFHVL\RWHGDxDUDPXFKR HQHVWHLQVWDQWH" ³¢'DxDUPH" ³6L³DGXMR$OLFLD)RQVHFDFRQSHVDU³0XFKR6HUtDLJXDOTXHVLW~PHGLMHUDV DKRUDTXHWXSDGUHHVXQLQGHVHDEOH ³£$OLFLD« ³3HUGRQD6LQRSHQVDUDFDVDUPHPX\SURQWRFRQWXSDGUHQDGDWHGLUtD1R VHUtD \R TXLpQ SDUD LQPLVFXLUPH HQ WX YLGD SULYDGD 3HUR« YR\ D VHU FRPR XQD VHJXQGDPDGUHSDUDWL
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
+DFHFRVDGHXQDxRSDSiUHFRPHQGyD(UQHVWRXQDFKLFDOODPDGD,VDEHO(FKHJDUD\ (UDXQDPXFKDFKLWDWtPLGDRULXQGDGHXQSXHEORGH&DVWLOOD/DDGPLWLyDVXODGR FRPR VXSOHQWH GH VHFUHWDULD \ DO FDER GH XQRV PHVHV RFKR R PiV OD FKLFD GHVDSDUHFLy LQRSLQDGDPHQWH 0L SDGUH FRPR HV OyJLFR OH SUHJXQWy D (UQHVWR
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
&DStWXOR &DStWXOR ³¢4Xp«TXpYHUGDG" ³(UHVXQDFKLFDYDOHURVD%HED$WUDYpVGHORTXHWXSDGUHPHFXHQWDGHWLPH IXLGDQGRFXHQWD0HUHFHVTXHWHDPHXQKRPEUHWDOFRPRFUHHVTXHWHDPD(UQHVWR 5ROGiQ3HUR(UQHVWRHVLQFDSD]GHDPDUDQDGLHH[FHSWRDVtPLVPR
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
(VWDEDPHGLRORFDHVRHUDORTXHHVWDED1RHUDFDSD]GHFDOODU6ROOR]DEDFRPR VL HQ DTXHO LQVWDQWH PXULHUD VX PDGUH < D~Q HUD SHRU 6X PDGUH KDEtD PXHUWR PXFKRVDxRVDQWHV\VXVLOXVLRQHVWRGDVHVWDEDQPXULHQGRHQDTXHOPLVPRLQVWDQWH 6H R\HURQ SDVRV \ HQ VHJXLGD OD ILJXUD GH WtD 3HSD HPSXMDQGR OD PHVD GH UXHGDV $OYHUDVXVREULQDOORUDQGRJULWy ³¢4XpWHSDVDFKLTXLOOD"'L¢TXpWHSDVD" %HEDOLPSLyODVOiJULPDVGHXQPDQRWD]R ³(V«HV«³KLSy³ODHPRFLyQGHVDEHUTXHSDSi«SDSi«YDDFDVDUVH $OLFLD SRU WRGR FRPHQWDULR OD DFHUFy D VX KRPEUR \ OD EHVy HQ HO SHOR FDULxRVDPHQWH 0DWtDVHQJXOOtDVDOLYD\VHDJLWDEDLQTXLHWR 9HtDD(UQHVWRHOYHUGDGHURLUGHXQODGRDRWURGHODDOFREDGLVSRQLHQGRVX URSD'HUHSHQWHVHGHWXYR ³¢4Xp KDFHV DKt SDUDGR" ³JULWy IXULRVR³ ¢1R YHV TXH DFDER GH OOHJDU \ WHQJRPXFKDVFRVDVTXHKDFHU"¢'yQGHHVWiPLJHPHOR"¢4XpKDFHTXHQRYLHQH" ³+DLGRD9DOHQFLDVHxRU ³9D\D %XHQR HV LJXDO 'LVSyQ HO EDxR 9HQJR UHQGLGR GHO YLDMH 1R PH HVSHUDEDLV¢HK" ³3XHV«QRQR³ ³¢4Xp WDO OD VHxRULWD 4XLQWDQD" ³SUHJXQWy EXUOyQ³ ¢6H FRQVROy" ¢5HJUHVy \DGHOYLDMH"¢<SRUTXpPHSXVLVWHDTXHOFDEOHYDPRVDYHU" ³3RUVL«SRUVLHOVHxRUOHHVFULEtD ³
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
³9DPRVYDPRV¢TXpHVSHUDV" ³(OEDxRVHxRU ³'LVSRQOR\OXHJROODPDDPLQRYLD 0DWtDVKL]RXQDSUHJXQWDXQSRFRLPSHUWLQHQWHDMXLFLRGH(UQHVWR ³¢/DDPDPXFKRHOVHxRU" (UQHVWRJLUyHQUHGRQGR ³¢4XpGLFHV"3HUR¢FyPRWHDWUHYHV"¢4XLpQHUHVW~SDUD«"³VHHFKyDUHtUGH V~ELWR³6tODDPRPXFKR'HERDPDUODSRUTXHODUHFRUGyEDVWDQWH ³£$K ³¢7LHQHVDOJXQDREMHFLyQTXHKDFHU" ³3XHV« QR QR VHxRU ³VROWy ORV JULIRV³ 1R FODUR 3HUR FRPR DQWHV GH PDUFKDUHOVHxRUOHRtGHFLUTXHODVHxRULWD4XLQWDQDHUDXQHQWUHWHQLPLHQWR« ³<VLJXHVLpQGROR3HUR«¢TXp"¢3DUDTXpYLYHXQR" ³(VRGLJR\RVHxRU ³¢4XpHVORTXHGLFHV" ³3XHV«³WHPSOyHODJXD/DSHUIXPy³QDGDVHxRU1XQFDGLJRQDGD ³0HMRUSDUDWL ³(OEDxRHVWiGLVSXHVWRVHxRU ³3UHSiUDPHHOWUDMHJULVFODUR¢/OXHYH"1RSHURKDFHIUtR<HOJDEiQD]XO\HO VRPEUHUR GHO PLVPR FRORU ³VH SHUGtD \D HQ HO EDxR³ $QGD \ QR WH ROYLGHV GH OODPDUSRUWHOpIRQRD%HED4XLQWDQD/HGLFHVTXHDODVVLHWHLUpDEXVFDUOD ³6tVHxRU ³£+DODDQGDOLJHUR(VWiVSDVPDGRKR\¢4XpGLDEORVWHSDVD" 3HURVLQHVSHUDUUHVSXHVWDVHFHUUyHQHOEDxR (OSREUH0DWtDVOOHYyORVGHGRVDOFDEHOOR/RVUHYROYLyDOOt\DVSLUyPX\KRQGR ¢4XpKDFHU" ¢/ODPDUDOJHPHORD9DOHQFLD"1RKDEUtDOOHJDGRD~Q¢'HFLUOH«" ©6R\XQFULDGR<ORVR\GHORVGRV³VHGLMRSDUDVL&XLGDGR0DWtDV1RPHWDVODSDWD 7~DORWX\RDKDFHUORTXHWHPDQGDQ\DVHUVRUGR\PXGR\FLHJR4XHVHODVDUUHJOHQ HOORVª &RPR VL OH SHVDVHQ ORV SLHV VH DFHUFy DO WHOpIRQR )XH D PDUFDU SHUR HO GHGR HPSH]yDWHPEODUOH ©¢4XpWHLPSRUWDDWLWRGRHVWHOtR0DWtDV"7~QRHUHVPiVTXHXQFULDGR\VLWHPHWHV GRQGH QR WH OODPDQ YDVD SHUGHU HO HPSOHR \ QRWH FRQYLHQH $TXt IXPDV D HVFRQGLGDV SHUR IXPDVEXHQRVKDEDQRV EHEHVZKLVN\HVFRFpV\KDVWDDOJXQDYH]FRTXHWHDVFRQODFKLFDGHDO ODGRODGRQFHOOLWDGHORV0XQWDQHU<DGHPiVVDFDVWXVEXHQDVSHVHWLWDVDOFDERGHOPHV$ WHQHUFXLGDGR0DWtDV+D\TXHVHUSUXGHQWHª
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
0DUFyHOQ~PHURSHURDQWHVGHTXHVRQDUDORVROWy ©0DWtDV HO TXH W~ WHQJDV VLPSDWtD SRU ,xDTXH QR TXLHUH GHFLU TXH GHEDV PHWHUWH HQ FDPLVDGHRQFHYDUDV¢(VWDPRV"¢(VWDPRV0DWtDV"ª 9ROYLyDPDUFDU /HWHPEODEDXQSRFRODPDQRSHURHVWDYH]HVSHUy &RQWHVWyXQDYR]JDQJRVD ©7tD3HSD³SHQVy³/DVLPSiWLFDWtD3HSDª ³'LJD'LJD 6LOHQFLR ³'LJD 0DWtDVFDUUDVSHy ³¢/DVHxRULWD4XLQWDQD" ³1RHVWiSDUDQDGLH³UHSOLFyHQRMDGDODYR]GHWtD3HSDGLIHUHQWH6tVHxRU GLIHUHQWH eOYROYLyDFDUUDVSHDU ³(VDTXtGHFDVDGHOVHxRU5ROGiQ$ODVVLHWHLUiDEXVFDUDODVHxRULWD%HED ³¢&yPR"¢1RHVWDEDGHYLDMHHOVHxRU5ROGiQ" ³3HURKDYXHOWR³GLMR<QRPHQWtD³,UiDEXVFDUDODVHxRULWDDODVVLHWHHQ SXQWR <FROJy $OYROYHUVHVHPLUyDVtPLVPR ©(UHVWDQFRFKLQRFRPRHOJHPHOR(UQHVWR0DWtDV7DQFRFKLQRVtª
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
&DStWXOR &DStWXOR ³0H DVXVWD HVWD H[SUHVLyQWX\D %HED ³VHDJLWy OD GDPD³ /D YHUGDGKLMLWD PHGDVPXFKRPLHGR %HEDVHQWDGDDQWHHOERUGHGHOOHFKRPLUDEDDQWHVLVLQSDUSDGHDU 7HQtDORVGHGRVDSR\DGRVHQODVURGLOODV\ODEDUELOODHQODVGRVSDOPDVDELHUWDV \XQLGDVFDVLMXQWRDODERFD ³%HED«VLOORUDV 1R1RLEDDOORUDU ¢3RGtDOORUDUXQDSHUVRQDPXHUWD" $VtHVWDEDHOODFRPRPXHUWDFRPRVLQROHLPSRUWDUDQDGDGHHVWHPXQGR ³+LMLWDQRVpVL$OLFLDKL]RELHQHQGHFLUWH ³+L]R³VDOWR³+L]RVt ³8QKRPEUHSXHGHVHUPX\UXLQGXUDQWHDxRV\GHUHSHQWH«HODPRUGHXQD PXMHUGHWHUPLQDGDKDFHUOHEXHQR %HEDDO]yHOURVWUR8QSRFRWDQVyOR/RVXILFLHQWHSDUDTXHWtD3HSDDSUHFLDUD HOGRORUGHVJDUUDGRGHVXVRMRV ³7H OR KH FRQWDGR WRGR WtD 7RGR VLQ RPLWLU QDGD 6L WLHQH XQ KLMR VL QR KD WHQLGR MDPiV HVFU~SXORV FRQ ODV PXMHUHV VL KD KHFKR DODUGH GH XQD GLJQLGDG PDVFXOLQD TXH QXQFD H[LVWLy ¢FyPR SUHWHQGHV TXH PL DPRU OH KD\D FDPELDGR" 1XQFDSRGUtDFDVDUPHFRQXQKRPEUHTXHKDSHUGLGRDXQDPXMHU1LVHULDFDSD]GH FUHHUHQTXLHQHQJDxyDWDQWDVFKLTXLOODVLQRFHQWHV ³3HUR«HVWiVGLVSXHVWDDUHFLELUORDODVVLHWH\IDOODVyORXQDKRUD ³6t ³GLMR³ 6t /R YR\ D UHFLELU (V GHFLU YR\ D VDOLU FRQ pO /R TXH QR PH H[SOLFRD~QHV«FyPRKDYXHOWRFXDQGRQRKDFHQLGRVKRUDVPHHQYLyXQUDPRGH IORUHVSRUVXYLDMHKDFLD9DOHQFLD ³6HOHKDEUiROYLGDGRDOJR\QRVDOGUiKDVWDPDxDQD ³£4XpPiVGD ³¢4XpOHYDVDGHFLU" ³¢'HFLU"¢6HVDEH HVR"¢6HSUHYp QXQFD ORTXHVHSXHGH GHFLU DXQKRPEUH D TXLHQVHKDTXHULGRWDQWR\DTXLHQVHGHVSUHFLDLQGHVFULSWLEOHPHQWH" ³3HURW~«W~«KLMLWDPtDHVWiVGHVWUR]DGD /D MRYHQ EDMy OD FDEH]D 0LUy DO IUHQWH /D DOIRPEUD PXOWLFRORU SDUHFLROH TXH EDLODEDDQWHVXVRMRV ¢4XpLEDDGHFLUOHD(UQHVWR"¢7RGRFXDQWRVDEtDSRU$OLFLD)RQVHFD"1R6HUtD KXPLOODQWHSDUDHOOD6HUtDGHVWUXLUODSRFDGLJQLGDGTXHOHTXHGDED 2FXOWyHOURVWURHQWUHODVPDQRV
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
³%HED³VXVXUUyWtD3HSDFD\HQGRGHEUXFHVMXQWRDHOOD\WUDWDQGRGHTXLWDUOH ODV PDQRV GHO URVWUR³ (VF~FKDPH KLMLWD 3RU IDYRU« HVF~FKDPH ¢4XLHUHV TXH WH FXHQWHXQSDVDMHGHPLYLGD"4XL]iQRWHQJDGHPDVLDGDVLPLOLWXGFRQHOWX\RSHURWH KDUi SHQVDU XQ SRFR +D\ PRPHQWRV HQ OD YLGD HQ TXH XQD VH FUHH PRULU (Q TXH SDUHFHTXHHOPXQGRVHGHUUXPEDVREUHXQD\ODGHVWUX\H&XDQGRVHPXHUHXQVHU TXHULGRVLHQWHVODVHQVDFLyQGHTXHODYLGD\DQRWLHQHLPSRUWDQFLDSDUDWL'XUDQWH XQD HQIHUPHGDG JUDYR GH XQ SDGUH XQD PDGUH XQ KHUPDQR DOJXQR GH HVRV VHUHV TXH WDQ KRQGR FDODQ HQ HO FRUD]yQ KXPDQR GH XQ IDPLOLDU R DOOHJDGR XQD VH FUHH WDPELpQ HQIHUPD \ OH SDUHFH TXH QR H[LVWH PD\RU GRORU QL PD\RU GHVHVSHUDFLyQ < GHVSXpVDPHGLGDTXHSDVDHOWLHPSRODVSHQDVVHDOLYLDQ\XQDYDSHQVDQGRTXHQR VH YD D PRULU \ YLYH SXUJDQGR \ OORUDQGR /DV OiJULPDV WDPELpQ VH GHVYDQHFHQ XQ GtD/OHJDXQWLHPSRHQTXHHQYH]GHGHUUDPDUGRFHVyORVHGHUUDPDXQD\GHVSXpV VLHQWHVHQWLDTXHOUHFXHUGRGRORURVRFRPRDOJRTXHWHKL]RPXFKRGDxRSHURTXH QR WH PDWy« < SDUHFH LPSRVLEOH TXH VH KD\D HVWDGR PHGLR PXHUWD R XQD KD\D TXHULGRGRUPLUWRWDOPHQWH(VDVVRQODVSHQDV3HQDVTXHSDVDQ%HEDTXHULGD³KL]R XQDSDXVD³%HEDKLMLWD«¢TXLHUHVTXHWHFXHQWH«HVHSDVDMHGHPLYLGD"¢4XLHUHV %HED" ³&XHQWD³VXVXUUyODMRYHQFRQXQKLORGHYR]³&XHQWDWtD1XQFDVXSHSRU TXpWHTXHGDVWHVROWHUD ³3RUTXHPHGLRDVFRGHODYLGD\GHORVKRPEUHV3RUTXHYLVXVPHQWLUDV\VXV IDOVHGDGHV 3RUTXH DSUHFLp HO HJRtVPR KXPDQR \ PH UHVXOWy LQGHVFULSWLEOHPHQWH PH]TXLQR¢6DEHV"+XERXQWLHPSRHQTXH\RHVWDEDDSXQWRGHFDVDUPH7HQJRXQ ED~OHQHOFXDUWRGHORVWUDVWRVFRQPLHTXLSR0LVViEDQDVGHKLORPLVPDQWHOHUtDV PLV HQFDMHV« 3DxLWRV SDUD ODV EDQGHMDV SDxLWRV SDUD OD FRFLQD« 7RGR VH KDFH FRQ XQD LOXVLyQ LQHQDUUDEOH /RV GHGRV WLHPEODQ \ VXHxDV FRQ OD ODERU HQ OD PDQR 3LHQVDVHQORVKLMRVTXHKDVGHWHQHUDOJ~QGtDHQFXDQGROHQD]FDHOSULPHUGLHQWH FXDQGR Gp ORV SULPHURV SDVRV FXDQGR EDOEXFHH WX QRPEUH (Q OD VDWLVIDFFLyQ GHO SDGUH FXDQGR OH OODPH ©SDSiª (Q WX DPRU KDFLD ORV GRV (Q ODV FiOLGDV QRFKHV GH YHUDQRMXQWRDODSHUVRQDDPDGDTXHWHKDUiSHQVDUHQOLQGRVSRHPDV(QODVIUtDV QRFKHVGHLQYLHUQRUHIXJLDQGRWXLQTXLHWXGHVDTXHODVQRFKHVFUXGDVGHOLQYLHUQR RFDVLRQDHQORVEUD]RVTXHULGRV(QRtUVXYR]VXDYHHQVXVEHVRVHQVXVFDULFLDV ³7tD« ³
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
1RHUDVXHVSRVD1RSRGtDGHMDUDPLKHUPDQRVRORFRQXQDQLxD\FRQXQEiUEDUR GRORUSRUTXHPLQRYLRIXHUDXQHJRtVWD ³4XL]iGHELVWHTXHGDUWH ³1R%HED9LQHD0DGULG(UDPLGHEHUGHFULVWLDQD\PLGHEHUILOLDO(UDPL KHUPDQR\PLVREULQDTXLHQHVPHQHFHVLWDEDQ\PLQRYLRGHKDEHUPHDPDGRDVtOR KXELHUDFRPSUHQGLGR$ORVWUHVPHVHVUHJUHVp,EDDFDVDUPHRDOPHQRVDVtORFUHt \R
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
1DGLH DO YHU OD ILJXULWD GHOLFDGD HQYXHOWD HQ XQ DEULJR GH DQWH D]XO PDULQR EDMR HO FXDO VH DSUHFLDEDXQVXpWHU GH ILQD ODQDD]XOFHOHVWHFRQ ORV URML]RV FDEHOORV SHLQDGRVKDFLDDUULEDIRUPDQGRXQPRxRFDO]DGDFRQ]DSDWRVGHDOWRVWDFRQHV\XQ EROVR KDFLHQGR MXHJR VHUHQD \ ERQLWD KXELHUD LPDJLQDGR TXH HQ OD KRQGXUD GH DTXHOORV RMRV DSDUHQWHPHQWH WUDQTXLORV VH RFXOWDED HO PD\RU GRORU TXH SXHGH VRSRUWDUXQFRUD]yQKXPDQRIHPHQLQR $VtDSDUHFLyHQODFDOOH\DVtVHUHQDPHQWHVHGLULJLyDODXWRTXHODHVSHUDED 1R HUD HO ©0HUFHGHVª GH WRGRV ORV GtDV (UD XQ ©-DJXDUª ~OWLPR PRGHOR EULOODQWH\DFKDURODGRGHOtQHDDHURGLQiPLFD6HILMyHQDTXHOGHWDOOHSHURQROHGLR PD\RU LPSRUWDQFLD SRUTXH VDEtD TXH (UQHVWR 5ROGiQ SRVHtD XQD JUDQ IRUWXQD \ SRGtDFDPELDUGHDXWRFRPRHOODGHDEULJR (UQHVWR OD HVSHUDED GH SLH MXQWR DO DXWR $O YHUOD DYDQ]y KDFLD HOOD
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
6XELy DO DXWR \ VH DFRPRGy GHQWUR 6LQ XQ VXVSLUR VLQ XQD TXHMD VLQ XQ UHSURFKH (UQHVWR WUDQTXLODPHQWH SHQVDQGR HVR VL TXH HVWDED PiV JXDSD TXH QXQFDGLRODYXHOWDDODOWR\VHVHQWyDQWHHOYRODQWH ³¢$GyQGH"³SUHJXQWyFRQVXDPDELOLGDGGHVLHPSUHEDMRODFXDOVHRFXOWDED VXVDGLVPR ³8QSDVHR ³7HHQFXHQWURDSiWLFD ³+HSHQVDGR7XYHWLHPSRGHKDFHUOR ³%XHQR³ULy(UQHVWRSRQLHQGRHODXWRHQPDUFKD³
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
³+HWHQLGRWLHPSRSDUDSHQVDU(UQHVWR ³¢6t"¢6REUHTXp" ³6REUHQRVRWURVGRV ³¢6L" ³9DPRVDGHMDUOR¢VDEHV"
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
³6tVt«(VWiHQXQSXHEORGH&DVWLOOD(VMRYHQ\ERQLWD\WLHQH«HVR ³£'LRV ³'pMDPHDTXt³SLGLyHOODFRPRVLQRWXYLHUDQDGDPiVTXHGHFLU (UQHVWROHSDVyXQEUD]RSRUGHODQWH\PDQWXYRODSRUWH]XHODVXMHWD ³$JXDUGD«³VXURVWUROtYLGRTXHGyIUHQWHD%HED8QURVWURUtJLGRGLVWLQWR WRWDOPHQWHWUDQVILJXUDGR³¢4XLpQ«TXLpQWHORGLMR" ³3DSiVHYDDFDVDUFRQ$OLFLD)RQVHFD« ³/DKLMDGH« ³6t ³<KDVVDOLGRVyORSDUDGHFLUPH«HVR ³6tVyORSDUDHVR$KRUDGpMDPHSDVDU6LWLHQHVFRUD]yQ«YHDFXPSOLUFRQ WXGHEHU ³8Q«KLMR« ³6LWX\R\GHWXVFDODYHUDGDVGHWXVGHVFRQVLGHUDFLRQHVGHWXVYLOH]DV ³0HGHVSUHFLDVPXFKR³GLMRpOEDMRFRQLQWHQVLGDG ³&XPSOHFRQWXGHEHU4XL]iGHVSXpV«WHGHVSUHFLHPHQRV <EDMyVLQHVSHUDUUHVSXHVWD $OGtDVLJXLHQWH%HED4XLQWDQDHPSH]yDWUDEDMDUHQODFDVDSXEOLFLWDULD
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
&DStWXOR &DStWXOR ³1R«QR«1RHVSRVLEOHTXHHVHHVW~SLGRKD\DOOHJDGR\KD\DFLWDGRD%HED GRVKRUDVGHVSXpVGHOOHJDU ³/RVLHQWRVHxRU+DVLGRDVt ³¢< W~" ¢4Xp KLFLVWH W~ PDOGLWR HVW~SLGR" ¢3RU TXp QR OR KDV LPSHGLGR"
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
³3HURHO(UQHVWRTXHHOODDPDQRHV(UQHVWR ³¢<VLQRORKDGHVFXELHUWR"¢<VLPLJHPHOROOHJyDOOt\ODDEUD]y\«"¢<VL³" (QDTXHOLQVWDQWHVRQyHOWHOpIRQR ³3tOODOR 0DWtDV ³JULWy GHVHVSHUDGR³ 6t HV %HED GLOH« GLOH TXH HVWR\ PXULHQGR'LOH« 0DWtDV\DWHQtDHOWHOpIRQRHQODPDQR ³'LJD ³SHGtD FRQ VX YR] VHUHQD VLHPSUH LQDOWHUDEOH DXQTXH HVWXYLHUD SHOHiQGRVHODJHQWHHQWRUQRDpO ³(VSDUDXVWHGVHxRU ³¢4XLpQ"¢4XLpQ" ³(OVHxRUJHPHOR ³£2K < FRPR XQ ORFR VH ODQ]y DO WHOpIRQR $VLy HO UHFHSWRU FRQ ODV GRV PDQRV \ GHVSXpVJULWy ³'LPHGLPH« ³¢4XpWHSDVD,xDTXH"(VWiVKHFKRSROYR ³(VWR\PXHUWR ³¢&yPR" ³1DGD 'LPH GyQGH HVWiV 6p TXH KDV OOHJDGR KDFH GRV GtDV SHUR VHJ~Q 0DWtDVGHVDSDUHFLVWHLQPHGLDWDPHQWH ³$FDERGHFDVDUPH ,xDTXH VHSDUy HO DSDUDWR GHO RtGR SDUD YROYHU D DFHUFDUOR FRQ OD PLVPD SURQWLWXG ³¢&yPR"¢4Xp"£0DOGLWDVHD¢4Xp" ³3HURJHPHORTXpGLDEORWHSDVD$FDERGHFDVDUPH)XLDYHUD%HED ³1RPHGLJDVTXHWHFDVDVWHFRQHOOD ³&ODUR TXH QR /D YL D ODV GRV KRUDV GH OOHJDU D 0DGULG 0H GLMR TXH QR PH DPDED ³£2K ³4XHWXYRWLHPSRGHUHIOH[LRQDU4XHQRPHTXHUtDQLXQDPLJDMD ³£$K£2K ¢1R OH KDEtD GLFKR TXH pO HVWXYR VXSODQWiQGROR" 1R FODUR (UD PXFKD %HED SHURSDUDpO«FDVLHUDSHRUSRUTXHVLQGXGDHVWDUtDRGLiQGROH3RUTXHVtQROHFDEtD ODPHQRUGXGDGHTXH%HEDHVWDEDDOFRUULHQWHGHWRGDDTXHOODVXSHUFKHUtD ³+HYHQLGRDFDVDUPHFRQ,VDEHO(FKHJDUD\2\H,xDTXH¢HVWiVDKt"¢7HKDV TXHGDGRPXGR"
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
0DWtDVWHQtDHORtGRDSOLFDGRDODXULFXODUFHUFDGHOGHVXDPR,xDTXHOHGLRXQ HPSHOOyQ ³$WUHYLGR³JULWy³$WUHYLGR ³¢4XpGLFHV,xDTXH"³JULWy(UQHVWRDORWURODGR ³£2KQDGD0HUHIHUtDD0DWtDV ³3XHV FRPR WH GHFtD DFDER GH FDVDUPH (VWR\ HQ XQ KRWHO GHO (VFRULDO 0H ODUJRGHYLDMH2\HFXDQGRSXHGDVYHSRU3RQIHUUDGD\KD]WHFDUJRGHPLKLMR ³¢4Xp" ³6HOODPDFRPR\R\WLHQHPLPLVPDDUURJDQFLD\ORVRMRVOXPLQRVRVGH,VDEHO ³(UQHVWR ³FKLOOy ,xDTXH³ 4XH QR WH HQWLHQGR QL SDSD ¢$ TXp KLMR WH UHILHUHV"¢7HKDVYXHOWRORFR" ³&ODURTXHQR'HUHSHQWHFRPSUHQGtTXHDTXtHVWLEDPLIHOLFLGDG+D]ORTXH WHSLGR£$K\\DSXHGHVLUGHVDORMDQGRHOSLVR1RTXLHURKHUPDQRVFRQPLJR ³¢&yPR" ³(VR&ROJy 0DWtDVTXHYROYtDDHVWDUMXQWRDVXDPRFRQHORtGRDSOLFDGRDODXULFXODUGLR XQSDVRDWUiVDWXUGLGR ³(UHVXQDVQR0DWtDV ³6tVHxRU ³<XQHQWURPHWLGR ³6LVHxRU ³¢(QWLHQGHVDOJRGHHVR" ³1RVKHPRVFDVDGRVHxRU\SRUORYLVWR\DQDFLyXQEHEp ³0DWtDV« \R QR VR\ FDSD] GH FRPSUHQGHU QDGD SHUR GHER VHU PX\ HJRtVWD SRUTXHQRSXHGRDVLPLODUWRGDVHVDVQRWLFLDV7HQJREDVWDQWHFRQORPtR¢6DEHVXQD FRVD 0DWtDV" 3RU QDGD GHO PXQGR SHUGHUp D %HED 6L QR VH FDVD FRQPLJR SRU ODV EXHQDV«£3RU'LRVTXHODUDSWR ³$HOORVHxRU ³¢4XpGLFHV" ³4XHEXHQR (QDTXHOLQVWDQWHVRQyHOWLPEUHGHODSXHUWD ³/ODPDQVHxRU ³1RDEUDV ³(VTXHOODPDQ ³7HGLJRTXHQRHVWR\SDUDQDGLH ³¢6HORGLJRDVtDTXLHQVHD"
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
³'tVHORHQHOLGLRPDTXHWHGpODJDQDDWUDYHVDQGRODHVWDQFLDVHSHUGLyHQVX FXDUWRGDQGRXQIRUPLGDEOHSRUWD]R
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
&DStWXOR &DStWXOR %HED 4XLQWDQD HVWDED PX\ QHUYLRVD SHUR QDGLH OR GLUtD DO YHUOD \ PXFKR PHQRV0DWtDVTXHFRQH[SUHVLyQGHERERODFRQWHPSODEDHQDTXHOLQVWDQWH ³%XHQDV WDUGHV ³GLMR HOOD FRQ YR] TXH D 0DWtDV OHSDUHFLy HO FDVFDEHO GH XQ DQKHOR ©0DWtDV VH GLMR VLQ DEULU ORV ODELRV³ 1R KDV YLVWR D %HED 4XLQWDQD SHUR DSXHVWR HO SXUR TXH WHQJR SDUD IXPDU HVWD QRFKH GH VREUHPHVD D TXH HV pVWD &XLGDGR 0DWtDV QR UHVEDOHV7~QRVDEHVQDGDGHQDGD(UHVWRQWRGHQDFLPLHQWRª $PDEOHPHQWHDEULyODSXHUWDGHSDUHQSDU ³4XLHUHSDVDUODVHxRULWD" ³'HVHRYHUD,xDTXH5ROGiQ³GLMRODPRQGDGDYHVWLGDGHD]XOTXHVHKDOODED GHSLHHQHOXPEUDO ³6tVHxRULWD¢4XLHUHSDVDU" %HEDWLWXEHySHURSDVyDOILQ 6DOtD GH OD RILFLQD SXEOLFLWDULD HQ DTXHO LQVWDQWH 1R SRGtD SDVDU VLQ GHFLUOH D ,xDTXHWRGRFXDQWRSHQVDEDGHpO\VXYLOH]D\VL(UQHVWRHVWDEDSUHVHQWH«ORRLUtD WDPELpQ 0DWtDVDMHQRDVXVSHQVDPLHQWRVSHURLQWX\pQGRORVGLMRDORLGLRWD ³(OVHxRUHVWiPX\FRQPRYLGR)LJ~UHVHXVWHGTXHVHKDFDVDGRGRQ(UQHVWR ³£&D«VD«GR³GHOHWUHy³¢&DVDGR" ³6t ³DGPLWLy 0DWtDV HQ VX SDSHO GH HVW~SLGR GH KRPEUH QR HQWHUDGR GH QDGD³6HQRVKDFDVDGR$FDEDPRVGHVDEHUOR<ILJ~UHVHXVWHGTXH\DWLHQHKLMR ³1RPHGLJDTXHVHKDFDVDGRFRQ,VDEHO(FKHJDUD\ (QDOWDYR]PXUPXUyFRQODPLVPDVLPSOLFLGDG ³¢&RQRFHXVWHGDODHVSRVDGHOVHxRU" ©(VWHFULDGRHVLGLRWDªSHQVy%HED ³1R3HURRtKDEODUGHHOOD ³(VPX\OLQGD ³£
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
(QDOWDYR]PXUPXUyVHUYLOPHQWH ³/DDQXQFLDUp <VDOLyLUJXLHQGRDUURJDQWHPHQWHODFDEH]D $WUDYHVyHOSDVLOOROODPyDXQDSXHUWD\XQDYR]URQFDJULWy ³4XHWHSDUWDXQUD\R0DWtDV'pMDPHHQSD] 0DWtDV PX\ PDO HGXFDGR SRU FLHUWR HPSXMR OD SXHUWD \ FHUUy WUDV GH Vt 6H TXHGySODQWDGRHQPLWDGGH£DHVWDQFLD ,xDTXHHVWDEDWHQGLGRHQHOOHFKRYXHOWRKDFLDODSDUHGFRQ]DSDWRV\WRGR 0DWtDVSHQVy ©(VWiSRQLHQGRSHUGLGDODVREUHFDPDª ³6HxRU« ³7HGLJRTXHPHGHMHVHQSD]0DWtDV¢1RPHKDVRtGR"1RHVWR\SDUDQDGLH 7HQJRTXHSHQVDU¢0HR\HV"3HQVDUHVRHV ³6tVHxRU ³3XHVOiUJDWH ³(VTXHHQHOOLYLQJKD\XQDPXMHUMRYHQ ³0iWDOD ³6HxRU ³4XHODPDWHV0DWtDV ³0HGDPXFKDSHQDVHxRU£(VWDQERQLWD ³eFKDODIXHUD ³(VTXHVHWUDWDGH%HED4XLQWDQDVHxRU ³&RPRVLVHWUDWDUDGH«¢4Xp"³\GHOVDOWRTXHGyVHQWDGRHQHOOHFKR ³/DVREUHFDPDVHxRU ³¢4Xp" ¢&yPR" ¢4Xp VREUHFDPD" £2K ³PLUy VXV SLHV³ (UHV XQ DQLPDO 0DWtDV 8Q PDOGLWR DQLPDO PHQFLRQDQGR OD VREUHFDPD ³\D HVWDED GH SLH HQ HO VXHOR³FXDQGRXQDPXMHUOODPDGD%HED4XLQWDQDHVWiDKtDGRVSDVRV³DSDUWyDO FULDGRVDOLHQGRFRPRXQORFR
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
³£0DWtDV ³3HUGRQHHOVHxRU6HORGLMHSDUDDOODQDUOHDXVWHGHOFDPLQR ³¢4XpFDPLQR" ³(OGHODH[SOLFDFLyQVHxRU ³(UHVXQHQWURPHWLGR 3HURQRHVSHUyPiV 6DOLyFRUULHQGR$OOOHJDUDOILQDOGHOSDVLOORIUHQyVXPDUFKD ©&DOPD ,xDTXH 0XFKD FDOPD (OOD QR YLHQH DTXt QR VH DUULHVJD D YHQLU DTXt XQD PXMHUFRPRHOODDHFKDUVHHQWXVEUD]RV0pWHWHHVWRHQODFDEH]D,xDTXH(OODYLHQHDTXtD HVFXSLUWHHQODFDUD$HVRHVDORTXHYLHQH8QSRFRGHFDOPD,xDTXH1RWHGHMHVDUUHEDWDU SRUODSDVLyQ«ª < PiV VHUHQR SHUR QR WDQWR FRPR pO SUHWHQGtD HPSXMy OD SXHUWD \ VH TXHGy SODQWDGRDQWHODILJXULWDYHVWLGDFRQXQDEULJRD]XOPDULQRGHDQWH 8QVLOHQFLR /DUJRHPEDUD]RVRSDUDpO3HQRVtVLPRSDUD%HED ³'LUiV³PXUPXUyWRGRORVHUHQDTXHSXGR\%HED4XLQWDQDSRGtDPXFKR³ TXHVR\XQDWRQWDYLQLHQGRDWXDSDUWDPHQWR ³1RORGLJR ³7HQtDTXHYHQLU3UHIHUtKDFHUOR\RDTXHIXHUDVW~DHVSHUDUPHDODSXHUWDGH PLFDVDDODVVLHWHGHODWDUGH ³$QWHVWHKXELHUDOODPDGRSRUWHOpIRQR ³¢3DUDTXp"&RQODSUHVHQFLDGH(UQHVWRDQWHD\HUHQPLSXHUWDWHQJRPiVTXH VXILFLHQWH 1R HV SUHFLVR TXH PH GHV H[SOLFDFLRQHV 1R YR\ D DGPLWLUODV 6yOR KH YHQLGRDGHFLUWH« ³3RUIDYRUGpMDPHTXHWHH[SOLTXH ³(VRQR
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
³
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
TXHUHUDVtFRPRWHKHTXHULGRDWL,xDTXH¢/RPLyFRQ(UQHVWR"1R$TXHOORIXHXQ FRPLHQ]RVLQVHQWLGR1RHUD\RFDSD]GHHQDPRUDUPHGHWXKHUPDQR1RVXSHSRU TXpKDVWDTXHHORWURGtDORYLDQWHPt\FRPSUHQGtTXHQRHUDVW~(QWRQFHVPHGL FXHQWD GH TXH VLHPSUH WH TXLVH D WL (PSH]y WRGR DTXHOOD YH] HQ FDVD GH ORV 0RQWHQHJUR 4XL]i SDUD WL VyOR VHD XQ SDVDMH VLQ LPSRUWDQFLD 3DUD Pt IXH HO FRPLHQ]RGHWRGR« ³%HEDDPRUPtRHVF~FKDPH ³1R+HYHQLGRGHFLUWHHVWR1RSRGtDSDVDUVLQGHFtUWHOR3RUTXHGHORVGRV WHSUHIHUtDWLVLHPSUHVLQVDEHUORLQFOXVR<\DYHVGHORTXHPHVLUYLy7HGLWRGDPL YLGD&UHtHQWLFRPRHQPLPLVPD$KRUD\D«DXQTXHPHHPSHxDUDQRVHULDFDSD] GHYROYHUDFUHHU ³$JXDUGD QR WH YD\DV (VF~FKDPH 'DPH RSFLyQ D XQD H[SOLFDFLyQ 7HQJR GHUHFKR D HOOR 5HFXHUGD TXH« HO GtD TXH PH IXL D 9DOHQFLD WH DGYHUWt TXH D PL UHJUHVRWHGLUtDDOJR\WHSHGtLQGXOJHQFLDSDUDHVFXFKDUPH ³+XELHUDVLGRHOPRPHQWR,xDTXH³GLMRHOOD\DGHVGHHOXPEUDO³$KRUDHV GHPDVLDGRWDUGH 6DOLy ,xDTXH FRPR HQORTXHFLGR IXH WUDV HOOD 7UDWy GH DOFDQ]DUOD 0DWtDV HVWDED GHWUiVGHXQDFRUWLQDFRQWHQLHQGRODUHVSLUDFLyQ ³%HED%HEDHVF~FKDPH3RU'LRVHVF~FKDPH'pMDPHTXHWHH[SOLTXH« ³$GLyV³GLMRHOODDKRJDGDPHQWHDEULHQGRODSXHUWDGHOSLVR³$GLyV« <DQWHVGHTXH,xDTXHSXGLHUDLPSHGLUORVHSHUGLyHQHODVFHQVRU 0DWtDVVDOLyGHWUDVODFRUWLQD ³1RHVSRVLEOHFRQYHQFHUODSRUDKRUDVHxRU1RQRVFUHH ,xDTXH JLUy VREUH Vt GLR XQ PDQRWD]R HQ HO DLUH \ SRU SULPHUD YH] QR OH PROHVWyHOSOXUDOGHVXFULDGR ³1R0DWtDV³GLMRGDQGRXQWUDVSLpV³1RQRQRVFUHH«
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
&DStWXOR &DStWXOR 'XUDQWHXQPHVDQGXYRFRPRXQORFRGHXQODGRDRWUREXVFiQGROD/DHVSHUy D OD VDOLGD GHO WUDEDMR FXDQGR VXSR TXH WUDEDMDED (OOD QR TXLVR QL YHUOR QL HVFXFKDUORQLGDUXQSDVRDVXODGR 9LVLWy D WtD 3HSD HQ VX DXVHQFLD &DVL OORUy D VX ODGR SHUR WtD 3HSD VyOR SXGR GHFLUOH ³1R GHSHQGH GH PL PXFKDFKR 6p TXH HUHV VLQFHUR SHUR« QR VR\ \R TXLHQ WLHQHTXHFUHHUORDVt(VHOOD ³6LQRTXLHUHHVFXFKDUPH ³
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
(OPDULGRODPLUyFRQWHUQXUD ³7RGDVODVPXMHUHVFXDQGRDPDQVRQSDUHFLGDV$OLFLD1RHVPLKLMDGLVWLQWD WHORDVHJXUR(VWiGROLGDHVRVt SHURQRKDGHMDGRGHDPDUD,xDTXH1RHVGHODV TXHFDPELDQGHVHQWLPLHQWRVVHJ~QHOWLHPSR\HOSDQRUDPD (Q DTXHO LQVWDQWH D OR OHMRV VHR\y XQ WLPEUD]R 6HJXLGDPHQWHXQDSXHUWD DO DEULUVH\GHVSXpVXQVXDYHWDFRQHRGHPXMHU ³(V HOOD ³PXUPXUy $OLFLD DODUPDGD³ 6H FRQRFH TXH DO VDOLU GH OD RILFLQD UHFRUGyTXHKDFHGRVGtDVTXHQRYLHQHSRUDTXt ³¢4XpKDJR"³VHDWUDJDQWy,xDTXH &RPR SDUHFtD GLVSXHVWR D OHYDQWDUVH GRQ )pOL[ OH HPSXMy GH QXHYR KDFLD HO VLOOyQ ³4XpGDWHGRQGHHVWiV&UHRTXHHVORPHMRU %HEDKL]RVXDSDULFLyQHQDTXHOLQVWDQWHHQHOXPEUDO ³£+ROD³VDOXGy<GHUHSHQWHVHTXHGyPXGDFRQORVRMRVILMRVHQODVLOXHWD GH,xDTXHHUJXLGDMXQWRDOVLOOyQTXHVHJXQGRVDQWHVRFXSDED ³3DVD« 3DVD ³VRQULy $OLFLD KDFLpQGRVH OD GHVHQWHQGLGD \ VDOLHQGR D VX HQFXHQWUR³ 3DVD TXHULGD 1R WH HVSHUiEDPRV KR\ 7HQHPRV XQD YLVLWD« \D YHV (OODTXH\DKDEtDGHMDGRGHPLUDUORSDVyORVRMRVVREUHpOVLQUR]DUORDSHQDVFRQVXV SXSLODV ³£+ROD ,xDTXHVXVXUUy ³£+ROD«%HED /D PLUDED HPEREDGR 1R SRGtD UHPHGLDUOR £(UD WDQ OLQGD ,ED PDUDYLOORVDPHQWHYHVWLGD8QWUDMHGHFKDTXHWDGHILUPDFDUDGHXQWRQRPiVELHQ JULVDFXDGURVGLPLQXWRV1ROOHYDEDEOXVDGHEDMR\SRUORVKRPEURVOXFtDXQDEULy VSRUWKDFLHQGRMXHJR&DO]DED]DSDWRVGHDQWH\EROVRGHOPLVPRFRORU8QFDVTXHWH VREUHODFDEH]D\DTXHOODJDODQXUDVX\DWDQIHPHQLQD 6HTXLWRHODEULJRFRQVXPDJUDFLD\ORGHMyHQHOUHVSDOGRGHOVLOOyQ6HVHQWy &UX]yXQDSLHUQDVREUHRWUD $OLFLDOHPRVWUyODFDMDGHFXHUR ³¢)XPDV" ³6tSRUVXSXHVWR³\KDFLpQGRVHODLQGLIHUHQWHFRQUHVSHFWRDOKRPEUHTXHOD PLUDED³+DFHXQIUtRLQIHUQDO1RVpFXiQGRYDDSDVDUHOLQYLHUQR ³0X\ SURQWR ³VRQULy VX SDGUH \ GHVSXpV VLQ WUDQVLFLyQ³ ¢4Xp WDO HQ WX WHUTXHGDG" ³¢/R GLFHV SRU PL HPSOHR" 0DJQLILFR (VWR\ HQFDQWDGD 7HQJR DPLJRV HVWXSHQGRV\FRPSDxHURVDGPLUDEOHV ,xDTXHSDUHFtDXQWRQWRDOOtVLQGHFLUSDODEUD
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
'HFLGLy PDUFKDUVH 1R SRGtD FRQWLQXDU MXQWR D HOORV 6H YHtD D Vt PLVPR GHVDLUDGR ³/RVLHQWR³GLMRGHV~ELWR³7HQJRTXHLUPH ³¢&yPR"¢7DQSURQWR,xDTXH" ³$VtHV2WURGtD«YROYHUp$OLFLD)pOL[«PHDOHJURPXFKRGHKDEHUKDEODGR FRQ XVWHG ³VH YROYLy KDFLD OD ILJXULOOD LQTXLHWD SHVH D QR GHPRVWUDUOR³ +DVWD« RWURGtD%HED ³$GLyV 3HURQROHGDEDODPDQR ,xDTXH VH PRUGLy ORV ODELRV \ WUDV HVWUHFKDU OD PDQR GHO PDWULPRQLR VH DOHMy DFRPSDxDGRGH)pOL[ ³+DFHVPDO³GLMR$OLFLDDOTXHGDUVHDVRODV³0X\PDO ³+DJRORTXHGHER ³eOORKL]RSRUFDULxR ³¢3RU FDULxR" ¢6H HQJDxD D XQD PXMHU SRU FDULxR" 'L ¢FUHHV KRQUDGDPHQWH HVR" ³0XMHU«HOHQJDxRQRIXHFRPRSDUDTXHW~ORWRPHVDVt4XLVRFRQTXLVWDUWH
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
(OORV TXp VDEtDQ /R QHFHVLWDED (UD« FRPR XQ WXER GH HVFDSH FRPR XQ GHVDKRJRDWRGDVVXVLQTXLHWXGHV\pVWDVHUDQPXFKDV /RV EHVy D ORV GRV FRQ WHUQXUD /H GDED JXVWR TXH VX SDGUH IXHUD IHOL] \ TXH $OLFLDOHDPDUDWDQWR\OHFRPSUHQGLHUDWDQELHQ ³0DxDQDYROYHUp³GLMR 3HURQRLEDDYROYHU 1XQFD VXSR VL IXH OD QRFKH R ORV UHFXHUGRV GH RWUDV QRFKHV FRPR DTXpOOD FDPLQDQGRSRUODVOXPLQRVDVFDOOHVGHVXEUD]RRTXHVXUHQFRU\DQRHUDPiVTXH XQSUHWH[WRVDOYDJXDUGDQGRVXGLJQLGDGKHULGDRTXHDTXHOODQRFKHQHFHVLWDEDSD] /RFLHUWRHVTXHFXDQGRGHMyHOSRUWDO\ORYLRHQPLWDGGHODFDOOHQRVHDVRPEUy eOVHDFHUFy&RQQDWXUDOLGDG'HPRVWUDQGRpVWDKDVWDGHVFRQFHUWDUOD ³7HHVSHUDED (OOD\DORYHtD 1R GLMR QDGD ,xDTXH OD DVLy GHO EUD]R FRQ WLPLGH] SULPHUR FRQ GHFLVLyQ GHVSXpV DO QRWDU TXH HOOD QR KXtD FDPLQDURQ ORV GRV DVt« DVLGRV GHO EUD]R UR]iQGRVHPX\MXQWRVXQRGHORWUR ³¢$SLH"³SUHJXQWypOFRPRVLMDPiVHQWUHDPERVKXELHUDXQPDOHQWHQGLGR ³6t ³7HQJRHODXWRDKtFHUFD ³£4Xp«PiVGD 6HPH]FODURQHQWUHORVWUDQVH~QWHV+DFLDPXFKRIUtReOGLMREDMRDWUD\pQGROD KDFLDVt ³¢&XiQGR" (OODSDUSDGHy ³¢&XiQGR«TXp" ³1RVFDVDPRV 6LOHQFLR ³¢'HQWURGHXQDVHPDQD" 6LOHQFLR /RV GHGRV PDVFXOLQRV VH PHWLHURQ EDMR HO JXDQWH IHPHQLQR+XUJDURQ DOOt 6LQ VROWDUOHHOEUD]ROHPHWLyODPDQRHQHOEROVLOORGHVXJDEiQ ³3DUD ³7LHQHV«ORVGHGRVIUtRV³\GHVSXpVEDMtVLPRLQFOLQDQGRVXDOWD\DUURJDQWH WDOODKDFLDHOOD³ ¢&XiQGR"«
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
3DUSDGHyRWUDYH] /HWHPEODEDQXQSRFRORVODELRV &DPLQDEDVLQGHWHQHUVHVLQUHVSRQGHU SHURWDPELpQVLQUHVFDWDUORVGHGRVTXH pODFDULFLDEDHQVXEROVLOOR 0XFKRUDWRDVt&RPRVLDTXHOVLOHQFLRIXHUDXQDFRQGLFLyQSDUDOOHJDUDODSD] ³9R\DVXELUFRQWLJR³GLMRpODOOOHJDUDOSRUWDO ³¢&RQ«FRQPLJR" ³$«VDOXGDUDWtD3HSD ³£$K /RVGRVVHSHUGLHURQHQHODVFHQVRU ,xDTXHDSUHWyHOERWyQ\DVtFRPRHVWDEDPHGLRODGHDGRODDVLySRUHOEUD]R\ ODPHWLyHQWUHVXFXHUSR\HOPDPSDUR ³¢4XpKDFHV" ³1RVp /R HVWDED KDFLHQGR $SUHWiQGROD VXDYHPHQWH SHUR FRQ LQWHQVLGDG DO PLVPR WLHPSR /D PHWLy HQ VX FXHUSR 0XFKR PXFKR KDVWD TXH HOOD TXHGy DOOt LQPyYLO SHJDGD D pO VLQ SURWHVWDU $Vt FRPR HVWDED OD FHUUy FRQ ORV GRV EUD]RV \ PHWLy OD FDEH]DEDMRODGHHOOD ³¢4XpKDFHV"³YROYLyDVXVXUUDUODYR]IHPHQLQDDKRJDGDPHQWH ³1RVp (ODVFHQVRUVHGHWHQtD\HOODHVFDSDEDGHVXVEUD]RV SHUR,xDTXHFRPRXQORFR GHVTXLFLDGRODTXHUtDUHWHQHU ³'HMD«GHMD« (UDXQDYR]WHQXHDKRJDGD 6DOLyWUDVHOODGHODVFHQVRUeOPLVPRSXOVyDOWLPEUH ³7HQJROODYH³VXVXUUyHOODEDMR )HOLVDOHVDEUtD\D /RVGRVVHFRODURQGHQWUR 7tD3HSDFUX]DEDHOSDVLOORHQDTXHOLQVWDQWH$OYHUORVVHHFKyDUHtU ³£+RODFKLFRV³GLMRFRPRVLWDOFRVD <ORVGRVVHORDJUDGHFLHURQ ³¢9DVDFHQDUFRQQRVRWURV"³SUHJXQWyGHVSXpV ³6t7tDGLOHD)HOLVDTXHSRQJDODPHVDSDUDWUHV <GLFKRORFXDOURMDFRPRODJUDQDVHSHUGLyHQHOVDORQFLWR
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
,xDTXH IXH WUDV HOOD &HUUy OD SXHUWD 6H TXHGDURQ DVt XQR IUHQWH D RWUR VLQ WRFDUVH\GHV~ELWRORVGRVDODYH]DYDQ]DURQ)XHHOODODTXHVHFROJyGHVXFXHOOR ³1RSRGtDPiV³VXVXUUyDKRJDGDPHQWH³1RSRGtDWHORDVHJXUR« <VXVERFDVDOHQFRQWUDUVHSDUHFtDQWHQHUIXHJR ,VDEHO(FKHJDUD\HUDXQDPXFKDFKDSUHFLRVDMRYHQFtVLPDPRGHUQD6yORWHQtD HQ HO IRQGR GH ODVSXSLODV FRPR XQDVRPEUD GH PHODQFROtDFRPR GH KDEHU SDVDGR XQDDJRQtDTXHSRFRDSRFRSRGtDLUVHGLVLSDQGR 'HVSHGtDDODQRYLDHQDTXHOPRPHQWR (UQHVWRHVWDEDDORWURODGRPiVMXQWRD,xDTXH\ORVGHPiVLQYLWDGRV ³,VDEHO« ³6H TXH IXLVWHW~ ³GLMR OD MRYHQFLWD³ 6LQR pO VHKXELHUD DJXDQWDGR VLQ LU D EXVFDUPH ³3HURWHDPDEDeOORVDEtD ³3HURGHWHVWDEDHOPDWULPRQLR %HEDULy7HQtDXQDULVDUDGLDQWH ³7RGRV ORV KRPEUHV GHWHVWDQ HO PDWULPRQLR KDVWD TXH OHV OOHJD OD KRUD GH FDVDUVH ³$ODXWRJULWy,xDTXHDOREHVWLDFRPRKDFtDVLHPSUH³2VGHMDPRVDPLJRV <DVLHQGRHOEUD]RGHVXHVSRVDVHODOOHYyVLQGHMDUODGHVSHGLUVHGHQDGLH 7RGRVULHURQ SHURWRGRVJUDFLDVD'LRVVHTXHGDEDQDOOt (ODXWRGH,xDTXHFRUUtDSRUODVFDOOHVPDGULOHxDVFRQVXPXMHUDVLGDGHOEUD]R (OFRQGXFtDFRQXQDVRODPDQR\HOEUD]ROLEUHVHORDSUHVDEDHOOD ³¢$GyQGHTXLHUHVLU"³SUHJXQWypOEXUOyQ ³&RQWLJR ³6XSRQJRTXHDDOJXQDSDUWH³ULypOVRFDUURQDPHQWH ³6XSRQHVELHQ³ULyHOODDVXYH]SHURPX\DWXUGLGD ³¢6DEHVTXHHUHV\DPLPXMHU"¢/RVDEHV" ³6t³VXVXUUyEDMtVLPR³Vt« ³1R«QRORVDEHVD~Q/RYDVDVDEHUHQVHJXLGD« <HODXWRVHGHWXYRDQWHXQHQRUPHHGLILFLRGHODDYHQLGDGHO*HQHUDOtVLPR ³¢4XpKDFHPRVDTXt" ³(V QXHVWUR QXHYR KRJDU 0H JXVWD HVWH EDUULR 7HQJR DTXt XQ DSDUWDPHQWR
13iJLQDV
&RUtQ7HOODGR²7HSUHILHURDWL
³6HJXLUHPRV YLDMH PDxDQD +R\ QL KDEODU ¢HK PL YLGD" 7tD 3HSD \D WLHQH DYLVRGHYHQLUPDxDQDSDUDDFiFRQ)HOLVD<0DWtDVYHQGUiGRVGtDVGHVSXpV1RKH SRGLGR SUHVFLQGLU GH pO +H FRPSUREDGR TXH PH SUHILHUH D Pt D PL JHPHOR ³\D HVWDEDQ HQ HO DSDUWDPHQWR ,xDTXH FHUUDED OD SXHUWD³ +R\ ³GLMR OHYDQWiQGROD HQ YLOR³HVWDUHPRVVRORV6RORV¢VDEHV"¢7HGDVFXHQWDGHORTXHHVRVLJQLILFD" 6HODGDED 7HQtDTXHGiUVHOD,xDTXHODHVWDEDEHVDQGRHQSOHQDERFD\ODGHSRVLWDEDHQXQ GLYiQ\VHTXHGDEDDVXODGR(OODDO]yORVEUD]RVOHURGHyHOFXHOOR ³0H«PHGDYHUJHQ]D $ pO QR $ pO VyOR OH GDED IHOLFLGDG 8QD ORFD IHOLFLGDG DTXHOOD VROHGDG GH ORV GRV (QDOJXQDSDUWHGHOYLHMR0DGULG0DWtDVPX\VHULRGHFtDDVXVDPLJRVHQXQD WHUWXOLDGHFDIp ³1RVKHPRVFDVDGRKR\«
)LQ )LQ
13iJLQDV
