U[G]G JEFMFHDG\DGF NGYM@ OE@GAG_ YMYXG DE@GY RMM LG@GJ [EJOE@GAG_GF JEF]MJGD OE_M\G JE@G@UM JCLE@ [EJOE@GAG_GF ICC[E_G\MRE YI_M[\
OGO M [EFLGNU@UGF
7&7 @g|gr Oe`gdgfh
Durm Durmdu du`u `uj j fgym fgymcf cfg` g` uf|u uf|ud d jg|g jg|g gagr gagr Ogng Ogngyg yg lgf lgf Ygy| Ygy|rg rg Mflc Mflcfe feym ymgg oercrm oercrmef ef|gy |gymm {glg {glg ngdmdg ngdmdg|| {ejoe {ejoe`ga `gagrg grgf f ogngyg ogngyg lgf ygy|rg ygy|rg Mflcf Mflcfey eymg& mg& Ngdmdg Ngdmdg|| oe`gag oe`gagrr ogngyg ogngyg glg`g glg`gn n oe`gag oe`gagrr oerdc oerdcjuf jufmdg mdgym& ym& Ngdmdg Ngdmdg|| oe`ga oe`gagr gr ygy|rg ygy|rg glg`gn glg`gn jejgn jejgngjm gjm jgfuy jgfuymg mg lgf fm`gm*f fm`gm*fm`g m`gmm dejgf dejgfuym uymgg ggf& f& Lefhg Lefhgf f lejmdm lejmdmgf, gf, ngdmd ngdmdg| g| {ejoe`gagrgf ogngyg lgf ygy|rg Mflcfeymg mg`gn {efmfhdg|gf dejgj{ugf ymyxg uf|ud oerdcjufmdgym lg`gj ogngyg Mflcfeymg }gfh ogmd lgf oefgr yeigrg `mygf lgf |u`my& [ejoe`gagrgf ogngyg Mflcfeymg }gfh lmoermdgf de{glg {grg ymyxg je`m{u|m ej{g| ej{g| gy{ed gy{ed,, }gm|u }gm|u jef}mj jef}mjgd, gd, oeromi oeromigrg grg,, jejogi jejogig, g, lgf lgf jefu`m jefu`my& y& Lm gf|gr gf|grgg deej{g deej{g|| gy{ed gy{ed |eryeou |eryeou|, |, {efe`m {efe`m|m |m ngf}g ngf}g jejbcd jejbcduy uydgf dgf {glg {glg gy{ed gy{ed jef}mjg jef}mjgd& d& Gy{e Gy{ed d jef} jef}mj mjgd gd mfm mfm lm{m lm{m`mn `mn dgre dgrefg fg ygfh ygfhg| g| jefl jeflud uduf ufh h |erag |eraglm lmf} f}gg {rcy {rcyey ey oerdcjufmdgym yeigrg `mygf& Dehmg|gf jef}mjgd jeru{gdgf dehmg|gf }gfh {g`mfh yermfh lm`gdudgf c`en ymyxg {glg ygg| oer`gfhyufh oer`gfhyufhf}g f}g {rcyey {rcyey {ejoe`gagrgf {ejoe`gagrgf&& Ngj{mr Ngj{mr ye`urun ye`urun huru }gfh jefhgagr, |gd |erdeiug`m ogngyg Mflcfeymg, ye`g`u jejoermdgf {efae`gygf jg|erm {e`gagrgf de{glg ymyxg je`g`um {rcyey `mygf& Uf|ud jejgngjm {efae`gygf huru, ymyxg ngruy jef}mjgd lefhgf ogmd& Amdg |mlgd, ymyxg jefejum dehghg`gf lg`gj {rcyey {ejoe`gagrgf& Dehmg|gf Dehmg|gf jef}mjgd jef}mjgd oer{ergf oer{ergf {ef|mfh {ef|mfh lg`gj lg`gj {efhejog {efhejogfhgf fhgf dejgj{ug dejgj{ugf f oerogngyg yeyecrgfh |eru|gjg {grg ymyxg& Fgjuf, {ejoe`gagrgf jef}mjgd oudgf yejg|g*jg yejg|g*jg|g |g {ef}gamgf {ef}gamgf jg|erm jg|erm lefhgf lefhgf jeflefhgrd jeflefhgrdgf gf yehg`g yehg`g yeyug|u yeyug|u mfbcrjgym, mfbcrjgym, je`gmfdgf glg {rcyey {ejgngjgf }gfh ngruy lmdejogfhdgf&
[efe`m [efe`m|mg |mgf f |ef|gf |ef|gfh h jef}mj jef}mjgd gd durgfh durgfh jeflg{ jeflg{g| g| {erng {erng|mg |mgf f lgrm lgrm dg`gf dg`gfhg hgf f {efe`m|m& Ng` mfm oerlgygrdgf {eflg{g| \grmhgf .7==<179?-, ‐Yug|u {efe`m|mgf }gfh ygfhg| oerngrhg lg`gj omlgfh de|ergj{m`gf jef}mjgd }gfh ygj{gm dmfm jgymn `gfhdg&‚ `gfhdg&‚ De`gfhdggf De`gfhdggf {efe`m|mgf {efe`m|mgf jef}mjgd jef}mjgd |eryeou| |eryeou| iudu{ iudu{ oerg`gygf oerg`gygf,, yeogo yeogo lm yedc`gn |mlgd {erfgn lm`gdudgf |ey jef}mjgd& Ujujf}g |ey }gfh lm`gdudgf c`en {mngd yedc`gn glg`gn jefhudur ngym` oe`gagr, yelgfhdgf dejgj{ugf jef}mjgd jefm|mdoer jefm|mdoerg|dg g|dgf f {glg {rcyey& {rcyey& M|u`gn M|u`gn yeogof}g yeogof}g,, dejgj{ug dejgj{ugf f jef}mjgd jef}mjgd durgfh durgfh jeflg{g| |ej{g| lm yedc`gn& Jefuru| Yur}g .?;;91?=-, ‐Lm fehgrg Mflcfeymg, gfgd lmlmd yeoghmgf oeygr ngf}g jgj{u jejuyg|dgf {erng|mgf lgf {mdmrgf oerdmygr 7;*?; jefm| ygag ye|mg{ |g|g{ |g|g{ judg& judg& Ng` mfm lmyeog lmyeogodg odgf f durgf durgfhf} hf}gg de|er` de|er`mog mog|gf |gf ymyxg ymyxg yeigrg yeigrg dcf|mf} dcf|mf}u u lg`gj oe`gagr&‚ [ejoe`gagrgf jef}mjgd oerm|g |e`gn lmoermdgf huru de{glg ymyxg de`gy RMM YJ[ Jungjjglm}gn \gfaufh _gag Dgou{g|ef Chgf M`mr, fgjuf hgjogrgf }gfh glg jefufauddgf jefufauddgf ognxg ognxg yeigrg yeigrg d`gymdg`, d`gymdg`, ngym`f}g ngym`f}g ngf}g ngf}g jefig{gm jefig{gm rg|g*rg|g 55 g|gu oe`uj jejugydgf& Ng` mfm lmlg{g| lgrm ngym` |ey }gfh lmoermdgf {glg |gfhhg` < G{rm` ?;;= |ernglg{ ymyxg& Ngym` mfm auhg |erhgjogr ygg| {efe`m|m jefgf}gdgf dejog`m mym oghmgf oerm|g }gfh lmgjom` lgrm yg`gn yg|u yurg| dgogr [g`ejogfh, {grg ymyx ymyxgg ogf} ogf}gd gd |mlgd |mlgd omyg omyg jefa jefagx gxgo gof} f}gg lefh lefhgf gf ogmd ogmd&& Ymyx Ymyxgg jgym jgymn n durg durgfh fh dcfyef dcfyef|rg |rgym ym lg`gj lg`gj jef}mj jef}mjgd gd yenmfh yenmfhhg hg jeredg jeredg yu`m| yu`m| jefie jefierm|g rm|gdg dgf f dejog dejog`m `m mym oerm|g oerm|g }gfh }gfh jefagl jefaglmm coaed coaed ymjgd ymjgdgf& gf& Dcflmy Dcflmymm mfm lmyeog lmyeogodg odgf f def}g def}g|gg |ggf f ognxg ognxg {efledg|gf {ejoe`gagrgf ogngyg Mflcfeymg }gfh lmhufgdgf huru jgymn oerimrmdgf {efledg {efledg|gf |gf y|rud|urg` y|rud|urg` lefhgf lefhgf je|cle je|cle iergjgn, iergjgn, yenmfhhg yenmfhhg ymyxg durgfh jgj{u jefhufhdg{dgf dejog`m mym ogngf ymjgdgf& G|gy G|gy lgygr lgygr def}g def}g|gg |ggf f `g{gfh `g{gfhgf gf |eryeo |eryeou| u| jgdg jgdg {er`u {er`u lm|erg{ lm|erg{dgf dgf yeougn yeougn jcle` {ejoe`gagrgf ydrm{ dcc{erg|mb . icc{erg|me yirm{| - }gfh lg{g| jejogf|u jefmfhdg jefmfhdg|dgf |dgf dejgj{ug dejgj{ugf f ymyxg lg`gj jef}mjgd jef}mjgd oerm|g& oerm|g& [efhhufgg [efhhufggf f jcle` jcle` {ejoe` {ejoe`gag gagrgf rgf ydrm{ ydrm{ dc{erg dc{erg|mb |mb lg{g| lg{g| jefmfh jefmfhdg| dg|dgf dgf {rcyey {rcyey oe`ga oe`gagr gr ymyxg ymyxg lg`gj lg`gj {ejoe`gagrgf }gfh {glg hm`mrgff}g lmngrg{dgf lg{g| jefmfhdg|dgf ngym` oe`gagr ymyxg&
icc{erg|me me yirm{| yirm{| Lg`gj Lg`gj {rcyey {rcyey {ejoe {ejoe`ga `gagrg grgf, f, jcle` jcle` {ejoe {ejoe`gag `gagrgf rgf icc{erg|
lm|erg{dgf yeigrg oer{gygfhgf, }gdfm yg|u crgfh yeoghgm {eflefhgr lgf yg|u crgfh yeoghgm {ejomigrg g|gu yeog`mdf}g uf|ud je`mygfdgf mdn|mygr, oghmgf*oghmgf lgrm jg|erm jg|erm }gfh }gfh lm{e`g lm{e`gagr agrm& m& Jcle` Jcle` {ejoe {ejoe`ga `gagrg grgf f mfm lg{g| lg{g| jefhh jefhhufg ufgdgf dgf je|cle je|cle oerjgmf {ergf .rc`e {`g}mfh-, lmyduym, g|gu {ejoermgf |uhgy& Ye{gfagfh Ye{gfagfh ye{efhe|g ye{efhe|gnugf nugf {efu`my, {efu`my, jcle` jcle` {ejoe`gag {ejoe`gagrgf rgf icc{erg|me yirm{| oe`uj oe`uj {erfgn {erfgn lm{gdgm lm{gdgm lg`gj {efe`m|mgf {efe`m|mgf |mflgdgf |mflgdgf de`gy de`gy c`en jgngymyxg& jgngymyxg& [efu`my [efu`my auh auhgg
|mlg |mlgd d
jefe jefeju judg dgf f
ngym ngym``
{efe {efe`m `m|m |mgf gf {efe {eferg rg{g {gf f
jcle jcle``
{ejo {ejoe` e`ga gagr grgf gf
icc{erg|me yirm{| , ogmd oeraefmy edy{ermjef jgu{uf {efe`m|mgf leydrm{|mb&
[efe`m|mgf [efe`m|mgf ]urmlgn ]urmlgn .?;;<1<=.?;;<1<=- jefhefg jefhefgmm dejgj{ugf dejgj{ugf jef}mjgd jef}mjgd je`g`um je`g`um jcle` lmy|ch`cyy lg{g| jefmfhdg| yeoeygr =;%& [efe`m|mgf mfm lm`gdygfgdgf {glg ymyxg ymyxg de`gy de`gy R YL Fehe Feherm rm \gfauf \gfaufh h Dgrgfh Dgrgfh deigjg deigjg|gf |gf _gjou| _gjou|gf gf Dgou{g Dgou{g|ef |ef Ogf} Ogf}ug ugym ymf& f& Oero Oeroel elgg lefh lefhgf gf {efe {efe`m `m|mg |mgf f |erlg |erlgnu nu`u `u,, {efe {efe`m| `m|mm dg`m dg`m mfm mfm {efe {efe`m| `m|mm icc{erg|me e yirm{| yirm{| uf|ud jefmfhdg| jefhhu jefhhufgd fgdgf gf jcle` jcle` {ejoe` {ejoe`gag gagrgf rgf icc{erg|m jefmfhdg|dgf dgf
dejgj{ugf jef}mjgd ymyxg& [ef| [ef|mf mfhf hf}g }g
jcle jcle``
{ejo {ejoe` e`ga gagr grgf gf
icc{er icc{erg|m g|mee
yirm{| yirm{| dgre dgrefg fg
jcle jcle``
{ejoe` {ejoe`gag gagrgf rgf mfm jej{uf jej{uf}g }gmm {ergf {ergf y|rg|e y|rg|ehmy hmy lg`gj lg`gj u{g}g u{g}g jeflcf jeflcfhd hdrgd rgd ngym` ngym` oe`gagr ymyxg& Lg`gj {eferg{gff}g huru jef}eyugmdgf lefhgf dcflmym deou|ungf ymyxg, ymyxg, yenmfh yenmfhhg hg huru huru lmngrg{ lmngrg{dgf dgf jgj{u jgj{u jef}g jef}gj{g j{gmdg mdgf f jg|erm jg|erm lefhgf lefhgf |e{g| |e{g| |gf{g jefhgdmog|dgf ymyxg jefhg`gjm deocygfgf& Oerl Oerlgy gygr grdg dgf f
urgm urgmgf gf
}gfh }gfh |e`g |e`gn n
lmde lmdeju judg dgdg dgf f
yeoe yeoe`u `ujf} jf}g, g, {efe {efe`m| `m|mm
je`gdudgf {efe`m|mgf |mflgdgf de`gy jefhefgm u{g}g jefmfhdg|dgf ngym` oe`gagr ymyxg myxg de`g de`gyy
RMM RMM
lg`g lg`gj j
{ejo {ejoee`gag `gagrg rgf f
jef} jef}mj mjggd
oerm oerm|g |g je`g je`g`u `umm
jcl jcle`
Icc{erg|me e Yirm{| Yirm{| lm YJ[ {ejoe`gagrgf Icc{erg|m YJ[ Jung Jungjj jjgl glm} m}gn gn \gfa \gfauf ufh h _gag _gag
Dgou{g|ef Chgf M`mr& Lm{m`mnf}g ymyxg de`gy RMM YJ[ Jungjjglm}gn \gfaufh _gag Dgou{g|ef Chgf M`mr yeoghgm `cdgym {efe`m|mgf dgrefg {efe`m|m yeoghgm huru jg|g {e`gagrgf Ogngyg Mflcfeymg lm yedc`gn |eryeou|& Lm ygj{mfh m|u, dejgj{ugf ymyxg de`gy RMM jef}mjgd oerm|g jgymn {er`u lm|mfhdg|dgf `ghm&
7&? _ujuygf Jgyg`gn
Jgyg`gn lg`gj {efe`m|mgf mfm glg`gn g{gdgn ngym` oe`gagr ymyxg de`gy RMM lg`g lg`gj j
{ejo {ejoe` e`ga gagr grgf gf
jef} jef}mj mjgd gd
oerm oerm|g |g
lg{g lg{g||
jefm jefmfh fhdg dg||
je`g je`g`u `umm
jcle jcle``
{ejoe`gagrgf icc{erg|me irm{| lm YJ[ Jungjjglm}gn \gfaufh _gag Dgou{g|ef Chgf M`mr&
7&9 \uaugf [efe`m|mgf
\uaugf \uaugf {efe`m|mgf {efe`m|mgf mfm glg`gn glg`gn uf|ud jefhe|gnum jefhe|gnum lgf jefleydr jefleydrm{ymd m{ymdgf gf ngym` oe`gag oe`gagrr ymyxg ymyxg de`gy de`gy RMM lg`gj lg`gj {ejoe {ejoe`ga `gagrg grgf f jef}m jef}mjgd jgd oerm|g oerm|g je`g`u je`g`umm jcle` jcle` {ejoe`gagrgf icc{erg|me irm{| lm YJ[ Jungjjglm}gn \gfaufh _gag Dgou{g|ef Chgf M`mr&
7&< Jgfbgg| [efe`m|mgf
[e`gdygfggf {efe`m|mgf mfm lg{g| oerjgfbgg| ogmd yeigrg |ecre|my jgu{uf {rgd|my& 7&<&7 7&<&7
Jgfbgg Jgfbgg|| \ecre| \ecre|my my
Yeig Yeigrg rg |ecr |ecre| e|my my,, ngym ngym`` {efe {efe`m| `m|mg mgf f mfm mfm lg{g lg{g|| lmag lmaglm lmdg dgf f ogng ogngf f |gjo |gjogn gngf gf `m|erg|ur lg`gj jefufagfh {rchrgj {efhgagrgf Ogngyg Mflcfeymg lm YJ[&
7&<&? 7&<&?
Jgfbgg Jgfbgg|| [rgd|m [rgd|myy
Yeigrg Yeigrg {rgd|my {rgd|my ngym` ngym` {efe` {efe`m|mg m|mgf f mfm lg{g| lg{g| oerjg oerjgfbg fbgg| g| oghm oghm ymyxg, ymyxg, }gfh }gfh ngym`f}g lg{g| lmrgygdgf `gfhyufh lg`gj jefhg|gym deyu`m|gf ymyxg {glg xgd|u jef}mjgd& Ye`gmf m|u, ngym` {efe`m|mgf mfm auhg lg{g| oerjgbgg| oghm huru yeoghgm g`|erfg|mb uf|ud jefmfhdg|dgf dejgj{ugf jef}mjgd oerm|g je`g`um {ejoe`gagrgf icc{erg|me yirm{| &
OGO MM \MFAGUGF [UY\GDG
?&7 Ngym` Oe`gagr
Jefuru| Ygner|mgf .?;;<1?;-, ‐Ngym` oe`gagr jeru{gdgf hgjogrgf |mfhdg| {efhugyg {efhugyggf gf ymyxg |ernglg{ ygygrgf oe`gagr {glg |c{md ogngygf ogngygf }gfh }gfh lm{e`gagrm, lm{e`gagrm, }gfh }gfh lmudur lmudur lefhg lefhgf f oerlg oerlgygr ygrdgf dgf auj`gn auj`gn ydcr ydcr agxgog agxgogf f oefgr oefgr {glg {glg ycg` ycg` }gfh }gfh lmyuyuf yeyugm lefhgf ygygrgf oe`gagr&‚ Hghfe Hghfe lgf Ormhh Ormhhyy .lg`gj .lg`gj Fgyu| Fgyu|mcf mcf,, ?;;21? ?;;21?-- jef}g jef}g|gd |gdgf gf ognxg ognxg ngym` ngym` oe`gagr oe`gagr glg`gn glg`gn dejgj{ug dejgj{ugf f }gfh lm{erc`en lm{erc`en yeyecrgf yeyecrgfh h yeyulgn yeyulgn jefhmdu|m jefhmdu|m {rcyey {rcyey oe`gagr& _emhe`u|n .lg`gj Fgyu|mcf, ?;;21?- jefhejudgdgf ognxg ngym` oe`gagr glg`gn {rm`gdu }gfh lg{g| lmgjg|m }gfh jefufauddgf dejgj{ugf }gfh lmjm`mdm yeyecrgfh& [eflg{g| `gmf lmdg|gdgf c`en Yur}g .?;;912<- ognxg ngym` oe`gagr mg`gn ‐oeroef|ud {eruogngf {glg {efhe|gnugf, ymdg{, lgf de|ergj{m`gf&‚ [rg}m|fc .?;;?172<- jef}g|gdgf ognxg ngym` oe`gagr glg`gn ‐yeyug|u }gfh ogru, ogru, ogmd ogmd lg`gj lg`gj dgxgyg dgxgygf f dchfm| dchfm|mb, mb, gbed|mb gbed|mb,, dcfg|m dcfg|mb, b, jgu{uf jgu{uf {ymdc {ymdcjc| jc|crm crmd# d# de|ergj{ de|ergj{m`gf&‚ m`gf&‚ [eflg{g| [eflg{g| }gfh }gfh yefglg yefglg lmdejudgd lmdejudgdgf gf c`en Le{lmdfgy Le{lmdfgy .?;;919-, .?;;919-, ‐Ngym` oe`gagr ymyxg glg`gn dejgj{ugf }gfh u|un }gfh jefigdu{ dejgj{ugf dchf dchfm|m m|mb, b, dejg dejgj{ j{ug ugf f {ymd {ymdcj cjc| c|cr cr,, lgf lgf dejg dejgj{ j{ug ugf f gbed gbed|mb |mb g|gu g|gu {erm` {erm`gd gdu& u&‚‚ Yelg Yelgfh fhdg dgf f jefu jefuru ru|| Ngjg Ngjg`md `md .?;; .?;;<1 <1?> ?>-, -, ‐Ngy ‐Ngym` m` oe`g oe`gag agrr }gfh }gfh u|gj u|gjgg mg`g mg`gn n {eruogngf {c`g |mfhdgn `gdu }gfh ou`g|&‚ Oerlgygr Oerlgygrdgf dgf {efher|mgf {efher|mgf |eryeou| |eryeou| lg{g| lg{g| lmymj{u`dgf lmymj{u`dgf ognxg ognxg ngym` oe`gagr oe`gagr glg`gn hgjogrgf |mfhdg| {efhugyggf ymyxg |ernglg{ ygygrgf oe`gagr {glg |c{md ogngy ogngygf gf }gfh }gfh lm{e`g lm{e`gagr agrmm oeru{ oeru{gg {eruo {eruogng gngf f {erm`gd {erm`gdu u oe`gag oe`gagrr ymyxg& ymyxg& [eruogn [eruogngf gf |mfhd |mfhdgn gn `gdu `gdu mfm mfm je`m{ je`m{u| u|mm yehe yehefg fg{ { rgfg rgfgn n dchf dchfm|m m|mb, b, gbed gbed|mb |mb,, lgf lgf {ymd {ymdcj cjc| c|cr cr&& Oerdg Oerdgm|g m|gf f lefhg lefhgf f {efe`m {efe`m|mg |mgf f mfm {efu` {efu`my my jejog jejog|gy |gymm ngym` ngym` oe`gag oe`gagrr {glg {glg rgfgn rgfgn dchfm| dchfm|mb mb }gfh }gfh lm`mng lm`mng|| lgrm lgrm dejgj dejgj{ug {ugf f ymyxg ymyxg lg`gj lg`gj {rcyey {rcyey {ejoe {ejoe`ga `gagrg grgf f }gfh }gfh lm|mfagu lgrm fm`gm*fm`gm }gfh lm{erc`en c`en ymyxg&
?&? Bgd|cr*Bgd|cr }gfh Jej{efhgrunm Ngym` Oe`gagr
Ngym Ngym`` oe`g oe`gag agrr glg` glg`gn gn oud| oud|mm deoe deoern rngy gym`g m`gf f uygn uygngg }gfh }gfh lmig lmig{g {gmm Jefu Jefuru ru|| Xmfde` Xmfde` .?;;<1 .?;;<172? 72?-& -& Oerlg Oerlgygr ygrdg dgf f {efhe {efher|mg r|mgf f lm g|gy g|gy lg{g| lg{g| lmymj{ lmymj{u`d u`dgf gf ognxg ognxg {rey|gym oe`gagr glg`gn oud|m lgrm yug|u {rcyey uygng }gfh lm`gdudgf c`en mflmmlu hufg hufg jej{er jej{erc`e c`en n {eruog {eruogng ngf f |mfhdgn |mfhdgn `gdu `gdu }gfh }gfh lm|ej{ lm|ej{g|d g|dgf gf lg`gj lg`gj mf|ergd mf|ergdym ym lefhgf `mfhdufhgf yedm|grf}g& Lg`gj Lg`gj u{g}g u{g}g jefmfh jefmfhdg| dg|dgf dgf lg}g lg}g yerg{ yerg{ ngym` ngym` oe`gag oe`gagrr lg{g| lg{g| lm{efh lm{efhgru grunm nm bgd|cr gf|grg `gmf 1 g& Bgd|cr Bgd|cr mf|erfg mf|erfg`` Bgd|c Bgd|crr mf|erf mf|erfg` g` glg`gn glg`gn bgd|cr bgd|cr }gfh }gfh glg lg`gj lg`gj lmrm lmrm gfgd, gfgd, jmyg`f} jmyg`f}gg jc|mb jc|mb |er|ef |er|ef|u |u lg`gj lg`gj ymyxg& ymyxg& Ymyxg Ymyxg }gfh }gfh jej{uf jej{uf}g }gmm jc|mb jc|mb |er|ef |er|ef|u |u lg`gj lg`gj oe`gagr gdgf `eomn `eomn oerngym` lgrm {glg ymyxg }gfh }gfh |mlgd jej{uf}gm jej{uf}gm jc|mb& Yeyecr Yeyecrgfh gfh je`gdu je`gdudgf dgf gd|mm gd|mm|gy |gy dgref dgrefgg glg }gfh }gfh jeflcr jeflcrcfh cfhf}g f}g&& Lg`gj Lg`gj ng` mfm jc|mg jc|mgym` ym`gn gn yeogh yeoghgm gm lgygr lgygr
{efhh {efhherg ergdf} df}gg }gfh }gfh jeflcr jeflcrcfh cfh
yeyecrgfh uf|ud oe`gagr& Yeyecrgfh }gfh oerjmfg| uf|ud oe`gagr }gfh oe`uj ygj{g ygj{gmm {glg {glg |g|grg |g|grgf f jc|mg jc|mgym ym jgdg jgdg oe`uj oe`uj jefufa jefufaudd uddgf gf gd|mm gd|mm|gy |gy f}g|g f}g|g&& Jc|mgym yeyecrgfh lg{g| lmagogrdgf lg`gj oef|ud jmfg|& Jmfg| jeru{gdgf deieflerufhgf {ymdc`chmy }gfh jef}efgfhm coaed, oe`uj ygj{gm je`gdudgf dehmg|gf& Ng` mfm oergr|m {u`g ognxg jmfg| glg`gn g`g| jc|mgym lg`gj oe`gagr& Jmfg| jeru{gdgf {c|efym {ymdc`chmy }gfh lg{g| lmjgbgg|dgf uf|ud jefhhg`m jc|m jc|mg gym ym&& Om`g Om`g yeye yeyecr crgf gfh h |e`gn |e`gn |erj |erjc| c|m mgy gymm uf|u uf|ud d oe`g oe`gag agr, r, jgdg jgdg mg gdgf gdgf je`gdudgf gd|mm|gy oe`gagr lg`gj ref|gfhgf xgd|u |er|ef|u& C`en dgrefg m|u, jc|mgym jc|mgym lmgdum lmgdum yeoghgm yeoghgm lgygr lgygr {efhherg {efhhergd d }gfh }gfh jeflcrcfh jeflcrcfh gd|mm|gy oe`gagr yeyecrgfh& Jc|mgym ymyxg {glg {ejoe`gagrgf dcc{erg|mb |eru|gjg |er`e|gd {glg oghg oghgmj mjgf gfgg oef| oef|ud ud nglm nglmgn gn g|gu g|gu y|ru y|rud| d|ur ur {efi {efig{ g{gm gmgf gf |uau |uaugf gf ygg| ygg| ymyx ymyxgg je`gd je`gdygf ygfgdg gdgf f dehmg| dehmg|gf gf&& [glg [glg {ejoe {ejoe`gag `gagrgf rgf dcc{er dcc{erg|m g|mbb ymyxg ymyxg }gdmf }gdmf ognxg ognxg |uaugf |uaugf jeredg jeredg |erig |erig{gm {gm amdg amdg lgf ngf}g ngf}g amdg ymyxg `gmf `gmf auhg auhg gdgf gdgf jefig jefig{gm {gm |uaugf |eryeou|&
o& Bgd|cr Edy|erfg`
Bgd|cr edy|erfg` glg`gn bgd|cr }gfh lg|gfh lgrm `ugr lmrm gfgd m|u yeflmrm jmyg`f}g bgd|cr de`ugrhg, yedc`gn, `mfhdufhgf lgf jgy}grgdg|& Ym|ugym de`ugrhg }gfh durgfh jefufagfh {rcyey oe`gagr ye{er|m1 dedgigugf rujgn |gfhhg .orcdef ncje-, durgfh {erng|mgf crgfh |ug, igrg crgfh |ug jeflmlmd }gfh durgfh ogmd, durgfh dejgj{ugf crgfh |ug lg`gj jejoermdgf {efhgxgygf lgf {erng|mgf& Bgd|cr `mfhdufhgf yedc`gn }gfh durgfh jgj{u jefufagfh {rcyey oe`gagr, ye{er| ye{er|mm durgfh durgfh jejgl jejglgmf} gmf}gg ygrgf ygrgfgg g|gu g|gu yujoer yujoer oe`gag oe`gagr4 r4 igrg* igrg*igr igrgg huru huru lg`gj lg`gj jefhgagr }gfh durgfh jefgrmd, durmdu`uj g|gu jg|erm }gfh lm{e`gagrm |mlgd yeyugm lefh lefhgf gf dejg dejgj{ j{ug ugf f {eye {eyer| r|gg lmlm lmlmd, d, {er` {er`ef efhd hdg{ g{gf gf oe`g oe`gagr agr }gfh }gfh
durg durgfh fh,, igrg igrg
eg`ugym eg`ugym,, rugfh oe`gagr, ymy|ej gljmfmy|rgy gljmfmy|rgym, m, xgd|u oe`gagr, oe`gagr, ym|ugym ym|ugym yedc`gn yedc`gn lgf yeoghgmf}g& @mfhdufhgf ycymg` }gfh }gfh durgfh jejglgm, ye{er|m1 {efhgrun fehg|mb lg`gj lg`gj {erhgu`gf, {erhgu`gf, ym|ugym ym|ugym jgy}grgdg jgy}grgdg|| }gfh }gfh dgigu, dgigu, hgfhhug hgfhhugf f deoulg}gg deoulg}ggf, f, ye{er|m ye{er|m bm`j, ogiggf*ogiggf lgf yeoghgmf}g .Y`gje|c, ?;;91?<-& Ogf}gd crgfh }gfh oe`gagr lefhgf yuygn {g}gn, |e|g{m |mlgd jeflg{g|dgf ngym` ngym` g{g*g{ g{g*g{g, g, ngf}g ngf}g dehghg dehghg`gf `gf }gfh }gfh lm|ejum lm|ejum&& [ef}e [ef}eogo ogof}g f}g |mlgd |mlgd `gmf `gmf dgref dgrefgg oe`gagr |mlgd |erg|ur, |mlgd lmym{`mf, lgf durgfh oeryejgfhg|, |mlgd |gnu oghgmjgfg igrg oerdcfyef|rgym lg`gj oe`gagr, jefhgogmdgf jgyg`gn {efhg|urgf xgd|u lg`gj oe`gag oe`gagr, r, my|mrg my|mrgng| ng| }gfh }gfh |mlgd |mlgd iudu{, iudu{, lgf durgfh durgfh |mlur& |mlur& C`en C`en dgrefg dgrefg m|u, lg`gj lg`gj oe`gag oe`gagrr |erlg{ |erlg{g| g| ng`*ng ng`*ng`` }gfh }gfh ngruy ngruy lm|gfg lm|gfgjdg jdgf f c`en c`en crgfh crgfh |ug de{gl de{glgg ymyxg ymyxg&& Lagjgr Lagjgrgn gn .?;;?1 .?;;?17;7;- oer{e oer{eflg flg{g| {g| ognxg ognxg ‐ymyxg ‐ymyxg {er`u {er`u lm|gfg lm|gfgjdg jdgf f deomgy deomgygg ggf f oe`g oe`gag agr, r, }gm|u }gm|u11 .7.7- oe`g oe`gag agrr lefh lefhgf gf |erg |erg|u |ur4 r4 .?.?- lmym lmym{` {`mf mf44 .9.9- dcfy dcfyef ef|rg |rgym ym44 .<.<{efhg|urgf xgd|u&‚ Jefuru| {eflg{g| Xmfde` .?;;<1??- ognxg Delmym{`mfgf glg`gn yug|u {erg|urgf }gfh yelmdm|, |e|g{m ae`gy g|gu |ehgy lm jgfg mym lgf rujuygf {erg|urgf lm{mdmrdgf yeigrg jgf|g{ lgf jg|g jg|gfh, fh, lmomf lmomfgg lgf lmdejo lmdejogf gfhdg hdgf f yeigrg yeigrg `eomn `eomn f}g|g f}g|g ghgr ghgr yu{g} yu{g}gg g{g }gfh }gfh lmmfh lmmfhmfd mfdgf gf m|u lg{g| lg{g| |erxua |erxuaul ul lefhg lefhgf f ogmd, ogmd, yeyugm lefhgf g{g }gfh lmngrg{dgf&
Jefujo Jefujound undgf gf delmy delmym{` m{`mfg mfgf f jeru{g jeru{gdgf dgf oghmgf oghmgf lgrm lgrm |uhgy |uhgy crgfh crgfh |ug lm rujgn& Jefim{|gdgf delmym{`mfgf mfm ngruy lmju`gm lgrm lg`gj lmrm dm|g yeflmrm, ogru`g ogru`gn n lg{g| lg{g| jeflmy jeflmym{` m{`mfd mfdgf gf crgfh crgfh `gmf `gmf de|e de|ef| f|rg rgjg jgf, f,
lgf lgf
deng dengrj rjcf cfmy mygf gf&&
Ng` Ng`
yenmf yenmfhh hhgg gdgf gdgf |erim{ |erim{|g |g de|efg de|efgfhg fhgf, f, |ery |eryeo eou| u|
yeyu yeyugm gm
lefh lefhgf gf
{efl {eflg{ g{g| g|
Lgrjclmng Lgrjclmngrlac rlac .7===17?.7===17?- }gfh jefhg|gdgf jefhg|gdgf ognxg ognxg ‐yecrgfh ‐yecrgfh |mlgd gdgf gdgf ebed|mb ebed|mb jefgfgjdgf delmym{`mfgf g{gom`g lmg yeflmrm |mlgd jefhe|gnum g{g }gfh jefaglm demfhmfgf crgfh `gmf&‚ Jefe Jeferg rg{d {dgf gf lmym lmym{` {`mf mf }gfh }gfh dcfy dcfymy my|e |ef f jeru jeru{g {gdg dgf f dufi dufimm u|gj u|gjgg uf|u uf|ud d jefhg|gym yeoghmgf oeygr jgyg`gn }gfh lmnglg{m {grg crgfh |ug lg`gj jeflmlmd gfgd*gfgd& [rcyey {eflmym{`mfgf jejufhdmfdgf crgfh |ug uf|ud jej{er|gngfdgf dexefgfhgf }gfh ebed|mb lm rujgn, yenmfhhg nuoufhgf }gfh yergym gf|grg crgfh |ug lgf gfgd*gfgd lg{g| |erxuaul& Crgfh Crgfh |ug }gfh }gfh lmym{` lmym{`mf, mf, }gm|u }gm|u jeredg jeredg }gfh }gfh omyg omyg oerym oerymdg{ dg{ |ehgy |ehgy,, `g}gd `g}gd lm{erig}g lgf lg{g| oerdcjufmdgym lefhgf ae`gy, {gy|m jgj{u jefim{|gdgf yug|u ymy|ej lgf jefaglm yurm |e`glgf oghm gfgd*gfgd jeredg& Crgfh |ug ye{er|m mfm gdgf jgj{u jgj{u jeflcr jeflcrcfh cfh gfgd* gfgd*gf gfgd gd uf|ud uf|ud jefagl jefaglmm gfgd*g gfgd*gfgd fgd }gfh }gfh lmym{` lmym{`mf mf auhg& auhg& Lg`gj ng` mfm I`ejey .?;;718- jefhejudgdgf ognxg ‐g`gygf u|gjg jefhg{g gfgd*gfg gfgd*gfgd d }gfh }gfh oerjgyg`g oerjgyg`gn n |mlgd jgu oeruogn oeruogn glg`gn glg`gn dgrefg dgrefg delug delug crgfh |ug jeredg |mlgd oeryelmg jefhuogn igrg jeredg lg`gj jefhg|gym ye|mg{ jgyg`gn&‚ Lg`g Lg`gj j oe`g oe`gag agrr lmym lmym{` {`mf mf ygfh ygfhg| g| lm{e lm{er` r`ud udgf gf&& Lmym{ Lmym{`mf `mf lg{g lg{g|| je`g je`gnm nmrd rdgf gf yejg yejgfh fhg| g|
jefh jefhng ngrh rhgm gm
xgd| xgd|u, u,
oudg oudgf f jef}mg* jef}mg*f} f}mg mgdg dgf f xgd|u xgd|u oer`g oer`g`u `u lg`g lg`gj j
den dengj{g j{ggf& gf& Oulg} lg}g agj agj dgre dgre|| glg`g lg`gn n juyu juyun n oey oeygr ogh oghm jere jeredg dg }gfh gfh jefhgh jefhghujd ujdgf gf lmym{`m lmym{`mf f lg`gj lg`gj oe`gag oe`gagr& r& Jered Jeredgg oefim oefim jefufl jefuflg*f g*fufl uflgg xgd|u xgd|u oe`gagr& Ye|mg{ agj ogndgf ye|mg{ le|md ygfhg| oergr|m oghm jeredg }gfh jefuf|u| m`ju lm jgfg lgf dg{gf {uf auhg& Crgfh*crgfh }gfh oerngym` lg`gj oe`gagr lgf oerdgr}g lmyeogodgf jeredg ye`g`u jefej{g|dgf lmym{`mf lm g|gy yejug |mflgdgf lgf {eroug|gf& Yejug aglxg` oe`gagr }gfh |e`gn lmyuyuf jeredg |gg|m lefhgf mdn`gy& Jeredg je`gdygfgdgff}g lefh lefhgf gf {efu {efun n yejg yejgfh fhg| g|&& _e`g _e`g jefh jefhcr crog ogfd fdgf gf g{g g{g ygag ygag lejm lejm {era {eraug ugfh fhgf gf jefehgddgf lmym{`mf {rmoglm&
Uf|u Uf|ud d
jefh jefhg| g|gy gymm
{erj {erjgy gyg` g`gn gngf gf lg`g lg`gj j
oe`g oe`gag agrr
ymyx ymyxgg
jeje jejer` r`ud udgf gf
omjomfhgf omjomfhgf oe`gagr yeigrg ebed|mb, ebed|mb, }gm|u }gm|u `eomn {rgd|my lgf jefhgrgn jefhgrgn de{glg ng` }gfh yelgfh lmnglg{m& lmnglg{m& Jgyg`gn Jgyg`gn oe`gagr oe`gagr jeru{gdgf jeru{gdgf jgyg`gn }gfh yermfh |eraglm {glg gfgd*gfgd lm yedc`gn, dgrefg m|u oe|g{g {ef|mfhf}g {ergfgf crgfh |ug lg`gj uygng uf|ud jefhg|gym deyu`m|gf oe`gagr ymyxg, ghgr g{g }gfh lmngrg{dgf lg{g| |erig{gm lefhgf ogmd& Omjomfhgf Omjomfhgf jejehgfh jejehgfh {ergfgf {ergfgf {ef|mfh {ef|mfh ogmd oerymbg| mflmmlug` mflmmlug` jgu{uf de`cj{cd& Omjomfhgf }gfh oerymbg| mflmmlug` jgdyulf}g yeyug|u }gfh lmoermdgf de{g de{glg lg ymyx ymyxgg jeju jejug| g| g{g g{g }gfh }gfh mg |erm |ermjg jg,, lmlef lmlefhg hgrr lgf lgf g{g g{g }gfh }gfh mg gjg| gjg|mm yenm yenmfh fhhg hg jefa jefagl glmm jm`m jm`md d mflm mflmm mlu lu&& Omjo Omjomf mfhg hgf f de`c de`cj{ j{cd cd lm`g lm`gdu dudg dgf f yeig yeigrg rg de`cj{cd de{glg ymyxg }gfh oerjgyg`gn&
?&9 [efher|mgf Jef}mjgd
Jef Jefuru uru|
\grmh rmhgf
.7== .7==<1 <1?> ?>-, -,
‐Jef} Jef}mj mjggd
glg`gn `gn
yug yug|u
{rc {rcyey yey
jeflefhg jeflefhgrdgf rdgf `gjogfh*`gj `gjogfh*`gjogfh ogfh `mygf lefhgf lefhgf {efun {efun {erng|mgf {erng|mgf,, {ejgngjg {ejgngjgf, f, g{rey g{reymgy mgym, m, yer|g yer|g mf|er{r mf|er{re|g e|gym ym uf|ud uf|ud jej{e jej{erc` rc`en en mfbcrj mfbcrjgym gym,, jefgfh jefgfhdg{ dg{ mym g|gu g|gu {eygf {eygf yer|g yer|g jejgng jejgngjm jm jgdfg jgdfg dcjuf dcjufmdg mdgym ym }gfh }gfh |e`gn |e`gn lmygj{ lmygj{gmd gmdgf gf c`en c`en ygfh ygfh {ejomigrg je`g`um uagrgf g|gu ogngyg `mygf&‚ Jef Jefuru uru|
Erlmf rlmfgg
.7== .7==>1 >188-,,
‐Jef} Jef}mj mjggd
{gl {glg
ngd ngdmdg mdg|f} |f}g
glg`g lg`gn n
jefl jeflef efhg hgrd rdgf gf lgf lgf jejgn jejgngj gjmm mym mym ogng ogngf f ymjg ymjgdg dgf& f&‚‚ C`en C`en dgre dgrefg fg m|u, m|u, lg{g lg{g|| lmymj{u`dgf ognxg |uaugf u|gjg jef}mjgd glg`gn jefgfhdg{, jejgngjm, g|gu jefhng}g|m {eygf, mle, hghgygf }gfh |erymrg| lg`gj ogngf ymjgdgf&
?&< Oerm|g ?&<&7 [efher|mgf Oerm|g
Oerm|g glg`gn ngym` redcfy|rudym |er|u`my lgrm reg`m|gy ycymg` }gfh |erlg{g| lg`gj denmlu{gf& M|u`gn yeogof}g glg crgfh }gfh oergfhhg{gf ognxg {efu`mygf oerm|g oerm|g `eomn `eomn jeru{g jeru{gdgf dgf {eder {ederagg aggf f jeredc jeredcfy| fy|rud rudymd ymdgf gf reg`m|g reg`m|gyy ycymg` ycymg` lgrm{ lgrm{glg glg hgjog hgjogrgf rgf lgrm lgrm reg`m|g reg`m|gyy m|u yeflm yeflmrm& rm& [eflg{ [eflg{g| g| Fgfi} Fgfi} Fgyu|m Fgyu|mcf cf .lg`gj .lg`gj Ogyud Ogyudm, m, 7=>917- jef}eou|dgf ognxg oerm|g mg`g `g{crgf |ef|gfh {ermy|mxg*{ermy|mxg }gfh |eragl |eraglm, m, }gfh }gfh mfhmf mfhmf lmde|g lmde|gnum num c`en c`en ujuj, ujuj, lefhg lefhgf f ymbg|* ymbg|*ymb ymbg| g| gd|ug` gd|ug`,, |eragl |eraglmm lm
`mfhd `mfhdufh ufhgf gf {ejog {ejogig, ig, jefhe jefhefgm fgm |cdcn |cdcn |erdeju |erdejudg, dg, gdmog| gdmog| {ermy| {ermy|mxg mxg |eryeo |eryeou| u| oer{efhgrun |ernglg{ {ejogig& [urxglgrj [urxglgrjmf|g mf|g .7==>.7==>- jefhg|gd jefhg|gdgf gf ognxg oerm|g glg`gn glg`gn `g{crgf `g{crgf |ef|gfh |ef|gfh yg|u deaglmgf }gfh |erogru& Delug {efher|mgf mfm jefmjou`dgf {eflg{g| ognxg |mlgd |mlgd yejug yejug }gfh }gfh |er|u`my |er|u`my lg`gj lg`gj yurg| yurg| dgogr dgogr g|gu g|gu jgag`g jgag`gn n omyg omyg lmyeo lmyeou| u| yeogh yeoghgm gm oerm|g oerm|g&& Md`gf Md`gf lgf reye{ reye{ jgygdg jgygdgf f |mlgd |mlgd omyg omyg lmyeou lmyeou|| oerm|g oerm|g&& ]gfh ]gfh lmyeou lmyeou|| oerm|g oerm|g glg`gn `g{crgf |ef|gfh yeougn {ermy|mxg& Lefhgf {erdg|ggf `gmf, yeougn {ermy|mxg |mlgd gdgf {erfgn jefaglm oerm|g om`g {ermy|mxg |eryeou| |mlgd lm`g{crdgf&
?&<&? Fm`gm*fm`gm Oerm|g
\mlgd ye|mg{ oerm|g omyg lmaglmdgf lmaglmdgf oerm|g aurfg`my|md& aurfg`my|md& Glg udurgf*ud udurgf*udurgf urgf |er|ef |er|ef|u |u }gfh }gfh lm{efu lm{efunm nm ghgr ghgr yug|u yug|u deagl deaglmgf mgf g|gu g|gu {ermy {ermy|mxg |mxg lg{g| lg{g| lmoerm| lmoerm|gdg gdgf& f& Fexy Rg`ue Rg`ue-, }gm|u Udur Udurgf gf mfm mfm lmye lmyeou ou|| yeog yeoghg hgmm Drm|e Drm|ermg rmg @g}g @g}gd d Oerm| Oerm|gg . Fexy }gm|u `g}gd `g}gd
|mlgdf}g |mlgdf}g yug|u {ermy|mxg {ermy|mxg lm|u`my c`en yug|u jelmg& Jefuru| Ngrmgf|c .?;;817-, .?;;817-, {ermy|mxg {ermy|mxg }gfh lmgfhhg{ lmgfhhg{ jej{uf}gm jej{uf}gm fm`gm oerm|g g|gu `g}gd oerm|g glg`gn glg`gn }gfh }gfh jefhgflufh yg|u g|gu oeoerg{g ufyur oermdu| mfm1 7& Gi|ug` .dedmfmgf-& [ermy|mxg lm`m{u| lgf lm|u`my dgrefg ogru ygag |eraglm g|gu jefhgflufh ng` dedmfmgf& Amdg {ermy|mxg yulgn `exg|, jgdg lmgfhhg{ ogym& Icf|cn1 Gigrg Lmg`ch Mf|ergd|mb ‐Dedergygf Yedyug` lg`gj _ujgn \gfhhg‐ }gfh lmglgdgf c`en UDJ [efu`my UJ {glg |gfhhg` ?9 Fc{ejoer ?;;2, gdgf jefaglm |mlgd gi|ug` amdg oerm|gf}g lmjug| yejmfhhu dejulmgf Ymhfmdgfym .{ef|mfh-& .{ef|mfh-& [ermy|m ?& Ymhfmdgfym [ermy|mxg xg {ef|mf {ef|mfh h }gfh }gfh oer{e oer{e`ug `ugfh fh jej{ef jej{efhg hgrun runmm
denmlu denmlu{g {gf f crgfh crgfh ogf}gd ogf}gd,, g|gu g|gu deagl deaglmgf mgf }gfh }gfh jej{uf jej{uf}g }gmm gdmog| gdmog| |erngl |ernglg{ g{ denmlu{gf {ejogig& Icf|cn Icf|cn11 oefig oefigfg fg g`gj g`gj \yufgj \yufgjmm jefag jefaglm lm {ermy|m {ermy|mxg xg ygfhg| ygfhg| {ef|m {ef|mfh fh dgref dgrefg g lgj{gdf}g ygfhg| oeygr, ogmd dcrogf amxg jgu{uf deruhmgf jg|ermg`&
9& Jghfm|ule .oeygr-& [ermy|mxg oeygr }gfh oer{efhgrun oghm denmlu{gf crgfh ogf}gd, g|gu {ermy|mxg }gfh jef}gfhdu| gfhdg*gfhdg }gfh om`g lmauj`gndgf gdgf ygfhg| jefgrmd oghm {ejogig& Icf|cn1 oefigfg g`gj \yufgjm lm Gien jefaglm oeygr dgrefg lgrm yedmgf ogf}g ogf}gdd lgergn lgergn }gfh }gfh |erde |erdefg fg \yufgj \yufgjm& m& Gien Gien glg`gn glg`gn lgerg lgergn n }gfh }gfh {g`mfh {g`mfh
|eroey |eroeygr gr lg`gj lg`gj auj`gn auj`gn deruy deruygd gdgf gf lgf auj`gn auj`gn dcrogf dcrogf&& Icf|cn Icf|cn `gmf glg`g glg`gn n gfhdg lrc{ cu| jgngymyxg }gfh jefig{gm gfhdg rg|uygf&
<& [rc~mjm|} .deledg|gf-& [ermy|mxg }gfh |eraglm ledg| lefhgf {ejogig& Omgygf}g, deledg|gf mfm oerymbg| hechrgbmy g|gu ejcymcfg`& Icf|cn1 `elgdgf ocj lm Mflmg lgf Og`m }gfh jgymfh*jgymfh jefexgydgf 7; crgfh& Crgfh Mflcfeymg gdgf jejm`mn jejogig `elgdgf ocj lm Og`m |er`eomn lgnu`u lgrm{glg `elgdgf ocj lm Mflmg&
5& [rcjmfefie .|efgr-& [ermy|mxg }gfh jef}gfhdu| crgfh, oeflg g|gu |ej{g| }gfh |erdefg` g|gu ygfhg| lmdefg` c`en {ejogig& Icf|cn1 {erde`gnmgf gf|grg Xg`mdc|g lgf Xgdm` Xg`mdc|g g|gu {ejuhgrgf Igflm Ocrcoulur&
2& Nujgf Mf|erey| .jgfuymgxm-& [ermy|mxg }gfh jejoerm yef|ungf {ergyggf oghm {ejogig& Omgygf}g, {ermy|mxg jef}gfhdu| crgfh omgyg lg`gj ym|ugym `ugr omgyg, g|gu crgfh oeygr lg`gj ym|ugym omgyg& Icf|cn1 {ermy|mxg c{ergym dejogr ymgj g|gu _ed|cr UJ je`mng| dcfyerf}g \gfm Jgau&
8& Dcfb`md& [ermy|mxg }gfh jefhnglmrdgf lug {mngd }gfh yg`mfh oer`gxgfgf de{ef|mfhgf& Icf|cn Icf|cn11 {ermy|m {ermy|mxg xg {erg {ergfh fh lm Gien, Gien, lejcfy lejcfy|rgy |rgymm jefef jefef|gf |gfh h {ejogf {ejogfhuf hufgf gf JG\CY, {er|gflmfhgf Grejg je`gxgf [eryeog}g, {erye`mymngf gf|grg _ed|cr lefhgf jgngymyxg&
>& \ne Ufyug` .|mlgd omgyg-& [ermy|mxg }gfh |mlgd omgyg |eraglm& Icf|cn Icf|cn11 xgfm|g xgfm|g }gfh }gfh jejm`md jejm`mdmm |mfhhm |mfhhm =; ij jefagl jefaglmm {ejgmf {ejgmf ogyde ogyde|| }gfh }gfh ygfhg| gflg`&
\mlgd yejug `g{crgf |ef|gfh deaglmgf {gf|gy lm`g{crdgf de{glg dng`g}gd& [er|efhdgrgf gf|grg yugjm*my|rm crgfh deogf}gdgf |mlgd {er`u lm`g{crdgf de{glg dng`g} dng`g}gd gd&& [edera [ederagg ggf f yecrg yecrgfh fh lcyef lcyef jejomj jejomjomf omfh h jgngy jgngymyx myxgg auhg auhg |mlgd |mlgd {er`u {er`u lm`g{c lm`g{crdg rdgf f de{gl de{glgg dng`g} dng`g}gd& gd& Lm ygj{m ygj{mfh fh jeru{g jeru{gdgf dgf {ermy| {ermy|mxg mxg ru|mf, ru|mf, delug delug {ermy|mxg {ermy|mxg |eryeou| |eryeou| auhg |mlgd jejm`mdm fm`gm oerm|g& Ye`gfau|f} Ye`gfau|f}g, g, drm|ermg {ermy|mxg {ermy|mxg }gfh {g|u| lm`g{crdgf de{glg dng`g}gd, }gm|u {ermy|mxg }gfh jejm`mdm fm`gm oerm|g& Fm`gm oerm|g yeflmrm, jefuru| Au`mgf Ngrrmyy, Ngrrmyy, De``} @em|er @em|er lgf Y|gf`e} Acnfycf, Acnfycf,
jefhgflufh le`g{gf ufyur, }gm|u1 dcfb`md, dejgaugf, {ef|mfh, ledg|, gd|ug`, ufmd, jgfuymgxm, lgf oer{efhgrun .lg`gj G`meb, ?;;>19-& Gr|mf}g, yeoe`uj yeyecrgfh je`g{crdg je`g{crdgf f yeougn yeougn {ermy|mxg, {ermy|mxg, mg {er`u jefhdcfbmr jefhdcfbmrjgymd jgymdgff} gff}gg lefhgf lefhgf drm|ermg* drm|ermg* drm|ermg |eryeou|& 7- Dcfb`md
Mfbcrjgym }gfh jefhhgjogrdgf {er|ef|gfhgf gf|gr jgfuymg, ogfhyg lgf fehgrg {er`u lm`g{crdgf de{glg dng`g}gd& Lefhgf oehm|u dng`g}gd julgn uf|ud jefhgjom` ymdg{& ?- Dejgaugf
Mfbcrjgym Mfbcrjgym |ef|gfh |ef|gfh dejgaugf dejgaugf m`ju {efhg|gn {efhg|gnugf ugf lgf |edfc`chm |edfc`chm yefgf|mgy yefgf|mgygg {er`u {er`u lm`g{cr lm`g{crdg dgf f de{glg de{glg dng`g} dng`g}gd gd&& Lefhg Lefhgf f lejmdmg lejmdmgf, f, dng`g} dng`g}gd gd jefhe jefhe|gn |gnum um dejgau dejgaugf gf {erglg {erglg{g {gf f jefuy jefuymg& mg& [ef|mfh [ef|mfh Mfbcrj Mfbcrjgym gym }gfh }gfh {ef|mf {ef|mfh h oghm oghm dng`g} dng`g}gd gd lg`gj lg`gj rgfhdg rgfhdg jefag`gfm jefag`gfm denmlu{gf denmlu{gf jeredg yengrm*ngr yengrm*ngrmm {er`u yeherg lm`g{crdg lm`g{crdgf f de{glg dng`g}gd&
9- Ledg|
Mfbcrj Mfbcrjgy gymm }gfh }gfh jejm`md jejm`mdmm deledg deledg|gf |gf ejcym ejcym lgf lgf agrgd agrgd hechr hechrgbm gbmyy lefhg lefhgf f dng`g} dng`g}gd gd {er`u {er`u yeherg yeherg lm`g{ lm`g{crd crdgf& gf& Jgdmf Jgdmf ledg| ledg| yg|u yg|u `cdgy `cdgymm {ermy {ermy|mx |mxgg lefhg lefhgf f |ej{g| dng`g}gd, mfbcrjgymf}g gdgf jgdmf lmyudgm dng`g}gd& <- Gd|ug`
Mfbcrjgym Mfbcrjgym |ef|gfh {ermy|mxg }gfh ufmd, }gfh agrgfh |eraglm {er`u yeherg yeherg lm`g{crdgf de{glg dng`g}gd& Ogf}gd yedg`m {ermy|mxg }gfh ufmd, jmyg`f}g jcom` oerjgmf ye{gd oc`g, {erdgxgfgf jgfuymg lefhgf hcrm`g, lgf yeoghgmf}g& 5- Jgfuymgxm
Mfbc Mfbcrj rjgy gymm }gfh }gfh omyg omyg jef} jef}ef ef|u |un n ejcy ejcymm dng` dng`g} g}gd gd,, ye{e ye{er|m r|m }gfh }gfh omyg omyg jejoug| jejoug| jefgfhmy jefgfhmy,, |erngru, |erngru, |er|gxg, |er|gxg, lgf yeoghgmf}g yeoghgmf}g,, {er`u lm`g{crdg lm`g{crdgf f de{glg de{glg dng`g}g g}gd&
Lefhg fhgf
oeh oehm|u m|u,
dng`g} `g}gd
gdgf dgf
omyg myg
jefmfh mfhdg|dg |dgf
|gr |grgb
dejgfuymggff}g& 2- Oer{efhgrun
Mfbcrjgym jefhefgm {ermy|mxg }gfh oer{efhgrun |ernglg{ denmlu{gf crgfh ogf}gd ogf}gd {er`u lm`g{crdg lm`g{crdgf f de{glg de{glg dng`g}gd dng`g}gd&& Jmyg`f}g Jmyg`f}g mfbcrjgym mfbcrjgym |ef|gfh |ef|gfh c{ergym c{ergym
{gygr Ou`ch, mfbcrjgym |ef|gfh ogfamr, lgf yeoghgmf}g& Auj`gn ufyur fm`gm oerm|g }gfh ngruy lm{efunm ye|mg{ {ermy|mxg yeoe`uj lmaglmdgf oerm|g oeroelg {glg ye|mg{ {eferom|gf {ery& Glg yurg| dgogr }gfh jefe|g{dgf ngf}g `mjg ufyur fm`gm oerm|g& \e|g{m \e|g{m,, glg auhg }gfh }gfh efgj efgj ufyur& ufyur& ]gfh ]gfh ae`gy, ae`gy, jgdmf jgdmf ogf}g ogf}gd d yeoug yeougn n {erm|mx {erm|mxgg jejm`mdm ufyur fm`gm oerm|g, jgdmf oeygr dejufhdmfgf oerm|gf}g lmymgrdgf c`en {eferom|gf {ery&
?&<&9 Aefmy*Aefmy Oerm|g
Dg`gu dm|g ye{gdg| ognxg }gfh jefaglm ogngf lgygr oerm|g glg`gn reg`m|gy ycymg` lg`gj oef|ud {ermy|mxg, jgdg ae`gy {ermy|mxg m|u oerjgigj*jgigj& Glg {erm {ermy| y|mx mxgg crgf crgfh h oerye oeryejm jmfg fgr& r& Glg Glg {u`g {u`g {erm {ermy| y|mxg mxg {ejo {ejouf ufun ungf gf&& Ognd Ogndgf gf glg glg {ermy|mxg {ejog|g`gf YMU[[& Uf|ud jejulgndgf {efhhc`cfhgf aefmy*aefmy oerm|g oerlgygr oerlgygrdgf dgf {ermy|mxg {ermy|mxg }gfh |eraglm lg`gj lg`gj denmlu{gf denmlu{gf jgfuymg, jgfuymg, Ogyudm Ogyudm jejoghm jejoghm oerm|g oerm|g oerlg oerlgyg ygrdg rdgf1 f1 .7- ymbg| ymbg| deagl deaglmgf mgf44 .?- jgyg`g jgyg`gn n }gfh }gfh lmigdu lmigdu{4 {4 .9- `mfhdu{ `mfhdu{ {ejoerm|ggf4 lgf .<- ymbg| {ejoerm|ggf .Ogyudm 7=>915-& 7- Oerlgygrdgf Ymbg| Deaglmgf
Oerlgygrdgf ymbg| deaglmgf |erlg{g| ej{g| aefmy oerm|g, }gm|u1 g& Oerm|g Oerm|g }gfh }gfh gdgf gdgf |eraglm |eraglm&& Jmyg`f Jmyg`f}g }g11 xgxgf xgxgfigr igrgg yecrg yecrgfh fh xgr|gx xgr|gxgf gf lefhg lefhgf f Hcefgxgf Jcngjgl }gfh |gj{m` lg`gj yeougn yejmfgr& o& Oerm|g Oerm|g |ef|gfh |ef|gfh {ermy|mxg }gfh |eraglm |eraglm jeflglgd jeflglgd ycf|gd& ycf|gd& Jmyg`f}g1 Jmyg`f}g1 {ermy|mxg {ermy|mxg deogdgrgf dgf|cr yef|rg` |e`e{cf& i& Oerm|g Oerm|g |ef|gfh {ermy|mxg {ermy|mxg }gfh lmrefigfgdg lmrefigfgdgf f gdgf |eraglm& Jmyg`f}g1 Jmyg`f}g1 {ermy|mxg {ermfhg|gf Ngrm @mfhdufhgf Nmlu{ ye|mg{ 5 Aufm& l& Oerm Oerm|g |g |ef|g |ef|gfh fh hgou hgoufh fhgf gf {ermy {ermy|mx |mxgg |erl |erluh uhgg lgf lgf |mlgd |mlgd |erl |erluh uhg& g& Jmyg` Jmyg`f} f}g1 g1 {ermy|mxg {ericoggf {ejoufungf de{g`g fehgrg {glg gigrg {ermfhg|gf Jgu`ml Fgom Jungjjgl YGX&
?- Oerlgygrdgf Jgyg`gn }gfh Lmigdu{
Jgyg`g Jgyg`gn n lm ymfm ymfm omgygf omgygf}g }g jerua jeruaud ud de{glg de{glg gy{ed gy{ed denml denmlu{g u{gf f }gfh }gfh glg glg lm |efhgn |efhgn*|e *|efhg fhgn n jgy}grg jgy}grgdg| dg|&& Yeigrg Yeigrg ujuj, ujuj, |erlg{ |erlg{g| g| ej{g| ej{g| gy{ed gy{ed denmlu denmlu{g {gf f
jgfuymg, }gm|u1 gy{ed ycymg`, edcfcjm, {c`m|md, lgf deoulg}ggf& Oermdu| icf|cn oerm|g gy{ed ycymg`, edcfcjm, {c`m|md, lgf deoulg}ggf& Icf|cn1 Oerm|g Gy{ed Ycymg` [ghe`g [ghe`grgf rgf {ermfh {ermfhg|g g|gf f NU\ de* <> Ogfd Ogfd Agogr Agogr Ogf|ef Ogf|ef }gfh }gfh oer`gfhyufh {edgf `g`u lm Gu`g Ogfd Agogr Ogf|ef, ag`gf Fgrm{gf 7?*7< Ogflufh, lmmym lefhgf oeroghgm dehmg|gf ycymg`& Lm gf|grgf}g, yufg|gf jgyg` de{glg 7;; crgfh gfgd, ygf|ufgf de{glg {efymufgf |efghg lgygr, lgf ogf|ugf {eflmlmdgf de{glg ?; }g}gygf&
Icf|cn1 Oerm|g Edcfcjm Uf|u Uf|ud d deye deyedm dmgf gf dg`m dg`mf} f}gg [\& [\& [cy [cy Mflcf flcfey eymg mg oery oerygj gjgg [\ \E@DCJ \E@DCJ je`gdu je`gdudgf dgf g`mgf g`mgfym ym y|rg|e y|rg|ehmy hmy lg`gj lg`gj ng` {ejgfb {ejgfbgg| gg|gf gf yujoer lg}g {eruygnggf, }gfh lm|ugfhdgf lg`gj yug|u {eragfamgf deragygjg deragygjg&& Fc|g deye{gng deye{gngjgf jgf |eryeou| |eryeou| lm|gflg|gf lm|gflg|gfhgfm hgfm {edgf {edgf `g`u c`en Xgdm` Lmru|{cy, M De|u| Jgrlagfg, lgf Lmru| [\& \E@DCJ, _mfg _mfg`l `lmm Bmrj Bmrjgf gfy} y}gn gn,, }gfh }gfh lmyg lmygdy dymd mdgf gf Jef|e Jef|erm rm Fehg Fehgrg rg OUJF OUJF Ycb}gf Lag`m`, lm Dgf|cr Dejef|rmgf Dejef|rmgf OUJF Agdgr|g&
Icf|cn1 Oerm|g [c`m|md Uf|u Uf|ud d
jefm jefmfh fhdg dg|d |dgf gf
dejg dejgj{ j{ug ugf f
[e|u [e|uhg hgyy
[efh [efhgx gxgy gy
@g{gfhgf lgf Deigjg|gf jefhnglg{m [m`{rey ?;;=, [gfxgy`u Dc|g [g} [g}gdujo dujou un
jefh jefhgl glggdgf
‐[e`g [e`g|m |mng ngf f,
Omjo mjomfh mfhgf
\ed \edfmy fmy
[efhgxgy [efhgxgygf gf lgf [e`gfhhgr [e`gfhhgrgf gf [glg [ejm`mngf [ejm`mngf [reymlef [reymlef ?;;=‚, ?;;=‚, lm Nc|e` Ouflc Dgflufh, Dc|g [g}gdujoun& [e`g|mngf m|u lmmdu|m c`en yedm|gr 7;; crgfh [e|uhgy [efhgxgy @g{gfhgf .[gfxgy @g{gfhgf- lgf [gfxgy Deigjg|gf, lefhgf fgrg yujo ujoer Yulmr ulmrjg jgf f L|& [glu [gludc dc \ug \ugf .De .De|ug |ug [gf [gfxgy xgy`u Dc|g Dc|g [g}gdujoun-4
E`bgmq,
YN
.Gfhhc|g
[gfxgy`u
Dc|g
[g}gdujoun#Dccrlmfg|cr Omlgfh [efhgxgygf lgf Nuoufhgf Gf|gr @ejogh oghg- lgf lgf ]uyr ]uyrm` m` ]gqml, qml, YN .Gfh .Gfhh hc|g c|g [gf [gfxgy xgy`u Dc|g Dc|g [g}gdujoun#Dccrlmfg|cr Omlgfh \ejugf lgf [e`gfhhgrgf-&
Icf|cn1 Oerm|g Gy{ed Deoulg}ggf Dgrefg yeagd Jmfhhu {ghm nmfhhg ymgfh ngrm |e`gn oer`gfhyufh gigrg {ejo {ejogi gigg ggf f
lcg* lcg*lc lcgg
deye deye`g `gjg jg|g |gf# f#my my|m |mhn hncy cygn gn
oery oerygj gjgg
}gfh gfh
lm`gf|ufdg lm`gf|ufdgf f yeigrg yeigrg oerhgf|mgf oerhgf|mgf c`en oe`gygf oe`gygf {grg Dmgm |erfgjg |erfgjg lgrm oeroghgm deigjg|gf }gfh |eryeogr lm Dgou{g|ef Ogf}ujgy, lmmdu|m c`en c`en {grg {grg ygf| ygf|rmx rmxgf gf#y #ygf gf|r |rmx mxg| g|mm lgf lgf xgrh xgrhgg deig deigjg jg|g |gf f ye|e ye|ej{ j{g| g|&& Yelgf Yelgfhdg hdgf f {glg {glg jmfhhu jmfhhu jg`gj jg`gj ngrmf} ngrmf}gg |e`gn |e`gn oer`gf oer`gfhy hyufh ufh gigrg gigrg {ghe`g {ghe`grgf rgf xg}gfh xg}gfh du`m| du`m| yejg` yejg`gj gj yuf|ud yuf|ud,, }gfh }gfh lmjgmf lmjgmfdg dgf f c`en c`en Dm Lg`gfh Lg`gfh Ef|nuy Ef|nuy Yuyjcfc Yuyjcfc lefhgf lefhgf jefgj{m`dg jefgj{m`dgf f `gdcf ierm|g _glef _glef Hg|c|dgig Jefuf|u| Agfam .de{glg {grg lexg|g-&
Yemrmfh lefhgf {erdejogfhgf jgy}grgdg|, deej{g| gy{ed mfm |ergyg |mlgd jejglgm jejglgm `ghm& Mg {er`u lm{eign lm{eign `ghm jefaglm jefaglm oeroghgm oeroghgm gy{ed& Dgrefg m|u, |mlgd glg yg`gnf}g jefhhc`cfhdgf aefmy oerm|g oerlgygrdgf jgyg`gn }gfh lmigdu{ jefuru| auj` auj`gn gn deje dejef| f|rm rmgf gf }gfh }gfh glg glg lg`g lg`gj j Dgom Dgomfe fe|| [ejo [ejogf gfhu hufg fgf f 2& G|gy G|gy lgyg lgygrr {ejmdmrgf mfm, aefmy*aefmy oerm|g |eryeou| jefaglm1 oerm|g lg`gj feherm, oerm|g `ugr feherm feherm,, oerm|g oerm|g nuduj, nuduj, oerm|g oerm|g ycymg ycymg`, `, oerm|g oerm|g {eflmlm {eflmlmdgf dgf lgf deoul deoulg} g}ggf ggf,, oerm|g oerm|g {er|gfmgf {er|gfmgf,, oerm|g `mfhdufhgf `mfhdufhgf nmlu{, nmlu{, oerm|g {erujgngf, {erujgngf, oerm|g oerm|g {ejulg {ejulg lgf c`en rghg, oerm|g |rgfyjmhrgym, oerm|g deyeng|gf, oerm|g m`ju {efhe|gnugf, oerm|g dc{erym, oerm|g {er|gfgngf, oerm|g {efergfhgf, oerm|g {ermfluy|rmgf, oerm|g {erogfdgf, oerm|g {ern {ernuo uouf ufhg hgf, f, oerm| oerm|gg {erl {erlgh ghgf gfhg hgf, f, oerm| oerm|gg denu denu|g |gfg fgf, f, oerm oerm|g |g ghgj ghgjg, g, oerm oerm|g |g {er|gjogfhgf, lgf oerm|g {gfhgf& Icf|cn1 Yulgn jefaglm deieflrufhgf lgrm de`ugrhg yedgrgfh yedgrgfh uf|ud jejm`mdm auj`gn gfgd }gfh `eomn deim` lgrm{glg de`ugrhg }gfh `eomn yefmc yefmcrr uymgf uymgf}g }g&Dm &Dm|g |g {er`u {er`u uf|ud uf|ud oer|e oer|ermj rmjgg dgymn dgymn g|gy g|gy {rchr {rchrgj gj DO }gfh yulgn `gjg lm`ufiurdgf c`en {ejermf|gn& Dg`gu oehm|u g{gdgn gfgd*gfg gfgd*gfgd d lgrm de`ugrhg de`ugrhg deim` deim` nmlu{ `eomn oeruf|ufh oeruf|ufh lmogflmfhdgf lmogflmfhdgf lefhgf gfgd*gfgd lgnu`u lgrm de`ugrhg oeygr& Lgrm yehm {er|ujoungf omc`chm omyg lmagxgo ‐}g‚ dgrefg de`ugrhg deim` omyg jef}elmgdgf
deou|ungf ogngf ygflgfh lgf {gfhgf }gfh `eomn ogmd& \e|g{m lgrm yehm yehm {er| {er|uj ujou oung ngf f jef|g jef|g`, `, ejcy ejcymc mcfg fg`` lgf lgf ycym ycymg` g` ,{gl ,{glgg yeog yeoghm hmgf gf de`ugrhg deim` yedgrgfh, {er`u |e`ggn `eomn `gfau|& 9- Oerlgygrdgf @mfhdu{ [ejoerm|ggf
@mfhdu{ {ejoerm|ggf, omgygf}g, lmoghm jefaglm ej{g| oghmgf, }gm|u `cdg`, rehmcfg`, fgymcfg`, lgf mf|erfgymcfg`& Yeougn oerm|g lmyeou| oer`mfhdu{ `cdg` dg`gu {ermy|mxg }gfh lm`g{crdgff}g |eraglm lm yeougn dgou{g|ef lgf gdmog|f}g ngf}g lmrgygdgf lm lgergn m|u, g|gu {g`mfh*{g`mfh lm dgou{g|ef `gmf lg`gj {rc{mfym }gfh ygjg& Yeougn oerm|g lmyeou| oer`mfhdu{ fgymcfg` dg`gu {e`g{crgf {ermy|mxg }gfh |eraglm lm yg|u fehgrg lg{g| lmrgygdgf lm fehgrg `gmf& Icf|cn1 Jefuru Jefuru|| Lg|g Lg|g Oglgf Oglgf Mfbcrj Mfbcrjgy gymm lgf lgf Dcjufm Dcjufmdgy dgymm Yujg|e Yujg|erg rg U|grg, U|grg, Dc|g \eomfh \mfhhm jeru{gdgf yg`gn yg|u {ejermf|gngf dc|g lgrm ?= Dgou{g|ef # Dc|g lm Yujg|erg U|grg oeragrgd yedm|gr >; dj lgrm Dc|g Jelgf .Moudc|g [rcmfym Yujg|erg U|grg- yer|g |er`e|gd {glg `mf|gy u|gjg u|gjg Yujg|e Yujg|erg, rg, }gm|u }gm|u jefhn jefhnuou uoufhd fhdgf gf @mf|gy @mf|gy \mjur \mjur lgf @mf|gy @mf|gy \efhg \efhgn n Yujg|e Yujg|erg rg je`g`u je`g`umm `mf|gy `mf|gy lmghc lmghcfg` fg` {glg {glg rugy rugy Ag`gf Ag`gf \eomfh \eomfh \mfhhm, [ejg|gfh Ymgf|gr, [grg{g|, Og`mhe, lgf Ymocrcfh ’ Ocrcfh&
<- Oerlgygrdgf Ymbg| [ejoerm|ggf
Ymbg| Ymbg| oerm|g oerm|g omyg omyg lm`mng lm`mng|| lgrm lgrm mymf} mymf}g& g& Glg mym oerm|g oerm|g }gfh }gfh jejoer jejoerm|g m|gnu, nu, jeflmlmd, jefhnmour, jejoermdgf icf|cn, jej{efhgrunm, lgf yeoghgmf}g& Omyg yg}g yg}g yeougn yeougn oerm|g oerm|g jej{uf jej{uf}g }gmm ymbg| ymbg| `eomn `eomn lgrm lgrm yg|u& yg|u& \e|g{ \e|g{m, m, ymbg| ymbg| oerm|g oerm|g }gfh }gfh |eru|gjg glg`gn jejoerm|gnu& Icf|cn1 Juy{ Juy{md mdgg Ygjo Ygjogy gy,, |e`g |e`gn n jefh jefhmj mjog ogu u {grg {grg {efau {efaug` g` {e|g {e|gyg ygf f ghgr ghgr jefhnef|mdgf gd|mm|gyf}g& Jeredg jejoermdgf og|gy g|gu legl`mfe yg|u
jmfh mfhhu
ye|e` |e`gn
de`ugrf}g f}g
mjogugf
oerygjg
}gfh
lm|gfl lm|gflg|g g|gfhg fhgfm fm Lgfrgj Lgfrgjm`, m`, Igjg| Igjg| lgf Dg{c` Dg{c`ye yed d Ygjog Ygjogyy m|u& m|u& Amdg mjogugf |mlgd lmhuormy jeredg gdgf je`gdudgf rgqmg&
?&<&< Ufyur*Ufyur Oerm|g
Yeigrg Yeigrg ujuj, ujuj, ufyur* ufyur*ufy ufyur ur oerm|g oerm|g }gfh }gfh ye`g`u ye`g`u glg {glg {glg yeoug yeougn n oerm|g oerm|g glg`gn1 negl`mfe, legl`mfe, `egl, lgf ocl} .Ogyudm 7=>91??*?5-& 7- Negl`mfe
Omgyg lmyeou| aulu`& Yermfh auhg lm`efhdg{m lefhgf gfgd aulu`& Mg oerhufg uf|ud1 uf|ud1 .7- jefc`c jefc`cfh fh {ejogi {ejogigg ghgr ghgr yeherg yeherg jefhe jefhe|gn |gnum um {ermy {ermy|mx |mxgg }gfh }gfh gdgf gdgf lmoerm|gdgf4 .?- jefcfac`dgf yg|u oerm|g lefhgf ludufhgf |edfmd hrgbmdg& Icf|cn1 ‚Gr|g`}|g Yur}gfm |erlgdxg dgyuy {ef}ug{gf yefm`gm _{2 jm`mgr, lmcfmy 5 |gnuf {efagrg lgf leflg _{?5; au|g&‚ ?- Legl`mfe
Glg }gfh }gfh |erlmr |erlmrmm g|gy g|gy fgjg fgjg jelmg jelmg jgyyg, jgyyg, |ej{g |ej{g|| deagl deaglmgf mgf lgf lgf |gfhh |gfhhg` g` deaglm deaglmgf gf&& Glg {u`g {u`g }gfh }gfh |erlmr |erlmrmm g|gy g|gy fgjg fgjg jelmg jelmg jgyyg jgyyg,, |ej{g| |ej{g| deagl deaglmgf mgf lgf lgf |gfhhg |gfhhg`` deagl deaglmgf mgf&& \uaugf \uaugff} f}gg glg`gn glg`gn uf|ud uf|ud jefufa jefufaudd uddgf gf |ej{g| |ej{g| deagl deaglmgf mgf lgf lgf mfmymg` jelmg& Icf|cn1 Jef Jefuru uru| Igjg Igjg|| Ygjo Ygjoggy, Urg} rg} Ourng urngf fullm ullmf f Y Ycy Ycy de{ de{glg [cf|mg [cf|mgfg fgd d [cy|, [cy|, {mngd {mngdf} f}gg yulgn yulgn je`g}g je`g}gfhd fhdgf gf mjogug mjogugf f de{glg de{glg {efaug` jericf yeagd 9; Cd|coer ?;;9& /Lg`gj u{g}g {eje`mngrggf degjgfgf lgf de|er|mogf ujuj yer|g uf|ud jefhnmflgrm |eraglmf}g ng`*ng` ng`*ng` }gfh }gfh |mlgd lmmfhmfdgf, lmmfhmfdgf, dm|g jmf|g de{glg de{glg jgy}grgd jgy}grgdg| g| g|gu {efa {efaug ug`` jeri jericf cf,, ghgr ghgr |mlg |mlgd d jefa jefaug ug`` ogrg ogrgfh fh |ery |eryeo eou| u|,/ ,/ dg|g dg|g Ourng Ourngful fullmf lmf lm|ejum lm|ejum [cf|mg [cf|mgfg fgd d [cy| [cy| lmye`g lmye`g*ye *ye`g `g dehmg| dehmg|gf gf {gygr {gygr jurg jurgn n lm helu helufh fh [gfi [gfigy gym`g m`g,, dejg dejgrmf rmf&& Amdg Amdg lg`g lg`gj j xgd| xgd|u u yg|u yg|u jmfhh jmfhhu, u, |e|g{ |e|g{ ygag ygag glg }gfh }gfh jejgf jejgfle` le`,, dg|g dg|g Ourng Ourngful fullmf lmf,, |ef|u |ef|u gdgf gdgf lm`gdudgf lm`gdudgf rgqmg& /Jefhg{g /Jefhg{g lejmdmgf, lejmdmgf, dgrefg dgrefg ye`gmf jericf ogrgfh |er`grgfh, auhg ygfhg| oerogng}g& @mng| ygag oeoerg{g |gnuf |ergdnmr |ergdnmr |eraglm |eraglm {ergfh*{e {ergfh*{ergfh rgfhgf gf lefhgf lefhgf jericf jericf dejulmgf dejulmgf |eraglm |eraglm {erde`gnmgf& Mfm dgf jeruhmdgf dm|g yejug,/ dg|g lmg&
9- @egl
@gqmj @gqmj lmyeo lmyeou| u| |ergy |ergy oerm|g oerm|g&& Omgyg Omgygf}g f}g lm|u`m lm|u`myy {glg {glg {grgh {grghrg{ rg{n n {er|gj {er|gjgg yeougn oerm|g& Mg jeru{gdgf ufyur }gfh {g`mfh {ef|mfh lgrm yeougn oerm|g, }gfh
jefef| jefef|udg udgf f g{gdg g{gdgn n mym oerm|g oerm|g gdgf gdgf lmogig lmogig g|gu g|gu |mlgd& |mlgd& Mg jeru{g jeru{gdgf dgf ygrm ygrm {g|m {g|m yeougn oerm|g, }gfh je`udmydgf ye`urun oerm|g yeigrg ymfhdg|& Icf|cn1 Ye`gjg Ye`gjg {erymlgfh {erymlgfhgf, gf, \erlgdxg \erlgdxg Gr|g`}|g Gr|g`}|g Yur}gfm Yur}gfm jefc`gd jefc`gd lm|ulun lm|ulun jef}ug{ agdyg Urm{ lgf jef}g|gdgf {ejoermgf ugfh yeoeygr 22; rmou lc`gr Gjermdg glg`gn ugfh {mfagjgf jclg` uf|ud agdyg Urm{ hufg ufg
de{ef {ef|mf |mfhgf hgf
omyf myfmy
oef oefhde`& de`&
Fgjuf juf,
jgae jgae`m `myy
ngd ngdmj
jef}g jef}g|gd |gdgf gf g`gygf g`gygf |eryeo |eryeou| u| |mlgd |mlgd jgyud jgyud gdg`, gdg`, yg`gn yg`gn yg|u yg|u gfhhc gfhhc|g |g jgae`my ngdmj Gflm Ogin|mgr& <- Ocl}
G|gu |uoun oerm|g& Mymf}g jefierm|gdgf {ermy|mxg }gfh lm`g{crdgf lefhgf ogng ogngyg yg }gfh }gfh ymfh ymfhdg dg|, |, {glg {glg|, |, lgf lgf ae`g ae`gy& y& Lefh Lefhgf gf lejm lejmdm dmgf gf ocl} ocl} jeru{ jeru{gd gdgf gf {erdejogfhgf oerm|g& Icf|cn1 Gr|g`} |g`}|g |g
Yur}g r}gfm
g`mgy mgy
G}mf
lm|g m|gfhdg fhdg{ {
{e|uhgy
dcjmym mym
{ejoergf|gygf dcru{ym gxg` ou`gf Jgre| `g`u yengrm ye|e`gn {e|uhgy jefgfhdg{ agdyg Urm{ lefhgf ugfh lc`gr Gjermdg yefm`gm 2 jm`mgr ru{m ru{mgn gn lm |gfh |gfhgf gf&& Ugfh Ugfh |ery |eryeo eou| u| lmlu lmluhg hg dug| dug| yeog yeoghg hgmm yug{ yug{ g|gy g|gy {efh {efhne nef| f|mg mgf f {ef} {ef}e` e`ml mlmd mdgf gf dgyu dgyuyy O@OM O@OM uf|u uf|ud d ogfd ogfd OLFM OLFM jm`md jm`md Yagj Yagjyu yu`` Fury Furyg` g`mj& mj& Lg`g Lg`gj j {ery {eryml mlgf gfhg hgf f lm|e lm|ejud judgf gf bgd| bgd|gg ognx ognxgg Gr|g`m|g jefhnuoufhm yeauj`gn agdyg ghufh julg |erdgm| jgyg`gn mfm mfm }gfh }gfh deju dejulm lmgf gf jejg jejgdy dygg agdy agdygg ghuf ghufh h Nefl Neflgr grjg jgf f Yu{g Yu{gfa famm jefic{c|m yeauj`gn agdyg ghufh julg }gfh lmluhg |er`mog| dgyuy yug{ |eryeou|&
?&<&5 Y|rud|ur oerm|g
Y|rud| Y|rud|ur ur oerm|g oerm|g ygfhg ygfhg|| lm|ef|u lm|ef|udg dgf f c`en c`en bcrjg| bcrjg| oerm|g oerm|g }gfh }gfh gdgf gdgf lm|u`my lm|u`my&& Y|rud|ur Y|rud|ur oerm|g `gfhyufh `gfhyufh oeroelg oeroelg lefhgf lefhgf oerm|grmfhg oerm|grmfhgf f lgf oerm|g oerm|g dmygn&, dmygn&, |e|g{m, |e|g{m, uf|ud oerm|g `gfhyufh, jefuru| Oruie L& M|u`e lgf Lcuh`gy G& Gflerycf, y|rud|ur }gfh `gqmj ngf}g yg|u, }gm|u {mrgjmlg |erog`md .M|u`e lgf Gflerycf, 7=>812?*29-& Om`g lmydejgdgf, y|rud|ur mfm jefaglm1
Oerlgygrdgf ydejg lm g|gy lg{g| lm`mng| ognxg yejug oghmgf oerm|g ygjg {ef| {ef|mf mfhf hf}g }g&& Y|rud Y|rud|u |urr mfm mfm yermf yermfh h jef} jef}er er|g |gdg dgf f yuo yuo aulu aulu`` {glg {glg oghm oghmgf gf ocl} ocl}&& Y|rud|ur.7Y|rud|ur.7- auhg icicd icicd uf|ud jef}gamdgf jef}gamdgf oerm|g oerm|g yeigrg yeigrg drcfc`chmy drcfc`chmy&& Yelgfhdg Yelgfhdgf f y|rud|ur y|rud|ur .?- jej{er`mn jej{er`mng|dg g|dgf f ocl}, ocl}, }gfh }gfh yejgdmf yejgdmf de ogxgn ogxgn yejgdmf yejgdmf oerdurgf oerdurgfh h ococ|f}g& Y|rud|ur*y| Y|rud|ur*y|rud|u rud|urr oerm|g oerm|g lm g|gy omyg lm{gflgfh lm{gflgfh yeoghgm yeoghgm dergfhdg dergfhdg oerm|g, oerm|g, }gfh gdgf lmmym lefhgf bgd|g& Lg`gj jefhmym dergfhdg oerm|g, yg|u ng` }gfh {er`u lm{erng|mdgf glg`gn de|erdgm|gf mle }gfh lmdgflufh yg|u g`mfeg lefhgf mle }gfh lmdgflufh g`mfeg oermdu|f}g& Dg`gu de|erdgm|gf m|u |mlgd glg, jgdg ierm|gf}g gdgf
|eryeflg|*yeflg|, |mlgd ‚jefhg`mr‚& [efhg`gjgf jefufauddgf, ngf}g oerm|g }gfh |ergyg ‚jefhg`mr‚ ygag }gfh lmyefgfhm c`en dng`g}gd&
?&5 Dcj{cfef#Bgd|cr*Bgd|cr }gfh [ef|mfh lg`gj Jef}mjgd
Jefu Jefuru ru|| \grmh \grmhgf gf .7== .7==<1 <12? 2?-, -, dcj{ dcj{cf cfef ef#b #bgd gd|c |cr* r*bg bgf| f|cr cr {ef| {ef|mfh mfh lg`g lg`gj j jef}mjgd glg`gn yeoghgm oermdu|1 g& jejoelgdg jejoelgdgf f gf|gro gf|grouf}m uf}m bcfejmy, bcfejmy, o& jefhmfhg| jefhmfhg| dejog`m dejog`m dg|g*d dg|g*dg|g, g|g, i& jefhmlef| jefhmlef|mbmdgy mbmdgymm |g|g ogngyg ogngyg lgrm lgrm yede`cj{cd yede`cj{cd dg|g, dg|g, l& jefh jefhml mlef ef|mb |mbmd mdgy gymm
oghm oghmgf gf*o *ogh ghmg mgf f
{rgh {rghjg jg|md |md,,
eyd{ eyd{re reym ym,,
lgf lgf
ye{e ye{erg rgfh fhdg dg||
{efhhufggf }gfh oerbufhym yeoghgm ufm| yejef|grg jefigrm gr|m#jgdfg& e& jefhnuoufhdgf jefhnuoufhdgf |gflg*|gflg |gflg*|gflg `mfhuym|d `mfhuym|d de |gflg*|gflg |gflg*|gflg {grg `mfhumy|md `mfhumy|md .mf|cfgymlgf de fcf `mfhumy `mfhumy|md |md .ym|ugy .ym|ugymm }gfh }gfh yeyug yeyugmm lefhg lefhgf f coaed coaed yu{g} yu{g}gg |erogf |erogfhu huf f jgdfg, jefhhufgdgf {efhe|gnugf gxg` .}gfh dm|g |gnu |ef|gfh mym lgf oef|ud lgf dcf|edy .}gfh |e`gn ymg{ lmdg|gdgf- uf|ud jej{erdmrgdgf lgf dejulmgf jefae`gydgf jgdfg, b& jefhu`gfh jefhu`gfh dg|g*dg|g dg|g*dg|g {ef|mfh {ef|mfh lgf mle*mle mle*mle {ef|mfh& {ef|mfh& Jefuru Jefuru|| {eflg {eflg{g| {g| _cy| _cy| .7==71 .7==717;> 7;>-- ognxg ognxg bgd|cr bgd|cr*bg *bgd|c d|crr }gfh }gfh {ef|mf {ef|mfh h lg`gj de|ergj{m`gf jef}mjgd lg`gj de`gy glg`gn ymyxg jefu`mydgf ou|mr*ou|mr {ef|mfh ogngf ymjgdgf |eru|gjg }gfh oernuoufhgf lefhgf ogngf ymjgdgf& Ye`gfau|}g, Jminge` .7==717;>- jefhejudgdgf ognxg bgd|cr*bgd|cr }gfh {ef|mf {ef|mfh h lg`gj lg`gj de|erg de|ergj{m` j{m`gf gf jef}mj jef}mjgd gd lg`gj lg`gj de`gy de`gy glg`g glg`gn n ymyxg ymyxg jefu`m jefu`mydg ydgf f ou|mr*o ou|mr*ou|mr u|mr {ef|mf {ef|mfh h ogngf ogngf ymjgdg ymjgdgf f |eru|g |eru|gjg jg }gfh }gfh oernuo oernuoufh ufhgf gf lefhgf lefhgf ogngf ogngf ymjgdgf& ymjgdgf& Uf|ud lg{g| jefhgagrd jefhgagrdgf gf jef}mjgd jef}mjgd ygj{gm ygj{gm {glg {ejgngjgf, {ejgngjgf, huru {er`u {er`u jef}u jef}uyuf yuf ogngf ogngf ymjgd ymjgdgf& gf& [ef}u [ef}uyu yufgf fgf jg|erm jg|erm jef}m jef}mjgd jgd {uf |mlgd |mlgd gyg` gyg` jeflg{g|dgf jg|erm ygag, |e|g{m glg oeoerg{g }gfh ngruy lm{erng|mdgf huru lg`gj {ef}uyufgf jg|erm mfm lm gf|grgf}g1 .7- ygygrgf dehmg|gf, .?- ygygrgf dcj{e|efym ymyxg, .9- je|cle {ejoe`gagrgf, lgf .<- bgd|cr deoerngym`gf jef}mjgd .Oulmjgf, ?;;>1?-& Ygygrg Ygygrgf f dehmg| dehmg|gf gf oergr| oergr|mm |uaugf |uaugf {ejoe {ejoe`ga `gagrg grgof of jef}m jef}mjgd jgd,, jmyg`f jmyg`f}g }g jef}mj jef}mjgd gd mfbcrj mfbcrjgy gymm oeru{g oeru{g bgd|g bgd|g g|gu g|gu c{mfm& c{mfm& Ng` mfm lm|ef|u lm|ef|udgf dgf `eomn `eomn lgnu` lgnu`u& u&
Ygygrgf dcj{e|efym ymyxg oernuoufhgf lefhgf dejgj{ugf }gfh lmjm`mdm ymyxg lm gdnm gdnmrr {ejo {ejoe` e`ga garg rgf& f& Jmyg Jmyg`f} `f}g1 g1 dejg dejgj{ j{ug ugf f jef} jef}e` e`ed edym ym mfbc mfbcrj rjgy gymm }gfh }gfh jefhgf jefhgfluf lufh h bgd|g, bgd|g, jefhml jefhmlef| ef|mbmd mbmdgy gymm de|mlg de|mlgdye dyeyug yugmgf mgf {erf} {erf}g|g g|ggf gf yeyecr yeyecrgfh gfh lefh lefhgf gf befc befcje jefg fg }gfh }gfh glg& glg& Ye`g Ye`gmf mf m|u, m|u, jef} jef}mjg mjgd d lg{g lg{g|| jefh jefhej ejog ogfh fhdg dgf f dejjgj{ugf ymyxg uf|ud ye`ed|mb g|gy mfbcrjgym& Deoern Deoerngy gym`g m`gf f jef}mjg jef}mjgd d lm{efh lm{efhgru grunm nm auhg auhg lefhg lefhgf f bgd|cr bgd|cr `mfhduf `mfhdufhg hgf& f& @mfhdufhgf jej{efhgrunm def}g|ggf ymyxg lg{g| jef}mjgd ogngf lefhgf ogmd g|gu g|gu |mlgd |mlgd&& Bgd| Bgd|cr cr `mfhu `mfhufh fhgf gf }gfh }gfh oer{ oer{ef efhg hgru run n ouru ourud d oghm oghm deoe deoerng rngym ym`g `gf f {efhejogfhgf dcj{e|efym jef}mjgd glg`gn jmfmjf}g bgym`m|g g|gu |mlgd glg `go, yugygf yugygfgg jef}mjg jef}mjgd d |mlgd |mlgd f}gjg f}gjgf f .rugfhg .rugfhgf f |e`g`u |e`g`u `eogr, `eogr, de`gy de`gy lm yeoe`g yeoe`gn n dm|g |er`g` |er`g`u u oermym oermymd-& d-& C`en C`en dgrefg dgrefg m|u, m|u, {ergf {ergf huru huru lg`gj lg`gj jefef| jefef|udg udgf f deoern deoerngy gym`g m`gf f jef}mjgd ygfhg| {ef|mfh& Deej{g| ng` lm g|gy {er`u lm{erng|mdgf& Jg|erm }gfh lmyuyuf {uf yeogmdf}g jej{erng|mdgf |mfhdg| {erdgjogfhgf ymyxg& \ejg jg|erm }gfh lm{erhufgdgf yeogmdf}g oergrmg|mb& Lefhgf lejmdmgf, ymyxg dm|g |mlgd gdgf aefun oe`gagr lgf {ejoe`gagrgf jef}mjgd jefaglm jef}efgfhdgf&
?&2 Dufim Deoerngym`gf lg`gj Dehmg|gf Jef}mjgd
[ef}mjgd }gfh ogmd g{gom`g mflmmlu jgj{u jefhhufgdgf xgd|u edy|rg uf|ud jefhgd|mbdgf {mdmrgf {glg ygg| jef}mjgd& De|mdg {grg ymyxg jef}mjgd, {erng|mgff}g |er|uau {glg coaed ogngf ymjgdgf& [glg ygg| m|u`gn gdgf lmlg{g|dgf {rcyey jef}mjgd }gfh ebed|mb, jef}mjgd }gfh `ejgn, lgf jef}mjgd }gfh dug|, yeoghgmjgfg lmdejudgdgf c`en Igj{oe``, ldd .?;;2172- {glg |goe` oermdu| mfm&
\goe` 7 Jef}mjgd }gfh Ebed|mb Jef}mjgd }gfh Ebed|mb
7&
Jef}mjgd }gfh @ejgn
Jef}mjgd }gfh Dug|
\eju \ejudg dgf f oeoe oeoerg rg{g {g greg greg
Jefhnm`gfhdgf
Jefhhufgdgf Jefhhufgdgf {e`ugfh
jmfg|
{e`gagrgf }gfh
lefhgf oer|gf}g ‐G{g
‐dermfh‚
mymf}g uf|ud yg}g3‚
?&
9&
Fm`g Fm`gm`g m`gn n mymf} mymf}g, g, oudg oudgf f
Jefhnm`gfhdgff}g
Jefm`gm mym, je`exg|m
{ef}gj{gmgff}g
amdg {ef}gj{gmgff}g {ef}gj{gmgff}g
deyg`gngf*deyg`gngf
ae`ed
{ef}gj{gmgf
Iefl Iefler eruf ufh h
Jef}ejouf}mdgf
oergrhujef
{efm`gmgf ygj{gm {gngj
\gng \gngf` f`gn gn yejg yejgfh fhg| g| Gflg Gflg
<&
Lefhg fhgrdgf dgf mle*mle
Jef}mjg mjgd def}g f}g|gg |ggf
Jef}mjgd |ejg |ejg mf|m mf|m
5&
Oerymdg{ b`edymoe`
Jejoug| ig|g|gf
Jejoug| ig|g|gf `eomn
mf|efymb lefhgf
ogf}gd& Jejgdgm <*5
jejgdgm ngf}g yg|u
ymy|ej oeroelg |erhgf|ufh
ymy|ej
{ejomigrg
[urg [urg*{ *{ur urgg jef} jef}mjg mjgd d
Oede Oederag rag derg dergy, y,
2&
Oede Oederag rag`g `gn n ygg| ygg| jef} jef}mj mjgd gd
jefufauddgf deglggf |uoun }gfh gd|mb 8&
Jefgngf hgfhhugf
Julgn |erhclg
Oeraugfh#jefhnmflgrm hgfhhugf, |c`ergfym {glg dehmg|gf*dehmg|gf dehmg|gf*dehmg|gf ae`ed, |gnu igrg oerdcfyef|rgym
>&
@g|mn |mn`gn {mdmrgf rgf gflg
Jefgngf ogngf }gfh
Jefhhufgdgf ogngf }gfh
yu`m|, jefigrm ogngf
{glg| uf|ud je`g|mn {mdmrgf
}gfh yelerngfg =&
Oudg`gn {mdmrgf gflg
Ye|uau lefhgf
Jej{er|mjogfhdgf Jej{er|mjogfhdgf yulu|
mfbcrjgym amdg
{gflgfh }gfh oeroelg
jefludufh mle*mle
yeoe`uj jejoef|ud
}gfh |eroef|ud
{eflg{g|&
yeoe`ujf}g 7;& \u`my` \u`my`gn gn lefhgf lefhgf nurub nurub
Ieflerufh je`gjuf
Jefgf|gfh,
oeygr |ef|gfh bgd|g dgrefg
oerygjg lefhgf
jefhgf|mym{gym,
oer{mdmr `eomn ie{g|
{ejomigrg }gfh `ejgn
jergfhduj, jefmjogfh
lgrm{glg oeromigrg
oud|m, jeflefhgr g{g }gfh |erymrg|&
?&8 Jcle` [ejoe`gagrgf Icc{erg|me Irm{|
[glg [glg lgyg lgygrf} rf}g, g, ghgr ghgr yeju yejugg jcle jcle`` oern oerngy gym` m` ye{e ye{er|m r|m }gfh lmng lmngrg rg{d {dgf gf {ejo {ejoe` e`ga gagr grgf gf dcc{ dcc{er erg| g|mb, mb, ye|mg ye|mg{ { jcle jcle`` ngru ngruyy je`mo je`mog| g|dg dgf f jg|e jg|erm rm gagr gagr }gfh }gfh jejufhdm jejufhdmfdgf fdgf ymyxg yg`mfh jejogf|u jejogf|u lgf jefludufh jefludufh de|mdg jeredg jeredg oe`gagr oe`gagr jg|erm lgf oederag yg`mfh |erhgf|ufh .mf|erle{eflef- uf|ud jef}e`eygmdgf |uhgy& De|rgj{m`gf ycymg` }gfh lmou|undgf lg`gj uygng oerdc`gocrgym ngruy lm{gflgfh {ef|mfh lg`gj deoerngym`gf jef}e`eygmdgf |uhgy de`cj{cd& De|rgj{m`gf mfm lg{g| lmgagr lmgagrdg dgf f de{glg de{glg ymyxg ymyxg lgf lgf {ergf {ergf ymyxg ymyxg lg{g| lg{g| lm|ef|u lm|ef|udg dgf f uf|ud uf|ud jejbgy jejbgym`m| m`m|gy gymm {rcyey {rcyey de`cj de`cj{cd {cd&& [ergf [ergf |eryeo |eryeou| u| jufhd jufhdmf mf oerjg oerjgigj igj*jg *jgig igj j jefuru| jefuru| |uhgy |uhgy,, jmyg`f}g, {ergf {efig|g| . reicrler -, -, {ejoug| deymj{u`gf . yujjgrmqer -, -, {efhg|ur jg|erm .jg|ermg` jgfgher -, -, g|gu bgym`m|g|cr lgf {ergf huru omyg yeoghgm {ejcfm|cr {rcyey oe`gagr& Jefuru| Yulrgag| .?;;81?-, jcle` {ejoe`gagrgf icc{erg|me yirm{| .ydrm{ dcc{ dcc{er erg| g|mbmb- glg` glg`gn gn je|c je|cle le oe`g oe`gag agrr lm jgfg jgfg ymyx ymyxgg oede oederag rag oer{ oer{gy gygf gfhg hgf f lgf lgf oerh oerhgf gf|m |mgf gf yeig yeigrg rg `mygf `mygf jefh jefhmd mdn| n|my mygr grdg dgf, f, oghm oghmgf gf*o *ogh ghmg mgf f lgrm lgrm jg|er jg|ermm }gfh }gfh lm{e`gagrm& Glg{uf Glg{uf `gfhdg `gfhdgn*` n*`gfh gfhdgn dgn {efer {eferg{ g{gf gf jcle` jcle` {ejoe {ejoe`ga `gagrg grgf f icc{erg|me yirm{| glg`gn yeoghgm oermdu|1
g& Huru jejog jejoghm hm ymyxg ymyxg uf|ud uf|ud oer{gy oer{gygfhg gfhgf& f& o& Huru jejoghmd jejoghmdgf gf xgigfg#jg|e xgigfg#jg|erm rm |mg{ ymyxg uf|ud lmogig lmogig lgf jejoug| jejoug| ogngf rmfhdgygf& i& Huru lgf ymyxg ymyxg jefe|g{dgf jefe|g{dgf ymg{g }gfh {er|gjg {er|gjg oer{ergf oer{ergf yeoghgm yeoghgm {ejomigrg {ejomigrg lgf ymg{g }gfh oer{ergf yeoghgm {eflefhgr& l& [ej [ejom omig igrg rg
jejo jejogi gigd gdgf gf
rmfh rmfhdg dgyg ygff ff} }g
ye`e ye`efh fhdg dg{ {
jufh jufhdm dmf, f,
lefh lefhgf gf
jejgyu jejgyuddg ddgf f mle*ml mle*mlee {cdcd {cdcd lg`gj lg`gj rmfhdg rmfhdgygf ygff} f}g& g& Yejef Yejef|grg |grg {eflef {eflefhgr hgr jef}mjgd#jefhcredym# jefufauddgf mle*mle {cdcd }gfh durgfh `efhdg{ lgf jejogf jejogf|u |u jefhmf jefhmfhg hg|# |# jefhng jefhng{g` {g` mle*ml mle*mlee {cdcd {cdcd lefh lefhgf gf jefhn jefhnuou uoufhd fhdgf gf jg|erm yeoe`ujf}g g|gu lefhgf jg|erm `gmff}g& e& Oer|ud Oer|udgr gr {ergf, {ergf, yeju`g yeju`g yeoghg yeoghgmm {ejomi {ejomigrg grg lm|udg lm|udgrr jefagl jefaglmm {eflef {eflefhgr hgr lgf yeog`mdf}g, yer|g je`gdudgf ye{er|m lm g|gy& b&
Deymj Deymj{u` {u`gf gf huru& huru&
h& [efu|u [efu|u{& {& Jefu Jefuru ru||
Ogrc Ogrc|c |c .?;; .?;;81 8177- jcle jcle``
icc{erg| rg|me me yirm{ yirm{| | {ejo {ejoe` e`ga gagr grgf gf icc{e
jej{uf}gm de`eomngf yeoghgm oermdu|1 7- Je`g|mn {eflefhgrgf, de|e`m|mgf#deierjg|gf& ?- Ye|mg{ ymyxg jeflg{g| {ergf& 9- Je`g|mn jefhufhdg{dgf deyg`gngf crgfh `gmf lefhgf `mygf& Ye`gfau|f}g, jcle` {ejoe`gagrgf icc{erg|me yirm{| jejm`mdm dedurgfhgf }gm|u1 7- Ngf}g Ngf}g lmhufgdgf lmhufgdgf uf|ud jg|g jg|g {e`gagrgf {e`gagrgf |er|ef|u |er|ef|u ?- Ngf}g Ngf}g lm`gdudgf lm`gdudgf lug crgfh .|mlgd .|mlgd je`mog|dgf je`mog|dgf ye`urun de`gy yenmfhhg yenmfhhg dcredym dcredym ngf}g yeog|gy {glg lug crgfh |eryeou|-&
OGO MMM JE\CLC@CHM [EFE@M\MGF
9&7 Je|cle [efe`m|mgf
[efe`m|mgf mfm jefhhufgdgf je|cle {efe`m|mgf |mflgdgf de`gy . i`gyyrccj gi|mcf reyegrn-& Jefuru| {eflg{g| Xmogxg .?;;91>-, ‚•, lm`gdygfgdgff}g [\D
.[efe` .[efe`m|mg m|mgf f \mflg \mflgdgf dgf De`gy De`gy-- lm gf|gr gf|grgf} gf}gg mg`gn mg`gn uf|ud uf|ud jefmfh jefmfhdg| dg|dgf dgf dug`m|g dug`m|gyy {eflmlmdgf lgf g|gu {efhgagrgf }gfh lmye`efhhgrgdgf c`en huru, }gfh lgj{gdf}g |mlgd `ghm jefejudgf {erjgyg`gngf }gfh jefhhgfag` lm de`gy&‚
9&? @cdgym lgf Yuoaed [efe`m|mgf
[efe`m [efe`m|mg |mgf f mfm lm`gdy lm`gdygfg gfgdg dgf f lm YJ[ Jungjj Jungjjglm glm}g }gn n \gfauf \gfaufh h _gag _gag }gfh }gfh |er`e|gd lm Ag`gf C`gnrghg fcjcr 7>> Deigjg|gf \gfaufh _gag Dgou{g|ef Chgf M`mr& Yuoaed {efe`m|mgf glg`gn ymyxg de`gy RMM |gnuf {e`gagrgf ?;;>#?;;=& Auj`gn yuoaed {efe`m|mgf glg`gn 9; crgfh, }gfh |erlmrm g|gy ?7 crgfh `gdm*`gdm lgf = crgfh {erej{ {erej{ugf ugf&& Lm{m`mn Lm{m`mnf} f}gg |ej{g| |ej{g| lgf lgf yuoaed yuoaed {efe` {efe`m|mg m|mgf f mfm, dgref dgrefgg dejgj{ dejgj{ugf ugf jef}mjgd jeredg jgymn reflgn lm de`gy |eryeou|& C`en dgrefg m|u, ymyxg de`gy RMM {er`u lmoerm |mflgdgf uf|ud jefhg|gym jgyg`gnf}g&
9&9 [rcyelur [efe`m|mgf 9&9&7 9&9&7
Jejoug| Jejoug| _gfigfhgf _gfigfhgf [ejoe`gagr [ejoe`gagrgf gf
_gfi _gfigf gfhg hgf f {ejo {ejoe` e`ga gagr grgf gf jefh jefhgi giu u {glg {glg jcle jcle`` {ejo {ejoe` e`ga gagr grgf gf ydrm ydrm{ { dcc{erg|mb& 9&9&? 9&9&?
_gfigfhgf _gfigfhgf [e`gdygfgg [e`gdygfggf f [efe`m|mgf [efe`m|mgf
_gfigfhgf {e`gdygfggf jefhmdu|m `gfhdgn*`gfhdgn, }gm|u1 7& [erefigfggf [erefigfggf \mflgdgf [glg |gng{ {erefigfggf |mflgdgf mfm {efe`m|m je`gdudgf dehmg|gf gf|grg `gmf1 g& Jef}mg{dgf {ergfhdg| {ejoe`gagrgf oeru{g _[[ lgf [rchrgj Yejey|er& o& Jejf}mg{dgf mfy|rujef |ey lgf mfy|rujef coyergym&
i& Jef}e`edym oerm|g }gfh oeryujoer lgrm yg`gn yg|u yurg| dgogr [g`ejogfh, jmyg`f}g Yujg|erg Edy{rey, Yrmxmag}g [cy, g|gu Oerm|g [ghm&
?& [e`gdygfggf \mflgdgf [glg |gng{ {e`gdygfggf |mflgdgf mfm {efe`m|m je`gdudgf dehmg|gf gf|grg `gmf1 g& Huru jefae`gydgf dcj{e|efym dcj{e|efym lgygr }gfh gdgf gdgf lmig{gm c`en ymyxg& o& Huru jejoghm ymyxg ymyxg yeigrg oer{gygfhgf& oer{gygfhgf& i& Huru Huru jejogh jejoghmdg mdgf f xgigf xgigfg#j g#jg|e g|erm rm oerm|g oerm|g }gfh }gfh oeryuj oeryujoe oerr lgrm lgrm yg`gn yg`gn yg|u yg|u yurg| dgogr [g`ejogfh de{glg |mg{*|mg{ ymyxg l& Huru jejermf|gndg jejermf|gndgf f de{glg de{glg ymyxg uf|ud jejogig jg|germ jg|germ ogngf ogngf lmogig lmogig lgf jejoug| ogngf rmfhdgygf& e& Huru lgf ymyxg jefe|g{dgf jefe|g{dgf ymg{g }gfh {er|gjg {er|gjg oer{ergf yeoghgm yeoghgm {ejomigrg lgf ymg{g }gfh oer{ergf yeoghgm {eflefhgr& b& [ejo [ejomi migr grgg
jejo jejogi gigd gdgf gf
rmfh rmfhdg dgyg ygff ff} }g
ye`e ye`efh fhdg dg{ {
jufh jufhdm dmf, f,
lefh lefhgf gf
jejgyuddgf mle*mle {cdcd lg`gj rmfhdgygff}g& h& [eflefhgr jef}mjgd#jefhcredym#jefufauddg jef}mjgd#jefhcredym#jefufauddgf f mle*mle {cdcd }gfh durgfh `efh `efhdg dg{ { lgf lgf jejo jejogf gf|u |u jefh jefhmf mfhg hg|#j |#jef efhn hng{ g{g` g` mle* mle*ml mlee {cdc {cdcd d lefh lefhgf gf jefhnuoufhdgf jg|erm yeoe`ujf}g g|gu lefhgf jg|erm `gmff}g& n& Oer|ud Oer|udgr gr {ergf {ergf,, ymyxg ymyxg }gfh }gfh yeju` yeju`gg yeoghg yeoghgmm {ejom {ejomig igrg rg lm|udg lm|udgrr jefagl jefaglmm {eflefhgr lgf yeog`mdf}g& m& Huru jef}mj{ jef}mj{u`dg u`dgf f jg|erm jg|erm {ejoe`gagrg {ejoe`gagrgf& f& d& [efu|u{& [efu|u{&
9& Coyergym [glg [glg ygg| ygg| {e`gdy {e`gdygfg gfggf gf |mflg |mflgdgf dgf {efe`m {efe`m|m |m je`gdu je`gdudg dgf f coyer coyergym gym |erng |ernglg{ lg{ de|e{g de|e{g|gf |gf ymyxg ymyxg {glg {glg ygg| ygg| je`g{ je`g{crd crdgf gf ngym` ngym` ymjgdg ymjgdgf& f& Dehmg| Dehmg|gf gf coyer coyergym gym mfm lmhu lmhufg fgdg dgf f uf|u uf|ud d jefm jefm`g `gmm deoe deoern rngy gym`g m`gf f {rcy {rcyey ey {ejo {ejoe` e`ga gagr grgf gf&& [glg [glg xgd| xgd|u u je`gdudg je`gdudgf f coyergym coyergym {efe`m|m oederag oederag ygjg lefhgf yg`gn yecrgfh huru Ogngyg Mflcfe Mflcfeymg ymg }gfh }gfh jefhg jefhgagr agr lm de`gy de`gy `gmf& `gmf& Gy{ed Gy{ed }gfh }gfh lmcoye lmcoyerg rgym ym mg`gn mg`gn gd|mm| gd|mm|gy gy ymyxg ymyxg oeder oederag ag ygjg ygjg lg`gj lg`gj de`cj de`cj{cd {cd,, gd|mm gd|mm|gy |gy ymyxg ymyxg jefagx jefagxgo go {er|gf} {er|gf}ggf ggf,, gd|mm|gy ymyxg jefhgaudgf {er|gf}ggf, lgf |gfhhufh ymyxg lg`gj de`cj{cd&
<& _eb`edym _eb`ed _eb`edym ym lm`gdu lm`gdudgf dgf ye|e`g ye|e`gn n gdnmr gdnmr |mflgd |mflgdgf& gf& [glg [glg |gng{ |gng{ reb`ed reb`edym ym {efe`m {efe`m|m |m je`gdu je`gdudgf dgf {erefu {erefufhg fhgf f |erng |ernglg{ lg{ {e`gd {e`gdygf ygfggf ggf |mflgd |mflgdgf, gf, ogmd ogmd lgrm lgrm ymym ymym {rcye {rcyeyy jgu{uf ngym`& Fgjuf, }gfh {g`mfh lmu|gjgdgf glg`gn {efm`gmgf {rcyey& \gng{ mfm lmjgdyuldgf uf|ud jefhe|gnum oeoerg{g deflg`g lgf ngjog|gf }gfh |eraglm {glg ygg| {e`gdygfggf |mflgdgf& G{gom`g lm lg`gj {rcyey |mflgdgf |erlg{g| deflg`g g|gu ngjog|g, ngjog|g, {efe`m|m {efe`m|m je`gdudgf je`gdudgf {erogmdg {erogmdgf f |mflgdgf& |mflgdgf& [erogmdg [erogmdgf f |mflgdgf |mflgdgf lm`gdudgf lm`gdudgf uf|ud {ef}ej{urfggf {erefigfggf |mflgdgf }gfh gdgf lm`gdygfgdgf {glg ymd`uy oermdu|f}g& 9&< \edfmd [efhuj{u`gf Lg|g 9&<&7 9&<&7
\edfmd \edfmd Coyer Coyergym gym
Coyergym lm`gdudgf de{glg {gygfhgf de`cj{cd, ogmd yeoghgm {ejomigrg jgu{uf jgu{uf yeogh yeoghgm gm {efle {eflefh fhgr& gr& Coaed Coaed }gfh }gfh lmcoye lmcoyerg rgym ym glg`gn glg`gn de|e{g de|e{g|gf |gf ymyxg ymyxg jef}gj{g jef}gj{gmdgf mdgf mdn|mygr mdn|mygr oerm|g oerm|g .oghm .oghm {ejomigrg {ejomigrg-- lgf de|e{g|g de|e{g|gf f ymyxg jef}mjgd mdn|myg mdn|mygrr oerm|g oerm|g .oghm .oghm {eflef {eflefhgr hgr-& -& Mfy|r Mfy|ruje ujef f coyer coyergym gym lmymg{ lmymg{dgf dgf lg`gj lg`gj oef|ud oef|ud lgb|gr ief|gfh .ineid `my| - }gfh |erlmrm g|gy lug {m`mn }gm|u1 |e{g| lgf |mlgd |e{g|& Amdg Amdg ymyxg ymyxg |e{g| |e{g| je`g{c je`g{crdg rdgf f oerm|g oerm|g,, lmoerm lmoerm ydcr ydcr 7& Yeog`m Yeog`mdf} df}g, g, amdg amdg ymyxg ymyxg |mlgd |mlgd |e{g| je`g{crdgf ogngf ymjgdgf lmoerm ydcr ;& Glg{uf mflmdg|cr }gfh lmgjg|m glg`gn yeoghgm oermdu|& g& De|e{g|g De|e{g|gf f jef}gj{g jef}gj{gmdgf mdgf |c{md |c{md ymjgdg ymjgdgf f o& De|e{g|g De|e{g|gf f jef}gj{gm jef}gj{gmdgf dgf {mdmrgf {mdmrgf {cdcd& {cdcd& i& De|e{g|g De|e{g|gf f jef}gj{gm jef}gj{gmdgf dgf {mdmrgf {mdmrgf {efae`g {efae`gy& y& l& De|e{g|g De|e{g|gf f jefgrmd jefgrmd deymj{u`g deymj{u`gf f mym ymjgdgf& ymjgdgf& 9&<&? 9&<&?
Lcduj Lcdujef| ef|gym gym
Lcdujef|g Lcdujef|gym ym glg`gn glg`gn yujoer yujoer lg|g |er|u`my |er|u`my yeoghgm yeoghgm {efluduf {efludufh h {e`gdygfg {e`gdygfggf gf {efe {efe`m `m|m |mgf gf&& Lg|g Lg|g lcdu lcduje jef| f|gy gymm }gfh gfh lm{e lm{er` r`ud udgf gf lm ymfm ymfm glg` glg`gn gn {erg {ergfh fhdg dg|| {ejoe`gag {ejoe`gagrgf, rgf, ig|g|gf ig|g|gf denglmrgf denglmrgf ymyxg lg`gj jefhmdu|m jefhmdu|m dehmg|gf, dehmg|gf, lgf ig|g|gf ig|g|gf `g{gfhgf&
9&<& 9&<&9 9
\edf \e dfmd md \e \eyy
\ey lm`gdudgf yeigrg |er|u`my& \ey oeroef|ud eygm oerauj`gn 7; ycg`& Jg|erm }gfh lmuamdgf jefhefgm dejgj{ugf ymyxg jef}mjgd oerm|g }gfh oeryujoer lgrm Yurg| Dgogr Ngrmgf Yujg|erg Edy{rey, Yrmxmag}g [cy| , lgf Oerm|g [ghm& Iu{`mdgf oerm|g lmogig c`en huru lgf ymyxg& Ye|e`gn ymyxg jef}mjgd mym oerm|g, ymyxg lmoerm ycg` uf|ud jefgf}gdgf mym oerm|g }gfh lmymjgd& 9&5 \edfmd Gfg`mymy Lg|g
Lg|g* Lg|g*lg lg|g |g }gfh }gfh lm{erc lm{erc`en `en gdgf gdgf lmc`gn lmc`gn lefhgf lefhgf `gfhd `gfhdgn gn*`gf *`gfhd hdgn gn yeoghg yeoghgmm oermdu|1 7- jefydcr jefydcr ngym` ngym` oe`gagr oe`gagr lg`gj jef}mjgd jef}mjgd oerm|g oerm|g ?- jefhnm|ufh jefhnm|ufh rg|g*rg|g rg|g*rg|g ydcr }gfh lm{erc`e lm{erc`en n ymyxg lefhgf lefhgf rujuy1
^
b~
.Grmduf|c, ?;;91?52-
F
De|ergfhgf1 ^
: Fm`gm rg|g*rg|g
b~ Auj`gn fm`gm
F
: Auj` Auj`gn gn ymyx ymyxgg
9- jefhgfg`mymy de|uf|gygf de|uf|gygf oe`gagr ymyxg ymyxg yeigrg d`gymdg` d`gymdg` De|uf|gygf oe`gagr ymyxg yeigrg d`gymdg` lmde|gnum amdg >5% ymyxg jeflg{g| ydcr
≥
25& De|uf De|uf|gy |gygf gf oe`gag oe`gagrr ymyxg ymyxg yeigrg yeigrg d`gymd d`gymdg` g` mfm lmhufg lmhufgdgf dgf uf|ud uf|ud
jefhe|gnum deoerngym`gf {e`gdygfggf |mflgdgf& <- jef}m jef}mj{u j{u`dg `dgf f
OGO MR NGYM@ [EFE@M\MGF LGF [EJOGNGYGF
<&7 <&7
Ngym` Ngym` [efe [efe`m| `m|mg mgf f
[efe`m|mgf mfm oeraefmy {efe`m|mgf |mflgdgf de`gy }gfh lm`gdudgf {glg ymyxg de`g de`gyy de`g de`gyy RMM RMM YJ[ YJ[ Jung Jungjj jjgl glm} m}gn gn \gfa \gfauf ufh h _gag _gag Dgou Dgou{g {g|e |ef f Chgf Chgf M`mr M`mr oerauj oerauj`gn `gn 9; crgfh crgfh {glg {glg yejey yejey|er |er hefg{ hefg{ |gnuf |gnuf {e`ga {e`gagrg grgf f ?;;>#? ?;;>#?;;= ;;=&& Xgd|u Xgd|u {efe`m|mgf lmju`gm lgrm |gfhhg` 2 G{rm` ?;;= lgf oergdnmr {glg |gfhhg` < Jem ?;;=& [e`gdygfggf {efe`m|mgf lm`gdudgf lg`gj lug ymd`uy& Ymd`uy 7 lm`gdygfgdgf {glg {glg |gfhhg |gfhhg`` 2 G{rm` G{rm` ?;;= ?;;= lgf lgf ymd`uy ymd`uy ? lm`gdy lm`gdygfg gfgdg dgf f |gfhh |gfhhg` g` 7= G{rm` G{rm` ?;;=& ?;;=& Yeoe`uj lm`gdudgf |mflgdgf ymyxg lmoermdgf |ey gxg`& \ey gxg` lmoermdgf {glg |gfhhg` < G{rm` ?;;=& Glg{uf ngym` |ey gxg` lg{g| lm`mng| {glg {efae`ggf oermdu| mfm&
<&7&7 Ngym` [efe`m|mgf \ey Gxg`
[gl [glg
gxg` xg`
{efe {efe`m `m|m |mggf,
huru uru
jejo jejoeermdg rmdgf f
|ey |ey
gxg` xg`
de{glg {glg ymyx ymyxgg&
[e`gdygfggff}g lm`gdudgf {glg |gfhhg` < G{rm` ?;;=& Xgdu {e`gdygfggf ? agj {e`gagrgf& Ycg` |ey gxg` oeroef|ud eygm& Auj`gn ycg` yeogf}gd 7; ougn& Ycg Ycg` |ey |ey gxg` xg` lmde mderag ragdgf ymyx myxg yei yeigrg grg mflm mflmm mlu lugg`& Ymy Ymyxg lmjmf mjmf|g |g jefheragdgf ycg`, ymyxg |mlgd lm{eroc`endgf uf|ud oederag ygjg lg`gj jefagxgo ycg`& [glg ygg| {e`gdygfggf |ey gxg`, huru jejmf|g ogf|ugf de{glg yg`gn yecrgfh huru }gfh jefhgagr jefhgagr ogngyg Mflcfeymg Mflcfeymg uf|ud jefhgxgym jefhgxgym ngym` {ederaggf {ederaggf ymyxg& Ye|e`g Ye|e`gn n xgd|u xgd|u jefhe jefheragd ragdgf gf oergd oergdnmr nmr,, ymyxg ymyxg lmjmf|g lmjmf|g uf|ud uf|ud je`e|g je`e|gddg ddgf f ngym` ngym` {ederaggff}g lm g|gy jeagf}g jgymfh*jgymfh& Dejulmgf huru lmogf|u redgf huru `gmf jefhgjom` ngym` {ederaggf ymyxg& Ye|e`gn lm`gdudgf {efhcredymgf, ngym` {ederaggf ymyxg lmoerm fm`gm& Glg{uf fm`gm |ey gxg` ymyxg m|u lg{g| lm`mng| {glg |goe` oermdu| mfm&
\goe` ?
Lmy|rmouym Breduefym Fm`gm \ey [glg \ey Gxg`
Fc&
Fm`gm
Breduefym
Breduefym
Breduefym
Goyc`u|
_e`g|mb
Duju`g|mb
7&
8; ’ 8=
<
79,99%
<
?&
2; ’ 2=
<
79,99%
>
9&
5; ’ 5=
?;
22,28%
?>
<&
<; ’ <=
?
2,28%
9;
5&
9; 9; ’ 9=
*
Auj`gn
9;
*
*
7;;%
Oerlgy Oerlgygrd grdgf gf |goe` |goe` lm g|gy g|gy lg{g| lg{g| lmae`gy lmae`gydg dgf f ymyxg ymyxg }gfh }gfh jej{er jej{erc`e c`en n fm`gm fm`gm fm`g fm`gmm 8; ’ 8= yeog yeogf} f}gd gd < crgf crgfh h g|gu g|gu yeoe yeoeyg ygrr 79,9 79,99% 9%,, auj` auj`gn gn ymyx ymyxgg }gfh gfh jej{erc`en fm`gm 2; ’ 2= yeogf}gd < crgfh g|gu yeoeygr 79,99 %, auj`gn ymyxg }gfh jej{erc`en fm`gm 5; ’ 5= glg`gn ?; crgfh g|gu yeoeygr 22,28 %, lgf auj`gn ymyxg }gfh jej{erc`en fm`gm <; ’ <= ngf}g ? crgfh g|gu yeoeygr 2,28 %& Lgrm lg|g |eryeou| |eryeou| lg{g| lg{g| lmymj{u`dgf lmymj{u`dgf deoerngym` deoerngym`gf gf ymyxg jefig{gm jefig{gm fm`gm DDJ 6 25 yeogf}gd 2 crgfh& Lefhgf dg|g `gmf, {efig{gmgf de|uf|gygf oe`gagr ymyxg {glg \ey Gxg` ngf}g yeoeygr ?; %&
<&7&7 Ngym` [e`gdygfggf Ymd`uy [er|gjg
[e`gdy [e`gdygfg gfggf gf {efe`m {efe`m|mg |mgf f {glg {glg ymd`uy ymd`uy {er|gj {er|gjgg {glg {glg |gfhh |gfhhg` g` 2 G{rm` G{rm` ?;;=& ?;;=& Xgd|u {e`gdygfggf lmju`gm lgrm {udu` ;8&9; y&l& ;>&<; .? agj {e`gagrgf-& De`gy }gfh }gfh lm|e`m|m lm|e`m|m glg`g glg`gn n de`gy de`gy RMM YJ[ Jungjj Jungjjglm} glm}gn gn \gfauf \gfaufh h _gag _gag Dgou{g Dgou{g|ef |ef Chgf M`mr& Ngym` {e`gdygfggf {efe`m|mgf leydrm{ymdgf oermdu| mfm& [efe`m|mgf ymd`uy {er|gjg lm`gdudgf lg`gj yg|u dg`m |g|g{ judg lgf dehmg|gf }gfh lm`gdudgf yeyugm lefhgf dehmg|gf }gfh |erlg{g| lg`gj refigfg {e`gdygfggf {ejo {ejoe` e`ga gagr grgf gf ._[[ ._[[ |er` |er`gj gj{m {mrr- lefh lefhgf gf jefh jefhhu hufg fgdg dgf f jcle jcle`` {ejo {ejoe` e`ga gagr grgf gf icc{erg|me yirm{| & Y|gflg Y|gflgrr dcj{e dcj{e|ef |efym ym mg`gn mg`gn jejgng jejgngjm jm xgigf xgigfgg `mygf `mygf je`g`u je`g`umm
dehmg|gf jeflefhgr oerm|g& Jg|erm }gfh lmgagrdgf glg`gn |edy oerm|g&
[glg oghmgf gxg` {er|ejugf {er|gjg {efe`m|m je`gdudgf g{erye{ym lefhgf jejc|m jejc|mgy gymm ymyxg ymyxg&& [efe`m [efe`m|m |m jef}g jef}gj{g j{gmdg mdgf f mflmdg mflmdg|cr |cr {ejoe {ejoe`gag `gagrgf rgf .|uaug .|uaugf f {ejoe`gagrgf }gfh gdgf lmig{gm c`en ymyxg-& Glg |mhg {efig{gmgf mflmdg|cr }gfh ngruy ngruy lmig{g lmig{gmm c`en c`en ymyxg, ymyxg, }gm|u }gm|u11 7- jgj{u jgj{u jefle jeflefhg fhgrdg rdgf f {cdcd* {cdcd*{c {cdcd dcd oerm|g oerm|g }gfh }gfh lmogig lmogigdgf dgf44 ?- jgj{u jgj{u jefu`m jefu`mydg ydgf f mym oerm|g oerm|g lg`gj lg`gj oeoer oeoerg{g g{g dg`mjg dg`mjg|4 |4 9jgj{ jgj{u u jejo jejoer ermd mdgf gf |gfh |gfhhg hg{g {gf f jefh jefhef efgm gm mym mym oerm oerm|g |g&& Ye|e Ye|e`g `gn n m|u m|u {efe {efe`m `m|m |m je`gdudgf dehmg|gf {ejoe`gagrgf& Dehmg| Dehmg|gf gf {ejoe {ejoe`gag `gagrgf rgf }gfh }gfh lm`gdud lm`gdudgf gf lmgxg` lmgxg`mm lefhgf lefhgf jejogh jejoghmm ymyxg ymyxg oer{gygf oer{gygfhgf hgf lg`gj de`cj{cd de`cj{cd yenmfhhg yenmfhhg |erlg{g| |erlg{g| 75 de`cj{cd& de`cj{cd& [efhe`cj{ [efhe`cj{cdgf cdgf lmlg lmlgyg ygrd rdgf gf |ej{ |ej{g| g| lulu lulud d ymyx ymyxg& g& Dehm Dehmg| g|gf gf mfm mfm lm`g lm`gdu dudg dgf f ye`g ye`gjg jg 5 jefm jefm|& |& Deju Dejulm lmgf gf,, huru huru jejo jejogh ghmdg mdgf f bc|c bc|cdc dc{m {m mym mym oerm oerm|g |g de{g de{glg lg |mg{ |mg{ ymyx ymyxgg lg`g lg`gj j de`cj{cd& Jgymfh*jgymfh de`cj{cd jeflg{g|dgf yg|u aulu` oerm|g .aulu` oerm|g }gfh lmoghmdgf |er`gj{mr-& Huru jefuhgydgf jgymfh*jgymfh de`cj{cd jejoug| rmfhdgygf mym oerm|g& Mym oerm|g }gfh lmrmfhdgy jefhefgm |c{md oerm|g, {mdmrgf {cdcd#mle {cdcd, {mdmrgf {efae`gy, lgf jef}mj{u`dgf mym oerm|g& Dehmg|gf mfm lm`gdudgf ye`gjg ?; jefm|& Ye|e`g Ye|e`gn n xgd|u xgd|u }gfh }gfh lmyelmg lmyelmgdg dgf f oergd oergdnr, nr, huru huru lgf ymyxg ymyxg jefuhg jefuhgydg ydgf f jgymfh jgymfh** jgymfh jgymfh de`cj{cd de`cj{cd jefufaud yg|u crgfh oer|mflgd oer|mflgd yeoghgm yeoghgm {ejomigrg {ejomigrg lgf }gfh }gfh `gmff}g yeoghgm {eflefhgr& Dejulmgf huru jefuhgydgf {ejomigrg jejogigdgf ngym` ngym` rmfhdgyg rmfhdgygff}g ff}g&& Yejef|grg Yejef|grg {eflefhg {eflefhgrr jef}mjgd#j jef}mjgd#jefhc efhcredym# redym#jefu jefufaudd fauddgf gf mle*mle {cdcd }gfh durgfh `efhdg{ lgf jejogf|u jefhmfhg|#jefhng{g` mle*mle {cdcd {cdcd lefhgf lefhgf jefhnuou jefhnuoufhdg fhdgf f jg|erm jg|erm yeoe`ujf} yeoe`ujf}gg g|gu lefhgf lefhgf jg|erm jg|erm `gmff}g& `gmff}g& Dehmg|gf mfm lm`gdudgf lm`gdudgf oerhm`mrgf {er de`cj{cd, de`cj{cd, jgymfh*jgymfh jgymfh*jgymfh ye`gjg ? jefm|& [glg ygg| oer`gfhyufhf}g dehmg|gf {efe`m|m je`gdudgf {efhgjg|gf |ernglg{ dehmg|gf dehmg|gf }gfh }gfh lm`gdudgf lm`gdudgf ymyxg& [glg xgd|u ymyxg jejoug| rmfhdgygf rmfhdgygf |gj{gd |gj{gd ymyxg |eduf lgf oederag ygjg lefhgf ogmd& Jgymfh*jgymfh de`cj{cd jejoug| rmfhdgygf rmfhdgygf lgf oernef|m oernef|m oederag oederag ye|e`gn ye|e`gn xgd|u {efheraggf {efheraggf ?; jefm| jefm| lmf}g|gdg lmf}g|gdgf f ye`eygm& Ye|e`gn xgd|u jejogig lgf jermfhdgy oergdnmr jgymn glg |mhg de`cj{cd }gfh jef}g|gdgf oe`uj ye`eygm& De|mhgf}g glg`gn de`cj{cd 9, de`cj{cd 79 lgf de`cj{cd 79& Gdnmrf}g {efe`m|m jejoermdgf {er{gfagfhgf xgd|u ye`gjg ? jefm|&
Ye|e`gn xgd|u {er{gfagfhgf, jgymfh*jgymfh {ejomigrg jejogigdgf ngym` rmfhdgygf de`cj{cd jeredg lm le{gf de`gy, yejef|grg gfhhc|g `gmff}g lmyurun jeflefhgrdgf ngym` rmfhdgygf de`cj{cd& [e`gdygfggf {ejogiggf rmfhdgygf oerag`gf lefhgf ogmd& Ye|e`gn {ejomigrg ye`eygm jef}gj{gmdgf rmfhdgygf mym oerm|g, huru jefuhgydgf ymyxg jejoermdgf |gfhhg{g |gfhhg{gf f |ernglg{ |ernglg{ rmfhdgygf rmfhdgygf }gfh }gfh lmygj{gmdgf lmygj{gmdgf |ejgff}g& |ejgff}g& @g{crgf @g{crgf {efm`gmgf {efm`gmgf {eflefhgr |ernglg{ {ef}gj{gmgf rmfhdgygf oerm|g lg{g| lm`mng| {glg |goe` oermdu| mfm& \goe` 9 @g{crgf [ef}gj{gmgf _mfhdgygf Oerm|g \mg{ De`cj{cd c`en [ejomigrg
Fc&
Ou|mr
Auj`gn
De|ergfhgf
Ymyxg
7&
De|e{g|gf jef}gj{gmdgf |c{md oerm|g
79
?&
De|e{g|gf
7;
jef}gj{gmdgf
{mdmrgf
{cdcd 9&
De|e{g|gf
22,28% jef}gj{gmdgf
{mdmrgf
77
{efae`gy <&
>2,28%
89,99%
De|e{g|gf jefgrmd deymj{u`gf mym oerm|g _g|g*rg|g
7?
>;,;;%
77,5
82,28%
Lgrm Lgrm |goe |goe`` lm g|gy g|gy lg{g lg{g|| lmae lmae`g `gyd ydgf gf ognx ognxgg glg glg 79 de`c de`cj{ j{cd cd }gfh gfh jef}g jef}gj{g j{gmdg mdgf f |c{md |c{md oerm|g oerm|g lefhg lefhgf f |e{g|, |e{g|, ng` ng` mfm oergr| oergr|mm glg glg ? de`cj{ de`cj{cd cd }gfh }gfh oe`uj oe`uj |e{g| |e{g| jef}g jef}gj{g j{gmdg mdgf f |c{md |c{md oerm|g oerm|g&& Ng` mfm |eragl |eraglmm dgref dgrefgg ymyxg ymyxg ngf}g ngf}g jejog jejogig igdgf dgf aulu` aulu` oerm|g oerm|g lgf jeredg jeredg jefhh jefhhgfh gfhhg hg{ { aulu` aulu` oerm|g oerm|g m|u`gn m|u`gn }gfh }gfh jefaglm |c{md oerm|g& Jmyg`f}g oerm|g }gfh oeraulu` [rgouju`mn Jmf|g \gjogngf Lcd|er, yelgfhdgf |c{md oerm|g jefhefgm deyeng|gf& Ye`g Ye`gfa fau| u|f} f}g, g, de|e de|e{g {g|g |gf f jef} jef}gj gj{g {gmd mdgf gf {mdm {mdmrg rgf f {cdc {cdcd d auhg auhg ogf} ogf}gd gd jefmjou`dgf deyg`gngf& [glg oghmgf mfm ngf}g 7; de`cj{cd }gfh lmfm`gm iudu{ ogmd jef}gj{gmdgf {mdmrgf {cdcd }gfh |erlg{g| lm lg`gj oerm|g, yelgfhdgf 5
de`cj{cd jgymn yg`gn& Oehm|u {u`g {glg oghmgf de|e{g|gf jef}gj{gmdgf {mdmrgf {efae`gy ngf}g 77 de`cj{cd jgj{u jef}gj{gmdgff}g lefhgf ogmd lgf oefgr, yelgfhdgf < de`cj{cd yg`gn jefagxgo& Deyg`gngf ymyxg lg`gj jejoug| {mdmrgf {cdcd lgf {mdmrgf {efae`gy oerm|g dgrefg ymyxg oe`uj jejgngjm mym oerm|g yeigrg deye`urungf& [glg xgd|u {efe`m|m jefae`gydgf |ef|gfh {mdmrgf {cdcd lgf {mdmrgf {efa {efae` e`gy gy ymyx ymyxgg |ery |eryeo eou| u| jgym jgymn n glg glg }gfh }gfh rmou rmou|| lgf lgf oero oeromig migrg rg lefh lefhgf gf |ejg |ejgf f yeogfhdu, yenmfhhg ng` mfm jejoug| ymyxg durgfh jejgngjm g{g }gfh {efe`m|m ae`gydgf& Dede`mrugf ymyxg jef}gj{gmdgf {mdmrgf {cdcd lgf {mdmrgf {efae`gygf mym oerm|g glg dgm|gff}g lefhgf dedurgfh{gngjgf ymyxg lefhgf dg|g*dg|g dufim }gfh lmomigrgdgf lg`gj oerm|g& Dejulmgf {glg oghmgf de|e{g|gf ymyxg jefgrmd deymj{u`gf lmde|gnum 7? de`cj{cd yulgn oefgr lgf ogmd lgf jgymn glg 9 de`cj{cd }gfh oefgr jejoug| deymj{ deymj{u`g u`gf& f& Ymyxg Ymyxg jgymn jgymn jef}g jef}g`mf `mf dg`mjg dg`mjg|| gxg` gxg` oerm|g oerm|g,, glg {u`g {u`g }gfh }gfh ngf}g ngf}g jef}g`mf dg`mjg| aulu` oerm|g, lgf yg|u de`cj{cd |mlgd jefu`mydgf deymj{u`gf oerm|g& Lgrm ngym` dehmg|gf {ef}gj{gmgf rmfhdgygf mym oerm|g yeigrg deye`urungf iudu{ iudu{ ogmd& ogmd& _g|g*r _g|g*rg|g g|g 82,28% 82,28% ymyxg ymyxg lg{g| lg{g| jef}g jef}gj{g j{gmdg mdgf f rmfhdg rmfhdgyg ygf f oerm|g oerm|g,, yelgfhdgf ?9,<9%*f}g jgymn {er`u jeflg{g|dgf omjomfhgf lgrm {efe`m|m& Lm|mfagu lgrm gd|mm|gy ymyxg lg`gj de`cj{cd {efe`m|m auhg jefhglgdgf {efhgjg {efhgjg|gf |gf lefhgf lefhgf lmogf|u lmogf|u c`en |ejgf huru ogngyg Mflcfeymg Mflcfeymg&& Gd|mm|gy Gd|mm|gy }gfh }gfh lmgjg|m je`m{u|m derag ygjg, jefagxgo {er|gf}ggf, jejoermdgf |gfhhg{gf, lgf degd|mbgf degd|mbgf,, lgf de|edufgf& de|edufgf& @g{crgf @g{crgf de`mjg gd|mm|gy gd|mm|gy m|u lg{g| lg{g| lm`mng| lm`mng| {glg {glg |goe` |goe` oermdu| mfm& \goe` < Lmy|rmouym [efm`gmgf Gd|mm|gy Ymyxg lg`gj De`cj{cd Ymd`uy 7 Gy{ed }gfh lmfm`gm Fc
7
?
D`{
7
?
Mfmymg`
Deragygjg
Jefagxgo
Jejoermdgf
{er|gf {er|gf}ggf }ggf
\gfhhg \gfhhg{gf {gf
Degd|mbgf
De|edufgf
\Y
7
7
7
7
7
ML
7
7
7
7
;
_Y
7
;
7
;
7
Yu{
7
;
7
7
7
9
<
5
2
8
>
=
7;
77
7?
79
7<
75
GX
;
;
;
;
;
Lgj
;
;
7
7
7
J]
7
7
7
7
7
Huy
7
7
7
7
7
G{r
;
;
7
7
7
GY
7
;
7
7
7
Ju
7
7
;
7
7
Fgy
;
7
;
;
;
GM
7
7
7
7
7
BG
7
7
7
7
7
J]
7
;
7
7
;
J&D_
7
7
;
;
7
M[
7
7
7
7
7
N[
7
7
7
7
7
C[F
7
7
7
7
7
_M
7
7
7
7
7
GQ
;
;
7
7
7
L_
;
;
;
7
7
EJ
7
7
7
7
7
AY
7
7
7
7
7
Yud
7
;
7
7
;
BX
;
;
;
;
;
DN
7
7
;
7
7
IGX
7
7
7
7
7
GYg{
7
;
7
7
7
Grf
7
7
7
7
7
Auj`gn
?9
7>
?9
?5
?<
_g|g*rg|g .%-
82,28
2;,;;
82,28
>9,99
>;,;;
9
<
5
2
8
>
=
7;
77
7?
79
7<
75
De|ergfhgf1 Fm`gm 7 : je`gdudgf dehmg|gf Fm`gm ; : |mlgd je`gdudgf
Lgrm \goe` < lm g|gy ngym`f}g lg{g| lmde|gnum lg`gj |goe` oermdu| mfm&
\goe` 5
@g{crgf Gd|mm|gy Ymyxg lg`gj De`cj{cd Fc&
Dehmg|gf
Auj`gn ymyxg
[eryef|gye
7
Derag ygjg
?9
82,28%
?
Jefagxgo {er|gf}ggf
7>
2;,;;%
9
Jejoermdgf |gfhhg{gf
?9
82,28%
<
Degd|mbgf
?5
>9,99%
5
De|edufgf
?<
>;,;;%
Auj`gn
779
*
_g|g*_g|g
??,2
85,99%
Gd|m Gd|mm|g m|gyy dera deragy gygj gjgg lmde lmde|g |gnu numm yeoe yeoeyg ygrr 82,2 82,28% 8%,, gd|m gd|mm m|g |gyy jefa jefagx gxgo go {er|gf}ggf 2;,;;%, gd|mm|gy jejoermdgf |gfhhg{gf yeoeygr 82,28%, degd|mbgf ymyxg lg`gj de`cj{cd de`cj{cd lmde|gnum lmde|gnum yeoeygr yeoeygr >9,99%, >9,99%, lgf de|edufg de|edufgf f ymyxg lg`gj jefagxgo {er|gf}ggf yeoeygr >;,;;%& _g|g*rg|g gd|mm|gy ymyxg lg`gj de`cj{cd lmde lmde|g |gnu numm yeoe yeoeyg ygrr 85,9 85,99% 9%&& Gr|mf Gr|mf}g }g jgym jgymn n glg glg ymyx ymyxgg }gfh gfh |mlg |mlgd d je`g je`gdu dudg dgf f gd|mm|gy lefhgf ogmd }gdfm yeoeygr ?5,28%& [glg gdnmr ymd`uy {efe`m|m jejoermdgf |ey ymjgdgf .ycg` |er`gj{mr-& [glg ygg| je`gdudgf |ey, {efe`m|m jejogigdgf |edy oerm|g& Ymyxg lmyurun jef}mjgd mym oerm|g oerm|g |eryeo |eryeou|& u|& Ye|e`g Ye|e`gn n ymyxg ymyxg jef}m jef}mjgd jgd oerm|g oerm|g,, {efe`m {efe`m|m |m jejogh jejoghmdg mdgf f ycg` ycg` |ey de{glg de{glg |mg{*|mg{ |mg{*|mg{ ymyxg& ymyxg& [efe`m|m [efe`m|m jefhmfhg| jefhmfhg|dgf dgf de{glg de{glg ymyxg ghgr |mlgd oederag ygjg lg`gj jefagxgo ycg`& Ngym` |ey ymd`uy 7 lg{g| lm`mng| {glg |goe` oermdu| mfm&
\goe` 2 Ngym` \ey Gdnmr Ymd`uy 7 Fc&
Fgjg
Fm`gm
7
\I
>;
?
ML
>;
9
_LY
2;
<
Yu{
2;
5
GX
8;
2
Lgj
25
8
J]
=;
>
G{r
8;
=
N[
>;
7;
GY
2;
77
Gr
2;
7?
BG
85
79
GM
7;;
7<
Fgy
25
75
J&]ul
8;
72
Huy
8;
78
M[
>;
7>
C[
=;
7=
IGX
85
?;
DN
2;
?7
Ju
8;
??
J&D_
8;
?9
EJ
7;;
?<
_M
>;
?5
AY
>5
?2
GQ
85
?8
L_
25
?>
Yud
2;
?=
BX
25
9;
Gd Yg{
25
Auj`gn
?7=5
_g|g*_g|g
89,78
Yujoer1 Lg|g lmc`gn |gnuf ?;;=& Ye`gfau|f}g, lgrm lg|g lm g|gy gdgf lmurgmdgf auj`gn ymyxg lgf {eryef|gye {efig{gmgf de|uf|gygf oe`gagr |erlg{g| {glg |goe` oermdu| mfm&
\goe` 8 Lmy|rmouym Ngym` \ey Gdnmr Ymd`uy 7 Fc&
Ngym` \ey
Fm`gm
Breduefym
[eryef|gye .%-
7
≥
25
?<
>;
?
0 25
2
?;
9;
7;;
Auj`gn
Oerlgygrdgf |goe` lm g|gy lg{g| lmae`gydgf ymyxg }gfh jefig{gm de|uf|gygf oe`gag oe`gagrr {glg {glg ymd`uy ymd`uy {er|g {er|gjg jg oerauj oerauj`gn `gn ?< crgfh crgfh g|gu g|gu yeoey yeoeygr gr >;%, >;%, yelgf yelgfhdg hdgf f ymyxg }gfh oe`uj jefig{gm og|gy de|uf|gygf glg`gn 2 crgfh g|gu ?;%& Lgrm lg|g lm g|gy jefufauddgf ognxg fm`gm }gfh lmig{gm ymyxg {glg |ey gdnmr ymd`uy 7 rg|g*rg|g ngf}g jefig{gm 89,78& Yeigrg mflmmlug` {efig{gmgf fm`gm gdnmr {glg {glg ymd`uy ymd`uy {er|gj {er|gjgg jgymn jgymn glg glg ymyxg ymyxg }gfh }gfh jeflg{ jeflg{g|d g|dgf gf fm`gm fm`gm durgfh durgfh lgrm lgrm 25, yelgfhdg yelgfhdgf f {efig{gmg {efig{gmgf f de|uf|gyg de|uf|gygf f oe`gagr oe`gagr ymyxg yeigrg yeigrg d`gymdg` d`gymdg` jefig{gm jefig{gm >;%& Lefhgf lejmdmgf yeigrg d`gymdg` ngym` oe`gagr ymyxg oe`uj |uf|gy& C`en dgrefg m|u, {efe`m|mgf mfm lm`gfau|dgf {glg ymd`uy delug& Lgrm ngym` coyergym {glg ymd`uy 7 mfm jefhhgjogrdgf ognxg |mflgdgf }gfh lmoermdgf {efe`m|m jgymn jejm`mdm deflg`g*deflg`g, }gm|u1 7- Ymyxg Ymyxg jgymn jgymn durgfh durgfh ogmd ogmd lg`gj lg`gj jejoug jejoug|| rmfhdgy rmfhdgygf gf |eru|g |eru|gjg jg jermfh jermfhdg dgyy {mdmrgf {efae`gy lgf {mdmrgf {cdcd mym oerm|g& Ng` mfm lmyeogodgf c`en ymyxg oedera oederagg jgymn jgymn durgfh durgfh oerng oerng|m*n |m*ng|m g|m lgf lgf durgfh durgfh jefhmd jefhmdu|m u|m {efae {efae`gy `gygf gf lgrm lgrm {efe`m|m lgf |ejgff}g& ?- [glg ygg| ygg| oer`gfhyufhf}g {ejoe`gagrgf yugygfg de`gy jgymn rgjgm rgjgm g|gu rmou|& 9- Jgymn glg glg ymyxg }gfh }gfh |mlgd jejoug| jejoug| deymj{u`gf deymj{u`gf mym oerm|g& oerm|g& <- Lg`g Lg`gj j
jejo jejoug ug||
rgfh rgfhdu dujg jgf# f#de deym ymj{ j{u` u`gf gf
ymy ymyxg
jgym jgymn n
durg durgfh fh
oeh oehm|u m|u
jejgngjm lmyeogodgf c`en oeoerg{g deflg`g, }gm|u1 .g.g- Ymyxg Ymyxg }gfh jejog jejogig igdg dgf f reyu reyuje je jgym jgymn n oe`u oe`uj j oehm oehm|u |u `gfi `gfigr gr lg`g lg`gj j jejogig jejogig yenmfhhg yenmfhhg {gygfhgf {gygfhgf yu`m| uf|ud jef}mjgd#j jef}mjgd#jejgn ejgngjm gjm jgdyul jgdyul lgf |uaugf reyuje& .o- Mfbcrjgym }gfh lmoermdgf lgrm reyuje yu`m| lm{gngjm g|gu |er`g`u |mfhhm&
.i- Lg`gj Lg`gj xgigfg xgigfg reyuje reyuje |erlg |erlg{g| {g| dg|g* dg|g*dg| dg|g#d g#dg`mj g`mjg|* g|*dg dg`mjg `mjg|| }gfh }gfh yu`m| yu`m| lm{gngjm, icf|cn1 AGJDEYJGY& Jeydm{uf |erlg{g| deflg`g lg`gj {e`gdygfggf jcle` Icc{erg|me Yirm{| , ye`g ye`gjg jg oer`g oer`gfh fhyu yufh fhf} f}gg |mflg |mflgdg dgf f {efe {efe`m| `m|mm je`m je`mng ng|| glg glg oeoe oeoerg rg{g {g ng` ng` }gfh }gfh jefludufh dehmg|gf& 7- Ymyxg |er`mog| |er`mog| `gfhyuf `gfhyufh& h& ?- Ymyxg |mlgd jergyg jergyg |gdu| |er{cacd |er{cacd om`g jejoug| jejoug| yug|u deyg`gngf& 9- Ymyxg jergyg {erig}g lmrm lg`gj lg`gj jefhufhdg{dgf jefhufhdg{dgf {eflg{g|& {eflg{g|& <- De`cj{ De`cj{cd cd }gfh }gfh |erogm |erogmd d lg`gj lg`gj jejoug jejoug|| deymj{ deymj{u`g u`gf f glg`g glg`gn n de`cj{ de`cj{cd cd MM, dgrefg gfhhc|g de`cj{cd oederag ygjg lefhgf ogmd, |eduf, lgf gd|mb& Lgrm lg|g de`ejgngf lgf deflg`g lm g|gy {efe`m|m jereb`edym {e`gdygfggf |mflgdgf {glg ymd`uy 7 yeoghgm oermdu|1 icc{erg|me e yirm{| yirm{| jgymn 7- Jcle` Jcle` {ejoe`gag {ejoe`gagrgf rgf icc{erg|m jgymn lm`gfa lm`gfau|d u|dgf gf {glg {glg |mflgd |mflgdgf gf
oermdu|f}g& ?- [ejoermgf bc|cdc{m |edy oerm|g jgymn |e|g{ lm`gfau|dgf {glg ymd`uy ye`gfau|f}g& 9- Ymyxg ngruy lmoerm {efedgfgf {glg dehmg|gf jefigrm {mdmrgf {cdcd lgf {mdmrgf {efae`gy mym oerm|g& <- [efe [efe`m| `m|mm jefh jefhmf mfhg hg|d |dgf gf de{g de{glg lg ymyx ymyxgg ghgr ghgr jejo jejoug ug|| deym deymj{ j{u` u`gf gf jg|e jg|erm rm {e`gagrgf& 5- Huru jefhcf|rc` dehmg|gf ymyxg yeigrg de|g|&
<&7&9 Ngym` [e`gdygfggf Ymd`uy Delug
[glg [glg ymd` ymd`uy uy delu delugg jg|e jg|erm rm }gfh gfh lmga lmgagr grdg dgf f glg` glg`gn gn jefl jeflef efhg hgrd rdgf gf lgf lgf jejgngjm mym oerm|g }gfh lmogigdgf& [glg gxg` {ejoe`gagrgf {er|ejugf {efe`m|m jef}uyuf {erefigfggf lefhgf |er`eomn lgnu`u jefhglgdgf |gf}g*agxgo |ernglg{ jg|erm }gfh yulgn lm{e`gagrm {glg {er|ejugf yeoe`ujf}g& [efe`m|m auhg jeoug| refigfg _[[ lgf mfy|rujef {efm`gmgf lgf jef}gj{gmdgf mflmdg|cr {ejoe`gagrgf .|uaugf {ejoe`gagrgf }gfh neflgd lmig{gm ymyxg-& [glg oghmgf mf|m#dehmg|gf {e`gdygfggf |mflgdgf {efe`m|m jef}uyuf `gfhdgn* `gfhdg `gfhdgn n lefhg lefhgf f |e|g{ |e|g{ |er`eo |er`eomn mn lgnu`u lgnu`u jejogh jejoghmm ymyxg ymyxg oer{g oer{gygf ygfhg hgf f lg`gj lg`gj 75
de`cj{ de`cj{cd cd jefuru jefuru|| |ej{g |ej{g|| lulud lulud ymyxg ymyxg&& De{glg De{glg jgymfh jgymfh*jg *jgymf ymfh h ymyxg ymyxg lg`gj lg`gj de`cj{cd lmoghmdgf bc|cdc{m mym oerm|g .aulu` oerm|g }gfh lmoghmdgf |er`gj{mr-& @gfhdgn ye`gfau|f}g, huru jefuhgydgf jgymfh*jgymfh de`cj{cd jejoug| rmfhdgygf mym oerm|g& \mg{*|mg{ ymyxg jejoug| rmfhdgygf mym oerm|g& Mym oerm|g }gfh lmrmfhdgy jefhefgm |c{md oerm|g, {mdmrgf {cdcd#mle {cdcd, {mdmrgf {efae`gy, lgf jef} jef}mj mj{u {u`d `dgf gf mym mym oerm| oerm|g& g& Dehm Dehmg| g|gf gf mfm mfm lm`g lm`gdu dudg dgf f ye`g ye`gjg jg 7; jefm jefm|& |& Ye|e Ye|e`g `gn n dehmg|gf ye`eygm ymyxg lmjmf|g oer|udgr {ergf, }gfh {glg ymd`uy 7 oer{ergf yeoghgm {ejo {ejomi migr grgg yedg yedgrg rgfh fh oer{ oer{er ergf gf yeog yeoghg hgmm {efl {eflef efhg hgr, r, oehm oehm|u |u {u`g {u`g yeog yeog`md `mdf} f}g& g& [ejomigrg dejulmgf jejogigdgf ngym` rmfhdgygf, yejef|grg {eflefhgr lmjmf|g jef}mjgd#jefhcredym lgf jefufauddgf mle*mle {cdcd }gfh durgfh |e{g|& Ymyxg lmjmf|g {u`g jefhmfhg|#jefhng{g` mle*mle {cdcd lefhgf jefhnuoufhdgf jg|erm yeoe`u yeoe`ujf} jf}gg g|gu g|gu lefhgf lefhgf jg|erm jg|erm `gmff} `gmff}g& g& jefhhm jefhhm`mrd `mrdgf gf ymyxg ymyxg yeogh yeoghgm gm xgdm` xgdm` de`cj{cd uf|ud jejogigdgf ngym` rmfhdgygf& [glg oghmgf ye`gfau|f}g, jgymfh* jgymfh ymyxg lmoerm xgd|u jef}gj{gmdgf jef}gj{gmdgf ngym` rmfhdgygff}g rmfhdgygff}g ye`gjg ? jefm|& [glg ygg| oer`gfhyufhf}g dehmg|gf {efe`m|m je`gdudgf {efhgjg|gf |ernglg{ dehmg|g dehmg|gf f }gfh }gfh lm`gd lm`gdudg udgf f ymyxg& ymyxg& [glg xgd|u xgd|u ymyxg ymyxg jejoug jejoug|| rmfhdgy rmfhdgygf, gf, ymyxg ymyxg jgj{u oederag ygjg lefhgf ogmd& Jgymfh*jgymfh {gygfhgf jejoug| rgfhdujgf lgf oernef|m oederag ye|e`gn xgd|u jefheragdgf lmf}g|gdgf ye`eygm& Ye|e`gn xgd|u jejogig lgf jermfhdgy mym oerm|g oergdnmr, |mlgd glg `ghm de`cj{cd }gfh oederag& Yejug de`cj{cd jej{erymg{dgf ngym` rmfhdgygff}g& Ymyxg }gfh oer{ergf oer{ergf yeoghgm yeoghgm {ejomigrg {ejomigrg jejogigdgf jejogigdgf ngym` rmfhdgyg rmfhdgygf f de le{gf le{gf de`gy, de`gy, dejulmgf dejulmgf ymyxg }gfh }gfh oer{ergf oer{ergf yeoghgm yeoghgm {eflefhg {eflefhgrr jeficicd jeficicddgf dgf ngym` ngym` rmfhd rmfhdgyg gygf f }gfh }gfh lmoug|f lmoug|f}g }g lefhg lefhgf f ngym` ngym` rmfhd rmfhdgyg gygff} ff}gg yeflm yeflmrm& rm& @g{cr @g{crgf gf {efm`gmgf {efm`gmgf {eflefhg {eflefhgrr |ernglg{ |ernglg{ {ef}gj{g {ef}gj{gmgf mgf rmfhdgygf rmfhdgygf oerm|g lg{g| lm`mng| lm`mng| {glg |goe` oermdu| mfm&
\goe` > @g{crgf [ef}gj{gmgf _mfhdgygf Oerm|g \mg{ De`cj{cd c`en [ejomigrg Fc&
Ou|mr
Auj`gn Ymyxg
De|ergfhgf
7& De|e{g|gf jef}gj{gmdgf |c{md oerm|g
79
?& De|e{g|g De|e{g|gf f jef}gj{gmd jef}gj{gmdgf gf {mdmrgf {mdmrgf
7?
{cdcd
>2,28%
>;,;;%
9& De|e{g|g De|e{g|gf f jef}gj{gmd jef}gj{gmdgf gf {mdmrgf {mdmrgf
7?
{efae`gy
>;,;;%
<& De|e{g|gf jefgrmd deymj{u`gf mym oerm|g _g|g*rg|g
79
>2,28%
7?,5
>9&99%
Lgrm |goe` lm g|gy lg{g| lmae`gydgf ognxg glg 79 de`cj{cd }gfh jgj{u jef}gj{gmdgf |c{md oerm|g lefhgf |e{g| lgf oefgr, ng` mfm oergr|m glg ? de`cj{cd }gfh gfh oe`u oe`uj j |e{g |e{g|| jef} jef}gj gj{g {gmd mdgf gf |c{m |c{md d oerm oerm|g |g,, }gdfm gdfm de`c de`cj{ j{cd cd 5 lgf lgf 2& Ye`gfau|f}g, de|e{g|gf jef}gj{gmdgf {mdmrgf {cdcd auhg ogf}gd jefmjou`dgf deyg`g deyg`gng ngf& f& [glg [glg oghmgf oghmgf mfm ngf}g ngf}g 7? de`cj{ de`cj{cd cd .>;%.>;%- }gfh }gfh lmfm`g lmfm`gmm iudu{ iudu{ ogmd ogmd jef} jef}gj gj{g {gmd mdgf gf {mdm {mdmrg rgf f {cdc {cdcd d }gfh }gfh |erl |erlg{ g{g| g| lm lg`g lg`gj j oerm oerm|g |g,, yelg yelgfh fhdg dgf f 9 de`cj{cd jgymn yg`gn& Oehm|u {u`g {glg oghmgf de|e{g|gf jef}gj{gmdgf {mdmrgf {efae` {efae`gy gy glg glg 7? de`cj{ de`cj{cd cd }gfh }gfh jgj{u jgj{u jef}g jef}gj{g j{gmdg mdgff} ff}gg lefhg lefhgf f ogmd ogmd lgf lgf oefgr, yelgfhdgf 9 de`cj{cd jgymn yg`gn& Deyg`gngf ymyxg m|u dgrefg mg jgymn jef} jef}g` g`mf mf dg`mj dg`mjg| g| }gfh gfh glg glg lm lg`g lg`gj j oerm| oerm|gg yeig yeigrg rg u|un u|un&& Dede Dede`mr `mrug ugf f ymyx ymyxgg jef}g jef}gj{g j{gmdg mdgf f {mdmrg {mdmrgf f {cdcd {cdcd lgf lgf {mdmrg {mdmrgf f {efae {efae`gy `gygf gf mym oerm|g oerm|g glg dgm|g dgm|gff} ff}gg lefhgf dedurgfh{gngjgf ymyxg lefhgf dg|g*dg|g dufim }gfh lmomigrgdgf lg`gj oerm|g& Dejulmgf {glg oghmgf de|e{g|gf ymyxg jefgrmd deymj{u`gf lmde|gnum 7? de`cj{cd yulgn oefgr lgf ogmd lgf jgymn glg 9 de`cj{cd }gfh oefgr jejoug| deymj{u`gf& Ng` mfm |eraglm dgrefg ymyxg jgymn jef}g`mf dg`mjg| oerm|g, glg {u`g }gfh ngf}g jef}g`mf dg`mjg| aulu` oerm|g, lgf yg|u de`cj{cd |mlgd jefu`mydgf deymj{u`gf oerm|g& Lgrm ngym` dehmg|gf {ef}gj{gmgf rmfhdgygf mym oerm|g yeigrg deye`urungf iudu{ ogmd& _g|g*rg|g dejgj{ugf ymyxg jefig{gm >9,99%, yelgfhdgf 72,28%* f}g oe`uj |e{g|& Lm|mfagu lgrm gd|mm|gy ymyxg lg`gj de`cj{cd, }gfh je`m{u|m derag ygjg, jefagxgo jefagxgo {er|gf}gg {er|gf}ggf, f, jejoermdgf jejoermdgf |gfhhg{gf |gfhhg{gf,, lgf degd|mbgf degd|mbgf,, lgf de|edufgf de|edufgf&& @g{crgf de`mjg gd|mm|gy m|u lg{g| lm`mng| {glg |goe` oermdu| mfm&
\goe` = Lmy|rmouym [efm`gmgf Gd|mm|gy Ymyxg lg`gj De`cj{cd Ymd`uy ? Gy{ed }gfh lmfm`gm Fc
7
?
9
<
5
2
8
>
=
7;
77
7?
79
D`{
7
?
9
<
5
2
8
>
=
7;
77
7?
79
Mfmymg`
Deragygjg
Jefagxgo
Jejoermdgf
{er|gf {er|gf}ggf }ggf
\gfhhg \gfhhg{gf {gf
Degd|mbgf
De|edufgf
\Y
7
7
7
7
7
ML
7
7
7
7
7
_Y
7
7
7
7
7
Yu{
7
7
7
7
7
GX
7
;
;
7
;
Lgj
7
;
7
7
;
J]
7
7
7
7
7
Huy
7
7
7
7
7
G{r
7
7
;
;
7
GY
7
;
;
;
;
Ju
7
;
;
;
;
Fgy
7
;
;
;
;
GM
7
7
7
;
7
BG
7
7
7
7
7
J]
7
;
7
7
7
J&D_
7
7
7
7
7
M[
7
7
;
7
7
N[
7
7
;
7
7
C[F
7
7
7
7
7
_M
7
7
7
7
7
GQ
7
7
7
7
7
L_
7
7
7
7
7
EJ
7
7
7
7
7
AY
7
7
7
7
7
Yud
7
;
7
7
7
BX
7
7
7
7
7
DN
7
7
7
7
7
7<
7<
IGX
7
7
7
7
7
75
75
GYg{
7
7
7
7
7
Grf
7
7
7
7
7
Auj`gn
9;
?9
?9
?5
?5
_g|g*rg|g .%-
7;;
82,28
82,28
>9,99
>9,99
De|ergfhgf1 Fm`gm 7 : je`gdudgf dehmg|gf Fm`gm ; : |mlgd je`gdudgf Lgrm \goe` = lm g|gy ngym`f}g lg{g| lmde|gnum lg`gj |goe` oermdu| mfm&
\goe` 7; @g{crgf Gd|mm|gy Ymyxg lg`gj De`cj{cd Fc&
Dehmg|gf
Auj`gn Ymyxg
[eryef|gye
7
Derag ygjg
9;
7;;,;;%
?
Jefagxgo {er|gf}ggf
?9
82,28%
9
Jejoermdgf |gfhhg{gf
?9
82,28%
<
Degd|mbgf
?5
>9,99%
5
De|edufgf
?5
>9,99%
Auj`gn
7?2
_g|g*_g|g
Gd|m Gd|mm|g m|gyy
dera deragy gygj gjgg
?5,?;
lmde lmde|g |gnu numm
yeoe yeoeyg ygrr
><,;;%
7;;% 7;;%,,
gd|m gd|mm|g m|gyy
jefa jefagx gxgo go
{er|gf}ggf 82,28%, gd|mm|gy jejoermdgf |gfhhg{gf yeoeygr 82,28%, degd|mbgf ymyxg lg`gj de`cj{cd de`cj{cd lmde|gnum lmde|gnum yeoeygr yeoeygr >9,99%, >9,99%, lgf de|edufg de|edufgf f ymyxg lg`gj jefagxgo {er|gf}ggf yeoeygr >9,99%& _g|g*rg|g gd|mm|gy ymyxg lg`gj de`cj{cd lmde|gnum yeoeygr ><%& Gr|mf}g jgymn glg ymyxg }gfh |mlgd je`gdudgf gd|mm|gy lefhgf ogmd }gdfm yeoeygr 72%& [glg gdnmr ymd`uy {efe`m|m jejoermdgf |ey ymjgdgf .ycg` |er`gj{mr-& [glg ygg| je`gdudgf |ey, {efe`m|m jejogigdgf |edy oerm|g& Ymyxg lm{ermf|gndgf uf|ud jef} jef}mj mjgd gd mym mym oerm oerm|g |g |ery |eryeo eou| u|&& Ye|e Ye|e`g `gn n ymyx ymyxgg jef} jef}mj mjgd gd oerm oerm|g |g,, {efe {efe`m `m|m |m jejoghmdg jejoghmdgf f ycg` de{glg de{glg |mg{*|mg{ |mg{*|mg{ ymyxg& ymyxg& [efe`m|m [efe`m|m jefhmfhg| jefhmfhg|dgf dgf de{glg de{glg ymyxg ymyxg ghgr |mlgd oederag ygjg lg`gj jefagxgo ycg`& Ngym` |ey ymd`uy ? lg{g| lm`mng| {glg |goe` oermdu| mfm&
\goe` 77 Ngym` \ey Gdnmr Ymd`uy ? Fc&
Fgjg
Fm`gm
7
\I
>5
?
ML
7;;
9
_LY
25
<
Yu{
2;
5
GX
85
2
Lgj
8;
8
J]
=;
>
G{r
>5
=
N[
>5
7;
GY
25
77
Gr
8;
7?
BG
85
79
GM
=;
7<
Fgy
25
75
J&]ul
85
72
Huy
2;
78
M[
85
7>
C[
=5
7=
IGX
85
?;
DN
2;
?7
Ju
>5
??
J&D_
85
?9
EJ
=5
?<
_M
>;
?5
AY
>5
?2
GQ
>;
?8
L_
25
?>
Yud
25
?=
BX
85
9;
Gd Yg{
>;
Auj`gn
?9;5
_g|g*_g|g
82,>9
Yujoer1 \ey gdnmr ymd`uy ? lmc`gn |gnuf ?;;=&
Ye`gfau|f}g, lgrm lg|g lm g|gy gdgf lmurgmdgf auj`gn ymyxg lgf {eryef|gye {efig{gmgf de|uf|gygf oe`gagr |erlg{g| {glg |goe` oermdu| mfm&
\goe` 7? Lmy|rmouym Ngym` \ey Gdnmr Ymd`uy ? Ngym` \ey Fc&
Fm`gm Breduefym
[eryef|gye .%-
7
≥
25
?8
=;
?
0 25
9
7;
9;
7;;
Auj`gn
Oerlgygrdgf |goe` lm g|gy lg{g| lmae`gydgf ymyxg }gfh jefig{gm de|uf|gygf oe`gagr oe`gagr {glg ymd`uy delug oerauj`gn oerauj`gn ?8 crgfh g|gu yeoeygr yeoeygr =;%, yelgfhdgf yelgfhdgf ymyxg }gfh oe`uj jefig{gm og|gy de|uf|gygf glg`gn 9 crgfh g|gu 7;%& Lgrm lg|g lm g|gy jefufauddgf ognxg fm`gm }gfh lmig{gm ymyxg {glg |ey gdnmr ymd`uy ? rg|g*rg|g ngf}g jefig{gm 82,>9& Yeigrg mflmmlug` {efig{gmgf fm`gm gdnmr {glg ymd`uy delug |e`gn je`eomnm og|gy de|uf|gygf >5%& Lefhgf lejmdmgf yeigrg d`gymd d`gymdg` g` ngym` ngym` oe`gag oe`gagrr ymyxg ymyxg lmf}g|g lmf}g|gdg dgf f |uf|gy |uf|gy&& C`en C`en dgrefg dgrefg m|u, {efe` {efe`m|mg m|mgf f mfm lmnef|mdgf dgrefg yulgn oerngym` jefig{gm de|uf|gygf oe`gagr d`gymdg`& Lgrm ngym` coyergy coyergymm {glg ymd`uy ? jefhhgjog jefhhgjogrdgf rdgf ognxg |mflgdgf |mflgdgf }gfh lmoermdgf {efe`m|m jgymn glg oeoerg{g deflg`g, }gm|u jgymn glg ymyxg durgfh ogmd lg`gj jejoug| rmfhdgygf |eru|gjg jermfhdgy {mdmrgf {efae`gy lgf {mdmrgf {cdcd
mym oerm|g& Ng` mfm lmyeogodgf c`en ymyxg oederag jgymn durgfh oerng|m*ng|m lgf durgfh jefhmdu|m {efae`gygf lgrm {efe`m|m lgf |ejgff}g& Fgjuf lejmdmgf, yeigrg ujujf}g rmfhdgygf oerm|g }gfh lmoug| ymyxg .jgj{u- lg{g| lm`g{crdgf yeoghgm oermdu|1 7- ymyxg yulgn yulgn `gfigr `gfigr jejogig jejogig reyuje reyuje rmfhdgygf rmfhdgygf mym oerm|g ?- {gygfhgf |mlgd jefhg`gjm jefhg`gjm deyu`m|gf lg`gj jejoug| jejoug| rmfhdgygf rmfhdgygf 9- {eflef {eflefhg hgrr je`gdud je`gdudgf gf |gfhhg |gfhhg{gf {gf yeigrg yeigrg gd|mb gd|mb |erng |ernglg{ lg{ mymy mymy rmfhdg rmfhdgygf ygf }gfh }gfh lmygj{gmdgf {ejomigrg <- {ejog {ejogig ig yulgn yulgn jgj{u jgj{u lgf lgf ogmd ogmd lg`gj lg`gj jejog jejogig igdgf dgf reyuje reyuje rmfhdgy rmfhdgygf gf mym oerm|g& Lgrm Lgrm lg|g lg|g lm g|gy g|gy {efe` {efe`m|m m|m jereb` jereb`ed edym ym {e`gd {e`gdygf ygfggf ggf |mflgdg |mflgdgf f {glg {glg ymd`uy ymd`uy ? yeoghgm oermdu|1 7- Gd|mm|gy Gd|mm|gy ymyxg {glg {glg ymd`uy ? lg`gj |mflgdgf |mflgdgf lmf}g|gdg lmf}g|gdgf f ogmd& ?- De|uf|gyg De|uf|gygf f oe`gagr oe`gagr ymyxg |e`gn |e`gn je`eomnm je`eomnm >5% 9- Ngym` Ngym` oe`ga oe`gagr gr ymyxg ymyxg ymd`uy ymd`uy ? jefhg jefhg`gj `gjmm {efmfh {efmfhdg dg|gf |gf lmogfl lmogflmfh mfhdg dgf f lefhg lefhgf f ymd`uy 7& <- Ngym` {efe`m|mgf {efe`m|mgf ymd`uy ? lmf}g|gdgf lmf}g|gdgf oerngym`, oerngym`, dgrefg gd|mm|gy gd|mm|gy ymyxg lgf ngym` oe`gagr ymyxg |e`gn jefhg`gjm {efmfhdg|gf lmogflmfhdgf lefhgf ymd`uy 7& Yeoghg Yeoghgmm {erogf {erogflmf lmfhg hgf f ngym` ngym` |ey ymd`uy ymd`uy 7 lgf lgf ymd`uy ymd`uy ymd`uy ymd`uy ? lg{g| lg{g| lm`mng lm`mng|| {glg |goe` lm ogxgn mfm& \goe` 7? [erogflmfhg [erogflmfhgf f Fm`gm \ey Gdnmr Ymd`uy 7 lgf Ymd`uy ? [erogflmfhgf Fm`gm
Auj`gn
Ngym` \ey Ymd`uy 7 0 Ngym` \ey Ymd`uy ?
78
Ngym` \ey Ymd`uy 7 6 Ngym` \ey Ymd`uy ?
<
Ngym` \ey Ymd`uy 7 : Ngym` \ey Ymd`uy ?
=
\c|g`
9;
Oerlgygrdgf |goe` lm g|gy lg{g| lmde|gnum ognxg {erogflmfhgf fm`gm ngym` |ey ymd`uy 7 `eomn deim` lgrm ymd`uy ? yeogf}gd 78 crgfh, fm`gm ngym` |ey ymd`uy 7
`eomn oeygr lgrm |ey ymd`uy ? yeogf}gd < crgfh, lgf fm`gm ngym` |ey ymd`uy 7 ygjg lefhgf ngym` |ey ymd`uy ? yeogf}gd = crgfh& Ye`gfau|f}g, g{gom`g lm`mng| lgrm ngym` {efhuamgf uam | }gfh lg|gf}g lmc`gn je`g`u je`g`umm [rchrg [rchrgj j Y[YY Y[YY .y|g|my|mig` erym 75&;;& 75&;;& y|g|my|mig` [rclui| [rclui| gfl Yermie Yermie Yc`u|mcf Yc`u|mcf- erym Glg{uf ngym` {efhuamgf uam | lg{g| lm`mng| {glg |goe` oermdu| mfm&
\goe` 79 Ngym` Uam | [erogflmfhgf Fm`gm \ey Ymd`uy 7 lgf Ymd`uy ?
[gmrel Lmbberefiey Ymh& .?*
=5% Icfbmlefie Y|l&
Y|l& Errcr
Mf|erg` cb |ne
Lemg|mcf
Jegf
Lmbberefie
Um Y|g|my|md Jegf
@cx @cxer [gmr
Ngym` \ey Ymd`uy ? *
7
Ngym` \ey Ymd`uy 7
9 , 2 28
2 ,= < ;
7 ,? 2 8
|
lb
U{{er {{er
7 ,; 8 5
2 ,? 5 >
? ,> = <
?=
Oerlgygrdgf |goe` lm g|gy lmde|gnum fm`gm uam | nm|ufh yeoeygr ?,>=<, oerglg {glg |gng{ ymhfmbmdgfym ;,;;8 g|gu `eomn deim` lgrm ;,;;5& Lefhgf lejmdmgf fm`gm |ey ymd`uy ? lmf}g|gdgf `eomn oeygr lgrm{glg fm`gm |ey ymd`uy 7&
<&? <&?
[ejo [ejogn gngy gygf gf
Lgrm ngym` coyergym {efe`m|m {glg ymd`uy {er|gjg lgf delug }gfh lm`gdudgf {glg ygg| ymyxg jefheragdgf jefheragdgf |ey gdnmr gdnmr jgdg ngym`f}g jefhg`gjm jefhg`gjm {efmfhdg {efmfhdg|gf& |gf& [efmfhdg|gf gd|mm|gy ymyxg |eryeou| |erhgjogr {glg hrgbmd oermdu| mfm&
8> 82,>9
88 82 85 8<
89,78
89 8? 87 Fm`gm rg|g*rg|g ymd`uy 7
|gm`el-
Fm`gm rg|g*rg|g ymd`uy ?
,; ; 8
Hrgbmd 7& Ngym` \ey Gdnmr Ymd`uy 7 lgf ?
Gd|mm|gy ymyxg {glg ymd`uy 7 rg|g*rg|g lm{erc`en 89,78 %, lgf {glg ymd`uy delug delug lm{erc`en lm{erc`en 82,>9 %& Lefhgf Lefhgf lejmdmgf, lejmdmgf, |erlg{g| defgmdgf gd|mm|gy, gd|mm|gy, ogmd gd|mm|gy jefu`my lgf oer{mdmr ymyxg lgrm ymd`uy {er|gjg de ymd`uy delug& Ye`gmf Ye`gmf m|u, m|u, {efmf {efmfhdg hdg|gf |gf de|uf| de|uf|gyg gygf f oe`gag oe`gagrr ymyxg ymyxg auhg auhg |eragl |eraglmm {glg {glg ye|mg{ ye|mg{ ymd`uy& ymd`uy& De|uf|gyg De|uf|gygf f oe`gagr ymyxg {glg ymd`uy {er|gjg {er|gjg jefig{gm jefig{gm >; %, {glg ymd`uy delug =; %& Lefhgf lejmdmgf, |erlg{g| defgmdgf {efig{gmgf de|uf|gygf oe`gagr ymyxg yeigrg d`gymdg` lgrm ymd`uy {er|gjg de ymd`uy delug& Ngym` {efe`m|mgf mfm jefufauddgf glgf}g {efmfhdg|gf {ejgngjgf |ernglg{ mym oerm|g je`g`um jcle` {ejoe`gagrgf icc{erg|me yirm{| {glg {glg ymyx ymyxgg de`gy de`gy RMM RMM YJ[ Jungjjglm}gn \gfaufh _gag Dgou{g|ef Chgf M`mr& [efmfhdg|gf |eryeou| lmde|gnum lgrm ngym` |ey gdnmr ymd`uy {er|gjg jefufauddgf rg|g*rg|g {ejgngjgf ymyxg 89,78 lgf ymd`uy delug jefmfhdg| yeoeygr 82,>9& [ejgngjgf |ernglg{ mym ymjgdgf oerm|g ogmd yeigrg d`gymdg` auhg jefhg`gjm {efmfhdg|gf lgrm ymd`uy 7 ygj{gm lefhgf ymd`uy ?& [glg ymd`uy 7 auj`gn ymyxg }gfh jgj{u jefig{gm fm`gm
≥
25 glg`gn >;% lgf ymd`uy delug jefig{gm =;%& Gr|mf}g,
{glg {glg gdnmr gdnmr {efe`m {efe`m|mg |mgf f lmlg{ lmlg{g|d g|dgf gf `eomn `eomn lgrm lgrm >5% ymyxg ymyxg jgj{u jgj{u jef}mjgd jef}mjgd mym oerm|g& Dehmg ehmg|g |gf f
}gfh gfh lm`g m`gdudg dudgf f
huru uru mfm mfm
jeru jeru{g {gd dgf u{g} u{g}gg
huru uf|ud |ud
jefhurgmd jefhurgmdgf gf `gfhdgn*`g `gfhdgn*`gfhd fhdgn gn jcle` jcle` {ejoe`gag {ejoe`gagrgf rgf icc{erg|me yirm{| yenmfhhg ymyxg ymyxg lmngrg lmngrg{dg {dgf f lg{g| lg{g| jejgn jejgngjm gjm mym oerm|g oerm|g&& [ejgn [ejgngjg gjgf f |erngl |ernglg{ g{ mym oerm|g oerm|g jgymn {er`u lm`gdudgf {efehgygf dejog`m lgf lm{e`udgf {u`g omjomfhgf |eru|gjg {glg gd|mm|gy ymyxg jefagxgo {er|gf}ggf lgf jejoermdgf |gfhhg{gf& Ye`gjg oer`gf oer`gfhy hyufh ufh {rcyey {rcyey {ejoe` {ejoe`gag gagrgf rgf,, ymyxg ymyxg |gj{gd |gj{gd rghu*rg rghu*rghu hu uf|ud uf|ud jefagx jefagxgo go
{er| {er|gf gf} }ggf& ggf& Ng` Ng` mfm mfm lmye lmyeog ogod odgf gf {grg {grg ymyx ymyxgg |gdu |gdu|| yg`g yg`gn n lg`g lg`gj j jefa jefagx gxgo go {er|gf}gg {er|gf}ggf& f& Oehm|u Oehm|u {u`g {glg gd|mm|gy jejoermdg jejoermdgf f |gfhhg{g |gfhhg{gf, f, dehmg|gf dehmg|gf jgymn jgymn durgfh durgfh lm`gdudgf lm`gdudgf ymyxg& Yeoghmgf Yeoghmgf oeygr ymyxg ngf}g lmgj ygag jeflefhgr jeflefhgrdgf dgf {er|gf {er|gf}g }ggf gf lgrm lgrm |ejgf |ejgff} f}g& g& Ye|e`g Ye|e`gn n huru huru jejoe jejoermd rmdgf gf jc|mg jc|mgym ym lgf omjomf omjomfhg hgf f ogru`gn {grg ymyxg oergfm uf|ud jejoermdgf |gfhhg{gf& Ng` mfm lm`gdudgf uf|ud jefgrm jefgrmd d {erng| {erng|mgf mgf lgf jmfg| jmfg| ymyxg ymyxg lg`gj lg`gj {rcye {rcyeyy {ejoe {ejoe`ga `gagrg grgf f yenmfhh yenmfhhgg {glg {glg gdnmrf}g lg{g| jefim{|gdgf degd|mbgf lgf de|e`m|mgf ymyxg lg`gj jejgngjm mym oerm|g& Ygj{gm {glg gdnmr |mflgdgf delug jgymn glg |mhg crgfh }gfh jeflg{g|dgf fm`g fm`gmm gdnm gdnmrr lm ogxg ogxgn n 25& 25& Og|g Og|gyy fm`g fm`gmm }gfh }gfh lmig lmig{g {gmm c`en c`en ymyx ymyxgg glg` glg`gn gn og|g og|gyy dejgj{ dejgj{ug ugf f oerlgy oerlgygrd grdgf gf {rmfy {rmfym{ m{ oe`gag oe`gagrr |uf|gy |uf|gy&& Ng` mfm jefufa jefufaudd uddgf gf ognxg ognxg icc{erg|me me yirm{| yirm{| jgymn jefejudg {eferg{g {eferg{gf f jcle` jcle` {ejoe`gagr {ejoe`gagrgf gf icc{erg| jefejudgf f deflg`g& deflg`g&
Deflg` Deflg`gg |eryeo |eryeou| u| lmde|g lmde|gnum num lgrm lgrm ngym` ngym` |ejugf |ejugf `g{gf `g{gfhg hgf f ognxg ognxg `ejgnf `ejgnf}g }g lg}g lg}g mfhg|gf mfhg|gf ymyxg, ymyxg, jeydm{uf jeydm{uf yulgn yulgn oeru`gfh oeru`gfh*u`gfh *u`gfh {efe`m|m jefae`gyd jefae`gydgf gf |ef|gfh |ef|gfh mym oerm|g fgjuj de|mhg crgfh ymyxg |eryeou| oe`uj auhg jefig{gm og|gy de|uf|gygf jmfmjuj& Ebed|m|mm|gy jcle` {ejoe`gagrgf icc{erg|me yirm{| {er`u jeflg{g|dgf {erng|mgf huru {glg ygg| jefhgagrdgf jg|erm {ejoe`gagrgf& Deebed|mbgf |eryeou| |er`mng| {glg ygg| ymyxg jefagxgo ycg` lgrm |ejgff}g& Lm gf|grg ymyxg jgymn glg }gfh durgfh `efhdg{ jefhmdu|m {e|ufaud uf|ud jefhmdu|m `gfhdgn*`gfhdgn jcle` {ejoe`gagrgf icc{erg|me yirm{| lg`gj jejgngjm mym oerm|g& [glg [glg ymym ymym `gmf `gmf lmde lmde|g |gnu numm {u`g {u`g ognx ognxgg {efh {efhhu hufg fggf gf jcle jcle`` {ejo {ejoe` e`ga gagr grgf gf icc{er icc{erg|m g|me e
yirm{| yirm{| jejo jejoer ermd mdgf gf
oeoe oeoerg rg{g {g
jgfb jgfbgg gg||
lg`g lg`gj j
jefm jefmfh fhdg dg|d |dgf gf
dejg dejgj{ j{ug ugf f ymyx ymyxgg lg`g lg`gj j jejg jejgng ngjm jm mym mym oerm| oerm|g, g, dnuy dnuyuy uyf} f}gg lg`g lg`gj j je`g je`g|mn |mn de|ergj{m`gf ymyxg uf|ud oerlmyduym lgf |gf}g agxgo, gf|grg `gmf& 7& [ejoe`gagrgf oer`gfhyufh oer`gfhyufh `eomn ebed|mb& ebed|mb& ?& Degd|mbgf ymyxg gdgf `eomn `eomn jefmfhdg| lefhgf omjomfhgf omjomfhgf lgrm huru& 9& \eraglm \eraglm mf|erg mf|ergdym dym }gfh }gfh {cym|mb {cym|mb gf|gr gf|grgg ymyxg ymyxg lefhg lefhgf f ymyxg ymyxg lgf gf|grg gf|grg ymyxg ymyxg lefhgf huru& <& [rcyey {ejoe`gagrgf {ejoe`gagrgf oerag`gf `eomn |ergrgn lgf `eomn jefgrmd&
OGO R YMJ[U@GF LGF YG_GF
5&7 5&7
Ymj{ Ymj{u` u`gf gf
Oerl Oerlgy gygr grdg dgf f ngym ngym`` {efe {efe`m| `m|mg mgf f lm g|gy g|gy lg{g lg{g|| lmym lmymj{ j{u` u`dg dgf f ognx ognxgg jcle jcle`` {ejoe`gagrgf icc{erg|me yirm{| lg{g| jefmfhdg|dgf ngym` oe`gagr ymyxg de`gy RMM YJ[ Jungjjgl Jungjjglm}gn m}gn lg`gj {ejoe`gag {ejoe`gagrgf rgf jef}mjgd jef}mjgd oerm|g& oerm|g& Ng` mfm |eroud|m |eroud|m lgrm glgf}g {efmfhdg|gf rg|g*rg|g ngym` |ey ymd`uy 7 lmde|gnum 89,78 lgf ngym` |ey ymd`uy ? rg|g*rg|g 82,>9& Lm|mfagu lgrm {efig{gmgf de|uf|gygf oe`gagr ymyxg {glg ymd`uy 7 lm{erc`en >;% lgf ymd`uy ? lm{erc`en =;%& Lefhgf lejmdmgf, de|uf|gygf oe`gagr ymyxg jefhg`gjm {efmfhdg|gf lgrm ymd`uy 7 de ymd`uy ? yeoeygr 7;%&
5&?
Ygrgf
Oerlgygrdgf ymj{u`gf lm g|gy oermdu| mfm lg{g| {efu`my ygrgfdgf1 7& De{glg huru ogngyg Mflcfeymg dmrgf}g dmrgf}g lg{g| jeferg{dgf jcle` {ejoe`gagrgf icc{erg|me yirm{| yeoghgm yg`gn yg|u g`|erfg|mb }gfh lg{g| lm{m`mn lg`gj {rcyey
{ejoe`gagrgf oerm|g& Dejulmgf lg`gj jeferg{dgf {ejoe`gagrgf icc{erg|me yirm{| , neflgd neflgdf} f}gg huru huru ogngy ogngygg Mflcfe Mflcfeymg ymg lg{g| lg{g| jej{e jej{erng rng|md |mdgf gf ebed|m ebed|mm|g m|gyy
lg`gj jefhe`c`g de`gy lgf {efhhufggf xgd|u& ?& Lmngrg{dgf ngym` {efe`m|mgf mfm lg{g| lmhufgdgf lmhufgdgf c`en huru#{efe`m|m `gmf, yeoghgm u{g}g jefludufh mfcgym {ejoe`gagrgf dnuyuyf}g lg`gj jeferg{dgf jcle` {ejoe`gagrgf icc{erg|me yirm{| &
LGB\G_ [UY\GDG
G`meb& G`meb& ?;;>& ?;;>& ‐Lgyg ‐Lgygrr [efu`m [efu`mygf ygf Oerm|g Oerm|g‚& ‚& n||{1##xxx&rm`edy&icj n||{1##xxx&rm`edy&icj&& Lmgdy Lmgdyey ey {glg {glg |ghhg` = Beorugrm ?;;=& Ogrc|c, Gam& ?;;>& Icc{erg|me Yirm{| & n||{1##oogxcr&o`chy{c|&icj& Lmgdyey {glg |gfhhg` 7? Fcejoer ?;;>& Xmogxg, Ogyudm& ?;;9& [efe`m|mgf \mflgdgf De`gy& Agdgr|g1 Le{lmdfgy& Ogyudm, Yu`my|}c& 7=>9& \edfmd lgf Agyg lcdujef|gym& Agdgr|g1 Hrgjelmg [uy|gdg U|gjg, 7 Oulmjgf, Drmy& ?;;>& ‐Lgygr*lgygr Aurfg`my|md‚& Jgdg`gn lmjug| lg`gj [e`g|mngf Aurf Aurfg` g`my my|md |md’M ’Mfb fbc c Agxg Agxg,, 7? ’ 75 Leye Leyejo joer er ?;;5 ?;;5&& xxx&mfbcagxg&crh xxx&mfbcagxg&crh&& Lmgdyey {glg |gfhhg` = Beorugrm ?;;=& Igj{oe``, ldd& ?;;2& Je|cle [rgd|my [ejoe`gagrgf1 Oerogymy Ju`|m{`e Mf|e``mhefiey& Le{cd1 Mf|umym [reyy& I`ejey, Ngrrmy& ?;;7& Jefhgagrdgf Lmym{`mf De{glg Gfgd & Agdgr|g& Jm|rg U|gjg& Lgrjclmngrlac, Lgrlam& 7===& Yedm|gr [eflmlmdgf [gfigym`g& Agdgr|g1 Durfmg Eyg& Le{lmdfgy& ?;;9& Jg|erm [cdcd Ogngyg Mflcfeymg& Agdgr|g1 Lmraef Lmdlgyjef& Lagjgrgn, Y}gmbu` Ognrm& ?;;?& [ymdc`chm Oe`gagr& Agdgr|g1 _mfedg Im{|g& Erlmfg, Jgrmg Ymf|g lgf Ghuy Yu{rmg|fg& 7==>& [efg|grgf \er|u`my \m{e G uf|ud Huru*Huru Y@\[ auruygf Ogngyg Mflcfeymg & Agdgr|g1 Le{lmdoul& Ngjg`md, Cejgr& ?;;<& [rcyey Oe`gagr Jefhgagr & Agdgr|g1 [\ Oujm Gdygrg& M|u`e, M|u`e, Oruie Oruie L&, gfl Gflerycf, Gflerycf, Lcuh`gy& Lcuh`gy& 7==7& 7==7& G& Fex Xrm|mfh gfl _e{cr|mfh bcr \clg}”y \clg}”y Jelmg& Jelmg& Fex ]crd1 _gflcj Ncuye Mfi& Fgyu|mcf, Xgn}ulmf Fur& ?;;2& ‐Ebed|mm|gy Y|rg|ehm [ejoe`gagrgf Dc{erg|mb Lgf Edy{cym|crm \ernglg{ Ngym` Oe`gagr Ygmfy Lm|mfagu Lgrm Igrg Oer{mdmr‚& Jgdg`gn lmjug| lg`gj Aurfg` [efe`m|mgf Elmym 5 \gnuf ?;;2 & [rg}m|fc lgf Gj|m& ?;;?& Lgygr*lgygr Omjomfhgf lgf Dcfye`mfh & Agdgr|g1 _mfedg Im{|g& [cerxglgrjmf|g& 7==>& Dgjuy Ujuj Ogngyg Mflcfeymg& Agdgr|g1 Og`gm [uy|gdg&
_cy|, Jminge`& Jminge`& 7==7& 7==7& @my|efm @cflcf1 f1 [ref|m [ref|mie ie Ng`` Ng`` Mf|erf Mf|erfg|m g|mcfg cfg`` @my|efmfh fh mf Gi|mcf Gi|mcf& @cflc Efh`myn @gfhughe \eginmfh& Ygner|mgf, Inrmy|mgfg Lejgag X& ?;;<& [efhgrun [efhhufggf Ogngf Gagr lgf Hg}g Oe`gagr |ernglg{ Ngym` Oe`gagr& Gr|mde` {efe`m|mgf lm{uo`mdgymdgf je`g`um xxx& eludgym&fe|& Lmgdyey {glg |gfhhg` 7< Fcejoer ?;;>& Oe`gagrr lgf Bgd|cr Bgd|cr*bg *bgd|c d|crr }gfh }gfh Jej{ef Jej{efhgr hgrunm unmf}g f}g& Agdgr| Y`gje|c& Y`gje|c& ?;;9& ?;;9& Oe`gag Agdgr|g1 g1 _mfedg Im{|g&
Yulrgag|, Gdnjgl& ?;;8& ‐[ejoe`gagrgf Dcc{erg|mb‚& n||{1##gdnjglyulrgag|&icj& Lmgdyey {glg |gfhhg` 7< Fcejoer ?;;>& Yur}g, Neflrg& ?;;9& Dmg| Jefhgagd Gfgd Oe`gagr lgf Oer{rey|gym & Agdgr|g1 [\ E`e~ Jelmg Dcj{u|mflc& \grmhgf, Nefr} Huf|ur& 7==<& Jef}mjgd yeoghgm Yug|u De|ergj{m`gf Oerogngyg & Ogflufh1 Gfhdgyg& Ufmerym|gy Yrmxmag}g& ?;;8& [elcjgf [efu`mygf Ydrm{ym& [g`ejogfh1 \mj Lcyef& Xmfde`, X&Y& ?;;<& Omjomfhgf lgf Dcfye`mfh lm Mfy|m|uym [eflmlmdgf& Agdgr|g1 [\ Hrgjelmg Xmlmgygrgfg Mflcfeymg& ]urmlgn& ?;;<& U{g}g Jefmfhdg|dgf Dejgj{ugf Jef}mjgd Ymyxg De`gy R YL \gfaufh \gfaufh Dergfh Dergfh Deigjg|gf Deigjg|gf _gjou|gf _gjou|gf Dgou{g|ef Dgou{g|ef Ogf}ugymf Ogf}ugymf je`g`um je`g`um Jcle` Lmy|ch`cyy& Ydrm{ym jgngymyxg [rchrgj Y|ulm Ogngyg Mflcfeymg, |mlgd lm{uo`mdgymdgf& [g`ejogfh1 BDM[ Ufyrm&