Written Statement and Objections on Behalf of Defendant in Injunction Suit

BF QCO LJ_QJ@
J\ ?0>* ;773

WDMBFQB@@8

\et Emfjcmrm

P*\

AO@OFAMFQ 8

\ [jkort Fodsjf

^[BQQOF \QMQOEOFQ @BDOA KR AO@OFAMFQ _FAO[ J[AO[ PBBB [_DO = & ; J@ LWL8%

= Qco pmrm = j` tco pdmbft bs fjt absputoa Mt tco jut%sot$ tco subt `bdoa ky tco Wdmbftb``s bs prbem `mlbo fjt embftmbfmkdo obtcor bf dmw jr jf tco `mlts j` tco lmso mfa tco smeo bs dbmkdo tj ko absebssoa bf% dbebfo

; Ms smba bf soljfa pmrm j` pdmbft$ Bt bs truo tcmt —jrbnbfmddy tco prjporty eoftbjfoa bf tco pdmbft slcoaudo bs jrbnbfmtoa `rje \y Fj8 2*;l= j` mftcmrmsmfmcmddb vbddmno Imsmkm Cjkdb$ Queiur tmdui$ kodjfns tj jfo N \cmarmli$ tco `mtcor j` tco pdmbftb`` mfa tco aoòfamft― Kut aoòfamft cuekdy sukebts tcmt$

pdmbftb`` wbtc

udtorbjr ejtbvo cms fjt absldjsoa tco `mlt tcmt tco abeofsbjf bf rospolt tj mkjvo smba survoy fuekor bs jfdy 7 mlros %=7 nuftms stbdd bf tco fmeo j` N& \cmarmli wbtc [ovofuo Icmtcm Fuekor <<<& Qco lortb`boa Oxtrmlt j` mkjvo smba pcmfb bs prjauloa ko`jro tcbs Cjf‒kdo ljurt `jr ibfa porusmd j` tco smeo ms Mffoxuro%M &

< Ms smba bf soljfa pmrm j` pdmbft$ Bt bs `mdso tj smy tcmt tco `mtcor j` tco pdmbftb`` mfa aoòfamft cmvo `jreoa rosbaoftbmd dmyjut bf tco smba survoy fuekor Kut aoòfamft cuekdy sukebts tcmt$ tco `mtcor j` tco pdmbftb`` mfa aoòfamft cmvo mppdboa tj Aoputy Ljeebssbjfor Queiur `jr ljfvorsbjf j` dmfa bf \y Fj8 2*;l j` mftcmrmsmfmcmddb mftcmrmsmfmcmddb vbddmno Imsmkm Imsmkm Cjkdb$ Queiur tmdui$ tmdui$ eomsurbfn >? òot x =?7 òot

=

#=7 N_FQM\"& Qco smba mppdblmtbjf bs mpprjvoa vbao K&abs& Fj8 MDF\[8 =<0*3>%33 AMQOA 72%=7%=23>& Qco Fjtmrbsoa ljpy j` mdbofmtbjf jraor bs prjauloa `jr ibfa porusmd j` tco Cjf‒kdo ljurt ms Mffoxuro%K& Qcbs mdbofmtbjf bs fjt ljffoltoa wbtc subt slcoaudo prjporty bt bs tco mdbofmtbjf jraor j` aoòfamft‒s prjporty&

1 Ms smba bf soljfa pmrm j` pdmbft$ Bt bs `mdso mfa ebsdomabfn tj smy tcmt mf oxtoft j` >? x ==2)==; òots wms mppdboa `jr mdbofmtbjf mfa tco smba oxtofts wms tmiof `jr tco ljfstrultbjf j` rosbaoftbmd cjuso Kut aoòfamft cuekdy sukebts tcmt$ m`tor mdbofmtbjf j` mf oxtoft j` >? òot x =?7 òot #=7 N_FQM\"$ m sopmrmto pcjab wms emao ky [ovofuo mutcjrbtbos mfa oftoroa sulc mdbofmtoa dmfa pjrtbjf bf \urvoy fuekor 2*;l; j` mftcmrmsmfmcmddb vbddmno$ Imsmkm Cjkdb$ Queiur tmdui& Kut pdmbftb`` wbtc udtorbjr ejtbvo cms fjt absldjsoa tco `mlt tcmt Qjwf Qjwf pdmffbfn mpprjvmd mpprjvmd wms nbvof tj mf mf oxtoft j` >? x ==2)==; * ; òot$ Fj8 FM&RJ&W[M8 \&FJ8 32? 8 <;1 8 =23>%33 amtoa8 ;3%7?%=233& Qco fjtmrbsoa ljpy j` Qjwf pdmffbfn mpprjvmd mpprjvmd bs prjauloa ms mffoxuro “ L& Qco lortb`boa ljpy j` \urvoy fuekor 2*;l; [QL bs prjauloa `jr ibfa porusmd j` tco Cjf‒kdo ljurt ms Mffoxuro%A&

? Ms smba bf soljfa pmrm j` pdmbft$ bt bs bfljepdoto mfa wrjfn tj smy tcmt tco smba oxtofts wms tmiof ky tco aoòfamft ufaor tco ronbstoroa rodomso aooa amtoa 7;%70%=233 Kut aoòfamft cuekdy sukebts tcmt$

Qco [odomso jr \bfndo pmrtbtbjf aooa ronbstoroa jf

7<%70%=233 vbao Kjji Fj8 = bf Pjd8 Fj8 ;300 mt pmno Fj8 ===%==1 bf tco yomr =233%32 j` Queiur \ukronbstrmr j``blo wbtc [onbstrmtbjf fuekor 3>? wms oxolutoa ky aoòfamft$ ky ldomrdy stmtbfn `mlts bf pmno ; j` tco aooa ronmrabfn mdbofmtbjf$ tjwf pdmffbfn mpprjvmd$ suksoquoft nb`tbfn j` prjporty tj mf oxtoft j` >?x;3 òot tj Queiur Eufblbpmdbty `jr rjma purpjsos& Kut pdmbftb`` wbtc mf udtorbjr ejtbvo cms fjt absldjsoa tco smba `mlts bf cor pdmbft ovof m`tor mlloptbfn sulc `mlts bf tco smba rodomso jr sbfndo pmrtbtbjf aooa& Qco fjtmrbzoa ljpy j` sulc [odomso jr \bfndo pmrtbtbjf aooa bs prjauloa `jr ibfa porusmd j` tco Cjf‒kdo ljurt ms Mffoxuro% O&

;

0 Ms smba bf soljfa pmrm j` pdmbft$ — Mlljrabfndy mfjtcor sjf j` scmarmli ky fmeo \ \mesjf mdsj sopmrmtoa `rje tco `mebdy ky tmibfn tco scmro Oxtoft Omst wost 2; òot$ Fjrtc \jutc =;>)=;1 òot ky oxolutbfn ronbstoroa rodomso aooa bf `mvjur j` scmarmli jf <=%=7%;77;― bs m ebsdomabfn mssortbjf Bt bs ùddy aofboa ky aoòfamft Aoòfamft cuekdy sukebts tcmt$

m`tor tcbs pdmbftb``

tjji tco mdbofmtoa pjrtbjf$ tco roembfbfn oxtoft wms ;= nuftms jut j` tcmt == == nuftms wms tmiof ky \& \mesjf mfa sulc Icmtcm bs emao emao bf rovofuo ronbstor vbao Icmtcm Fuekor ;23 ms lmf ko soof `rje Mffoxuro%M& Qco smba dmfa bs stbdd mnrbludturmd dmfa mfa fj mdbofmtbjf jraor wms emao bf rospolt tj sulc dmfa$ m rodomso aooa `mflbdy qujtbfn oxtofts woro oxolutoa wbtcjut mfy donmd kmsbs `jr bt&

> Ms smba bf soljfa pmrm j` pdmbft$ tcmt —tco `mtcor j` tco pdmbftb`` rotmbfoa tco oxtofts roembfbfn Omst%ôst 33 òot Fjrtc \jutc$ tjwmras Omstorf sbao =;= òot$ jf wostorf sbao ==0 òot wcorobf ljfstrultoa [LL cjuso― bs mf bddonmd mssortbjf Bt bs ùddy aofboa ky aoòfamft Aoòfamft cuekdy sukebts tcmt$

tco oxtoft roembfoa

m`tor pmrtbtbjf mejfn twj sjf‒s bs =7 Nuftms wcblc wms oftoroa bf Icmtcm j` Wdmbftb``‒s mfa tcbs aoòfamft‒s `mtcors fmeo& Qco `mtcor j` tco pdmbftb`` rotmbfoa sulc oxtoft jfdy& Qco smba dmfa ovof mt prosoft bs stbdd mnrbludturmd dmfa mfa fj mdbofmtbjf jraor wms emao bf rospolt tj sulc dmfa$ kut `mtcor j` pdmbftb`` bf ljddusbjf wbtc eufblbpmd mutcjrbtbos cms lromtoa bddonmd eufblbpmd Icmtcm tj mf oxtoft j` Omst%ôst 33 òot Fjrtc \jutc$ tjwmras Omstorf sbao =;= òot$ jf wostorf sbao ==0 òot wbtcjut mfy mdbofmtbjf jraor jr mfy Qjwf pdmffbfn mpprjvmd& \ulc mttbtuao bs vbjdmtbjf j` \oltbjf 2?#;" mfa \oltbjf 20 j` Imrfmtmim Dmfa [ovofuo Mlt =201$ pdmbftb`` bs ufaor donmd pofmd prjvbsbjf mfa sooibfn tcbs Cjf‒kdo ljurts prjloss wbtcjut ljebfn bf ldomf cmfas ko`jro tco ljurt&

3 Ms smba bf soljfa pmrm j` pdmbft$ tcmt — \ubt slcoaudo prjporty wms nb`toa ky cbe bf `mvjur j` tco pdmbftb`` ufaor ronbstoroa nb`t aooa amtoa =0%7>%;771 mfa aodbvoroa pcysblmd pjssossbjf tj tco pdmbftb`` `jr cor kjfm`bao uso mfa jllupmtbjf― bs m ebsdomabfn mssortbjf Bt bs ùddy aofboa ky aoòfamft Aoòfamft cuekdy

<

sukebts tcmt$

tco `mtcor j` pdmbftb`` mfa aoòfamft jfdy cma mkjut

=7 nuftms j` dmfa bf cbs fmeo$ co cms fjt ljfvortoa tco smeo jr emao mfy o``jrt tj cmvo mfy MAD[ jraor tj ljfvort Nuftm eomsuroeoft tj @oot eomsuroeoft$ cms `mflbdy wrbttof wrjfn eomsuroeoft j` Omst%ôst 33 òot Fjrtc \jutc$ tjwmras Omstorf sbao =;= òot$ jf wostorf sbao ==0 òot$ wcblc turfs jut tj mf mpprjxbemto mpprjxbemto =71;3 sq `t mfa mfa rjma emrnbf ;101 ;101 sq `t wcblc turfs jut tj ==&3< ==&3< nuftms& Qcbs tbtdo tbtdo tj tco oxtoft oxtoft j` ==&3< ==&3< nuftms bs fjt tcoro tj tco ajfjr Er N&\cmarmli& Qmibfn mdd tcoso bddonmd mlts Wdmbftb`` bf ljddusbjf j` N&\cmarmli sooibfn ljurts prjloss tj bddonmddy cbao tcobr ebsaooas&

2 Ms smba bf soljfa pmrm j` pdmbft$ —co #`mtcor" mdsj dbvbfn wbtc tco pdmbftb`` bf cor eoss tj oio jut cbs dbvodbcjja bf cbs jdaof amys― Bt bs ùddy aofboa ky aoòfamft Qcbs `mdso `mlt bs purpjsoùddy arm`toa tj not tco pbty j` Cjf‒kdo ljurt bfspbto j` tco `mlt ` mlt tcmt tcbs aoòfamft‒s aoòfamft‒s `mtcor bs nottbfn pofsbjf `rje loftrmd njvorfeoft ms rotbroa Mssbstmft Wjst Emstor mfa wodd j`` bf cbs rotbroa dbò

=7 Qco mvoreofts emao bf soljfa pmrm j` tco pdmbft ldmbebfn mksjduto jwforscbp mfa pjssossbjf mfa ofhjyeoft j` tco subt slcoaudo prjporty bs ùddy aofboa Bt bs put tj strblt prjj` j` donmdbty j` trmfsòr mfa jwforscbp bf tco mddonoa eomsuroeoft Qco mvoreofts emao bf tco pdmbft soljfa pmrm rodmtoa tj icmtcm bf tco fmeo j` tco pdmbftb`` mfa pmyeoft j` tmxos tj bt bs ùddy aofboa$ mfa bt bs dbmkdo tj strblt prjj` wcotcor sulc icmtcm bs emao jut m`tor mdbofmtbjf mfa tjwf pdmffbfn mpprjvmd Qco eomsuroeofts qujtoa bf pdmbft btsod` bs bddonmd mfa bts pjssossbjf mfa ofhjyeoft bs btsod` lmffjt ko mslortmbfoa mt tcbs stmno wbtcjut prjaultbjf j` rovofuo roljras sulc ms —WMIIM KJJI #CB\\M \_[POR" @J[E ?―$ mfa —Imrfmtmim [ovbsbjf \ottdoeoft

MIM[KMFAC #_QQM[_"―$ tj

mslortmbf mslortmbf tco kjufamrbos j` subt slcoaudo prjporty

== Qco mvoreofts bf pmrm tcroo j` tco pdmbft tcmt tcbs aoòfamft bs krjtcor j` pdmbftb`` bs fjt aofboa Qco mvoreofts bf pmrm tcroo j` pdmbft tcmt —aoòfamft cms ljfstrultoa m rosbaoftbmd cjuso ky

1

oflrjmlcbfn tco wostorf pjrtbjf eomsurbfn ;7; sq `t mfa cms ljfstrultoa bddonmddy wbtcjut domvbfn tco sot kmli mfa tco smba oxtofts corobf m`torwmras lmddoa ms subt K slcoaudo prjporty― tcbs mvoreofts bs tjtmddy `mdso$ Bt bs ùddy aofboa ky aoòfamft Kut aoòfamft cuekdy sukebts tcmt$ tcoro bs fj oflrjmlceoft jr tcoro bs fj oflrjmlceoft wbtc rospolt tj sot kmli$ tco pdmbftb`` bs wodd mwmro j` sulc `mlt mfa coflo tcoy cmvo fjt ldomrdy stmtoa bf subt slcoaudo prjporty mkjut –K slcoaudo prjporty‒ bfspbto j` kobfn roòrroa bf pmrm tcroo j` tco pdmbft&

=; Aoòfamft cuekdy sukebts tcmt$ Qco pdmbftb`` cms mvorroa bf pmrm tcroo j` tco pdmbft tcmt sco cms aoslrbkoa ejro ùddy tco K slcoaudo prjporty bf tco rjunc siotlc$ tco rjunc siotlc ljpy bs fjt suppdboa tj tcbs aoòfamft$ tco rjunc siotlc bs tjtmddy absputoa ky tcbs aoòfamft$ coflo tcbs aoòfamft rosorvos cbs rbnct tj `bdo ùrtcor wrbttof stmtoeoft m`tor ljpy j` rjunc siotlc bs prjvbaoa ky pdmbftb``& Qco aoslrbptbjf j` rjunc siotlc mfa ljfsoquoft mddonmtbjf bf pmrm tcroo j` pdmbft bs ljepdotody aofboa& Qco eomsuroeofts qujtoa bf pmrm tcroo j` pdmbft mro `mdso& Qcoro bs fj oflrjmlceoft ms tj mddonoa eomsuroeoft j` ;7; sq `t& Qco pdmbftb`` prjporty bs 0 òot mwmy `rje aoòfamfts kubdabfn dbfo& Qco sot kmli kmli j` 0 òot mltumddy kodjfns tj aoòfamft mfa pdmbftb`` bs ldmbebfn sulc eomsuroeoft wbtcjut mfy donmd kmsbs&

=< Aoòfamft cuekdy sukebts tcmt$ Qco pdmbftb`` mfa `mtcor j` pdmbftb`` auo tj tcobr jda mno cms fjt prjpordy embftmbfoa tcobr mnrbludturmd dmfa mfa coflo bt bs lmusbfn fubsmflo tj kjtc pdmbftb`` mfa tcbs aoòfamft mdsj& \ulc fubsmflo bs sod` lromtoa jfo$ mfa pdmbftb`` `mdsody mddonbfn sulc tcbfns bf cor pdmbft pmrm tcroo& Qco eomsuroeoft j` rjjes mfa scoa mro fjt absputoa sulc ljfstrultbjfs mro wbtcbf tco kjufamry j` aoòfamft prjporty$ pdmbftb`` bs fjt cmvbfn mfy rbnct jvor tco smeo& Qco smba ljfstrultbjfs mro ljepdotoa ky aoòfamft bf =232

mfa m`tor tcmt tcoro wms fj fow ljfstrultbjfs& Qcoro bs fj

oflrjmlceoft ronmrabfn sulc ljfstrultbjfs& Qco smba ljfstrultbjfs cmvo fjt oflrjmlcoa mfy j` tco pjrtbjfs j` pdmbftb`` prjporty&

?

=1 Ms mddonoa bf pmrm tcroo j` tco pdmbft$ Bt bs `mdso tj smy tcmt aoòfamft wmfts tj ifjli j`` vmdumkdo prjporty j` pdmbftb`` Bt bs `mdso tj smy tcmt rmbf wmtor bs `djwbfn tjwmras pdmbftb`` cjuso mfa lromtbfn fubsmflo mfa ofamfnorbfn dbò j` pdmbftb`` Bt bs `mdso tj smy tcoro bs sjeo bfstbnmtbjf `rje bfnofbjus krmbf kocbfa aoòfamft Bt bs `mdso tj smy tcmt aoòfamft cms ajfo bddonmd mlts mfa donmd jr bddonmd oflrjmlceofts Bt bs `mdso tj smy tcmt tcbs aoòfamft cms lmusoa amemnos amemnos tj pdmbftb`` tj tco tufo j` [s =7$777%77 sbflo ;77; ;77; Bt bs `mdso tj smy tcmt pdmbftb`` mdjfn wbtc cor `mtcor roquostoa aoòfamft tj aoejdbsc tco ufmutcjrbsoa strulturo wcblc wms ljfstrultoa bf tco dmfa j` tco pdmbftb``

=? Ms mddonoa bf pmrm tcroo j` pdmbft$ Bt bs `mdso tj smy tcmt tcbs aoòfamft bs ejfboa mfa pjdbtblmddy bf`duofloa porsjf bf tco djlmdbty mfa cmvbfn kma odoeofts bf cbs cmfa Aoòfamft cuekdy sukebts tcmt$ Ljftrmrbdy pdmbftb`` mfa cor `mtcor wbtc sjeo ljurt kbras mro `bdbfn `mdso lmsos mnmbfst sjeo bfstbtutbjfs bfstbtutbjfs bf jraor jraor tj kdmliembd tcoe mfa tj sottdo tco emttor `jr ejfotmry nmbf& Ms

mddonoa bf pmrm tcroo j` tco pdmbft$ Bt bs `mdso tj smy tcmt aoòfamft cms tcromtofoa tco pdmbftb`` emfy tbeo fjt tj quostbjf cbe bf tcbs ronmra

=0& Ms mddonoa bf pmrm tcroo j` tco pdmbft$ Bt bs [bnct tj smy tcmt dmfa j`

aoòfamft bs vmdumkdo dmfa kobfn bt bs mdbofmtoa jfo cmvbfn >?x;3 òot rjma tjwmras sjutcorf sbao j` tco prjporty Kut aoòfamft cuekdy sukebts tcmt$ pdmbftb`` `mdsody ldmbes rbnct jvor tco eufblbpmd rjma pjrtbjf oxldusbvody `jr tcobr bfnross mfa jutnross$ bfspbto j` tco `mlt tcmt bt bs pukdbl rjma&

=> Ms mddonoa bf pmrm tcroo j` tco pdmbft$ Bt bs `mdso tj smy tcmt dmfa j` pdmbftb`` bs oflrjmlcoa ky aoòfamft Bt bs `mdso tj smy tcmt dmfa j` pdmbftb`` bs vmdumkdo Bt bs `mdso tj smy tcmt aoòfamft cms mdsj aunnoa sjmi pbt bf tco oflrjmlcoa oflrjmlcoa pjrtbjf Bt bs `mdso tj smy tcmt sulc sjmi pbt oeornos `jud seodd Bt bs `mdso tj smy tcmt bt bs ofamfnorbfn ofamfnorbfn cuemf dbò

0

=3 Ms mddonoa bf pmrm tcroo j` tco pdmbft$ Bt bs `mdso tj smy tcmt auo tj `jud seodd `mtcor j` pdmbftb`` bs su`òrbfn `rje vmrbjus bddfoss Bt bs `mdso tj smy tcmt `mtcor j` pdmbftb`` spofabfn cuno ejfoy `jr cbs roljvory mt cbs jda mno Aoòfamft cuekdy sukebts tcmt$ ljftrmrbdy aoòfamft cuekdy sukebts tcmt pdmbftb`` `mtcor cms `bdoa bepdomabfn mppdblmtbjf ms NWM cjdaor scjwbfn ab`òroft lmuso bf cbs m``bamvbt& Wdmbftb`` pdomas cor `mtcor ms koarbaaof mfa bepdomabfn mppdblmft swomrs cor amunctor ms koarbaaof& Bt bs poròlt mkuso j` prjloss j` ljurt&

=2 Ms mddonoa bf pmrm tcroo j` tco pdmbft$ Bt bs `mdso tj smy tcmt aoòfamft aoòfamft cms do`t tco wmsto wmsto wmtor pudd jut `rje tco kmtcrjje kmtcrjje tjwmras tco dmfa j` pdmbftb`` Bt bs `mdso tj smy tcmt tcbs aoòfamft bs ofamfnorbfn tco cuemf dbò Bt bs `mdso tj smy tcmt aoòfamft wmft tj cmrmss tco pdmbftb`` Bt bs `mdso tj smy tcmt aoòfamft bs emibfn mfa mttoeptbfn tj ljfstrult poremfoft poremfoft strulturo tjwmras wostorf sbao j` cbs cjuso Bt bs `mdso tj smy tcmt spmlo tjwmras wostorf sbao j` aoòfamft cjuso kodjfns tj pdmbftb`` Ljftrmrbdy aoòfamft cuekdy sukebts tcmt$ tco 0 òot spmlo tjwmras wostorf sbao j` aoòfamft cjuso kodjfns tj tcbs aoòfamft mfa bt bs tco donmd sotkmli& Wdmbftb`` tmibfn mavmftmno j` fjf mdbofmtbjf j` cor mnrbludturmd prjporty `mdsody ldmbebfn aoòfamfts sot kmli&

;7 Ms mddonoa bf pmrm tcroo j` tco pdmbft$ Bt bs `mdso tj smy tcmt aoòfamft bs fjt m dmw mkbabfn lbtbzof Qco `mlt j` fjtblo nbvof ky pdmbftb`` ljufsod mfa ropdy j` aoòfamft ljufsod bs fjt aofboa$ kut tco mddonmtbjf tcmt ropdy bs ovmsbvo bs aofboa Bt bs `mdso tj smy tcmt `bdbfn j` lmvomt bs eomft tj cmrmss c mrmss pdmbftb`` pdmbftb``

;= Ms mddonoa bf pmrm `jur j` tco pdmbft$ Qco ajlueofts prjauloa ky pdmbftb`` ajos fjt tostb`y `mlt j` pdmbftb``‒s mksjduto pjssossbjf mfa ofhjyeoft Wdmbftb`` `mbdoa tj prjvbao mfy dbst j` ajlueofts ms roqubroa ufaor rudos j` prmltblo Qcbs aoòfamft rosorvos cbs rbnct tj `bdo maabtbjfmd wrbttof stmtoeoft m`tor suppdybfn dbst j` ajlueofts ky pdmbftb`` Wdmbftb`` `mbdoa tj prjaulo bepjrtmft rovofuo ajlueofts wcblc wbdd mslortmbf kjufamrbos mfa oxtoft j`

>

subt slcoaudo prjporty Bfstoma ajlueofts prjauloa ky tcbs aoòfamft scjws tcmt pdmbftb`` cms ebsroprosoftoa tj ljurt wbtc `mio lromtoa ajlueofts ky vbjdmtbfn emfamtjry Imrfmtmim dmfa rovofuo dmws

;; Qco lmuso j` mltbjf ms scjwf bf tco pmrm `bvo j` pdmbft ky pdmbftb`` ms =0%7>%;771 mfa jf =2%70%;773 bs `mdso Aoòfamft cms `bfbscoa cbs cjuso ljfstrultbjf bf =232 btsod`$ tcoro wms fj maabtbjfmd ljfstrultbjf m`tor =232 Wdmbftb`` mfa cor `mtcor m`tor dbvbfn pomloùddy wbtcjut rmbsbfn mfy jkholtbjfs `rje =232 cms lromtoa `mio lmuso j` mltbjf tcrjunc mf bddonmd mddonmtbjf Coflo subt bs dbmkdo tj ko absebssoa `jr wmft j` lmuso j` mltbjf Qco mddonoa lmuso j` mltbjf bs dbmkdo tj strblt prjj` j` tco smeo

;< Qco subt bs kmrroa ky dbebtmtbjf Qco pdmbftb`` mfa cor `mtcor rosbabfn bf fobnckjurbfn dmfa bs vory eulc mwmro j` tco `mlt j` ljfstrultbjf mfa ljepdotbjf j` aoòfamft aoòfamft cjuso bf =232 mfa tcoro wms fj absputo jr jkholtbjf mt tcmt tbeo jr uftj tj tco tbeo j` fjtblo soft ky pdmbftb`` jf =2%70%;773 Qco pdmbftb`` mfa cor `mtcor mro ostjppoa ky —Ostjppod j` Ljfault― mdsj Qco jtcor mddonmtbjfs emao bf pmrm ? j` tco pdmbft bs jflo mnmbf ropomtoa ky pdmbftb`` mdd sulc mddonmtbjfs mro `mdso mfa bs aofboa bf tjtj

;1 Qco subt slcoaudo prjporty `jr `jr tco purpjsos j` pmyeoft pmyeoft j` ljurt òo bf rospolt tj rodbo` sjunct bf pdmbft prmyor mfa rodbo` ljduef bs purpjsoùddy ufaor vmduoa$ tco prosoft emriot vmduo j` tco surrjufabfn pdmlo bs mkjut [s 177 tj [s 077 por sq `t$ bfspbto j` tco ldmbes tcmt bt bs rosbaoftbmd prjporty ms eoftbjfoa bf subt mvoreofts mfa mfa

slcoaudo$ slcoaud o$ mfa rodbo` ldmbeoa bs bf rospolt tj

aoldmrmtbjf j` tbtdo$ pdmbftb`` cms cms tj pmy ljurt òo òo jf emriot vmduo vmduo j` tco prjporty$ b` tco emriot vmduo bs tmiof mt [s 177%77 por sq òot tcof emriot vmduo j` subt slcoaudo prjporty ljeos tj [s 1=$>=$;77%77$ wcblc lrjssos tco polufbmry hurbsabltbjf j` tcbs Cjf‒kdo ljurt Coflo subt bs dbmkdo dbmkdo tj ko absebssoa jf tcmt nrjufa mdsj

3

;? Qco pdmbftb`` cms mdsj sjunct emfamtjry bfhufltbjf uf%ljffoltoa tj embf rodbo` wcblc cms tj ko vmduoa sopmrmtody ky pmybfn ljurt òo `jr tco rodbo` fj8 #l" ms sjunct bf tco pdmbft prmyor mfa rodbo` ljduef Coflo subt bs beprjpordy vmduoa mfa dbmkdo tj ko absebssoa ufdoss prjpor ljurt òo bs pmba$ wbtc prjpor vmdumtbjf sdbp

;0 \ubt bs kma `jr `j r fjf%hjbfaor j` folossmry pmrty tcmt bs ljeebssbjfor LEL Queiur [jma j` >?x;3 òot tjwmras sjutcorf sbao j` aoòfamfts prjporty oxldusbvody kodjfns tj LEL `jr pukdbl uso kut pdmbftb`` ljftofas bf pmrm tcroo j` pdmbft tcmt bt bs eomft `jr bfnross mfa onross j` kjtc pmrtbos bflduabfn \ \mesjf Ky sulc mssortbjf pdmbftb`` wmfts tj ostmkdbsc prbvmto rbnct jvor sulc pukdbl rjma

;> Qco \lcoaudo prjporty bf rospolt tj bts eomsuroeoft bs ùddy aofboa ky tcbs aoòfamft aoòfamft Wdmbftb`` bs put tj strblt prjj` j` tco tc o smeo

;3 ^btcjut prohuablo tj tco mkjvo ljftoftbjfs$ tcbs Aoòfamft cuekdy sukebts$ tcmt$ tco Wdmbftb``s cmvo aodbkormtody emao lortmbf `mdso mvoreofts tj subt tcobr lmso mnmbfst tcbs Aoòfamft Qcbs Aoòfamft ùrtcor sukebts$ tcmt$ tco mvoreofts wcblc mro fjt spolb`blmddy aofboa jr trmvorsoa coroky mro aooeoa tj ko aofboa ms `mdso mfa Wdmbftb``s wbdd ko put tj tco strblt prjj` j` tco smeo Qcbs Aoòfamft lrmvos `jr ibfa bfaudnoflo j` tcbs Cjf‒kdo Ljurt mfa tcbs Cjf‒kdo Ljurt emy ko pdomsoa tj mddjw tcbs Aoòfamft tj rmbso maabtbjfmd nrjufas$ nrjufas$ b` mfy$ mt tco tc o tbeo j` comrbfn tco subt

^CO[O@J[O$ bf tco mkjvo `mlts mfa lbrluestmflos j` tco lmso$ bt bs ejst rospoltùddy prmyoa$ tcmt$ tcbs Cjf‒kdo Ljurt emy ko pdomsoa tj absebss tco subt `bdoa ky tco Wdmbftb``s mnmbfst tcbs Aoòfamft mdjfn wbtc oxoepdmry ljsts bf tco bftorost j` hustblo mfa oqubty

MAPJLMQO @J[ AO@OFAMFQ AO@OFAMFQ PO[B@BLMQBJF

2

B$ \ [JKO[Q FOD\JF$ tco Aoòfamft corobf$ aj coroky vorb`y mfa aoldmro tcmt$ wcmt bs stmtoa mkjvo bs truo mfa ljrrolt tj tco kost j` ey ifjwdoano$ bf`jremtbjf mfa kodbo`

Wdmlo8 Queiur Amto8 =2%73%73

AO@OFAMFQ

BF QCO LJ_[Q J@ * ;773 WDMBFQB@@8

\et Emfjcmrm

P*\ AO@OFAMFQ 8

\ [jkort Fodsjf

DB\Q & AJL_EOFQ\ W[JA_LOA KR AO@OFAMFQ

FJ

AJL_EOFQ WM[QBL_DM[\

WMNO\

FMQ_[O

M

[QL% WCMFB J@ \y Fj8 2*;l= j`

=

LO[QB@BOA

mftcmrmsmfmcmddb mftcmrmsmfmcmddb vbddmno K

Qco mdbofmtbjf jraor j` Aoputy

OSQ[MLQ ;

ljeebssbjfor Kabs Fj8 MDF\[8

FJQM[B\OA LJWR

=<0*3>%33 AMQOA 72%=7%=23> L

Qjwf pdmffbfn mpprjvmd mpprjvmd ljpy

=

FMRJW[M8 \FJ8 32? 8 <;1 8 =23>%33

FJQM[B\OA LJWR

amtoa8 ;3%7?%=233 A

[QL% WCMFB J@ \y Fj8 2*;l; j`

=

mftcmrmsmfmcmddb mftcmrmsmfmcmddb vbddmno O

[odomso jr \bfndo pmrtbtbjf aooa

LO[QB@BOA OSQ[MLQ

?

FJQM[B\OA LJWR

=7

Wdmlo8 Queiur Amto8 =2%73%73 Aoòfamft Mavjlmto `jr aoòfamft PO[B@BLMQBJF

Qco ljftofts j` ajlueofts prjauloa ms mffoxuro M tj O mro truo mfa ljrrolt tj tco kost j` ey ifjwdoano$ bf`jremtbjf mfa kodbo` kodbo`

Wdmlo8 Queiur Amto8 =2%73%73 Aoòfamft

BF QCO LJ_QJ@
J\ ?0>* ;773

WDMBFQB@@8

\et Emfjcmrm

P*\

AO@OFAMFQ 8

JKHOLQBJF\

\ [jkort Fodsjf

QJ

QCO

[OM\JF\

\^J[FOA

BF

MAPMFLOEOFQ

MWWDBLMQBJF J@ WDMBFQB@@8%

= Qco mppdblmft Er N\cmarmli cms `bdoa mppdblmtbjf tj mavmflo tco lmso `rje =2%73%;773 Qco mppdblmft cms fj djlus stmfab tj `bdo sulc mppdblmtbjf ufdoss co bs bs porebttoa ufaor ufaor Jraor < [udo [udo ; j` LWL Coflo tco mppdblmtbjf mfa bts mlljepmfybfn m``bamvbt bs dbmkdo tj ko roholtoa bf dbebfo bf tco bftorost j` Hustblo

; Qco mppdblmft cms swjrfoa tj `mdso m``bamvbt j` `mlts$ tco mddonoa bflbaofts cmvo fjt cmppofoa mt tco mddonoa tbeo Qco slofmrbj oxbstbfn ms jf jr ko`jro `bdbfn j` tco mkjvo subt obtcor bf ey

==

proebsos jr tjwmras mfy j` ey fobnckjurors$ f obnckjurors$ tco smeo slofmrbj bs ljftbfubfn mfa fj ovoft jr lcmfno cms jllurroa ms mddonoa jr bf mfy jtcor wmy

< Qco stjfo dmybfn ky fobnckjurbfn dmfa jwfors wms stjppoa ky mppdblmft tcmt bs N\cmarmli wbtc sjeo vofnomflo sjeowcoro bf =221 Qco stjfo ljepjufa kodjfns tj fobnckjurbfn dmfa jwfor tcmt bs N \cmftcmrmhu bf survoy fuekor 2*;a j` Mftcmrmsmfmcmddb Nrmem$ Imsmkm Cjkdb$ Queiur tmdui Qco smba fobnckjuror bs m ldjso rodmtbvo j` kjtc N \cmarmli mfa mdsj j` tcbs aoòfamft

1 Aoòfamft Aoòfamft jr Mppdblmft cms fjtcbfn tj aj wbtc omstorf pjrtbjf j` aoòfamfts aoòfamfts dmfa jfdy porsjf wcj lmf quostbjf mfy nrbovmflo ms tj omstorf pjrtbjf j` aoòfamft dmfa bs Er N \cmftcmrmhu Qco mppdblmft ldmfaostbfody jut j` bdd%wbdd mfa nruano cms `bdoa mavmfloeoft mppdblmtbjf hust tj cmrmss tcbs aoòfamft wcof co wms jut j` tjwf tj omrf cbs kroma

? Qcoro bs fj lmuso tj mavmflo tco lmso mfa tco mddonoa lmuso bs `mkrblmtoa jfo hust tj cmrmss tcbs aoòfamft Qco mppdblmft mddonos tcmt co cms dmba tco stjfo sdmks Bf mltumdbty bt bs tco stjfo sdmks j` fobnckjuror Bt mejufts tj fjf%hjbfaor j` folossmry pmrty mfa mdsj prjsolutbjf j` fow lmuso j` mltbjf fjt rodmtoa tj tco subt lmuso

0 Ms mddonoa bf bf tco mppdblmtbjf tcbs aoòfamft aoòfamft bs fjt pjworùd tcmf cbs `mtcor fjfo jtcor tcmf tco mppdblmft Qco mppdblmft bf tco mno j` 3= yomrs scjwbfn cbs bepmtboft mrrjnmflo mfa vofnomflo ky `jrnottbfn cbs pmst oxporboflo j` dbò Bf fj wmy tcbs aoòfamft cms scjwf mfy mrrjnmflo tjwmras cbs `mtcor Bf fj wmy aoòfamft bs ao`mlbfn tco strulturo bf jraor tj absprjvo tco pdmbft rjunc siotlc Wdmbft rjunc siotlc bs fjt m donmddy mutcoftblmtoa ajlueoft ajlueoft

=;

> Qco subt slcoaudo prjporty bs stbdd mf mnrbludturmd dmfa$ fjt ljfvortoa tj fjf%mnrbludturmd uso$ jfdy rovofuo ajlueofts lmf mslortmbf truo kjufamrbos j` subt slcoaudo prjporty Qco icmtcm mfa bts eomsuroeofts bf eufblbpmd roljras mro fjt emao bf m donmd wmy \ulc bddonmd ajlueofts lmffjt `jre tco kmsbs `jr mfy ldmbes j` obtcor pdmbftb`` jr cor mppdblmft

3

Qco eomsuroeofts qujtoa bf pdmbft btsod` bs bddonmd mfa bts pjssossbjf mfa ofhjyeoft bs btsod` lmffjt ko mslortmbfoa mt tcbs stmno wbtcjut prjaultbjf j` rovofuo roljras sulc ms —WMIIM KJJI #CB\\M \_[POR" @J[E ?―$ mfa —Imrfmtmim [ovbsbjf \ottdoeoft MIM[KMFAC #_QQM[_"―$ tj mslortmbf tco kjufamrbos j` subt slcoaudo prjporty

2 Bf tcbs mno dbstofbfn tj kma oljfjeblmddy nrooay vjblos tco mppdblmft mfa pdmbftb`` mro prjsolutbfn `mdso ljepdmbfts mfa lmsos

Wdmbftb`` mfa mppdblmft emy ko mavbsoa ky tcbs Cjf‒kdo ljurt tj mpprjmlc ljflbdbmtbjf mfa ljufsoddbfn `jrue tj sottdo tco emttor bf m pomloùd wmy bf jraor tj mvjba uf%folossmry dbtbnmtbjf mfa wmsto j` tbeo `rje wrjfn mavbsos mavbsos

Mavjlmto `jr Aoòfamft

Aoòfamft

PO[B@BLMQBJF B aj m``bre mkjvo ljftofts ms truo mfa ljrrolt tj tco kost j` ey ifjwdoano mfa kodbo`

Wdmlo8 Queiur Amto8 73%73%73

Aoòfamft

=<

BF QCO LJ_QJ@
J\ ?0>* ;773

WDMBFQB@@8

\et Emfjcmrm

P*\

AO@OFAMFQ 8

\ [jkort Fodsjf

JKHOLQBJF\ JKHOLQ BJF\ QJ QCO

MWWDBLMQBJF J@ WDMBFQB@@ _FAO[ J[AO[ <

[_DO ; 8%

=1

= Qco mppdblmft Er N\cmarmli cms `bdoa mppdblmtbjf tj sooi porebssbjf tj prjsoluto tco lmso Qco `mlts swjrfoa bf tco m``bamvbt mro `mdso ; Qcoro bs fj suppjrtbfn ajlueoft tj prjvo tco romsjfs swjrfoa bf tco m``bamvbt < Qco pdmbftb`` bs vory eulc cmdo mfa comdtcy mfa prosoft jf <7%7>% ;773 ko`jro tco ljurt 1 Qco romsjf swjrfoa bs `mdso$ pdmbftb`` bs fjt mnoa$ jfdy tco mppdblmft bs mnoa Qco mppdblmft mppdblmft cms fjt scjwf prjpor lmuso tj `bdo sulc mppdblmtbjf ? Qco mppdblmtbjf bs fjt embftmbfmkdo obtcor obtcor bf dmw jr jf `mlts 0 Coflo tco mppdblmtbjf mfa bts mlljepmfybfn m``bamvbt bs dbmkdo tj ko roholtoa roholtoa bf dbebfo bf tco bftorost j` Hustblo > Wdmbftb`` cms mddonoa oflrjmlceoft bf wostorf sbao j` aoòfamft prjporty bf tco pdmbft$ wcblc bs absputoa ky tcbs aoòfamft aoòfamft kut fjw mppdblmft cms `bdoa mppdblmtbjf ms mf mnoft tj put `jrwmra cbs jwf lmuso ldmbebfn cbs tbtdo tj stjfo ljepjufa$ wcblc bs bf fj wmy rodmtoa tj prosoft subt Qco mppdblmft cms tj `bdo sopmrmto subt bepdomabfn

fobnckjurbfn

dmfa

jwfor

bf

jraor

tj

ldmbe

fobnckjurors stjfo ljepjufa 3 Qcoro bs fj lmuso tj mavmflo tco lmso jr tj `bdo tco mppdblmtbjf mppjbftbfn mnoft mfa tco mddonoa lmuso bs `mkrblmtoa jfo hust tj cmrmss tcbs aoòfamft 2 Bf tcbs mno dbstofbfn tj kma oljfjeblmddy nrooay vjblos tco mppdblmft mfa pdmbftb`` mro prjsolutbfn `mdso ljepdmbfts mfa lmsos

=7 Bt bs cuekdy sukebttoa tcmt$ Wdmbftb`` mfa mppdblmft emy ko mavbsoa ky tcbs Cjf‒kdo ljurt tj mpprjmlc ljflbdbmtbjf mfa ljufsoddbfn `jrue tj sottdo tco emttor bf m pomloùd wmy bf jraor tj mvjba uf% folossmry dbtbnmtbjf mfa wmsto j` tbeo `rje wrjfn mavbsos Fj cmre jr bfhury wbdd ko lmusoa tj mppdblmft*pdmbftb`` b` tcbs BM bs absebssoa Jf tco jtcor cmfa tcbs aoòfamft wbdd ko put tj nromt cmrascbp ky tco bddonmd mlts j` mppdblmft*pdmbftb`` wcj emy tmio mavmftmno j` mfy bftorbe jraors mfa oflrjmlc upjf prjporty j` fobnckjuror lromtbfn tofsbjf ko`jro aoòfamft cjuso

=?

^coro`jro tco Cjf‒kdo ljurt emy ko pdomsoa tj absebss mppdblmtbjf bf tco bftorost j` hustblo


Aoòfamft



Aoòfamft

BF QCO LJ_QJ@
J\ ?0>* ;773

WDMBFQB@@8

\et Emfjcmrm

P*\

AO@OFAMFQ 8

\ [jkort Fodsjf

JKHOLQBJF\ JKHOLQ BJF\ QJ QCO

MWWDBLMQBJF J@ WDMBFQB@@ _FAO[ J[AO[ <2

[_DO = & ; 8%

= Qco BM bs fjt embftmbfmkdo embftmbfmkdo obtcor jf `mlts jr jf j f dmw

=0

; Qco `mlts swjrfoa bf tco m``bamvbt mro `mdso mfa ebsdomabfn wbtcjut nbvbfn ldomr pblturo ms tj wcmt mppdblmft wmft‒s tj ljfvoy tj tco Cjf‒kdo ljurt

< Qcbs aoòfamft cms fjt absemftdoa tco stjfo sdmks ljepjufa tjwmras omstorf sbao j` tco aoòfamft‒s prjporty Wdmbftb`` cms mddonoa oflrjmlceoft bf wostorf sbao j` aoòfamft prjporty bf tco pdmbft$ wcblc bs absputoa ky tcbs aoòfamft kut fjw mppdblmft cms `bdoa mppdblmtbjf ms mf mnoft tj put `jrwmra cbs jwf lmuso ldmbebfn cbs tbtdo tj stjfo ljepjufa$ wcblc bs bf fj wmy rodmtoa tj prosoft subt Qco mppdblmft cms tj `bdo sopmrmto subt bepdomabfn fobnckjurbfn dmfa jwfor bf jraor tj ldmbe fobnckjurors stjfo ljepjufa

1 Qco mppdblmft mddonos tcmt co cms dmba d mba tco stjfo sdmks Bf mltumdbty bt bs tco stjfo sdmks j` fobnckjuror Bt mejufts tj fjf%hjbfaor j` folossmry pmrty mfa mdsj prjsolutbjf j` fow lmuso j` mltbjf fjt rodmtoa tj tco subt lmuso

? Qco fobnc kjurbfn dmfa Jwfor bs Ers Coemdmtcm N \cmftcmrmhu mfa tcmt dmfa bs mdsj mf mnrbludturmd dmfa$ tcoro wms vorkmd absputo kotwoof kotwoof N \cmarmli mfa mfa N \cmftcmrmhu \cmftcmrmhu jvor tco dmybfn j` stjfo stjfo ljepjufa ky N \cmftcmrmhu bf =221

0 Qco stjfo dmybfn ky fobnckjurbfn dmfa jwfors wms stjppoa ky mppdblmft tcmt bs N\cmarmli wbtc sjeo vofnomflo bf =221 Qco stjfo ljepjufa kodjfns tj fobnckjurbfn dmfa jwfor tcmt bs Dmto N \cmftcmrmhu bf survoy fuekor 2*;a j` Mftcmrmsmfmcmddb Nrmem$ Imsmkm Cjkdb$ Queiur tmdui Qco smba fobnckjuror bs m ldjso rodmtbvo j` kjtc N \cmarmli mfa mdsj j` tcbs aoòfamft aoòfamft

> Wdmbftb`` jr Mppdblmft Mppdblmft cms cms fjtcbfn tj aj wbtc omstorf omstorf pjrtbjf j` aoòfamfts aoòfamfts dmfa jfdy porsjf wcj lmf quostbjf mfy nrbovmflo ms tj omstorf pjrtbjf j` aoòfamft dmfa bs Ers Coemdmtcm N \cmftcmrmhu Qco mppdblmft ldmfaostbfody jut j` bdd%wbdd mfa nruano

=>

cms `bdoa mavmfloeoft mppdblmtbjf hust tj cmrmss tcbs aoòfamft wcof co wms jut j` tjwf tj omrf cbs kroma

3 Qco subt slcoaudo prjporty bs stbdd mf mnrbludturmd dmfa$ fjt ljfvortoa tj fjf%mnrbludturmd uso$ jfdy rovofuo ajlueofts `rje Qmcsbdamr j``blo lmf mslortmbf truo kjufamrbos j` subt slcoaudo prjporty Qco icmtcm mfa bts eomsuroeofts bf eufblbpmd roljras mro fjt emao bf m donmd wmy \ulc bddonmd ajlueofts lmffjt `jre tco kmsbs `jr mfy ldmbes j` obtcor pdmbftb`` jr cor mppdblmft

2 Qco eomsuroeofts qujtoa bf pdmbft btsod` bs bddonmd mfa bts pjssossbjf mfa ofhjyeoft bs btsod` lmffjt ko mslortmbfoa mt tcbs stmno wbtcjut prjaultbjf j` rovofuo roljras sulc ms —WMIIM KJJI #CB\\M \_[POR" @J[E ?―$ mfa —Imrfmtmim [ovbsbjf \ottdoeoft MIM[KMFAC #_QQM[_"―$ tj mslortmbf tco kjufamrbos j` subt slcoaudo prjporty

=7 Obtcor pdmbftb`` jr Mppdblmft cmvo prjauloa rodovmft ajlueofts tj scjw tco oxmlt kjufamry emri j` subt slcoaudo prjporty Qco rjunc siotlc bs mf bddonmd ajlueoft

== Qcbs aoòfamft cms fjt oflrjmlcoa upjf obtcor pdmbftb``‒s prjporty jr mppdblmft‒s rbncts

=; Qcbs aoòfamft cms fjt roejvoa cmakust stjfo jr mfy stjfo sdmks Qcbs aoòfamft cms fj rbncts jvor tco mahjbfbfn dmfas wcblc bs jtcors prjporty

=< Qco mppdblmft wmfts tj ljfùso tcbs aoòfamft ky `bdbfn mf m``bamvbt wbtcjut cmvbfn ljeem jr pudstjp Qco softoflo `jreoa ajos fjt nbvo mfy ldomr eomfbfn Qco mppdblmft wmfts tj bddonmddy bftorprot mfa nmbf jut j` sulc aumd eomfbfn wjras

=1 Qco pdmbftb`` cms fjt sjunct mfy rodbo` tjwmras omstorf sbao j` aoòfamft‒s aoòfamft‒s prjporty Qco pdmbftb``‒s mddonmtbjf bf pdmbft bs tjwmras wostorf sbao j` aoòfamft‒s prjporty

=3

=? Qco mppdblmft rmbsos m fow lmuso ufrodmtoa tj mddonoa lmuso bf pdmbft mvoreofts Qco prjportbos mro vory eulc tcoro bt bs fjt omtmkdo omtmkdo tcbfn tj swmddjw

=0 B` pdmbftb`` prjvos cor donmddy vmdba tbtdo tj abeofsbjfs j` subt slcoaudo prjporty sco bs cmvbfn vory eulc dbkorty tj tmio mltbjf bf tco mkjvo subt Qcbs aoòfamft aoòfamft lmffjt aostrjy tco kjufamry emris jr fobnckjurbfn dmfa jwfors rbncts B` sulc tcbfn cms cmppofoa bt bs fobnckjuror wcj emy cmvo ljepdmbfoa mt `brst bfstmflo

=> ^btc mf bddonmd bftoftbjf mppdblmft wmfts tj tmio sjeo bftorbe jraor `rje tco ljurt ky scjwbfn fobnckjurbfn dmfa jwfor ms ey mnoft mfa wmfts tj prjsoluto fobnckjurbfn dmfa jwfor ky aoprbvbfn tcobr rbncts tj tcobr dmfa Qcbs lmffjt ko mddjwoa bf tco bftorost j` Hustblo

=3 Qcoro bs fj prbem `mlbo lmso jr kmdmflo j` ljfvofboflo bf `mvjur j` pdmbftb`` jr mppdblmft Fj bfhury wbdd ko lmusoa tj pdmbftb`` jr mppdblmft B` tco BM bs mddjwoa$ tmibfn mavmftmno j` ljurt jraor pdmbftb`` jr mppdblmft emy `bdo lmso mnmbfst fobnckjurbfn dmfa jwfor bf jraor tj sottdo mppdblmft‒s pmst nrbovmflos

=2 Qco pcjtjnrmpcs prjauloa aj fjt ro`dolt mfy lmuso Qco rjunc siotlc bs fjt m prjpor ajlueoft `jr mf mnrbludturmd dmfa

;7 Bf jraor tj ioop pomlo mfa mebty aoòfamft bs romay tj `bdo m``bamvbt m``bamvbt stmtbfn co ajos fjt bftoròro bf tco prosoft stmto j` m``mbrs bf tco pdmbft slcoaudo prjporty Dot tco pdmbftb`` mfa mppdblmft mdsj ufaortmio wbtc sulc m``bamvbt stmtbfn tcmt tcoy mro fjt cmvbfn mfy bftoftbjf tj bftoròro wbtc aoòfamfts prjporty Qcbs ajos fjt eomf aoòfamft cms mlloptoa pdmbftb``‒s ldmbes jvor tco `mdsb`boa eomsuroeofts j` subt slcoaudo prjporty Wdmbftb`` bs put tj strblt prjj` j` tco smeo mfa fjt mt dbkorty tj wbtcarmw tco subt wbtcjut pmybfn mfy amemnos tj tco aoòfamft

=2

;= Qco mppdblmft cms fj djlus stmfab tj `bdo tcbs mppdblmtbjf ufdoss co wms porebttoa tj mlt ms mf mnoft j` pdmbftb`` Qco mppdblmtbjf bs proemturo Qco bftorbe mppdblmtbjf cms fjt ldomrdy scjwf slcoaudo `jr wcblc bfhufltbjf bs sjunct Qco pdmbftb`` cms ljfùsoa tcbs aoòfamft ky `bdbfn pdmbft mvoreofts bf pmrm tcroo j` tco pdmbft stmtbfn mkjut –K slcoaudo prjporty‒ prjporty‒ kut pdmbft pdmbft ajos fjt cmvo mfy K slcoaudo prjporty Wdmbftb`` cms fjt prjvbaoa mfy [junc \iotlc ljpy jr dbst j` ajlueofts bf jraor tj ebsdoma tcbs aoòfamft mfa ljurt ky `bdbfn `mdso subt ldmbe Fj cmre jr bfhury wbdd ko lmusoa tj mppdblmft*pdmbftb`` b` tcbs BM bs absebssoa Jf tco jtcor cmfa tcbs aoòfamft wbdd ko put tj nromt cmrascbp ky tco bddonmd mlts j` mppdblmft*pdmbftb`` wcj emy tmio mavmftmno j` mfy bftorbe jraors mfa oflrjmlc upjf prjporty j` fobnckjuror lromtbfn tofsbjf ko`jro aoòfamft cjuso

^coro`jro tco Cjf‒kdo ljurt emy ko pdomsoa tj absebss mppdblmtbjf bf tco bftorost j` hustblo


Aoòfamft



Aoòfamft

BF QCO LJ_QJ@
J\ ?0>* ;773

;7

WDMBFQB@@8

\et Emfjcmrm

P*\

AO@OFAMFQ 8

\ [jkort Fodsjf

M@@BAMPBQ

B [jkort Fodsjf \*J N\cmarmli mnoa mkjut ?7 yomrs rosbaoft j` Queiur$ tco aoòfamft aoòfamft bf tco mkjvo lmso aj sjdoefdy m``bre mfa stmto jf jmtc ms `jddjws8%

= Qco pdmbftb`` cms `bdoa mkjvo lmso mnmbfst eo$ bme swomrbfn jf m``bamvbt m``bamvbt mkjut tco romd `mlts j` tco lmso

; Qco subt slcoaudo prjporty bs stbdd mf mnrbludturmd dmfa$ fjt ljfvortoa tj fjf%mnrbludturmd uso$ jfdy rovofuo ajlueofts `rje Qmcsbdamr j``blo lmf mslortmbf truo kjufamrbos j` subt slcoaudo prjporty Qco icmtcm mfa bts eomsuroeofts j` subt slcoaudo prjporty bf eufblbpmd roljras mro fjt emao bf m donmd wmy m`tor mdbofmtbjf mfa tjwf pdmffbfn \ulc bddonmd ajlueofts lmffjt `jre tco kmsbs `jr mfy ldmbes j` obtcor pdmbftb`` jr cor mppdblmft

< Bf jraor tj ioop mebty mejfn ey fobnckjurcjja$ —B aj swomr bf tco fmeo j` nja tcmt bme bf fj wmy ljfstrult jvor tco subt slcoaudo prjporty uftbd abspjsmd j` tcbs subt― Qcbs ajos fjt eomf B cmvo mlloptoa tco jwforscbp j` subt slcoaudo prjporty Qcbs ajos fjt eomf B wjf‒t ljfstrult bf ey vmlmft dmfa dmybfn tjwmras omstorf sbao j` ey cjuso$ m`tor tmibfn auo dbloflo `rje tco eufblbpmd mfa Q_AM mutcjrbtbos B` B tmio mfy porebssbjf `jr ljfstrultbjf bf ey dmfa$ B wbdd krbfn tj tco ifjwdoano j` tcbs Cjf‒kdo ljurt aurbfn tco pofaofly j` subt m`tor prjaulbfn mdd rodovmft pmpors rodmtoa tj smfltbjf

;=

1 Wdmbftb`` cms mddonoa oflrjmlceoft bf wostorf sbao j` aoòfamft prjporty bf tco pdmbft$ wcblc bs absputoa ky tcbs aoòfamft aoòfamft kut fjw mppdblmft cms `bdoa mppdblmtbjf ms mf mnoft tj put `jrwmra cbs jwf lmuso ldmbebfn cbs tbtdo tj stjfo ljepjufa$ wcblc bs bf fj wmy rodmtoa tj prosoft subt Qco mppdblmft cms tj `bdo sopmrmto subt bepdomabfn

fobnckjurbfn

dmfa

jwfor

bf

jraor

tj

ldmbe

fobnckjurors stjfo ljepjufa

? B` pdmbftb`` bs mkdo tj prjvo cor mddonoa eomsuroeoft j` subt slcoaudo

prjporty

mfa

mddonoa

oflrjmlceoft

m`tor

auo

eomsuroeoft `rje rovofuo survoy mutcjrbtbos ky eomsurbfn mdd tco fobnckjurcjja dmfas$ bme romay tj pmy amemnos tj pdmbftb`` mfa romay tj aostrjy mfy j` ey prjvoa oflrjmlceofts mt ey porbd

0 Fj cmre jr bfhury wbdd ko lmusoa tj mppdblmft*pdmbftb`` b` tcbs BM bs absebssoa Jf tco jtcor cmfa tcbs aoòfamft wbdd ko put tj nromt cmrascbp ky tco bddonmd mlts j` mppdblmft*pdmbftb`` wcj emy tmio mavmftmno j` mfy bftorbe jraors mfa oflrjmlc upjf prjporty j` fobnckjuror lromtbfn tofsbjf ko`jro aoòfamft cjuso

^coro`jro tco Cjf‒kdo ljurt emy ko pdomsoa tj absebss mppdblmtbjfs j` mppdblmft bf tco bftorost j` hustblo

B aj swomr mfa m``bre mkjvo ljftofts ms truo mfa ljrrolt mfa sbnf ms kodjw


Aoòfamft

;;

Written Statement and Objections on Behalf of Defendant in Injunction Suit

Recommend Documents