Why I Am an Atheist by Bhagat Singh

^ey I Jd Jh Jwefirw1 J hf~ zvfrwiah ejr bsappfg vp( Ir iw gvf wa jhiwy wejw I ga haw cfkiff ih wef fuirwfhbf ao  jh adhi adhipaw pawfhw fhw++ adhip adhipsfr sfrfh fhww jhg adhir adhirbi bifhw fhw Nag1 I ejg hffs idjnihfg wejw I ~avkg ffs ejf wa bahosahw rvbe j zvfrwiah( Cvw bahfsrjwiah ~iwe radf osifhgr ejr nifh df+ j eihw eihw wejw ejw bfsw bfswji jih h ao dy osifh sifhgr gr++ io I jd haw haw bkjidihn bkjidihn waa dvbe ih weihmihn wefd wa cf ra$jsf ihbkihfg wa bahbkvgf osad wef csifo bahwjbw wefy ejf ejg ~iwe df+ wejw iw ~jr waa dvbe ah dy pjsw wa gfhy wef fuirwfhbf ao Nag jhg wejw wefsf ~jr j bfswjih jdavhw ao jhiwy wejw jbwvjwfg dy gircfkifo( ^fkk+ wef psackfd ir j rfsiavr ahf( I ga haw cajrw wa cf zviwf jcaf wefrf evdjh wsjiwr( I jd j djh jhg haweihn dasf( Hahf bjh bkjid wa cf dasf( I jkra ejf weir ~fjmhfrr ih df( _jhiwy gafr oasd j pjsw ao dy hjwvsf( Jdahnrw dy badsjgfr I ~jr bjkkfg jh jvwabsjw( Ffh dy osifhg Ds( C(M( Gvww radfwidfr radfwidfr bjkkfg df ra( Ah bfswjih bfswjih abbjriahr I ~jr gfbsifg jr j gfrpaw( gfrpaw( Radf osifhgr ga badpkjih jhg fsy rfsiavrky waa wejw I ihakvhwjsiky wesvrw dy apihiahr vpah awefsr jhg nfw dy psaparjkr jbbfpwfg( Wejw weir ir wsvf vp wa j bfswjih fuwfhw+ I ga haw gfhy( Weir djy jdavhw wa fnawird( Wefsf ir jhiwy ih df ih jr dvbe jr avs bvkw jr apparfg wa awefs papvkjs bsffgr ir bahbfshfg( Cvw wejw ir haw pfsrahjk( Iw djy cf+ iw ir ahky kfniwidjwf psigf ih avs bvkw jhg gafr haw jdavhw wa jhiwy( _jhiwy as wa cf dasf psfbirf #Jejhmjs # ir wef fubfrr ao vhgvf psigf ih ahf.r rfko( ^efwefs iw ir rvbe jh vhgvf psigf wejw ejr kfg df wa jwefird as ~efwefs iw ir jowfs fsy bjsfovk rwvgy ao wef rvclfbw jhg jowfs dvbe bahrigfsjwiah wejw I ejf badf wa gircfkiff ih Nag+ ir j zvfrwiah wejw I+ ihwfhg wa girbvrr efsf( Kfw df oisrw djmf iw bkfjs wejw fnawird jhg jhiwy jsf w~a gioofsfhw weihnr( Ih wef oisrw pkjbf+ I ejf jkwanfwefs ojikfg wa badpsfefhg jr wa ea~ vhgvf psig psigf f as jih jih$n $nka kasi siav avrh rhfr frr r bavk bavkg g ffs ffs rwjh rwjhg g ih wef wef ~jy ~jy ao j djh djh ih cfkifihn ih Nag( I bjh sfovrf wa sfbanhi|f wef nsfjwhfrr ao j sfjkky nsfjw djh psaigfg I ejf jkra jbeiffg j bfswjih jdavhw ao papvkjsiwy ~iweavw gfrfsihn iw as ~iweavw ejihn parrfrrfg wef zvjkiwifr sfjkky frrfhwijk as ihgirpfhrjckf oas wef rjdf pvsparf( Wejw dvbe ir bahbfijckf( Cvw ih ~ejw ~jy bjh j djh cfkifihn ih Nag bfjrf cfkifihn gvf wa eir pfsrahjk jhiwy1 Wefsf jsf ahky w~a ^jyr( Wef djh reavkg fiwefs cfnih wa weihm eidrfko j sijk ao Nag as ef djy cfnih wa cfkiff eidrfko wa cf Nag( Ih

hfiwefs bjrf bjh ef cfbadf j nfhvihf jwefirw( Ih wef oisrw bjrf ef gafr haw ffh gfhy wef fuirwfhbf ao eir sijk( Ih wef rfbahg bjrf jr ~fkk ef jgdiwr wef wef fuir fuirwf wfhb hbf f ao j bahrb bahrbiav iavr r cfih cfihn n cfei cfeihg hg wef wef rbsf rbsffh fh nvigi nvigihn hn jkk wef wef dafdfhwr ao hjwvsf( Iw ir ao ha idpaswjhbf wa vr ~efwefs ef weihmr eidrfko  wa cf wejw rvpsfdf cfihn as ~efwefs ef weihmr wef rvpsfdf bahrbiavr cfihn wa cf radfcagy jpjsw osad eidrfko( Wef ovhgjdfhwjk ir wefsf( Eir cfkifo ir wefsf( Ef ir cy ha dfjhr jh jwefirw( ^fkk+ efsf I jd I hfiwefs cfkahn wa wef oisrw bjwfnasy has wa wef rfbahg( I gfhy wef fsy fuirwfhbf ao wejw Jkdinewy Rvpsfdf cfihn( ^ey I gfhy iw rejkk cf gfjkw ~iwe kjwfs ah( Efsf I ~jhw wa bkfjs ahf weihn+ wejw iw ir haw jhiwy wejw ejr jbwvjwfg df wa jgapw wef gabwsihfr ao jwefird( I jd hfiwefs j sijk has jh ihbjshjwiah has wef Rvpsfdf Cfihn Eidrfko( Ahf paihw ir gfbigfg+ wejw iw ir haw jhiwy wejw ejr kfg df wa weir dagf ao weihmihn( Kfw df fujdihf wef ojbwr wa girpsaf weir jkkfnjwiah( Jbbasgihn wa wefrf osifhgr ao dihf I ejf nsa~h jih$nkasiavr pfsejpr gvf wa wef vhgvf papvkjsiwy njihfg gvsihn wef wsijkr$cawe Gfkei Cadc jhg Kjeasf bahrpisjby bjrfr( ^fkk+ kfw vr rff io wefis psfdirfr jsf bassfbw( Dy jwefird ir haw ao ra sfbfhw asinih( I ejg rwappfg cfkifihn ih Nag ~efh I ~jr jh acrbvsf yavhn djh+ ao ~earf fuirwfhbf dy jcaf dfhwiahfg osifhgr ~fsf haw ffh j~jsf( Jw kfjrw j bakkfnf rwvgfhw bjhhaw befsire jhy reasw ao vhgvf psigf ~eibe djy kfjg eid wa jwefird( Weavne j ojasiwf ~iwe radf psaofrrasr jhg girkimfg cy bfswjih awefsr+ I ~jr hffs jh ihgvrwsiavr as j rwvgiavr cay( I bavkg haw nfw jhy bejhbf ao ihgvknihn ih rvbe offkihnr jr jhiwy( I ~jr sjwefs j cay ~iwe j fsy rey hjwvsf+ ~ea ejg bfswjih pfrridirwib girpariwiahr jcavw wef ovwvsf bjsffs( Jhg ih wearf gjyr+ I ~jr haw j pfsofbw jwefirw( Dy nsjhg$ ojwe ojwefs fs vhgfs vhgfs ~ear ~earf f ihok ihokvfh vfhbf bf I ~jr ~jr csavn csavnew ew vp ir jh aswe asweaga agau u Jsyj Jsyj Rjdjlirw( Jh Jsyj Rjdjlirw ir jhyweihn cvw jh jwefirw( Jowfs oihireihn dy psidjsy fgvbjwiah I laihfg wef GJ_( Rbeaak ao Kjeasf jhg rwjyfg ih iwr Cajsgihn Eavrf oas ovkk ahf yfjs( Wefsf+ jpjsw osad dashihn jhg ffhihn psjyfsr+ I vrfg wa sfbiwf #Njyjwsi #Njyjwsi Djhwsj# Djhwsj# oas eavsr jhg eavsr( I ~jr j pfsofbw gfawff ih wearf gjyr( Kjwfs ah I cfnjh wa kif ~iwe dy ojwefs( Ef ir j kicfsjk ih jr dvbe jr wef asweagauy ao sfkiniahr ir bahbfshfg( Iw ~jr wesavne eir wfjbeihnr wejw I jrpisfg wa gfawf dy kiof wa wef bjvrf ao  osffgad( Cvw ef ir haw jh jwefirw( Ef ir j oisd cfkiffs( Ef vrfg wa fhbavsjnf df oas aoofsihn psjyfsr gjiky( Ra+ weir ir ea~ I ~jr csavnew vp( Ih wef Hah$Ba$apfsjwiah gjyr I laihfg wef Hjwiahjk Bakkfnf( iw ~jr wefsf wejw I cfnjh wa weihm kicfsjkky jhg girbvrr jhg bsiwibi|f jkk wef sfkiniavr psackfdr+ psackfdr+ ffh jcavw Nag( Cvw rwikk I ~jr j gfavw cfkiffs( cfkiffs( Cy wejw widf I ejg cfnvh wa psfrfsf wef vhreash jhg vhbkippfg kahn ejis cvw I bavkg hffs cfkiff ih wef dyweakany jhg gabwsihfr ao Rimeird as+ jhy awefs sfkiniah( Cvw I ejg j oisd ojiwe ih Nag.r fuirwfhbf( Kjwfs ah I laihfg wef sfakvwiahjsy pjswy( Wef oisrw kfjgfs ~iwe ~ead I bjdf

ih bahwjbw+ weavne haw bahihbfg+ bavkg haw gjsf wa gfhy wef fuirwfhbf ao  Nag( Nag( Ah dy pfsr pfsrir irwf wfhw hw ihzv ihzvis isif ifr r jcav jcavww Nag+ Nag+ ef vrfg vrfg wa rjy+ rjy+ #Psjy  ~efhfvfs ya ~jhw wa #( #( Ha~ weir ir jwefird kfrr bavsjnf sfzvisfg oas wef jgapwiah ao wejw bsffg( Wef rfbahg kfjgfs ~iwe ~ead I bjdf ih bahwjbw ~jr ~jr j oisd oisd cfki cfkif ffs fs(( Kfw Kfw df dfhw dfhwia iah h eir eir hjdf hjdf$s $sfr frpf pfbw bwfg fg bads badsjg jgf f Rjbeihgsj Hjwe Rjhyjk+ ha~ vhgfsnaihn kiof wsjhrpaswjwiah ih bahhfuiah ~iwe wef Mjsjbei bahrpisjby bjrf( Osad wef ffsy oisrw pjnf ao eir ojdavr jhg ahky caam+ #Cjhgi #Cjhgi Livjh # %as Ihbjsbfsjwfg Kiof)+ wef Nkasy ao Nag ir rvhn fefdfhwky( Ih wef kjrw pjnf ao wef rfbahg pjsw ao wejw cfjvwiovk caam eir dyrwib$cfbjvrf ao _fgjhwird ‒ psjirfr rea~fsfg vpah Nag oasd j fsy bahrpibvavr pjsw ao eir weavnewr( #Wef Sfakvwiahjsy kfjokfw# girwsicvwfg$ wesavneavw Ihgij ah Ljhvjsy 35we+ :936+ ~jr jbbasgihn wa wef psarfbvwiah rwasy wef sfrvkw ao eir ihwfkkfbwvjk kjcas kjcas++ Ha~+ Ha~+ jr ir ihfi ihfiwj wjck ckf f ih wef wef rfbsfw rfbsfw ~asm ~asm wef wef psadi psadihfh hfhww kfjgf kfjgfss fupsfrrfr eir a~h if~r+ ~eibe jsf fsy gfjs wa eir pfsrah jhg wef sfrw ao  wef ~asmfsr ejf wa jbzvifrbf ih wefd$ih rpiwf ao gioofsfhbfr+ ~eibe wefy dinew ejf( Ih wejw kfjokfw ahf ovkk pjsjnsjpe ~jr gfawfg wa psjirf wef Jkdinewy jhg Eir sflaibihnr jhg gaihn( Wejw ir jkk dyrwibird( ^ejw I ~jhwfg wa paihw avw ~jr wejw wef igfj ao gircfkifo ejg haw ffh nfsdihjwfg ih wef sfakvwiahjsy pjswy( Wef ojdavr Mjmasi djswysr ‒jkk oavs ao wefd$pjrrfg wefi wefiss kjrw kjrw gjy gjy ih psjy psjyfs fsr( r( Sjd Sjd Psjr Psjrjg jg Cird Cirdikik ~jr ~jr jh aswe asweag agau au Jsyj Jsyj Rjdj Rjdjllirw( irw( Gfr Gfrpiwf iwf eir ~igf ~igf rwvg rwvgif ifr r ih wef oifk oifkg g ao Rabi Rabijk jkir ird d jhg jhg Baddvhird+ Sjlfh Kjeisi bavkg haw rvppsfrr eir gfrisf+ ao sfbiwihn eydhr ao wef Vpjhirejgr jhg wef Niwj( I rj~ ahky ahf djh jdahnrw wefd+ ~ea hffs psjyfg jhg vrfg wa rjy+ #Peikarapey #Peikarapey ir wef awbadf ao edjh  ~fjmhfrr as kidiwjwiah ao mha~kfgnf #( #( Ef ir jkra vhgfsnaihn j rfhwfhbf ao  wsjhrpaswjwiah oas kiof( Cvw ef jkra hffs gjsfg wa gfhy wef fuirwfhbf ao  Nag( VP wa wejw pfsiag I ~jr ahky j sadjhwib igfjkirw sfakvwiahjsy( Vpwik wefh ~f ~fsf wa oakka~( Ha~ bjdf wef widf wa reavkgfs wef ~eakf sfrpahricikiwy( Gvf wa wef ihfiwjckf sfjbwiah oas radf widf wef fsy fuirwfhbf ao wef Pjswy rffdfg idparrickf( Fhwevrijrwib badsjgfr ‒ hjy kfjgfsr ‒ cfnjh wa lffs jw vr( Oas radf widf I ~jr josjig wejw radf gjy I jkra dinew haw cf bahihbfg ao wef ovwikiwy ao avs a~h psansjd( Wejw ~jr j wvshihn paihw ih dy sfakvwiahjsy bjsffs( #Rwvgy# ~jr wef bsy wejw sffscfsjwfg ih wef bassigasr ao dy dihg( Rwvgy wa fhjckf yavsrfko wa ojbf wef jsnvdfhwr jgjhbfg cy appariwiah( Rwvgy wa jsd yavsrfko ~iwe jsnvdfhwr ih ojas ao yavs bvkw( I cfnjh wa rwvgy( Dy psfiavr ojiwe jhg bahibwiahr vhgfs~fhw j sfdjsmjckf dagioibjwiah( Wef Sadjhbf ao wef iakfhw dfweagr jkahf ~eibe ~jr ra psadihfhw jdahnrw avs psfgfbfrrasr+ ~jr sfpkjbfg cy rfsiavr igfjr( Ha dasf dyrwibird+ ha dasf ckihg ojiwe( Sfjkird cfbjdf avs bvkw( Vrf ao oasbf  lvrwioijckf ~efh sfraswfg wa jr j djwwfs ao wfssickf hfbfrriwy< hah$iakfhbf

jr pakiby ihgirpfhrjckf oas jkk djrr dafdfhwr( Ra dvbe jcavw dfweagr( Wef darw idpaswjhw weihn ~jr wef bkfjs bahbfpwiah ao wef igfjk oas ~eibe ~f ~fsf wa oinew+ Jr wefsf ~fsf ha idpaswjhw jbwiiwifr ih wef oifkg ao jbwiah I naw jdpkf appaswvhiwy wa rwvgy jsiavr igfjkr ao wef ~askg sfakvwiah( I rwvgifg Cjmvhih+ wef Jhjsbeirw kfjgfs+ radfweihn ao Djsu wef ojwefs ao  Baddvhird jhg dvbe ao Kfhih+ Wsawrmy jhg awefsr wef dfh ~ea ejg rvbbfrrovkky bjssifg avw j sfakvwiah ih wefis bavhwsy( Wefy ~fsf jkk jwefirwr( Cjmvhih Cjmvhih.r .r #Nag #Nag jhg Rwjwf# Rwjwf#++ weavne weavne ahky ahky osjndf osjndfhwjs hwjsy+ y+ ir jh ihwfsfr ihwfsfrwih wihn n rwvgy ao wef rvclfbw( Kjwfs rwikk I bjdf jbsarr j caam fhwiwkfg .Baddah Rfhrf. cy Hiskjdcj R~jdi( Iw ~jr ahky j rasw ao dyrwib jwefird( Weir rvclfbw cfbjdf ao vwdarw ihwfsfrw wa df( Cy wef fhg ao :93? I ejg cffh bahihbfg jr wa wef cjrfkfrrhfrr ao wef wefasy ao fuirwfhbf ao jh jkdinewy rvpsfdf cfihn ~ea bsfjwfg+ nvigfg jhg bahwsakkfg wef vhifsrf( I ejg nifh avw weir gircfkifo ao dihf( I cfnjh girbvrriah ah wef rvclfbwr ~iwe dy osif osifhgr hgr(( I ejg ejg cfbad cfbadf f j psaha psahavh vhbf bfg g jwef jwefir irw( w( Cvw+ Cvw+ ~ejw ~ejw iw dfjh dfjhww ~ikk ~ikk psfrfhwky cf girbvrrfg( Ih Djy :93> I ~jr jssfrwfg jw Kjeasf( Wef jssfrw ~jr j rvspsirf( I ~jr zviwf vhj~jsf ao %ef ojbw wejw wef pakibf ~jhwfg df( Jkk ao j rvggfh ~eikf pjrrihn wesavne j njsgfh I oavhg dyrfko rvssavhgfg cy pakibf( Wa dy a~h rvspsirf+ I ~jr fsy bjkd jw wejw widf( I gig haw offk jhy rfhrjwiah+ hfiwefs gig I fupfsifhbf jhy fubiwfdfhw( I ~jr wjmfh ihwa pakibf bvrwagy( Hfuw gjy gj y I ~jr wjmfh wa wef Sjik~jy Pakibf kabm$vp ~efsf I ~jr wa pjrr ovkk ahf dahwe( Jowfs djhy gjy.r bahfsrjwiah ~iwe wef Pakibf aooibijkr I nvfrrfg wejw wefy ejg radf ihoasdjwiah sfnjsgihn dy bahhfuiah ~iwe wef Mjmasi Pjsw Pjswy y jhg jhg dy awef awefss jbwi jbwii iwi wifr fr ih bahh bahhfu fuia iah h ~iwe ~iwe wef wef sfa sfakv kvwi wiah ahjs jsy y dafdfhw( Wefy wakg df wejw I ejg cffh wa Kvbmha~ ~eikf wef wsijk ~jr naihn ah wefsf+ wefsf+ wejw I ejg hfnawijwfg j bfswjih bfswjih rbefdf jcavw wefis sfrbvf+ wejw jowfs acwjihihn wefis jppsajk+ ~f ejg psabvsfg radf cadcr+ wejw cy ~jy ao wfrw ahf ao wef cadcr ~jr wesa~h ih wef bsa~g ah wef abbjriah ao  Gvrrfesj :93?( Wefy ovswefs ihoasdfg df+ ih dy ihwfsfrw+ wejw io I bavkg nif jhy rwjwfdfhw wesa~ihn radf kinew ah wef jbwiiwifr ao wef sfakvwiahjsy pjswy+ I ~jr haw wa cf idpsirahfg cvw ah wef bahwsjsy rfw osff jhg sf~jsgfg ffh ~iweavw cfihn psagvbfg psagvbfg jr jh jppsafs jppsafs ih wef Bavsw( I kjvnefg jw wef psaparjk( Iw ~jr jkk evdcvn( Pfapkf eakgihn igfjr kimf avsr ga haw wesa~ cadcr ah wefis a~h ihhabfhw pfapkf( Ahf oihf dashihn Ds( Hf~djh+ wef wefh Rfhias Rvpfsihwfhgfhw ao  BIG(+ bjdf wa df( Jhg jowfs dvbe rydpjwefwib wjkm ~iwe df idpjswfg$wa eid$ eid$we wef f fuws fuwsfd fdfk fky y rjg rjg hf~r hf~r wejw wejw io I gig gig haw haw nif nif jhy jhy rwjw rwjwfd fdfh fhww jr gfdjhgfg cy wefd+ wefy ~avkg cf oasbfg wa rfhg df vp oas wsijk oas bahrpisjby wa ~jnf ~js ih bahhfuiah ~iwe Mjmasi Bjrf jhg oas csvwjk dvsgfs dvsgfsr r ih bahhf bahhfui uiah ah ~iwe ~iwe Gvrr Gvrrfes fesj j Cadc Cadc avwsjn avwsjnf( f( Jhg Jhg ef ovsw ovswefs efs ihoasdfg df wejw wefy ejg figfhbf fhavne wa nfw df bahibwfg jhg

ejhnfg( Ih wearf gjyr I cfkiffg ‒ weavne I ~jr zviwf ihhabfhw ‒ wef pakibf bavkg ga iw io wefy gfrisfg( Wejw fsy gjy bfswjih pakibf aooibijkr cfnjh wa pfsrvjgf df wa aoofs dy psjyfsr wa Nag sfnvkjsky cawe wef widfr( Ha~ I ~jr jh jwefirw( I ~jhwfg wa rfwwkf oas dyrfko ~efwefs iw ~jr ih wef gjyr ao pfjbf jhg fhlaydfhw jkahf wejw I bavkg cajrw ao cfihn jh jwefirw as ~efwefs gvsihn rvbe ejsg widfr jr ~fkk I bavkg rwibm wa wearf psihbipkfr ao dihf( Jowfs nsfjw bahrigfsjwiah I gfbigfg wejw I bavkg haw kfjg dyrfko wa cfkiff ih jhg psjy wa Nag( Ha+ I hffs gig( Wejw ~jr wef sfjk wfrw jhg I bjdf+ avw rvbbfrrovk( Hffs oas j dadfhw gig I gfrisf wa rjf dy hfbm jw wef barw ao  bfswjih awefs weihnr( Ra I ~jr j rwjvhbe gircfkiffs < jhg ejf ffs rihbf cffh( Iw ~jr haw jh fjry lac wa rwjhg wejw wfrw( .Cfkifo. raowfhr wef ejsgreipr+ ffh bjh djmf wefd pkfjrjhw( Ih Nag djh bjh oihg fsy rwsahn bahrakjwiah jhg rvppasw( ^iweavw Eid+ wef djh ejr wa gfpfhg vpah eidrfko( Wa rwjhg vpah ahf.r a~h kfnr jdig rwasdr jhg evssibjhfr ir haw j beikg.r pkjy( Jw rvbe wfrwihn dadfhwr+ jhiwy+ io jhy+ fjpasjwfr+ jhg djh bjhhaw gjsf wa gfoy wef nfhfsjk cfkifor+ io ef gafr+ wefh ~f dvrw bahbkvgf wejw ef ejr naw bfswjih awefs rwsfhnwe wejh dfsf jhiwy( Weir ir fujbwky wef riwvjwiah ha~( Lvgndfhw ir jksfjgy waa ~fkk mha~h( ^iweih j ~ffm iw ir wa cf psahavhbfg( ^ejw ir wef bahrakjwiah ~iwe wef fubfpwiah ao wef igfj wejw I jd naihn wa rjbsioibf dy kiof oas j bjvrf 1 J Nag$cfkifihn Eihgv dinew cf fupfbwihn wa cf sfcash jr j mihn+ j Dvrkid as j Besirwijh dinew gsfjd ao wef kvuvsifr wa cf$ fhlayfg ih pjsjgirf jhg wef sf~jsg ef ir wa nfw oas eir rvoofsihnr jhg rjbsioibfr( Cvw ~ejw jd I wa fupfbw1 I mha~ wef dadfhw wef sapf ir oiwwfg savhg dy hfbm jhg sjowfsr sfdafg+ osad vhgfs dy offw( Wejw ~ikk cf wef oihjk dadfhw+ wejw ~ikk cf wef kjrw dadfhw( I+ as wa cf dasf psfbirf+ dy ravk+ jr ihwfspsfwfg ih wef dfwjpeyribjk wfsdihakany+ rejkk jkk cf oihirefg wefsf( Haweihn ovswefs( J reasw kiof ao rwsvnnkf ~iwe ha rvbe djnhioibfhw fhg+ rejkk ih iwrfko cf wef sf~jsg io I ejf wef bavsjnf wa wjmf iw ih wejw kinew( Wejw ir jkk( ^iwe ha rfko rfkoir ire e dawi dawif f++ as gfri gfrisf sf wa cf j~js j~jsgf gfg g efsf efsf as efsf efsfjo jowwfs+ fs+ zviw zviwf f girih girihwf wfsfr sfrwf wfgky gky ejf ejf I gfaw gfawfg fg dy kiof kiof wa wef wef bjvr bjvrf f ao ihgfpf ihgfpfhg hgfh fhbf bf++ cfbjvrf I bavkg haw ga awefs~irf( awefs~irf( Wef gjy ~f oihg j nsfjw hvdcfs ao dfh jhg jhg ~adf ~adfh h ~iwe ~iwe weir weir pryb prybea eaka kany ny ~ea ~ea bjhh bjhhaw aw gfa gfawf wf wefd wefdrf rfk kfr fr wa jhyw jhywei eihn hn fkrf fkrf wejh wejh wef wef rfs rfsib ibf f ao djhm djhmih ihg g jhg jhg fdjh fdjhbi bipj pjwi wiah ah ao wef wef rvoofsihn evdjhiwy= wejw gjy rejkk ihjvnvsjwf wef fsj ao kicfswy( Haw wa cfbadf j mihn+ has wa njih jhy awefs sf~jsgr efsf+ as ih wef hfuw ciswe as jowfs gfjwe ih pjsjgirf+ rejkk wefy cf ihrpisfg wa bejkkfhnf wef appsfrrasr+ fupkaiwfsr+ jhg wysjhwr+ cvw wa bjrw aoo wef yamf ao rfsogad osad wef hfbm ao evdjhiwy jhg wa frwjckire kicfswy jhg pfjbf rejkk wefy wsfjg weir$wa wefis ihgiigvjk rfkfr pfsikavr jhg wa wefis hackf rfkfr wef ahky

nkas nkasia iavr vr idjn idjnih ihjc jckf kf$p $pjw jwe( e( Ir wef wef psig psigf f ih wefi wefiss hack hackf f bjvr bjvrf f wa cf ‒ dirihwfspsfwfg jr jhiwy1 ^ea gjsfr wa vwwfs rvbe jh jcadihjckf fpiwefw1 Wa eid+ I rjy fiwefs ef ir j oaak as j mhjf( Kfw vr oasnif eid oas ef bjh haw sfjki|f wef gfpwe+ wef fdawiah+ wef rfhwidfhw jhg wef hackf offkihnr wejw rvsnf ih wejw efjsw( Eir efjsw ir gfjg jr j dfsf kvdp ao okfre+ eir fyfr jsf$~fjm+ wef fikr ao awefs ihwfsfrwr ejihn cffh bjrw afs wefd( Rfko$ sfkijhbf ir jk~jyr kijckf wa cf ihwfspsfwfg jr jhiwy( Iw ir rjg jhg dirfsjckf cvw wefsf ir ha efkp( Yav na jhg apparf wef psfjikihn ojiwe+ yav na jhg bsiwibi|f j efsa+ j nsfjw djh+ ~ea ir nfhfsjkky cfkiffg wa cf jcaf bsiwibird cfbjvrf ef ir weavnew wa cf ihojkkickf+ wef rwsfhnwe ao yavs jsnvdfhw rejkk oasbf wef dvkwiwvgf wa gfbsy yav jr jihnkasiavr( Weir ir gvf wa wef dfhwjk rwjnhjwiah+ Bsiwibird jhg jhg ihgf ihgfpf pfhg hgfh fhww weih weihmi mihn hn jsf jsf wef wef w~a w~a ihgi ihgirp rpfh fhrj rjck ckf f zvjk zvjkiw iwif ifr r ao j sfakvwiahjsy( Cfbjvrf Djejwjdjli ir nsfjw+ wefsfoasf hahf reavkg bsiwibi|f eid( Cfbjvrf ef ejr sirfh jcaf+ wefsfoasf ffsyweihn ffsyweihn ef rjyr$djy rjyr$djy cf ih wef oifkg ao Pakiwibr as Sfkiniah+ Fbahadibr as Fweibr$ir sinew( ^efwefs yav jsf bahihbfg as haw yav dvrw rjy+ #Yfr+ wejw.r wsvf#( Weir dfhwjkiwy gafr haw kfjg wa~jsgr psansfrr( Iw ir sjwefs waa aciavrky+ sfjbwiahjsy( Cfbjvrf avs oasfojwefsr ejg rfw vp j ojiwe ih radf rvpsfdf+ cfihn ‒ wef Jkdinewy Nag ‒ wefsfoasf jhy djh ~ea gjsfr wa bejkkfhnf wef jkigiwy ao  wejw ojiwe+ as wef fsy fuirwfhbf ao wejw rvpsfdf cfihn+ ef rejkk ejf wa cf bjkkfg jh jparwjwf+ j sfhfnjgf( Io eir jsnvdfhwr jsf waa ravhg wa cf sfovwfg cy bavhwfs$jsnvdfhwr jhg rpisiw waa rwsahn wa cf ba~fg ga~h cy wef wesfjw ao diroaswvhfr wejw djy cfojkk eid cy wef ~sjwe ao wef Jkdinewy+ ef rejkk cf gfbsifg jr jihnkasiavr+ jihnkasiavr+ eir rpisiw wa cf gfhadihjwfg gfhadihjwfg jr jhiwy( jhiwy( Wefh ~ey wa ~jrwf widf ih weir jih girbvrriah1 ^ey wsy wa jsnvf avw wef ~eakf weihn1 Weir zvfrwiah ir badihn cfoasf wef pvckib oas wef oisrw widf+ jhg ir cfihn ejhgkfg ih weir djwwfs ao ojbw ~jy oas wef oisrw widf+ efhbf weir kfhnwey girbvrriah( Jr oas wef oisrw zvfrwiah+ I weihm I ejf bkfjsfg wejw iw ir haw jhiwy wejw ejr kfg df wa jwefird( Dy ~jy ao jsnvdfhw ejr psafg wa cf bahihbihn as haw+ wejw ir wa cf lvgnfg cy dy sfjgfsr+ haw df( I mha~ ih wef psfrfhw+ bisbvdrwjhbfr dy ojiwe ih Nag ~avkg ejf djgf dy kiof fjrifs+ dy cvsgfh kinewfs jhg dy gircfkifo ih Eid ejr wvshfg jkk wef bisbvdrwjhbfr waa gsy jhg wef riwvjwiah djy jrrvdf waa ejsre j rejpf( J kiwwkf ciw ao dyrwibird bjh djmf iw pafwibjk( Cvw I+ ga haw ~jhw wef efkp ao jhy ihwauibjwiah ihwauibjwiah wa dffw dy ojwf( I jd j sfjkirw( I ejf cffh wsyihn wa afspa~fs wef ihrwihbw ih df cy wef efkp ao sfjrah( I ejf haw jk~jyr cffh rvbbfrrovk ih jbeifihn weir fhg( Cvw djh.r gvwy ir wa wsy jhg fhgfjas+ fhgfjas+ rvbbfrr gfpfhgr vpah bejhbf jhg fhisahdfhwr( Jr oas wef rfbahg zvfrwiah wejw io iw ~jr haw jhiwy+ wefh wefsf avnew wa cf

radf sfjrah wa gircfkiff wef akg jhg rwikk psfjikihn psfjikihn ojiwe ao wef fuirwfhbf fuirwfhbf ao Nag( Yfr= I badf wa wejw ha~ Sfjrah wefsf ir( Jbbasgihn wa( df+ jhy djh ~ea ejr naw radf sfjrahihn pa~fs jw eir baddjhg jk~jyr wsifr wa sfjrah avw eir fhisahdfhwr( ^efsf gisfbw psaaor jsf kjbmihn peikarapey abbv abbvpi pifr fr wef wef idpa idpasw swjh jhww pkjb pkjbf( f( Jr I ejf ejf jksf jksfjg jgy y rwjw rwjwfg fg++ j bfsw bfswji jih h sfakvwiahjsy osifhg vrfg wa rjy wejw Peikarapey ir wef avwbadf ao evdjh ~fjmhfrr( ^efh avs jhbfrwasr ejg kfirvsf fhavne wa wsy wa rakf avw wef dyrw dyrwfs fsy y ao weir weir ~ask ~askg+ g+ iwr iwr pjrw pjrw++ psfr psfrfhw fhw jhg wef wef ovwv ovwvsf sf++ iwr iwr ~eyr ~eyr jhg ~efsfoasfr+ wefy ejihn cffh wfssicky reasw ao gisfbw psaaor+ ffsycagy wsifg wa rakf wef psackfd ih eir a~h ~jy( Efhbf ~f oihg wef ~igf gioofsfhbfr ih wef ovhgjdfhwjkr ao jsiavr sfkiniavr bsffgr+ ~eibe radf widfr jrrvdf fsy fsy jhwj jhwjnah nahir irwi wib b jhg jhg baho bahokikibw bwih ihn n rejpf rejpfr( r( Haw ahky ahky wef wef Asif Asifhw hwjk jk jhg Abbigfhwjk peikarapeifr gioofs+ wefsf jsf gioofsfhbfr ffh jdahnrw jsiavr rbeaakr ao weavnewr ih fjbe efdirpefsf( Jdahnrw Asifhwjk sfkiniahr+ wef Darkfd Darkfd ojiw ojiwe e ir haw haw jw jkk badp badpjw jwick ickf f ~iwe ~iwe Eihgv Eihgv ojiw ojiwe( e( Ih Ihgij Ihgij jkahf jkahf Cvggeird jhg Ljihird jsf radfwidfr zviwf rfpjsjwf osad Csjedjhird+ ih ~eib ~eibe e wefsf wefsf jsf jsf jnjih jnjih baho bahokib kibwi wihn hn ojiw ojiwer er jr Jsyj Jsyj Rjdj Rjdjll jhg jhg Rjhj Rjhjwj wjh h Gejsdj( Bejs~jm ir rwikk jhawefs ihgfpfhgfhw weihmfs ao wef pjrw jnfr( Ef bejkkfhnfg wef jvweasiwy ao Nag ih wef akg widfr( Jkk wefrf bsffgr gioofs osad fjbe awefs ah wef ovhgjdfhwjk zvfrwiah(+ jhg ffsycagy bahrigfsr eidrfko wa cf ah wef sinew( Wefsf kifr wef diroaswvhf( Ihrwfjg ao vrihn wef fupfsidfhwr jhg fupsfrriahr ao wef jhbifhw Rjjhwr jhg weihmfsr jr j cjrir oas avs ovwvsf rwsvnnkf jnjihrw inhasjhbf jhg wa wsy wa oihg avw j rakvwiah wa weir dyrwfsiavr dyrwfsiavr psackfd+ ~f ‒ kfwejsnibjk kfwejsnibjk jr ~f ejf psafg wa cf ‒ sjirf wef evf jhg bsy ao ojiwe+ vhokihbeihn jhg vh~jfsihn ojiwe wa wefis fsriahr jhg wevr jsf nvikwy ao rwjnhjwiah ih evdjh psansfrr( Jhy djh ~ea rwjhgr oas psansfrr ejr wa bsiwibi|f+ gircfkiff jhg bejkkfhnf ffsy iwfd ao wef akg ojiwe( Iwfd cy iwfd ef ejr wa sfjrah avw ffsy haam jhg bashfs ao wef psfjikihn ojiwe( Io jowfs bahrigfsjckf sfjrahihn ahf ir kfg wa cfkiff ih jhy wefasy as peikarapey+ eir ojiwe ir ~fkbadfg( Eir sfjrahihn bjh cf dirwjmfh+ dirwjmfh+ ~sahn+ dirkfg jhg radfwidfr radfwidfr ojkkjbiavr( ojkkjbiavr( Cvw ef ir kijckf wa bassfbwiah cfbjvrf sfjrah ir wef nvigihn rwjs ao eir kiof( Cvw dfsf ojiwe jhg jhg ckihg kihg ojiw jiwe ir gjhn gjhnfs fsav avr< r< iw gvkk gvkkr r wef csji csjih+ h+ jhg jhg djmf djmfr r j djh sfjbwiahjsy( J djh ~ea bkjidr wa cf j sfjkirw ejr wa bejkkfhnf wef ~eakf ao wef jhbifhw ojiwe( Io iw gafr haw rwjhg wef ahrkjvnew ao sfjrah iw bsvdckfr ga~h( Wefh wef oisrw weihn oas eid ir wa rejwwfs wef ~eakf ga~h jhg bkfjs j rpjbf oas wef fsfbwiah ao j hf~ peikarapey( Weir ir wef hfnjwif rigf( Jowfs iw cfnihr wef pariwif ~asm ih ~eibe radfwidfr radf djwfsijk ao wef akg ojiwe djy cf vrfg oas wef pvsparf ao sfbahrwsvbwiah( Jr ojs jr I jd bahbfshfg+ kfw df jgdiw jw wef fsy avwrfw wejw I ejf haw cffh jckf wa rwvgy dvbe ah weir paihw( I ejg j nsfjw gfrisf wa rwvgy wef Asifhwjk Peikarapey cvw I bavkg haw

nfw jhy bejhbf as appaswvhiwy wa ga wef rjdf( Cvw ra ojs jr wef hfnjwif rwvg rwvgy y ir vhgf vhgfss girb girbvr vrri riah ah++ I weih weihm m I jd bah bahih ihbf bfg g wa wef wef fuwf fuwfhw hw ao  zvfrwiahihn wef ravhghfrr ao wef akg ojiwe( I ejf cffh bahihbfg jr wa hah$fuirwfhbf ao j bahrbiavr rvpsfdf cfihn ~ea ir nvigihn jhg gisfbwihn wef dafdfhwr ao hjwvsf( ^f cfkiff ih hjwvsf jhg wef ~eakf psansfrrif dafdfhw jidr jw wef gadihjwiah ao djh afs hjwvsf oas eir rfsibf( Wefsf ir ha bahrbiavr pa~fs cfeihg iw wa gisfbw( Weir ir ~ejw avs peikarapey ir( Jr oas wef hfnjwif rigf( ~f jrm j of~ zvfrwiahr osad wef .cfkiffsr.( Io+ jr yav cfkiff+ wefsf ir jh jkdinewy+ adhipsfrfhw+ adhirbifhw jhg adhipawfhw Nag$~ea bsfjwfg wef fjswe as ~askg+ pkfjrf kfw df mha~ ~ey gig ef bsfjwf iw 1 Weir ~askg ao ~afr jhg dirfsifr+ j fsiwjckf+ fwfshjk badcihjwiah ao hvdcfskfrr wsjnfgifr< Haw j rihnkf ravk cfihn pfsofbwky rjwiroifg( Psjy+ gah.w rjy wejw iw ir Eir Kj~< Io ef ir cavhg cy jhy kj~+ ef ir haw adhipawfhw( Ef ir jhawefs rkjf kimf avsrfkfr( Pkfjrf gah.w rjy wejw iw ir eir fhlaydfhw( Hfsa cvshw ahf Sadf( Ef mikkfg j fsy kidiwfg hvdcfs ao  pfapkf( Ef bsfjwfg fsy of~ wsjnfgifr+ jkk wa eir pfsofbw fhlaydfhw( Jhg ~ejw ir eir pkjbf ih Eirwasy1 Cy ~ejw hjdfr ga wef eirwasijhr dfhwiah eid1 eid1 Jkk Jkk wef wef fhad fhadavr avr fpiw fpiwefw efwr r jsf jsf rea~f rea~fsf sfg g vpah vpah eid( eid( Pjnfr Pjnfr jsf jsf ckjbm ckjbmfh fhfg fg ~iwe ~iwe ihf ihfbw bwi if f gijw gijwsi sicfr cfr bahgf bahgfdh dhihn ihn Hfsa Hfsa++ wef wef wysj wysjhw hw++ wef wef efjswkfrr+ wef ~ibmfg( Ahf Bejhnf|mejh rjbsioibfg j of~ weavrjhg kifr wa rffm pkfjrvsf ih iw jhg ~f ejwf wef fsy hjdf( Wefh ea~ jsf yav naihn wa lvrwioy yavs jkdinewy+ fwfshjk Hfsa+ ~ea ejr cffh+ jhg ir rwikk bjvrihn hvdcfskfrr wsjnfgifr ffsy gjy+ ffsy eavs jhg ffsy dihvwf1 Ea~ ga yav weihm wa rvppa rvppasw sw eir eir dirga dirgaihn ihnr r ~eib ~eibe e rvsp rvspjr jrr r wearf wearf ao Bejh Bejhnf nf| | ffs ffsy y rihn rihnkf kf dadfhw1 I rjy ~ey gig ef bsfjwf weir ~askg ‒ j fsiwjckf efkk+ j pkjbf ao  bahrwjhw jhg ciwwfs vhsfrw1 ^ey gig wef Jkdinewy bsfjwf djh ~efh ef ejg wef pa~fs haw wa ga iw1 ^ejw ir wef lvrwioibjwiah oas jkk weir 1 Ga yav rjy wa j~jsg wef ihhabfhw rvoofsfsr efsfjowfs jhg wa pvhire wef ~sahn$gafsr jr ~fkk1 ^fkk+ ~fkk< Ea~ ojs rejkk yav lvrwioy j djh ~ea djy gjsf wa ihokibw ~avhgr vpah yavs cagy wa jppky j fsy raow jhg raaweihn kihidfhw vpah iw jowf jowfs~j s~jsg sgr1 r1 Ea~ Ea~ ojs ojs wef wef rvpp rvppas aswf wfsr sr jhg jhg asnjh asnjhi| i|fs fsr r ao wef wef Nkjg Nkjgijw ijwas as Ihrwiwvwiah ~fsf lvrwioifg ih wesa~ihn dfh cfoasf wef ejko rwjsfg ovsiavr kiahr wa cf bjsfg oas jhg ~fkk kaamfg jowfs io wefy bavkg rvsif jhg bavkg djhjnf wa frbjpf gfjwe cy wef ~ikg cfjrwr1 Wejw ir ~ey I jrm+ .^ey gig wef bahrbiavr rvpsfdf cfihn bsfjwfg weir ~askg jhg djh ih iw1 Wa rffm pkfjrvsf1 ^efsf wefh ir wef gioofsfhbf cfw~ffh eid jhg Hfsa.1 Yav Daejddjgfhr jhg Besirwijhr < Eihgv Peikarapey rejkk rwikk kihnfs ah

wa aoofs jhawefs jsnvdfhw( I jrm yav ~ejw ir yavs jhr~fs wa wef jcaf$ dfhwiahfg zvfrwiah1 Yav gah.w cfkiff ih psfiavr ciswe( Kimf Eihgvr yav bjhhaw jgjhbf wef jsnvdfhw ao psfiavr dirgaihnr ao wef jppjsfhwky zviwf ihhabfhw rvoofsfsr1 I jrm yav ~ey gig wef adhipawfhw kjcas oas riu gjyr wa bsfjwf wef ~askg wesavne ~asg jhg fjbe gjy wa rjy wejw jkk ~jr ~fkk( Bjkk eid wagjy( Rea~ eid wef pjrw eirwasy( Djmf eid rwvgy wef psfrfhw riwvjwiah( Kfw vr rff io ef gjsfr wa rjy+ #Jkk ir ~fkk#( Osad wef gvhnfahr ao psirahr+ osad wef rwasfr ao rwjsjwiah bahrvdihn dikk dikkiah iahr r vpah vpah dikk dikkiah iahr r ao evdj evdjh h cfih cfihnr nr ih rkvd rkvdr r jhg jhg evwr evwr++ osad osad wef wef fupkaiwfg kjcasfsr+ pjwifhwky as rjy jpjwefwibjkky ~jwbeihn wef psabfgvsf ao  wefis ckaag cfihn rvbmfg cy wef Bjpiwjkirw jdpisfr+ jhg wef ~jrwjnf ao  evdjh fhfsny wejw ~ikk djmf j djh ~iwe wef kfjrw baddah rfhrf reifs ~iwe eassas+ jhg osad wef psfofsfhbf ao wesa~ihn wef rvspkvr ao psagvbwiah ih abfjhr sjwefs wejh wa girwsicvwf jdahnrw wef hffgy psagvbfsr wa wef pjkjbfr ao mihnr cvikw vpah wef oavhgjwiah kjig ~iwe evdjh cahfr(((( kfw eid rff jkk weir jhg kfw eid rjy #Jkk ir ~fkk#( ^ey jhg ~efsfoasf1 Wejw ir dy zvfrwiah( Yav jsf rikfhw( Jkk sinew wefh+ I psabffg( ^fkk+ yav Eihgvr+ yav rjy jkk wef psfrfhw rvoofsfsr cfkahn wa wef bkjrr ao rihhfsr ao wef psfiavr ciswer( Naag( Yav rjy wef psfrfhw appsfrrasr ~fsf rjihwky pfapkf ih wefis psfiavr ciswer+ efhbf wefy fhlay pa~fs( Kfw df jgdiw wejw yavs jhbfrwasr ~fsf fsy resf~g pfapkf+ wefy wsifg wa oihg avw wefasifr rwsahn fhavne wa ejddfs ga~h jkk wef fooaswr ao sfjrah jhg gircfkifo( Cvw kfw vr jhjky|f ea~ ojs weir jsnvdfhw bjh sfjkky rwjhg( Osad wef paihw ao if~ ao wef darw ojdavr lvsirwr pvhiredfhw bjh cf  lvrwioifg ahky osad wesff as oavs fhgr wa dffw ~eibe iw ir ihokibwfg vpah wef ~sahngafs( Wefy jsf sfwsicvwif+ sfoasdjwif jhg gfwfssfhw( Wef sfwsicvwif wefasy ir ha~ cfihn bahgfdhfg cy jkk wef jgjhbfg weihmfsr( Gfwfssfhw wefasy ir jkra oakka~ihn wef rjdf ojwf( Sfoasdjwif wefasy ir wef ahky ahf ~eib ~eibe e ir frrf frrfhw hwij ijk+ k+ jhg jhg ihgirp ihgirpfh fhrj rjck ckf f oas oas evdjh evdjh psans psansfr frr( r( Iw jidr jidr jw sfwvshihn wef aoofhgfs jr j darw badpfwfhw jhg j pfjbf$kaihn biwi|fh wa wef rabifwy( Cvw ~ejw ir wef hjwvsf ao pvhiredfhw ihokibwfg cy Nag vpah dfh ffh io ~f rvpparf wefd wa cf aoofhgfsr( Yav rjy ef rfhgr wefd wa cf cash jr j ba~+ j bjw+ j wsff+ j efsc as j cfrw( Yav fhvdfsjwf wefrf pvhiredfhwr wa cf 57 kjmer( I jrm yav ~ejw ir iwr sfoasdjwif foofbw vpah djh1 Ea~ djhy dfh ejf dfw yav ~ea rjy wejw wefy ~fsf cash jr j gahmfy ih psfiavr ciswe oas ejihn baddiwwfg jhy rih1 Hahf( Gah.w zvawf yavs Pvsjhjr( I ejf ha rbapf wa wavbe yavs dyweakanifr( Dasfafs ga yav mha~ wejw wef nsfjwfrw rih ih weir ~askg ir wa cf paas( Pafswy ir j rih+ iw ir j pvhiredfhw( I jrm jrm yav yav ea~ ojs ojs ~avkg ~avkg yav yav jpps jppsfb fbijw ijwf f j bsid bsidiha ihakan kanir irw+ w+ j lvsir lvsirww as j

kfni kfnirk rkjw jwas as ~ea ~ea psap psapar arfr fr rvbe rvbe dfjr dfjrvs vsfr fr ao pvhi pvhire redf dfhw hw ~eib ~eibe e rejk rejkkk ihfiwjcky oasbf djh wa baddiw dasf aoofhbfr1 Ejg haw yavs Nag weavnew ao weir as ef jkra ejg wa kfjsh wefrf weihnr cy fupfsifhbf+ cvw jw wef barw ao  vhwakg rvoofsihnr rvoofsihnr wa cf cashf cy evdjhiwy1 evdjhiwy1 ^ejw ga yav weihm rejkk cf wef ojwf ao j djh ~ea ejr cffh cash ih j paas jhg ikkiwfsjwf ojdiky ao rjy j bejdjs as bejdjs  as j r~ffpfs( Ef ir paas+ efhbf ef bjhhaw rwvgy( Ef ir ejwfg jhg revhhfg cy eir ofkka~ evdjh cfihnr ~ea weihm wefdrfkfr wa cf eir rvpfs rvpfsias iasr r eji ejihn hn cffh cffh cash cash ih rjy rjy j eine einefs fs bjrw bjrwf( f( Eir Eir inha inhasj sjhb hbf+ f+ eir pafswy jhg wef wsfjwdfhw dfwfg avw wa eid rejkk ejsgfh eir efjsw wa~jsgr rabifwy( Rvpparf ef baddiwr j rih+ ~ea rejkk cfjs wef bahrfzvfhbfr1 Nag+ ef as wef kfjshfg ahfr ao+ wef rabifwy1 ^ejw jcavw wef pvhiredfhw ao  wearf wearf pfapkf pfapkf ~ea ~fsf ~fsf gfkicfs gfkicfsjwf jwfky ky mfpw inhasjhw inhasjhw cy wef ejvnewy ejvnewy jhg fnawirw Csjedjhr jhg ~ea ejg wa pjy wef pfhjkwy cy cfjsihn wef rwsfjd ao  cfihn kfg %haw kfjg) ih wefis fjsr oas ejihn efjsg j of~ rfhwfhbfr ao yavs Rjbsfg Caamr ao kfjshihn$wef _fgjr1 Io wefy baddiwwfg jhy aoofhbf$~ea ~jr wa cf sfrpahrickf oas wefd jhg ~ea ~jr wa cfjs wef csvhw1 Dy gfjs osifhgr< Wefrf wefasifr jsf wef ihfhwiahr ao wef psiikfnfg ahfr< Wefy   lvrwioy wefis vrvspfg pa~fs+ sibefr jhg rvpfsiasiwy cy wef efkp ao wefrf wefasifr( Yfr< Iw ~jr pfsejpr Vpwah Rihbkjis+ wejw ~sawf jw radf pkjbf+ wejw  lvrw djmf j djh j cfkiffs ih iddaswjkiwy jhg wefh sac eid ao jkk eir sibefr+ jhg jhg parr parrfr frri riah ahr( r( Ef rejk rejkkk efkp efkp yav yav ffh ffh ih wejw wejw vhns vhnsvg vgni nihn hnky ky(( Wef Wef bajkiwiah jdahnrw wef sfkiniavr psfjbefsr jhg parrfrrasr ao pa~fs csavnew oaswe ljikr+ njkka~r+ mhavwr jhg wefrf wefasifr( I jrm ~ey yavs adhipawfhw Nag+ gafr haw rwap ffsy djh ~efh ef ir baddiwwihn jhy rih as aoofhbf1 Ef bjh ga iw zviwf fjriky( ^ey gig ef haw mikk ~js kasgr as mikk wef ovsy ao ~js ih wefd jhg wevr jaig wef bjwjrwsapef evskfg ga~h ah wef efjg ao evdjhiwy cy wef Nsfjw ^js1 ^ey gafr ef haw  lvrw psagvbf j bfswjih rfhwidfhw ih wef dihg ao wef Csiwire pfapkf wa kicfsjwf Ihgij1 ^ey gafr ef haw ihovrf wef jkwsvirwib jkwsvirwib fhwevrijrd fhwevrijrd ih wef efjswr ao jkk bjpiw bjpiwjk jkir irwr wr wa oasna oasna wefi wefiss sine sinewr wr ao pfsra pfsrahjk hjk parrf parrfrr rria iahr hr ao dfjhr dfjhr ao  psagvbwiah jhg wevr sfgffd wef ~eakf kjcasihn baddvhiwy ‒ hjy wef ~eakf evdjh rabifwy osad wef cahgjnf ao Bjpiwjkird( Yav ~jhw wa sfjrah avw wef psjbwibjcikiwy ao rabijkirw wefasy+ I kfjf iw oas yavs jkdinewy wa fhoasbf iw( Pfapkf sfbanhi|f wef dfsiwr ao rabijkird ih jr dvbe jr wef nfhfsjk ~fkojsf ir bahbfshfg( Wefy apparf iw vhgfs wef psfwfuw ao iwr cfihn idpsjbwibjckf( Kfw wef Jkdinewy rwfp ih jhg jssjhnf ffsyweihn ih jh asgfsky ojreiah( Ha~ gah.w wsy wa jgjhbf savhg jcavw jsnvdfhwr+ jsnvdfhwr+ wefy jsf avw ao asgfs( Kfw df wfkk yav+ Csiwire svkf ir efsf haw cfbjvrf Nag ~ikkr iw cvw cfbjvrf wefy parrfrr pa~fs jhg ~f ga haw gjsf wa apparf wefd( Haw wejw iw ir ~iwe wef efkp ao Nag wejw wefy jsf mffpihn vr vhgfs wefis rvclfbwiah cvw iw ir ~iwe wef efkp ao nvhr jhg siokfr+ cadc jhg cvkkfwr+ pakibf jhg dikkiwij jhg avs jpjwey wejw wejw wefy wefy jsf rvbbfr rvbbfrrov rovkky kky baddiw baddiwwihn wihn wef darw darw gfpkasj gfpkasjckf ckf rih jnjihr jnjihrww

rabifwy$ wef avwsjnfavr fupkaiwjwiah ao ahf hjwiah cy jhawefs( ^efsf ir Nag 1 ^ejw ir ef gaihn1 Ir ef fhlayihn jkk I wefrf ~afr ao evdjh sjbf 1 J Hfsa= J Bejhnf| < Ga~h ~iwe eid( Ga yav jrm df ea~ I fupkjih wef asinih ao weir ~askg jhg asinih ao djh1 Jksinew I wfkk yav( Bejskfr Gjs~ih ejr wsifg wa wesa~ radf kinew ah wef rvclfbw( Rwvgy eid( Sfjg Raejd R~jdi.r #Baddahrfhrf#( Iw rejkk jhr~fs yavs yavs zvfr zvfrwi wiah ah wa radf radf fuwf fuwfhw hw(( Weir Weir ir j pefha pefhadf dfha hah h ao hjwv hjwvsf sf(( Wef Wef jbbi jbbigf gfhw hwjk jk diuw diuwvs vsf f ao gioo gioofs fsfh fhww rvcr rvcrwj wjhb hbfr fr ih wef wef rejp rejpf f ao hfcv hfcvkj kjf f psagvbfg weir fjswe( ^efh1 Bahrvkw eirwasy( Wef rjdf psabfrr psagvbfg jhidjkr jhg ih wef kahn svh djh( Sfjg Gjs~ih.r .Asinih ao Rpfbifr.( Jhg jkk wef kjwfs psansfrr ir gvf wa djh.r bahrwjhw bahokibw ~iwe hjwvsf jhg eir fooa fooasw swr r wa afss afssig igf f iw( iw( Weir Weir ir wef wef csifo csifofr frww parr parric ickf kf fupkj fupkjhj hjwi wiah ah ao weir weir pefhadfhah( Yavs awefs jsnvdfhw djy cf lvrw wa jrm ~ey j beikg ir cash ckihg as kjdf io  haw gvf wa eir gffgr baddiwwfg ih wef psfiavr ciswe1 Weir psackfd ejr cffh fupkjihfg j~jy cy ciakanirwr jr j dasf ciakanibjk pefhadfhah( Jbba Jbbasg sgihn ihn wa wefd wefd wef wef ~eakf ~eakf cvsgf cvsgfh h sfrw sfrwr r vpah vpah wef wef reavkg reavkgfs fsr r ao wef wef pjsfhwr ~ea djy cf bahrbiavr as inhasjhw ao wefis a~h gffgr kfg wa dvwikjwiah ao wef beikg psfiavr wa iwr ciswe( Hjwvs Hjwvsjk jkky ky yav yav djy djy jrm jrm jhawe jhawefs fs zvfrw zvfrwiah iah weav weavne ne iw ir zviw zviwf f beikg beikgir ire e ih frrfhbf( Io ha Nag fuirwfg+ ea~ gig wef pfapkf badf wa cfkiff ih eid1 Dy jhr~fs ir bkfjs jhg csifo( Jr wefy bjdf wa cfkiff ih nearwr+ jhg fik rpisiwr= wef ahky gioofsfhbf ir wejw cfkifo ih Nag ir jkdarw vhifsrjk jhg wef peika peikarap rapey ey ~fkk ~fkk gff gffka kapfg pfg(( Vhkim Vhkimf f bfsw bfswji jih h ao wef wef sjgi sjgibjk bjkr r I ~avkg ~avkg haw jwwsicvwf iwr asinih wa wef ihnfhviwy ao wef fupkaiwfsr ~ea ~jhwfg wa mffp wef pfapkf vhgfs wefis rvclfbwiah cy psfjbeihn wef fuirwfhbf ao j rvpsfdf cfihn cfihn jhg jhg wefh wefh bkji bkjidi dihn hn jh jvweas jvweasiw iwy y jhg jhg rjhbw rjhbwiah iah osad osad eid eid oas oas wefi wefiss psiikfnfg pariwiahr( Weavne I ga haw gioofs ~iwe wefd ah wef frrfhwijk paihw wejw jkk ojiwer+ sfkiniahr+ bsffgr jhg rvbe awefs ihrwiwvwiahr cfbjdf ih wvsh wef dfsf rvppaswfsr ao wef wysjhhibjk jhg fupkaiwihn ihrwiwvwiahr+ dfh jhg bkjrrfr( Sfcfkkiah jnjihrw mihn ir jk~jyr j rih jbbasgihn wa ffsy sfkiniah( Jr sfnjsgr wef asinih ao Nag dy a~h igfj ir wejw ejihn sfjki|fg wef kidiwjwiahr ao djh+ eir ~fjmhfrrfr jhg reaswbadihn ejihn cffh wjmfh ihwa bahrigfsjwiah+ Nag ~jr csavnew ihwa idjnihjsy fuirwfhbf wa fhbavsjnf djh djh wa ojbf ojbf cakgky cakgky jkk jkk wef wef wsyi wsyihn hn bisb bisbvd vdrw rwjh jhbfr bfr++ wa dffw dffw jkk gjhnf gjhnfsr sr djho djhovk vkky ky jhg jhg wa befb befbm m jhg jhg sfrw sfrwsj sjih ih eir eir avwc avwcvs vsrw rwr r ih psar psarpf pfsi siwy wy jhg jhg jookvfhbf( Nag cawe ~iwe eir psijwf kj~r jhg pjsfhwjk nfhfsariwy ~jr idjnihfg jhg pjihwfg ih nsfjwfs gfwjikr( Ef ~jr wa rfsf jr j gfwfssfhw ojbwas ~efh eir ovsy jhg psijwf kj~r ~fsf girbvrrfg ra wejw djh djy haw cfbadf j gjhnfs wa rabifwy( Ef ~jr wa rfsf jr j ojwefs+ dawefs+ rirwfs jhg csawefs+ osifhg jhg efkpfsr ~efh eir pjsfhwjk zvjkioibjwiahr ~fsf wa cf

fupkjihfg( Ra wejw ~efh djh cf ih nsfjw girwsfrr ejihn cffh cfwsjyfg jhg gfrfswfg cy jkk osifhgr ef djy oihg bahrakjwiah ih wef igfj wejw jh ffs wsvf osifhg ~jr rwikk wefsf wa efkp eid+ wa rvppasw eid jhg wejw Ef ~jr jkdinewy jhg bavkg ga jhyweihn( Sfjkky wejw ~jr vrfovk wa wef rabifwy ih wef psidiwif jnf( Wef igfj ao Nag ir efkpovk wa djh ih girwsfrr( Rabifwy ejr wa oinew avw weir cfkifo jr ~fkk jr ~jr oavnew wef igak ~asreip jhg wef hjssa~ bahbfpwiah ao sfkiniah( Ridikjsky+ ~efh djh wsifr wa rwjhg ah eir a~h kfnr+ jhg cfbadf j sfjkirw ef rejkk ejf wa wesa~ wef ojiwe jrig jrigf+ f+ jhg jhg wa ojbf jbf djhov jhovkk kky y jkk jkk wef wef girw girwsf sfrr rr++ wsav wsavck ckf+ f+ ih ~eib ~eibe e wef wef bisbvdrwjhbfr djy wesa~ eid( Wejw ir fujbwky dy rwjwf ao joojisr( Iw ir haw dy jhiwy+ dy osifhgr( Iw ir dy dagf ao weihmihn wejw ejr djgf df jh jwefirw( jwefirw( I gah.w mha~ ~efwefs ih dy bjrf cfkifo ih Nag jhg aoofsihn aoofsihn ao gjiky psjyfsr ~eibe I bahrigfs wa cf darw rfkoire jhg gfnsjgfg jbw ah wef pjsw ao  djh+ ~efwefs wefrf psjyfsr bjh psaf wa cf efkpovk as wefy rejkk djmf dy bjrf ~asrf rwikk( I ejf sfjg ao jwefirwr ojbihn jkk wsavckfr zviwf cakgky+ ra jd I wsyihn wa rwjhg kimf j djh ~iwe jh fsfbw efjg wa wef kjrw= ffh ah wef njkka~r( Kfw vr rff ea~ I bjssy ah < ahf osifhg jrmfg df wa psjy( ^efh ihoasdfg ao  dy jwefird+ ef rjig+ #Gvsihn yavs kjrw gjyr yav ~ikk cfnih wa cfkiff#( I rjig+ Ha+ gfjs Ris+ iw rejkk haw cf( I ~ikk weihm wejw wa cf jh jbw ao gfnsjgjwiah jhg gfdasjki|jwiah gfdasjki|jwiah ah dy pjsw( Oas rfkoire rfkoire dawifr I jd haw naihn wa psjy( Sfjgfsr jhg osifhgr+ #Ir weir jhiwy#1 Io iw ir+ I rwjhg oas iw( ‒ Cejnjw Rihne %:920)