Caso de resolución de casos para toma de decisiones
turnerFull description
Uvod u sociologiju
Uvod u sociologijuFull description
Descripción completa
Descripción completa
flute
PELAYANAN PADA PERUSAHAAN PELAYARAN ( Service in Shipping Company ) Dosen : Riza Syafrizal Citasuara, SE, MM [email protected][email protected] A. Industri Jasa dan Jasa Transportasi…Full description
Shipping and Returns Shopify TemplateFull description
Uploaded from Google Docs
asdfsdafdsafasdf
Uploaded from Google Docs
Full description
Turner Turner v. v. Lorenzo Shipping Corporation Corporation G.R. No. 157479 Facts: •
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
etitioners hi!ip an" #!nora Turner $ere the o$ners o% 1&'1'&''' shares o% stoc(s o% Respon"ent Lorenzo Shipping Corporation. etitioners vote" against the restriction o% pre)e*ptive right to ne$!+ issue" stoc(s& to ,e e-ecte" via the a*en"*ent o% the artic!es o% incorporation o% the Respon" espon"ent ent Corpor Corporati ation on.. The+ The+ a!!ege a!!ege" " that that it is preu preu"i "icia cia!! to their their interests as shareho!"ers. Thus& through through the e/ercise e/ercise o% their appraisa! right& the+ "e*an"e" the pa+*ent o% their shares at 0.072share 0.072share 30&09&7'.''. Respon"ent Respon"ent Corporation countere" that it $as an accepta,!e a*ount a!!eging that that&& the the F6 F6 o% etit etitio ione ners rs88 shar shares es ,e%o ,e%orre the the i*p! i*p!e* e*en enta tati tion on o% the the corporate action to "en+ pre)e*ptive right $as at '.412share 3414&1''.''. Respo espon" n"en entt Corp Corpor orat atio ion n %urt %urthe herr a!!e a!!ege ge" " that that the the corp corpor orat atio ion n ha" ha" no unrestricte" retaine" earnings at the ti*e the "e*an" $as *a"e. isagr isagree* ee*ent ent to stoc( stoc( va!uat va!uation ion !e" to the const constitu itutio tion n o% an appra appraisa isa!! co**ittee $hich va!ue" the shares in "ispute at 0.542share 30&55&'''.''. etitioners then as(e" %or pa+*ent at sai" va!ue p!us 0 interest per *onth %ro* the "ate o% origina! "e*an". Respon"ent Corporation& through a !etter& to!" etitioners that the+ cannot pa+ "ue to the a,sence o% ;R#& an" that the corporation ha" a "ee o% the case pursuant to the ?nteri* Ru!es o% ?ntracorporate ispute. The case $as ra>e" in RTC 6ani!a& the court $hich e/ercise e/ercise territoria! territoria! uris"iction uris"iction in the p!ace $here the principa! o@ce o% Respon"ent Respon"ent Corporation is %oun" RTC 6ani!a& in ru!ing in %avor o% the etitioners an" or"ering the Respon"ent to pa+& state" that the Corporation Co"e "oes not reAuire that ;R# *ust e/ist at the ti*e o% "e*an". #ven i% there is no ;R# at such ti*e& i% there $ou!" ,e ;R# !ater& the F6 o% the stoc(s sha!! ,e pai"& provi"e" that there *ust ,e su@cient %un"s to cover cre"itors a%ter such pa+*ent. Respon"ents& aggrieve"& e!evate" the case to the Court o% Bppea!s $hich reverse" the RTC ecision an" enoine" the pa+*ent to the petitioners. This pro*pte" the etitioners to e!evate the sa*e to the Supre*e Court& thus& this recourse.
?ssue: hether or not the Court o% Bppea!s erre" in reversing the RTC ecision. Ru!ing: •
No. The RTC erre" in or"ering the Respon"ent Corporation to pa+& an" that the sa*e e/cee"e" in the e/ercise e/ercise o% its uris"iction in ren"ering u"g*ent in %avor o% etitioners an" in the issuance o% $rit o% e/ecution. B stoc( ho!"er $ho "issents certain corporate actions has the right to "e*an" F6 o% his share 3appraisa! 3appraisa! right& provi"e" that the corporation has ;R# as provi"e" %or un"er Sec. 1 o% the Corporation Co"e. Such right *a+ ,e e/ercise" $hen there is a change in the Bo? preu"icing the interests o% the stoc(ho!"er. No pa+*ent sha!! ,e *a"e un!ess there are unrestricte" retaine" earnings in its ,oo(s to cover such pa+*ent. a+*ent ,+ the corporation to a "issenting stoc(ho!"er e/ercising his appraisa! right $ithout the e/istence o% ;R# is in vio!ation o% the trust %un" "octrine $hich proscri,es the "istri,ution o% assets to a stoc(ho!"er $ithout
a+*ent *a"e un"er such circu*stance is preu"icia! to the corporate cre"itors an" is nu!! an" voi". Cre"itors are a!$a+s pre%erre" over stoc(ho!"ers. •
etitioners8 cause o% action is pre*ature& ,ecause there is no ;R# at the ti*e o% "e*an". Right to "e*an" has not +et accrue". No va!i" "e*an"& no actiona,!e $rong. The su,seAuent e/istence o% ;R# "oes not cure the !ac( o% cause o% action. etition %or Certiorari enie". Deah.