STUDY
OF
PRODUCTION,
PLANNING
AND
CONTROL IN ASTRA META ME TAL L SYSTEMS SYSTEM S PVT LTD. LTD.
Name
: VASUDEV N BHANAJI
Regise! N".
: #$$%#&'(&
NAME OF THE INSTITUTE: LEARNING, BATCH : #$
%$SYMBIOSIS
CENTRE
FOR
DISTANCE
1
NO OBJECTION CERTIFICATE
This is to certify that Mr Vasudev N Bhanaji is an employee of M/s Astra Metal Systems Pvt. td.! for the past " years.
STUDY OF #e have ave no o$je o$ject ctio ion n for for him to carr carry y out out a proj projec ectt %or& %or& titl titled ed ' STUDY PRODUCTION, PLANNING AND CONTROL IN ASTRA METAL SYSTEMS PVT LTD( in our )r*ani+ation and for su$mittin* the same to the ,irector! S-, as a part of
fulfilment of the P,BA )perations0 Pro*ram.
#e %ish him him all the success. succe ss.
Si*n Si*nat atur uree of the the comp compete etent nt authority of the of the nstitute / )r*ani+ation
P)a*e: Verna! oa! ndia
Dae: 223,ec32414
2
DECLARATION BY THE LEARNER
This is to declare that have carried out this project %or& myself in part fulfilment of the P,BA Pro*ram of S-,.
The %or& is ori*inal! has not $een copied from any%here else and has not $een su$mitted to any other 5niversity 5niversity / nstitute for an a%ard of any ,e*ree / ,iploma. ,iploma.
Dae: 223,ec32414
Sig+a!e:
P)a*e: Verna! oa
Name: Mr Vasudev N Bhanaji
6
CERTIFICATE OF SUPERVISOR -GUIDE
-ertified that the %or& incorporated in this Project 7eport ' STUDY OF PRODUCTION, PLANNING AND CONTROL IN ASTRA METAL SYSTEMS PVT LTD/ su$mitted
$y Mr Vasudev N Bhanaji is his ori*inal %or& and completed under my supervision.
Material o$tained from other sources has $een duly ac&no%led*ed in the Project 7eport.
Sig+a!e "0 Gi1e: Name: Mr Pradip A. P. da -osta. A11!ess: Astra Metal Systems Pvt. td.
389! Verna ndl. :state! Verna ; oa <46822 2a)i0i*ai"+: ,ip. Production :n**. Desig+ai"+: ,irector S3e*ia) Fie)1 "0 4"!5: )perations E63e!ie+*e: Product ,evelopment < years0
Vendor ,evelopment < years0 )perations 1= years0
Dae: 22nd ,ecem$er 2414
P)a*e: Verna ; oa ; ndia <46822
<
1. ntroduction>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
= 3 1<
2. )$jectives and Scope>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
19
6. imitations >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>.
19
<. Theoretical Perspective>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
19 3 2"
9. Methodolo*y and Procedure of #or& >>>>>>>>
2" 384
=. Analysis of ,ata>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>.
81
8. ?indin*s! nferences and 7ecommendations>>>>>>>
82 3 8<
". -onclusion>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
89 38=
@. Summary of the Project 7eport >>>>>>>>>>>
88
ANN:57:S 0 Proposal 0 7eferences >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
88
0 ist of ?i*ures! -harts! ,ia*rams>>>>>>>>>>>
8"
V0 ist of Ta$les >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
8"
INTRODUCTION As!a Mea) S7sems P8. L1. -AMSPL ! are in field of Precision Sheet Metal
?a$rication ndustry! Manufacturin* and Supplyin* Sheet Metal ?a$ricated Products. AMSP started its operation in 1@@". t is an S) @4413244" -ertified -ompany. t initiated its epansion plan $y settin* up an unit in Sancoale ndustrial :state! %here it can use lar*er space for the purpose of production and also addin* stora*e space. t aims at caterin* to the Sheet ; Metal -omponent / Product needs of 5C! ermany and 5SA $ased 9
customers. t also plans to increase its capacity throu*h epansion. t has $een outsourcin* certain activities and for some activities also provides its o%n infrastructure. ts production is $ased on customer specification. t has no desi*nin* of its o%n. Astra follo%s Statistical Process -ontrol Systems for all $asic manufacturin* processes. The Principles of 9S for house3&eepin* is an on3*oin* activity %hich Astra $elieve is of utmost importance to its vision to $e a '#orld -lass Manufacturin* -ompany(.
Astra Metal Systems Pvt. td. is strate*ically located at Verna ndustrial :state in oa ; ndia %hich is in close proimity to the Airport! 7ail Terminus as %ell as the sea port all %ithin ran*e of 19&m $oundary. t has plant area of 1244 sD.mts.
Astra Metal Systems Pvt. td. %as promoted $y < technocrats Mr. Satish A. Shinde! Mr. -harlton -olaco! Mr Pravin . Pai and Mr Pradip A. P. da -osta.
-ompanyEs clientele %ith their product ran*e %hich includesF •
Siemens td. Medical :n*ineerin* ,iv! Verna! oa 3ray housin*s! machine parts and Machine enclosures.0
•
,ie$old ndia Pvt. td. ATM Sheet Metal -omponents0
•
Andre% Telecommunications ndia Pvt. td. Base Antenna Parts G Accessories0
•
,3in& ndia td! Verna! oa. :nclosures G parts for net%or&in* products0
•
Tata -onsultancy Services 3 Tivim oa. Mail / -heDue sortin* machine parts.0
•
il$arco Veeder 7oot ndia Pvt.td. ?uel ,ispensin* Cios&s0
•
Siemens A PT,3Berlin! ermany0 Sheet Metal -omponents for Po%er Sector0.
•
Mceoch Technolo*ies Marines 3 Birmin*ham! 5C Marine li*htin* ?ittin*s 0
•
Pentair #ater Pvt. td. Sheet Metal -omponents G :nclosures for #ater3Treatment0
•
V:S Andover ; Hampshire !5C
Sheet Metal -omponents G :nclosures for Air
Handlin* systems G controls0 •
Miscellaneous customer
O!ga+i9ai"+a) S!*!e "0 As!a Mea) S7sems P8. L1.
=
Pa*e 1 of <
)r*ani+ational chart continued.... Pa*e 2 of <
8
)r*ani+ational chart continued.... Pa*e 6 of <
"
)r*ani+ational chart continued.... Pa*e < of < @
B!ie0 1eai)s "0 1e3a!me+s i+ As!a a+1 ei! !")es ;Res3"+si
14
I
Punchin*
I
Bendin*
I
nsertin*
# Fa
I
#eldin*
I
,rillin*
I
Sanderin*
( S!0a*e 0i+isi+g
I
Po%der -oatin*
I
Pre3treatment
Se!8i*e De3a!me+s: & Dis3a*
I
Prepares an nvoice -um -hallan
I
Sees to it that the pac&a*in* is done as per customer needs and specifications
I
Arran*es the material to $e dispatched.
# S"!es
I
-lassification of *oods
I
BN card system
I
Maintain N
I
)utsourcin* *oods
( 2a)i7
I
-ompany documentation
I
Monitor G measure productsF ncomin*! n3process G ?inal sta*e.
I
-ontrol of ,ra%in*s
I
-ontrol of non3conformin* products at all sta*es
I
-ali$ration )f :Duipments
I
Vendor authentication
I
Special process validation
' Mai+e+a+*e
I
7educe Machine ,o%ntime
I
Preventive Maintenance
I
Servicin* )f Machinery Accordin* To %ee&ly/monthly/Juarterly/Kearly Plan
I
ive ist )f Spares To Purchase 11
= HR
I
7ecruitment F :mployee referrals and ne%spaper ads
I
Selection F ntervie% Method
I
)rientationF nformal intro.
I
Trainin* F)n3the3jo$
I
SafetyF Shoes! *loves! mas&s! *o**les! ear *ear
I
nsuranceF :S! Mediclaim Policy
I
Health G Hy*ieneF ood li*htin* G ventilation! %ater purifier! Shift system
I
ncentives F Monetary form! $onus at festivals
I
:mployee #elfareF Travel G food allo%ance
I
eave of a$senceF -ard system! 14 days in advance! 62 days
% Fi+a+*e
I
Purchase payments
I
,is$ursement of salary
I
Annual financial statement
I
7eserves
I
?ollo% up for receiva$les
> Mae!ia)s
I
nterrelated to PP-
I
Schedulin*
I
7eorder level
I
?indin* out potential suppliers
I
AB- analysis
? Ma!5ei+g
I
Mana*ed $y the M,
I
Meets potential customers
I
Advertisin* throu*h the nternet
@ De8e)"3me+
I
Study the feasi$ility of ne% nDuiry
I
,evelopment of Blan&s for Production
I
,efine Process ?lo% for Production
&$ PPC
I
Transfers information of ra% material to the purchase mana*er.
I
-alculate the timin* for the jo$. 12
I
Ma&e monthly plan for the various departments.
I
Transfer of nformation relatin* to Production.
I
Production control.
I
7elease Production orders planned from sales orders as standard or project.
I
Production Bill of Materials
I
Versions of manufacturin* $ills of materials and routin*s created.
I
Multi3location plannin* throu*h efficient information and material flo%.
I
nteractive action messa*in*Lfor the immediate $alancin* of supply and demand
I
Multiple %or&sheets for revie%in* various production options
I
Su$contractin* $y %or& center or operation
SOT ANALYSIS -As!a Mea) S7sems P8. L1
S!e+gs
O33"!+iies
I
:perienced staff
I
:pansion
I
#ell defined process
I
?orei*n mar&ets
I
Technolo*y / Sophisticated machinery
I
?or%ard nte*ration of product
I
Technical epertise
I
)%n Product
I
ar*e customer $ase
I
Serve additional customer *roups
ea5+ess
T!eas
I
Small scale operations
I
?luctuation of -ustomer )rders
I
ac& of Vision
I
Ne% :ntrants
I
5nplanned Approach
I
-ustomers *ro%in* $ar*ain po%er
I
,ependency on &ey human resource
I
)perators/%or&ers non3involvement
Astra Metal Systems Pvt. td.! has identified the process needed and have determined the process and its interactions as per $elo%F
16
O<e*i8es: Te 3!ima!7 "<e*i8e "0 3!"1*i"+ 3)a++i+g a+1 *"+!") i+ As!a Mea) S7sems P8. L1. is " e+s!e a e 1esi!e1 3!"1*s a!e ma+0a*!e1.
1<
I
At the ri*ht time!
I
n the ri*ht Duantities!
I
Meetin* Duality specifications! and
I
At minimum cost.
S*"3e: The Project study is limited to production and plannin* department. Limiai"+s: Some of the inter related processes are not analysed in depth in vie% of avoidin* any violation of company rules and re*ulations.
Te"!ei*a) Pe!s3e*i8e: Production Plannin* and -ontrol philosophy isF ' Fi!s 3)a+ 7"! 4"!5, a+1 e+ 4"!5 7"! 3)a+(. Before startin* any %or&! plannin* is necessary for the effective utili+ation of
availa$le resources.
Production Plannin* is concerned %ith the determination! acDuisition and arran*ement of all facilities necessary for the future operations! %hereas production control is concerned %ith the implementation of a predetermined Production plan or policy and the control of all aspects of Production accordin* to such a plan or policy.
PP- can $e defined as the process of plannin* the production in advance! settin* the eact route of each item! fiin* the startin* and finishin* date for each item! *ivin* production orders to shop and lastly follo%in* up the pro*ress of products accordin* to orders. t is also called the nerve centerE of the factory.
MAIN FUNCTIONS OF PPC
The follo%in* are the &ey functions of Production Plannin* and -ontrolF a0 7elease orders to the system in accordance %ith the priority plan. Priority means control over the status of jo$s and %or& activities $y specifyin* the order in %hich materials or jo$s are assi*ned to %or& centers. $0 Assi*n jo$s to specific %or& centers. c0 Provide seDuencin* priorities to specify the order in %hich jo$s are to $e processed. d0 -ontrol the manufacturin* lead time $y trac&in* and epeditin* jo$s if reDuired. 19
e0 Monitor the priority status of jo$s via summary! scrap! re%or&! and other reports. f0 Monitor the capacity status of facilities via input/output reports of %or&load/capacity. *0 ,isplayin* and settin* plannin* file entries manually h0 Maintainin* master data i0 :ecutin* total plannin* run for master schedule items j0 displayin* availa$ility overvie% for material &0 Processin* $ac&lo*s l0 -onvertin* planned orders into purchase reDuisitions! production orders or process orders m0 :ecutin* mass chan*es of planned orders n0 :ecutin* collective availa$ility chec& for components in the planned order to plan materials that almost plan themselves in the operative flo% o0 to *ain an overvie% of the future reDuirements and stoc& situation and to compare the ,emand plannin* %ith the availa$le capacities.
The production plannin* and control in a company is achieved $y inte*ratin* activities asF I
determinin* product demand!
I
translatin* product demand into feasi$le manufacturin* plans!
I
esta$lishin* detailed plannin* of material flo%s!
I
capacity to support the overall manufacturin* plans!
Te ma"! e)eme+s "0 a PPC a!e:
A. ,emand mana*ement B. A**re*ate production plannin* -. Master production schedulin* ,. 7ou*h3cut capacity plannin* :. Material reDuirement plannin* ?. -apacity plannin* . )rder release H. Shop floor schedulin* and control
1=
A. DEMAND MANAGEMENT:
Since Astra Metal Systems Pvt. td. is $asically o$ shopper! does not have its o%n product and its production is $ased on customer specification hence plannin* %ith respect to demand mana*ement does not ta&e place instead at Astra Metal Systems Pvt. td. PPinteracts %ith customer for their tentative reDuirement for a Duarter or for su$seDuent 6 month %herein 1st month actual and net t%o months tentative demand. Based on %hich further plannin* processes are initiated. Dema+1 0"!e*asi+g:
I
,emand for products is the drivin* force for any production activity.
I
,emand forecastin* is an important input to production plannin*.
I
?orecastin* is concerned %ith estimatin* future demand or reDuirement0 for products.
B. AGGREGATE PRODUCTION PLANNING:
Astra Metal Systems Pvt. td. are -ontract 3 Manufacturers and have %ide variety of customers! produces hi*h3variety! distinct products! as such there is vide fluctuation in demand for product. )n the other end! the resources of the company num$er of machines! num$er of %or&ers! etc.0 remain constant. The $est approach to o$tain feasi$le solution is to a**re*ate the information $ein* processed.
18
?or a**re*ation purposes the product demand is epressed in a common measurement unit such as production hours. Production plannin* is concerned primarily %ith determinin* optimal production! inventory! and %or& force levels to meet demand fluctuation.
Basi* s!aegies 0"))"4e1 " a
I
-urrently Astra Metal Systems Pvt. td. maintain %or& force $ut chan*es the production rate $y permittin* planned overtime! idle time and su$3contractin*.
I
f needed Astra Metal Systems Pvt. td. chan*es the production rate $y chan*in* the si+e of the %or& force throu*h planned hirin*.
I
:plore the possi$ility of planned $ac&lo*s if customers are %illin* to accept delays in delivery of products.
I
A suita$le com$ination of these strate*ies should $e eplored to develop an optimal a**re*ate production plan.
C. MASTER PRODUCTION SCHEDULE:
The primary use of an a**re*ate production plan is to level the production schedule so that the production costs are minimi+ed. Ho%ever! the output of an a**re*ate plan does not indicate individual product. This means that the a**re*ated plan must $e disa**re*ated into individual product. The result of such a disa**re*ation is %hat is &no%n as master production schedule.
Master production schedule does not present an eecuta$le manufacturin* plan! $ecause the capacities and the inventories have not $een considered in this sta*e. Therefore! further analysis for the material and capacity reDuirements are reDuired to develop an eecuta$le manufacturin* plan.
The MPS translates the Sales G )perations Plan S)P0 into a plan for producin* specific products in the future. -urrently said activity is done usin* 'n( of ecel files of different customers. The MPS is the translation of the S)P into produci$le products that ma&e up the output of a production plan.
D. ROUGHCUT CAPACITY PLAN:
The o$jective of rou*h3cut capacity plannin* is to ensure that the master production schedule is feasi$le. ?or each product family the avera*e amount of %or& needed and &ey 1"
%or& centers unit can $e calculated from each temEs Bill of Materials and from production routin*s process plannin* sheets0.
The availa$le resources are compared %ith the resource reDuirements profile o$tained for all the %or& centers considerin* all the product families. f the availa$le resources are less than reDuired! then decisions related to overtime! su$contractin*! hirin* %or&ers are ta&en.
-onsider t%o families of Sin*le Tan& Housin*s t%o of the items reDuired $y customer for t%o different final products0 developed in standard hours of resources per 12 units as follo%sF #or& -enter
Sin*le Tan& MM2.9
Sin*le Tan&s MM14
Total resources
Standard time in Mins0
Standard time in Mins0
reDuired for all
per 12 5nits0
per 12 5nits0
families
Punchin*
1=
21
68
,e$urrin*
9<
==
124
Bendin*
<2
<2
"<
#eldin*
"4<
1424
1"2<
Sanderin*
1"=
644
<"=
,rillin*! tappin*
21=
21=
<62
Pre3treatment
8"
8"
19=
Mas&in*
124
124
2<4
Po%der -oatin*
11<
124
26<
,e3mas&in*/ead
6=4
6=4
824
Varnishin*
612
6=4
=82
T"a) Time -i+
#($#
#>$(
=$$=
Res"!*e 0"!
(?
'=
?(
Res"!*e 0"!
=
%
&&
E. MATERIAL RE2UIREMENTS PLANNING:
I
The material reDuirements plannin* system is essentially an information system consistin* of lo*ical procedure for mana*in* inventories of component assem$lies! su$assem$lies! parts! and ra% materials in a manufacturin* environment.
I
The primary o$jective of an M7P system is to determine ho% many of each item in the $ill of materials must $e manufactured or purchased and %hen.
1@
The &ey concept used in determinin* material reDuirements areF a0 Product structure and $ill of materials $0 ndependent versus dependent demand c0 Parts eplosion d0 ross reDuirement e0 -ommon3use items f0 Scheduled receipts/)n3hand inventories/Net reDuirements *0 Plant order releases h0 ead time
a0 Product structure and Bill of MaterialsF Product is the sin*le most important identity in an or*ani+ation. A product may $e made from one or more assem$lies! su$assem$lies and components. A
-ontrol of product li&eF ,ra%in* No! 7ev No! 7ev ,ate.
•
7outin* F ProcessOs and Process SeDuence
•
ocation of processOs out of 6 units %hich location %ill do %hich process0F i.e location of Punchin* / aser! Bendin*! ?a$! Surface ?inish Po%der coatin* / Platin*0
•
Time estimate of processOs li&eF No. of Setup for $endin*! No of Bends! No of ,rills / -.S.C! No of Taps! No )f Spots! Area for surface finish etc..
?or e.* Specimen of Bill of Material for one of the Cios& since data cannot fit its $ro&en in 6 part. S!. N". $ &
Re8 Le8e)s
N"
Dae
D!a4i+g N"
1
:
4<.4".14
B@1<<9
Pa! N". PB@$@@? B@1<<9
&
G :
&&..$@
[email protected]"
GB@&''> B81<@@
GB@&''> B81<@@
BASE ASLYSLIM MONO BAS: 3 M:MB:7SM M)N)
64.11.4@
B81961
A
[email protected]"
B81966
B)4944@9 B81961 B)4944@9 B)4944@= B81966
#:, N5T M" BAS: K3M:MB:73M)N) S::C #:, N5T M" #:, N5T M14 M)T)7 MT. M:MB:73S::C M)N)
$
2 6 2 6 6 2
Des*!i3i"+ HPCL SLEE MONO IOS C)SC ASS:MBK B)T:,
24
6 2 2 2
4 4 4
64.4=.4=
[email protected]" 19.12.48
=49<6 PB844@9 B8196<
A
$%.&&.$@
PB>$&>&
6 & & & & &
# (
P!"*. Se. >>
T"a) 27 & 1
UOM NOS N)S
& 2
N"s Nos
< 2 " " 2 < < 2 1 < 2 2 2 ' ''
Nos Nos Nos Nos Nos Nos Nos Nos Nos Nos Nos Nos Nos N"s N"s
((,(@,'%,'@ 11!1=!66
11!1=!66
11!1=!66 M/11!1= 11!1=!66
&&,&%
B)4944@9 B)414128 PB844@9 B8196< B)4944@= B)4941=1 B)4941<8
#:, N5T M" ocatin* Pin #elded0 BAS: S,: S5PP)7T AN:F SP7NT 7:S:NT S5PP)7T B7A-C:T #:, N5T M14 -arria*e Bolt 6"mm 7) H,! 9/"BS# SJ5A7: N5T 9/"O BS# QKP PAN #ASH:7 , 24.86 ), 6".6 2.= MM
B)49416= PB>$&>& PM$($$#&
THC. e73a1 C)am3 EP FOAM ITH GUM -&=$ $ =MM TH
S!0a*e
TYPE FG ASS:MBK
PURE POLYESTER BLAC -GLOSSY P57: P)K:ST:7 BA-C )SSK0
P57: P)K:ST:7 BA-C )SSK0
P57: P)K:ST:7 BA-C )SSK0
P57: P)K:ST:7 BA-C )SSK0 P57: P)K:ST:7 BA-C )SSK0 QKP QKP QKP PURE POLYESTER BLAC -GLOSSY
Ma).
SHEET METAL SH::T M:TA
B/) SH::T M:TA B/) B/) SH::T M:TA B/) B/) SH::T M:TA SH::T M:TA B/) B)/A3H B)/A3H B)/A3H SHEET METAL BO;AH
-7-A 7A,: , -7-A 7A,: ,
-7-A 7A,: ,
-7-A 7A,: , -7-A 7A,: ,
CRCA GRADE D
Basi* P!"*ess )"*ai"+
+ i a s e ! m A ) a s " T
3 , e S 0 " . " N
. S 0 . " C " ; s N ) ) i ! D
s 3 a T 0 " " N
s " 3 S 0 O " N
; g + ! i e : * s a + L , P
+ " i a * i ! < a F
s m + i : 1 i
s m + i : g + e L
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
#?
$
6
4.21@
4.949
4.<<2
1
<
"
4
4
4
As!a
As!a
As!a
6
4.129
4.68@
4.1@
1
1
#
4
4
4
As!a
As!a
As!a
6
4.1
4.2"
4.112
1
1
#
4
4
4
As!a
As!a
1
4."1
4.92
1.="9
1
1
#
4
4
4
As!a
As!a
6
4.186
4.68@
4.161
1
2
#
4
4
4
As!a
As!a
5 : T
s 1 + e B
s 1 + e B ) a " T
g + i 1 + e B
: s i + i F e * a 0 ! , S
7 ) < m e s s A As!a
As!a
As!a
Re5
Re5
21
2
4.46
4.419
4.44<
1
<
1=
4
4
4
Re5
As!a
As!a
$0 ndependent versus ,ependent ,emandF The demand for the end item ori*inates from customer order and customer forecasts. Such a demand for end items and spare parts is called i+1e3e+1e+ 1ema+1. The demand $y a parent item for its components is called 1e3e+1e+ 1ema+1. :.*
R independent demand num$er of end item0 K R num$er of components for each end item K Rdependent demand num$er of su$assem$ly demanded0
c0 Parts :plosionF The process of determinin* *ross reDuirements for component items i.e reDuirements for su$assem$lies! components! and ra% materials for a *iven num$er of end3item units is &no%n as parts eplosion. Part eplosion represents the eplosion of parents into their components.
d0 ross 7eDuirements of -omponent temsF ross reDuirement of component items is the total num$er of component items reDuired to manufacture the end products. ross reDuirement of component items is computed $y usin* the information from the product information and the $ill of materials.
e.* f the demand for end3item :1 is 94! than *ross reDuirements for the item components. ,emand of S1 R 1 demand of :1 R 94 units ,emand of S2 R 2 demand of :1 R 144 units ,emand of -1 R 1 demand of S1 R 94 units ,emand of -2 R 2 demand of S1 R 144 units ,emand of -6 R 2 demand of S2 R 244 units ,emand of -< R 6 demand of S2 R 644 units 22
,emand of -9 R 1 demand of S2 R 144 units e0 -om -ommon3 mon35s 5see tems temsFF They are the component items %hich are used in different su$assem$lies of different end3 products. These items must $e added to have more more economic purchasin*. purchasin*.
f0 )n3Hand )n3Hand nven nventory tory!! Schedul Scheduled ed 7eceipts 7eceipts!! and Net 7eDuirem 7eDuirementsF entsF O+a+1 i+8e+"!7 is the availa$le availa$le items in stoc& from the previous period. S*e1)e1 !e*ei3 is the items already $een ordered $ut not $een received from the vendors yet. Ne !ei!eme+ is found $y su$tractin* the "+-a+1 i+8e+"!7 and s*e1)e1 !e*ei3s from
the g!"ss !ei!eme+s .
*0 Plan Planned ned )rder )rder 7elea 7eleaseF seF P)a++e1 "!1e! !e)eases refer to the process of releasin* a lot of every component item for
production or purchase. ,etermination ,etermination of lot si+e is an economic issue. The trade off is $et%een e i+8e+"!7 ")1i+g *"ss and the se 3 *"ss. ot si+es in M7P system are determined for component items for each sta*e seDuentially startin* %ith level 1! then level 2 and so on.
h0 ead Tim Timee and ead ead Tim Timee )ffsett )ffsettin* in*FF The )ea1 ime is the time it ta&es to produce or to purchase a part. The lead time depends onF ;
setup time
;
production time
;
lot si+e
;
seDuence of machin machines es on %hich %hich operations are performed
;
Dueuin* delays
The 3!*asi+g )ea1 ime is the time $et%een placin* an order %ith a vendor and receipt of the order. The manufactu manufacture re or purchase purchase of component component items must $e offset offset $y at least their )ea1 imes to ensure availa$ility of these items for assem$ly into their parent items at the desired
time.
F. CAPA CAPACITY CITY PLAN PLANNI NING NG::
26
The output of Material 7esource Plannin* does not produce an eecuta$le manufacturin* plan! $ecause it contains material reDuirement reDuirement information information only $ut does not contain information a$out the manufacturin* capacity of the plant. -apacity -apacity planni plannin* n* is concerned concerned %ith ensurin ensurin* * the feasi$ feasi$il ility ity of production production plans plans $y determin determinin* in* resources resources such as la$or la$or and eDuipmen eDuipmentt %ith a vie% vie% to developi developin* n* %hat is &no%n as an e6e*a<)e ma+0a*!i+g 3)a+ . The process of capacity plannin* is comple and involves a num$er of decisionsF ;
:plorin* :plorin* overtime / multiple multiple shifts shifts / su$3contractin* options options
;
,evelopin* ,evelopin* alternative alternative process plans plans for effective effective resource utili+ation
;
Splittin* Splittin* lots
;
ncreasin* or decreasin* employ employment ment levels levels to respond to capacity chan*es chan*es
;
nventory options! options! $uffer $uffer stoc&s
;
ncreasin* capacity $y $y addin* addin* capital capital eDuipment eDuipment such as machines/eDu machines/eDuipme ipments. nts.
G. ORDE ORDER R RELEA RELEASE SE::
)nce an eecuta$le manufacturin* plan is o$tained! orders are released to the shop floor. )rder release documents includeF includeF ;
Part No ! Jty to $e produced of each item.
;
B)M is also also referred as 7outin* sheets sheets havin* havin* informati information on onF I
oper operat atio ion n seD seDuences nces!!
I
%or& centers!
;
Standard machine machine time time allo%ed allo%ed for each operation! etc.
;
Appropriate shop floor floor records such as cards! move cards! and part lists for assem$l assem$ly y jo$s B)M is is referred0.
The "!1e! !e)ease tri**ers a num$er num$er of activities at the shop floorF I
Schedu Scheduli lin* n* of jo$ jo$ order orderss on on the the %or& %or& center centers. s.
I
SeDu SeDuen enci cin* n* of jo$ jo$ss on on a %or %or& & cent center er..
I
Allo Alloca cati tion on of ji*s ji*s and and fi fitu ture re..
I
oadin* oadin* of %or& %or& centers centers consider considerin* in* optimal optimal process conditio conditions. ns.
I
-oordinati -oordination on of materia materiall hand handlin lin*! *! stora*e! stora*e! %arehousi %arehousin*! n*! and and machi machine ne tools.
H. SHOP FLOOR FLOOR SCHEDULING SCHEDULING AND AND CONTROL: CONTROL:
2<
#hen the planned orders are released to the shop floor for manufacturin*! the primary o$jective is to deliver deliver the product. I
at the ri ri*ht time!
I
in the the ri* ri*ht ht Duan Duanti titi ties es!!
I
Meetin* Duality specifications.
But some unepected event machine $rea&do%n for eample0 eample0 may cause delays! the up to date information from shop floor is send to mana*ement via $rea& do%n memo. n order to ta&e action for e.* chan*in* the schedulin*0! up to date information from the shop floor is sent to the mana*ement. mana*ement.
A num$er of methods are used for data collection in Astra Metal Systems Pvt. td. areF I
Han Hand %rit %ritte ten n rep reports orts..
I
Manual Manual data data entry termina terminals! ls! for for enterin* enterin* data data in ecel ecel files files called called #P #P file files. s.
The major functions "0 a s"30)""! *"+!") s7sem follo%ed areF I
Sche Schedu dule le jo$ jo$ orde orders rs on on the the %or& %or& cen center ters! s!
I
SeDue SeDuence nce the jo$s jo$s in order order on a %or& %or& cent center! er!
I
Provi Provide de accur accurate ate and time timely ly order order status status infor informat mation ion..
The %or& order status s tatus information information includesF includesF I
order $a $atch si+es
I
jo$ co completion
I
rema remain iniin* jo$s jo$s and and ope operat ratio ions ns
The %or& order status information information is usedF I
To moni monitor tor the the pro*ress pro*ress of of manu manufa factu cturin rin* * activ activiti ities. es.
I
To determi determine ne priorit priorities ies for schedu schedulin lin* * jo$s jo$s in in the shop shop in respons responsee to chan*es chan*es in jo$ jo$ order status.
I
To main maintai tain n and contro controll %or& %or& in in process process..
I
To provi provide de output output data data for capaci capacity ty contro controll purpo purposes. ses.
)peration schedulin*F There are t%o t %o major activities to $e performed %hen 4"!5 "!1e!s are released to the shop floorF
29
1.
The %or& orders are assi*ned to the %or& centers such that due dates are satisfied. Allocation of jo$s to %or& centers is referred to as ma*i+e )"a1i+g.
2.
The seDuence of each %or& order throu*h each %or& center is determined. This process is referred to as "< see+*i+g.
The o$jectives of "3e!ai"+ s*e1)i+g areF ;
Meetin* due dates.
;
Minimi+in* manufacturin* throu*hput time.
;
Minimi+in* %or&3in3process.
;
Maimi+in* %or& center utili+ation.
o$ SeDuencin* and Priority 7ulesF Normally! the total num$er of jo$s eceeds the num$er of %or& centers. -urrently Astra Metal Systems Pvt. td. uses com$inations of priority rules li&e S"!es 3!"*essi+g ime %herein hi*hest priority is *iven to the jo$ %ith the shortest processin* time. n some cases Ea!)ies 1e 1ae :,,0 or Leas s)a*5 rule is *iven the hi*hest priority. S)a*5 R time remainin* until due date 3 process time remainin*.
More suita$le priority rule for Astra Metal Systems Pvt. td. &ind of entrepreneurship %ill $e Fi!s I+ Fi!s O ??)0. This %ill improve performance in plant operations. Since too many chan*es lo%ers productivity and even too many chan*es lo%ers one or other customerEs service level.
J5ATK ASS57AN-:F n Astra Metal Systems Pvt. td. Juality is maintained in t%o %aysF 1. :ach %or&er monitors his %or& and 2. Periodic inspections are performed $y individuals from the Duality control function
nspection is necessary at several places in the manufacturin* process! includin*F 1. nspection of ra% materials 2. nspection of manufactured productF I
Preprocess
I
n3process 2=
I
Post process
nspection of production process parametersF ;
Tools
;
?itures
;
Production machinery
;
Verification/cali$rationF 1. nspection fitures 2. nspection *au*es 6. nspection machinery
Juality Assuarnce Process at Astra Metal Systems Pvt. td.
Me"1")"g7 a+1 P!"*e1!e "0 "!5: n Astra Metal Systems Pvt. td. the production of hi*h3Duality parts is the company policy! production operators inspect the parts durin* the production process to ensure that
28
the process is under control. Some operations involve 144 inspection and some use random samples.
Astra follo%s samplin* $ased inspection %herein randomly a sample is ta&en from a $atch %hich is representative of the entire $atch. Thus! only the sample is inspected in determinin* the Duality of the entire $atch. No of samples to $e inspected depends on $atch si+e. ?or fa$ricated products and $ou*ht out items samplin* plans are desi*ned to avoid non value added activity.
Machine components reDuired for production process are verified at Juality department! as an inspection process M/ced components are inspected under sample plan %ith acceptance Duality limit. The num$ers of inspection samples are eDual to the sample si+e as defined $elo%. -riteria for acceptin* or rejectin* a lot depends on num$er of non conformin* items! if they are eDual to the acceptance num$er! full lot is accepta$le su$ject to the functional fitment acceptance.
Lot size Quantity in Numbers 2 to 8 9 to 15 1 to 25 2 to 50 51 to 90 91 to 150 151 to 280 281 to 500 501 to 1200 1201 to 3200 3201 to 10000
Sample size
2 3 5 8 13 20 32 50 80 125 200
Acceptan ce
0 0 0 0 0 1 1 2 3 5 "
Rejecti on
1 1 1 1 1 2 2 3 ! 8
?or in3process inspection of Product a*ain samplin* plan is follo%ed throu*hout the production line. The SAMP:31U0 ?irst conform Piece %ill $e :cludin* of Settin* Pieces0. f the settin* pieces found to $e Non3 conformin*! it is transferred to Juality -ustody for further disposition action. Visual characters li&e dent mar&! $o%! punchin* mar&! 7ust! #eld distortion! %eld Juality! tapper $end! po%der shade! po%der pattern! scratch mar&! pin holes and forei*n particle0 are inspected 144.
2"
Batch Si+e
Sample s
Sample31U
Sample32
Sample36
Sample3<
Sample39
33
33
33
33
33
5p to 19
2
?irst -onform Piece
ast Piece
1= 3 <@
6
?irst -onform Piece
94
144
94 and A$ove
9
?irst -onform Piece
29
94
89
144
P!"1*i"+ 3!"*e1!eF -ustomer *ives orders to PP- for re*ular production! for ne%
parts inDuiry comes throu*h ne% development team to PP- Duotes are sent! on approval of Duotes! commitment for delivery of proto/samples *iven than samples approval process is follo%ed $efore ta&in* actual production process.
H"4 is P!"1*i"+ P)a++i+g 1"+e: Production plannin* and control PP-0 department
receives a Production )rder P)0 that consists of client reDuirements such as product type! Duantity! revision status! item rate and delivery date. PP- cross verifies Purchase )rder terms G conditions a*ainst correspondin* Duotation released $y M, / -:) or Previously a*reed rates as per ?inal Product ist. After revie% of Purchase )rder the same is updated in data$ase pro*ram and ac&no%led*ement sent to the customer if needed.
PP- controls su$ units such as schedulin*! routin*! ra% material handlin*! and personnel! etc necessary for the successful completion of the order. #hen a contract affectin* product parameters is modified! PP- initiate the component Modification process. PP- transmits the order reDuirements to these su$ units electronically in the form of a production reDuest. Based on inputs a$out availa$ility of respective resources from various su$ units! PP $rea&do%ns the P) into production $atches and lots. -ustomer releases purchase orders %hich can $e specific Dty %ith tar*et dates or open order %ith monthly or %ee&ly schedule %hich follo%s from time to time
Mae!ia) De3a!me+:
The material department is responsi$le for material reDuirement plannin* and for providin* materials such as -7-A! H7-A! Hard%are! M/c items! Po%der! chemicals. ,urin* the process of P) order $rea&do%n! the main role of the Material department is to determine the amount of ra% material reDuired to satisfy the P) and chec& for their availa$ility either via in3house inventory or an eternal vendor. ,ependin* on the availa$ility of the ra% material reDuired for production or the due dates as to %hen the procurement %ould $e complete! the Material department provides the necessary feed$ac& to the schedulin* department PP-0. 2@
F+*i"+a) A!eas "0 Mae!ia) De3a!me+:
Material department has five primary functionsF I
7a% Material reDuirement computation
I
nventory Mana*ement
I
Vendor Selection
I
o*istics
I
#arehouse Mana*ement
The P)s Production )rders0 arrive on the floor at irre*ular intervals and for various types of products %ith various compositions. The orders are currently processed manually $y a PP- Production! Plannin* and -ontrol0 %ho after innumera$le consultations %ith other departments $rea&s do%n the order into $atches and fi*ures out the $est %ay to produce the lot %ith the *iven specifications and availa$ility of ra% materials. Since the iterative process and manual schedulin* of the orders is time consumin* and depends on real time information! it invaria$ly results in a hapha+ard schedulin* and delays in finishin* an order.
-urrently Astra is implementin* :7P module. This module %ill $e inte*rated %ith the overall production order information system at a later sta*e. :pected $enefits of the ne% :7P Module are follo%in*F I
Juic&er cycle time
I
ncreased productivity
I
a$or savin*s
I
:fficient schedulin*
I
:liminate $ottle nec&s and ma&e $etter use of machine time
I
#aste prevention and efficient use of ra% material
I
mproved morale / 7educed stress
:7P Module %ill ena$le Astra Metal Systems Pvt. td. employees toF I
-alculate the amount of ra% material reDuired to complete a P)
I
enerate reports of ra% material inventory across all the 5nits
I
enerate list of approved vendors
I
-ompare different vendors from the list and select vendors $ased on price! lead time! and Duality 64
I
enerate purchase orders to vendors
I
:ffective mana*ement of contractin* process
I
,evelop user *uidelines and policies
I
:nsure secure authori+ed user access
I
Protect vendor and customer information
Astra Metal Systems Pvt. td. follo%s J"< "! +i 3!"1*i"+ of production system %herein production is initiated as per customer specifications! each $atch or order consists of a small lot of products and may $e different from other $atches. t is flei$le and can $e adapted to chan*es in product desi*n and order si+e %ithout much inconvenience. n this system varied products are produced a*ainst specific orders.
Production as a System Production System
nputs nputs
-onversion -onversion Su$system Su$system Su$system
)utputs )utputs
-ontrol -ontrol Su$system Su$system
61
Astra Metal Systems Pvt. td. ?ollo%s "<
T!a+s0"!mai"+ P!"*ess I+3 Materials Machines Man / %or&ers Money / capital nformation
P!"*ess Manufacturin* Assem$lin* Transportin* Storin* -onsultin*
O3 37ay M/cOs ATM M/cOs Cios&s Services
62
P!"*ess La7" P+*i+g
Assem<)7 Tes
Be+1i+g
P"41e!*"ai+g
Fa
P!"*ess La7" 4"!5 !a8e)s " 1e1i*ae1 3!"*ess *e+e!s
ProcessF A series of activities that ta&es an input adds value to it and produces an output for a customer
Production Plannin* and -ontrol PP-0 is a process that comprises the performance of some critical functions on either side! vi+.! plannin* as %ell as control. ?i*ure PP- Process Production Plannin* and control
66
Production Plannin*
Production -ontrol
Plannin*
,ispatchin*
7outin*
?ollo%in* up
oadin*
nspection
Schedulin*
-orrective
P!"1*i"+ P)a++i+g a+1 C"+!") F+*i"+s
All of the four $asic phases of control of manufacture are easily identified in production plannin* and control. The plan for the processin* of materials throu*h the plant is esta$lished $y the functions of process plannin*! loadin*! and schedulin*. The function of dispatchin* puts the plan into effect that is! operations are started in accordance %ith the plan. Actual performance is then compared to the planned performance! and! %hen reDuired! corrective action is ta&en. n some instances re3plannin* is necessary to ensure the effective utili+ation of the manufacturin* facilities and personnel.
A. P!"1*i"+ P)a++i+g:
Production plannin* may $e defined as the techniDue of foreseein* every step in a lon* series of separate operations! each step to $e ta&en at the ri*ht time and in the ri*ht place and each operation to $e performed in maimum efficiency. t helps to %or& out the Duantity of material manpo%er! machine and money reDuires for producin* predetermined level of output in *iven period of time.
a0 P!"*ess P)a++i+g -R"i+g: The determination of %here each operation on a component part! su$assem$ly! or assem$ly is to $e performed results in a route for the movement of a manufacturin* lot throu*h the factory. Prior determination of these routes is carried out $y ne% product development team. 5nder this! the operations! their path and seDuence are esta$lished. The main aim of routin* is to determine the $est and cheapest seDuence of operations and to ensure that this seDuence is strictly follo%ed. 7outin* procedure involves follo%in* different activities. 10 An analysis of the article to determine %hat to ma&e and %hat to $uy. 6<
20 To determine the Duality and type of material 60 ,eterminin* the manufacturin* operations and their seDuence. <0 A determination of lot si+es 90 ,etermination of scrap factors =0 An analysis of cost of the product
$0 L"a1i+g: )nce the route has $een esta$lished! the %or& reDuired is loaded a*ainst the selected machine or %or&station. The total time reDuired to perform the operation is computed $y multiplyin* the unit operation times *iven on the standard process sheet $y the num$er of parts to $e processed. This total time is then added to the %or& already planned for the %or&station. This is the function of loadin*! and it results in a ta$ulated list or chart sho%in* the planned utili+ation of the machines or %or&stations in the plant. The net step is the eecution of the schedule plan as per the route chal&ed out it includes the assi*nment of the %or& to the operators at their machines or %or& places.
So oadin* determines %ho %ill do the %or& as 7outin* determines %here and Schedulin* determines %hen it shall $e done.
c0 S*e1)i+g: Schedulin* is the last of the plannin* functions. t determines %hen an operation is to $e performed! or %hen %or& is to $e completed the difference lies in the detail of the schedulin* procedure. n Astra de3centrali+ed schedulin* system is follo%ed %here all process plannin*! loadin*! and schedulin* for the units are done in main unit the details of the schedule may specify the startin* and finishin* time for an operation. And accordin*ly location PP- %ith the help of production supervisor schedules on day to day $asis to meet completion time for the %or& in a *iven department. t means %or&in* out of time that should $e reDuired to perform each operation and also the time necessary to perform the entire series as routed! ma&in* allo%ances for all factors concerned. t mainly concerns %ith time element and priorities of a jo$.
The pattern of schedulin* differs from one jo$ to another %hich is eplained as $elo%F
69
I
Mase! S*e1)eF Schedulin* usually starts %ith preparation of master schedule %hich
is monthly! $ro&en do%n to %ee&ly production reDuirement for each product for a definite time period! $y havin* this as a runnin* record of total production reDuirements the PP- is in $etter position to shift the production from one product to another as per the chan*ed production reDuirements. This forms a $ase for all su$seDuent schedulin* activities. A master schedule is follo%ed $y operator schedule %hich fies total time reDuired to do a piece of %or& %ith a *iven machine or %hich sho%s the time reDuired to do each detailed operation of a *iven jo$ %ith a *iven machine or process.
I
P!"1*i"+ s*e1)eF The main aim is to schedule that amount of %or& %hich can
easily $e handled $y one unit %ithout interference. To sta$ili+e or avoid freDuent chan*es in location of manufacturin* any product! at the initial period i.e at the time of prototype itself feasi$ility study is carried out and as far as possi$le %here all the processEs can $e done in totality that location is selected as manufacturin* unit for that *iven product. tEs not independent decision as it ta&es into account follo%in* factors. 10 Physical plant facilities of the type reDuired to process the material $ein* scheduled. i&e some jo$s may reDuire laser cuttin* %hich in availa$le only %ith one unit out of 6 Astra 5nits. 20 Personnel %ho possess the desired s&ills and eperience to operate the eDuipment and perform the type of %or& involved. 60 Necessary materials and purchased parts.
•
S*e1)i+g "0 J"< "!1e! ma+0a*!i+g F Schedulin* is of utmost importance as it
$rin*s out efficiency in the operations and reduces cost price. Astra PP- $asically maintains different types of schedules to have a close scrutiny of all sta*es namely an enDuiry schedule! a production schedule! a shop schedule out of a$ove three! a shop schedule is the most important as it ena$les to see at a *lance. 1. The total load on any section. 2. The operational seDuence. 6. The sta*e! %hich any jo$ has reached.
•
C"m
much %or&( as loadin*! and '%hen as schedulin*! in actual operations these three functions are often com$ined and performed concurrently. )$viously! it is desira$le that 6=
a minimum of chan*es $e made after schedules are esta$lished. This o$jective can $e approached if the amount of %or& scheduled for the unit or department is eDual to or sli*htly *reater than the manufacturin* cycle. ?or optimum control! it should never $e less than the manufacturin* cycle.
B. P!"1*i"+ *"+!"):
Production control is the process of plannin* production in advance of operations! esta$lishin* the etract route of each individual item part or assem$ly! settin*! startin* and finishin* for each important item! assem$ly or the finishin* production and releasin* the necessary orders as %ell as initiatin* the necessary follo%3up to have the smooth function. The production control is of complicated nature. The production plannin* and control department can function at its $est only %hen the production mana*er! the purchase mana*er! the personnel mana*er and the financial controller assist in plannin* production activities.
a Dis3a*i+g: Authori+in* the start of an operation on the shop floor is the function of
dispatchin*. This ?unction may $e centrali+ed or decentrali+ed. n Astra said function is ,e3centrali+ed %herein production supervisors are authori+ed to start each of the machine operations $ased on the routin* and schedulin* of the %or& throu*h his department. ,ispatchin* involves issue of production orders for startin* the operations. Necessary authority and conformation is *iven forF 1. Movement of materials to different %or&stations. 2. Movement of tools and fitures necessary for each operation. 6. Be*innin* of %or& on each operation. <. 7ecordin* of time and cost involved in each operation. 9. Movement of %or& from one operation to another in accordance %ith the route sheet. =. nspectin* or supervision of %or& ,ispatchin* is an important step as it translates production plans into production.
< Re3"!i+g "! F"))"4 3 : n Astra this function is carried on daily $asis %hich starts
%ith production meetin* %ith necessary departments li&e Press Shop! ?a$ Shop! Po%der -oatin*! )ffloadin*! Purchase! Maintenance Juality and PP-. The manufacturin* activity of a plant is said to $e 'in control( %hen the actual performance 68
is %ithin the o$jectives of the planned performance. #hen jo$s are started and completed on schedule! there should $e very little! if any! concern a$out the meetin* of commitments. :very production pro*ramme involves determination of the pro*ress of %or&! removin* $ottlenec&s in the flo% of %or& and ensurin* that the productive operations are ta&in* place in accordance %ith the plans. i&e mornin* meetin* concern in3char*e in respective department monitors/revie%s dayEs production at the end of shift. t spots delays or deviations from the production plans. t helps to reveal detects in routin* and schedulin*! misunderstandin* of orders and instruction! under loadin* or overloadin* of %or& etc. All pro$lems or deviations are investi*ated and remedial measures are underta&en to ensure the completion of %or& $y the planned date! currently measures li&e providin* necessary ji*s G fitures! identifyin* unnecessary activities and eliminatin* them alon* %ith overtime %or&in* is emphasised.
* C"!!e*i8e A*i"+: This is the &eystone of any production plannin* and control
activity. f all processes are on schedule that means in all pro$a$ility production is not $ein* scheduled to its optimum productive capacity. #ith an optimum schedule! manufacturin* delays are the rule! not the eception. As a -orrective action in Astra activities of adjustin* the route! reschedulin* of %or&! repairs and maintenance of machinery or eDuipment! control over inventories is initiated. Alternate methods li&e overtime! increase in %or& force is ta&en to handle pea& loads. 1 I+s3e*i"+: This is mainly to ensure the Duality of *oods. t can $e reDuired as effective
a*ency of production control. To move to%ards %orld class manufacturin* unit Astra is in the process of im$i$in* this inspection process in the $lood of producer operator0. As such necessary on*oin* trainin* are provided operators.
e Re3)a++i+g: 7e3plannin* is not corrective action. 7e3plannin* revises routes! loads!
and schedules! a ne% plan is developed. Astra $ein* jo$ shopper and have vide variety products and lar*e customer $ase this function is often reDuired. -han*es in customer reDuirements! machine $rea&do%ns! a$senteeism! material shorta*es or any other factors affectin* the day to day %or&in* often indicate that a re3plannin* is needed.
As in many manufacturin* industries today! Astra is under increasin* pressure to transform $usinesses from ma&e3to3forecast $ased on the predictions *iven $y customers0 to small $atch made3to3order MT)0 production. The emphasis is also stron* on just3in3time 6"
deliveries and minimal stoc&holdin* throu*hout the manufacturin* process. The customer no%adays epects a fast delivery of Duality products that are ali*ned %ith current trends. ?lei$ility on the shop floor is $ecomin* essential and attitudes have had to chan*e from pre3set machine runs for producin* and stoc&in* to a ne% ean approach of ma&in* only %hat can $e sold.
#ithin our or*ani+ation it %as %idely reco*ni+ed that the performance of production systems is not only determined $y the %ay the production system is controlled $ut also $y its or*ani+ational desi*n. And as a measure to try and improve performance de3centrali+ed plannin* came into eistence %herein for all 6 units! plans are released $y central PP- and $ased on central PP- plans! location PP- at each unit does function of controllin* the production $y simultaneously implementin* plannin* and control systems and utili+in* or*ani+ational measures. Not%ithstandin* its importance! the field of production and operations mana*ement still lac&s. )ne of the reasons for this shortcomin* seems to $e a lac& of understandin* ho% plannin* and control systems interact %ithin or*ani+ational plant.
)ur )r*anisation %as eamined durin* a continuous period of si months. After this intensive research period! all 6 units %ere follo%ed durin* a period of one year. ,urin* this period developments re*ardin* the plannin* and control system and the or*anisational desi*n of the production and distri$ution system %ere o$served. The si+e of the firm is ± 194 employees0. All distinctive functional areas li&e production! sales! procurement eisted G only mar&etin* did not eist.
,ata %as *athered $y studyin* internal reports! visitin* and o$servin* meetin*s! and $y means of semi0 structured intervie%s. n all cases plannin*! production! materials and lo*istics employees %ere intervie%ed for several times. #ithin each or*anisation the employees $ein* intervie%ed consisted of employees %or&in* at $oth the lo%er! middle and hi*her mana*ement levels. Both the semi30 structured intervie%s and the Duestionnaires %ere conducted. n all case studies some participative research elements %ere included. These included Duestions li&eF do %e need a lo*istical or materials mana*ement department! ho% can conflicts $et%een Production! Sales and o*istics $e reduced! are there any co3ordination pro$lems $et%een Purchasin*! Production and Sales and if! ho% can they $e solved! and 6@
last $ut not leastF are interfaces %ithin the company $et%een functional areas mana*ed properly. ?rom this evaluation in all units an improvement and reor*anisation process needs to $e conducted.
Questions
#nit 1 better ,ommunicati on) nee(s Re(esi*n or*anization structure
#nit 2
#nit 3
nee(s re(esi*n or*anizati on structure
Re(e-ne responsibilit ies an( aut$orities
/es
/es
R') Lean process
R'
R'
aterials
aterials
aterials
No
No
No
$o% can con&icts bet%een 'ro(uction) Sales an( Lo*istics be re(uce(+ are t$ere any co.or(ination problems bet%een 'urc$asin*) 'ro(uction an( Sales+ /es i) $o% can t$ey be sole(+ (o %e nee( a lo*istical or materials mana*ement (epartment+ Are interaces %it$in t$e company bet%een unctional areas mana*e( properly+ P!"1*i"+ De3a!me+s -P!"*ess:
P!ess S"3
I
Punchin*
I
Bendin*
I
nsertin*
Fa
I
#eldin*
I
,rillin*
I
Sanderin*
S!0a*e 0i+isi+g
I
Po%der -oatin*
I
Pre3treatment
P!ess S"3:
Astra $ein* $asically sheet metal manufacturin* unit! -A,3-AM systems are %idely used. Typically! sheetmetal parts are produced $y a num$er of different 2, and 6, operations. n this study! %e only consider the cuttin* and $endin* process. Startin* from a flat $lan&! a suita$le cuttin* process %ill $e chosen to produce the 2, part. Since material is an <4
important cost component! optimi+ation of this process %ill $e driven $y the need to decrease the scrap percenta*e. Nestin* al*orithms! implemented in computer systems! is used to *roup a num$er of parts %ith the same thic&ness on a sin*le sheet. f the reDuired end product is a 6, part! air $endin* %ill $e applied. The $endin* process is la$or intensive and reDuires an operator continuously. The production time of a 6, part is influenced $y the num$er of time3consumin* setups $et%een parts. A part reDuires a certain production layout! i.e. a seDuence of punch3die com$inations positioned on the press $ra&e. nterchan*in* production layouts is time consumin* and thus needs to $e avoided as much as possi$le. Plannin* of the air $endin* process is still hi*hly eperience3$ased.
Here focus is on an inte*rated approach for production plannin* of sheet metal parts for turret punch press cuttin*0 and press $ra&e air $endin*0.
See mea) "3e!ai"+s: "3imi9ai"+ "0 e 1isi+* 3!"*esses
Sheet metal operationsF Sheet metal operations are used to transform a flat $lan& into 2, or 6, o$jects $y applyin* different processesF punchin*! cuttin*! $endin*! %eldin*! po%der coatin*! platin*! etc. The thic&ness typically varies $et%een 4." and 9 mm. n the first step! a cut to si+e sheet or standard si+e sheet %ill $e punched on turret punch press TPP0 or cut %ith the laser! resultin* in a 2, intermediate or end product.
f 6, parts are reDuired! air $endin* is used. By applyin* a vertical force! the sheet is forced into a die. ,ependin* on the ma*nitude of this force! the $end an*le %ill vary. :ach $end line reDuires a certain toolset. Such toolset comprises a punch and a die! positioned on the press $ra&e. ?or $endin* one part! often consistin* of multiple $end lines! different toolsets mi*ht $e needed.
Those sets %ill all $e positioned on the press $ra&e! resultin* in a production layout. -han*in* production layouts is time consumin* and should $e avoided as much as possi$le. The operatorEs eperience plays an important role in reducin* the num$er of tool chan*es at the press $ra&e.
?i*ure displays the different sheet metal operations.
<1
T!!e P+* P!ess -Ci+g: Nesi+g "0 e "!1e!s
-urrently! Astra manufacture ta&es production $atch si+e %ith smaller lot si+es than $efore. To decrease the costs for sheet metal punchin* or laser cuttin*! nestin* is applied. -urrently nestin* is $asically done to produce items %ith minimum $atch si+es that too under same product $rand and same customer.
?uture nestin* plans %ill imply com$inin* multiple orders of the same material on a sheet! such that the amount of %aste material is reduced. This can $e of different product and different customers.
The pro$lem of com$inin* different parts on a sheet is &no%n as the cuttin* stoc& Pro$lem. n the first sta*e the parts are en*a*ed in minimum area rectan*ular modules either sin*ly or in com$ination %ith other parts. n the second sta*e! those modules are *rouped on a sheet! minimi+in* the %aste material. An important remar& is the fact that these simplifications can create additional %aste material. Parallelo*ram shaped parts can ideally $e nested %ithout any %aste material.
An instruction to punchin* operator is *iven usin* o$ )rder for pro*ram to $e punched G shall chec& for the follo%in* parametersF 1. Pro*ram No <2
2. -A, ?ile Name 6. Sheet Si+e <. Sheet thic&ness 9. Material used =. NoEs of sheets to $e punched 8. o$ description G Si*nature ". Special nstructions
Punchin* operator than chec&s the Tools indicated in the Pro*ram to $e punched G note do%n the correct die clearances *iven G direction of Tool loadin*. Tool loadin* %ith proper direction and proper clearance is initiated for that particular thic&ness.
P+* T"") Basi*s
Toolin* for a punch press consists of a punch! die and stripper. The punch is located in a *uide mechanism that fits in the turret on a turret punch press. Turrets hold a variety of tools and inde to $rin* different punch tools into the %or& +one of the machine.
:ach punch tool has a correspondin* die that is located under the machine toolOs %or&ta$le. The si+e and shape of the hole created in the sheet metal is determined $y the *eometry of the punch. -learance $et%een the punch and die is adjusted to reflect the material thic&ness.
#hen the punch press is actuated! a ram descends! causin* the punch to &noc& out the material creatin* a slu*. The die is desi*ned to allo% the slu* to fall throu*h. The stripper holds the sheet metal in place until the punch is fully %ithdra%n from the sheet. Most sheet metal punch tools used in shops today are self3strippin*. nstead of usin* the ram to push the punch throu*h the material and pull it out! these tools are $uilt %ith an internal sprin* that automatically retracts the punch. The ram then only needs to %or& in one direction. This saves cycle time and %ear on the turret punch press. T"") Li0e
The punchin* process *enerates heat. There is friction $et%een the punch and the *uide assem$ly as the punch reciprocates %ithin its $ushin*s. Modern turret punch presses are capa$le of 1!444 stro&es per minute. Most punch presses are eDuipped %ith! or have availa$le! an automatic oil lu$rication system. t supplies an air3oil mist throu*h ports in the <6
*uide assem$ly to lu$ricate the movin* parts in the tool. This si*nificantly etends the life of %ear parts %ithin the punch tool.
Be+1i+g: Mi+imi9ai"+ "0 e +m
?or the $endin* operation! production time minimi+ation is reDuired. After careful studies of dra%in* proper tools are selected accordin* to the sheet thic&ness! $end shape and $endin* len*th. 7elationship $et%een Sheet Thic&ness t0 and V3%idth See i*5+ess
$.=#.% mm
(.$? mm
@&$ mm
mm "! m"!e
V3%idth
=t
"t
14t
12t
V3)penin* selections normally should $e as per the standards i.e for material thic&ness less then 6mm it should $e =T! and for 6mm to
Selection of Punch and ,ieEs -om$ination is done such that components are $ent %ith minimum noEs of Tool Set upEs! also as far as possi$le ,ie removal is avoided %hile seDuencin* of $ends.
RECOMENDED VOPENING DIES TO BE USED FOR BENDING. Re*"m. Mi+ Be+ F)a+ges A*ie8e1.-mm "+ Di00. P+*es. S.T5s.VOPEN #&$ -$.?! '&=-&.=! '=#&=-&.=!'$?-$.?! '>&=&-&.=! 4." = < 9 9 9 9 1 = < 9 9 9 9 1.2 " =.2 8.2 8.2 8.2 8.2 1.9 14 8 " " " " 1." 12 @ 14 14 14 14 2 12 @ 14 14 14 14 2.9 1= 11.9 12.9 12.9 12.9 12.9 6 1= 12 16 16 16 NA < 29 1".9 1".9 1".9 1".9 NA
Blan& are chec&ed and ensured there are no $urrs in the supportin* area $ac& *au*e0. Tool ori*in point is set $y *ivin* adeDuate pressure. ?ormula R ma pressure / "69 punch len*th. Ma pressure ; 8.1/"69 mm0 -N- pro*ramme is corrected to *ive enou*h feed speed ?SW! $ac& *au*e retract len*th and ,3ais movement.
<<
Actual $endin* is done and dimensions are chec&ed in each cycle! pro*ramme is corrected only in the case of dimension variation. This pro*ramme is saved for $atch production. ,imensions related to $endin*! are %ritten do%n in $endin* report re*ister. Parts are chec&ed after predefined $atch to avoid any sort of deviation from dra%in* specifications.
After completin* $endin* operation of $atch! the part are moved to net station $ased on route! herein process locations are defined to store the material from %here net station collects material for further processin*. Parts are identified %ith %hite ta*Es filled %ith data li&e part no! part description! Dty! date of production. ?or the production plannin* model some important data reDuirements need to $e fulfilled. ?irst! the partsE characteristics! sheetsE characteristics and the production layouts are needed. The partEs characteristics and the sheetEs dimensions can $e etracted from the Bill of Material. The production layout is determined $ased on the press $ra&e operatorEs eperience. All data is put in datasheets to $e lin&ed %ith the plannin* model.
Second! the Punchin* times and the $endin* times are needed. The Punchin* times are determined usin* Soft%are output! %hile the $endin* times are determined $y means of a time3motion study.
F+*i"+i+g "0 P!ess S"3:
Press3Shop n char*e plans production as per %ee&ly plan released $y PP-. This is $ro&en do%n to daily plan for Turret Punch! Press3Bra&e! nsertin* respectively0. Shift n3char*e chec&s for the manpo%er! material G machine availa$ility.
Pro*ram for punchin* is made ready as per daily production plan G same is do%nloaded on m/c $ased on o$ order slip %hich is issued to operator. )perator chec&s for tools that are reDuired to process the do%nloaded pro*ram G accordin*ly load the Turret.
Su$seDuent to punchin* and prior to $endin* the $lan&ed material is made $urr free to avoid any hindrances %hile $endin* )n Press3Bra&e! $ased on the process seDuence tool set up is carried out and accordin*ly jo$s are processed.
<9
?irst piece inspection is carried out G relevant data is recorded in in3process inspection re*ister JA Maps0. f any variation in product characteristics is noticed than it is corrected G jo$ are re3inspected G a*ain re3relevant data is recorded in in3process inspection re*ister.
After the first piece is accepted! production is carried out as per process seDuence. The inspection of the products is done at freDuency defined for monitorin* G measurement of product. Material to $e moved to concerned department for further processin* is moved as per $elo% movement note 1. To stores for further processin*0F3 material movement note start %ith PS3 follo%ed $y increasin* serial no. if moved from Bendin* and TS if moved after punchin* 2. To stores ,ispatch0F3 material movement note start %ith P,3 follo%ed $y increasin* serial no. if moved from Bendin* and T, if moved after punchin* 6. To ?a$rication ShopF3 material movement note start %ith P?3 follo%ed $y increasin* serial no. if moved after $endin* and T? if moved after punchin* <. To Po%der -oatin* ShopF3 material movement note start %ith PP3 follo%ed $y increasin* serial no. if moved after $endin* and TP if moved after punchin*
n3process rejections that occur in the process are entered in inspection re*ister and controlled as per set procedures for controllin* N- Non conformin*0 items. An operator does the inspection for parameters identified in dra%in*s! and in case of non3conformities necessary disposition and corrective actions are initiated.
Fa
?a$rications involvin* sheet metal! plate or pipes %hich are commonly %elded $y an arc process. The most %idely used %eldin* processes rely on fusion of the components at the joint line. n fusion %eldin*! a heat source melts the metal to form a $rid*e $et%een the components. T%o of the most important processes use a *as shield to protect the %eld metal from atmospheric contamination. M / MA / T %eldin* principles as shielded metal arc %eldin* is a semi3automatic process %hich is suita$le for $oth manual and mechanised operation. t is &no%n $y a variety of namesF M 3 Metal nert as! MA 3 Metal Active as! -ar$on ,ioide / Ar*on
<=
A lo% volta*e 1".<4V0! hi*h current =4.944A0 arc $et%een the end of a %ire electrode and the %or& provides the heat needed for the %eldin* operation. The arc and the %eld are protected from atmospheric contamination $y a *as shield.
Time study of fa$rication process is carried out to facilitate eecution of fa$rication activity.
Srl
Time in minutes
Part no
,escription
Jty
* n i d l e #
Product
r e t n u o c / * n i l l i r ,
* n i p p a T
/ * n i r e d n a S * n i r u $ e d
* n i l l i ? / r e t t a p S
Total Time
* n i l i o
* n i t e v i r
* n i t s e t
l a v o m e r d n n e mins $
MM2.9
1
9<2411" 441
?ront -over
1
"
3333
3333
@
14
3333
3333
3333
3333
28
2
9<2414@ 441
Top Panel -omplete
1
3333
19
3333
3333
3333
6"
-ap -omplete
1
3333
3333
3333
3333
<1
9<12<11 441
1
<9
24
24
1"4
1
3333
3333
"
3333
3333 9
24
9
64 12
3333
9<24169 441
Tan& Housin* -omplete -olumn -ap
19 64
3333
<
3333 19
19 1=
3333
9<12<64 441
" 14
3333
6
3333
3333
64
=
9<24119 441
-assette Bo
1
9
3333
3333
19
19
3333
3333
3333
3333
69
8
9<21=9@ 441
#heel uard
1
19
3333
3333
1"
3333
3333
3333
3333
<9
"
9<12<21 441
Top Plate -omplete
1
14
3333
3333
12 "
=
3333
3333
3333
3333
2<
@
9<16=61 442
inverter $ase tray
1
6
33333
@
3333
92
-over -omplete
1
33333
33333
=
14 9
3333
9<12<2@ 441
29 "
9
14
33333 9
3333
3333
2<
9
3333
F+*i"+i+g "0 Fa< S"3:
Based on time study production is line up for net day. #herein daily Production line3up for man G machine -)2 #eldin*! Spot %eldin*! ,rillin*! Sanderin*! etc.0 is monitored and measured.
<8
?a$3Shop n char*e plans production as per %ee&ly plan released $y PP-. This is $ro&en do%n to daily plan for #eldin*! ,rillin*! Sanderin*! ,e$urrin*! fillin*! $uffin*0. Shift n3 char*e chec&s for the manpo%er! material G machine availa$ility.
Visual inspection for Duality of fa$rication is carried out $y operators themselves $efore movin* said item to net station. n case of detection of any visual defects! the shift supervisor initiates necessary disposition and corrective action.
?irst piece is verified for conformity as per the procedure for monitorin* G measurement of product! and then the production is $e carried out as per process seDuence route0. Here a*ain similar to Press Shop material movement method is follo%ed for identifyin* movement from fa$rication to other department! %here in T is placed %ith ? for ?a$0
n3process rejections that occur in the process are entered in inspection re*ister and controlled as per set procedures for controllin* N- Non conformin*0 items. An operator does the inspection for parameters identified in dra%in*s! and in case of non3conformities necessary disposition and corrective actions are initiated.
P"41e! C"ai+g:
Po%der coatin* is $y far the youn*est of the surface finishin* techniDues in common use today. t %as first used in Australia a$out 1@=8. Po%der coatin* is the techniDue of applyin* dry paint to a part. The final cured coatin* is the same as a 23pac& %et paint. n normal %et paintin* such as house paints! the solids are in suspension in a liDuid carrier! %hich must evaporate $efore the solid paint coatin* is produced. n po%der coatin*! the po%dered paint may $e applied $y either of t%o techniDues. I
The item is lo%ered into a fluidised $ed of the po%der! %hich may or may not $e electrostatically char*ed! Astra does not have this set up0 )7
I
The po%dered paint is electro3statically char*ed and sprayed onto the part. Astra uses this method.
The part is then placed in an oven and the po%der particles melt and coalesce to form a continuous film. There are t%o main types of po%der availa$le to the surface finisherF I
Thermoplastic po%ders that %ill re3melt %hen heated! and
<"
I
Thermosettin* po%ders that %ill not re3melt upon reheatin*. ,urin* the curin* process in the oven0 a chemical cross3lin&in* reaction is tri**ered at the curin* temperature and it is this chemical reaction %hich *ives the po%der coatin* many of its desira$le properties.
P!e3a!ai"+ 0"! P"41e! *"ai+g:
The $asis of any *ood coatin* is preparation. The vast majority of po%der coatin* failures can $e traced to a lac& of a suita$le preparation. The preparation treatment is different for different materials. n *eneral! for all applications the preparation treatment for aluminium is as follo%sF -lean
)r
-lean
7inse
7inse
:tch
:tch
7inse
7inse
-hromate
Phosphate
7inse
7inse
,emin 7inse
,emin 7inse
)ils and *reases are removed in %ea& al&ali or neutral deter*ent solutions and the surface is etched to remove heavy oides. After rinsin*! the aluminium is dipped into a chromate or phosphate solution to form a conversion coatin* on the aluminium. This film is chemically attached to the aluminium. After rinsin* the aluminium is finally rinsed in demineralised %ater. The conversion coatin* has t%o functionsF I
t presents a surface to the po%der %hich favours adhesion more than the oides that form very readily on aluminium surfaces! and
I
t reduces the incidence of under film corrosion.
The use of demineralised %ater reduces the presence of chemical salts on the aluminium surface. ?or steel the preparation Astra has set up hot treatment plant %hich $asically follo% as per $elo% flo%.
Srl 1 2 6
Description ,e*reasin* #ater 7inse ,erustin*
Vol
Time
Temp.
Points
Ph.
93= 3
19 min.
=43894-
@4 3114
3
3 19 324
=38 3
19324
1 min 14 min
4
7T 7T4-
<@
3
1 min
7T4-
3
=38
4.4"
1 min.
7T4-
3
A$ove @
2@ 361
3
7T4-
3
=38
=43894-
3
<3=
<
#ater 7inse
9
Activation
=
Phosphatin*
9
8
#ater 7inse
3
1 min
"
Passivation
4.429
1 min.
938 min <"3994-
The *rain refiner is used after acid cleanin* of steel surfaces and $efore +inc phosphatin*! other%ise the +inc phosphate coatin*s produced %ill $e very coarse %ith lo% adhesion. The po%der coatin* applied to a coarse phosphate %ill produce rou*h coatin*s a little li&e sandpaper0 and possess lo% adhesion. H"4 is i 1"+e e)e*!"sai* s3!a7
The po%der is applied %ith an electrostatic spray *un to a part that is at earth or *round0 potential. Before the po%der is sent to the *un it is fluidisedF I
to separate the individual *rains of po%der and so improve the electrostatic char*e that can $e applied to the po%der and
I
so that the po%der flo%s more easily to the *un.
Because the po%der particles are electrostatically char*ed! the po%der %raps around to the $ac& of the part as it passes $y to%ards the air off ta&e system. The po%der %ill remain attached to the part as lon* as some of the electrostatic char*e remains on the po%der. To o$tain the final solid! tou*h! a$rasion resistant coatin* the po%der coated items are placed in an oven and heated to temperatures that ran*e from 1=4 to 214 de*rees - dependin* on the po%der0. 5nder the influence of heat a thermosettin* po%der *oes throu*h < sta*es to full cure. M:T! ?)#! :! -57:. The final coatin* is continuous and %ill vary from hi*h *loss to flat matt dependin* on the desi*n of the po%der $y the supplier. P"41e! *"ai+g g+s
There are at least three types of electrostatic *uns in useF I
-orona char*in* *uns %here electric po%er is used to *enerate the electrostatic char*e. -orona *uns are either internal or eternal char*in*.
94
I
Tri$o char*in* *uns %here the electrostatic char*e is *enerated $y friction $et%een the po%der and the *un $arrel.
I
Bell char*in* *uns %here the po%der is char*ed $y $ein* flun* from the perimeter of the $ell
Not all po%der is applied usin* *uns. )ne system ma&es use of electrostatic tunnels.
F+*i"+i+g "0 S!0a*e C"ai+g S"3:
i&e functionin* of Press Shop and ?a$3Shop! functionin* of surface coatin* is also initiated $ased on production plans released $y PP- as per %ee&ly plan. This is $ro&en do%n to daily plan for treatment and po%der coatin*0. Shift n3char*e chec&s for the manpo%er! material G machine availa$ility. Time study of po%der coatin* process is done to facilitate eecution of po%der coatin* activity.
T"a) Time
Time i+ mi+es
S!)
Pa! +"
Des*!i3i"+
27
g + i 5 s a M
3 , : * , " T
9
33333
33333
33333
1
33333
<
1 1
33333
9<12<11 441
Tan& Housin* -omplete
1
2
9<12<21 441
Top Plate -omplete
1
6
9<12<2@ 441
-over -omplete
< 9
9<12<64 441 9<2414@ 441
= 8 " @
9<24119 441 9<2411" 441 9<24169 441 9<21=9@ 441
-ap -omplete Top Panel -omplete -assette Bo ?ront -over -olumn -ap #heel uard
g + i 3 3 a T
9 33333
1
1 1 1 1
14
g + i a " C
2 33333 2 33333 33333
g + i + a e ) C
s e , + i m + I
94
84
33333
14
14
1
9
33333
14
6 9
33333
6 8
33333
= 18
9 9 9 <
33333
33333 2 33333 33333
9 " < =
6 33333 6 33333 33333
14 24 @ 14
P!e T!eame+ P!"*ess C"+!")
Before loadin* material in treatment $ath! Pre3treatment parameters li&e Pointa*e / Temperature / pH are chec&ed as per %or& and said data is recorded in -hemical Test 7eport 7e*ister.
91
Pre3treatment is carried out $y loadin* jo$s inside $as&et! loadin* of jo$s is done &eepin* in mind %ater/chemicals should not accumulate on jo$. Than the jo$s are inspected for oil mar&s G rust! if needed jo$s are retreated.
o$s %ith overlappin* surface are heated in oven for temperature $et%een 194 to 244X $efore coatin*. After heatin* the jo$s in oven! they are inspected for -hemical :ntrapment G oil! only -hemical/)il free material is ta&en for coatin*. o$s %ith -hemical :ntrapment G oil are treated a*ain. o$s %ithout any overlappin* surface need not $e heated in oven $efore coatin*! instead they are &ept for air dryin* G are coated &eepin* in one of the criteria of coatin* treated jo$s %ithin 2< hours to avoid any undue effect on coated jo$s. P"41e! C"ai+g P!"*ess C"+!"): Before start of coatin*! Po%der -oatin* uns are
chec&ed for char*ea$ility G flo% of po%der. o$s %hich reDuire earthin* or $earin* surface for rollers are mas&ed %ith ru$$er sleeves or mas&in* tapes. -oated jo$s are inspected for any visual defects G ,?T! and same is recorded in inspection re*ister. ?urther activities li&e touch/re3tappin*/cleanin* are carried out $efore movin* the jo$s to concerned department.
Surface coatin* process is validated $y pre3treatin* and phosphatin* 9 nos of -7-A test specimen of si+e 84.4 1<4.4 1.4 m.m. Test specimen is coated in the po%der coatin* $ooth %ith 2 ; 6 passes to achieve the reDuired 144 Y ,?T. Than the panels are $a&ed at 1"4 ; 1@4 X- for a period of 24 ; 64 minutes. Test Panels are allo%ed to cool to the room temperature and send for third party analysis %herever reDuired. -urrently Astra conducts $elo% mentioned tests.
S!) 1 2 6 < 9
Ca!a*e!s mpact Stren*th -onical Mandrel Bend Salt Spray 7esistance -ross -ut Adhesion
Sa+1a!1 Va)e 144C*;mZ<4/<4[ " m.m. 1/< 1444 Hrs t R 4/144
Re0 Sa+1a!1 ASTM ,28@< /@9 Ball\9/" ASTM , 9223B / ,N 96192 ,N 9619= ASTM B 118 ASTM , 669@ / ,N 96191
Va)i1i7 Pe!i"1 = Months = Months = Months = Months ,aily
The inspection of the products is done as per set procedures for monitorin* G measurement of product. ?inal rejections that occur in the process are entered in inspection re*ister. ?inished Material is moved to either dispatch department or for further assem$ly! as such for Astra ?a$ricated Material includin* in3house G material received from 92
vendors0 material movement note starts %ith ?P-3 follo%ed $y increasin* serial no! and for o$ %or& items i.e customer supplied items0 material movement note starts %ith P-3 follo%ed $y increasin* serial no! for ?urther ProcessEs li&e assem$ly carried out in3house or off3loadin*0 material movement note start %ith P-3 follo%ed $y increasin* serial no.
n3process rejections that occur in the process are entered in inspection re*ister and controlled as per set procedures for controllin* N- Non conformin*0 items. An operator does the inspection for parameters identified in dra%in*s! and in case of non3conformities necessary disposition and corrective actions are initiated. PRODUCTION PLANNING AND CONTROL
A Bird view of Production System Ma!5ei+g De3a!me+
Cs"me!
Ne4 P!"1* De8e)"3me+
Mae!ia)s Ma+ageme+ Di8isi"+
Ve+1"!; S33)ie!s
Ra4 Mae!ia)s S"!es
Fi+a+*e De3a!me+
Hma+ Res"!*e De3a!me+
P!"1*i"+ De3a!me+ -S"3 0)""! Sa)es De3a!me+ 2a)i7 Ass!a+*e De3a!me+
Presently Astra Metal Systems Pvt. td. as&s for production lead time of < to = %ee&s as such starts production of < %ee&s $efore the planned completion date.
The $asic control pro$lem is that the capacity need in different phases of production chan*es a$ruptly as demand fluctuates. The Supervisors try to solve the pro$lem $y maimi+in* capacity in all production phases $y shufflin* the Dueue in order to minimi+e setups. ot si+e is &ept rather lar*e for the same reason. Shufflin* causeEs variation in Dueuin* times to *ro% and therefore throu*hput times *ro%. Prioriti+in* is used amply for late jo$s. The effect is that lots pro*ress throu*h production Duite randomly and lead times are lon*. There is a lar*e amount of %or& in process and the need for capacity fluctuates a lot.
96
deally! the plannin* and control method should level the need for capacity in a %ay that allo%s for Duic& and predicta$le completion of each %or& phase and simultaneously results in adeDuate capacity utili+ation. The company has developed $ufferin*! orderin*! and forecastin* methods to*ether %ith its customers in order to level demand. Ho%ever! the demand for products produced $y Astra is hi*hly varia$le and difficult to forecast and therefore also $ufferin* is ris&y not only $ecause of increase in inventory level $ut more over may result in o$solescence.
The production schedulin* policy used in Astra Metal Systems Pvt. td.! is $ased on a system %here monthly demands are divided into short periods in %hich a predetermined amount of each product is produced. Althou*h this policy is appropriate for the flei$ility of the schedulin*! it may cause production of a$undant num$ers of setup %aste. The reason of this is that as period of schedulin* plan $ecomes smaller! the num$er of machine adjustments $ecomes hi*her! %hich in turn increases the num$er of setup %aste.
Therefore! the schedulin* periods and num$er of setup %aste are inversely proportional. f lon*er schedulin* periods are chosen! then the production of setup %astes %ill $e decreased $ut the flei$ility of the schedulin* %ill $e lost and ne% costs such as inventory holdin* costs %ill appear. )n the other hand! if the schedulin* period is shortened! then the schedulin* %ill $e more flei$le and the num$er of setup %aste %ill increase. ?or this reason! there is a need to find out an optimum schedulin* plan ta&in* into account the %aste production. Production plannin* and control can $e vie%ed vertically in a top3do%n! hierarchical fashion. Ho%ever! reDuires stron* cooperation hori+ontally across the functional disciplines.
Re)ai"+si3
n any manufacturin* enterprise production is the drivin* force to %hich most other functions react. This is particularly true %ith inventories they eist $ecause of the needs of production. The ultimate o$jective of PP-! li&e that of all other manufacturin* controls! is to contri$ute to the profits of the enterprise. As %ith inventory mana*ement and control! this is accomplished $y &eepin* the customers satisfied throu*h the meetin* of delivery schedules. Specific o$jectives of PP- are to esta$lish routes and schedules for %or& that
9<
%ill ensure the optimum utili+ation of materials! %or&ers! and machines and to provide the means for ensurin* the operation of the plant in accordance %ith these plans.
T73es "0 I+8e+"!ies:
i&e any other industry Astra Metal Systems Pvt. td. also has different &ind of inventory throu*hout its manufacturin* process. Astra maintains inventory in terms of stoc& of some &ind of physical commodity li&e ra% materials! component parts! supplies G consuma$le stores! %or&3in3pro*ress G finished *oods. The analysis of the cost structure of many of the product reveals that inventories cost ran*e from 89 to "9 of the product cost. Thus inventories indicate a major of application of financial resources G efficient inventory control can contri$ute su$stantially to the profita$ility of the $usiness. The Principal Types of nventories are F NP5T Production nventory P7)-:SS n3process nventory )5TP5T ?inished nventory
1. Production Inventories:
tems %hich *o into the final products! ra% materials and
$ou*ht out components. Astra $ein* $asically sheet metal fa$rication unit stoc& of -7-A! SS or P sheets is a must to start first operation of cuttin*. )n an avera*e Astra maintains ] 94 tons of ra% material in sheet form at any *iven time. 2.
Maintenance! 7epair and )peratin* nventoriesF tems %hich do not form a part of final
Product $ut are consumed in a prod. Processes spare parts! -onsuma$le items etc. 3. In Process Inventories:
#or&3in3pro*ress items %hich are partly manufactured and
A%ait the net sta*e in process. 4.
?inished oods nventories completed products ready for dispatch.
5. Miscellaneous Inventories:
#hich arise out of the a$ove four types of inventory scrap!
Surplus and o$solete items %hich are not to $e disposed off.
As a step to%ards %orld class manufacturin* unit Astra is $een practisin* 9S for Duite a fe% years.
99
Here’s what 5-S means: Sort
Separate %hat is needed and %hat is not needed! and &eep only those thin*s that are needed in the %or&place. ,iscard unnecessary items. Set-In-Order
Neatly place and identify needed %or& items. ,esi*nate a place for everythin* so that anyone can find it. Al%ays put thin*s $ac& in their desi*nated spots. Shine
-lean up. Al%ays maintain a clean and shiny %or& place. dentify %hy thin*s are *ettin* dirty. Standardize
Become a role model for adherin* to the standards of the first three SEs and encoura*e others to follo% them. Ma&e rules and procedures to promote a *ood %or& environment until the first three SEs $ecome every$odyEs second nature. Sustain
Maintain and practice the first four SEs. Be thorou*h in strai*htenin* up! puttin* thin*s in order and cleanin*. Operate to the standard
ean manufacturin* is certainly an effective strate*y $ut some principles such as one piece flo%! ta&t time! level schedulin* and Can$an all $rea& do%n for intermittent production hi*h mi and lo% volume supplies. The need of a pull system to &eep shop floor under control. n a pull environment! in contrast to push systems! orders are released to factory only %hen the total %or&load does not eceed a predetermined level. Besides the manufacturin* efficiency! the company must ma&e availa$le a suita$le production plannin* and control system in order to meet their customerEs needs. The constant meetin* due dates %ill *ive to the relia$le supplier a very important competitive advanta*e.
Lea+ Ma+0a*!i+g 9=
ean manufacturin* is a multidimensional approach that encompasses a %ide variety of mana*ement practices! includin* T! Duality systems! %or& team! cellular manufacturin*! Can$an! Juality -ircles! etc. in an inte*rated system. The core thrust of M is that these practices can %or& syner*istically to create a streamline! hi*h Duality system and produce at the pace of customer demand %ith no %aste.
ean Manufacturin* $rin* a$out a chan*e in the approach to dynamic environment! populari+in* the idea of incorporatin* flei$ility in manufacturin* system %ithout sacrificin* the efficiency. The strate*ic approach of use $uffers in human and other resources to deal %ith uncertainties is less attractive choice for companies operatin* on M $asis! thus necessitatin* findin* %ays to achieve manufacturin* flei$ility.
Manufacturin* flei$ility means havin* the a$ility to rapidly increase or decrease production level! or to shift production capacity Duic&ly from one product to another. Such flei$ility is achieved throu*h flei$le plants! processes! and %or&ers! as %ell as throu*h strate*ies that use the capacity of other or*ani+ations. The main features of the lean manufacturin* %hich help meet this o$jective include set3up reduction! multi3s&illed %or&ers! preventive maintenance! and cellular layout.
ean manufacturin* represents a more fundamental frame%or& for enhancin* efficiency throu*h elimination of %astes. Seven %astes identified under lean manufacturin* that needs to $e eliminated are Motion! #aitin*! )verproduction! Processin*! ,efects! nventory and Transportation. Production is lean if it is accomplished %ith minimal cost. The less o$vious source of cost is varia$ility. This can ta&e many forms! includin* varia$ility in process time! delivery time! yield rates! demand rates! etc.
S"me E6am3)es "0 ase a As!a
I
#aitin* for parts
I
-ountin* parts
I
Multiple inspections
I
)ver3runs in production
I
Movin* parts over lon* distances
I
Storin* and retrievin* inventory
I
oo&in* for tools 98
I
Machine $rea&do%n
I
7e%or&
Lea+ ma+0a*!i+g im3)eme+ai"+
As an implementation strate*y manufacturin* process redesi*nin* on the $asis of lean manufacturin* principles is started. M System implementation process %as started %herein ?irst step adopted %as chan*es in company culture and *ets people commitment for sustainin* the chan*e to%ard lean. After that! process flo%! %or& method and production times are under the process of revision. The main issue that Astra is facin* is simplifyin* the shop floor! developin* multis&illed %or&ers and set3up reduction. ?illin* lines $ecame more flei$le %hich could %or& %ith a lar*e variety of product in small Duantities. As a step to%ards improvin* throu*hput time thin&in* process is initiated at all levels li&e chan*es are made in the set3up procedure to reduce si*nificantly the set3up time. Trainin* of %or&ers is initiated to handle multiples machines $rin*in* more flei$ility for the shop floor. Thou*ht process of productive maintenance is &ic& started aimin* to *uarantee hi*her process relia$ility. The achievements that are tar*eted to achieve after implementin* lean tools includes plant efficiency improvement! setup time and delivery lead time reduction. ean -oncept implementation in process... a Is Va)e
I
Value is %hat the customer is $uyin*
I
Al%ays thin& first a$out the end3customer ;
#ho is the customer^
9"
; I
#hat are they $uyin*^
,escri$e value usin* the customersO %ords
a Is Va)e S!eam A+a)7sis
I
Plannin* tool to optimi+e results of eliminatin* %aste
To $e*in %ith! $ein* ean manufacturin* needs a cultural chan*e in thou*ht processes! thin&in* approach! etc. :mployees of Astra needed trainin* on said matter as such consultants %ere approached and selected one of the prominent leadin* consultant in sad field. Than the process of trainin*s $e*ins! after $rief trainin*s on manufacturin* #astes G VSM teams %ere formed at all 6 locations %ith *roup of 14312 mem$ers and each team selected an item from final product list as a case study.
This case study is of a product %hich is reDuired $y one of the most valua$le customer of Astra %ho is %ith Astra from incorporation period rather Astra %as started to support said customer. The main o$jective is to analy+e ho% lean manufacturin* can $e effectively implemented on MT) strate*y! includin* the PP- system reDuirements.
e 4i)) 1is*ss *ase s17 "0 VSM 0"! Si+g)e Ta+5 H"si+g..
#e carried out value stream mappin* ri*ht from receipt of purchase order to dispatch of product to customer. Team of 14 mem$ers %as formed %hich included at3least one personnel from PP-! Production! Purchase! :cise! H7! Stores! Maintenance! Juality. Team selected a leader to *uide the team %ith valua$le support of lean consultant. #e selected MM2.9 sin*le tan& Housin* for Value Stream analysis. ?irst noted do%n all the processes that are involved ri*ht from receipt of purchase order from customer to delivery of product. Here process flo% alon* %ith information flo% is mapped on A2 si+e. 5sin* lean manufacturin* flo% sym$ols. -alculated Total Product -ycle timeF ,etail off3line activities that are Non3Value added activities>
Than statement statin* the scope of the project is defined. Than all VA ratio calculations %ere done to find out %hich process to $e prioriti+ed for eliminatin* non3value added
9@
activities! alon* %ith present order to delivery time and its correspondin* VA time is %or&out.
?rom $elo% value stream mappin* it %as identified that %aitin* time amounts to 94<=4 mins eDuals to ] 69 days %here as actual cycle time is 1@9" mins eDuals to ] 1 and half day for a $atch of 14 nos. Similarly results of all the team indentified %aitin* time a most dan*erous manufacturin* %aste. To conclude %ith it %as realised and understood $y all team mem$ers that %aitin* time is the most dan*erous manufacturin* %aste so all team needs to %or& to%ards eliminatin* this %aitin* %aste. As such a first step to%ards elimination of %aste in the form of %aitin*! production lot %ere $ro&en do%n to smaller $atch si+e! *ivin* scope for line $alancin* at every sta*e. Herein concept of releasin* production plans for month is chan*ed to releasin* %ee&ly production plans %ith priority %ise ??).
Va)e S!eam Ma33i+g "0 MM #.= Si+g)e Ta+5 H"si+g -i+ a<)a! 0"!m Batch Si+eF 14 Nos
-ycle Time
No )f Men Transportation
,istance
#aitin* Time
Tool Set 5p
Mins
Nos
in Mts
Mins
Mins
Mins
Supplier To Astra 7a% Material
124
24444
241=4
Punchin*
16
2
1.9
9
144"4
12
,e$urin*
<9
1
2
=
2""4
2
Bendin*
69
1
2
<
1<<4
19
Ta* #eldin*
19
1
2
12
2""4
94
nternal -orner #eldin*
94
1
4
4
4
4
?ull #eldin*
94
1
4
4
4
4
124
1
9
<4
4
<
?rame #eldin*
24
1
9
29
144"4
<2.9
?ame Sanderin* Ta* #eldin* ?rame And Tan& Housin*
94
1
2
<
4
1
19
1
9
<4
<24
99
,rillin*
"4
1
14
24
1<<4
94
Tappin*
144
1
4
4
24
?ull #eld #ith Template
244
1
24
1<<4
94
M/- tem #eld
1<4
1
4
4
=9
Spatter 7emoval
94
1
14
2
124
Sanderin*
69
1
14
2
2<4
9
ea&a*e Test
94
1
9
9
1<<4
144
Bend 7emoval
94
1
14
1
4
Sanderin*
14
=4
nspection 7eport And o$ Num$erin*
94
1
Pretreatment
94
6
Pre3Heatin*
19
4
1<<4
14
94
2""4
4
2
14
<9
144
1
2
14
=4
Po%der -oatin*
94
6
29
9
=4
)ven -urin*
<9
4
2
9
=4
,e3mas&in* And -leanin*
644
1
14
14
=4
ead Pastin*
144
1
6
4
1<<4
Varnishin*
94
1
4
1<<4
7e3Tappin*
94
1
9
2
6=4
nspection
64
1
9
2
=4
1
9
9
144"4
1
9 9 &=?.= $.&
14 1944 &>@= &.#
19
Mas&in*
?inished ood Stora*e ?inished oods oadin* And ,ispatch Astra To -ustomer ,oor T"a) Time -i+ 1a7s
&@=? &.'
('
=$'%$ (=.$
=4
64
144
9
%%%.= $.=
After completion of VSM chart and calculation of VA and NVA time net step %as flo% dia*rams %ere dra%n related to only production process. #hile dra%in* flo% dia*ram of process its related process time and NVA processes are also identified.
n ?lo% dia*rams elements related to %aitin* time %ere eliminated and only value added VA0 and non value added NVA0 activities %ere dra%n %ith respective process time.
=1
?rom a$ove findin* processes li&e Pre3treatment!Pre3heatin* and )ven currin* since more than one jo$ is processed in one cycle0 %hich %ere carried out in $atch %ere eleminated for time $ein*. Than processes %hich %ere in t%o di*its fi*ures i.e 14 mins or more than 14 mins %ere identifed for further study for eleminatin* NVAEs %ithin the processes. )ut of 29 activities " activities %hich reDuired processin* time in dou$le di*it %ere considered for further action.
=2
Srl
Activity
Time
1 ,emas&in* And cleanin*
64
2 ?ull %eldin*
24
6 Varnishin*
1"
< M/c item %eldin*
1<
9 Sanderin*
12
= ead pastin*
14
8 Mas&in*
14
" Tappin* @ ,rillin*
14 "
Ta&in* activity %hich needs hi*hest cycle time for further study to atleast $rin* do%n said cycle time to net hi*ht cycle time i.e nearer to cycle time for full %eldin* 24mins0
:very process has VA and NVA activities identifyin* and cuttin* do%n NVA is the net step for %hich commonly 5sed Tools for Pro$lem Solvin* and -ontinuous mprovement are made into use.
?irst tool used to identify VA and NVA %as ?ish Bone dia*ram or cause3and3effect dia*ram is dra%n identifyin* all possi$le causes to eliminate Non Value Added NVA0 activities %ithin micro level0 process.
=6
Brain stormin* tool is used to identify possi$le causes %hile dra%in* fish $one dia*ram. Herein each team mem$er starts *ivin* root cause %hich are than *rouped accordin*ly under Man! Machine! Method or material discipline of only one at a time0 %ith at3least 6 rounds for each mem$er %here in minimum 6 causes are identified $y each mem$er! same is continued till mem$ers do not have any more points. #hile doin* this activity team does not ar*ue on %hether points that one mem$er has *iven is ri*ht or %ron*.
)nce these possi$le causes are identified than collectively net round of $rain stormin* is done %here in mem$erEs de$ate on each points and accordin*ly decide on valid and non3 valid causes! non3valid causes are stri&eout.
All other causes %hich are a*reed up on net step is to chal& out action plan! herein there may $e more than one action plan for one possi$le cause %hich than are assi*ned usin* 6# G 1H concept #ho! #hen! #hat and Ho%0.
Than team identifies '%ho %ill $e doin* that tas& he/she may $e %ithin the VSM team or outside one team %hich depends on need of activity. Belo% is Action Plan initiated for ,emas&in* G -leanin* %hich need 64 mins. ,emas&in* And -leanin* ta&es 64 mins Hi*h NVA0 Sr l
Man
1 2
-auses
-hitchattin* %hile demas&in* 5ntrained Person
:cess use of mas&in* tape and 6 paper < )perator does demas&in* slo%ly 9 ,istractin* %or&place surroundin* Machine
Material
1
mproper i*htin*
1 2 6 < 9
lue remains after removin* the mas&in* tape Poor Duality of mas&in* tape Mas&in* tape is used Mas&in* tape cuts %hile removin* Smooth cloth is used
-orrective Action :ducate %or&ers %herein they can have their discussions durin* tea! lunch $rea&s.
#ho
#hen
Manju
613 ,ec
-han*e the process of mas&in* itself. 5se sheet metal plates G scre%s ti*htened usin* $attery operated scre% drivers! instead of paper G mas&in* tape! than define ne% revised %or& instructions for carin* out mas&in* G demas&in* 7ohit
243,ec
chan*e of process addressOs this point
7ohit
243,ec
chan*e of process addressEs chan*e of process addressEs
7ohit 7ohit
243,ec 243,ec
=<
Method
1 2 6 < 9 = 8 " @ 14 11
12
Manual removal of mas&in* tape &erosene Applin* More contact area of jo$ surface and mas&in* Paper is used Holdin* of jo$ is reDd %ith one hand %hile demas&in* No time standard mproper tools used for demas&in* Proper seDuence fro removin* the tape is not used ,emas&in* is done after coolin* #ron* shape of paper is used #or& place or*ani+ation lue stic&s to the hand of operator and *ets transferred on the jo$ %hich a*ain needs to $e cleaned
chan*e of process addressEs chan*e of process addressOs this point
7ohit
243,ec
7ohit
243,ec
chan*e of process addressEs
7ohit
243,ec
chan*e of process addressEs chan*e of process addressEs
7ohit 7ohit
243,ec 243,ec
chan*e of process addressOs this point
7ohit
243,ec
Similarly $rain stormin* is follo%ed $y action plan for ?ull %eldin*! Varnishin*! M/c item %eldin*! Sanderin*! ead pastin*! Mas&in* and Tappin*. ,ay to day follo% up is done for the action plans so as to ma&e sure that tar*et dates for implementation are not defaulted.
#hile doin* $rain stormin* and action plans VA and NVAEs are monitored and measured. All data related to fact findin*s are collected filed for future reference alon* %ith any other relevant information! photo*raphs etc. #ith each improvement action plan implementation VA calculations are done to trac& %hether team is movin* in ri*ht direction or not.
7esults of VSM study %as its on*oin* continual improvement process! most of the actions that are su**ested and implemented a*ainst said product are also applica$le *lo$ally for the product ran*e that Astra manufactures for different customers. i&e for e.*. one of the cause for more cycle time for full %eldin* %as unor*anised %or&place as such team %or&ed out on ne% layout %hich is not only applica$le for product %hich %as ta&en for case study! said action %as also applica$le for entire ran*e of product that Astra manufactures in3 house.
Fa*"!s A00e*i+g P!"1*i"+ P)a++i+g a+1 C"+!") F"!e*as gi8e+ <7 *s"me!s: ts value to production plannin* and control is that it %ill
indicate future trends in demand for product that needs to $e supplied. #or& shift policies! plans for an increase or decrease in manufacturin* activity! or possi$le plant epansions
=9
may often $e $ased upon the customer forecasts and in turn affect the plannin* of the production plannin* and control *roup.
Sa)es O!1e!: This is the second of the five classes of orders. t is a re%rite of the customer
order specifyin* %hat they %ant in terms of product and Duantity and authori+in* shipment of the *oods to the customer.
S"*5 O!1e! -B00e! s"*5i+g: This third class of order is not al%ays used. t is
particularly ta&en in conjunction %ith customer.
S"3 O!1e!: This fourth class of order deals %ith the manufacture of component parts.
?orecasts *iven $y customers! sales orders! and stoc& orders $uffer stoc&s0 are for the finished product.
Sa+1a!1 P!"*ess see: This form is prepared $y process en*ineerin* and it is the source
of $asic data as to the type of machine to $e used! the time reDuired for processin* and the seDuence of operations in the manufacture of the product. 7outin* and schedulin* of shop orders! as %ell as loadin* of %or&stations in advance of schedulin*! depend on up3to3date standard process sheets $ein* availa$le to the production plannin* and control *roup.
E+gi+ee!i+g S3e*i0i*ai"+s: Blueprints and $ills of materials are used $y production
plannin* and control %hen they $ecome a component part of the pac&a*ed instructions issued to the shop throu*h the control office. )ne *ood plannin* procedure is to accumulate all necessary data for a shop order in a sin*le pac&a*e the standard process sheet! the $lueprint! the $ill of material if an assem$ly operation is involved0! the route sheet! and possi$ly the schedule for the production of the order.
R"e See: This is the form on %hich the route of a shop order is indicated. n practice!
this form is *enerally com$ined %ith one of the other forms in the system. ?or eample! the shop order! the standard process sheet! and the route sheet are often one piece of paper3 usually called the shop order or he manufacturin* order.
J"< Ti*5es: This is the fifth and last type of order in a manufacturin* situation. o$ tic&ets
authori+e the performance of individual operations in the manufacturin* process. ==
Ce+!a)i9e1 P!"1*i"+ P)a++i+g a+1 C"+!")F -entrali+ation or decentrali+ation of
duties of the production control staff depends upon the desi*n of the production plannin* and control system. n a completely centrali+ed setup! determination of shippin* promises analysis of sales! stoc&! and shop orders preparation of routes! load charts! and schedule charts and dispatchin* of %or& to the shop complete %ith jo$ tic&ets and all other necessary paper %ould $e accomplished $y a central production plannin* and control unit. n addition! as %or& is completed! a careful analysis of the actual performance %ould $e made! and if corrective action %ere reDuired! it %ould $e initiated $y this *roup.
De*e+!a)i9e1 P!"1*i"+ P)a++i+g a+1 C"+!"): No matter ho% *eneral the plannin*
may $e under central PP-! the plan must eventually $e developed into a detailed plan on the shop floor. As such Astra is endeavourin* to ma&e each foreman a mana*er of his o%n departmental operation.
Meas!eme+ "0 E00e*i8e+ess: n determinin* the effectiveness of a production plannin*
and control system! Astra has Duite a fe% pro$lems. The &ey criterion mi*ht %ell $e %hether or not shippin* promises are $ein* &ept ; the percenta*e of the order shipped on time. This! ho%ever! %ould not $e a true criterion if ecessive overtime of epeditin* costs %ere involved in *ettin* any of these orders shipped.
=8
Res)s a+1 a+a)7sis "0 e *ase s1ies: To a certain de*ree! production activities are repetitive and often lar*ely predicta$le. No a**re*ated production plan... No eplicit overall control concept... A$sence of priorities in allocatin* production capacities... insta$ility in the production plannin*... a lar*e no of rush orders... uncertainties in the production... fra*mented allocation of authorities and responsi$ilities %ith respect to production and distri$ution.... Personal conflicts and domain discussions $et%een PP- and other ,epts. Hi*h de*ree of de3concentration %ith respect to plannin* activities.... n practice! ho%ever! 6units solved conflictin* issues $et%een Production and Purchase or PP- $y applyin* a functional hierarchy and not $y some inte*ratin* mechanism $et%een the parties involved. t is noticed that the de*ree of inte*ration $et%een functional areas in Astra is much lo%er than one %ould epect.
t is interestin* to note that there is necessity for improvin* the overall performance in terms of decreasin* costs! shortenin* delivery times! improvin* delivery relia$ility! Duality and customer service. ?rom this! chan*in* the plannin* and control as %ell as the or*anisational desi*n of the production system should $e re*arded as a potential opportunity to contri$ute to this improvement.
7esults of VSM study %as its on*oin* continual improvement process! most of the actions that are su**ested and implemented a*ainst said product are also applica$le *lo$ally for the ="
product ran*e that Astra manufactures for different customers. i&e for e.*. one of the cause for more cycle time for full %eldin* %as unor*anised %or&place as such team %or&ed out on ne% layout %hich is not only applica$le for product %hich %as ta&en for case study! said action %as also applica$le for entire ran*e of product that Astra manufactures in3 house.
Fi+1i+gs, I+0e!e+*es a+1 Re*"mme+1ai"+s: Some of the chan*es need to $e initiated for $etter co3ordination! communication! inte*ration! follo%3up action. Meetin* %ith respect to certain predefined points needs to $e eecuted at the start and end of shift on daily $asis %ith shift operators and shift in3char*e! than on daily $asis %ith departmental heads to analyse and resolve day to day issues! and finally %ith functional heads on future *oal/ o$jectives on %ee&ly $asis.
1. Shift Be*innin* G Shift :nd / -han*e Meetin* a. Participants F i. Shift )perators G Shift n char*e $. Time G ,uration F i. 9314mins c. A*enda F i. Production in last Shift ii. ap in actual Production G plan iii. Pro$lems encountered in the previous shift iv. Production Plan for the net shift v. Availa$le Manpo%er vi. -han*e )ver reDuirements vii. Preventive Maintenance Plans viii. House Ceepin* i. Any )ther Planned Stoppa*e =@
2. ,aily #or& Mana*ement Meetin* $y ,epartment head a. Participants F i. Shift n char*e ii. PPiii. Maintenance iv. ,ispatch v. Purchase/Stores vi. Juality $. Time G ,uration F i. 24364mins c. A*enda F i. Productivity evel G rejection status of day $efore ii. ,ayEs Plan considerin*! *aps in plan v/s actual of day $efore iii. ?reDuency G duration of m/c maintenance G their countermeasures iv. ,ispatch plan v. Juality pro$lems/ customer complaints G their counter measures vi. ap Analysis for Production /maintenance/ dispatch /chan*e over time
6. #ee&ly meetin* of ,epartmental Heads a. Participants F i. Shift n char*e ii. PPiii. Maintenance iv. Purchase/Stores v. Juality $. Time G ,uration F i. =4389mins c. A*enda F i. Productivity in terms of stro&es/minute! stro&es/person! spots per person G efficiency ii. Juality coverin* in process rejection in PPM of the Press shop! ?a$rication shop G Po%der coatin*. Qero ,efects. iii. -ustomer -omplaints 84
iv. ,elivery Performance %.r.t -ustomer schedule v. ,o%ntime due to m/c Brea&do%n vi. A$senteeism vii. )vertime #or&in* viii. Vendor Performance %.r.t Juality G delivery i. -apacity 5tili+ation . #or&place mprovements! 9S Audit results i. Safety3Accidents ii. :mployee developments! :mployee rievances! Trainin* imparted G employee Participation in su**estions iii. mprovements in the Duality system iv. nventories v. -ustomer satisfaction internal/:ternal vi. -ontinual mprovements
n order to reach the *oals set! production should $e made more predicta$le. The proposed remedies areF After the initial Dueue arran*ement in the $e*innin* of production! the Dueue order should only $e reor*ani+ed in one %ell thou*ht control point. n other places prioriti+in* or shufflin* orders should $e avoided.
Stoc& should $e used in order to level capacity need and provide fast service. nstead of the current practice of havin* lots of %or& in process every%here in production! stoc& should $e &ept as final stoc& or as $uffer stoc&. Smaller $atches should $e used in order to level capacity need. Small $atches also allo% concurrent processin* and therefore shorten throu*hput time.
The simulation model should $e used for ans%erin* Duestions li&eF #hich one of the alternative points should $e chosen as the Dueue reor*ani+in* point^ Ho% %ell do the alternative schedulin* and Dueuin* lo*ics %or& in this case^ #hat is the effect of the proposed stoc& policies on production^ #hat is the effect of smaller $atch si+es and ho% small can the $atches $e^
81
C"+*)si"+s: The efficiency of Production Plannin* and -ontrol department depends upon the information it *ets from other departments and the accuracy of such information. To prepare load and schedule chat! it must &no% the preventive maintenance schedule. To *ive realistic delivery date! it must &no% the %or& content of each jo$. PP- %hich are *enerally reDuires the $elo% information. Astra need to have formal departments li&e sales/mar&etin* and su$ department of PP-. 1. Production 1. Juantity to $e manufactured. pro*ramme. 2. ,elivery date. I+0"!mai"+ Deai)s C"+*e!+i+g
Sales order or )rder Acceptance S"!*e
Sales De3a!me+ "!igi+ai+g i+1i*ae1 I+0"!mai"+
Cind and Duality of material.,ra%in*s/Bill of Material Juantity of material Stoc& -ards reDuired 6. Stoc& on hand and reservations Tool -ard <. ead time reDuired for procurement. 1. Standard and special toolin*
2. Production 1. materials 2.
,ra%in* -ontrol ,es& Stores Purchase
6. Toolin*
PP- / Prod
<. Juality Standards
9. )peration Methods.
1. 2. 6. <. 1.
=. Path of Materials.
,imensional reDuirements. ,ra%in*s -ustomerEs feed$ac& ?inish reDuirements Tolerance reDuirements Hardness desired. Process sheets -apacity charts )perations and their
seDuence. 2. Machine tool for each indicated operation 6. i*s and fitures needed <. Speeds G ?eeds.
1 ist of )perations and their 8. )peration time. SeDuence 2. Alternatives possi$le
,ra%in* -ontrol des& Mar&etin* ,ept
PPPP-
:perience
7oute sheets Plan layout
PP-
#or& Measurement data
,evelopment dept.
". Schedulin* 1. Setup time and standard time for Machine oad G ScheduledP.P.charts each operation ,aily production reports @. Pro*ress of Production /Time tic&et/Perforated slips #or&. 82 1. Startin* and finishin* dates. 1. #or& -ompleted as on date.
Astra need to have $etter control over plannin* %hich is done manually. Because of comple nature of process transactions AstraEs needs to have inte*rated :7P system to avoid conflicts and hierarchical interferences. Astra *oin* ahead %ith implementation of :7P module for plannin*! follo%in* performance criteria $y %hich production plannin* and control systems mi*ht $e jud*ed! since all plannin* activity is done usin* %ith data throu*h ecel Astra currently measures only $road $ase delivery commitments for the month. 1. nventory turnover 2. ,elivery lead time 6. Percent of time meetin* delivery promises <. Percent of orders reDuirin* 'splits( $ecause of unavaila$le material. 9. Num$er of epeditors =. Avera*e unit cost.
86
Smma!7: The rapid *ro%th in the num$er of options provided $y manufacturers/suppliers to their customers has forced Astra to $e flei$le enou*h under hi*h varia$le demand. n addition! the orders should $e shipped %ith hi*her Duality and shorter due3date times.
Astra $ein* $asically jo$ shopper and has lar*e variety of products under um$rella for different customers! %hich are $ased on customer specifications. There is hi*h variation in demand and %ith lo% volume orderEs! as such Astra needs to operate accordin* to the Ma&e3to3)rder MT)0 strate*y. Astra have to cope %ith unsta$le production schedules and materials mana*ement due to freDuent chan*es in planned production orders! and a lot of production process inefficiencies as %ell.
As a conseDuence! the Production Plannin* and -ontrol PP-0 $ecomes rather comple and often $ased on inaccurate data the $i* challen*e for Astra to operate on MT) strate*y is to meet customer demand on time. To achieve this o$jective! companies have adopted continuous improvement pro*rams to enhance their manufacturin* process. Ne% manufacturin* principles such lean manufacturin* M0 %hich is under %ay of implementation same have helped Astra to *reat etend to reali+e %astes in manufacturin* and or*anisation is confident to manufacture on MT) $asis $ecause of the reduced lead time that is achieved even %hen lean implementation is not even half %ay throu*h.
Re0e!e+*es: )hno! Taiichi. Toyota Prodcution systeF $eyond lar*e3scale production. Bertrand! .#.M.! .-. #ortmann and . #ijn*aard! 1@@40 Production -ontrol. A Structural and ,esi*n )riented Approach. :ilon! Samuel. :lements of Production Plannin* and -ontrol! Bom$ay 7o$otics and computer inte*rated manufacturin*
8<