Search
Home
Saved
0
122 views
Upload
Sign In
RELATED TITLES
0
RULE 111 - De Lima v. Reyes Uploaded by beaenriquez
Bestsellers
Books
Audiobooks Magazines
News
Documents
Crimpro
Save
Embed
Share
Print
Download
Join
CASE DIGEST Michael C. Guy
1
of 3
2. Office of the Ombudsman vs
Quisay v People
Search document
DE LIMA v. REYES
Sheet Music
G.R. No. 209330; 11 January 2016 Leonen, J. FACTS:
Dr. Gerardo Ortega (Dr. Ortega) or "Doc Gerry," a! a eter#nar#an and anc$or o% !e rad#o !$o! #n 'a&aan. e a! !$ot dead around 1030a* #n!#de t$e +agu#o aga -ay/uay #n an 'edro, 'uerto 'r#nce!a #ty, 'a&aan. %ter a r#e% c$a!e #t$ 4o o%%#ce o%%#cer!, r!, 5ar&o 5ar&on n Reca* Reca*ata ata a! a! arre!t arre!ted. ed. On t$e !a*e !a*e day, day, $e *ade *ade an etra7 etra7 con%e!!#on ad*#tt#ng t$at $e !$ot Dr. Ortega. e a&!o #*4&#cated Rodo&%o "+u*ar" 8 (8drad), (8drad), Denn#! Denn#! rana!, rana!, and r*ando r*ando "a&ao "a&aota$" ta$" R. Noe&, Noe&, Jr. u!euent& u!euent&y, y, 8 eecuted a #nu*4aang a&ay!ay e%ore t$e ounter/:error#!* D##!#on o% t$e N+ $ $e a&&eged t$at #t a! %or*er 'a&aan Goernor 5ar#o Joe& Reye! (%or*er Goernor Re $o ordered t$e #&&#ng o% Dr. Ortega. nd t$e %o&&o#ng day, DOJ ec. Le#&a De L#*a #!! De4art*ent Order No. 091 creat#ng a !4ec#a& 4ane& o% 4ro!ecutor! (<#r!t 'ane&) to con 4re&#*#nary #ne!t#gat#on. #ne!t#gat#on.
Dr. 'atr#a G&or#a nocenc#o/Ortega (Dr. nocenc#o/Ortega), Dr. Ortega=! #%e, !u!eue %#&ed %#&ed a u44&e u44&e*en *enta& ta& %%#d %%#da# a#t/ t/o*4 o*4&a# &a#nt nt #*4&# #*4&#cat cat#ng #ng %or*er %or*er Goern Goernor or Reye! Reye! a! *a!ter*#nd o% $er $u!and=! *urder. a&ent#n Le!#a!, rturo D. Rega& r*ando Noe&, Noe&, Rodo&%o 8drad, 8drad, and !eera& Jo$n Jo$n and Jane Doe! Doe! ere a&!o #*4&#cated. #*4&#cated.
-4on conc&u!#on o% t$e <#r!t 'ane& 4re&#*#nary #ne!t#gat#on, t$e Re!o&ut#on a! #!! d#!*#!!#ng t$e %%#da#t/o*4&a#n. nocenc#o/Ortega %#&ed a 5ot#on to Re/O4en 're&#*# ne!t#gat#on, $#c$, a*ong ot$er!, !oug$t t$e ad*#!!#on o% *o#&e 4$one co**un#cat eteen %or*er Goernor Reye! and 8drad. $#&e t$e 5ot#on to Re/O4en a! !t#&& 4end Dr. Dr. nocen nocenc#o c#o/Or /Orteg tega a %#&ed %#&ed a 5ot#o 5ot#on n %or 'art#a 'art#a&& Recon Recon!#d !#dera erat#o t#on n d aute aute&a* &a* Re!o&ut#on. Re!o&ut#on. +ot$ 5ot#on! ere den#ed y t$e <#r!t 'ane& #n t$e Re!o&ut#on.
De L#*a #!!ued DO No. ?10 creat#ng a ne 4ane& o% #ne!t#gator! (econd 'ane&) 'ane&) to con a re#ne!t#gat#on o% t$e ca!e, "#n t$e #ntere!t o% !er#ce and due 4roce!!" a! e&& a addre!! t$e o%%er o% add#t#ona& e#dence den#ed y t$e
Home
Saved
Bestsellers
Books
Audiobooks
Magazines
News
Documents
Sheet Music
Upload
Sign In
Join
Search
Home
Saved
122 views
0
Upload
Sign In
RELATED TITLES
0
RULE 111 - De Lima v. Reyes Uploaded by beaenriquez
Bestsellers
Books
Audiobooks Magazines
News
Documents
Sheet Music
Crimpro
Save
Embed
Share
Print
CASE DIGEST Michael C. Guy
1
Download
Join
of 3
2. Office of the Ombudsman vs
Quisay v People
Search document
ca!e to 4reent a *#!carr#age o% 7u!t#ce. <#r!t 'ane& "a44eared to $ae #gnored t$e ru&e 4re&#*#nary #ne!t#gat#on" $en #t re%u!ed to rece#e add#t#ona& e#dence t$at ou&d $ een cruc#a& %or t$e deter*#nat#on o% t$e e#!tence o% 4roa&e cau!e. :$ey a!!ert re!4ondent a! not de4r#ed o% due 4roce!! $en t$e re#ne!t#gat#on a! ordered !#nc a! not 4reented %ro* 4re!ent#ng controert#ng e#dence to Dr. nocenc#o/Or add#t#ona& e#dence. 'et#t#oner!, a! e&&, contend t$at !#nce t$e n%or*at#on $ad een % t$e d#!4o!#t#on o% t$e ca!e a! a&ready #t$#n t$e d#!cret#on o% t$e tr#a& court.
On t$e ot$er $and, Reye! argue! t$at De L#*a $ad no aut$or#ty to order *otu 4ro4r#o re#ne!t#gat#on o% t$e ca!e !#nce Dr. nocenc#o/Ortega a! a&e to !u*#t $er a&&eged e#dence to t$e <#r!t 'ane& $en !$e %#&ed $er 5ot#on %or 'art#a& Recon!#derat#on. e arg t$at a&& 4art#e! $ad a&ready een g#en t$e o44ortun#ty to 4re!ent t$e#r e#dence e%ore <#r!t 'ane& !o #t a! not nece!!ary to conduct a re#ne!t#gat#on.
You're Reading a Preview ISSUES:
Unlock full access with a free trial.
(1) ! t$e #!!uance o% DO No. ?10 an eecut#e %unct#on eyond t$e !co4 4et#t#on %or cert#orar# or 4ro$##t#onA Download With Free Trial (2) ! t$e ecretary o% Ju!t#ce aut$or#Bed to create *otu 4ro4r#o anot$er 4 4ro!ecutor! #n order to conduct a re#ne!t#gat#on o% t$e ca!eA (3) ! t$e 'et#t#on %or ert#orar# a&ready een rendered *oot y t$e %#&#ng o #n%or*at#on #n courtA HELD:
(1) :$e deter*#nat#on y t$e De4art*ent o% Ju!t#ce o% t$e e#!tence o% 4ro cau!e #! not a ua!#/7ud#c#a& 4roceed#ng. oeer, t$e act#on! o% t$e ecretar Sign up to vote on this title Ju!t#ce #n a%%#r*#ng or reer!#ng t$e %#nd#ng! o% 4ro!ecutor! *ay !t#&& e !u7e Useful Not useful 7ud#c#a& re#e #% #t #! ta#nted #t$ grae au!e o% d#!cret#on. n a 4re&#*# #ne!t#gat#on, t$e 4ro!ecutor doe! not deter*#ne t$e gu#&t or #nnocence
Home
Saved
Bestsellers
Books
Audiobooks
Magazines
News
Documents
Sheet Music
Upload
Sign In
Join
Search
Home
Saved
122 views
0
Sign In
Upload
RELATED TITLES
0
RULE 111 - De Lima v. Reyes Uploaded by beaenriquez
Bestsellers
Books
Audiobooks Magazines
News
Documents
Sheet Music
Crimpro
Save
Embed
Share
Print
Download
Join
CASE DIGEST Michael C. Guy
1
of 3
2. Office of the Ombudsman vs
Quisay v People
Search document
t$e 4ro#nc#a& 4ro!ecutor or t$e c#ty 4ro!ecutor." ccord#ng&y, t$e ecretary o% *ay !te4 #n and order a re#ne!t#gat#on een #t$out a 4r#or *ot#on or 4et#t#on %ro 4arty #n order to 4reent any 4roa&e *#!carr#age o% 7u!t#ce. t #! c&ear t$at ecretary o% Ju!t#ce #!!ued DO No. ?10 ecau!e !$e $ad rea!on to e&#ee t$at <#r!t 'ane&=! re%u!a& to ad*#t t$e add#t#ona& e#dence *ay cau!e a 4r *#!carr#age o% 7u!t#ce to t$e 4art#e!. :$e econd 'ane& a! created not to oer t$e %#nd#ng! and reco**endat#on! o% t$e <#r!t 'ane& ut to *ae !ure t$at a& e#dence, #nc&ud#ng t$e e#dence t$at t$e <#r!t 'ane& re%u!ed to ad*# #ne!t#gated. :$ere%ore, t$e ecretary o% Ju!t#ce d#d not act #n an "ar#trary de!4ot#c *anner,=y rea!on o% 4a!!#on or 4er!ona& $o!t#&#ty. (3) e!. :$e %#&#ng o% t$e #n%or*at#on and t$e #!!uance y t$e tr#a& court o re!4ondent=! arrant o% arre!t $a! a&ready rendered t$#! 'et#t#on *oot. #n%or*at#on #! %#&ed #n court, t$e court acu#re! 7ur#!d#ct#on o% t$e ca!e and any to d#!*#!! t$e ca!e or to deter*#ne t$e accu!ed=! gu#&t or #nnocence re!t! #t$#n !ound d#!cret#on o% t$e court. tr#a& court $a! a&ready deter*#ned, #nde4endent&y o% %#nd#ng or reco**endat#on y t$e <#r!t 'ane& or t$e econd 'ane&, t$at 4ro cau!e e#!t! %or t$e #!!uance o% t$e arrant o% arre!t aga#n!t re!4ondent. 'ro cau!e $a! een 7ud#c#a&&y deter*#ned. Jur#!d#ct#on oer t$e ca!e, t$ere%ore, tran!%erred to t$e tr#a& court. 4et#t#on %or cert#orar# ue!t#on#ng t$e a&#d#ty o% 4re&#*#nary #ne!t#gat#on #n any ot$er enue $a! een rendered *oot y t$e #!!ua o% t$e arrant o% arre!t and t$e conduct o% arra#gn*ent. !$ou&d $ae d#!*#! t$e 'et#t#on %or ert#orar# %#&ed e%ore t$e* $en t$e tr#a& court #!!ued #t! arran Readingacu#red a Preview7ur#!d#ct#on oer t$e ca!e and arre!t. #nce t$e tr#a& courtYou're $a! a&ready e#!tence o% 4roa&e cau!e $a! 7ud#c#a&&y deter*#ned, a 4et#t#on %or cert# Unlock fulleen access with a free trial. ue!t#on#ng t$e conduct o% t$e 4re&#*#nary #ne!t#gat#on cea!e! to e t$e "4 !4eedy, and adeuate re*edy" 4ro#ded &a. na!*uc$ a! t$#! 'et#t#on %or Re Download Withy Free Trial #! an a44ea& %ro* a *oot 'et#t#on %or ert#orar#, #t *u!t a&!o e rendered *
Sign up to vote on this title
Useful
Not useful
Home
Saved
Bestsellers
Books
Audiobooks
Magazines
News
Documents
Sheet Music
Upload
Sign In
Join
