SALVADOR FLORDELIZ Y ABENOJAR, PETITIONER, VS. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, RESPONDENT. [G.R. No. 186441 : Ma!" #$, %#1#&
The ones with the “%” signs are the ones that got changed they’re just minimal. **Scene one: (changed a bit) *slide one* just text “Case Digest” *Slide two* just text “Salvador Flordeliz y Abenojar, petitioner” %*slide tree* “versus” *slide !our* just text “"eople o! te "ilippines, respondent”
Scene two: *slide one* #$"&'A(' in pretty big text and in bold) “FAC'S F '+ CAS+” *slide two* “$ar -../” 0just to sow te date1 *Slide tree* sow $oter2 0A3C1, Dialogue) “4oodbye, be good girls and wait !or 5e to o5eba62 Call 5e wenever you need to2 # love you2” *slide !our* sow two girls 7AAA8 7AA A8 and 73338, Dialogue) “4oodbye 5o59” *slide :ve* sowing a 7plane8 0i! possible1 going toward te geograpial 5ap o! $alaysia
Scene three: *slide one* “April -../” *slide two* Sow “;uezon ill”2 Caption) “Flordeliz8s &esidene” *slide tree* Sow !ater on top o! daugter in a bed 0AAA1 0as long as it loo6s li6e it1 6ait yung bed lang no need !or bg2 Dialogue) “Fater, please don8t insert your :ngers in 5y vagina, #85 only -- years old” “it urts2” *slide !our* Sow Sow !ater, Dialogue) Dialogue) “#! you dare tell anyone anyone about tis, # will ar5 ar5 you” *slide :ve*
Scene our: (changed a bit) *slide one*
*slide two*Sow **i! possible a si5ple building wit “$untinlupa
a 'rinidad, 3enguet” *slide !our* sow two girls 0AAA ? 3331 at te le!t side o! te slide2 Sow !ater at te rigt side2 'ext) “AAA and 333 visited teir !ater oasionally wit ards ontaining te words=” *slide :ve* @one by one “appy valentines”, “ur te best dad in te world”, “# love you "apa, love 333, love 3<” “til we 5eet again”
Scene !"e: (changed a bit) *slide one*
Scene si#: *slide one*
Scene se"en: *slide one* sow 5oter 0A3C12 'ext) A3C sougt out elp !ro5 te (ational 3ureau o! #nvestigations and a!ter onduting 5edial exa5inations on AAA and 333, te attending pysiian re5ar6ed tat tere was a “dislosure o! sexual abuse and se
noted te presene o! y5enal not in posterior portion o! y5enal ri5 5ay be due to previous blunt !ore or penetrating trau5a suggestive o! abuse” *slide two* “te :ndings tere!ore sow tat te petitioner was to be arged o! te ri5es o! Ats o! >asiiousness, o55ited against AAA, and nine ounts o! ;uali:ed &ape troug Sexual Assault, o55ited against 333, be!ore te &'C2 'e ri5e o! ats o! lasiviousness was allegedly *slide tree* just text2 “&'C rendered judg5ent against te aused2” *slide !our*just text) “ CA aLr5ed2” *slide :ve* just text) “'e aused ontends tat te proseution did not obtain a strong evidene against i5 to get a onvition o! guilt beyond reasonable doubt2”
*slide six* “e !urter ontends tat te testi5onies o! AAA and 333 are not redible2 e interposed te de!ense o! denial and insisted tat te arges against i5 were !abriated by is wi!e to over up te in:delity se o55itted wile wor6ing abroad” *slide seven*just text) “ "etitioner also relied on te testi5onies o! Florabel Flordeliz, >evy ope Flordeliz and &oderi6 Flordeliz, wose testi5onies onsisted 5ainly o! te alleged in:delity o! A3CJ and petitioner, being a good !ater, was o!ten visited by is daugters at is residene, were te roo5s tey oupied were only separated by seeMtroug urtains2”
Scene eight: *slide one* #$"&'A(' in pretty big text) “#SSN+S F '+ CAS+” Slide two* just text) “Keter or not te arges !or Ats o! >asiviousness and ;uali:ed &ape troug Sexual Assault o55itted by te aused were properly establised on te aount o! te testi5onies o! te oOended parties2”
Scene nine: $&' T legal discussion and bases: +rt. ,,-. /oral damages include 0hysical su1ering2 mental anguish2 right2 serious an#iety2 besmirched re0utation2 wounded eelings2 moral shoc32 social humiliation2 and similar injury. Though inca0able o 0ecuniary com0utation2 moral damages may be reco"ered i they are the 0ro#imate result o the deendant4s wrongul act or omission. Art2 BB-.2 $oral da5ages 5ay be reovered in te !ollowing and analogous ases 0-1 A ri5inal oOense resulting in pysial injuriesJ
0B1 ;uasiMdelits ausing pysial injuriesJ 0E1 Sedution, abdution, rape, or oter lasivious atsJ 0G1 Adultery or onubinageJ 0/1 #llegal or arbitrary detention or arrestJ 0I1 #llegal searJ 0P1 >ibel, slander or any oter !or5 o! de!a5ationJ 0H1 $aliious proseutionJ 0.1 Ats 5entioned in Artile E.J 0-1 Ats and ations re!erred to in Artiles B-, BI, BP, BH, B., E, EB, EG, and E/2 'e parents o! te !e5ale sedued, abduted, raped, or abused, re!erred to in (o2 E o! tis artile, 5ay also reover 5oral da5ages2 'e spouse, desendants, asendants, and broters and sisters 5ay bring te ation 5entioned in (o2 . o! tis artile, in te order na5ed2 Art2 BBB2 Kill!ul injury to property 5ay be a legal ground !or awarding 5oral da5ages i! te ourt sould :nd tat, under te iru5stanes, su da5ages are justly due2 'e sa5e rule applies to breaes o! ontrat were te de!endant ated !raudulently or in bad !ait2 2 #n riminal ase 5o. ,6-789 !or Ats o! >asiviousness, te #ndeter5inate "enalty o! I 5onts o! Arresto $ayor as te 5ini5u5 penalty to I years o! "rision Correional as te 5axi5u5 penalty and to inde5ni!y te viti5 AAA te a5ount o! "B,2 as 5oral da5ages and to pay te osts2 'e penalty sall also arry te aessory penalty o! perpetual speial disuali:ation !ro5 te rigt o! suOrage 0Art2 GE, &evised "enal Code1Q2R Artile --I-2 Civil obligations arising !ro5 ri5inal oOenses sall be governed by te penal laws, subjet to te provisions o! artile B-PP, and o! te pertinent provisions o! Capter B, "reli5inary 'itle, on u5an &elations, and o! 'itle T### o! tis 3oo6, regulating da5ages2 0-.Ba1 #n riminal ases 5os. ,6,9 to ,6;9 , te #ndeter5inate "enalty o! twelve 0-B1 years o! "rision $ayor as te 5ini5u5 penalty to twenty 0B1 years o! &elusion 'e5poral as te 5axi5u5 penalty !or ea ase or nine 0.1 ounts o! sexual assault onsidering te aggravatingUuali!ying iru5stane o! relationsip against te aused and to inde5ni!y 333 te a5ount o! "P/,2 as 5oral da5ages and to pay te osts2 'e penalties sall arry wit te5 te aessory penalties o! ivil interdition !or li!e and perpetual absolute disuali:ation 0Art2 G-, &evised "enal Code12
+<<'$$+T' T ='>S>5: 'e CA aLr5ed Flordeliz onvition wit a 5odi:ation o! te a5ount o! is ivil liabilitees &A'# D+C#D+(D#
Keter te a5ount o! ivil liabilities o! Flordeliz is orret2
S<'/' T =>SSS5 +5= $'?+$ @+S'S: (o, te CA is not orret2 For te ri5e o! Ats o! >asiviousness, te guilt o! Flordeliz as not been proven beyond reasonable doubt wit 5oral ertainty2 For te ri5e o! &ape, te guilt o! Flordeliz as also not been proven beyond reasonable doubt wit 5ore ertainty and o5plete absene o! evidene2 te viti5 o! &ape troug sexual assault is entitled to reover ivil inde5nity in te a5ount o! "E,2 !or ea ount2 'is is 5andatory upon a :nding o! te !at o! &ape2QGR $oreover, te award o! 5oral da5ages is auto5atially granted witout need o! !urter proo!, it being assu5ed tat a rape viti5 as atually suOered 5oral da5ages entitling er to su award2 Se is, tus, entitled to reover 5oral da5ages o! "E,2 !or ea ount2 QG-R #n addition, te presene o! te aggravating iru5stanes o! 5inority and relationsip entitles er to an award o! exe5plary da5ages2 'e a5ount o! "E,2 !or ea ount is appropriate under te iru5stanes2
Kit respet to te lasivious ondut a5ounting to ild abuse under Setion /0b1 o! &2A2 (o2 PI- o55itted by petitioner, we i5pose a :ne o! "-/,22 Q/ER
i"il indemnity ex delicto in the amount o <,2. shall be awarded. A87B +dditionally2 u0on a !nding o guilt o the accused or acts o lasci"iousness2 the amount o <-82. as moral damages may be awarded to the "ictim in the same way that moral damages are awarded to "ictims o ra0e e"en without need o 0roo because it is assumed that they su1ered moral injury. A88B >n "iew o the 0resence o the aggra"ating circumstance o relationshi02 the amount o <-82. as e#em0lary damages should li3ewise be awarded.