Resenha: A Conveniência da Cultura (usos da cultura na era global).

 _×MOJN% @nlv`n+ C Jlkynkoçkjoc mc J~e}~vc7 ~zlz mc j~e}~vc kc nvc nvc `elfce+ Fnel Dlvowlk}n7 Nmo}lvc ^IB@% 6889+ Kl }nt}l l c~}lv zn vninvn cl xvnjlkjno}l% cl vcjozbl% cl bnml s~n cz jeczznz z~xnvolvnz }nb jlb vnecàêl c jeczzn z~fce}nvkc% s~n l i~ka kêl }okdc vnecàêl jlb c xleâ}ojc% nen kêl cflvmc l zljoce% ï cxleâ}ojl+ L i~ka kêl zn mnz}okcyc c b~mckàc mn yozêl mlz s~n nz}êl cl zn~ vnmlv n zob c znkzcàêl mn eofnvmcmn s~n lz i~kanovlz xlzz~nb s~ckml nz}êl jck}ckml n mckàckml klz fcoenz+ L }nt}l ï b~o}l fnb necflvcml% xlzz~o ~bc ok}vlm~àêl mn iãjoe eno}~vc n okilvbc zlfvn c nyle~àêl ml }nt}l% kl mnznkvlecv ntxþn }vnjdlz mn b÷zojcz% cv}o`lz mn glvkcoz% nk}vnyoz}cz mn xnvzlkceomcmnz ml i~ka% lxokoþnz mn ok}nenj}~coz zlfvn l blyobnk}l% jlbxcvcàþnz nk}vn blbnk}lz doz}úvojlz n cxvnznk}c ~bc flc jvlklel`oc mc doz}úvoc ml blyobnk}l+ Nb z~c jlkje~zêl ntxvobn jecvcbnk}n lz znk}obnk}lz mlz i~kanovlz s~ck}l c vnceomcmn n c jlkzns~çkjoc $ okxnkzcmcz n mnzok}nkjolkmcz / mn zn~z c}lz n vnxvnznk}càþnz cv}âz}ojcz+ L }nt}l ï necflvcml xlv }úxojlz+

C I~kaoiojcàêl ml Vol L c~}lv nb z~c ok}vlm~àêl ntxeojc jlbl ilo }vcfcedcml l jcxâ}~el% jcx â}~el% okilvbckml s~n znvyn mn xvne÷mol xcvc c lfvc ml blyobnk}l zljoce + Civl"Vn``c nb nzxnjoce n mn}cedckml l z~v`obnk}l mn yãvolz l~}vlz blyobnk}lz zljocoz xcvc jlbfc}nv lz bcenz mc zljonmcmn kl Fvczoe

C J~e}~vc Glynb n c Mnjcmçkjoc mc Omnk}omcmn Kcjolkce Fvczoenovc Cl mnznkyleynv zn~ xnkzcbnk}l% }nk}c mnblkz}vcv c moinvnkàc nk}vn 6 nz}oelz b~zojcoz s~n c}ok`nb c bnzbc jeczzn zljoce% xlvïb s~n xlzz~nb x÷feojl n ok}nkàþnz moinvnkjocmcz+ Ï c &j~e}~vc ml jlkznkzl& movn}cbnk}n vnecjolkcmc cl zcbfc% jlb jlvmoceomcmn mlz xlylz% vcàcz n jeczznz zljocoz mn ~bc ilvbc oe~zúvoc% mnblkz}vckml ~bc icezc obc`nb mn s~n l Fvczoe ï zcbfc% i~}nfle n cen`voc+ Mozzn _÷mojn7 &L s~n vncebnk}n cjlk}njn ï s~n% mnzmn c mïjcmc mn 3?:8% cz mo}cz xvã}ojcz yçb znkml blfoeowcmcz xnec bâmoc% xnelz kn`újolz $ nb nzxnjoce% l }~vozbl /% xnec xleâ}ojc $ okje~zoyn c bckox~ecàêl ml jcvkcyce/% n l~}vlz ic}lvnz mn bnmocàêl xcvc c vnxvlm~àêl zobfúeojc mn ~b Fvczoe &jlvmoce&% s~n vnz~e}c kl cfljckdcbnk}l mn fnkniâjolz bc}nvocoz xlv xcv}n mc neo}n&+

Cz Jlk}vcmoàþnz mc Mnbljvcjoc è Fvczoenovc Ntnbxeoiojc c okjlkz}ækjoc ml xnkzcbnk}l ml xlyl vnecjolkckml movn}cbnk}n c : nynk}lz s~n ljlvvnvcb nb ~b j~v}l nzxcàl mn }nbxl+ Jlbnàckml xnel obxncjdbnk} mn Jleelv% lkmn ljlvvn~ ~bc mcz bcolvnz bckoinz}càþnz ml xlyl fvczoenovl% mnblkz}vckml z~c okzc}ozicàêl jlb l `lynvkl% `nvcyc ~bc znkzcàêl mn jcvkcyce% lkmn l Fvczoe xcvnjoc znv  klycbnk}n ~bc kcàêl ~komc+ L zn`~kml nynk}l ilo c okyczêl mc xvozêl ml Jcvckmov~ nb Zêl Xc~el n l bczzcjvn mn xvozolknovlz% lkmn c xlx~ecàêl cxlol~ n mninkmn~ c c}o}~mn mcz ilvàcz xleojocoz% ce`~kz cv`~bnk}cycb &s~n l xlmnv  xleojoce n c jvnkàc mn s~n ï bnedlv nt}nvbokcv lz jvoboklzlz ï ~bc ok}nvkceowcàêl ml nz}cml mn }nvvlv% klz mloz znk}omlz mc ivczn+& L }nvjnovl nynk}l ilo ~b cvvcz}êl vnceowcml kc Wlkc Z~e ml Vol mn Gcknovl% eljce lkmn c bcolv  xcv}n mc neo}n vnzomn% xlv z~fce}nvklz ml z~f÷vfol ml Vol mn Gcknovl+

Bnml mn I~ka Vnecjolkcml jlb l }úxojl ck}nvolv% okilvbc s~n l cvvcz}êl nvc jlbxlz}l xlv i~kanovlz n glynkz mn icynecz mcz wlkcz klv}n n lnz}n ml Vol+ B~o}lz glvkcoz n vnyoz}cz c}vof~âcb l }nvvlv kc jomcmn c nz}c jeczzn mn z~fce}nvklz% `nvcvcb ~b xvnjlkjno}l cokmc bcolv mc xlx~ecàêl+ Nb jlbxcvcàêl jlb c bckoinz}càêl ml obxncjdbnk} mn Jleelv% l c~}lv ~zl~ nz}cz xcecyvcz7 &Lz i~kanovlz kêl }ç l s~n jlbnblvcv+ Cz jeczznz bïmocz n ce}c }çb% c zn~ mozxlv% ~bc klyc zob~ecàêl mn mnbljvcjoc% nkjnkcmc xnel obxncjdbnk} ml xvnzomnk}n Jleelv% n c jlkjnxàêl mlz xlfvnz n icynecmlz jlbl jvoboklzlz n xcvczo}cz xvn`~oàlzlz+

L b~kml ml I~ka Jcvoljc Jlbnàc c mnzjvnynv jvlklel`ojcbnk}n l blyobnk}l i~ka% mnzmn zn~ okâjol n z~c nyle~àêl+ Kêl zú jlbl vnxvnznk}càêl cv}âz}ojc bcz }cbfïb jlbl blyobnk}l zljoce+ Ljlvvn c kcjolkceowcàêl ml i~ka% mnotc mn znv zlbnk}n ~bc b÷zojc yokmc ml nt}nvolv n `ckdc jlbxlzoàþnz kcjolkcoz% c~bnk}ckml cokmc bcoz z~c omnk}oiojcàêl jlb l xlyl+ Vnceowc c jlbxcvcàêl jlb l nz}cml mn Zêl Xc~el% lkmn l blyobnk}l xvnmlbokck}n ï l vcx% s~n vnceowcyc xvlgn}lz xcvc mnznkyleynv jomcmckoc xcvc l xlyl ml `~n}l+ Okilvbc s~n l Fvczoe k~kjc ilo ~b xcâz dlbl`çknl% xlvs~n znbxvn }nyn nzxcàl xcvc klycz vnxvnznk}càþnz+ ^b mlz ic}lvnz obxlv}ck}nz nvc s~n c neo}n `lz}c ml s~n ynb mn ilvc ml xcâz% n l i~ka bnzbl znkml jvocml ilvc ml Fvczoe% bck}ïb cz vcâwnz mc j~e}~vc kcjolkce n nvc c vnzoz}çkjoc ã j~e}~vc mlbokck}n+

C Xleâ}ojc J~e}~vce ml I~ka Jcvoljc Lz nz}~molzlz }nk}cvcb cyceocv c j~e}~vc mlz i~kanovlz n zn~ blml mn yomc% bcz nenz kêl xvnjozcb mn jvâ}ojc j~e}~vce xvc blz}vcv z~c xvúxvoc vnceomcmn% xloz zcfnb b~o}l fnb s~ce ï n icwnb ~zl mnec n mc jlkzjoçkjoc mnec xcvc cejckàcv zn~z xvúxvolz lfgn}oylz+ Zn`~kml _÷mojn7 &C j~e}~vc ml i~kanovl nz} ½znkml l~yomc% nz}ã cfvokml klylz jâvj~elz mn mnfc}nz kc }nenyozêl n kc obxvnkzc% nk}vckml kl bnvjcml% jvockml klycz blmcz% `nvckml klycz nz}vnecz mc b÷zojc+ Ozzl xlmn kêl vnkmnv c nzznz glynkz ~b `ckdl bc}nvoce% xlmn kêl zceyã"elz mc yoleçkjoc1 bcz% ciokce mn jlk}cz% }coz ntxnj}c}oycz kêl zêl z~c vnce nzxnvckàc+ L s~n nenz s~nvnb ï f~zjcv ~b nzxcàl s~n zngc zn~+&

Jlkje~zêl Fnc}vow Zcvel mozzn s~n l wcxxok` ï ~bc jlkz}v~àêl ivnkï}ojc mn jlk}n÷ml ok÷}oe% fczncml kc vn}vleno}~vc n vno}nvcàêl ml s~n cjlk}njn kc xvúxvoc }nenyozêl+ ^bc mn z~cz &enoz& icec zlfvn c bcolv cj~b~ecàêl mn obc`nkz mn ce}l obxcj}l kl bnklv }nbxl xlzzâyne n% xcvcmltcebnk}n% fcotc s~ck}omcmn mn okilvbcàêl+ Oz}l cjlk}njn klz xvl`vcbcz mn }nenyozêl n klz MYM'z mlz fcoenz i~ka% lkmn c jcbçvc s~czn kêl iojc iotc nb mn}nvbokcmlz blbnk}lz% znbxvn }vljckml mn cjlvml jlb l vo}bl mc b÷zojc% fczojcbnk}n iojcb kl jojel7 jck}lv% klbn mc ns~oxn mn i~ka% b~ednvnz mckàckml n lz ivns~nk}cmlvnz% `nvcebnk}n lz bcoz flko}lz n fnb ynz}omlz ml eljce+ Bnzbl s~ckml lz cxvnznk}cmlvnz nz}êl iceckml zlfvn ~b czz~k}l% cl i~kml znbxvn dã ~bc b÷zojc }ljckml n ce`~bcz ynwnz ~b `v~xl mn mckàc cjlbxckdc l vo}bl% mnotckml l nzxnj}cmlv  znbxvn jlb l xvokjoxce nb z~c bnk}n% l i~ka+ Zn`~kml Blvok% ce`~bcz jnenfvomcmnz zn o`~cecb clz Mn~znz ml Leobxl cl nenycvnb z~cz yomcz c ~b kâyne mn nz}vneozbl n xczzcvnb c znv omlec}vcmcz jlbl mn~znz+ Kl jczl ml i~ka jcvoljc% }lml lz s~n icwnb xcv}n ml blyobnk}l s~nvnb znv o`~coz% mn bcknovc s~czn ntc}c% clz zn~z âmlelz+ Jlbxvcb vl~xcz% jlv}cb l jcfnel% icecb mn bcknovc o`~ce n b~mcb c}ï z~cz c}o}~mnz xcvc zn blz}vcvnb o`~coz c zn~z âmlelz+ Ce`~kz âmlelz bnzbl cxúz z~c z ~c blv}n jlk}ok~cb kc bnk}n mlz ok}n`vck}nz ml i~ka% xlmnblz jo}cv l jczl mc m~xec Jec~mokdl n F~jdnjdc% lkmn Jec~mokdl icenjn~ nb ~b cjomnk}n dã s~czn 38 cklz n c}ï dlgn xczzcb &xvl`vcbcz nzxnjocoz& kc }nenyozêl n kl vãmol mc m~xec n mn z~c yomc% n cokmc ï omlec}vcml xnelz i~kanovlz+ Nkwnkzfnv`nv jlb l jlkjno}l mc b~znceowcàêl mozzn7 &l lvo`okce mnotc mn znv l lfgn}l c znv yoz}l n c xvúxvoc zo}~càêl ï s~n xczzc c nkjnkcv lvo`okceomcmn kl lfznvycmlv+ Zn ck}nz dcyoc ~bc c~vc% s~n ml}cyc c lfvc mn cv}n mn ~b fvoedl nzxnjoce% dlgn nec }vckzinvo~"zn xcvc }lmc c jnkc ml b~zn~% lkmn j~e}~c"zn ntc}cbnk}n cs~oel s~n kc yomc jl}omockc mnzcxcvnjn~% s~n ï ntc}cbnk}n ~b jlkjno}l mn yoyçkjoc nz}ï}ojc }l}ce+& oz}l ljlvvn~ jlb c i~kaiojcàêl+ L lvo`okce% l xvokjoxce% l i~ka $ b÷zojc / xnvmn~ c c}nkàêl xvokjoxce% jlb en}vcz s~n zêl

xvc}ojcbnk}n l lxlz}l ml s~n nvcb nb zn~ okâjol% &jcbokdl~& ml cblv n mc xlfvnwc xcvc c fcotcvoc n lz}nk}càêl+ L i~ka c}~ce zlfvnyoyn xnel cbfonk}n cl zn~ vnmlv% jlb b~ednvnz jlb jlvxlz nzj~e}~vcoz n xl~jc vl~xc% dlbnkz jlb jcvvlz klylz% vl~xcz mn bcvjc n jlvmþnz mn l~vl n xvc}c+ Okml ntc}cbnk}n mn cjlvml jlb l s~n Nkwnkzfnv`nv mozzn7 &jlkjno}l mn yoyçkjoc nz}ï}ojc }l}ce&+ L c~}lv mnjecvc s~n nzznz blyobnk}lz zljocoz nz}êl c}vnecmlz cl s~n jdcbcblz mn &omnk}omcmn kcjolkce& n s~n cz ynwnz kúz bnzblz klz nkynv`lkdcblz ml s~n }nblz c blz}vcv xcvc lz klzzlz ioedlz n xcvc l b~kml+ S~nb `lz}c mn ynv l Fvczoe znkml ynkmoml eã ilvc jlbl l xcâz ml gno}okdl n ml e~`cv lkmn zn xlmn icwnv }~ml< L~ l e~`cv lkmn cz xnzzlcz ml xcâz ml jcvkcyce ckmcb xnecmcz xnecz v~cz< L I~ka s~ckml z~v`o~ jc~zl~ ~b nzxck}l xcvc c kcàêl nb `nvce% ntjn}l xcvc lz dcfo}ck}nz mc xnvoinvoc $l~ icynecz/ ml Vol mn Gcknovl+ Nzzn }oxl mn b÷zojc bnol znb en}vc% jlb fc}omcz nz}vomnk}nz n s~n c`o}cb lz fcoenz jcvoljcz enyckml ynvmcmnovcz b~e}omþnz clz zn~z fcoenz% ck}nz vnz}vo}lz clz blvcmlvnz mcz jlb~komcmnz n mnxloz ivns~nk}cmlz xnec ce}c zljonmcmn n xnelz jdcbcmlz &xecflwokdlz& mc jeczzn bïmoc+ Jdljl~ n cbnmvlk}l~ c neo}n fvczoenovc+ Nb xvobnovl blbnk}l c bâmoc zn xlzojolkc jlk}vãvoc n jlbl l vnientl mc xlx~ecàêl s~n ï% xvï g~e`l~ nzzn blyobnk}l n lz czzljol~ c cxlel`oc cl }vãiojl%zntl%yoleçkjoc n c fckmomc`nb mnzjcvcmc mc icynec% $]nblz mn jlkjlvmcv s~n nzzc cokmc ï c obc`nb s~n ï xczzcmc s~ckml l~yoblz lz jdcbcmlz Xvlofomþnz/+ Icwnb zob cxlel`ocz%zêl j÷bxeojnz nb ce`~kz jczlz ml jvobn lv`ckowcml n mcz icvvcz eofnv}okcz s~n zêl vnceowcmcz vn`~ecvbnk}n knzzcz jlb~komcmnz `nvcebnk}n fckjcmcz xnel mokdnovl z~gl ml }vãiojl+ Jlkjlvml s~n l i~ka zngc c ntxvnzzêl mn ~b `vo}l mn eofnvmcmn l~ mn vnx÷mol mn ~b xlyl s~n cxnzcv mlz zn~z movno}lz `cvck}omlz xnec eno+ ]nblz mn en`o}obcv l i~ka jlbl ~bc bckoinz}càêl xlx~ecv n mn j~e}~vc kcjolkce yokmc ml znol mc jlb~komcmn+ Kêl xlmnblz nktnv`cv cxnkcz c y~e`cvomcmn%lz ecàlz ntj~zlz s~n ce`~kz xlzz~nb kl bnol n lz nks~cmvã"elz jlbl bcv`okcoz n fckmomlz mnblkowckml lz i~kanovlz jlbl j lbl gã l iownblz n b~o}lz cokmc l icwnb nb klzzlz mocz+ Enbfvcblz s~n l zcbfc n l~}vlz vo}blz l~ bckoinz}càþnz j~e}~vcoz gã xczzcvcb xlv nzzc iczn mn cmcx}càêl s~n }nblz jlb vncecàêl cl klyl n moinvnk}n+ Jlb l xnvjlvvnv mlz cklz c bâmoc b~ml~ zn~ xlzojolkcbnk}l n dlgn nktnv`c l i~ka n zn~z vnxvnznk}ck}nz mn ilvbc moinvnk}n n jlb l vnzxno}l mnyoml%xlv jlkzns~çkjoc kúz cxvnkmnblz c vnzxno}ã"elz+ C jlb~komcmn kêl ï jlbxlz}c cxnkcz mlz }vciojck}nz n ml }vãiojl s~n ynblz xnelz kl}ojoãvolz%n nb z~c bcolvoc ~b xlyl e~}cmlv%zlivoml xlvïb dlknz}l n mo`kl mn klzzl vnzxno}l+ ^b xlyl s~n f~zjc c}vcyïz mn bckoinz}càþnz jlbl l i~ka %civl"vn``cn n }ck}lz l~}vlz yoz}l%l~yoml n vnzxno}cml+ Cxúz znvnb }ctcmlz mn nzjúvoc mc zljonmcmn ilvcb cxvnznk}cmlz nb klynecz%zïvonz%ioebnz n cxcvnjnvcb jlb z~cz b÷zojcz l~ fc}omþnz nb }lmlz lz xvl`vcbcz xlx~ecvnz n lz kêl }êl xlx~ecvnz jlb z~cz mckàcvokcz znbo"k~cz+ L I~ka mnotl~ mn znv%mnyoml c `vckmn ntxlzoàêl kc bâmoc%mn xlfvn%xvn}l n icynecml% $jlbl mowoc c b÷zojc/ n c}ok`o~ c jeczzn bïmoc n clz &bc~vojokdlz& n &xc}vojokdcz& mc wlkc z~e%

$yovl~ infvn kcjolkce#/+ Kêl zêl dlgn l nz}oel bcoz cmbovcml n cokmc kêl zêl cjno}lz jlbl j~e}~vc l~ vnxvnznk}càêl zljoce xlv xcv}n mc zljonmcmn s~n vngno}cb l i~ka jlbxen}cbnk}n+ Kêl icvno g~e`cbnk}l mn ycelv s~ck}l cl i~ka%bcz lz vnjlkdnàl jlbl ~bc bckoinz}càêl xlx~ecv% vnxvnznk}c}oyc n bnvnjn l bn~ vnzxno}l bnzbl kêl znkml l vo}bl mn s~n n~ `lz}n l~ mn bokdc xvninvçkjoc+

Ckc Xc~ec Dnvfz}nv ï ce~kc ml j~vzl mn Jlb~kojcàêl Zljoce jlb Dcfoeo}càêl nb X~feojomcmn n Xvlxc`ckmc mc ^JF+ Tobnkkn Ivno}cz ï ce~kc ml j~vzl mn Jlb~kojcàêl Zljoce jlb Dcfoeo}càêl nb X~feojomcmn n Xvlxc`ckmc mc ^JF+