!"#$%"#&
!"#$%"#& (#") *+, ,-&./
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
;3":,4. <$)$1,3+ <2+. ,)4"23$1, $)# +2;;"3. ./,*3 ;3"-,++*")$0 13"6./7 () $##*.*")& "31$)*K$.*")+ <2+.
6*00 ;3"9*#, $4$#,<*$ ./, *<;,.2+ 3,O2*3,# ." *).3"#24, ;3":,4. <$)$1,<,). *)." ./,*3 4233*4202<7 C3":,4. <$)$1,<,). *+ ./, *<;,3$.*9, -"3 ()#*$X+ 13"6./ +."3% $)# 6, 5,0*,9,& ./, 6$% -"36$3# *+ -"3 *)#2+.3% $)# $4$#,<*$ ." 6"3E *) .$)#,< ") ./*+ 4"23 +, ." 3,$4/ ./, 4"2).3%X+ 1"$0 "- 5,*)1 3$)E,# $+ $) ,4")"<*4 +2;,3;"6,3 $)# $ #,9,0";,# )$.*")7 '() +(,(&.(/(01/0 21#$34"# 5.6 6/&1(
!"#$%"#& (#") 0*+1 .- ,-&./
()-3$+.324.23, ;0$%+ $ ;$3$<"2). 3"0, *) ./, ,4")"<*4 13"6./ "- $ 4"2).3%7 ()-3$+.324.23, *)9,+.<,).+ *) ()#*$
%,$3 ;0$)& ./, 1"9,3)<,). +,.+ $) $<5*.*"2+ .$31,.
*)-3$+.324.23, +,4."3 ." 53*#1, ./, /21, *)-3$+.324.23,
(. #,0*5,3$.,+ ") 5"./ ./, ,[.,3)$0 3,$+")+ -"3 #,0$%+& 6/*4/ $3, 5,%")# ./, 4").3"0 "- *<;0,<,).*)1 $1,)4*,+ $)# *).,3)$0 3,$+")+& 6/*4/ 4$) 423.$*0,# $. ./, ;3":,4. 0,9,0 6*./ ;3";,3 ;0$))*)1 $)# ;3":,4. <$)$1,<,).7 !/, +.2#% $0+" #6,00+ ") ./, ;3";"+,# $4.*")+ ." 5, .$E,) -"3 ,[;,#*.*)1 *)-3$+.324.23, ;3":,4.+ *) ()#*$7
.3*00*") ./3"21/ UV@YP@R 6*./ ZV ;,34,). "- ./, -2)#*)1 ." 5, <,. 5% ;3*9$., +,4."37 F0./"21/& ./, +,4."3 *+ 4")+*#,3,# ." 5, $ E,% #3*9,3 "- ,4")"<*4 13"6./& .*<, $)# 4"+. "9,332)+ ./3,$.,) ." 0*<*. ./, +,4."3 X+ ;".,).*$0
4$;*.$0 ,[;,)#*.23,7 !" 2)#,3+.$)# ./, 3,$+")+ -"3 .*<, $)# 4"+. "9,332)+ JCGD *)*.*$.,# ./, CG(PJCGD +.2#% ") ./, 3,O2,+. "G">C( ." $)$0%K, ./, 3,$+")+ -"3 +4/,#20, $)# 4"+. "9,332)+ $43"++ 9$3*"2+ *)-3$+.324.23$0 ;3":,4.+ 32))*)1 $43"++ ./, 4"2).3%7 !/, +.2#% 6$+ 2)#,3.$E,) $-.,3 +239,%*)1 E,% +.$E,/"0#,3+ *) ./, *)-3$+.324.23, +,4."3 $)# $)$0%K*)1 +,9,3$0 E,% ;3":,4.+ $)# 4"<;$3*)1 ./,< 6*./ 5,+. ;3$4.*4,+ $9$*0$50, 10"5$00%7
*) *.+ 5*# ." /*1/0*1/. ./, 3,$+")+ -"3 "9,332) *) ./, *)-3$+.324.23, ;3":,4.+ $)# ;"++*50, 3,4"<<,)#$.*")+7 7$$#() 8(/9(, 5(#4/$#: '$(, ;94(4$ (/& <"/94#=341"/9 +5.> 1/ 6/&1(
?(@,$ "A <"/4$/49 \[,42.*9, >2<<$3%
V@
M,$+")+ -"3 >4/,#20, ]9,332)+
VR
M,$+")+ -"3 L"+. ]9,332)+
UW
>,4."3P6*+, (<;$4. "- A$4."3 ") L"+. $)# >4/,#20, ]9,332)+
WW
G*.*1$.*") >.3$.,1*,+ P
C3":,4. G$)$1,<,). ^ C3"9,) G,./"# -"3 >244,++-20 ?,0*9,3%
_R
M,+"234, >/"3.$1, ^ C0$12*)1 !/, D3"6./ "- ./, >,4."3
Z@
M,4"<<,)#$.*")+ ^ `,[. >.,;+
ZS
L$+, >.2#*,+ ^ F ?,,; ?*9, ()." C3":,4.+
YS
D0"5$0 ()+*1/.+ ^ a,$3)*)1 A3"< D0"5$0 C3":,4.+
SW
>,4."3+ ]9,39*,6 ^ =)#,3+.$)#*)1 ()-3$+.324.23, >,4."3 *) ()#*$
SS
F;;,)#*[
@UW
1 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
BC
7 E 6 ? < ; D
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 2
;F$3=41G$ D=HH(#-
!/, JCGD *) ()#*$ P CG( +.2#% UV@U 6$+ *)*.*$.,# ") ./, 3,O2,+. "- G">C(& /*1/0*1/.+ ./, <$:"3 3,$+")+ -"3 +4/,#20, $)# 4"+. "9,332)+ $43"++ <$:"3 +,4."3X+ *)-3$+.324.23, ;3":,4.+7 b/*0, +"<, ;3":,4.+ $3, *<;$4.,# #2, ." ,[.,3)$0 -$4."3+ 6/*4/ $3, 5,%")# ./, 4").3"0 "- ./, *<;0,<,).*)1 $1,)4*,+ +24/ $+ 0$)# $4O2*+*.*")& 3,120$."3% $;;3"9$0+& ,.47& <$:"3*.% "- ;3":,4.+ $3, #,0$%,# 5% -$4."3+ 6/*4/ 4$) 5, 4").3"00,# $. ./, ;3":,4. 0,9,0 ./3"21/ ;3";,3 ;0$))*)1 $)# ;3":,4. <$)$1,<,).7 !/, +.2#% $0+" /*1/0*1/.+ ./, +,9,3, +E*00 +/"3.$1, $)# ./, 13"6*)1
;3"-,++*")$0+ $--,4.*)1 ./, *)-3$+.324.23, +,4."3 *) ()#*$7 C3":,4. "6),3+ -,,0 ./*+ *+ $ 0")1P .,3< *++2, 6/*4/ )". ")0% <$E,+ ./, ;3":,4.+ <"3, ,[;,)+*9, $)# 3*+E%& 52. $0+" 3,+20.+ *) 4"<;3"<*+, ") O2$0*.% $+ 6,00 $+ .*<,0*),+7
3 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
!"#$%&'$()'($* ,-%.& % ,%$%/0("' $0-* 1" '2* *)0"0/1) 3$04'2 0# % )0("'$.5 !"#$%&'$()'($* 1"6*&'/*"'& 1" !"71% 2%6* 8**" 3$041"3 0" % )0"&1&'*"' 8%&1&5 !" %" %/81'10(& '%$3*' 421)2 1& 2132*$ '2%" )0"&17*$*7 '0 8* % 9*. 7$16*$ 0# *)0"0/1) '0 -1/1' '2* &*)'0$:& ,0'*"'1%- '0 2*-, %)21*6* '2* 7*&1$*7 3$04'2 %"7 *"&($*
?,$3./ "- +E*00,# ;3":,4. <$)$1,3+
#,0*9,3% ;20$'%3* 0# &91--*7 ,$0<*)' /%"%3*$& */*$3*& %& '2* $00' )%(&* #0$ '1/* %"7 )0&' 06*$$("& 1" % ,$0<*)' -1#*).)-*5 !' 2%& 1" '2* 1"#$%&'$()'($* &*)'0$ 2%& 8**" 7*)-1"1"3 = %& $*&0($)*& %$* 301"3 #0$ )0")*$" 1& #*-' %)$0&& 6%$10(& &'%3*& 0# ,$0<*)' -1#*).)-*5 >? ,*$)*"' 0# '2* $*&,0"7*"'& %3$** '2%' '2* &*)'0$ #%)*& &20$'%3* 0# &91--*7 ,$0<*)' /%"%3*$& 41'2 '1/*@&)2*7(-* 06*$$("&5
&*)'0$ 2%& */*$3*7 %& '2* */8$.0"1) )%(&* #0$ '1/* %"7 )0&' 06*$$("& 1" '2* ,$0<*)' -1#* ).)-*5 A*&0($)*& %$* /0$* -()$%'16* 0,'10"&5 %)$0&& 6%$10(& &'%3*& 0# '2* ,$0<*)' -1#* ).)-* 2%& 8**" &(,,0$'*7 8. >? ,*$)*"' 0# '2* $*&,0"7*"'& '2%' %760)%'* '2* &%/* 8*-1*# 0# /%"%3*$& -%)91"3 '2* #($'2*$ -*%7& '0 1&&(*& &()2 %& ,$0-0"3*7 )0"'$%)'(%- 71&,('*&5
7*-16*$. 1& '2* ,%()1'. 0# &91--*7 ,$0<*)' /%"%3*$& 1" '2* 1"#$%&'$()'($* &*)'0$5
M,$+")+ -"3 ;3":,4. .*<, "9,332)+ $43"++ ;3":,4. 0*-,4%40,
>.$1,+
B$*C,-%""1"3
\[.,3)$0 *++2,+
D*-%. 1" $*3(-%'0$. %,,$06%-& E"%6%1-%81-1'.@7*-%.*7 %6%1-%81-1'. 0# #("7& F%"7@&1'* 2%"706*$
().,3)$0 *++2,+
B-%""1"3 %"7 7*&13"
/0"1'0$1"3
J-0&($* %"7 2%"706*$
F%)9 0# &'$0"3 AHA ,0-1)1*& !"*##*)'16* ,$0)($*/*"' ,-%""1"3 D*&13"@&)0,* )2%"3* D*-%. 1" $*3(-%'0$ . %,,$06%-& D*-%. 1" 7*)1&10" /%91"3 I*%9@1"*##*)'16* ,$0<*)' ,-%""1"3 H /0"1'0$1"3 J0"'$%)'(%- 71&,('*& E"%6%1-%81-1'.@7*-%.*7 %6%1-%811-'. 0# #("7& F%)9 0# &'$0"3 AHA ,0-1)1*& D*-%. -%"7@&1'* 2%"706*$ B$*C)0//1&&10"1"3 '**'21"3 '$0(8-*& J0"'$%)'(%- 71&,('*&
F%)9 0# ,$0<*)' /%"%3*$&@)0//*$)1%- /%"%3*$& 41'2 %7*G(%'* ,-%""1"3 &91--& F%)9 0# )0&' /%"%3*$& F%)9 0# ,-%""1"3 *"31"**$@)0//*$)1%- /%"%3*$&
F%)9 0# ,$0<*)' /%"%3*$&@&1'* /%"%3*$&@,-%""1"3 *"31"**$&@G(%"'1'. &(,*$61&0$& F%)9 0# %4%$*"*&& /07*$" *G(1,/*"' H '*)2"0-03. %(71' %"7 '0'%- G(%-1'. /%"%3*/*"' ,$0#*&&10"%-&
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 4
F%)9 0# $*G(1&1'* &91-- &*' %& % /%<0$ )%(&* 0# )0")*$" 1& %-&0 &(,,0$'*7 8. ;($6*. KLMK5 N80(' OP ,*$)*"' 0# '2* -*&& %,,$*2*"&16* %80(' ("#%60$%8-* *)0"0/1) ,$0&,*)'& %& )0/,%$*7 2132-132'*7 '2%' 421-* */*$31"3 /%$9*'& -19* !"71% $*,$*&*"' % 813 0,,0$'("1'. #0$ *"31"**$1"3 %"7 )0"&'$()'10" %))0/,%"1*7 8. % 2132 7*3$** 0# ,*$)*"' 0# '2* $*&,0"7*"'& )0"&17*$*7 &91--*7 $*&0($)*& %& '2* &1"3-* 8133*&' )(-'($%- 71##*$*")*&5 ,-%""1"3 %"7 /0"1'0$1"3 &'$%'*31*& '0
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
>"234,c JCGD *) ()#*$ P CG( >239,% ") 4"+. $)# +4/,#20, "9,332)& UV@U
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
5 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
a$4E "- /*1/0% +E*00,# ;3"-,++*")$0+ 5,4"<,+ 43*.*4$0 ." $##3,++ "0"C%6%1-%81-1'. 0# 2132-.C&91--*7 ,$0#*&&10"%-& )%" 2%6* %" %76*$&* 1/,%)' 0" '2* &20$'%3* 0# %$0("7 '2$** /1--10"M 1")$*%&* 1"6*&'/*"' 1" '$%1"1"3 %"7 /*"'0$1"3 '0 7*6*-0, '2* $*G(1&1'* &91-- &*' 1" '2*
'0 1"'$07()* ,$0<*)' /%"%3*/*"' 1" '2* 1"&'1'('*& %& % ,%$' 0# '2* /%1" &'$*%/ *7()%'10"5 !" /%". 0# '2* %76%")*7 1& )0"&17*$*7 %' ,%$ 41'2 ("16*$&1'. 1& "0' &0(32' %#'*$ 8. '2* 8$132' %"7 %/81'10(& &'(7*"'&5 S"* 0# '2* ,$1/%$. $*%&0"& 1& '2%' '2*&* 1"&'1'('*& )%""0' 1
KPMG in India Analysis
0##*$ % Q7*3$**: = 421)2 &**/& '0 8* % )$1'1)%- $*G(1$*/*"' #0$ %". #($'2*$ #0$/%- *7()%'10" 1" !"71% %"7 %)$0&& '2* 3-08*5 !' 1& 1/,0$'%"' '0 ("7*$&'%"7 '2* /%",04*$ %"7 &91-- $*G(1$*/*"'& 0# '2* 1"7(&'$1*& 8*#0$* 4* 8*31" 0($ $*#0$/& 3$041"3 !"71%" "**7& '$%1"*7 /%",04*$ &(,,0$' 1"&'1'('10"& '2%' "**7 /%",04*$ '0 &(,,0$' '2*/5 )($$1)(-(/ 1" /%1" &'$*%/ *7()%'10" 1& &'%"7%$7& %"7 %--041"3 3-08%--. $*"04"*7
1"&'1'('*& '0 &*' (, '$%1"1"3 )*"'*$& 1" '2* 8*&' 3-08%- )0"&'$()'10" )0/,%"1*& !"71% %"7 )0"'$18('* '0 '2* $1)2"*&& 0# 2*-, '2* !"71%" -%80$ '0 8* 40$-7C)-%&& %"7 )-%1/ 2132*$ &%-%$1*& %"7 4%3*&5
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 6
;3":,4. #,0*9,3%
C3";"+,# $4.*") ;"*).+ -"3 ,[;,#*.*)1 *)-3$+.324.23, ;3":,4.+ *) ()#*$
)0")*,' #0$ 1"7*,*"7*"' $*,0$'1"3 %"7 N80(' UT ,*$)*"' 0# '2* $*&,0"7*"'& %3$** '2%' BRS )0(-7 8* %" *##*)'16* 4%. 0# /0"1'0$1"3 ,$0<*)'&5 B$0<*)' '*%/& '2%' 2%6* %70,'*7 BRS #**- '2%' 1' 2*-,& 1" *"&($1"3 &())*&&#(- 1/,-*/*"'%'10" 0# ,$0<*)'& '2$0(32 7*,-0./*"' 0# ,$0<*)' /%"%3*/*"' 8*&' ,$%)'1)*&5 BRS %-&0 %"7 ,$0617*& %7*G(%'* 3(17%")* %"7 1"#0$/%'10" #0$ '1/*-. 7*)1&10"C/%91"35
0")* 1/,-*/*"'*7 )0(-7 2*-, 1" 7*80''-*"*)91"3 1"#$%&'$()'($* ,$0<*)'& %"7 2*-, *"&($* '1/*-. ,$0<*)' 1/,-*/*"'%'10" 41'21" '2* &'1,(-%'*7
1/,0$'%")* 0# ,$0<*)' /%"%3*/*"' 0" 1/,$061"3 '2* ,$0<*)' /%"%3*/*"' &91--& %)$0&& )0("'$. '0 3*' 8*''*$ $*'($"& #$0/ ,(8-1) 1"6*&'/*"' 1" 1"#$%&'$()'($* %"7 %-&0 1" '2* &0)1%- &*)'0$&K5 B$0<*)' !"71%5
2
&'$()'($* '2$0(320(' '2* )0("'$. '0 /0"1'0$ 1"#$%&'$()'($* ,$0<*)'&
'$%"&,%$*"' 81771"3 )$1'*$1%
&*''-*/*"' /*)2%"1&/
-
!"'$07()1"3 % &1"3-* 41"704 )-*%$%")* /*)2%"1&/ '0 /%9* '2* $*3(-%'0$. %,,$06%- ,$0)*&& /0$* *##*)'16*
'$%"&,%$*"' '$%"&,0$' ,0-1). #0$ /06*/*"' 0# ,$0<*)' /%'*$1%-& -031&'1)& &.&'*/ '0 *"%8-* #%&'*$ ,$0<*)' 1/,-*/*"'%'10" '2$0(320(' '2* )0("'$.5
%"7 B;E& 0" '2*1$ $*&,*)'16* 1"'*$"*' 4*8&1'*&
B$0/0'1"3 8%-%")*7 B(8-1) B$16%'* &*)'0$ #0$ #%&'*$ 1/,-*/*"'%'10" 0# ,$0<*)'&
B$0/0'1"3 <01"' *6%-(%'10" 0# ,$0<*)' 7*&13" 8. ,$0<*)' 04"*$& %"7 )0"'$%)'0$& #0$ 6%-(* *"31"**$1"35
-
-
V($'2*$ &'$*"3'2*"1"3 !"71%:& ,$03$%/ '0 1/,%$' ,$0<*)' /%"%3*/*"' 9"04-*73* '0 V0&'*$ )0--%80$%'10" %"7 )00,*$%'10" 41'2 *7()%'10"%1"&'1'('*& '0 )0("'*$ '2* ,$0#*&&10"%-& 4*-- *G(1,,*7 '0 2%"7-* 1"#$%&'$()'($* ,$0<*)'&
“An approach to the 12th Five year plan”, Planning Commiss ion, October 2011, p12
0# 1"C20(&* %)%7*/1*& %"7 &'$()'($*7 '$%1"1"3 ,$03$%/&
7 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
BI
7 E 6 ? < ; D
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 8
'$(9"/9 A"# 93J$&=,$ "G$##=/9
G$:"3*.% "- *)-3$+.324.23, ;3":,4.+ *) ()#*$ $3, $--,4.,# 5% .*<, "9,332)+7 !/,+, "9,332)+ 9$3%
%,$3+& ;0$4*)1 ./, ;3":,4. 9*$5*0*.% $. 3*+E7 >239,%
$--,4. ./,*3 ;3":,4.+ $)# ./, 4/$00,)1,+ ./,% -$4, *) 4")O2,3*)1 ./,<7 !/,+, 5"..0,),4E+& $+ ,)0*+.,# 5,0"6& $3, #*9*#,# *)." .6" ;/$+,+ ^ H*I ;3,P,[,42.*") ;/$+, $)# H**I ,[,42.*") $)# 40"+*)1 ;/$+,7
9 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
'$(9"/9 A"# 93J$&=,$ "G$##=/9 1/ 4J$ K#$L$F$3=41"/ KJ(9$
D*-%.& 1" -%"7 %)G(1&1'10" %"7 &1'* 2%"706*$ 1& '2* ,$1/%$. $*%&0" #0$ &)2*7(-* -%"7 8. ,$0<*)' 04"*$&5 D*-%. 1" &(8&*G(*"' -%"7 %)G(1&1'10" %"7 1"%7*G(%). 1" ,$0<*)' ,-%""1"3 )0"&17*$1"3 '2* 1/,%)' 0# 7*#*$$*7 -%"7 %)G(1&1'10" 1& ,0&&18-. '2* &1"3-* $*%&0" #0$ ,$0<*)' 7*-%.&5
\[/*5*. @c M,$+") -"3 ;3":,4. +4/,#20, #,0$% *) ;3,P,[,42.*") ;/$+,
>"234,c JCGD *) ()#*$ P CG( >239,% ") 4"+. $)# +4/,#20, "9,332)& UV@U
D*-%.& 1" -%"7 %)G(1&1'10" %$* 7$16*" 8. &*6*$%- #%)'0$&5 S"* 0# '2* ,$1/* #%)'0$& #0$ 0# ,00$ )0/,*"&%'10" %"7 '2* ("7*$6%-(*7 /%$9*' ,$1)* 0# -%"7 = -*%71"3 '0 /%". ,$0<*)' -%"7 6%-(* 0#'*" %,,$*)1%'*& )0"&17*$%8-. 42*$* 1" '2* 1")(/8*"' 04"*$ 70*& "0' 2%6* %". &2%$*5
MI
T 3,+;")#,).+ -,,0 ./$. #,0$%+ *) 0$)# $4O2*+*.*") 0,$# ." ;3":,4. +4/,#20, "9,332)+7
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 10
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
%76*$&*-. %##*)' '2* &*"'1/*"'& 0# ,*0,-* %80(' '2* ,$0<*)'5 F%"7 %)G(1&1'10" -*%7& '0 71&,-%)*/*"' %"7 ("*/,-0./*"'5 %"7 -%"7 7*3$%7%'10" %##*)'1"3 '2* -0)%*"61$0"/*"' %"7 '2* -1#*&'.-* 0# ,*0,-*5 &'1## $*&1&'%")* #$0/ &0)1%- %)'161&'& %"7 -0)%-& %-19*5 F%"7 %)G(1&1'10" 1&&(*& %$* 2%& 8**" &'%--*7 7(* '0 ,*0,-*:& %31'%'10" %3%1"&' '2* -%"7 %)G(1&1'10"M5 F0)%-& #*%$ 41-- -0&* '2*1$ %3$0C8%&*7 &(&'%1"%8-* -16*-120075
,$0"0(")*7 1" '$%"&,0$'%'10" &*)'0$
?#(/9K"#4 O P"0194139 (/& ;/$#09$34"# (#$ 4J$ %"#94 (AA$34$& @- ,(/& (3Q=19141"/ 199=$9R &()2 %& W1324%.CA0%7& %"7 A%1-4%. '21& &*)'0$ %3$** '2%' '2*1$ ,$0<*)'& %$* #0$ % "*4 $%1- -1"* ,$0<*)' 1" '2* ;'%'* 0# ,$0<*)' 4%& '0 8* %)G(1$*7 8. S)'08*$ '2* -%"7 %)G(1&1'10" ,$0)*&& %"7 1"'*$C 0"* 0# '2* /0&' ,$*&'1310(& ,$0<*)'& 1" .*%$& 7(* '0 '2* -%"7 %)G(1&1'10" 1&&(*&5 41'2 &)2*7(-*7 )0/,-*'10" 7%'* 0# D*)*/8*$ KLLOK 30' )0/,-*'*7 0"-. 1" X%"(%$. KLMK5
\[/*5*. Uc >,4."3+ *<;$4.,# 5% 0$)# $4O2*+*.*")+
>"234,c JCGD *) ()#*$ ^ CG( >239,% ") 4"+. $)# +4/,#20, "9,332)& UV@U
1 2 3
Posco’s Orissa project hangs in balance, The Hindu, 21 June 2012 Golden Quadrilateral project may miss deadline, The Hindu, January 07, 2003 Govt declares Golden Quadrilateral complete, Indian Express, dated January 7, 2012
11 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
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
D($1"3 '2* 1"'*$%)'10" 41'2 B$0<*)'& %"7 $*3(-%'0$. %,,$06%-& 70 "0' 2%6* % 2%& %" 1/,%)' 0" &(8&*G(*"' ,$0<*)' ,-%"& $*&(-'1"3 1" ("%))0("'*7 7*-%.& 1" ,$0<*)' 7*-16*$.5
4 5
MoSPI, January 2012 Flash Report; KPMG in India Analysis Posco’s Orissa project hangs in balance, The Hindu, 21 June 2012
/%"7%'0$. %' '2* &'%$' 0# '2* ,$0<*)' 8* )2%--*"3*7 '2$0(32 ,(8-1) 1"'*$*&' -1'13%'10"& 421)2 )0(-7 -*%7 '0 ,$0<*)' *"61$0"/*"' )-*%$%")*& '2$0(32 71$*)' /%<0$:& ,$0<*)' 1" S$1&&% 1& % &'$191"3 &13"*7 % R*/0$%"7(/ 0# E"7*$&'%"71"3 *"'%"3-*7 1" -*3%- %"7 *"61$0"/*"'%)-*%$%")*&5 N#'*$ % $*61*4 0# '40 %"7 % 1"60-6*& 0"* 0# '2* -%$3*&' VD! 7*%- 1" &*6*" .*%$&P5
SI
T 3,+;")#,).+ -,,0 ./$. #,0$% *) 3,120$."3% $;;3"9$0+ 0,$# ." ;3":,4. +4/,#20, "9,332)7
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 12
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
&*)'0$ 1& % )%&* 1" ,01"'5 !" %771'10" '0 )-*%$%")*& "**7 '0 8* 08'%1"*7 #$0/ W1324%.& N('20$1'. 0# !"71% *')5 N& /0&' &)2*7(-*5 TK ,*$)*"' 0# $*&,0"7*"'& #**- '2%' 7*-%. 1" $*3(-%'0$. %,,$06%-& -*%7& '0 ,$0<*)'
MB K$#3$/4 "A #$9K"/&$/4 "K1/$& 4J(4 H$4(,9 (/& H1/1/0 19 4J$ %"#94 (AA$34$& 9$34"# &=$ 4" &$,(- 1/ #$0=,(4"#- (KK#"G(,9R &)2*7(-* 06*$$("&5 S($ 1"'*$%)'10" 41'2 '2* ,$0<*)' 04"*$& &(33*&'& '2%' 8* 7*-%.*7 0" %))0("' 0# $*3(-%'0$. %,,$06%-&5
\[/*5*. Wc >,4."3+ *<;$4.,# ") $44"2). "- #,0$% *) 3,120$."3% $;;3"9$0+ !$E*)1 40,$3$)4,+ -3"< 9$3*"2+ $2./"3*.*,+ *+ $ .*<, 4")+2<*)1 ;3"4,++Q "-.,) ./,3, *+ 0$4E "- .,$< 6"3E $<")1 #*--,3,). D"9,3)<,). #,;$3.<,).+7 .(/(01/0 21#$34"#: 5"%$# ?#(/9H1991"/ <"HK(/-
)0"&1&'*"' %)$0&& %-- 1"#$%&'$()'($% $*G(1$*/*"'&5 ;*)($1"3 '2*&* %,,$06%-&
>"234,c c JCGD *) ()#*$ ^ CG( >239,% ") 4"+. $)# +4/,#20, "9,332)& UV@U
13 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
B00$ ,$03$%/ /%"%3*/*"' $*&(-'1"3 1" 1"*##*)'16* )0C0$71"%'10" 41'2 0'2*$ ,$0<*)'& %"7 &)2*7(-* 7*-%. $*G(1$* )0C0$71"%'10" 41'2 &*6*$%- 0'2*$ ,$0<*)'&5 D*-%. 1" *1'2*$ 0# '2* ,$0<*)'& 7*-16*$. 0# 0'2*$ %&&0)1%'*7 ,$0<*)'& %"7 *6*"'(%--. '2* *"'1$* ,$03$%/5 V0$ 0# %$0("7 !YA TLL )$0$* 1& 7*-%.*7 8. %-/0&' '40 .*%$& 7(* '0 7*-%. 1" ,04*$ '$%"&/1&&10" -1"* 1& '0 &0($)* *-*)'$1)1'.T5 &($6*. 41'2 %$0("7 OM ,*$)*"' 0# '2* $*&,0"7*"'& %3$**1"3 '2%' 1"*##*)'16* ,$03$%/ /%"%3*/*"' $*&(-'& 1" &)2*7(-* 06*$$("& 7(* '0 1"'*$C7*,*"7*")1*&
!"%7*G(%'* )0C0$71"%'10" 8*'4**" ,$0<*)'& 1& ,$1/%$1-. 7(* '0 '2* -%)9 0# 7*'%1-*7 '1/* %"7 $1&9 ,-%""1"3 %' )0/,-*'*-. #0$*&** '2* &."*$31*& %"7 '2* $1&9& %/0"3 6%$10(& ,$0<*)'& -*%71"3 '0 '2* ,$0<*)' /%"%3*/*"' )%,%81-1'1*& 1"
TC
T 3,+;")#,).+ -,,0 ./$. 3,0$.*")+/*; 6*./ "./,3 ;3":,4.+ 0,$# ." ;3":,4. +4/,#20, "9,332)7
KPMG in India’s point of view '0 8* -%$3*-. %##*)'*7 8. '2* #%)'0$& 3*"*$%'1"3 #$0/ -%"7 %)G(1&1'10" %"7 ,$0<*)' 7*-16*$. %$* ,$1/%$1-. 7(* '0 '%9* '2*&* %)'161'1*& 1"'0 %))0("' 421-* )0"&17*$1"3 '2* '1/* ).)-* #0$ '2* ,$0<*)' )0/,-*'10"5 1")$*%&* 1" "(/8*$ 0# &'%9*20-7*$& %"7 %##*)'*7 &*)'10"& 1& 1"*61'%8-*5 N-&0 '2* 3$041"3 )0")*$" %"7 &'$0"3*$ /*%&($*& #0$ ,$0'*)'10" %"7 $*&'0$%'10" 0# *"61$0"/*"' 2%6* %77*7 '0 '2*
6
*##0$'& $*G(1$*7 8. ,$0<*)' /%"%3*/*"' )%" 8* /1'13%'*7 8. '1/*-. %)'10"& 316*" '2%' '2* &'$0"3 %"7 ,*$1071) 1"#0$/%'10" &.&'*/ 1& *&'%8-1&2*7 '0 ,$0617* '2* "*)*&&%$. 1"#0$/%'10"5 N-'20(32 '2* #%)'0$& %##*)'1"3 '2* ,$0<*)' '1/*-1"*& ,$1/%$1-. %,,*%$ '0 8* ("7*$-.1"3 $*%&0" 8*21"7 '2*/ $*/%1"& $*G(1&1'*& '0 06*$)0/* '2*&* #%)'0$&5 !" 1" '($" /%"1#*&'& 1"'0 7*-%.*7 ,$0<*)' 7*-16*$. 0$ 2132*$ )0&' %' )0/,-*'10"5
Based on one-to-one discussion with the survey respondent
Study Bridging on the Project Urban Schedule Housingand Shortage Cost Overruns in India | 14
'$(9"/9 A"# 93J$&=,$ "G$##=/ 1/ $F$3=41"/ (/& 3,"91/0 KJ(9$ '2* 1"#$%&'$()'($* &*)'0$ R0&' 1"#$%&'$()'($* ,$0<*)'& %$* 61)'1/& 0# )2%"3* 1" ,$0<*)' 7*&13" %"7 &)0,* 421)2 0#'*" -*%7 '0 ,$0<*)' 7*-%.&5 B00$ ,$0<*)' ,-%""1"3 )0(,-*7 41'2 -%)9 0# %''*"'10" '0 7*'%1-& -*%7& '0 ,$0-0"3*7 71&)(&&10"& 8*'4**" ,$0<*)' 04"*$& %"7 )0"'$%)'0$&@ ,$0<*)' &)0,* 1& 3*"*$%--. -04 1# % ,$0<*)' 2%& 8**" ,-%""*7 4*--5
\[/*5*. _c M,$+")+ -"3 ;3":,4. +4/,#20, #,0$% *) ,[,42.*") $)# 40"+*)1 ;/$+,
>"234,c JCGD *) ()#*$ ^ CG( >239,% ") 4"+. $)# +4/,#20, "9,332)& UV@U
15 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
1"6*&'13%'10" %"7 '0,03$%,21)%- &($6*.&5 !"%,,$0,$1%'* %&&*&&/*"' 0# 3*0-031)%%"7 '0,03$%,21)%- #%)'0$& )%" -*%7 '0 &'%3* )%" -*%7 '0 71&,('*& $*-%'*7 '0 $*3(-%'0$. %,,$06%-& %"7 )0"&'$()'10" &)2*7(-* 06*$$("&5
;)2*7(-* 06*$$("& 0" %))0("' 0# )2%"3*& 1" '2* ,$0<*)' 7*&13" %"7 &)0,* 7($1"3 #*%'($* 1" -%$3* ,(8-1) &*)'0$ ,$0<*)'& )161- %61%'10" %"7 $0%7 )0"&'$()'10"5 ,$0<*)'*7 #0$ )0/,-*'10" 8. KLMLCMM5
-%'*$ 7*)17*7 '0 &,-1' '2* )0"&'$()'10" )0//1&&10"1"3 1" KLML>5
UV
T 3,+;")#,).+ -,,0 ./$. 4/$)1, *) ;3":,4. +4";,d #,+*1) 0,$#+ ." ;3":,4. +4/,#20, "9,332)+ *) ./, ,[,42.*") ;/$+,7
\[/*5*. Zc L3*.*4$0*.% "- #,+*1)d+4";, 4/$)1, $43"++ +,4."3+
>"234,c JCGD *) ()#*$ ^ CG( >239,% ") 4"+. $)# +4/,#20, "9,332)& UV@U
A*&,0"7*"'& #$0/ '2* $0%7 )0"&'$()'10" &*3/*"' $*,0$'*7 '2%' 6*$. 0#'*" '2* 0$131"%- ,$0<*)' &)0,* 1& )0"&17*$%8-. $*G(1$*/*"' '0 &(,,0$' % ,$08%8-* 2%& &(33*&'*7 '0 $*7()* $0%7 &*)'0$ 8177*$&U )0/,%"1*& 1" '2* 81771"35
6 7
>? ,*$)*"' $*&,0"7*"'& %3$** '2%' )2%"3* 1" ,$0<*)' &)0,* -*%7& '0 &) 2*7(-* )161- %61%'10" %"7 '*-*)0/ &*)'0$& %$* /0$* ,$0"* '0 7*-%.& 8*)%(&* 0# &)0,* )2%"3* 61&CZC61& &*)'0$& &()2 %& ,0$'& %"7 !" 61*4 0# '2* #%&' 3$041"3 $*G(1$*/*"'& 2%6* '($"*7 0(' '0 8* '2* "*)*&&%$.
)0"6*$'*7 '0 %76%"'%3* 0# '2* 04"*$&5 *##*)'16* 1/,-*/*"'%'10" 0# )2%"3* ,$0<*)' /%"%3*/*"' #$%/*40$9& 1" (&* '2* &)0,* )2%"3* )%""0' 8* 70"* %4%. &20(-7 8* %70,'*7 '0 06*$)0/* '2* 1/,%)' 0# '2*&* )2%"3*& 0" '1/* %"7 )0&' 8(73*' 0# '2* ,$0<*)'&5
6/3,=91"/ "A 3J(/0$ H(/(0$H$/4 19 #$Q=1#$& A"# $AA$341G$,- H(/(01/0 3J(/0$9 1/ K#")$34 93"K$R
Based on one-to-one discussion with the survey respondent IOC’s Paradip refinery behind schedule; may complete in 2013 Q1, The Economic Times, 11 August 2011
8
NHAI urged to prune project sizes to attract more bidders, Business Line, 31 August 2012
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 16
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
#0$/%-1'1*& 8*#0$* )0/1"3 '0 !"71% 421)2 1& % '1/* )0"&(/1"3 ,$0)*&& %"7 3*"*$%--. )0/*& %' % 2132*$ )0&'5
5#")$34 H(/(0$#9: $/G1#"/H$/4(, 4"K 4J#$$ #$9"=#3$9 Y 1/A#(94#=34=#$ 1/&=94#- 19 A(31/0 ( 9J"#4(0$R
\[/*5*. Yc M$)E*)1 "- 3,+"234,+ *) .,3<+ "- ./,*3 +/"3.$1, *) ./, *)#2+.3%
;($6*. $*&,0"7*"'& %-&0 %3$**7 '2%' '2* &*)'0$ 1& #%)1"3 % &*6*$* &20$'%3* 0# ,$0<*)' /%"%3*/*"'5 `".,c C,34,).$1, "- 3,+;")#,).+ 6/" -,0. ./$. ./, *)#2+.3% *+ 4233,).0% -$4*)1 $ +/"3.$1,+ "- ./,+, 3,+"234,+ >"234,c JCGD *) ()#*$ ^ CG( >239,% ") 4"+. $)# +4/,#20, "9,332)& UV@U
9
Power Projects in India: Implementati on Challenge s and Opportunities, Focus 2015 by Raajeev B. Batra
17 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
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
N"0'2*$ 1&&(* 1/,%)'1"3 '2* ,$03$*&& 0# 1"#$%&'$()'($* ,$0<*)'& %)$0&& 1"7(&'$1*& 1& '2* -04 ,$07()'161'. 0# -%80$ 7(* '0 &0)10C)(-'($%-C,0-1'1)%- $*%&0"&5 V0$ *')5 %76*$&*-. %##*)' ,$07()'161'. %' )0"&'$()'10" &1'*& %"7 1/,%)' '2* ,$0<*)' 2%6* %" 1/,%)' 0" ,$0<*)' 7*-16*$.5
a$4E "- $9$*0$5*0*.% "- +E*00,# 0$5"3 *+ $) *++2,7 =)3,+;")+*9,),++& +.3*E,+ $)# ,[.,)#,# /"0*#$%+ -23./,3 /$<;,3 ./, .*<,0% ;3":,4. ,[,42.*")7 >$/$#(, .(/(0$# 5"%$# >$/$#(41"/ <"HK(/-
PP ,*$)*"' 0# $*&,0"7*"'& 0,1"* '2%' "0"C%6%1-%81-1'. 0# &91--*7 -%80$ 1& % /%<0$ %"7 /1"1"3 &*)'0$ 1& 40$&' %##*)'*7 8. '2* &20$'%3* 0# -%80$5
\[/*5*. Rc L3*.*4$0*.% "- 0$4E "- $9$*0$5*0*.% "- +E*00,# 0$5"3 $43"++ +,4."3+
>"234,c JCGD *) ()#*$ ^ CG( >239,% ") 4"+. $)# +4/,#20, "9,332)& UV@U
10 World Bank; World Bank’s medium growth scenario is based on the vision documents of the states and the country; and High growth scenario incorporates the massive investments in national highways and rural roads announced by GOI.
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 18
W111X DJ"#4(0$ "A 0""& $Q=1KH$/4 9=KK,1$#9 (/& 3"/4#(34"#9 !"#$%&'$()'($* ,$0<*)'& *&,*)1%--. 1" ,04*$ &*)'0$ %$* 2%/,*$*7 7(* '0 -%)9 0# 3007 )0"'$%)'0$& %"7 1"#$%&'$()'($* ,$0<*)'& 1" '2* )0("'$. %$* 3$041"3 %' % #%&'*$ ,%)* '2%" '2* )%,%)1'. 2%& )$*%'*7 % 417* 3%, 8*'4**" '2* 7*/%"7 %"7 &(,,-. -*%71"3 '0 7*-%.& 1" )0/,-*'10" 0# ,$0<*)'& 7(* '0 "0" %6%1-%81-1'. 0# 9*. ,$0<*)' *G(1,/*"'&5 V0$ ,04*$ 3*"*$%'10" )0/,%". 2%& $0--*7 0(' &*6*$%- "*4 ,$0<*)'& 41'2 *G(1,/*"' &(,,-. 0$7*$& '0 .*' %"0'2*$ ;'%'* 04"*7 %"7 )0("'$.:& 0"* 0# '2* -%$3*&' ,04*$ *G(1,/*"' /%"(#%)'($*$5 R%". 0# '2*&* ,$0<*)'& %$* #%)1"3 ,0'*"'1%- 7*-%.& 0" %))0("' 0# 1"%81-1'. 0# '2* *G(1,/*"' /%"(#%)'($*$ '0 /**' '2* &(,,-. 0$7*$& %& ,*$ &)2*7(-*5 !"71%:& 1"%81-1'. '0 /**' ,04*$ 3*"*$%'10" )%,%)1'. %771'10" 8**" /%1"-. %''$18('*7 '0 "0" %6%1-%81-1'. ,$0<*)'& 1" '2* ,04*$ &*)'0$ %$* %-&0 #%)1"3 &20$'%3* 0# 8%-%")* 0# ,-%"' *G(1,/*"' &()2 %& )0%- 2%"7-1"3 %"7 %&2 2%"7-1"3 &.&'*/&5
!/,3, *+ 0$4E "- 1""# ,O2*;<,). <$)2-$4.23,3+ *) ./, 4"2).3% 0,$#*)1 ." /,$9% #,;,)#,)4, ") -,6 ;0$%,3+7 ;F$3=41G$ 21#$34"# D4$$, .(/=A(34=#1/0 <"HK(/-
N,%$' #$0/ '2* /%"(#%)'($*7 %-&0 #%)1"3 2($7-*& 7(* '0 &20$'%3* 0#
$(" '2* 2132 $1&9 0# 1"#*$10$ G(%-1'. 0# *G(1,/*"'5 !"71% 1& %-&0 #%)1"3 % &20$'%3* 0# 3007 *"31"**$1"3 ,$0)($*/*"' %"7 #*4 )0/,%"1*& 1" !"71% 41'2 7*&1$*7 N6%1-%81-1'. 0# '2*&* )0"'$%)'0$& 1& % )2%--*"3* %& '2*1$ 0$7*$ 8009& %$* %-$*%7. !"71% 1& 06*$8009*7 8. #0($ '1/*& 1'& )($$*"' )%,%)1'.MM5
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
11 Based on one-to-one discussion with the survey respondent 12 Report on Construction in India 2011, India Infrastructure
1& % '*710(& %"7 '1/* )0"&(/1"3 ,$0)*&&5 ,*$)*"' 0# '2* $*&,0"7*"'& %3$**1"3 '2%' '2*&* #%)'0$& 1/,%)' ,$0<*)' 7*-16*$.5
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
19 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
a$4E "- ().,13$.*") G$)$1,<,). *) ;3":,4. ;0$))*)1 3,+20.*)1 *) 4""3#*)$.*") *++2,+ #,0$%*)1 ./, ;3":,4.+ F%$3* 1"#$%&'$()'($* ,$0<*)'& 8. '2* 61$'(* 0# '2*1$ 1/,%)' %"7 &)%-* 1"60-6* /(-'1,-* 8*'4**" 6%$10(& %3*")1*& 8*)0/*& % )$1'1)%- #%)'0$ #0$ &())*&&#(- ,$0<*)' (&(%--. % $*&(-'%"' 0# ,00$ 1"'*3$%'10" 7($1"3 '2* ,-%""1"3 ,2%&*5 PL ,*$)*"' 0# '2* $*&,0"7*"'& ;'%'*7 )00$71"%'10" 1&&(*& 41'2 ,$0<*)' '*%/ 0$ 6*"70$& %& 0"* 0# '2* ,$1/%$. $*%&0"& #0$ 7*-%. 1" ,$0<*)'&5
]./,3 -$4."3+ S'2*$ 80''-*"*)9& &()2 %& ,$*C )0//1&&10"1"3 '**'21"3 '$0(8-*& %$* /%"%3*/*"' '*%/& %"7 )0$$*)'16* &0/* #%)'0$& 420&* ,$08%81-1'. 0# '0,& '21& -1&' 41'2 >T ,*$)*"' 0# '2* $*&,0"7*"'& #**-& '2%' '21& 2%& 2132 '0 /07*$%'* 1/,%)' 0" &)2*7(-* 06*$$("&5
\[/*5*. ec \[.,). "- *<;$4. ") ;3":,4. +4/,#20, *) ,[,42.*") $)# 40"+*)1 ;/$+,
>"234,c JCGD *) ()#*$ ^ CG( >239,% ") 4"+. $)# +4/,#20, "9,332)& UV@U
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 20
21 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
!(34"#9 1HK(341/0 5D[\9 (/& /"/L5D[\9 K#")$34 93J$&=,$ ,$0<*)'& /%"%3*7 8. ,(8-1) &*)'0$ ("1'& "0"CB;E& &()2 %& A%1-4%.& %"7 YWN!5 N-'20(32 /0&' #%)'0$&[&()2 %& 7*&13"@ 2%6* /0$* 0$ -*&& '2* &%/* 1/,%)' 0" 80''-*"*)9 #0$ "0"CB;E ,$0<*)'& 41'2 OO ,*$)*"' 0# $*&,0"7*"'& %3$**1"3 '2%' 0,1"*7 '2%' '21& 2%& %" 1/,%)' 0" ,$0<*)' )0(-7 8* '2%' B;E& 2%6* 1"'*$"%- #("7&
#0$ '2*1$ ,$0<*)'& %"7 '2*. 70":' 7*,*"7 1"6*&'/*"' 7*)1&10"& (, '0 )*$'%1" -1/1' )$0$* #0$ R1"1$%'"% )%'*30$. !! &'%'(& 5 1" 7*)1&10" /%91"3 %& )0/,%$*7 41'2 1"%7*G(%'* %6%1-%81-1'. 0# &91--*7 $*&0($)*& 1& /0$* ,$0/1"*"' #0$ B;E:& ,$0<*)'&5 %3$**1"3 '2%' ,$0<*)'& %$* 7*-%.*7 7(*
\[/*5*. Sc M,$+")+ -"3 ;3":,4. +4/,#20, "9,332) -"3 )")PC>= $)# C>= ;3":,4.+
>"234,c JCGD *) ()#*$ ^ CG( >239,% ") 4"+. $)# +4/,#20, "9,332)& UV@U
0"-. OO ,*$)*"' 0# "0"CB;E $*&,0"7*"'& 0,1"*7 '2%' '21& 2%& %" 1/,%)' 0" ,$0<*)' 7*-16*$.5 !" '2* $*)*"' .*%$& B;E:& %33$*&&16*-. %"7 )0/,*'1"3 41'2 ,$16%'* &*)'0$ #0$ '%-*"'5
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 22
KPMG in India’s point of view ,2%&* %$* %##*)'*7 8. "0" %6%1-%81-1'. 0# )2%"3*& 1" '2* &)0,* %"7 7*&13" 0# ,$0<*)'& ,(&2 ,$0<*)' 7*-16*$. '1/*-1"*&5 ,$0<*)' )2%"3* /%"%3*/*"' 1" )%&* 0# 1"#$%&'$()'($* ,$0<*)'& 1" '2* )0("'$.5 %,,-1)%'10" 0# '00-& %"7 '*)2"1G(*&
#0$ &*%/-*&& 1"'*3$%'10" 0# 71##*$*"' #(")'10"& 0# ,$0<*)'@,$03$%/ %/0"3 '2* ,$0<*)' /%"%3*/*"' ,$0#*&&10"%-& 0#'*" -*%7 '0 7*-%.&5 1"#$%&'$()'($* &*)'0$ -%3& 8*21"7 1'& #0$*13" )0("'*$,%$'& 1" '*$/& 0# 9"04-*73* %"7 ("7*$&'%"71"3 0# -%'*&' '*)2"0-031*& 1" *"31"**$1"3 %& 4*-- %& &-04 ,$03$*&& 0# 1"#$%&'$()'($* ,$0<*)'&5
23 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
B]
7 E 6 ? < ; D
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 24
'$(9"/9 A"# 3"94 "G$##=/9
L"+. 3,9*+*")+ $)# 4"+. "9,332)+ $3, 4"<<") $43"++ *)-3$+.324.23, ;3":,4.+7 F44"3#*)1 ." G">C(& *)-3$+.324.23, ;3":,4.+ *) 4,).3$0 D"9,3)<,). +,4."3 4"+.*)1 (`M @ZV 43"3, $)# $5"9,& $3, 4233,).0% ,[;,3*,)4*)1 42<20$.*9, 4"+. "9,332)+ "- @Y7S ;,34,). @ "- ./,*3 ;0$)),# 4"+.7 ]23 +239,% <$E,+ $) $..,<;. ." *#,).*-% ./, E,% -$4."3+& ,[;,3*,)4,# 5% ;3":,4. "6),3+& 3,+20.*)1 *) 4"+. "9,332)+ *) $ ;3":,4. -3"< ./, ;3, ,[,42.*") +.$1, 2).*0 ./, 40"+, "2. ;/$+,7 1
MoSPI flash report, dated January 2012
25 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
'$(9"/9 A"# <"94 "G$##=/9 1/ K#$L $F$3=41"/ KJ(9$
1/,%)'1"3 )0&' 06*$$("& %&&*&&/*"' 0# '2* $1&9& %"7 /('(%- 1"'*$7*,*"7*")1*& '2%' ,$0<*)'& )0(-7 #%)* 1" '2* 421)2 %##*)' '2* 7*-16*$. 80'2 1" '*$/& 0# '1/* &)2*7(-* %& 4*-- %& 8(73*'*7 )0&'5 7$%41"3 %"7 7*&13"1"3 0# '2* ,$0<*)'& %' '2* '1/* 0# %4%$7 0# )0"'$%)' 1& "0' /%"7%'0$.5 8* *%&1-. /1'13%'*7 8. ,(''1"3 %" *##*)'16* ,$0<*)' /%"%3*/*"' &.&'*/ 1" ,-%)* %"7 ,$06171"3 '$%1"1"3 '0 ,$0<*)' /%"%3*$&5
\[/*5*. @Vc M,$+")+ -"3 4"+. "9,332)+ *) ;3,P,[,42.*") ;/$+,
>"234,c JCGD *) ()#*$ ^ CG( >239,% ") 4"+. $)# +4/,#20, "9,332)& UV@U
UB
T 3,+;")#,).+ $13,, ./$. +4";, 43,,; 0,$#+ ." ;3":,4. 4"+. "9,332)+ *) ./, ;3,P,[,42.*") ;/$+,7
SU
T 3,+;")#,).+ $13,, ./$. *)$#,O2$., ?CM+ 0,$# ." ;3":,4. 4"+. "9,332)+ *) ./, ;3,P,[,42.*") ;/$+,7
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 26
J0&' 06*$$(" 7(* '0 1"%7*G(%'* DBA& 1& *"*$3. %"7 '$%"&,0$' %"7 -031&'1)& &*)'0$ $*&,0"7*"'& %3$** '2%' 1"%7*G(%'* DBA& -*%7 '0 )0&' 06*$$("& 1" '2*1$ $*&,*)'16* &*)'0$&5
\[/*5*. @@c L3*.*4$0*.% "- *)$#,O2$., ?CMX+ $43"++ +,4."3+
I1'2 1")$*%&1"3 1/,0$'%")* 0# $*G(1$* %771'10"%- 8(73*'& N& !"71%" $*3(-%'0$. %3*")1*& '132'*" '2*1$ "00&* 8. 8$1"31"3 1" %771'10"% ,$0<*)' 04"*$& "**7 '0 *"&($* ,$0<*)' )0/,-1%")* 41'2 &'$1"3*"' &%#*'. %"7 *"61$0"/*"' &'%"7%$7&5 N72*$1"3 '0 '2* *60-61"3 *"61$0"/*"' %"7 &%#*'. &'%"7%$7& -*%7& '0 %771'10"%- )0&'&5
UC
T 3,+;")#,).+ -,,0 /*1/ 4"+. "- ,)9*3")<,).$0 +$-,12$3#+ /$+ /*1/ ." <,#*2< ;3"5$5*0*.% "$--,4.*)1 ./, ;3":,4. 4"+.7
!,0,4"< +,4."3 #",+)X. ,[;,3*,)4,# 4"+. "9,332)+ -"3 ./, +239,%,# ;3":,4.+ >"234,c JCGD *) ()#*$ ^ CG( >239,% ") 4"+. $)# +4/,#20, "9,332)& UV@U
\[/*5*. @Uc C3"5$5*0*.% "- 3,$+")+ $--,4.*)1 ;3":,4. 4"+. "9,332)+ *) ;3,P,[,42.*") ;/$+,
$*)*"' .*%$& 2%& #0$)*7 ,$0<*)' 04"*$& '0 1")-(7* *"61$0"/*"'%- &%#*3(%$7& *"61$0"/*"'%- ,0-1)1*& 1" '2* )0("'$. )0"&'$()'10" ,$0<*)' /132' "**7 '0 )0/,-. 41'2 '2*&* &'%"7%$7& /174%. '2* ,$0<*)' )%" #%)* )0&' *&)%-%'10"& 1" '2%' '2* 2132 )0&' 0# '2* *"61$0"/*"'% >M ,*$)*"' %&&13" % 2132 '0 /*71(/ ,$08%81-1'. 0# ,$0<*)' )0&' 06*$$("& 7(* '0 '21& $*%&0"5
>"234,c JCGD *) ()#*$ ^ CG( >239,% ") 4"+. $)# +4/,#20, "9,332)& UV@U
27 | Bridging Study onthe Project Urban Schedule Housingand Shortage Cost Overruns in India
'$(9"/9 A"# 3"94 "G$##=/9 1/ $F$3=41"/ KJ(9$
R%'*$1%- ,$1)* *&)%-%'10" 8*.0"7 ,$0<*)'10"& 1& '2* ,$1/%$. $*%&0" #0$ )0&' *&'1/%'*& 08&0-*'* -*%71"3 '0 )0&' 06*$$("&5 \[/*5*. @Wc M,$+")+ -"3 ;3":,4. 4"+. "9,332)+ *) ,[,42.*") $)# 40"+*)1 ;/$+,
>"234,c JCGD *) ()#*$ ^ CG( >239,% ") 4"+. $)# +4/,#20, "9,332)& UV@U
L")+.324.*") <$.,3*$0 ;3*4,+ /$9, *)43,$+,# +,9,3$0 -"0#+ *) 0$+. -,6 %,$3+& *<;$4.*)1 ./, ;3":,4. 4"+. ,+.*<$.,+7 >$/$#(, .(/(0$#: <1G1, NG1(41"/ D$34"#
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 28
06*$ '2* %3$**7 ,*$)*"'%3* -*%7& '0 71&,('* 8*'4**" ,$0<*)' 04"*$& %"7 8*'4**" 0"* 0# '2* !"71%:& -%$3*&' ;'%'* 04"*7 ,04*$ 3*"*$%'10" )0/,%". %"7 1'& 1"1'1%- *G(1,/*"' &(,,-1*$ 0" ,$1)* '40 .*%$&K5
*&'1/%'10" 7($1"3 ,$0<*)' )0&' &)2*7(-1"3 %$* "0' %7*G(%'* '0 )06*$ %-- %&,*)'& )0&' 1'*/& '2%' %$* "*)*&&%$. #0$ '2* ,$0<*)' 8(73*' *&'1/%'10" $*/%1" *1'2*$ %' '2* ,-%""1"3 &'%3* %"7 -*%7 '0 )0&' 06*$$("& %' % -%'*$ &'%3*5 B$0<*)' '*%/& % $*%-1&'1) 8(73*' *&'1/%'* #0$ '2* ,$0<*)'5
V]
T 3,+;")#,).+ -,,0 <$.,3*$0 ;3*4, ,+4$0$.*")+ 5,%")# ;3":,4.*")+ 0,$# ." 4"+. "9,332)+7
/%'*$1%- )0&' 1& /0&' &(&)*,'18-* '0 *&)%-%'10" #0--04*7 8. -%80$ 0$ /%",04*$ )0&'5 T> ,*$)*"' $*&,0"7*"'& #**- '2%' 1",(' /%'*$1%-& %$* /0&' &(&)*,'18-* '0 &(##*$ %" *&)%-%'10"5 I21-* 0"-. M? ,*$)*"' $*&,0"7*"'& 0,1"* '2%' J0"'$%)'0$@&(8 )0"'$%)'0$ )0&'& %$* 2132-. #*-' '2%' /%"(#%)'($*7 *G(1,/*"' )0&' 2%6* % 2132 &(&)*,'181-1'. #0$ *&)%-%'10"5
SU
T 3,+;")#,).+ -,,0 <$.,3*$0 4"+.+ $3, /*1/0% +2+4,;.*50, ." ,+4$0$.*")+7
\[/*5*. @_c L"+. ,0,<,).+X +2+4,;.*5*0*.% ." *)43,$+,
>"234,c JCGD *) ()#*$ ^ CG( >239,% ") 4"+. $)# +4/,#20, "9,332)& UV@U
2
“Contract disputes delay NTPC’s Barh project”, Livemint, 1 May 2008
29 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
C""3 4")),4.*9*.% ." ;3":,4. +*., !"#$%&'$()'($* ,$0<*)'& -0)%'*7 1" $*/0'* -0)%'10"& 2%6* ,00$ '$%"&,0$' '$%"&,0$'%'10" %"7 -031&'1)& 1"#$%&'$()'($* ,$0<*)' -0)%'*7 1" % 21--. '*$$%1" 41'2 "0 0" $0%7& #0$ 1'& $%4 /%'*$1%- &(,,-1*&5 )0"&(/1"3 %"7 )0&'-1*$ 1" )0/,%$1&0" '0 $*&,0"7*"'& #*-' '2%' ,00$ )0""*)'161'. '0 ,$0<*)' &1'* 2%& 2132 '0 /*71(/ ,$08%81-1'. 0# 1/,%)'1"3 '2* ,$0<*)' )0&'5
()$#,O2$., $9$*0$5*0*.% "- +E*00,# 3,+"234,+ %7*G(%'* %6%1-%81-1'. 0# &91--*7 $*&0($)*& %,,*%$*7 %& )$1'1)%- #%)'0$ #0$ &())*&& 0# ,$0<*)'5 S41"3 '0 '2* %771'10"%*/,-0./*"' &(,,0$' &)2*/*& '2* -0)%--. %6%1-%8-* */,-0./*"' 40$9#0$)* #0$ )0"&'$()'10" 40$9& 2%&
N,%$' #$0/ '2* 71$*)' /%",04*$ $*G(1$*7 ,$0<*)' /%"%3*/*"' ,*$&0""*- %$* )0/,*"&%'10"& -*%71"3 '0 )0&' 06*$$("&5
\[/*5*. @Zc C3"5$5*0*.% "- 3,$+")+ $--,4.*)1 ;3":,4. 4"+. "9,332)+ *) ,[,42.*") $)# 40"+*)1 ;/$+,
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
>"234,c JCGD *) ()#*$ ^ CG( >239,% ") 4"+. $)# +4/,#20, "9,332)& UV@U
UT
T 3,+;")#,).+ -,,0 ./$. 0"4$.*") $)# 4")),4.*9*.% "- ;3":,4. +*., /$+ /*1/ ." <,#*2< ;3"5$5*0*.% "$--,4.*)1 ./, ;3":,4. 4"+.7 3
306 Flash report on central sector projects, MoSPI, April 2011
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 30
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
!(34"#9 1HK(341/0 5D[\9 (/& /"/L5D[\9 K#")$34 3"94 1/,%)' 0" '2* &)2*7(-* 06*$$(" %"7 '2* )0&' 06*$$("5 '0 ,$0<*)' )0&' 06*$$("5 !' 2%& 8**" 08&*$6*7 '2%' B;E& 80$$04 /0"*. #$0/ 8%"9@-*"7*$& %' /%$9*'C7*'*$/1"*7 1"'*$*&' $%'*& '0 #("7 '2*1$ ,$0<*)'& 42*$*%& "0"CB;E ,$0<*)'& %$* ,$1/%$1-. 7*-16*$1"3 '2* ,$0<*)'5 UU ,*$)*"' 0# B;E $*&,0"7*"'& %3$** 42*$*%& 0"-. PT ,*$)*"' 0# "0"CB;E $*&,0"7*"'& *)20*7 '2* #0$ 8*''*$ ,$0)($*/*"' /%"%3*/*"' 0# B;E ,$0<*)'&5 S'2*$
)0(-7 8* *%&1-. )0"'$0--%8-* 41'2 4*-*&'%8-1&2*7 ,$0<*)' /%"%3*/*"' '*)2"1G(*&5
\[/*5*. @Yc M,$+")+ -"3 ;3":,4. 4"+. "9,332) -"3 )")PC>= $)# C>= ;3":,4.+
>"234,c JCGD *) ()#*$ ^ CG( >239,% ") 4"+. $)# +4/,#20, "9,332)& UV@U
31 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
KPMG in India’s point of view '2* )0("'$. 2%& 8**" )0"&(/1"3 % /%<0$ ,$0<*)' #("71"3 2%7 8**" 1" '2* 70/%1" ,$16%'* ,-%.*$& 2%6* %-&0 6*"'($*7 1"'0 '2* "**7 #0$ )0&' )0"'$0- *6*" /0$* #%)1"3 2(3* )0&' 06*$$("& 7(* '0 /(-'1,-* $*%&0"& $%"31"3 #$0/ 7*-%.*7 %,,$06%-& '0 &)0,* )$**, %"7 &20$'%3* 0# ,$0<*)' ,$0#*&&10"%-& '0 ,$1)* *&)%-%'10"& %"7 )0"'$%)'(%- 71&,('*&5
N-'20(32 (")0"'$0--%8-* #%)'0$& &()2 '2%' "**7 '0 8* %77$*&&*7 41'2C1" '1/* '0 2%6* $*,*%'*7-. #%1-*7 '0 %77$*&& '2* 1&&(*& $*-%'*7 '0 )0"'$%)'& %7/1"1&'$%'10" &(8&'%"'1%--.5
$*%-1&'1) *&'1/%'* )%" 30 % -0"3 4%. 1" ,$06171"3 %))($%'* %"7 '1/*-. 1"#0$/%'10" '0 $*-*6%"' %('20$1'1*& '0 '%9* /0$* %$* (&(%--. 7(* '0 '2* -%)9 0# 1"#0$/%'10" '2%' ,-%""1"3 %"7 1/,-*/*"'1"3 %3*")1*&
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 32
33 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
BT
7 E 6 ? < ; D
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 34
D$34"#L%19$ 1HK(34 "A A(34"#9 "/ 3"94 (/& 93J$&=,$ "G$##=/9
!/, $-"3,<,).*"),# -$4."3+ /$9, $ 9$3%*)1 #,13,, "- *<;$4. ") ./, ;3":,4. #,0*9,3% -3"< "), +,4."3 ." $)"./,37 A"3 ,[$<;0,& 4"$0 +,4."3 *+ <"3, +,)+*.*9, ." 3,120$."3% $;;3"9$0+& $+
$)# *. .$E,+ $3"2)# WPZ %,$3+ -"3 $4O2*3*)1 $00 3,O2*+*., -"3,+. $)# ,)9*3")<,).$0 40,$3$)4,+7 ]) ./, "./,3 /$)#& .,0,4"< ;3":,4.+ $3, 0,$+. *<;$4.,# ") $44"2). "- 3,120$."3% $;;3"9$0+7 >*<*0$30%& +4";, 43,,;+ $3, 4"<<") *) $*3;"3. *)-3$+.324.23, ;3":,4.+ <$*)0% #2, ." ./, ),,# ." $44"<<"#$., $00*,# +,39*4,+ H+24/ $+ *<<*13$.*")& 42+."<& ,.4I7 A"00"6*)1 +,4.*") ;3"9*#,+ +,4."3P6*+, $)$0%+*+ "- /"6 9$3*"2+ -$4."3+ $--,4. ./, +4/,#20, $)# 4"+. "9,332)+7
35 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
M,$+")+ -"3 +4/,#20, "9,332) $43"++ +,4."3+
M$*06$%+
M"$#+ N 8*1/6$%+
C"3. N +/*;;*)1
!,0,4"<<2P )*4$.*")
!"*##*)'16* ,$0)($*/*"' ,-%""1"3
D*&13"@&)0,* )2%"3*
I*%9@1"*##*)'16* ,$0<*)' /0"1'0$1"3
!"%7*G(%'* %6%1-%81-1'. 0# &91--*7 $*&0($)*&
J0"'$%)'(%- 71&,('*&
F%)9 0# %4%$*"*&& 0# /07*$" *G(1,/*"'
82<$) 3,+"234,+
C,.3"0,2<
C"6,3
L"$0
>.,,0
F%"7@&1'* 2%"706*$
D*-%. 1" $*3(-%'0$. %,,$06%-&
A*-%'10"&21, 41'2 0'2*$ ,$0<*)'&
>"234,c
]*$. 2132 1/,%)'
L*9*0 F9*$P .*")
W132 1/,%)'
R07*$%'* 1/,%)'
F04 1/,%)'
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 36
M,$+")+ -"3 4"+. "9,332) $43"++ +,4."3+
C,.3"0,2<
C"6,3
L"$0
>.,,0
L*9*0 F9*$P .*")
M$*06$%+
M"$#+ N 8*1/6$%+
C"3. N +/*;P ;*)1
;)0,* )$**,
D*&13" )2%"3*@1'*$%'10"&
W132 )0&' 0# *"61$0"/*"'%&%#*3(%$7&
N)G(1&1'10" 0# -%"7 %' /%$9*' ,$1)*
!"%7*G(%'* DBA
I*%9 ,$0)($*/*"' ,-%""1"3
R%'*$1%- ,$1)* *&)%-%'10"& 8*.0"7 ,$0<*)'10"&
B00$ &*-*)'10" 0# )0"&(-'%"'
F0)%'10" %"7 )0""*)'161'. 0# ,$0<*)' &1'*
82<$) 3,+"234,+
]*$. 2132 1/,%)'
`".,c >"234,c
W132 1/,%)'
R07*$%'* 1/,%)'
F04 1/,%)'
37 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
B^
7 E 6 ? < ; D
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 38
.1410(41"/ 94#(4$01$9 Y _$,K1/0 K#")$34 &$,1G$#-
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
39 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
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
*+ $) ,--,4.*9, 6$% -"3 <")*."3*)1 ;3":,4.+ '0 )0&' %"7 &)2*7(-* 06*$$(" %"7 %--04 )0/,%"1*& '0 '%9* )0$$*)'16* %)'10"& 1"7*,*"7*"' 807. 71$*)'-. $*,0$'1"3 '0 '2* ^0%$7 0# D1$*)'0$& %80(' '2* ,$03$*&& 0# ,$0<*)' %"7 &(,,0$'& 06*$&132' 0" '2* ,$0<*)'&5 !' 7$16*& &())*&&#( 1/,-*/*"'%'10" 0# -*%71"3 ,$0<*)' ,$0<*)' %3%1"&' $1&9& %"7 *"&($1"3 %7*G(%'* 3(17%")* %"7 1"#0$/%'10" #0$ '1/*-. 7*)1&10"C/%91"35 !/,-*/*"'1"3 % BRS )0(-7 2*-, 1" %)21*61"3 '2* #0--041"3
3-08%--. *&'%8-1&2*7 &'%"7%$7& 1/,$06*& '2* %))*,'%81-1'. 0# '2* 7*-16*$%8-*& 40$-7417*5
'$%)9& '2* &'%'(& 0# '2* ,$0<*)'& %"7 *&'%8-1&2*7 /*'2070-031*& %' $*3(-%$ *"%8-1"3 '1/*-. 7*)1&10" /%91"3 8. '2* $*-*6%"' %('20$1'1*&5
(<;3"9,# $4423$4% "- ;3":,4. ,+.*<$.,+c 0# '2* ,0'*"'1%- $1&9& %"7 8*")2/%$9& 0# '2* '$%1"*7 ,$0#*&&10"%-& $*7()*& '2* )2%")*& 0# *$$0$& 1" 71##*$*"' *&'1/%'10"&5
M,#24,# 4%40, .*<, $)# #,0*9,3% 4"+.+c
(<;3"9,# ;,";0, $)# 3,+"234, <$)$1,<,).c
&'%"7%$7 &*' 0# ,$0<*)' /%"%3*/*"' *"%8-*& ,$0<*)' /%"%3*$& 41'2 %" *&'%8-1&2*7 %"7 '*&'*7 /07(-* #0$ 8*''*$ /%"%3*/*"' %"7 /0"1'0$1"3 0# ,$0<*)'&5 )0/,0"*"'& 2*-, ,$0<*)'& '0 *"3%3* '2* -*%$"1"3 '1/* #0$ '2* ,$0<*)' '*%/ 421-* %7%,'1"3 '0 '2* -1/1'%'10"& %"7 ("1G(*"*&& 0# % ,$0<*)'5
/*"'0$& /%"%3*$& '0 8(1-7 )0$* ,$0<*)' /%"%3*/*"' )0/,*'*")1*&5 !" )*$'%1" $*&0($)*& 8*'4**" 6%$10(& ,$0<*)'& #0$/1"3 ,%$' 0# % )0//0" ,$03$%/ 0# '2*&* $*&0($)*&5
(<;3"9,# O2$0*.% "- ;3":,4. #,0*9,3$50,+c 1"'*$"%'10"%- 8*&' ,$%)'1)*& (&*7 %'
M,P2+, "- E)"60,#1, $)# ./, $5*0*.% ." 0,9,3$1, ./$. E)"60,#1, ") 4233,). d -2.23, ;3":,4.+c $*,0&1'0$. 0# 9*. -*%$"1"3:& #$0/ % ,$0<*)' = ,*$'%1"1"3 '0 8*&' ,$%)'1)*& -*%$"1"3 %$* 71&&*/1"%'*7 '0 %- %"7 %,,-1*7 '0 )($$*"'@#('($* ,$0<*)'& '2(& %60171"3 '2* $1&9 0# &1/1-%$ 1&&(*& %' 71##*$*"' ,$0<*)'&5
]23 4"<;$)% /$+ $ 4")4,;. "- ().,13$.,# C3":,4. G$)$1,<,). H(CGI& 2)#,3 6/*4/ $00 #,;$3.<,).+ 3,0$.,# ." $ ;3":,4. #*3,4.0% 3,;"3. ." ./, ;3":,4. \[,42.*9, ?*3,4."3 H\?I7 3,;"3. ." ./, ;3":,4. \?7 !/*+ $9"*#+ 523,$243$.*4 #,0$%+ 6*./*) ./, "31$)*+$.*") $)# -$4*0*.$.,+ -$+.,3 #,4*+*") <$E*)17 ;F$3=41G$ 21#$34"#: D4$$, .(/=A(34=#1/0 <"HK(/-
1
PMI-KPMG study on drivers for success in infrastructure projects 2010 – Managing for change
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 40
PMO Role
PMO Responsibilities
PMO Manager
PMO Management; Quality Management; Stakeholder Management
Planner
Work plan/ milestone Management; Scope management
Coordinator
Project Support: Scope, integration, change and resource management
Controller
Financial Management
Program Administration Support
Project Support: General Administration
Project Information
Internal and external project communication (not change management)
Project Stream Lead
All typical PMO responsibilities for each of the work streams
R0"1'0$ ,$0<*)' ,*$#0$/%")* %3%1"&' '2* &*' '%$3*'& %"7 %)' %& %" 1"#0$/%'10" )*"'*$ 0" ,$0<*)' ,$03$*&& ;*'C(, %"7 7*,-0. &'%"7%$7 #0$ ,$0<*)' 1/,-*/*"'%'10" R*"'0$ B$0<*)' /%"%3*$& #0$ #('($* ,$0<*)' "**7& B$0617* )0"&(-'1"3 &(,,0$' 0" ,$0<*)' ,-%""1"3 %"7 1/,-*/*"'%'10" J0"7()' ,0$'#0-10 /%"%3*/*"' 15*5 /0"1'0$ 1"'*$ ,$0<*)'
UT ,*$)*"' 0# '2* $*&,0"7*"'& #*-' '2* "**7 #0$ %" 1"7*,*"7*"' BRS #0$ /0"1'0$1"3 ,$0<*)' %"7 ,0&1'16*-. $*%)'*7 1" 1'& ,0'*"'1%- '0 /%"%3* )0&' %"7 &)2*7(-* 06*$$("&5
>"234,c JCGD *) ()#*$ ^ CG( >239,% ") 4"+. $)# +4/,#20, "9,332)& UV@U
41 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
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
\[/*5*. @ec =+$1, "- 3*+E <$)$1,<,). .,4/)*O2,+ -"3 *#,).*-%*)1 $)# <")*."3*)1 3*+E
>"234,c JCGD *) ()#*$ ^ CG( >239,% ") 4"+. $)# +4/,#20, "9,332)& UV@U
\[/*5*. @Sc \--,4.*9,),++ "- 3*+E <$)$1,<,). ;3$4.*4,+
>"234,c JCGD *) ()#*$ ^ CG( >239,% ") 4"+. $)# +4/,#20, "9,332)& UV@U
2
315 Flash report on central sector projects, MoSPI, January 2012
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 42
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
(<;3"9, 3*+E <$)$1,<,). +E*00+ -"3 +244,++-20 ;3":,4. #,0*9,3%
\[/*5*. UVc (<;$4. "- 3*+E+ ") ;3":,4. #,0*9,3%
>"234,c JCGD *) ()#*$ ^ CG( >239,% ") 4"+. $)# +4/,#20, "9,332)& UV@U
\[/*5*. U@c >.3$.,1*,+ ." ,)/$)4, 3*+E <$)$1,<,). *) ;3":,4.+
1/,$061"3 $1&9 /%"%3*/*"' 1" ,$0<*)'& 1& '0 *"2%")* '2* $1&9 /%"%3*/*"' '2* $*&,0"7*"'& 8*-1*6* '2%' 1/,%$'1"3 '$%1"1"3 '0 ,$0<*)' '*%/ #0$ 17*"'1#.1"3 71&)(&&10" 41'2 $*&,0"7*"'& 2132-132'*7 '2%' /%<0$1'. 0# '2* ,$0<*)' '*%/& 2%6*":' $*)*16*7 %". #0$/%- ,$0<*)' 0$ $1&9 /%"%3*/*"' '$%1"1"35 D*6*-0,1"3 ,$0<*)' $1&9 /%"%3*/*"' $*61*4& %"7 7*6*-0,1"3 $1&9 /%"%3*/*"' $*,0$'& %$* &0/* 0'2*$ #%)'0$& '2%' )0(-7 ,0&1'16*-. 1/,%)' '2* $1&9 /%"%3*/*"' 1" ,$0<*)'&5
>"234,c JCGD *) ()#*$ ^ CG( >239,% ") 4"+. $)# +4/,#20, "9,332)& UV@U
43 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
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
\[/*5*. UUc L"<<")0% $#";.,# +.3$.,1*,+ ." 4").3"0 ;3":,4. +4/,#20, #,0$%+
>"234,c JCGD *) ()#*$ ^ CG( >239,% ") 4"+. $)# +4/,#20, "9,332)& UV@U
\[/*5*. UWc \--,4.*9,),++ "- ;3":,4. <")*."3*)1 .""0+
/%1"'%1" ,*$1071) $1&9 /%"%3*/*"' $*,0$'& '0 17*"'1#. '2* ,$08%8-* ,$0<*)' &,-1' '2* 6%$10(& &'%3*& 0# '2* ,$0<*)' 1"'0 &/%--*$ )0/,0"*"'& '0 '$%)9 '2* '%$3*' %)21*6*/*"' 0" % $*3(-%$ 8%&1&5 )-0&*$ /0"1'0$1"35 B$0<*)' $*61*4& 8. '21$7 ,%$'1*& 1& %"0'2*$ '*)2"1G(* '0 $*61*4 ,$0<*)'&5 !"7*,*"7*"' $*61*4& 8. '21$7 ,%$'1*& ,$0617* %" 08<*)'16* 0,1"10" 0" '2* 1" 8$1"31"3 "*4 17*%& %"7 8$*%9 &20$' &132'*7 '21"91"35 B$0<*)' ,-%"& %-&0 &(##*$ 7(* '0 -%)9 0# %" 1"'*$"%'10"%- %1$,0$' 1" *%&'*$" !"71% $*G(1$*7 '2* 7*/0-1'10" 0# %" 0-7 8(1-71"3 421)2 &'%'10"*7 )$1'1)%- #%)1-1'1*& &()2
>"234,c JCGD *) ()#*$ ^ CG( >239,% ") 4"+. $)# +4/,#20, "9,332)& UV@U
%"7 3*"*$%'0$ $00/ #0$ '2* #(")'10"1"3 '*%/ ("%8-* '0 %&&*&& '2* )$1'1)%-1'. 0# '2* 8(1-71"3 %"7 2*")* 717 "0' &(33*&' %" %,,$0,$1%'* $*-0)%'10" 0# '2* #%)1-1'1*& '2* 7*-%. 1" 7*/0-1'10" 0# '2* 0-7 8(1-71"3 %"7 %##*)'*7 '2* '1/* &)2*7(-* 0# '2* ,$0<*)'5
B$0<*)' $*,0$'& %"7 ,$0<*)' /%"%3*/*"' '00-& %$* $%'*7 %& /0&' *##*)'16* '00 7%&280%$75
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 44
M*+E $)# 3,6$3# ;3"13$< -"3 ;3":,4. <$)$1,<,). .,$<+d4").3$4."3+ $3, 2+,# "44$+*")$00% A1&9 %"7 $*4%$7 ,$03$%/ #0$ ,$0<*)' /%"%3*/*"' '*%/& %"7 )0"'$%)'0$& %$* "0' )0//0" 1" )0/,%$1&0" '0 0'2*$ ,*$)*"' $*&,0"7*"'& #$*G(*"'-. (&*7 $1&9 %"7 $*4%$7 ,$03$%/ %& % /*%&($* #0$ )0"'$0--1"3 &)2*7(-* 06*$$("&5 D(* '0 -%)9 )0"'$%)'0$& %"7 &(8)0"'$%)'0$& %$* "0' /0'16%'*7 *"0(32 '0 '%9* 1"'*$*&' 8*.0"7 '2* ,$0<*)' /%"%3*/*"' '*%/& 7*&1&' #$0/ 1"'$07()1"3 1""06%'16* /06*& #0$
$*4%$7 ,$03$%/ 1" '2* ,$0<*)' ,-%" #0$ %,,$0,$1%'*-. $*4%$71"3 '2* ,$0<*)' '*%/ %"7 '2* )0"'$%)'0$& #0$ /**'1"3 $1&9C$*4%$7 ,$03$%//*7 &20(-7 8* /%""*$ &0 '2%' 1' /0'16%'*& "0' 0"-. '2* '0, -*6*- ,*$&0""*- 0# '2* ,$0<*)' %' %-- '2* -*6*-& 0# '2* '*%/5 !")*"'16*& *")0($%31"3 '2* ,$0<*)' '*%/ '0 %,,-. 1""06%'16* '*)2"1G(*& #0$ /**'1"3 '2*
45 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
>.3$.,1*,+ ." 4").3"0 4"+. D(* '0 '2* -0"3 3*&'%'10" ,*$107 0# 1")-(7* )0&' *&)%-%'10" )-%(&* %& % ,%$' 0# '2* )0"'$%)' %3$**/*"'5 TP ,*$)*"' 0# '2* $*&,0"7*"'& (&* '21& &'$%'*3. '0 )0&' *##*)'16* ,$0<*)' 7*&13"& %"7 <01"' *6%-(%'10" 0# ,$0<*)' 7*&13" #0$ 6%-(* *"31"**$1"3 1& %-&0 (&*7 #$*G(*"'-.5
\[/*5*. U_c >.3$.,1*,+ 2+,# ." 4").3"0 ;3":,4. 4"+. "9,332)+
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
>"234,c JCGD *) ()#*$ ^ CG( >239,% ") 4"+. $)# +4/,#20, "9,332)& UV@U
4").3$4. 6*./ ./, 9,)#"3& ./2+ $)% 4"+. *)43,$+, *+ 5"3), 5% ./, 4").3$4."37 >$/$#(, .(/(0$#: ?$,$3"H 3"HK(/-
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 46
(++2,+ -$4,# *) $#";.*)1 4").3"0 +.3$.,1*,+ 1" %70,'1"3 &)2*7(-* )0"'$0- &'$%'*31*&5 UT ,*$)*"' 0# 0($ &($6*. $*&,0"7*"'& &(33*&' '2%' '2*. %$* ("%8-* '0 %70,' )0"'$0--1"3 &'$%'*31*& 0" '1/* 7(* '0 &'$1"3*"' #$0/ 7%. '0 7%. 0,*$%'10"& $*G(1$*& %" %,,$06%- #$0/ 2132*$ %('20$1'1*&5 N"0'2*$ /%<0$ $*%&0" 2132-132'*7 1" '2* &($6*. 1" %70,'1"3 '2* /1'13%'10" &'$%'*3. 1& '2*
\[/*5*. UZc (++2,+ -$4,# *) $#";.*)1 ./, +4/,#20, 4").3"0 +.3$.,1*,+
>"234,c JCGD *) ()#*$ ^ CG( >239,% ") 4"+. $)# +4/,#20, "9,332)& UV@U
47 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
BS
7 E 6 ? < ; D
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 48
5#")$34 H(/(0$H$/4 Y 5#"G$/ H$4J"& A"# 9=33$99A=, &$,1G$#-
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
49 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
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
'*)2"1)%- )2%--*"3*& %-0"3 41'2 &*"&1'161'. 1" 3*"*$%- ,(8-1) %"7 ,0-1'1)%- &)*"%$10 2%6* "0' 0"-. 1"7()*7 '2* "**7 #0$ 08<*)'161'. @ 1"7*,*"7*"' 0,1"10" @ 6%-(*7 %-&0 0" (&%3* 0# %&&0$'/*"' 0# ,$0<*)' ,$%)'1)*&5 N8&*")* 0# $08(&' B$0<*)' R%"%3*/*"' $*-%'1"3 '0 $*&0($)* ("%6%1-%81-1'. %"7 0$ $*&(-'1"3 1" 71&,('*& #($'2*$ -*%71"3 '0 )0"&17*$%8-* $*&0($)* &,*"71"3 0" 2*%6. &'$*&& 0" ,-%""1"3 %"7 /%"%3*/*"' '00-&
*"61$0"/*"' !"%))($%'* #0$*)%&'& 0" (&%3* /%$9*' )0"71'10"& %"7 1//1"*"' '*)2"0-031)%- 80''-*"*)9& D(* 71-13*")* 7*)1&10"& %"7 %&)*$'%1"/*"' 0# $1&9& @ )2%"3*& 1" 7*)1&10" /%91"3 ,$0)*&& N8&*")* 0# "*4 17*%& 8*1"3 8$0(32' 1" )%(&1"3 &20$' &132'*7 2%81'& %"7 '21"91"35
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 50
51 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
BU
7 E 6 ? < ; D
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 52
'$9"=#3$ 9J"#4(0$ Y 5,(0=1/0 4J$ 0#"%4J "A 4J$ 9$34"#
!/, ()#*$) ()-3$+.324.23, +,4."3 ;0$%+ $) *<;"3.$). 3"0, *) ./, ()#*$ 13"6./ +."3% +,39*4*)1 ./, ),,#+ "- ./, 5"./ ;250*4 $)# ;3*9$., +,4."3+7 !/, +,4."3 /$+ $ /21, <20.*;0*,3 ,--,4. ") ./, 13"6./ "- ./, ,4")"<%7 8"6,9,3& *. -$4,+ <$);"6,3 4/$00,)1,+& 6/*4/ $3, #,.3*<,).$0 ." ./, 13"6./ "- ./, +,4."37
53 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
% 7*%$'2 0# &91--*7 /%",04*$ %)$0&& &*)'0$& %"7 '21& &20$'%3* )%" 2%6* %" %76*$&* 1/,%)' 0" '2* 7*-16*$. %"7 &91--*7 ,$0<*)' /%"%3*$& 1& ,$061"3 '0 8* )2%--*"3* 1" '2* !"71%" !"#$%&'$()'($* &*)'0$ %"7 '21& &1'(%'10" 1" -19*-. '0 3*' *6*" '2* )($$*"' *7()%'10" &.&'*/ 1& ("%8-* '0 7*-16*$ '2* $*G(1$*7 "(/8*$ 0# &,*)1%-1&'& %)$0&& '2* ,$0<*)' *"31"**$& 41'2 '2* 7*&1$*7 ,$0<*)' /%"%3*/*"' &91-- &*'& '0 '%9* (, -%$3*$ $0-*&5
$*&,0"7*"'& #**- '2%' -%)9 0# ,$0<*)' %,,%$*"' %)$0&& 6%$10(& &*)'0$& %& 4*--5 $*&,0"7*"'& 1" '2* *"*$3. &*)'0$ #**- '2%' -%)9 0# &91--*7 ,$0<*)' /%"%3*$& 1& % /%<0$ )%(&* 0# )0")*$"5
>,4."3P6*+, +/"3.$1, "- +E*00,# ;3"-,++*")$0 P F 4$2+, "- 4")4,3) $43"++ +,4."3 +
>"234,c JCGD *) ()#*$ ^ CG( >239,% ") 4"+. $)# +4/,#20, "9,332)& UV@UQ JCGD *) ()#*$ $)$0%+*+
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 54
a$4E "- +E*00,# ;3":,4. <$)$1,3+ *+ ./, 3"". 4$2+, -" 3 ./, .*<, "9,332)+ *) $ ;3":,4.
>,4."3P6*+, +/"3.$1, "- +E*00,# ;3"-,++*")$0 P F 4$2+, "- 4")4,3) $43"++ +,4."3 +
>"234,c CG(PJCGD +239,% ") 4"+. $)# +4/,#20, "9,332)
2132-132'*7 1" '2* JCGD ().,3)$.*")$0X+ D0"5$0 L")+.324.*") >239,% UV@U *)#*4$.,+
./$. $5"2. _Z ;,34,). "- ./, 3,+;")#,).+ *) ./, F>CFL 3,1*") $3, 0,++ ;,++*<*+.*4
4").*)2*)1 6"33%7
a$4E "- $9$*0$5*0*.% "- +E*00,# 0$5"23 *+ $) *++2,7 >$/$#(, .(/(0$#: 5"%$# >$/$#(41"/ 3"HK(/-
55 | Bridging the Urban Housing Shortage in India
8=1,&1/0 <(K(@1,141$9 Y 5(#(H"=/4 4"
!"71%" *)0"0/. 2%& 8**" 41'"*&&1"3 % 2(3* &,%'* 0# 1"#$%&'$()'($%- 1"6*&'/*"'& 06*$ '2* -%&' #*4 .*%$& %"7 '2* '$*"7 1& 80("7 '0 )0"'1"(* #0$ '2* )0/1"3 .*%$& %& 4*--5 I* 2%6* 8**" 41'"*&&*& '0 '2* &'$0"3 %"7 &(&'%1"*7 3$04'2 ,04*$*7 ,$1/%$1-. 8. 1"6*&'/*"' 1" 6%$10(& 1"#$%&'$()'($* &*3/*"'&5 J0"&'$()'10" 1& '2* &*)0"7 -%$3*&' *)0"0/1) %)'161'. 1 " !"71% %#'*$ %3$1)(-'($* 1" '*$/& 0# */,-0./*"' %"7 2%& 8**" 3$041"3 %' % ,%)* "*6*$ &**" 8*#0$*M 0# '2* /%1" &'$*%/5
?,<$)# -"3 4")+.324.*") ;3"-,++*")$0+ *+ 13"6*)1 *) ()#*$ %" 1")$*%&* 1" 7*/%"7 #0$ '2* )0"&'$()'10" ,$0#*&&10"%-& %)$0&& '2* ,$0<*)' /%"%3*/*"' ).)-*5 K5
M,O2*3,<,). "- /2<$) 3,+"234,+ -"3 4")+.324.*") *)#2+.3% HfVVVX+I 82<$) 3,+"234,+
UV@V
?KU
TO>
J-*$1)%-
;91--*7 40$9*$&
E"&91--*7 40$9*$&
!".$0
UVUU P A"3,4$+.,#
WZVVV
>"234,c
1 2
MoSPI, January 2012 Flash Report “An approach to the 12th Five year plan”,Planning Commiss ion, October 2011, p123
PT?TL
SUVVV
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 56
1"7(&'$. 40(-7 $*G(1$* 8*'4**" O5T = P5K /1--10" ,$0#*&&10"%- 421)2 1& %$0("7 #0($ 5
?,<$)# "- +E*00,# 4")+.324.*") ;3"-,++*")$0+ 5% ./, ,)# "- UVUU H*) fVVVX+I C3"-,++*")$0+
UV@V P \+.*<$.,#
UVUU ^ A"3,4$+.,#
B$0<*)' /%"%3*$&
>L
J161- *"31"**$&
UMP
B-%""*$&
PL
;($6*.0$&
PL
_(%-1'. )0"'$0- ,$0#*&&10"%-&
MLL
PL
!".$0
@@WZ
_ZeZPZ@SV
>"234,c
b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
3 4 5
KPMG in India Analysis factoring the investment projections and distributio n of human resources in infrastructure sector “India lagging China in project management”, The Economic Times, 18 June 2010 “A High-Tech Titan Pl agued by Potholes”, The NewYork Times, 25 August 2010
N"0'2*$ $*%&0" 1& '2* "(/8*$ 0# &'(7*"'& '2%' )0(-7 *"$0-#0$ )161- *"31"**$1"3 )0($&*& 2%& "0' 1")$*%&*7 /()2 1" &)1*")* %"7 0'2*$ 1"#0$/%'10" '*)2"0-03. ,$03$%/& $*%)2*7 '0 P5
57 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
>2;;0% "- +E*00,# 4")+.324.*") ;3"-,++*")$0+ 5% ./, ,)# "- UVUU H*) fVVVX+I Y C3"-,++*")$0+
UVUU P A"3,4$+.,# +2;;0%
B$0<*)' /%"%3*$&
MKL
J161- *"31"**$&
MOLL
B-%""*$&
?L
;($6*.0$&
UP
_(%-1'. )0"'$0- ,$0#*&&10"%-&
M>L
UP
!".$0
@SZV
>"234,c
40$9*$& */,-0.*7 %)$0&& %-- )%'*30$1*& 40$9#0$)* 2%& 8**" )0"&1&'*"'-. 301"3 8*'4**" 7*/%"7 %"7 &(,,-. 0# &91--*7 ,$0#*&&10"%-& 1/,%)'1"3 '2* ,$0<*)'
,*$)*"' 0# '2* '0'%- 7*/%"7> 1" &91--*7 40$9*$& ,$0,0$'10" 8$1"3& 0(' '2* "**7 #0$ &91-- 7*6*-0,/*"' 0# '2* 40$9*$& */,-0.*7 1" '2* 1"7(&'$.5
>/"3.$1, "- C3":,4. C3"-,++*")$0+ *) UVUU
>"234,c `>?L P g2*0#*)1& L")+.324.*") $)# M,$0 \+.$., >,39*4,+ >,4."3 HUVUUIQ JCGD *) ()#*$ F)$0%+*+
6 7
KPMG in India Analysis assuming number of students passing out each year and percentage of students joining the infrastructure industry KPMG in India Analysis assuming number of students passing out each year and percentage of students joining the infrastructure industry
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 58
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
1"&'1'('*& 41'2 '2* )%,%81-1'. '0 &)%-*5 ,$0617*$& '0 %''$%)' /0$* &)200- -*%6*$& 1"7(&'$.5 1"7(&'$.5 J0/,%"1*& &20(-7 %- &0 &**9 '0 &'%. 1" '0()2 41'2 )2%"31"3 */,-0.** %&,1$%'10"&5 ^. *")0($%31"3 716*$&1'. 1" &*)'0$ )%" $*%)2 0(' '0 % 417*$ ,0'*"'1%%(71*")* '2%' ,*$2%,& 40(-7 "0' ,$*610(&-. 2%6* )0"&17*$*7 &()2 % )%$**$5 )%$**$5 0" '$%1"1"3 %"7 2132*$ &%-%$1*& 42*$* ,0&&18-*5
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
>.3$.,1*,+ ." "9,34"<, +E*00 +/"3.$1,
h,3% \--,4.*9,
\--,4.*9,
D*6*-0, 1"C20(&* B$0<*)' N)%7*/. @ QJ*"'*$ 0# B$0<*)'
D*6*-0, &'$()'($*7 '$%1"1"3 ,$03$%/& %"7 &())*&&10" ,-%"& '0 8(1-7 &'$0"3 ,$0#*&&10"%-& ,$0#*&&10"%-&
B$0,%3%'* !"#$%&'$()'($* %"7 %--1*7 &*)'0$ %& % -()$%'16* */,-0./*"' 0,'10"
)0/,*"&%'10"
>"234,c
8
Case for Setting up Sector Skill Councils in India”, CII, p7
>239,% 3,+;")+,
59 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
BM
7 E 6 ? < ; D
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 60
'$3"HH$/&(41"/9 Y 7$F4 94$K9
g$+,# ") ./, +239,% 3,+;")+,+ $0")1 6*./ "23 3,+,$34/ $)# ,[;,3*,)4, ,[;,3*, )4, "- ;3":,4. <$)$1,<,).X <$)$1,<, ).X++
3,4"<<,)#$.*")+ -"3 D"9,3)<,).& ;"0*4% <$E,3+ $)# ;3":,4. "6),3+ ./$. 4"20# /,0; *) #,5"..0,),4E*)1 *)-3$+.324.23, ;3":,4.+ $)# *<;3"9, ;3":,4. #,0*9,3% *) ./, 4"2).3%7
61 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
BC
D$4 =K ( 91/0,$ %1/&"% 3,$(#(/3$ H$3J(/19H 4" 91HK,1A4J$ #$0=,(4"#- (KK#"G(, K#"3$99 3(17* %-0"3 41'2 % -1&' 0# $*G(1$*7 %77$*&&*& %"7 )0"'%)' 7*'%1-&5
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
%,,$06%-& 41'2 % &'*,C8.C&'*,
41"704 1"'0 0"* &'0, %3*"). '2%' ,$0)*&&*& %,,-1)%'10"& 1"'*$"%--. %"7 2%& '2* %('20$1'. '0 '%9* 1"#0$/*7 7*)1&10"& 8. )0/,$1&1"3 $*,$*&*"'%'16*& 0# 6%$10(& %,,$06%%3*")1*& %' % )*"'$%- -*6*-5
!"71% $%"9& %' "(/8*$ MUK %/0"3 MUP *)0"0/1*& 0" '2* *%&* 0# 08'%1"1"3 1--(&'$%'*& !"71%:& &'%'(& 6*$&(& 0'2*$ )0("'$1*& 0" 6%$10(& %&,*)'& $*-%'*7 '0 )0"&'$()'10" ,*$/1'&5 %". )0"&'$()'10" ,$0<*)' $*G(1$*& %-/0&' M?T 7%.& '0 )0")-(7*5 I1'2 '2* 1"'$07()'10" 0# `&1"3-* 41"704 )-*%$%")*a 1/,-*/*"'*7 % &1"3-* 41"704 #0$ ,$*C
1/,-*/*"'*7 &1"3-* 41"704 )-*%$%")* #0$ 1"7(&'$1%- 7*6*-0,/*"'[/07*'2%' )%" 8* $*,-1)%'*7 #0$ 1"#$%&'$()'($* &1"3-* 41"704 )-*%$%")* #%)1-1'. '0 )-*%$%")*& #$0/ 6%$10(& %('20$1'1*& ("7*$ 0"* $00# '0 &*' (, 1"7(&'$1%- ("1'& 1 " '2* 1"'$07()*7 &1"3-* I1"704 )-*%$%")* 1" K5 !"6*&'0$& )%" &(8/1' ,$0,0&%-& 0"-1"* %"7 %6%1 1" (,3$%71"3 '*)2"0-03. 1"#$%&'$()'($* '0 )0"&0-17%'* %"7 &'$*%/-1"* 6%$10(& ,$0)*&&*& %"7 &'%3*& $*-%'*7 '0 &/00'2 3$%"'1"3 0# %,,$06%-&5
()#"),+*$
i$;$)
G,[*4"
g,+. ;,3-"3<,3 10"5$00% HD0"5$0 M$)E*)1I
MUM
>P
>K
M>
KU
MO
ML
OT?
K>L
MPU
T?
()#*$
g3$K*0
D*%-1"3 41'2 J0"&'$()'10" B*$/1'&
MUK
M?T
>"234,c
1 2
S,*" &1"3-* &*$61)* 41"704& '2%' '2*/ '0 $*-*6%"' %('20$1'1*& '0 %"7 &%6* '1/*5
L/*)$
()#*4$."3+
)0"&'$()'10" %,,$06%-& %"7 /%7* )2%"3*& '0 '2* $(-*& %,,-1)%8-* '0 )0"&'$()'10" 0# 7*%-1"3 41'2 )0"&'$()'10" ,*$/1'&M5
Doing Business 2013, World Bank, October 2012 http://www.indextb.com/destination-gujarat/formalities.aspx
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 62
1/,-*/*"'1"3 %" *##*)'16* &1"3-* 41"704
'2*1$ &%. 1" '2* )-*%$%")* ,$0)*&& 7*,%$'/*"' */*$3*&5 ;()2 %" %3*"). "**7& '0 8* &%#*3(%$7*7 8. &*"10$ &/00'2-.5
\<;"6,3<,).c N &1"3-* 41"704 )-*%$%")* %3*"). 40(-7 8* %8-* '0 ,$0/0'* 1"6*&'/*"' %"7 %--04 &/00'2 1/,-*/*"'%'10" 0# 1"#$%&'$()'($* ,$0<*)'&5 !' 1& 1/,0$'%"' 7*,%$'/*"'& '04%$7& *##*)'16* #(")'10"1"3 0# &()2 %" %3*"). '2%' (&2*$& ,0&1'16* 3$04'2 1" '2* 1"#$%&'$()'($* &*)'0$ 8. ,$06171"3 %-$*3(-%'0$. %,,$06%-& 1" % '1/* 80("7 /%""*$5 D1##*$*"' %('20$1'1*& 0#'*" #**- '2%' '2*. 41-- *6*"'(%--. -0&*
BI
()9,+.<,). *) .,4/)"0"1%c 1& "**7 '0 %--0' %,,$0,$1%'* 8(73*' #0$ &*''1"3 (, %"7 *##*)'16*-. $(""1"3 &1"3-* 41"704 0,*$%'10"&5 1"#$%&'$()'($* '0 %))*&& 6%$10(&
'2%' &()2 % ,$0<*)' /%. $*G(1$*['2*. "**7 '0 8* %&&*&&*7 #0$ (,3$%7*& 0$ $*,-%)*/*"'5 0# '2* $*G(1&1'* 70)(/*"'& %"7 ,$0)*&& 3(17* '0 %--04 *%&. %))*&& '0 1"#0$/%'10" %"7 &/00'2 ,$0)*&&1"3 '2* %,,$06%-& )%" 8* 08'%1"*7 '2$0(32 % &1"3-* %))*&& ,01"' '2%' )0--*)'& 1"#$%&'$()'($* ,$0<*)'& 1" '2* )0("'$.5
3"=/4#- 4" H"/14"# (/& &$L@"44,$/$3Z 1/A#(94#=34=#$ K#")$349
0# )*"'$%- &*)'0$ ,$0<*)'& 1" MT &*)'0$& )($$*"' /*)2%"1&/ 0# /0"1'0$1"3 ,$0<*)'& 1& %' % 8$0%7 -*6*- %"7 70*&":' #0)(& 0" ,$0<*)' 7*C80''-*"*)91"3 '0 %6017 )0&' %"7 &)2*7(-* 06*$$("&5
06*$&132'& %' "%'10"%- -*6*-5 N-- ,$0<*)'& 1/,0$'%")* 40(-7 #%-- ("7*$ '21& &'$()'($*5 ^*-04 1& '2* &'$()'($* %"7 #(")'10"& 0#
!/3,,P.*,3 +.324.23, -"3 CG] CG]
A2)4.*")+
M5 K5 O5 J0("'$. &'$%'*3. #0$ )0/,*'*")* 7*6*-0,/*"'5
BRS& 1" *%)2 ;'%'*
M5 K5 A*,0$'1"3 '0 BRS %' '2* )*"'$* 0" '2* )($$*"' &'%'(& 0# ,$0<*)'&5 O5 P5
BRS& 1" 1/,-*/*"'1"3 %3*")1*&
M5 R0"1'0$1"3 %"7 $*,0$'1"3 '0 ;'%'* BRS 0" '2* )($$*"' &'%'(& 0# ,$0<*)'&5 K5 ^(1-71"3 ,$0<*)' /%"%3*/*"' )%,%81-1'. %' '2* &1'*5 O5 !7*"'1#.1"3 '$%1"*7 /%",04*$ $*G(1$*/*"'& %"7 %$$%"31"3 #0$ '$%1"1"3 %"7 )0/,*'*")* 7*6*-0,/*"'5
>"234,c
63 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
B]
."&1A- @1&&1/0 3#14$#1( K#"3$&=#$9
%4%$7*7 '2$0(32 )0/,*'1'16* 81771"35 )%,%81-1'1*& %$* *-1318-* '0 817 #0$ '2* ,$0<*)'&5 S")* '2* G(%-1#.1"3 )$1'*$1% ,$0<*)' &0-*-. 7*,*"7& 0" '2* 817 )0&'@ &($6*. $*&,0"7*"'& %$* 0# '2* 61*4 '2%' %4%$71"3 )0"'$%)'& 1" '21& /%""*$ /%. "0' 8* 2*%-'2. 1" '2* -0"3 '*$/ #$0/ '2* ,*$&,*)'16* 0# ,$0<*)' G(%-1'. /%. "0' "*)*&&%$1-. 1")-(7* %-- '2* )0&'
BT
1& %4%$7*7 '0 '2* )0"'$%)'0$ 420&* &%#*3(%$7& %3%1"&' &13"1"3 % )0"&'$()'10" )0"'$%)' #0$ %" ("$*%-1&'1)%--. -04 817 ,$1)* '2%' 40(-7 %-/0&' )*$'%1"-. -*%7 '0
N"0'2*$ %-'*$"%'16* )0(-7 8* %--041"3 '2* ,$0<*)' 04"*$& '0 "*30'1%'* 41'2 0'2*$ 8* )0"7()'*7 1" % '$%"&,%$*"' /%""*$ '2$0(32 $*6*$&* %()'10"&5 E"7*$ $*&*$6* 41'20(' 9"041"3 '2* 17*"'1'. 0# '2* 1"&'%"'-. 2%6* %" ("7*$&'%"71"3 0# 42*$* '2*. &'%"7 1" $*-%'10" '0 0'2*$ 8177*$&5 %"7 ,$0617* #**78%)9 #0$ ,%$'1)1,%"'&5
,$0)*&& %"7 /%. '%9* &*6*$%- .*%$& %$81'$%'10" 1& % ,$*#*$$*7 /*)2%"1&/ %$81'$%'10" /*)2%"1&/ 1& &'1-- *60-61"35 M??T 4%& *"%)'*7 '0 %)21*6* '2* $*%-1'. 1& #%$ %4%. #$0/ '2* '%$3*'5 S"* 0# '2* ("7*$-.1"3 )%(&*& 1& '2%' "*1'2*$ '2* ,(8-1) "0$ '2* ,$16%'* &*)'0$ 1" !"71% 1& *"'2(&1%&'1) %80(' '2* 17*% 0# '2%' N$81'$%'10" %4%$7& %$* 1"6%$1%8-. )2%--*"3*7 1" '2* )0($' 0" %))0("' 0# 0# ,$0)**71"3&5
3
)0/,$0/1&* 0" G(%-1'. %"7 '1/*-1"* 8. 7*,-0.1"3 $*&0($)*& &0 %& '0 8* 41'21" '2* G(0'*7 ,$1)*5
N #*4 1"1'1%'16*& '2%' )0(-7 1/,$06* '2*
L3,$., ?*+;2., M,+"02.*") g"$3# H?MgI ." $9"*# #*+;2.,+c DA^& %$* )$*%'*7
>.3,)1./,) ,[*+.*)1 $35*.3$.*") 0$6+c
%"7 '2* )0"'$%)'0$ '0 /0"1'0$ '2* ,$0<*)' /0"1'0$ '2* ,$03$*&& 0# '2* ,$0<*)' 41'2 $*&,*)' '0 )0"'$%)' $*G(1$*/*"'&5 !" )%&* 0# %". "0" )0/,-1%")* 41'2 $*&,*)' 1"'*$#*$*& %"7 &(33*&'& 4%.& '0 $*&0-6* '2* 71&,('*5
%$81'$%'10" /*)2%"1&/ 1" % 4%. '2%' /%9*& 1' /0$* *##*)'16* %"7 *"#0$)*%8-*5 &()2 %& %" Q!"#$%&'$()'($* B$0<*)'& &*''-*/*"' 0# '2*&* 71&,('*&5
\)4"23$1, *)+.*.2.*")$0 $35*.3$.*")c J0"&'$()'10" !"7(&'$. N$81'$%'10" J0(")1 !"&'1'('10"%- %$81'$%'10" ,$0617*& %" *"&($*& 1/,%$'1%- 7*)1&10"C/%91"3 %"7 %72*$*")* '0 ,$*C*&'%8-1&2*7 $(-*& %"7 ,$0)*7($*&5
Arbitration and Conciliat ion Act 1996, Vakilno1 website, http://www.vakilno1.com/ bareacts/arbitandonciliation/ArbitrationandConciliationAct-1996.htm, accessed 15 December 2 012
W04*6*$ 0"* 0# '2* 4%.& '0 7*%- 41'2 71&,('*& 1& '0 %6017 71&,('*&5 R%". 71&,('*& 1" '2* 1"#$%&'$()'($* &*)'0$ )0(-7 8* %6017*7 1# )0"'$%)' %3$**/*"'& %$* )0&'& %"7 $1&9& 1"'0 )0"&17*$%'10"5 $*&,0"&181-1'1*& 0# %-- ,%$'1*& )0(-7 2*-, 1" %60171"3 (""*)*&&%$. /1&("7*$&'%"71"3&5
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 64
B^
6/9414=41"/(,1`$ K#")$34 H(/(0$H$/4 4#(1/1/0 A"# K#"A$991"/(,9
-%)9 0# ,$0<*)' /%"%3*/*"' &91--& 1" ,$0#*&&10"%-& 40$91"3 0" 1"#$%&'$()'($* 7*-16*$.5 !"71%" ,$0<*)' /%"%3*$& 2%6* %)G(1$*7 ,$0<*)' /%"%3*/*"' &91--& "**7 '0 1/,%$' #0$/%- '$%1"1"3 '0 ,$0<*)' /%"%3*$& %"7 $*3(-%$-. (,7%'* '2*1$ &91--&5 '2*1$ 7%. '0 7%. 40$9 8(' %-&0 *G(1, '2*/ '0 2%"7-* "*4 )2%--*"3*& 1" '2* /0&'
L/$)1, 4233*4202< ." *).3"#24, ;3":,4. <$)$1,<,).c 1"&'1'('*& 1" !"71% %$* "0' 3161"3 /()2 1/,0$'%")* '0 '2* ,$0<*)' /%"%3*/*"' )($$1)(-(/ %"7 1" )0/,%$1&0" '0 0'2*$ )0("'$1*& 6*$. #*4 1"&'1'('10"& 1" !"71% 0##*$ ,$0<*)' /%"%3*/*"' 7*3$** "(/8*$ 1& -*&& '2%" MLO
4
1' 1& 1/,0$'%"' '0 1"'$07()* ,$0<*)' /%"%3*/*"' 1" '2* )($$1)(-(/ 0# '2* ,$0<*)' /%"%3*/*"' )0($&*& 1" '2* #0--045
L"";,3$.*") 5,.6,,) *)#2+.3% $)# ,#24$.*")$0 *)+.*.2.*")+c "**7 #0$ 3$*%'*$ 7*3$** 0# )0--%80$%'10" 8*'4**" '2* 1"7(&'$. %"7 *7()%'10"%1"&'1'('10"& &0 %& '0 $*7()* '2* 7*/%"7 &(,,-. 3%, #0$ '$%1"*7 ,$0<*)' /%"%3*/*"' ,$0#*&&10"%-&5 !"7(&'$. )%" 2*-, *7()%'10"%- 1"&'1'('10"& *7()%'10"%- 1"&'1'('*& 40(-7 "0' 0"-. #0$ ,$0<*)' /%"%3*/*"' ,$0#*&&10"%-& 8(' )%" %-&0 2*-, 1" *"2%")1"3 '2* '$%1"1"35
“India lagging China in project management”, The Economic Times, 18 June 2010
g2*0# *) /"2+, $4$#,<% -"3 ./, ;3":,4. <$)$1,<,). .3$*)*)1c !"#$%&'$()'($* )0/,%"1*& '0 /**' '2* &20$'%3* 0# 2%6* 7*6*-0,*7 1"C20(&* %)%7*/. #0$ '$%1"1"3 '2*1$ */,-0.**& 0" 9*. &91--& "**7*7 #0$ '2*1$ 7%. '0 7%. 40$95 !"71%" 1"#$%&'$()'($* 1"7(&'$. )%" -009 '0 '$%1"1"3 )%" 8* )0"7()'*7 #0$ "*4-. *"2%")* '2*1$ ,$0#*&&10"%- )0/,*'*")1*&5
65 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
BS
'$A"#H 6/&1(\9 a"3(41"/(, ;&=3(41"/ (/& ?#(1/1/0 K#"0#(H 4" 3#$(4$ ( ,(#0$ K"", "A $HK,"-(@,$ %"#Z A"#3$
"**7& '0 1/,$06* '2* *7()%'10" %"7 1"#$%&'$()'($* &*)'0$5 N))0$71"3 '0 (,,*$ &*)0"7%$. -*6*-P "0' $*&,0"71"3 '0 '2* "**7& 0# '2* -%80$ T5 %"7 1"7(&'$. "**7 '0 )0/* '03*'2*$ %"7 7*6*-0, % /*)2%"1&/ '0 1/,%$' '$%1"1"3 %"7 7*6*-0, &91--&5
,*0,-* 8. KLKK> #0--041"3 '40 1"1'1%'16*& )0(-7 2*-, 1"
L3,$.*)1 $ `$.*")$0 g"$3# -"3 9"4$.*")$0 ,#24$.*") ^ &20(-7 2%6* '2* $*,$*&*"'%'10" #$0/
;*''1"3 (, 0# Y%'10"%- ;91-- D*6*-0,/*"' '0 #%)1-1'%'* &91-- 7*6*-0,/*"' 1" '2* )0("'$. 1& % &'*, 1" $132' 71$*)'10"5 Y;DJ '%$3*'& '0 *"2%")* &91--& 0# MPL /1--10"
5 6 7
7*6*-0,1"3 % 8$0%7C8%&*7 )($$1)(-(/ #0$ 60)%'10"%- *7()%'10" 8%&*7 0" *"&($1"3 % )-0&* 1"'*$%)'10" 8*'4**" 1"7(&'$1*& %"7 60)%'10"%- 1"&'1'('*&
?,9,0";*)1 +E*00+ "- 0"4$0 ;,";0, 5% 4"3;"3$.,+ ^ -%"7 %)G(1&1'10" %"7 $*3(-%'0$. %,,$06%-& )0(-7 &'%$' 1/,%$'1"3 '$%1"1"3 '0 '2* -0)%-
World Bank report on vocational education and training system in India World Bank report on vocational education and training system in India National Skill Development Mission, Press Information Bureau, 16 August 2010
,*0,-*5 ;0 42*" '2* )0"&'$()'10" 0# 0# &91--*7 ,*0,-* %6%1-%8-* -0)%--.5 ;'%'* %/0"3 '2* -0)%- ,*0,-* %80(' '2*
J$*%'*& -%$3* ,00- 0# -0)%--. %6%1-%8-* &91--*7 %"7 */,-0.%8-* ,*0,-* F*&& $*&1&'%")* #$0/ -0)%- ,*0,-* */,-0./*"' #$0/ '21& ,$0<*)' 7*6*-0,*7 #($'2*$ #0$ ,-%"' 0,*$%'10"&5
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 66
BU
$/(@,$ A(94$# K#")$34 1HK,$H$/4(41"/
,%)* 41'2 1")$*%&1"3 -031&'1)& 7*/%"75 1& "**7 '0 $*#0$/ '2* !"71%:& '$%"&,0$' %"7 -031&'1)& &*)'0$5 S($ &($6*. $*&(-'& 1"71)%'* '2%' /%". ,$0<*)'& &(##*$ #$0/ -%)9 0# 3007 '$%"&,0$' 1"#$%&'$()'($* 1" '2* )0("'$.5 N& /*"'10"*7 8. 0($ "0" %6%1-%81-1'. 0# -%&' /1-* )0""*)'161'. '0 ,$0<*)' &1'*& %"7 2132 )0&' 0# '$%"&,0$'%'10" %$* &0/* 0# '2* #%)'0$& 0# '2* ,$0<*)'5 V0--041"3 &'*,& )0(-7 2*-, 1" 1/,$061"3 '2* '$%"&,0$' 1"#$%&'$()'($* 1" '2*
\[;,#*., ./, 4")+.324.*") "- ?,#*4$.,# A3,*1/. L"33*#"3+ H?ALI $)# 43,$., ),6 ?AL+c '0 1")$*%&* '2* $%1-4%.&: '$%"&,0$'%'10" )%,%)1'. 8. 8(1-71"3 2132C&,**7 %"7 2132C)%,%)1'. 7*71)%'*7 #$*132' )0$$170$&5 $*7()* '$%6*- '1/* 8. % '21$7U
8 9 10 11
$*7()* '$%"&,0$'%'10" )0&'5 E"7*$ ,2%&* '$%6*$&* '2* 71&'%")* #$0/ D%7$1 '0 41-- &'%$' #$0/ F(721%"% 1" B("<%8 %"7 B$%7*&2 %"7 ^12%$ 8*#0$* '*$/1"%'1"3 %' D%"9("1 1" I*&' ^*"3%-?5 $%1-4%. )0""*)'161'. %-0"3 '2* 4*&'*$" % /*3% 1"6*&'/*"' ,$0<*)' 0# E;D ?L *"61&%3*& '0 7*6*-0, ? !"6*&'/*"' $*310"& %$* %)$0&& '2* ;'%'*& 0# E''%$ R%2%$%&2'$%ML5
Freight corridor back on track,Times of India, dated November 16, 2011 Dedicated Freight Corridor Corporation of India (www.dfccil.org) Delhi Mumbai Industrial Corridor (www.dmic.co.in) India Transport Sector, World Bank
/*3% ,$0<*)'& 1& 4%. 8*21"7 '%$3*'&5 ,$0<*)'& %"7 '%9* %-- ,0&&18-* &'*,& '0 $*/06* 80''-*"*)9& #0$ '1/*-. )0/,-*'10" &'%$' ,-%""1"3 #0$ %' -*%&' '40 %771'10"%DVJ& = D*-21CJ2*""%1 %"7 J2*""%1C R(/8%15
()43,$+, )$.*")$0 /*1/6$% ),.6"3E+ $)# *<;3"9, 3"$# <$*).,)$)4, ;3"13$
67 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
BM
<#$(4$ (/ $FJ(=941G$ ,194 "A $HK(/$,,$& G$/&"# (4 <$/4#(, ,$G$, A"# 1/A#(94#=34=#$ K#")$349
7*,%$'/*"'& /%1"'%1" 71##*$*"' */,%"*--*7 -1&' 0# 6*"70$& #0$ '2*1$ $*&,*)'16* ,$0<*)'& %"7 &*$61)*&5 V0$ -1&' 0# */,%"*--*7 6*"70$& %' )*"'$% 1"#0$/%'10" %80(' '2* 6*"70$ )$*7*"'1%-& '2* 9"04-*73* 0# ,$0<*)' /%"%3*/*"' *"&($* '2%' 6*"70$ 2%& '2* )0/,-*'* 9"04-*73* 0# ,$0<*)' /%"%3*/*"' 1"#0$/%'10" ,$0617*7 8. '2* 6*"70$&
BV
'2*$* &20(-7 8* % ,$061&10" 0# (,7%'1"3 $*/061"3 '2* "0"C,*$#0$/1"3 0"*&5
L3,$., $ 0$31, ;""0 "- 3,1*+.,3,# 9,)#"3+ '0 )200&* #$0/ %)$0&& '2*
M,#24, ;"++*5*0*.% "- -"3<*)1 4$3.,0 5% 9,)#"3+ %& -%$3* "(/8*$ 0# 6*"70$& 40(-7 8* %6%1-%8-* #0$ % ,%$'1)(-%$ 40$9
C3,++23*K, 9,)#"3+ ." ,[4,0 *) ;3":,4.+ %& ,00$ ,*$#0$/%")* 0" % &1"3-* ,$0<*)' )0(-7 )0&' '2*/ '2* 7*-1&'1"3 #$0/ '2* )*"'$%- */,%"*--*7 -1&'5
)0("'$.
M,#24, .*<, *) $6$3#*)1 ./, 4").3$4.+ %& %4%$71"3 % )0"'$%)' '0 '2* */,%"*--*7 -1&' 6*"70$ 70*&":' $*G(1$* 8%)93$0("7 )2*)9 %& '2* 6*"70$:& )$*7*"'1%-& %$* %-$*%7. )0(-7 &%6* %" %6*$%3* 0# KCO /0"'2& 1" %4%$71"3 '2* )0"'$%)'
5#"H"4$ 5=@,13 5#1G(4$ 5(#4/$#9J1K W555X 1/ 6/A#(94#=34=#$ 9$34"#
B0$'& 2%6* 8**" #("7*7 8. ;'%'* %"7 1& -0091"3 %' 1")$*%&*7 ,%$'1)1,%'10" #$0/ '2* ,$16%'* &*)'0$ #0$ '$%"&,0$' 1"6*&'/*"' 2%& #%--*" &20$' 0# '2* $0%7 &*3/*"' ,$16%'* &*)'0$ 1"6*&'*7 B$16%'* $0%7 7*6*-0,*$& 7*,*"7 -%$3*-. 0" 21324%. '0-- )0--*)'10"& %& % /*71(/
'0-- )0--*)'10"& 1" !"71% %$* #$%(32' 41'2 )2%--*"3*& &()2 %& $*6*"(* -*%9%3*& 421)2 %$* ,$061"3 '0 8* % /%<0$ 7*'*$$*"' #0$ ,$16%'* 1"6*&'/*"' 1" $0%7&5MK V0--041"3 &'*,& )0(-7 2*-, 1" ,$0/0'1"3 BBB 1"6*&'/*"' 1" '2* 1"#$%&'$()'($*
L3,$., $ #,.$*0,# ;"0*4% -"3 *<;0,<,).*)1 CCC ;3":,4.+c 1& "**7 '0 )$*%'* % 7*'%1-*7 BBB ,0-1). '2* ,$*#*$$*7 &)2*/* #0$ *%)2 &*)'0$ %"7 %1/ '0 8$1"3 /0$* '$%"&,%$*"). 1" '2* ,%$'1)1,%'10" 0# ,$16%'* 1"6*&'0$& 1" '2* 1"#$%&'$()'($* &*)'0$5
12 Mid-term appraisal of Eleventh Five Year Plan, Planning Commissio n
\)+23, $#,O2$., 3,.23)+ ." ;3*9$., ;0$%,3+c 1"#$%&'$()'($* ,$0<*)'& %$* $*3(-%'*7 %"7 $*'($"& '0 ,$16%'* ,-%.*$& 0" '2*1$ 1"6*&'*7 "*)*&&%$. &%#*3(%$7&5
?,9,0"; 0")1 .,3< #,5. <$3E,. -"3 *)-3$+.324.23, ;3":,4.+c BBB 7*&13" %"7 ,0-1). &20(-7 ,$0617* %7*G(%'* '0 -*"7 '2*1$ /0"*. '0 BBB ,$0<*)'&5 -0"3='*$/ 80"7 /%$9*' %"7 ,$0/0'10" 0# 1"#$%&'$()'($* 80"7& )0(-7 $*&(-' 1" 8*''*$ ,%$'1)1,%'10" #$0/ #0$*13" 1"6*&'0$&5
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 68
CB
5#"H"4$ )"1/4 $G(,=(41"/ "A K#")$34 &$910/ A"# G(,=$ $/01/$$#1/0
-%)9 6%-(* *"31"**$1"3 %,,$0%)2 -*%61"3 /1"1/%- 0,,0$'("1'1*& #0$ )0"'$%)'0$& %"7 )0/,%"1*& -%)9 %7*G(%'* 70*& "0' /0'16%'* '2* )0"'$%)'0$& *"0(32 '0 */,-0. 6%-(* *"31"**$1"3 %,,$0%)2 %& '2*. 70 "0' 3*' %". 1")*"'16* #0$ '2* &%61"3&5
*"31"**$1"3 7*)1&10"& 1" ,$0<*)'& 8%&*7 *"3%3* '2* )0"'$%)'0$& #0$ <01"' *6%-(%'10" 0# ,$0<*)' 7*&13"5 J0"'$%)'0$& "**7 '0 &*'C(, 7*71)%'*7 6%-(* *"31"**$1"3 '*%/& '2* )0"'$%)'0$& &20(-7 %-&0 %''*/,' '0 )0--%80$%'* 41'2 3-08%- *"31"**$1"3 1"&'1'('*& %"7 )0/,%"1*& &0 %& '0 */,-0. ,$0<*)'5
B$0<*)' 04"*$& %"7 )0"'$%)'0$& &20(-7 )0&' &%61"3 %' '2* 6%$10(& &'%3*& 0# ,$0<*)' 1/,-*/*"'%'10"5 ^%&*7 0" '2* ,*$#0$/%")* 0# '2* 6%-(* *"31"**$1"3 1" '2* *&'1/%'*7 )0&' &%61"3 0$ 0'2*$ 1")*"'16*& '0 7$16* '2*/ #0$ 3$*%'*$ %70,'10" 0# 6%-(* *"31"**$1"3 )0")*,'&5
69 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
BV
7 E 6 ? < ; D
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 70
<(9$ 94=&1$9 Y N &$$K &1G$ 1/4" K#")$349
,[/$2+.*9,0%& 6, 9*+*.,# -,6 ;3":,4. +*.,+& *).,39*,6,# +,9,3$0 ;,";0, $43"++ 0,9,0+ *)402#*)1 ;3":,4. <$)$1,3+& 4").3$4."3+ $)# 9,)#"3+& ,.47 !" ;3"9*#, $ /"0*+.*4 "9,39*,6 "*)-3$+.324.23, *)#2+.3%& ./,+, ;3":,4.+ /$9, 5,,) +,0,4.,# -3"< #*--,3,). +,4."3+& $. #*--,3,). +.$1, "- *<;0,<,).$.*") $)# ,[;,3*,)4*)1 #*--,3,). <$1)*.2#, "- +4/,#20, $)# 4"+. "9,332)+7
71 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
2345 46789 :
;6*2 <.-&=>/?=/@ 4A/B$ ,<:
!3264
1//*71%'* )0$$*)'16* %)'10"& 1" )%&* 0# %". &-1,,%3*& D*-%.*7 7*-16*$. 0# )$1'1)%- *G(1,/*"'& %"7 ,00$ &1'* )0""*)'161'. %$* /%<0$ $*%&0"& #0$ ,$0<*)' 7*-%. 1")$*%&* (&* 0# $%1-4%.& #0$ *G(1,/*"' '$%"&,0$' %$* &0/* '*)2"1G(*& (&*7 8.
().3"#24.*") K %"7 1& -0)%'*7
A"00"6*)1 $3, ./, E,% #,.$*0+ "- ;3":,4. L$;$4*.% 2)#,3 *)+.$00$.*")
a"4$.*")
L"$0 +"234,
YJF /1"*&
b$.,3 +"234,
;'%'10"
()9,+.<,). $;;3"9$0
L233,). ;3":,4. +.$.2+ ]3*1*)$00% ;0$)),# F).*4*;$.,#d M,9*+,#
]9,332)
C3":,4. 4"<;0,.*") #$.,
S)'08*$CKLMK
D*)*/8*$CKLMK
K R0"'2&
C3":,4. 4"+. H(`M L3"3,I
Y!F
$*&,0"7*"'&
1 2
KPMG in India- PMI Survey on cost and schedule overrun, 2012 Coal Based Power Stations, NTPC Website, accessed 26 June 2012
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 72
42*$* '2* &.&'*/& %$* "*%$1"3 )0/,-*'10"5
=)*. @ >37 G*0,+."), `"7
C0$) H$+ ;,3 aU +4/,#20,I
]3*1*)$0d M,9*+,# ,[;,4.,# 4"<;0,.*")
=)*. U F4.2$0d,[P ;,4.,# #,0$% H<")./+I P
C0$) H$+ ;,3 aU >4/,#20,I
]3*1*)$0d M,9*+,# ,[;,4.,# 4"<;0,.*")
F4.2$0d,[P ;,4.,# #,0$% H<")./+I
R%$CML
X("CML
M
K
N,$CML
X("CML
K
N(3CML
X%"CMM
P
R%$CMM
X("CMM
X(-CMM
D*)CMM
P
O
;*,CMM
Y06CMM
K
X%"CMK
R%.CMK
O
P
Y06CMM
X%"CMM
K
R%$CMK
X("CMK
T
;*,CML
S)'CML
M
X%"CMM
X("CMM
P
>
Y06CML
D*)CML
M
R%$CMM
X(-CMM
O
U
S)'CMM
D*)CMM
K
V*8CMK
X("CMK
O
Y06CL?
R%$CML
?
D*)CMM
X%"CMK
M
N,$CMK
X("CMK
K
ML
V*8CMK
V*8CMK
C
X("CMK
N(3CMK
K
R%$CMK
C
S)'CMK
C
MM
V(-- F0%7
73 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
C3":,4. G")*."3*)1 N M,;"3.*)1 +%+.,< *) ;0$4, $. ./, ;3":,4. +*.,
?DG& CN>
/0"1'0$1"3 %"7 $*,0$'1"3 '*%/ %' &1'* 421)2 $*,0$'& 71$*)'-. 1" '0 '2* B$0<*)' B-%""1"3 H ;.&'*/& '*%/ 1& &204" 0" %"7 )0"'$%)'0$& 0" 7%1-. 8%&1& '0 )0-- *)' 1"#0$/%'10" 0" ,$0<*)' ,$03$*&& %"7 (,7%'*& $*,0$'& 421)2 %$* )1$)(-%'*7 '0 '2* ,$0<*)' '*%/5 V0--041"3 $*,0$'& %$* 3*"*$%'*7 #0$ '2* ,($,0&* 0# $*,0$'1"3
?$*0% C3"13,++ C3"13,++ M,;"3. M,;"3. H?CMIc DBA )0"'%1"& ,%)9%3*C41&* ,$03$*&& %& %3%1"&' /0"'2-. ,-%""*7 G(%"'1'1*&5 ,%)9%3* *"31"**$& %"7 &(8/1''*7 2%& &*,%$%'* &*)'10" #0$ 40$9 70"* 1" (&*$& 61% ;R;5
b,,E0% C3"13,++ M,;"3. HbCMIc IBA 1& ,%)9%3*C41&* $*,0$' 0" 4**9-. 40$9 70"* %& %3%1"&' /0"'2-. 1"#0$/%'10" 0" 40$9 )0/,-*'*7 0" )$1'1)%- ,%)9%3*&5
G")./0% C3"13,++ M,;"3.c /0"'2-. ,$03$*&& $*,0$' )0"'%1"& 7*'%1-*7 ,$0<*)' &'%'(& $*,0$' )0"'%1"1"3 1"#0$/%'10" 0" '2* ,$0<*)'
>37 G$)$1,3
?%7 G$)$1,3
>37 G$)$1,3
?%7 G$)$1,3
?%7 G$)$1,3
>37 \)1*),,3
M,$+")+ -"3 ;3":,4. #,0$% I21-* %" *"'*$,$1&*C-*6*- $1&9 )%$$1*7 0('5 Y0 #0$/%- &.&'*/ 0# $1&9 ,-%)* %' '2* ,$0<*)' -*6*-5 V0--041"3 %$*
6*$. 4*-- )0""*)'*7 41'2 /%<0$ -031&'1)& %"7 '$%"&,0$' $*-%'*7 1&&(*&5 $0%7& )0""*)'1"3 '0 '2* ,-%"' &1'* -0"3*$ '$%"&,0$'%'10" '1/* %##*)'1"3 '2* ,$03$*&& 0# '2* 40$95
G$.,3*$0 ?,0*9,3% -3"< -3"< g8\ac g8\ac 1" ,$03$*&& %"7 $*&(-'*7 1" 7*-%. 0# )$1'1)%- /1-*&'0"*&5 D(* '0 -1/1'*7 "0' /**' '2* &(,,-. &)2*7(-* 0# 6%$10(& )0")($$*"' ,$0<*)'& ("7*$ ;'%'* ('1-1'1*&5 D(* '0 &,($$1"3 -*%71"3 '0 % 417* 3%, 1" 7*/%"7 %"7 &(,,-. 0# ,04*$ ,-%"' *G(1,/*"'&5 #0$31"3 %"7 ,1,1"3 /%'*$1%-& #0$ ,04*$ ,-%"' *G(1,/*"'&5 D(* '0 2*%6. 0$7*$ 20"0$ '2*1$ )0//1'/*"'& 1" &(,,-.1"3 %"7 '21& 1" '($" &*6*$*-. %##*)'*7 '2* /%"(#%)'($1"3 %"7 &(,,-. &)2*7(-*5 )$1'1)%- /1-*&'0"*& %"7 $*&(-'*7 1"
>*., 4")),4.*9*.%c
L").3$4."3 ?,-$20.c /07* %"7 '2*$* %$* &*6*$%- &/%-%"7 813 )0"'$%)'0$& '2%' %$* ,$06171"3 /%'*$1%- %"7 &*$61)*& #0$ '2* ,$0<*)'5 0"* )0"'$%)'0$ '2%' )%" -*%7 '0 06*$%- 42*$* '2* )0"'$%)'0$& 2%7 8%)9*7 0('5
C3":,4. ().,13$.*")c %"7 2*")* '2* $1&9 0# 1"'*3$%'1"3 !"71617(%- )0"'$%)'0$& 41-- ,*$#0$/ '2*1$ ,1*)* 0# 40$9 %"7 41-- 8* $*&,0"&18-* #0$ )0/,-*'1"3 '2*1$ &)0,* 0"-.5 N". 1&&(*& $*-%'1"3 '0 )00$71"%'10" 8*'4**" %)'161'1*& 0# '40 )0"'$%)'0$& %"7 *"&($1"3 ,*$#0$/%")*
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 74
G,$+23,+ .$E,) 5% `!CL ." #,P5"..0,),4E ;3":,4. M5 71$*)'-. '0 '2*1$ &(8C)0"'$%)'0$& 0$ %' '1/*& 3161"3 '2*/ %76%")* ,%./*"'&5 '2* )0"'$%)'0$ 81--& %"7 %$* 2*-,#(- 1" %60171"3 7*-%.&5 K5 $%1-4%.& '0 '$%"&,0$' 1'& /%'*$1%-5 &(,,-1*& 0# 1'& 71##*$*"' )0"'$%)'0$& '2* $*G(1$*/*"'& 0# 0"* ,-%"' 0$ "*%$8. /(-'1,-* ,-%"'&5 !# '2*&* '$%1"& 1' 1& '2*" '$%"&,0$'*7 '0 7*&13"%'*7
/0"1'0$1"3 %"7 $*,0$'1"3 &.&'*/ 1" ,-%)*5 B$0<*)'& %$* /0"1'0$*7 %' /1)$0 %". &-1,,%3* %"7 *"&($1"3 1//*71%'* )0$$*)'16* %)'10"5
75 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
2345 46789 C
15
!3264
/1"* C %"7 7*-%. 1" 3*''1"3 $*3(-%'0$. %,,$06%-& %$* /%<0$ $*%&0"& #0$ )0&' %"7 '1/* 06*$$("& 2%& ,$0%)'16*-. ,$*,%$*7 */,-0./*"' ,$0,0&%-& %"7 $*61&*7 )0/,*"&%'10"
1" \0$8% D1&'$1)' 0# J22%''1&3%$25 !' 2%& %" %$*% 0# %80(' M? &G5 9/5 %"7 1& '2* -%$3*&' 0,*" )%&' )0%- /1"* 1" !"71%M
A"00"6*)1 $3, ./, E,% #,.$*0+ "- ;3":,4. \[;$)+*") 4$;$4*.%
/',%
a"4$.*")
a$)# M,O2*3,<,).
OMUO5P W%
()9,+.<,). $;;3"9$0 ?$., C3":,4. 4"+. !$31,. 4"<;0,.*")
$*&,0"7*"'&
1
Mineral Resources of Korba, Official website of Korba district, http://korba.nic.in/ kwMines.htm
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 76
g$4E13"2)# $)# 4233,). +.$.2+ #0$ %(3/*"'%'10" 0# ,$07()'10" 8. K /',% 4%& ,$*,%$*7 %"7 &%")'10"*7 8. J0%- !"71%
D,93$ <*), 4$;$4*.% ,[;$)+*") ;0$)
>"234,c JCGD *) ()#*$ ^ CG( >239,% ") 4"+. $)# +4/,#20, "9,332)& UV@UQ 5$+,# ") *).,3$4.*") 6*./ +239,% 3,+;")#,).+
`,,# -"3 ,[;$)+*") -3"< UZ <.;$ ." WZ <.;$ ,$07()'10" ,-%"5
77 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
a$)# M,O2*3,<,). K
`".,c P h$02,+ <,).*"),# *) 13,,) *)#*4$., ./$. ./, 0$)# /$+ 5,,) $4O2*3,#7
!,4/)"0"1%
!/,$06*/*"' 1" )0%- G(%-1'. 8. &*-*)'16* /1"1"3
R1"1/(/ /%",04*$ $*G(1$*7 #0$ 0,*$%'1"3 '2* /%)21"*&
2
%". 7(&' 421)2 )0(-7 8* 3*"*$%'*7 7($1"3 )0%- )(''1"3
As on Dec 31, 2011
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 78
`$.23, "- 4").3$4.+
\4")"<*4 h$02$.*")
%"7 (&1"3 2132 )%,%)1'. ;206*-CD(/,*$ )0/81"%'10" /*)2%"1&/5 N' ,$*&*"' 8%-%")* 1& '2$0(32 )0"6*"'10"%- /*'207
N))0$71"3 '0 1"1'1%- ,$0<*)' $*,0$' 7%'*7 *&'1/%'* #0$ '2* ,$0<*)' 7%'*7 X(-. KLL> 4%& !YA >UL5MK )$0$*5 !" ;*,'*/8*$ '2* %)'(%- *&'1/%'*&5
J0%- /1"1"3 1& &(8)0"'$%)'*7 '0 6%$10(& )0"'$%)'0$& @ 6*"70$& 420 %$* JWB H ("-0%71"3 0# )0%-5
/%)21"*$. #0$ 1")$*/*"'%- ML /',% 4%& %-0"* 4%& *&'1/%'*7 %' !YA OTO5L? )$0$*5
G*0,+."), >.$.2+
>7 `"7
G*0,+."), ?,+43*;.*")
!$31,. ?$., "- L"<;0,.*")
M5
X(-. KLLP
K5
V1"%- V0$*&' J-*%$%")* 0# MLL5LM W% -%"7
N(3(&' KLLU
X("* KLL?
O5
J0//1&&10"1"3 0# I0$9&20,
R%$)2 KLMM
P5
J0//1&&10"1"3 0# ;'0$*
R%$)2 KLMM
T5
Y06*/8*$ KLLT
>5
X%"(%$. KLML KLML
U5
N(3(&' KLML KLML
?5
J0 J0"&'$()'10" 0# W%(- A0%7
R%$)2 KLMM
ML5
J0"&'$()'10" 0# A*&17*"'1%- ^(1-71"3
R%$)2 KLMK
MM5
R%$)2 KLMK KLMK
MK5
D*)*/8*$ D*)*/8* $ KLMK KLMK
MO5 MO5
N(3/* N(3/*"'% "'%'10 '10" " 0# JWB 1")-(7 1")-(71"3 1"3 ;1-0 ;1-0
MP5
!"&'%--%'10" !"&'%--%'10" %"7 )0//1&&10"1" )0//1&&10"1"3 3 0# !"C,1' )0%- '$%"&,0$' '$%"&,0$' &.&'*/ &.&'*/
79 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
M,$+")+ -"3 4"+. $)# +4/,#20, "9,332)+
4%& %&&(/*7 %&&(/ *7 %& !YA >5LL >5LL F%92 F%9 2 ,*$ %)$*&5 N& ,*$ '2* $*61&*7 J22%''1&3%$2 '2* $%'* 4%& 1")$*%&*7 '0 !YA U5LL 1")$*%&*7 8. 06*$ MUL ,*$)*"' #$0/ !YA K>5U K>5U )$0$* '0 ' 0 !YA >U5K> )$0$*5 )$ 0$*5
C3"423,<,). "- +;,4*$0*K,# ,O2*;<,). $. $ /*1/,3 4"+.c P !" '2* OK )(/ 4%& )0"&17*$*7 '0 8* !YA %)'(%- )0&' 0# ,$0)($*/*"' #0$ *%)2
?,0$% *) 1,..*)1 $;;3"9$0+ $;;3"9$0+ -3"< -3"< >.$., D"9,3)<,).c C N,,$06%-& @ AHA *')5 %$* ,*"71"3 41'2 '2* ;'%'* 80''-*"*)9& @ 7*-%. #%)'0$& 1" ,2.&1)%
?,0$% *) C3"423,<,). "- 8\GGc P ,*$107 0# 0"* .*%$ #0$ /%"(#%)'($1"3 '2* )0"'$%)'& '2$0(32 3-08%
!YA OM )$0$* ,*$ ;206*- H 1")$*%&* 0# %"7 0'2*$ BHR 4*$* 8%&*7 /%1"-. 0" '2* &'%"7%$7 ,$1)* -1&' 0# /1"1"3 A%")215
()43,$+, *) 0$)# 4"<;,)+$.*") 4"<;,)+$.*") #2, #2, ." ;"0*4% 4/$)1,cP !" '2* ,$0<*)'
-
W*-, '0 '0 &'%$' 41'2 ,$07()'10" ,$07()'10" #$0/ #$0/ '2* 0"-. -%"7 -*#' ("7*$ ,2.&1)%,0&&*&&10"5
-
E'%$7%5
-
;(8/1&&10" 0# ;'%'*/*"' ] H ]! 0# $*/%1"1"3 61--%3*& ("7*$ %)G(1&1'10"5
?,0$% *) 1,..*)1 *).,3)$0 *).,3)$0 $;;3"9$0+ $;;3"9$0+ H>\La g"$3#Ic P R%". 0# '2*
-
B$0,0&%- #0$ */,-0./*"' 0# %"0'2*$ P Y0&5 *-1318-* )%"717%'*& 0# -%"7 -00&*$ 4%& &(8/1''*7 '0 W_ #0$ %,,$06%- 617* -*''*$ Y05 ?L 7%'*7 MK N,$1N, $1- KLMM KLMM
-
J0/,*"&%'10" 0# 20(&*& %"7 B0"71 61--%3* 4%& &(8/1''*7 '0 W_ #0$ %,,$06%- 617* ,$0,0&%- "05 M>P 7%'*7 MO X("* KLMM KLMM
-
A*61&*7 )0/,*"&%'10" 0# M>K5>M? M>K5>M? W% -%"7 0# B0"71 61--%3* 4%& &(8/1''*7 '0 W_ #0$ %,,$06%- 617*
,$0,0&%- "05 OTU 7%'*7 MM MM X(-. KLMM
-
B$0,0&%- #0$ %,,01"'/*"' 0# %" #%)1-1'%'*7 -%"7 %)G(1&1'10"5
%)G(1&1'10" 0# -%"75
F<5*12*.% "9,3 "9,3 MNM C"0*4%c P */,-0./*"' '0 %-- '2* -%"7 -0&*$& &(8<*)' '0 %6%1-%81-1'. 0# 6%)%")1*& 1" '2%' -%"7 -0&*$& 420 %$* "0' *-1318- * #0$ */,-0./*"' &2%-- 8* 0##*$*7 )%&2 )0/,*"&%'10" %' '2* $%'* ,$*&)$18*7 R1"1&'$. 0# A($%- D*6*-0,/*"' %/813(1'. 1" )0/,%".:& )0/,%".:& %"7 ;'%'* '2* */,-0./*"' %"7 )0/,*"&%'10" 1& %##*)'1"3 '2* -%"7 %)G(1&1'10"5
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 80
G,$+23,+ .$E,) 5% >\La ." #,5"..0,),4E ;3":,4. M5 ,$0%)'16*-. ,$*,%$*7 */,-0./*"' '2* )0--*)'0$ %"7 08'%1"*7 )0"&*"' '*%/ ,$0,0&*7 %,,01"'/*"' 0# $*'1$*7 -%"7 %)G(1&1'10" ,$0)*&&5 K5 !" '2* )%&* 0# %/813(1'. 06*$ AHA $*&0-6*7 %& &00" %& ,0&&18-*5
$*G(*&' 0# '2* ,$0<*)' 04"*$ %--0'& '2* -%"7 1" '2* "*%$8. %$*% 0# '2* 41'2 1"#$%&'$()'($%- #%)1-1'1*& &()2 2%"7*7 06*$ '0 '2* %##*)'*7 #%/1-1*&5 1" "*%$8. %$*% 0# '2* ,$0<*)' #0$ /%. 8* 0('&0($)*7 0$ )%&2
)0/,*"&%'10" @ /0"*'%$. ,%)9%3* 1" -1*( 0# $*&*''-*/*"' ,-0' %"7 8(1-71"3 ,$0617*75
81 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
2345 46789 L
2"-GA#M?A."- "( /- H((G="#$ 2"-A/.-$# 6$#).-/@ /A +M)N/. *"#A 6#MGA
!3264
1")$*%&* 8. OL ,*$)*"' #$0/ &)2*7(-*7 )0&' 8*'4**" 7$*731"3 %"7 8*$'2 )0"&'$()'10" 40$9& -*%7& '0 &)2*7(-* %"7 )0&' 06*$$("5
M 0# '2*
L")+.324.*") #,.$*0+
D0)9 8%&1" %$*%& (, '0 bO5>?/ JD 8. 7$*731"3 &%"7 %6%1-%8-* "*%$ D2%$%/%'%$ R@& X%1&( ;21,,1"3 J05 1"'*3$%'*7 7*6*-0,/*"' 0# '2* )0"'%1"*$ .%$7 %"7 $*-0)%'10" 0# &*$61)*&5
g,0"6 $3, ./, <$:"3 #,.$*0+ "- ;3":,4. L$;$4*.% F##*.*")
a"4$.*")
C3":,4. \[,42.*")
()9,+.<,). $;;3"9$0 ?$.,
$*&,0"7*"'&
1
Introduction, Mumbai Port Tr Trust, ust, http://mumbaipo rt.gov.in/index2.asp? slid=34&sub lin kid=10&langid=1, ac cessed 19 June 2012
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 82
L233,). ;3":,4. +.$.2+
C3":,4. 4"<;0,.*") #$., C3":,4. 4"+. H(`M L3"3,I
]3*1*)$00% ;0$)),# F).*4*;$.,#d M,9*+,#
]9,332)
D*) KLML
KU R0"'2&
D*) KLML
OOP
TML
C3":,4. C0$))*)1 $)# 4233,). +.$.2+ F1,)4%
(L!
G5C!
C,34,).$1, "6"3E 4"<;0,.,#
C0$)),# #$.,
F4.2$0 #$.,
?,0$% *) <")./+
F1)*"&* N3$**/*"' &13"*7 8*'4**"
D*) KLL>
D*) KLL>
C
MLL
V1"%")1%- J-0&($*
X("* KLLU
Y06 KLLU
P
MLL
J0//*")*/*"' 0# J0"&'$()'10"
N(3 KLLU
R%. KLL?
?
MLL
J0/,-*'10" 0# )161- 40$9& %"7 )0//1&&10"C
D*) KLML
UP
W%"71"3 06*$ '2* &1'* #0$ '$*&'-*
D*) KLL>
D*) KLL>
C
MLL
W%"71"3 06*$ %-$*%7. 7*6*-0,*7 -%"7 %' B$1")*& %"7 ]1)'0$1% D0)9 0# '2* F1)*"&*7
D*) KLL>
!" ,2%&*&
C
UP
J0/,-*'10" 0# J%,1'%- 7$*731"3 #0$ '2* 8*$'2 ,0)9*' %"7 2%"71"3 06*$ '0 '2* F1)*"&** #0$ )0"&'$()'10"
D*) KLL?
N,$ KLMK
KU
MLL
V1--1"3 0# ]1)'0$1% D0)9 %"7 2%"71"3 06*$ '0 '2* F1)*"&**5
D*) KLL?
D*) KLMK
UP
V1-1"3 0# B$1")*:& D0)9 %"7 2%"71"3 06*$ '0 '2* F1)*"&**
D*) KLL?
D*) KLMK
UP
J0/,-*'10" 0# J%,1'%- 7$*731"3 #0$ N,,$0%)2
S)' KLML
R%$ KLMK
M>
PP
D*) KLML
KU
P
?,+43*;.*")
83 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
C3":,4. 4"+. "9,332) F1,)4%
]3*1*)$0 ,+.*<$., H(`M 43"3,I
?,+43*;.*")
()43,$+, HTI
>K5K
ML>5P
OPL
T>5>
ML5L
OO5?
^B; 1"6*&'/*"'&
MP5L
KP5L
J0"'1"3*")1*&
OM5K
KL5U
>T5L
UT5>
MO5M
KP5?
T5T
MLU5U
MMO
O5U
@&V@Z7R
@&_US7@
_V7R
J%,1'%- D$*731"3
K>?5O
OTU5K
T>5T
V1--1"3
>U5L
D0)9 )-0&($* 40$9&
A%1- '$%)9& #0$ AJD
?5K
MT5L
>O5>
A*-0)%'10" 0# ("7*$3$0("7 &*$61)*&
L5>
L5>
C
Y%613%'10"%- %17&
M5U
M5K
M5K
C
___7S
Y@V7V
WR7@
@&_YV7Y
U&VWS7@
WS7Y
R*)2%"1)%- *G(1,/*"'& %"7 *-*)'$1)%- H V1$* V132'1"3 40$9&
(L!
F4.2$0d3,9*+,# H(`M 43"3,I
D*8' &*$61)* $*&*$6* !"'*$*&' 7($1"3 )0"&'$()'10"
!".$0
PU?5T
TT5>
G5C!
!".$0 D3$)# !".$0
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 84
M,$+")+ -"3 +4/,#20, $)# 4"+. "9,332)
N& % ,%$' %$$%"3*7 8. ,$16%'* )0")*&&10"%1$*5 D(* '0 KLLU 3-08%- $*)*&&10" 8%"9& ,(' &'$1"3*"' "0$/& #0$ ,$0<*)'
/1-*&'0"*& 15*5 7$*731"3 1" 8*$'2 BH] D0)9 8%&1"& 8. X("* KLML %"7 7$*731"3 1" %,,$0%)2 )2%""*- 8. /1&&*7 '2* '%$3*'& -*%71"3 '0 7*-%. 0# %)21*61"3 '2*&* /1-*&'0"*& 4*$* %&
G"3, #3,#1*)1 6"3E ./$) ,+.*<$.,#c D(* '0 1"%))($%'* %)'(%- $0)9 7$*731"3 G(%"'1'. 4%& '2* *&'1/%'*& ,$*,%$*7 8. '2* )0"&(-'%"' 4*$* 1"%))($%'* $*&(-'1"3 -*%71"3 '0 ,$0<*)' &)2*7(-* %"7 )0&' 421)2 2%& )%&)%71"3 1/,%)' 0" '2* 06*$%-- ,$0<*)' 7*-16*$.5
- N))17*"' 0# R;J J21'$% 1" R(/8%1 W%$80$ $*&(-'*7 1" &(&,*"&10" 0# &01- 7$*731"3 8. KU 7%.&
- D*-%. 1" 7*,-0./*"' 0# 7$*73*$& 1" '1/* 8. '2* )0"'$%)'0$
- )0"'$%)'0$
>0"6 <"5*0*K$.*") 5% \CL 4").3$4."3c %)'(%- 40$9 )0//*")*7 0"-. #$0/
- Y0"C7*,-0./*"' 0# $*G(1&1'* 7$*73*$& '0 /**' '2* 4**9-. '2* )0"'$%)'0$
?,0$% *) ;3":,4. +*., /$)#"9,3c
?,0$% *) $6$3#*)1 #3,#1*)1 6"3E 4").3$4.c D*-%. 1" '*"7*$1"3 ,$0)*&& 0))($$*7 %& '2* *-13181-1'. )$1'*$1% 4*$* 0##*$& $*)*16*7 #$0/ '2* )0"'$%)'0$& "*)*&&1'%'*7 $*61&10" 1" )0&' ,$0<*)' 7*-%.5
a$4E "- *).,13$.,# ;3":,4. <$+.,3 +4/,#20,c '40 ,%)9%3*& 15*5 7$*731"3 %"7 8*$'2 2%6* 1"71617(%- ,$0<*)' &)2*7(-*5 '0 /%9* % &1"3-* ,$0<*)' &)2*7(-*5 40$9& 8. '2* 7$*731"3 )0"'$%)'0$ 2%& $*&(-'*7 1" 7*-%.*7 2%"71"3 06*$ -*%71"3 '0 06*$%-- ,$0<*)' 7*-%.5
,$0<*)' $*G(1$*& &0/* 40$9 0" '2* 06*$ 0# '21& %$*% '0 '2* )0"'$%)'0$ 8. '21& ,*$1075
?,0$% *) 4"<;0,.*)1 6"3E 5% #3,#1*)1 4").3$4."3c N& ,*$ '2*
?,0$% *) "5.$*)*)1 +,423*.% 40,$3$)4,c #0$ '2* 8177*$ 4%& $*)*16*7 %#'*$ % ,*$107 0# MU /0"'2& #$0/ '2* J*"'$%
G,$+23,+ .$E,) 5% G5C!d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
85 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
2345 46789 O
,-GA/@@/A."- "( !227 /A +M)N/. D$(.-$#>
!3264
C B$0<*)' 4%& 7*-%.*7 8. 0"* .*%$ %"7 '2$** /0"'2& .*%$& %"7 )0/,-*'*7 41'21" '2* 8(73*'*7 )0&' 0# &91--*7 /%",04*$ %$* &0/* #%)'0$& '2%' -*%7& '0 &)2*7(-* %"7 )0&' 06*$$(" "*30'1%'10" 41'2 6*"70$&5
A"00"6*)1 $3, ./, E,% #,.$*0+ "- ;3":,4. L$;$4*.% 2)#,3 *)+.$00$.*")
a"4$.*")
L").3$4. !%;,
C
()9,+.<,). $;;3"9$0
R%$)2 KLL>
$*&,0"7*"'&
C3":,4. ?,+43*;.*")
VJJE V**7 ;*)'10" )0"&1&'1"3 0# #**7 B$*C2*%'*$& H V($"%)*
V(*- 3%& '$*%'1"3 &*)'10"
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 86
C3":,4. C0$))*)1 $)# 4233,). +.$.2+ ]3*1*)$00% ;0$)),# F).*4*;$.,#d M,9*+,#
]9,332)
C3":,4. 4"<;0,.*") #$.,
;*,'*/8*$CKLL?
D*)*/8*$CKLML
MP R0"'2&
C3":,4. 4"+. H(`M L3"3,I
?LL5O>
?LL5O>
Y!F
$*&,0"7*"'&
%--0)%'*7 8(73*'5 V0--041"3 %$* '2* /%<0$ /1-*&'0"*& ,-%""*7 41'2 '2*1$ %)'(%
C3":,4. C0$))*)1 $)# 4233,). +.$.2+
C3"4,++
\)1*),,3*)1
?,0$% H*) <")./+I
G*0,+."), ?,+43*;.*")
C0$)),# ?$.,
F4.2$0 ?$.,
!&&(* 0# *G(1,/*"' 7%'% &2**'&
MT N(3(&' KLL>
MT Y06*/8*$ KLL>
!&&(* 0# B H !Dc& H -1"* -1&' #0$ *"31"**$C 1"3
M> ;*,'*/8*$ KLL>
KT D*)*/8*$ KLL>
!&&(* 0# )0/,-*'* ,$0)*&& ,%)9%3* C VJJE
LM S)'08*$ KLL>
KT D*)*/8*$ KLL>
K5?
!&&(* 0# B H !Dc& H -1"* -1&' #0$ ('1-1'. 71&'$18('10"
MP S)'08*$ KLL>
LP V*8$(%$. KLLU
B$*,%$* %"7 1&&(* BH!Dc& %"7 -1"* -1&' #0$ ('1-1'1*&@0##&1'*&
LM V*8$(%$. KLLU
LM S)'08*$ KLL>
K? Y06*/8*$ KLL>
K
C
P
K? V*8$(%$. KLLU
MM N,$1- KLLU
LM ;*,'*/8*$ KLLU
ML Y06*/8*$ KL L?
MP S)'08*$ KLLU
MU ;*,'*/8*$ KLL?
B$*,%$* /%1" %1$ 8-04*$
LM S)'08*$ KLL>
KT D*)*/8*$ KLL>
K5?
B$*,%$* #$%)'10"%'0$ )0-(/"
LO S)'08*$ KLL>
LT Y06*/8*$ KLL>
M5M
!&&(* FS! #0$ /%1" %1$ 8-04*$
LM V*8$(%$. KLLU
K? N,$1- KLLU
K5?
!&&(* FS! #0$ #$%)'10" J0-(/"
LP V*8$(%$. KLLU
LU V*8$(%$. KLLU
M? V*8$(%$. KLLU
LK N,$1- KLLU
M5O
!&&(* FS! #0$ 6*&&*-&
LO R%$)2 KLLU
P
!&&(* FS! #0$ DJ;
KO S)'08*$ KLLU
!&&(* FS! #0$ ^($"*$
MO S)'08*$ KLLU
O5P
M5O MO5P
C
]3#,3*)1
87 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
G$)2-$4.23*)1 $)# ?,0*9,3%
?,0$% H*) <")./+I
G*0,+."), ?,+43*;.*")
C0$)),# ?$.,
F4.2$0 ?$.,
R%"(#%)'($1"3 %"7 7*-16*$. %' &1'* C V-(* 3%& )00-*$
L? N,$1- KLL?
R%"(#%)'($1"3 %"7 7*-16*$. %' &1'* C
KL X%"(%$. KLL?
LO ;*,'*/8*$ KLML
M?5>
D*-16*$. %' &1'* C ;-($$. B(/,&
LT V*8$(%$. KLL?
KP ;*,'*/8*$ KLML
M?5?
R%"(#%)'($1"3 %"7 7*-16*$. %' &1'* C I*' 3%& )0/,$*&&0$
K> V*8$(%$. KLL?
R%"(#%)'($1"3 %"7 7*-16*$. %' &1'* C V$%)'10"%'0$ J0-(/"
LO N,$1- KLL?
T5L
R%"(#%)'($1"3 %"7 7*-16*$. %' &1'* = DJ;
K? N,$1- KLL?
D*-16*$. %' &1'* = ^($"*$
LM N,$1- KLL?
KK S)'08*$ KLL?
T5U
R%"(#%)'($1"3 %"7 7*-16*$. %' &1'* C R%1" LM X("* KLL? %1$ 8-04*$
C
)-*%$%")*
M? N(3(&' KLLU
MP R%$)2 KLML
J161- 40$9 #0$ &(8C&'%'10" )0/,-*'*
K? N,$1- KLL?
KP R%$)2 KLML
MM
!"&'%--%'10" 0# 4*' 3%& )0/,$*&&0$
LT R%. KLL?
C
V%8$1)%'10" H *$*)'10" 0# 2*%'*$
K? X(-. KLL?
ML X("* KLML
ML5P
!"&'%--%'10" 0# DJ;
MP ;*,'*/8*$ KLL?
M5P
J0/,-*'10" 0# &)$(881"3 ("1' 40$9
MT D*)*/8*$ KLML
MT5U
LP N(3(&' KLL?
J0/,-*'* *-*)'$1)%- %"7 1"&'$(/*"'%'10" 40$9
K? ;*,'*/8*$ KL L?
MP D*)*/8*$ KLML
MO5>
R*)2%"1)%- )0/,-*'10"
K? ;*,'*/8*$ KLL?
MT D*)*/8*$ KLML
MO5U
MO5L
>5>
L")+.324.*")
C
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 88
M,$+")+ -"3 >4/,#20, ?,0$% L/$)1, *) C3":,4. >4";,c D(* '0 -%)9 0#
?,0$% -3"< 9,)#"3+ $)# 4").3$4."3+c
?,0$% *) +/*-.*)1 "- ,[*+.*)1 -$4*0*.*,+c
,$0<*)' &)0,* 4%& )2%"3*7 7($1"3 '2* ,$0<*)' &)0,* 4%& )2%"3*7 0" #0--041"3
R%". 0# '2* )$1'1)%- *G(1,/*"' &(,,-1*& 4*$* 7*-%.*7 #$0/ '2* )0"'$%)'0$& %"7 *G(1,/*"'& 4*$* 7*-%.*7 %##*)'1"3 '2*
/%9* &1'* $*%7. #0$ )0"&'$()'10"5 D*-%.
*&'1/%'*7 KO /0"'2& N "(/8*$ 0# 1/,$06*/*"' /*%&($*& 4*$* 1"1'1%'*7 7($1"3 '2* )0($&* 0# '2* ,$0<*)' 1/,-*/*"'%'10" 1")-(71"3 1/,-*/*"'%'10" 0# )%'%-.&' )00-*$ 421)2 4*$* "0' ,-%""*7 1" 0$131"%,$0<*)' ,-%"5
D*-%. 0# MP /0"'2& 1" 7*-16*$. 0# '0 ,$0<*)' &)2*7(-* D*-%. 0# MO /0"'2& 1" 7*-16*$. 0# '2* ^WB] UL ,*$)*"' 7*'%1-*7 *"31"**$1"3 /1-*&'0"* %"7 7*-%. 0# MP '0 MT /0"'2& 41'2 $*&,*)' '0 )$1'1)% )%&)%71"3 1/,%)' 0" ,$0)($*/*"' %"7 )0"&'$()'10"
]./,3 -$4."3+c S'2*$ #%)'0$& 421)2 4*$* "0' )0"&17*$*7 7($1"3 ,$0<*)' ,-%""1"3
)0"71'10"& #$0/ X(-. '0 ;*,'*/8*$ %)'161'1*& ;20$'%3* 0# &91--*7 /%",04*$ &()2 %& ,1,1"3 *"31"**$& %' '2* )0"'$%)'0$ &17*5
D*-16*$1*& 0# 8%-%")* -0&* 1'*/& #0$ J0/,-*'10" 0# J%'%-.&' J00-*$ Y06*/8*$ KLML5
G,$+23,+ .$E,) 5% 8CLa ." #,5"..0,),4E ;3":,4. M5 S"* 0# '2* $*%&0"& #0$ &)2*7(-* 06*$$(" 4%& 7*-%. #$0/ 6*"70$& /%"%3*/*"' %"7 ,$0<*)' '*%/ 1"1'1%'*7 % &*$1*& 1"'*$%)'10"& 41'2 &*"10$ /%"%3*/*"' 0# *G(1,/*"' '2* )2%--*"3*& %"7 7*)17* 0" '2* )0$$*)'16* /*%&($*&5 K5 WBJF ,$0<*)' ,$03$*&& 4%& )-0&*-. /0"1'0$*7 8. '2* ,$0<*)' '*%/ %"7 '2* )$1'1)%- 1&&(*& 4*$* *&)%-%'*7 '0 '2* '2* 1&&(*& 4*$* *6*" *&)%-%'*7 '0 '2*
0# $*)06*$. ,-%"& %"7 1""06%'16* /*%&($*& 4*$* 1/,-*/*"'*75 V0$ &0 '2%' 7$%41"3& 4*$* $*-*%&*7 0" ,$10$1'. 8%&1& 1" -1"* 41'2 '2* &*G(*")*
89 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
2345 46789 P
5EF/-G."- /-& +"&$#-.Q/A."- "( ;42R, 3.#F"#A
!3264
C )$1'1)%- #%)'0$& '2%' -*%7& '0 &)2*7(-* 06*$$("&5
M !"71% F1/1'*75
A"00"6*)1 $3, ./, E,% #,.$*0+ "- ;3":,4. L$;$4*.% ,[;$)+*")
V$0/ ?5T /1--10" ,%&&*"3*$& '0 KL /1--10" ,%&&*"C 3*$& %""(%--.
a"4$.*")
()9,+.<,). $;;3"9$0 #$.,
N(3(&' KLLU
$*&,0"7*"'&
C3":,4. C0$))*)1 $)# 4233,). +.$.2+ ]3*1*)$00% ;0$)),# F).*4*;$.,#d M,9*+,#
]9,332)
C3":,4. N(3(&' KLMM 4"<;0,.*") #$.,
S)'08*$ KLMK
MO R0"'2&
C3":,4. 4"+. H(`M L3"3,I
M?OK5P
$*&,0"7*"'&
1
Traffic News, Airport Authority of India; KPMG in India Analysis
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 90
C3":,4. G*0,+."),+
F4.2$0d\[;,4.,# A*)*+/ ?$.,
!$+E `$<,
>.$3. ?$.,
L")+.324.*") "- ().,13$.,# C$++,)1,3 !,3<*)$0 g2*0#*)1 H`>Lg(& J"0E$.$I
Y06*/8*$ KLLU
R%$)2 KLMK
Y06*/8*$ KLLU
R%$)2 KLMK
Y06*/8*$ KLLU
R%$)2 KLMK
Y06*/8*$ KLLU
V*8$(%$. KLML
B$*-1/1"%$1*&
Y06*/8*$ KLLU
;*,'*/8*$ KLMM
R%$)2 KLL?
X(-. KLMM
R%. KLL?
D*)*/8*$ KLML
R%. KLL?
R%$)2 KLML
Y06*/8*$ KLL?
D*)*/8*$ KLML
R%$)2 KLL?
X(-. KLMM
R%$)2 KLL?
X(-. KLML
S)'08*$ KLL?
X(-. KLMM
S)'08*$ KLL?
;*,'*/8*$ KLMM
S)'08*$ KLL?
;*,'*/8*$ KLMM
S)'08*$ KLL?
;*,'*/8*$ KLMM
N$$16%- F04*$ F*6*-
S)'08*$ KLL?
Y06*/8*$ KLML
N$$16%- E,,*$ F*6*-
X%"(%$. KLML
X%"(%$. KLMM
D*,%$'($* F04*$ F*6*-
N,$1- KLML
R%$)2 KLMM
D*,%$'($* E,,*$ F*6*-
X%"(%$. KLMM
;*,'*/8*$ KLMM
R%. KLL?
; *,'*/8*$ KLMM
D0/*&'1)
V*8$(%$. KLML
;*,'*/8*$ KLMM
!"'*$"%'10"%-
R%. KLL?
;*,'*/8*$ KLMM
D*)*/8*$ KLML
D*)*/8*$ KLMM
A$j$#,
V*8$(%$. KLMM
S)'08*$ KLMM
M"$# b"3E
R%. KLL?
D*)*/8*$ KLMM
b""# b"3E
N,$1- KLML
D*)*/8*$ KLMM
N,$1- KLML
Y06*/8*$ KLMM
;*,'*/8*$ KLML
D*)*/8*$ KLMM
N,$1- KLML
D*)*/8*$ KLMM
;*,'*/8*$ KLML
D*)*/8*$ KLMM
N,$1- KLML
D*)*/8*$ KLMM
Y06*/8*$ KLL?
X(-. KLMM
AJJ V-00$ ;-%8
Y06*/8*$ KLL?
D*)*/8*$ KLML
AJJ R177-* F*6*-
X(-. KLML
N,$1- KLMM
N(3(&' KLML
X(-. KLMM
\$3./6"3E ().,3)$.*")$0 !,3<*)$0
?"<,+.*4 !,3<*)$0
>.324.23, ML >2;,3+.324.23, ().,3)$.*")$0 !,3<*)$0
>.,,0 >.324.23,+
().,3)$0 A*)*+/*)1
L$3 C$3E
91 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
F4.2$0d\[;,4.,# A*)*+/ ?$.,
!$+E `$<,
>.$3. ?$.,
\[.,3)$0 A*)*+/*)1
N(3(&' KLML
D*)*/8*$ KLMM
G\> b"3E
N(3(&' KLML
D*)*/8*$ KLMM
N(3(&' KLML
Y06*/8*$ KLMM
N,$1- KLMM
D*)*/8*$ KLMM
V1$* V132'1"3
Y06*/8*$ KLML
D*)*/8*$ KLMM
W]NJ
S)'08*$ KLML
D*)*/8*$ KLMM
Y06*/8*$ KLML
Y06*/8*$ KLMM
Y06*/8*$ KLML
D*)*/8*$ KLMM
X(-. KLMM
;*,'*/8*$ KLMM
M,$+")+ -"3 >4/,#20, $)# L"+. ]9,332)+ ?,0$% *) /$)#*)1 "9,3 "- ./, +*.,c N' '2*
8* 2%"7*7 06*$ '0 '2* )0"'$%)'0$ #0$ &'%)91"3 0# )0"&'$()'10" /%'*$1%-& %"7 #%8$1)%'10" @ &'$()'($%- &'**- 40$9& )0"&'1'('*& % /%<0$ ,%$' 0# '2* <085 &'**- &'$()'($* 4*$* &'%)9*7 1" "0"C )0"'13(0(& %"7 &)%''*$*7 &1'*& %$0("7 '2* N1$,0$' ,$*/1&*& )%(&1"3 -031&'1)& ,$08-*/ %"7 7*-%. 1" #%8$1)%'10" 40$95
0# -%"7 4%& 2%"7*7 06*$ '0 '2* )0"'$%)'0$5 7*-%. 1" $*G(1$*7 $*/06%- 0$ 7*/0-1'10" 06*$$("5
()$4423$., ?CM+ $)# *),--,4.*9, ;0$))*)1c 0" '2* $*-0)%'10" 0# )$1'1)%- #%)1-1'1*& &()2 )0"71'10"1"3 ,-%"' %"7 3*"*$%'0$ $00/ 421)2 4*$* &'%'10"*7 1" %" 0-7 8(1-71"3 %"7 "**7*7 '0 8* 7*/0-1&2*7 ("7*$ '2* 7*/0-1'10" 0# '2* 0-7 &'$()'($* 4%&
>/"3.$1, "- 0$)# $. 4")+.324.*") +*., -"3 +.$4E*)1 "- 4")+.324.*") <$.,3*$0+c
2
70/*&'1) '*$/1"%- 8(1-71"3 %"7 0'2*$ %--1*7 &'$()'($*& 7(* '0 421)2 "0 -%"7 )0"'13(0(& '0 '2* 40$9 &1'* )0(-7
As on September 2011
D*-%. 1" )0/,-*'1"3 &*)($1'. )-*%$%")* 1"&17* 0,*$%'10"%- %$*%
C,)#*)1 3,9*+,# 52#1,. $;;3"9$0 -3"< C(g& 0,$#*)1 ." #,0$% *) $6$3#*)1 ;$4E$1,+c D(* '0 )0&' *&)%-%'10" 0# 4%& 06*$$(" 8. KL ,*$)*"'5 N $*61&*7 )0&' *&'1/%'* 4%& &(8/1''*7 '0 B(8-1) %,,$06%- 1& %4%1'*7K5 D(* '0 8(73*' )0"&'$%1"' '2*$* 1& 7*-%. 1" %4%$71"3 '2* )0"'$%)'&5
?,0$% *) "5.$*)*)1 $;;3"9$0+c Y;J^! N1$,0$' $*)*16*7 -%'* %,,$06%- #$0/ ;'%'* % 7*-%. 1" $*/06%- 0# *")$0%)2/*"'& 8. ;'%'* /("1)1,%-1'.5
fb"3EP."P320,X $1*.$.*")c B$0'*&' #$0/ '%9*" %$0("7 TL *"31"**$& 0## '2* /%<0$ $*%&0"& #0$ ,(&21"3 '2* ,$0<*)' )0/,-*'10" 7%'* #$0/ R%$)2 KLMK '0 S)'08*$ KLMK5
G,$+23,+ .$E,) 5% FF( ." #,5"..0,),4E ;3":,4. M5 J2%1$/%" 0# NN! 4%& 21/&*-# 1"60-6*7 %"7 2%7 /**'1"3& 41'2 '2* -*%7*$& 0# ,$0'*&'1"3 */,-0.**&5 !' 4%& 0"-. %#'*$ 21& %&&($%")* %31'%'10" 4%& &(&,*"7*75 K5 N-0"3 41'2 1"C20(&* B$0<*)' R0"1'0$1"3 H _(%-1'. N&&($%")* 1"7*,*"7*"' )0"&(-'%"' '0 *"&($* '2* G(%-1'. 0# )0"&'$()'10" 40$95
Study Bridging on the Project Urban Schedule Housing and Shortage Cost Overruns in India | 92
<"HH"/ #19Z9 (/& 9=00$941G$ '2*$* %$* )0//0" #%)'0$& 1/,%)'1"3 '2* ,$0<*)' 7*-16*$. %)$0&& '2*&* ,$0<*)'& 42*$*%& '2* $1&9 %$* ,*)(-1%$ '0 *%)2 %70,' 71##*$*"' %,,$0%)2*& '0 06*$)0/* 06*$%-- ,$0<*)' )0/,-*'10"5 ^%&*7 0" 0($ #*4 &(33*&'10"& '2%' )%" 8* %77$*&&*7 8. ,$0<*)' 04"*$& '0 2*-, $(-* 0(' 9*.
4J$ K,(//1/0 94(0$ )0"7()' 7*'%1-*7 $1&9 %&&*&&/*"' %' '2* &'%9* 20-7*$& '2%' )0(-7 1/,%)' ,$0<*)' ,$0<*)' 2%& $1&9& %$0("7 '1/*-. &(,,-. #$0/ *G(1,/*"' &(,,-1*$ %"7 Y;J^! %1$,0$' 2%& $1&9 $*-%'*7 '0 )0"&'$()'1"3 % 1& "**7 '0 70 % 6*$. 7*'%1-*7 %"%-.&1& 0# %- 8* #0$/%--. 70)(/*"'*7 %"7 /0"1'0$*7
_",19413 G1$% "A #$0=,(4"#(KK#"G(,9 R%<0$1'. 0# ,$0<*)'& #%)*7 21"7$%")*& 1" "**7 '0 1")-(7* %,,$06%-& ,$0)*&& %"7 '1/*-1"*&5 N". 7*61%'10" 1" %)21*61"3 '2*&* '1/*-1"*& &20(-7 2%6* % &(1'%8-* &17* '2*$* 1& % "**7 '0 /%9* %,,$06%%"7 )-*%$%")* ,$0)*&&*& &/00'2 8. 1"'$07()1"3 1""06%'16* /*%&($*& &()2 %& &1"3-* 41"704 )-*%$%")*5
2$G$,"K 6/4$0#(4$& 5#")$34 2$,1G$#- D3J$&=,$ )0"'$%)'0$& %$* )%$$.1"3 0(' 71##*$*"' 1'& 04" &)2*7(-* 421)2 1& 3*"*$%--. "0' 1"'*3$%'*7 '0 /%9* % &1"3-* ,$0<*)' 8%&*7 0" 1"71617(%- &)2*7(-*&5 !" '21& *##*)' 41-- "0' 8* &**" 0" %)'161'1*& 0# 1/,0$'%"' '0 2%6* 0"* % &1"3-* 1"'*3$%'*7 ,$0<*)' &)2*7(-* *")0/,%&&1"3 '2* &)2*7(-* 2%& '0 8* (,7%'*7 #$*G(*"'-. '0 /0"1'0$ 06*$%-- ,$0<*)' &'%'(&5
8=1,& K"%$# K(#4/$#9J1K %14J G$/&"#9 D*-%. 1" 3*''1"3 *G(1,/*"'& #$0/ &(,,-1*$&@)0"'$%)'0$& 1& %"0'2*$ $*%&0" 421)2 1/,%)'& '2* ,$0<*)' 7*-16*$.5 ^(1-71"3 % -0"3 '*$/ $*-%'10"&21, 41'2 6*"70$& )0(-7 2*-, 1" '1/*-. 7*-16*$. 0# 0# ,$0<*)' 8. ,$0<*)' 04"*$& %"7 '2* 80''-*"*)9& %"7 '%91"3 )0$$*)'16* %)'10"&5 '2* )0")*$"& %"7 '2*. /('(%--. %3$** 0" '2* )0$$*)'16* %)'10"&5
;/J(/3$ H"/14"#1/0 (0$/3- W5.EX 4" H"/14"# 4J$ K#"0#$99 (/& @"44,$/$3Z9 "/ #$0=,(# @(919 R0&' )0/,%"1*& 2%6* %" 1"C20(&* &.&'*/ 0# /0"1'0$1"3 ,$0<*)' ,$03$*&&5 )0(-7 2*-, 1" /0"1'0$1"3 '2* ,$0<*)' ,$03$*&& %"7 17*"'1#.1"3 80''-*"*)9& 1" %"
%& %" 1"'*$#%)* 8*'4**" ,$0<*)' &1'* %"7 7*-16*$.5
8=-L1/ A#"H $F$3=41"/ 4$(H "/ K#")$34 93J$&=,$ %))0("'%81-1'. 0# '2* '1/*-1"*& 316*" 1" '2* &13"*7 0## 8. %-- %3*")1*& %#'*$ %3$**1"3 '0 '2* '1/*-1"*& 316*" #0$ '2*1$ %)'161'1*&5
93 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
CB
7 E 6 ? < ; D
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 94
>,"@(, 1/910J49 b P$(#/1/0 A#"H 0,"@(, K#")$349
F0./"21/ 52*0#*)1 *)-3$+.324.23, ;3":,4.+ *+ $ 10"5$0 4/$00,)1, ."#$%& ./, +,4."3 *+ ,[;,4.,# ." ,[;,3*,)4, $) 2);3,4,#,).,# 0,9,0 "- *)9,+.<,). $)# ,[;$)+*") *) *)-3$+.324.23, $3"2)# ./, 6"30#7 F) ,+.*<$.,# =>? _V .3*00*") "- *)9,+.<,). 6"20# 5, ),,#,# 5% UVZV ." +2+.$*) ./, 10"5$0 13"6./ @7 !" 2)#,3+.$)# ./, *)-3$+.324.23, 4/$00,)1,+ $)# /"6 *)#2+.3% *+ ;3,;$3*)1 ." "9,34"<, ./,<& JCGD ().,3)$.*")$0 4")#24.+ fD0"5$0
$)# 9*,6+ "- ./, 6"30#X+ 0,$#*)1 ,)1*),,3*)1 $)# 4")+.324.*") 4"<;$)*,+7 !/*+ +239,% $0+" /*1/0*1/.+ ./$. 6/*0, ./, *).,)+*.% "- +"<, *++2,+ *+ +$<, $43"++ ./, 10"5,& "./,3+ /$9, <"3, *<;$4. *) $ ;$3.*420$3 3,1*") "3 4"2).3%7 1
KPMG International’s publicatio n — “Insi ght –The global infrastructure magazine”, November 2010
95 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
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
M,$+")+ -"3 +4/,#20, #,0$% 10"5$00%
`".,c M,+;")#,).+ 4"20# $)+6,3 <"3, ./$) "), ";.*") >"234,c D0"5$0 L")+.324.*") >239,% UVVe& JCGD ().,3)$.*")$0
M,$+")+ -"3 4"+. "9,332) 10"5$00%
`".,c M,+;")#,).+ 4"20# $)+6,3 <"3, ./$) "), ";.*") >"234,c D0"5$0 L")+.324.*") >239,% UVVe& JCGD ().,3)$.*")$0
2
Global Construction Survey 2008, KPMG Internationa l
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 96
a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
C3,-,33,# ;$3.),3+/*; 6*./ +2;;0*,3+ P #0$/%- 0$ 1"#0$/%- ,%$'"*$1"3 %3$**/*"'& ?L ,*$)*"' 0# $*&,0"7*"'& 2%7 &0/* ,$*#*$$*7 ,%$'"*$&21,& 41'2 '2*1$ )0"'$%)'0$& %"7 &(,,-1*$& 5 B$*#*$$*7 ,%$'"*$&21,& "0' 0"-. 2*-,*7 )0/,%"1*& '0 3*' $*7()*7 ,$1)*& 8(' %-&0 3(%$%"'**7 3%1" ,$10$1'. %''*"'10" #0$ )$1'1)%- ,$0<*)'& %"7 $*7()* )0"'$%)'(%- )-%1/&5
!$0,). <$)$1,<,). P 1& 0"* 0# '2* '0, %3*"7% #0$ 1"#$%&'$()'($* 8*&' ,*0,-* 7($1"3 %76*$&* )0"71'10"&5 %" 1/,$06*7 &%-%$. %"7 )% $**$ &'$()'($*5
b,X3, ,).,3*)1 *)." <"3, +.3$.,1*4 ;$3.),3+/*;+ $)# :"*). 9,).23,+ 6/,) ,[,42.*)1 0$31,3 ;3":,4.+& *) "3#,3 ." +;3,$# ./, 3*+E $)# 0,9,3$1, E,% +.3,)1./+ D=#G$- #$9K"/&$/4: [/14$& D4(4$9 >,"@(, <"/94#=341"/ 9=#G$- IBBV: +5.> 6/4$#/(41"/(,
b, .3% ." *#,).*-% E,% +.$-- ,$30% $)# 1*9, ./,< :"5 3".$.*") $)# .3$*)*)1 ";;"3.2)*.*,+7 D=#G$- #$9K"/&$/4: ;=#"K$: .1&&,$ ;(94 (/& NA#13( #$01"/ >,"@(, <"/94#=341"/ 9=#G$- IBBV: +5.> 6/4$#/(41"/(,
97 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
L"+. ,+4$0$.*") <$)$1,<,).c !" % 40$-7 42*$* )0&'& %$* )0"&'%"'-. %$* )%$*#(--. /%"%31"3 %-- *-*/*"'& 0# '2* '2*1$ ,$07()'161'.5 J0/,%"1*& */,-0. % 6%$1*'. 0# '*)2"1G(*& '0 /%"%3* $1&1"3 '2* &(,,-. )2%1" %"7 2*731"3 61'%)0//071'1*&5
M,$+")+ -"3 +4/,#20, #,0$% 10"5$00%
L").3$4. 40$2+,+c D(* '0 (")*$'%1"'.
`".,c M,+;")#,).+ 4"20# $)+6,3 <"3, ./$) "), ";.*")
%$* 1")$*%&1"3-. (&1"3 )0"'$%)' )-%(&*& )0/,%"1*& )200&* '0 8* '$%"&,%$*"' 8. $*#*$$1"3 '0 ,(8-1)-. %6%1-%8-* )0&' 1"71)*& 1" '2*1$ )0"'$%)'&5 N))0$71"3 '0 )-%1/ '0 ,$%)'1)* '21& #0$ '2* /%<0$1'. 0# '2*&* '.,*& 0# )0"'$%)'& %$* ,$*#*$$*7 04"*$& %$* 41--1"3 '0 &2%$* '2*&* $1&9& 8. %3$**1"3 '0 )0"'$%)' )-%(&*& '2%' )06*$ $1&1"3 )0&'&5
>"234,c D0"5$0 L")+.324.*") >239,% UVVe& JCGD ().,3)$.*")$0
KPMG in India’s point of view R%<0$1'. 0# $*%&0"& '2%' -*%7 '0 ,$0<*)' )0&' %"7 &)2*7(-* 06*$$("& 1" !"71% %$* "0' 40$-7 1" '*$/& 0# ,$0<*)' 7*-16*$.5
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 98
99 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
7 E 6 ? < ; D
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 100
101 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
5$4#",$=H
()#*$X+ #,<$)# -"3 "*0 N 1$+ *+ 4").*)2"2+0% *)43,$+*)1& ./"21/ ./, *)#*1,)"2+ ;3"#24.*") *+ $0<"+. +.$1)$).& 0,$#*)1 ." *)43,$+*)1 *<;"3.+ G$:"3 +,4."3 ;0$%,3+ $3, ]`DL& (]La& gCLa& 8CLa& ](a& DF(a& M(a& \++$3@ 4").3"00,# ;3*4, 3,1*<, $3, +"<, "- ./, E,% 4/$00,)1,+7
>,4."3 ]9,39*,6
!"71% 1& '2* #0($'2 -%$3*&' )0"&(/*$ 0# %$0("7 OL ,*$)*"' 1" !"71%:& ,$1/%$. *"*$3. )0"&(/,'10"K5
C,.3"0,2< ;3"#24.+ $)# )$.23$0 1$+ 4")+2<;.*")
5 O5 '2* &%/* ,*$107 '2* ,$07()'10" 0# "%'($%- 3%& 2%& 1")$*%&*7 %' T5> ^JRP5 )0"&(/,'10" 0# ,*'$0-*(/ ,$07()'& 1")$*%&*7 %' O5T ,*$)*"' ,5% %"7 3%& P >"234,c 8*+."3*4 4")+2<;.*") "- ;,.3"0,2< ;3"#24.+ $)# )$.23$0 1$+& C,.3"0,2< ;0$))*)1 $)# $)$0%+*+ 4,00 HCCFLI& $44,++,# i2), UV@W
1 2 3 4 5
India Oil & Gas sector competitive landscape, BMI, 11 December 2012 BP statisti cal review of world energy 2012, June 2012 Handbook of Statistic s on Indian Economy, Rese rve Bank of India, June 2013 Installed Refinery Capacity, PPAC, accessed June 2013 Historic production of petroleum products and natural gas, (PPAC), accessed June 2013
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 102
A*9, %,$3 ;0$)+ ;,3-"3<$)4,
C0$)),# ,[;,)#*.23, 9+ F4.2$0 ,[;,)#*.23,
S1- %"7 3%& 1& 0"* 0# '2* #*4 &*)'0$& /%1"-. 8*)%(&* 0# %33$*&&16* 1"6*&'/*"' %,,$06*7 0('-%.T5 k l( ;0$) $4.2$0 ,[;,)#*.23, *+ ")0% 2; ." F212+. UVVS >"234,c C0$))*)1 4"<<*++*")
J,% L/$00,)1,+ @7 >0"6 ;$4, "- ,[;0"3$.*") $4.*9*.*,+c > '1/*5
U7 R0&' 0# '2* %$* 41'"*&&1"3 % 7*)-1"1"3 ,$07()'10"5 7*)-1"*5
\<,31*)1 !3,)#+ _7 M*+E "- )$.23$0 1$+ *)-3$+.324.23, )". 5,*)1 0$*# #"6)c D(* '0 -04 *"'*$*7 1" '0 '2* 8(&1"*&& %"7 "04 '2*. /132' "0' -%. '2* 3%& ,1,*-1"*&5 V($'2*$ &0/* "*4 )0/,%"1*& '2%' 2%6* *"'*$*7 1" '2* 3%& 8(&1"*&& 70":' 2%6* $*G(1&1'* )%,%81-1'1*& '0 -%. 1"#$%&'$()'($*5
W7 =)#,32.*0*K$.*") "- ,[*+.*)1 )$.23$0 1$+ *)-3$+.324.23,c Y%'($%- 3%& ,$1/%$1-. 7(* '0 )0"&'$%1"*7 70/*&'1) &(,,-. 0# "%'($%- 3%&5
6 7 8 9
Seventh to Eleventh FiveYear Plans, Planning Commissi on Directorate General of Hydrocarbon (DGH) India to launch shale gas exploration bid during 12th Plan, Indian Express, dated 22 November, 2011 Poor consumers may get cash subsidy on LPG, kerosene and fertilizers, Economic Times, 6 July 2011
@7 \[;0"3$.*") $4.*9*.*,+c 1"6*&'/*"' 1" (,&'$*%/ %)'161'1*& 8-0)9& 5T
U7 =)4")9,).*")$0 +"234,+c !"71% 2%& 2(3* ,0'*"'1%- '0 7*6*-0, (")0"6*"'10"%- &0($)*& 0# 2.7$0)%$80" 1")-(71"3 ;2%-* 3%& %"7 V16* B-%"U
W7 A2,0 ;3*4,+c B*'$0- ,$1)*& 2%6* 8**" 7*)0"'$0--*7 41'2 *##*)' #$0/ X("* KLML %"7 '2*$* %$* ,-%"& '0 7*)0"'$0- 71*&*- ,$1)*& %& 4*--5 0" % /*)2%"1&/ 0# 71$*)' '$%"&#*$ 0# ?
103 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
5"%$#
b*./ +25+.$).*$0 $##*.*") *) ;"6,3 1,),3$.*") 4$;$4*.%& ;,$E ;"6,3 G$:"3 +,4."3 ;0$%,3+ $3, `!CL& `8CL& CDL(a& C!L& !$.$ ;"6,3& a$)4" C"6,3@ >0"6 ;$4, "- ;3":,4. ,[,42.*")& +/"3.$1, "- ;"6,3 ,O2*;<,).+& #,0$%+ *) 0$)# $4O2*+*.*") $)# 3,120$."3% $;;3"9$0+ $3, +"<, "- ./, E,% 4/$00,)1,+7
>,4."3 ]9,39*,6
!"71%:& ,04*$ 7*/%"7 %"7 &(,,-. 1& )0"'1"(0(&-. 1")$*%&1"35 D($1"3 K5
C,$E ;"6,3 #,<$)# +2;;0% *) ()#*$
)%,%)1'. #0$ ,04*$ 3*"*$%'10" 4%& %"7 '2* $*/%1"1"3 MP ,*$)*"' 1& 0'2*$ $*"*4%8-* &0($)*& 0# *"*$3.5
>"234,c C"6,3 >4,)$3*" $. $ D0$)4,& L,).3$0 \0,4.3*4 F2./"3*.%& UV@W
1 2 3
India power sector competitive landscape, BMI, 4 January 2013 “Power Scenario at a Glance”, Central Electric Authrotiy, June 2013 “Installe d Generation Capacity”, Central Electric Authority, April 2013
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 104
A*9, %,$3 ;0$)+ ;,3-"3<$)4,
C0$)),# .$31,. 9+ $4.2$0 $4/*,9,<,).
#%--*" &20$' 0# %)21*61"3 '2* ,-%""*7 2%-# 0# '2* ,-%""*7 )%,%)1'. %771'10"5 -009 8*''*$ %"7 %))0$71"3 '0 /17C'*$/ %$0("7 UL ,*$)*"' 0# '2* '%$3*'*7 )%,%)1'. %771'10"5 %771'10" '%$3*'& %$* /()2 2132*$ #$0/ '2* ,$*610(& .*%$ %)21 *6*/*"'5 V0$ 1& %$0("7 #0($ '1/*& '2*" '2* %)'(%)%,%)1'. %771'10"& %)21*6*7 1" '*"'2 ,-%"5 B%$'1)1,%'10" #$0/ '2* ,$16%'* &*)'0$ 1& %-&0 1")$*%&1"3 /%1"-. 7(* '0 #%60$%8-* $*#0$/&5
>"234,c C"6,3 >4,)$3*" $. $ D0$)4,& L,).3$0 \0,4.3*4 F2./"3*.%& UV@U
J,% L/$00,)1,+
\<,31*)1 !3,)#+
@7 ?,0$% *) ;3":,4. ,[,42.*")c !"71%
@7 C"6,3 M,-"3<+c
2%& 8**" #%1-1"3 '0 /**' '2* )%,%)1'. %$0("7 >L ,*$)*"'O 0# '2* ,-%""*7 '%$3*' )%,%)1'. %771'10" 4%& /*'5
U7 >/"3.$1, "- -2,0 $9$*0$5*0*.%c B04*$ 1" &*)($1"3 #(*- &(,,-. ,$1/%$1-. 7(* '0 -%)9 0# 3007 G(%-1'. 70/*&'1) -1/1'%'10" 1" 70/*&'1) 3%& &(,,-.5
W7 ?,0$% *) 0$)# $4O2*+*.*") $)# ,)9*3")<,). 40,$3$)4,+c N8&*")* 0# &1"3-* 41"704 )-*%$%")* /*)2%"1&/ $*&(-'& 1" 7*-%. 1" %)G(1$1"3 -%"7 '2(& -*%71"3 '0 % ,$0-0"3*7 ,$*C 7*6*-0,/*"' ).)-*5
_7 >/"3.$1, "- ;"6,3 ,O2*;<,).c #0$ '21& /1&/%')2 1& '2* *G(1,/*"' /%"(#%)'($*$& 4*$* ("%8-* '0 9**, ,%)* 41'2 1")$*%&1"3 3*"*$%'10" )%,%)1'.5
W7 C3"<".*") "- 3,),6$50, ,),31% -"3 ;"6,3 1,),3$.*")c
'%9*" &*6*$%- &'*,& '0 ,$0/0'* 1"6*&'/*"' %"7 ,$16%'* &*)'0$ ,%$'1)1,%'10" 1" '2* &*)'0$5 ;0/* 0# '2* /%<0$ $*#0$/& '2%' 2%6* 8**" B04*$ D*6*-0,/*"' %"7 A*#0$/ $1&* '0 "*4 0,,0$'("1'1*& #0$ ,04*$ ,-%.*$& *&,*)1%--. 1" '2* ,04*$ 3*"*$%'10" &,%)*5
1& ,$0/0'1"3 $*"*4%8-* *"*$3. #0$ ,04*$ 3*"*$%'10" '0 /**' '2* 7(%)2%--*"3*& 0# *"*$3. &*)($1'. %"7 ,0'*"'1%- #0$ &0-%$ *"*$3. %"7 '0 '%, '21& ,0'*"'1%- '2* X%4%2%$-%- Y*2$( T5
U7 ()43,$+,# ;3*9$., +,4."3 ;$3.*4*;$.*")c N& % $*&(-' 0# #%60$%8-* '2*$* 2%6* 8**" % ,-*'20$% 0# "*4 ,$0<*)'& %""0(")*7 8. '2* ,$16%'* ,$16%'* &*)'0$ 1" '0'%- *-*)'$1)1'. 3*"*$%'10" 2%& 3$04" $%,17-. #$0/ '0 #($'2*$ 1")$*%&* '0 PLCTL ,*$)*"' P5
4
Mid-term appraisal of Eleventh Five Year Plan, Planning Commission 5 Tenth and Eleventh Five Year Plan, Planning Commission 6 PM launches Jawaharlal Nehru National Solar Mission – Solar India, Press Information Bureau, 11 January 2010
105 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
<"(,
+,4."3+& ./, 1$; 5,.6,,) ./, #,<$)# $)# +2;;0% "- 4"$0 *+ 6*#,)*)1
G$:"3 +,4."3 ;0$%,3+ $3, L(a& >LLa@ >0"6 ;$4, "- ,[;0"3$.*")& 0$4E "- ,9$42$.*") *)-3$+.324.23, $)# ,)9*3")<,).$0 4")4,3)+ $3, +"<, "- ./, E,% 4/$00,)1,+7
>,4."3 ]9,39*,6
!"71% 1& '2* '21$7 -%$3*&' ,$07()*$ %80(' P5T ,*$)*"' 0# '2* '0'%- 3-08%,$07()'10"K5
L"$0 ;3"#24.*") $)# 4")+2<;.*")
,$1/%$. *"*$3. )0"&(/,'10" 1& &0($)*7 '2$0(32 )0%-5 $*)06*$%8-* )0%- $*&*$6*& &'007 %' %80(' MMU 8' %$* ,$06*7 $*&*$6*&O5 )0"&(/*$ 0# )0%- 1" !"71% %))0("'1"3 #0$ %80(' >P ,*$)*"' 0# '2* '0'%)0%- )0"&(/,'10"M5 S'2*$ &*3/*"'&
>"234,c G*)*+.3% "- L"$0
1 2 3 4
India mining sector competitive landscape, BMI, 26 October 2012 BP Statisti cal Review 2012, June 2012 Ministry of Coal Ministry of Coal
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 106
A*9, %,$3 ;0$)+ ;,3-"3<$)4,
C0$)),# ,[;,)#*.23, 9+ F4.2$0 ,[;,)#*.23,
&*)'0$ 4%& %8-* '0 %)21*6* '2* ,-%""*7 .*%$ ,-%"& 2%& 8**" 71&%,,01"'1"35 V0$ 2%& $*61&*7 1'& ,-%""*7 0('-%. 0# !YA $*%&0" 8*21"7 '21& 1& '2* /0"0,0-1&'1) $0-* 0# '2* ;'%'* 04"*7 ,-%.*$& 1" '2* !"71%" )0%- &*)'0$P5
k l( ;0$) $4.2$0 ,[;,)#*.23, *+ ")0% 2; ." F212+. UVVS >"234,c C0$))*)1 4"<<*++*")
J,% L/$00,)1,+ @7 >0"6 ;$4, "- ,[;0"3$.*") $4.*9*.*,+c S# '2* '0'%- $*)06*$%8-* )0% Q1"71)%'*7 %"7 '2* 1"#*$$*7: )%'*30$.T5 &*)'0$5
U7 >"4*"P,)9*3")<,). *++2,+c )0%- $*&*$6*& -1* 1" '2* #0$*&' %$*%& 1" &()2 &*"&1'16* %$*%& ,0&*& % *"61$0"/*"'%- )-*%$%")* %"7 #0$*&' )-*%$%")* ,$0)*&&*& #0$ ,$0<*)' 1/,-*/*"'%'10" 1& 3*"*$%--. &-045
W7 a$4E "- L"<;,.*.*")c &*)'0$ 1& ,$*70/1"%"'-. /0"0,0-1&'1) !"71% %"7 0'2*$ ;'%'* 04"*7 /1"*$&5 1"7*,*"7*"' $*3(-%'0$ 1" '21& &*)'0$5
_7 ()$#,O2$., ,9$42$.*") *)-3$+.324.23,c J0%- &*)'0$ ,$1/%$1-. 7*,*"7& 0" $%1- *6%)(%'10" #0$ 0##C'%9* %"7 7*-16*$. 0# )0%- &'0)9&5 I1'2 *6%)(%'10" 1"#$%&'$()'($* "**7& '0 8* '$%"&,0$'%'10"5
Z7 \)9*3")<,).$0 4")4,3)+c
W7 b*#,)*)1 #,<$)#P+2;;0% 1$;c
2%& -*7 '0 % "(/8*$ 0# *"61$0"/*"'% 70/1"%")* 0# 0,*" )%&' /1"1"3 '*)2"1G(*& 1" !"71% %& '2* ,$07()'10" #$0/ (&1"3 &()2 '*)2"1G(*& )%" &'%$' 1" &20$' &,%" 0# '1/*5
1")$*%&1"3 /%1"-. 7$16*" 8. '2* "*4 1"713*"0(& ,$07()'10" 1& "0' %8-* '0 2%& )$*%'*7 % 7*/%"7 &(,,-. 3%, !"71% 2%& 8**" 1")$*%&1"3-. 1/,0$'1"3 OO ,*$)*"' 1")$*%&* 06*$ 1/,0$'& 0# TU5? /1--10" '0"& 1" KLML=MMU5
\<,31*)1 !3,)#+ @7 L$;.*9, <*)*)1 -"3 4"$0c J%,'16* /1"1"3 #0$ )0%- 1& 3$%7(%--. 1")$*%&1"3 )0%- 8-0)9& 41'2 $*&*$6*& 0# OP5U? 81--10" '0""*& 2%6* 8**" %--0)%'*7 #0$ 420&* 1"60-6*/*"' 1" '2* )0("'$.:& 2%6* 8**" %--0)%'*7 MLL 8-0)9& 41'2 >5
U7 \--"3.+ -"3 .,4/)"0"1% ,)/$)4,<,).c !"71%" )0%- /1"*$& %$* 1" %" %''*/,' '0 *"2%")* '*)2"0-03. %"7 *"&($* ,$07()'161'. 3%1"&5 !"71%" ,-%.*$& %$* %-&0 4%$/1"3 (, '0 )0--%80$%'* 41'2 '2* #0$*13" ,%$'"*$& ,$0<*)'& 1" '2* &*)'0$5 5 6 7 8
Seventh to Eleventh Five Year Plans, Planning Commission Ministry of coal 2011 India Energy Handbook Coal Imports, Press Information Bureau,14 May 2012
107 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
D4$$,
()#*$ /$+ +23;02+ *3") ;3"#24.*") $)# *+ $ ),. ,[;"3.,3 "- +.,,0
G$:"3 +,4."3 ;0$%,3+ $3, >F(a& !(>L]& i>b& \++$3@
8*)#3$)4,+ *) 0$)# $4O2*+*.*")& #,;0,.*)1 *3") "3, 3,+,39,+ $)# +/"3.$1, "- 3$6 <$.,3*$0+ $3, +"<, "- ./, E,% 4/$00,)1,+7
>,4."3 ]9,39*,6
1 2 3 4
!"71% 2%& 8*)0/* #0($'2 -%$3*&' ,$07()*$ 0# )$(7* &'**- 1" '2* 40$-7 &*)0"7 -%$3*&' ,$07()*$ 8. KLMPK5
A*)*+/,# +.,,0 ;3"#24.*") $)# 4")+2<;.*")
/1--10" '0""*&5 N-'20(32 '2* ,*$ )%,1'%- &'**- (&* 2%& 93 1" KLMLCMM )0/,%$*7 '0 '2* 40$-7 %6*$%3* 0# %80(' KMP 935 &*3/*"' 4%& '2* -%$3*&' )0"&(/*$ TM ,*$)*"' 0# '2* '0'%- )0"&(/,'10"O5 S'2*$ /%<0$ &*3/*"'& 1")-(7* /%"(#%)'($1"3 %"7 %('0/081-* 1"7(&'$.5
>"234,c F))2$0 3,;"3. UV@@P@U& G*)*+.3% "- >.,,0
India Metal sector competitive landscape, BMI, 25 May 2012 Annual Report 2011-12, Ministr y of Steel Ministry of Steel IBEF Report
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 108
A*9, %,$3 ;0$)+ ;,3-"3<$)4,
C0$)),# ,[;,)#*.23, 9+ F4.2$0 ,[;,)#*.23,
N#'*$ %)21*61"3 0"-. OL ,*$)*"' %"7 OO ,*$)*"' 0# '2* ,-%""*7 0('-%. 7($1"3 '2* &'**- &*)'0$ 2%& ,0&'*7 % &'$0"3 %)21*6*7 %80(' UL ,*$)*"' 0# '2* ,-%""*7 /%1" $*%&0" 8*21"7 '21& 1& '2* %33$*&&16* &,*"71"3 8. '2* &'**- )0/,%"1*& #0$ P5
k l( ;0$) ,[;,)#*.23, #23*)1 F;3*0 UVVRP?,4,<5,3 UV@V >"234,c C0$))*)1 4"<<*++*")
J,% L/$00,)1,+
\<,31*)1 !3,)#+
@7 8*)#3$)4,+ *) 0$)# $4O2*+*.*")+c
@7 !"
F%"7 %)G(1&1'10" 1& % &*"&1'16* 1&&(* 1" !"71%5 F%"7 %)G(1&1'10" %,,$06%-& 0#'*" '%9* % -0"3 '1/* 1" '2* )0("'$. '2* *"61$0"/*"'%- )-*%$%")*& %-&0 3*"*$%--. '%9* -0"3*$ '2%" &'1,(-%'*7 '1/* 1" '2* )0("'$.5
U7 >/"3.$1, "- 3$6 <$.,3*$0+c &'**- /%"(#%)'($*$& 0#'*" #%)* '2* &20$'%3* 0# $%4 /%'*$1%-& *&,*)1%--. )0%- %"7 "%'($%- 3%& 1" !"71%5 !"71% 1& %" 1/,0$'*$ 0# 2132 3$%7* )091"3 )0%421)2 1& % /%<0$ #**7&'0)9 #0$ '2* &'**- &*)'0$5
W7 ?,;0,.*)1 *3") "3, 3,+"234,+c !"71% 2%& -1/1'*7 $*&0($)*& 0# 1$0" 0$*5 R0$*06*$ '2* 1$0" 0$* $*&0($)*& %$* 7*,-*'1"3 #%&' 1" '2* )0("'$.5
_7 a$4E "- $#,O2$., *)-3$+.324.23,c I21-* '2* )091"3 )0%- 1& 1/,0$'*7 '2* &'**- /%"(#%)'($1"3 ,-%"'& %$* 8($7*" 1" '2*1$ '$%"&,0$'%'10" )0&'&5
5 6
Seventh to Eleventh FiveYear Plans, Planning Commissi on IBEF Report
61*4 0# '2* &($3* 1" &'**- 7*/%"7 1" ,$0<*)'& 2%6* 8**" 1"1'1%'*7 1" '2* $*)*"' ,%&' '0 1")$*%&* '2* ,$07()'10" %" %""(%- %6*$%3* $%'* 0# 06*$ ML ,*$)*"' '1-- KLMO %"7 40(-7 $*G(1$* ,$07()'10" )%,%)1'.T5
U7 \--"3.+ -"3 .,4/)"0"1% ,)/$)4,<,).c !"71%" &'**/%"(#%)'($*$& %$* 4%$/1"3 (, '0 '2* %,,-1)%'10" 0# %76%")* '*)2"0-031*& 1"<*)'10" 1" '2* ,$07()'10" ,$0)*&&*&5 ^0'2 ,(8-1) %"7 ,$16%'* &*)'0$ ,-%.*$& %$* %-&0 1")$*%&1"3 '2*1$ AHD 8(73*' 41'2 #0)(& 0" 1"'$07()'10" 0# %76%")* '*)2"0-031*&5
W7 G,31,3+ $)# $4O2*+*.*")+c !"71%" &'**- 1"7(&'$. 2%& 41'"*&&*7 % "(/8*$ 0# /%<0$ /*$3*$ %"7 %)G(1&1'10" 7*%-& 1" '2* $*)*"' ,%&'5
109 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
5"#49
;,34,). *) UVVZPVY ." _V ;,34,). *) UV@@P@U
G$:"3 +,4."3 ;0$%,3+ $3, D"9,3)<,). $2./"3*.*,+& F#$)* D3"2;& ?C 6"30#& FCG !,3<*)$0@ >0"6 ;$4, "- #,9,0";<,).& 0$4E "- *).,13$.,# $;;3"$4/ $)# /*1/0% 4")1,+.,# ;"3.+ $3, +"<, "- ./, E,% 4/$00,)1,+7
>,4."3 ]9,39*,6
1 2 3 4 5
!"71%:& ,0$' &*)'0$ 2%"7-*& %80(' ?P ,*$)*"' 0# !"71%:& '0'%- 1"'*$"%'10"%)%$30 8. 60-(/* %"7 %80(' >L ,*$)*"' 8. 6%-(*K5
0# /%<0$ ,0$'& 2%& 8**" $*7()1"3 1" 3$04'2 '*$/& 42*" )0/,%$*7 '0 "0"C 421-* '2%' %' "0"C/%<0$ ,0$'& 2%& 8**" 71##*$*")* 0# 06*$ ML ,*$)*"'5 KLKL %1/& '0 1")$*%&* '2* ,&0$' '2*"O ?L ,*$)*"' '0 %80(' UL ,*$)*"'P $*7()1"3 ,0$' )0"3*&'10"5
>"234,c ()#*$) C"3.+ F++"4*$.*")& L3*+*0& JCGD *) ()#*$ $)$0%+*+
India port sector,BMI, accessed 4January 2013 India in Business, Ministry of External Affairs Indian Ports Association , Crisil; KPMG in India analysis Ministr y of Shipping’s Maritime Agenda 2010-20 Indian Ports Association, Crisil; Maritime Agenda 2010-20; KPMG in India analysis
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 110
A*9, %,$3 ;0$)+ ;,3-"3<$)4,
C0$)),# ,[;,)#*.23, 9+ F4.2$0 ,[;,)#*.23,
,-%"& 4%& )$1'1)%--. ("#%60($%8-* 41'2 '%$3*' 1" '2* ,0$' &*)'0$ 1& $*7()*7 '0 !YA T5
>"234,c C0$))*)1 4"<<*++*")
J,% L/$00,)1,+
\<,31*)1 !3,)#+
@7 ?,0$% *) ()-3$+.324.23, #,9,0";<,).c !' 2%& 8**" 08&*$6*7
@7 L$;$4*.% $##*.*")c
'2%' 0# '2* K>T ,0$' ,$0<*)'& *"61&%3*7 ("7*$ Y%'10"%- R%$1'1/* > 7*6*-0,/*"' 0# ,0$' ,$0<*)'&
U7 a$4E "- *).,13$.,# $;;3"$4/c ;'%"7%-0"* 1"1'1%'16*& 8. 6%$10(& /1"1&'$1*& $*&(-'& 1" -%)9 0# /%&'*$ ,-%" %,,$0%)2 #0$ 7*6*-0,/*"' 0# /*3% ,$0<*)'&5
W7 ]9,3 ;"3. 2.*0*K$.*") 0,9,0+c ?L ,*$)*"' %& %3%1"&' '2* 3-08% '($"%$0("7 '1/* %"7 2%/,*$1"3 3-08%)0/,*'1'16*"*&& 0# /0&' 0# !"71%" /%<0$ ,0$'&5
U5
U7 L/$)1, *) ().,3)$.*")$0 .3$#, ;$..,3)c 1'& '$%7* ,%''*$" #$0/ '$%71'10"%70/1"%")* 0# '2* E; %"7 I*&'*$" &2%$* 0# 7*6*-0,*7 /%$9*'& &()2 %& *1'2*$ $*/%1"*7 &%/* 0$ 7*)$*%&*7 '0 2%-# 0# '2*1$ $*&,*)'16* -*6*-& 7($1"3 '2* &%/* ,*$107?5
W7 L/$)1,+ *) L$31" 8$)#0*)1c !"71%" /%$1'1/* &*)'0$ 2%& 8**" 41'"*&&1"3 '2* #0--041"3 /%<0$
6 7 8 9 10
Seventh to Eleventh FiveYear Plans, Planning Commissi on Crisil research Crisil research; KPMG in India analysis Ministry of Commerce, KPMG in India analysis Indian Ports Associatio n, Crisil, KPMG in India analysis
!" '*$/& 0# 06*$%-- )%$30 2%"7-*7 1" 0# *%&'*$" /%<0$ ,0$'& 2%& 8**" 06*$'%9*" 8. 4*&'*$" /%<0$ ,0$'&5 2%"7-*7 %' 4*&'*$" /%<0$ ,0$'& *%&'*$" /%<0$ ,0$'& 1")$*%&*7 %' % ML 2%& 8**" 41'"*&&1"3 % 71##*$*"' 3$04'2 &'0$.5 !" '*$/& 0# %8&0-('* ,1* 0# %$0("7 UUP /1--10" '0""*&5 '0""*&T5
111 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
'(1,%(-9
M$*06$%+ *+ ./, ;3*)4*;0, <"#, "- .3$)+;"3.$.*") -"3 -3,*1/. $)# ;$++,)1,3+ ()#*$) M$*06$%+ ,):"%+ $ ),$3 <")";"0% ;"+*.*") *) ./, 4"2).3% 8*1/0% 4")1,+.,# ),.6"3E $)# -3,O2,). D"9,3)<,). *).,39,).*")+ $3, +"<, "- ./, E,% 4/$00,)1,+7
>,4."3 ]9,39*,6
1 2 3
8**" 1")$*%&1"3 #$0/ %80(' T5K 81--10" M5
M$*0 -3,*1/. $)# ;$++,)1,3 <"9,<,).
1")$*%&1"3 #$0/ >KU /1--10" '0""*& ,*$)*"'M5 J0%- 1& '2* -*%71"3 )0//071'. '$%"&,0$'*7 '2$0(32 $%1-4%.& %"7 1" KLMLCMM 1'& &2%$* 1" '0'%- $%1#$*132' 1& %$0("7 OT ,*$)*"'K5 S'2*$ 9/& 0# "*4 -1"*& 1" '2* ,*$107 KLMLC KLKL5
Ministry of Railways, KPMG in India analysis Crisil research; KPMG in India analysis Indian railways, web search
>"234,c G*)*+.3% "- M$*06$%+
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 112
A*9, %,$3 ;0$)+ ;,3-"3<$)4,
C0$)),# ,[;,)#*.23, 9+ F4.2$0 ,[;,)#*.23,
1" '2* $%1-4%.& &*)'0$& 2%6* 8**" 6*$. ,*$)*"' 1" '2* ;*6*"'2 B-%"5 !" '2* )*"' -04*$ '2%" '2* *%$-1*$ ,$0<*)'10" 0# %"7 ,$16%'* 1"6*&'/*"'& %$* 8*-04 '2* 1"6*&'/*"' *"61&%3*7 1" $%1-4%.& 1& !YA O5
>"234,c C0$))*)1 4"<<*++*")
J,% L/$00,)1,+
\<,31*)1 !3,)#+
@7 ()-3$+.324.23, 4/$00,)1,+c A%1-4%.
@7 M"0, "- CCCc I1'2 '2* *"'$. 0# ,$16%'* )0/,*'1'16*"*&& %/0"3 ,(8-1) 6*$&(& ,$16%'* ,-%.*$& 1& 3$%7(%--. $*&(-'1"3 1" )0/,*'1'16* 0##*$1"3 '0 *"7 (&*$&5
*&,*)1%--. 1" %$*%& '2%' %$* )$1'1)% 1& "0' /07*$" .*'5
U7 a$4E "- 3,0*$50, -3,*1/. .3$)+;"3.$.*") +,39*4,+c F%)9
U7 A"42+ ") <,.3" 3$*0c I21-* )($$*"'-. 6*$. #*4 )1'1*& &()2 %& D*-21 %"7 W.7*$%8%7 %"7 F()9"04 %$* )($$*"'-. P5
0# '$%)9& 7*71)%'*7 '0 #$*132' '$%"&,0$'%'10" %"7 -04 ,$10$1'. %))0$7*7 '0 #$*132' '$%1"& 61&CZC61& '0 ,%&&*"3*$ '$%1"& 2%6* 8**" $*&(-'1"3 1" $%1- 8*1"3 (&(%--. )0"&17*$*7 %& &-04 %"7 ("$*-1%8-* '$%"&,0$'%'10" '2* )0/,*'1'16*"*&& 0# $%1-4%.&5
W7 M,120$."3% 4/$00,)1,+c !")$*%&1"3-. #$*G(*"' 1"'*$6*"'10"& 8. !"71%" $%1-4%.& 1" 7*'*$/1"1"3 ,$1)1"3 21"7*$*7 '2* 8(&1"*&& ,0'*"'1%- '2%' ,$16%'* ,-%.*$& 2%6* 8**" *"61&10"1"3 8**" '2* )%&* 41'2 ,$16%'* 1"6*&'0$&5 ,0-1). 306*$"1"3 ,$16%'* ,%$'1)1,%'10" 1& &'1-- *60-61"35
4 5 6 7
Seventh to Twelfth Five Year Plans, Planning Commission Indian railways, city metro authorities , web search Ministr y of Railways, web search DFC website, KPMG in India Analysis
W7 *)-3$+.324.23,c \**,1"3 %" *.* 0" '2* '40 D*71)%'*7 V$*132' J0$$170$& T5 !" /1--10" '0"& %""(%--. 8. KLKMCKK>5
113 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
<1G1, NG1(41"/
G$:"3 $*3;"3. #,9,0";,3+ $3, FF(& DhJ& DGM@ 8*1/ 4$;*.$0 3,O2*3,<,).+& *)43,$+*)1 +,423*.% 4")4,3)+& 0$4E "+E*00,# <$);"6,3 $3, +"<, "- ./, E,% 4/$00,)1,+7
>,4."3 ]9,39*,6
1 2
8**" ,-%.1"3 %" 1")$*%&1"3-. )$1'1)%$0-* 1" '2* 06*$%-- &)2*/* 0# %1$C8%&*7 0$ ,%&&*"3*$ /06*/*"'5
F*3 -3,*1/. $)# ;$++,)1,3 <"9,<,).
/1--10" '0""*& 1" KLLTCL> '0 %80(' K5K 2%& 1")$*%&*7 #$0/ %80(' ?T /1--10" '0 MP? /1--10" 7($1"3 '2* &%/* ,*$107 K5 %))*&&0$1*& %"7 ,*$1&2%8-* 1'*/&5 J2%"3*& 1" $*3(-%'0$. &,%)* 2%6* '2* )($$*"'-. 71&)(&&*7 ,0-1). 3(17*-1"*& 0" %--041"3 #0$*13" )%$$1*$& ,-*'20$% 0# 1"6*&'/*"' 0,,0$'("1'1*&5
India airport sector, BMI, accessed 3 January 2013 Crisil, Airports Authority of India, KPMG in India analysis
>"234,c LM(>(a& FF(& JCGD *) ()#*$ $)$0%+*+
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 114
A*9, %,$3 ;0$)+ ;,3-"3<$)4, 0"-. &*3/*"' 41'21" '$%"&,0$'%'10" 1"#$%&'$()'($* '2%' 2%& 41'"*&&*7 6*$&(& '2* ,-%""*7 %--0)%'10"5 I1'2 '2* *"61&%3*7 %' '2* )0//*")*/*"' 0# '2* %--0)%'10" 2%& 8**" 1")$*%&1"3 /%"1#0-7 1" %--0)%'10" 1")$*%&*7 #$0/ -*&& '2%" !YA '0'%- 1"6*&'/*"' 1" %1$,0$' 1"#$%&'$()'($*5 5
C0$)),# ,[;,)#*.23, 9+ F4.2$0 ,[;,)#*.23,
>"234,c C0$))*)1 4"<<*++*")
J,% L/$00,)1,+
\<,31*)1 !3,)#+
@7 a$4E "- +E*00,# ;3"-,++*")$0+c
@7 ()43,$+, *) *)-3$+.324.23, *)9,+.<,).+c
;20$'%3* 0# &91--*7 /%",04*$ 1" )161- %61%'10" &*)'0$5
U7 A*)$)4*$0 4")+.3$*).+c I1'2 '2*$* 1& % "**7 #0$ -%'*&' '*)2"0-031*& %"7 1"#$%&'$()'($* %' '2* %1$,0$'&
W7 ()-3$+.324.23$0 4")+.3$*).+c J161%61%'10" 0,*$%'10"& 8*1"3 %&&*'C '2* )%,1'%- )0&' ("7*$ )0"'$0- 1& %" 1//*"&* )2%--*"3*5 F%)9 0# -0"3 %771'10"%- -%"7 %6%1-%81-1'. #0$ #($'2*$ 1/,%)' '2* ,$0&,*)'& 0# )161- %61%'10" 1"#$%&'$()'($* %& 7*/%"7 3$04& -%"7 %)G(1&1'10" %"7 *"61$0"/*"'%)0")*$"& %$* -19*-. '0 8*)0/* %-- '2* /0$* )$1'1)%- 1" '2* .*%$& %2*%75
3 4
Seventh toTwelfth FiveYear Plans, Planning Commissi on Airport Authority of India, Crisil Research
,*$)*"' 0# '2* 1"6*&'/*"'& 40(-7 8* O 5
U7 $*3;"3.+c ,*$)*"'%3* 0# '2*1$ &*$61)*& '0 $0('*& % &($3* 1" -*1&($* %"7 /*71)%- '0($1&/ 1"'*$"%'10"%--. %"7 ,$0617* 71$*)' )0""*)'161'. '0 "0"C/*'$0 '0($1&'
W7 ()43,$+, *) ]./,3 D3"6./ F9,)2,+c S,,0$'("1'1*& 1" 3*"*$%- %61%'10" %' % #%&' ,%)* 41'2 3$041"3 80''0/C -1"* 0# )0$,0$%'* %"7 2132 "*' 40$'2 1"71617(%-&5
115 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
'"(&9
b*./ ,[;$)+*") "- /*1/6$%+ $)# 323$0 3"$#+& ./, #,<$)# -"3 3"$# -3,*1/. /$+ *)43,$+,# G$:"3 ;0$%,3+ *) 3"$# 4")+.324.*") +,4."3 $3, `8F(& aN!& M,0*$)4,@ ?,0$%+ *) ;3":,4. ,[,42.*") $)# +25P";.*<$0 *)-3$+.324.23, -"3 <$*).$*)*)1 3"$#+ $3, +"<, "- ./, E,% 4/$00,)1,+7
>,4."3 ]9,39*,6
1 2 3 4
316*" '2%' '2* &2%$* 0# 21324%.& 1" 70/*&'1) #$*132' /06*/*"' 2%& <(/,*7 #$0/ % -04 0# MM ,*$)*"' 0# UK /1--10" '0""*& 1" M?PLCPM '0 TM KLL>CLUK5
M"$# -3,*1/.
8**" 3$041"3 #$0/ TKM 8'9/ 1" KLLPC 5 I21-* '2* Y%'10"%- W1324%.& )0"&'1'('* % /*%3*$ K ,*$)*"' 0# '2* '0 %80(' OL ,*$)*"' 0# '2* '0'%- $0%7 #$*132'O ("7*$-1"1"3 '2* "**7 #0$ )0"&'%"' /%1"'*"%")* %"7 %771'10" 0# "*4 21324%.&5
>"234,c LM(>(a& JCGD *) ()#*$ $)$0%+*+
%$* '%91"3 &*6*$%- /%<0$& /*%&($*& '0 ,$0/0'* ,$16%'* ,%$'1)1,%'10" 1" )0"&'$()'10"@/%1"'*"%")* 0# ;'%'* $0%7&5
India road sector, BMI, accessed 4 January 2013 IDBI Capital’s Railways Sector report 2010, KPMG in India Analysis Crisil, KPMG in India Analysis KPMG in India’s report — ‘Adding Wheels’
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 116
A*9, %,$3 ;0$)+ ;,3-"3<$)4,
C0$)),# ,[;,)#*.23, 9+ F4.2$0 ,[;,)#*.23,
'21& '$*"7 30' $*6*$&*7 1" '2* -%&' -%'*&' '2* #%)' '2%' ,-%""*7 1"6*&'/*"' 1" 8*31""1"3 0# '2* ,-%" 4%& 06*$ !YA 42%' 4%& ,-%""*7 #0$ '2* ;*6*"'2 ,-%"5 #$0/ 0$131"%- ,$0<*)'10"&P 1" 1"6*&'/*"' 1& 7(* '0 % &20$'#%-- 1" '2* %4%$7 0# $0%7 ,$0<*)'& 8. YWN! 7($1"3
>"234,c C0$))*)1 4"<<*++*")
J,% L/$00,)1,+
\<,31*)1 !3,)#+
@7 ?,0$% *) ,[,42.*") "- ;3":,4.+c
@7 A"42+ ") #,9,0";<,). ",[;3,++6$%+c
B*$&1&'*"' 1&&(*& 1" -%"7 %)G(1&1'10" %"7 *"61$0"/*"'%- )-*%$%")* 2%6* /%<0$1'. 0# )%&2 )0"'$%)' ,$0<*)'5 N6*$%3* '1/* 06*$$(" 2%& 8**" %80(' KK /0"'2&T5
U7 >25P";.*<$0 *)-3$+.324.23,c V%)'0$& &()2 %& -%)9 0# '1/*-. %"7 G(%-1'. 1"'*3$%'*7C)(/C%('0/%'*7 '0- )0"3*&'10"& %"7 #$*G(*"' 610-%'10" 8* )%$$1*7 8. % '$()9 $*&(-' 1" &(8C 0,'1/%- $0%7 1"#$%&'$()'($* %"7 #$*132' $*7()*7 %6*$%3* &,**7 0# '$()9& %"7 0'2*$ )0//*$)1%- 6*21)-*&5
5 6 7
Seventh toTwelfth FiveYear Plans, Planning Commissi on CRISIL Report on Road Sector, 2010 Seventh to Eleventh Five Year Plans, Planning Commissi on
41'"*&&1"3 1")$*%&*7 #0)(& 0" %''*/,' '0 ,$0617* 7*71)%'*7 $0%7 )0""*)'161'. 8*'4**" "*%$C,-%)*7 1/,0$'%"' )1'1*&5 N '0'%- 0# %$0("7 >
U7 ()43,$+, *) ";;"3.2)*.*,+c R0&' 0# '2* ,$0<*)'& ("7*$ B2%&* !!! Y%'10"%- W1324%. D*6*-0,/*"' 7($1"3 KLMLCMPT5
W7 ()43,$+*)1 #,<$)# -"3 ,[.,)+*9, 3"$# ),.6"3Ec !")$*%&1"3 7*/%"7 1" '1*$ K )1'1*& 1& )$*%'1"3 /(-'1,-* )0"&(/,'10" 2(8& 1"&'*%7 0# '2* )0"6*"'10"%- Q7*/%"7 1&-%"7&: 1" $*&(-'1"3 1" '2* "**7 #0$ 1/,$06*7 $*'%1-1"3 1& 1")$*%&1"3 '2* "**7 #0$ -%&' /1-* $*%)2 421)2 1& #*%&18-* 0"-. 61% 8**" 7$161"3 '2* 7*6*-0,/*"' 0# ;'%'* %"7 $($%- $0%7&5
117 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
?$,$3"H
./"21/ ./, $9,3$1, 3,9,)2, ;,3 2+,3 HFMC=I 3,<$*)+ $. $ 0"6 0,9,0 4"<;$3,# ." 10"5$0 $9,3$1,
G$:"3 +,4."3 ;0$%,3+ $3, g>`a& G!`a& F*3.,0& h"#$-"),& (#,$@ 8*1/ 4"<;,.*.*")& *)-3$+.324.23, 5"..0,),4E+ $)# D"9,3)<,). 3,120$.*")+ $3, +"<, "- ./, E,% 4/$00,)1,+7
>,4."3 ]9,39*,6
/%$9*' 2%& )0"'1"(*7 '0 &204 )0"&1&'*"' 3$04'2 41'2 '0'%&(8&)$18*$& $*%)21"3 /0$* '2%" U?U K
!,0,4"< +25+43*5,3 5$+,
I1$*-*&& &(8&)$18*$& )0"'$18('* /0$* '2%" UT> /1--10" 41'2 % '*-*C7*"&1'. 0# /0$* '2%" >L ,*$)*"'K E$8%" 41$*-*&& /%$9*' 1& $*%)21"3 &%'($%'10" 41'2 % '*-*C7*"&1'. 0# /0$* /%$9*' 2%& -0' 0# ,0'*"'1%- 41'2 % '*-*C 7*"&1'. 0# OL ,*$)*"' 0"-.K !"71%" '*-*)0/ &*$61)* $*6*"(*& %$* 5 >"234,c ?]! P F))2$0 M,;"3.& UV@VPUV@@Q \4")"<*4 ().,00*1,)4, =)*.& UV@U
1 2 3
India telecommun ication sector competitive landscape, BMI, 18 December 2012 Telecom Subscription Data, TRAI, March 2013 Telecom outlook, Crisil Research, April 2013
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 118
A*9, %,$3 ;0$)+ ;,3-"3<$)4,
C0$)),# ,[;,)#*.23, 9+ F4.2$0 ,[;,)#*.23,
,2*"0/*"%- %"7 '21& &*)'0$ /0&'-. 0(',*$#0$/& 1'& 1"6*&'/*"' '%$3*'& %& %)21*6*/*"' 1& 7(* '0 % TL ,*$)*"' 2132*$ -*6*- 0# 1"6*&'/*"' 8. '2* ,$16%'* &*)'0$ %& )0/,%$*7 '0 '2* 0$131"%- ,$0<*)'10"&O5 J0/,*'1'10" 1" '21& &*)'0$ 2%& 8**" G(1'* '0 '2* *)0"0/. %"7 '2* (&*$& '2$0(32 1/,$06*7 G(%-1'. 0# &*$61)* %' -04*$ )0&'&5
>"234,c C0$))*)1 4"<<*++*")
J,% L/$00,)1,+
\<,31*)1 !3,)#+
@7 ().,)+, L"<;,.*.*")c B$*&*")* 0#
M5 )0"'$18('1"3 '0 NABE (,-1#'T5
$*&(-'1"3 1" 6*$. -04 NABE -*6*-&5 ,-%.*$&5
U7 M,120$.*")c D*-%. 1" $*61&10" 0# (")*$'%1"'. 1" '2* &*)'0$5
W7 ()-3$+.324.23, g"..0,),4Ec Y*'40$9 "*'40$9 1"#$%&'$()'($*& 1" $($%- %$*%& $*/%1" -1/1'*75
_7 a"6 g3"$#5$)# >25+43*5,3 5$+,c D*&,1'* 2(3* 1"6*&'/*"'& 1" '2* 8$0%78%"7 &(8&)$1,'10"& $*/%1"& 6*$. )0/,%$*7 '0 '2* '%$3*' 0# OL /1--10" %"7 KL /1--10" 8. KLMLP5
4 5 6
Seventh to Eleventh FiveYear Plans, Planning Commissi on Performance Indicator Report , TRAI, December 2011 India Strategy, Motilal Oswal, January 2011
K5 R081-* Y(/8*$ B0$'%81-1'. 2%& &*$61)* G(%-1'.5 &20$' '*$/ 0" %))0("' 0# '2* 2132 '*-*)0/ ,-%.*$& %& 4*-- %& '2* 1" 1"6*&'/*"' 1& "0' -19*-. '0 &'("' 3$04'2 41'2 -*%71"3 0,*$%'0$& 2%61"3
O5 &'%$'*7 '2* ,$1)* 4%$ 06*$ '%8-*'& %"7 &*$61)*& %"7 2*")* '2* 7%'% &*$61)*&5
119 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
C]
7 E 6 ? < ; D
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 120
5(#4131K(/4 H$4J"&","0-
121 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
;($6*. $*&,0"&*& 4*$* 3%'2*$*7 '2$0(32 % #%)*C'0C#%)* 1"'*$61*4 #0--04*7 8. % 7*'%1-*7 G(*&'10""%1$* 1"7(&'$. %"7 )-1*"'&5
C,34,).$1, "- 3,+;")#,).+ $43"++ +,4."3+
C3":,4. L$;*.$0 4"+. H(`M L3"3,I
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 122
C3":,4. #23$.*") H%,$3+I
C$3.*4*;$).X+ 4"<;$)% .23)"9,3 H(`M 43"3,I
123 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
CI
7 E 6 ? < ; D
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 124
NKK$/&1F
125 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
>2<<$3% "- C3":,4.+ P >,4."3 b*+, M"$# .3$+;"3. $)# /*1/6$% /$9, <$[*<2< )2<5,3 "- ")1"*)1 ;3":,4.+ >,4."3$0 53,$E 2; "- ")P1"*)1 *)-3$+.324.23, ;3":,4.+ *) ()#*$
>"234,c G]>C(& ?,4,<5,3 UV@U A0$+/ M,;"3.
C"6,3 +,4."3 ;3":,4.+ /$9, /*1/,+. 9$02, h$02, b*+, 53,$E2; -"3 $00 ")1"*)1 ;3":,4.+
>"234,c G]>C(& ?,4,<5,3 UV@U A0$+/ M,;"3.
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 126
>,4."3 0,9,0 >4/,#20, $)# L"+. "9,332)+ >37 `"7
>,4."3
`2<5,3 "C3":,4.+
C3":,4.+ 6*./ >4/,#20, "9,3P 32)
]3*1*)$0 L"+. H*) M+7 L3"3,I
F).*4*;$.,# 4"+. H *) M+7 L3"3,I
L"+. "9,332) ;,34,).$1,
@
F."<*4 \),31%
Z
W
_@&Z_e
_R&eWU
@Z
U
L*9*0 F9*$.*")
Y
U
Z&_R_
Y&VYW
@@
W
L"$0
Z@
U@
WY&VZR
WR&Z@@
_
_
A,3.*0*+,3+
W
V
_&VYY
_&VYY
V
Z
>.,,0
@R
@V
YZ&UeY
R@&__W
S
Y
C,.3"4/,<*4$0
@
V
Z&_Y@
e&SUV
YW
R
C,.3"0,2<
RW
W_
@&RR&__e
@&ee&YSU
Y
e
C"6,3
SS
ZU
U&UR&eUW
U&_W&YZW
R
S
M$*06$%+
@UY
WZ
Y@&WS_
@&_e&@WU
@_@
@V
M"$# !3$)+;"3. N 8*1/6$%+
@_Y
eZ
S_&_@e
SY&WZR
U
@@
>/*;;*)1 N C"3.+
UV
Y
@Z&SVe
@e&@RZ
@_
@U
!,0,4"<<2)*4$.*")+
@_
e
Z&SYZ
Z&SVY
P@
@W
=35$) ?,9,0";<,).
_
@
__&U_Z
_S&Z@e
@U
@_
b$.,3 M,+"234,+
@
@
Z_W
@&@eR
@@S
>"234,c G]>C(& ?,4,<5,3 UV@U A0$+/ M,;"3.
>.,,0 C3*4, !3,)#+ >.,,0 C3*4,+ /$+ .3*;0, *) 0$+. @V %,$3+ F9,3$1, G")./0% ;3*4,+ "- >.,,0 g*00,. UVV VPUV@@
>"234,c L3*+*0
127 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
L,<,). C3*4, !3,)#+ >"2./ ()#*$ /$+ /*1/,+. 4,<,). ;3*4,+ G")./0% L,<,). C3*4, .3,)#+
>"234,c \<5$% 4,<,). 3,;"3.
()#*$ \),31% ?,<$)# ()#*$ \),31% #,<$)# *+ 13"6*)1 $. $ LFDM "- R7S ;,34,). ()#*$ C3*<$3% \),31% ?,<$)#
>"234,c gC >.$.*+.*4$0 M,9*,6& UV@U
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 128
L"$0 /$+ <"3, ./$) ZV ;,34,). +/$3, *) ()#*$X+ .".$0 ;3*<$3% ,),31% 4")+2<;.*") C3*<$3% \),31% L")+2<;.*") 5% -2,0
>"234,c gC >.$.*+.*4$0 M,9*,6& UV@U
M$*06$%+ M$*06$%+ >,4."3c C3":,4. +4/,#20, $)# 4"+. "9,32) .3,)#+
>"234,c G]>C(& ?,4,<5,3 UV@U A0$+/ M,;"3.+
129 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
M$*06$%+ +,4."3 53,$E 2; "- __ #,0$%,# ;3":,4.+ *) ?,4,<5,3 UV@U M$*06$% >,4."3c `" "- ;3":,4.+ #,0$%,# H*) <")./+I
>"234,c G]>C(& ?,4,<5,3 UV@U A0$+/ M,;"3.
>"234,c >.$.*+.*4$0 >2<<$3%& ()#*$) M$*06$%+
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 130
M$*06$%+ M"00*)1 >."4E >37 `"7
B,$3
UVVYPVR
UVVRPVe
UVVePVS
UVVSP@V
UV@VP@@
UV@@P@U
_W
__
_W
_U
_W
_W
@
>.,< 0"4"+
U
?*,+,0 a"4"+
_&e@Y
_&e_W
_&SYW
Z&VUU
Z&@WR
Z&@SR
W
\0,4.3*4 a"4"+
W&US_
W&__W
W&ZeY
W&eUZ
_&VWW
_&WVS
_
C$++,)1,3 4$33*$1,+
We&eZZ
_V&YSY
_U&VRS
_W&ZUY
_Z&V_e
_Y&Yee
Z
\G=d?G=d?8G=
Y&_Z_
Y&Y_@
Y&Se_
R&_eR
e&VZW
e&Y@R
Y
M$*0 4$3+
_@
We
We
WR
W_
W_
R
]./,3 4"$4/*)1 9,/*40,+
Z&SVZ
Y&@eV
Z&SeZ
Y&_RR
Y&ZVV
Y&ZYV
e
b$1")+
U&VR&RUW
U&V_&VW_
U&@U&eWZ
U&UV&Z_S
U&US&SSR
U&WS&WU@
>"234,c G]>C(& ?,4,<5,3 UV@U A0$+/ M,;"3.
C"6,3 >,4."3 F3"2)# ZV ;,34,). "- ./, ;"6,3 +,4."3 ;3":,4.+ $3, #,0$%,# C"6,3 >,4."3c C3":,4. +4/,#20, $)# 4"+. "9,32) .3,)#+
>"234,c G]>C(& ?,4,<5,3 UV@U A0$+/ M,;"3.+
131 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
C"6,3 +,4."3 53,$E 2; "- ZU #,0$%,# ;3":,4. *) ?,4,<5,3 UV@U C"6,3 >,4."3c `" "- ;3":,4.+ #,0$%,# H*) <")./+I
>"234,c G]>C(& ?,4,<5,3 UV@U A0$+/ M,;"3.
ZR ;,34,). "- *)+.$00,# ,0,4.3*4*.% 1,),3$.*") 4$;$4*.% *+ 4"$0P5$+,# g3,$E2; "- *)+.$00,# ,0,4.3*4*.% 4$;$4*.% +"234, 6*+, H$+ ") WV i$)2$3%& UV@WI
>"234,c L\F
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 132
C,$E C"6,3 ?,<$)# >2;;0% *) ()#*$
>"234,c L\F
133 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
>.$.,P6*+, ,+.*<$.,# F9,3$1, 3$., "- ,0,4.3*4*.% H2;#$.,# 2; ." G$34/ UV@VI
>.$.,
?"<,+.*4 @Jb H@VVVJb/d G")./I
F)#/3$ C3$#,+/
?"<,+.*4 @VJb H@VVVJb/d G")./I
L"<<,34*$0 UJb HWVVVJb/d G")./I
L"<<,34*$0 WVJb H_ZVVJb/d G")./I
F13*420.23, U8C H_ZVVJb/d G")./I
F13*420.23, @V8C HUVVVJb/d G")./I
UWe7Z
_SU7UZ
ZSW7Z
YUW7eW
WW7RZ
US7RZ
W_V
_RZ
ZZe7WW
ZY_7@e
UR@7@S
WRW7YZ
U_W7e
WSZ7We
Z@Z7eR =
ZVV7Ve
@U_7VV =
@U_7VV =
@_V7_Z
P
@YY7VR M
P
R_7VV M
R_7VV M
@eR7_
WYe7S
_VW7WZ
_YV7U
@@V
@@V
_WR7eW
Y@R7eW =
YYV7YY
RVW7RU
ZZ
ZZ
WZW7eW
ZUY7ZW M
P
P
P
P
WYR7_
_YW7__
_e@
_e@
UZ
UZ
87 C7
UU@7_Z
WVR7R@
_eY
_ee7ee
U@V7We
UV_7ee
iNJ
@US7eY
UW_7SW
U_U7_
WeV7VR
Y@
Y@
@Y@
@eV
_WY7YR =
_WY7YR
ZU
ZU
@VR
P
@WY7WW M
P
P
USU7_W
ZRV7ZU ?
Yee7YW ?
R@V7Ye ?
V
V
USU7_W
ZUR7_R \
YeW7We \
RVZ7_W \
Ue@7SW
ZVR7ZU A
YWS7YW A
YZY7Re \
@eR
Z@R7Y@
RRZ7eW
SZU7@R
RW7R_
RW7R_
WeY7U
ZSU7U_ =
YV@7V_
YVU7YS
U@R7Z
WR_7e
ZZZ7eZ M
Z_@7RZ
Z_W7U_
URR7S_
ZSe7RU
ZWV7ee
Re@7Ze
@WW7__
@WW7__
]3*++$
@WZ7U
UeY
We_7e
_ZU7RZ
@VU
@VU
C2):$5
WUV7U
_eW7UU
ZZV7@
ZZV7@
V
V
M$:$+./$)
_@R7Z
WSU7RZ =
ZZY7YR
ZZZ7Re
@UY7Z
@@Y7Z
WSV7UZ
WZe7ZW M
P
P
P
P
!$<*0)$#2
@UV
UYS7Z
YVU
YVe7ZW
V
V
=..$3;3$#,+/
WYS
WSW7VV =
ZVZ7YR =
ZVZ7YR =
UU_7VV =
UU_7VV =
@U_
@U_7VV M
UWU7WW M
UWU7WW M
S@7ZV M
S@7ZV M
=..$3$E/$)#
UWV
U@Y7Z
WRZ
_WY7RY
eZ7VV =
eZ7VV =
b,+. g,)1$0
URU7ZS
ZZY7VY =
_R@7_@ =
Y_Z7SS =
@Y_7@Z
@YU7@S
F37 C3$#,+/
W_Z
W_Z
_@V
_@V
UYZ
UYZ
D"$
@We
UWU7Z
WeW
_US7YR
@@e
@@e
L/$#*1$3/
@RS
WV_
WeR
WeR
@YZ
@YZ
@ZS7Y
WUS7R
_YW7_
ZUY7_
P
P
F++$< g*/$3 L/$..*+/1$3/ D2:$3$. 8$3%$)$
i/$3E/$)# J$3)$.$E$
J,3$0$ G$#/%$ C3$#,+/ G$/$3$+/.3$
?,0/* `?GL >"234,c L\F F))2$0 M,;"3.& UV@VP@@
U_R7Z
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 134
C,.3"0,2< >,4."3 F3"2)# _Z ;,34,). "- ./, ;,.3"0,2< +,4."3 ;3":,4.+ $3, #,0$%,# C,.3"0,2< >,4."3c C3":,4. +4/,#20, $)# 4"+. "9,32) .3,)#+
>"234,c G]>C(& ?,4,<5,3 UV@U A0$+/ M,;"3.+
C,.3"0,2< +,4."3 53,$E 2; "- WS #,0$%,# ;3":,4.+ *) ?,4,<5,3 UV@U C,.3"0,2< >,4."3c `" "- ;3":,4.+ #,0$%,# H*) <")./+I
>"234,c G]>C(& ?,4,<5,3 UV@U A0$+/ M,;"3.
135 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
L"<;$)%
a"4$.*")
(]L
LCLa gMCa
L$;$4*.% H<.;$I V@7V_7UV@W
?*15"*
V7R
D26$/$.*
@7V
g$3$2)*
Y7V
g$3"#$
@W7R
8$0#*$
R7Z
G$./23$
e7V
C$)*;$.
@Z7V
L/,))$*
@V7ZV
`$3*<$)$<
@7V
g")1$*1$")
U7_
?"4(, L 6E<
S^RM
gCLa
G2<5$*
@U7V
JMa
L"4/*)
S7Z
`Ma
`2<$0*1$3/
W7V
?"4(, L 85
ITR^
8CLa
G2<5$*
Y7Z
h*K$1
e7W
8G\a& DD>M
S7V
?"4(, L _5
I]RM
GMCa
G$)1$0"3,
@Z7V
M(a
i$<)$1$3
WW7V
M(a H>\mI
i$<)$1$3
UR7V
]`DL
!$.*;$E$
V7@
\++$3 ]*0
h$#*)$3
UV7V
g]Ma
g*)$
Y7V
?"4(,
IC^RC
>"234,c CCFL
`"., c L$;$4*.% $+ ") F;3*0 UV@W
C,.3"0,2< C3"#24.+ -"3 UV@@PUV@U HG!CFI ?*+.*00$.,+ a*1/. #*+.*00$.,+
C3"#24.
?"4(, >"234,cCCFL
\[;"3.+
@Z7_
Z7V
V7U
G>
UR7U
@Z7V
V7R
@_7W
`$;/./$
@e7e
@@7U
@7S
@V7U
^^RS
TCR^
UR^
ITRU
>J]
e7V
e7U
V7Y
V7V
F!A
@V7@
Z7Z
V7V
_7Y
8>?
eU7e
Y_7e
@7@
@S7S
CBBRV
UMR^
CRU
ITR^
A]da>8>
@S7_
S7U
V7S
R7S
g*.2<,)
_7Y
_7Y
V7@
V7V
UW7_
@_7@
_7R
W7@
_R7_
UR7S
Z7R
@@7V
IB]RV
CTMRB
CTRV
SBRI
]./,3+ >25 !".$0
(<;"3.+
S7Y
D=@ ?"4(,
8,$9% #*+.*00$.,+
L")+2<;.*")
aCD
D=@ ?"4(,
G*##0, #*+.*00$.,+
C3"#24.*")
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 136
L"$0 >,4."3 ]),P./*3# "- 4"$0 +,4."3 ;3":,4.+ $3, #,0$%,# L"$0 >,4."3c C3":,4. +4/,#20, $)# 4"+. "9,32) .3,)#+
>"234,c G]>C(& ?,4,<5,3 UV@U A0$+/ M,;"3.+
L"$0 +,4."3 53,$E 2; "- U@ #,0$%,# ;3":,4.+ *) ?,4,<5,3 UV@U L"$0 >,4."3c `" "- ;3":,4.+ #,0$%,# H*) <" )./+I
>"234,c G]>C(& ?,4,<5,3 UV@U A0$+/ M,;"3.
137 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
L"$0 ;3"#24.*") $)# 4")+2<;.*") /$9, 13"6) $. $ LFDM "- _7S ;,34,). $)# e7Y ;,34,). 3,+;,4.*9,0% L"$0 >,4."3c C3"#24.*") $)# L")+2<;.*")
>"234,c F))2$0 M,;"3.& G*)*+.3% "- L"$0
L"$0 *<;"3.+ $3, *)43,$+*)1 $. $ LFDM "- @e7Y ;,34,). L"$0 (<;"3.+ !3,)#+
>"234,c F))2$0 M,;"3.& G*)*+.3% "- L"$0
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 138
G$:"3*.% "- ()#*$X+ 4"$0 3,+,39,+ $3, )")P4"E*)1 4"$0 L"$0 >,4."3c L"$0 M,+,39,+ 5% .%;, $+ ") F;3*0& UV@U
>"234,c G*)*+.3% "- L"$0
>.,,0 >,4."3 L"+. "9,332) /$+ #,43,$+,# *) +.,,0 +,4."3 >.,,0 >,4."3c C3":,4. +4/,#20, $)# 4"+. "9,332) .3,)#+
>"234,c G]>C(& ?,4,<5,3 UV@U A0$+/ M,;"3.+
139 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
>.,,0 +,4."3 53,$E 2; "- @V #,0$%,# ;3":,4.+ *) ?,4,<5,3 UV@U >.,,0 >,4."3c `" "- ;3":,4.+ #,0$%,# H*) <"). /+I
>"234,c G]>C(& ?,4,<5,3 UV@U A0$+/ M,;"3.
>.,,0 4$;$4*.% 2.*0*K$.*") *+ 4")+*+.,).0% /*1/ $. eZPSV ;,34,). L32#, >.,,0 C3"#24.*")& L$;$4*.% $)# L$;$4*.% =.*0*K$.*")
>"234,c F))2$0 M,;"3. UV@UP@W& G*)*+.3% "- >.,,0
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 140
>.,,0 *<;"3.+ $3, *)43,$+*)1 $)# ,[;"3.+ $3, #,43,$+*)1 \[;"3. (<;"3. !3,)#+ -"3 A*)*+/,# >.,,0
>"234,c F))2$0 M,;"3. UV@@P@U& G*)*+.3% "- >.,,0
!,0,4"< >,4."3 () 0$+. %,$3 +,9,3$0 .,0,4"< ;3":,4.+ 6,3, 4"<;0,.,# !,0,4"< >,4."3c C3":,4. +4/,#20, $)# 4"+. "9,32) .3,)#+
>"234,c G]>C(& ?,4,<5,3 UV@U A0$+/ M,;"3.+
141 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
!,0,4"< +,4."3 53,$E 2; "- e #,0$%,# ;3":,4.+ *) i$)2$3% UV@U !,0,4"< >,4."3c `" "- ;3":,4.+ #,0$%,# H*) <")./+I
>"234,c G]>C(& ?,4,<5,3 UV@U A0$+/ M,;"3.
b*3,0,++ FMC= /$9, +.$5*0*K,# *) 0$+. -,6 %,$3+ b*3,0,++ FMC=
>"234,c ?,;$3.<,). "- !,0,4"<
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 142
>25+43*5,3 5$+, $)# .,0,#,)+*.% /$+ +.$3.,# #,40*)*)1 !".$0 >2543*5,3 5$+, $)# !,0,#,)+*.%
>"234,c ?,;$3.<,). "- !,0,4"<
().,3),. 2+,3+ $3, *)43,$+*)1 $. $ LFDM "- @S ;,34,). ;7$ ().,3),. $)# g3"$#5$)# =+,3
>"234,c !MF(Q L3*+*0
143 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
?$.$ 3,9,)2,f+ +/$3, *) ./, .".$0 3,9,)2, *+ *)43,$+*)1 ?$.$ M,9,)2,+ $+ T "- !".$0 3,9,)2,+
>"234,c ?,;$3.<,). "- !,0,4"<
>/*;;*)1 N C"3. >,4."3 F3"2)# _V ;,34,). "- +/*;;*)1 $)# ;"3. +,4."3 ;3":,4.+ $3, #,0$%,# >/*;;*)1 N C"3. >,4."3c C3":,4. +4/,#20, $)# 4"+. "9,32) .3,)#+
>"234,c G]>C(& ?,4,<5,3 UV@U A0$+/ M,;"3.+
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 144
>/*;;*)1 N ;"3. +,4."3 53,$E 2; "- R #,0$%,# ;3":,4.+ *) ?,4,<5,3 UV@U >/*;;*)1 N C"3. >,4."3c `" "- ;3":,4.+ #,0$%,# H*) <"). /+I
>"234,c G]>C(& ?,4,<5,3 UV@U A0$+/ M,;"3.
HfVVV .")),+I
C]a
(3") "3,k
A,3.*0*K,3+ A*)*+/,#
J"0E$.$
L"$0
M$6
L").$*),3
!/,3<$0
L"E*)1
!"))$1,
]./,3+
!".$0
!\=+
RVV
@Ze
Y_
US
P
WR
Y&SZR
_YW
W&eZZ
@@&eVV
8$0#*$
Y&@SY
@&R@Z
@VS
URe
@&SRY
_&ZVU
U&eYS
@WR
@V&_WS
Ue&Ve_
C$3$#*;
@Y&_YY
@&eW_
@_U
_&VV_
U@&WS_
_&S@U
@R@
@W
R&YUS
ZY&ZZU
h*+$E/$;$.)$<
@Z&VU@
@U&URS
U&V@e
ZYZ
U&SZ@
Y&eUV
_&ZZ_
U_e
@_&RZU
Ze&SYV
\))"3,
@&@U_
P
P
P
@_&U_V
YeZ
P
P
@&eWY
@R&eeZ
L/,))$*
@W&_UZ
ZU
@SV
UW@
P
P
US&RVe
@&ZWS
S&RSe
ZW&_V_
!2.*4"3*)
RSU
P
_eR
ZY_
Y&YY@
P
S&WRU
_RS
@V&We_
Ue&UYV
L"4/*)
@W&eSY
P
UU
WW@
Ue
P
_&YVR
WUY
SY@
@S&e_Z
`,6 G$)1$0"3,
U_&WV@
U&Y@Y
Z@S
@R
U&ZZW
_&WZR
YSU
_e
@&Se@
WR&VWY
eUW
R&_U@
Re
V
RYe
Y&YVZ
U@W
UV
@&ReZ
@R&YSW
W_&Re_
P
@ZY
WZY
_&U@V
P
eUS
Ze
@R&RVU
Ze&VWR
_&UeY
P
P
P
P
P
ZR&SVS
_&UZS
U&WVY
Y_&ZV@
J$)#0$
Z_&WZZ
@&VVY
W&YRe
S_Y
_&VY_
WR_
@&SW_
@@e
UR&UYZ
SW&YUU
!".$0
@eY&@YS
UR&Ve@
R&_YW
R&WU@
Ze&e_Z
Ue&USU
@@S&e@Z
R&RVe
@@V&YSW
Z_Z&YRS
G"3<21$" G2<5$* i`C!
`".,c `".,+c C]ac C,.3"0,2<& "*0 $)# 0253*4$).+Q !\=c !6,).%P-"". ,O2*9$0,). 2)*.Q i`C!c i$6$/$30$0 `,/32 C"3. !32+. >"234,c(CF& LM(>(a
145 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
L$;$4*.% $. G$:"3 C"3.+ H<*00*") .")),+I
UV VZPVY
UV VYPVR
UV VRPVe
UV VePVS
UV VSP@V
UV@VP@@
UV@@P@U
UV@UP@W
J"0E$.$
@U7Y
@W7_
@_7Y
@Z7e
@Z7e
@Y7_
@Y7_
@R7@
8$0#*$
_U7U
_W7Z
_Y7R
_Y7R
_Y7R
ZV7R
ZV7R
ZV7e
C$3$#*;
Z@7_
ZY7V
ZY7V
R@7V
RY7Z
RY7Z
RY7Z
@VY7W
h*+$E/$;$.)$<
ZZ7V
Ze7Z
Y@7U
YU7U
YU7U
Y_7S
RU7S
YR7W
\))"3,
_e7e
ZV7V
ZW7_
ZZ7e
YS7_
RS7R
RS7R
eW7U
L/,))$*
@W7V
@W7V
@W7V
@Y7V
@Y7V
W@7V
W@7V
W@7V
!2.*4"3*)
UV7Y
UV7Y
UV7e
UU7e
UU7e
UR7V
WW7W
WW7W
L"4/*)
@S7_
UV7U
Ue7_
Ue7_
US7S
_@7V
_@7V
__7R
`,6 G$)1$0"3,
We7V
_@7W
_W7Z
__7U
__7U
_Z7Y
Z@7V
YS7V
G"3<21$"
US7Z
WV7V
WW7@
WW7@
WR7@
_@7S
_@7S
_@7S
G2<$5*
_W7e
__7R
__7R
_W7R
_W7R
__7Z
__7Z
__7Z
i`C!
WY7@
ZU7_
Z_7W
Ze7V
Ze7V
Y_7V
Y_7V
Y_7V
J$)#0$
_Y7V
Y@7W
YW7Z
RR7W
RR7U
eY7S
eY7S
S@7U
T^SRI
^BTRM
^]]RB
^UTRV
^VVRT
SUBRC
SMVRM
?"4(,
R__7W
>"234,c(CF & LM(>(a
H`"+7I
?3% g20E
a*O2*# g20E
g3,$E g20E
L").$*),3+
]./,3+k
!".$0
J"0E$.$
YV
UWS
W@S
ZRR
UR
@&UUU
8$0#*$
RY@
eZW
ZR
US@
P
@&SYU
C$3$#*;
SV_
W@R
RZ
WV
@Y
@&W_U
@&@_R
R@Z
U@S
WZ@
We
U&_RV
\))"3,
U_@
SU
P
P
ZU
WeZ
L/,))$*
UUW
ZVR
ZU_n
ReS
P
@&Z@S
!2.*4"3*)
_UZ
UUY
_WV
WYZ
_Y
@&_SU
ZV
WZS
WR
WeS
Z_R
@&WeU
`,6 G$)1$0"3,
UVY
YSW
@ZR
eV
@S
@&@ZZ
G"3<21$"
Z_R
@ZW
WR
_e
P
ReZ
G2<$5*
WWW
@&@VU
ZYe
@_
_V
U&VZR
YY
__Z
_Z
U&UWW
@UR
U&S@Y
R@Z
@&W@e
_ZY
UUZ
P
U&R@_
^:SUM
U:BCV
I:VIT
^:]VI
VCI
IC:TBC
h*+$E/$;$.)$<
L"4/*)
i`C! J$)#0$ N,, 5"#49 >"234,c(CF & LM(>(a
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 146
M"$#+ $)# 8*1/6$%+ ]9,3 ./, %,$3& +4/,#20, "9,332) *) 3"$# +,4."3 ;3":,4.+ /$+ #,43,$+,# M"$# !3$)+;"3. N 8*1/6$% >,4."3c C3":,4. +4 /,#20, $)# 4"+. "9,332) .3,)#+
>"234,c G]>C(& ?,4,<5,3 UV@U A0$+/ M,;"3.+
M"$# +,4."3 53,$E 2; "- eY #,0$%,# ;3":,4.+ *) ?,4,<5,3 UV@U M"$# !3$)+;"3. N 8*1/6$% >,4."3c `" "- ;3":,4.+ #,0$%,# H*) <")./+ I
>"234,c G]>C(& ?,4,<5,3 UV@U A0$+/ M,;"3.
147 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
>.$.,P6*+, M"$# 0,)1./ *) 3,0$.*") ." $3,$ $)# ;";20$.*") !".0$ M"$0# a,)1./ HE<+I
>.$.,+ F)#/3$ C3$#,+/
M"$# a,)1./ C,3 @&VVV +O E<+ "- $3,$ ;,3 @&VVV "- ;";20$.*")
W&_Z&V@U
@&UZ_7_
_7U
@Y&_S_
@SR7V
@W7e
F++$<
U&WV&WW_
U&SWY7Z
R7e
g*/$3
@&UV&@UR
@&URZ7R
@7W
L//$..*+1$3/
R_&_W_
ZZV7Y
W7U
D"$
@V&ZYS
U&eZ_7S
Y7Y
@&_Y&YWV
R_e7V
U7Y
8$3%$)$
US&RUY
YRU7_
@7U
8*<$4/$0 C3$#,+/
WY&USe
YZU7V
Z7Z
i$<<2 N J$+/<*3
UU&WUW
@VV7Z
U7V
i/$3E/$)#
@R&ZW@
U@S7S
V7Y
J$3)$.$E$
U&ZZ&_Z_
@&WW@7S
_7_
J,3$0$
U&V_&RZR
Z&UYe7R
Y7@
G$#/%$ C3$#,+/
@&YZ&R_V
ZWR7R
U7_
G$/$3$+/.3$
U&UW&WUU
RUZ7e
U7@
@Y&ZVU
RWS7@
R7V
G,1/$0$%$
S&eWS
_We7R
W7S
G*K"3$<
Y&@Ze
USU7@
Y7_
`$1$0$)#
UU&WV_
@&W_Z7W
@V7W
]3*++$
U&@Z&_V_
@&WeW7_
Z7_
C2):$5
_Z&@Re
eSR7@
@7R
@&R@&_RS
ZV@7@
U7R
@&eRW
UY_7V
W7U
@&e@&U@W
@&WSW7W
U7R
W@&RWW
W&VUY7U
S7@
U&e_&YRW
@&@e@7Y
@7Z
=..$3$E/$)#
_@&V_@
RYR7_
_7W
b,+. g,)1$0
U&@@&RRV
U&WeY7@
U7_
F32)$4/$0 C3$#,+/
D2:$3$.
G$)*;23
M$:$+./$) >*EE*< !$<*0 `$#2 !3*;23$ =..$3 C3$#,+/
>"234,c G]>C( &G]M!8
L$;$4*.% "- `$.*")$0 8*1/6$%+ b*#./ "4$33*$1,6$% o A"23 P 0$),
`$.*")$0 8*1/6$%+ `$.*")$0 8*1/6$%+ `$.*")$0 8*1/6$%+ `$.*")$0 8*1/6$%+ 0,)1./ HUVVRPVeI 0,)1./ HUVVePVSI 0,)1./ HUVVSP@VI 0,)1./ HUV@VP@@I HE
H;,3 4,).I
HE
H;,3 4,).I
HE
H;,3 4,).I
HE
H;,3 4,).I
`$.*")$0 8*1/6$%+ 0,)1./ HUV@@P@UI HE
H;,3 4,).I
S&WUZ
@_7V
@U&VZW
@R7@
@Y&W@_
UW7V
@Y&@eR
UU7e
@R&RVV
U_7R
!6" P 0$),
WS&VRS
Ze7Z
WR&Y_Y
ZW7_
WY&eeY
ZU7V
WY&SSZ
ZU7U
We&ZWY
ZW7R
]), P 0$),
@e&WZV
UR7Z
UV&e_S
US7Y
@R&RW_
UZ7V
@R&RZU
UZ7V
@Z&ZWY
U@7Y
!".$0
YY&RZ_
@VV7V
RV&Z_e
@VV7V
RV&SW_
@VV7V
RV&SW_
@VV7V
R@&RRU
@VV7V
>"234,c G]>C( &G]M!8
M"$# `,.6"3E *) ()#*$ $+ *) %,$3 UV@@PUV@U M"$# `,.6"3E
`$.*")$0 8*1/6
%$a,)1./ HJ*0"<,.,3+I
C,34,).$1, "- !"$.$0 a,)1./
R@&RRU
@7R
>.$., 8*1/6
%$@Z_&ZUU
W7e
G$:"3 $)# "./,3 ?*+.3*4. M"$#+
UYY&VZe
Y7Z
M23$0 3"$#+
W&Y@R&U_V
ee
UV
!".$0
_&@VS&ZSU
@VV
@VV
>"234,c G]>C( &G]M!8
_V _V
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 148
L*9*0 F9*$.*") ZV ;,34,). "- ./, 4*9*0 $9*$.*") ;3":,4.+ $3, #,0$%,# *) ?,4,<5,3 UV@U L*9*0 F9*$.*") >,4."3c C3":,4. +4/,#20, $)# 4"+. "9,332) .3,)#+
>"234,c G]>C(& ?,4,<5,3 UV@U A0$+/ M,;"3.+
L*9*0 $9*$.*") +,4."3 53,$E 2; "- W #,0$%,# ;3":,4.+ *) ?,4,<5,3 UV@U L*9*0 >,4."3c `" "- ;3":,4.+ #,0$%,# H*) <")./+ I
>"234,c G]>C(& ?,4,<5,3 UV@U A0$+/ M,;"3.
149 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
?"<,+.*4 -3,*1/. H.")),+I F*3;"3.+ G,.3" F*3;"3.+ G=GgF( ?\a8( L8\``F( gF`DFa]M\ J]aJF!F 8B?\MFgF? !".$0 `") P <,.3" F*3;"3.+ F8G\?FgF? D]F !M(hF`?M=G LFa(L=! D=bF8F!( FGM(!>FM >M(`FDFM iF(C=M `FDC=M L]L8(` C=`\ L](GgF!]M\ a=LJ`]b GF`DFa]M\ hFMF`F>( CF!`F !M(L8=MFCFaa( hF?]?FMF iFGG= (`?]M\ h(>FJ8FCF!`FG FDFM!FaF g8=gF`\>bFM =?F(C=M gFD?]DMF C]M!gaF(M GF?=MF( g8]CFa MFiJ]! F=MF`DFgF? MF(C=M (GC8Fa L8F`?(DFM8 a\8 i=8= i]?8C=M MF`L8( >(aL8FM !(M=CF!( ?(gM=DFM8 ]./,3 F*3;"3.+ ?"4(, D3$)# !".$0 >"234,c F*3;"3. F2./"3*.% "- ()#*$
UVVYPVR
UVVRPVe
UVVePVS
UVVSP@V
UV@VP@@
UV@@P@U
@&ZU&@ZS @&@Y&VUR _U&SYS YR&Y_U _R&@__ UU&SW_ _&_e&eRZ
@&ZS&RU_ @&WV&SV_ _@&S@e RV&V@@ _S&SeS UR&@@S _&RS&YYZ
@&Z@&WUe @&Ue&WWU ZU&eVY Ze&W@V _R&WVZ U_&ZeV _&YU&YY@
@&R_&@e_ @&YW&S@W R@&U_Y R@&eSW RV&@Ye WV&@Y_ Z&e@&ZYe
@&SS&eW@ U&VS&@@W SW&WWY eR&Z@Z e_&eY@ WY&WSV R&@@&V_Y
@SVUee UVVZUZ e_RWV eWUZY e@RVW W__RU Y&R_&SR_
@Y&eYe _&@e@ @&_@W YVU @&S@S @@@ @&S@e U&ZWS _&VZe Y&@YY S&SeW W&Y@R @&YZW _@V WZU @&RYe @U @&SYU @&@YR W&WRe ZWZ _&RWR @&UZe P ZYe @&SYU YZZ R__ e@U @&VZe @&YVV ZYe WSZ SVU WW_ @V@ WWY WWe P P P MB:VMB
@U&RWS W&UeS @&_@Z WYW @&Y_U WRY @&ZV@ U&@_U W&RRW Z&SW_ @@&YZW _&Y@Y @&eRW W@@ W@Z @&SZR UV U&@Se @&VS_ _&SZU RYY Z&SRS @&UeR P YWY U&@WS ZRU @&VUe YYY SYW @&___ YWY _@W e_U _@U SV __S W@S UR USS P MC:C]B
@@&V@e W&_YV @&__U WYe Z&URY U&USV @&e@Z Z&RYW _&R@R R&eZR @R&e_Z Y&UeZ W&_VR WeU WYW @&SUe UZ @&R_Z @&@ZR Z&WV@ SWe Y&RZZ @&SSe P eYS U&USV ZR_ SU_ YWZ @&U_R @&ZSW _&R@S U@S @&WYe WeW )7$ YRR W_U UW WW@ @&VZR C:BV:]MS
@Z&VYV _&U_R @&Z_V UeU e&ZUV @Y@ U&V@Y e&@RR S&@_Z e&Y@V UR&eUe Y&YWR W&_SU WVZ _UU W&URS V U&VSS @&WR@ Z&WeV @&@VR R&@VZ U&YYR V @&@@_ U&USS ZeV @&@RZ SWW @&e_@ U&WZY Y&VVU @&V@W @&_UY
@SSY_ _V@Y @__S @S@ RRY@ eS UWY@ Y_RZ _Zee eZWW U_@W_ RUe@ WYSV UYR WZY W_UZ V UUeU @UYZ _RW_ @V_Y YeeS UUeY V @YRU UWeY e_U eSV RWe @UUR UeRV _Se_ WV_U @WWY
UR @&WVY _eV @U WUU @&URS C:TC:SC^
_@ @YZV _SR UY W_W @_S@ C:]U:CCU
@Z&VYV _&U_R @&Z_V UeU e&ZUV U&USS U&V@Y e&@RR S&@_Z e&Y@V UR&eUe Y&YWR W&_SU WVZ _UU W&URS P U&VSS @&WR@ Z&WeV @&@VR R&@VZ U&YYR P @&@@_ U&USS ZeV @&@RZ SWW @&e_@ U&WZY Y&VVU Z_S @&_UY W@@ )7$7 @&WVY _eV @W WUU SSZ C:T]:IVB
_&eU&_ZR
Z&WU&@S@
Z&YV&Y_Z
Z&_W&RS@
Y&SV&SZ_
e&Z_&WWY
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 150
F*3;"3.+ G,.3" F*3;"3.+ G=GgF( ?\a8( L8\``F( gF`DFa]M\ J]aJF!F 8B?\MFgF? !".$0 `") P <,.3" F*3;"3.+ F8G\?FgF? D]F !M(hF`?M=G LFa(L=! D=bF8F!( FGM(!>FM >M(`FDFM iF(C=M `FDC=M L]L8(` HL(FaI C]M! gaF(M C]M! gaF(M C=`\ L](GgF!]M\ a=LJ`]b GF`DFa]M\ hFMF`F>( gFD?]DMF !M(L8=MFCFaa( DFBF CF!`F !".$0 ]./,3 F*3;"3.+ >#(/& ?"4(, >"234,c F*3;"3. F2./"3*.% "- ()#*$
UVVYPVR
UVVRPVe
UVVePVS
UVVSP@V
UV@VP@@
UV@@P@U
R7WZ Y7YZ U7SV @7UY V7e@ @7U@ UV7@R
R7Se R7W_ W7_@ @7Z_ @7VV @7__ UU7RW
e7@U R7RR W7YY @7Y_ @7VV @7ZR UW7RY
e7UW e7W@ W7eY @7S_ @7@S @7RU UZ7UZ
S7Ve S7Ue _7UZ U7UU @7_W @7eS Ue7@_
S7RV @V7RZ _7W@ U7WZ @7ZR @7SW WV7Y@
V7_V V7_V @7@S V7SV P V7_S V7VU V7@S V7Ve @7_W
V7RV V7_W @7_V @7Ve P V7UV V7VU V7Ve V7ZZ @7RR
V7Ye V7WS @7_R @7ZU V7V@ V7__ V7VU V7UU V7VS U7V@
V7eZ V7_W @7RV @7YY V7V@ V7ZV V7VU V7UY V7VZ U7UW
P V7VZ V7V@ V7@W V7VW V7VW P V7@Y V7VZ P Z7ZY
P V7VW V7VZ V7@R V7@Y V7VZ P V7WV V7VZ P R7VR
P V7VW V7VS V7@R V7U@ V7VZ P V7We V7VZ P R7e@
P V7V_ V7VS V7Ue V7Ue V7VZ V7VU V7ZS V7VY P S7@V
I^RU]
IVRUV
]CR^U
]TR]S
V7eW V7Ze @7e_ @7eW V7V@ V7_R P V7UZ V7V_ U7WY V7VV V7VV V7VY V7@V V7W_ V7UZ V7VY V7VU V7YR V7VZ P S7RZ V7VU ]URVC
V7R_ V7Ze @7e_ @7Se V7VW V7_V P V7UW V7V_ U7ZS P V7VV V7VY V7@V V7WY V7UY V7VY V7VU V7RS V7Ve P @V7@R V7VU TBRMB
151 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
().,3)$.*")$0 -3,*1/. -"3 ./, 0$+. +*[ %,$3+ H*) .")),+I F*3;"3.+ G,.3" F*3;"3.+ G=GgF( ?\a8( L8\``F( gF`DFa]M\ J]aJF!F 8B?\MFgF? ?"4(, `") P <,.3" F*3;"3.+ F8G\?FgF? D]F !M(hF`?M=G LFa(L=! D=bF8F!( FGM(!>FM >M(`FDFM iF(C=M `FDC=M L]L8(` C=`\ L](GgF!]M\ a=LJ`]b GF`DFa]M\ hFMF`F>( CF!`F !M(L8=MFCFaa( DFBF !".$0 ]./,3 F*3;"3.+ D3$)# !".$0 >"234,c F*3;"3. F2./"3*.% "- ()#*$
UVVYPVR
UVVRPVe
UVVePVS
UVVSP@V
UV@VP@@
UV@@P@U
W&UR&ZVR U&R_&eV@ @&SZ&@SR SR&e_R WY&WRS U@&R@Z V:^]:TTS
W&RW&RRV W&V@&SZS U&UR&SZe @&VR&RV@ _@&VV_ U_&VZS CB:US:T^C
W&Re&Y@V U&SR&SW@ U&@S&ZYU SS&YSV _V&R_W US&YYZ CB:SS:IBC
_&Ve&_ZU W&WW&_RW U&_S&ZUU @&VU&RZ@ _V&Vee WY&USZ CC:UB:^MC
_&RV&_VU W&SV&SWU U&SZ&_SR @&WZ&UYW _Z&VSe _U&@RV C]:UV:]SI
_&YR&@eU W&YR&eWV U&RU&_Y@ @&_@&YSW _W&eSV _W&YUR C]:]S:SM]
_&@UY SY_ WV&_YZ @V&YS@ Z@ @&R__ P RUe @ @R&VVS R @&Y@Z @Ze P P P eYe P Ye&_UR
Y&RVe RRZ WV&YRW e&R_R Y @&UZU P WSZ _ @e&SeR @ @&WVV @W_ P @W P @&@ZW P RV&@_e
@V&US_ Yee WV&@YS @U&ZZY U @&RSe P W_V U@R UZ&U@S P S@R _S P W P SV_ P eW&@ZY
@@&YZR S@R W@&RVe @R&@WU P U&Re_ P __Y URS WU&RRS P RVU WRe P P P @&W_S P @&VV&@W@
@V&U@&eRW
@@&_Y&ZSS
@@&_S&WZR
@U&RV&R@U
@U&SeV U&ZWZ WR&RSZ U@&SY_ P Z&eW_ P WSe W_Y WU&@Se P WSV ZeY P P P @&RRZ P @&@Y&eV@ RY @_&SY&UWS
@@&RSW U&@Z_ _Y&RZW UZ&_VV P Y&SSe P UWZ Wee W_&@RW P _YR eWS P @ P U&V@U P @&W@&U@W P @_&YR&eSY
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 152
F*3;"3.+ G,.3" F*3;"3.+ G=GgF( ?\a8( L8\``F( gF`DFa]M\ J]aJF!F 8B?\MFgF? !".$0 `") P <,.3" F*3;"3.+ F8G\?FgF? D]F !M(hF`?M=G LFa(L=! D=bF8F!( FGM(!>FM >M(`FDFM iF(C=M `FDC=M L]L8(` C]M!gaF(M C=`\ L](GgF!]M\ a=LJ`]b GF`DFa]M\ hFMF`F>( CF!`F !(M=L8L8(MFCCFaa( DFBF hF?]?FMF iFGG= (`?]M\ h(>FJ8FCF!`FG FDFMF!FaF g8=gF`\>bFM =?F(C=M gFD?]DMF GF?=MF( g8]CFa MFiJ]! F=MF`DFgF? MF(C=M (GC8Fa L8F`?(DFM8 a\8 ?(gM=DFM8 !(M=CF!( i=8= i]?8C=M MF`L8( >(aL8FM !".$0 ]./,3 F*3;"3.+ D3$)# !".$0
UVVYPVR
UVVRPVe
UVVePVS
UVVSP@V
UV@VP@@
UV@@P@U
@_7SV @W7RS Y7Ve Y7eY Z7@S _7Z_ Z@7WY
@R7ee @Y7YW R7U@ e7Ze Y7_Y Z7Z_ YU7WV
@Z7WU @Z7VR Y7@e R7@U Z7SS _7YZ Z_7WW
@R7WR @R7e@ Y7YR e7VV Y7eY _7eV Y@7Z@
UV7VV UV7YR R7eV S7WR e7UV Z7R@ R@7RZ
U@7V_ UZ7@W e7YU @V7W_ e7R_ Y7ZU eV7WS
U7VS @7e@ V7YV V7UW @7VR V7@@ V7Ye V7YV V7Ze @7@W V7ZV @7ZW V7eZ V7_e V7_Z V7WU V7W@ V7VZ V7VV V7_V V7_R V7WY V7WW V7WU V7WZ V7U_ V7UY V7UY V7@R V7@Y V7@R V7UZ V7U@ V7@Z V7@_
U7_Y U7@_ V7RV V7UW @7W_ @7@_ V7RY V7RR V7@W @7ZR V7WW @7Y_ @7V@ V7Z_ V7ZZ V7_V V7WS V7VS V7VV V7ZV V7ZZ V7ZV V7ZZ V7_@ V7_@ V7US V7WR V7_@ V7US V7@Z V7UV V7_@ V7WU V7UW V7@R
U7@_ @7eW V7_e V7@Y @7WR V7@W V7RU V7Se V7R@ @7WZ V7_e @7R_ V7SU V7YZ V7_S V7WY V7W_ V7VS V7VV V7__ V7_V V7YV V7YV V7WR V7YR V7UY V7__ V7WZ V7UW V7@W V7@S V7_V V7WU V7WY V7UV
U7Ye U7UV V7Y_ V7U@ @7Ze V7UV V7S@ @7UR V7RY @7YZ V7ZU U7U@ @7V@ V7S@ V7ZY V7_W V7ZZ V7@V V7VV V7ZV V7ZU V7RV V7YW V7ZV V7eW V7WY V7ZW V7WR V7UY V7@S V7UU V7__ V7_@ V7_R V7UW
V7@_ V7@@ V7@Z V7@U @e7@Y
V7@_ V7@_ V7@@ V7@Z UU7ZU
V7@Z V7Ve V7UZ V7@_ U@7Z_
YS7ZU
e_7e@
RZ7eR
V7@Z )7< V7UR V7@Z UY7@U @7_@ eS7V_
W7UU U7ZV V7Ye V7UW @7SU V7WV @7V_ @7_@ @7UV @7Se V7Ze U7RZ @7@_ @7U_ V7ZS V7ZV V7e_ V7VS V7VV V7YV V7YS V7ee V7R@ V7RZ @7V_ V7WR V7YZ V7WS V7WU V7UW V7UR V7ZW V7ZY V7YZ V7UY V7UW V7@R V7VV V7@e V7WY V7@Y WU7UU @7ZZ @VZ7ZU
W7SZ U7S_ V7Se V7UW U7UU V7_S @7YW @7YV @7We U7@W V7Y@ W7UW @7U_ @7YY V7YW V7Ye @7VU V7@U V7VU V7YR V7eS @7@@ V7SY V7e_ @7UZ V7WR V7R@ V7Z@ V7_U V7UY V7_V V7eV V7RW V7eV V7WR V7UW V7U_ V7VV V7U@ V7_S V7U@ WS7U_ @7eR @U@7Z@
>"234,c F*3;"3. F2./"3*.% "- ()#*$ p )7
153 | Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns
3N"MA 0*+1 .- ,-&./
7*&)$18*& 1'&*-# %& &()25 420/ %$* 1"'*$"%'10"%--. '$%1"*75 N& /*/8*$& 0# % )02*&16* 8(&1"*&& ("1' '2*. $*&,0"7 '0 % )-1*"' &*$61)* *"61$0"/*"' 8. -*6*$%31"3 '2* $*&0($)*&
N@"=4 +5.> '$(, ;94(4$ O <"/94#=341"/ 5#(3413$ ("1G(* )2%--*"3*& #%)*7 8. 1 "7(&'$. %"7 )0/,%".5 ;0/* 0# '2* 0##*$1"3& %"7 0'2*$&5 40$91"3 41'2 &0/* 0# '2* 1"7(&'$. -*%7*$& %"7 2132 3$04'2 *"'*$,$1&*& 80'2 1" !"71% %"7 !"'*$"%'10"%--.5 *"61$0"/*"'5
Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns | 154
3N"MA *+,
#0$ '2* ,$0<*)' /%"%3*/*"' ,$0#*&&10"5 S($ ,$0#*&&10"%- $*&0($)*& %"7 BR!:& 40$-7417* %760)%). #0$ ,$0<*)' /%"%3*/*"' 1 & $*1"#0$)*7 8. 0($ ,$0#*&&10"%- 7*6*-0,/*"' 0,,0$'("1'1*&5
