UNIVERSISDAD CATOLICA SANTA MARIA LA ANTIGUA MAESTRIA EN DERECHO PROCESAL ADMINSITRATIVO
PROCESO CONTENCIOSO-ADMINISTRATIVO DE PROTECCIÓN DE LOS DERECHOS HUMANOS.
AGOSTO DE 2014
LOS DERECHOS HUMANOS Y SUS CARA CARACTERÍSTICAS CTERÍSTICAS 1 1Ofcin !"# #$% c%&i'i%n!% !" #%' !"("c)%' )*&n%' !" #' Nci%n"' Uni!'
L%' !"("c)%' )*&n%' '%n !"("c)%' in)"("n$"' $%!%' #%' '"("' )*&n%'+ 'in !i'$inci,n #*n !" nci%n#i!!+ #*( !" ("'i!"nci+ '"%+ %(i"n nci%n# % /$nic%+ c%#%(+ ("#ii,n+ #"n*+ % c*#*i"( %$( c%n!ici,n. T%!%' $"n"&%' #%' &i'&%' !"("c)%' )*&n%'+ 'in !i'c(i&inci,n #*n. E'$%' !"("c)%' '%n in$"(("#ci%n!%'+ in$"(!""n!i"n$"' " in!ii'i3#"'. L%' !"("c)%' )*&n%' *ni"('#"' "'$n &"n*!% c%n$"&#!%' "n # #"5 5 (n$i6!%' %( "##+ $(/' !" #%' $($!%'+ "# !"("c)% in$"(nci%n# c%n'*"$*!in(i%+ #%' (incii%' "n"(#"' 5 %$(' 7*"n$"' !"# !"("c)% in$"(nci%n#. E# !"("c)% in$"(nci%n# !" #%' !"("c)%' )*&n%' "'$3#"c" #' %3#ici%n"' *" $i"n"n #%' %3i"(n%' !" $%&( &"!i!' "n !"$"(&in!' 'i$*ci%n"'+ % !" 3'$"n"('" !" c$*( !" !"$"(&in! 7%(& "n %$('+ fn !" (%&%"( 5 (%$""( #%' !"("c)%' )*&n%' 5 #' #i3"($!"' 7*n!&"n$#"' !" #%' in!ii!*%' % (*%'. Uni"('#"' " in#i"n3#"' E# (incii% !" # *ni"('#i!! !" #%' !"("c)%' )*&n%' "' # i"!( n*#( !"# !"("c)% in$"(nci%n# !" #%' !"("c)%' )*&n%'. E'$" (incii%+ $# c%&% '" !"'$c( inici#&"n$" "n # D"c#(ci,n Uni"('# !" D"("c)%' H*&n%'+ '" ) ("i$"(!% "n n*&"(%'%' c%n"ni%'+ !"c#(ci%n"' 5 ("'%#*ci%n"' in$"(nci%n#"' !" !"("c)%' )*&n%'. En # C%n7"("nci M*n!i# !" D"("c)%' H*&n%' c"#"3(! "n Vi"n "n 1889+ %( ":"&#%+ '" !i'*'% *" $%!%' #%' E'$!%' $"n;n "# !"3"(+ in!""n!i"n$"&"n$" !" '*' 'i'$"&' %#;$ic%'+ "c%n,&ic%' 5 c*#$*(#"'+ !" (%&%"( 5 (%$""( $%!%' #%' !"("c)%' )*&n%' 5 #' #i3"($!"' 7*n!&"n$#"'. L%' !"("c)%' )*&n%' '%n in#i"n3#"'. N% !"3"n '*(i&i('"+ '#% "n !"$"(&in!' 'i$*ci%n"' 5 '"%(&' !"
Di'c(i&inci,n Rci# 5 # C%n"nci,n '%3(" # E#i&inci,n !" $%!' #' >%(&' !" Di'c(i&inci,n c%n$( # M*:"(. E# (incii% '" #ic $%! "('%n "n ("#ci,n c%n $%!%' #%' !"("c)%' )*&n%' 5 #' #i3"($!"'+ 5 (%);3" # !i'c(i&inci,n '%3(" # 3'" !" *n #i'$ n% ")*'$i !" c$"%(;' $#"' c%&% '"%+ (6+ c%#%(+ 5 '; '*c"'i&"n$". E# (incii% !" # n% !i'c(i&inci,n '" c%&#"&"n$ c%n "# (incii% !" i*#!!+ c%&% #% "'$i*# "# ($;c*#% 1 !" # D"c#(ci,n Uni"('# !" D"("c)%' H*&n%'? @T%!%' #%' '"("' )*&n%' nc"n #i3("' " i*#"' "n !ini!! 5 !"("c)%'. D"("c)%' 5 %3#ici%n"' L%' !"("c)%' )*&n%' inc#*5"n $n$% !"("c)%' c%&% %3#ici%n"'. L%' E'$!%' '*&"n #' %3#ici%n"' 5 #%' !"3"("'+ "n i($*! !"# !"("c)% in$"(nci%n#+ !" ("'"$(+ (%$""( 5 ("#i6( #%' !"("c)%' )*&n%'. L %3#ici,n !" ("'"$(#%' 'inifc *" #%' E'$!%' !"3"n 3'$"n"('" !" in$"(7"(i( "n "# !i'7(*$" !" #%' !"("c)%' )*&n%'+ % !" #i&i$(#%'. L %3#ici,n !" (%$""(#%' "i" *" #%' E'$!%' i&i!n #%' 3*'%' !" #%' !"("c)%' )*&n%' c%n$( in!ii!*%' 5 (*%'. L %3#ici,n !" ("#i6(#%' 'inifc *" #%' E'$!%' !"3"n !%$( &"!i!' %'i$i' ( 7ci#i$( "# !i'7(*$" !" #%' !"("c)%' )*&n%' 3'ic%'. En "# #n% in!ii!*#+ '; c%&% !"3"&%' )c"( ("'"$( n*"'$(%' !"("c)%' )*&n%'+ $&3i/n !"3"&%' ("'"$( #%' !"("c)%' )*&n%' !" #%' !"&'. HISTORIA DE LOS DERECHOS HUMANOS 2 E# !"'"% !" *n &*n!% &' :*'$%+ &' #i3(" 5 &' '%#i!(i% '"*(&"n$" ) 'i!% *n 'i(ci,n c%&
En A&/(ic !"# N%($" #%' "7"c$%' !" # c%#%ni6ci,n 7*"(%n $%!; &' !"'$!%("'+ (%!*ci/n!%'" *n "n%ci!i% *" 7"c$, # &5%(; !" #' %3#ci%n"' in!;"n'+ # &i'&% $i"&% *" '" ("c#*; #%' %c%' '*"(ii"n$"' "n ("'"('. D*(n$" "# 'i#% VII+ "n In#$"((+ '" (%!*c"n $("' )"c)%' i&%($n$"'? L P"$ici,n !" D"("c)%' 1F2+ *" (%$"; #%' !"("c)%' "('%n#"' 5 $(i&%ni#"'= E# Ac$ !" H3"' C%(*' 1F8+ *" (%)i3; #' !"$"nci%n"' 'in %(!"n :*!ici#= L D"c#(ci,n !" D"("c)%' 1F8+ *" c%n'(3 #%' !"("c)%' ("c%i!%' "n #%' $"$%' n$"(i%("'. E# in#/' J%)n L%cK" 1F92-104+ "' *n f*( ci$# !"# 'i#% VII. C%n'i!"(!% "# !(" !"# #i3"(#i'&% &%!"(n%+ (%*'% *" # '%3"(n; "&n3 !"# *"3#%+ *" "# E'$!% !"3; (%$""( #%' !"("c)%' !" #%' ci*!!n%' 5+ n$icin!%'" M%n$"'*i"*+ *" "# %!"( #"i'#$i% 5 "# :*!ici# )3;n !" "'$( '"(!%'. T*% *n (n inB*"nci "n # ("!cci,n !" #' (n!"' !"c#(ci%n"' !" !"("c)%' )*&n%' !" fn#"' !"# 'i#% VIII. L' (i&"(' (n!"' !"c#(ci%n"' '" (%!*:"(%n "n #' c%#%ni' in#"'' !" N%($"&/(ic+ i&*#'!' %( '*' c%nBic$%' c%n # c%(%n in#"'? "n :*ni% !" 1F '" (%c#&, # D"c#(ci,n !" D"("c)%' !" Vi(ini 5 "n :*#i% # D"c#(ci,n !" In!""n!"nci !" #%' E'$!%' Uni!%'. L D"c#(ci,n !" In!""n!"nci+ ("!c$! %( T)%&' J""('%n+ f(&3 #% 'i*i"n$"? S%'$"n"&%' c%&% "(!!"(' "i!"nci' *" $%!%' #%' )%&3("' nc"n i*#"'+ *" "'$n !%$!%' %( '* C("!%( !" ci"($%' !"("c)%' in#i"n3#"'+ "n$(" #%' c*#"' '" "nc*"n$( "# !"("c)% # i!+ # #i3"($! 5 # 3<'*"! !" # 7"#ici!!.... Un !/c! &' $(!"+ !" n*"% "n E*(%+ "n #%' $i"&%' i$!%' !" # R"%#*ci,n >(nc"'+ "n 18 '" (%c#& "n P(;' # D"c#(ci,n !" #%' D"("c)%' !"# H%&3(" 5 !"# Ci*!!n%. A "'$ !"c#(ci,n+ #" 'i*i, "n 189 *n '"*n! &' (!ic# 5 *n $"(c"(+ "n 18+ &' c%n'"(!%(. D*(n$" "# 'i#% VIII 7*"(%n 7*n!&"n$#"' #' i!"' !" M%n$"'*i"* 5 R%*''"*. M%n$"'*i"* 1F8-1+ c(i$ic, '""(&"n$" #%' 3*'%' !" # I#"'i 5 !"# E'$!%. A# "'$*!i( #' in'$i$*ci%n"' 5 c%'$*&3("' 7(nc"'' !" # /%c+ !i% 7%(&' ("ci'' # $"%(; !"# %3i"(n% !"&%c($ic% (#&"n$(i% c%n # '"(ci,n !" #%' $("' %!"("'+ #"i'#$i%+ ":"c*$i% 5 :*!ici#+ c%&% &"cni'&% !" c%n$(%# ("c;(%c% "n$(" #%' &i'&%'+ c3n!% $",(ic&"n$" c%n # c%nc"n$(ci,n !"# %!"( "n *n &i'& "('%n 5 #%' c%n'"c*"n$"' 3*'%' *" )i'$,(ic&"n$" )3; (%!*ci!% "# i#i&i$!% %!"( !"# &%n(c. R%*''"* 112-1+ %( '* ($"+ !"n*nci, i%(%'&"n$" #' in:*'$ici' 5 &i'"(i' ("'*#$n$"' !" # !"'i*#!! '%ci# !" '* /%c+ (%*n, # i!" !" *n '%ci"!! 3'! "n i*#!! 3'%#*$+ "n # *" c! &i"&3(%+ # ( *" '" '%&"$" #' !"ci'i%n"' !"# c%#"c$i%+ "' # &i'&% $i"&% ($" !"# *"3#% '%3"(n%+ c*5 %#*n$! "n"(# c%n'$i$*5" # L"5. E'$' i!"' !" R%*''"* 7%("ci"(%n # "#3%(ci,n !"# c%nc"$% !" #%' !"("c)%' )*&n%' # #n$"( # n"c"'i!! !" # "i'$"nci !" *n i*#!!
"n$(" #%' )%&3("'+ *i"n"' !"3"n '%&"$"( '* %#*n$! in!ii!*# # %#*n$! !"# c%#"c$i%+ c%n "# %3:"$% !" #cn6( "# 3i"n"'$( ( $%!%'. E# 'i#% VIII 7*" *n 'i#% !" #%(%' i&%($n$"' 5 # &i'&% $i"&% !" c%n'i!"(3#"' #i&i$ci%n"'. D%' ":"&#%'? 1 L' !"c#(ci%n"' )3#n !" #%' D"("c)%' !" #%' H%&3("' #' &*:"("' *"!3n "c#*i!'. 2 >("c*"n$"&"n$" "(n c%&$i3#"' c%n # "'c#i$*!. En E'$!%' Uni!%' n% '" 3%#i, # "'c#i$*! )'$ # G*"(( !" S"c"'i,n+ "n 1F. En E'+ '" 3%#i, "n 114+ *n*" '" "(&i$i, *" c%n$in*( "n #' c%#%ni' c%nc("$&"n$" "n C*3+ )'$ 10. D*(n$" "# 'i#% I+ "# f#,'%7%+ %#;$ic% 5 "c%n%&i'$ in#/' J%)n S$*($ Mi## 10F-19+ $*% *n (n inB*"nci. En '* #i3(% S%3(" # #i3"($!+ ("B"i%n, c"(c !" # n$*(#"6 5 #%' #;&i$"' !"# %!"( *" *"!" '"( #";$i&&"n$" ":"(ci!% %( # '%ci"!! '%3(" "# in!ii!*%+ (*&"n$n!% *" $%! "('%n !"3"(; '"( #i3(" ( ("#i6( #' c%n!*c$' *" !"'"" 'i"&(" 5 c*n!% n% !" #%' !"&'. >*" *n !"7"n'%( !" # #i3"($! !" "("'i,n 5+ c%&% &i"&3(% !"# (#&"n$% 3(i$nic%+ (%*'% (i' ("7%(&' !"# 'i'$"& "#"c$%(#+ "'"ci#&"n$" '%3(" #' c*"'$i%n"' !" # ("("'"n$ci,n (%%(ci%n# 5 # "$"n'i,n !"# '*7(i%. A # P(i&"( G*"(( M*n!i# 'i*i, # c("ci,n !" # S%ci"!! !" Nci%n"'+ *" *n*" n% 7*" c6 !" "i$( # S"*n! G*"(( M*n!i#+ '; $*% "# &/(i$% !" '"( "# ("c"!"n$" !" *n %(ni6ci,n '*(nci%n# !" c(c$"( inc*#n$". O$(%' #%(%' !" # S%ci"!! !" Nci%n"' 7*"(%n # c("ci,n !"# T(i3*n# In$"(nci%n# !" # H5+ # f(& !"# C%n"ni% in$"(nci%n# ( # '*("'i,n !" # "'c#i$*! f(&!% "n 182F 5 c%&#"$!% 5 ($ifc!% %( #' Nci%n"' Uni!' "n 18F % # c("ci,n !" # O(ni6ci,n In$"(nci%n# !"# T(3:%. A # S"*n! G*"(( M*n!i# 'i*i, # c("ci,n !" #' Nci%n"' Uni!'. L%' )%((%("' !" # *"(( 5 #%' :*ici%' !" N*("&3"( 5 T%Ki% c%n$( #%' #$%' ("'%n'3#"' n6i' 5 :%n"'"'+ c*'!%' !" c(;&"n"' !" *"(( 5 "n%ci!i%'+ &%'$(3n # n"c"'i!! !" ("*#( !" 7%(& ("ci' "# c%nc"$% !" !"("c)%' )*&n%' 5+ '%3(" $%!%+ !" "'$3#"c"( c#(&"n$" c*#"' "(n. E# ("'*#$!% 7*" # (%3ci,n+ "n 184+ !" # D"c#(ci,n Uni"('# !" #%' D"("c)%' H*&n%'. C%n "# '% !" #%' %'+ # D"c#(ci,n Uni"('#+ *" c%&% $# n% "' !" c(c$"( inc*#n$"+ '" ) i!% c%&#"$n!% c%n *n '"(i" !" c%n"ni%'+ c%n"nci%n"' 5 c$%'+ "'$%' '; inc*#n$"'+ *" n !"'((%##n!%+ 5 "n #*n%' c'%' &#in!%+ #%' c%n$"ni!%' !" # D"c#(ci,n Uni"('#. E# %3:"$i% !"&' "' *" "'$%' !"("c)%' ##"*"n 7%(&( ($" !"# !"("c)% %'i$i% !" $%!' #' nci%n"'+ #% *" "n &*c)%' c'%' 5 ) '*c"!i!% %$( c%' "' *" #*"% '"n ("'"$!%'. L' n%(&' 5 (incii%' "&"6!%' (%&*#( )c" 'i#%' !" 7%(& 7(&"n$! 5 !i7*' "n !i'$in$%' "n$%(n%' c*#$*(#"' c%n *n inci!"nci "n "n"(# #i&i$! '%3(" # i! c%$i!in !" #%' ci*!!n%' !" #' c%(("'%n!i"n$"' /%c' )i'$,(ic'+ c%n "# '% !"# $i"&% '" )n i!% c%n'%#i!n!% 5 !i7*n!i"n!%? %( *n #!%+ !"$##n!% c! "6 c%n &' ("ci'i,n #%' !i'$in$%' !"("c)%' 5+ %( %$(% #!%+ c%n'$(*5"n!% '%ci"!!"'
!%$!' !" #%' &"cni'&%' n"c"'(i%' ( "#( %( "# ("'"$% "7"c$i% !" "'$%' !"("c)%'. L D"c#(ci,n Uni"('# "' # c*#&inci,n+ )'$ "# &%&"n$%+ !" "'$" 7n !" *ni"('#i6ci,n 5 c%nc("ci,n !" #%' !"("c)%' !" #' "('%n'. DERECHOS HUMANOS JUSTICIALES R"'"$( #%' !"("c)%' "' *n !"3"( !" #%' ci*!!n%'+ "(% # %3#ici,n !" (n$i6(#%' ( '* ("c%n%ci&i"n$%+ ("'"$%+ (%$"cci,n+ '$i'7cci,n 5 (%("'ii!!+ c%&"$" "c#*'i&"n$" # E'$!%+ %(*" /'$" "' # in'$i$*ci,n c%n %!"("' 5 7c*#$!"' !"'in!' "n *n &(c% !"&%c($ic% ( (%c*(( 5 ("'*(!( "# in$"(/' "n"(# 5 "# 3i"n c%&
(n$;' !" cc"'% %#;$ic'+ &"!i!' 5 3i"n"' 5 '"(ici%' (n$i6!%' %( "# E'$!%. T%!%' #%' !"("c)%' '%n "ii3#"' "n i($*! !" '* ("#ci,n c%n %$(%' !"("c)%'+ 5 *"!"n in%c( #%' (incii%' "n"(#"' !" #%' !"("c)%' )*&n%'+ c%&% # i*#!! 5 # n% !i'c(i&inci,n % "# !"("c)% # $*$"# :*!ici# "7"c$i. GENERACIONES DE LOS DERECHOS HUMANOS 9 L%' !i7"("n$"' "n7%*"' *" %( #%' *" n%' %!"&%' *i( ( c#'ifc( #%' D"("c)%' H*&n%' '%n? •
•
E# "n7%*" )i'$%(ici'$? En "'$" "n7%*" '" $%& "n c*"n$ # (%$"cci,n (%("'i !" #%' D"("c)%' H*&n%' E# "n7%*" 3'!% "n # :"((*;? En "'$" "n7%*" '" !i'$in*i( "n$(" #%' D"("c)%' "'"nci#"' 5 #%' D"("c)%' c%&#"&"n$(i%'
En$(" #' c#'ifcci%n"' !" #%' D"("c)% H*&n%' $"n"&%' *n !" #' &' c%n%ci!' *" "' # *" c(" *n !i'$inci,n "n$(" #' !"n%&in!' T("' G"n"(ci%n"' !" #%' D"("c)%' H*&n%' 5 "'$ 7*n!&"n$! 3:% *n "n7%*" "(i,!ic% 7*n!&"n$!% "n # (%("'i c%3"($*( !" #%' D"("c)%' H*&n%'. E'$ c#'ifcci,n "'$ 7%(&! %(? •
•
L P(i&"( G"n"(ci,n? E'$ "n"(ci,n nc" c%n # R"%#*ci,n >(nc"' c%&% ("3"#i,n c%n$( "# 3'%#*$i'&% !"# &%n(c. S" "nc*"n$( in$"(! %( #%' !"n%&in!%' !"("c)%' cii#"' 5 %#;$ic%'. I&%n"n # E'$!% ("'"$( 'i"&(" #%' D"("c)%' >*n!&"n$#"' !"# '"( )*&n% # i!+ # #i3"($!+ # i*#!!+ "$c. L S"*n! G"n"(ci,n? L c%n'$i$*5"n #%' D"("c)%' !" $i% c%#"c$i%+ #%' D"("c)%' S%ci#"'+ Ec%n,&ic%' 5 C*#$*(#"'. S*("n c%&% ("'*#$!% !" # R"%#*ci,n In!*'$(i#+ "n M/ic%+ # C%n'$i$*ci,n !" 181 inc#*5, #%' D"("c)%' S%ci#"' %( (i&"( "6 "n "# &*n!%. C%n'$i$*5"n *n %3#ici,n !" )c"( !"# E'$!% 5 '%n !" '$i'7cci,n (%("'i !" c*"(!% #' %'i3i#i!!"' "c%n,&ic' !"# &i'&%.
9 M!#"n C*"' A*i#(+ #' $("' "n"(ci%n"' !" #%' !"("c)%' )*&n%'. P*3#ic!% %( # UNAM+
•
L T"(c"( G"n"(ci,n? S" 7%(& %( #%' ##&!%' D"("c)%' !" #%' P*"3#%' % !" S%#i!(i!!. S*("n "n n*"'$(% $i"&% c%&% ("'*"'$ # n"c"'i!! !" c%%"(ci,n "n$(" #' nci%n"'+ '; c%&% !" #%' !i'$in$%' (*%' *" #' in$"(n.
DERECHOS DE LA PRIMERA GENERACION D"("c)% *" c%&("n!"? L%' D"("c)%' H*&n%' !" P(i&"( G"n"(ci,n 3(cn #' Li3"($!"' >*n!&"n$#"'+ #%' D"("c)%' Cii#"' 5 #%' P%#;$ic%'. E'$%' !"("c)%' '" ("f"("n # in!ii!*% 7("n$" # "'$!% % c*#*i"( %$( *$%(i!!. C(c$"(;'$ic'? •
•
• •
E# E'$!% "'$ %3#i!% ("'"$(#%' 'i"&(" 5 '%#% *"!"n '"( #i&i$!%' "n #%' c'%' ("i'$%' "n # c%n'$i$*ci,n. En #%' D"("c)%' Cii#"' '* $i$*#( '%n $%!%' #%' '"("' )*&n%' "n "n"(#. En #%' D"("c)%' P%#;$ic%' "# $i$*#( '%n #%' ci*!!n%'. E# ("c#&% c%(("'%n!" # (%i% in!ii!*%.
D"("c)%' 5 Li3"($!"' 7*n!&"n$#"'? •
•
• • •
•
• • •
•
• •
T%! "('%n $i"n" #%' !"("c)%' 5 #i3"($!"' 7*n!&"n$#"' 'in !i'$inci,n !" (6+ c%#%(+ i!i%&+ %'ici,n '%ci# % "c%n,&ic. T%!% in!ii!*% $i"n" !"("c)% # i!+ # #i3"($! 5 # '"*(i!! :*(;!ic. L%' )%&3("' 5 #' &*:"("' %'""n i*#"' !"("c)%'. N!i" "'$( '%&"$i!% "'c#i$*! % '"(i!*&3(". N!i" '"( '%&"$i!% $%($*('+ ni "n' % $($%' c(*"#"'+ in)*&n%' % !"(!n$"' ni '" %!( )c"(n%' !% 7;'ic%+ ';*ic% % &%(#. N!i" *"!" '"( &%#"'$!% (3i$((i&"n$" "n '* i! (i!+ '* 7&i#i+ '* !%&ici#i% % '* c%(("'%n!"nci+ ni c%n $*"' '* )%n( % '* ("*$ci,n. T%! "('%n $i"n" !"("c)% ci(c*#( #i3("&"n$" 5 "#"i( '* ("'i!"nci. T%! "('%n $i"n" !"("c)% *n nci%n#i!!. En c'% !" "('"c*ci,n %#;$ic+ $%! "('%n $i"n" !"("c)% 3*'c( 'i#% 5 !i'7(*$( !" /#+ "n c*#*i"( ;'. L%' )%&3("' 5 #' &*:"("' $i"n"n !"("c)% c'('" 5 !"ci!i( "# n<&"(% !" )i:%' *" !"'"n. T%! "('%n $i"n" !"("c)% # #i3"($! !" "n'&i"n$% 5 !" ("#ii,n. T%!% in!ii!*% $i"n" !"("c)% # #i3"($! !" %ini,n 5 !" "("'i,n !" i!"'.
•
T%! "('%n $i"n" !"("c)% # #i3"($! !" ("*ni,n 5 !" '%cici,n c;fc'.
DERECHOS DE LA SEGUNDA GENERACION? D"("c)%' *" C%&("n!"? L%' D"("c)%' H*&n%' !" # S"*n! G"n"(ci,n 3(cn #%' !"("c)% Ec%n,&ic%'+ S%ci#"' 5 C*#$*(#"' '%n !"("c)%' !" c%n$"ni!% '%ci# ( (%c*(( #' &":%("' c%n!ici%n"' !" i!. C(c$"(;'$ic'? •
• •
•
A&#; # "'7"( !" ("'%n'3i#i!! !"# E'$!%= I&%n"n *n !"3"( )c"( %'i$i% %( ($" !"# E'$!%= S* $i$*#( "' "# in!ii!*% "n c%&*ni!!+ *" '" '%ci ( '* !"7"n'. S* ("c#&% "' &"!i$% " in!i("c$%+ "'$ c%n!ici%n!% #' %'i3i#i!!"' "c%n,&ic' !"# ;'. S%n #";$i&' 'i(ci%n"' !" # '%ci"!!.
L%' D"("c)%' Ec%n,&ic%'+ S%ci#"' 5 C*#$*(#"'? •
•
•
•
• •
• • • •
T%! "('%n $i"n" !"("c)% # '"*(i!! '%ci# 5 %3$"n"( # '$i'7cci,n !" #%' !"("c)%' "c%n,&ic%'+ '%ci#"' 5 c*#$*(#"'. T%! "('%n $i"n" !"("c)% # $(3:% "n c%n!ici%n"' "*i$$i' 5 '$i'7c$%(i'. T%! "('%n $i"n" !"("c)% 7%(&( 'in!ic$%' ( # !"7"n' !" '*' in$"("'"'. T%! "('%n $i"n" !"("c)% *n ni"# !" i! !"c*!% *" #" '"*("+ '; c%&% '* 7&i#i+ # '#*!+ # #i&"n$ci,n+ "# "'$i!%+ # ii"n!+ # 'i'$"nci &/!ic 5 #%' '"(ici%' '%ci#"' n"c"'(i%'. T%! "('%n $i"n" !"("c)% # '#*! 7;'ic 5 &"n$#. L &$"(ni!! 5 # in7nci $i"n"n !"("c)% c*i!!%' 5 'i'$"nci "'"ci#"'. T%! "('%n $i"n" !"("c)% # "!*cci,n "n '*' !i"('' &%!#i!!"'. L "!*cci,n (i&(i 5 '"c*n!(i '"( %3#i$%(i 5 ($*i$. T"n"&%' !"("c)% # '"*(i!! <3#ic. L%' !("' $i"n"n !"("c)% "'c%"( "# $i% !" "!*cci,n *" )3( !" !('" '*' )i:%'.
DERECHOS DE LA TERCERA GENERACION?
D"("c)%' *" c%&("n!"? E'$%' D"("c)%' H*&n%' $&3i/n '%n c%n%ci!%' c%&%? • •
D"("c)%' D" #%' P*"3#%'. D"("c)%' D" S%#i!(i!!.
D"n$(% !" "'$%' !"("c)%' '" !"'("n!"n $("' $i%' !" 3i"n"' *" '%n? P6 Cii#"' 5 P%#;$ic%'+ D"'((%##% Ec%n,&ic%'+ S%ci#"' 5 C*#$*(#"' 5 M"!i% A&3i"n$" D" C%%"(ci,n "n$(" #%' P*"3#%'. Y "'$%' '" *"!"n ("*ni( "n? D"("c)%' !" #%' !i'$in$%' (*%' *" c%n7%(&n *n E'$!%. D"("c)%' !" *n Nci,n 5 D"("c)%' !" #' Nci%n"' "n$(" ';. C(c$"(;'$ic'? •
•
•
P"($"n"c"n (*%' i&("ci'%' !" "('%n' *" $i"n"n *n in$"(/' c%#"c$i% c%&
L%' D"("c)%' !" #%' P*"3#%' '%n? • • • • • • • • • • •
• • •
A # *$%!"$"(&inci,n. A # in!""n!"nci "c%n,&ic 5 %#;$ic. A # i!"n$i!! nci%n# 5 c*#$*(#. A # P6. A # c%"i'$"nci c;fc. A# "n$"n!i&i"n$% 5 c%nfn6. A # c%%"(ci,n in$"(nci%n# 5 ("i%n#. A# !"'((%##%. A # :*'$ici '%ci# in$"(nci%n#. A# *'% !" #%' nc"' !" #' ci"nci' 5 $"cn%#%;'. A # '%#*ci,n !" #%' (%3#"&' #i&"n$ici%'+ !"&%(fc%'+ "!*c$i%'+ "c%#,ic%'. A# &"!i% &3i"n$". A# $(i&%ni% c%&
INICIO+ >INALIADAD+ IMPORANCIA DEL PROCESO
4
L C%($" S*("& !" J*'$ici ("'"n$, n$" # A'&3#" L"i'#$i+ "n ":"(cici% !" *n %$"'$! c%n'$i$*ci%n#+ *n (%5"c$% !" #"5 *" %'$"(i%(&"n$" 7*" !%$!% 5 '" c%ni($i, "n # L"5 18 !" 1881. En "# ($;c*#% 11 !" !ic) #"5 '" c%n'(, "# (%c"'% c%n$"nci%'% !&ini'$($i% !" (%$"cci,n !" #%' !"("c)%' )*&n%' &"!in$" "# c*# # S# *"!" n*#( c$%' !&ini'$($i%' ""!i!%' %( *$%(i!!"' nci%n#"' 5+ 'i (%c"!"+ ("'$3#"c"( % ("(( "# !"("c)% i%#!% c*n!% &"!in$" !ic)%' c$%' !&ini'$($i%' '" i%#"n !"("c)%' )*&n%' :*'$ici3#"' ("i'$%' "n #' #"5"' !" # R"<3#ic+ inc#*'% */##' *" (*"3"n c%n"ni%' in$"(nci%n#"' '%3(" !"("c)%' )*&n%'. C%n "'$" n*"% (%c"'% '" #" ! # c%n$"nci%'% !&ini'$($i%+ c%&% #% '"#, "# Lic. J%(" >3(" P%nc"+ *n n*"% "n7%*"? !" # c%nc"ci,n $(!ici%n# c%&% *n (%c"'% # c$% !&ini'$($i%QQ *n i'i,n *" "n7$i6 "# "# !" "'$ :*(i'!icci,n c%&% (%$"c$%( !" #%' !"("c)%' )*&n%' !" #%' !&ini'$(!%'. E'$% i&#ic *n *"#c% "n # c%nc"ci,n !" "'$ in'$i$*ci,n+ $# c%&% # )"&%' ("ci3i!% in!i("c$&"n$" !" >(nci+ $(/' !" C%#%&3iQQ T(!ici%n#&"n$" "n n*"'$(% ;' '" !%$(%n #%' c*$(% (%c"'%' c%n$"nci%'% !&ini'$($i%' *" "i'$"n "n "# 'i'$"& 7(nc/' 1F+ '3"(? "# !" n*#i!! "c/' !" %*%i(+ "# !" #"n :*(i'!icci,n+ "# !" in$"(("$ci,n 5 "# !" ("cici,n !" #i!/6. C%n "'$ n*" #"5 '" (", *n n*"% (%c"'% *" n% ("*i"(" "# %$&i"n$% ("i% !" # ; *3"(n$i 5 "n "# c*# "# P(%c*(!%( !" # A!&ini'$(ci,n c$< "c#*'i&"n$" "n in$"(/' !" # #"5. En # '"n$"nci !" 4 !" :*ni% !" 1889+ *" !"ci!i, "# (i&"( (%c"'% !" "'$ n$*(#"6+ '" '"#, *" "( n*#% *n c%n"ni% c"#"3(!% "n$(" # Di("cci,n !" T(n'i$% 5 T(n'%($" T"(("'$(" 5 # C%%(!in!%( !" 7*"(6' (%!*c$i' !" C%#,n *" (""; *" ',#% ci"($%' ");c*#%' %!;n $(n'%($( ':"(%' )ci # %n Li3(" !" C%#,n %(*" i%#3 # #i3"($! !" $(n'i$% % !"("c)% !" ci(c*#ci,n ("i'$% "n "# ($;c*#% 22 !" # C%n"nci,n A&"(icn '%3(" !"("c)%' )*&n%'+ ($ifc! %( # L"5 1 !" 18. En !ic) ("'%#*ci,n '" '"#, *" "'" c%n"ni% "'$3#"c; (c$ic' !" c(c$"( &%n%,#ic%+ (%)i3i!' %( "# ($;c*#% 289 !" # C%n'$i$*ci,n+ 5 *" )3; *" in$"(("$( # n%(& #"# *" ("/ # #i3"($! !" $(n'i$% !" c%n7%(&i!! c%n # ci$! (%)ici,n c%n'$i$*ci%n#. ASPECTOS RELEVANTES DEL PROCESO
4 D(. A($*(% H%5%'+ L A!&ini'$(ci,n 5 '* :*"6? L :*(i'!icci,n c%n$"nci%'%!&ini'$($i "n Pn& D*(n$" "# *#$i&% Si#%
M"!in$" # L"5 N 18 !" 8 !" :*#i% !" 1881 *" !ici%n "# n*&"(# 1 !"# ($;c*#% 8 !"# C,!i% J*!ici#+ '" in'$i$*5, "n n*"'$(% 'i'$"& :*!ici# "# (%c"'% c%n$"nci%'% !&ini'$($i% !" #%' !"("c)%' )*&n%'. En "7"c$%+ ($i( !" "'$ L"5+ # '# $"(c"( !" # C%($" S*("& !" J*'$ici !"3"( c%n%c"(+ "n$(" %$(%' '"c$%'? @D"# (%c"'% !" (%$"cci,n !" #%' !"("c)%' )*&n%' &"!in$" "# c*# # S# %!( n*#( c$%' !&ini'$($i%' ""!i!%' %( *$%(i!!"' nci%n#"' 5+ 'i (%c"!"+ ("'$3#"c"( % ("(( "# !"("c)% i%#!% c*n!% &"!in$" !ic)%' c$%' !&ini'$($i%' '" i%#"n !"("c)%' )*&n%' :*'$ici3#"'+ inc#*'% *"##' *" (*"3"n c%n"ni%' in$"(nci%n#"' '%3(" !"("c)%' )*&n%'. E'$" (%c"'% '" $(&i$( '"
In$"(nci%n# !" D"("c)%' Cii#"' 5 P%#;$ic%'+ Pc$% in$"(nci%n# !" D"("c)%' Ec%n,&ic%'+ S%ci#"' 5 C*#$*(#"'+ "$c.+ ni "n $%!%' #%' '**"'$%' !" i%#ci,n !" !"("c)%' )*&n%'+ *"!" !"&n!('" (%$"cci,n :*(i'!icci%n# c%n 7*n!&"n$% "n # n%(& :*(;!ic ci$!. En "7"c$%+ # (%$"cci,n :*(i'!icci%n# !" #%' !"("c)%' )*&n%' "'$ #i&i$! *"##%' c*5 c%nc"ci,n :*(;!ic c$*# "(&i$" !"&n!( '* #"n i"nci 5 "fcci+ !"n$(% !" #%' c*#"' '" "nc*"n$(n #%' !"("c)%' )*&n%' !" # (i&"( "n"(ci,n. Hn !" "c#*i('" c%n'"c*"n$"&"n$" #%' !"("c)%' !" # '"*n! "n"(ci,n c%n #*n' "c"ci%n"'+ %(*" '%n !"("c)%' (%(&$ic%'. N% !" %$( &n"( ) !" "n$"n!"('" # "("'i,n D"("c)%' H*&n%' JUSTICIALES c%n$"ni! "n "# ("c"$% :*(;!ic% $(n'c(i$%. ANALISIS Y CARACTERISTICAS DEL PROCESO E# D(. A($*(% H%5%' "n '* "n'5% @J*'$ici C%n$"nci%'-A!&ini'$($i 5 D"("c)%' H*&n%' 7*" # (i&"( "('%n "n #n$"( #' !i'$in$' c(c$"(;'$ic' *" "#ic3n "'$" &"cni'&% (%c"'#.
1. P(%c"'% E'"ci#? L ($ic*#(i!! !" "'$" P(%c"'% "' !"$"(&in! %( '* %3:"$% 5 *" '" 3' "n 3(in!(#" #%' !&ini'$(!%' *n "'"ci# (%$"cci,n :*!ici# !i("c$ '*' !"("c)%' )*&n%' :*'$ici3#"' !" (i%' (%"ni"n$"' !" c$%' !&ini'$($i%' ""!i!%' %( #' *$%(i!!"' nci%n#"'+ '" !"'$c c%&% *n #ii% (%c"'# in$"(n% !" $*$"# !" #%' !"("c)%' )*&n%'. S"
2. P(%c"'% !i(ii!% (%$""( #%' D"("c)%' H*&n%' J*'$ici3#"'? En Pn& ( !"$"(&in( */ D"("c)%' )*&n%' '%n :*'$ici3#"' $(/' !"# P(%c"'% C%n$"nci%'%-A!&ini'$($i% !" P(%$"cci,n !" #%' D"("c)%' H*&n%'+ '" ) ("c*((i!% #% *" '" '"#, "n # "%'ici,n !" &%$i%' !"# P(%5"c$% !" L"5 *" ("'"n$, # C%($" S*("& !" J*'$ici c%n c*# '" c("3 "'$" (%c"'% 5 # !%c$(in+ %( #% *" "nc%n$(&%' #' #i3"($!"' !" '%cici,n+ "("'i,n+ 5 ("*ni,n+ # #i3"($! 5 '"c("$% !" c%(("'%n!"nci'+ "# !"("c)% # in$i&i!!+ #i3"($! ("#ii%'+ "n$(" %$(%'+ c%&% !"("c)% *n !"3i!% (%c"'% #"#+ (incii% !" i*#!!. 9. P(%$"" #%' D"("c)%' H*&n%' c%n$( i%#ci%n"' (%"ni"n$"' !" Ac$%' A!&ini'$($i%' ""!i!%' %( *$%(i!!"' nci%n#"'. C*n!% #' *$%(i!!"' nci%n#"' "i!"n c$%' !&ini'$($i%' *" i%#n #%' !"("c)%' )*&n%'+ '" c%n'$i$*5" "n "# "#"&"n$% (%c"'# n"c"'(i% c%n "# c*# '" ! inici% "'$" "'"ci# (%c"'% !" (%$"cci,n !i("c$ !" #%' D"("c)%' H*&n%'. Sin "&3(% n% '" *"!" $c( %( &"!i% !" "'$" (%c"'% #%' c$%' !&ini'$($i%' i%#$%(i%' !" #%' !"("c)%' )*&n%'+ "&n!%' !" *$%(i!! <3#ic *" c("6c !" c%&"$"nci "n "# &3i$% nci%n#. E# 'i'$"& in$(%!*ci!% "n n*"'$(% ;'+ inc#*5" *n 7%(& !" (%$"cci,n !" #%' !"("c)%' )*&n%' !" $i% :*'$ici3#"'+ c%n *n 7%(&*#ci,n #"i'#$i *" ("!*c" "# &(c% !" cci,n 5 #% ("'$(ic$i% !" '*' c%nc"$%' $*$"#!%("'. D(. H%5%'? @"'$" (%c"'% '" "nc&in "i$( *" #%' &i"&3(%' !" #%' !i7"("n$"' ,(n%' !"# E'$!%+ &"!in$" c$%' !&ini'$($i%' *"!n #"'i%n( !"("c)%' )*&n%' :*'$ici3#"'. P(%7"'%( A(ici%? @',#% (%c"!" "# ("c#&%+ !" *"##' i%#ci%n"' *" $i"n"n #*( "n 7*nci,n !" *n c$% !&ini'$($i% !" #%' En$"' P<3#ic% !"# E'$!%. 4. N% '" ("*i"(" "# %$&i"n$% !" # ; !&ini'$($i? A%$( # ; !&ini'$($i "' *$i#i6( #%' ("c*('%' %(!in(i%' c*5 $(&i$ci,n # ##"n #' *$%(i!!"' !&ini'$($i' c%&"$"n$"'+ 5 "## "' *n "i"nci ( *$i#i6( cci%n"' c%n$"nci%'-!&ini'$($i' !" #"n :*(i'!icci,n. P%( "##% "' *" "# P(%c"'% C%n$"nci%'% A!&ini'$($i% !" P(%$"cci,n !" #%' D"("c)%' H*&n%'+ %'"" %( i($*! !" # #"5 *n "c"ci,n *" '" c%nci3" "n *" n% "' n"c"'(i% ni %3#i$%(i% *" "# (i!% %( c$%' !&ini'$($i%' !" *$%(i!!"' nci%n#"' "n '*' !"("c)%' )*&n%'+ n% %$" # #*!i! ; #% *" #" "(&i$" c*!i( "n 7%(& ""!i$ n$" # S# T"(c"( ( *" $(/' !" *n "'"ci# (%c"'% '" #" (%$": '*' !"("c)%' )*&n%'.
. E# P(%c*(!%( !" # A!&ini'$(ci,n in$"(i"n" "n # !"7"n' !" #%' D"("c)%' H*&n%'. L L"5 c%n c#(i!! "'$3#"c" *n $(i3*ci,n *" !"3" ":"(c"( "# P(%c*(!%( !" # A!&ini'$(ci,n+ # c*# 7%(& ($" !" # !"7"n' !" # #"#i!! "n #% c%n$"nci%'% !&ini'$($i%+ *" ) !" ("#i6( "'$" 7*nci%n(i%. E'$% n%' &*"" "n'( *" # 7&! !"7"n' !" #%' !"("c)%' )*&n%' *" !"3" ("#i6( "# P(%c*(!%( !" # A!&ini'$(ci,n "' *n !" #' &%!#i!!"' !" !"7"n!"( # #"#i!! *" '*& "n #%' (%c"'%' c%n$"nci%'%'+ #% *" # #"5 3*'c "' *" # "&i$i( "'$" 7*nci%n(i% '* c%nc"$% "n "'$ c#'" !" (%c"'%'+ #% ) "n 7%(& #i3(" " i&(ci#+ *!i"n!% !" "' &n"( !"7"n!"( # c*' % 'i$*ci,n &' c%(("c$ *" '* c(i$"(i% 3"n"fci" # #"5. F. L"i$i&ci,n (%c"'# !"# !"7"n'%( !"# *"3#% ( ":"(c"( # cci,n c%n$"nci%'-!&ini'$($i !" (%$"cci,n !" #%' D"("c)%' H*&n%'. E'$ #"i$i&ci,n '" #" *"!" !"fni( c%&% *n "(&i'% %$%(!% %( # L"5 # $i$*#( !" # D"7"n'%(; !"# P*"3#% ( in$"(%n"( #*n' cci%n"' 5 ("c*('%' c%&% ("("'"n$n$" !" #%' ($ic*#("'+ c%n "# fn !" inici( (%c"'%' n$" # ; :*(i'!icci%n#+ 7c*#$!"' *" '" ":"(c"(n "n #%' c'%' *" #% "'$i&" !"c*n!% "n (6,n !" #%' %3:"$i%' !" # !"7"n'%(; 5 (%&%"( n$" #' *$%(i!!"' :*!ici#"' c! c'%. En$(" #' cci%n"' *" *"!" ":"(c"( # D"7"n'%(; !"# P*"3#% %!"&%' "nc%n$(( #' cci%n"' %*#("'+ #%' ("c*('%' !" &(% !" (n$;' c%n'$i$*ci%n#"'+ "n$(" %$(%'. A# D"7"n'%( !"# P*"3#% #" c%(("'%n!" # ("("'"n$ci,n !"# !&ini'$(!% *" " '*' !"("c)%' 7"c$!%'+ %( #% *" !"3" '*&i( $%!' #' $(i3*ci%n"' (%i' *" !"3" ":"(c"( *n 3%!% ($ic*#( c*n!% c$< "n "'$ c#'" !" (%c"'%