POSSESSION SYNOPSIS
1. Definition ................................. ............................................. ............1
(viii)
2. Element of possession .......................... ..........................1
Modes of acquisition of Possession:- ... 3
(i)
Corpus possessionis Corpus possessionis ...................1
1. By taking possession........................ possession.......................... 4
(ii)
Animus possidendi possidendi . .....................1
2. By delivering possessi on .................. 4 i.
3. Kinds of possession...................... possession............................... .........1 (i)
Actual delivery ........................... ........................... 4
ii.
Immediate and Mediate .............. ..............1 ii.
Constructive delivery ............. 4 Actual Delivery:-........................ ........................ 4
i.
Kinds of mediate possession: ............2
Duplicate possession .............. 3
Constructive delivery ..................... ..................... 4
(ii)
Corporeal and Incorporeal ..........2
(iii)
Representative possession ..........2
a)
Traditio brevi manu ................ ................ 4
(iv)
Concurrent possession ................2
b)
Constitutum possesorium ....... 4
(v)
Derivative possession .................3
c)
Attornment.............................. .............................. 4
(vi)
Constructive possession .............3
(vii)
Adverse possession .................... ....................3
3. By operation of law of inheritance ........................................... .............................................................. ................... 5
1. Definition:
According to Salmond, Salmond, “in the whole whole range of legal theory, there is no conception more difficult than that of possession.” According to Bentham, Bentham, “legal possession cannot be defined absolutely and perfectly, but for practical purposes certain conditions and rules of legal possession can be laid laid down for the guidance of the courts.”
2. Element of possession: According to Roman Law Law essential elements of possession possession are as under:(i) Corpus possessionis Corpus possessionis: The physical aspect of possession. It comprises of the power to use the thing possessed and the existence of grounds for the expectation that the possessor’s use will not be interfered with.
(ii)
Animus possidendi : It is intent to appropriate to oneself the exclusive use of the thing possessed.
3. Kinds of possession:(i)
Immediate and Mediate: Immediate possession is also called direct possession and mediate possession is also known as indirect possession. Example: If the relation between the possessor and the thing possessed is a direct one, it is a case of immediate possession. When
ZEESHAN HUSSAIN ADIL (Adv.): ENGLISH JURISPRUDENCE (Q&A-LL.B-I, Session 2012-13)
9
2
Possession the relation is through the intervention or agency of some other person, it is called mediate possession.
Kinds of mediate possession: There are three kinds of mediate possession possess ion which are as under:(a) The first is that which is acquire through an agent or servant; that is to say, through someone who holds solely on my account and claims no interest of his own.
Example: When I allow my servant to use my tools in his work, or when I send him to buy or borrow a chattel for me, or when I deposit goods with a warehouseman who holds them on my account, or when I send my boots to a shoemaker to be repaired. In all the above said cases, though the immediate possession is in the servant, warehouseman, or artisan, the mediate possession is in me; for the immediate possession is held on my account. (b) The second kind of mediate possession is that in which the direct possession is in one who holds both on my account and on his own, but who recognises my superior right to obtain from him the direct possession whenever whenever I choose to demand it. Example: In case of a borrower or tenant at will, I do not lose possession of a thing because I have lent it to someone who acknowledge my title to it and is prepared to t o return it to me m e on demand, and who in the meantime holds it and looks after if on my behalf. (c) The third kind of mediate possession, respecting which more doubt may exist, but which must be recognised by sound theory as true possession. It is the case in which the immediate possession is in a person who claims it for himself until some time has elapsed or some condition has been fulfilled, but who acknowledges the title of another for whom he holds the thing, and to who he is prepared to deliver it when his own temporary claim has come to an end. Example: When I lend a chattel to another for a fixed time, or deliver it as a pledge to be returned on the payment of a debt, Even in such a case I retain possession of the thing, so far as third persons are concerned.
(ii)
Corporeal and Incorporeal: Corporeal possession possession is the possession of a material object and incorporeal possession is the possession of anything other than a material object.
(iii)
Representative possession: Representative possession is that in which the owner has possession of a thing through an agent or a servant
.
(iv)
Concurrent possession: In the case of concurrent possession, the possession of a thing may be in the hands of two or more person at the
ZEESHAN HUSSAIN ADIL (Adv.): ENGLISH JURISPRUDENCE (Q&A-LL.B-I, Session 2012-13)
9
Toppers Law College
3
same time. Claims which are not adverse and which are not mutually destructive admit of concurrent realization. Two or more persons may possess the same thing jointly.
(v)
Derivative possession: In the case of derivative possession, the holder of the thing combines in himself both the physical and mental elements which constitute legal possession. Example: A Example: A creditor has a derivative possession of the thing pledged to him. Likewise, a watchmaker has derivative possession of a watch entrusted to him for repairs so long as the repair charges are not paid.
(vi)
Constructive possession: It is not actual possession. It is a possession in law and not possession in fact. The good sold by me are lying in a warehouse and if I hand over the keys of the warehouse to the purchaser, the latter comes to have the constructive possession of the thing.
(vii)
Adverse possession: The possession of property by a person is adverse to every other person having or claiming to have a right to the possession of that property by virtue of a different title. a) To be adverse, possession must be an invasion of the ownership of another. b) It should be actual, exclusive and adequate in continuity and publicity. c) The acts of possession must be exercised without without violence, without stealth and without permission. d) When these conditions are present, possession is considered to be adverse. e) The conception of adverse possession is very important in law because when it had for the period laid down by law, it extinguishes the title of the true owner and creates a title in the adverse possession.
(viii)
Duplicate possession: Possession is a right to exclusive use and it is not possible for two persons to have independent and adverse claims to possession of the same thing at the same time. The possession of a thing by one person is compatible with its possession by another only when the two claims are not mutually adverse. Claims to possession which admit of concurrent realization give rise to duplicate possession
Modes of acquisition of Possession:Transfer or acquisition of possession can be done in the following three ways which are as under:1. By taking possession , 2. By delivering possession, 3. By operation of law of inheritance. inheritance.
ZEESHAN HUSSAIN ADIL (Adv.): ENGLISH JURISPRUDENCE (Q&A-LL.B-I, Session 2013-14)
9
4
Possession
1. By taking possession:
It means acquisition of possession without the consent of the previous possessor. The thing taken may or may not not have been already already in the possession possession of some one else, and in either case the taking of it may be either rightful or wrongful.
2. By delivering possession:
Acquisition of possession possession by delivery means acquisition acquisition of possession possession with the consent and co-operation of the previous possessor. It is of of two kinds, distinguished distinguished by law as under:i.
Actual delivery
ii.
Constructive delivery
i.
Actual Delivery:
ii.
Actual delivery is the transfer of immediate possession; possession; it is such such a physical dealing with the thing as transfers it from the hands of one person to those of another. It is of two kinds, according according as the mediate possession is or or is not retained by the transferor. The delivery of a chattel by way of sale sale is an example of dlivery without any reservation of mediate possession; the delivery of a chattel by way of loan or deposit is an instance of the reservation of mediate possession on the transfer of immediate. Actual delivery may be either to the deliveree himself or to a servant or agent for him.
Constructive delivery:
Constructive delivery, delivery, on the other hand, is all which is not actual, actual, and it is of three kinds which is as under;-
a) Traditio brevi manu b) Constitutum possesorium c) Attornment
a) Traditio brevi manu:
Traditio brevi manu is termed by Roman lawyers, but it has no recognised name in the language of English law. It consists in the surrender of the mediate possession nof nof a thing to him who is already in immediate possession of it. Example: I lend a book to someone, and afterwards, while he still retains it, I agree with him to sell it to him, or to make him a present of it, I can effectually deliver it to him in fulfilment of this sale or fit, by telling him that he may keep it. It is not necessary for him to go through the from of handing it back to me and receiving it a second time from a t e p o s s e s s i o n of my hands. For he has already the i m m e d i at of it, and all
ZEESHAN HUSSAIN ADIL (Adv.): ENGLISH JURISPRUDENCE (Q&A-LL.B-I, Session 2012-13)
9
Toppers Law College
5
that is needed for delivery under the sale of gift is the destruction of the animus through which mediate possession still retained by me. b) C o n s t i t u t u m p o s s e s s o r i u m :
The second form of constructive delivery is i s that which the commentators on the civil law have termed c o n s t i t u t u m p o s s e s o r i u m (that is to say, an agreement touching possession). a d i t i o n b r e v i m a n u . It is the transfer of mediate This is converse of t r ad possession, while the immediate possession remains in the transferor. Any thing may be effectually delivered by means means of an agreement that the possessor of it shall for the future hold it no longer on his own account but on account of some one else. No physical dealing with the thing is requisite, because by the mere agreement mediate possession is acquired by the transferee, through the immediate possession retained by the transferor and held on the other’s behalf. Example: If I buy goods from a warehouseman, they are delivered to me so soon as he has agreed with me that he will hold them as warehouseman on my account. The position is then exactly the same as if I had first taken actually delivery of them, and then brought them back to the warehouse, and deposited them there for safe custody.
c) Attornment: The third form of constructive constructive delivery is that which is a t t o r n m e n t. This is the transfer of mediate possession, while immediate possession remains outstanding in some third person. The mediate possessor of a thing may deliver it by procuring the immediate possessor to agree with the transferee to hold it for the future on his account, instead of on account of the transferor. Example: If I have goods in the warehouse of A and sell them to B, I have effectually delivered him, and no longer for me. Neither in this nor in any other case of constructive delivery is any physical dealing with the thing required, the change in a n i m u s of the persons concerned being adequate in itself.
3. By operation of law of inheritance :- In Islamic Republic of Pakistan possession is transferred by operation of law of inheritance to the legal heirs. If a person dies, the constructive possession of his property is transferred to his legal representatives by operation of Islamic Law of Inheritance. Possession is said to be 9/10 of law. Discuss Define possession. possession. What are the various modes of acquisition of possession?
Sup. 2006 Sup. 2007
Define possession, discuss various modes of acquisition of possession.
Sup. 2008 Ann. 2009
ZEESHAN HUSSAIN ADIL (Adv.): ENGLISH JURISPRUDENCE (Q&A-LL.B-I, Session 2013-14)
9
