Harald Motzki-Jurisprudence of Az-Zuhri

7KH-XULVSUXGHQFHRI,EQjLKED]=XKUª$6RXUFHFULWLFDO6WXG\  E\+DUDOG0RW]NL1LMPHJHQ

,

 :KDWGRZHNQRZDERXWWKHOH  :KDWGRZHNQRZDERXWWKHOHJDOGRFWULQHRI,EQjLK JDOGRFWULQHRI,EQjLKED]=XKUªRQHRIWK ED]=XKUªRQHRIWKHOHDGLQJ HOHDGLQJ VFKROD VFKRODUV UV LQ 0HGLQ 0HGLQD D GXULQ GXULQJ J WKH WKH ILUVW ILUVW TXDUW TXDUWHU HU RI WKH VHFRQ VHFRQG G FHQWX FHQWXU\ U\ $+" $+" -RVH -RVHSK SK 6FKDFK 6FKDFKW W ZURWH ZURWH DERXW DERXW WKH WKH LVVXH LVVXH LQ KLV HSRFK HSRFKP PDN DNLQJ LQJ ZRUN ZRUN 7KH 7KH 2ULJL 2ULJLQV QV RI 0XKD 0XKDP P o7KRVH VH FDVH FDVHV V LQ ZKLF ZKLFK K 0OL 0OLN N H[SO H[SOLF LFLW LWO\ O\ VWDW VWDWHV HV WKDW WKDW KH DVNH DVNHGG PDGDQ -XULVSUXGHQ -XULVSUXGHQFH FH o7KR =XKU =XKUª ª RU KHDU KHDUG G =XKU =XKUª ª VD\ VD\ VRPH VRPHWK WKLQ LQJ J FDQ FDQ XQKHVLWDWLQJO\ EH UHJD UHJDUG UGHG HG DV JHQX JHQXLQ LQH Hpp  0XZD°°Dº +HFRQWLQXHVo7KHUHDUHRWKHU 6FKDFKWEDVHGKLVFRQFOXVLRQRQ0OLNnV 0XZD°°Dº  6FKDFKWEDVHGKLVFRQFOXVLRQRQ0OLNnV +HFRQWLQXHVo7KHUHDUHRWKHU REYLRXVO\DXWKHQWLFp $VDVRXUFHZKHUHWKHVH RSLQLRQVDVFULEHGWR=XKUªZKLFKDUH REYLRXVO\DXWKHQWLFp  0XZD°°Dº DJDLQDQG6D¨Q³QnV0X RSLQLRQVDUHWREHIRXQG6FKDFKWPHQWLRQVWKH 0XZD°°Dº  RSLQLRQVDUHWREHIRXQG6FKDFKWPHQWLRQVWKH DJDLQDQG6D¨Q³QnV0X GDZZDQD GDZZDQD7K 7KHQ HQ6FK 6FKDFK DFKW WVWD VWDWHV WHVo% o%XW XWWR WRZDU ZDUGVWKH GVWKHHQ HQG GRI RIWK WKH HVHF VHFRQ RQG GFH FHQW QWXU\ XU\ $+ $+  VSXULRXVDQGRIWHQFRQWUDGLFWRU\RSLQ =XKUªKDGDOUHDG\EHHQFUHGLWHGZLWKPDQ\ VSXULRXV =XKUªKDGDOUHDG\EHHQFUHGLWHGZLWKPDQ\ DQGRIWHQFRQWUDGLFWRU\RSLQ LVQG VRIWUDGLWLRQVZKLFKGLGQRW\HWH[LVWLQKLV LRQVDQGKLVQDPHLQVHUWHGLQLVQG  LRQVDQGKLVQDPHLQVHUWHGLQ VRIWUDGLWLRQVZKLFKGLGQRW\HWH[LVWLQKLV WLP WLPH DQG IUR IURP ZKLF KLFK  ILFWLWLRXV VWD VWDWHP WHPHQWV RQ KLV VXSSR SSRVHG VHG GRFW GRFWUL ULQQH ZHUH ZHUH DE VWUDFWHGp ,Q6FKDFKWnVRSLQLRQWKHVHILFWLWLRXVWUDQVPLVVLRQVIURP=XKUªDUHWREH IRXQGIRUH[DPSOHLQjDLEQªnVUHF IRXQGIRUH[DPSOHLQjDLEQªnVUHFHQVLRQRIWK HQVLRQRIWKH H 0XZD°°Dº  LQjIL·ªnVWUHDWLVHVDQGLQ  0XZD°°Dº LQjIL·ªnVWUHDWLVHVDQGLQ  0XGDZZDQD WKH 0XGDZZDQD ,Q YLHZ YLHZ RI WKLV WKLV SUHV SUHVHQ HQWD WDWL WLRQ RQ RQH RQH ZRXO ZRXOG G H[SH H[SHFW FW 6FKD 6FKDFK FKW W WR H[FO H[FOXG XGH H 0OL 0OLNn NnVV  0XZD°°Dº IURPWKHVXVSLFLRQRIFRQWDLQLQJIRUJHG=XKUªWUDGLWLRQV7KDWLVQRWWKH IURPWKHVXVSLFLRQRIFRQWDLQLQJIRUJHG=XKUªWUDGLWLRQV7KDWLVQRWWKH 2ULJLQVPDNHFOHDU $OWKRXJKUHIHUULQJWRoWKH FDVHKRZHYHUDVRWKHUSDUWVRIKLV 2ULJLQVPDNHFOHDU HQGRIWKHVHFRQGFHQWXU\pDVWKHWLPHLQZKLFKILFWLWLRXV=XKUªWUDGLWLRQVZHUHFLU FXODWHG6FKDFKWDFWXDOO\WKLQNVWKDWWKH\ZHUHIDEULFDWHGGXULQJWKHHQWLUHVHFRQG KDOIRIWKHVHFRQG KDOIRIWKHVHFRQGFHQWXU FHQWXU\DQGWKDWWKH \DQGWKDWWKH\DUHIRXQGLQDOOVRXUFH \DUHIRXQGLQDOOVRXUFHVRIWKLVSHULRG VRIWKLVSHULRGLQ LQ

 0XZD°°Dº (DUOLHUVRXUFHVZHUHQRWDYDLODEOHWR6FKDFKW+HDVVXPHV FOXGLQJ0OLNnV 0XZD°°Dº  (DUOLHUVRXUFHVZHUHQRWDYDLODEOHWR6FKDFKW+HDVVXPHV  0XZD°°Dº DVWUDQVPLWWHGE\
8QWLOUHFHQWWLPHV6FKDFKWnVZRUNRQWKHRULJLQVRI,VODPLFMXULVSUXGHQFHKDV GHHSO\ GHHSO\ DIIH DIIHFWH FWHG G UHVHD UHVHDUFK UFK LQWR LQWR WKH WKH KLVWRU KLVWRU\ \ RI ,VODP ,VODPLF LF ODZ ODZ ,W LQIOXH LQIOXHQF QFHG HG HVSHF HVSHFLDO LDOO\ O\ ZHVWHUQVFKRODUVEXWDIHZ0XVOLPRQHVDVZHOO
SRUWDQWERWKEHFDXVHRIWKHODUJHQXPEHURI=XKUªWH[WVWKH\FRQWDLQDQGEHFDXVH RIWKHLUDJHIRUWKH\RULJLQDWHIURPEHIRUHRUDWOHDVWWKHVDPHSHULRGDV0OLNnV  0XZD°°Dº ,DPUHIH , DPUHIHUULQ UULQJWR JWRWKH WKHWUDQVPL WUDQVPLVVLRQ VVLRQVRI VRI0D·P 0D·PDUE DUE5vL 5vLGG GGDQG DQG ·$EG ·$EGDO DOPD PDOL OLN N ,EQ ,EQ £XUDL XUDL¤ ¤ G G     FRQW FRQWDL DLQH QHG G LQ ·$EG ·$EGDU DUUD UD]] ]]T T D¬« D¬«DQ DQ· ·Qª QªnV nV  0X®DQQDI $V,KDYHVKRZQHOVHZKHUHLQPRUHGHWDLOWKHLUWUDQVPLVVLRQVDUHROGDQG $V,KDYHVKRZQHOVHZKHUHLQPRUHGHWDLOWKHLUWUDQVPLVVLRQVDUHROGDQG JHQXLQHDQGZHUH JHQXLQHDQGZHUHRULJ RULJLQDOO LQDOO\ \FRQW FRQWDLQH DLQHG GLQWKH LQWKHZULWW ZULWWHQZRUNVRI HQZRUNVRIWKH WKHVHVFKRODU VHVFKRODUV·$E V·$E GDUUD]]TUHFHLYHGWKHLUPDWHULDOZKHQVWXG\LQJZLWKWKHWZRVFKRODUVDQGODWHU LQ WHJUDWHGLWLQWRKLVPXFKODUJHUFRPSLODWLRQRIWUDGLWLRQV ,QELRJUDSKLFDOOLWHUDWXUH0D·PDUDQG,EQ£XUDL¤DUHNQRZQOLNH0OLNDV =XKUªn =XKUªnV V VWXGHQ VWXGHQWV WV
,,

$PRQ $PRQJ JWK WKH HWK WKUH UHH HFR FRUS USRU RUD DPR PRVW VW RI WKH WKH=X =XKU KUª ªWH WH[W [WV V DUH DUHWR WR EH IRXQ IRXQG G LQ 0D·P 0D·PDU DU E 5vLGnVFRUSXVZKLFKFDQEHUHFRQVWUXFWHGRQWKHEDVLVRIWKH DVQ¬G LHWKHWUDQV LHWKHWUDQV PLVVLRQ PLVVLRQ FKDLQV FKDLQV LQ ·$EGDUUD ·$EGDUUD]]T ]]TnV nV 0X®DQQDI  :KHQ ZH FODV FODVVL VLI\ I\ WKH WKH SHUV SHUVRQ RQV V IURP IURP  0X®DQQDI  :KHQ ZKRP0D·PDUVD\VKHGHULYHGOHJDORSLQLRQVRUWUDGLWLRQVDFFRUGLQJWRWKHLUIUH TXHQF\DUHPDUNDEOHSLFWXUHHPHUJHV0RVWRIWHQKHPHQWLRQVWKH0HGLQDQVFKRODU =XKUª IROORZHGE\WKH%D¬UDQ4DWGD+HUHSRUWVPXFKOHVVIURPWKH %D¬UDQ$\\³E>E$Eª7DPªPD@HYHQOHVVIURPWKHDO%D¬Uª@WKH0HGLQDQ+LvP E·8UZDDQGWKH.³IDQV§DPPG>E$Eª6XODLPQ@DQGDO$·PDv +HUHSRUWVIURPPRUHWKDQRWKHUSH +HUHSRUWVIURPPRUHWKDQRWKHUSHRSOHRQO\VSRUDGLFDOO\OHVVWKDQ RSOHRQO\VSRUDGLFDOO\OHVVWKDQ%HVLGHV %HVLGHV WKHVHDUHODWLYHO\KLJKSHUFHQWDJHRIDQRQ\PRXVWUDGLWLRQVLVWREHIRXQGLH WUDGLWLRQVLQZKLFK0D·PDUGRHVQRWPHQWLRQKLVGLUHFWLQIRUPDQW 7KHVHSHUFHQWDJHVGRQRWPDWFKWKHDVVXPSWLRQWKDW0D·PDUJHQHUDOO\IDEUL FDWHGKLVWUDQVPLVVLRQGDWDWRDVFULEHKLVRZQOHJDORSLQLRQVWRHDUOLHUDXWKRULWLHVRU DVQ¬G $IRUJHUPRYHGE\VXFK WRSURYLGHWUDGLWLRQVFLUFXODWLQJDQRQ\PRXVO\ZLWKDVQ¬G  WRSURYLGHWUDGLWLRQVFLUFXODWLQJDQRQ\PRXVO\ZLWK $IRUJHUPRYHGE\VXFK JRDOV JRDOVZRX ZRXOG OGKD KDYH YHSUR SURFH FHHGH HGHG G RWKHUZ RWKHUZLVH LVH HLWKH HLWKHU U PRUH PRUH XQV\V XQV\VWHP WHPDWL DWLFD FDOO\ OO\ RU PRUH PRUH V\V WHPDWLFDOO\E\DVFULELQJDOORIKLVWH[WVWRRQO\DIHZLPSRUWDQWLQIRUPDQWVLQVWHDG RIWRDODUJHQXPEHURISDUWO\XQNQRZQSHRSOH$QRQ\PRXVWUDGLWLRQVJDSVLQ UDº\GRQRWPDWFKDWDOO WKH DVQ¬G DQGPRUHRYHUWH[WVUHIOHFWLQJ0D·PDUnVRZQ DQGPRUHRYHUWH[WVUHIOHFWLQJ0D·PDUnVRZQ UDº\GRQRWPDWFKDWDOO ZLWKWKHSLFWXUHRIDSUHVXPHGIRUJHU,I0D·PDUUHDOO\KDGEHHQDIRUJHURIWUDQV PLVVLRQGDWDRQHFRXOGDOVRDVNZKDWLQGXFHGKLPWRFKRRVHD0HGLQDQVFKRODUDV RQHRIKLVPDLQDXWKRULWLHVDOWKRXJKKHJHQHUDOO\SUHIHUUHGVFKRODUVIURP%DVUD$I WHUDOOKHRULJLQDWHGIURP%D¬UDDQGODWHUPRYHGWR
SODXVLEO\ EH H[SODLQHG E\ KLVWRULFDO FLUFXPVWDQFHV ,Q KLV KRPHWRZQ %D¬UD KH PDLQO\VWXGLHGZLWK4DWGDEXWRFFDVLRQDOO\DOVRZLWKRWKHUVFKRODUVDQGKHFRQ WLQXHGKLVVWXGLHVLQ0HGLQDPDLQO\ZLWK=XKUªDQGVSRUDGLFDOO\ZLWKRWKHU0HGL QDQVFKRODUV+HPD\KDYHREWDLQHGKLVPDWHULDOVGHULYLQJIURPRWKHUFHQWUHVRIMX ULVSUXGHQFHGXULQJKLVWULSVRUKLVVWD\LQWKH§L¤]KHDULQJSLOJULPVFKRODUV7KH GRXEWVDERXWWKHIRUJLQJK\SRWKHVLV GHHSHQ ZKHQFRPSDULQJ WKH WH[WFRUSRUDRI  0D·PDUnVWZRPDLQLQIRUPDQWV=XKUªDQG4DWGD 7ZRWKLUGVRI0D·PDUnV=XKUªWH[WVUHSURGXFHKLVSHUVRQDORSLQLRQUDº\DQG RQO\RQHWKLUGWUDGLWLRQV³UDªG¬³ LQZKLFK=XKUªRQO\SRVLWVDVWUDQVPLWWHU,Q WKHVHWUDQVPLVVLRQVIRXU WEL¹µQIURP0HGLQDSUHYDLO6D·ªGEDO0XVD\\DE 6OLPE·$EGDOOKE·8PDUDQG·8UZDED]=XEDLUHDFKDQG·8EDLGDOOKE ·$EGDOOKE·8WED2WKHUNQRZQWEL¹µQIURP0HGLQDOLNH6XODLPQE
IURPRWKHUV'LIIHUHQWO\ IURP=XKUª WKH\DUH GRPLQDWHG E\RQO\WZR WEL¹µQDO §DVDQ DO%D¬Uª  DQG DW VRPH GLVWDQFH WKH 0HGLQDQ VFKRODU 6D·ªG E DO 0XVD\\DE2WKHUWEL¹µQOLNHWKH.³IDQV,EUKªPDQ1D¦D·ªDQGjXUDL¨RU WKH%D¬UDQ$E³vjD·±¸>£ELUE=DLG@DSSHDUUDWKHUUDUHO\&RQWUDU\WRWKHFRPSD UDEOH=XKUªWUDGLWLRQVWKHWH[WVZKLFK4DWGDWUDQVPLWVIURPWEL¹µQXVXDOO\UHSUR GXFHWKHLU UDº\RIWKHWH[WVDWWULEXWHGWR§DVDQDO%D¬UªFRQVLVWRIKLVOHJDO RSLQLRQV DQG WKRVH UHIHUULQJ WR ,EQ DO0XVD\\DE FRQWDLQ QR WUDQVPLVVLRQV IURP RWKHUDXWKRULWLHVDWDOOLQWKHVDPSOHDQDO\VHGKHUH,Q=XKUªnV,EQDO0XVD\\DEPD WHULDORQWKHFRQWUDU\WKHUHLVDVPHQWLRQHGDERYH DEDODQFHEHWZHHQ UDº\DQG WUDGLWLRQV 1RWDEO\XQGHUGHYHORSHGLQFRPSDULVRQWRWKH=XKUªWH[WVLVWKHXVHRIWKH LV QG LQ4DWGDnVWUDGLWLRQV,QRI=XKUªnVWUDGLWLRQVRQHFRPHVDFURVVDQLVQG  RULQIRUPDWLRQDERXWDQ LQIRUPDQWLQ4DWGDnVWUDGLWLRQVVXFKWH[WVDPRXQWWR RQO\0D·PDUnV4DWGDWH[WVDOVRGLIIHUIURP=XKUªnVLQWKHGLVWULEXWLRQRIWKH DXWKRULWLHVPHQWLRQHGWKHROGHUWEL¹µQGRPLQDWHDWWKHH[SHQVHRIWKH ®DªED$OVR FRQWUDU\WR=XKUªnV ®DªEDWUDGLWLRQVZHILQGWKDWLQ4DWGDnVWH[WV·$OªDQG,EQ 0DV·³GSUHYDLORYHUm8PDULQIUHTXHQF\RITXRWDWLRQV,EQ·$EEVIROORZVDWDFRQ VLGHUDEOH GLVWDQFH ZKHUHDV RWKHU &RPSDQLRQV DUH RQO\ VSRUDGLFDOO\ PHQWLRQHG 7UDGLWLRQVIURPWKH3URSKHWDUHTXLWHUDUHLQ0D·PDUnVWUDQVPLVVLRQIURP4DWGD ZKLOH0D·PDUWUDQVPLWVWKHPIURP=XKUªILYHWLPHVPRUHIUHTXHQWO\)LQDOO\DGLI IHUHQFH LQWKHWHUPLQRORJ\RIWUDQVPLVVLRQPXVWEHSRLQWHGRXW0D·PDURIWHQ UH SURGXFHV=XKUªnVUDº\LQWKHIRUPRIDQDQVZHUUHVSRQVXPWRKLVRZQTXHVWLRQIRU H[DPSOHZLWKWKHIRUPXODo,DVNHG=XKUªDERXWe+HVDLGep 7KLVWH[WJHQUHRF FXUVRQO\YHU\UDUHO\LQ0D·PDUnV4DWGDPDWHULDO 7KH FKDUDFWHULVWLF GLIIHUHQFHV GHVFULEHG DERYH EHWZHHQ WKH WH[W FRUSRUD RI  0D·PDUnVWZRPRVWLPSRUWDQWDXWKRULWLHVIRUOHJDORSLQLRQVDQGWUDGLWLRQVUHQGHU YHU\XQOLNHO\WKHDVVXPSWLRQZKLFKFRXOGEHPDGHRQWKHEDVLVRI6FKDFKWnVWKHR

ULHVWKDW0D·PDUIDNHGWKHRULJLQRIWKHWH[WVLQRUGHUWROHJLWLPDWHKLVRZQWHDFK LQJVWKURXJKD0HGLQDQDQGD%D¬UDQDXWKRULW\ 7KHUHDUHRWKHULQGLFDWLRQVWRVXSSRUWWKLVWKHVLV0D·PDURIWHQ UHIHUVWRWKH IDFWWKDW=XKUªnVDQG4DWGDnVRSLQLRQVDJUHHRQDOHJDOSUREOHP +HXVXDOO\LQ WURGXFHVVXFKDWH[WZLWKWKHZRUGVo¹DQD]=XKU¬ZD4DWGDTOpIURP=XKUªDQG 4DWGDERWKVDLG RUKHVRPHWLPHVSXWVDQRWHDWWKHHQGRID=XKUªWH[WVXFKDV oZDTODKX4DWGDpVRVDLG4DWGD>DVZHOO@ RUo¹DQ4DWGDPL³ODKXp>,WUDQVPLW@ WKHVDPHIURP4DWGD 7KLVPHDQVLQIDFWWKDWLQWKRVHFDVHVZKHUHKHRQO\TXRWHV WKH0HGLQDQVFKRODURQDOHJDOLVVXH0D·PDUHLWKHUGLGQRWNQRZDUHOHYDQW VWDWH PHQWRI4DWGDnVRULWDSSHDUHGWRKLPQRWZRUWKPHQWLRQLQJRUPD\EHLWZDVVR GLIIHUHQWWKDWLWQHHGHGDVHSDUDWHWH[WRUWKH4DWGDWH[WZDVOHIWRXWE\·$EGDUUD] ]T7KHVDPHLVWUXHLQFDVHVZKHUH0D·PDURQO\SUHVHQWV4DWGDnVRSLQLRQZLWK RXWPHQWLRQLQJ=XKUªnV ,IRQHZLVKHVWRVHHLQ0D·PDUnVPHWKRGRITXRWDWLRQFLUFXPVWDQWLDOHYLGHQFH RIIRUJHU\DQGLIRQHZLVKHVWRFODLPWKDW0D·PDUWULHGLQWKLVZD\WRFUHDWHDGGL WLRQDODXWKRULWLHVIRUKLVRZQOHJDORSLQLRQVWKHTXHVWLRQUHPDLQVDVWRZK\KHKDG QRWGRQHLWPRUHRIWHQ)XUWKHUHYLGHQFHDJDLQVWWKHDVVXPSWLRQRIIRUJHU\LVWKH IDFW WKDW LQVRPHFDVHV0D·PDUH[SOLFLWO\UHIHUV WRDGLIIHUHQFHRIRSLQLRQEHWZHHQ =XKUªDQG4DWGDZLWKRXWFODULI\LQJZKLFKRIWKH WZRKHSUHIHUV +HUH DUHWZRH[ DPSOHV ·$EGDUUD]]T IURP0D·PDU IURP=XKUª KHVDLGo:KHQD PDQ EX\VD GLYRUFHIURPKLV ZLIHLWLV¨XO¹ UDQVRPGLYRUFHp4DWGDVDLGo,WLVQRW¨XO¹  p ·$EGDUUD]]TIURP0D·PDUIURP=XKUªDQG4DWGDERWKVDLGo+HUULJKWWRGLYRUFH DP UXKLVLQKHUKDQGXQWLOVKHGHFLGHV>RQWKHRIIHURIGLYRUFH@p 4DWGDVDLG>PRUHRYHU@ oe(YHQLIKHUKXVEDQGKDVVH[ZLWKKHU>D®EDK@EHIRUHVKHGHFLGHVp

,QWKHILUVWFDVHZHKDYHFRQWUDGLFWRU\RSLQLRQVLQWKHVHFRQGFDVHZHMXVWVHH DQH[WHQVLRQRUFRQFUHWLVDWLRQRIWKHRSLQLRQDVFULEHGWRERWK=XKUªDQG4DWGD ,QERWKFDVHVLWLVQRWFOHDUZKLFKRSLQLRQ0D·PDUKLPVHOIIDYRXUV :K\VKRXOG 0D·PDUKDYHIDOVHO\DVFULEHGVXFKFDVHVRIGLYHUJLQJRSLQLRQVWRKLVPDLQDXWKRUL WLHV RIZKRPKHPRUH RIWHQUHSRUWV DJUHHPHQW",WLVHYHQ PRUH GLIILFXOW WRGHIHQG WKHIRUJHU\WKHVLV LQYLHZRIWH[WVLQZKLFK0D·PDURSSRVHV WKH UDº\RIKLVDXWKRU LW\$QH[DPSOH ·$EGDUUD]]TIURP0D·PDUIURP4DWGDDERXWDPDQZKRJDYHKLVZLIHWKHULJKWWRGL YRUFHDPU LQKHURZQKDQGV+H>4DWGD@VDLGo,IRQHRIWKHPGLHVEHIRUHVKHKDVPDGHD GHFLVLRQQHLWKHURIWKHPLQKHULWVIURPWKHRWKHU:KHQKHSXWVWKHSRZHUWRGLYRUFHKHU LQDQRWKHUPDQnVKDQGVDQGWKLVPDQWRZKRPWKHSRZHURIGLYRUFHKDVEHHQJLYHQGLHV EHIRUHGHFLGLQJDQ\WKLQJKHFDQQRWPDUU\KHUDJDLQXQWLOVKHKDVILUVWPDUULHGDQRWKHU PDQ,IRQHRIWKHPGLHVEHIRUHKH>LHWKHRQHHQWUXVWHGZLWKWKHSRZHURIGLYRUFH@KDV PDGHDGHFLVLRQWKH\FDQQRWLQKHULWIURPDQRWKHU 0D·PDUVDLGo,KHDUGVRPHERG\VD\m:KHQWKHPDQLQWRZKRVHKDQGVWKHSRZHUWRGL YRUFHKHUKDVEHHQSXWGLHVEHIRUHPDNLQJDGHFLVLRQWKDWLVQRWKLQJ>LHWKLVVKRXOGQRW EHFRQVLGHUHGDGLYRUFH@n,SUHIHUWKLV>RSLQLRQ@WRWKDWRI4DWGDnVp

7KH FLUFXPVWDQWLDO HYLGHQFH SUHVHQWHG DERYH JRHV DJDLQVW WKH LGHD WKDW 0D·PDUIRUJHGRULQYHQWHGKLVLQIRUPDWLRQRQWKHRULJLQRIKLVWH[WV$VDFRQVH TXHQFHXQWLOWKHFRQWUDU\LVSURYHQZHPXVWFRQVLGHUKLV=XKUªDQG4DWGDWH[WVDV DXWKHQWLFLHUHDOO\UHFHLYHGIURPWKHSHUVRQVQDPHG7KHDWWHPSWWRDYRLGWKLV FRQVHTXHQFHE\DVVXPLQJWKDWDSDUWRI0D·PDUnVPDWHULDOHJWKHWUDGLWLRQVIURP HDUOLHUDXWKRULWLHVLVWKHZRUNRIDQRQ\PRXVIRUJHUVDV6FKDFKWDUJXHG rLVQRW FRQYLQFLQJ7KHVHIRUJHUVZRXOGKDYH EHHQ 0D·PDUnVFRQWHPSRUDULHVLHDFWLYHLQ WKHVHFRQGTXDUWHURIWKHVHFRQGFHQWXU\$+DQGWKH\PXVWKDYHSURGXFHG=XKUª DQG 4DWGD WUDGLWLRQVLQKXJHQXPEHUV 7KHVHoZRUNVKRSVRIIRUJHUVp FRXOG QRW KDYHUHPDLQHGXQGHWHFWHGE\DORQJVHUYLQJVWXGHQWRI=XKUªDQG4DWGD7KHUHLV KRZHYHUQRKLQWRIVXFKoZRUNVKRSVpHLWKHULQ0D·PDUnVRULQKLVSXSLO·$EGDUUD] ]TnVWH[WV0RUHRYHUWKHDVQ¬G LQ0D·PDUnV=XKUªDQG4DWGDWUDGLWLRQVDUHWRR

IUDJPHQWDU\:HZRXOGH[SHFWPRUHVRSKLVWLFDWHG DVQ¬G IURPSURIHVVLRQDOIRUJHUV RIWKLVWLPH 7KH H[LVWHQFH RI 0D·PDUnV =XKUª DQG 4DWGD WH[WV VKRXOG EH LQWHUSUHWHG WKHUHIRUH DV IROORZV 0D·PDU ZDV IRU D ORQJHU SHULRG RI WLPH D VWXGHQW RI ERWK WHDFKHUV7KHODUJHQXPEHURIWH[WVDQGWKHIDFWWKDWKHRFFDVLRQDOO\SRLQWVWRWLQ\ GLIIHUHQFHVLQKLVWHDFKHUVnRSLQLRQVFHUWDLQO\SUHVXSSRVHZULWWHQQRWHVPDGHGXULQJ RUDIWHUWKHOHFWXUHVDVPHPRU\DLGV7KHGLIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQERWK ERGLHVRIWUDQV PLVVLRQUHIOHFW GLIIHUHQW FLUFXPVWDQFHVLQZKLFKWKHWH[WVZHUH UHFHLYHG)RUH[DP SOHWKHIDFWWKDW0D·PDU UDUHO\ WUDQVPLWV 4DWGDnVDQVZHUVWRKLV RZQ TXHVWLRQV ZKHUHDVKHIUHTXHQWO\GRHVVRLQWKHFDVHRI=XKUªPD\EHDUHVXOWRIWKHIDFWWKDW 0D·PDUZDVVWLOOYHU\\RXQJZKHQVWXG\LQJZLWK4DWGDDQGZDVWKHUHIRUHQRWDO ORZHGWRDVNTXHVWLRQV7KHVLWXDWLRQ FKDQJHG ZKHQKH ODWHUEHFDPHDVWXGHQWRI  =XKUªDQGZDVQRORQJHUFRXQWHGDVDEHJLQQHU$QRWKHUH[SODQDWLRQIRUWKHGLIIHU HQFHV PD\OLH LQWKHWZR OHJDOVFKRODUVnGLIIHUHQWVWDJHV RIGHYHORSPHQWDQGLQUH JLRQDOSHFXOLDULWLHVLQOHJDOWHDFKLQJLQERWKFHQWUHVRIOHDUQLQJ7KLVFRXOGH[SODLQ IRUH[DPSOHWKHPRUHIUHTXHQWXVHRIWKHLVQG LQ=XKUªnVWUDGLWLRQVRUWKHUDUHURF FXUUHQFHRI DªG¬³IURPWKH3URSKHWLQ4DWGDnVWH[WV,QWHUSUHWHGLQWKLVZD\WKH WH[WVWUDQVPLWWHGE\0D·PDUHQDEOHXVWRJHWGHWDLOHGLQVLJKWVLQWRWKHVWDWHRIGH YHORSPHQWWKDWOHJDOWKLQNLQJDQGWHDFKLQJKDGUHDFKHGLQWKHILUVWTXDUWHUVHFRQG FHQWXU\$+ )RU WKLV UHDVRQ 0D·PDUnV =XKUª WUDQVPLVVLRQ FDQ EH UHJDUGHG DV D XVHIXO VRXUFHIRUWKH OHJDOGRFWULQHVDQGWUDGLWLRQVRIWKLV IDPRXV0HGLQDQ VFKRODU7KLV FRQFOXVLRQGRHVQRWH[FOXGHWKHSRVVLELOLW\RI0D·PDUnVKDYLQJRFFDVLRQDOO\ PDGH PLVWDNHVZKHQSUHVHUYLQJRUWUDQVPLWWLQJWKHPDWHULDOUHFHLYHGIURP=XKUª 7KHFRQFOXVLRQVGUDZQXSWRQRZDUHEDVHGVROHO\RQ0D·PDUnV WH[WVDVFRQ WDLQHGLQ·$EGDUUD]]TnV 0X®DQQDI ,GLGQRWUHIHUWRELRJUDSKLFDOWUDGLWLRQVDERXW 0D·PDUDVWKLVW\SHRILQIRUPDWLRQDERXW,VODPLFVFKRODUVOLYLQJGXULQJWKHILUVW

WZRFHQWXULHV$+LVUHJDUGHGDVJHQHUDOO\XQUHOLDEOHE\PDQ\QRQ0XVOLPVFKRODUV +RZHYHUWKHSUHVHUYHGELRJUDSKLFDOWUDGLWLRQVDERXW0D·PDUFRQILUPWKHUHVXOWV REWDLQHGWKURXJKRXUWH[WDQDO\VLVWRDODUJHH[WHQW/HWXVKDYHDORRNDWWKHELR JUDSKLFDOPDWHULDO 0D·PDUE5vLGDPDXORIWKHWULEHDO$]GJUHZXSLQ%D¬UDZKHUHKHEH JDQKLVVWXGLHVDVKHKLPVHOIVDLGLQWKH\HDUZKHQDO§DVDQDO%D¬UªGLHGLHLQ ZKHQKHZDV\HDUVROG,WLVSRVVLEOHWKDWKHVWLOOKHDUGKLPEXWWKDWLV QRW FRQILUPHG LQ WKH ELRJUDSKLFDO VRXUFHV $JDLQ DFFRUGLQJ WR KLPVHOI KH WKHQ VWXGLHGZLWK4DWGD +HOHIW%D¬UDZKHUHKHKDGIRUPHGDFORVHIULHQGVKLSZLWK $\\³EE$Eª7DPªPDHLWKHUVKRUWO\EHIRUHRUDIWHU4DWGDnVGHDWKDQG EHFDPHDVWXGHQWRI=XKUª+HLVLQGHHGFRQVLGHUHGDORQJZLWK0OLNE$QDVDV RQHRI=XKUªnVPRVWLPSRUWDQWVWXGHQWV+HRFFDVLRQDOO\UHWXUQHGWR%D¬UDIRUYLVLWV DQGWRRNWKHRSSRUWXQLW\WRVWXG\ZLWKVRPHRIWKHVFKRODUVWKHUH$WDQXQNQRZQ GDWHKHPRYHGWR«DQ·¸WKHFHQWUHRIOHDUQLQJLQ
ZHUHQRWJHQHUDOO\IROORZHGE\WKHWUDGLWLRQLVWVRIWKHILUVWKDOIRIWKHVHFRQGFHQ WXU\$+WRVD\QRWKLQJRIWKHHDUO\ IXTDKº ZKRPDLQO\WDXJKWWKHLURZQ UDº\ 1HYHUWKHOHVV LWLVZRUWKSRLQWLQJ RXW WKDW 0D·PDUnV WUDQVPLVVLRQ IURP =XKUª LV FRQVLGHUHGYHU\UHOLDEOHE\WKH ªDG¬³ FULWLFV

$QRWKHULPSRUWDQW HDUO\VRXUFHIRU=XKUªnV ILTKLVWKHWUDQVPLVVLRQRIWKH0HFFDQ VFKRODU,EQ£XUDL¤G/LNHWKHRQHE\0D·PDULWLVFRQWDLQHGLQ·$EGDU UD]]TnV 0X®DQQDI DQG LWFDQEHUHFRQVWUXFWHG RQ WKH EDVLV RI WKHFKDLQVRIWUDQV PLVVLRQ6LQFH ,KDYHDOUHDG\GLVFXVVHGWKHYDOXHRI,EQ£XUDL¤nVWUDQVPLVVLRQHOVH ZKHUH , VKDOO OLPLW P\VHOI WR WKH HVVHQWLDO SRLQWV ZKLFK DUH LPSRUWDQW IRU WKH FRPSDULVRQZLWKRWKHUHDUO\VRXUFHVDQGIRUWKH=XKUªWH[WV7KH,EQ£XUDL¤WUDQV PLVVLRQ LQ ·$EGDUUD]]TnV 0X®DQQDI  LV TXD H[WHQVLRQ RQO\ VOLJKWO\ LQIHULRU WR 0D·PDUnVDQGFRQWDLQVPRUHWKDQLQGLYLGXDOWH[WV $VZHKDYHDOUHDG\VHHQ 0D·PDUnV FRUSXV LV GRPLQDWHG E\ WZR DXWKRULWLHV LQFOXGLQJ =XKUª ZKHUHDV ,EQ £XUDL¤nVPDWHULDOSUHVHQWVRQO\ RQH PDLQ DXWKRULW\WKH 0HFFDQ  IDT¬K·$®¸E$Eª 5DE¨1HDUO\RI,EQ £XUDL¤nV WH[WVDUHDVFULEHGWRKLP7KHUHVWDUHDVFULEHG WRDODUJHQXPEHURILQIRUPDQWVPRUHWKDQSHUVRQVDPRQJZKRPILYHQDPHV DUH PHQWLRQHGPRUHIUHTXHQWO\WKDQRWKHUVWKH0HFFDQ·$PUE 'ªQUWKH 0HGLQDQ,EQjLKEWKHDO£D]DUª@ $VLQWKHFDVHRI·$EGDUUD]]TnV0D·PDUWUDQVPLVVLRQ,FRQVLGHUWKHVWURQJO\ YDU\LQJDWWULEXWLRQRIWH[WVWRLQIRUPDQWVZKLFKLVIRXQGLQ,EQ£XUDL¤nVFRUSXV DORQJZLWKWKHIDFWWKDWLWDOVRFRQWDLQVOHJDORSLQLRQVRIKLVRZQDQGDFRQVSLFXRXV QXPEHURIDQRQ\PRXVWUDGLWLRQVDVHYLGHQFHDJDLQVWWKHIRUJHU\WKHRU\%\IRUJHU\ WKHRU\,PHDQWKHK\SRWKHVLVWKDW,EQ£XUDL¤IDOVHO\DVFULEHGKLVRZQOHJDORSLQLRQV DQGWKRVHRIRWKHUVFKRODUVDW0HFFDDQGHOVHZKHUHDVZHOODVWUDGLWLRQV ³U DQG DªG¬³  FLUFXODWLQJ GXULQJ KLV OLIHWLPH WR WKH SUHYLRXV JHQHUDWLRQ RI VFKRODUV ,W

VHHPV PRUH SODXVLEOH WR H[SODLQ WKH SHFXOLDU DWWULEXWLRQ RI WH[WV WR LQIRUPDQWV IRXQGLQ,EQ£XUDL¤nVPDWHULDOE\KLVWRULFDOFLUFXPVWDQFHVGXULQJKLVOLIHWLPH)RU H[DPSOHWKHIDFWWKDWKHKDVRQO\RQHPDLQDXWKRULW\·$®¸PD\EHGXHWRWKHIDFW WKDW·$®¸ZDVKLVPRVWLPSRUWDQWWHDFKHUZLWKZKRPKHVWXGLHGWKHORQJHVWDQG IURPZKRPKHOHDUQHGWKHPRVW 2WKHUDUJXPHQWVDJDLQVWWKHIRUJHU\WKHRU\FDQEHIRXQGLQDFRPSDULVRQRI  WKH WH[WV DVFULEHGE\,EQ £XUDL¤WRGLIIHUHQWSHUVRQV$FRPSDULVRQEHWZHHQ,EQ £XUDL¤nVWUDQVPLVVLRQVIURP·$®¸E$Eª5DE¨DQG=XKUªZKRPKHXVXDOO\FDOOV ,EQjLKEZLOOGRDVDQH[DPSOH /HWnVILUVWKDYHDORRNDWWKHSHFXOLDULWLHVRI,EQ£XUDL¤nVWUDQVPLVVLRQIURP ·$®¸ 7KH ·$®¸WH[WVUHSURGXFH IRU WKH PRVWSDUWKLV UDº\2QO\DILIWKRI  WKHP FRQWDLQ WUDGLWLRQV IURP RWKHUV LQZKLFK ·$®¸ LVRQO\ WKH WUDQVPLWWHU 7KH IRUPVLQZKLFK,EQ£XUDL¤SUHVHQWV·$®¸nVUDº\DUHVWULNLQJ%HVLGHWKHXVXDOVD\LQJV GLFWDZHILQGDQDOPRVWVLPLODUQXPEHURIUHVSRQVDLHDQVZHUVZKLFK·$®¸JDYHWR TXHVWLRQVDVNHGE\,EQ£XUDL¤KLPVHOIRUPRUHUDUHO\E\RWKHUSHRSOHNQRZQE\ QDPHRUQRW:KHQFODVVLI\LQJ·$®¸nV ³U DQGDªG¬³ DFFRUGLQJWRWKHDXWKRULWLHVWR ZKLFKWKH\UHIHUZHJHWWKHIROORZLQJUHVXOW+HTXRWHVWKH ®DªEDPRVWIUHTXHQWO\ WKH3URSKHWPXFKOHVVDQGKLVFRQWHPSRUDULHVRQO\VSRUDGLFDOO\)XUWKHUPRUHD ODUJHQXPEHURITXRWDWLRQVIURPWKH4XU¸QDUHQRWDEOH$PRQJWKH&RPSDQLRQV LWLV,EQ·$EEVZKRFOHDUO\GRPLQDWHV·$®¸UHIHUVWRKLPQHDUO\WKUHHWLPHVPRUH WKDQ WR ·8PDUEDO¥D®®EWKH VHFRQG PRVW IUHTXHQWO\ PHQWLRQHG &RPSDQLRQ ZKRKLPVHOILVTXRWHGWKUHHWLPHVPRUHWKDQ·$OªRU·¸LvD7KH&RPSDQLRQV£DELU E·$EGDOOK$E³+XUDLUD,EQ·8PDUDQGRWKHUVDSSHDURQO\UDUHO\7KH DªG¬³ RI  WKH3URSKHWDUHFOHDUO\RXWQXPEHUHGE\·$®¸nVUHIHUHQFHVWR,EQ·$EEVEXWWKH 3URSKHWIROORZVLQVHFRQGSODFHDKHDGRIDOORWKHU ®DªED·$®¸RQO\VSRUDGLFDOO\ JLYHVKLVLQIRUPDQWVIRUWKH&RPSDQLRQWUDGLWLRQVDQGDPRQJKLV DªG¬³ IURPWKH 3URSKHWRQO\DTXDUWHUKDYHDrSDUWO\LQFRPSOHWH LVQG 

,Q VKDUSFRQWUDVW WRKLV WUDQVPLVVLRQ IURP·$®¸ LQZKLFK WKH ODWWHUVn UDº\ GRPLQDWHV,EQ£XUDL¤nVWUDQVPLVVLRQIURP=XKUªFRQVLVWVPRVWO\RIWUDGLWLRQVLQ ZKLFK=XKUªIXQFWLRQVRQO\DVWUDQVPLWWHU7KHWH[WVZKLFKFRQWDLQ=XKUªnV UDº\ DUH IHZHU EXW QHYHUWKHOHVVQRWLFHDEOH LQQXPEHU  7KH UDº\DSSHDUVLQ PRVWFDVHVLQWKHIRUPRIVD\LQJVGLFWDDQGVHOGRPDVDQVZHUVUHVSRQVD,QVWULN LQJFRQWUDVWWR,EQ£XUDL¤nVUHVSRQVDWUDQVPLWWHGIURP·$®¸ZKHUH,EQ£XUDL¤RIWHQ DVNVWKHTXHVWLRQVKLPVHOIKLVUHVSRQVDWUDQVPLWWHGIURP=XKUªDUHRQO\H[FHSWLRQ DOO\RIWKDWW\SH $PRQJ,EQ£XUDL¤nVWUDGLWLRQVWUDQVPLWWHGIURP=XKUª·8UZDE D]=XEDLULVWKHPRVWLPSRUWDQWLQIRUPDQWRI=XKUª,QWKDWIXQFWLRQKHFOHDUO\ RXWGRHV RWKHU0HGLQDQ VFKRODUVVXFK DV $E³ 6DODPD E·$EGDUUD¨PQ6OLPE ·$EGDOOKE·8PDU·8EDLGDOOKE·$EGDOOKE·8WED6XODLPQE
WKHWH[WVDQGVXSSOLHGWKHPDUELWUDULO\ZLWKDVQ¬G 7KHUHLVRWKHUHYLGHQFHZKLFK, KDYHSUHVHQWHGHOVHZKHUH WKDWVXSSRUWVWKHK\SRWKHVLVWKDW,EQ£XUDL¤LQIDFWDF TXLUHGKLV·$®¸WH[WVIURP·$®¸KLPVHOIIRUH[DPSOH,EQ£XUDL¤nVSHUVRQDOOHJDO RSLQLRQVKLVFRPPHQWVRQ·$®¸nVWH[WVKLVFRQVFLRXVGHYLDWLRQVIURP·$®¸nVRSLQ LRQVRFFDVLRQDOLQGLUHFWWUDQVPLVVLRQIURP·$®¸DQGWKHUHSRUWLQJRIGLIIHUHQWVR OXWLRQVRI·$®¸nVWRWKHVDPH SUREOHP6LPLODUSHFXOLDULWLHV FDQDOVREHUHFRJQLVHG LQ,EQ£XUDL¤nVWUDQVPLVVLRQIURP,EQjLKEIRUH[DPSOHWKHLQGLUHFWWUDQVPLVVLRQ IURPKLP RUUHIHUHQFHVWRFRQWUDGLFWRU\VWDWHPHQWV )LQDOO\LWLVQRWHDV\WRXQ GHUVWDQGZK\WKH0HFFDQVFKRODU,EQ£XUDL¤ZKRPDLQO\UHIHUVWRDXWKRULWLHVIURP WKLV WRZQ VKRXOG KDYH IDEULFDWHG WH[WV UHSURGXFLQJ WKH UDº\ DQG WUDGLWLRQV RI D 0HGLQDQ IDT¬KDQGWUDQVPLWWHU $OOWKLVOHQGVVXSSRUWWRWKHK\SRWKHVLVWKDWWKHWH[WVZKLFK,EQ£XUDL¤UH SURGXFHV UHDOO\ FRPH IURP WKH SHUVRQV LQGLFDWHG LQ WKH LVQG  $OWHUQDWLYHO\ ZH ZRXOGKDYHWRLPDJLQHWKDW,EQ£XUDL¤UHFHLYHGKLVPDWHULDOIURPDQRQ\PRXVIRUJ HUVUDWKHUWKDQIURPRIWKHSHUVRQVKHQDPHV
£XUDL¤ZDVQRWRQHRI=XKUªnVUHJXODUVWXGHQWV+HPD\KDYHDFTXLUHGDSDUWRIKLV =XKUªWH[WVQRWE\KHDULQJEXWE\FRS\LQJDZULWWHQ VRXUFHZKLFK=XKUªRURQHRI  KLV SXSLOV SXW DW ,EQ £XUDL¤nV GLVSRVDO ,Q,EQ £XUDL¤nV =XKUª PDWHULDO WKH SUH GRPLQDQFHRIWUDGLWLRQVRYHUKLVUDº\WKHKLJKHUIUHTXHQF\RILQIRUPDQWVJLYHQIRU WUDGLWLRQVDQGWKHHPLQHQWUROHSOD\HGE\WKH3URSKHWDVDOHJDODXWKRULW\PD\EH W\SLFDORI=XKUªnVDQGRU0HGLQDQMXULVSUXGHQFHLQWKLVSHULRG6XFKDKLVWRULFDO H[SODQDWLRQGRHVQRWODFNSODXVLELOLW\rWRP\PLQGDQGRIIHUVWKHDGYDQWDJHWKDW LWLVIDOVLILDEOH )RU WKLVUHDVRQ ZHVKRXOG PDLQWDLQXQWLO WKHFRQWUDU\LVSURYHQ WKDWWKHWH[WVZKLFK,EQ£XUDL¤DVFULEHVWR,EQjLKE>D]=XKUª@GRUHDOO\GHULYH IURPWKHODWWHU 7KLVFRQFOXVLRQDQGRXUDVVXPSWLRQVDVWRKRZ,EQ£XUDL¤FRXOGKDYHFRPH E\KLVWH[WVDUHEDVHGVRIDUH[FOXVLYHO\RQ·$EGDUUD]]TnVWH[WVDVSUHVHUYHGLQKLV  0X®DQQDI ,KDYHOHIWDVLGHELRJUDSKLFDOLQIRUPDWLRQDERXW ,EQ£XUDL¤IRUWKHUHD VRQVDOUHDG\PHQWLRQHGDERYH7KLVZLOOEHUHPHGLHGQRZ ·$EGDOPDOLNE·$EGDO·D]ª]E£XUDL¤DPDXORIWKH8PD\\DGFODQO¥OLG E $VªG ZDV ERUQ LQ WKH \HDU  SUREDEO\ LQ 0HFFD ZKHUH KH JUHZ XS +H VWDUWHGVWXG\LQJZKHQKHZDVXQGHUWKHSDWURQDJHRI·$®¸E$Eª5DE¨WKHOHDG LQJ0HFFDQVFKRODURIWKDWWLPH+HIUHTXHQWHGKLVVWXG\FLUFOHIRUDERXW\HDUV EXWKHVHSDUDWHGIURPKLVWHDFKHURQHRUWZR\HDUVEHIRUHKLVGHDWKLQWR MRLQ WKH \RXQJHUVFKRODU·$PUE'ªQUZKRVHOHVVRQVKHDWWHQGHGIRUDERXWVHYHQ \HDUV7KLVLQIRUPDWLRQFRUUHVSRQGVWRWKHSLFWXUHZHIRXQGZKHQLQYHVWLJDWLQJWKH IUHTXHQF\RIWUDQVPLWWHUVLQ,EQ£XUDL¤nVFRUSXV·$®¸LVE\IDUWKHPRVWIUHTXHQWO\ TXRWHGIROORZHGE\·$PUE'ªQU ,QWKLVSHULRG,EQ£XUDL¤SUREDEO\DOVRVWXG LHGZLWKRWKHUVFKRODUVIRUH[DPSOHWKH0HFFDQ,EQ$Eª0XODLNDGRU DQGWKH0HGLQDQVFKRODU1IL·G RU WKH PDXORI,EQ ·8PDUZKRVWD\HGDW0HFFDIURPWLPHWRWLPH$OOWKLVLQIRUPDWLRQWUDQVPLWWHG E\ ,EQ£XUDL¤nVVWXGHQWVLVXVXDOO\EDVHGRQKLVRZQVWDWHPHQWV+HGLHGLQ

,EQ£XUDL¤LVRQHRIWKHILUVWDXWKRUVLIQRWWKHILUVWRIERRNVRIWUDGLWLRQV FRPSLOHGLQWKHPX®DQQDI VW\OHLHRUGHUHGDFFRUGLQJWROHJDOWRSLFV+LVERRNZDV SUREDEO\HQWLWOHGo.LWEDV6XQDQp 0RVWRILWPXVWKDYHEHHQFRPSULVHGRIZKDW KLV SXSLO·$EGDUUD]]T WUDQVPLWWHG IURPKLP LQKLV 0X®DQQDI +LVZRUNKDGDO UHDG\EHFRPH IDPRXV EH\RQG 0HFFD GXULQJKLVOLIHWLPH DQG LWSUREDEO\JDYHDQ LPSXOVHWRRWKHUVFKRODUVVXFKDV0D·PDUE5vLG6XI\QD±¯DXUªDQG0OLNE $QDVWRFRPSRVHVLPLODUZRUNV ,QELRJUDSKLFDOOLWHUDWXUH,EQ£XUDL¤LVFRQVLGHUHGDQH[FHOOHQW IDT¬K4XU¸Q UHFLWHUDQGH[HJHWH+LVGLVFLSOHVFRPSRVHGDo.LWEDW7DIV¬U pIURPKLV4XU¸QOHV VRQV 
£XUDL¤nVTXHVWLRQVRUUHIHUHQFHVWRKDYLQJKHDUG=XKUª VDP¹ %XWWKHUHDUHDIHZ DVWKHIROORZLQJH[DPSOHVKRZV ·$EGDUUD]]TIURP,EQ£XUDL¤KHVDLG,EQjLKEWUDQVPLWWHGWRPH>ZKHQ@ ,DVNHGKLP DERXWDPDQZKRGLYRUFHGKLVZLIHWKUHHWLPHVZKLOHKHZDVVXIIHULQJSDLQV I¬ZD¦D¹ >LH GXULQJDQLOOQHVV@·+RZLVLW"0XVWVKHREVHUYHKHUZDLWLQJSHULRGZKHQKHGLHVDQGGRHV VKHLQKHULWIURPKLP"n+H,EQjLKEVDLG·8±PQGHFLGHGDERXWDZLIHRI·$EGDUUD¨PQ >E·$XI@WKDWVKHKDGWRREVHUYHKHUZDLWLQJSHULRGDQGWKDWVKHLQKHULWVIURPKLP+HOHW KHULQKHULWIURPKLPDIWHUVKHKDGFRQFOXGHGKHUZDLWLQJSHULRG·$EGDUUD¨PQKDGVXI IHUHGSDLQVIRUDORQJWLPH

7H[WVVXFKDVWKLVRQHVKRZWKDWRQHFDQQRWJHQHUDOLVHDERXWWKHELRJUDSKLFDO UHSRUWVDERXWKRZ,EQ£XUDL¤UHFHLYHG=XKUªnVDªG¬³ ,QGHHGLWLVDOVRPHQWLRQHG LQELRJUDSKLFDOOLWHUDWXUHWKDW,EQ£XUDL¤KDGSHUVRQDOFRQWDFWVZLWK=XKUª+HZDV QRWRQHRIKLVUHJXODUVWXGHQWVKRZHYHU7KLVODWWHUIDFWGRHVQRWH[FOXGHWKHSRVVL ELOLW\WKDWKHoKHDUGpIURPKLPRFFDVLRQDOO\RUDVNHGKLPTXHVWLRQVPD\EHGXULQJ RQHRI=XKUªnVVWD\VLQ0HFFDIRUWKHªD¦¦ 7KLVH[SODLQVWKHRFFDVLRQDOUHVSRQVD WR ,EQ£XUDL¤nVDQVZHUV,WZRXOGEHXQZDUUDQWHGWRUHJDUG,EQ£XUDL¤DVXQUHOLDEOHRU DVDIRUJHURQO\EHFDXVHRIDDIHZFDVHVRIFRQWUDGLFWLRQEHWZHHQWKHLQIRUPDWLRQ KHLVJLYLQJDERXWKLVPRGHRIWUDQVPLVVLRQDQGWKHELRJUDSKLFDOLQIRUPDWLRQSUH VHUYHGDERXWKLP$KLVWRULDQQHHGQRWQHFHVVDULO\VKDUHWKH ªDG¬³ FULWLFVnUHVHUYD WLRQVUHJDUGLQJ,EQ£XUDL¤nV=XKUªWUDQVPLVVLRQ(YHQLI,EQ£XUDL¤UHFHLYHGPRVW RI=XKUªnVoDªG¬³p rWKDWWHUPGRHVQRWQHFHVVDULO\LQFOXGHKLVUDº\LQZULWWHQ IRUPWKDWLVZLWKRXW KHDULQJWKHP IURP KLP RUUHDGLQJWKHP RXWWRKLPLWGRHV QRWPHDQ WKDWWKH\VKRXOGEHFRQVLGHUHGDVIDOVHRUXQUHOLDEOHIRUWKDWUHDVRQ EXW RQO\WKDW WKHVH VRXUFHVGRQRW PHHWWKHKLJKVWDQGDUGV RIWKHODWHU 0XVOLP ªDG¬³  FULWLFLVP,IWKHKLVWRULDQZHUHRQO\SHUPLWWHGWRXVHVRXUFHVZKLFKPHWWKHVHFULWH ULDPRVWRIWKHVRXUFHVRQZKLFKKLVWRULDQVRI,VODPUHO\ZRXOGEHXQXVDEOH 2XULQYHVWLJDWLRQRIWKHHYLGHQFHFRQFHUQLQJ,EQ£XUDL¤ZKLFKFDQEHIRXQG LQELRJUDSKLFDOOLWHUDWXUHOHDGVRQWKHZKROHWRDSLFWXUHYHU\VLPLODUWRWKHRQH

WKDWZHFRXOGRXWOLQHRQWKHEDVLVRIKLVWH[WV7KLVFRXOGOHDGWRWKHVXSSRVLWLRQ WKDW WKH ELRJUDSKLFDOWUDGLWLRQVFRXOGKDYHEHHQH[WUDSRODWHGIURPWKHWH[WV+RZ HYHU WKHUHLVKDUGO\DQ\HYLGHQFHIRUVXFK DFODLP2QO\WKHODWHUYROXPLQRXVOLVWV RIWHDFKHUVDQGSXSLOVDVZHILQGWKHPIRUH[DPSOHLQ,EQ§D¤DUnV7DK¢¬ESURED EO\DURVHDWOHDVWSDUWLDOO\LQWKDWZD\ 7KXVRQWKHEDVLVQRWRQO\RI,EQ£XUDL¤nV WH[WVEXWDOVRRIWKHELRJUDSKLFDOLQIRUPDWLRQRQKLPZKLFKJRHVEDFNIRUWKHPRVW SDUW WR KLV VWXGHQWV ZH DUH MXVWLILHG LQ FRQVLGHULQJ KLV =XKUª WUDQVPLVVLRQ DV DXWKHQWLFLQWKHVHQVHWKDWKHLQIDFWUHFHLYHGWKHWH[WVIURP=XKUª ,9 

7KHVPDOOHVWEXWQROHVVLPSRUWDQWRIWKHWKUHHHDUO\FRUSRUDRIWUDQVPLVVLRQVIURP =XKUªLVWKDWRI0OLNE$QDVLQKLV 0XZD°°Dº  7KH 0XZD°°Dº LVEDVLFDOO\DPX®DQ QDI ZRUNVLPLODUWRWKRVHE\0D·PDUDQG,EQ£XUDL¤EXWPRUHIXOO\DPSOLILHGZLWK DQQRWDWLRQV,IDQDO\VHGDFFRUGLQJWRWKHDOOHJHGRULJLQRILWVWUDQVPLVVLRQVWKHIRO ORZLQJSLFWXUHHPHUJHV0OLNUHIHUVPRVWIUHTXHQWO\WR,EQjLKE>D]=XKUª@ ZKRIRUWKLVUHDVRQFDQEHFRQVLGHUHGKLVPDLQLQIRUPDQW7H[WVIURP1IL·WKH PDXORI,EQ·8PDUDQGIURP
RI=XKUª":K\GRHVKHRQO\TXRWH1IL·DVRIWHQDV
7KLV RFFXUV KRZHYHU RQO\ LQ FROOHFWLYH TXRWDWLRQV LQ ZKLFK RWKHU HDUOLHU DXWKRULWLHVDUHPHQWLRQHGEHVLGHV=XKUª6XFKDQRQ\PRXVUHIHUHQFHVE\0OLNWR WKH UDº\ RI ODWH ILUVW FHQWXU\ $+ 0HGLQDQ WEL¹µQ DUH WR EH IRXQG LQ
$QRQ\PRXVWUDGLWLRQVOLNHWKLVRQHDUHXVXDOO\QRWIRXQGWUDQVPLWWHGIURP ,EQjLKEDORQHLQWKH 0XZD°°Dº 6RZHKDYHWRFRQFOXGHWKDWWKHDQRQ\PRXVUHIHU HQFHWR,EQjLKELQFROOHFWLYHTXRWDWLRQVLVDQLQH[DFWEHFDXVHVKRUWHQHGIRUPRI  TXRWDWLRQZKLFKDFWXDOO\VKRXOGUXQDVIROORZV

>WKH6XFFHVVRUV@;DQG<WKDWWKH\XVHGWRVD\e

7KLV PRUH HODERUDWH EXW PRUH SUHFLVH IRUP RI FROOHFWLYH TXRWDWLRQ RFFXUV RQO\RFFDVLRQDOO\ 0OLNnVDQRQ\PRXVLQGLUHFWUHIHUHQFHWR,EQjLKELQFROOHFWLYH TXRWDWLRQVVKRXOGQRWEHFRQVLGHUHGWKHUHIRUHDVDUHDOLQGLUHFWWUDQVPLVVLRQ6XFK H[DPSOHV GR QRW SURYHDW DOO WKDW 0OLNGHULYHV WKHPDMRU SDUW RI ,EQjLKE D] =XKUªnVUDº\IURPVRXUFHVZKLFKKHSDVVHVRYHULQVLOHQFH5HDOLQGLUHFWWUDQVPLV VLRQVIURP=XKUªDUHWREHIRXQGLQ0OLNnV 0XZD°°Dº RQO\UDUHO\,QWKHP0OLN UHIHUV WR =XKUª WKURXJK D WKLUG SHUVRQ FDOOHG E\ QDPH (YHQ LI VXFK LQGLUHFW WUDQVPLVVLRQVDUHTXLWHXQXVXDO WKHLUVKHHU H[LVWHQFHVKRZVWKDWZHFDQKDUGO\LP SXWHWR0OLNWKHDPELWLRQWRUHODWHGLUHFWO\DOO=XKUªWH[WVNQRZQWRKLPHYHQ WKRVHZKLFKKHKDGQRWKHDUGIURP=XKUªKLPVHOIVXSSUHVVLQJWKHQDPHVRIWKHLQ IRUPDQWVIURPZKRPKHDFWXDOO\UHFHLYHGWKH=XKUªWH[WV 7KH³U DQGªG¬³ VRI0OLNnV=XKUªWUDQVPLVVLRQPRVWO\UHIHUWRWKH ®DªED JHQHUDWLRQRQO\KDOIDVPDQ\JREDFNWRWKH3URSKHWDQGWKHVPDOOHVWQXPEHUJR EDFNWRWKHWEL¹µQ$Q\ZD\ WKH 3URSKHWLVWKH PRVW IUHTXHQWO\PHQWLRQHGDPRQJ DOOVLQJOHDXWKRULWLHVKHRFFXUVWZLFHDVRIWHQDV·8PDURU·8WKPQ,EQjLKEnVID YRXULWHV DPRQJ WKH &RPSDQLRQV RI WKH 3URSKHW $PRQJ WKH ®DªED WUDGLWLRQV WKRVH ZLWK DQ LVQG  SUHYDLO RYHU WKRVH ZLWKRXW DPRQJ WKH WUDGLWLRQV IURP WKH 3URSKHWERWKW\SHVRIWUDQVPLVVLRQDUHHYHQIUHTXHQWZKHUHDVWKH6XFFHVVRUWUDGL WLRQVDUHIRUWKHPRVWSDUWDQRQ\PRXVLHODFNDQ\ LVQG  7KHVHILQGLQJVJHQHUDWHVHYHUDOTXHVWLRQVIRUWKHDGYRFDWHVRIWKHIRUJHU\WKH RU\ :K\ GRHV 0OLN ZKR YLD ,EQ jLKE PRVWO\ UHIHUV WR WKH ®DªED RU WR WKH 3URSKHWDSSHDOWR,EQjLKEnV UDº\DWDOOLIKHZDQWHGWREDVHKLVRZQ ILTKILFWL WLRXVO\RQHDUOLHUDQGPRUHHPLQHQWDXWKRULWLHV"'RHVLWPDNHVHQVHWRDVVXPHWKDW

0OLNLQYHQWHG3URSKHWLFWUDGLWLRQVZLWKLQFRPSOHWH DVQ¬G ODFNLQJRQHRUHYHQ WZRWUDQVPLWWHUVDVZHOODVWUDGLWLRQVZLWKFRPSOHWHFKDLQVRIWUDQVPLWWHUV" 0OLNnV 1IL· WUDQVPLVVLRQ LVWRWDOO\ GLIIHUHQW IURP KLV ,EQ jLKE D]=XKUª WH[WV,WJHQHUDOO\GRHVQRWFRQWDLQWUDGLWLRQVDERXW1IL·V UDº\ EXWFRQVLVWVDOPRVW HQWLUHO\RIWUDGLWLRQVZKLFK1IL·WUDQVPLWVIURPRWKHUSHRSOH$ERXWWZRWKLUGVRI  WKHPUHODWHWRWKH UDº\RUWKHOHJDOO\UHOHYDQWEHKDYLRXURI·$EGDOOKE·8PDUZKR LVFRXQWHGDPRQJWKH ®DªED7KHUHVWUHIHUWRWKH3URSKHWKLVZLYHVRUWRD&RP SDQLRQ OLNH=DLGE¯ELWRIWHQLQFRQQHFWLRQ ZLWKDPHPEHURI ·8PDUnV RU,EQ ·8PDUnVIDPLO\1IL·nVLQIRUPDQWLVIRUWKHPRVWSDUWKLVSDWURQ,EQ·8PDUPRUH UDUHO\WKHODWWHUnVZLIH«IL\\DELQW$Eª·8EDLGKLVVRQ6OLPRURWKHUIDPLO\PHP EHUV*HQHUDOO\ZHILQGLQIRUPDQWVJLYHQLQWKLVPDWHULDOIRUWUDGLWLRQVIURPWKH 3URSKHWDQG&RPSDQLRQVRWKHUWKDQ,EQ·8PDU7KHUHDUHKDUGO\DQ\ UHVSRQVD E\ 1IL·WRTXHVWLRQVDVNHGE\0OLNKLPVHOI RULQGLFDWLRQVWKDWKHKHDUGKLPSHU VRQDOO\ VDP¹  $VLQWKHFDVHRI0D·PDUDQG,EQ£XUDL¤LWLVSRVVLEOHWRH[SODLQrK\SR WKHWLFDOO\ WKH DVWRQLVKLQJ GLIIHUHQFHV EHWZHHQ 0OLNnV ,EQ jLKE >D]=XKUª@DQG 1IL·WUDQVPLVVLRQVE\KLVWRULFDOFLUFXPVWDQFHV)RUH[DPSOH7KHIDFWWKDW0OLN IUHTXHQWO\WUDQVPLWVIURP=XKUªUHVSRQVDWRKLVRZQTXHVWLRQVDVZHOODVWH[WVZKLFK 0OLNH[SOLFLWO\VD\VKHKHDUGIURP=XKUªZKHUHDVKHKDUGO\WUDQVPLWVDQ\RIWKH VHVW\SHVRIWH[WVIURP1IL·PD\EHWKHUHVXOWRIGLIIHUHQWIRUPVRIWHDFKLQJ1IL· PD\KDYHKDGKLVSXSLOVRQO\FRS\WH[WVDQGUHDGWKHPRXWRU0OLNPD\KDYH RQO\DWWHQGHGVXFKOHVVRQVZKHUHDV=XKUªPD\KDYHKHOGDGGLWLRQDOTXHVWLRQWLPHV RUGLVFXVVLRQVDERXWOHJDOWRSLFV7KHILQGLQJWKDW0OLNUHSRUWVIURP=XKUªPDQ\ LQVWDQFHVRIKLVUDº\DQGE\FRPSDULVRQDOPRVWQRQHIURP1IL·PD\KDYHVLPLODU UHDVRQVRUrPRUHOLNHO\rLWPD\PLUURUWKHIDFWWKDW1IL·GLGQRWWHDFKKLVRZQ UDº\DWDOOEXWFRQILQHGKLPVHOILQKLVFODVVHVWRWKHWUDQVPLVVLRQDQGGLIIXVLRQRI  WUDGLWLRQVRQO\

7KH GLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQ 0OLNnVWUDQVPLVVLRQVIURP,EQjLKEDQG1IL· ZDV QRWLFHGE\6FKDFKWDVZHOO
K\SRWKHVHVRQWKHGRFWULQHRIDSUHVXPHGROGo0HGLQHVHVFKRROpZKLFKKHKLPVHOI  FRQVWUXFWHGRQWKHEDVLVRIFRQMHFWXUHVZKLFKDOUHDG\FRQWDLQHGKLVSUHMXGLFHVFRQ FHUQLQJWKHYDOXHRIWKH DVQ¬G RIWKHVHFRQG FHQWXU\)LQDOO\ZHFDQTXHVWLRQZK\ 0OLN VKRXOG KDYH IDNHG D GLUHFW WUDQVPLVVLRQ IURP 1IL· WKRXJK KH GRHV QRW VKULQNIURPTXRWLQJKLPRFFDVLRQDOO\ YLDDWKLUGSHUVRQIRUH[DPSOH1IL·nVVRQ $E³%DNU 2XUFRPSDULVRQRIWKHWH[WFRUSRUDRI0OLNnVPRVWLPSRUWDQWLQIRUPDQWV OHDGVWRWKHFRQFOXVLRQWKDWZHPXVWDVVXPHWKDW0OLNnVWUDQVPLVVLRQVIURPERWK 1IL·DQG=XKUªUHDOO\GHULYHIURPWKHPXQWLOWKHFRQWUDU\LVSURYHQ 7KLVFRQFOXVLRQEDVHGRQO\RQ0OLNnV 0XZD°°Dº UHPDLQVWHQDEOHHYHQZKHQ ZHORRNDWWKHELRJUDSKLFDOUHSRUWVSUHVHUYHGDERXW0OLN6FKDFKWKDVGHDOWZLWK 0OLNnVELRJUDSK\LQGHWDLO +HWKLQNVWKDWZHKDUGO\KDYHDQ\UHOLDEOHLQIRUPD WLRQDERXWWKHSHULRGRI0OLNnVVWXGLHV6FKDFKWRQO\DFFHSWVWKHUHSRUWWKDW0OLN VWXGLHG ILTKZLWK5DEª·DE)DUU³¦WKRXJKWKLVLQIRUPDWLRQLVRQO\IRXQGLQODWHU VRXUFHV+HVHHPVWRUHMHFWDVXQWUXVWZRUWK\RWKHUUHSRUWVHYHQHDUO\RQHVFRQFHUQ LQJRWKHUWHDFKHUVRI0OLN6FKDFKWHPSKDVLVHVWKDWWKHIDFWRI0OLNnVWUDQVPLW WLQJIURP1IL·DQG=XKUªLVQRWSURRIWKDWKHVWXGLHGZLWKWKHDXWKRULWLHVLQTXHV WLRQ 6FKDFKWLVVXUHO\ULJKWLQEHLQJVXVSLFLRXVRIWKHVWHDG\LQFUHDVHLQWHDFKHUVn DQGSXSLOVnQDPHVLQWKHELRJUDSKLFDOVRXUFHVEHFDXVHWKH\SUREDEO\DUHEDVHGDW OHDVWSDUWLDOO\RQWKH DVQ¬G NQRZQWRWKHLUDXWKRUV
$FFRUGLQJWR0OLNKLPVHOIDVWUDQVPLWWHGE\KLVVWXGHQWEDO§D¤¤¤@DVOLJKWO\ROGHUFRQWHPSRUDU\RI0OLNnVHYHQUHSRUWHGWKDW0OLN DOUHDG\KDGKLVRZQFLUFOH ªDOTDRIVWXGHQWVZKHQKHjX·EDFDPHWR0HGLQDD\HDU DIWHU1IL·nVGHDWK 0OLNnVVWXGHQWVOLNH
 9 

$VZHKDYHVKRZQWKHLQYHVWLJDWLRQRIWKHWKUHHHDUOLHVWFRUSRUDFRQWDLQLQJODUJH QXPEHUVRI=XKUªWH[WVJLYHVULVHWRWKH FRQFOXVLRQWKDWWKH=XKUªWUDQVPLVVLRQ RI  DOORIWKHPFDQQRWEHFRQVLGHUHGDVIDEULFDWLRQVRIWKHFRPSLODWRUVRIWKHVHFRU SRUDLHWH[WVIDOVHO\DVFULEHGWR=XKUª7KLVGRHVQRWH[FOXGHWKHSRVVLELOLW\WKDW WKH\PD\FRQWDLQHUURUVZKLFKFUHSWLQGXULQJWKHSURFHVVRIWUDQVPLVVLRQ,ILWLV WUXHWKDW0D·PDUnVDQG,EQ£XUDL¤nVWUDQVPLVVLRQVIRXQGLQ·$EGDUUD]]TnV0X®DQ QDI DQG0OLNnVWUDQVPLVVLRQLQWKH 0XZD°°º LQGHSHQGHQWO\JREDFNWR=XKUªWKHQ ZHFRXOGH[SHFWWKDWWKHVHWKUHHWUDQVPLVVLRQVWRFNVFRQWDLQDWOHDVWSDUWLDOO\VLPL ODUPDWHULDOV:KHWKHUWKLVLVWKHFDVHZLOOEHH[DPLQHGQRZ 7RVWDUWZLWKZHKDYHWRUHFRUGWKDWRQWKHIDFHRILWWKHUHDUHVLPLODULWLHV DQG GLIIHUHQFHV EHWZHHQ WKH WKUHH WUDQVPLVVLRQ FRUSRUD )RU H[DPSOH 0D·PDUnV FRQWDLQVPDQ\PRUHWH[WVWKDQWKHRWKHUWZR\HWWKLVGRHVQRWQHFHVVDULO\PHDQ WKDWLWVDGGLWLRQDOPDWHULDOLVIDEULFDWHG7RH[SODLQ WKH GLIIHUHQFHZHFDQLPDJLQH WKDWIRUVRPHUHDVRQ0OLNDQG,EQ£XUDL¤GLGQRWFRPPXQLFDWHHYHU\WKLQJWKH\ NQHZIURP=XKUªDQGRUWKDWWKH\KDGOHDUQHGOHVVIURPKLPWKDQ0D·PDUKDG PD\EHEHFDXVHWKH\GLGQRWVWXG\ZLWK=XKUªDVORQJDV0D·PDUGLG7KHIDFWWKDW LQ0D·PDUnVFRUSXV=XKUªnVUDº\SUHGRPLQDWHVZKHUHDVLQ,EQ£XUDL¤nVDQG0OLNnV FRUSRUDKLVWUDGLWLRQVIURPHDUOLHUDXWKRULWLHVDUHPRUHIUHTXHQW PD\KDYH VLPLODU FDXVHVRUPD\PLUURU0D·PDUnVVWURQJHULQWHUHVWLQ=XKUªnV UDº\/LNHZLVHZHFDQ H[SODLQ WKH GLIIHUHQW GLVWULEXWLRQ RI =XKUªnV LQIRUPDQWV LQ WKH WUDGLWLRQV RI WKH WKUHHWH[WFRUSRUD7KHIDFWIRUH[DPSOHWKDW,EQDO0XVD\\DEDQG6OLPE·$EGDO OKE·8PDUDUHPRUHIUHTXHQWO\PHQWLRQHGLQ0D·PDUnV =XKUªWUDGLWLRQVWKDQLQ WKRVHRIWKHRWKHUWZRFDQSHUKDSVEHH[SODLQHGE\WKHREVHUYDWLRQWKDW,EQ£XUDL¤ WUDQVPLWV PDQ\,EQ DO0XVD\\DEWUDGLWLRQV IURPRWKHULQIRUPDQWV OLNH
VLPLODU LV WUXH LQ 0OLNnVFDVH,Q DGGLWLRQLW LV LPSRUWDQWWR EHDU LQ PLQG WKDW 0OLNRIWHQGRHVQRWPHQWLRQKLVLQIRUPDQWVIRUWKH WUDGLWLRQVIURPWKH6XFHVVRUV WKRXJKLQPDQ\FDVHV=XKUªSUREDEO\LV0OLNnVVRXUFHIRUWKHP $FRPSDUDWLYHDQDO\VLVWKHWH[WVPXWµQFRQWDLQHGLQWKHWKUHHFRUSRUDZLOO RIIHUPRUHVXEVWDQWLDWHGFRQFOXVLRQV)RUWKHVDNH RIFODULW\,GLVWLQJXLVKEHWZHHQ =XKUªnVUDº\DQGKLVWUDGLWLRQV7KHTXHVWLRQ,ZLOODQVZHUILUVWLV+RZVLPLODUDUH WKHWH[WVUHSURGXFLQJ=XKUªnVUDº\FRQWDLQHGLQWKHWUHHFRSRUD" ,IWKH=XKUªWUDQVPLVVLRQE\,EQ£XUDL¤LVFRPSDUHGWRWKHRQHE\0D·PDU IURPWKLVSRLQWRIYLHZWKHUHVXOWLVWKDWPRUHWKDQKDOIRIDOOUDº\WH[WVWUDQVPLWWHG E\,EQ£XUDL¤KDYHDSDUDOOHOLQ0D·PDUnVFRUSXV0RVWRIWKHPKDYHWKHVDPHFRQ WHQWLHGLIIHURQO\LQWKHFKRLFHRIZRUGVRULQWKHIXOOQHVVRIWKHWH[WVRPHWH[WV DUHFRPSOHWHO\LGHQWLFDORWKHUVGHDOZLWKDVRPHZKDWGLYHUJLQJSRLQWRIWKHVDPH OHJDOLVVXHREYLRXVFRQWUDGLFWLRQVDUHRQO\UDUHO\IRXQG+HUHDUHVRPHH[DPSOHV ,Q KLV 0X®DQQDI  ·$EGDUUD]]T RIWHQ UHSURGXFHV VD\LQJV GLFWD RI =XKUª ZKLFKDUHWUDQVPLWWHGE\ERWK0D·PDUDQG,EQ£XUDL¤LQWKHVDPHRUYHU\VLPLODU ZRUGVE\TXRWLQJRQO\RQHWH[WLQIXOODVDUXOHWKDWRI0D·PDUDQGJLYLQJIURP WKHRWKHURQHRQO\WKH LVQG IRUH[DPSOHo¹DQ,EQ£XUDL¤¹DQ,EQjLKEpWRJHWKHU ZLWKWKHUHPDUNoPL³ODKXpWKHVDPH ([DPSOHVRIWH[WVZLWKWKHVDPHFRQWHQWEXWGLIIHUHQWZRUGLQJDUH D ·$EGDUUD]]TIURP0D·PDUIURP=XKUª7KHUHLVQRREMHFWLRQPDUU\LQJDIUHH>ZRPDQ@ LQDGGLWLRQWRDVODYHZRPDQ>EXW@LWLVQRWSHUPLWWHGWRPDUU\DVODYHZRPDQLQDGGL WLRQ WR D IUHH >ZLIH@ ,I >D PDQ@ PDUULHG DOUHDG\ WR D IUHH ZRPDQ PDUULHV D VODYH ZRPDQKHPXVWEHVHSDUDWHG IXUULTDIURPWKHVODYHZRPDQDQGKHLVWREHSXQLVKHG ,IKHPDUULHVDIUHHZRPDQLQDGGLWLRQWRDVODYHZRPDQZKLOHVKHNQRZVWKDWKHLV>DO UHDG\@ PDUULHG WR D VODYH ZRPDQ VKH KDV WKH ULJKW WR WKH VDPH QXPEHUTLVPD>RI  QLJKWV@DQGPDLQWHQDQFH>%XW@LIVKHPDUULHG >KLP@ZLWKRXWNQRZLQJWKDWKHLVPDU

ULHGWRDVODYHZRPDQVKHKDVWKHULJKWWRGHFLGH,IVKHZDQWVVKHFDQVHSDUDWHIURP KLPRUVWD\ZLWKKLP E ·$EGDUUD]]T IURP,EQ £XUDL¤KHVDLG,EQjLKE WUDQVPLWWHG WR PHDERXWWKH IUHH ZRPDQZKRLVPDUULHG>E\DPDQ@LQDGGLWLRQWRDVODYHZRPDQ7KH VXQQDFRQFHUQLQJ WKH>ZRPDQ@ZLWKZKRPDIUHHPDQGRHVWKDW>LHPDUULHVKHU@LVWKDWWKHIUHHPDQLV QRWSHUPLWWHGWRPDUU\DVODYHZRPDQLIKHILQGVWKHILQDQFLDOPHDQV °µO WR>PDUU\@D IUHHZRPDQ ,IKHGRHVQRWILQGWKHILQDQFLDOPHDQVPDUULDJHZLWKDVODYHZRPDQLV DOORZHG,IKHWKHQPDUULHVDIUHHZRPDQLQDGGLWLRQWRKHU>WKHVODYHZRPDQ@KHFDQ GR WKDWSURYLGHGWKDWWKH IUHH ZRPDQNQRZVWKDWKHLV>DOUHDG\@ PDUULHG WR D VODYH ZRPDQ,IVKHGLGQRWNQRZWKHIUHHZRPDQFDQFKRRVHEHWZHHQVHSDUDWLRQIURPKLP DQGVWD\LQJZLWKKLPIRUWKHVDPHQXPEHU TLVPD>RIQLJKWV@DQGPDLQWHQDQFH>+RZ HYHU@LIKHPDUULHVDVODYHZRPDQLQDGGLWLRQWRKHU>WKHIUHHZRPDQ@VKH>WKHVODYH ZRPDQ@ZLOOEHWDNHQDZD\IURPKLPDQGKHZLOOEHSXQLVKHG

'LIIHUHQFHVVXFKDVWKHODUJHQXPEHURIWH[WVWDOO\LQJRQO\LQFRQWHQWEXWQRW LQZRUGLQJVKRZWKDWWKHWH[WVGLGQRWUHVXOWIURPFRS\LQJRIPDQXVFULSWVEXWIURP QRWHVPDGHGXULQJDQGRUDIWHUWKHOHVVRQV6XFKDSURFHGXUHDSSHDUVWRKDYHEHHQ TXLWHQRUPDOIRUWKHW\SHRIOHJDOWHDFKLQJLQZKLFKTXHVWLRQVZHUHDVNHGDQGOHJDO SUREOHPVZHUHGLVFXVVHGDVRSSRVHGWRªDG¬³ LQVWUXFWLRQZKHUHWH[WVZHUHUHFLWHGRU UHDGRXW7KHIDFWWKDWRFFDVLRQDOO\DGLIIHUHQWSRLQWRIDOHJDOLVVXHLVHPSKDVLVHG PD\ UHIOHFW GLIIHUHQW SHUVRQDO LQWHUHVWV DQG LQGLYLGXDO VWXGHQWVn GLIIHUHQW EDFN JURXQGNQRZOHGJH)XUWKHUPRUHZHKDYHWRWDNHLQWRDFFRXQWWKDWRXUWKUHHWUDQV PLWWHUVRI=XKUªnVOHJDORSLQLRQV0D·PDU,EQ£XUDL¤DQG0OLNSUREDEO\GLGQRW VWXG\ZLWKKLPDWWKHVDPHWLPHVRWKDWWKHLUGLIIHUHQWSUHVHQWDWLRQVRIWKHPDWHULDO PD\EHGXHWR=XKUªKLPVHOIZKRSHUKDSVGLGQRWDOZD\VH[SUHVVKLVGRFWULQHVLQ H[DFWO\WKHVDPHZRUGV 7KHUDUHSDUDOOHOWH[WVLQZKLFKREYLRXVFRQWUDGLFWLRQVDSSHDUDUHQRWHDVLO\ H[SODLQHG$QH[DPSOH

D ·$EGDUUD]]TIURP0D·PDUIURP=XKUªDERXWWKHRQHZKRJUDWLILHVKLVVH[XDOGHVLUHV ZLWKDQDQLPDO \DºW¬DOEDK¬PDWD+HVDLGo+HPXVWEHIORJJHGWLPHVLWGRHVQRW PDWWHUZKHWKHUKHLVPXª®LQDª®DQDLHKDVEHHQPDUULHGEHIRUH@RUQRWp E ·$EGDUUD]]TVDLG,EQ£XUDL¤WUDQVPLWWHGWRXVKHVDLG,EQjLKEWROGDERXWDPDQ ZKRFRKDELWDWHVZLWKDJUHJDULRXVDQLPDO \DTD¹X¹DOOEDK¬PDWLPLQ DODQ¹PWKHIRO ORZLQJo,KDYHQRWKHDUGD VXQQDDERXWLWEXWZHFRQVLGHUKLPOLNHWKHRQHZKRKDV LOOHJLWLPDWH VH[XDO LQWHUFRXUVH >ZLWK D KXPDQ EHLQJ@ D]]Q¬  LW GRHV QRW PDWWHU ZKHWKHUKHLVPXª®LQDª®DQDRUQRWp

,QWKHODVWWH[WWKHSXQLVKPHQWLVQRWPHQWLRQHGH[SUHVVO\EXWZHFDQLQIHU LWIRURQO\WKH ]Q¬ ZKRLVQRW PXª®LQLVIORJJHGZKLOHWKHPXª®LQLVVWRQHG 2EYL RXVO\WKHUHLVDFRQWUDGLFWLRQEHWZHHQERWKWH[WV,WLVQRWHDV\WRWHOOKRZWKLVFDPH DERXW:HFDQLPDJLQHDFKDQJHRIPLQGRQ=XKUªnVSDUWZKLFKZRXOGQRWEHDWDOO XQXVXDO RUDPLVXQGHUVWDQGLQJE\RQHRIWKHSXSLOVZKRWUDQVPLWWHGWKHWH[W  :KHQ0OLNnVTXRWDWLRQVRI=XKUªnVUDº\IRXQGLQWKH 0XZD°°Dº DUHFRPSDUHG ZLWK 0D·PDUnV DQG ,EQ £XUDL¤nV UDº\ WUDQVPLVVLRQV IURP =XKUª FRQWDLQHG LQWKH  0X®DQQDI WKHFRUUHVSRQGHQFHVDUHHYHQKLJKHUWKDQEHWZHHQ0D·PDUDQG,EQ £XUDL¤+HUHWRRFRPSOHWHO\LGHQWLFDOWH[WVDUHUDWKHUXQXVXDOWKHPDMRULW\RQO\ KDYH WKHVDPH FRQWHQWDQGZHRFFDVLRQDOO\ ILQG FRQWUDGLFWLRQVDVZHOO 7KHFDXVHV RI WKH VRPHWLPHV VPDOOHU VRPHWLPHV ELJJHU GLIIHUHQFHV DUH SUREDEO\WKH VDPH DV PHQWLRQHGDERYH $QH[DPSOHRILGHQWLFDODQGVLPLODUWH[WV D  ·$EGDUUD]]TIURP@ 0D·PDUIURP=XKUªKHVDLGo(YHU\GLYRUFHGZRPDQKDVWKH ULJKWWRDQDOORZDQFHPXW¹Dp

F ·$EGDUUD]]TIURP,EQ£XUDL¤ IURP,EQjLKEKHVDLGo7KHDOORZDQFHLVWKHVDPH IRUWKHZRPDQZKRKDGPDULWDOLQWHUFRXUVHDQGIRUWKHRQHZKRKDGQRWp+HVDLG >PRUHRYHU@o7KH\ERWKKDYHWKHULJKWWRDOORZDQFHp

$QH[DPSOHRIFRQWUDGLFWRU\WH[WV D  RIVH[XDO DEVWLQHQFH@¬Oº RIDVODYH>FRQFHUQLQJKLVZLIH@+H>,EQjLKE@VDLGo,WLVOLNHWKH ¬Oº  RIWKHIUHHPDQLWLVELQGLQJ>EXW@WKH¬Oº RIWKHVODYH>FRYHUVRQO\@WZRPRQWKVp E ·$EGDUUD]]T IURP 0D·PDU IURP =XKUª KH VDLG o7KH VODYHnV RDWK >RI VH[XDO DEVWL QHQFH@WRDVODYHZRPDQ>FRYHUV@IRXUPRQWKVp

7KHIDFWVWKDWVXFKFRQWUDGLFWLRQVDUHDQH[FHSWLRQDQGWKDWWKHPDMRULW\RI  WKH=XKUªGLFWDH[SUHVVLQJKLVUDº\FRUUHVSRQGLQFRQWHQWFRUURERUDWHP\FRQFOXVLRQ WKDWDOOWKUHHVRXUFHFRUSRUDFRQWDLQJHQXLQHWUDGLWLRQVRI=XKUªnVUDº\,WLVYHU\XQ OLNHO\WKDWWKHWKUHHFRPSLODWRUVrRQHOLYLQJLQ«DQ·¸DQRWKHULQ0HFFDDQGWKH WKLUGLQ0HGLQDrLQGHSHQGHQWO\RIRQHDQRWKHUFDQKDYHDVFULEHGDUELWUDULO\VR PDQ\ VLPLODU WH[WV WR =XKUª ,Q WKLV FDVH RI IRUJHU\ FRQWUDGLFWLRQV ZRXOG RFFXU PRUHIUHTXHQWO\$QRWKHUSRVVLEOHDVVXPSWLRQQDPHO\WKDWDOOWKUHHVFKRODUVDFWX DOO\REWDLQHGWKHLUPDWHULDOIURPWKHVDPHoFRXQWHUIHLWZRUNVKRSpRUIHOOYLFWLPWR DZDQGHULQJoSLRXVVZLQGOHUpZKRFLUFXODWHGIDEULFDWHG=XKUªGRFWULQHVDQGWKDW WKH\WKHQFRQFHDOHGWKHVRXUFHRIWKHLUPDWHULDOE\VXSSUHVVLQJWKHQDPHVRIWKHLU LQIRUPDQWVLQWKHDVQ¬G LVXQFRQYLQFLQJDVZHOO6FKDFKWDVVXPHGWKLVIRUDSDUWRI  0OLNnV=XKUªWUDQVPLVVLRQWKRXJKKHGLGQRWVXVSHFW0OLNRI SLDIUDXVH[SUHVVO\ 7KHSUDFWLFDOGLIILFXOWLHVRIWKLVK\SRWKHVLVDSDUWLQVXFKDFDVHZHFRXOGH[SHFW PRUHFRUUHVSRQGHQFHLQZRUGLQJEHWZHHQWKHWH[WVRIWKHWUDQVPLWWHUV 3HUKDSV6FKDFKWZRXOGKDYHJRQHVRIDUDVWRUHFRJQLVH DVJHQXLQHWKHFRP SOHWHUDº\RI=XKUªDVWUDQVPLWWHGE\0OLNEXWLQWKHFDVHRIKLV=XKUªWUDGLWLRQV IURPHDUOLHU DXWKRULWLHV QR FRPSURPLVHZDV SRVVLEOHIRU 6FKDFKW IRU WKLVZRXOG

KDYH FRQWUDGLFWHGKLVLGHDVDERXWWKH GHYHORSPHQWRI,VODPLFMXULVSUXGHQFH:KDW FDQEHVDLGDERXW=XKUªnV ³U DQG DªG¬³ LQRXUWKUHH HDUO\VRXUFHV"$QH[WHQVLYH FRPSDULVRQRIWKHQXPHURXVWH[WVZRXOGEHGHVLUDEOHEXWFDQQRWEHGRQHLQWKH IUDPHZRUNRIWKLVHVVD\6XFKDFRPSDULVRQVKRXOGFRQVLVWRIDV\QRSVLVRIWKHWUD GLWLRQVFRUUHVSRQGLQJLQFRQWHQWLWVKRXOGXQGHUOLQHWKHGLIIHUHQFHVDQGVXJJHVW H[SODQDWLRQVIRUWKHP+RZHYHU DIHZUHVXOWVRIVXFK DQLQYHVWLJDWLRQZLOODWOHDVW EHSUHVHQWHGDQGLOOXVWUDWHGZLWKH[DPSOHV 7DNLQJ0OLNnV 0XZD°°Dº DVDVWDUWLQJSRLQWZHFDQGHWHFWWKDWIRUWKHPDMRU LW\   RI KLV WH[WV LQ ZKLFK ,EQ jLKE IXQFWLRQV DV WUDQVPLWWHU IRU HDUOLHU DXWKRULWLHVWKHUHDUHSDUDOOHOWH[WVLQWKHFRUSRUDRI0D·PDUDQGRU,EQ£XUDL¤$ PLQRULW\RIWH[WVLVWUDQVPLWWHGRQO\E\WKHODWWHUWZRRUE\RQHRIWKHWKUHHVFKRODUV DORQH7KHFRUUHVSRQGHQFHYDULHVIURPLGHQWLFDOWH[WVWRRQO\DYDJXHUHVHPEODQFHLQ FRQWHQW,FDQQRWGHWHFWDQ\GLIIHUHQFHLQYDULDWLRQFRQFHUQLQJFHUWDLQW\SHVRIWUD GLWLRQVVXFKDVWKRVHUHIHUULQJWRWKH WEL¹µQJHQHUDWLRQWKH ®DªEDRUWKH3URSKHW )URP WKH SRLQW RI YLHZ RI OLWHUDU\ JHQUHV VKRUW OHJDO PD[LPV DUH IRXQG EHVLGH HODERUDWHGFDVHVDQGGHWDLOHGQDUUDWLYHV TL®D® 7KHVHIDFWVSURYLGH HYLGHQFHDJDLQVWWKH VXVSLFLRQ KHOGE\6FKDFKWDQGRWK HUV WKDW WKH WUDGLWLRQV ODEHOOHGDV=XKUª WUDQVPLVVLRQV LQWKH ªDG¬³  FRPSLODWLRQV HPHUJHGRQO\DIWHU KLV GHDWKDQGWKDWWKH\ ZHUHIDOVHO\DVFULEHGWRKLPDQG KDS SHQHGWRUHDFK WKHDXWKRUVRI RXU WKUHH FRPSLODWLRQVE\RUDOWUDQVPLVVLRQ rRUDO EHFDXVHRIWKH PDQ\GLIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQWKHWH[WV )LUVWO\WKHERG\RI=XKUªWUDGL WLRQVLVWRRODUJHWRILWWKLVWKHRU\6HFRQGO\WKHSHULRGRIWLPHEHWZHHQ=XKUªnV GHDWK  DQG WKH oSXEOLFDWLRQp RI RXU WKUHH DXWKRUVn FRPSLODWLRQV LV WRR VKRUW 7KH\ SUREDEO\ FRPSRVHG WKHLU ZRUNV VRPH WLPH EHIRUH WKHLU GHDWKV ,EQ £XUDL¤ZDVDOUHDG\GHDGE\DQG0D·PDUGLHGLQ0OLNnV  0XZD°°Dº  PXVW KDYH H[LVWHG DURXQG  DW WKH ODWHVW EHFDXVH jDLEQª ZKR ZDV ERUQ LQ  SUREDEO\ UHFHLYHG KLV YHUVLRQ RI WKH 0XZD°°Dº  DV D \RXQJ VWXGHQW RI  0OLNnVDFFRUGLQJWRELRJUDSKLFDOUHSRUWVDWWKHDJHRI 7KH\HDUFDQEH

FRQVLGHUHGWKHUHIRUHDVWKHWHUPLQXVDQWHTXHPRIWKHH[LVWHQFHRIDOOWKUHHFRPSLOD WLRQVEXWPRVWSUREDEO\WKH\KDGDOUHDG\EHHQFRPSLOHGPXFKHDUOLHU,IWKLVLVDF FHSWHGLWUHPDLQVGLIILFXOWWRH[SODLQKRZWKHWKUHHDXWKRUVZKROLYHGIDUDZD\ IURPRQHDQRWKHUFDPHLQWRSRVVHVVLRQRIWKLVKXJHQXPEHURIWH[WVZKLFKDUH VLPLODULQFRQWHQWEXWRIWHQYDU\LQZRUGLQJLIRQHDVVXPHVDWWKHVDPHWLPHWKDW WKHWH[WVZHUHIRUJHGE\RWKHUV)LQDOO\LWVHHPVDYHU\RGGFRLQFLGHQFHWKDWHDFKRI  WKHWKUHHFRPSLOHUVVXSSUHVVHGWKHLUUHDOLQIRUPDQWVRUWKHLUFRPPRQVRXUFHVDV LIWKH\KDGDJUHHGWRWKLVIUDXG ,QWKHIROORZLQJ,VKDOOSUHVHQWDQH[DPSOHWRVKRZWKHGLIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQ WKH=XKUªWUDGLWLRQVLQRXUWKUHHFRUSRUDDQGWRFODULI\WKHFRQFOXVLRQVUHDFKHGVR IDU D >\HW@ERWKPXVWEHVHSDUDWHG  IXUULTDEDLQDKXPVKHPXVW>ILUVW@REVHUYHWKHUHPDLQLQJSDUWEDTL\\DRIKHUZDLW LQJ SHULRG RI >WKH PDUULDJH ZLWK@ KHU ILUVW KXVEDQG DQG WKHQ WKH VHFRQG PDQ FDQ PDUU\KHUDJDLQNQD¨°LEDQPLQDO¨X°°E>+RZHYHU@LIKHKDVFRQVXPPDWHGWKH PDUULDJHZLWKKHUERWKPXVWEHVHSDUDWHGVKHPXVWREVHUYH>ILUVW@ZKDWUHPDLQVRIWKH ZDLWLQJSHULRGRI>WKHPDUULDJHZLWK@KHUILUVWKXVEDQGWKDQWKHZDLWLQJSHULRGRIWKH VHFRQG RQH DQG WKHQ ERWK DUH IRUELGGHQ WR PDUU\ DQRWKHU DJDLQ IRU HYHU O  \D¦WDPL¹QL  p 0OLNVDLG ,EQDO0XVD\\DEVDLGo6KH>WKHZRPDQLQWKHODVWFDVH@LVHQWLWOHGWRKHU EULGHZHDOWK>DVDFRPSHQVDWLRQ@IRUZKDWZDVSHUPLWWHGWRKLPIURPKHU p

,QWKHQRWHVWKHGLIIHUHQFHVIRXQGLQjDLEQªnV 0XZD°°Dº UHFHQVLRQDUHJLYHQ 7KHVHGLIIHUHQFHV FRQVLVWRIDGGLWLRQVYDU\LQJQDPHVDQGYDULDWLRQVLQWKHWH[WWKDW

VRPHWLPHV ORRNOLNHVSHFLILFDWLRQVDQGVRPHWLPHVOLNHHUURUV7KHRPLVVLRQRUVXS SUHVVLRQRIWKHZRUGVoTOD0OLNpEHIRUHWKH,EQDO0XVD\\DEGLFWXPDGGHGDWWKH HQGRIWKHWH[WPHDQVWKDWLWLVWREHXQGHUVWRRGDVDFRQVWLWXHQWSDUWRI,EQjLKEnV WUDQVPLVVLRQ2ULJLQDOO\ WKLVDGGLWLRQDOUHPDUN WRWKH WUDGLWLRQ IURP ·8PDUZDV SUREDEO\DQRQ\PRXVOLNHVRPDQ\RI0OLNnVUHIHUHQFHVWR,EQDO0XVD\\EIRXQG LQRIWKHPDUULDJHZLWK@WKHILUVW>KXVEDQG@DQGWKHQ WXUQWDVWDTELOXWRKHUZDLWLQJSHULRG RI>WKH PDUULDJHZLWK@WKHVHFRQGRQH>+RZ HYHU@LIKHKDVQRW>\HW@FRQVXPPDWHGWKHPDUULDJHZLWKKHU ODP\X®LEKERWKPXVW EHVHSDUDWHG \XIDUUDTXEDLQDKXPXQWLOVKHKDVFRPSOHWHGWDVWDNPLOXZKDWUHPDLQV RIWKHZDLWLQJSHULRGRI>WKHPDUULDJHZLWK@WKHILUVW>KXVEDQG@WKHQKH>WKHVHFRQG RQH@FDQPDUU\KHUDJDLQ \D¨°XEXKPD¹DO¨X°°Ep =XKUªVDLGo,GRQRWNQRZKRZPDQ\>ODVKHV@WKDWIORJJLQJDPRXQWHGWRp+HVDLG >PRUHRYHU@o·$EGDOPDOLNKDGERWKRIWKHPIORJJHGZLWKODVKHVLQWKDW>LHVXFKD FDVH@4DEª¬DEX¸DLEZDVTXHVWLRQHGRQLW>·$EGDOPDOLNnVYHUGLFW@+HVDLGo,I\RX KDGGLPLQLVKHGLWDQGIORJJHGHDFKRIWKHPZLWKODVKHV>LWZRXOGKDYHEHHQPRUH DSSURSULDWH@p F

·$EGDUUD]]T IURP 0D·PDU IURP =XKUª IURP 6XODLPQE ZKR@KDGPDUULHGKHUGXULQJ KHUZDLWLQJSHULRG>DVFRPSHQVDWLRQ@IRUWKHFODLPKHKDGLVWDªDTTDRQKHU>WRVH[XDO LQWHUFRXUVH@ ERWK PXVW EH VHSDUDWHG  \XIDUUDTX EDLQDKXP ERWK DUH IRUELGGHQ WR

PDUU\ DJDLQ  \DWDQNDªQL  IRU HYHU DQG VKH PXVW REVHUYH KHU ZDLWLQJ SHULRG WD¹WDGGXRIERWK>PDUULDJHV@ G

·$EGDUUD]]TIURP0D·PDUIURP=XKUªWKDW6XODLPQDQG,EQDO0XVD\\DEKDGGLI IHUHQW RSLQLRQV =XKUª VDLG >,EQ DO0XVD\\DE VDLG@ o6KH LV HQWLWOHG WR KHU EULGH ZHDOWKp6XODLPQVDLGo+HUEULGHZHDOWKJRHVWRWKHWUHDVXU\EDLWDOPO p

7KHFRPSDULVRQEHWZHHQWKH 0XZD°°Dº WH[WDQG0D·PDUnVYHUVLRQIURP,EQ DO0XVD\\DEWH[WEERWKRIWKHP FHUWDLQO\GHULYLQJ IURP DFRPPRQVRXUFH VXS SRUWVRXUK\SRWKHVLVWKDWVRPHRIjDLEQªnVGHYLDWLRQVIURPDO£D]DUª@ G WUDQVPLWWHGE\ ,EQ £XUDL¤KHUHWKHZRPDQLVFDOOHGoXODL¨DELQW·8EDLGDOOKWKHVLVWHURIXODL¨DE ·8EDLGDOOKp 8QFHUWDLQW\DERXWWKHUHDGLQJRIDKDQGZULWWHQWH[WODFNLQJGLD FULWLFDOSRLQWVPD\KDYH OHG WRGRXEWVDERXWWKHFRUUHFWQDPH RIWKHVHFRQG KXV EDQG,EQ0XQDEELKRU,EQ0XQD\\DKZKLFKDSSHDUVRQO\LQjDLEQªnVYHUVLRQ 0D·PDUnV DQG 0OLNnV YHUVLRQV DUH KDUGO\ WKH UHVXOW RI FRS\LQJ WKH VDPH PDQXVFULSW7KHGLIIHUHQFHVQRWRQO\LQYRFDEXODU\EXWDOVR LQWKHVHTXHQFHRIWKH DUJXPHQWVDUHWRRJUHDWIRUVXFKDQDVVXPSWLRQ7KDWPHDQVHLWKHUWKDWRQHRUERWK WUDQVPLWWHUVREWDLQHGWKHWH[WE\RUDOWUDQVPLVVLRQrWKLVGRHVQRWH[FOXGHWKHSRV VLELOLW\WKDWDOVRZULWWHQQRWHVZHUHXVHGDVPHPRU\DLGVrRUWKDW=XKUªGLGQRWDO ZD\VWHOOWKHWUDGLWLRQLQH[DFWO\ WKHVDPHIRUPRUWKDWERWKSRVVLELOLWLHVRFFXUUHG DWWKHVDPHWLPH

0D·PDUUHSRUWVWKHFDOLSK·8PDUnVYHUGLFWLQWZRYHU\GLIIHUHQWYHUVLRQVIURP WZRGLIIHUHQWLQIRUPDQWVRI=XKUªnV,EQDO0XVD\\DE6XODLPQ E·8EDLGDOOK E@ ·8WEDDQG$E³6DODPDE·$EGDUUD¨PQWKDW·8PDUEDO¥D®®EVHSDUDWHG IDU UDTDEDLQDDZRPDQZKRKDGPDUULHGLQKHUZDLWLQJSHULRGIURPKHUKXVEDQG7KHQ KHGHFLGHGTDo,IDZRPDQD\\XPPUDºDWLQPDUULHVLQKHUZDLWLQJSHULRG>EXW@ KHUKXVEDQGGLGQRW>\HW@FRQVXPPDWHWKHPDUULDJHODP\DG¨XOELKERWKPXVWEH VHSDUDWHG \XIDUUDTX EDLQDKXPVKHPXVWFRPSOHWHZKDWUHPDLQVRIKHUZDLWLQJSH ULRGWD¹WDGGXPEDTL\DZKHQLWLVILQLVKHGWKHVHFRQGPDQFDQPDUU\KHU>DJDLQ@ ¨D°DEDI¬O¨X°°ELIVKHZDQWVVKHFDQPDUU\KLPLIVKHGRHVQRWZDQW>DQ\PRUH@VKH FDQDEVWDLQIURPLW>%XW@LIKHKDVFRQVXPPDWHGWKHPDUULDJHZLWKKHU>DOUHDG\@WKHQ ERWKDUHIRUELGGHQWRPDUU\ \D¦WDPL¹QL DQRWKHUDJDLQIRUHYHUVKHPXVWFRPSOHWH >ILUVW@KHUZDLWLQJSHULRGRI>WKHPDUULDJHZLWK@WKHILUVW>KXVEDQG@WKHQREVHUYHWKH ZDLWLQJSHULRGWD¹WDGGXRI>WKHPDUULDJHZLWK@WKHVHFRQGRQH

,Q ,EQ £XUDL¤nV WUDQVPLVVLRQ ·8PDUnV GLFWXP VKRZV JUHDWHU VLPLODULW\ LQ VWUXFWXUHDQGYRFDEXODU\ZLWK0OLNnVYHUVLRQWKDQZLWK0D·PDUnVWKRXJKWKHUHDUH DOVRYDULDWLRQV7KHKLVWRULFDOLQWURGXFWLRQLVPLVVLQJDVZHOODVWKHQDPHVRIWKH SHUVRQVLQYROYHGDQGPRVWRGGO\WZRRWKHUSHUVRQVDUHPHQWLRQHGDV=XKUªnVLQ IRUPDQWVRIWKHFDVH0XVWZHFRQFOXGHIURPWKHVHIDFWVWKDW,EQ£XUDL¤VKRUWHQHG WKHRULJLQDOWH[WDQGFRQVFLRXVO\FKDQJHGWKHQDPHVRI=XKUªnVLQIRUPDQWV"2UGLG

KHIRUJHWWKHRULJLQDOYHUVLRQDQGWKHQFRYHUXSWKHJDSLQKLVPHPRU\E\SURGXF LQJ DUELWUDULO\WZR RWKHU QDPHV DVLQIRUPDQWV" 6XFKFRQFOXVLRQVDUH QRW FRPSHO OLQJ $FFRUGLQJWRWKHELRJUDSKLFDOLQIRUPDWLRQPHQWLRQHGDERYH,EQ£XUDL¤ RE WDLQHGPRVWRIKLV=XKUªWUDGLWLRQVQRWE\KHDULQJWKHPIURPKLPRUUHDGLQJWKHP RXWWRKLPEXWLQZULWWHQIRUPSHUKDSVKHHYHQFRSLHGWKHPDQXVFULSWRIRQHRI  =XKUªnVVWXGHQWVrWRJHWKHUZLWKDQL¦]DLHDSHUPLVVLRQWRWUDQVPLWWKHPDWH ULDO ,IWKLVZDVVRIDGLQJPHPRU\FDQQRWKDYHEHHQWKHFDXVHRIWKHGLIIHUHQFHVLQ KLV YHUVLRQ)XUWKHUPRUH,EQ £XUDL¤ XVXDOO\ GRHV QRW KHVLWDWH WRDGPLWPHPRU\ JDSVDQGPDUNWKHPDVVXFK,IIDGLQJPHPRU\LVQRWWKHFDXVHZK\WKHQVKRXOGKH KDYHIDEULFDWHGWKHQDPHV"$WOHDVWWKLVZDVQRWKLVKDELWDV,KDYHVKRZQHOVH ZKHUH ,I =XKUª NQHZ WZR GLIIHUHQW WUDGLWLRQV DERXW ·8PDUnV MXGJPHQW r ,EQ DO 0XVD\\DEnVDQG6XODLPQEDO£D]DUª@ZKRKDGEHHQIRUVRPH WLPHDVWXGHQWRI,EQDO0XVD\\DEnVDQGIURPWKH0HFFDQVFKRODU·$PU>E'ªQU@ ZKROLNHZLVHKDGFRQWDFWVZLWKWKH0HGLQDQ IXTDKº EXW,EQ£XUDL¤GRHVQRWJLYH WKHLQIRUPDQWVIURPZKRPWKHVHVFKRODUVREWDLQHGWKHWUDGLWLRQ0D·PDUTXRWHVLW LQDVKRUWIRUPWKURXJKKLV%D¬UDQFROOHDJXH$\\³E>E$Eª7DPªPD@IURPWKHODW WHUnV WHDFKHU $E³ 4LOED DQG 6XI\Q D±¯DXUª WUDQVPLWV D UHPLQLVFHQFH RI LW YLD §DPPGIURP,EUKªP>DQ1D¦D·ª@ ,WLVQRWSODXVLEOHWRDVVXPHWKDW=XKUªKLPVHOILQYHQWHGDGGLWLRQDOLQIRU PDQWVIRUKHFRXOGPRUHHDVLO\KDYHQDPHGWKHPDOOLQDFROOHFWLYHLVQG LQVWHDGRI  IDEULFDWLQJVSHFLDOWH[WVIRUWKHP$WPRVWZHFDQDVVXPH WKDW =XKUªFRXOGQRWDO ZD\VFRUUHFWO\UHPHPEHUKLVVRXUFHV ZKHQTXRWLQJWKHVWRU\IURPPHPRU\6XFKD K\SRWKHVLVKRZHYHUVHHPVOHVVSODXVLEOHWKDQWKHLGHDWKDWVHYHUDOGLIIHUHQWYHUVLRQV

RIRQHDQGWKHVDPHFDVHZHUHLQFLUFXODWLRQ7KHSHFXOLDULW\WKDW,EQ£XUDL¤QDPHV LQIRUPDQWVRWKHUWKDQ0D·PDUDQG0OLNIRU=XKUªnVWUDGLWLRQVFDQEHH[SODLQHG WKHUHIRUHE\WKHDVVXPSWLRQWKDWKHUHSURGXFHVYDULDQWWUDGLWLRQVRI=XKUªnVZKLFK DUH LQGHSHQGHQWRIWKRVHWUDQVPLWWHGIURPKLPE\0D·PDUDQG0OLN7KHIDFWWKDW WKHKLVWRULFDOEDFNJURXQGRIWKHFDVHLVODFNLQJLQ,EQ£XUDL¤nVYHUVLRQPD\EHLQLWV IDYRXUDVZHOO  :HKDYHFRPSDUHGWKHYDULDQWVRIRQHVLQJOH=XKUªWUDGLWLRQDERXWDYHUGLFW RIWKHFDOLSK·8PDUEDO§D®®EDVFRQWDLQHGLQWKUHHYHU\HDUO\FRUSRUDRIWUDGL WLRQV:KDWLVWKHILQDOUHVXOWRIWKLVFRPSDULVRQ"7KLVWUDGLWLRQSUREDEO\UHDOO\ FRPHVIURP=XKUª6RWKHVWRU\DOUHDG\FLUFXODWHGLQWKHILUVWTXDUWHURIWKHVHFRQG FHQWXU\$+,EQjLKEKDUGO\LQYHQWHGLWKLPVHOIRUSLFNHGLWXSIURPVRPHRQH ZKRVHQDPHKHFRQFHDOHGQDPLQJRWKHUSHUVRQVDVKLVLQIRUPDQWVVLQFHKHUHSRUWV DOVRWKHL¨WLOI LHWKHGLIIHUHQFHV RIRSLQLRQ RIKLVLQIRUPDQWV DQG KHDGPLWVKLV LJQRUDQFHFRQFHUQLQJDGHWDLORIWKHVWRU\WKHTXHVWLRQDVWRKRZ PDQ\ODVKHV ·8 PDU VHQWHQFHG HDFK RIWKH FXOSULWV WR  7KH VWRU\ FHUWDLQO\ JRHV EDFN WR WKH WEL¹µQJHQHUDWLRQLHGDWHV IURP WKH ODVW TXDUWHURIWKH ILUVW FHQWXU\$+ +DYLQJ UHJDUGWRWKHHDUO\GDWHLWVKRZVDFRQVLGHUDEO\KLJKOHYHORIOLWHUDU\VNLOODQGOHJDO UHIOHFWLRQ7KH VWRU\FRQWDLQVPDQ\ IRUPDO HOHPHQWV WKDW DFFRUGLQJ WR6FKDFKWnV FULWHULDDUHWREHFRQVLGHUHGODWHRUVHFRQGDU\DDQLQWURGXFWLRQFRQWDLQLQJQDUUD WLYHHOHPHQWVTL®®DDQGQDPHVRIWKHSHUVRQVLQYROYHGLQWKHFDVHEDYHU\ORQJ DQGFRPSOH[OHJDOVHQWHQFHZKLFKQRWRQO\RIIHUVDVROXWLRQLQDFRQFUHWHFDVHr KHUHDPDUULDJHFRQFOXGHGGXULQJWKHZDLWLQJSHULRGEXWDOVRUHIOHFWVK\SRWKHWLFDO FRQGLWLRQVZKLFKPD\EHUHOHYDQWLQVLPLODUFDVHVWKHPDUULDJHGXULQJWKHZDLWLQJ SHULRG ZLWKRUZLWKRXWFRQVXPPDWLRQ 7KH GLFWXPZKLFKLQ0OLNnVYHUVLRQ FRQVLVWV RI  ZRUGV LV QRW LQ DFFRUGDQFH ZLWK WKH VKRUW oOHJDO PD[LPVp ZKLFK 6FKDFKWSXWDWWKH EHJLQQLQJRIWKH GHYHORSPHQW RI,VODPLF MXULVSUXGHQFH
PDUZHUHWUDQVPLWWHGLQ YDU\LQJYHUVLRQVE\GLIIHUHQW IXTDKº RIWKH WEL¹µQJHQHUD WLRQ WKH VWRU\PXVW JREDFN WRD FRPPRQVRXUFHRUKDYH DKLVWRULFDOFRUH 6LQFH WKHUHLVQRFLUFXPVWDQWLDOHYLGHQFHIRUDFRPPRQVRXUFHZHPXVWDVVXPHDKLVWRUL FDOFRUHHYHQLIQRQHRI=XKUªnVLQIRUPDQWVFDQKDYHUHDOO\H[SHULHQFHGWKHWLPHRI  ·8PDUnVFDOLSKDWHEHFDXVHRIWKHLUDJHOHWDORQHKDYHZLWQHVVHGWKHFDVHLQTXHVWLRQ  :H FDQ LPDJLQHWKDW WKHWUDGLWLRQ WUDQVPLWWHG E\ =XKUª IURP 6XODLPQ E
 9,

2XUDQDO\VLVRID=XKUªWUDGLWLRQDERXW·8PDUKDVVKRZQWKDWWKHUHDUH&RPSDQLRQ WUDGLWLRQVWKDWFDQEHGDWHGWRWKHODVWTXDUWHURUHYHQWKHODVWKDOIRIWKHILUVWFHQ WXU\$+DSRVVLELOLW\ZKLFK6FKDFKWFDWHJRULFDOO\H[FOXGHG7KLVLVRQO\RQH RI  VHYHUDOFDVHVRIHDUO\&RPSDQLRQWUDGLWLRQV%XWZKDWVKRXOGZHWKLQNRI=XKUªnV DªG¬³ IURP WKH 3URSKHWZKLFKDFFRUGLQJWR6FKDFKWEHORQJ LQSULQFLSOHWRDVWLOO \RXQJHUVWDJHRIOHJDOGHYHORSPHQWWKDQWKH&RPSDQLRQWUDGLWLRQV"7KLVLVVXHZLOO EHGLVFXVVHGLQWKHIROORZLQJRQWKHEDVLVRIDQRWKHUH[DPSOH D  
$E³§XDLIDE·8WEDE5DEª·Dr KHEHORQJHGWRWKH&RPSDQLRQVRIWKHPHVVHQJHU RI*RGHXORJ\ DQG WRRNSDUWLQ>WKHEDWWOHRI@%DGU rKDGDGRSWHG6OLP ZKRZDVFDOOHG6OLPWKHPDXORI$E³§XDLIDMXVWDVWKHPHVVHQJHURI*RGHXORJ\ KDGDGRSWHG =DLGE§UL±D $E³§XDLIDKDGPDUULHG6OLP ZKRPKHFRQVLG HUHG KLV VRQ ZLWK WKH GDXJKWHU RI KLV EURWKHU )®LPD ELQW DO:DOªG E ·8WED E 5DEª·D 6KHEHORQJHGDWWKDWWLPH WRWKHILUVWHPLJUDQWVDQGWRWKHQREOHVW PLQ DIDO XQPDUULHGZRPHQRI4XUDLv:KHQ*RGHXORJ\ UHYHDOHGLQKLVERRN ZKDW KHUHYHDOHGDERXW=DLGE§UL±D DQGVDLG o&DOOWKHPDIWHUWKHLUIDWKHUV7KDWLV PRUHHTXLWDEOHLQ*RGnVH\HV,I\RXGRQRWNQRZWKHLUIDWKHUVWKHQ>OHWWKHPEH@\RXU EURWKHUVLQIDLWKDQG\RXUFOLHQWV PDZO¬ p HYHU\RQH RIWKRVH>DGRSWHGVRQV@ ZDV WUDFHG EDFNWRKLVIDWKHU>EXW@ LI KLVIDWKHU ZDV XQNQRZQ KHZDVWUDFHGEDFN UXGGDWRKLVSDWURQPDXO 6DKODELQW6XKDLOrVKHZDV $E³§XDLIDnVZLIHDQGEHORQJHGWRWKH%DQ³·PLUE /X¸D\\rFDPHWRWKHPHVVHQJHURI*RGHXORJ\ DQGVDLGo0HVVHQJHURI*RG :H FRQVLGHUHG 6OLPDV>RXU@VRQZDODG DQGKHZDVXVHGWRFRPHLQWRPH>HYHQ@ZKHQ ,ZDVLQXQGHUZHDUZDDQIXXO ZHKDYHRQO\RQHKRXVH EDLW >LQZKLFKZHFDQQRW OLYHWRJHWKHUVLQFH6OLPLVQRWRXUVRQDQ\PRUH@:KDW LV\RXURSLQLRQDERXWKLV FDVH" 7KHPHVVHQJHURI*RG HXORJ\VDLGWRKHU o6XFNOHKLP>LHJLYHKLPIURP\RXU PLON@ILYHWLPHV¨DPVUD¹W p6RKHEHFDPHSURKLELWHG \DªUXPX >WRPDUU\KHU@ WKURXJKKHUPLON DQGVKHUHJDUGHGKLPDVDoPLONVRQpLEQDQPLQDUUD¹D>DQG FRQVHTXHQWO\KHFRXOGIUHTXHQWKHUZLWKRXWUHVWULFWLRQV@ ·¸LvD WKH oPRWKHU RI WKH EHOLHYHUVp DGRSWHG >WKDW PHWKRG@ ZLWK WKH PHQ VKH ZDQWHG WREHDEOHWRFRPHWRVHHKHUDQGVKHRUGHUHGKHUVLVWHU 8PP.XO±³PELQW $Eª%DNUD¬«LGGªT DQGWKHGDXJKWHUVRIKHUEURWKHUWRVXFNOHZKLFKHYHUPHQ VKH ZDQWHGWRFRPHLQWRVHHKHU 7KHRWKHUZLYHVRIWKH3URSKHWHXORJ\UHIXVHGWROHWDQ\RQH FRPHLQWRWKHPRQWKH EDVLVRIWKDW>IRUPRI@VXFNOLQJ7KH\VDLG o1R E\*RG:HFRQVLGHUWKDWZKDW WKHPHVVHQJHURI*RGHXORJ\ RUGHUHG6DKODELQW6XKDLO >WRGR@RQO\DVDSHUPLV

VLRQRIWKHPHVVHQJHURI*RGHXORJ\ IRUWKHVXFNOLQJRI6OLPDORQH 1R *RG1RERG\FDQFRPHLQWRXVE\WKLV>IRUPRI@VXFNOLQJp

E\

7KLVZDVWKHSUDFWLFH¹DOK¢NQD RIWKHZLYHVRIWKH3URSKHWHXORJ\ FRQFHUQ LQJWKHVXFNOLQJRIDGXOWV

,KDYHSUHVHQWHG0OLNnVWH[WLQWKUHHYHUVLRQVWKHRQHWUDQVPLWWHGE\
DVDZKROHFDQQRWSRVVLEO\KDYHEHHQWROGE\·¸LvDEHFDXVHVKHLVPHQWLRQHGLQLW QRWLQWKHILUVWEXWLQWKHWKLUGSHUVRQ $ILUVW FOXHWRWKHVROXWLRQ RIWKLV SUREOHPLVRIIHUHGE\WKH DQDO\VLV RIWKH WH[WZKLFKLVE\WKHZD\RQHRIWKHPRVWHODERUDWHVWRULHVDPRQJ0OLNnVOHJDOWUD GLWLRQV%\GLYLGLQJWKHWUDQVODWLRQRIWKHWH[WLQWRSDUDJUDSKV,KDYHWULHGVKRZ WKDWLWFRQVLVWVRIIRXULQGHSHQGHQW VWRULHV7KHWUDGLWLRQ VWDUWV ZLWKWKHVWRU\ RI  $E³§XDLIDDQGKLVDGRSWHGVRQ6OLPWKDWLVDVRUWRISURORJXHIRUWKHIROORZLQJ VWRU\DERXW6DKODDQGWKH IDWZRIWKH3URSKHW7ZRUHSRUWVDERXWWKHSUDFWLFHRI  WKH3URSKHWnV ZLYHVDUHDGGHGWKHILUVWFRQFHUQVRQO\·¸LvDWKHVHFRQGGHDOVZLWK WKHRWKHUZLYHVRIWKH3URSKHW7KHFRPSRVLWLRQLVFORVHGE\DFRQFOXGLQJVHQWHQFH WKDWUHFDOOVDJDLQWKHWRSLFRIWKHHQWLUHWUDGLWLRQ ,QYLHZRIWKLVVNLOIXOFRPSRVLWLRQWKHLVVXHRIDXWKRUVKLSPXVWEHEURNHQ GRZQLQWRWKHTXHVWLRQRIZKRLVWKHDXWKRURIWKHHQWLUHFRPSRVLWLRQDQGZKRDUH WKHDXWKRUVRILWVGLIIHUHQWSDUWV7KHTXHVWLRQZKHWKHULWZDV0OLN=XKUªRU·8UZD ZKRWLHGWKHGLVFUHWHWUDGLWLRQVWRJHWKHUFDQQRWEHDQVZHUHGRQWKHEDVLVRI0OLNnV WH[W$FRPSDULVRQZLWKRWKHUHDUO\YHUVLRQVRIWKHWUDGLWLRQZLOOWDNHXVDVWHSIXU WKHU E ·$EGDUUD]]TIURP0D·PDUIURP=XKUªIURP·8UZDIURP·¸LvDVKHVDLG6DKODELQW 6XKDLOE·$PUFDPHWRWKH3URSKHWHXORJ\DQGVDLGo6OLPXVHGWREHFDOOHG \XG¹ DIWHU$E³§XDLIDDQG>QRZ@*RGHXORJ\KDVUHYHDOHGLQKLVERRNm&DOOWKHPDIWHU WKHLUIDWKHUVn+HXVHGWRFRPHLQWRPHZKLOH,ZDVLQXQGHUZHDU  IXXO >DQGWKLVZDV LQHYLWDEOHVLQFH@ZHOLYH>WRJHWKHU@LQDIODWPDQ]LO p7KH3URSKHWHXORJ\VDLGo6XFNOH 6OLP>VRWKDW@\RXDUHIRUELGGHQWDªUXP¬ IRUKLPp =XKUªVDLG6RPHRIWKH3URSKHWnVHXORJ\ZLYHVVDLGo:HGRQRWNQRZZKHWKHUWKLV ZDVRQO\DSHUPLVVLRQJUDQWHGIRU6DOLPDORQH¨®®DWDQ>RUQRW@p =XKUªVDLG>PRUHRYHU@ 8QWLOVKHGLHG ·¸LvD XVHGWRJLYHWKHOHJDODGYLFHWXIW¬ WKDW VXFNOLQJDIWHUZHDQLQJPDNHVIRUELGGHQ>IRUPDUULDJH@

F ·$EGDUUD]]TWUDQVPLWWHGWRXVKHVDLG,EQ£XUDL¤WUDQVPLWWHGWRXVKHVDLG,EQjL KEWUDQVPLWWHGWRPHD¨EDUDQ¬ KHVDLG·8UZDWUDQVPLWWHGWRPHIURP·¸LvD$E³ §XDLIDDGRSWHG6OLPrKHZDVDFOLHQWPDXORIDZRPDQIURPWKH$Q¬UrMXVWDV WKH3URSKHWHXORJ\>DGRSWHG@=DLG,IVRPHRQHDGRSWHGDPDQLQWKH£KLOL\\DSHR SOHFDOOHGKLPKLVVRQDQGKHLQKHULWHGIURPKLVLQKHULWDQFH>7KLVZDVWKHKDELW@XQWLO *RGHXORJ\UHYHDOHGo&DOOWKHPDIWHUWKHLUIDWKHUV,I\RXGRQRWNQRZWKHLUIDWKHUV WKHQ>OHWWKHPEH@\RXUEURWKHUVLQIDLWKp6RWKH\ZHUHWUDFHGEDFNWRWKHLUIDWKHUV >DQG@ZKRHYHUnVIDWKHUZDVXQNQRZQ>EHFDPH@DFOLHQWPDXODQGDEURWKHULQIDLWK $IWHULW>WKHUHYHODWLRQ@6DKODFDPH>WRWKH3URSKHW@DQGVDLGo0HVVHQJHURI*RG :H ZHUHXVHGWRFRQVLGHU6OLPDV>RXU@VRQZDODG ZKROLYHGWRJHWKHUZLWKXVDQGVDZPH LQ XQGHUZHDU  IXXO  *RG KDV >QRZ@ UHYHDOHG ZKDW \RX NQRZp 7KH 3URSKHW VDLG o6XFNOHKLPILYHWLPHV¨DPVUDD¹W p6RKHDFTXLUHGWKHVWDWXVRIKHUoPLONVRQp

7KHVHWZR=XKUªWUDGLWLRQVWKHRQHE\0D·PDUDQGWKHRWKHUE\,EQ£XUDL¤ DUHXQGRXEWHGO\SDUDOOHOWH[WVWR0OLNnV,EQ£XUDLJnVWH[WLVOLPLWHGKRZHYHUWRD VKRUWHQHGYHUVLRQRIWKH6DKODVWRU\DQGLWVSURORJXHDQGLWLJQRUHVWKHUHDFWLRQVRI  WKH3URSKHWnVZLYHVWRKLV IDWZ7KHWKUHHWH[WVFRUUHVSRQGPDLQO\LQFRQWHQWHYHQ WKRXJKPDQ\FRUUHVSRQGHQFHVLQZRUGLQJRFFXU7KHUHDUHDOVRFRQWUDGLFWLRQV$F FRUGLQJWR0D·PDUIRUH[DPSOHWKHZLYHVRIWKH3URSKHWDSDUWIURP·¸LvDFRQ IHVVHGWKDWWKH\GLGQRWNQRZZKHWKHUWKH IDWZRIWKH3URSKHWZDVPHDQWJHQHUDOO\ ZKHUHDV LQ0OLNnV YHUVLRQ WKH\ YHKHPHQWO\ UHMHFW LWV JHQHUDO LQWHUSUHWDWLRQ 7KLV GLIIHUHQFHFDQEHDVFULEHGWRDQLPSUHFLVHZD\RIUHWHOOLQJWKH VWRU\VLQFH0D·PDU GLGNQRZWKHQHJDWLYHDWWLWXGHRIWKHRWKHUZLYHVRIWKH3URSKHWDVZHOODVZHVKDOO VHHEHORZ,EQ£XUDL¤nVDQG0D·PDUnVYHUVLRQVWDOO\ZLWKHDFKRWKHUDJDLQVW0OLNnV LQWKDWWKH\WUDFHWKH6DKODVWRU\EDFNYLD·8UZDWR·¸LvD6LQFHWZRVWXGHQWVLQGH SHQGHQWO\UHSRUWWKLVLVQG IURP=XKUªLWPXVWEHKLV7KLVILQGLQJ KHOSVXVWRDQ VZHUWKHTXHVWLRQDVNHGDERYHDVWRZK\·$EGDUUD]]TFRPSOHWHG0OLNnV LVQG ,W VHHPVOLNHO\WKDWKHGLGVREHFDXVHKHUHDOLVHGWKDWLQ=XKUªnVWUDQVPLVVLRQWKHFRUH RIWKH WUDGLWLRQWKH 6DKODVWRU\ ZDVRULJLQDOO\DVFULEHGWR·¸LvDUDWKHUWKDQEH FDXVHKHZDQWHGWRIDNHDQXQEURNHQWUDQVPLVVLRQFKDLQIRUD ªDG¬³ RIWKH3URSKHW

,Q0D·PDUnVYHUVLRQ=XKUªGRHVQRWUHIHUH[SOLFLWO\WR·8UZDZKHQUHSRUWLQJ WKHOHJDORSLQLRQVRI·¸LvDDQGWKHRWKHUZLYHVRIWKH3URSKHW :HFDQRQO\LQIHU IURP0D·PDUnV LVQG RIWKH6DKODVWRU\WKDW·8UZDPD\EH=XKUªnVLQIRUPDQWIRU WKHVHSDUWVDVZHOO·$®¸@VDLGo1Rp,VDLG>WR KLP@o,VWKLV\RXUUDº\"p+HVDLGoPRUHRYHU@o·¸LvDRUGHUHG>WRGR@WKDW WRWKHGDXJKWHUVRIKHUEURWKHUNQDW¹ºLvDWDºPXUXEL¢OLNDEDQWLD¨¬Kp

7KHODVWVHQWHQFHLVREYLRXVO\DUHIHUHQFHWRWKHWUDGLWLRQDERXW·¸LvDDVLWLV IRXQGLQ0OLNnVYHUVLRQRI,EQjLKEnV·8UZDWUDGLWLRQFRQFHUQLQJWKHVXFNOLQJRI  DGXOWV %XW ZKR LV·$®¸nV VRXUFH IRU LW" $V ·8UZD ZDV DQ ROGHU FRQWHPSRUDU\ RI  ·$®¸nVDQGH[SOLFLWO\KLVLQIRUPDQWIRUVHYHUDOWUDGLWLRQVZHFDQDVVXPHWKDWKH ZDV·$®¸nVVRXUFHIRUWKLVWUDGLWLRQDVZHOOZKHUHDVZHFDQH[FOXGH·$®¸nVKDYLQJ KHDUGLWIURPWKH\RXQJHU=XKUªIURPZKRPDVIDUDV,NQRZKHGLGQRWWUDQVPLW  :DV ·8UZD DOVR =XKUªnV VRXUFH IRU WKH RSLQLRQ RI WKH RWKHU ZLYHV RI WKH 3URSKHW"7KLVFDQQRWEHUXOHG RXW FRPSOHWHO\EXWLW VHHPV GRXEWIXOLQYLHZ RID =XKUªWUDGLWLRQWUDQVPLWWHGE\,EQ6D·GYLD:TLGªIURP0D·PDU 0X¨DPPDGE·8PDUWUDQVPLWWHGWRPH0D·PDUDQG0X¨DPPDGE·$EGDOOKWUDQVPLW WHG WR PH IURP =XKUª IURP $E³ ·8EDLGD IURP ·$EGDOOK E =DPD·D IURP KLV PRWKHU 8PP 6DODPD VKH VDLG 7KH ZLYHV RI WKH 3URSKHW HXORJ\ UHIXVHG WR DGRSW WKDW >ZKDW ·¸LvDZDVGRLQJ@7KH\VDLGo7KLVLVRQO\DSHUPLVVLRQRIWKHPHVVHQJHURI*RGHXORJ\ IRU6DKODELQW6XKDLO>DORQH@p

$FFRUGLQJWRWKLVUHSRUW=XKUªGLGQRWREWDLQKLVWUDGLWLRQDERXWWKHRSLQ LRQ RIWKH RWKHU ZLYHV RI WKH 3URSKHW IURP ·8UZD EXW IURP DQRWKHU LQIRUPDQW

$E³·8EDLGD ZKRILQDOO\WUDFHVWKHVWRU\EDFNWRRQHRIWKHZLYHVRIWKH3URSKHW 8PP6DODPDDQROGRSSRQHQWRI·¸LvDnV,I WKLVLVWUXHZHPXVWFRQFOXGHWKDW 0OLNRPLWWHGWKDWSDUWLFXODULVQG DQGDVFULEHGDOOSDUWVRI=XKUªnVVWRU\WR·8UZD  :HGRQRWNQRZKLVUHDVRQVIRUGRLQJVR0RUHRYHU0OLNOHIWRXW·¸LvDnVQDPHLQ WKHLVQG +HKDGUHDVRQVWRGRWKDWEHFDXVHVKHFRXOGEHWKHVRXUFHRIQHLWKHUWKH UHSRUWDERXWKHURZQSUDFWLFHLQZKLFKVKHLVPHQWLRQHGLQWKHWKLUGSHUVRQQRU WKHWUDGLWLRQDERXWWKHREMHFWLRQVRIWKHRWKHUZLYHVRIWKH3URSKHWZKLFKLVFOHDUO\ FULWLFDORI·¸LvD 0D·PDUnVYHUVLRQRIWKH6DKODVWRU\UHYHDOVILQDOO\WKDWLWZDV=XKUªZKRKDG DOUHDG\SXWWRJHWKHUWKH$E³§XDLID6OLP6DKODWUDGLWLRQ ZLWKWKHUHSRUWV DERXW WKHSUDFWLFHRIRSLQLRQVRIWKH3URSKHWnVZLYHVIRU0D·PDUnVDQG0OLNnVWUDQVPLV VLRQFRLQFLGHLQWKLVUHVSHFW $FRPSDULVRQRIWKHVHYHUDOYDULDQWVWUDQVPLWWHGIURP=XKUªWKXVOHDGVWRWKH FRQFOXVLRQWKDWHLWKHU=XKUªKLPVHOIFLUFXODWHGWKHWUDGLWLRQVDERXWWKHVXFNOLQJRI  DGXOWVDWGLIIHUHQWSHULRGVRIWLPHLQYDU\LQJIRUPRUWKDWKLVVWXGHQWVDUHUHVSRQ VLEOHIRUWKHGLIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQWKHWH[WV,IWKHODWWHUK\SRWKHVLVLVFRUUHFW0OLNnV YHUVLRQPXVWEHFRQVLGHUHGWKHRQHWKDWEHVWSUHVHUYHG=XKUªnVRULJLQDOWH[WDSDUW IURPWKHLVQG %\FRQWUDVWWKHYHUVLRQVRI0D·PDUDQG,EQ£XUDL¤ORRNOLNHDE EUHYLDWHGYHUVLRQV2QHFRXOGDOVRDVVXPHRIFRXUVHWKDW=XKUªnVRULJLQDOYHUVLRQ ZDVVKRUWDQGWKDW0OLNH[SDQGHGLWEXWWKLVLVOHVVOLNHO\LQYLHZRIWKHFRUUH VSRQGHQFHEHWZHHQ0OLNnVYHUVLRQDQG·$®¸nVUHIHUHQFHWRWKHVWRU\ZKLFKVKRZV WKDWWKHUHSRUWDERXW·¸LvDZDVDOUHDG\SDUWRIWKHRULJLQDOYHUVLRQ:KDWHYHUWKH FDVHWKHLPSRUWDQWUHVXOWWKDWRXUFRPSDULVRQRIHDUO\YDULDQWVRID3URSKHWLFDO ªDG¬³  SURGXFHV LV WKDW LW LV DQ DXWKHQWLF =XKUª WUDGLWLRQ LH UHDOO\ JRHV EDFN WR =XKUª  :KDWVKRXOGZHWKLQNRI=XKUªnVFODLPKRZHYHUWKDWKHREWDLQHGWKH6DKOD VWRU\ DQGWKHUHSRUWDERXW·¸LvDnVSUDFWLFHIURP ·8UZDED]=XEDLUGRU

" 7KHUHDUHVHYHUDO DUJXPHQWVDJDLQVWWKHDVVXPSWLRQWKDW=XKUªLQYHQWHG WKHWUDGLWLRQDERXWWKHVXFNOLQJRIDGXOWVKLPVHOI)LUVWRQHFDQSRLQWWRWKHIDFW WKDWWKHWUDGLWLRQHQGVZLWKDQ L¨WLOI DGLIIHUHQFHRIRSLQLRQEHWZHHQWKHZLYHVRI  WKH3URSKHWZKLFKOHDYHVRSHQWKHTXHVWLRQDERXWWKHDXWKRUnVRZQSRLQWRIYLHZ 6HFRQGO\ZHNQRZIURPDQRWKHUHDUO\WUDGLWLRQUHSRUWLQJ=XKUªnV UDº\WKDWKHRE MHFWHGWRWKHSUDFWLFHGHVFULEHGLQWKHDªG¬³ IURPWKH3URSKHWDQG·¸LvD ,WLV KDUG WRLPDJLQH WKDW =XKUª IDNHG WKRVH DªG¬³  WKDWZHUH FRPSOHWHO\ LQFRQVLVWHQW ZLWKKLVRZQOHJDORSLQLRQRUWKDWKHZRXOGKDYHDFFHSWHGWKHPIURPVRPHRQHKH GLGQRWNQRZYHU\ZHOO )XUWKHUPRUHWKHUHIHUHQFHRIWKH0HFFDQVFKRODU·$®¸WR WKHSUDFWLFHRI·¸LvDVXJJHVWVDVDUJXHGDERYHWKDW·8UZDZDVWKHVRXUFHRIWKHWUD GLWLRQ7KLVDOOWHQGVWRVXSSRUWWKHDVVXPSWLRQ WKDW=XKUªUHDOO\UHFHLYHGWKHWUDGL WLRQIURP·8UZDDVKHFODLPVLQKLV LVQG  ,Q·8UZDnVFDVHZHFDQDVNWKHVDPHTXHVWLRQV,VKHWKHDXWKRURIWKHWH[WV" 'LGKHDFWXDOO\REWDLQKLVLQIRUPDWLRQIURP·¸LvDDVFODLPHGLQWKHLVQG ":HFDQ RQO\ZHLJKWKHSURVDQGFRQVRIWKHHYLGHQFHRIIHUHGE\WKHWH[WV7KHUHLVDQDUJX PHQWDJDLQVWWKHDVVXPSWLRQWKDW·8UZDLQYHQWHGWKHWUDGLWLRQLQTXHVWLRQWKHIDFW WKDWKHKLPVHOIDQGRWKHU0HGLQDQ IXTDKº RIKLVJHQHUDWLRQVXFKDVWKHOHDGLQJ VFKRODU,EQDO0XVD\\DEGLVDSSURYHGRIWKHVXFNOLQJRIDGXOWVDQGGHQLHGWKDWLW KDGDQ\OHJDOFRQVHTXHQFHV ,WGRHVQRWVHHPUHDVRQDEOHWRDVVXPHWKDW·8UZDIDE ULFDWHGD ªDG¬³ IURPWKH3URSKHWWKDWFRQWUDGLFWHGKLVRZQOHJDOGRFWULQHVREOD WDQWO\
GXULQJWKHOLIHRIWKH3URSKHW&LUFXPVWDQWLDOHYLGHQFHIRUWKLVDVVXPSWLRQPD\EH WKDW8PP6DODPDLQWKHWUDGLWLRQWUDQVPLWWHGIURPKHUGRHVQRWGLVSXWHWKHHYHQW DVVXFKZKLFKZHZRXOGH[SHFW LI·¸LvDKDGLQYHQWHGWKHHQWLUHVWRU\ 7KHUHVXOWVRIRXUVRXUFHFULWLFDODQDO\VLVFRQWUDVWVKDUSO\ZLWK6FKDFKWnVLGHDV DERXWWKLV W\SHRI OHJDO WUDGLWLRQ 6FKDFKW ZRXOG QRW KDYH DFFHSWHG WKDW 0OLNnV ªDG¬³ DERXWWKHVXFNOLQJRIDGXOWVLVHDUO\EHFDXVHRILWVOHQJWKWKHQDUUDWLYHHOH PHQWVDQGWKHQDPHVFRQWDLQHGLQLWDQGODVWEXWQRWOHDVWEHFDXVH RIWKHVLPSOH IDFWWKDWLWLVDWUDGLWLRQIURPWKH3URSKHW6FKDFKWZRXOGKDYHVHHQYDULRXVWHQGHQ FLHVDWZRUNLQWKLVWUDGLWLRQDQGZRXOGKDYHDUJXHGDVIROORZV 7KHSDUWRIWKHWUDGLWLRQZKLFKGHVFULEHVWKHSUDFWLFHRI·¸LvDLVDSURGXFWRI  WKHoWUDGLWLRQLVWVpDLPHGDWFKDQJLQJWKHGRFWULQHRIWKHROG0HGLQDQVFKRRORIMX ULVSUXGHQFH7KLVRULJLQDOO\DQRQ\PRXVGRFWULQHWKDWZDVSUREDEO\DGYRFDWHGE\ =XKUª KDG VRPHZKDW HDUOLHU EHHQ ILFWLWLRXVO\ DVFULEHG WR ,EQ DO0XVD\\DE DQG ·8UZDED]=XEDLU,QWKHIRUJHG·¸LvDWUDGLWLRQDW\SLFDO WDFWLFRIWKHoWUDGLWLRQ LVWVpFDQEHVHHQQDPHO\DWWULEXWLQJWKHLUoFRXQWHUWUDGLWLRQVpWRWKHVDPHSHUVRQV ZKRDUHFODLPHGE\WKHoDQFLHQWVFKRROVpDVUHSUHVHQWDWLYHVRIWKHLUGRFWULQHLQWKLV FDVH=XKUª,EQDO0XVD\\DEDQG6XODLPQE
IRXQGLQWKH 0XZD°°Dº PXVWWKHQEHGDWHGWRDURXQGWKHPLGGOHRIWKHVHFRQGFHQ WXU\$+ 6FKDFKWGLGQRWGHDOZLWKWKLVWUDGLWLRQDVWKRURXJKO\DV,GLGKHUHLQDGRSW LQJKLVPHWKRGRIUHDVRQLQJ+HRQO\JDYHKLQWVDVWRKRZWRLQWHUSUHWLW 
7RVXPPDULVHWKHDUJXPHQWVSUHVHQWHGLQWKLVDUWLFOHOHWXVUHWXUQWRWKHVWDUWLQJ SRLQW $FFRUGLQJWRWKH YLHZGHFLVLYHO\VKDSHGE\WKHZULWLQJVRI-RVHSK 6FKDFKW DQGVLQFHWKHQFXUUHQWDPRQJ:HVWHUQVFKRODUVRI,VODPWKHQXPEHURIUHOLDEOHOH JDOWUDGLWLRQVJRLQJEDFNWR,EQjLKED]=XKUªLVYHU\VPDOO,WPXVWEHOLPLWHGWR WKHLQIRUPDWLRQDERXW=XKUªnV UDº\ZKLFK0OLNLQKLV 0XZD°°Dº H[SOLFLWO\VD\VKH KHDUGKLPVHOIRUDVNHG=XKUªDERXW7KLVYLHZKDVEHHQFKDOOHQJHGLQWKLVDUWLFOH $SDUWIURPWKH 0XZD°°Dº RWKHUHDUO\VRXUFHVKDYHEHFRPHDYDLODEOHVLQFHWKHSXEOL FDWLRQRI6FKDFKWnV 2ULJLQVWKDWFDQEHXVHGIRUDUHFRQVWUXFWLRQRI=XKUªnVOHJDO GRFWULQHVDQGWUDGLWLRQV$VRXUFHFULWLFDOVWXG\RIWKHHDUO\VRXUFHVQRZDYDLODEOH VKRZVWKDWWKHQXPEHURIWH[WVWKDWFDQEHDWWULEXWHGWR=XKUªLVPXFKODUJHUWKDQ 6FKDFKWWKRXJKW$FRPSDULVRQRIWKH=XKUªWH[WVSUHVHUYHGLQHDUO\VRXUFHVOHDGVWR WKHFRQFOXVLRQWKDWKLVOHJDOWHDFKLQJGLGQRWDWDOOFRQVLVWRI UDº\DORQHEXWDOVR LQFOXGHGrIRUDQLPSRUWDQWSDUWWUDGLWLRQVDERXWWKHOHJDORSLQLRQVDQGWKHSUDF WLFH RI WKH SUHFHGLQJ JHQHUDWLRQV RI 0XVOLPV 6XFFHVVRUV &RPSDQLRQV DQG WKH 3URSKHW 2QWKHEDVLVRIWKHQXPHURXVOHJDOWH[WVWKDW=XKUªnVVWXGHQWVWUDQVPLWWHG LQ WKHLU FRPSLODWLRQV D GHWDLOHG SLFWXUH RI KLV MXULVSUXGHQFH FDQ EH GUDZQ %XW

ZKDWLVPRUHWKHVWDWHRI GHYHORSPHQWZKLFK,VODPLFMXULVSUXGHQFHKDGUHDFKHGLQ WKHILUVWTXDUWHURIWKHVHFRQGFHQWXU\$+FDQEHUHFRQVWUXFWHGDQGSDUWO\HYHQ WKHSUHOLPLQDU\VWDJHVRIWKHILUVWFHQWXU\7KHVRXUFHVDUHQRZDYDLODEOHWRYHQWXUH RQVXFKUHFRQVWUXFWLRQV

1RWHV  7KLVLVWKH(QJOLVKYHUVLRQRIP\DUWLFOHo'HU)LTKGHVr=XKUªGLH4XHOOHQSUREOHPDWLNpZKLFK ZDVSXEOLVKHGLQ'HU,VODP  ,ZLVKWR WKDQN 6HUJLR1RMD 1RVHGD ZKR HQFRXUDJHGWKH WUDQVODWLRQDQGSXEOLVKHGDILUVWXQUHYLVHGYHUVLRQLQWKHMRXUQDO 7DTXLQR7DTZ¬P0LVV %DUEDUD3DROLZKRPDGHDILUVWWUDQVODWLRQDQG0UV9LYLHQ5HLGZKRFDUHIXOO\UHYLVHGWKHWUDQVOD WLRQ &I IRU =XKUªnV ELRJUDSK\ - +RURYLW] o$O=XKUªp LQ (Q]\NORSÀGLH GHV ,VOP  HGLWLRQ /HL GHQ/HLS]LJYROSS -6FKDFKW7KH2ULJLQVRI0XKDPPDGDQ-XULVSUXGHQFH/RQGRQS(PSKDVLVPLQH ,ELGHP(PSKDVLVPLQH ,ELGHP(PSKDVLVPLQH &IRSFLWSS 2SFLWS 2S FLWS (PSKDVLVPLQH$ VLPLODU MXGJHPHQW FRQFHUQLQJ =XKUªnV WUDQVPLVVLRQVZDV PDGH E\ *+$ -X\QEROO LQ KLV ERRN  0XVOLP 7UDGLWLRQ 6WXGLHV LQ &KURQRORJ\ 3URYHQDQFH DQG   $XWKRUVKLSRIHDUO\©DG¬WK&DPEULGJHSoeLWLVQRORQJHUSRVVLEOHWRVLIWWKHJHQXLQH =XKUªWUDGLWLRQVIURPWKHIDEULFDWHGRQHVRUDVLVP\FRQWHQWLRQHYHQWKHJHQXLQH,EQ6KLKEDO =XKUªWUDGLWLRQVIURPWKHSRVVLEOHKXQGUHGVRISVHXGR=XKUªRQHVp 0OLN 0XZD°°Dº TXRWHGLVWKHQXPEHURIWKHERRNDQGDIWHUWKHFRORQVWKHQXPEHUXQGHU ZKLFKWKHWUDQVPLVVLRQLQWKHFXUUHQWHGLWLRQRI0)·$EGDOETªLVIRXQG 0OLN 0XZD°°Dº  &IP\ERRN $QIÀQJHGHULVODPLVFKHQ-XULVSUXGHQ],KUH(QWZLFNOXQJLQ0HNNDELV]XU0LWWHGHV  -DKUKXQGHUWV6WXWWJDUWDQGWKHDUWLFOHo7KH 0X®DQQDI RI·$EGDO5D]]TDO«DQ·QªDVDVRXUFH RIDXWKHQWLFDªG¬WKRIWKHILUVW,VODPLFFHQWXU\pLQ -RXUQDORI1HDU(DVWHUQ6WXGLHV 6HHWKHSUHFHGLQJQRWH 7KHSHUFHQWDJHVDUHURXQGHG7KH\DUHEDVHGRQDVDPSOHRIWH[WVRI0D·PDUnVFRQWDLQHG LQWKHERRNVo.LWEDQ1LNªpDQGo.LWED°¯DOTpRI·$EGDUUD]]TnV 0X®DQQDI LHYRODQG QRV7KLVVDPSOHLVUHSUHVHQWDWLYHIRUPRVWRIWKHERRNVRIWKH 0X®DQQDI  &I·$EGDUUD]]T 0X®DQQDI )RUWKHGLIIHUHQWJHQUHVFI0RW]NL $QIÀQJHSS )RU H[DPSOH ·$EGDUUD]]T 0X®DQQDI   ,Q =XKUªnV WH[WV WKLV JHQUH DSSHDUV ILYH WLPHVPRUHRIWHQ )UHTXHQF\LQ=XKUªnVLQ4DWGDnVWH[WV 7KLVRFFDVLRQDOO\RFFXUVLQWUDGLWLRQVDVZHOO&IIRUH[DPSOH·$EGDUUD]]T 0X®DQQDI &I·$EGDUUD]]T 0X®DQQDI &I·$EGDUUD]]T 0X®DQQDI &I·$EGDUUD]]T 0X®DQQDI ·$EGDUUD]]T 0X®DQQDI $GGLWLRQVLQVTXDUHEUDFNHWVDUHDGGHGE\PHIRUDEHWWHUXQGHUVWDQGLQJ ·$EGDUUD]]T 0X®DQQDI %XWVXFKFDVHVFDQEHIRXQGVSRUDGLFDOO\DVLQ·$EGDUUD]]T 0X®DQQDI ·$EGDUUD]]T 0X®DQQDI &I6FKDFKW2ULJLQVS )RU 4DWGD DV WUDGLWLRQLVW DFFRUGLQJ WR ELRJUDSKLFDO VRXUFHV FI * 9LWHVWDP o4DWGD E 'L·PDDV6DG³VªHWODVFLHQFHGX ªDG¬³ pLQ 9&RQJUÄVLQWHUQDWLRQDOGnDUDELVDQWVHWGnLVODPLVDQWV  $FWHV%UX[HOOHVSS &I,EQ6D·G¯DEDTW YROS%X¦Uª 7DºU¬¨YROSSDKDEª 7D¢NLUDYRO SS,EQ§D¤DU 7DK¢¬EYROSS7KDWLVRQO\DVHOHFWLRQRIVRXUFHV2WKHULP ∗

 SRUWDQWELRJUDSKLFDOWUDGLWLRQVDERXW0D·PDUDUHWREHIRXQGLQ,EQ·$VNLUnV 7DºU¬¨0DG¬QDW  'LPDvTDQGDKDEªnV6L\DUD¹OPDQQXEDOº  &I,EQDO0DGªQª ¹,ODODOªDG¬³ SII ) 6H]JLQ ZDV RQH RI WKH ILUVWWRPHQWLRQ LW LQKLV DUWLFOH o+DGLV PXVDQQHIDWLQLQ PHEGHL YH 0D·PHUE5¼|LGnLQ&¼PL·LpLQ7ØUNL\DW SS0-.LVWHUZDVRQHRIWKHILUVWXVLQJ LWHYHQEHIRUHLWZDVSXEOLVKHG&IKLVDUWLFOHo§DGGLWK³·DQEDQª LVU¸ªODZDO¨DUDMDpLQ ,VUDHO  2ULHQWDO6WXGLHVSS &I0RW]NL $QIÀQJHS 7KH IROORZLQJREVHUYDWLRQVDUHEDVHG RQ WKHVDPHWH[WFRUSXV DVLQWKHSUHYLRXVFKDSWHUVHH QRWH &I0RW]NL $QIÀQJHS &I·$EGDUUD]]T 0X®DQQDI,EQ£XUDL¤r$\\v,EQjLKE &I·$EGDUUD]]T 0X®DQQDI 7KHELRJUDSKLFDOLQIRUPDWLRQDERXWKLPKDVEHHQPDLQO\WDNHQIURPWKHIROORZLQJZRUNV,EQ 6D·G¯DEDTW YROSYROS§DOªIDE¥D\\® ¯DEDTW S%X¦Uª7DºU¬¨ YROS,EQ4XWDLED 0D¹ULI S,EQ$Eª§WLP 7DTGLPDSDVVLPLG ¥DUªYRO S,EQ§LEEQ 0DvK¬U QDQGRWKHUVLG±LTW YROS,EQDQ1DGªP )LKULVW S%D¢GGª 7DºU¬¨YROSLG .LI\DSjªU]ª¯DEDTW S 1DZDZª7DK¢¬EYROS,EQ¥DOOLNQ :DID\W YROSDKDEª 'XZDO S LG 0¬]QYROSLG7D¢NLUDS,EQ§D¤DU7DK¢¬EYROS)RUDGHWDLOHG DQDO\VLVRIWKLVWH[WVHH0RW]NL $QIÀQJHS 6HHDERYHS &I%D¢GGª7DºU¬¨YROSjªU]ª¯DEDTW S,EQ§D¤DU 7DK¢¬EYROS,EQ $Eª§WLP¥DUªYROS,EQDQ1DGªP)LKULVW S &I ,EQ §DQEDO ¹,ODO  YRO  S  %D¢GGª 7DºU¬ª YRO  S  YRO  S  DKDEª 7D¢NLUDYROS,EQ$Eª§WLP¥DUªYROS &I,EQ§D¤DU7DK¢¬EYROS,EQ$Eª§WLP7DTGLPDS%D¢GGª7DºU¬¨YROS $E³¥DL±DPD·,OPSQ &I%D¢GGª.LI\DSLG7DºU¬¨YROS,EQ§D¤DU7DK¢¬EYROS DKDEª7D¢NLUDYROS &I,EQ$Eª§WLP7DTGLPDSDKDEª7D¢NLUDYROS,EQ§D¤DU 7DK¢¬EYROS  ·$EGDUUD]]T 0X®DQQDI ,WIROORZVDQRWHDERXWWKHQDPHRIWKHZRPDQZKLFKSUREDEO\ EHORQJHGRULJLQDOO\WRWKHSUHFHGLQJWUDGLWLRQ)RUH[DPSOHVRI VDP¹FI·$EGDUUD]]T 0X®DQQDI )RUDEHWWHUXQGHUVWDQGLQJRIWKHWH[WLWKDVWREHQRWHGWKDWWKHUHSRUWHGGHFLVLRQRI  WKHFDOLSK·8±PQVKDWWHUHGWKHSODQRIDPDQZKRGXULQJKLVLOOQHVVNQHZKHZRXOGGLHVHSD UDWHGIURPKLVZLIHWR H[FOXGHKHU IURPKLVLQKHULWDQFH DQG WRDYRLG WKH 4XU¸QLF LQKHULWDQFH UXOHV 7RVKRZLWLQGHWDLODVSHFLDODQDO\VLVZRXOGEHQHFHVVDU\ ,QWKHIROORZLQJWKHUHFHQVLRQRIWKH 0XZD°°Dº E\
 &IWKHSUHFHGLQJQRWH &I6FKDFKW 2ULJLQVSI*+$-X\QEROOKDVH[SUHVVHGVLPLODUUHVHUYDWLRQVDERXWWKLV LVQG o9HU\PDQ\IRUJHGWUDGLWLRQVVXSSRUWHGE\WKLV LVQG SUREDEO\RULJLQDWHGGXULQJ0OLNnV OLIHWLPHp 0XVOLP7UDGLWLRQS &ISDERYHDQGWKHELRJUDSKLFDOWUDGLWLRQVRQ0OLNLQ,EQ§D¤DU7DK¢¬EYROSS &I,EQ§D¤DU7DK¢¬EYROS &I6FKDFKW2ULJLQVS 2SFLWS 6HHEHORZS 2IDVLPLODURSLQLRQDUH-5REVRQo7KH ,VQG LQ0XVOLP7UDGLWLRQpLQ 7UDQVDFWLRQVRIWKH *ODVJRZ8QLYHUVLW\2ULHQWDO6RFLHW\ SIDQG00$]DPL 6WXGLHVLQ(DUO\©DGLWK/LW HUDWXUH HGLWLRQ,QGLDQDSROLVSIDQGLG 2Q6FKDFKWnV2ULJLQVRI0XKDPPDGDQ-XULV  SUXGHQFH5L\DGS &I0OLN 0XZD°°Dº QRWLQP\VDPSOH &I6FKDFKWo0OLNE$QDVpLQ(QF\FORSDHGLDRI,VODP  HGYROSS 2SFLWS &IDKDEª7D¢NLUDYROS 2SFLWS)RUDGLVFXVVLRQRIWKLVUHSRUWFIDOVR+0RW]NLo  4XRYDGLV©DG¬³ )RUVFKXQJ" (LQHNULWLVFKH8QWHUVXFKXQJYRQ*+$-X\QEROOm1IL·WKH PDZORI,EQ·8PDUDQGKLVSRVL WLRQLQ0XVOLP ©DG¬WK/LWHUDWXUHoLQ'HU,VODPSSHVS &I,EQ§D¤DU7DK¢¬EYROSS &I·$EGDUUD]]T 0X®DQQDI  ·$EGDUUD]]T 0X®DQQDI  )RUWKLVVHQWHQFHWKHUHLVDOVRDVSHFLDOWUDQVPLVVLRQE\0D·PDUFI·$EGDUUD]]T  0X®DQQDI   ·$EGDUUD]]T 0X®DQQDI  ·$EGDUUD]]T 0X®DQQDI )RUWKHFRQFHSWRILª®QFI+0RW]NLo:DOPXª®DQWXPLQDQ QLVº¬LOOPPDODNDWDLPQXNXP.RUDQXQGGLHNRUDQLVFKH6H[XDOHWKLNpLQ 'HU,VODP  ZLWKIXUWKHUOLWHUDWXUH ·$EGDUUD]]T 0X®DQQDI  &IDPRQJRWKHUVWKH=XKUªWH[WVFROOHFWHGE\·$EGDUUD]]TXQGHUWKHWLWOHo%EDUUD¦PZDO Lª®Qp 0X®DQQDI YROSSII )RUVLPLODUFDVHVFRQFHUQLQJ·$®¸E$Eª5DE¨FI0RW]NL $QIÀQJHS 0OLN 0XZD°°Dº  /DFNLQJLQWKHPDQXVFULSWSUREDEO\GXHWRDQWUDQVPLVVLRQHUURU ·$EGDUUD]]T 0X®DQQDI  7KHWH[WRIWKHHGLWLRQKDV0D·PDUEXWWKLVLVFHUWDLQO\DQHUURUIRULQ0D·PDUnV DVQ¬G WKH QDPH=XKUªLVDOZD\VXVHG ·$EGDUUD]]T 0X®DQQDI  0OLN 0XZD°°DºFKDS ·$EGDUUD]]T 0X®DQQDI  &IWKHLQWURGXFWLRQE\·$EGDOZDKKE·$EGDOOD®ªIWKHHGLWRURIjDLEQªnV  0XZD°°Dº UHFHQVLRQ S 2SFLWS$VVRXUFHVDKDEªnV 0DQTLE$E¬©DQ¬IDDQG§D®ªEDO%D¢GGªnV7DºU¬NK%D¤GG  DUHPHQWLRQHGQRWH joWKHGDXJKWHURIDO¨DE·8EDLGDOOKpLQVWHDGRIXODL¨DDO$VDGL\\D7KHOHWWHUjUHIHUVWR jDLEQªnVULZ\DRIWKH 0XZD°°Dº  jDGGV$E³6D·ªGE0XQDEELKRU$E³O£XOVE0XQD\\D jODP\DQNDªK LQjODFNLQJ jIURPKHUYDJLQD

 0OLN 0XZD°°Dº LG 0XZD°°Dº jQR 7KLVGRHVQRWSUHFOXGHWKDW0OLNQHYHUWKHOHVVUHFHLYHGWKHWUDGLWLRQIURP=XKUª ·$EGDUUD]]T 0X®DQQDI  ·$EGDUUD]]T 0X®DQQDI  7KLVQDPHZDVSUREDEO\ORVWDVWKHFRQWH[WRIWKHWUDGLWLRQVVKRZ ·$EGDUUD]]T 0X®DQQDI  )RU DO¨D E ·8EDLGDOOK RQH RI WKH SURPLQHQW &RPSDQLRQV FI : 0DGHOXQJ oDO¨D E ·8ED\G$OOKpLQ(QF\FORSDHGLDRI,VODP HGLWLRQYROSS )RUWKLVVFKRODUDQGWKHSUREOHPVRILGHQWLILFDWLRQFI0RW]NL $QIÀQJHSS ·$EGDUUD]]T 0X®DQQDI ,EQ6D·GPHQWLRQVDPDQFDOOHGXODL¨DDO$VDGªLQKLV ¯DEDTW EXWJLYHVQRIXUWKHULQIRUPDWLRQDERXWKLP &I·$EGDUUD]]T 0X®DQQDI 0D·PDU 7KLVHOHPHQWRIWKHQDPHSUREDEO\ZDVGURSSHGE\FDUHOHVVQHVVGXULQJWKHODWHUWUDQVPLVVLRQRI  WKHWH[WRUWKHHGLWLQJSURFHVV$VDUXOH=XKUªGRHVQRWWUDQVPLWIURP·8WED ·$EGDUUD]]T 0X®DQQDI  6HHDERYHS &I0RW]NL $QIÀQJHSDVVLP ·$EGDUUD]]T 0X®DQQDI ,QWKHILUVWWZRWH[WVo5XvDLGD±¯DTDIªpDSSHDUVDV WKHQDPHRI WKH VHFRQG KXVEDQG7KLVDFFRUGVZLWK0D·PDUnVYHUVLRQVHHWH[WE DQG WKLVZDV SUREDEO\,EQDO0XVD\\DEnVWH[W0OLNnVYHUVLRQVHHPVWREHGXHWRDPLVWDNH &IWKHWH[WERI0D·PDURQS jZD7KHWUDQVODWLRQLVEDVHGRQ
 j·$ I¬PEDOD¤DQLVDGGHG·$ZDOOKXD¹ODPXLVDGGHG j·$WDªDUUDPD jELODEDQLNDDXELODEDQLK j·$XPPDOPXºPLQ¬QLVPLVVLQJ ·$WXU¬GXLQVWHDGRIWXªLEEX j·$X¨WDKLVPLVVLQJ joELQW$Eª%DNUD¬«LGGªTpLVPLVVLQJ·$LEQDW LQVWHDGRIELQW oD¬«LGGªTpLVPLVVLQJ j·$DQLVPLVVLQJODKLVDGGHG jDªDEQDLQVWHDGRIDªDEEDW PLQDUUL¦O LVPLVVLQJ ·$DªDGXQPLQDQQVLVPLVVLQJ jOL ¹ºLvDLVDGGHG·$ZDLVPLVVLQJ j·$OLVPLVVLQJ ·$QDE¬ LQVWHDGRIUDVµOXOOKELKL IROORZVWKHVXEMHFWQRWWKHSUHGLFDWH ·$oELQW6XKDLOpLVPLVVLQJ jPLQUDVµOLOOKL  FRPHVRQO\ DWWKHHQG RI WKHVHQWHQFH ODKLVDGGHG·$ PLQUDVµOLOOKL  LV PLVVLQJ ·$HQGRIWKHWH[W jOLVPLVVLQJ jUDº\LVDGGHG jUDVµOLOOKLQVWHDGRIDQQDE¬  0OLN 0XZD°°Dº  0XZD°°Dº jQR·$EGDUUD]]T 0X®DQQDI :HPXVWLPDJLQH WKHoVXFNOLQJpRIDGXOWVLQWKHIRUPRISXWWLQJGURSVRIPRWKHUPLONLQWRDGLVKRUDGULQN ·$EGDUUD]]T 0X®DQQDI  ·$EGDUUD]]T 0X®DQQDI  +HGRHVQRWVSHDNRIDSUDFWLFHRI·¸LvDLQ0D·PDUnVYHUVLRQ ·$EGDUUD]]T 0X®DQQDI &IDOVR0RW]NL $QIÀQJHSSIIDQGLGo7KH 0X®DQQDI RI  ·$EGDO5D]]TpS ,EQ6D·G¯DEDTW YROS 2QKLPFI,EQ§D¤DU7DK¢¬EYROSQR 2QKLPFI*6FKRHOHUo·8UZDEDO=XEDLUpLQ (QF\ORSDHGLDRI,VODP HGLWLRQYROSS  &I·$EGDUUD]]T 0X®DQQDI  7KHUHLVDOVRDELRJUDSKLFDOUHSRUWSUHVHUYHGLQDELRJUDSKLFDOOH[LFRQRI$QGDOXVLDQ ¹XODPº  WKDW=XKUªWUDQVPLWWHGWUDGLWLRQVZKLFKUXQFRXQWHUWRKLVRZQOHJDOGRFWULQHWKH LVQG JRHVEDFN WKURXJK$QGDOXVLDQDQG(J\SWLDQWUDQVPLWWHUVWR·$EGDUUD]]TDQGYLDKLPWR0D·PDU&I§X PDLGª¥D¢ZDWDOPXTWDELV HG0X¨DPPDGE7ZªWD®DQ¤ª.DLURQGSI,RZHWKHUHIHU HQFHWR0)LHUUR &I0OLN 0XZD°°Dº ·$EGDUUD]]T 0X®DQQDI  $WUDGLWLRQWUDQVPLWWHGE\,EQ£XUDL¤IURPKLV0HFFDQWHDFKHU,EQ$Eª0XODLNDFRUURERUDWHV WKLV FRQFOXVLRQ 7KH ODWWHU UHSRUWHG WKDW KH REWDLQHG ·¸LvDnV 6DKODVWRU\ IURP WKH 0HGLQDQ VFKRODUDO4VLPE0X¨DPPDGE$Eª%DNU&I·$EGDUUD]]T 0X®DQQDI  &I6FKDFKW2ULJLQVSSI



%LEOLRJUDSK\RIOLWHUDWXUHTXRWHGZLWKVKRUWWLWOHV

·$EGDUUD]]TE+DPPPD¬«DQ·Qª DO0X®DQQDI HG§DEªEDUUD¨PQDO$·µDPªYROV%HLUXW  )DKULV $E³¥DL±DPD=XKDLUE§DUEDQ1DV¸ª.LWEDO¹,OPHG01DO$OEDQª'DPDVFXVQG %D¢GGª$¨PDGE·$Oª¥D®ªEDO7DºU¬¨%D¤GG YROV&DLUR s,G.LWEDO.LI\DI¬¹LOPDUULZ\D+\GHUDEDG %X¦Uª0X¨DPPDGE,VP·ªODO.LWEDW7DºU¬¨DONDE¬U YROVLQ+\GHUDEDG DKDEª0X¨DPPDGE$¨PDGD7D¢NLUDWDOªXII· YROV%HLUXWQG s,G.LWE'XZDODOLVOPYROVLQ+\GHUDEDG s,G 0¬]QDOL¹WLGOI¬QDTGDUUL¦O HG0X¨DPPDG%DGUDGGªQDQ1Dv·DQª&DLUR ¥DOªIDE¥D\\®$E³·$PU.LWED°¯DEDT° HG$NUDP'L\¸DO·8PDUª%DJKGDG ,EQ$Eª§WLP·$EGDUUD¨PQDU5]ª 7DTGLPDWDOPD¹ULIDOL.LWEDO¥DUªZDWWD¹G¬O +\GHUDEDG  s,G.LWEDO¥DUªZDWWD¹G¬O YROVLQ+\GHUDEDG ,EQ§D¤DUDO·$VTDOQª$¨PDGE·$Oª7DK¢¬EDWWDK¢¬EYROVLQ+\GHUDEDG ,EQ¥DOOLNQ$¨PDGE0X¨DPPDG :DID\WDOD¹\QZDDQEºDEQºD]]DPQHG0X¨DPPDG 0X¨\ªGGªQ·$EGDO¨DPªGYROV&DLUR

 ,EQ §DQEDO $¨PDG E 0X¨DPPDG .LWE DO¹LODO ZDPD¹ULIDW DUUL¦O  HG 7 .RÁ\LLW, &HUUDKROXYRO$QNDUD ,EQ§LEEQDO%XVWª0X¨DPPDG 0DvK¬U ¹XODPº DODP®U  HG 0)OHLVFKKDPPHU:LHVEDGHQ  s,G.LWED³±LTW YROV+\GHUDEDGII ,EQDO0DGªQª ·$OªE·$EGDOOK¹,ODODOªDG¬³ZDPD¹ULIDWDUUL¦O HG·$EGDOPX·®ª$PªQ4DO·D¤ª $OHSSR ,EQDQ1DGªPDO)LKULVW &DLURQG>@ ,EQ4XWDLED·$EGDOOKE0XVOLP.LWEDO0D¹ULI &DLUR ,EQ6D·G0X¨DPPDG.LWED°¯DEDTWDONDE¬U HG(GXDUG6DFKDXHDYROV/HLGHQ  -X\QEROO *+$ 0XVOLP 7UDGLWLRQ 6WXGLHV LQ &KURQRORJ\ 3URYHQDQFH DQG $XWKRUVKLS RI HDUO\  ©DG¬WK&DPEULGJH 0OLNE$QDVDO0XZD°°DºULZ\DW 