P a g e |
1
CHANAKYA NATIONAL LAW LA W UNIVERSITY
FEMALE AS KARTA (FAMILY LAW II! SUBMITTED TO :MR. RAVI RAVI RANJAN SIR FACULTY OF FAMILY LAW
SUBMITTED BY :ANKIT ANAND ROLL NO :- 917,
TABLE OF CONTENT
4TH SEMESTER
P a g e |
1. ACKNOWLED"EMENT############.####..($%! &. OBJECT OF STUDY####################.($4! %. RESEARCH METHODOLO"Y###########.####...($4! 4. HY'OTHESIS#######################($4! . SOURCE OF DATA####################...($4! ). INTRODUCTION#################.####..($4! 7. 'OSITION 'RIOR TO THE ACT OF 19)#######.###.($)-$*! *. 'OSITION AFTER THE ENACTMENT OF HINDU SUCESSION ACT 19##########################.....($9-1&! 11. CASE LAW AND JUDICIAL VIEW############.(1%-1)! 1&. CONCLUSION######################.(17! 1%. BIBLIO"RA'HY#####################.(1*!
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
2
P a g e |
3
T+ /0 23 20 + 5F68 / K +/ 0 8 2 ; </ =<08 /+ ><+ + /?2 0@ +8 2= 28 =26 <2?/ ?/. M /<0 +0/ ;2 2 88 + 66/ ><+2? >+26 + /?@ 2?8@ 02 + 26 2 </ /0 /. I 6 2?@ 2 02>8@; ;<?@ 2 + <0@<<@?8/ @?<0; 6 /?@ 0@ ><+2? >+26 + /?@ 6 02 268@. I + 0 + 22?0< 2 +0 +2/ >+2 ;0?<08 +8@ 6.
W<+ <660/ 8/?, I // 6 @/ /0/ 2= ;<?@ 2 M. R< R030 /<, F?8 =2 F6<8 L>, C+0 N<208 L> U0</< =2 +8<0; 6 <0 6 23. I 6 8/2 +0=?8 2 + >+28 C+0 N<208 L> U0</< =6<8 + 2<@@ 6 88 + 6<8 I ?<@ =2 + 23. N2 2 =2; +0<0; 2 6 0/ ><+2? + 2-2<20 2= >+<+ 268<20 2= + 23 >2?8@ 02 +@ 0 2//<8.
I + 6@ ==2 2 02>8@; @</, ? I 282;</ <0 @0 =2 0 26/<20 + 6 + <0@08 0 8.
OBJECT OF STUDY:
P a g e |
4
A= 60@60 6@ H<0@? S?//<20 (A60@60! A, &$$, @?;+ 0 20 2= HUF 8< + /20/ 2= HUF. B<0; 20, /+ 0 8/2 / <<20 2= + @>88<0; +2?/ >+ + =6<8 /<@/ 0@ /+ 0 8/2 @2/ 2= + /+ <0 20 2 + 2>0 ><88. S2,+ + 22// 2 6<0 + 2 <;+/ 2= H<0@? 0@ M?/8<6 >260 <0 +< /208 8>/. A0 6 +/ 8/2 0 6@ 2 26 + <0+<0 <;+/ 2= >260 <0 +< /< /208 8>/. T+ + 8/2 +<;+8<;+/ + @/< =26/ 2?;+ 2? <0 + H<0@? >260/ <;+ 2 2 + H<0@? S?//<20 (A60@60! A &$$ + 20=@ <+ <;+ 2 H<0@? >260 <0 + M<+/+ 32<0 H<0@? =6<8 2. T+?/, < <620 2 02> + 0?0/ 2= F68 / K.
RESEARCH METHEDOLO"Y: T+ /+ 6+2@282; ?/@ + <0 + /+ >2 >2?8@ + @2<08 /+ 6+2@282; 0@ + 0< 200 >2?8@ /@ 20 + /<=< 6<8/ 288@ +2?;+ @<==0 22/ 0@ 32?08/.
HY'OTHESIS: T+ /+ +2+/ ;<0 2 + =68 = + 60@60 2= &$$.
SOURCE OF DATA: F2 0 23, /+ /+ +/ >2 /2?/ 2= @ :-1.'<6 @ &. S20@ @. H /+ +/ 8<@ ?20 + /20@ @ <0 + =26/ 2= 22/, 32?08/, <8/, / 8>/ 0@ 2+ 208<0 6<8 . 8@ 2 +<0@? 8>.
P a g e |
5
1. INTRODUCTION T+ K 2= H<0@? 32<0 F6<8 <0 H<0@? L> + /0<2 62/ 66 2= + =6<8 0<8@ 2 60; =6<8 ==</, <0 + /0 + 0 8@/ 68 66 = +<6 0<8@ 2 + K1. A K + 2= + >+28 =6<8 0@ 822/ = + >8= 2= 88 + 66/ 2= + =6<8. H 8<20/+< ><+ 2+ 66/ 8<20/+< 2= ?/ 0@ 20=<@0. A 8/ 20 68 66 0// 2 20/<? 20. B? + ?/<20 / + <= 02 68 66 8= <0 + =6<8 2 <= 88 68 66/ 6<02/ +0 >+2 26/ + K 2 C0 =68 66 2= H<0@? J2<0 F6<8 26 K +0 <0 /?+ <?6/0/ + /<?<20 6/ ?/ 8 20 <2?/ 3?@<<8 202?060/ >+<+ + @8 ><+ + ?/<20. T+ <> 2= + 3?@<< <020/0. N2> >+0 632 / 2>@/ 0@<0; ;0@ @<6<0<20 0@ 2 /2 + ;0@-</ 80 <0 =6<8</ 0@ 2 <62 @/ 20@<<20 2= >260 <0 /2< +/ 0 0 <0 + =26 2= T+ H<0@? S?//<20 A60@60 A, &$$. T+ 60@60 +/ 20=@ ?8 2 <;+/ 20 @?;+/ / >88. N2> + @?;+/ <+ ><88 ?< <;+/ 2 20 2. E8< >260 > 02 <08?@@ / 20 66/, 0@ 2@<0; 2 + H<0@? /;/ 208 20 0 26 , 0@ +=2 + 2?8@ 02 + K. B? 02> ?/ 2= + +0;@ 2/<<20 2= @?;+/ / 20/ + /<?<20 <0 =2? 2= 2//<<8< 2= >260 26<0; K. T+ @</ <>/ 2= + C2? / 20 + 2<0. I0 2? 23 > + <@ 2 8<0 + 2/<<20 2= >260 <0 8<20 2 + 2= K, > + 8/2, ;2<0; +2?;+ /-8>/ 0@ 3?@<<8 202?060/. O? '23 @<<@@ <0 /. T+ F</ @8/ ><+ +2<8 ;2?0@. T+ /20@ @8/ ><+ 0 >260 . T+ +<@ @8/ ><+ ;?60/ =2 0@ ;<0/ 2= >260 / K. T+ L/ /0+/ 2= + ;?60/ @0@ <. + 208?/<20. Background
S<0 0<0 <6/ + =6<0; 2= 88 2 8>/ + 0 8?/<8 =2 + 0=< 2= 60, 0@ >260 +/ 0 @ / /?/<0, 0@ @0@0 20 68 /?2. T+ <;+ 2 2 <620 =2 + =@26 0@ @8260 2= +?60 <0;.
1 https://bharath!gh"#$r%press"$&/tag/#h$'(s'a')arta'*+"*,"1-.*:0p"&.IST
P a g e |
6
2. Pos!on "ror !o !#$ Ac! o% 1&'( H<0@?/ > ;20@ S+/< 0@ C?/26 8>/ >+<+ <@ =26 ;<20 2 ;<20 0@ /26<6/ < <@ <0 + /6 ;<20 20 / / @<==<?8, < 8@ 2 @</< <0 + 8>. C20/?08, <0 6/ 2= /?//<20 8/2, + > @<==0 /+228/, 8< D+; <0 B0;8 0@
+ @32<0<0; /
M?+ <0 B26, K200 0@
"?3 0@
M?66 2 N6?@< <0 K8 0@ M</+ <0 2+ / 2= I0@< ><+ /8<;+ <<20/. T+ 6?8<8<< 2= /?//<20 8>/ <0 I0@<, @</ <0 +< 0?, 2><0; 2 +< <@ 2<;<0 6@ + 2 8>/ 0 6 268. A >260 <0 32<0 H<0@? =6<8, 20/<0; 2+ 2= 60 0@ >260, +@ <;+ 2 /?/00, ? + 2028 0@ 2>0/+< 2= 2 @<@ 02 / <0 +. N2 =68 66 2= + 20 <0 M</+ 8>.& U0@ + M</+ //6, 32<0 =6<8 2 @28/ /?<2/+< ><+<0 + 20. T+ 60/ + ><+ <+ 2 @+ 2= 68 <0 + =6<8, + /+ 2= 2+ /?<<0; 68 <+ ;/ @<6<0+@ 2 08;@. T+ M</+ 8> 8/2 2;0/ <0+<0 /?//<20 ? 208 2 + 2 /8 2>0@ 0 <0@<<@?8, 68 2 =68. F68/ <08?@@ / +</ 2 + <0@ 2= 2 M</+ 8>. B=2 + H<0@? L> 2= I0+<0 (A60@60! A 19&9, T+ B0;8, B0/ 0@ M<+<8 /? /+228/ 2= M</+ 2;0@ 208 =< =68 8<20/ / <0; 0<8@ 2 <0+< 068 - ><@2>, @?;+, 62+ 08 ;0@62+, 0@ 08 ;-;0@62+. T+ M@/ /?-/+228 2;0@ + +<8 < 2= 8; 0?6 2= =68/ +</ + 2= + /20/ @?;+, @?;+/ @?;+ 0@ + /, / +</ >+2 //8 06@ / +</ <0 H<0@? L> 2= I0+<0 (A60@60! A,19&9.% T+ /20/ @?;+ 0@ + @?;+/ @?;+ 0@ / 0@+?/ <0 B26 0@ M@/. T+ B26 /+228 >+<+ 62/ 8<8 2 >260, 2;0@ 0?06 2= 2+ =68 +</,
0 http://###"2ega2ser3(e(4%(a"$&/art(2es/)ar"ht&.*+"*,"1-.1*:0p"&.IST http://###"2a#teaher"4et/e5!(t6'2a#/(4her(ta4e'!4%er'tra%(t($4a2'h(4%!'2a#' e5!(t6'2a#'essa6"php.*+"*,"1-.11:0p"&.IST
P a g e |
7
<08?@<0; +8= /, =+/ / 0@ >260 6<@ <02 + =6<8 /?+ / /62+, /20/ ><@2>, 2+/ ><@2> 0@ 8/2 60 2+ =68/ 8//<=<@ / 0@+?/. Durng !#$ Br!s# R$g)$
H2>, @?<0; + B<+ ;<6, + 2?0 6 28<<88 0@ /2<88 <0;@, ? + B<+ "2060 @<@ 02 0? 2 <0= ><+ + /208 8>/ 2= H<0@?/ 2 2= 2+ 266?0<</. D?<0; + <2@, +2>, /2<8 =26 6260/ @ + /? 2= 68<2<20 2= + >260/ 2/<<20 <0 /2<. T+ 8</ 8;8<20 <0;<0; =68/ <02 + /+6 2= <0+<0 + H<0@? L> 2= I0+<0 A, 19&9. T+ A, 20=@ <0+<0 <;+/ 20 + =68 +</ <.. /20/ @?;+, @?;+/ @?;+ 0@ / (+ <0; 8<6<@ /<<20 20 + ?8 2= /?<2/+<!.4 A02+ 80@6 8;8<20 20=<0; 2>0/+< <;+/ 20 >260 >/ + H<0@? W260/ R<;+ 2 '2 A (VIII 2= ! 19%7. T+ A 2?;+ 2? 28?<20 +0;/ <0 + H<0@? L> 2= 88 /+228/, 0@ 2?;+ +0;/ 02 208 <0 + 8> 2= 20 ? 8/2 <0 + 8> 2= <<20, 8<0<20 2= 2, <0+<0 0@ @2<20. T+ A 2= 19%7 08@ + ><@2> 2 /?@ 820; ><+ + /20 0@ 2 /+ ?8 2 + 2= + /20. B?, + ><@2> @<@ 02 26 20 0 +2?;+ /+ 2////@ <;+ <0 2 20 <0/ <0 + 2 0@ >/ 66 2= + 32<0 =6<8. T+ ><@2> >/ 0<8@ 208 2 8<6<@ / <0 + 2 2= + @/@ ><+ <;+ 2 8<6 <<20. A @?;+ +@ <?88 02 <0+<0 <;+/. D/< +/ 060/ +<0; 2?;+ <620 +0;/ <0 + 8> 2= /?//<20 20=<0; 0> <;+/ 2= /?//<20 20 <0 =68/, +/ > /<88 =2?0@ 2 <02+0 0@ @=< <0 60 // 0@ ; 2 0?6 2= 0268</ 0@ 8= ?02?+@ + /< =?/ 2= @<6<0<20 ;<0/ >260. T+/ 060/ 02> /0@ 8@.)
, 7a%h! K(sh#ar.88C$%(9e% H(4%! La#. 76th a4% Rea2(t688 (/.E$4$&( a4% P$2(t(a2 Wee)26. 01,-;1++,<.*+"*,"0*1-.1*:0P"7.IST - http://###"2ega2ser3(es(4%(a"$&/art(2e/art(2e/)arta'$='a'=a&(26'h(4%!'2a#'1,+>' 1"ht&2.*+"*,"1-.11:0p"&.IST
P a g e |
8
T#$ Indan Cons!!u!on
T+ =6/ 2= + I0@<0 C20/<?<20 22 02 2= + @/ 0@ @<6<02 2/<<20 2= >260 <0 /2< 0@ 22 /<8 2 0/? + + S 22 2/<< // 2 ;< + ?8 /?/. A<8/ 14, 1(&! 0@ (%! 0@ 1) 2= + C20/<?<20 2= I0@<, +?/ 02 208 <0+<< @<6<0<20 ;<0/ >260 ? <0 2< <?6/0/ 2<@ = +0@ 2 + S 2 2<@ 2< @<6<0<20 <0 =2? 2= >260.7 T+/ 2<20/ 2= + F?0@608 R<;+/ ;?0@ + C20/<?<20. ' IV 2= + C20/<?<20 20<0/ + D<< '<0<8/ >+<+ 02 8// =?0@608 <0 + ;200 2= + S 0@ <0-8< 8/2 2<@ + + S /+88 0@2? 2 0/? ?8< >0 60 0@ >260 N2><+/0@<0; +/ 20/<?<208 60@/@<</ ;<0 62 +0 =<= / ;2, >260 /<88 0;8@ <0 + 2>0 08 =6<8 / >88 / <0 + =6<8 /+ 6</ <02 ?/ 2= 80 @;@ 0@ ?03?/<=<@ <28<20 2= +/ 2<20/ /26 2 = + /208 80@.
? http://###"2ega2ser3(es(4%(a"$&/art(2e/art(2e/)arta'$='a'=a&(26'h(4%!'2a#'1,+>' 1"ht&2.*+"*,"1-.10:0p"&.IST > Art(2e"1- $= the I4%(a4 C$4st(t!t($4.1*"*,"1-.*?:0p"&.IST
P a g e |
*.
Pos!on
a%!$r
!#$
$nac!)$n!
o%
+ndu
,ucc$sson
9
Ac!-1&''
T+ H<0@? S?//<20 A,19 =26@ + H<0@? /208 8> 0@ ; >260 ; 2 <;+/, 882><0; + =?88 2>0/+< <;+/ <0/@ 2= 8<6<@ <;+/ <0 2. T+ @?;+/ > 8/2 ;0@ 2 <;+/ <0 +< =+/ /. I0 + 6 2= /?//<20 2 + 2 2= H<0@? 68 @<0; <0/, + A 8/ @2>0 / 2= ;08 ?8/ <0 /<20/ * 2 1%. S<20/ 1 0@ 1) 2= + A 20<0 / ;08 ?8/ ==<0; /?//<20 2 + 2 2= =68 <0/. S2<8 3?/< @60@/ + >260 /+2?8@ @ ?88 2+ <0 + 2026< 0@ + /2<8 /+.* D<6<0<20 ;<0/ >260 /2 /< + < /26<6/ /?=/ 20 ?/8 2= + 8> 6@ + 8;8? </8=. T+ <?88 /2 <0 8<20 2 8>/ ;20<0; + <0+<0/?//<20 2= 2 620;/ + 66/ 2= J2<0 H<0@? =6<8. I /6/ + + @<6<0<20 /2 @ 0@ //6< + < / 8@ >260 + <<0; 0@. '2/<<20
=
+
60@60
<0
+
S?//<20
A
T+ L> C266/<20 >/ 200@ ><+ + @<6<0<20 <0+0 <0 + M</+ 20 ?0@ S<20 ) 2= + H<0@? S?//<20 A, / < 208 20// 2= 68 66/. T+ C266/<20 <0 + ;@ /<0@ + 2<0<20 2= 2// /<20 2= /2< <0 2@ 2 =<0@ 2?, >++ + M</+ 20 /+2?8@ <0@ / 2<@@ <0 /<20 ) 2= + H<0@? S?//<20 A, 19), 2 <0 0 8@ =26, 2 < /+2?8@ 288 28+@. T+ > 2+ ?/<20/ <028@ 8/2, 8< /+2?8@ >260 <0 /0 2= 68 66/ T+ C266/<20/ 6<0 <6 >/ 2 0@ ;0@ @<6<0<20 >+<+ 0 <0 /<20 ) 2= + H<0@? S?//<20 A,19), /?;;/<0; 2< 60@60/ 2 + A.9 A2@<0;8, + 60@60 >/ 6@ + 8;8? <0 D6 &$$4 0@ < 20=@ ?8 2 /+ Paras @(#a4. @a!ghters R(ght t$ I4her(ta4e a4% Brag&e4tat($4 $= H$2%(4gs SC ;D< 1-" ;1+><.1*"*,"1-.*>0p"&.IST
P a g e |
10
=26 + 0/8 2 20 + @?;+. B <+ @?;+ >2?8@ ?< 2 <;+/ 0@ >2?8@ 8< 0 2+ 20. I0 + = 2= /?+ 6?8<8<< 2= /?//<20 8>/ @</ <0 +< 0?, 2 8>/ 20<0?@ 2 268 0@ @<6<02 ;<0/ >260. T+ /2<8 =26 6260 @?<0; + -<0@0@0 <2@ @ + /? 2= ;0@ @<6<0<20 0@ 0?6 2= 68<2< // > <0<<@. A= T+ H<0@? S?//<20 A60@60 A, &$$ >260 2;02 02> 2@ 2= /20/ ><+<0 32<0 =6<8 0@ 20// 2= =+, /20, /20/ /20 0@ /20/ /20/ /20. A 20 0 8/2 2= ;0@=+ 0@ ;0@/20, 2 2= 2+/,2 0 ?08 0@ 0+> 0@ /2 20. T+?/ 0/8 2 20<0?/ 2 ;20@ >+288 <8<08 ;<6, >+<0 2 @/0@/ 208 +2?;+ + 68 8<0 / 208 + 68 66/ 2= 32<0 H<0@? =6<8 + 0 <0/ <+ <0 + 32<0 2 20 2. S<0 >260 2?8@ 02 20, /+ >/ 02 0<8@ 2 /+ <0 + 0/8 2 <+. A /20/ /+ <0 + 2 <0 / + =+ @</ <0/ >2?8@ <0 @@<<20 2 + /+ + +/ 20 <+. B? = + 60@60 @?;+/ + =26 <+ 20 <;+/. S2 + 0 / / + 02> 2;0
C0 W260 B K A ?/<200< >/ /?@ + L> C266/<20 2 8<< + <>/ 2= + ?8< ;@<0; ;<<0; 2= <;+/ 2 @?;+ <0 + M</+ 2 2= H<0@? ?0@<<@@ =6<8. T+ ?/<200< 20/@ 2= + / +<0; &1 ?/<20/. S<-S0 /20@0/ + 8<@
+ A&r(t$ @as. N$t($4a2 Part(t($4. A r(t(5!e". Set($4 ? $= The H(4%! S!ess($4 At 1+-?FF. D 1,+ AIR ;0**,<.1*"*,"1-.1*:--p"&.IST 1* http://###"%4a(4%(a"$&/&!&ba(/rep$rt'h(4%!'s!ess($4'at'g(r2s'b$r4'be=$re' 0**-'2a#.11"*,"1-.*?:0p"&.IST
P a g e |
11
2 + ?/<200<. %$ /20@0/ > =26 + 2=//<20 2= 8> 0@ + / 26 /2<282;/, N"O/ .11 A2? + / 2= D?;+ 26<0; K <0 + J2<0 F6<8, 2? +8= + /20@0/ >0@ + @?;+ 2 26 K <0 + J2<0 F6<8. T+ 0268 2/<<20 2= 8> @2/ 02 ;< /?+ <;+ 2 >260 ?0@ /<8 <?6/0/. I= /?+ <;+ /0<20@ 8> +0 >+ ><88 + 2/ 0@ 20/ 2 >+ /+2?8@ > /0<20 /?+ <;+, =2 >+ /20/ /+2?8@ >260 882>@ 2 26 + 60; 2= 32<0 =6<8 T2 0/> 88 +/ ?/<20/ > ><88 + 2 822 <02 ;?60/ >+<+ =2? + >260 26<0; K 0@ + ;?60/ >+<+ @2 02 =2? /?+ @2/<<20. Argu)$n!s In /a0our
M<0;
+
+
K
>2?8@
6
+
2/<<20
62
/8
D/< + C20/<?<20 ;?0<0; ?8< 2 >260, + /<88 60 @<6<02 // <0 + H<0@? 8> <0 + /+ 2= 2 <;+/. I0 2? /2< 6860 2= >260 <0 + +?/0@/ =6<8, .;. =2 =<8<0; 2 /20@ 2 @60@ 2= @2>, 2=0 /?8/ <0 + @+. B? + ;@ + + @<6<02 60 ;<0 2 + 0 + 66/ 2= + 2>0 08 =6<8. T+?/, <= /+ 6@ + K 2= + =6<8, +0 88 + 66/ 2= + =6<8 ><88 / + ?/ 2= + 2/<<20 0@ >260 ?/ ><88 20288@. T+ ><88 0+0 + /8=-20=<@0 0@ /2<8 >2+ 0@ ;< + ; ;<0<0; 2> =2 +/8= 0@
+
+<8@0,
<0
2+
08
0@
6<8
=6<8</.1&
W260 =?88 8 2= 60;<0; ?/<0//, <0; ? ?8< 8<= / >88 / 60; 8; =6<8</
/
62+/.
T+ /<88 8?0 2 6<0; + K / + ;08 68 <> + /+ <08 2= 60;<0; + 2</ 2 ?00<0; + ?/<0// 0@ ;088 /?/<8 2 + <0=8?0 2= + +?/0@ 0@ + =6<8, <= 6<@. T+ /6/ 2 08 ?0=< / >260 2<0;
11 http://###"2a#$&&(ss($4$94%(a"4("(4/)era2a"ht&2.10"*,"1-.*:0p"&.IST 10http://###"aa%e&(a"e%!/>->-+>,/AGCRITICALGANALYSISGOBGTHEG1>,THGREPOR TGOBGTHEGLAWGCO77ISSIONGOBGIN@IAGS!betGBa&(26GLa#.1"*,"1-.*-:0p"&.IST
P a g e |
12
+6/8/ ?8 2 0 / 0@ <= >260 <0=8?0@ +< +?/0@/ 0@ +< =6<8</, 60 02 8// <0=8?0@ +< ></ 0@ +< =6<8</. T+ ><88 0@ ;0@ @<6<0<20 <0 M</+ 20 <08?@<0; @?;+/ <0 + //6. S<0 + ;<8 ><88 + ?8 <0+<2 2= + 0/8 2, + <0-8>/ 6 02 <0/ 20 @2>. I <0; /?;;/@ + + =6<8 @>88<0; ><88 02 8<0@ ><+2? + // 20/0. T+?/ ><88 6 + 2/<<20 /20;. S+ ><88 02> 26 66 ?8 2 + / 0 2+ 68 66. S?+ 0 ><88 /@ >0// 0@ <0/ 8< 620; >260 / + ><88 <028@ <0 =6<8 ==</ 0@ + ><88 + / <0 ?/<0//. Argu)$n!s Agans! Wo)$n B$co)ng Kar!a
D?;+/ 002 6@ / + 8< > =26 32<0 =6<8 = +< 6<; + @?;+-<0-8>/ @2 02 8/2 2<;<088 820; 2 +< <0-8>/ =6<8, 0@ +=2 +< 2//<<8< 2= 26<0; 8/2 ?8@ 2?. I= >260 6@ +0 + ><88 8@ 2 <02860 2= >260 <0 ?/<0// ==</ + ><88 8@ 2 @?@ @26/< ==</. T+ >260 2= +2?/-+28@ ?/?88 ?/ ><+ +< @26/< >2, 0 <= + 6@ + ><88 20 + @< 2= =6<8 66/ 0@ <0 62/ // >+ + >260 <88< +0 < ><88 3?/ 8@ 2 <@8 66/ 2= + 32<0 =6<8 2/<0; + 0/ 2= + +@->2<0; W+ ><88 + >2 2= + 68 66/ <= =68 66/ 2= 32<0 =6<8 6@ . W260 <08 2= 60;<0; 2</ 2 ;<?8?, + <08 2= ?00<0; ?/<0//.
P a g e |
13
I= >260 6@ ><88 + 0<8@ 2 0 <0@ 2= 6<000 + + /? 2= + 286/ >+<+ 2 0/>@.1%
. CA,E LAW, AND UDICIAL 3IEW
T+ 2//<<8< 2= =68 <0; + K <0 /0 2= /0<2 68 66 <0; ?8@ 2?. B? + ?/<20 >++ <0 + /0 2= + 60;, >++ 2820;@ 32?0/ 2@ 2 @<0; ><+2? 8<0; 02+ 60; 2 /?@ +<6 <0 + =?0<20, =68 2?8@ / 60;. N2 @2?, < ? + + 0 / ;?@<0 2= H<0@? M<02/ + H<0@? M<02< 0@ "?@<0/+< , 19) ? < /<0/ + =26 <0=<0; ><+ + 8?/< 2>/ 2= 60;/ 2 @8 ><+ + <0// 2= 6<02/ <0 + J2<0 F6<8 '2. S2, + /28?<20 8</ <0 2? 8<;<2?/ >+<+ D+6/+/. I // + 8<0<20 0 @20 + ><= 2= 0 /0, 2 + ><@2> 2= @@ 60;, 2= =6<8 2 820;<0; 2 0?62?/ 6<02/, ?08 2 0 <02 20?8 8<20/+</ <0 +< 2>0 /20/, /208 =2 6<0<0<0; @0@0/ 0@ <0; + <2?/ ?@0/ 2= + =6<8. H, + 0=< 2= + =6<8 + 2?+/20, 02 + <@0< 2= + 8<02. T+ / 2= =68 66 <0; / 60; /+2?8@ 2/<< =2 + 0=< 2= + F6<8. S?+ / ><88 <0@<0; ?20 + 60; >+0 + ?0/ 2 / 20 + /0 /<68 26<0; 2= ; / + / 6 . I =?+ /?2@ K0, S6<<+0@<, B+/6<0 0@ Y;08 S6<<. S26 2= + S0/< // /+0/<-@/-/<-<< K??6+2 ?+<06 2@+6 K??6<0 T+ 60; (2 +2?/+28@, ?8 2 0?8! 8<8 2 (2 @6<! 88 8<0<20/ 6@ =2 + ?2// 2= + F6<8 ?<8, 0<, /8, ><=, ;0 2 <8<==.
1 http://p(b"4("(4/=eat!re/=e1*++/=101*++0"ht&2.1,"*,"1-.*+:0p"&.IST
P a g e |
14
N@ //N +-<6 <06 +0< ? + A <@ <, ?6/6 ??6+2 +< + A @ 20@ + ><= 0 <0@/ + +?/0@, + <0?@ <0 <6 2= @//: 0// =2 + 0=< 2= + =6<8 =88 ?20 68/. E0 + 23<20 <0; @, A 02 >260 @8@ + // 2 <08, 2 ?0=< =2 <0@0@0 W+ 68 66 2= + =6<8 <88, + /<;0? /+2?8@ 0 + +0 + 2= 0 =68/ /. B? + 0/> 8</ <0 + =2882><0; /60. T+ >260 <0 ?/<20 @ =2 /00: / /220 / + +?/0@ ?0/ 2 + /20 +/ 632< /+ 26/ 0 ;<0, ? 60>+<8 + /20/<<8< // ><+ +, 0@ 2>/ /+2?8@ 2<2?/8 882>@ 2 + 2@<0;8.
T#$ Cas$ La4s5 In ,u""or!
I0 H?02260/?@/ /14 >+<+ >/ 20 2= + ;/ // <0 + +2 2= H<0@? L> @8 ><+ + 2>/ 2= ><@2> 62+ / 60; 2= 2 2= + 6<02 /20, 0@ >/ <0 8< / <0 + 20 2= 60; /+< + +0 ;?@<0/+< 28 /2 88@. T+ / 2= + 8@/ >/ 02 >+2 /+ >/ 2 <0 >+ < /+ ?2@ 2 , ? >++ + >/ 0// 2 <0 + 6<02/ <0/ / ?0@/22@ + 8>. I0 '0@?0; D+ . '0@?0; "281, + + ><@2>@ 62+ //@ 26/2 02 =2 0//< / ;?@<0 2= + >2 6<02 /20/. S + >/ @=2 60; 0@ >/ +8@ 2 + 60;<8 2>/, 0@ + /20/ 2?8@ 02 ?@< + @.
1, AIR(1939) 1 MLJ 792 1- AIR(34) 1947 Nagpur 178)
P a g e |
15
I0 I.T C266. . L/+6< N01), + 62+ / 2= + ?0@<<@@ =6<8 20/<0; 2= +/8= 0@ + >2 6<02 /20/ 0@ <02 0/+< 0><0; + + 0/+< >+<+ + 8 +?/0@ +@ +@ ><+ + 2+. T+ 2? /<@ + D+; 8> >260 2?8@ 20 0@ /2 2//<8 0 60;/, 0@ 02@ + =68 6<;+ + 60; 2= 8<;<2?/ 0@2>60. T+ A 2= 19%7 +/ <62@ + /?/ 2= + W<@2>.
T#$ Madras Pos!on
I0 S+< .. N/<6+ 17+ + ><@2>/ 8<6@ + + > ?0@<<@@ 66/ 2= + 20 + 2<20 2= + 2= &19%7. T+ 23@ 2 + 2<060 2= ;?@<0 =2 + 2 2= + 6<02/. T+ 2? 2<0@ 20 ><@2> ;?@<0 2= 20 2= + 6<02 0@ /0; >/ 2<0@ + ;?@<0 2= + 2+. N20 2= + ><@2>/ < >/ +8@ + 2?8@ 60;. T2 60; 20 6?/ ? 20, 68 ><+ <+ <;+ 0@ 02 6 /? <0/. I0 R@+ A668 . I.T266/<20 1*, M@/ 62+ , ;?@<0 2= 6<02 /20/ , ?2@ 2 ? @@ 2= 0/+< @6<<0; /0; / 2> <0 + 0/8 ?/<0//. I >/ +8@ + + >/ 2?/<@ + 2>/ 0@ + @@ 2?8@ 02 ;@ ?0@ /<20 &)(! 2= +
I026
T
A
19&&.
A >260
2?8@
02
60;.
T+
;?60
+ H?02260/?@/ /* 882>@ + 2= @-=2 60; 2 <0@<0; 0 <= /+ > >260, >/ 02 @<@@, 6?+ 8// 6<0@. T+ >/ > / <0 M@/ @<20 >+<+ >/ <0 0 / /<8 =268 0@ 0<-P?<0 <0 2+.
1?AIR (1935) 37 BOMLR 692, 159 Ind Cas 424 1> AIR(1945) 1 MLJ 60 1
AIR 19$ M@ %*,
P a g e |
16
T#$ Bo)6a7 +g# Cour!
I0 R+6< . S<<19 / 62+ / 60; 2= J2<0 F6<8 20/<0; 2= + 2-><@2> 0@ 6<02 /-/20 0@ 6<02 / @?;+ 0@ +@ + 2> 2 / + 2<060 2= ;?@<0 2= + 2 2= + /-/20. S+ >/ + 60;<0; + / 0@ + ?+2< /+2?8@ 02, < >/ ?;@ ?0@6<0@ /?+ 0 2<060. T+ 80@ 2? /<@ + + 2 2?/ >/ 2 2<0 ;?@<0 =2 + 20 '2. A ><@2> 2?8@ 02 60; 2= J2<0 F6<8 '2. T+ / 2= S+< >/ ;@ ><+.
T#$ Orssa +g# Cour!5
I0 M;?0< '@+02 . L200<@+< L<0;3&$, < >/ +8@ + 62+, >+2/ +?/0@ 8<, 002 60;. S+ 6<;+ <0@@ / ;?@<0 2= + /20, <= + +?/0@ >/ @@ 0@ +/ / @=2 ;?@<0. B? / 60; /+ +@ 02 2>/ >+. L6< N0/ / >/ 02 =2882>@. T+ '<0<8 + >260 2?8@ 60; >/ @<8 3@. T#$ Pa!na +g# Cour!
I0 S+2;?86 . K+?0 C+?@+<&1, + 2? @0<@ + 62+ 2= 6<02 /20, @?<0; + 820; /0 2= + +?/0@ , 6<;+ / 0@ <0? @/ =2 =6<8 ?2//. A88 /?+ @/ >2?8@ 02 <0@<0; ?20 + =6<8. T+ / 2= M;?0< >/ 8<@ ?20. O0 + /?= < 6<;+ /6 + M@/ +/ + / 2= <. B? =?+ 6<0<20 6/ ?/ +/<. T+ 0?8 @/< + @/@ 62+/ 0@ ><@2>/ /+2?8@ + 68 2>/ 2 822
1+ AIR 1952 Bom 160, (1952) 54 BOMLR 55, ILR 1952 Bom 455 0* AIR 19) O< 1 01
AIR 19)1 ' &1&
P a g e |
17
= +< 6<02 /20/ <0/, <0; =2 0//< 2 + 0=< 2= + F6<8, +/ //@ </8=, / +<0;/ ><88, <0 0 <;?8 >, /<0; + < >/ =?/@ <0 //<0; </8= <0 /26 ?/ <0 ;?8 >.
'.Conc8uson
U0@ + S+/< L>, @?;+ 20 6<; // 2 66 2= + 08 =6<8, ? + A60@<0; A/ + +0;@ + 2/<<20, >+<+ ?< 8<0 2 H<0@? <+8 02<20/. T+2?;+ + 2/<<20 / @=2 60; >/ 2;0+0 62+/ @ / ;?@<0/ 2= +< 6<02 /20/ = + @+ 2= +< +?/0@/, + @3? 20=60 2= + <;+ 8?@@ +. T+ 8> 266/<20 8/2 +/ <;+8 2/@ + 8+2?;+ + H<0@? S?//<20 A60@60 A, &$$ +/ 20=@ ?20 + @?;+ 2= 20 /?/ ? + /<88 8?0 2 6<0; + K. T+ /6/ 2 08 ?0=< / >260 2<0; +6/8/ ?8 2 0 /. S<0 + 0 / 20</ +0 + 6?/ 8/2 ;<0 + 2>/ 2= K. T+ /+/ 8 + <0 + /0 2= /0<2 66 3?0<2 66 (<= + +/ +@ + ; 2= 8;8 260! 6 <0? @/ =2 + 0@/ 2= + =6<8, 0@ <0 + /0 2= 68 66 =68 66 6 @2 /2. T+ S0/<< / 62> >260 2 / K <0 <0/0/ 8< >+0 + +?/0@ > 2 6/<0; 2 + /20 2 <0 632<.
P a g e |
18
E?8< =2 >260 02 3?/ 6 2= ?< =2 + /2-88@ > /, ? 6/? 2= + 62@0< 2= I0@<0 /2< 0@ + ;6< 0? 2= 2? <<8
B68ogra"#7
R.K. A"RAWAL, HINDU LAW, C08 L> A;0 &%@ @, &$$7. D. 'ARAS DIWAN, FAMILY LAW, A88+@ L> A;0 1$+ @, &$1% B/?, M206, H<0@? W260 0@ M<; L>: F26 S60 2 C20, &$$1, O=2@ U0</< '//, ;. 1&1 D, J D?00, M H<0@? W260 + M0; 2= J2<0 F6<8 M</+ L>, 199, U0</8 B22 T@/, B26. L.R.., J., V28.- LVIII, ;- 1&) A;>8 R.K, H<0@? L>, 19+ E@<<20, C08 L> A;0, ;- &9* L> C266/<20 2= I0@< 2 20 '2 R<;+/ 2= W260: '22/@ R=26/ ?0@ + H<0@? L>, M &$$$. B.S<6, C20 R<;+/ 2 D?;+/ C20/<?<208 0@ <0<208 I//?/, (1997! % SCC (J!, '.&. A88 I0@< R2/ R3 S+ '8<60 B?88<0 ' II. (N2 41**4! @@ + &7+ D6, &$$4. B+@+@ N<8<6 , S A60@60/ 2 H<0@? S?//<20 A 0@ C20=8< 2= L>/ : N@
P a g e | F2 L> R=26, (&$$1! 1 SCC (J2?! 4$ T+26/ E.C, T+ 2@ 2 ;0@ ?8<. S+< L8<, R=26<0; '2 R<;+/ O= W260
URLS +:>>>.++<0@?.26++<0@?6;&$$$9&/2</&$$$9&$$$$1$$.+6 +:>>>.6<88;G.26/?/<.+6 +:>>>.-<0@<.268><8/
19