Dalai Lama Asylum in India- a case study

P#BLIC I$%&'$A%I$AL LA LA  A*+L#,- A CA*& *%#+ $ A*+L#, % ALAI LA,A

Submitted By: Arpit Bansal B.Com LL.B. (2015-20) Section C Section C III Semester III Roll No.: No.: 173/15 173/15 Paper: Publi Publi Int!rnationa Int!rnationall La"-I

Submitted To:

Submitted on:

,s. $ii

//201

1

Aslum- A Cas! *tu n Aslum %o alai Lama

ACKNOWLEDGEMENT

An "or r!4uir!s t! !ort o man p!opl! an tis is no i!r!nt. 6irst o all I "oul li! to !8pr!ss m !arti!st tans to t! ir!tor o #ni9!rsit Institut! o L!al *tui!s r. *anita Balla or i9in m! an opportunit to stu in su a r!at institution. %!n I tan m t!a!r ,s. $ii or irstl main m! un!rstan t! ont!nts o m topi an t!n i9in m! a "on!rul opportunit to pr!s!nt tis topi in  orm o an assinm!nt. ;is support an t!ain !lp! m! a lot to ompl!t! tis assinm!nt. I "oul also li! to tan m ri!ns "o "!r! al"as a9ailabl! to m! or !lp an also !lp! m! oll!t ata or m pro
2


TABLE OF CONTENTS

Ano"l!!m!nt......................................................................................................................i %abl! o Cont!nts....................................................................................................................... ii Introution................................................................................................................................ 1 La" on Aslum...................................................................................................................... 1 Basis o Aslum.................................................................................................................... .2 Is Aslum t! 'it o a P!rson=...............................................................................................3 Inia>s ?i!" on iplomati Aslum..........................................................................................@ Aslum an Inia....................................................................................................................... 5 A Cas! *tu on Aslum to 1@ t alai lam in inia................................................................... 1.

Bri! ;istor o *ino-%ib!tan '!lation...........................................................................

2.

Bri! ;istor about 1@t alai Lama............................................................................... 7

3.

iso9!r as t! 1@t alai Lama....................................................................................7

@.

%! Cin!s! In9asion......................................................................................................

5.

Counto"n to &sap! o t! alai Lama......................................................................10

.

&sap! into &8il!...........................................................................................................10

7.

In &8il!..........................................................................................................................11

.

 o!s Inia pro9i! aslum to t! alai Lama=....................................................12

'!!nt *!narios......................................................................................................................13 Conlusion................................................................................................................................1@ Bibliorap.............................................................................................................................15 !bliorap........................................................................................................................... 15

1


INTRODUCTION

Aslum un!rstoo as t! prot!tion tat a *tat! rants on its t!rritor or in som! ot!r pla! un!r t! ontrol o !rtain o its orans to a p!rson "o om!s to s!! it> 1 is a "!llno"n institution in int!rnational la" an its istorial roots in stat! prati! ar! "!ll !stablis!.2 %! "or Aslum is Latin an !ri9!s rom t! r!! "or DAsliaD "i m!ans in9oilabl! pla!. %! t!rm is r!!rr! to tos! as!s "!r! t! t!rritorial *tat! !lin!s to surr!n!r a p!rson to t! r!4u!stin *tat! an pro9i!s s!lt!r an prot!tion in its o"n t!rritor. %us aslum in9ol9!s t"o !l!m!nts. 6irstl s!lt!r "i is mor! tan a t!mporar r!u!E an s!onl a !r!! o ati9! prot!tion on t! part o t! autoriti!s in ontrol o t! t!rritor o aslum. 3 %!s! t"o !l!m!nts istinuis aslum rom tat o immiration. A p!rson !n
Aslum is b!in prati! b t! *tat!s sin! a lon tim! !it!r b!aus! it is r!!rr! to in som! !8traition tr!ati!s or in muniipal la"s. *om!tim!s it is also rant! "itout an ormal l!al basis. ;o"!9!r i! on!pt o aslum as still not a4uir! t! n!!ssar larit. Prati! o *tat!s is insuii!nt to onstitut! it tat tp! o ustom "i Int!rnational 1 Institut! o Int!rnational La" (5t Commission) Aslum in Publi Int!rnational La"> '!solutions Aopt! at its Bat *!ssion *!pt 1F50 art 1. 2 6or an o9!r9i!" o t! !9olution o tis institution s!! A ral-,as!n %!rritorial Aslum (Alm49ist G is!ll Int!rnational 1F0) an & '!al! L! roit >asil!> (1F3) 3 '!u!il !s Cours ! l>AaHmi! ! roit Int!rnational ! La ;a! @73. 3 *tar!Ds Int!rnational La" &l!9!nt &ition (1FF@) p. 323. Also s!! Artil! 1 o t! '!solution aopt! b t! Institut! o Int!rnational La" in 1F50 "i !in! aslum as t! prot!tion "i a *tat! rants on its t!rritor or in som! ot!r pla! un!r t! ontrol o !rtain o its orans to a p!rson "o om!s to s!! it.

2

Aslum- A Cas! *tu n Aslum %o alai Lama La" r!4uir!s to all t! prati! as a ustomar Int!rnational La". %is r!ason alon! l! to t! Int!rnational La" Commission to inlu! t! topi o aslum in its pro9isional list or oiiation. %! Ass!mbl in 1F5F r!4u!st! t! Commission Das soon as it onsi!rs a9isabl! to un!rta! t! oiiation o t! prinipl!s an rul!s o Int!rnational La" r!latin to t! rit o aslumD. Aorinl in 1F2 t! Commission !i! to inlu! t! topi o aslum in its proramm! but "itout s!ttin an at! or t! start o its onsi!ration.@ In t! abs!n! o an la" t! topi at pr!s!nt is o9!rn! mainl on t! basis o t! *tat! prati! an
A *tat! as a rit to rant aslum to a p!rson on t! prinipl! tat it as a so9!r!in rit to ontrol o9!r t! ini9iuals oun on its t!rritor. %us t! rit o t!rritorial aslum as b!!n on!rr! to a *tat! on t! basis o its so9!r!int o9!r t! t!rritor. %is rit is !8lusi9! in t! s!ns! tat ot!r *tat!s ar! !8lu! to !8!ris! t!
@ +!ar Boo o Int!rnational La" Commission (1F0) ?ol. J p 10 Para 3F.

3


IS ASYLUM THE RIGHT OF A PERSON?

It is sai tat a p!rson as a rit to !t aslum in ot!r *tat!s. #ni9!rsal !laration o ;uman 'its un!r Artil! 1@ (Para 1) las o"n tat D!9!ron! as a rit to s!! an to !n
@

Aslum- A Cas! *tu n Aslum %o alai Lama aslum to p!rsons p!rs!ut! or politial r!asons but it annot !t b! sai tat su a rit as b!om! a D!n!ral prinipl! o la"D r!oni! b i9ili! nations an as su ormin part o Int!rnational La". It ma b! not! tat t! rit to rant aslum 9!sts in t! *tat!. It is !8!ris! on t! basis o t! prinipl! o t!rritorial so9!r!int. Altou t! rat Con9!ntion on %!rritorial Aslum pro9i!s tat t! parti!s to t! Con9!ntion sall us! t!ir Db!st !n!a9ors> in a Dumanitarian spiritD to rant aslum in t!ir t!rritor to a p!rson !liibl! un!r t! rat Con9!ntion it annot b! int!rpr!t! as tat *tat!s a9! un!r an l!al obliations to rant aslum to t!m.

INDIA’S VIEW ON DIPLOMATIC ASYLUM

Inia as ma! its position l!ar r!arin t! iplomati aslum b issuin a irular on !!mb!r 301F7 to all or!in iplomati missions in Inia "!r!in it "as stat! tat t! o9!rnm!nt o Inia o!s not r!oni! t! rit o su missions to i9! aslum to an p!rson or p!rsons "itin t!ir pr!mis!s. In t! stat!m!nt missions "!r! r!4u!st! tat i t! r!!i9! a r!4u!st or aslum or t!mporar s!lt!r or r!u! su r!4u!st soul not b! rant!. %! abo9! 9i!" "as urt!r larii! b t! Inian !l!at! r. *!i ,uamma on $o9!mb!r 3 1F75 in t! *i8t Committ!! on t! it!m on!rnin iplomati Aslum. ;! stat! tat t! iplomati aslum in9ol9!s a !roation rom t! so9!r!int o t! t!rritorial *tat! an an int!r9!ntion in matt!rs "i ar! !8lusi9!l "itin t! omp!t!n! o tat *tat!. ;! urt!r stat! tat Diplomati missions ar! aor! pri9il!!s an immuniti!s or untional r!asons as is l!arl brout out in t! ?i!nna Con9!ntion on iplomati '!lations. %is Con9!ntion sp!lls out l!arl t! untions o iplomati a!nts. An unilat!ral !8pansion o t!s! untions b a iplomati mission "oul b! onsi!r! as an !nroam!nt on its autorit b a t!rritorial *tat!. *tat! prati! o"!9!r p!rmits a iplomati mission to i9! "itin its pr!mis!s t!mporar r!u! to a p!rson "o is in immin!nt an!r o is li! until t! !ssation o su an!r. %! prati! o t!mporar r!u! is l!arl
5

Aslum- A Cas! *tu n Aslum %o alai Lama an!r to is li!. It is to b! not! tat t! Inian 9i!" onorms "it t! rul!s I o Int!rnational La" r!arin iplomati aslum.




ASYLUM AND INDIA

Inia in t! !ar 1F55 a9! t!rritorial aslum to alai Lama an is ollo"!rs "o "!r! oppr!ss! rom t! r!pr!ssi9! polii!s o Cina. Altou t!ir aslum "as ritii! b Cina on t! roun tat Inia b rantin aslum as int!r!r! in its int!rnal aairs Inia "as omp!t!nt !nou to o so b!aus! o t! prinipl! o t!rritorial so9!r!int. %! rant o t!rritorial aslum soul not b! onsi!r! as an unri!nl at b Cina. Inia o!s not r!oni! t! rant o !8tra-t!rritorial aslum. It is l!ar rom t! irular issu! to all t! iplomati missions in Inia on !!mb!r 301F7 an also rom t! stat!m!nt o Inian !l!at! r. *!i ,uamma on $o9!mb!r 3 1F75 in t! *i8t Committ!! on t! it!m on!rnin iplomati Aslum. ;o"!9!r it a9! iplomati aslum to lat! Min %ribu9an o $!pal "!n ! sout aslum at t! !it o t! 'ana r!9olt aainst im. !n t! *o9i!t !!tor Ai ulou-Na! too r!u! in t! Am!rian &mbass in Inia it "as rant! to im t!mporaril. n prot!st ! "as surr!n!r! to t! Inian autoriti!s. 6urt!r on 6!bruar 13 2013 Inia a9! aslum to ,oam! $as!a t! orm!r Pr!si!nt o ,ali9!s in Inian ;i Commission in ,all "!n ! sout r!u! in or!r to !9a! arr!st "arrant issu! b t! Court. At!r a9in sta! in t! Inian ;i Commission or !l!9!n as ! !i! to l!a9! on is o"n.

7


A CASE STUDY ON ASYLUM TO 14

TH

DALAI LAM IN INDIA

1. BRIEF HISTORY OF SINO-TIBETAN RELATION

Aorin to t! *!9!nt!!n Point *ino-%ib!tan Ar!!m!nt Cina a i9!n assuran! to r!sp!t t! autonom o %ib!t b i9in 9arious ommitm!nts. But t! 1F51 to 1F5F !ra "itn!ss! t! raual an sst!mati br!ain o ma
%ib!t "as r!oni! as a part o Cina an "as to r!turn to t! bi amil o t! mot!rlan t! P!opl!>s '!publi o Cina. %! op!nin s!nt!n! o t! Ar!!m!nt !srib!s t! %ib!tans as on! o t! nationaliti!s "it a lon istor "itin t! bor!r

  

o Cina. Cina "as to onut all or!in r!lations an !!n!. %ib!tan monast!ri!s "!r! to b! prot!t!. A ,ilitar Ar!a ;!a4uart!rs o t! P!opl!>s Lib!ration Arm an a militar aministrati9! ommitt!! "!r! to b! !stablis! in %ib!t. %! alai Lama am! 9!r los! to l!a9in %ib!t or *antuar in Inia rat!r tan r!turn an rul! in t! ont!8t o tis Ar!!m!nt. %! militar stipulations o tis Ar!!m!nt "!r! partiularl



  

obno8ious to im an ! a b!!n !sirous o a9oiin a militar oupation. %ib!tan autonom "as r!onis!. In 9i!" o pro9ision our o"!9!r tis "as to b! littl! mor! tan !mplo aa!. %! Pan!n Lama "as to b! !stablis! in is traitional rol!. %! r!liious b!li!s ustoms an abits o t! %ib!tans "!r! to b! r!sp!t!. '!orms "!r! to b! introu! in %ib!t onl "it t! ons!nt o oiials o t! %ib!tan Loal o9!rnm!nt upon r!4u!st o t! p!opl!. %is aa! "oul o ours! b! us! as a o9!r or Cin!s! ultural p!n!tration an r!orms.

F ,. L. *ali Inia-Cina Bor!r isput!: A Cas! *tu o t! &ast!rn *!tor 7 (AP; PublD 1FF).



Aslum- A Cas! *tu n Aslum %o alai Lama 

%! %ib!tan Loal o9!rnm!nt "as to assist t! P!opl!>s Lib!ration Arm to !nt!r



%ib!t an onsoliat! national !!n!. %! %ib!tan Loal o9!rnm!nt "as to assist t! P!opl!>s Lib!ration Arm in t!

 

puras! an trans!r o oo o!r an ot!r n!!ssiti!s. %! %ib!tan Arm "as to b! int!rat! "it t! P!opl!>s Lib!ration Arm. %! %ib!tan Loal o9!rnm!nt ar!! in prinipl! to a proram o utur! soio!onomi r!orm an promis! to ri %ib!t o Oall imp!rialisti inlu!n!s.

&9!nts in t! !ars ollo"in tis Ar!!m!nt "!r! most onsist!nt "it Cina>s istorial approa to its bor!rs - t! !sir! or t!rritorial ain an t! ani!nt ;an obs!ssion "it t! s!urit o t! !artlan o Cina. At!r onluin 17-point Ar!!m!nt Cin!s! n!9!r ulill! t!ir ommitm!nts "i t! m!ntion! in 17-point Ar!!m!nt. n t! ot!r an to stamp out %ib!tan ultur! to maintain stronol o9!r %ib!t an to ! t! r!9olt ati9iti!s $ul!arisation ,ilitarisation an ,o!rnisation o %ib!t is b!in ontinu! b P!opl!>s '!publi o Cina .10 2. BRIEF HISTORY ABOUT 14 DALAI LAMA TH

%! alai Lama "as born on  Qul 1F35 an nam! Lamo %onup to a %ib!tan armin amil in t! small 9illa! o %ats!r loat! in t! pro9in! o Amo. %! nam! Lamo %onup lit!rall m!ans is-6ulillin o!ss>. ;is par!nts "!r! small arm!rs "o mostl r!" barl! bu"!at an potato!s. ;! r!alls is at!r as a man o m!ium !it "it a 9!r 4ui t!mp!r. +!t ! "as a in man too an ! n!9!r bor! ru!s an is mot!r as unoubt!l on! o t! in!st p!opl! ! as !9!r no"n. ;! is onsi!r! to b! t! r!inarnation o !a o t! pr!9ious tirt!!n alai Lamas o %ib!t (t! irst a9in b!!n born in 13F1 A). 3. DISCOVERY AS THE 14 DALAI LAMA TH

!n Lamo %onup "as t"o !ars ol a s!ar part tat a b!!n s!nt out b t! %ib!tan o9!rnm!nt to in t! n!" inarnation o t! alai Lama arri9! at Mumbum monast!r. It a b!!n l! t!r! b a numb!r o sins. n! o t!s! on!rn! t! !mbalm! bo o is pr!!!ssor %upt!n atso t! %irt!!nt alai Lama "o a i! a! it-s!9!n in 1F33. urin its p!rio o sittin in stat! t! !a "as iso9!r! to a9! turn! rom ain sout to nort!ast. *ortl at!r tat t! '!!nt ims!l a s!nior lama 10 ,. L. *ali Inia-Cina Bor!r isput!: A Cas! *tu o t! &ast!rn *!tor 272 (AP; PublD 1FF).

F

Aslum- A Cas! *tu n Aslum %o alai Lama a a 9ision. Looin into t! "at!rs o t! sar! la! Lamoi Latso in sout!rn %ib!t ! l!arl sa" t! %ib!tan l!tt!rs A Ma an ,a loat into 9i!". %!s! "!r! ollo"! b t! ima! o a tr!!-stori! monast!r "it a tur4uois! an ol roo an a pat runnin rom it to a ill. 6inall ! sa" a small ous! "it stran!l sap! utt!rin. ;! "as sur! tat t! l!tt!r A r!!rr! to Amo t! nort-!ast!rn pro9in! so it "as t!r! tat t! s!ar part "as s!nt. %! bo Lamo %onup "as irst ta!n to Mumbum monast!r. Lamo %onup "as !9!ntuall to b! r!unit! "it is par!nts an to!t!r t! "!r! to
A a at!r t! op!ra !sti9al in t! summ!r o 1F50 '!!nt %atra r!!i9! a t!l!ram rom t! o9!rnor o Mam bas! in Camo r!portin a rai on a %ib!tan post b Cin!s! soli!rs. Alr!a t! pr!9ious autumn t!r! a b!!n ross-bor!r inursions b Cin!s! Communists "o stat! t!ir int!ntion o lib!ratin %ib!t rom t! ans o imp!rialist ar!ssors. It no" loo! as i t! Cin!s! "!r! main oo t!ir tr!at. %! alai Lama "as "!ll a"ar! tat %ib!t "as in ra9! an!r or t!ir arm ompris! no mor! tan 500 oi!rs an m!n. %"o monts lat!r in tob!r n!"s r!a! Lasa tat an arm o 0000 soli!rs o t! P!opl!>s Lib!ration Arm a ross! t! riu ri9!r !ast o Camo. *o t! a8! a all!n. An soon Lasa "oul a9! to all. As t! "int!r r!" on an t! n!"s ot "ors! p!opl! b!an to a9oat! tat alai Lama b! i9!n is ull t!mporal (politial) po"!r. At a !r!mon t! o9!rnm!nt onsult! t! $!un ral! a 9!r t!ns! mom!nt "o am! o9!r to "!r! alai Lama "as s!at! an lai a ata a "it! o!rin sar on alai LamaDs lap "it t! "ors tu-la bap is tim! as om!. %us at t! oun a! o it!!n alai Lama "as on 17 $o9!mb!r 1F50 oiiall !ntron! as t! t!mporal l!a!r o %ib!t in a !r!mon !l at t! $orbulina Pala!.

10

Aslum- A Cas! *tu n Aslum %o alai Lama At t! b!innin o $o9!mb!r about a ortnit b!or! t! a o alai LamaDs in9!stitur! is !l!st brot!r arri9! in Lasa. As soon as ;! s!t !!s on is brot!r ;! n!" tat ! a su!r! r!atl. B!aus! Amo t! pro9in! "!r! t! "!r! bot born li!s so los! to Cina it a 4uil all!n un!r ontrol o t! Communists. ;! ims!l "as !pt 9irtual prison!r in is monast!r. At t! sam! tim! t! Cin!s! !n!a9our! to inotrinat! im in t! n!" Communist "a o tinin an tri! to sub9!rt im. %! a a plan "!r!b t! "oul s!t im r!! to o to Lasa i ! "oul un!rta! to p!rsua! alai Lama to a!pt Cin!s! rul!. I alai Lama r!sist! is brot!r "as to ill im. %! Cin!s! "oul t!n r!"ar im. In onsultation "it t! t"o Prim! ,inist!rs appoint! b im an t! Masa alai Lama !i! to s!n !l!ations abroa to Am!ria r!at Britain an $!pal in t! op! o p!rsuain t!s! ountri!s to int!r9!n! on %ib!t>s b!al. Anot!r "as to o to Cina in t! op! o n!otiatin a "itra"al. %!s! missions l!t to"ars t! !n o t! !ar. O*ortl at!r"ars "it t! Cin!s! onsoliatin t!ir or!s in t! !ast t! !i! tat alai Lama soul mo9! to sout!rn %ib!t "it t! most s!nior m!mb!rs o t! o9!rnm!nt. %at "a i t! situation !t!riorat! I oul !asil s!! !8il! aross t! bor!r "it Inia. ,!an"il! Lobsan %asi an Lunan"a (P,s) "!r! to r!main in an atin apait. il! alai Lama "as in romo "i la
11

Aslum- A Cas! *tu n Aslum %o alai Lama o9!rnm!nt o %ib!t. As it turn! out t! Cin!s! "o !9!n or! t! %ib!tan s!al a or! t! !l!ation !a! b $abo into sinin t! ar!!m!nt. %! Cin!s! a in !!t s!ur! a ma
%! n!8t nin! !ars sa" alai Lama trin to !9a! a ull-sal! militar ta!o9!r o %ib!t b Cina on on! an an plaatin t! ro"in r!s!ntm!nt amon %ib!tan r!sistan! it!rs aainst t! Cin!s! ar!ssors on t! ot!r. alai Lama ma! a istori 9isit to Cina rom Qul 1F5@ to Qun! 1F55 or p!a! tals an m!t "it 9arious Cin!s! l!a!rs. 6rom $o9!mb!r 1F5 to ,ar 1F57 alai Lama 9isit! Inia to partiipat! in t! 2500t Bua Qaanti !l!brations. But is!art!nin r!ports o inr!asin brutalit to"ars is o"n p!opl! ontinu! to pour in "!n t! oun alai Lama "as i9in is inal monasti !8aminations in Lasa in t! "int!r o 1F5/5F. 6. ESCAPE INTO EXILE

n! "int!r a o 1F5F (,ar 10) !n!ral Nan C!n"u o Communist Cina !8t!n! a s!!minl inno!nt in9itation to t! %ib!tan l!a!r to att!n a t!atrial so" b a Cin!s! an! troup!. !n t! in9itation "as r!p!at! "it n!" onitions tat no %ib!tan soli!rs "!r! to aompan t! alai Lama an tat is bouars b! unarm! an aut! an8i!t b!!ll t! Lasa population. *oon a ro" o t!ns o tousans o %ib!tans at!r! aroun t! $orbulina Pala! !t!rmin! to t"art an tr!at to t!ir oun l!a!rDs li! an pr!9!ntin alai Lama rom oin. n 17 ,ar 1F5F urin a onsultation "it t! $!un ral! alai Lama "as i9!n an !8pliit instrution to l!a9! t! ountr. %! ral!Ds !ision "as urt!r onirm! "!n a i9init p!rorm! b alai Lama prou! t! sam! ans"!r !9!n tou t! os aainst main a su!ssul br!a s!!m! t!rriinl i. A !" minut!s b!or! t!n oDlo alai Lama isuis! as a ommon soli!r slipp! past t! massi9! tron o p!opl! alon "it a small !sort an pro!!! to"ars t! Miu ri9!r "!r! ! "as
12

Aslum- A Cas! *tu n Aslum %o alai Lama 'umors lat!r irulat! amon %ib!tans tat t! alai Lama Oa b!!n sr!!n! rom '! plan!s b mist an lo" lous on
%r!! "!!s at!r !sapin Lasa alai Lama an is !ntoura! r!a! t! Inian bor!r on 30 ,ar 1F5F rom "!r! t! "!r! !sort! b Inian uars to t! to"n o Bomila in t! pr!s!nt a Inian stat! o Arunaal Pra!s. %! Inian o9!rnm!nt a alr!a ar!! to pro9i! aslum to alai Lama an is ollo"!rs in Inia. *oon at!r is arri9al in ,ussoori! on 20 April 1F5F alai Lama m!t "it t! Inian Prim! ,inist!r an t! t"o tal! about r!abilitatin t! %ib!tan r!u!!s. '!aliin t! importan! o mo!rn !uation or t! ilr!n o %ib!tan r!u!!s alai Lama impr!ss! upon $!ru to un!rta! t! ormation o an in!p!n!nt *oi!t or %ib!tan &uation "itin t! Inian ,inistr o &uation. %! Inian o9!rnm!nt "as to b!ar all t! !8p!ns!s or s!ttin up t! sools or t! %ib!tan ilr!n. %inin t! tim! "as rip! or im to br!a is !l!t! sil!n! alai Lama all! a pr!ss on!r!n! on 20 Qun! 1F5F urin "i ! ormall r!puiat! t! *!9!nt!!n-Point Ar!!m!nt. n 10 ,ar 1F0
11 ttp://tim!.om/37@22@2/alai-lama-1F5F/

13

Inia an %ib!t o a lon "a an a9! a a app r!lationsip or o9!r 15 !nturi!s. 6or man Inians %ib!t is a spiritual lan (;inuismDs oli!st sit! is in ,anasaro9ar) an in t! sam! "a %ib!tans s!! Inia as a spiritual lan. %is mutual r!sp!t an unam!ntal bon is " alai Lama "as i9!n an aslum in Inia. ,or!o9!r all aounts so" tat $!ru n!9!r r!alis! tat Cina oul atta Inia. IniaDs ar!ssi9! 6or"ar Poli so"! tat ! an is omman!rs a un!rpla! CinaDs r!taliation "it or!. $!ru sp!ar!ain t! $on-Alin! ,o9!m!nt an sloan!!rin ;ini Cini bai bai al"as 9i!"! it as strul! o9!r isput! an unmar! ar!as. Inia pro9i!s aslum to alai Lama b!aus! Inia tins it is t! rit tin to o. An p!rson "o as out aainst oppr!ssion an or r!!om an p!rsonal lib!rt an is b!in p!rs!ut! or it is "!lom! in Inia. $ot onl tis Inia is prou tat it as a 9ibrant %ib!tan population toa in ;imaal an #ttaraan omprisin mainl o tos! "o l! Cina "it t! alai Lama. ! ar! also prou to a9! on! o t! "orlDs lar!st %ib!tan Buist #ni9!rsiti!s. 15

12 Proil!: %! alai Lama. BBC $!"s. 25 6!bruar 200F. '!tri!9! 31 !!mb!r 200F. 13 &9!nts o 1F71. +!ar in '!9i!". #nit! Pr!ss Int!rnational. 1F71. Ari9! rom t! oriinal on 5 ,a 200F. '!tri!9! 2 Auust 2010 1@ Supra not! 12 15 ttps://""".4uora.om/at-is-Inias-b!n!it-b-i9in-aslum-to-t!-alai-Lama

1@


15


RECENT SCENARIOS

6ollo"in t! r!!nt !ision o t! Inian o9!rnm!nt to ilit t! issu!s o Baluistan t! Balo l!a!rs a9! start! looin or support rom Inia. Inian Prim! ,inist!r in is In!p!n!n! a sp!! ilit! t! issu! o uman rits 9iolation in t!s! parts o t! "orl. In t! lit o tis Balo l!a!r in !8il! in !n!9a approa! t! Inian !mbass t!r! s!!in aslum in Inia. %!r! is a r!at !r!! o ons!nsus in Paistan an in ot!r parts o t! "orl tat t! poli o Paistan to"ars Baluistan as b!!n a ailur!. Pla! in t!s! irumstan!s t! poli tat Inia as aopt! "it r!sp!t to %ib!t Banla!s an *ri Lana as b!!n on! o s!l-r!straint. Paistan 9iolat! t! 1F@7 Ar!!m!nt an oribl "!nt to oup Baluistan in "i it su!!!. Inia i mo9!s or"ar in tis r!ar as to aopt a !lib!rat! poli o i9in s bain o Baluistan "oul b! ain to Paistan>s bain o Malistan mo9!m!nt in Punt a9! an t!rritorial laim on Pun
1


CONCLUSION

%! "or Aslum is Latin an !ri9!s rom t! r!! "or DAsliaD "i m!ans in9oilabl! pla!. %! t!rm is r!!rr! to tos! as!s "!r! t! t!rritorial *tat! !lin!s to surr!n!r a p!rson to t! r!4u!stin *tat! an pro9i!s s!lt!r an prot!tion in its o"n t!rritor. Inia in its istor a9! Aslum to t! 1@ t alai Lama a as! stu o "i as b!!n pr!s!nt! in tis pros pala! in Lasa to !!p im rom b!in abut! arr!st! or ill!. 9!r t! ollo"in !" as t! prot!sts !8pan! into !larations o %ib!tan in!p!n!n! an t! mobiliin o r!b!l troops to it t! Cin!s! or!s. %! *tat! ral! t! alai Lama>s a9isor ur! im to l!!. n tis a ,ar 17 in 1F5F %ib!t>s spiritual an politial l!a!r t!n 23 isuis! ims!l as a soli!r an slipp! trou t! ro"s outsi! t! pala! !> n!9!r s!! aain. ;! !mbar! on a an!rous
17


BIBLIOGRAPHY



r. ;.. Aar"al Int!rnational La" an ;uman 'its (21st !. C!nt. La"



Publiations 201). ,. L. *ali Inia-Cina Bor!r isput!: A Cas! *tu o t! &ast!rn *!tor (AP;

 

PublD 1FF) pp!ni!mDs Int!rnational La"D ?ol. L $int &ition (1FF2) +!ar Boo o Int!rnational La" Commission (1F0) ?ol. J

WEBLIOGRAPHY

      

ttp://partn!rs.ntim!s.om ttps://boos.ool!.o.in ttp://alailama.om ttp://tim!.om ttps://""".4uora.om ttp://i

Dalai Lama Asylum in India- a case study

Recommend Documents