SEÑORES: JUEZ PRIMERO ADMINISTRATIVO ORAL DE BUCARAMANGA E.S.D.
RADICADO: 2016-0589 ASUNTO: DEMANDA DE REPARACIN DIRECTA !" RUBEN SUAREZ BLADEZ "# $"%$ $"%$"&" "&"#' #'() ()*+ *+# # ,"(, ,"(, !" & /* /* LUI LUIS S MIGUE MIGUEL L SUAREZ SUAREZ MONCADA MONCADA "# )#'$( !" La Nación Ministerio de Defensa Ejército Nacional3 Distrito Militar N!"# $%inta Bri&ada .
4EID4 4AMILE MONTO4A GOMEZ3 ($ !" "!(! 7")*#( !" "&'( )*!(!3 *!"# *!"#''**) **)(! (!(( )# )# ,( )"! )"!,( ,( !" )*! )*!((!(# !(#(( # #"$ "$ 1.0 1.098.; 98.;25 25.< .<69 69 !" B)($((#(3 "# )(,*!(! !" (%!"$(!( !", E"$)*' N()*#(, !" C,=*( ()'(#! "!*(#'" ,(& (),'(!"& )#"$*!(& ( * "!*(#'" %!"$ !"=*!("#'" )#"$*!3 " !*$* ( &'"! & &">$( )# ", *# !" CONTESTAR ,( !"(#!( !" ,( R""$"#)*( !"#'$ !", %$)"& !" )#'$, )#'$, !" R"%($()*+# R"%($()*+# D*$")'( )#&($( )#&($( ", ($'), 1<0 !", C+!* !" P$)"!**"#' A!*#*&'$('*7 !" , C#'"#)*& A!*#*&'$('*73 ( , )(, (#**"&' , &**"#'":
RES'EC(O A LOS )EC)OS:
1. E& )*"$' )*"$'.. E, 7"# 7"# LUIS MIGUEL SUAREZ MONCADA " $"),'(! %$ ", B('(,,+# !" *#(#'"$( #"$ 5 C(,!(& (!&)$*' ( ,( ?*#'( B$*(!( ", !( 01 !" J,* !" 2015.
2. E& )*"$'3 ( ,& '$"& "&"& !" "&'($ %$"&'(#! ", &"$7*)* *,*'($ =,*('$* "# ,(& *#&'(,()*#"& !", B('(,,+# C(,!(&3 (!@*$*+ #( "#"$"!(! )& &#'(& $")("$# "# *"=$"& (,'(&3 %$ ", )(, '7 @" &"$ *#)(%()*'(!. . N "& )*"$'. C(#! ", 7"# LUIS MIGUEL SUAREZ MONCADA )%,*+ 2 "&"& "# ", B('(,,+#3 $")*=*+ #( )($'( !#!" & %($"( &"#'*"#'(, L" (#*"&'(=( '"$*#($ ,( $",()*+# @" &&'"#(#3 "&'3 )#,,"7 @" ", 7"# )(,,"$( "# !"%$"&*+# %$ , )(, &" NEGO DE MANERA ROTUNDA *#&'*')*+#3 %"&
( $")*=*$ ('"#)*+# !*)( "# ,( "#"$"$( !" ,( !"&"(=(
$*$. P(&(!(
,( *#)(%()*!(!3 &" ,"
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
($"&*7*!(! )#
&&
)%(>"$&3 )$$*"#! %$ ,(&
*#&'(,()*#"& !", =('(,,+# '(=*# "&))/(=( ,(& 7)"& !" & "%($"( &"#'*"#'(,. E# $"*'"$(!(& %$'#*!(!"& *#'"#' ()(=($ )# & 7*!(3 '$('(=( !" *#$"&($ ( ,( "$( (, ($"$*,, !" ,( *#&'*')*+#3 /")/ "&'" @" ),($("#'" %!( %#"$ "# %",*$ & 7*!( ,( !" ,(& !"& %"$&#(&.
5. E& )*"$'3 %"& ", %$* !" LUIS MIGUEL SUAREZ MONCADA# ", &">$ M*", F#", S($" "# 7*&'( !" #( !*,*"#)*( @" $"(,*(=( "# ,(& *#&'(,()*#"& *,*'($"& "#)"#'$( (, 7"# "# (, "&'(! !" &(,! !( (7*& ( && %(!$"& /"$(#. 6. E& %($)*(,"#'" )*"$'. C(#! ", &">$ RUBEN SUAREZ BLADES# enc%entra a s% *ijo en el +atio de la instit%ción , en $%( *#'"$*$ "#
%,"# &,3 %$)"!" ( %$"#'($," ( ,& &%"$*$"& @" "&'(=(# (/3 @*"#"& ," (#*"&'($# @" # %!(# ()"$)($&" ( 7"$, !", ,($ %"& "&'"3 "# (#'"$*$"& %$'#*!(!"& ,& /(=( ("#((! !" "$'" ,( ($"&*7*!(! "$( !" "&'" 7"# )(!( 7" "$( ($3 @" %$ , @" !"=(# "&%"$($ ( @" "&'7*"&" !*&'$(! %($( !$*$, ( ,( "$( ,,"7($, ( ,( "#"$"$(. T"&'*#* !" & )%(>"$ !" *,( - O($ )*%(H. ;. E& )*"$'. E& 7"# %"$*'*+ &"$ $"*'*! ( ,( C,#*)( L( M"$)"! )(#! "7*!"#)*( @" "& & %(!$"3 ", &">$ RUBEN SUAREZ BLADES
@*"# ,"
$"( &" &"'( ( # %$)"!**"#' !*). 8. E& )*"$'. E, 7"# L*& S($" *#$"&( #"7("#'" ( ,(& *#&'(,()*#"& *,*'($"& !", =('(,,+# C(,!(&3 )# ", *# !" )#'*#($ )# && ()'*7*!(!"& *,*'($"&3 %$ ", )(,3 #"7("#'" !*)" &"#'*$&" %"$&"*!3 /&'*(! " '(#' ,( $(7"!(! !" ,& *&& @" ($"!*+ "# 7($*(& %$'#*!(!"& ( && )%(>"$&. 9. N "& )*"$'. S" $"*'*+ (, J7"# L*& S($" ( ,( C,#*)( P&*@*('$( ISNOR3 "# !#!" ,( ),#*)( ," &,*)*'( (, "$)*' N()*#(, !($ !" =(( (, &,!(! %($( %!"$ $"(,*($," '$('(*"#' !$(#'" ,& &**"#'"& !& 2H (>&3 *#$()*+# @" &" ," (#*"&'+ ( ,( (*,*( "!*(#'" "$*(,.
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
RES'EC(O A LAS 'RE(ENSIONES
C (%!"$(!( !", E"$)*' N()*#(, !" C,=*( (#**"&' @" " %# ( '!(& )(!( #( !" ,(& %$"'"#&*#"& )#!"#(& &,*)*'(!(& %$ ,( %($'" !"(#!(#'"3 "%#*"#! !" "&( (#"$( ,(& &**"#'"& ")"%)*#"& !" #!:
DEPRESION PERSONAL E, E$)*' N()*#(, ' ,(& "!*!(& $"@"$*!(& %($( )#'$,($ ,( !"%$"&*+# ($"&*7*!(! !", 7"# &,!(!3 @*"# %$ !")*&*+# %$%*( &" NEGO "# '!(& ,(& )(&*#"& ( $")*=*$ '$('(*"#'& !*)& (@",,& @" ," "$# &*#*&'$(!& &" $"(,*($# ( ,( "$( "# )#'$( !" ,( 7,#'(! !", *&3 ( @" "&'"3 !"&"(=( $*$ %$ $(#"& %"$&#(,"&. L( %($'" !"(#!(!( (,"( @" %$ #",*"#)*( !" ,( "#'*!(! ", &">$ LUIS MIGUEL SUAREZ %(!")*+ !*)/( "#"$"!(! &*# '"#"$ "# )"#'( @" "&'" /=$"3 "$( (,' )# "&'('$( !" 1390 )# ;5 !" %"& #( "$( %$!)' !", ""$)*)* @" $"(,*(=( "# ", *#(&* (#'"& !" *#$"&($ (, =('(,,+#3 %$ , )(, )#'$,($, $"@"$( !" < %"$&#(&.
COBRO DE LO NO DEBIDO L( %($'" !"(#!(#'"3 *#'"#'( @" &" ," $"%($" (, &">$ L*& M*", S($"3 %$ #( %&*=," (,,( "# ", &"$7*)*3 &*"%$" @" # &" "&%")**)( "# @" )#&*&'" ,( &%"&'( (,,( %$ %($'" !" #"&'$( "#'*!(!3 %$ ," )#'$($* *& #&'$& @*"#"& ," %$"&'(& ('"#)*+# *#"!*('( %$'#( "# ", '$('(*"#' !" & %(',(. ?" # "&"& !"'")'(!( & )#!*)*+# "# ,& ""#"& !" *#$"&3 # @*"$" !")*$ @" "*&'( #( $"&%#&(=*,*!(! !*$")'( %$ %($'" !" #&'$&. N "*&'" !"#'$ !", "&)$*' !" !"(#!( %$"&"#'(!(3 #( $",()*+# !*$")'( "#'$" ", "&'(! "#'(, !", &">$ L*& M*", S($" ,( %&*=*,*!(! @" "&' "$( )(&(! %$ #"&'$( "#'*!(!3 , @" ),($("#'" $%" ,( $",( !", #" !" )(&(,*!(!. S" "&' "# %$"&"#)*( !" $"&%#&(=*,*!(! $!*)( )(#! ( )(&( !" #( ())*+# *&*+# &" "#"$( # %"$*)* ( '$( %"$&#( )(#! ", $"&,'(! !" "&& /")/& "&. E# &'(3 (, )#'$($* !" ,( $"&%#&(=*,*!(! $(,3 ", $"&,'(! @" !"=" &"$ # %"$*)*3 '$(#&)*"#!" (, )(% "'"$# (")'(#! ,( 7*!( "# &)*"!(! 7*,(#! #$(& $!*)(&3 %$ , )(, && "")'& &" "&)(%(# !", "$ *#'"$#
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
'RUEBAS DOCUMEN(ALES
S$7(&" & &">$( '"#"$ ) %$"=(& !)"#'(,"& ,& &**"#'"&: 1. D*)'("# !*) !" &(#*!(! N 0125< D", "$)*' N()*#(, !" C,=*(. 2. D*)'("# %"$*)*(, !", M!*) P&*@*('$( D$. J(# R# R*@",". A!&)$*' ( ,( E#'*!(! . D*)'("# !*) %&*),+*) !", D$. D*" A$(#! M($(!#(. A!&)$*' ( ,( E#'*!(!. <. *&'$*( C,#*)( !", &">$ L*& M*", S($" 5. M"$*(, $"*'*! ( ,( (*,*( !", &">$ L*& M*", S($" !#!" &" *#$( !" ,( $"*&*+# ( ,( C,#*)( P&*@*'$*)(. 6. C($'( !" ,( 7"# 4,*( G+" !#!" ," (#**"&'( ,( '"$*#()*+# !" ,( $",()*+# !" %($"(. ;. C($'( !", 7"# L*& M*", S($" !*$**!( ( & (*,*( !#!" (#**"&'( ", !"&" !" $*$. 8. $,( !*)( $")*=*!( %$ ", !)'$ D*" A$(#! M($(!#(. 9. C%*( !" ,(& )#&*#()*#"& $"(,*(!(& ( ,( ),#*)( P&*@*'$*)( !", %( %$ ", '$('(*"#' !*).
T"&'*#*(,"&. 1. S" &*$7( )*'($ (, D"&%()/3 %$"7*( *()*+# !" ")/( /$(3 (, &">$ G"#"$(, MARCO IDEL SUAREZ3 "" !" S(#*!(! !", E"$)*' N()*#(, !" C,=*( D*&'$*' M*,*'($ 2 ?*#'( B$*(!( %($( @" $('**@" ,(& !"),($()*#"& "# )(#' (, "&'(! !" &(,! !", &">$ L*& M*", S($".
2.
?" &" *" ")/( /$(3 &" ,,(" ( !"),($($ (, !)'$ D*" A$(#! M($(!#(. A!&)$*' ( ,( "#'*!(! %($( @" !"%#( (=&",7( ", *#'"$$('$* @" $(,"#'" ," $,($ &=$" ,& /")/& !" ,( %$"&"#'" !"(#!(.
3.
?" &" *" ")/( /$(3 &" ,,(" ( !"),($($ ( ,( 7"# 4,*( G" "%($"( !", 7"# &,!(!H %($( @" !"%#( (=&",7( ", *#'"$$('$* @" $(,"#'" ," $,($ &=$" ,& /")/& !" ,( %$"&"#'" !"(#!(.
<. ?" &" *" ")/( /$(3 &" ,,(" ( !"),($($ ( ,( 7"# O($ C*%( )%(>"$ !" *,( !", &,!(!H %($( @" !"%#( (=&",7( ", *#'"$$('$* @" $(,"#'" ," $,($ &=$" ,& /")/& !" ,( %$"&"#'" !"(#!(. 5. L(& @" ", S">$ J" )#&*!"$" %"$'*#"#'"&3 '*,"& #")"&($*(&.
-UNDAMEN(OS DE DEREC)O
L" 1<; !" 20013 C#&'*')*+# N()*#(, !" C,=*( !"& #$(& )#)$!(#'"&.
NO(I-ICACIONES
E&'(! N()*+# M*#*&'"$* !" D""#&( E$)*' N()*#(, "# ", D*&'$*' M*,*'($ N. 23 ?*#'( B$*(!( !" B)($((#(. C($$"$( )# C(,," 18. T",#: 6 < << 66 "# ", )$$" ",")'$+#*) @" & !"&%()/ '"#( "# )#)**"#' %($( &'" *#.
D", &">$ J" ('"#'("#'":
4EID4 4AMILE MONTO4A GOMEZ CC. 1098;25<69 !" B)($((#( TP. 12<.2<8 DEL CSJ.