+SSJM NJDIOL:S T:L/C ZhXdWZgiV YV9jhig|a^V' VheZhhdVhYd EjcYd 9ci^\d ckZcX^YVh YZfjZ a\Q\` dh X^hcZh ZgVb WgVcXdh) =hiVZgVjbV Zhi^dc|kZaedg hZgVWhdajiVbZciZXdc[^gbVYV edg Zk^Y•cX^Vh ZeVgVg(hZ Xdb d eg^bZ^gdX^hcZcZ\gV edYZ iZgh^YdjbV iZgZhhVciZ eVgVVa\jch dgc^iƒad\dh $ZdjigVh eZhhdVh ciZ egZdXjeVYVhXdb VXdadgV•~d Ydhe|hhVgdh%'bVh c~d * V^bedgi}cX^VYZhhV ]^hiƒg^V)=aVh^beaZhbZciZ ^ajhigV ~d hZkZgV cd VegZcY^oVYd edg bZ^d YZdWhZgkV•…Zh dj Z V[gV\^a^YVYZ YZcdhhd Xdc]ZX^bZcid)MbV †c^XV edYZ ^ckVa^YVg jbV V[^gbV•~ddg^\^cVYV eZaVZm^hi•cX^V YZX^hcZhWgVcXdh) LjYd fjZ hZegZX^hV € YZjb †c^Xd AgV $fjZ iVbW€b' eZad fjZ hZ^'€ bj^id [Z^d%)!
^Xd'V\gVY|kZaZ Xdb jbV ^bedgiVciZ bZchV\Zb)! 6YaGV[R``I1RRX [VhX^cVciZ hdWgZ Xdbd ZhiVbdhXdchiVciZbZciZ { bZgX• O&! ii'
HUR;aaN_QVN[
N+SSJM NJDIOL+S T+L/C
+
LhHJD+EO r
-LSN/ N/HRO d ^beVXid
Yd VaiVbZciZ ^begdk|kZa
DYIL\kjV =IYKMSVCKPQSL BM]QZjVDlKUQKI =IYQV@QUV
!!
+@MN6@FF@L
;AH(:J9KAD) ;9L9DG?9x9G(F9(>GFL= KAF
LVaZW'FVhh^b 9 aƒ\^XVYd ;^hcZ FZ\gd5 d ^beVXid Yd VaiVbZciZ ^begdk|kZa *FVhh^b F^X]daVhLVaZW6 igVYj•~d YZEVg( XZadKX]^aY)( J^d YZBVcZ^gd5 6R`aGRYYR_& ,**2( LgVYj•~d YZ5L]Z :aVX` KlVc AK:F 423(30(213/(-,-(0
DN_N6R[\Va AN[QRYO_\a& bZ T_RT\ R[a_R_\ZN[\`
,) AcXZgiZoV $LZdg^V YV^c[dgbV•~d%( 9heZXidhhdX^V^h) -) HgZk^h~d)Y'L‚ijad) ;<<5 ++.)0/ ;
;deng^\]i
L‚ijad dg^\^cVa L@= :D9;C KO 9F a -++2 WnFVhh^b F^X]daVhLVaZW)
;VeV5 KZchZ
;=5Z:37
8RhLOHO KdWgZ VeajbV\Zb Ydhe|hhVgdh ? ^bR c\Po [l\ `NOR 9e]R_a` R !aR_[\` cNgV\`! 5]_R[QR[Q\ N N]_R[QR_ Mb cdkd i^ed YZ^c\gVi^Y~d 9 k^YV€ bj^id ZhigVc]V HaVi~dZd cZgY ;]Vid YZbV^heVgVhZZhXgZkZg VgZheZ^id G eg^cX^eVa
,0 ,0 +1 +2 ,* -, -. -/ -0 -2
AN]N QRPN]pabY\` 8+:+43.+\`/;
,2 ./
=5,/:<7
/-7&
7= -757
-BPgTULO=M) 7 BPRFNEJXBEO EF UM DeTJDOFMPgRJDO 9cVidb^V YZjb ;^hcZ FZ\gd G\O_RSNgR_\ R`]R_NQ\ !DN_Np`\!RcN]\_NQ\ 5 [\VaRR`a_RYNQN @^hiƒg^VZ d iZgXZidYVdeVX^YVYZ BV[TbnZ `NOR\ ^bR R`aj NP\[aRPR[Q\
-4
., ., -. -/ -0 .1 .2
5
-BPgTULO
=be^g^hbd cZ\Vi^kd 7\[aN[Q\ Nana_o` JV \ba_\ AV[V cR_ZRYU\ BRZ abQ\ 8R c\YaNN\ ARQV\P_V`al\ -BPgTULO;FJS)+ GBLaDJB NBRRBTJVB KdWgZVhXVjhVhYVb^c]V gZ_Z^•~dVXVjhVh <^k^Y^cYdX€gZWgdh VdbZ^d IZ ]\bP\ ZNV`QRQ\]NZV[N 5 _RT_NQR5[Q_Rf BVX\YNfRcVPU IZ Z\Q\ ZRYU\_QRZ\__R_ JZXdgYV•…Zh YZXd^hVh c~d ZmViVbZciZeVhhVYVh 5 [N__NaVcN Q\ Y\bP\ BN__NaVcN R aR_N]VN =hiVgZggVYdXdb egZX^h~d^c[^c^iV 7Vo[PVNVZ]N_PVNY G hZchVX^dcVa Z d ;^hcZ FZ\gd 7RTbRV_N N\ 7V`[RBRT_\ 5 Na_Nml\Q\ `R[`NPV\[NY Gh ViVa]dh 7bVQNQ\P\Z \ Pn_RO_\ 7\Z\ RcVaN_ NSNYjPVN [N__NaVcN
** ** "!" "!% "!' "!) "!) ""! """ ""# ""%
-BPgTULO;FTF) >JVFNEONB BNTFDbMBRBEB FSPFRBNdB ;gjZaYVYZYdh^\jV^h C[QR \ _RYRcN[aR n \ `R[`NPV\[NY Bl\ YV[RN_VQNQR` D_RSR_V[Q\ \ ]_\PR``\ N\` _R`bYaNQ\` BNab_RgNUbZN[N&SRYVPVQNQR R_RP\Z]R[`N` V__RTbYN_R` 5 N[aRPkZN_NQNR`]R_N[mN =[RO_VNQ\ ]RYNR`]R_N[mN 5 Q\PRN_ZNQVYUN QNRe]RPaNaVcN EbN[Q\ c\Po ]_RPV`NQNS\_aNYRgN 6N`aVN[V 9Y8R`VR_a\QR@\` Hj_aN_\` GN[T_N_\b Re]Y\QV_
,-0
,,0
""' ,,4
"#! "## "#$
"#' "#) ,-4
"$! "$" "$$ "$$ ,./ ,.0
"$' ,.3
-BPgTULO7JTO)+ SORTF JNGBLgVFL EF 1JBDOMO -BSBNOVB) 7 PROCLFMBEB FVJEfNDJBSJLFNDJOSB 9 ]^hiƒg^VYdhVYdgVYdgZh V[d\VYdh G XZb^i€g^dYZaZigVh# 7\Z\ SVPN_ZVYV\[j_V\ RZ QRg]N``\` MbV VXVYZb^V YZ\^c|hi^XVeVgVgVidh JVn` ]R_cR_`\ Cba_N` N]YVPNmsR` \PbYaN` 5 Rc\Ybml\ Q\ P\_]\ QR[NQNQ\_ G fjZ kdX• k• Z d fjZ kdX• c~d k• AnQVP\` 9 egdiZ•~d YZiZ[adc YZ?^VXdbd ;VhVcdkV !G\b bZN ]R``\N ^bR P\__R _V`P\`! Kdj jb ;^hcZ FZ\gd5 G k^€hVcigƒe^Xd G !]\_^bo! `b]R_SVPVNY
,/,/-
"%& "%( "%* "&" "&" "&# "&$ "&& "&' "&* "'" "'%
-BPgTULO6OVF) + GBLaDJB LiEJDBOU B JNDFRTFXB EO NFRE Ldcn ?dgYjX]d >\U[ QRS\_N Q\ 6_\\XYf[ 9abd•d cd aV\d ;dbd 5 V[PR_aRgNQ\ [R_Q 5]\`aN[Q\ P\Z \` QNQ\` R__NQ\` =cXZggVcYdVHVgiZMb ? `b]R_SVPVNY cRZ U a\[N 8V`ak[PVN Q\` ]_VZN aN`
"'' "'' "') "(! "(# "(% "(' "(' "()
8+:
")" ")#
87./57;
8:/>/:
-BPgTULO.FX) 7 FSDbNEBLOEB PRFEJdcO KdWgZV^begZX^h~dYVXdciV\Zb YZVbVciZh YZ;ViVg^cV ;Z\jZ^gV Vd;^hcZ FZ\gd gZk^h^iVYV 5QVcV[UN[Q\ R]_RcR[Q\ Ac[dgbV•~d € gj^b eVgVd Xdc]ZX^bZcid G egdWaZbVYd ZheZX^Va^hiV dj VigV\€Y^VYd iZgcd kVo^d G ^bR `R Z\cR R \ ^bR [l\ `R Z\cR 7\Z\ _V_]\_ tYaVZ\
")$ ")% ")) ")* ")* "*# "*$ "*&
9cR[a\` `l\ R`a_N[U\` 5__RON[UN[Q\'`R P\Z\ TNQ\ 9b R`aNcN!^bN`R! PR_a\ FRNYVQNQR4 DN_N^bo4 !HdgV^hhd!' ZhiVkVXZgid 5 ORYRgNQNaRP[\Y\TVN3DYN[VYUN`Q\ 9ePRY ? PN_jaR_Q\` R__\` QR]_RcV`l\ F~d VigVkZhhZ jb g^dhZZaZi^kZg$Zb b€Y^V%jb bZigd Zk^ciZ YZegd[jcY^YVYZ 5__bZR \ba_\ RZ]_RT\ B\>:?
,42 ,43
"** #!$ #!& #!( #!* #"! -,.
#"%
-BPgTULO7NXF) -OMO PRODURBR TJTJDB EF PBSSBRJNIO ;dbd egdXjgVgi^i^XVYZeVhhVg^c]d 8R`P\OR_aN` V[NQcR_aVQN` IZN `\Ybml\ U R`]R_N QRbZ ]_\OYRZN 7\[aV[bR ]_\Pb_N[Q\ ;dbd egZkZghjVhegZk^h…Zh 9 Zc€h^bVWdaVYZW^a]Vg 8RP\_\ N\ R`aVY\QN HR_PRV_N FR]tOYVPN ? ]_\OYRZN Q\` a_o`P\_]\` 9YR` NV[QNVT[\_NZ
#"' #"' #") ##" ### ##$ ##( ##( ##* #$$ #$& #$( #$( #%! #%$
-BPgTULO.OXF) /PJSTFMODRBDJB$ UM SONIO A\[`VRb_ QRA\[aNVT[R& R]V`aRZ\P_NaN 9]V`aRZ\P_NPVN G eVhhVYdYd eVhhVYdZ d [jijgd Yd eVhhVYd D_RQVml\&R__\` QR]_RQVml\ RSRYVPVQNQR
#%& #%' #%( -/3
#&! #&" #&" -0. *-,
CE=dB;?
-BPgTULO
GRWN a\Y\ [\` YbTN_R`PR_a\` 9`aRWN ]_R]N_NQ\ 9 ^Y€^V Yd VX^YZciZ edh^i^kd
J\YNaVYVQNQR R_V`P\QR7V`[RBRT_\ 5 R`a_NanTVN WVgWZaa !BV[TbnZ `NOR[NQN! 5 T_N[QRN``VZRa_VN 8+:
-36A/6<7;
-02 -02
#&* #&* #'! #'" #'" #'# #'(
ARQV\P_VQNQR Q\b_NQN ? R__\QRQRb` D\V[PN_n_bZ\ N\ `NYcNZR[a\ 9YVZV[N[Q\V[SYbo[PVN` V[Wb`aN` !C` ;_RT\` N aR_VNZQRVSVPNQ\! 5]R[N` !`VZ)[l\!& ]\_ SNc\_
Zhi| hZ\jgd cd =migZb^hi~d
IZ S_N[Po`Q\ 6_\\XYf[ 5 PNbQNY\[TN " ;Y\ONYVgNml\V[To[bN JZkZgh…Zh eVgVadc\Z Yd =migZb^hi~d
-BPgTULO9UJNXF)+ DURVBNB GORMB EF SJNO$ B HRBNEF GRBUEF JNTFLFDTUBL
8R`VTbNYQNQR 9ea_RZV`al\ RN _RT_N2*),* ;_NZN Rj_c\_R` 7\Z\ OROR_ PNSn]\QR `R_`RTb_\ 5Z\_ ]\_ PR_aRgN` 7\Z\ ]_\c\PN_ PNaj`a_\SR`
.+.
$!% $!& $!& $!& $!'
Mb ZmeZg^bZcid bZciVa $a^iZg|g^d% hdWgZVdg^\Zb YVXjgkV cV [dgbV YZh^cd
D_R``b]\`VmsR`P\[S\_aN[aR` !5 bOV^uVQNQR QNTNb``VN[N! -BPgTULO.FXFSSFJS)+ FSTeTJDB EB BLFBTORJFEBEF
-2. #($ #(& #(( #() #(* #)! #)# #)% #)'
G edZiV YVVaZVidg^ZYVYZ G eaVidc^hbd Ydhig^}c\jadh
5 TR\ZRa_VNQN[Nab_RgN :_NPaNYVQNQR IZN NO\_QNTRZcV`bNYQ\ 9ea_RZV`al\)ARQV\P_V`al\ Dn_\YN`N\` ]\_P\` 9 aƒ\^XVYVVaZVidg^ZYVYZ [gVXiVa $Xdb jb Vk^hd% ? ]_\OYRZNQ\ YVZVaR `b]R_V\_
7bVQNQ\P\Z N]_RPV`l\ FRcV`VaN[Q\N]\mN Q"jTbN 8N _R]_R`R[aNml\U _RNYVQNQR EV^h jbV kZo' Xj^YVYdXdb dh egZk^hdgZh
G ?Vjhh^Vcd Zd EVcYZaWgdi^Vcd ? NbZR[a\ QNQVZV[bVml\ G ZN[QRYO_\aVN[\ ? ^bR QRcR`R_YRZO_NQ\
.+-
$!( $"$ $"%
.7 /?<:/53;<[7
-BPJTULO-BTORXF).O 5FEJODRJSTcO BO /WTRFMJSTcO$ F EF VOLTB BO 5FEJODRJSTcO ? Zb[Q\ n V[Wb`a\ ? RSRVa\ ANaRb` @p[TbNS_N[PN =QnVN` RP\[ajTV\` F^c\j€b
( G bdchigd b€Y^d YZIj€iZaZi
'(
ANV` bZN cRg&bZN `\Ybml\ SRYVg #)* #)* #*" #*$ #*& #*& #*' #*( #*) $!! $!"
GcYZ Zhi| d ;^hcZ FZ\gd8
-BPgTULO.FXFSSFTF)7S LOUDOS EF 4ODKF$OUDURVBS NB GORMB EF SJNONOSLUHBRFS FRRBEOS 5]R[N` PV[^uR[aNN[\` 5 a_NVml\Q\ R`P_Vab_j_V\ EbNY^bR_bZ ]\QR `R_]_R`VQR[aR ANV` U\__\_ 7\[SV_ZNml\ >d^ VeZcVhjb ;^hcZ FZ\gd
7\Z\
!]_\cN_! P\V`N`
$"' $"' $"* $#! $#" $#$ $#% $#( $$! $$" $$" $$$ $$% $$& $$(
$$* $%! $%" $%# .// ./2 ./3 ./3
-BPgTULO.FXOJTO)+ JNDFRTFXB EO JMPOSTOR 9 [Va|X^V a†Y^XV gZk^h^iVYV
9[P\[a_R \ VZ]\`a\_ C` SVYq`\S\` ]\QRZ `R_]R_VT\`\` ]N_N N `\PVRQNQR4 ? ]_\OYRZN QN]_jaVPN IjVcidh O^ii\ZchiZ^ch edYZb YVc•VgcV XVWZ•V YZjb Va[^cZiZ8 C[QR R`aj D\]]R_ ^bN[Q\ c\Po ]_RPV`NQRYR4 ? OV`]\ R \ N[NYV`aN ANV` SjPVYQ\ ^bR `R ]R[`N3 G ]_\OYRZN QNQRPV`l\ `\O \
.0-
$&# $&$ .0/
$&& .00 .02 .03
8:_4717
PRaVPV`Z\
8+:
035
-BPgTULO.FXFNOVF) 5FJO B MFJO$OUDOMO GJDBR QUJTFDOM O -JSNF 6FHRO IjVcYd eZgYZgjb igZb c~d Yƒ^ >^b
$'$ .10
$''
/PgLOHO)7S -JSNFS,RBNDOSEF @FVHFNJB
+./
+HRBEFDJMFNTOS
.14
1LOSSaRJO
.20
6OTBS
.3,
,JCLJOHRBGJB
%!*
gNEJDFRFMJSSJVO
/0,
;OCRFO BUTOR
%&*
9ciZh YVYZhXdWZgiV YV9jhig|a^V' VheZhhdVhYd 9ci^\d EjcYd ZhiVkVb XdckZcX^YVhYZ fjZ a\Q\` dh X^hcZhZgVb WgVcXdh)=hiV ZgVjbV XgZc•V ^cfjZhi^dc|kZa edg hZgVWhdajiVbZciZ Xdc[^gbVYVedg Zk^Y•cX^VhZbe‚( g^XVh)
ˆ 9 Y^hhZb^cV•~dYZiZaZ[dcZhXZajaVgZh Xdb X}bZgVhegdedgX^dcdj(bZ jbV kVhiVXdaZ•~d YZ[did\gV[^VhYZX^hcZhcZ\gdh Zck^VYVh edg aZ^idgZhk^V_VciZh) Fd †ai^bd FViVa'gZXZW^ iVb( W€b jbV XV^mV YZk^c]d ;^hcZ FZ\gd $fjZ c~d € bZj [Vkdg^id%'jbV [^iVYZk‚YZd $c~d Vhh^hidVk‚YZdh%Z Yd^ha^kgdh)HgZ[^gdVh[didh)
;^hcZ FZ\gd $Xdb ^c^X^V^h bV^†hXjaVh% € jb ZkZcidXdb dhig•h Vig^Wjidh YZhXg^idh VhZ\j^g) Hg^bZ^gd'd ;^hcZ FZ\gd € jb CbaYVR_&+ ed^h Zhi| [dgVYd }bW^id YVh ZmeZXiVi^kVh Xdbjch' _~fjZ cVYVcd eVhhVYdedYZ VedciVgXdck^cXZc( iZbZciZ eVgVVhjV edhh^W^a^YVYZ) KZ\jcYd' ZaZZmZgXZ jb ^beVXidZmigZ( bd) LZgXZ^gd' VeZhVg YZhZgjb \baYVR_& VcVijgZoV]jbVcV [VoXdb fjZ YZhZckdakVbdhZmea^XV•…Zh eVgVhjV dXdgg•cX^V N]q` d ZkZcid' idgcVcYd( d Zmea^X|kZa ZegZk^h‚kZa) HVgdV\dgVeVgVgZhjb^g d iZgXZid5 gVg^YVYZ' ^beVXid ZmigZbdZ egZ( k^h^W^a^YVYZ gZigdheZXi^kV $bVhc~d egdheZXi^kV%)& Mb eZfjZcd c†bZgd YZ;^hcZh FZ\gdh Zmea^XV fjVhZ ijYd cd bjcYd' YdhjXZhhdYZ^Y€^Vh ZYZ gZa^\^…Zh {hY^c}b^XVh YZZkZcidh]^hiƒg^XdhZ VZaZbZcidhYZcdhhVhk^YVh eZhhdV^h)
cVhVkdX•' hZj eg^bd BdZnZ Vb^b' Z h^b VfjVhZ idYdh dh !X^Zci^hiVh hdX^V^h! fjZ' edg bV^hYZjb h€Xjad'deZgVgVbhdWVXgZc•V[VahV YZfjZ Vh[ZggVbZciVhYZaZh edYZg^VbbZY^gV^cXZgiZoV) 9[^gbd ^hhdedgfjZ Vh Vea^XV•…Zh YVhX^•cX^Vh YV^cXZgiZoV VegdWaZbVhYd bjcYd gZVai^kZgVb Z[Z^idhg^Y‚Xjadh) L^kZd eg^k^a€\^dYZiZhiZbjc]Vg ^hhdcVh[^cVc•VhZcV ZXdcdb^V)HZg\jciZ Vd\ZgZciZYZhjV XVgiZ^gV YZi‚ijadh Xdbd ZaZYZ[^( c^g^V!g^hXd!'Z h~d\gVcYZhVhX]VcXZh YZfjZ ZaZ[dgcZ•VVkdX• jbV ZR' QVQNfjZ RePYbVVedhh^W^a^YVYZ Yd ;^hcZ FZ\gd ( dj hZ_V'Va\d fjZ c~d iZb bV^hkVadgegZY^i^kdYd fjZ VVhigdad\^V eVgVVkVa^Vg dh g^hXdh idiV^h $kZgZbdhXdbd ZaZhZc[Z^iVbV[gVjYZ^ciZaZXijVa Xdb bViZb|i^XV%)=hhZ egdWaZbV€ ZcY•b^XdZb fjZhi…ZhhdX^V^h) 9 ^Y€^VXZcigVaYZhiZa^kgd€ VWdgYVg cdhhV XZ\jZ^gVZb gZaV•~d{ VaZVidg^ZYVYZ' eVgi^XjaVgbZciZdh \gVcYZhYZhk^dh5 edg fjZ bdi^kd cƒh' X^Zci^hiVh dj c~d' [^\jg…Zhdj XVgVh Xdbjch' iZcYZbdh VkZgdh XZciVkdh Zb kZoYdhYƒaVgZh8 HdgfjZ Xdci^cjVbdh Vcdh XdcXZcigVg cVhb^c†X^Vh Z c~d cdh ZkZcidhh^\c^[^XVi^kVbZciZ \gVcYZhfjZ h~d edhh‚kZ^h'VeZhVg YVhegdkVhƒWk^Vh YZhjV ^c[aj•cX^V\^\VciZhXV8= hZkdX• VXdbeVc]Vg bZj Vg\jbZcid' edg fjZ bdi^kd aZg_dgcV^h'cV kZgYVYZ' _RQbghZj Xd( c]ZX^bZcid hdWgZ d bjcYd8 e [|X^akZgfjZ Vk^YV€ d Z[Z^idXjbjaVi^kd YZjb ejc]VYd YZX]dfjZh h^\c^[^XVi^kdh) F~d € i~d Y^[‚X^a ^YZci^[^XVg d eVeZaYZ;^hcZhFZ\gdh YZhjV edaigdcV $dj WVcfj^c]d YZWVg%) >V•Vd hZ\j^ciZ ZmZgX‚X^d) GWhZgkZ hjV egƒeg^VZm^hi•cX^V) ;dciZ dh ZkZcidh^bedgiVciZh' VhbjYVc•Vh iZXcdaƒ( \^XVhZ Vh^ckZc•…ZhfjZ dXdggZgVbZb cdhhd VbW^ZciZYZhYZfjZ kdX• cVhXZjZ XdbeVgZ(dhVdfjZ ZgVZheZgVYd VciZhYZhZj VYkZcid)IjVcidh VXdciZXZgVb Xdbd egd\gVbVYd8GWhZgkZ hjV k^YVeZhhdVa'hjV ZhXda]V YZegd[^hh~d'edg ZmZbead'dj ZcXdcigVghZj eVgXZ^gd' d Zm‚a^d Yd eV‚hYZ dcYZ cVhXZj'VhigV^•…Zh fjZ Zc[gZcidj' hZj h†W^idZcg^fjZX^bZcid dj ZbedWgZX^bZcid);db fjZ [gZf‡•cX^VZhhVh Xd^hVh VXdciZXZgVb Xdc[dg( bZ d eaVcZ_VYd8
; CbaYVR_ gZegZhZciVdh YVYdhZhe†g^dhZb jbV VbdhigV ZhiVi‚hi^XV) $F) Q\ F(H($ ˆ G [l\ RcR[a\ YZVa\d VbeaVbZciZ ZheZgVYdiVbW€b € jb ;^hcZ FZ\gd) GWhZgkZfjZ' h^bZ( ig^XVbZciZ' VdXdgg•cX^VYZjb ZkZcid VaiVbZciZ ^begdk|kZa € Zfj^kVaZciZ{ c~d(qXdgg•c( X^VYZjb ZkZcid VaiVbZciZegdk|kZa)
9 aƒ\^XVYd ;^hcZ FZ\gd idgcV \ ^bR c\Po [l\ `NORbV^hgZaZkVciZ Yd fjZ Vfj^ad fjZ kdX• hVWZ) DZkZZb Xdch^YZgV•~d fjZ bj^idh ;^hcZh FZ\gdh edYZb hZgXVjhVYdh dj ZmVXZgWVYdh ]\_ `R_RZ V[R`]R_NQ\`(
HZchZcd ViVfjZ iZggdg^hiVYZ ,, YZhZiZbWgd YZ-++,5 hZd g^hXd[dhhZ gVodVkZabZciZ P\[PROpcRY cd# Y^V,+ YZ hZiZbWgd' ZaZc~d iZg^VVXdciZX^( Yd) KZiVaedhh^W^a^YVYZ [dhhZXdch^YZgVYV Y^\cV YZViZc•~d' XV•VhiZg^Vb kdVYd Zb idgcd YVhidggZh \•bZVh' dh Vk^…Zh iZg^Vb edgiVh igVcXVYVh Z{ egdkV YZWVaVh Z d ViVfjZ c~d iZg^VVXdciZX^Yd'edcid [^cVa)9a\jbV djigV Xd^hVedYZg^ViZg VXdciZX^Yd)IjZ Xd^hV8F~d hZ^) F~d € ZhigVc]d kZg jb ZkZcid dXdggZgegZX^hVbZciZedgfjZ c~d YZ( kZg^VdXdggZg8IjZ i^ed YZYZ[ZhViZgcdh XdcigV^hhd8G fjZ fjZg fjZ kdX• kZc]V V hVWZg$fjZ FdkV Qdg` € jb VakdiZggdg^hiV[|X^a' edg ZmZbead%' edYZ eVhhVgVhZg^ch^\c^[^XVciZhZhZj ^c^b^\d hdjWZgfjZ kdX• hVWZY^h( hd) =b jb _d\d YZZhigVi€\^VXdgcd ZhhZ'edYZ hZgZhigVc]d fjZ d fjZ hZ hVWZ edhhV hZgkZgYVYZ^gVbZciZ^ch^\c^[^XVciZ) AhhdhZ ZhiZcYZV idYdh dh gVbdh YZ cZ\ƒX^dh) HZchZ hdWgZV !gZXZ^iV hZXgZiV!eVgVfjZ hZiZc]V jb hjXZhhdVWhdajidcd gVbd YZgZhiVjgVciZh) KZZaV[dhhZXdc]ZX^YVZ ƒWk^V'Zci~d Va\j€b _| iZg^VXdcXZW^Yd V ^Y€^VZ ZaViZg^VeVhhVYdVhZg\Zc€g^XV)G egƒm^bd hjXZhhdVWhdajidcV ^cY†hig^V YZgZhiVjgVciZhegZX^hV hZgjgcV ^Y€^VfjZ c~d € [VX^abZciZXdcXZW^YV eZaV edejaV•~d VijVaYZegdeg^Zi|g^dh YZgZhiVjgVciZh)=aVegZX^hVZhiVgVXZgiV Y^hi}cX^VYVhZmeZXiVi^kVh) IjVcid bV^h ^cZheZgVYd[dg d hjXZhhd YZjb ZbegZZcY^bZcid' bZcdg d c†bZgd YZ XdcXdggZciZhZ bV^h WZb(hjXZ( Y^YdhZg| d ZbegZh|g^d fjZ ^beaZbZciV V ^Y€^V)G bZhbd Vea^XV(hZ Vd cZ\ƒX^d YZhVeVidhZ a^kgdh( dj fjVafjZg i^ed YZZbegZZcY^bZcid) G bZhbd Vea^XV(hZ ViZdg^VhX^Zci‚[^XVh ( c^c\j€b Zhi| ^ciZgZhhVYdZb dj( k^g ig^k^Va^YVYZh) 9 gZXdbeZchV YZ jb ZbegZZcY^bZcid ]jbVcd €' Zb \ZgVa'^ckZghVbZciZ egdedgX^dcVa Vd fjZ hZZheZgVfjZ ZaVhZ_V) ;dch^YZgZ d ihjcVb^ cd dXZVcdHVX‚[^Xd Zb YZoZbWgdYZ-++/) ;Vhd [dhhZZheZgVYd'c~d iZg^VXVjhVYddh ZhigV\dhfjZ XVjhdj ( Vh|gZVhV[Z( iVYVhiZg^Vb bZcdh eZhhdVhZ jb h^hiZbV YZ VaVgbZVciZX^eVYdZhiVg^V Zb deZgV•~d) G fjZ kdX• hVWZc~d edYZ bVX]jX|(ad)
5 V[PN]NPVQNQR QR`R ]_RcR_ djia^Zgh VZ]YVPN[N V[PN]NPVQNQR QR`R]_RcR_ \ Pb_`\ QNUV`aq_VN& YVYVVeVgi^X^eV•~dYZiV^hZkZcidh cV Y^c}b^XV Ydh VXdciZX^bZcidh) Fd ZciVcid V\^bdh Xdgcd hZ[„hhZbdh XVeVoZh YZegZkZgZkZcidh ]^hiƒg^( Xdh'dj' V^cYVe^dg' Xdgcd hZ[„hhZbdh XVeVoZh YZbjYVg d Xjghd YV]^hiƒ(
YV)HgdYjo^bdh egd_Z•…ZhYZY€[^X^ihYVegZk^Y•cX^VhdX^Va Z YZegZ•dh YZ eZigƒaZd eVgVYVfj^ Vig^ciV Vcdh' hZb eZgXZWZg fjZ c~d edYZbdh egZk•( adhcZb bZhbd eVgVd egƒm^bd kZg~d( cdhhdh ZggdhYZegZk^h~dXjbjaV( i^kdh eVgVZkZcidh eda‚i^XdhZ ZXdc„b^Xdh h~d i~d \g^iVciZhfjZ egZX^hdbZ WZa^hXVg eVgViZg XZgiZoVYZfjZ c~d Zhidj hdc]VcYd hZbegZ fjZ dWhZgkd d gZ\^higdZbe‚g^Xd) G fjZ € hjgegZZcYZciZ c~d € VbV\c^ijYZ YZcdhhdh ZggdhYZegZk^h~d'bVh h^b cdhhV[VaiVYZXdchX^•cX^V YZaV) Ahhd€ V^cYVbV^h egZdXjeVciZ fjVcYd cdh ZckdakZbdh Zb Xdc[a^idhbdgiV^h5Vh\jZggVh h~d [jcYVbZciVabZciZ ^begZk^h‚kZ^h$Zc~d hVWZbdhY^hhd%)
€ ZmeZg^bZciVg d b|m^bd edhh‚kZaZ iZciVgXdaZX^dcVg d bV^dg c†bZgd edhh‚kZaYZdedgijc^YVYZhYZ;^hcZh FZ\gdh) #?A7=67=6>
B 3?A7=67A
Gjigd ^beZY^bZcid gZaVX^dcVYd Vdh]jbVcdh kZb Yd [dXdZmXZhh^kd cd fjZ hVWZbdh5 iZcYZbdh VVegZcYZg d ZheZX‚[^Xd' c~d d \ZgVa) G fjZ VheZhhdVhVegZcYZgVbXdb d Ze^hƒY^dYd '' YZKZiZbWgd8 KZg| fjZ VegZcYZgVbfjZ Va\jch ZkZcidh' YZk^YdVhjVh Y^c}b^XVh'gZh^YZb aVg\VbZciZ[dgVYd }bW^id Yd egZk^h‚kZa8 F~d) KZg|fjZ VegZcYZgVbd YZ[Z^idZbWji^YdcVhVWZYdg^V XdckZcX^dcVa8 F~d) 9 fjZ XdcXajh~dX]Z( \VgVb89h eZhhdVhVegZcYZgVbgZ\gVhegZX^hVh YZXdbd Zk^iVgegdidiZg( gdg^hiVh ^ha}b^XdhZ ZY^[‚X^dh Vaidh)Ej^iVh eZhhdVh[^XVbbZ aZbWgVcYd fjZ € ^bedgiVciZ fjZ hZ_Vbdheg|i^XdhZfjZ idbZbdh Vi^ijYZhiVc\‚kZ^h Zb kZoYZ!iZdg^oVgbdh!hdWgZ d Xdc]ZX^bZcid)9 ]^hiƒg^VYVD^c]VEV( \^cdi bdhigV Xdbd ZhiVbdhXdcY^X^dcVYdh VhZgbdhZheZX‚[^Xdh) Gh [gVc( XZhZh' YZed^hYV?gVcYZ?jZggV' Xdchigj‚gVb jb bjgd Vdadc\d YVgdiV YZ^ckVh~dig^a]VYV eZadhVaZb~ZheVgVegZkZc^gdjigV ^ckVh~d( @^iaZg h^beaZhbZciZ Xdcidgcdj d bjgd' $fjVhZ%hZb Zh[dg•dVa\jb) Gh [gVc( XZhZh [dgVb \gVcYZhZhijYVciZhYZ]^hiƒg^V( hƒ fjZ VegZcYZgVbXdb egZX^h~dZmXZhh^kV) >dgVb eg|i^Xdh YZbV^hZ ZmXZhh^kVbZciZ [dXVYdh' XdbegdbZiZcYd Vegƒeg^VhZ\jgVc•V) Fƒh c~d VegZcYZbdhZhedciVcZVbZciZfjZ [l\ N]_R[QRZ\` ^bR [l\ N]_R[QRZ\`( G egdWaZbVZhi| cV ZhigjijgV YZcdhhVhbZciZh5c~d VegZc( YZbdh aZ^h'bVh [Vidh'hdbZciZ [Vidh)F~d eVgZXZbdhWdchZb Vhh^b^aVg bZiVaZ^h$Xdbd VaZ^fjZ Y^ofjZ iZbdh jbV iZcY•cX^VVc~d VegZcYZg gZ\gVh%)
Essa lógica é foda!
Edited by Foxit Reader Copyright(C) by Foxit Corporation,2005-2010 For Evaluation Only. ( EVh RfV`aRjbV fjZhi~d bV^hegd[jcYV5cdhhVhbZciZh h~d[Z^iVheVgV j•8 HVgZXZ fjZ iZbdh d bVcjVa YZ^chigj•…ZhZggVYd) FdhhVhbZciZh c~d f ) ( X ) VgZ XZb [Z^iVh eVgVd eZchVbZcid ZVbigdheZX•Vd6XVhdadhhZb' Vh;GAhVh 6Zg^Vbbj^id bV^h[|XZ^heVgVcƒh VijVabZciZ' bVh Vhh^bc~d ZqiVg‚Vbdh Vfj^ ]d_ZZZj c~d ZhiVg^V Vfj^ eVgV[VaVg hdWgZ ^hhd( bZq Vc)XZhigVa Xqc( igV[VXijVa' ^cigdheZXi^kdZ egd[jcYVbZciZ eZchVYdgiZcV hAYdXdbAYd edg jb aZ~dZcfjVcid hZj eg^bd c~d(eZchVciZ' bVh Xdb gZV•…Zh bV^h g|e^YVh'iZg^VXdgg^YdeVgVhZegdiZ\Zg) ;dch^YZgZfjZ eZchVgXdchdbZ iZbed Z' Zb \ZgVa'YZheZcYZbj^iV ZcZg\^V'YZ[dgbV fjZ cdhhdhegZYZ( XZhhdgZh eVhhVgVbbV^h YZ,++ b^a]…ZhYZVcdh Xdbd bVb‚[Zgdh c~d( eZchVciZhZfjZ' cd e^hXVg YZda]dh YV]^hiƒg^VZb fjZ iZbdh jhVYdcdhhd X€gZWgd' ZaZ[d^ji^a^oVYdedg cƒh Zb VhhjcidheZg^[€g^Xdh YZbV^heVgVfjZ i^kZhhZbfjVafjZg ^bedgi}cX^V)9h Zk^Y•cX^Vh bdhigVb fjZ eZchVbdh bj^id bZcdh Yd fjZ VXgZY^iVbdh ( ZmXZid' € XaVgd' fjVcYd eZchVbdh V gZheZ^id)
e bj^id ig^hiZeZchVghdWgZ VheZhhdVhfjZ [dgVb bVaigViVYVh eZaV]^hiƒ(
g^V)@djkZ dh ]\RaR` ZNbQVa`&Xdbd =Y\Vg9aaVcHdZZ9gi]jg J^bWVjY' YZhegZoVYdh eZaVhdX^ZYVYZ Z'bV^hiVgYZ'VYdgVYdh ZhZgk^Ydh g [dg•VeVgV VhXg^Vc•Vh cVh ZhXdaVh) $9i€ Zm^hiZbZhXdaVh WVi^oVYVh Zb ]dbZcV\Zb VeZhhdVhfjZ VWVcYdcVgVb VZhXdaV)% Ac[Za^obZciZ'd gZXdc]ZX^bZcid kZ^djb edjXd iVgYZYZbV^heVgV\ZgVgcd edZiV jbV YZhXVg\V egVoZ( gdhVYZhZgdidc^cVdj eVgVbZa]dgVg hjV k^YVgdb}ci^XVcV LZggV)EVh Zm^hiZb]Zgƒ^hV^cYV bV^hbVaigViVYdh ( Vig^hi‚hh^bV XViZ\dg^V YVfjZaZh fjZ c~d hVWZbdhfjZ [dgVb ]Zgƒ^h'fjZ hVakVgVb cdhhVhk^YVh'fjZ cdh V_jYVgVbVZk^iVg YZhVhigZh) =aZheVgi^gVbhZb YZ^mVg gVhigd'cZb bZhbd hdjWZgVbfjZ ZhiVkVb[VoZcYdjbV Xdcig^Wj^•~d) DZbWgVbdhdh b|gi^( gZhfjZ bdggZgVb edg jbV XVjhVfjZ Xdc]ZX‚Vbdh'cjcXV dh c~d bZcdh Z[Zi^kdhZb hjVhXdcig^Wj^•…Zh' bVh YZXj_VhXVjhVh cjcXV idbVbdh Xd( c]ZX^bZcid ( egZX^hVbZciZedg iZgZb h^YdWZb(hjXZY^Ydh) FdhhV^c( \gVi^Y~dZb gZaV•~dVdh]\RaR` ZNbQVa`Y^hh^eV(hZ XdbeaZiVbZciZ Y^VciZ VXdciZXZg) $FdhhVh^cij^•…Zhh~d [Z^iVheVgVjb VbW^ZciZXdb XVjhVhZ Z[Z^idhbV^h h^beaZh Z Xdb ^c[dgbV•~d fjZ hZbdkZ aZciVbZciZ)%=hhZi^ed YZVaZVidg^ZYVYZ c~d egZkVaZX^V Yj( gVciZd Ha^hidXZcd'_| fjZ cZaZVk^YVhdX^dZXdc}b^XVZgVbj^id bV^h h^beaZh)
YZdjigd i^ed YZ^c\gVi^Y~d' fjZ € YZjbV Zhe€X^Zbj^id bV^h eZgkZghV5 VhZchV•~d YZ^cji^a^YVYZedg eVgiZ Yd ]Zgƒ^ h^aZcX^dhd)AajhigVgZ^ V ^Y€^V Xdb d hZ\j^ciZ ZmeZg^bZcid bZciVa) HVgiVbdh Yd eg^c€‚e^d YZfjZ jb aZ\^haVYdg Xdb XdgV\Zb' ^c[aj•cX^V' ^ciZaZXid'k^h~d Z eZghZkZgVc•VXdchZ\j^hhZ VegdkVgjbV aZ^fjZ ZcigVhhZ jc^kZghVabZciZ Zb k^\dg Z eVhhVhhZVhZgZbegZ\VYV cd Y^V,+ YZhZiZb( WgdYZ-++,) 9 aZ^^be…Z fjZ VhXVW^cZh YZXdbVcYd YZidYdh dh Vk^…Zh hZ_Vb{ egdkV YZWVaVh Z eZgbVcZ•Vb XdchiVciZbZciZ igVcXVYVh $\ZgVc( Yd Xjhidh VaidheVgVVhZbegZhVh YZVk^V•~d'fjZ ajiVb eVgVhdWgZk^kZg% ( VeZcVheVgVd XVhdYZiZggdg^hiVhYZX^Y^gZbjhVg dh Vk^…Zh eVgVViVXVg d OdgaY LgVYZ;ZciZg Zb FdkV Qdg`) =j hZ^fjZ ^hhd € adjXjgV' bVh € VeZcVhjb ZmeZg^bZcid bZciVa $Zhidj X^ZciZYZ fjZ edYZ c~d ]VkZg Va\d Xdbd jb aZ\^haVYdgXdb ^ciZaZXid'XdgV\Zb' k^h~d Z eZghZkZgVc•V6 ZhhZ€ d edcid Yd ZmeZg^bZcid%)9 aZ\^haV•~dc~d € jbV bZY^YVedejaVg ZcigZ eZhhdVaYVhXdbeVc]^Vh V€gZVh'ed^h Xdbea^XVhjVh k^YVh)EVh iZ( g^VXZgiVbZciZ Zk^iVYdd '' YZKZiZbWgd) 9 eZhhdVfjZ ^be„h fjZ VhXVW^cZh YZXdbVcYd [dhhZb igVcXVYVh c~d \Vc]V Zhi|ijVh Zb hjV ]dbZcV\Zb Zb egV•Vhe†Wa^XVh' cZb bZhbd jbV WgZkZbZc•~d Zb hZj dW^ij|g^d g Xdcig^Wj^•~d fjZ [Zo) !BdZ Kb^i]' fjZ V_jYdj V Zk^iVgd YZhVhigZYZ $$ YZ KZiZbWgd' bdggZj YZ Xdbea^XV•…Zh YZXdggZciZhYZ jbV YIZc•V cd [‚\VYd)! NZcYd d fjVcid V bZY^YV ZgV hje€g[ajV Z d fjVcid Xdchjb^V gZXjghdh'd e†Wa^Xd'Xdb \gVcYZ V_jYVYdh e^adidh YVhXdbeVc]^Vh V€gZVh'edYZ Vi€YZggjW|(AdYd XVg\d)J\e PYNZN[' aV`V[ QR`R_a\(=aZ ^g| hZ VedhZciVg YZeg^b^Yd' Xdb jbV \gVcYZ hZchV•~d YZ[gVXVhhd'Z bdggZg| Xdb V^begZhh~d YZc~d iZg [Z^id cVYVYZ†i^a) =j \dhiVg^VYZ^gVdhZj [jcZgVa' bVh' aZ^idg'c~d Xdch^\d ZcXdcig|(ad) =' V^cYV Vhh^b' d gZXdc]ZX^bZcid edYZ hZgjb \gVcYZZhi‚bjad) 9XgZY^iZZb b^b' bZhbd VfjZaZh fjZ VaZ\Vb \Zcj^cVbZciZ fjZ c~d VXgZY^iVbZb gZXd( c]ZX^bZcid Z fjZ hZeVgVb ? igVqVa]d Ydh [gjidh Yd igVWVa]dhZciZb jbV YZhXVg\V egVoZgdhVYZhZgdidc^cV fjVcYd h~d gZXdc]ZX^Ydh)NZ_VXdbd d ]Zgƒ^ h^aZcX^dhd€ gZXdbeZchVYd5Vi€hZj egƒeg^d h^hiZbV]dgbdcVa Xdch( e^gVg| eVgVc~d a]Z d[ZgZXZgcZc]jbV gZXdbeZchV) 9\dgV Xdch^YZgZcdkVbZciZ dh ZkZcidh YZ $$ YZKZiZbWgd)IjZb gZ( XZWZjgZXdc]ZX^bZcid cd gVhigdYd fjZ VXdciZXZj89fjZaZh fjZ kdX• k^j cV b‚Y^V ZcV iZaZk^h~dgZVa^oVcYd Vidh]Zgƒ^XdhZ VfjZaZhfjZ kdX• k^j iZc( iVcYd eVhhVgV ^begZhh~d YZ fjZ ZhiVkVb gZVa^oVcYd Vidh ]Zgƒ^;dh) =hhV †ai^bV XViZ\dg^V^cXaj^Va\j€b Xdbd d egZh^YZciZYV:dahV YZNVadgZhYZ
d
FdkV Qdg`' J^X]VgY?gVhhd' fjZ !hVakdj V:dahV YZNVadgZh!Z gZXZWZj jb W„cjh \^\VciZhXd edg hjV Xdcig^Wj^•~d$d Zfj^kVaZciZVbj^idh ZVYUN_R` YZ hVa|g^dhb€Y^dh%)LjYd fjZ ZaZegZX^hdj [VoZg[d^ ZhiVgegZhZciZeVgVidXVg d h^cd YZVWZgijgVYVhZhh~dYV:dahV YZNVadgZhcV iZaZk^h~d( ViZaZk^h~d fjZ' kZgZbdh' € V edgiVYdgVYV^c_jhi^•V Z jbV YVheg^cX^eV^hXVjhVhYV XZ\jZ^gVZb gZaV•~dVdh;^hcZh FZ\gdh) IjZb (€ gZXdbeZchVYd' d WVcfjZ^gd XZcigVafjZ Zk^iVjbV gZXZhh~d dj VfjZaZ fjZ X]Z\V eVgV!Xdgg^\^g! dh Zggdh YZ hZj egZYZXZhhdgZ' edg VXVhd'Zhi| cd aj\Vg XZgidYjgVciZ Va\jbV gZXjeZgV•~dZXdc„b^XV8IjZb € bV^h kVa^dhd'd eda‚i^Xd fjZ Zk^iVjbV \jZggV dj d fjZ ^c^X^VjbV cdkV \jZggV $ZiZb hdgiZ hj[^X^ZciZeVgVkZcX•(AV%8 e d bZhbd gZkZghdaƒ\^XdfjZ k^bdh VciZg^dgbZciZ Xdb d kVadgYd fjZ c~d hVWZbdh6idYdh hVWZbfjZ egZkZc•~d € bV^h cZXZhh|g^V Yd fjZ d igViV( bZcid' bVh edjXdh gZXdbeZchVb VidhegZkZci^kdh) ?adg^[^XVbdhVfjZaZh fjZ YZ^mVbdh cdbZh cdh a^kgdhYZ]^hiƒg^Vg XjhiVYZXdaVWdgVYdgZh hdWgZ fjZb dh a^kgdh[^XVb Zb h^a•cX^d)Fƒh ]jbVcdh c~d hdbdh VeZcVhjbV gV•VhjeZg[^X^Va $d fjZ edYZ hZgXjg|kZa' Vi€XZgidedcid%6 hdbdh jbV gV•V bj^id ^c_jhiV)
=hiZ € jb a^kgdhdWgZ^cXZgiZoV6 eVgVd Vjidg' jb ZkZcid gVgd R^bVcNYRV ^cXZgiZoV) =hhVYZXaVgV•~d edYZ eVgZXZg[dgiZ ( fjZ egZX^hVbdhZhijYVg eg^cX^eVabZciZ dh ZkZcidh gVgdhZZmigZbdh eVgVfjZ hZ_Vedhh‚kZaYZX^[gVg dh ZkZcidh Xdbjch (' bVh ZhXaVgZ•d(bZVhZ\j^g) =m^hiZb YjVh [dgbVh edhh‚kZ^hYZhZVWdgYVg [Zc„bZcdh) 9 eg^bZ^gV€ ZmXaj^gd ZmigVdgY^c|g^d Z XdcXZcigVg(hZcd !cdgbVa!) G ZmVb^cVYdgYZ^mVYZaVYdVh!eZXja^V( g^YVYZh!Z ZhijYV XVhdhXdbjch) 9 hZ\jcYV VWdgYV\Zb€ Xdch^YZgVg fjZ eVgVfjZ hZedhhV XdbegZZcYZg jb [Zc„bZcd € cZXZhh|g^daZkVgZb Xdc( iV eg^bZ^gd dh ZmigZbdh ( ZheZX^VabZciZhZ' Xdbd d ;^hcZ FZ\gd' ZaZh XVggZ\VgZbjb Z[Z^idXjbjaVi^kd ZmigVdgY^c|g^d) =j c~d bZ ^bedgid eVgi^XjaVgbZciZ Xdb d Xdbjb) KZkdX• fj^hZg qV cd•~d Yd iZbeZgVbZcid' YV€i^XVZ YVZaZ\}cX^VeZhhdVaYZjb Vb^\d' € cZXZhh|g^ddWhZgk|(AdhdWVhegdkV•…ZhYZX^gXjchi}cX^VhhZkZgVh AcVd hdWd Wg^a]dgdhVYdcdgbVa YVk^YVXdi^Y^VcV) e edhh‚kZa VkVa^Vg d eZg^\d gZegZhZciVYdedg jb Xg^b^cdhd ZmVb^cVcYd(hZVeZcVhd fjZ ZaZ [VoZb jb Y^VP\ZbZ4 HdYZbdh XdbegZZcYZg VhV†YZhZb aZkVgbdh Zb
Xdch^YZgV•~d VhYdZc•Vh^cXdcigda|kZ^hZ VhZe^YZb^Vh8 FV kZgYVYZ' d cdgbVa XdhijbV hZg^ggZaZkVciZ) IjVhZ ijYd cV k^YVhdX^Va € egdYjo^Yd edg X]dfjZh Z hVaidhgVgdh bVh XdchZf‡ZciZh6ZcfjVcid fjVhZ ijYd fjZ € ZhijYVYdhdWgZVk^YV hdX^Va € XZcigVYdcd !cdgbVa!' eVgi^XjaVgbZciZXdb b€idYdh YZYZYj( •~d Yd i^ed !XjgkVhcV [dgbV YZh^cd! fjZ c~d gZkZaVbegVi^XVbZciZ cVYV)Hdgfj•8 HdgfjZ VXjgkVcV [dgbV YZh^cd^\cdgV\gVcYZhYZhk^dh' hZcYd^cXVeVo YZa^YVg Xdb ZaZh'ZV^cYV Vhh^b[VoXdb fjZ cdh h^ciVbdh Xdc[^VciZhYZiZgbdh YdbVYd V ^cXZgiZoV) KZj VeZa^YdcZhiZ a^kgd€ V ?gVcYZ>gVjYZAciZaZXijVa $?A>( ?gZViAciZaaZXijVa >gVjY( cV h^\aV Zb ^c\a•h%)
Fd XdbZ•d YVgZkdaiV_jYV^XV cd eg^bZ^gdh€XjadYZcdhhVZgV'WdVeVgiZ YV^gVYdh_jYZjh [d^\ZgVYV eZaV^ch^hi•cX^V YdhgdbVcdh Zb XdadXVg jbV Zhi|ijV YZ;Va‚\jaV Zb hZj iZbead Zb BZgjhVa€bZb igdXVYVXdadXV•~d YZjbV Zhi|ijV Yd YZjh_jYZj QV]lZ] cdh iZbeadh gdbVcdh) Gh gdbV( cdh c~d eZgXZWZgVb fjZ d fjZ dh _jYZjh $Zdh bdcdiZ‚hiVh aZkVci^cdh hjWhZf‡ZciZh% fjZg^Vb Y^oZgedg QRb` ZgVVWhigVid' Zckdak^VijYd Z c~d i^c]V cVYVVkZgXdb V'gZegZhZciV•~dVcigdedbƒg[^XVZ ZmXZhh^kVbZciZ ]jbVcV fjZ dh gdbVcdh i^c]Vb Zb bZciZ fjVcYd Y^o^VbQRb`( ;g^i^( XVbZciZ'd YZjh_jYZj c~d hZegZhiVkVVgZegZhZciV•…Zh h^bWƒa^XVh)
qZcdh ZaZ\VciZh'VfjZaZhfjZ edhhjZb ZhigjijgVhbV^hXdc[jhVhZbZcdh igVi|kZ^h$^Y€^V fjZ ZaVWdgVgZ^ egd\gZhh^kVbZciZVdadc\d Yda^kgd%) G eaVidc^hbd€ d fjZ [VoXdb fjZ VX]ZbdhfjZ XdbegZZcYZbdhbV^h YdfjZ gZVabZciZXdbegZZcYZbdh)EVh ^hhdc~d VXdciZXZ Zb idYVhVheVg( iZh)F~d Zhidj Y^oZcYdfjZ [dgbVheaVi„c^XVh c~d Zm^hiVb) EdYZadhZXdch( igj•…Zh'dh bVeVh^ciZaZXijV^h YVgZVa^YVYZ' c~d Zhi~dhZbegZZggVYdh6 Zhi~d ZggVYdh hdbZciZ Zb Va\jbVh Vea^XV•…Zh ZheZX‚[^XVh) 9 Y^[^XjaYVYZ € fjZ V% kdX•c~d hVWZ YZVciZb~d $hdbZciZYZed^hYddXdgg^Yd% \[QR d bVeVZhiVg| ZggVYd ZW% dhZggdhedYZb iZgXdchZf‡•cX^Vh \gVkZh)Gh bdYZadhh~dXdbd gZb€Y^dhediZcX^VabZciZ†iZ^hfjZ XVggZ\VbZ[Z^idhXdaViZgV^h VaZViƒg^dh' edg€b bj^id \gVkZh) 9 Q\O_N]YNar[VPN€ V[gdciZ^gVZmeadh^kV dcYZVbZciZ eaVi„c^XV ZcigV Zb XdciVidXdb VgZVa^YVYZ Xdc[jhV'dcYZd k~d ZcigZd fjZ hVWZ Zd fjZ VX]VfjZ hVWZ idgcV(hZeZg^\dhVbZciZVbead) e Vfj^ fjZ d ;^hcZ FZ\gd € \ZgVYd)
>d^ Y^idfjZ d X^cZVhiV Vgi‚hi^Xd DjX]^cd N^hXdci^[Vo^VfjZhi~d YZfjZ' fjVcYd dh VidgZhVedciVhhZbeVgVjbV XV^mV [ZX]VYV fjZ YZkZg^V XdciZg _ƒ^Vh'Zm^hi^hhZb _ƒ^VhYZkZgYVYZ cV XV^mV) AhhdedYZg^VhZgjb b€idYd Z[Zi^kdYZ[VoZgXdb fjZ dh VidgZhk^kZhhZbdh eVe€^h)9X]d fjZ d \Zhid YZN^hXdci^edYZiVbW€b hZgdg^jcYd YZjbV cd•~d h^beaZhYZZhi€i^XV ZYZjb YZhZ_dedg VjiZci^X^YVYZ ( YZVa\jb bdYd' ZgVedhh‚kZafjZ c~d eVgZXZhhZ XZgidZc\VcVgd ZheZXiVYdg) =hiZ€ jb ZchV^dfjZ ZmegZhhV jbV ^Y€^V eg^b|g^V6c~d € cZb VgZX^XaV( ) \Zb cZb VgZZbWVaV\Zb YdheZchVbZcidh YZdjigVheZhhdVh) Mb ZchV^d € jbV bZY^iV•~d^bejah^kV' c~d jb gZaVidX^Zci‚[^Xd) HZ•d YZhXjaeVh hZ ejad Va\jch iƒe^XdhƒWk^dhcd a^kgdedg Xdck^X•~dYZfjZ Vfj^ad fjZ Xdc( h^YZgd X]VidYZbV^heVgVZhXgZkZg VgZheZ^idedYZhZgX]VidYZbV^heVgVd aZ^idg)$9a€b YZfjZ Zk^iVgVX]Vi^XZ iVbW€b edYZV_jYVg V[^aigVg d c~d( ZhhZcX^Va) % :NYN_nSjPVY(9a\j€b fjZ iZc]V [Z^idVjaVhYZbV^hYZ[^adhd[^V cV[VXja( YVYZ$dj iVakZoc~d d hj[^X^ZciZ% edYZ dW_ZiVg fjZ VdWhZgkV•~d YZjb ;^hcZ FZ\gd c~d ^ckVa^YV V iZdg^VYZfjZ a\Q\` \` PV`[R``l\ O_N[P\`&_| fjZ iVae|hhVgdcZ\gd c~d € iZXc^XVbZciZ jb e|hhVgded^h' eVgVZhhVeZh( hdV'VWgVcXjgV edYZhZgVegdeg^ZYVYZ ZhhZcX^Va YZjb X^hcZ) JZVabZciZ'
fjZb aZj O^ii\ZchiZ^c YZbV^h$ZiZmidhhdWgZ XdbZci|g^dq VgZheZ^idqZ O^ii\ZchiZ^c%edYZ iZgV^begZhh~dYZfjZ egdWaZbVhYZab\jV\Zb hVd ^bedgiVciZh)=aZhedYZb' XZgiVbZciZ'hZg^bedgiVciZh eVgVfjZ hZdWiZ( c]V egdZb^c•cX^Vcdh YZeVgiVbZcidhYZ[^adhd[^V' bVh h~dVa\dfjZ cƒh' egVi^XVciZh Z idbVYdgZhYZYZX^h…Zh cd bjcYd gZVa'QRVeNZ\` ]N_N \` SV[NV`QR`RZN[N( ;dbd Zmea^Xd cd ;Ve‚ijad ,3' ^ci^ijaVYd!9 AcXZgiZoV Yd Abedhidg!' VeZhVg Yd VeZad^ciZaZXijVa' ZhhVh[dgbVa^YVYZh c~d edh( hjZb ^bea^XV•…Zh h€g^Vh YZhZ\jcYV VhZmiV([Z^gV' VdXdcig|g^dYZdjigVh fjZhi…ZhbV^hhjWhiVcX^V^h $bVhcZ\a^\ZcX^VYVh%) HZhhdVh cVhVaV YZVjaV' edg c~d iZgZb ZcXVgVYd bj^iVh h^ijV•…Zh gZV^h YZidbVYVhYZYZX^h…Zh Y^VciZYZ^cXZgiZoVh' c~d eZgXZWZbd fjZ € Z d fjZ c~d € ^bedgiVciZ U cZb bZhbd dh VXVY•b^Xdh YV^cXZgiZoV $dj ]N_aVPbYN_ZR[aR dh VXV( Y•b^XdhYV^cXZgiZoV%) G fjZ X]Vbd YZeg|i^XVYV^cXZgiZoV edYZhZge^( gViVg^V' ZheZXjaV•~dYZXdbbdY^i^Zh'_d\Vgegd[^hh^dcVabZciZ'igVWVa]Vg Zb Va\jch gVbdh YVb|[^V dj h^beaZhbZciZ gZVa^oVg ZbegZZcY^bZcidh Zb h€g^Z)HdgiVcidedh^X^dcd(bZXdcigVd !XZi^X^hbdZhi€g^a!'YVZhe€X^Z hdWgZVfjVa c~d edYZbdh [VoZgcVYV'Z XdcigVdh egdWaZbVhYZa^c\jV( \Zb ZmXZhh^kVbZciZ iZƒg^XdhfjZ idgcVgVb WdVeVgiZYV[B),dhd[^V bd( YZgcVaVg\VbZciZ^ggZaZkVciZ eVgVd fjZ € X]VbVYdeZ_dgVi^kVbZciZ YZ !\gVcYZe†Wa^Xd!)$Fd eVhhVYd'eVgVbZa]dg dj eVgVe^dg' dh gVgdh[B),ƒ( hd[dhZeZchVYdgZh fjZ c~d ZgVb^cYZeZcYZciZh YZeZcY^VbYd Ved^dYZ jb eVigdcd) @d_Z'd ZhijYd VXVY•b^Xd YZY^hX^ea^cVh VWhigViVh YZeZcYZ YVde^c^~d YZdjigdh' hZb Xdc[Zg•cX^Vh ZmiZgcVh' Xdb d gZhjaiVYdeVid( aƒ\^XddXVh^dcVa Z\gVkZYZdh dW_Zi^kdh hZgZbkdaiVYdheVgVXdbeZi^•…Zh ^chjaVgZhYZZm^W^•~d YZegdZoVh)AcYZeZcYZciZbZciZYVha^b^iV•…Zh Yd h^hiZbVVci^\d' ZaZVdbZcdh YZ[ZcY^V NYTbZ eVYg~dYZgZaZk}cX^V)% 9 [B),ƒhd[V =YcVMaabVcc(EVg\Va^iYZiZXidjjbV ^cXdch^hi•cX^V cd a^( kgd ZeZY^j(bZ fjZ _jhi^[^XVhhZ d jhd ZheZX‚[^Xd YVbZi|[dgV YZjb ;^hcZ FZ\gd eVgVYZhXgZkZg d ^cXZgid_begZX^hd'd YZhXdc]ZX^Yd Z d VWhigVid ( XdgkdhWgVcXdh' ZaZ[VciZh Xdg(YZ(gdhV dj Vc^bV^hZkVedgVciZh YZjb eaVcZiVgZbdid cV ƒgW^iV YZLVj ;Zi^) JZVabZciZ' ZaVbZ eZ\dj cd Vid) =m^hiZjbV XdcigVY^•~d6 ZhiZa^kgd€ jbV ]^hiƒg^V'Z egZ[^gdjhVg]^hiƒg^Vh Zk^c]ZiVheVgV^ajhigVgcdhhVXgZYja^YVYZ Zb gZaV•~dV]^hiƒg^VhZ cdhhV egZ[Zg•cX^V edg gZhjb^g eZg^\dhVbZciZVhcVggVi^kVh) NdX• egZX^hV YZjbV ]^hiƒg^VeVgVYZhadXVg jbV ]^hiƒg^V)EZi|[dgVh Z ]^hiƒg^Vhh~dbj^id bV^hediZciZh Yd fjZ ^Y€^Vh $^c[Za^obZciZ%6 ZaVh iVb( W€b h~d bV^h[|XZ^hYZhZaZbWgVg Z bV^hY^kZgi^YVh YZhZaZg)KZegZX^hd
#hZ\j^gd fjZ X]Vbd YZY^hX^ea^cVh cVggVi^kVh' b^c]V bZa]dg [ZggVbZciV€ jbV cVggVi^kV) AY€^Vh k•b Zk~d' ]^hiƒg^Vh[^XVb)
9 WZhiV cZhiZa^kgdc~d € VeZcVhVXjgkVcV [dgbV YZh^cd Z d ZhiVi‚hi^Xd fjZ Zc\VcVVh^egƒeg^d' cZb d VXVY•b^Xd eAV idc^[^XVYd fjZ egZX^hV YZ iZdg^Vh eVgVhZVjid(Zc\VcVg( bVh h^b d ^bejahd YZhZ![dXVa^oVg! cd fjZ [VohZci^YdeVgVcƒh) N^kZgZb cdhhd eaVcZiV']d_Z' gZfjZg bj^id bV^h^bV\^cV•~dYdfjZ hdbdh [Z^idheVgViZg);VgZXZbdhYZ^bV\^cV•~d ZVgZeg^b^bdh cdh djigdh) GWhZgkZ fjZ' cd a^kgd'c~d gZXdggdVdb€idYd WZhi^Va YZgZjc^g!egd( kVhXdggdWdgVi^kVh! hZaZi^kVh) Hdg bdi^kdh fjZ Zmea^Xd cd ;Ve‚ijad 0' X]Vbd d ZmXZhhd YZZmZbeadhYZZbe^g^hbd ^c\•cjd ( hjXZhh…Zh YZ VcZYdiVhhZaZX^dcVYVh eVgVZcXV^mVgZb(hZ Zb jbV ]^hiƒg^Vc~d Xdchi^( ijZb egdkVh)IjVafjZg eZhhdVfjZ egdXjgZedg Xdc[^gbV•…Zh ZcXdcigVg| jb c†bZgd hj[^X^ZciZYZaVh eVgVZc\VcVgVh^egƒeg^d( ZiVbW€b' hZb Y†k^YV'VhZjhXdaZ\Vh5 9 ^Y€^V Yd ;^hcZ FZ\gd € WVhZVYV cVZhigjijgV YV VaZVidg^ZYVYZ cV gZVa^YVYZ Zbe‚g^XV) JZhjb^cYd5 cZhiZZchV^d$eZhhdVa%' Xdggdg^hXdh ZYZXaVgd' XdcigVbj^( idh YZcdhhdh ]|W^idh YZeZchVbZcid' fjZ d bjcYd € Ydb^cVYd eZad ZmigZbd' eZad YZhXdc]ZX^Yd Z eZad bj^id ^begdk|kZa $^begdk|kZa hZ( \jcYd cdhhd Xdc]ZX^bZcid XdggZciZ% ( Z fjZ eVhhVbdhd iZbed idYd Zckdak^YdhZb b^c†X^Vh'XdcXZcigVYdh cd Xdc]ZX^YdZcd fjZ hZgZeZiZ) Ahhd^bea^XVcV cZXZhh^YVYZ YZhZji^a^oVgd ZkZcid ZmigZbdXdbd edcid YZeVgi^YV'Z c~d igVi|(AdXdbd jbV ZmXZ•~d fjZ YZkZhZgkVgg^YV eVgV WV^md Yd iVeZiZ)LVbW€b [V•d VVaZ\V•~dbV^hdjhVYV$Z^cX„bdYV%YZ fjZ' VeZhVg Yd egd\gZhhdZ YVZmeVch~dYd Xdc]ZX^bZcid' d [jijgd hZg| XVYV kZobZcdh egZk^h‚kZa' ZcfjVcid iVcid VcVijgZoV]jbVcV fjVcid Vh Y # "" " ) ;aZc;aVh hdX^V^h eVgZXZbXdche^gVg eVgVZhXdcYZg YZcƒh ZhhV^Y€^V) ˆ LVbW€b € Zbe^g^hbd ^c\•cjd VegZhZciVg'Xdb d dW_Zi^kdYZhjhiZciVg Va\jb Vg\jbZcid' h€g^ZhYZX^iV•…Zh Xdc[^gbViƒg^VhZZadf‡ZciZh YZVjidg^YVYZh bdgiVh) Hdg bZ^d YZeZhfj^hV' € hZbegZ edhh‚kZaZcXdcigVgVa\j€b fjZ [ZojbV YZXaVgV•~d hdcdgV fjZ Xdc[^gbV hZj edc( id YZk^hiV( Z' Zb idYd iƒe^Xd' € edhh‚kZa ZcXdcigVg djigd eZchVYdg bdgid fjZ Y^hhZ ZmViVbZciZd Xdcig|g^d) IjVhZ idYVhVhX^iV•…Zh jhVYVhedg b^b fjZ c~d h~d YZQd\^ :ZggV h~d YZeZhhdVhYZfjZb Y^hXdgYd)
9 hZf‡•cX^VYd a^kgdhZ\jZ jbV aƒ\^XVh^beaZh6ZaZgZhjaiVYd fjZ edYZ hZggdijaVYdXdbd ejgVbZciZ a^iZg|g^d$Zb iZbV Z igViVbZcid%eVgVd fjZ edYZ hZgXdch^YZgVYd ^ciZ^gVbZciZX^Zci‚[^Xd $iZbVi^XVbZciZ'bVh c~d cd igViVbZcid%)9 eh^Xdad\^V ZhiVg|egZhZciZeg^cX^eVabZciZcVHVgiZ Mb Zcd eg^cX‚e^dYVHVgiZ^b!' hZg|bj^id XjgiV) L^kZjbV fjVci^YVYZ^cZheZgVYV YZegVoZgVd ZhXgZkZg ZhiZa^kgd( cV kZgYVYZ' ZaZZhXgZkZj(hZ hdo^c]d ( ZZheZgdfjZ d aZ^idgh^ciVd bZhbd) ;dc[Zhhd fjZ [^fjZ^ k^X^VYd cZhhZgZi^gdeVgVYZcigdYVh^Y€^Vh ejgVh YZ( ed^h YVhgZhig^•…Zh YZjbV k^YVVi^kVZ igVchVX^dcVa)
* *S7/+/+1/47.,* 7= $,*,
?
-/,$1/#*,0
#$ )%!$'(&
$"&
2#);%#$G&0 %
ZhXg^idg M5cWZgiq =Xd'eqgiZcXZ{fjZqVXaVhhZ gZhig^iV YZVXVY•b^( XdhfjZ hVdZcXaXadeZYa;dh' eZgXZeiakdhZ cVYVZciZY^VciZh) =aZ € Ydcd YZjbV kVhiVW^Wa^diZXV eZhhdVa$fjZ Xdci€b XZgXV YZ.+ b^a a^kgdh% Z Y^k^YZ dh k^h^iVciZh Zb YjVhXViZ\dg^Vh5 dh fjZ gZV\Zb Xdb5 !\ Vj)#KtA\cdgZ]_\>R``\_R 'p6 Q\aa\_R=Xd'fjZ W^Wa^diZXV d hZc]dg iZb IjVc( idh YZhhZh a^kgdhd hZc]dg _| aZj8!' Z dh djigdh ( jbV b^cdg^V bj^id eqfjZcV (' fjZ ZciZcYZb fjZ jbV W^Wa^diZXV eVgi^XjaVg c~d € jb Ve•c( qA;ZeVgVZaZkVg d egƒeg^d Z\d' Zh^b jbV [ZggVbZciVYZeZhfj^hV)D^kgdh aAYdh h~dbj^id bZcdh kVa^dhdh fjZ dhc~d(a^Ydh)9 W^Wa^diZXV YZkZXdciZg iVcid QN`P\V`N`^bR c\Po [l\ `NORfjVcid hZjh gZXjghdh[^cVcXZ^gdh iVmVh ]^ediZX|g^VhZ d VijVabZciZ gZhig^idbZgXVYdYZ^bƒkZ^ha]Z eZcqa^iVb XdadXVg cZaV)NdX• VXjbjaVg| bV^hXdc]ZX^bZcid Z bV^ha^kgdh{ bZY^( YVfjZ [dg ZckZa]ZXZcYd'Z d c†bZgd XgZhXZciZ YZa^kgdhc~d(a^YdhcVh egViZaZ^gVh da]Vg| eVgVkdX•VbZV•VYdgVbZciZ) FV kZgYVYZ' fjVcid bV^h NdX•hdjWZg'bV^dgZhhZg~dVhe^a]VhYZa^kgdhc~d(a^Ydh)NVbdh X]VbVg ZhhVXdaZ•~dYZa^kgdhc~d(a^YdhYZN[aVOVOYV\aRPN( Fƒh iZcYZbdh VigViVgd Xdc]ZX^bZcid Xdbd jbV egdeg^ZYVYZ eZh( hdVaqjZ YZkZhZgegdiZ\^YVZ YZ[ZcY^YV) =aZ€ jb dgcVbZcid fjZ cdh eZgb^iZ hjW^gcV ]^ZgVgfj^VhdX^Va) 9hh^b' ZhhViZcY•cX^VV d[ZcYZgV hZch^W^a^YVYZ YVW^Wa^diZXV YZ=XdXdcXZcigVcYd(hZ cd Xdc]ZX^Yd€ jbV eVgX^Va^YVYZ ]jbVcV fjZ hZZhiZcYZ{hcdhhVhdeZgV•…Zh bZciV^h)9h eZh(
hdVhc~d XVb^c]Vb edg V‚Xdb Vci^Xjgg‚Xjadh Y^oZcYdd fjZ c~d ZhijYV( gVb dj k^kZcX^VgVb $ZhhZ€#d igVWVa]d YZhZjh XdcXdggZciZh%' bVh hZg^V Wdb hZd [^oZhhZb)9hh^b Xdbd egZX^hVbdh XdadXVg Vaƒ\^XVYVW^Wa^diZXV YZedciV(XVWZ•V' igVWVa]VgZbdh XdadXVcYd d egƒeg^d Xdc]ZX^bZcid YZ eZgcVheVgVd Vg)GWhZgkZ fjZ d ;^hcZ FZ\gd € [gjid YV^cXdbegZZch~d YVegdWVW^a^YVYZ YVhhjgegZhVh'dh a^kgdhc~d(a^Ydh'edgfjZ aZkVbdhjb edjXd Vh€g^dYZbV^hVhXd^hVh fjZ hVWZbdh) NVbdh X]VbVgjb Vci^VXVY•b^Xd ( Va\j€b fjZ hZXdcXZcigV cdh a^( kgdhc~d(a^YdhZ[VojbV iZciVi^kVYZc~d igViVghZj Xdc]ZX^bZcid Xdbd jb iZhdjgd' cZb Xdbd jbV egdeg^ZYVYZ Z iVbedjXd Xdbd jb bZXV( c^hbd YZVjbZcid YZVjid(Zhi^bV( YZZbe^g^hiVX€i^Xd) Gh XVe‚ijadhcZhiVhZ•~dVWdgYVbV fjZhi~d YZXdbd cƒh ]jbVcdh a^( YVbdh Xdb d Xdc]ZX^bZcid ( Z cdhhVegZ[Zg•cX^V eZad VcZYƒi^XdVd Zbe‚q^Xd)G ;Ve‚ijad , VegZhZciV d ;^hcZ FZ\gd WVhZVcYd(hZ cV]^hiƒg^V YVb^c]V egƒeg^VdWhZhh~d) >VgZ^jbV Y^hi^c•~dXZcigVaZcigZ VhYjVh kVg^ZYVYZh YZVaZVidg^ZYVYZ cd ;Ve‚ijad .)
O +8:/6.3A+.7 =5 -]<3-7
./
/58g:3-7
*H@NI ?< IJ<>D?
VAL@HN@ $ G @MJ@FCI L@NLIPFMIL $ 7O?I JVP@F$ 6@G$
JL@A
=hiZa^kgdc~d € jbV VjidW^d\gV[^V' edgiVcid ejaVgZ^VhXZcVhYZ\jZggV) FV kZgYVYZ' bZhbd fjZ [dhhZjbV VjidW^d\gV[^V' Zj V^cYV ejaVg^VVhXZ( cVhYZ\jZggV)F~d edhhd XdbeZi^gXdb [^abZhYZV•~ddj Xdb bZbƒg^Vh YZVkZcijgZ^gdhfjZ gZVa^oVgVb bV^h[Z^idhYd fjZ Zj' YZ[dgbV fjZ bZ YZiZgZ^ {hb^c]Vh ZheZX^Va^YVYZh cdh gVbdh Yd VXVhd ZYV^cXZgiZoV)
oV6VheZhhdVha^YVkVbjbVh Xdb VhdjigVh hZ\jcYd jb egdidXdad XaVgd' egZhZgkVcYdjbV eVo XdA,YjXZciZVd Xdb€gX^d' Z hdX^Va^oVkVb WVhiVciZ ZcigZ VhXdbjc^YVYZh) G b^a•c^d YZeVo [d^ ^ciZggdbe^Yd hdbZciZ edg eZfjZcdh Vig^idhd€Vh^dcV^hQR[a_\ YVhXdbjc^YVYZh bj•jabVcVh Z Xg^h( i~h' gVgVbZciZ ZcigZ Xg^hi~dhZ bj•jabVcdh) =cfjVcid VhX^YVYZh ZgVb bZgXVci^h Z egZYdb^cVciZbZciZ ]ZaZc^hiVh'VhbdciVc]Vh ]Vk^Vb h^Yd dXjeVYVhedg idYV hdgiZ YZb^cdg^Vh gZa^\^dhVhfjZ VaZ\VkVb iZg [j\^Yd iVcid YVhdgidYdm^VhW^oVci^cVhfjVcid YVhbj•jabVcVh) Mb iZggZcd bdciVc]dhd € d gZ[†\^d ^YZVa eVgVfjZb [d\Z Yd eVYg~d' ZmXZidfjZ hZj ^c^b^\d € djigd gZ[j\^VYd fjZ Y^hejiV d bZhbd i^ed YZegdeg^ZYVYZYZ iZggZcd ZhXVgeVYd) G bdhV^Xd YZXjaijgVh Z gZa^\^…Zh YVgZ\^~d ZgVXdch^( YZgVYdjb ZmZbead YZXdZm^hi•cX^V5 Xg^hi~dhYZidYdh dh i^edh $bVgdc^( iVh' Vgb•c^dh' dgidYdmdh \gZXd(h‚g^dW^oVci^cdh'Vi€ XViƒa^Xdh W^oVci^cdh' Va€b Ydh edjXdh XViƒa^Xdh gdbVcdh YZ^mVYdh eZaVh;gjoVYVh%6bj•jabV( cdh#$m^^iVh Z hjc^iVh%6Ygjhdh Z Va\jch edjXdh _jYZjh) =gVYVYdXdbd XZg( id fjZ VheZhhdVhVegZcY^Vb VhZgidaZgVciZhVa^6aZbWgd(bZ YZfjZ cdh Zch^cVkVb cV ZhXdaV Xdbd €gVbdh bj^id bV^h X^k^a^oVYdh Zh|W^dhYd fjZ dh ]VW^iVciZhYVhXdbjc^YVYZh WVaX}c^XVh' dcYZ dh adXV^h c~d VeZcVhc~d idbVkVb WVc]d Xdbd iVbW€b ZgVb k‚i^bVh YZajiVh ^gVhX‚kZ^h) 9h Xd^hVh eVgZX^VbZhiVgZb jb Zfj^a‚Wg^dZhi|kZa' dg^jcYd YZjbV iZcY•cX^V]^h( iƒg^XVVd bZa]dgVbX5cid Z g idaZg}cX^V)Gh iZgbdh UN_Z\[VN Z R^bVYpO_V\ ZgVb jhVYdh Xdb [gZf‡•cX^V) 9bWdh dh aVYdhYVb^c]V [Vb‚a^Vk^ZgVb YVXdbjc^YVYZ \gZXd(h‚( g^V'd †ai^bd edhid W^oVci^cdcd FdgiZ YVK‚g^V'fjZ ^cXaj‚Vd fjZ ]d_Z € X]VbVYd YZ D‚WVcd)NZ_VfjZ dh W^oVci^cdhX]VbVkVb V h^bZhbdh YZ !gdbVcdh! ( F\bZV $eajgVa F\bZ$ cVh a‚c\jVh adXV^h)Fƒh k^Zbdh YV gZ\^~d YVheaVciV•…ZhYZda^kVhcV WVhZYd EdciZ D‚WVcd( ZmejahVbdh dh Xg^hi~dhbVgdc^iVh eVgVVhbdciVc]Vh cV [VbdhV WViVa]VYZ9b^djc' b^c]V k^aVVcXZhigVa)
hqbZciZ Zb \jZggV $Z edZh^V%'Z' bV^h iVgYZ'dh ijgXdh didbVcdh' fjZ VgZX^Vb^ciZgZhhVYdhVeZcVhZb \jZggV $ZegVoZg%'YZ^mVgVbeVgVcƒh q ZmZgX‚X^d YZh^ciZgZhhVciZ Yd Xdb€gX^d Z d ZmZgX‚X^d bZcdh eZg^\dhd Yd VXVYZb^X^hbd$Xdbd VigVYj•~d YZiZmidhVgVbV^XdhZ \gZ\dh%) edg fjVafjZg eVYg~d' d eV‚h X]VbVYd D‚WVcd'Vd fjVa cdh k^bdh gZ( eZci^cVbZciZ ^cXdgedgVYdhYZed^h YVfjZYV Yd Abe€g^d GidbVcd' cd XdbZ•d Yd h€XjadPP' eVgZX^V jb eVgV‚hdZhi|kZa6ZaZiVbW€b [d^ Y^k^Y^Yd YZ[dgbV fjZ [dhhZ egZYdb^cVciZbZciZ Xg^hi~d)G edkd hd[gZj jbV aV( kV\Zb XZgZWgVa gZeZci^cV eVgVVXgZY^iVg cd =hiVYd(cV•~d Xdbd jbV Zc( i^YVYZ5Gh Xg^hi~dhXdckZcXZgVb(hZ YZfjZ ZhiVkVb cV dg^\Zb Z XZcigd Yd fjZ € a^kgZbZciZ X]VbVYd YZXjaijgV dX^YZciVa'bVh Xdb jbV _VcZaV eVgVd Gg^ZciZ) =b jb XVhdXa|hh^XdYZeZchVbZcid Zhi|i^Xd' c^c\j€b aZkdj Zb Xdch^YZgV•~dVhY^[ZgZc•VhcVh iVmVhYZcViVa^YVYZ ZcigZ VhXd( bjc^YVYZh Z VXgZY^idj(hZfjZ jbV eZfjZcV bV^dg^VXg^hi~hZg^VeZgbV( cZciZ) Gh aZkVci^cdh gZXZWZgVb X^YVYVc^V gdbVcV' d fjZ eZgb^i^j VK~d HVjad' fjZ ZgVh‚g^d'k^V_Vg a^kgZbZciZ eZad bjcYd Vci^\d) 9h eZhhdVhhZc( i^Vb(hZ a^\VYVhVijYd fjZ Xdch^YZgVkVbY^\cd YZhZ XdcZXiVg6V gZ\^~d ZgVZmXZhh^kVbZciZ VWZgiV Vd bjcYd' Xdb jb Zhi^adYZk^YVkVhiVbZciZ hd[^hi^XVYd'jbV ZXdcdb^V egƒheZgV Z jb Xa^bViZbeZgVYd ^\jVa Vd YV ;Va^[ƒgc^V'Xdb bdciVc]Vh XdWZgiVh YZcZkZ YZWgj•VcYd(hZhdWgZd EZ( Y^iZgg}cZd)=aVVigV‚VjbV b^hijgV YZ Zhe^…Zh$iVcid hdk^€i^XdhfjVcid dX^YZciV^h%' egdhi^ijiVh $adjgVh%'ZhXg^idgZh'edZiVh' igV[^XVciZh YZYgd\Vh' VkZcijgZ^gdh'_d\VYdgZhXdbejah^kdh' iZc^hiVh' N]_R`'`XVR_`+Z bZgXVYdgZh ( egd[^hh…ZhXdbeaZbZciVgZh ZcigZ h^)Ej^iVh eZhhdVhV\^Vb Xdbd hZ Zhi^kZhhZbZb jb [^abZ Vci^\d YZ BVbZh:dcY' dj cdh Y^VhZb fjZ dh eaVnWdnh[jbVkVb' WZW^VbZ' Zb kZo YZ ^gZb { VXVYZb^VYZ \^c|hi^XV' Xjai^kVkVb gZaVX^dcVbZcidhXdb Wdch Va[V^ViZh) G eg^cX^eVaVig^WjidYd eVgV‚hdZhiVkVa|5 Y^o^VbfjZ dh bdidg^hiVh YZ i|m^ ZgVb ZYjXVYdh$VeZhVgYZfjZ' eZad fjZ aZbWgd' c~d ZgVb ZYjXVYdh Xdb^\d%) e kZgYVYZfjZ' Zb gZigdheZXid' d aj\Vg edYZ eVgZXZgbV^h Za‚h^d cV bZbƒg^V YVheZhhdVhYd fjZ gZVabZciZ ZgV)
r e cdi|kZa Xdb fjZ gVe^YZoZ Z[^X|X^V hZedYZ Xdchigj^g jbV cVX^dcVa^YVYZ Xdb jbV WVc( YZ^gV'Va\jch Y^hXjghdhZ jb ]^cd cVX^dcVa6 Vi€]d_Z Zk^id d gƒijad !a^WVc•h!'egZ[Zg^cYdV YZh^\cV•~d!aZkVci^cd!' bZcdh gZhig^i^kV) ; HZhhdVh fjZ YZed^hYZ jb Y^VZhfj^VcYd hdX^Va^oVb'gZ†cZb(hZ Zb WVgZh dj hVZb eVgV YVc•Vg)$F) Q\ H($
=j ZgV_dkZb YZbV^heVgVYZh[gjiVgdh egVoZgZh Ydaj\Vg' ZidgcZ^(bZ jb ^YZVa^hiV gZWZaYZ Z V^cYVbj^id XZYdYZhZckdak^ jb \dhid VhX€i^Xd' VkZghd{h dhiZciV•…Zh YZg^fjZoV'Va€g\^Xd { WjhXVZmV\ZgVYV YVXjaijgV aZkVci^cV edg ajmd'Z{ hjV dWhZhh~d edg fjZhi…ZhbdcZi|g^Vh) FV VYdaZhX•cX^V' Zj Vch^VkV edg bZ bjYVg eVgVjbV bZigƒedaZ Xdb bZcdh ]dbZch VdZhi^adBVbZh:dcY VdbZj gZYdg)EVh' V^cYV Vhh^b'gZ( XdgYdYZVa\dfjZ eVgZX^V ZheZX^Va cd Vg^ciZaZXijVa) =hijYZ^cd a^XZj[gVc( X•hfjZ i^c]V jb YdhbV^hVaidh‚cY^XZh YZhjXZhhdcd ONPPNYNb_nNa [gVcX•h $dY^eadbVYdZch^cdb€Y^d%'Vi€bZhbd cVY^hX^ea^cV YVa‚c\jV [gVcXZhV) G [gVcX•hZgV[VaVYd Va^Xdb XZgiV ejgZoV5Xdbd cVJ†hh^Veg€(gZkdajX^dc|( g^V'VhXaVhhZh eVig^VgXV^h YdhXg^hi~dh aZkVci^cdh Z Ydh_jYZjh $YZAhiVbWja V 9aZmVcYg^V% [VaVkVb ZZhXgZk^Vb d [gVcX•h[dgbVaXdbd jbV a‚c\jV YZY^h( i^c•~d) Gh bV^heg^k^aZ\^VYdh ZgVbZck^VYdh eVgVZhijYVgcV>gVc•V'Xdbd VXdciZXZjXdb bZjh Yd^hVkƒh( bZj ]db„c^bd eViZgcdZb ,4,- Z d eV^'YZb^c]V b~Z Zb ,4-4)
# JL Xdb d dW_Zi^kd YZZk^iVg!d[ZcYZg!dj ^cXdbdYVgdh djigdh) YZYdhZfj( ' ) $ V^kZX^Yd Zc~d bZ ^bedgiVkVXdb d fjZ bZjh eV^h ZbZj cg =j ZhiVkV Z ) Vb VbZj gZheZ^id( d fjZ dh YZ^PGM Xdb WVhiVciZ bZYd YZ Vkd% eZchVk )# ) ' ' YZ[dgbV fjZ Zj c~d edY^VbZ eZgb^i^gkdaiVgVigVh'cZb bZhbd 'LLF LH% # h j i^kZhhZ dXjaiVYdVeVgi^X^eV•~d cV gZWZa^~d $Xdbd bj^idh e^hXVg)Z Z ' Zjh [^oZgVb%Z [dhhZYZhXdWZgid' Zb kZo YZhZgVWZgiVbZciZ Vb^\dh b iZc]d XZgiZoV YZfjZ iZg^Vh^YdigViVYdXdbd jbV dkZa]V [^ Yd g' YZhVV ) ) ) g # gdjeVh c~d(XdckZcX^GcV^h eVgVYZhV[^Vg XdhbZi^;VbZciZ Ki^ N cZ\gV) Z ) #YVYZ d fjZ dh X^Zci^hiVh hdX^V^h Z ZXdcdb^hiVhX]VbVb YZ V Vji dc ( ) )U !h^cVa^oV•~d WVgViV! ( € jbV Xd^hV'ZegdkVgiZgY^hedh^•VdeVgVigVch( [dgbVg d fjZ VXgZY^iV Zb V•~d€ djigV WZb Y^[ZgZciZ) EZj i^d eViZgcdc~d [^Xdjbj^id ^cXdbdYVYdXdb b^c]Vh ^Y€^Vh ed( a‚i^XVh $ZaVh k•b Z k~d%6bVh [^Xdj jaigV_VYdfjZ Zj Vhji^a^oVhhZ Xdbd YZhXjaeV eVgVkZhi^g(bZbVa)HVgV ZaZ'Vd[ZchVbdgiVa ZgVVYZhZaZ\}cX^V edg eVgiZYZjb bZbWgd egƒm^bd YV[Vb‚a^V) G Xdc]ZX^bZcide†Wa^Xd YZb^c]V XVeijgViZkZdjigd \gVcYZWZcZ[‚( X^d5 eZgb^i^j(bZ Zk^iVg dh h^cV^h ZmiZgcdhigVY^X^dcV^h YZgZWZaY^V VYdaZh( XZciZ)
-3A3LB> 7E3?>A36>
EZjh eg^cX‚e^dh[dgVb bdaYVYdhfjVcYd' Vdh,0 Vcdh'[j^ egZhdedg $hj( edhiVbZciZ%ViVXVg jb eda^X^Va Xdb jb eZYV•dYZXdcXgZidYjgVciZjbV gZkdaiV ZhijYVci^a( jb ^cX^YZciZ Xdb gVb^[^XV•…Zh ZhigVc]Vh' _| fjZ bZj Vk„ZgV'cV €edXV'b^c^qigd Yd AciZg^dg Z iVbW€b fjZb Vhh^cdjVdgYZb eVgVgZeg^b^gcdhhVgZWZa^~d) (Mb YdhgZWZaYZh [d^ bdgid Xdb jb i^gd fjVcYd jb eda^X^Va fjZ [dgVVi^c\^YdcV XVWZ•V Xdb jbV eZYgVZcigdj Zb e}c^XdZ VWg^j[d\d VaZVidg^VbZciZ XdcigVcƒh) DZbWgd(bZYZZhiVg cd XZcigdYVgZWZa^~d ZYZiZghZci^YdjbV hVi^h[V•~d ZcdgbZ Xdb b^c]V XVeijgV'ZcfjVcid bZjh Vb^\dh ZhiVkVbXdb bZYd YVeg^h~dZiVbW€b YdheV^h)Fƒh VhhjhiVbdhiVcid d \dkZgcd fjZ [dbdh Vc^hi^VYdh) @djkZ Va\jch WZcZ[‚X^dh ƒWk^dhYZXdggZciZh YVYZbdchigV•~dYVXV( eVX^YVYZ YZV\^gYZVXdgYdXdb Vhegƒeg^Vhde^c^…Zh'hZb XZYZgjb
G !eVgV‚hd!a^WVc•h ZkVedgdj gZeZci^cVbZciZ' YZed^hYZVa\jch i^gdhZ WdbWVh YZbdgiZ^gd)9a\jch bZhZhVeƒhbZj Ze^hƒY^dcV eg^h~d'YZed^h YZfjVhZ ,. h€XjadhYZXdZm^hi•cX^V €ic^XVcdi|kZa' jb ;^hcZ FZ\gd' k^c( Yd Yd cVYV'igVch[dgbdj d eVgV‚hdZb ^c[Zgcd)LZkZ^c‚X^djbV \jZggV X^k^a [ZgdoZcigZXg^hi~dhZ bj•jabVcdh' ^cXaj^cYddh gZ[j\^VYdheVaZh( i^cdh' fjZ [^XVgVbYd aVYdYdh bj•jabVcdh) 9 ajiV [d^ WgjiVa'_| fjZ VhodcVhYZXdbWViZ[^XVkVbcd XZcigdYVX^YVYZ Z fjZ VbV^dg eVgiZ YdhXdbWViZh dXdgg^V Zb |gZVhgZh^YZcX^V^h $b^c]V ZhXdaV [^XVkV VedjXVh XZciZcVhYZbZigdh YVodcV YZ\jZggV%)G Xdc[a^idYjgdj bV^h YZjbV Y€XVYV Z bZ^V)F~d hZgZ^bj^id YZhXg^i^kd) HdYZhZgfjZ V^ckZc•~d YV eƒakdgVZ YVhVgbVhYZ[d\d iZc]V igVch[dgbVYdd fjZ' cV €edXVYVh
ZheVYVh' iZg^Vh^YdVeZcVhjbV h^ijV•~dYZiZch~d Zb jbV Zhe^gVa YZjb Xdc[a^id^cXdcigda|kZabdk^Yd edg gZiVa^V•…Zh) 9a€b YVYZhigj^•~d[‚h^XV $fjZ hZgZkZadj[|X^aYZhZggZkZgi^YV Xdb Va\jch ZbegZ^iZ^gdhbdi^kVYdh'eda‚i^XdhhjWdgcVYdhZ edgiVYdgZhYZi‚( ijadh ^c\•cjdh%' V\jZggVgZbdkZj WdVeVgiZYVXVbVYV ZmiZgcV YZhd[^h( i^XV•~dfjZ [^oZgV YVhX^YVYZh aZkVci^cVh jb XZcigdXdci‚cjd YZ\gVcYZ gZ[^cVbZcid^ciZaZXijVa YjgVciZ. b^a Vcdh)Gh Xg^hi~dh k^c]Vb YZ^mVcYd VgZ\^~dYZhYZ d eZg‚dYdYdhdidbVcdh ( dh fjZ [dgVb eVgVd GX^YZciZ VYdiVgVbcdbZh dX^YZciV^h Z ^chZg^gVb(hZ cV hdX^ZYVYZ) G •mdYdVj( bZcidj) G c†bZgd YZeZhhdVhVXjaijgVYVh XV^jVWV^md Yd c‚kZaXg‚i^Xd)
FV egƒm^bV kZo fjZ egZhZcX^Vg jb WaZXVjiZ' WjhfjZ Va\jb Xdchdad da]VcYd eVgVd X€j) NdX• c~d d gZXdc]ZXZg|):Z^gjiZ hd[g^VXdgiZhYZ ZcZg\^V[gZf‡ZciZhYjgVciZV\jZggV)9ciZh YZVheZhhdVhXdbegVgZb dh egƒeg^dh\ZgVYdgZh' eVgiZYd X€j [^XVkV XaVgV { cd^iZ' edg XdciVYVVjh•c( X^VYZedaj^•~d ajb^cdhV) =gVVeVgiZYVX^YVYZ bV^hY^hiVciZYVodcVYZ XdbWViZ)Hg^kVYVh YViZaZk^h~d'VheZhhdVhY^g^\^VbeVgVVhh^hi^g {h ajoZh Zb Zgje•~d YVhWViVa]Vh cdijgcVh) =aVheVgZX^Vb egZ[Zg^gXdggZgd g^hXd YZhZgZbVi^c\^YVh edg WdbWVhYZbdgiZ^gd Vdi€Y^dYZjbV cd^iZ bd( cƒidcV) =gVedhh‚kZakZgVhZhigZaVh Xdb bj^iV XaVgZoV) =j VegZcYZgV cd Zch^cd b€Y^d fjZ dh eaVcZiVhZhi~dZb Va\d X]VbVYdR^bVYpO_V\& YZ[dgbV fjZ c~d egZX^h|kVbdhcdh egZdXjeVgXdb ZhigZaVh Vi^c\^cYd(cdh^cZheZgVYV( bZciZ) HVgV b^b' Vfj^ad ZgVVa\dfjZ aZbWgVkV hdbWg^VbZciZVh]^hiƒ( g^VhfjZ iVbW€b cdh XdciVkVbhdWgZ V!ZhiVW^a^YVYZ ]^hiƒg^XV †c^XV!Yd D‚WVcd) 9 egƒeg^V^Y€^V Ydhjedhid Zfj^a‚Wg^d bZ ^cXdbdYVkV)=j da]VkV eVgVVhXdchiZaV•…Zh cd X€j Zc~d hVW^V Zb fjZ VXgZY^iVg)
9 ]^hiƒg^V€ deVXV) NdX• k• dh gZhjaiVYdh'bVh c~d k• d gdiZ^gdfjZ egd( Yjo ZkZcidh' d \ZgVYdgYV]^hiƒg^V)@| jbV ^cXdbeaZijYZ [jcYVbZciVa
) eg~d YdhZkZcidh'_| fjZ c~d hZk• d fjZ Zhi| edg YZcigdYVb|( cVeZgXZ"S" ) dgcd dh bZXVc^hbdh [jcX^dcVb) G fjZ X]Vbd YZ\ZgVYdgYZ fjbV' X*) L X ^hiƒg^Xdh€ Y^[ZgZciZ Ydhegdecdh ZkZcidh' VbZhbV adgbV fjZ ] ZkZcidK ) * ( YdhYZjhZhc~d edYZb hZgaAYVh hdbZciZ VigVkZh YVdWhZgkV•Vd VhbZc i ZK )# XZA#idh e bj^id egdk|kZa fjZ kdX• hZBV Zc\VcVYdhdWgZVhbiZc( YZhZjh a# ) •…ZhYZaZh) * )' ' ) ) =hhVY•hXdcZm~dZ hAb^aVg V YA[ZgZc•V ZcigZ V XdbAYVfjZ hZkZ cV bZhVYd gZhiVjgVciZZ d egdXZhhdfjZ hZedYZ dWhZgkVg cV Xdo^c]V)$FV †ai^bVkZofjZ [^ojb O_b[PUZb XZgidgZhiVjgVciZ X]^c•hcV;VcVaKigZZi' cVeVgiZWV^mV YZEVc]ViiVc' k^jb gVidhV^cYdYVXdo^c]V)% 9 bZciZ ]jbVcV € V[a^\^YV edg ig•h bVaZhfjVcYd ZcigVZb XdciVid Xdb V]^hiƒg^V'd fjZ X]Vbd YZaR_PRa\QN\]NPVQNQR( =aZhh~d5 V) V^ajh~dYVXdbegZZch~d'dj Xdbd idYdh VX]VbfjZ hVWZbd fjZ Zhi| VXdciZXZcYd Zb jb bjcYd fjZ € bV^hXdbea^XVYd$dj VaZV( iƒg^d%Yd fjZ eZgXZWZb6 W)VY^hidg•~dgZigdheZXi^kV' dj Xdbd edYZbdh VWdgYVg Vhhjcidh hd( bZciZ Veƒhd [Vid' Xdbd hZZhi^kZhhZbZb jb ZheZa]dgZigdk^hdg$V ]^hiƒg^VeVgZXZ bV^hXaVgV Zdg\Vc^oVYV cdh a^kgdhYZ]^hiƒg^VYdfjZ cVgZVa^YVYZ Zbe‚g^XV%' Z X)VhjeZgkVadg^oV•~d YV^c[dgbV•~d [VXijVaZ VYZ[^X^•cX^V YZeZhhdVh Xdb Xdc]ZX^bZcidh egd[jcYdh Z bj^id ZhijYd' eVgi^XjaVgbZciZ fjVcYd Xg^VbXViZ\dg^Vh ( fjVcYd !eaVidc^[^XVb!) 3
+:=8DJ<
B347
' @D7 7BCH35>=C757=6>
9 eg^bZ^gVeZ•VYd iZgXZid€ VeVidad\^VYZhZeZchVgfjZ d bjcYd Zb fjZ k^kZbdh€ bV^hXdbegZZch‚kZa'bV^hZmea^X|kZa Z'edgiVcid' bV^hegZ( k^h‚kZa YdfjZ gZVabZciZ€) Gh VYjaidhY^o^VbXdchiVciZbZciZeVgVb^b fjZ V\jZggV' fjZ Yjgdj fjVhZ ,2 Vcdh'iZgb^cVg^VZb !jbV fjZhi~d YZedjXdh Y^Vh!)=aZheVgZ( X^VbWVhiVciZ Xdc[^VciZhZb hjVhegZk^h…Zh hdWgZ VYjgV•~dYV\jZggV' d fMZedYZhZgegdkVYdeZadc†bZgd YZeZhhdVhfjZ [^XVkVbhZciVYVh Zb fjVgidh YZ]di€^h ZdjigVh ^chiVaV•…Zh iZbedg|g^VhZb ;]^egZ' cV ?g€X^V' cV>gVc•VZZb djigdh aj\VgZhV\jVgYVcYdd [^cVaYV\jZggV)Mb i^d gZ( eZi^VeVgVb^b fjZ' XZgXV YZig^ciVVcdhVciZh'fjVcYd dheVaZhi^cdh g^Xdh [j\^gVb eVgVd D‚WVcd'ZaZhVX]VkVbfjZ VfjZaVhZg^V jbV hdaj•~d ZbV' a\ aRZ]\_j_VN $VbV^dg^VYdhfjZ V^cYVZhi~dk^kdheZgbVcZXZba|' hZ^h
Y€XVYVh YZed^h%) ;dcijYd' fjVcYd Zj eZg\jciVkV VZaZhZVXdciZXZg^V d bZhbd Xdb d cdhhd Xdc[a^id'ZaZgZhedcY^V5 !F~d' € XaVgd fjZ c~d) 9fj^ € Y^[ZgZciZ6 hZbegZ [d^Y^[ZgZciZ)! ^YZa ;Vhigd) Gjk^bdh d bZhbd hdWgZgZ[j\^VYdh^gVc^VcdhZb HVg^hZ Ddc( YgZhfjZ [j\^gVb YVJZe†Wa^XV Aha}b^XV Zb ,423 VX]VcYdfjZ VVjh•cX^V c~d hZg^V bV^hYd fjZ jbVh [€g^Vh XjgiVh)9a\jch V^cYV Zhi~dV\jVgYVcYd eZad gZidgcd' bV^h YZjb fjVgid YZh€XjadYZed^h)Ej^idh gjhhdh fjZ eVgi^gVbZb ,4,2' Xdbd d ZhXg^idg NaVY^b^g F VWd`dk'^chiVaVgVb (hZZb :Zga^b' iVakZoV[^b YZZhiVgWVhiVciZ egƒm^bdh eVgVjb gZidgcd g|e^Yd) G egƒeg^d FVWd`dk eVhhdj Vk^YVidYVZb aVgZh iZbedg|g^dh' iVcid cV ^cY^\•cX^V fjVcid cd ajmd' k^kZcYdhZjh†ai^bdh Y^Vh cd ]diZa EdcigZjm HVaVXZ' cd aV\d?ZcZkV) @Vk^V'€ XaVgd'XZgiVYdhZYZeZchVbZcid fj^b€g^Xd Zb idYdh Zh( hZhZggdhYZegZk^h~d'VXZ\jZ^gVYVZheZgVc•V'bVh ]Vk^ViVbW€b jb egdWaZbVYZXdc]ZX^bZcid) 9 Y^c}b^XVYd Xdc[a^ida^WVc•h [dgVeViZc(
) i ) #MegZk^h‚kZa bVh V^cYVVhh^bVgVX^dcVa^oV•~d YVheZhhdVhVd iZgcZcZ # gZgcdh ZkZcidhYZbdchigVkVjbV XdchiVciZ5fjVhZ idYdhfjZ hZ ZmVgcaaaV i kVb eVgZX^Vb XdckZcX^Ydh YZfjZ XdbegZZcYAVbd fjZ ZhiVkV agcedgV [^XVkVbXdb( cYd ) ;VYVcdkd Y^VigVo^VVXdciZX^bZcidhfjZ VXdciZXZ ) ZciZ [dgVYVhegZk^h…Zh' bVh ZaZhc~d XdchZ\MaVbXdbegZZcYZg eaZiVgc sY sY U dh i^c]Vb egZk^hid)Ej^id Yd fjZ VXdciZXZjiZcV KAd XdcKaZ( `` ( "& Yd XdbeaZiVbZciZ adjXd Zb gZaV•~dVdeVhhVYd) EVh cVd eVgZ;AV iVd q6jXdQR]\V` YdhZkZcidh)=hhVeaVjh^W^a^YVYZ gZig8heZXi^kV \ZgVqb YZh( Xdcid cV gVg^YVYZ ZcV XdcXZe•~dYd ZkZcid)EVAKiVgYZ'YZeVgZA Xdb V bZhbV ^ajh~dYZXdbegZZch~d cd hjXZhhdYZcZ\ƒX^dhZ Zb bZgXVYdh +
d
d
d
d
[^cVcXZ^gdh) % ':BCMA:3=I>
(&3AA3BC3!6H B3;C>B
EV^hiVgYZ'gZkZcYddh ZkZcidhYd eZg‚dYdYZ\jZggV Zb b^c]V bZbƒ( g^VZcfjVcid [dgbjaVkVb^c]Vh ^Y€^Vh hdWgZ VeZgXZe•~dYZZkZcidhgVc( Y„b^Xdh' YZhZckdak^ V ^begZhh~degZYdb^cVciZ YZfjZ cdhhVhbZciZh h~d bVgVk^a]dhVh b|fj^cVh YZZmea^XV•…Zh' XVeVoZh YZVig^Wj^g hZci^Yd VfjVhZ ijYd Z YZVXjbjaVg Zmea^XV•…Zh eVgVidYd i^ed YZ[Zc„bZcdh' Z\ZgVabZciZ^cXVeVoZh YZVXZ^iVg V^Y€^V YV^begZk^h^W^a^YVYZ) Gh ZkZc( idh ZgVb^cZmea^X|kZ^h' bVh eZhhdVh^ciZa^\ZciZheZchVgVbhZgXVeVoZh YZ d[ZgZXZg Zmea^XV•…Zh Xdck^cXZciZheVgVZaZh( YZed^hYd ZkZcid) 9a€b YdbV^h'fjVcid bV^h^ciZa^\ZciZ[dg VeZhhdV'bZa]dg hdVg|VZmea^XV•~d) G bV^hegZdXjeVciZ € fjZ idYVhVhXgZc•VhZ gZaVidheVgZX^Vbad\^XV( bZciZ XdZgZciZh Z ^hZcidhYZ^cXdch^hi•cX^Vh) =ci~d YZ^mZ^ d aj\Vg X]VbVYdD‚WVcdfjVcYd ZgVVYdaZhXZciZ' bVh' Xdbd jb \gVcYZc†bZgd YZeVgZciZhZ Vb^\dh eZgbVcZXZgVba|' gZ( idbVkV Xdb [gZf‡•cX^VeVgVk^h^i|(Adh'ZheZX^VabZciZ YjgVciZVh]dhi^( a^YVYZh) 9 \jZggVc~d ZgVXdci‚cjV5]djkZ eZg‚dYdhZb fjZ dh XdbWViZh [dgVb ^ciZggdbe^Ydhedg hdaj•…Zh!eZgbVcZciZh!) KZci^(bZegƒm^bd YZ b^c]Vh gV‚oZh YjgVciZeZg‚dYdhY^[‚XZ^h ZZmeZg^bZciZ^ V}ch^VYZkdaiVgZ YZbdchigVgVed^dVdhfjZ [^XVgVb eVgVig|h ZfjZ' [gZf‡ZciZbZciZ' hZc( i^Vb(hZYZhbdgVa^oVYdh eZaVheVgi^YVh ( Z iVbW€b ^ckZ_dhdhYdhVb^( \dh fjZ hƒ VeVgZX^Vb fjVcYd VhXd^hVh bZa]dgVkVb' fjZ edY^Vb WjhXVg hZ\jgVc•VZXdc„b^XVZ eZhhdVaZ gZidbVg YZ[€g^VhYjgVciZdh eZg‚dYdh dXVh^dcV^h YZXVabVg^V cdh Xdc[a^idh)>^fjZ^ ^cXVeVo YZigVWVa]Vg ZYZaZg fjVcYd ZhiVkV [dgVYd D‚WVcdZcfjVcid eZhhdVhbdgg^Vb' bVh' eVgVYd(
mVabZciZ' egZdXjeVkV(bZ bZcdh Xdb dh ZkZcidh Z hZci^V(bZ bV^h XVeVo YZhZ\j^g bZjh ^ciZgZhhZh# ^ciZaZXijV^hhZb XjaeV fjVcYd R`aNcNcd D‚WV( cd) AciZgZhhVciZbZciZ' VheZhhdVh[VggZVkVbZb YZbVh^VYjgVciZ V\jZg( gVZ YZhZckdakZgVbjb \dhid V^cYVbV^dg eZad ajmd' idgcVcYd Vhk^h^iVh WVhiVciZ^ciZgZhhVciZh'VeZhVgYdh XdbWViZh) @Vk^VVa\jbVh fjZhi…Zh Y^[‚XZ^h) ;dbd Va\j€b edYZg^ViZg egZk^hid fjZ VheZhhdVhfjZ eVgZX^VbbdYZadh YZidaZg}cX^VedYZg^Vb hZ igVch( [dgbVg cdh bV^h ejgdh W|gWVgdhYVcd^iZ eVgVd Y^V8Hdg fjZ VbjYVc•V [d^ i~d VWgjeiV89 eg^cX‚e^d eZchZ^ fjZ iVakZoV\jZggV a^WVcZhV [dhhZcV kZgYVYZ^bedhh‚kZa YZ hZ egZkZg' Y^[ZgZciZbZciZ YZ djigdh Xdc[a^idh' Z fjZ dh aZkVci^cdh ZgVb jbV gV•VXdbea^XVYVYZbV^heVgVhZgZciZcY^YV) gVcXZ'HVja NZncZ' [Vadj Vegdeg^VYVbZciZ hdWgZgZa^\^…Zh fjZ hZZheVa]Vk{b !Xdbd WZhihZaaZgh!( jbV XdbeVgV•~d fjZ ^cY^XV^begZk^h^W^a^YVYZ) =hhZhi^(
YZYe)hXdci^cj^YVYZhcV Xgdcdad\^V Ydh ZkZcidh c~d idgcVb bj^id edh Y# # ' Y " #AVegd[^hh~d YZ]^hidg^VYdg5d ZmVbZZhij aGK+Z bAbbVbZciZ Z( NV;A L P" ! iVa]VYdYd eVhhVYdc~d Zch^cVbj^id hdWgZVbZciZ V AhidcV6VeZcVh i Vchb^iZ V^ajh~d YZfjZ VZciZcYZbdh) g @^hiƒg^VZhdX^ZYVYZh c~d hZVggVhiVb)=aVhY~d hVaidh'KZ\jZb YZgje( ijgV V gjeijgV' ^ciZgbZY^VYVhedg edjXVh k^WgV•…Zh) 9^cYV Vhh^b' cƒh $Zdh ]^hidg^VYdgZh% \dhiVbdh YZVXgZY^iVg cV egd\gZhh~d egZk^h‚kZaZ Zb eZfjZcdh ^cXgZbZcidh) ' >j^ Vi^c\^Yd edg jbV XgZc•VfjZ cjcXV bVAKbZ VWVcYdcdj YZfjZ hdbdh VeZcVhjbV \gVcYZ b|fj^cV YZda]Vg eVgVig|h' Z fjZ dh ]jbVcdh h~d ƒi^bdh Zb hZVjid(Zc\VcVgZb) ;VYV Vcd fjZ eVhhVVjbZciV b^c]V XgZc•VcZhhVY^hidg•~d) .D7A:6> 6:HA:>" + ':BCMA:33=63 ?3A3 CAHB =kZcidh VegZhZciVb(hZVcƒh YZ[dgbV Y^hidgX^YV) ;dch^YZgZ VcVijgZoVYV ^c[dgbV•~d5 Ydhb^a]…Zh'iVakZoVi€ig^a]…Zh'YZeZfjZcdh [VidhfjZ egZkVaZ( XZb VciZhfjZ jb ZkZcid dXdggV'VeZcVhjb c†bZgd bj^id eZfjZcd hZg| Xdch^YZgVYd gZaZkVciZYZed^hYd dXdgg^YdeVgVhjV XdbegZZch~d Yd fjZ VXdciZXZj)Hdg hjV bZbƒg^V hZga^b^iVYVZ[^aigVYV' kdX• ZhiVg|^cXa^cVYd VhZ aZbWgVgYdh YVYdhfjZ hZZcXV^mVbedhiZg^dgbZciZ Xdb dh [Vidh' Vc~d hZg fjZ kdX• hZ_V Xdbd d Ze„c^bd >jcZh Yd Xdcid YZBdg\ZDj^h:dg\Zh' !>jcZh' d EZbdg^dhd!' fjZ c~d hZZhfjZXZYZcVYVZeVgZXZ XdcYZcVYdVk^kZgXdb d [VgYdYd VX†bjad YZ^c[dgbV•…Zhc~d(egdXZhhVYVh) $=aZc~d XdchZ\jZ k^kZg edg bj^id iZbed)% E^c]V eg^bZ^gVZmedh^•~d{ Y^hidg•~dgZigdheZXi^kV VXdciZXZjYVhZ\j^c( iZ bVcZ^gV5YjgVciZ V ^c[}cX^V'[j^ jb aZ^idgkdgVo' hZWZb fjZ ^ggZ\jaVg' bVh eVhhZ^Veg^bZ^gV[VhZYV\jZggV Zb jb edg~d' bZg\ja]VcYd YZXdged Z VabVZb idYd i^ed YZa^kgdh)9 ZhXdaV ZhiVkV[ZX]VYVZ X]dk^VWdbWVhYZ bdgiZ^gd) >^XVgZb edg…Zh€ iZgg^kZabZciZiZY^dhd)E^c]Vh egZdXjeV•…Zh ^c^X^V^h ZgVb eg^cX^eVabZciZXdbd XdbWViZgd i€Y^dZd fjZ aZgZb hZ\j^YVt ( VeZhVgYZfjZ hZg[dg•VYd VaZgedg [VaiVYZdjigVh Vi^k^YVYZh c~d € i~d V\gVY|kZafjVcid aZgedg kdciVYZ egƒeg^V)=j fjZg^V hZg[^aƒhd[d $ZV^cYV
ˆ :Zcd^i EVcYZaWgdi'fjZ iZkZjbV ZmeZg^•cX^V eVgZX^YV bV^h dj bZcdh cV bZhbV ^YVYZ'hƒ fjZ fjVigd Y€XVYVh VciZh' aZbWgVd hZj egƒeg^d iZbed cV \jZggV Xdbd adc\dh eZg‚dYdhYZ i€Y^dYdadgdhd' edcijVYdh edg WgZkZh bdbZcidh YZZmigZbd bZYd)
fjZgd%' YZ[dgbV fjZ VX]Z^fjZ egZX^hVkV [VoZgjb ^ckZhi^bZcid ZhijYVc( Yd egd[jcYVbZciZ Vh^Y€^Vh YZdjigVh eZhhdVh)9h X^gXjchi}cX^Vh bZ bd( i^kVgVb VZhijYVggZaVidhiZƒg^XdhZ \ZgV^hYZ\jZggVh Z Xdc[a^idh'iZciVcYd bZg\ja]Vg cVhZcigVc]VhYV]^hiƒg^V'eVgVXdchZ\j^g ZcigVgcdh bZXVc^hbdh YZhhV\gVcYZb|fj^cV fjZ \ZgVZkZcidh) KjgegZZcYZciZbZciZ' d a^kgdfjZ bZ ^c[ajZcX^dj c~d [d^ ZhXg^idedg Va\j€b cd gVbd Yd eZchVbZcid' Z h^b edg jb _dgcVa^hiV5 8Vj_V\ QR6R_' YVZ& ,4./(,4/,' YZO^aa^Vb K]^gZg)K]^gZgZgVjb XdggZhedcYZciZ YZg|( Y^d' [Vbdhd edg hZj a^kgd5`PR[`l\ R^bRQNQ\ HR_PRV_\ FRVPU(GXdggZj(bZ fjZ d 8Vj_V\ d[ZgZX^V jbV eZgheZXi^kV^cXdbjb) =j _| i^c]V a^Yd$dj a^Yd hdWgZ% VhdWgVhYZ@Z\Za' EVgm' LdncWZZ' 9gdc Z >^X]iZ hdWgZV[^adhd[^V YV]^hiƒg^V Z hjVh egdeg^ZYVYZh'Z VX]VkVfjZ i^c]V jbV kV\V ^Y€^VYVh cd•…ZhYZY^Va€i^XV' Vi€ dcYZ ]Vk^VVa\d eVgVhZXdbegZZcYZg cZhhVhiZd( g^Vh)F~d ZciZcY^ bj^iV Xd^hV'ZmXZidfjZ V]^hiƒg^Vedhhj‚V Va\jbV aƒ\^XV Z fjZ VhXd^hVhhZ YZhZckdak^Vb V eVgi^g YZ XdcigVY^•…Zh$dj dedhidh%' YZ jbV bVcZ^gV fjZ ZaZkVkVV ]jbVc^YVYZ eVgV[dgbVh hjeZg^dgZh YZ hdX^ZYVYZ ( ZhhZi^ed YZXd^hV)LjYd eVgZX^V ^cXg^kZabZciZhZbZa]VciZ {h iZdg^VhVd bZj gZYdghdWgZV \jZggV cd D‚WVcd)9i€ ]d_Z hjgegZZcYd VheZhhdVhfjZ bZ [VoZb VeZg\jciV g^Y‚XjaVYZfjV^h a^kgdh!bdaYVgVb bZj eZchVbZcid! Y^oZcYd V ZaVhfjZ [d^ ZhhZa^kgd fjZ bV^h bZ Zch^( cdj $VeZhVgYZ^cVYkZg5i^YVbZciZ% hdWgZ[^adhd[^VZiZdg^VYV]^hiƒg^V( Z' Xdbd kZgZbdh' iVbW€b hdWgZX^•cX^V'ed^h VegZcY^Xdb ZaZVY^[ZgZc•V ZcigZ egdXZhhdhS\_dN_Q Z ONPXdN_Q$eVgVV[gZciZ Z eVgVig|h%) ;dbd8 K^beaZhbZciZ' d Y^|g^d egde…Z(hZV YZhXgZkZg dh ZkZcidh R[' ^bN[a\ NP\[aRPVNZZ c~d YZed^h)=j ZhiVkVZb jb edg~d Xdb V]^hiƒg^V YZhZcgdaVcYd(hZhdcdgVbZciZ hdWgZb^b $d hdb YVhWdbWVhYZbdgiZ^gd bZ bVci^c]V VXdgYVYd Vcd^iZ idYV%)=j ZgVjb VYdaZhXZciZ XdbeVgZXZc( Yd Vdh[jcZgV^hYZXdaZ\VhYZXaVhhZ) =j ZhiVkVk^kZcX^VcYdjb YZhZcgdaVg c~d iZƒg^XdYV]^hiƒg^VZ aZcYd qdWgZVa\j€b fjZ VeVgZciZbZciZ ZmeZg^( bZciVgV V]^hiƒg^V{ bZY^YVfjZ ZaVVXdciZX^V) =h[dgXZ^(bZeVgVegdYjo^g bZciVabZciZ jbV gZegZhZciV•~dX^cZbVid\g|[^XVYd [jijgd ZeZgXZW^ fjZ ZaZc~d ZgVi~d ƒWk^d)HZgXZW^ fjZ hZZj XdbZ•VhhZVZhXgZkZg hdWgZVfjZaZh ZkZcidh bV^h iVgYZ'ZaZheVgZXZg^VbbV^h))) UV`aq_VP\`( @Vk^VjbV Y^[ZgZc•V ZcigZ d N[aR`Z d QR]\V`( G Y^|g^d [d^ ZhXg^idegdedh^iVYVbZciZ hZb fjZ K]^gZghdjWZhhZd fjZ VXdciZXZg^V Zb hZ\j^YV' fjVcYd V ^c[dgbV•~d V fjZ i^c]V VXZhhdV^cYV c~d [dgV Xdggdbe^YV eZadh YZhZcaVXZh edhiZg^dgZh)9a\jch XdbZci|g^dh
j^ Z Va^[dgVb WVhiVciZZhXaVgZXZYdgZh' eVgi^XjaVgbZciZ VfjZaZh hdWgZ Vf )ia X XgZc•V[gVcXZhVYZfjZ @a Zg ZgVjb aZcdbZcd igVchAidcd' d fjZ Zm( Va^XVkV V [VaiVYZegZeVgd YV>gVc•V Z hjV g|e^YV XVe^ijaV•~dhjWhZf‡Zc( H =b cZc]jb bdbZcid VZmiZch~dgZVaYVYZkVhiV•~d[d^ Xdch^YZgVYV iZ) edhh‚kZa) ))')' ) 9eZhVg YZiZgbdh jbV bZbƒcV VaiVbZciZ bhiVkZa' jb YaVcd d[ZgZ( XZ[Vidh ^cYZa€kZ^hgZ\^higVYdhbV^h dj bZcdh ^bZY^ViVbZciZ6Vhh^b' ZaZ Zgb^iZ V [^mV•~dYZjbV eZgXZe•~d c~d(gZk^hVYVZ cdh ]VW^a^iV V Zhij( qVgbdh cd [jijgd dh ZkZcidh YZcigd YZhZj egƒeg^d XdciZmid)
r
%
r
ˆ G ]^hidg^VYdgF^Vaa>Zg\jhdc YZbdchigdj fjZ' VeZhVgYZidYdh dh gZaVidhigVY^X^dcV^h Yd eZg‚dYd fjZ egZXZYZjV?gVcYZ ?jZggV YZhXgZkZgZb !iZch…ZhXgZhXZciZh! Z !Xg^hZhXVYV kZo e^dgZh!' d Xdc[a^id[d^ jbV hjgegZhV)KdbZciZ Zb gZigdheZXid€ fjZ V\jZggV [d^ k^hiVXdbd ^cZk^i|kZaedg ]^hidg^VYdgZhfjZ da]VkVb eVgVig|h) >Zg\jhdc ji^a^odj jb Vg\jbZcid Zb( e‚g^Xd^ciZa^\ZciZeVgVYZ[ZcYZghjV edh^•~d5 ZaZdWhZgkdj dh kVadgZhYdh i‚ijadh ^beZg^V^h' fjZ cdgbVabZciZ ^cXajZb VhZmeZXiVi^kVh Ydh ^ckZhi^YdgZhZb gZaV•~d{h cZXZhh^YVYZh YZ [^cVcX^VbZcid Yd \dkZgcd' Xj_d kVadgXV^Zb eZg‚dYdh Zb fjZ Xdc[a^idh h~d ZheZgVYdh' ed^h \jZggVh \ZgVb Y€[^X^ih\gVkZh)EVh d kVadgYdh i‚ijadh c~d gZ[aZi^VV ZmeZXiVi^kV YZ jbV \jZggV) GWhZgkZfjZ ZhhZZhijYd ^ajhigV'Zb VY^•~d'Xdbd igVWVa]Vg Xdb egZ•dh edYZ [dgcZXZgjbV WdVXdbegZZch~d YV]^hiƒg^V)
V^Y€^VXdcYjo^j(bZ { VkZcijgV $dj bZa]dg' { VkZcijgdhV eg|i^XV YV^c( XZgiZoV%' Z iVbW€b { eg|i^XV YVbViZb|i^XV Z YVX^•cX^V)
9egZhZciVgZ^d iZgXZ^gdZaZbZcid Yd iZgXZid'VbVaY^•~d Yd VegZcY^oVYd'V hZ\j^g) GWhZgkZ^ ViZciVbZciZ bZj Vk„' fjZ ZgVb^c^higd YV
HZgXZW^ iVbW€b YjgVciZ V\jZggV cd D‚WVcdfjZ dh _dgcVa^hiVh iZcYZb VhZ V\adbZgVg c~d cZXZhhVg^VbZciZZb idgcd YVhbZhbVh de^c^…Zh'bVh Xdb
''! Q"S Zb idgcd Ydh bZhbdh eVYg…Zh YZVc|a^hZ)9ig^WjZb VbZhbV [gZfjZcX ))!# Y!Y Va# )! X^VVdh bZhbdh XdcBjcidh YZ;AgXjchiVc;aVhZ AN Zb V gZ )& ^bedgiVc )' U ) bZhbVh XViZ\dg^Vh ( bVAKjbV bVb[ZhiV•Vd Yd eaVidbhbd' d YVYZcVh ) W# ` # YZY^k^Y^g V gZVa^YVYZ Zb [dgbVh WZb YZ[^)aaaYVh) G fjZ Jd Zgi >AK YZhZBG ') Y# ' ) i A !#dgcVa^hbd YZ]diZa# VjbZcidj Vb VbVAKd XdciV\AGbZc V) X]VbV YZ B !Y ^c^X^VabZciZ dh B#dgcVa^hiVh XdcKAYZgVkVb d DAWVcdeVgiZ d =cfjVc id ' #)!) ) i dj KZB#V DZkVcZ' ' Yd EZYaiZggVcZddcZciVa' ZaZV\dgV ' 'hZidgcdj' gZeZciA( iAkZhhZigVchedgiVYd cVbZc i Z' HVgiZYd Gg^ZciZ E€Y^d ' Xdbd ) hZ Va\jZb )' ) ' eVgVbV^h eZgid YVhVgZ^Vh YV9g|WAVKVjYAiV) 9 ^a]VYZ;]AegZ' fjZ d eVAK )! [^XVVedjXd bZcdh YZ,++ fj^a„bZigdh YVbb]V k^aVcd FdgiZ Yd DAWVcd' ZXdb Xdb^YV'^\gZ_VhZ ]|W^idh fjVhZ ^Y•ci^Xdh'idgcdj(hZ eVgiZYq =jgd( VYZjbV ]dgV eVgVdjigV $€XaVgdfjZ' hjWhZf‡ZciZbZciZ' dh cViANGK Zb qbWdh dh aVYdhidgcVgVb(hZ XdcY^X^dcVYdh%) =cfjVcid' cd eVhhVYd'[dgV [Z^iVjbV Y^hi^c•~d ZcigZ d fjZ ZgVXdch^YZgVYd bZY^iZgg}cZd Z c~d(bZ( Y^iZgg}cZd$edg ZmZbead' ZcigZ d VoZ^iZZ VbVciZ^\V%' cV Y€XVYV YZ ,42+ ZhhVY^hi^c•~deVhhdj YZgZeZciZ VhZgZcigZ =jgdeV Z c~d(=jgdeV) ;db d ^ha~hZeVgVcYddh Yd^haVYdh'c~d hZhVW^V dcYZ XdadXVg dh Xg^hi~dh$dj _j( YZjh%VgVWƒ[dcdhcVi^kdh cZhhV]^hiƒg^VidYV) ;ViZ\dg^oV•…Zhh~d ^bedg( iVciZheVgVdh ]jbVcdh' bVh idgcVb(hZ eVidaƒ\^XVhfjVcYd VXViZ\dg^V€ i^YVXdbd YZ[^c^i^kV'^beZY^cYd fjZ VheZhhdVhXdch^YZgZbVkV\jZoV YVh [gdciZ^gVh'bj^id bZcdh gZk^hVg VhXViZ\dg^Vh) G eg^cX^eVabdi^kd Y^hhd[d^ d Xdci|\^d) KZkdX• hZaZX^dcVhhZ XZb _dgcVa^hiVh fjZ eZchVhhZb edg XdciV egƒeg^VZ[dhhZb XVeVoZh YZkZg[VidgZh^hdaVYdhjch Ydh djigdh' iZg^VjbV XZciZcVYZde^c^…ZhY^hi^ciVh)EVh d egdXZhhdYZ[VoZgXdb fjZ ZhhVheZh( hdVhgZedgiVhhZb Zb jb hƒ g^ibd [Zo Xdb fjZ VY^bZch~d Yd kdajbZ YZ de^c^…Zh[dhhZXdch^YZgVkZabZciZgZYjo^YV( Vhde^c^…ZhXdckZg\^gVb Z ZaZhjhVkVb dh bZhbdh ^iZch Xdbd XVjhVh)Hdg ZmZbead' V[VhiVcYd(cdh edg jb ^chiVciZ Yd D‚WVcd'idYdh dh gZeƒgiZgZhgZ[ZgZb(hZ { Y€XVYV YZ ,43+ Xdbd !Vcdh ZmigVdgY^c|g^dh!eVgi^cYd Yd eg^cX‚e^d YZ fjZ ]Vk^V Va\d ZheZX^[^XVbZciZ Y^hi^cid cZhhVY€XVYV)
ˆ NZgZbdh cd ;Ve‚ijad
KZkdX• fj^hZg kZg d fjZ fjZgd Y^oZgedg VgW^igVg^ZYVYZh YVhXViZ\d( g^Vh'VcVa^hZV h^ijV•~d YVeda‚i^XVedaVg^oVYV) FV egƒm^bV kZo fjZ jb bVgX^Vcd k^h^iVgV LZggV' iZciZ Zmea^XVg(a]Z edg fjZ VfjZaZh fjZ h~d V [VkdgYVZa^b^cq•~d YZjb [Zid YZcigd Yd †iZgd YVb~Z h~d iVbW€b Xdc( igV VeZcV YZbdgiZ' Gj iZciZ Zmea^XVg(a]Z edg fjZ VfjZaZh fjZ VXZ^iVb d VWdgidh~d hjedhiVbZciZ [Vkdg|kZ^h V jbV VaiVXVg\Vig^Wji|g^V' bVh XdcigV jb b^a^iVg^hbd [dgiZ) Hdg fjZ VfjZaZh fjZ egZ[ZgZb Va^WZgYVYZ hZmjVaegZX^hVbhZgXdcigVVa^WZgYVYZ ZXdc„b^XV ^cY^k^YjVa8 HZgXZW^ d VWhjgYdYd egdXZhhd V\adbZgVi^kd fjVcYd V^cYVZgVWZb cdkd) FV \jZggV X^k^acd D‚WVcd'edg Va\jbV gZk^gVkdaiV [Vgh^hiV Ydh ZkZc( idh' dh Xg^hi~dhidgcVgVb(hZ V [Vkdg Yd a^kgZ(bZgXVYdZ Yd h^hiZbV XVe^( iVa^hiV( dj hZ_V'd fjZ jb _dgcVa^hiVX]VbVg^VYZ !V <^gZ^iV!(' Z dh ^ha}b^XdhidgcVgVb(hZ hdX^Va^hiVh' gZXZWZcYd Ved^d YZgZ\^bZh Xdbjc^hiVh #\ D_NcQN& ƒg\~d Yd gZ\^bZ Xdbjc^hiV' gZ[Zg^V(hZ VZaZhXdbd !XdbWViZc( iZh YVdegZhh~d!' VeZhVgYZfjZ' bV^h iVgYZ'fjVcYd dh gjhhdh ^ckVY^gVb d 9[Z\Vc^hi~d' [dgVb dh VbZg^XVcdhfjZ WjhXVgVbVhhdX^V•…Zh Xdb :^c DVYZcZ hZjh XdaZ\Vhbj•jabVcdh%) 9 bZa]dg [dgbV YZhZegdkVg d XVg|iZgVgW^ig|g^dYZhhVhXViZ\dg^VhZ d Xdci|\^d egdYjo^Yd edg ZaVh€ aZbWgVgXdb fjZ [gZf‡•cX^Vdh V\adbZgVYdh gZkZgiZb(hZcV ]^hiƒg^V)9 Va^Vc•VVijVaZcigZ dh [jcYVbZciVa^hiVh Xg^hi~dh Z dh adW^hiVh ^hgVZaZchZh ^cig^\Vg^Vjb ^ciZaZXijVaYd h€XMad PAP ( dh Xg^h( i~dh XdhijbVkVb hZgVci^(hZb^iVh Z dh bj•jabVcdh ZgVb dh egdiZidgZh Ydh _jYZjh' VfjZb egZ[Zg^Vb Zb gZaV•~dVdhXg^hi~dh)D^WZgi|g^dhXdhij( bVkVb hZgYZZhfjZgYV)G fjZ VX]d^ciZgZhhVciZ'ZcfjVcid egdWVW^a^hiV' € fjZ Va\jb ZkZcid VaZViƒg^d[VoXdb fjZ jb \gjed fjZ Veƒ^V^c^X^VabZciZ jbV fjZhi~d Va^Z(hZ Vdjigd \gjed fjZ Veƒ^VdjigV fjZhi~d' gZhjaiVcYd cV [jh~d Z cV jc^[^XV•~d Ydh Yd^h^iZch)))Vi€VhjgegZhVYVhZeVgV•~d) 9 XViZ\dg^oV•~dhZbegZ \ZgVjbV gZYj•~d cV XdbeaZm^YVYZ gZVa)=hhV € jbV bVc^[ZhiV•~d Y)d\ZgVYdgYZ;^hcZh FZ\gdh' d ^cVWVa|kZa eaVidc^h( bd fjZ YZ[^c^cd Hgƒad\d) IjVafjZg gZYj•~d Yd bjcYd Vd cdhhd gZYdg edYZ iZg XdchZf‡•cX^VhZmeadh^kVh'ed^h ZmXaj^Va\jbVh [dciZh YZ^cXZgiZ( oV6VhgZYj•…ZhaZkVb(cdh VjbV XdbegZZch~d ZggVYV Yd iZX^YdYd bjc( Yd) Hdg ZmZbead' kdX• edYZ eZchVg fjZ d ^ha~gVY^XVa $ZhZjh kVadgZh% h~d hZjh Va^VYdh XdcigVVVbZV•VYd Xdbjc^hbd' Z Xdb ^hhdedYZ V_jY|(AdhV hZYZhZckdakZg'Vi€ fjZ _d\jZb Yd^hVk^…Zh cd XZcigd YZEVc]ViiVc) 9a\jch Vcdh YZed^hYd ^c‚X^dYV\jZggV a^WVcZhV' fjVcYd ZhijYVkVcV O]Vgidc KX]dda' Vdh-- Vcdh' [j^ Vi^c\^Yd eZaV^Y€^VYZbZgXVYdhZ[^X^Zc(
) UjbVa #Y€^VfjZ Y^ofjZ c~d € edhh‚kZa dWiZgajXgdh VeVgi^gYZi‚ij( ' iZh ' Ydh B#|fjZ ZhhZh^chigjbZcidh ^cXdgedgVb VjidbViAXVbZciZ ; cqq ' ) GK ' 1 bV•~d Y^hedc‚kZa) HdgiVcid' V ^c[dgbV•~d e†WaAXV edYZ hZg idYV baGg !#' !' ' ! ZX^VabZciZeVgVjb ]dbZb YZcZ\ƒXaGh' HGaKdh egZ•dhTV aaa( bji^a' !ZheYVZhhV^c[dgbV•~d' Z cdi‚XAVh ' XdbeVgiA#a]VYVhXdb b ^a](dZh YZ YjZb id e" #A c~d d[ZgZXZbcZc]jbV kVciV\Zb gZVa) bMaid egdkVkZ fjZ jb eZhhdVh 1 $ ' YZjb ZcigZ VhXZciZcVhYZba #a]…ZhYA# Z ZaidgZhYA# Z iV aaaadgbV•Vd dMbVAK ' Y! A ! iZc]V XdbegVYd d i‚ijad' ZaZkVcYdhZj egZ•d) 9KKAb' ZKAhia' Xdbe ZiV( H Y aZgB# dgcV^hZ YZVhh^hi^g { iZaZk^h~d'd fjZ bZ egdedgXaGcdj jgcV bZciZ Z ' ' ' #YVYZ Xdch^YZg|kZa YZiZbed aAkgZ$YA\VbdhjgcV ]dgV dj bVAKedg i fjVc A ! ' # d hj[^X^ZciZeVgVaZgbV^h YZXZb aAkgdhVbVAKedg Vcd' d fjZ' YZeGAK YAV' YZjb eVg YZY€XVYVh' XdbZ•V V[VoZgkdajbZ%) EVh ZhhZVg\jbZcid c~d € ZmViVbZciZV gVo~dXdbeaZiV eVgVb^c]V b|m^bV Xdci^YVcZhiZ a^kgd fjZ Y^ofjZ hZ YZkZZk^iVgdh _dgcV^h'ed^h' qZgZbdh dh djigdh WZcZ[‚q^dh YZhZZk^iVgVidm^X^YVYZ YV^c[dgbV•~d' Ab;aVabZciZ' ZhhVZgVjgcV ƒiAbV YZhXjaeVeVgVZk^iVgbZ bVciZg VeVg YVhb^c†X^Vh Yd cZ\ƒX^d' d fjZ ZgV jb |a^W^eZg[Z^id' _| fjZ Zj c~d VX]VkVcVYVYZ^ciZgZhhVciZcdh YZiVa]Zh Yd bjcYd Ydh cZ\ƒX^dh ( fjZ € YZhZaZ\VciZ'iZY^dhd' edbedhd' \VcVc( X^dhd'c~d ^ciZaZXijVa'Z\d‚hiV Z YZhV\gVY|kZa)
9^cYVc~d XdbegZZcYd edg fjZ Va\j€b fjZ eaVcZ_VhZgjb ![^aƒhd[d! dj jb ![^aƒhd[d X^Zci‚[^XdYV]^hiƒg^V! iZgb^cVg^VZhijYVcYd cZ\ƒX^dh' V^cYV edg X^bVcV O]Vgidc KX]dda)9a^' eZgXZW^ fjZ c~d ZgVVeZcVhjb eda‚i^Xd ^cXdchZf‡ZciZ Zb jb eV‚h eZfjZcd Z Vci^\d $ZhZj bdidg^hiV [^adhƒ[^Xd' E^`]V^a%'fjZ c~d hVW^V d fjZ ZhiVkVVXdciZXZcYd)9[^cVa YZXdciVh' eZh( hdVhZb eV‚hZheZfjZcdh YZkZb [l\ `NOR_d fjZ Zhi| VXdciZXZcYd)G fjZ k^[d^ fjZ Zb jgcV YVhZhXdaVh YZcZ\ƒX^dh bV^h egZhi^\^VYVh Yd bjcYd' cd eV‚hbV^h edYZgdhd YV]^hiƒg^VYd bjcYd' dh ZmZXji^kdhYVhXdgedgV•…Zh bV^h edYZgdhVhk^c]Vb YZhXgZkZg d fjZ [Vo^VbeVgV\Vc]Vg Vk^YV'Z ZgV eGhh‚kZafjZ iVbW€b c~d hdjWZhhZb d fjZ ZhiVkVVXdciZXZcYd'FV kZgYV( YZ'Zb b^c]V bZciZ ^hhdZgVbj^id bV^h Yd fjZ jbV edhh^W^a^YVYZ) KZci^ Zb b^c]V Zhe^c]V d eZhd YVVggd\}cX^VZe^hi•b^XVYVgV•V]jbVcV5
((((
ˆ >d^)cZhhZedcid fjZ eZgXZW^ fjZ V\gVcYZ[dg•V Yd h^hiZbVYZa^kgZ(Xdb€gX^d€ fjZ dh ZmZ( Xji^kdh YVhXdbeVc]^Vh c~d egZX^hVbhVWZg d fjZ Zhi| VXdciZXZcYd'
>^fjZ^ dWXZXVYd) FVfjZaZ bdbZcid' XdbZXZ^ V idbVg XdchX^•cX^V Yd bZj dW_ZidYZZhijYd ( d RcR[a\ _R`bYaN[aRNYaNZR[aRVZ]_\cjcRY( = c~d ZgVb VeZcVhdh ZmZXji^kdhXdgedgVi^kdhWZb kZhi^YdhZ XVggZ\VYdh YZ iZhidhiZgdcV fjZ XdhijbVkVb hZgZc\VcVYdh edg ZhhVhdgiZ XdcXZc( igVYV'bVh iVbW€b eZhhdVhbj^id ZhijYVYVh)LVaeZgXZe•~d igVch[dgbdj bZj ;^hcZ FZ\gd YZjb egdWaZbVYZeZhhdVhfjZ i•b hdgiZ dj VoVgcdh cZ\ƒX^dh Zb jb egdWaZbVYZXdc]ZX^bZcid Z X^•cX^V) E^c]V ^Y€^V€ fjZ Va\jch gZhjaiVYdhX^Zci‚[^Xdhc~d h~d VeZcVh^c†iZ^h cV k^YVgZVa'edg hj( WZhi^bVgZb d ^beVXid Yd VaiVbZciZ ^begdk|kZa $dj edg aZkVgZb(cdh V ^\cdg|(Ad%' bVh fjZ bj^idh YZaZhiVbW€b edYZb ZhiVg'cV kZgYVYZ' Xg^VcYd;^hcZh FZ\gdh) F~d h~d VeZcVhZggdhiVmdc„b^Xdh fjZ edYZb gZegdk|(Ad cV VjaVYZdgc^idad\^V) ;dbZXZ^ VeZgXZWZg VhXdchZf‡•cX^Vh YZhhV^Y€^V)
IjVigd Vcdh Z bZ^d YZed^hYZbZ [dgbVg Zb O]Vgidc $ZfjVigd fj^adh bV^h eZhVYd%'cd Y^V,4 YZdjijWgd YZ ,432' Zj ZhiVkVXVb^c]VcYd eVgV XVhVk^cYd Yd ZhXg^iƒg^dYd WVcXdYZ ^ckZhi^bZcidh ;gZY^i Kj^hhZ>^ghi :dhidc' fjZ [^XVcV eVgiZ XZcigVaYZ EVc]ViiVc' gjbd Vd MeeZg =Vhi K^YZ);Vb^c]VkV YZkV\Vg'ed^h ZhiVkVidiVabZciZ Xdc[jhd) ? Y^ViZhiZbjc]dj jb ZkZcid [^cVcXZ^gdigVjb|i^Xd5 VbV^dg fjZYV Yd bZgXVYdcV ]^hiƒg^V $bdYZgcV%)G ZkZcid [d^ V^cYVbV^h igVjb|i^Xd edg iZg VXdciZX^YdZb jbV €edXV Zb fjZ VXgZY^i|kVbdhfjZ i‚c]Vbdh cdh idgcVYd hj[^X^ZciZbZciZ hd[^hi^XVYdh Xdb idYdh VfjZaZh ZXdcdb^hiVh eaVidc^[^XVYdhYZ[VaV^ciZa^\ZciZ $Xdb hjVh ZfjV•…Zh[V_jiVhWVhZVYVh Zb XjgkVhcV [dgbV YZh^cd%eVgVegZkZc^g' dj Vd bZcdh egZkZgZ XdcigdaVg' \gVcYZhX]dfjZh) 9 fjZYV cZb bZhbd [d^ jbV gZhedhiVVfjVafjZg cdi‚( X^VY^hXZgc‚kZa) 9 dXdg)g•cX^V Yd ZkZcid _Vo^V [dgVYZfjVafjZg Xd^hVfjZ hZ edYZg^ViZg ^bV\^cVYd cV k€heZgV( hZZj i^kZhhZ^cY^XVYdhjV edhh^W^a^( YVYZ'iZg^Vb bZ X]VbVYd YZajc|i^Xd) G ZkZcid fjVa^[^XVkV(hZ Xdbd jb ;^hcZ FZ\gd' bVh Zj V^cYVc~d Xdc]ZX^VVZmegZhh~d) FV HVg`9kZcjZ' YZeVgZ^Xdb jb XdaZ\V'
) Y i chV•…ZhYd >^ghi :dhidc) =j eVhhVgVd Y^Vcd Ze^XZcigd Ydh hVaV ZgV) d Zcidh Xdb eZhhdVhZb ZhiVYdYZX]dfjZ XdggZcYdYZjb aVYd igd Xdbd XdZa]dh Y^VciZYVajo YZ jb [Vgda)IjVcYd X]Z\jZA d dd] HVgVd dj j eg^bd 9aZm^hbZ iZaZ[dcdj eVgVYAoZgfjZ hZj Naob d Xd( Zb XVhV'bZ d s;#YadGejaVcYd Yd VcYVghjeZg^dg Vd hZj) FZb bZ hZciAZhigV( bZiZgV KMaA ' d ~d ZgVXdbd cd D‚WVcd'hƒ fjZ Xdb jbV YA[ZgZc•V5 iZcYd c]d) 9 hZchV• dd ) d YjVh Xd^hVh[^fjZA AbegZhhaGcVYdVd XdchiViVgfjZ egdWaZbVh NAhidVh # ) [^cVcXZ^gdhedYZb hZgbV^h YZhbdgVa^oVciZhYd fjZ V \qZggV $KAbeaZh( bZciZ Xdch^YZgZfjZ dh egdWaZbVh[^cVcXZ^gdhZ Vh]jbAa]V•…Zh fjZ dh VXdbeVc]Vb edYZb aZkVgVd hj^X‚Y^d'bVh V\jZggV c~d eVgZXZ[VoZgd qqq
'
d
bZhbd i~d Y^gZiVbZciZ%) =j iZb^V jbV k^iƒg^Ve^gg„c^XV5Zj [dgV k^c\VYd ^ciZaZXijVabZciZ' bVh iZb^V ZhiVgXZgidYZbV^hZ kZg d h^hiZbV YZhbdgdcVg hdWbZjh e€h) FV kZgYVYZ'c~d fjZg^V ZhiVgal\ XZgid)KZbegZ bZ aZbWgVgZ^Yd [VaZX^( Yd B^bbn H)' fjZ Vd kZg hZj eVig^b„c^d a‚fj^Yd Y^hhdakZg(hZ Y^VciZYdh egƒeg^dh da]dh ^beadgVkV bZ^d fjZ Wg^cXVcYdeVgVfjZ d egZ•d cV iZaV eVgVhhZYZbjYVg) EVh eZgXZW^ cVfjZaZ ^chiVciZ fjZ c~d YVkV^bedgi}cX^V Va\jbV Vd Y^c]Z^gd)L^kZVhZchV•~dbV^h ZhigVc]VYVb^c]V k^YV'Xdbd jbV igdb( WZiVZchjgYZXZYdgV^cY^XVcYdfjZ Rb R`aNcNPR_a\YZ[dgbV i~d ZchjgYZ( XZYdgV fjZ [Vo^VbZjh dhhdh k^WgVgZb)FjcXV bV^h hZci^ VbZhbV Xd^hVZ cjcXV hZgZ^XVeVoYZZmea^X|(AV VdhfjZ cjcXV VhZci^gVb) =gVjbV hZchV( •~d [‚h^XV'iVakZojbV b^hijgV YZVaZ\g^V'dg\ja]d Z iZggdg) = hZci^V(bZ k^c\VYd8 ;dbd8
eZXjaVi^kVh'c~d !hƒ eVed!' d fjZ ZgVgVgdcdh fjVcih' ed^h ZgVb ^beZY^Ydh YZ!XdggZgg^hXdh!'hZcYdhZj eVeZagZhig^id{ Vc|a^hZ'Z c~d { idbVYV YZYZX^( h…Zh) =j ZhiVkVXdckZcX^YdYZfjZ ZgVidiVabZciZ ^cXdbeZiZciZ eVgVegZkZg egZ•dh YZbZgXVYd( bVh fjZ dh djigdh iVbW€b ZgVb Zb \ZgVa^cXdbeZ( iZciZh' Z c~d hVW^VbY^hhd'dj c~d hVW^VbfjZ ZhiVkVbXdggZcYdg^hXdh\^( \VciZhXdh)9 bV^dg^VYdhdeZgVYdgZhZhiVkVVeZcVh!XViVcYdXZciVkdhY^VciZ YZjbV adXdbdi^kV!' ZmedcYd(hZVd ZkZcid gVgdYZVaid^beVXid Z' V^cYV Vhh^b' Ydgb^cYd Xdbd WZW•h' ^cXdchX^ZciZhYVh^ijV•~d) EZj ZbegZ\d ZgV d †c^Xd fjZ edYZg^V[VoZgjbV eZhhdVfjZ hZk^VXdbd Va\j€b fjZ dYZ^V g^hXdh'iZb XdchX^•cX^V Ydhg^hXdhZ € VaiVbZciZ^\cdgVciZ) 9a€b Y^hhd' V WV\V\Zb i€Xc^XVfjZ € eVgiZ YZ hZg jb fjVci $jbV XdbW^cV•~d YZbViZb|i^XV Vea^XVYV' Zc\Zc]Vg^V Z ZhiVi‚hi^XV%' VXgZhXZc( iVYV{ ^bZgh~d cV eg|i^XV' gZkZadj(hZ bj^id †i^a eVgVVa\j€b fjZ fjZ( g^VhZg[^aƒhd[d5 =b eg^bZ^gd aj\Vg' fjVcYd hZeVhhVjb eVg YZY€XVYVh [VoZcYd igVWVa]dhZbe‚g^Xdh Zb bVhhV Xdb YVYdhZ Vhhjb^cYd g^hXdh Xdb WVhZ cZhhZhZhijYdh' idgcV(hZ edhh‚kZaYZiZXiVg[VX^abZciZZaZbZcidh cV iZmijgV Yd bjcYd fjZ d !eZchVYdg! e^Vidc^[^XVYd€ XdcY^X^dcVYd dj VbZV•VYdYZbV^heVgVkZg)=b hZ\jcYd' d igVWVa]deZgb^i^j(bZ hZg [dgbVa Z h^hiZb|i^Xd Zb b^c]V [dgbV YZ eZchVg' Zb kZo YZ bZg\ja]Vg cd VcZYƒi^Xd)>^cVabZciZ' iVcid V [^adhd[^VYV]^hiƒg^V fjVcid V Ze^hiZ( bdad\^V $V[^adhd[^VYd Xdc]ZX^bZcid% eVgZX^Vb^chZeVg|kZ^hYd ZhijYd Zbe‚g^Xd YZYVYdh#YZh€g^ZhiZbedgV^h' fjZ € jbV hjXZhh~dYZc†bZgdh cd iZbed' jbV Zhe€X^ZYZ YdXjbZcid ]^hiƒg^Xd XdciZcYd c†bZgdh Zb kZo YZeVaVkgVh) = c†bZgdh h~d [|XZ^hYZhZgZb egdXZhhVYdhZb Xdbej( iVYdgZh)=hijYVg YVYdh]^hiƒg^Xdh [Vo Xdb fjZ hZ iZc]V XdchX^•cX^VYZ fjZ V]^hiƒg^VVcYVeVgVV[gZciZ' c~d eVgVig|h' Z fjZ € bV^h WV\jc•VYV ' =heZX^Va^oZ^(bZ Zb ^chigjbZcidh [^cVcXZ^gdhXdbeaZmdh X]VbVYdh !YZg^kVi^kdh!'VfjZaZh fjZ gZfjZgZb d jhd YZbViZb|i^XV VkVc•VYV( bVh eVgVdh fjV^h dh ZggdhYZhZ jhVg V bViZb|i^XV ZggVYV ZgVb dh bV^dgqh edhh‚kZ^h)G iZbV ZgVhj[^X^ZciZbZciZ cdkd Z VigVZciZ eVgVfjZ hZidgcVhhZd iZbV YVb^c]V iZhZYZYdjidgVYd) GWhZgkZfjZ c~d [j^ XVeVoYZXdchigj^g jbV XVggZ^gV hdbZciZ VedhiVcYdZb ;^hcZh FZ( \gdh ( c~d ]djkZ dedgijc^YVYZh cZ\dX^|kZ^h hj[^X^ZciZh)=j ejYZ' edg djigd aVYd'Zk^iVg hZgZmedhid VZaZhegdiZ\ZcYd b^c]V XVgiZ^gV YZi‚ijadh YZ\gVcYZheZgYVh)HdgiVcid' eVgV Za^b^cVgV YZeZcY•cX^VYZ VaZVidg^ZYVYZh' XdcXZcigZ^(bZ Zb ^cZ[^X^•cX^Vh i€Xc^XVhZcigZ ^chigjbZcidh XdbeaZmdh Z Zb ZmeadgVgiV^hdedgijc^YVYZh hZb Zmedh^•~dVd ZkZcid gVgd' VciZh fjZ ZaVhYZhVeVgZXZhhZb { bZY^YVfjZ bZjh XdcXdggZciZhhZidgcVhhZb iZXcdad\^( XVbZciZ VkVc•VYdh)EV^h iVgYZZb b^c]V XVggZ^gV YZhXdWg^ d gVbd bV^h [|X^a $ZbZcdh XVggZ\VYdYZVaZVidg^ZYVYZh% YZ egdiZ\Zg \gVcYZhXVgiZ^gVh YZi‚ijadh Yd ;^hcZ FZ\gd' cV [dgbV YZhZ\jgdh)
) ) aVidhcVggVYdh)9 Ze^hiZbdad\^V' V [^adhd[^VYV]^hiƒg^V Z V Y fjZ dq gZ )# d ! WjhXVb XdbegZZcYZg kZgYVYZh'^ckZhiA\VcYddh bZXVbhbdh iaXV ZhiViaK ) #Y7 ) Zb fjZh i(dZh Z hZeVgVcYdV gZ\jaVg^YVYZYV Xdb;A Zc;aV jZ Vh\ZgVb (# f) ) L YVhZhhVhY^hX^ea^cVh a^YVbXdb VfjZhiVd Yd fjZ hZhVWZ'hd ]AhizgAXVh)d ) ) U XdcigVYVhZb eg€Y^dh Y^[ZgZciZh'edg VKKAb YAoZg) fjZ hVdZc
'
?3;3EAI> 63 :=67?7=6K=5:3
#iZZb ,4 YZdjijWgd YZ ,432' Ydgb^ ^c^ciZggjeiVbZciZ edg FVfjZ AV cGA ' ,- ]dgVh) =gV Y^[‚X^a[VaVgXdb dh Vb^\dh hdWgZVfjZaV hZchV•~d YZ ZhiVgk^c( d^hidYdh hd[gZgVb YZ Va\jbV [dgbV Xdb V fjZWgV YV:dahV YZ \VYd' H ) U U( NVadgZh)FVfjZaV €edXV' VhWdb[^XV•dZhZgVb jbV [gV•Vd Yd fjZ hVd ]d_Z Zb Y^V'bVh hZbZj ZbegZ\VYdg' d >^ghi :dhqdc' Z d )h^hiZbV[^cVc( XZ^gdhdWgZk^kZhhZbVi€ d [^cVaYd Vcd' Zj gZXZWZcV d ZfMakVaZciZVjbV WdahVYZ ZhijYdh) vh kZoZh' ^hhd € X]VbVYd YZ !Y^c]Z^gd Yd [!#(hZ!' d fjZ' VeZhVgYV\gdhhZg^VYd iZgbd' h^\c^[^XVfjZ V fjVci^V eZgb^iZ fjq kdX• hZXdbedgiZ Xdbd jb XVkVa]Z^gdk^idg^Vcd' a^kgZYVZhXgVk^Y~d) = jbV egdiZ•~d eh^Xdaƒ\^XV5d Y^c]Z^gd c~d € iVcid V edcid YZ idgc|(Ad edYgZ YZg^Xd'bVh € hj[^X^ZciZeVgVfjZ hZiZc]V Va^WZgYVYZ YZZhXda]Zg jbV cdkV egd[^hh~d hZb egZX^hVgVkVa^Vg ZmXZhh^kVbZciZVhgZXdbeZc( hVh[^cVcXZ^gVh) =aZ egdiZ\Z kdX• YZ egdhi^ij^g hjV bZciZ Z a^WZgiV(dYV Vjidg^YVYZZmiZgcV( fjVafjZg Vjidg^YVYZZmiZgcV)$9 ^cYZeZcY•cX^V€ ZheZX‚[^XV eVgVXVYV eZhhdV5hZbegZ [^fjZ^ ^begZhh^dcVYd Xdb d \gVcYZ c†bZgd YZ eZhhdVhV fjZb jbV gZcYV^cXg^kZabZciZ VaiVaZkdj V jb XdbedgiVbZcid V^cYVbV^h hZgk^aZ VYjaVYdg{ bZY^YVfjZ hZ idgcVkV bV^h YZeZcYZciZ Ydh Xa^ZciZhZ ZbegZ\VYdgZh' Z bV^h k^X^VYdZb [VoZg V^cYVbV^h Y^c]Z^gd)%9eZhVg YZedjXd hjWhiVcX^Va eVgVVa\jch eVYg…Zh' d Y^c]Z^gd Xjgdj(bZ a^iZgVabZciZYZidYV VbW^•~d [^cVcXZ^gV ( ZaZ[Zo Xdb fjZ Zj hZci^hhZkZg\dc]V hZbegZ fjZ bZ YZhk^VkV Ydh ZhijYdh Zb WjhXVYZg^fjZoV bViZg^Va)FdiZ fjZ VYZh^\cV•~d S%!'`R gZ[ZgZ(hZ{ XVeV( X^YVYZ Zhi^bjaVciZ YZegdcjcX^Vg ZhhV[gVhZXdbeVXiV VciZh YZYZha^\Vg d iZaZ[dcZ) 9fjZaV ZgVV €edXV Zb fjZ ZgVZmigZbVbZciZ Xdbjb eVgVdeZgV( YdgZhfjZWgVgiZaZ[dcZh fjVcYd eZgY^Vb Y^c]Z^gd) 9a\jch gZXdgg^VbV fjZWgVgXVYZ^gVh' bZhVh dj fjVafjZg Xd^hVfjZ [^oZhhZWVgja]d) ;ZgiV kZo' cd egZ\~d YZ;]^XV\d' jb deZgVYdgiZcidj bZ ZhigVc\jaVg Z [dgVb cZ(
XZhh|g^dh fjVigd hZ\jgVc•VheVgVAZk|(AdZbWdgV'=aZZhiVkV ^gVYdedg Zj ZhiVgcd fjZ ZaZXdch^YZgVkV hZj !iZgg^iƒg^d!)IjZb \dhiVg^VYZVWVcYd( cVgiVaVbW^ZciZ8;dbeVgZ(d Xdb Vabd•dh cd gZ[Z^iƒg^d hZb \gV•VYZ jbV jc^kZgh^YVYZ Xdb egd[ZhhdgZhZYjXVYdhY^hXji^cYdVbV^h gZXZc( iZ ^cig^\VYZeVgiVbZciVa) 9hh^b' eZgbVcZX^cd gVbd fjVci^iVi^kd Z YVh deZgV•…Zh [^cVcXZ^gVh $V^cYV Zhidj a|%'bVh dg\Vc^oZ^(bZeVgV[VoZgedj( fj‚hh^bd igVWVa]d' edg€b ^ciZchd $ZY^kZgi^Yd%' XdcXZcigVg(bZhdbZciZ cdh VheZXidh bV^hi€Xc^Xdh'cjcXV eVgi^X^eVg YZ!gZjc^…Zh!YZcZ\ƒX^dh' Zk^iVgVXdbeVc]^V YZ!gZVa^oVYdgZh! Z YZeZhhdVhfjZ jhVb iZgcd Zc~d a•Zb a^kgdhZi^gVgjb Vcd hVW|i^Xd VXVYV ig•h' Zb b€Y^V'eVgVegZZcX]Zg aVXjcVhcV b^c]V XjaijgV[^adhƒ[^XV Z X^Zci‚[^XV) HVgVYZhi^aVg aZciVbZciZ b^c]V †c^XV^Y€^V' Zj fjZg^VhZgjb SYj[Rb_&jb bZY^iVYdg egd[^hh^dcVa' hZciVg(bZZb XV[€h'eVhhVgd iZbed hZb [VoZgcVYV'YZha^\VYd YZZhXg^( kVc^c]VhZ YZZhigjijgVhYZdg\Vc^oV•…Zh' Ydgb^g d fjVcid egZX^hVg' aZg kdgVobZciZ Z c~d YZkZgZmea^XV•~d cZc]jbV Vc^c\j€b) =j fjZg^VhZg YZ^mVYd Zb eVoeVgVXdchigj^g'VeZfjZcdh eVhhdh'jb h^hiZbVYZeZchV( bZcid WVhZVYd cVb^c]V ^Y€^V Yd ;^hcZ FZ\gd)
9 \jZggV cd D‚WVc•7 Z VfjZWgVYV:dahV YZ,432 eVgZX^Vb[Zc„bZcdh ^Y•ci^Xdh)>^XdjƒWk^deVgVb^b fjZ fjVhZ idYdhi^c]Vb jb edcid XZ\d bZciVa fjZ dh ^beZY^VYZgZXdc]ZXZg d eVeZaYZiV^hZkZcidh5ZgVXdbd hZ c~d [dhhZb XVeVoZh YZkZgZhhZh bVhidYdciZhdj Xdbd hZZhfjZXZb YZaZh gVe^YVbZciZ) 9 gZhedhiVZhiVkVYZWV^md Yd bZj cVg^o5ZgVbZN(PRTbRV_N eh^Xdaƒ\^XV' iVakZoVi€bZhbd W^daƒ\^XV) ? egdWaZbVc~d ZhiVkV cVcVij( gZoVYdhZkZcidhZh^b cVbVcZ^gVfjZ dh eZgXZW‚Vbdh) ;dcXajd ZhiZegZa†Y^d VjidW^d\g|[^Xd Xdb V]^hiƒg^VVhZ\j^g'=j c~d i^( c]V jbV ZheZX^Va^YVYZ YZ[^c^YV $[dgVYdbZj igVWVa]d Xdbjb%' Zc~d YZhZ( _VkV cZc]jbV) IjVcYd' Zb XdfjZi€^h'eZg\jciVkVb(bZ d fjZ [Vo^V eVgV \Vc]VgVk^YV'Zj [^XVkV iZciVYdVgZhedcYZg!Kdj jb RZ]V_V`aNPnaVP\Zjb YRVa\_'SYj[Rb_& Va\j€b XdbegdbZi^Yd V ZmeadgVg bj^id egd[jcYVbZciZ jbV ^Y€^V!' bVh idgcVkVVhXd^hVh bV^hh^beaZhY^oZcYdfjZ ZgVbdidg^hiV YZa^bjh^cZ) ;ZgiV kZo' Zb jb k„d igVchVia}ci^Xd' gZXZW^ jb b]T_NQReVgVVeg^( bZ^gVXaVhhZ' dcYZbZ hZciZ^VdaVYdYZjbV hZc]dgVedYZgdh{'fjZ kZhi^V gdjeVh XVgVh' ZhiVkVXdWZgiV YZdjgd Z_ƒ^Vh'Xdb^VXVhiVc]Vh Xdci^cjV(
) Z $iYkZoZhi^kZhhZ [VoZcYdjbV Y^ZiVYZedjXdh XVgWd^YgVidh% Z^c( bZci ' , = # A# Y#( ) # b WZWZg hdbZciZ |\jV bbZgV NaVc'ZcfjVcid AVVZ a•VdZjgd( KaKiaV Z [^ Y #' ' ! Yd KNYYGa_RRa >\b_[NY(=aV a;VkViZciVc d ba;AVgjbV XdckZghV Zb eZaV ' A# A# $ [g 9%Y ##, bZ [gVcX•hgj^b' ed^h qj fjZ Zj aqjq akgG Zb VcXZh d KG;AG (& " *5+H^ZggZ :djgYaZj ( \d( NQ GK+,
fjZ' agdbXVbZciZ'igViVkV YVhbVgXVhYZ ' i^c ~d hdX^Va) Ac[dgbZ^(a]Z$Zb b\aZh%fjZ ZgVbdidchiV YZ]bjhbZ' YaK !YZViahhabd )! ")! ) Mb 'aaaKaK ' i#b• Yd#dg\ja]dhVbZciZ fjZ hd' Y#' b\aV' XVggdh bkZ #A9 egZkVaZXZj YjgVciZidYd d k„d ( Z VeZhVg YZXdchZ\j^g KA Zc;a#d\Z#A^Yd hZci^gViZch~d' ejYZ aZgZb eVo) )
%
3
!
%
O -3;6/
6/1:7
./
>/>1/63+
T>OFIM>IL$?@$LIM@MMI $ 5VTV 9@PB@HD< ?@DQ< LM>
@| X^cXdVcdh' Qi56k\Zc^V F^`daVnZkcVCgVhcdkVZgVjbV gdbVcX^hiV dWhXjgV Z V^cYV c~d(ejWa^XVYV' Xdb jb eVhhVYd ^cXdbjb) =aVZgVjbV cZjgdX^Zci^hiV ^ciZgZhhVYV Zb [^adhd[^V $hZjhig•heg^bZ^gdhbVg^YdhZgVb [^aƒhd[dh% ZXdadXdjZb hjV iZ^bdhVXVWZ•V [gVcXd(gjhhV fjZ ZmegZhhVg^V hjVheZhfj^hVhZ ^Y€^Vh Zb [dgbVid a^iZg|g^d)9YdgcVkVVhiZdg^VhXdbd ]^hiƒg^VhZ Vhb^hijgVkVXdb idYVhdgiZYZXdbZci|g^dh VjidW^d\g|[^Xdh) =aVZk^iVkV VhegZkVg^XV•…Zh _dgcVa‚hi^XVh YVc~d([^X•~dcVggVi^kV XdciZb( edg}cZV$!=b jbV bVc]~ XaVgV YZVWg^a' Bd]c Kb^i] YZ^mdjhjVXVhV )))!%) <^|ad\dh Zb a‚c\jVh ZhigVc\q^gVh ZgVbhZbegZ ZhXg^idh cd ^Y^dbVdg^\^( cVa'Xdb igVYj•…Zh ^chZg^YVh Xdbd aZ\ZcYVhYZ[^abZh)QZk\Zc^VgZXjhV( kV(hZVigVYjo^geVgVjb ^c\a•h gj^b XdckZghVh fjZ i^c]Vb VXdciZX^Yd Zb jb ^iVa^Vcd gj^b)# FZc]jb ZY^idgYVg^V ViZc•~d V ZaV'hƒ fjZ' cVfjZaZ bdbZcid' ]V( k^VVa\jb ^ciZgZhhZ cdh gVgdhX^Zci^hiVh fjZ XdchZ\j^Vb hZZmegZhhVg Zb [gVhZh hZb^XdbegZZch‚kZ^h) 9a\jch ZY^idgZh XdcXdgYVgVb Zb XdckZghVg
) Ba, QZk\Zc^V6 ZheZgVqVbfjZ ZaVVbqqjqZqZhhZZ k^ZhhZV5hXgZkZq jb qq dejaVgYZX^•cXAV hdWgZ VXdcK;AZc;aV ) =aViZkZViZc•Vdhj[^;AZciZ ]kgd HXZWZg YZXVgiVh Y# ' ( ZXdbZciVcdh *# GaZcKANGK D( ! VXdgiZh^V ZgZ%ZA•VG dXV( VgV g Z )# , Y ') #A9# H' # b kZoYd V^cYV bVAKbhj iVciZZ ZegZ;aViAkd KA ZcXaG) KaGcVAh Z ' =Y^idgZh [^XVkVbXdq[jhdh Xdb d bVcjhXci'd) =a5cZb qZhbd Xdchq( ' edcYZg{ eg^bZAgV eZg\jciV fjZ a]Z [VRAVb5e jb aAkgdYZ[^X•Vd \MaVgZh '!' GMc}d([^X#•}d8!LVbedjXd XdchZ\MAV gZhedcqZgV5 HVgVqjZb d ,)Akgd NQ^ ZhXg^id!'cdh [dgbja|g^dh YZegdedhiV YZaAkgdeVgVZYAidgZh)
YZiZgb^cVYV' Zh[dg•VYV Z YZjbV ^cYZeZcY•cX^V [Zgdo!)Hd^hd a^kgdeZ( \dj [d\d aZciVbZciZ'id#gcVcYd(hZ jb Ydh\gVcYZhZZhigVc]dhhjXZhhdhYV ]^hiƒg^VYVa^iZgVijgV' kZcYZcYdb^a]…ZhYZXƒe^VhZ Xdcfj^hiVcYdd fjZ hZX]VbVYZVXaVbV•~d Xg‚i^XV)
(@n[\S? DYmZ
6I=L@< ?DA@L@HX< >LZND>< @HNL@ @MJ@>OF
Z ,DMH@M 3@BLIM$
7@ILD< ?I >IHC@>DG@HNI Z L@H?
NL@GDMNWI HWI € d G@FCILFOB
hZPDMDN@NI% N
P@H>@?IL
9 VhXZch~d YZQZk\Zc^VYdhedg…ZhVd hjeZgZhigZaVid € edhh‚kZaZb jb †c^XdVbW^ZciZ'fjZ X]Vbd YZ=migZb^hi~d)& =b WgZkZ'VegZhZciVgZ^ V Y^hi^c•~dXZcigVa ZcigZVegdk‚cX^V\ZgVYdgV YZ;^hcZh FZ\gdh Yd =migZ( b^hi~d Z Vegdk‚cX^VXdbedgiVYV'igVcf‡^aVZ hZb hjgegZhVhYd EZY^d( Xg^hi~d)
'
5/427:
"837:# -76;/427
IjVcYd gZk^hdZb b^c]V bZciZ idYdhdh !XdchZa]dh!fjZ bZ YZgVb'kZ_d bR hdbZciZ jb eVgYZ^Y€^Vh [^XdjXdb^\d eVgVidYVVk^YV)G gZhiVciZ GgVbbZgVheVaVkgVh' Z[^Xd[Za^oYZc~d iZgYVYdViZc•~dg bV^dg^V):dV eVgiZYZaZh Xdch^hi^V Zb gZXdbZcYV•…Zh Xdbd !KZ_V Zfj^a^WgVYd ZgVod|(
D
(((
9dh aZ^idg ) ) ; € ) ZhfjZ egdXjgVgVb edg QZk\ZbV CgVhcdkVcd ?dd\aZ' aVbZcid Y^oZgfjZ Z V $d [^A;aVabZi % ) ) c Z jbV eZghdcV\Zb [^XiaXaV)
kZaZb hjVhYZXaVgV•…Zh!' XdcigVY^oZcYd V^Y€^V Yd ;^hcZ FZ\gd' jbV kZo fjZ VgZVa^YVYZ Zbe‚g^XVc~d € !Zfj^a^WgVYV! ZhjV egƒeg^VkZgh~dYZ!gV( odVW^a^YVYZ! c~d XdggZhedcYZ { YZ[^c^•~dXdckZcX^dcVa) KZg\Zcj^cVbZc( iZ Zbe‚g^Xd€ gZ[aZi^g VgZVa^YVYZ d bV^h[^ZabZciZedhh‚kZa6hZg]dcgVYd ^bea^XVZb c~d iZbZg VVeVg•cX^V ZVhXdchZf‡•cX^Vh YZhZgZhigVc]d)FV egƒm^bVkZofjZ jbV eZhhdV^cXdbdYVgkdX•Xdb XdchZa]dhYZhcZXZhh|( g^dh'aZbWgZVZaVXdb \qci^aZoVYd YZhi^cdYd bdc\Z fjZ AkVc'd LZgg‚( kZa'bVcYdj bViVgedg iZgYVYdXdchZa]dh^cYZhZ_|kZ^h $ZbdgVa^oVYdgZh%) Ahhd[jcX^dcVXdbd jbV XjgVYZXjgid egVod) =b gZigdheZXid'd XdchZa]dbV^h ^bedgiVciZ [d^ gj^b' bVh iVbW€b [d^' eVgVYdmVabZciZ' d bV^hXdchZf‡ZciZ'ed^hbZ [ZoZmeadgVg Xdb bV^h egd[jcY^YVYZ VY^c}b^XVYd ;^hcZ FZ\gd) =aZ[d^YVYdVb^b fjVcYd Zj i^c]V -- Vcdh'Zb jbV iVgYZYZ[ZkZgZ^gd' cd XdggZYdg Yd ZY^[‚X^d YZc†( bZgd .)/++ YVOVacji KigZZi'cV>^aVY€a[^V' dcYZZj k^k^V) Mb ZhijYVciZcd hZ\jcYd Vcd YVO]Vgidc Y^hhZ(bZfjZ Zj YZkZg^V ZhXda]Zg jbV egd[^hh~d fjZ [dhhZ!ZhXVa|kZa!' dj hZ_V'jbV egd[^hh~dcV fjVa c~d hZ€ eV\d edg ]dgV Z' edgiVcid' c~d hZZhi| hj_Z^id{ha^b^iV•…Zh Yd kdajbZ YZigVWVa]d) =gVjbV bVcZ^gVbj^id h^beaZhYZY^[ZgZcX^Vg egd[^hh…Zh Z' VeVgi^gYV‚' \ZcZgVa^oVg jbV hZeVgV•~d ZcigZi^edhYZ^cXZgiZoV (aZkVcYd(bZ Vd\gVc( YZegdWaZbV[^adhƒ[^Xd' d egdWaZbVYV^cYj•~d' fjZ € d cdbZ i€Xc^XdYd ;^hcZ FZ\gd) G XdchZa]deZgb^i^j(bZ igVch[dgbVgd ;^hcZ FZ\gd YZjb ^beVhhZaƒ\^XdZb jbV hdaj•~d YZ[|X^a^beaZbZciV•~d' Va€bYZ'Xdbd kZ( gZbdh cdh egƒm^bdhXVe‚ijadh'WVhZ|(Ad cViZmijgVYVgZVa^YVYZ Zbe‚g^XV) ;dbd jb XdchZa]deVgVb^c]V XVggZ^gV XdcYjo^j(bZ ViV^h^Y€^Vh hd( WgZVcVijgZoVYV^cXZgiZoV8 9a\jbVh egd[^hh…Zh' Xdbd YZci^hiVh' Xdchja( idgZhdj bVhhV\^hiVh egd[^hh^dcV^h' c~d h~dZhXVa|kZ^h5 Zm^hiZ jb a^b^iZVd c†bZgd YZeVX^ZciZh dj Xa^ZciZh fjZ hZedYZViZcYZg Zb jb YVYdeZg‚dYd YZiZbed) KZkdX•€ jbV egdhi^ijiV'kdX•igVWVa]V edg ]dgVZ$\ZgVabZciZ% gZXZWZ edg ]dgV)9a€b Y^hhd'ha5aV egZhZc•V$VXgZY^id% € cZXZhh|g^V eVgVd hZgk^•degZhiVYdedg kdX•)KZVWg^g jb gZhiVjgVciZ[^cd' kdX•' cV bZa]dg YVh]^eƒiZhZh'iZg| VXVhV hZbegZX]Z^V$Vc~d hZgfjZ VWgV [gVcfj^Vh%) FZh( hVhegd[^hh…Zh' c~d ^bedgiV d fjVcid VgZbjcZgV•~d hZ_V VaiV'VgZcYVZhi| hj_Z^iV{ \gVk^YVYZ) G [VijgVbZcid YZeZcYZbV^hYZZh[dg•dhXdci‚cjdh Yd fjZ YVfjVa^YVYZ YVhYZX^h…Zh) 9a€b Yd bV^h' € jb i^ed YZigVWVa]d VaiVbZciZegZk^h‚kZa5 ZaZhd[gZg|kVg^V•…Zh' bVh c~d Vedcid YZidgcVgV gZcYVYZjb †c^XdY^VbV^hh^\c^[^XVi^kV Yd fjZ VYd gZhidYZ# hjV k^YV) =b djigVheVaVkgVh' ZaZc~d hZg|bdk^Yd edg ;^hcZhFZ\gdh) QZk\Zc^VF^(
(, ZkcVc~d iZg^Vh^YdXVeVoYZVigVkZhhVg d VW^hbdZcigZZmXaj‚YV Z `d Vn' VhjegZbV YVcd^iZeVgVd Y^VhZadhhZ X Y #Va# XdciV dgVdj ZheZ;a AhiV Zb ]ZgGac ) ) ' ]€gc^Vh$bVhiVbW€b c~d qZcVhAYdjbq ZmXaMaYV%)' U GjigVhegd[^hh…Zh eZgbAiZb fjZ kdXZVXgZhXZciZ oZgdhVhjV egdYj•Vd $Z{ hjV gZcYV%' XVhdhZ_VXdbeZiZcqZ' Xdb edjXd dq cZc]jb Zq[dg•d ZmigV) 9\dgV' hZcYdegZ\j^•dhd' XdchAYZgVcYd VegZ\Ma•VjbV fjVa^YVYZ' Z Vch^dhdedg a^WZgVg d b|m^bd edhh‚kZaYd bZj Y^VeVgVbZY^iVgZ aZg' X]Z\jZ^^bZY^ViV $bVhZggdcZVbZciZ% VjbV XdcXajh~d)KZeVgZ^ VeZhhdV YZ!^Y€^Vh!'fjZ kZcYZjb egdYjid ^ciZaZXijVa Zb [dgbV YZjbV igVchV( •~d dj jb igVWVa]d' YVeZhhdVYZ!igVWVa]d!'fjZ a]ZkZcYZd igVWVa]d) KZkdX•€ jbV eZhhdVYZ^Y€^Vh' c~d € cZXZhh|g^d igVWVa]Vg bj^id' VeZ( cVheZchVg^ciZch^kVbZciZ)NdX• [Vod bZhbd igVWVa]d egdYjo^cYd XZb dj b^a jc^YVYZh)FVh igVchV•…Zh YZfjVcih' d bZhbd kdajbZ YZigVWV( a]d € gZVa^oVYd iVcid cV XdbegV YZXZb XdiVhfjVcid cV YZ,++ b^a' dj bZhbd , b^a]~d YZXdiVh)e d bZhbd iZaZ[dcZbV'VbZhbV XdbejiV( •~d' d bZhbd YdXjbZcid aZ\Va'd bZhbd \Vhid YZcZjg}c^dh' d bZhbd ZbeZc]d Zb kZg^[^XVg hZVigVchV•~dZhi| XdggZiV) 9a€b Yd bV^h' kdX• edYZigVWVa]Vg Zb hjV WVc]Z^gV dj Zb jb WVgZb JdbV) HdYZjhVghjV ^c[aj•cX^VXdbd hjWhi^ijiVeVgVd igVWVa]d:Zb' YZkdVYb^i^gfjZ ZhiVkV jb edjXd ZggVYdhdWgZd igVWVa]d YZdeZgVYdg5 kdX• c~d edYZ [Vo•(Ad cVWVc]Z^gV' bVh' fjVcYd € [Z^idYVbVcZ^gVXZgiV' egdedgX^dcVWVhiVciZ iZbed a^kgZ) 9 bZhbV egdeg^ZYVYZ Vea^XV (hZVVgi^hiVh YdgVbd [dcd\g|[^Xd dj Vid( gZhYZX^cZbV5kdX• YZ^mV fjZ dh Zc\Zc]Z^gdhYZhdb Zdh egd_ZX^dc^hiVh [V•Vb d igVWVa]d6 c~d € cZXZhh|g^dZhiVgegZhZciZZb idYVhVhVegZhZc( iV•…Zh eVgVYZhZbeZc]VghZj eVeZa)K^b^aVgbZciZ'jbV ZhXg^idgV [Vod bZhbd Zh[dg•deVgVVigV^g jb †c^XdaZ^idgdj eVgVXVeijgVgXZciZcVhYZ b^a]…ZhYZaZ^idgZh) B)C) Jdla^c\' VjidgVYdha^kgdhYZ@VggnHdiiZg'c~d egZX^hV ZhXgZkZg cdkVbZciZ XVYV a^kgdhZbegZ fjZ Va\j€b YZhZ_V a•(Ad) EVh d bZhbd c~d kVaZeVgVjb eVYZ^gd5 ZaZegZX^hV VhhVg XVYV e~d eVgV hVi^h[VoZg XVYV Xa^ZciZ VY^X^dcVa) 9hh^b' V Y^hi^c•~dZcigZ ZhXg^idg Z eVYZ^gd'ZheZXjaVYdg Z b€Y^Xd' [gVjYVYdg Z egdhi^ijiV' € jbV bVcZ^gV†i^aYZhZdWhZgkVg d bjcYd YVh Vi^k^YVYZh) =aVhZeVgV Vhegd[^hh…Zh Zb fjZ € edhh‚kZaVXgZhXZciVg oZgdh{ KMV gZcYV'hZb cZc]jb igVWVa]d VbV^h'YVhegd[^hh…Zh Zb fjZ € cZXZhh|( g^dVXgZhXZciVg igVWVa]d ZiZbed $YjVhXd^hVh Xj_Vhd[ZgiVhh~da^b^iVYVh% ( Zb djigVheVaVkgVh' Vhegd[^hh…Zh hj_Z^iVh { \gVk^YVYZ)
EVh edg fjZ d XdchZa]d YZbZj XdaZ\VZhijYVciZ [d^ gj^b8 KZd XdchZa]d $d^ †i^a' Z gZVabZciZ d [d^' cV Xg^V•~dYZ jbV XaVhh^[^( XV•~deVgVdgYZcVg^cXZgiZoVZ Xdc]ZX^bZcid' iVbW€b [d^ jb Zggd cd fjZ Y^ogZheZ^id{h ZhXda]VhYZegd[^hh…Zh) =aZedYZ iZg XdbeZchVYd eVgV b^b' bVh hdbZciZ edgfjZ i^kZ hdgiZ Z ZhiVkV!Fd aj\Vg XZgid' cV ]dgV XZgiV!'Xdbd Y^od Y^iVYd)KZZj [dhhZYVgjb XdchZa]d' gZXdbZcYVg^VV Va\j€b fjZ ZhXda]ZhhZjbV egd[^hh~d fjZ HWI [dhhZZhXVa|kZaHgd[^hh…Zh ZhXVa|kZ^h hƒ h~d WdVhhZkdX• [dg WZb(hjXZY^Yd6h~d bV^h XdbeZi^i^kVh' egdYjoZb Y^[ZgZc•VhbdchigjdhVh Z h~d bj^id bV^h VaZViƒg^Vh' Xdb Y^h( eVg^YVYZh ^bZchVh ZcigZ Zh[dg•dh Z gZXdbeZchVh ( edjXdh edYZb [^XVg Xdb jbV \gVcYZ [Vi^VYd Wdad' YZ^mVcYddjigdh ^ciZ^gVbZciZ YZ [dgV' hZb hZgZb gZhedch|kZ^h edg ^hhd) MbV XViZ\dg^VYZegd[^hh…Zh € bdk^YV eZaVbZY^dXg^YVYZ' d b€Y^d Zd Xdbjb) FZaV' d bZY‚dXgZ€ XdaZi^kVbZciZXdchZf‡ZcX^Va)9 djigV edhhj^ dj \^\VciZh dj Vc…Zh( bV^h ZmViVbZciZ'jb c†bZgd bj^id eZfjZcd YZ \^\VciZh Z jb c†bZgd ZcdgbZ YZVc…Zh) NZ_Vbdh Zci~d d fjZ Zhi| edg ig|h YV[dgbV•~d YZ\^\VciZh ^cZheZgV( Ydh ( V[dgbV•~d Yd ;^hcZ FZ\gd)
;dch^YZgZ d YZhi^cdYZ?^VXXdbd' jb XVcidgYZƒeZgV Yd [^cVaYd h€Xjad PAP' VciZhYV^ckZc•~d Ydh \gVkVYdgZhYZhdb) <^\Vbdh fjZ hZVegZhZc( iZ Zb jbV X^YVYZ eZfjZcV Z gZbdiV cV Ai|a^VXZcigVa)=aZ Zhi| egdiZ\^Yd YVfjZaZh Z\dh \gVcYZh Yd DVKXVaV YZ E^a~d Z YZ djigVh XVhVhYZ ƒeZ( gV^bedgiVciZh) KZciZ(hZhZ\jgd' ed^h hZbegZ ]VkZg| YZbVcYV edg hjVh XdgYVhkdXV^hZb Va\jb aj\Vg Yd Y^hig^id)F~d iZb Xdbd ZmedgiVghZj XVcid' Z dh [^\jg…ZhiVbW€b c~d i•b Xdbd ZmedgiVgdh YZaZhZ VbZV•Vg hjV [gVcfj^V adXVa)9^cYV c~d € edhh‚kZaeVgV?^VXXdbd \gVkVghZj igVWV( a]d' YZ[dgbV fjZ hjV egZhZc•V € cZXZhh|g^VZb idYVh VhVegZhZciV•…Zh' Vhh^b Xdbd jb WVgWZ^gd $V^cYV% € cZXZhh|g^d]d_Z eVgVidYdh dh XdgiZh YZXVWZad) 9hh^b' d bdciVciZ \ZgVa€ Y^k^Y^YdYZbdYd YZh^\jVa'bVh Zb \gVj bdYZgVYd' Vhh^bXdbd hjV ^c\Zhi~d YZXVadg^Vh) =aZ€ Y^k^Y^YdZb Va( \jbVh eVgiZh Z idYdh gZXZWZbjb edjXd6 dh [^\jg…Zh i•b jb e†Wa^Xd bV^dg Z gZXZWZbbV^h Xdck^iZh fjZ d XVgVeZfjZcd' bVh ^hhdc~d € i~d
( iZ
^c_jhid cV Y^hhZb^cV•~dYZa^kgdh8G Va[VWZid eZgb^i^j fjZ ]^hiƒg^VhZ ^Y€^Vh [dhhZb gZea^XVYVh Xdb VaiV[^YZa^YVYZ ZhZb a^b^iZh'hZb fjVafjZg YZh\VhiZ ZmigV YZZcZg\^Vedg eVgiZYdVjidg eVgVVhVijV•…Zh edhiZg^dgZh) =aZcZb egZX^hVkV ZhiVgk^kd eVgV^hhd( Xdb [gZf‡•cX^V'VbdgiZ € jb Wdb eVhhdcV XVggZ^gV YZjb ZhXg^idg) Ahhd^bea^XVfjZ VfjZaZhfjZ edg Va\jb bdi^kd XdbZXZbVgZXZWZg Va\jbV ViZc•~dedhhVb VaXVc•Vg gVe^( YVbZciZbV^hbZciZh fjZ djigdh Z gZbdkZg dh XdcXdggZciZh YVhegViZ( aZ^gVh) Fd iZbed YdhWVgYdh ZigdkVYdgZh' idYdhi^c]Vb jbV eaVi€^V) Mb XdciVYdgYZ]^hiƒg^Vh'Xdbd jb eVYZ^gddj jb igVWVa]VYdg Zb XdWgZ' i^c]V jb bZgXVYdZ V\VgVci^VYZfjZ c^c\j€b YZadc\Z edYZg^VYZhV( ad_|(AdYZhZj iZgg^iƒg^d) @d_Z'Va\jch edjXdh idbVb fjVhZ ijYd6 d gZhid [^XV Xdb fjVhZ cVYV) 9igVk€hYdbZhbd bZXVc^hbd' d VYkZcidYdX^cZbVYZhadXdjdh Vid( gZhadXV^h' ZmXaj^cYd dh eZfjZcdh cdbZh Yd gVbd) EVh ]| jbV Y^[ZgZc( •V)=b eg|i^XVhfjZ Zm^\Zbjb XdbedcZciZ i€Xc^Xd'Xdbd hZge^Vc^hiV dj cZjgdX^gjg\^~d' € [|X^aXdc[^gbVg? iVaZcid'Xdb Vde^c^~d hjW_Zi^kV YZhZbeZc]VcYdjb eVeZagZaVi^kVbZciZ eZfjZcd) 9 YZh^\jVaYVYZ hjg\Z fjVcYd Va\j€b k^hidXdbd bVg\^cVabZciZ bZa]dg aZkVd WdadidYd) FVh VgiZh( edg ZmZbead' cd X^cZbV( VhXd^hVh h~d bj^id bV^h eZgkZghVh) G fjZ X]VbVbdh YZriVaZcid! XdhijbV k^gYd hjXZhhd'c~d d Xdcig|g^d)Ej^id ZbJ^g^hbd [d^ Vea^XVYd VdVhhjcid' bV^hcdiVkZabZc( iZ edg 9gi
fqZhi~d YdXdc]ZX^bZcid' YVhYZYj•…Zh hdWgZ d YZhXdc]ZX^Yd ZYVhegd( eg^ZYVYZh Yd Xdc]ZX^Yd) /;-+4+,34L.+./
/ 147,+4LA+\[7
KZbegZ fjZ djk^bdh jb ZjgdeZj b€Y^d Vggd\VciZ$Z[gjhigVYd%Zm( edcYd hZjK ZhiZgZƒi^edhYZ VbZg^XVcdh'ZaZXdb [gZf‡•cX^Vdh YZh( XgZkZg|Xdbd r^cXjaidh!' rc~d(^ciZaZXijV^h!Z rgj^ch Zb bViZb|i^XV! edgfjZ' Y^[ZgZciZbZciZYdh XdaZ\VhZjgdeZjh' dh VbZg^XVcdhc~d hZ ^ciZgZhhVbedg igZ^cdhYZhdaj•~d YZZfjV•…ZhcZb eZaVhXdchigj•…Zh X]VbVYVhYZrVaiVXjaijgV! eZaVheZhhdVhYZXjaijgV bZY^VcV( Xdbd Xdc]ZX^bZcid YVk^V\Zb ^che^gVYdgV $ZZmigZbVbZciZ^bedgiVciZ%YZ ?dZi]Z { Ai|a^V'dj [Vb^a^Vg^YVYZ Xdb VZhXdaV
fjVcid eVgVVhdgiZ( bVh YZ^mVgZ^ VY^hXjhh~dhdX^dZXdc„b^XV eVgVV HVgiZLg•h Z ^gZ^bZ XdcXZcigVg'edg ]dgV' cd Xdc]ZX^bZcid)
=hhVY^hi^c•~dZcigZd ZhXVa|kZa Z d c~d(ZhXVa|kZa eZgb^iZ fjZ [V•Vbdh jbV Y^[ZgZcX^V•~d XaVgV ZcigZYjVhkVg^ZYVYZh YZ^cXZgiZoVh' Yd^hi^edh YZVaZVidg^ZYVYZh) :g^cfjZbdh Xdb d hZ\j^ciZ ZmeZg^bZcidbZciVa5hjedc]V fjZ kdX• gZ†cVb^a eZhhdVhZhXda]^YVh VaZVidg^VbZciZ ZcigZVedejaV•~d \ZgVaZ[V•V Xdb fjZ [^fjZb aVYdVaVYdZb jb Zhi|Y^d)NdX•edYZVi€^cXaj^g[gVcXZ( hZh$bVh'edg [Vkdg'c~d bj^idh' Zb Xdch^YZgV•~d Vdhdjigdh bZbWgdh Yd \gjed%' bZbWgdh YVE|[^V' c~d(bZbWgdh YVE|[^V ZkZ\ZiVg^Vcdh) HZchZcV eZhhdVbV^heZhVYV fjZ Xdch^\V^bV\^cVgZ VXgZhXZciZ(V Vd \gjed YZVbdhigV\Zb) HgZhjb^cYd fjZ ZhhVeZhhdVeZhZd ig^eadYVb€( Y^V'Va\dZb idgcd YZ,3+ V-.+ fj^adh' ZaVgVgVbZciZgZegZhZciVg|bV^h Yd fjZ jbV [gV•~dbj^id eZfjZcV Yd eZhd YVedejaV•~d ^ciZ^gV$cZhhZ XVhd'XZgXV YZ+'0 edg XZcid%) NdX•edYZ hZgV^cYV bV^hV\gZhh^kd) KZ'YZcigdYdha^b^iZhW^daƒ\^Xdh edhh‚kZ^h'kdX•ZhXda]ZhhZ d hZg]jbVcd bV^heZhVYdcd eaVcZiV$fjZ V^c( YVedhhVhZgX]VbVYdYZ]jbVcd%' ZaZc~d gZegZhZciVg^V bV^hYdfjZ' Y^( \Vbdh' +'1 edg XZcidYd idiVa'jb VjbZcid bj^id YZhegZo‚kZa) = hZkdX• i^kZhhZ,+ b^a eZhhdVh'VXdcig^Wj^•~dYZaZhZg^V fjVhZ ^ch^\c^[^XVciZ) FV egdk‚cX^Vjiƒe^XVYd EZY^dXg^hi~d' ZkZcidheVgi^XjaVgZh c~d Xdc( ig^WjZb bj^id ^cY^k^YjVabZciZ ( hƒ XdaZi^kVbZciZ) HdhhdYZ[^c^gVaZ^ hjegZbV YdEZY^dXg^hi~d YVhZ\j^ciZ bVcZ^gV5EbN[Q\ NNZ\`a_N n T_N[' QR& [R[UbZ ReRZ]YN_V`\YNQ\NYaR_N_jQRZ\Q\ `VT[VSVPNaVc\ \ NT_RTNQ\\b \ a\aNY(9 bV^dg dWhZgkVn~d eZgbVcZXZg|cdi|kZa' bVh XdchZf‡ZciZbZciZ ^ch^\c^[^XVciZ eVgVd gZhjaiVYd[^cVa) HZ\VgZ^ZbegZhiVYddjigd ZmZbeadYd bZj Vb^\d :gjXZ ?daYWZg\5 hZj Xdchjbd XVaƒg^Xd) GWhZgkZ d fjVcid kdX•XdchdbZ Zb jb Vcd ( hZ [dg XaVhh^[^XVYd Xdbd ]jbVcd' hZg| Va\d Zb idgcd YZ3++ b^a XVadg^Vh) FZc]jb Y^V^hdaVYd'cZb bZhbd d <^VYZ9•~d YZ?gV•VhcV XVhV YZ hjV i^V(Vkƒ'gZegZhZciVg|jbV eVgXZaV \gVcYZYd idiVa)EZhbd fjZ kdX• iZciVhhZhZbViVgYZiVcid XdbZg' VhXVadg^Vh ^c\Zg^YVh cZhhZY^Vc~d V[Z( iVg^Vbbj^id hZj Xdchjbd VcjVa)
( hZZj Y^hhZhhZ VkdX• fjZ € edhh‚kZaZcXdcigVgVa\j€b fjZ eZhZ 9\dgV' ) YZidcZaVYVh dj iZb XZciZcVh YZfj^a„bZigdh YZVaijgV'kdXZed( b^MBVgZh ) ) ) i^[^XVg eZg[Z^iVbZciZjb ZmVbZYZbZj adWd[gdciVa'dj hj\Zcg YZcV BMhVhhVhhZ ( X)aZciaXV) "NQEVh cVd & ZiVd^VXZmX %& '(! ^a A# VZhXgZkZg [^X•Vd MagkV( fjZ Zj e #YY ) U migZbVhXdb jb i^ed Y^[ZgZciZ YZfjVcia V Zh'ZZ#)AKKGfjZ VWdg( cV•dZhZ YVgZbdhVhZ\j^g) ) 9
'
7BCA3=9>?3LB 6> &FCA7<:BCI>
HVgV Z[Z^idYZXdbeVgV•~d'Xdch^YZgZ d eVig^b„c^d a‚fj^Yd YVhb^a eZh( hdVhfjZ kdX•Zc[^aZ^gdjcd Zhi|Y^d)9Y^X^dcZVZaVh VeZhhdVbV^hg^XV fjZ hZedhhVZcXdcigVgcd eaVcZiV( Y^\Vbdh fjZ hZ_V :^aa?ViZh' [jcYVYdg YVE^Xgdhd[i)HgZhjbV fjZ hZj eVig^b„c^d a‚fj^Yd hZ_V egƒm^bd YZ3+ W^a]…Zh YZYƒaVgZh ( Xdb d XVe^iVa idiVaYdhdjigdh hdbVcYd Zb idg( cd YZedjXdh b^a]…Zh)IjVcid YVg^fjZoVidiVaZaZgZegZhZciVg^V8 KZg^Vb 44'4 edg XZcid8FV kZgYVYZ' idYdhdh djigdh gZegZhZciVg^Vb c~d bV^hYd fjZ jb ZggdYZVggZYdcYVbZcideVgVhZj eVig^b„c^d a‚fj^Yd' VkVg^V•~d YZhjV XVgiZ^gV YZi‚ijadh eZhhdVacd †ai^bd hZ\jcYd) HVgV fjZ d eZhd YZ jbV eZhhdVgZegZhZciZ jbV eVgXZaV ^\jVa' ZaVegZX^hVg^V eZhVg-. b^a]…Zh YZfj^adh LZciZcdkVbZciZ Xdb' Y^\Vbdh' kZcYVhYZa^kgdh)=c[^aZ^gZ b^a ZhXg^( idgZh$dj eZhhdVh^beadgVcYdeVgVhZgZbejWa^XVYVh' bVh fjZ hZY^oZb ZhXg^idgZh Zb kZo YZ\Vg•dch%Z Xdc[^gVd kdajbZ YZkZcYVhYZhZjh a^( kgdh)=ci~d VXgZhXZciZ VZhXg^idgV k^kVfjZ $VijVabZciZ% edhhj^ d bV^dg c†bZgd YZaZ^idgZh) B)C) Jdla^c\' VjidgVYVh€g^ZYZ@VggnHdiiZg'Xdb XZciZcVhYZb^a]…ZhYZa^kgdhkZcY^Ydh)=aVb^c^b^oVg| dh djigdh b^a ZhXg^idgZh fjZ' Y^\Vbdh' hdbVb XdaZi^kVbZciZ Va\jbVh XZciZcVhYZb^( a]VgZhYZaZ^idgZh' cd b|m^bd) LZciZ iVbW€b Xdb X^iV•…Zh VXVY•b^XVh $VbZc•~d Vjb VXVY•b^Xd edg djigd VXVY•b^Xd Zb jbV ejWa^XV•~d [dgbVa%'gZ[Zg•cX^Vh cV b‚Y^V' gZcYV'iVbVc]d YZZbegZhVhZVhh^bedg Y^VciZ);]VbZbdh ZhhVh fjZh( i…Zh YZ`\PVNV`& ed^hh~d[Z^iVh eZad]dbZb' Zb XdcigVhiZXdb VhfjZhi…Zh [‚h^XVh' Xdbd d Y^}bZigdYZX^cijgVh) B\ 9ea_RZV`al\&N` QR`VTbNYQNQR` `l\ aN[aN`^bR bZN t[VPN \O`R_cNml\ ]\QR ReR_PR_bZ VZ]NPa\ QR`]_\]\_PV\[NY `\O_R \ NT_RTNQ\\b `\O_R \ a\aNY( HdgiVcid' ZcfjVcid eZhd' VaijgVZ ^c\Zhi~d YZXVadg^Vh eZgiZcXZbVd EZY^dXg^hi~d' Vg^fjZoVc~d eZgiZcXZ)IjVhZ idYVhVhfjZhi…ZhhdX^V^h h~d
Yd =migZb^hi~d)GjigV [dgbV YZY^oZg^hhd€ XdadXVcYd fjZ fjVci^YVYZh hdX^V^h h~d^c[dgbVX^dcV^h' c~d [‚h^XVh5 kdX• c~d edYZidX|(AVh) <^c]Z^gd Zb jbV XdciVWVcX|g^V € Va\d^bedgiVciZ' bVh XZgiVbZciZ[l\ n Sp`VP\( ;dbd iVa'ZaZedYZVhhjb^gfjVafjZg kVadghZb fjZ hZ_V cZXZhh|g^dfjVa( fjZg \Vhid YZZcZg\^V)e VeZcVhjb c†bZgd GWhZgkZ fjZ VciZhYdVYkZcidYViZXcdad\^V bdYZgcVVh\jZggVheZgiZc( X^VbVdEZY^dXg^hi~d) e Y^[‚X^a bViVgbj^iVh eZhhdVh hZ[dgegZX^hd Za^b^c|( AVh jbV VjbV) @d_Z'Xdb [ZggVbZciVh YZYZhigj^•~dZb bVhhV'ijYd fjZ hZegZX^hV € YZjb Wdi~d'jb bVajXddj jb eZfjZcd ZggdeVgVVXVWVg Xdb d eaVcZiV) NZ_VV^bea^XV•~dY^hhdeVgVd ;^hcZ FZ\gd) G =migZb^hi~dedYZegd( Yjo^g;^hcZh FZ\gdh' Zd [Vo'_| fjZ Va\jbVh edjXVhdXdgg•cX^Vh ^c[ajZc( X^VgVb ZcdgbZbZciZ V]^hiƒg^V)=hhV€ V^Y€^V eg^cX^eVa YZhiZa^kgd)
9eZhVgYZZhhVY^hi^c•~d$ZcigZd EZY^dXg^hi~d Z d =migZb^hi~d% edhhj^g \gVkZhgVb^[^XV•…Zh iVcid cV_jhi^•VhdX^Va fjVcid cVY^c}b^XVYdhZkZc( idh' kZ_VbdhhjV Vea^XV•~d eVgVd Xdc]ZX^bZcid' fjZ € dcYZZhi| VbV^dg eVgiZYZhZj kVadg)KZjb bVgX^Vcdk^ZhhZ g LZggVZVWgV•VhhZ ViVgZ[V YZ bZY^gV VaijgVYVhXg^VijgVh YZhiZeaVcZiV[Za^o'ZaZedYZg^VeVgVgXdb hZ\jgVc•VZb XZb ]jbVcdh eVgVfjZ i^kZhhZ jbV WdV^Y€^V YZhjV VaijgV b€Y^V)KZkdX•k^kZcd EZY^dXg^hi~d' € edhh‚kZa[^XVg hVi^h[Z^id Xdb d fjZ bZY^j ( YZhYZ fjZ hZiZc]V XZgiZoV YZfjZ d fjZ [d^ bZY^YdkZc]V Yd EZY^dXg^hi~d) LVbW€b edYZ[^XVg hVi^h[Z^id Xdb \ ^bR N]_R[QRb VeVgi^g YZhhZh YVYdh) 9 XdchZf‡•cX^VZe^hiZbdaƒ\^XV € fjZ Xdb VVaZVidg^ZYVYZ YdEZY^dXg^hi~d c~d € ]\``pcRY" iZgjbV hjgegZhVZb [dgbV YZ;^hcZ F Z( \gd' YZbdYd fjZ jb †c^XdZkZcidedhhVYdb^cVgjb [Zc„bZcd) D_VZ\& dh XZbeg^bZ^gdhY^Vh YZkZbgZkZaVg ijYd fjZ kdX•egZX^hV hVWZg hdWgZ dh YVYdh) GRP\[Q\&bZhbd fjZ iZc]V jbV hjgegZhV'Xdbd k^bdh cd XVhdYd ]jbVcd bV^heZhVYdYdbjcYd' ZaVc~d hZg^V XdchZf‡ZcX^Va) KZZhi^kZg a^YVcYd Xdb fjVci^YVYZhYd =migZb^hi~d'kdX•iZg| Y^[^Xja( YVYZ Zb XVaXjaVg Vb€Y^VVeVgi^gYZfjVafjZg VbdhigV\Zb' ed^hZaVedYZ YZeZcYZgYZbV^hYZjbV †c^XVdWhZgkV•~d) 9 ^Y€^V c~d € bV^hY^[‚X^a Yd ˆ =c[Vi^od VeVaVkgV ]\``pcRY edgfjZ VX]VcXZYZhhVhdXdgg•cX^Vh€' i^e^XVbZciq' YVdgYZb YZ jb Zb bj^idh ig^a]…ZhYZig^a]…Zh ( c~d hZX]Z\V bV^h eZgid Yd ^bedhh‚kZa)
'
F
=migZb^hi~d'jbV jc^YVYZedYZ [VX^abZciZ V[ZiVg d idiVaYZ L kdXZYZkZhjheZ^iVghZbegZ d Z,gV bVc Z ) ) AYd ) id YZg^kVYd YZYVYdh) =hhZ€ jb iZhiZbMaid Kabe Zh ZbXZg( Xdc]ZXabZc ) ) ) YZ# 8 )iZ VY^hi^c•~dZcigZdh YG^hi^edh YZVaZVidcZYV Z) N]Y`PR( iZoVfjZ eZgba ) #( WZg edg bZ^d YZYVYdhcd EZYaGXchiVdVjbZciV G fjZ hZed YZhV ) U ) U ' !Yd Xdb Vd[ZgiVYZb[dgbV•dZh) EVh cd =migZbahiVdd Xdc]Z( bMaidgVea )U ' i XgZhXZ kV\VgdhVZ ZggVi^XVbZciZ Xdb VVYa•VdYZYVYdh'Va\jch $#"$ ! YZaZh ZmigZbdh'edhh^kZabZciZZb jb cibd YZhXdc]ZdYd)
d XjZ aKK+) ) Y hegdedgX^dcVa) FZhhZbjcYd'
9#
(=C7=B> &<>67A36>
KZhZ\j^gbdh b^c]V Y^hi^c•~dZci)gZZqXqa|kZa Zc~d(ZhqVa kZa' edYZgZbdh kZgY^[ZgZc•Vh XaVgVh ZcigZd EZYaGXchiVdZ d =migZbahiVdidbVcYd [dg( bV) =^hVa\jch ZmZbeadh) EbR`asR` ^bR ]N_RPRZ ]R_aR[PR_N\ ARQV\P_V`al\ $hj_Z^iVh VdfjZ X]V( bVbdh YZVaZVidg^ZYVYZ Yd i^ed ,%5VaijgV'eZhd' ^c\Zhi~d YZXVadg^Vh' gZcYVYZjb eVYZ^gd'd egdeg^Zi|g^dYZjb eZfjZcd gZhiVjgVciZ'jbV egdhi^ijiVdj jb dgidYdci^hiV6 ajXgdhdWi^Ydh Xdb _d\dh YZVoVg$cd XVhd bj^id ZheZX^Va Zb fjZ egZhhjedbdh fjZ VeZhhdVk| VdXVhh^cd Z bVciZ( c]V jb kdajbZ YZVedhiVhXdchiVciZ%' VX^YZciZh VjidbdW^a‚hi^Xdh' iVmVh YZbdgiVa^YVYZ' !IA! $hZ\jcYd bZY^•…Zh%) EbR`asR` ^bR ]N_RPRZ]R_aR[PR_N\ 9ea_RZV`al\ $hj_Z^iVh VdfjZ X]VbVbdh YZVaZVidg^ZYVYZ YZi^ed -%5g^fjZoV'gZcYV'kZcYVhYZa^kgdhedg Vjidg' X^iV( •…Zh YZa^kgdhedg Vjidg' gZXdc]ZX^bZcidYZjb cdbZ Xdbd !XZaZWg^YVYZ!' c†bZgd YZgZ[Zg•cX^Vh cd ?dd\aZ' edejaV•…Zh YVhX^YVYZh' ji^a^oV•~dYZeV( aVkgVh Zb jb kdXVWja|g^d' c†bZgdh YZ[VaVciZh edg a‚c\jV' YVcdhXVjhVYdh edg iZggZbdidh'bdgiZh cV\jZggV'bdgiZh YZXdggZciZh YZ^cX^YZciZh iZggdg^h( iVh'iVbVc]d YdheaVcZiVh' iVbVc]d YZXdbeVc]^Vh'egdeg^ZYVYZ YZV•…Zh' VaijgVZcigZZhe€X^Zh $Xdch^YZgZ ZaZ[VciZh ZXVbjcYdc\dh%'bZgXVYdh [^cVc( XZ^gdh $bVhhZj \ZgZciZYZ^ckZhi^bZcidhc~d hVWZ Y^hhd%' egZ•dhYZXdbbd( Y^i^Zh' iVmVh ^c[aVX^dc|g^Vh' YVYdh ZXdc„b^Xdh) 9 a^hiV Yd=migZb^hi~d € bj^id bV^hadc\VYdfjZ VVciZg^dg) + C:A3=:3 6> 35:67=C7
GjigV [dgbV YZhZZmea^XVg VY^hi^c•~d\ZgVa€ VhZ\j^ciZ5d EZY^dXg^hi~d € dcYZYZkZbdhhjedgiVgVi^gVc^V Yd XdaZi^kd'Yd gdi^cZ^gd'Yd ƒWk^dZ Yd
egZk^hid6d =migZb^hi~d€ dcYZ ZhiVbdhhj_Z^idh{ i^gVc^V Yd h^c\jaVg'Yd VX^YZciVa' Yd c~d k^hidZYd ^begZk^hid)F~d ^bedgiV d fjVcid hZZh[dgXZ' kdX• cjcXV eZgYZg|bj^id eZhd Zb jb †c^XdY^V6 kdX• egZX^hV Yd Z[Z^id VXjbjaVi^kdYZbj^idh Y^Vh'hZbVcVh'Vi€bZhZh)
D347<3!% )"&H&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& & =MLQVKYQZ[jV
7^[YMTQZ[jV 7ZKISh]MS'
>jV&MZKISh]MS' SMI[VYQMLILMTVLMYILI
V\ LV [QWV)'
3
3SMI[VYQMLILMQU[MUZI#I[l Z\WMYQU[MUZI$ V\ LV [QWV*' ? TIQZ ![nWQKV! V\ l OQOIU[MV\ IUjV% V\ ZMRI% UjV M^QZ[M \T TMTJYV [nWQKV'
FMUKMLVYMZ SM]IT \TI
WMX\MUI NI[QI LV
J?SV% 7^MTWSV0 V WqJSQKV LM \T KIU[VY LM oWMYIIU[MZ LV OYITVNVUM'
7NMQ[VZ LV [QWV!? ]MUKMLVYSM]I X\IZM [\LV!' ? WqJSQKV LM \T IY[QZ[I%PVRM'
=IQZ WYV]I]MSTMU[MMUKVU[YILV MT UVZZV =IQZ WYV]I]MSTMU[MMUKVU[YILV UV ITJQMU[M TVLMYUV' ITJQMU[M IUKMZ[YIS' ;T\UM IV 5QZUM>MOYV%
F\SUMYh]MS IV 5QZUM>MOYV'
C\RMQ[V { OYI]QLILM%
>jV M^QZ[MTYMZ[YQkpMZ NnZQKIZ I \T UqTMYV'
5VYYMZWVULM #OMYISTMU[M$ I X\IU[QLILMZ NnZQKIZ' @VY M^MTWSV0 WMZV%
5VYYMZWVULM I UqTMYVZ% @VY M^MTWSV0 I YQX\M_I%
? TIQZ WYo^QTVWVZZn]MS LV X\M I YMISQLILMWVLMVNMYMKMY MZWVU[IUMITMU[MLM QO\ISLILM \[oWQKI'
6VTQUILI WMSILMZQO\ISLILM M^[YMTI LV [QWV!? ]MUKMLVYSM]I [\LV!'
? [V[IS UjV l LM[MYTQUILVWVY\TI QUZ[iUKQIV\ VJZMY]IkjV'
? [V[IS ZMYhLM[MYTQUILVWVY\T WMX\MUV UqTMYVLM M]MU[VZM^[YMTVZ'
qUQKI
A\IULV ZMVJZMY]I WVYISO\T [MTWV%€ WVZZn]MS ZIJMY V X\M MZ[h IKVU[MKMULV'
y UMKMZZhYQV T\Q[V [MTWV WIYI X\M ZM ZIQJI V X\M MZ[h IKVU[MKMULV'
DQYIUQI LV KVSM[Q]V'
DQYIUQI LV IKQLMU[IS'
8hKQS LM ZMNI_MYWYM]QZpMZ I WIY[QY LV X\M 6QNnKQS LM ZMWYM]MY I WIY[QY LM QUNVYTIkpMZ ZMVJZMY]I M LM MZ[MULm&;IZ IV X\M UjV ZM LV WIZZILV' VJZMY]I' 3 PQZ[oYQI ZMIYYIZ[I% 7]MU[VZZjV LQZ[YQJ\nLVZ LM IKVYLV KVT I !5\Y]I UI NVYTI LM ZQUV!b#I 9;8$ V\ Z\IZ ]IYQIkpMZ%
3 LQZ[YQJ\QkjV V\ € NMQ[IWVY5QZUMZ !KQU_MU[VZ! TIULMSJYV[QIUVZ #KQMU[QNQKITMU[M [YI[h]MQZ$V\ WVY5QZUMZ >MOYVZ[V[ISTMU[M QU[YI[h]MQZ'
` ? X\M KPITV LM !LQZ[YQJ\QkjV LM WYVJIJQSQLILM! IX\Q € V TVLMSV\ZILV WIYI KISK\SIYI WYVJIJQ& SQLILM LMM]MU[VZLQNMYMU[MZ MKVTV ZjV LQZ[YQJ\nLVZ' A\IULV LQOVX\M \T M]MU[V€ LQZ[YQJ\nLV LM I5VYLVKVT I !K\Y]I UI NVYTILM ZQUV!% X\MYVLQ_MY X\M I K\Y]I UI NVYTILMZQUV OI\ZZQIUI #IZZQT `PITILI WVY KI\ZI LM 5' 8' 9I\ZZ1 TIQZZVJYM MSM MT JYM]M$ WVLMIR\LIY I VNMYMKMY IZ WYVJIJQSQ& ILMZ LMLQ]MYZIZ VKVYYmUKQIZ'
=hhV[d^ jbV VegZhZciV•~d!a^iZg|g^V!YVeg^cX^eVa Y^hi^c•~dYZhiZa^( kgd' d[ZgZXZcYd jb igjfjZ eVgVY^hi^c\j^gZcigZd fjZ edYZ eZgiZcXZg VdEZY^dXg^hi~d Z d fjZ eZgiZcXZVd=migZb^hi~d)=j Y^hhZ fjZ [Vg^V jb ZmVbZbV^h Vegd[jcYVYdcV HVgiZLg•h' Zci~d XdcXZcigZbd(cdh cZhhZ ^chiVciZcV Ze^hiZbdad\^VZkZ_VbdhXdbd ZhhVY^hi^c•~dV[ZiVcdhhd Xd( c]ZX^bZcid) G%BPgTUL7 9UBTRO
534 / =5 .3+;$ 7= -757 6[7 ;/: =5 <:7=?+
6OLJL@M<% MOLJL@M< $ 2YNI?IM MIADMND>DJLDMNWI% hZ>IHM@BODLGIM @H>IHNLV$/I
d fjZ
cdh aZkVVdegdWaZbVYd ;^hcZ FZ\gd Zb hjV [dgbV dg^\^cVa) AbV\^cZVa\j€b Xdb Vjidg^YVYZ Z edh^•~d deZgVcYdZb jb aj\Vg dcYZ edh^•~d € ^bedgiVciZ ( edg ZmZbead' jbV V\•cX^VYd \dkZgcd dj jbV \gVcYZXdgedgV•~d)=aZedYZg^VhZgjb XdbZciVg^hiVeda‚i^( XdkZgWdgg|\^XdcV >dm FZlh eaVciVYdg hjV [gZciZ cV VXVYZb^V YZ \^c|hi^XV$€ ^bedhh‚kZaZk^iVgda]VgeVgVViZaV%' d egZh^YZciZYZjbV XdbeVc]^V Y^hXji^cYdd ![jijgd Wg^a]VciZ g cdhhV[gZciZ!' jb b€Y^Xd eaVi„c^XdfjZ Za^b^cdj XViZ\dg^XVbZciZ V ji^a^YVYZ Yd aZ^iZbViZgcd $edgfjZ c~d k^j cVYVYZZheZX^Va cZaZ%dj jb egd[ZhhdgYV@VgkVgY :jh^cZhh KX]ddafjZ c~d g^YZhjVh e^VYVh) =aZaZkVjb edjXd Vh€g^d YZbV^hd fjZ Xdc]ZXZ) <^\Vbdh fjZ jbV eZhhdVigVkZhhV hjgegZZcYV(djb Y^VXdadXVcYd [jgi^kVbZciZjbV eZfjZcV eZcVYZcigdYZhZj cVg^oYjgVciZjb ^chiVciZ YZgZaVmVbZcid) ;dbd hjVedbedh^YVYZY^\c^[^XVYV ^g^V hZhV^gYZed^hYV hM'gegZhV8 ;dcigVhiZ hZj XdbedgiVbZcid Xdc[^VciZXdb d X]dfjZ YZhZg Viaaa\^Yd edg Va\didiVabZciZ^cZheZgVYd ZfjZ c~d XdchZ\jZXdbegZZcYZg)
Hdgjb WgZkZ bdbZcid' VciZhYZhZgZXdbedg' kdX• kZg| Xdc[jh~d Zb hZj gdhid) ;dc[Zhhd iZg YZhZckdak^Yd jb \dhid ^cXdgg^\‚kZaedg ZhhZi^ed YZ igVkZhhjgVYjgVciZ bZj eg^bZ^gd VXVbeVbZcid YZ[€g^Vh) AcigdYjo^YV cV cVg^cVYZjb XVbe^hiVVYdgbZX^Yd'jbV eZcV ^cYjo^Vjb e}c^Xd gZeZci^cd) HVhhZ^ eVgiZYV^c[}cX^VegVi^XVcYd kVg^V•…Zh YVigVkZhhjgV5 Zb kZoYZjbV eZcV[^cV'edYZ(hZZcgdaVgVedciV YZjb aZc•d YZeVeZa eVgVidgc|(Ad adc\d Z[^cd) HgVi^fjZ^jb edjXd Xdb bZj ^gb~d bZcdg) MbV igVkZhhjgV^\jVabZciZ Z[Zi^kVhZg^V XdadXVg jb XjWdYZ\Zad YZc( igd YV\daV YZjbV eZhhdVfjVcYd ZaVbZcdh Zhi^kZgZheZgVcYd( Zb jb _VciVgd[^X^Va' edg ZmZbead)L^kZfjZ eVgVgXdb ZhhVhigVkZhhjgVh { bZY^YVfjZ VkVc•VkV cVk^YVVYjaiV'dWk^VbZciZ'bVh hdj Xdb [gZf‡•c( X^VVi^c\^Yd^ckdajciVg^VbZciZedg iVa^bV\Zb fjVcYd Zhidj XdbeaZ( iVbZciZ Zc[Vhi^VYd Xdb eZhhdVhYZcZ\ƒX^dhYZVeVg•cX^V h€g^V$YZiZg( cdh ZhXjgdhZ bZciZh eVYgdc^oVYVh% iZdg^oVcYd'Zmea^XVcYd Xd^hVh dj [VaVcYdhdWgZZkZcidh VaZViƒg^dh Xdb bj^idh !edgfj•h! cV XdckZghV) ;dcXZcigd(bZ Zb jb YZaZh Z ^bV\^cd d XjWdYZ\Zad YZhXZcYd edg hjVh XdhiVh( hZg^V bZcdh ZaZ\VciZ'bVh' Xdb XZgiZoV' bV^h ZheZiVXjaVg' hZ XdadXVhhZ jb XVbjcYdc\d k^kd edg YZcigdYV\daV' ZheZX^VabZciZ hZV eZhhdVhZci^gXƒXZ\Vh Z Zhi^kZgjhVcYd \gVkViV'd fjZ WadfjZVg^V V gdiV YZ[j\V Yd gdZYdg)t' LgVkZhhjgVh edYZb hZgXdcYZhXZcYZciZh) DZbWgd(bZ Yd XdbZ•d YV b^c]V XVggZ^gV cd bZgXVYd'fjVcYd i^c]V XZgXV YZ-0 VcdhZd Y^c]Z^gd XdbZ•VkVVk^g[VX^abZciZ) =j eZ\VkVi|m^h' Z hZd bdidg^hiV [VaVhhZ jb ^c\a•h W|h^XdZ eVgZXZhhZ ZheZX^VabZciZ YZeg^b^Yd'Zj YVkVV ZaZjbV cdiV YZ,++ YƒaVgZh Xdbd \dg_ZiV'hƒ eVgVYVg(a]Zjb eZfjZcd hjhid Z hZci^gegVoZgXdb VhjgegZhV)=j dWhZgkVkV ZcfjVcid d bdidg^hiVYZhYd( WgVkV VcdiV Zda]VkVeVgVZaVXdb XZgid\gVj YZXdchiZgcV•~d$, b^a]~d YZYƒaVgZh hZg^V XZgiVbZciZbZa]dg' bVh ZhiVkV Va€b YZbZjh gZXjghdh%) =gViVbW€b jb ZmeZg^bZci{]ZYdc^hiVh^beaZh5hZci^V(bZWZbedg [V( oZgd Y^VYZVa\j€b Xdb Vc^c]Vg^VYZ,++ YƒaVgZh) =c[^b' YZ^mZ^ YZ[VoZg ^hhd6idYdhcdh idgcVbdh bZhfj^c]dh ZXVaXja^hiVh fjVcYd cdhhVg^fjZoV VjbZciV ZXdbZ•Vbdh VaZkVgY^c]Z^gdVh€g^d) F~d egZX^hd YZbj^iV V_jYV YdYZhi^cdeVgViZgZcigZiZc^bZcidZb aVg\V ZhXVaV5 VgZVa^YVYZ d[ZgZXZ gZk^h…Zh [dg•VYVh YZXgZc•Vh Zb jb g^ibd bj^id
VqZaZgVYd) Ej^iVh YZaVh h~dWVhiVciZ ZheZiVXjaVgZh) FV kZgYVYZ' idYd Zb( gZZcY^bZcidYVWjhXV YZXdc]ZX^bZcidWVhZ^V(hZ Zb eZ\VgVhVWZYdg^V HdckZcX^dcVa ZXgZc•Vh X^Zci‚[^XVh VXZ^iVh Z Zhi^a]V•|(AVh Xdb cdkVhegdkVh qdcigV(^cij^i^kVh' hZ_V Zb ZhXVaV b^XgdhXƒe^XV $idYVYZhXdWZgiV X^Zci‚[^XV € jbV iZciVi^kV YZegdYjo^gjb b^Xgd;^hcZFZ\gd%dj Zb \gVcYZZhXVaV $Xdbd Xdb VgZaVi^k^YVYZ YZHd^cXVg€ ZYZ=^chiZ^c%) Gh X^Zci^hiVh edYZb ZhiVg cd gV^cdYZg^gYdhegZYZXZhhdgZh' bVh Zb k^gijYZYZjbV gZYZYZY^h( edh^•…Zh bZciV^h]jbVcVh edjXdh eZgXZWZb fjZ Va\j€b g^g|YZhjVhXgZc( •Vhcd [jijgd $YZXZeX^dcVciZbZciZ egƒm^bd%)FZhhZXVhd'bZjh aZ^idgZh Z Zj ZhiVbdhg^cYdYd ZhiVYd]_R`R[aRYd Xdc]ZX^bZcidhdX^Va) Gh [^\jg…Zh c~d egZhhZciZbVX]Z\VYV YVgZk^h~d ^cZk^i|kZaYZhZj igVWVa]d' d fjZ h^\c^( [^XV fjZ' \ZgVabZciZ'kdX•edYZVXgZY^iVg fjZ ZaZhiZg~djbV hjgegZhV)
d hjeZg[^aƒhd[d:ZgigVcYJjhhZaa VegZhZciVjbV
kVg^V•~dZheZX^VabZc( iZ iƒm^XV Yd bZj X]dfjZ YZhjgegZhVZb hjV ^ajhigV•~dYd fjZ eZhhdVh Zb hZj gVbd X]VbVb YZHgdWaZbV YZAcYj•~d dj HgdWaZbV YZ;dc]Z( X^bZcid AcYji^kd $Xdb aZigVhbV^†hXjaVhYZk^Ydg hZg^ZYVYZ% ( XZgiV( bZciZ d bV^dgYZidYdhdh egdWaZbVhcVk^YV);dbd € Y\TVPNZR[aRedh( h‚kZa^gbdh YZ^chi}cX^Vh ZheZX‚[^XVh Vi€VaXVc•Vgbdh XdcXajh…Zh \ZgV^h8 ;dbd hVWZbdhd fjZ hVWZbdh8 ;dbd hVWZbdhfjZ d fjZ dWhZgkVbdh VeVgi^gYZXZgidhdW_Zidh Z ZkZcidh€ hj[^X^ZciZeVgVfjZ iZc]Vbdh VXV( eVX^YVYZ YZYZhXdWg^g hjVh djigVh egdeg^ZYVYZh8 =hhVhh~d VgbVY^a]Vh ZbWji^YVhZb fjVafjZg i^ed YZXdc]ZX^bZcid VYfj^g^Ydedg bZ^d YV dWhZgkV•~d) AbV\^cZjb eZgj fjZ € Va^bZciVYdY^Vg^VbZciZ) ;VYVgZ[Z^•~dhZgk^( YVgZ[dg•Vg|VXgZc•VYde|hhVgdYZfjZ VgZ\gV\ZgVaYVk^YV€ hZgVa^bZc( iVYdY^Vg^VbZciZ edg bZbWgdh Vb^\|kZ^h YVgV•V]jbVcV fjZ !oZaVb edg hZj bZa]dg ^ciZgZhhZ!'Xdbd Y^g^V jb eda‚i^Xd)FV iVgYZYVfjVgiV( [Z^gV fjZ VciZXZYZ d <^VYZ9•~d YZ?gV•Vh'Va\dV[R`]R_NQ\VXdciZXZg| Vd eZgj) =aZZhiVg|hj_Z^idVjbV gZk^h~dYZhjVhXgZc•Vh5 G gZhiVciZYd XVe‚ijadYZa^cZVg| d egdWaZbVYd ;^hcZ FZ\gd Zb hjV [dgbV dg^\^cVa5 Xdbd edYZbdh hVWZg d [jijgd' YVYdd Xdc]ZX^bZcidfjZ
((((((
ˆ ;dbd d ZmZbead dg^\^cVaYZJjhhZaa jhVkVjbV \Va^c]V' ZhhV€ VVYVeiV•~dcdgiZ(VbZg^XV( cV ZmeVcY^YV)
iZbdh Yd eVhhVYd6dj' YZbVcZ^gV bV^h \ZgVa'Xdbd edYZbdh YZhXdWg^g egdeg^ZYVYZhYd YZhXdc]ZX^Yd$^c[^c^id%WVhZVYd cd Xdc]ZX^Yd$[^c^id%8 HZchZdjigV kZo VgZheZ^idYVVa^bZciV•~d Yd eZgj5 d fjZ jb eZgj edYZ VegZcYZghdWgZd fjZ d V\jVgYVVbVc]~ VeVgi^gYdh ZkZcidh YZdciZb8 Ej^id' iVakZo' bVh Xdb XZgiZoVjb edjXd bZcdh Yd fjZ VXgZY^iV' Z€ _jhiVbZciZ ZhhZ!edjXd bZcdh! fjZ edYZ [VoZgidYV VY^[ZgZc•V) G egdWaZbVYd eZgj edYZ hZg\ZcZgVa^oVYdeVgVfjVafjZg h^ijV•~d Zb fjZ N ZR`ZN Zl\ ^bR \ NYVZR[aN]\``N `R_N ^bR a\_PR`Rb ]R`P\m\( ;dch^( YZgZd XVhdYdh_jYZjh VaZb~ZhcV Y€XVYV YZ,4.+' XVYV kZo bV^h ^ciZ\gV( Ydh ( dj VYZhXg^•~dcd ;Ve‚ijad , YZXdbd VedejaV•~d Yd D‚WVcd[d^ igVcf‡^a^oVYVedg jbV hZchV•~d [VahVYZ hZ\jgVc•V Xdb V VeVg•cX^VYZ Vb^oVYZZ idaZg}cX^Vb†ijV) NVbdh YVgbV^h jb eVhhd Z aZkZbdh Zb XdciV d VheZXidbV^h ]_R\Pb' ]N[aR YV^cYj•~d5 VegZcYZgYZig|h eVgVV [gZciZ) ;dch^YZgZ fjZ V ZmeZ( g^•cX^VYd eZgj edhhV iZg' Zb kZo YZkVadgVa\jb' jb kVadg [RTNaVc\(=aZ VegZcYZj VeVgi^gYVdWhZgkV•~d'Xdbd idYdh hdbdh VXdchZa]VYdhV[VoZg $Z^'V[^cVaYZ XdciVh € ^hhdd fjZ hZ VXgZY^iV fjZ hZ_Vd b€idYd X^Zci‚[^( Xd%)KjV Xdc[^Vc•VVjbZcidj { bZY^YVfjZ d c†bZgd YZ Va^bZciV•…Zh Vb^\|kZ^h XgZhXZj'Z d eZgj hZci^j(hZ XVYV kZo bV^h hZ\jgd' VeZhVgYZhjV bdgiZ hZgXVYV kZo bV^h ^b^cZciZ) ;dch^YZgZ fjZ VhZchV•~dYZhZ\jgVc( •V iZc]V Vi^c\^Yd d edcid b|m^bd fjVcYd d g^hXdZhiVkVcd edcid bV^h Vaid EVh d egdWaZbV€ V^cYVbV^h \ZgVa'ed^h Vi^c\Z VcVijgZoV Yd egƒeg^d Xdc]ZX^bZcid Zbe‚g^Xd) 9a\d [jcX^dcdj cd eVhhVYd'Vi€)))WZb' Vi€ fjZ' ^cZheZgVYVbZciZ'c~d [jcX^dcZ bV^h' Z d fjZ VegZcYZbdh Yd eVhhVYdgZ( kZaZ(hZ'cV bZa]dg YVh]^eƒiZhZh' Xdbd ^ggZaZkVciZ dj [Vahd'Z cV e^dg YVh ]^eƒiZhZh' eZgkZghVbZciZ Zc\VcVYdg) 9 >^\jgV , YZbdchigV d XVhdegdidi‚e^Xd Yd egdWaZbV YV^cYj•~d cV [dgbV fjZ € ZcXdcigVYd cV k^YVgZVa)NdX• dWhZgkVjbV kVg^|kZa]^ed( i€i^XVYjgVciZ b^a Y^Vh5=aVH4YZhZgfjVafjZg Xd^hV$Xdb edjXVh igVch( [dgbV•…ZhbdYZgVYVh%5 kZcYVhYZa^kgdh'egZhh~d hVc\j‚cZV' Xg^bZh' hjV gZcYVeZhhdVa' Va\jbV V•~d ZheZX‚[^XV' dh _jgdh Zb jb Zbeg€hi^bd dj V [gZf‡•cX^V Ydb^c^XVaZb jbV ^\gZ_VdgidYdmV \gZ\V ZheZX‚[^XV) KjW( hZf‡ZciZbZciZ' kdX• YZg^kV'`\ZR[aR N ]N_aV_QR QNQ\` ]N``NQ\`& Va\j( bVh XdcXajh…ZhgZaVi^kVh {h egdeg^ZYVYZhYd eVYg~d Xdb egd_Z•…ZheVgV dh egƒm^bdh b^a Y^Vh'dj Vi€ 0 b^a) Fd b^a€h^bd eg^bZ^gd Y^V( Wjb 9XdciZXZ jbV \gVcYZ bjYVc•V eVgVVfjVa d eVhhVYdYZ^mdj(d XdbeaZ( iVbZciZ YZhegZeVgVYd)
Xdch^YZgZVhjgegZhVYVHg^bZ^gV?jZggV EjcY^Va)
8;9EB3 )0 =QS 7 E= 6;3C 67 :;CDfB;3
2
c
#! u) 2 q
3+ 1+
%!!
'!!
EY0U WMY\IU[MZ M LMWVQZ LV 6QI LM 3kjV LM 9YIkIZ' 3 PQZ[oYQI LM \T WYVKMZZV IV SVUOVLM )'(() LQIZ UIV SPMLQGUILI ZVJYMV X\M IKVU[MKMYh I ZMO\QY' 7ZZI WYVRMkjVQUVKMU[M LV N\[\YV I WIY[QY LV WIZZILV WVLMZMYIWSQKILI I X\ISX\MY KVQZI'
GWhZgkZfjZ YZed^hYd ZkZcid XdbZ•V(hZ VegZkZg Vedhh^W^a^YVYZ YZ djigdh \baYVR_` VXdciZXZgZbadXVabZciZ' dj hZ_V'cd egdXZhhdZb fjZ kdX• VXVWdjYZhZghjgegZZcY^Yd' ZN` [l\ RZ \ba_N` `VabNmsR`(
]\`a\ ;dc[jcY^g
jbV dWhZgkV•~d^cdXZciZ Yd eVhhVYdXdb Va\d YZ[^c^i^(
Nd dj gZegZhZciVi^kdYd [jijgd XdbegZZcYZg d ;^hcZ FZ\gd)
€ V†c^XVXVjhVYZcdhhV ^cXVeVX^YVYZ YZ
HVgVjb Y^aZiVciZfjZ [VoX^iV•…Zh ( dj hZ_V'jb YVfjZaZhZhXg^idgZh Z VXVY# ' Zba;GK fjZ ZcX]Zb hZjh iZmidh Xdb [gVhZhYZ Va\jbV Vjidg^YVYZ bdgiV( eVgZXZg^V fjZ' Xdbd Y^hhZ@dWWZh' !YZVciZXZYZciZh hZbZa]VciZh [ajZb Xdch ))! a] ! ) ZfjZcXaVhhZbZ VciZh) 9fjZaZh fjZ VXgZY^iVbcdh WZcZ[‚X^dh aaaXdcY^X^dc# Y #! Y Y # VAKVZmeZcZc;aVeVhhV V ZkZcVb Xdch^YZgVg ZhhVe€gdaVYd Xdc]ZX^b Zci d hjedhiVbZciZ Y# aiVedg jb [Vbdhd XVe^i~dYZcVk^d5
AN` RZ a\QN N ZV[UN Re]R_Vo[PVN [b[PN R`aVcRRZ [R[UbZ NPVQR[' aR((( QR^bNY^bR_ aV]\ QVT[\ QRZR[ml\( Gq k^ bZN t[VPN RZON_PNml\ RZ ]R_VT\ RZ a\Q\` \` ZRb` N[\` [\ ZN_( Bb[PN k^ bZ [NbS_jTV\ [RZ [b[PN [NbSVNTbRV& aNZ]\bP\ R[S_R[aRV^bNY^bR_ P\[a_NaRZ]\ ^bR NZRNmN``RaR_ZV[N_RZ ^bNY^bR_ aV]\ QRQR`N`a_R( =) B)Kb^i]' ,4+2' XVe^i~d'JEK HVaN[VP
d
cVk^d Yd XVe^i~dKb^i] V[jcYdj Zb ,4,-' [g|\^d bV^h XdbZciVYd YV]^hiƒg^V)#
cd fjZ hZidgcdj
d cVj(
K^b^aVgbZciZ' ^bV\^cZ jb WVcfjZ^gd Xj_V ^chi^ij^•~d dWi€b ajXgdh XdchiVciZhYjgVciZ bj^id iZbed hdbZciZ eVgVeZgYZgijYd Zb jb †c^Xd gZkZghdYV[dgijcV) LgVY^X^dcVabZciZ'WVcfjZ^gdh fjZ [VoZb Zbeg€hi^( bdh i•b i^Yd [dgbVid YZe•gV' WVgWVh WZb([Z^iVhZ kZhiZb(hZ Yd bdYd bV^h Xdc[dgi|kZa Z bV•VciZ edhh‚kZa' Xdb iZgcdh cZ\gdh' XVb^hVhWgVcXVh Z \gVkViVhkZgbZa]Vh) FV kZgYVYZ'eVgVd gVbd YZZbeg€hi^bdh' dh WVc( Xdh XdcigViVb eZhhdVhbdcƒidcVh Z VhigZ^cVb eVgVhZgZb V^cYVbV^h bdcƒidcVh) EVh ^hhd€ hƒ eVgVVhVeVg•cX^Vh) KZeVgZXZb XdchZgkVYdgZh' € edgfjZ dhZbeg€hi^5g6cdhhƒ Y~d ZggVYdZb dXVh^…Zh bj^id' bVh bj^( id gVgVh)F~d € edhh‚kZa VkVa^Vg V Z[^X^•cX^V YZ hjV ]VW^a^YVYZ Zb [VoZg Zbeg€hi^bdh dWhZgkVcYd(VYjgVciZ jb Y^V'jbV hZbVcV' jb b•h dj ))) Vi€ jb h€Xjad Fd kZg~d YZ ,43-' \gVcYZhWVcXdhVbZg^XVcdheZgYZgVb fjVhZ ijYd fjZ ]Vk^Vb \Vc]VYd cd eVhhVYd$XjbjaVi^kVbZciZ%' fjVhZ ijYd fjZ [VijgVgVb cV ]^hiƒg^VWVcX|g^VVbZg^XVcV( ijYd) =aZhk^c]Vb ˆ
[VoqcYd Zbeg€hi^bdh eVgVeV‚hZhYV9b€g^XV Yd Kja Z YV9b€g^XV ;Zc( igVafjZ YZ^mVgVbYZeV\Vg d fjZ YZk^Vb' idYdh VdbZhbd iZbed ( !jb ZkZcid YZcVijgZoV ZmXZeX^dcVa!) 9hh^b' [d^ cZXZhh|g^dVeZcVhjb kZg~d eVgVfjZ YZhXdWg^hhZb fjZ hZ igViVkVYZ jb cZ\ƒX^d YZ igdjmVh Z fjZ idYdh dh gZcY^bZcidh k^c]Vb YZjb _d\d bj^id Vgg^hXVYd) ZYZgVa JZhZgkZ:Vc` egdiZ\Zj(dh { cdhhV XjhiV5fjVcYd WVcXdh!XdchZgkVYdgZh!i•b ajXgd' d WZcZ[‚X^d€ YZaZh6 fjVcYd h~d aZhVYdh'cƒh eV\Vbdh dh Xjhidh)
e^hXVg YZda]dh' hZb cZc]jb Vk^hd$bV^h'bj^id bV^hhdWgZ ^hhdcd ;V( e‚ijad ,2%5 #
Yj#gVg Y€XVYVh) d^cZXZhh|g^d 2 b^a kZoZhbV^hiZbed ( Yd^hVcdh( eVgVgZXdchigj‚(AVh) =hhVVhh^bZig^V Zb ZhXVaVh iZbedgV^hZmea^XV VY^[^XjaYVYZ Zb hZgZkZgiZg d iZbed)%
G egdWaZbVYd eZgj $iVbW€b Xdc]ZX^YdXdbd d egdWaZbVYV^cYj( •~d%€ bj^id Vci^\d' bVh edg Va\jb bdi^kd € egdkVkZabZciZX]VbVYd YZ!egdWaZbVYZ@jbZ! edg hZj egd[ZhhdgadXVa YZ[^adhd[^V) 9h eZhhdVh^bV\^cVb fjZ cƒh' X€i^Xdh Z Zbe^g^hiVh'hdbdh bdgdhdh' eVgVcƒ^Xdh ZidgijgVYdhZb cdhhVhk^YVh eg^kVYVh' d fjZ edYZhZgd dedh( id ZmVidYdfjZ € gZaViVYd eZaV]^hiƒg^V$Zedg b^c]V ZmeZg^•cX^V eZhhdVa%) ;dbd bj^idh YdhX€i^Xdh Xdb fjZb Xdck^kd'@jbZ ZgVjb O\[ cVcN[a _dk^Va'Vch^dhdedg [VbV a^iZg|g^V' edg [gZf‡ZciVghVa…Zh Z edg XdckZghVh V\gVY|kZ^h) KjVk^YVc~d [d^ ^hZciVYZVcZYdiVh) ;ZgiV kZo' XV^jZb jb e}ciVcd egƒm^bd { XVhV fjZ ZhiVkV Xdchigj^cYdZb =Y^bWjg\d) ^X]iZ'KX]d(
eZc]VjZg Z @Z\Za' @jbZ € d i^ed YZeZchVYdg fjZ' i` cRgR`& € a^YdeZaV eZhhdVfjZ X^iVhjV dWgV)# Gj•d Xdb [gZf‡•cX^V !d egdWaZbV YZ @jbZ! X^iVYdZb a^\V•~d Vd egdWaZbV YV^cY†•~d' bVh d egdWaZbV € Vci^\d' bV^h Vci^\d Yd fjZ d ^ciZgZhhVciZZhXdX•h'iVakZoi~d Vci^\d fjVcid V egƒeg^V [^adhd[^V'iVakZo i~d Vci^\d fjVcid XdckZghVhZb eaVciV•…ZhYZda^kVh)JZidbZbdh VdeVh( hVYd'ed^h ZaZ[d^ [dgbjaVYd Xdb VbZhbV egZX^h~deZadh Vci^\dh)
=hXg^idg k^daZciVbZciZ Vci^VXVY•b^Xd Z ViakahiVVci^Yd\bV' KZmijh =be^g^Xjh Vijdj XZgXV YZjb b^a•c^d Z bZ^d VciZh YZ@jbZ Z [dgbj( adj d egdWaZbV Yd eZgj Xdb \gVcYZ egZX^h~d)KVWZbdhbj^id edjXd hdWgZZaZ6c~d hVWZbdhhZ ZgV[^aƒhd[d dj bV^h jb Xde^hiVYZiZmidh [^( adhƒ[^XdhYZVjidgZh fjZ ]d_Z' eVgVcƒh' h~d dWhXjgdh)HgZhjb^bdh fjZ iZc]V k^k^YdZb 9aZmVcYg^V'cd hZ\jcYd h€Xjad YZcdhhV ZgV)HZgiZcXZj V jbV ZhXdaVYZ bZY^X^cV X]VbVYV !Zbe‚g^XV!' _| fjZ dh egVi^XVciZh Yjk^YVkVb YZ iZdg^VhZ YVXVjhVa^YVYZ' Z Xdc[^VkVb Zb ZmeZg^•cX^Vh eVhhVYVhXdbd dg^ZciV•…Zhcdh igViVbZcidh' bVh hZb YZedh^iVgXdc( [^Vc•V YZbV^h cZaVh)9a€b Y^hhd' c~d Xdc[^VkVb fjZ VVcVidb^V gZkZ( aVhhZ[jc•…Zh i~d dWk^VbZciZ) <^o(hZ fjZ d egdedcZciZ bV^h [Vbdhd YVZhXdaVZbe‚g^XV' EZcdYdid YZF^Xdb€Y^V' fjZ [jcY^j Zbe^g^hbd Z XZi^X^hbd[^adhƒ[^Xd'bVciZkZ VbZY^X^cVjbV [dgbV YZVgiZ' c~d jbV !X^•cX^V!' Z ^hdadj V eg|i^XV Ydh egdWaZbVh YV X^•cX^VYd\b|i^XV) 9 eg|i^XV YVbZY^X^cV Zmea^XVV VY^•~d YZ RZ]V_VPb` $!d Zbe‚g^Xd!% Vd cdbZ YZKZmijh) KZmijhgZegZhZcidj Z XdadXdj cd eVeZa Vh^Y€^VhYVZhXdaVYdh X€i^Xdh e^gg„c^XdhfjZ WjhXVkVbVa\jbV [dgbV YZiZgVe^V^ciZaZXijVagZhjaiVciZ YVhjheZch~d YZXgZc•V)NdX• Zhi| Y^VciZYVedhh^W^a^YVYZ YZjb ZkZcid VYkZghd8F~d hZegZdXjeZ) IjZb hVWZ'ZaZedYZ VXVWVg hZcYd Wdb eVgV kdX•)
)=cigZ VhdWgVhgZbVcZhXZciZhYZKZmijhZhi| jbV Y^Vig^WZ Xdb d WZad i‚ijad 5QcR_`\` ANaURZNaVP\`& dXVh^dcVabZciZigVYjo^YdXdbd 7\[a_N \` ]_\SR``\_R`( :dV eVgiZYZaVedYZg^ViZg h^YdZhXg^iV cV †ai^bV fjVgiV([Z^gV KZmijh€ bV^h ^ciZgZhhVciZeVgVb^c]Vh ^Y€^VhZb hjV gVgVXdbW^cV( ~d YZ[^adhd[^VZ idbVYVh YZYZX^h…Zh Zb hjV eg|i^XV)=aZZgVjb gZVa^oV( qdg' YZ [dgbV fjZ VXVY•b^XdhXa|hh^Xdhc~d Y^oZb Xd^hVhV\gVY|kZ^hV hZj gZheZ^id)Gh b€idYdh YVbZY^X^cVZbe‚g^XV'WVhZVYdh Zb iZciVi^kVhZ ZggdhVeVgZciZbZciZ YZhegdedh^iVYdh'hZg~d [jcYVbZciV^h eVgVb^c]Vh ^Y€^VhhdWgZeaVcZ_VbZcid Z egZk^h~d' hdWgZXdbd WZcZ[^X^Vg(hZ Xdb d ;^hcZ FZ\gd) =b ,443' fjVcYd bZ idgcZ^ ^cYZeZcYZciZ' WVi^oZ^ bZj aVWdgViƒg^d YZ eZhfj^hVh Z ZbegZhV YZcZ\dX^V•~d YZV•…ZhYZ=be^g^XV' c~d eZaVhbZh( bVh gVo…Zh Vci^Yd\b|i^XVh' bVh edg XdciV YVaZbWgVc•Vbj^id bV^h YZ( eg^bZciZ YZfjZ [dgVb cZXZhh|g^dheZad bZcdh bV^h ,/ h€Xjadh hZ\jcYd VZhXdaVYZbZY^X^cVZbe‚g^XVVi€ fjZ VbZY^X^cVbjYVhhZ Z [^cVabZciZ hZidgcVhhZVYd\b|i^XV' YZhXdc[^VYV YZiZdg^oV•…Zh' egd[jcYVbZciZ X€( i^XVZ WVhZVYV Zb egdkVh 9 a^•~d8IjZ iZg XdchX^•cX^VYZjb egdWaZbV c~d h^\c^[^XVbj^iV Xd^hV( ZheZX^VabZciZfjVcYd ^ciZgZhhZhZheZX^V^h Z ^chi^ij^•…ZhfjZ hZgkZb Vh^egƒeg^VhZhi~d Zb _d\d)
d iZgXZ^gdbV^dg eZchVYdg fjZ
a^Ydj Xdb d egdWaZbV[d^ 9a(?]VoVa^' X€( i^XdVgVWƒ[dcdYd h€Xjad PA' Xdc]ZX^YdZb aVi^b Xdbd 9a\VoZa)G cdbZ YVYdedg ZaZeVgVjbV XaVhhZ YZVXVY•b^XdhYd\b|i^Xdh ZgVTUNOV (a^iZ( gVabZciZ' !dh ^bWZX^h!(' jbV [dgbV |gVWZfjZ € bV^h Zc\gV•VYVYd fjZ !^Y^diV!Z bV^h ZmegZhh^kV Yd fjZ !dWhXjgVci^hiV!)9a\VoZa ZhXgZkZjhZj egƒeg^d 7\[a_N \` ]_\SR``\_R`&jbV Y^Vig^WZ X]VbVYV HNUNSbaN=SN=N`VSN& fjZ igVYjod Xdbd !9 ^cXdbeZi•cX^V YV[^adhd[^V!)=aVZgVY^gZX^dcVYV { ZhXdaV SN=N`VSNU ' d ZhiVWa^h]bZci^ciZaZXijVa|gVWZZgVd ]ZgYZ^gdY^gZid 8V [^adhd[^VXa|hh^XV YVVXVYZb^V'Z ZaZhXdchZ\j^gVb gZXdcX^a^|(AV Xdb d Aha~ edg bZ^d YVVg\jbZciV•~d gVX^dcVa) G ViVfjZ YZ9a\VoZa Vd Xdc]ZX^bZcid !X^Zci‚[^Xd!^c^X^dj jb YZWViZ ;db 9kZggdZh' d [^aƒhd[d bZY^ZkVafjZ VXVWdjZmZgXZcYdV ^c[aj•cX^V bV^h egd[jcYV YZfjVafjZg eZchVYdg bZY^ZkVa$hdWgZ_jYZjh Z Xg^hi~dh' bVh c~d hdWgZbj•jabVcdh%) G YZWViZ ZcigZ 9a\VoZa Z 9kZggdZh [d^ edg [^b' bVh ^c[Za^obZciZ' kZcX^Ydedg VbWdh)=b hZj gVhigd'bj^idh eZchV(
YdgZhgZa^\^dhdh|gVWZh^ciZ\gVgVb Z ZmV\ZgVgVbd XZi^X^hbdYZ9a\VoZ, Zb gZaV•~dVd b€idYd X^Zci‚[^Xd'egZ[Zg^cYdYZ^mVg Xdch^YZgV•…Zh XVjhV^h VXVg\dYZ
=cfjVcid dh X€i^XdhVci^\dh YZ[ZcY^Vb V ^\cdg}cX^V VegZcY^YVXdbd d eg^bZ^gd eVhhd Zb ^cYV\V•…Zh ]dcZhiVh Zb Y^gZ•~dYVkZgYVYZ'dh X€i^Xdh bZY^ZkV^hfjZ k^ZgVb YZed^h'iVcid bj•jabVcdh fjVcid Xg^hi~dh'jhVgVb d XZi^X^hbdXdbd jbV [ZggVbZciVeVgVZk^iVgVVXZ^iV•~dYd fjZ X]VbV( bdh ]d_Z YZX^•cX^V) ;gZc•V cV ^bedgi}cX^V Yd egdWaZbVYd ;^hcZ FZ\gd' egZdXjeV•…ZhhdWgZ^cYj•~d Z d XZi^X^hbdedYZb [VoZgXdb fjZ Va\jch Vg\jbZcidh gZa^\^dhdq[^fjZb bV^h VigVZciZh'hZWZb fjZ YZ[dgbV h^b( ea^[^XVYV' Vci^XaZg^XVa ZiZ‚hiV)=hhV^Y€^VYZhZXdc[^VgcV [€' Zc~d cV gVo~d' ZgVXdc]ZX^YVXdbd [^YZ‚hbd) 9hh^b' Zm^hiZjbV igVY^•~dYZ X€i^XdhYd ;^hcZ FZ\gd fjZ ZcXdcigVb gZ[†\^d cV gZa^\^~d'gZegZhZciVYdheg^cX^eVa( bZciZ edg H^ZggZ:VnaZ' [gVcXƒ[dcd egdiZhiVciZ ZgjY^id' [^aƒhd[dZiZƒad\d' fjZ' Zm^aVYd cV @daVcYV'Xdchigj^j jbV ZmiZchVVgfj^iZijgV [^adhƒ[^XV gZ( aVX^dcVYV VdhX€i^Xdhe^gg„c^Xdh)Gh iZmidhYZ:VnaZ ZmZgXZgVb ^c[aj•cX^V Xdch^YZg|kZahdWgZ@jbZ' VegZhZciVcYd(dVd XZi^X^hbdVci^\d ( Vedcid YZ @jbZ VWgV•Vg ^Y€^Vh(YZ :VnaZ Zb \gVcYZ ZhXVaV) G 8VRaV\[NV_R UV`a\' _V^bRRaP_VaV^bR YZ:VnaZ [d^ VdWgVVXVY•b^XV bV^h a^YVYd h€Xjad PNAAA' bVh' Xdbd bj^idh Ydh bZjh ]Zgƒ^h [gVcXZhZh$Xdbd >g€Y€g^X:Vhi^Vi%' :VnaZ c~d eVgZXZhZgeVgiZ Yd Xjgg‚Xjad [gVcX•hZ € fjVhZ ^bedhh‚kZa YZ hZgZcXdcigVYdZb hjV a‚c\jV dg^\^cVa'd [gVcX•h)G bZhbd VXdciZXZXdb F^XdaVhYZ9jigZXdjgi' hZ\j^Ydg YZ9a\VoZaYd h€Xjad PAN) FV kZgYVYZ'c~d € jb [Vid bj^id Xdc]ZX^Yd fjZ V Zmedh^•~d bV^h XdbeaZiV YVh^Y€^VhYd XZi^X^hbd' Vi€ gZXZciZbZciZ' eZgbVcZ•V hZcYd V dWgVYZ jb W^hedXViƒa^XdedYZgdhd fjZ [d^ jb bZbWgd Vj\jhid YV
9XVYZb^V>gVcXZhV)H^ZggZ(
EVh egdbdkZg d XZi^X^hbd[^adhƒ[^Xdc~d € ZmViVbZciZVb^hh~d YZhiZa^( kgd) KZVXdchX^•cX^V Yd egdWaZbVYd ;^hcZ FZ\gd edYZ cdh aZkVg{ VWh( i^c•cX^VZ Vd XZi^X^hbdZmigZbd' h^\d Vfj^ V Y^gZ•~dZmViVbZciZdedhiV) =hidj ^ciZgZhhVYdZb [Z^idh Z cd Zbe^g^hbd kZgYVYZ^gd) 9hh^b' d a^kgd c~d [d^ ZhXg^idedg jb b‚hi^Xd hj[^' cZb edg jb X€i^Xdcd hZci^YdVci^\d dj bZY^ZkVa'cZb bZhbd $Xdbd kZgZbdh%Zb jb hZci^Yd[^adhƒ[^Xd'bVh edg jb egVi^XVciZXj_d dW_Zi^kdeg^cX^eVa€ c~d hZgigdjmV cVh Xd^hVhfjZ ^ciZgZhhVb'Z edcid [^cVa) @jbZ ZgVgVY^XVabZciZX€i^Xdcd YZeVgiVbZcid [^adhƒ[^Xd'bVh VWVc( Ydcdj iV^h^Y€^Vh fjVcYd d Vhhjcid ZgVVk^YVXdi^Y^VcV'_| fjZ c~d Xdc( hZ\j^V a^YVgXdb ZaVh)=hidj [VoZcYd Vfj^ _jhid d Xdcig|g^d5 hdj X€i^Xd Zb fjZhi…ZhfjZ edhhjZb ^bea^XV•…Zh cV k^YVXdi^Y^VcV)
YZg^hXdh $kZgZbdhfjZ [VkdgZ•djb i^ed V\gZhh^kd YZZmedh^•~dVg^hXdh%5 ijYd fjZ bdhigVgZ^€ Xdbd Zk^iVgVigVkZhhVg VgjV QR\YU\` cR[QNQ\`(
ƒh !ZcigVbdh Zb i†cZ^h!5dj hZ_V'XdcXZcigVbd(cdhZb edjXVh + F
[dciZh WZb YZ[^c^YVh YZ^cXZgiZoV' Zb jbV a^hiVZheZX‚[^XV YZbV^h YZ;^hcZh FZ\gdh #g XjhiVYdhdjigdh fjZ c~d cdh dXdggZb[VX^a( bZciZ%)
9XVWdYZVegZhZciVg d egdWaZbVYd;^hcZ FZ\gd Zb hjV [dgbV ]^hiƒg^XV5 VY^[^XjaYVYZ XZcigVaYZhZ\ZcZgVa^oVg VeVgi^gYV^c[dgbV•~d Y^hedc‚( kZa'dj YZhZVegZcYZgXdb d eVhhVYd'd Xdc]ZX^YdZ d k^hid)LVbW€b VegZhZciZ^ V a^hiVYVfjZaVhfjZ' VXgZY^id' h~d Vh[^\jgVh ]^hiƒg^XVh bV^h gZaZkVciZh) HdYZ(hZkZgfjZ cdh € ZmigZbVbZciZXdckZc^ZciZhjedg fjZ k^kZbdh cd EZY^dXg^hi~d) Hdgfj•8 HdgfjZ ^hhdeZgb^iZfjZ ZmXajVbdhVhhjgegZ( hVhYd ;^hcZ FZ\gd G egdWaZbVYd ;^hcZ FZ\gd dj c~d Zm^hiZ dj iZb edjXV ^bedgi}cX^V'hZkdX•k^kZcd EZY^dXg^hi~d) LVahjedh^•~d XdcYjo bV\^XVbZciZVdegdWaZbVYV^cYj•~d' fjZ YZh( YZKZmijh=be^g^XjhkZb V[a^\^cYdV]^hiƒg^VYdeZchVbZcid) G ZhiVi‚hi^( XdedYZa^kgVg(hZ YVZe^hiZbdad\^V) U IjZb cdh YZgVF~d k^kZbdh cd EZY^dXg^hi~d' edgiVcid d ;^hcZ FZ( \gd egZX^hV YZjbV bZciVa^YVYZ Y^[ZgZciZ) ;dbd c~d edYZbdh kVggZgd egdWaZbVeVgVWV^md Yd iVeZiZ'egZX^hVgZbdh Zmeadg|(AdbV^hegd[jcYV( bZciZ) =hhVc~d € jqV Y^[^XjaYVYZ iZgb^cVa( Z edYZbdh Vi€bZhbd cdh WZcZ[^X^Vg Xdb ZaV) 9\dgV' Zm^hiZbdjigdh iZbVhfjZ hjg\Zb YZcdhhVXZ\jZ^gV Zb gZaV•~d Vd;^hcZ FZ\gd5 V)Fƒh cdh XdcXZcigVbdhZb hZ\bZcidh eg€(hZaZX^dcVYdh Yd k^hidZ \ZcZgVa^oVbdh VeVgi^gYZaZh eVgVd c~d(k^hid5d ZggdYVXdc[^gbV( •~d) W)Fƒh cdh Zc\VcVbdh Xdb ]^hiƒg^VhfjZ hVX^Vb cdhhVhZYZeaVi„c^XV edg eVYg…Zh Y^hi^cidh5 V[Va|X^V cVggVi^kV) X)Fƒh cdh XdbedgiVbdh Xdbd hZ? ;^hcZ FZ\gd c~d Zm^hi^hhZ5 VcV( ijgZoV]jbVcV c~d € egd\gVbVYVeVgV;^hcZh FZ\gdh) Y) G fjZ kZbdh c~d € cZXZhhVg^VbZciZ ijYd fjZ Zhi| a|) 9 ]^hiƒg^V dXjaiVdh ;^hcZh FZ\gdh YZcƒh Z igVchb^iZ(cdhjbV ^Y€^V Zgg„cZV VXZgXV YVhegdWVW^a^YVYZh YZiV^hZkZcidh5ZhhV€ VY^hidg•~dYVZk^( Y•cX^V h^aZcX^dhV)
<^hXji^gZ^XVYV jb Ydhedcidh cdh X^cXdXVe‚ijadhhZ\j^ciZh)=ci~d' cV XdcXajh~dYVHVgiZMb' bdhigVgZ^Xdbd' cV eg|i^XV'h~d d ZR`Z\ iƒe^Xd)
-BPgTULO-JNDO
-7603:5+\[7
-73;+
6/62=5+
.O N@HCINIDM
^\jgV, cd ;Ve‚ijad /6 Va\j€b fjZ iZc]VdWhZgkVYd
dh#eg^bZ^gdh b^a Y^Vh YdeZgj $bVhc~d d X]dfjZ Ydb^a€h^bdeg^bZ^gd% Y^( g^V'ZXdggZiVbZciZ' fjZ [l\ Uj RcVQo[PVN YVedhh^W^a^YVYZ YZ\gVcYZhZkZc( idK'dj hZ_V' YZ;^hcZh FZ\gdh) ;dcijYd' kdX•egdkVkZabZciZXdc[jcY^g^V ZhhV YZXaVgV•~d' ZheZX^VabZciZ hZc~d egZhiVg bj^iV ViZc•~d'Xdb VYZXaVgV( •~d YZfjZ ]| RcVQo[PVN QR[R[UbZN ]\``VOVYVQNQR YZ;^hcZhFZ\gdh)9eZhVg YZcVkZgYVYZ hZg\gVcYZ'VY^hi}cX^V aƒ\^XVZcigZVhYjVhV[^gbV•…Zh eVgZ( XZg|bj^id eZfjZcV Zb hjVbZciZ' YZ[dgbV fjZ jbV edhhVhZg[VX^abZciZ hjWhi^ij‚YV eZaVdjigV)
fjZ VX]VkZYd hjXZhhd cZb hZbegZ € iVaZcid' ZaVhVX]Vb fjZ kdX• Zhi| Y^oZcYdfjZ cjcXV € iVaZcid' bVh hZbegZ hdgiZ) Fdhhd bVfj^c| g^dYZYji^kd' VfjZaZ fjZ jhVbdh cV k^YVXdi^Y^VcV' c~d [d^ [Z^ideVgVjb VbW^ZciZXdbea^XVYdcd fjVa jbV YZXaVgV•~d € VaiZgVYV YZ bdYd h^\c^[^XVi^kdfjVcYd hjV Xdchigj•~d € aZkZbZciZ bdY^[^XVYV) ;dch^YZgZ fjZ Zb jb VbW^ZciZeg^b^i^kd c~d ]| jbV Y^[ZgZc•VbVgXVc( iZ ZcigZ VhYZXaVgV•…Zh N ZNV\_VNQ\` N``N``V[\` `l\ N[VZNV` `RYcNTR[`Z N ZNV\_VNQ\` N[VZNV` `RYcNTR[``l\ N``N``V[\`( =m^hiZjb ZggdVfj^' bVh ZaZ € fjVhZ hZb ^bedgi}cX^V) FdhhVh ^cij^•…ZhZhiVi‚hi^XVh c~d Zkdaj‚gVb eVgV jb ]VW^iViZb fjZ iV^hhji^aZoVhedhhVb [VoZg\gVcYZ Y^[ZgZc•V)
H\Q\` \` g\\TYR` `l\ O\\TYR`(J\Po cVb bZ O\\TYR(9YRn bZ g\\TYR4F~d cZXZh( hVg^VbZciZ']\V` [RZ a\Q\` \` O\\TYR``l\ g\\TYR`( 9YdaZhXZciZhfjZ ZggVbVd gZhedcYZgV ZhhZi^ed YZfjZhi~d cd K9La edYZb c~d XdchZ\j^g ZcigVgcV jc^kZgh^YVYZ) Fd ZciVcid' djigV eZhhdVedYZ dWiZgjbV edcijV•~d bj^id VaiVcd K9L ZV^cYVhZci^gjbV edciVYVYZbZYd fjVcYd Va\j€b Yd aVYdZg( gVYdYVX^YVYZ ZcigVcd ZaZkVYdg) =hhV^cVW^a^YVYZ YZigVch[Zg^g VjidbVi^XV( bZciZ Xdc]ZX^bZcid Zhd[^hi^XV•~d YZjbV h^ijV•~d eVgVdjigV' dj YViZdg^V eVgVVeg|i^XV'€ jb Vig^WjidWVhiVciZ eZgijgWVYdgYVcVijgZoV]jbVcV) ;]VbZbdh ^hhdYZV R`]RPVSVPVQNQR QRQ\Zp[V\ YZcdhhVhgZV•…Zh) Hdg ZheZX^[^X^YVYZ YZ Ydb‚c^d fjZgd Y^oZgfjZ cdhhVh gZV•…Zh'cdhhd bdYd YZeZchVg' cdhhVh ^cij^•…Zh' YZeZcYZb Yd XdciZmid Zb fjZ VbVi€g^V € VegZhZciVYV'd fjZ eh^Xƒad\dh ZkdajX^dc|g^dh X]VbVb YZ!Ydb‚c^d! Yd dW_Ziddj Yd ZkZcid) 9 hVaVYZ VjaV € jb Ydb‚c^d' V k^YVgZVa€ djigd) JZV\^bdh VjbV ^c[dgbV•~d c~d edg hZj b€g^id aƒ\^Xd Z h^b iZcYd edg WVhZVZhigjijgV eZaVfjVa € Zckdak^YV'Z Xdbd € gZ\^higVYVZb cdhhd h^h( iZbV hdX^dZbdX^dcVa)HgdWaZbVhaƒ\^Xdh VWdgYVYdh YZjbV bVcZ^gV cV hVaVYZVjaVedYZb hZgigViVYdhYZbdYd Y^[ZgZciZcV k^YVXdi^Y^VcV) FV kZgYVYZ'`l\ igViVYdhY^[ZgZciZbZciZ cV k^YVXdi^Y^VcV) ;dc]ZX^bZcid' bZhbd fjVcYd ZmVid'c~d XdhijbV aZkVgVV•…Zh Vegd( eg^VYVhedgfjZ iZcYZbdh VZhfjZXZgd fjZ hVWZbdh'dj VZhfjZXZgXdbd
;
K^\aVZb ^c\a•h eVgVd KX]daVhi^X 9ei^ijYZ LZhi S=mVbZYZ9ei^Y~d =hXda|hi^XVB' egdkV fjZ ZhijYVciZh hZXjcYVg^hiVh VbZg^XVcdhi•b fjZ [VoZgVciZh YZ ^c\gZhhVgcV qc^kZgh^YVYZ) $F) Q\ H($
6dXZhh|(AdVYZfjVYVbZciZ hZc~d egZhiVgbdh ViZc•~d' bZhbd fjVcYd 6dgcdh ZheZX^Va^hiVh) >d^ YZbdchigVYd fjZ ZhiVi‚hi^XdhiZcYZb VYZ^mVg d X€gZWgd cV hVaVYZVjaVZ XdbZiZb dh ZggdhYZYji^kdh bV^h ig^k^V^hfjVc( Yd h~d hdaidh cVh gjVh) =b ,42,' dh eh^Xƒad\dh
[Z^idhi^e^XVbZciZZb eVX^ZciZh fjZ YZhZ_Vb hVWZg hZZhi~dXjgVYdhdj hZ ]| !gZXdgg•cX^V!) $FVkZgYVYZ' gZXdgg•cX^V € jb iZgbd Zgg„cZd6ZaVh^\c^[^( XVh^beaZhbZciZfjZ d igViVbZcidc~d bVidj idYVhVhX€ajaVh XVcXZgdhVh Z fjZ ZhhVh X€ajaVh bVa^\cVhc~d YZiZXiVYVh XdbZ•VgVbVhZbjai^ea^XVgYZh( XdcigdaVYVbZciZ)% F~d € k^|kZa'cd ZhiVYdVijVaYViZXcdad\^V'ZmVb^cVg XVYV X€ajaV YdeVX^ZciZ eVgVhVWZg hZidYVhh~dc~d(bVa^\cVh'YZ[dgbV fjZ d b€Y^XddWi€b jbV VbdhigVZhXVcZVcYd d XdgedXdb d b|m^bd edhh‚kZa YZegZX^h~d) =ci~d' ZaZ[VojbV hjedh^•~d VXZgXV YdfjZ c~d k^j) MbV kZo' [^fjZ^X]dXVYd fjVcYd jb b€Y^XdY^hhZ eVgVb^b YZed^hYZjb X]ZX`(je YZX}cXZg YZgdi^cV5!HVgZYZhZegZdXjeVg'iZbdh Zk^Y•cX^V YZXjgV)!!Hdg fj•8!' eZg\jciZ^) !=m^hiZZk^Y•cX^V YZfjZ HWI Uj X}cXZg!'[d^ VgZhedhiV) !;dbd kdX•hVWZ8!' eZg\jciZ^) =aZgZhedcYZj5!G `PN[ YZj cZ\Vi^kd)!9^c( YVVhh^b'ZaZXdci^cjVkVVcYVcYdedg V‚Y^oZcYd(hZ b€Y^Xd Mb VXg„c^bd jhVYd cV a^iZgVijgV b€Y^XV€ F=<' fjZ h^\c^[^XV FZ( c]jbV =k^Y•cX^V YZ
jbV ji^a^YVYZ fjZ ZhXVeVkV { YZiZX•~d) G bZhbd Xdb V[^WgV Va^bZciVg ZcXdcigVYV Zb [gjiVhZkZ\ZiV^h5 cVY€XVYV YZ,41+' b€Y^XdhVXdch^YZgV( gVb ^c†i^aedgfjZ c~d k^gVb fjVafjZg Zk^Y•cX^V ^bZY^ViV YZhjV cZXZh( h^YVYZ' ZXdb ^hhdXg^VgVb jbV \ZgV•~dbVacjig^YV)
HdgbZ^d YZjb bZXVc^hbd bZciVa fjZ X]Vbd YZZbe^g^hbd ^c\•cjd' iZbdh jbV iZcY•cX^VcVijgVaVegdXjgVgedg ^chi}cX^Vh fjZ Xdc[^gbVb cdhhV]^hiƒg^VZcdhhVk^h~dYdbjcYd ( iV^h^chi}cX^Vh h~dhZbegZ[|XZ^h YZhZZcXdcigVg)Ac[Za^obZciZ'Xdb [ZggVbZciVhZ Xdb idadh' fjVafjZg Xd^hV edYZ hZg[|X^aYZhZZcXdcigVg)NdX• eZ\V ^chi}cX^Vh eVhhVYVh fjZ XdggdWdgVb hjVhiZdg^Vh Z igViV(Vh Xdbd ]_\cN`( HdgZmZbead'jb Y^ead( bViVbdhigVg| VkdX•hjVh!gZVa^oV•…Zh!' Zc~d d fjZ c~d XdchZ\j^j [VoZg) EViZb|i^Xdh iZciVg~dXdckZcX•(Ad YZfjZ VX^•cX^V YZaZh € †i^aeVgVVhd( X^ZYVYZ ^cY^XVcYd ^chi}cX^Vh Zb fjZ hZbdhigdj Xdbd iVa'Z c~d dcYZ[d^ jb YZheZgY‚X^d YZiZbed' dj' e^dg' VfjZaVhcjbZgdhVh Vea^XV•…Zh bViZ( b|i^XVh fjZ ^c[a^\^gVbjb \gVcYZXjhid { hdX^ZYVYZ YZk^Yd{ cVijgZoV c~d(Zbe‚g^XVYVhiZdg^Vh bViZb|i^XVhZaZ\VciZh) EZhbd VdiZhiVgjbV ]^eƒiZhZ' iZcYZbdh VegdXjgVgedg ^chi}cX^Vh Zb fjZ V]^eƒiZhZegdkZ hZgkZgYVYZ^gV) e XaVgd fjZ edYZbdh ZcXdcigVg Xdc[^gbV•…Zh [VX^abZciZ6 ijYd fjZ egZX^hVbdh [VoZg€ egdXjgVg'dj [VoZg Xdb fjZ jb eZhfj^hVYdg[V•V^hhdedg cƒh) =j edhhd R[P\[a_N_P\[SV_ZN' XWI eVgVegVi^XVbZciZ fjVafjZg Xd^hV'Vhh^bXdbd jb bdidg^hiV YZi|m^ ]VW^a^Ydhd YZDdcYgZhXdchZ\jZ ZcXdcigVgd ig}ch^id eVgVVjbZciVg d kVadgYVXdgg^YV' bZhbd Zb jb [Zg^VYd) 9a\jbVh eZhhdVhk~d bV^hVa€bZbZ Y~dZmZbeadhYZZkZcidhfjZ [d( bdh XVeVoZh YZegZkZgXdb Va\jb hjXZhhd( ZgZVabZciZZm^hiZbVa\jch'
Xdbd VViZgg^hhV\Zb YZjb ]dbZb cV ajV Z d XgZhX^bZcidZXdc„b^Xd Yd h€XjadPPA) e edhh‚kZaZcXdcigVgbj^iVh !XdcigVegdkVh!eVgVdh edc( idh Xdci^YdhcZhiZa^kgd'Z VbZa]dg YZaVh € fjZ _dgcV^hh~dZmXZaZciZh cV egZk^h~dYZ]dg|g^dh #YZ X^cZbVZYZiZVigd)NZ_Vhƒ' egZk^dciZb fjZ d hda cVhXZg^V ]d_Z' ZZaZcVhXZj
9 WdVcdi‚X^V€ fjZ Zm^hiZ jbV [dgbV YZhZXdcidgcVgd Zbe^g^hbd ^c\•( cjd) =hidj Y^oZcYdfjZ jbV h€g^ZYZ[VidhXdggdWdgVi^kdh c~d € [RPR``N' _VNZR[aRZk^Y•cX^V) NZgX^hcZh WgVcXdh c~d Xdc[^gbVVc~d Zm^hi•cX^V YZ X^hcZhcZ\gdh) ;dcijYd' Zm^hiZ jbV ZmXZ•~d5 Zj hZ^fjVa V[^gbV•~dZhi| ZggVYV' bVh c~d cZXZhhVg^VbZciZ fjVa V[^gbV•~dZhi| XdggZiV) KZkZ_djb X^hcZcZ\gd' edhhd Xdc[^gbVgfjZ a\Q\` \` PV`[R`[l\ `l\ O_N[P\` KZkZ_dVa( \j€b bViVgjbV eZhhdV'edhhd ZhiVgegVi^XVbZciZ XZgidYZfjZ € jb Xg^( b^cdhd) KZc~d d kZ_dbViVgVa\j€b' c~d edhhd iZgXZgiZoV fjZ € ^cdXZciZ) G bZhbd Vea^XV(hZ g YZiZX•~d YZX}cXZg5 VYZhXdWZgiV YZjb †c^Xdijbdg bVa^\cd egdkVfjZ kdX•iZb X}cXZg'bVh VVjh•cX^VYZiVaYZhXdWZgiV c~d edYZeZgb^i^gfjZ kdX•Y^\VXdb XZgiZoV fjZ c~d iZb X}cXZg) HdYZbdh X]Z\VgbV^heZgid YVkZgYVYZ VigVk€hYZ^chi}cX^Vh cZ\Vi^( kVh'c~d edg kZg^[^XV•qd e Zc\Vcdhd Xdchigj^gjbV gZ\gV\ZgVaVeVgi^g YZ[VidhdWhZgkVYdh) ;dcig|g^d g hVWZYdg^V XdckZcX^dcVa' cdhhd XdgedYZ Xdc]ZX^bZcid c~d VjbZciV VeVgi^gYZjbV h€g^ZYZdWhZgkV•…Zh Xdc( [^gbViƒg^Vh' Vhh^bXdbd d Yd eZgj) EVh Zm^hiZbVa\jbVh Xd^hVh hdWgZ Vh fjV^h edhhd eZgbVcZXZgX€i^Xd'ZdjigVh fjZ edhhd hZ\jgVbZciZ Xdch^YZ( gVgXZgiVh) AhhdidgcVjc^aViZgV^h VhXdchZf‡•cX^Vh YVhdWhZgkV•…Zh) F~d € bj^id bV^hY^[‚X^a Yd fjZ ^hhd) =hhVVhh^bZig^V € ^bZchVbZciZ eg|i^XV)=aVcdh Y^ofjZ c~d egZX^hVbdh hZgXdbeaZiVbZciZX€i^Xdh' VeZqVhhZb^X€i^Xdh) 9 hji^aZoVYVk^YVgZVa Zb gZaV•~dVdha^kgdh€ fjZ' cVidbVYVYZYZX^h…Zh' kdX•egZX^hV ZhiVg^ciZgZh( hVYdZb VeZcVhjb aVYdYV]^hiƒg^V5hZkdX• WjhXViZg PR_aRgN fjZ d eV( X^ZciZiZb X}cXZgdj c~d' Zc~d iZgPR_aRgN fjZ € hVjY|kZa'Zci~d edYZg| [^XVg hVi^h[Z^id Xdb jbV ^c[Zg•cX^V cZ\Vi^kV'_| fjZ ZaVa]Z egdedgX^dcVg| VXZgiZoV fjZ egdXjgV)=ci~d' edYZbdh VegZcYZg bj^id VeVgi^gYZYVYdh ( bVh c~d iVcid fjVcid ZheZgVbdh)vh kZoZh'jb \gVcYZkdajbZ YZ YVYdhedYZ hZghZb hZci^Yd6Zb djigVh' jbV †c^XVeZ•VYZ^c[dgbV•~d
eƒYZ hZgbj^id h^\c^[^XVi^kV) e kZgYVYZ fjZ b^a Y^Vhc~d edYZb egdkVg fjZ kdX• Zhi| XZgid'bVh jb Y^VedYZegdkVgfjZ Zhi| ZggVYd) 9 eZhhdVfjZ egdbdkZj ZhhV^Y€^V YZhZb^XZi^X^hbd jc^aViZgVa [d^K^g d^jb egZhZciZfjZ \Vc]Z^ Zb Ejc^fjZ Yd ZchV‚hiV Bd( X]Zc OZ\cZg' fjZ' Xdbd Zj' Xdch^YZgV HdeeZg egVi^XVbZciZijYd !fjZ iZbdh! ZcigZdh eZchVYdgZh bdYZgcdh ( WZb' fjVhZ) =aZZhXgZkZ eVgV cƒh' c~d eVgVdjigdh [^aƒhd[dh)!Fƒh! hdbdh dh idbVYdgZhYZYZX^h~d bdYZgcdh fjZ YZ[ZcYZbfjZ V^cXZgiZoV € cdhhVY^hX^ea^cV ZfjZ VXdb( egZZch~dYZXdbd V\^ghdWgZXdcY^•…Zh YZ^c[dgbV•…Zh^cXdbeaZiVh€ V bV^hZaZkVYV ZbV^hjg\ZciZ YVhWjhXVh ]jbVcVh) HdeeZg \Zgdj jbV iZdg^VZb aVg\VZhXVaV Zb idgcd YZhhV Vhh^bZig^V' WVhZVYV Zb jbV i€Xc^XV X]VbVYV![Vah^[^XV•~d! $[Vah^[^XVg € egdkVgfjZ Va\dZhi| ZggVYd%' YZhi^cVYV VY^hi^c\j^gZcigZX^•cX^V Z c~d(X^•cX^V'Z Vh eZhhdVhXdbZ•VgVb^bZY^ViVbZciZVhZXdcXZcigVg Zb b^c†X^VhhdWgZ hjVhiZXc^XVa^YVYZh' VeZhVg YZZaVc~d hZgVbV^h^ciZgZhhVciZ' cZb VbV^h dg^\^cVa'YVh^Y€^Vh YZHdeeZg)=hhV^Y€^V hdWgZVVhh^bZig^V Yd Xdc]ZX^( bZcid € i~d VegZX^VYV edg egVi^XVciZh edgfjZ a]Zh€ ƒWk^V6 € Vhh^bfjZ VYb^c^higVbhZjh cZ\ƒX^dh)G [^aƒhd[dZNbQVa ;]VgaZh KVcYZgh HZ^gXZ' fjZ' Xdbd Vgi^hiV'hƒ dWiZkZgZheZ^idedhijbVbZciZ' iVbW€b YZhZc( k8akZj jbV kZgh~dYZhhVhdaj•~d eVgVd ;^hcZ FZ\gd fjVcYd HdeeZg VbYVjhVkV[gVaYVh ( Va\jbVh eZhhdVhVi€VX]VbVgVbYZVWdgYV\Zb YZ5Z^gXZ( HdeeZg)9 ^Y€^V bj^id bV^hedYZgdhVZdg^\^cVaYZHdeeZg € V hdXAZYVYZ !VWZgiV!' fjZ Xdc[^Vcd XZi^X^hbdXdbd jb Z\Qb` \]R_N[QV& gZXjhVcYdZ gZh^hi^cYd VkZgYVYZh YZ[^c^i^kVh) =aZVXjhdj HAV i~d YZ[ZX]Vg hVh cdh) bZciZh' hZ\jcYd dh Vg\jbZcidh fjZ YZhXgZk^ cd Hgƒad\d) EVh V bVAdg^Y€^V YZHdeeZg [d^ hZj ^ch^\]i gZaVi^kd{ ^begZk^h^W^a^YVYZ [jc( YVbZciVa'\gVkZZ ^cXjg|kZaYd bjcYd ( YZ^mVgZ^ ^hhdeVgVd XVe‚ijad hdWgZ egZk^h…Zh)#
ˆ G eg^bZ^gd VXdcXZWZg ZhhVVhh^bZig^Vc~d [d^ HZ^gXZ cZb HdeeZg) =b ,323' d [^aƒhd[dN^X( idg :gdX]VgY bZcX^dcdj V^bedgi}cX^V Yd Zbe^g^hbd cZ\Vi^kd Xdbd hZ[dhhZjbV fjZhi~d YZ[ZcY^YV eZadh Zbe^g^hiVhXdbd V[dgbV bV^h hVjY|kZa YZhZgZVa^oVg cZ\ƒX^dh ( dh Vci^( \dh VXdbegZZcY^Vb ^bea^X^iVbZciZ) D^kgdhZh\diVYdhegdedgX^dcVb bj^iVh hjgegZhVh)
GWk^VbZciZ'c~d € [|X^a![Vah^[^XVg!' dj hZ_V'V[^gbVgfjZ Va\dZhi| Zg( gVYdXdb XZgiZoV VWhdajiV) AbeZg[Z^•…Zh cd b€idYd YZiZhiV\Zb edYZb VegZhZciVg jb !c~d! 5fj^kdXVYd)G)b€Y^XdfjZ egdqjgq X€ajaVq qVcXZ( gdhVhedYZiZgjb Zfj^eVbZcid YZ[ZiijdhdfjZ XVjhZ^ajhdZhY)ZdiaX)V' dj edYZg^VhZgjb ZXdcdb^hiVfjZ ji^a^oVVXjgkVcV 5dgbV YZh)bd Yah[Vq( •VYdYZb€Y^Xd)MbV iZhiZbjc]V dXjaVgYZjb XcbZ edYZcVZhiVgW)Z( WVYV) AN` \ PN`\ P\[aV[bN `R[Q\ ^bR c\Po `NOR\ ^bR R`aj R__NQ\P\Z ZIYa\ ZNV` PR_aRgN Q\ ^bR \ ^bR `NOR^bR R`aj PR_a\(LdYVhVheZ•VhYZ^c[dgbV•~d c~d h~dYZ^\jVa^bedgi}cX^V) HdeeZg^cigdYjo^j d bZXVc^hbdYZXdc_ZXijgVh ZgZ[jiV•…Zh' fjZ [jc( X^dcVYVhZ\j^ciZ bVcZ^gV5kdX• [dgbjaV jbV Xdc_ZXijgV$Zk^YZciZ% Z XdbZ•V VegdXjgVgeZaVdWhZgkV•~d fjZ egdkVg| fjZ kdX• Zhi| ZggVYd) =hhV€ VVaiZgcVi^kV eVgVcdhhVWjhXVedg ^chi}cX^Vh Xdc[^gbViƒg^Vh) KZ kdX• eZchVfjZ ZhhViVgZ[V € [|X^a'[^XVg|YZXZeX^dcVYd ( edjXdh ]jbV( cdh edhhjZb V]VW^a^YVYZ cVijgVaYZ[VoZg^hhd);dc[Zhhd fjZ c~d hdj jb YZaZh6 ^hhdc~d bZ dXdggZcVijgVabZciZ)
"-,0*,+-
*01 0.2/
;^Zci^hiVhXd\c^i^kdhZhijYVgVbcdhhViZcY•cX^VcVijgVaVegdXjgVghd( bZciZ edg XdggdWdgV•…Zh6 ZaZhX]VbVb ZhhVkjacZgVW^a^YVYZ VdZggdYV XdggdWdgV•~d YZ cVn` P\[SV_ZNaq_V\( =m^hiZbVa\jch ZmeZg^bZcidhfjZ YZbdchigVb fjZ VheZhhdVhhZXdcXZcigVbVeZcVhcdh a^kgdha^YdhcV W^Wa^diZXV YZMbWZgid=Xd)HdYZ(hZiZhiVgjbV gZ\gVZheZX‚[^XV Y^gZiV( bZciZ' dWhZgkVcYd Vh^chi}cX^VhZb fjZ [jcX^dcV' dj ^cY^gZiVbZciZ' XdcXZcigVcYd(hZ cVhZb fjZ c~d [jcX^dcV);dbd k^bdh VciZg^dgbZciZ' ^chi}cX^Vh c~d(Xdc[^gbViƒg^Vhh~d bj^id bV^hedYZgdhVhcd ZhiVWZaZX^( bZcid YVkZgYVYZ) 9^cYVVhh^b'iZcYZbdh Vc~d iZg XdchX^•cX^V YZhhV egdeg^ZYVYZ)) ) G eg^bZ^gdZmeZg^bZcidfjZ Xdc]Z•d Zb idgcd YZhhZ[Zc„bZcd [GA [Z^ideZad eh^Xƒad\dH) ;) OVhdc) =aZVegZhZcidj {h XdWV^Vh VhZf‡•c( X^VYZig•h c†bZgdh -' /' 1 Z eZY^j(A]ZhfjZ VY^k^c]VhhZbV gZ\gVfjZ V \ZgVkV)G b€idYd YZVY^k^c]V•~dZgVegdYjo^g djigVh hZf‡•cX^VhY6 ig•h c†bZgdh' {h fjV^h d ZmeZg^bZciVYdg gZhedcYZg^V !h^b! dj !c~d# ' YZeZcYZcYdhZVhcdkVhhZf‡•cX^VhZgVbXdch^hiZciZh Xdb VgZ\gV)MbV kZo Xdc[^VciZhXdb VhgZhedhiVh'VhXdWV^Vh YZkZg^Vb[dgbjaVi VgZ\gV) $GWhZgkZ Vh^b^aVg^YVYZ Yd ZmeZg^bZcidXdb VY^hXjhh~dcd ;Ve‚ijad ,
hdWgZV[dgbV fjZ V]^hiƒg^VhZVegZhZciV Vcƒh5 hjedcYd fjZ V]^hiƒg^V € \ZgVYVhZ\jcYd Va\jbV aƒ\^XV'k^bdh VeZcVhdh ZkZcidh'cjcXV VhgZ( \gVh'bVh egZX^hVbdhVY^k^c]Vg Xdbd ZaV[jcX^dcV)%9 gZ\gVXdggZiV ZgV !c†bZgdh Zb dgYZb VhXZcYZciZ!'cVYVbV^h) Hdjfj‚hh^bVh XdWV^Vh V YZhXdWg^gVb' edgfjZ eVgV[Vo•(AdegZX^hVgVb VegZhZciVg jbV h€g^ZZb dgYZb YZhXZcYZciZ ${ fjVa d ZmeZg^bZciVYdg Y^g^V !c~d!%)OVhdc eZg( XZWZj fjZ Vh(XdWV^Vh i^c]Vb jbV gZ\gVZb bZciZ' bVh VegZhZciVkVb(a]Z ZmZbeadhYZhi^cVYdh VXdc[^gb|(AVZb kZoYZiZciVgd[ZgZXZg h€g^ZhfjZ [dhhZb ^cXdch^hiZciZh Xdb hjVh]^eƒiZhZh)9h XdWV^Vh Xdci^cjVkVb iZc( iVcYdiZcVobZciZ Xdc[^gbVgVhgZ\gVhfjZ RYR`i^c]Vb Xg^VYd) G ZmeZg^bZcid^che^gdjjbV h€g^ZYZiZhiZheVgZX^Ydh' ZcigZdh fjV^hhZ ZcXdcigVd hZ\j^ciZ ZmZbead5eZY^gVbfjZ VhXdWV^Vh Y^hhZhhZbfjV^h eZg\jciVh YZkZg^VbhZg[Z^iVheVgVfjZ hZYZhXdWg^hhZ hZjbV eZhhdVZgV ZmigdkZgi^YV dj c~d' egdedh^iVYVbZciZeVgVdjigd i^ed YZZmeZg^bZcid) =hiVWZaZXZj(hZ fjZ VhXdWV^Vh VegZhZciVkVbeg^cX^eVabZciZeZg\jciVh eVgVVhfjV^h VgZhedhiV!h^b! N]\VN_VNV]^eƒiZhZ) EVh Zm^hiZbZmXZ•…Zh) =cigZ ZaVhZhi~ddh \gVcYZhbZhigZhYd mVYgZo' fjZ' [d^ egdkVYd' cV kZgYVYZ XdcXZcigVb(hZcdh edcidh Zb fjZ jb bdk^bZcid ZheZXjaVi^kd edhhVhZg[gVXd6 cdkVidh' Zb XdbeVgV•~d'egd( XjgVb edg ^chi}cX^Vh Xdc[^gbViƒg^Vh Zb kZo YZ[Vah^[^XVYdgVh) EVh c~d _d\jZ mVYgZo eVgVegVi^XVg XZi^X^hbd) ;^Zci^hiVhVXgZY^iVb fjZ € VWjhXV eZaVhegƒeg^Vh[gVfjZoVhfjZ [VoYZaZhWdch_d\VYdgZhYZmVYgZo' Z c~d Veg|i^XVYd mVYgZo fjZ dh idgcV X€i^Xdh) K^b^aVgbZciZ'd ZheZXjaVYdg ?Zdg\Z Kdgdh'Vd[VoZgjbV VedhiV[^cVcXZ^gV' [^XV egdXjgVcYdedg ^ch( i}cX^VhfjZ egdkVg^VbfjZ ViZdg^V^c^X^Va Zhi^kZhhZ ZggVYV) Ahhd'iVakZo' hZ_V VkZgYVYZ^gV VjidXdc[^Vc•V5 VXVeVX^YVYZ YZda]VgeVgVd bjcYd hZb VcZXZhh^YVYZ YZZcXdcigVgh^cV^h fjZ V[V\jZb d egƒeg^d Z\d)t Lg^hiZbZciZ'Vcd•~d YZXdggdWdgV•~d Zhi| ZcgV^oVYV Zb cdhhdh ]|( W^idh^ciZaZXijV^h ZZb cdhhd Y^hXjghd) ;dch^YZgZZhhZXdbZci|g^d Yd Zh( Xg^idgZ Xg‚i^Xd Bd]c MeY^`Z5!IjVcYd Bja^VcBVncZh$)))%ZheZXjaV fjZ Vi€ ˆ =hhZ)egdWaZbVYVXdc[^gbV•~d eZgbZ^V cdhhV k^YVbdYZgcV' _| fjZ bj^idh Xdc[a^idhh~d ZcgVAoVYdh cd hZ\j^ciZ k^€hbZciVa5 fjVcYd |gVWZhZ ^hgVZaZchZh Vhh^hiZbVdcdi^X^|g^d' ZaZh k•Zb ]^hiƒg^VhY^[ZgZciZhcV bZhbV hjXZhh~dYZ ZkZcidh)
d [^cVaYd hZ\jcYd b^a•c^d VciZhYZ;g^hid dh ]dbZch c~d i^c]Vb Xdch( X^•cX^V ed^h ZhiVkVbdWZYZXZcYd VjidbVi^XVbZciZ{h kdoZhYdhYZjhZh' [^XVbdh^begZhh^dcVYdh bVh hdbdh ^beZa^YdhVhZ\j^g ZhhViZhZcdi|kZa VigVk€h YZidYVhVhZN^Y•cX^Vh XdggdWdgVi^kVh)! 9 iZhZYZBVncZh edYZZhiVg XZgiV' bVh' hg)MeY^`Z'd egdWaZbV XZcigVa YdXdc]ZX^bZcid$Zd edcid YZh( iZXVe‚ijad% € fjZ d Vc^bVaX]VbVYdZk^Y•cX^V P\__\O\_NaVcN c~d Zm^hiZ)
d edcid
VhZ\j^g ^ajhigVV^cYVbV^hd VWhjgYdYVXdc[^gbV•~d)KZkdX• VXgZY^iV fjZ kZgjb X^hcZWgVcXd VbV^higVg|VXdc[^gbV•~dYZfjZ c~d Zm^hiZbX^hcZhcZ\gdh' Zci~d iVbW€b YZkZg^V VXZ^iVg VV[^gbV•~d'Xdb WVhZ ejgVbZciZ cVaƒ\^XV'fjZ d Vk^hiVbZcidYZjb E^c^ ;ddeZg kZgbZ( a]d YZkZg^V Xdc[^gbVgfjZ [l\ Uj PV`[R`[RT_\`( Hdg fj•8 K^beaZhbZciZ Xdch^YZgZ fjZ VV[^gbV•~d!idYdh dh X^hcZh h~d WgVcXdh! ^bea^XVfjZ a\Q\` \` \OWRa\`[l\'O_N[P\` [l\ `l\ PV`[R`(G fjZ Xdc[^gbVV†ai^bVV[^gbV•~dYZkZg^V Xdc[^gbVgVeg^bZ^gV)HdgiVcid' d Vk^hiVbZcidYZjb dW_Zidc~d(WgVcXdfjZ c~d hZ_Vjb X^hcZYZkZg^V aZkVgVZhhVXdc[^gbV•~d)=hhZVg\jbZcid' Xdc]ZX^YdXdbd d eVgVYd( mdYd XdgkdYZ@ZbeZa' [d^gZYZh XdWZgid edg bZj Vb^\d' d bViZb|i^Xd $eZchVciZ% :gjcd
F~d hdbdh ^c\•cjdh Vedcid YZVXgZY^iVg fjZ Va\j€b hZg^V ^bdgiVaedg( fjZ cjcXV d k^bdh bdggZg' dj' fjZ Va\j€b hZg^V ^cdXZciZYZjb VhhVhh^( cVid edgfjZ cjcXV d k^bdh bViVg)G egdWaZbVYV\ZcZgVa^oV•~d ^c\•cjV c~d cdh V[a^\ZZb idYVhVheVgiZh)EVh iV^hWdah…Zh ^ciZa^\ZciZhYZXZi^( X^hbd ^cYjo^YdiZcYZb VZckdakZgZkZcidhfjZ ZcXdcigVbdh Zb cdhhd VbW^ZciZcVijgVa'fjZhi…ZhcVhfjV^h VegZcYZbdhVZk^iVg\ZcZgVa^oV•…Zh idaVh) Hdg ZmZbead'fjVcYd hZVegZhZciVVXg^Vc•Vh jbV [did\gV[^VYZjb †c^XdbZbWgd YZjb \gjed ZeZYZ(hZVZaVh fjZ VY^k^c]ZbVhiVgVXiZg‚h( i^XVh Ydhdjigdh bZbWgdh fjZ c~d h~dk^hidh'ZaVhh~dXVeVoZh YZhZaZX^d(
cVg^bNV`Vig^Wjidh ^g~d\ZcZgVa^oVg) EdhigZ V[did\gV[^VYZVa\j€b dWZhdV jbV Xg^Vc•V Z eZ•V(a]ZfjZ YZhXgZkV d gZhidYVedejaV•~d5ZaV$egdkVkZa( bZciZ%c~d X]Z\Vg|{ XdcXajh~dYZfjZ idYdh dh bZbWgdh YVig^Wdi•b egdWaZbVh YZeZhd)EVh ZaVgZhedcYZg^V Y^[ZgZciZbZciZV\ZcZgVa^oV•…Zh ZckdakZcYdVXdgYVeZaZ)KZkdX•bdhigVg{ Xg^Vc•V eZhhdVhYZeZaZZhXjgV ZeZY^g(a]ZfjZ YZhXgZkV dh djigdh bZbWgdh YVig^Wd'ZaVegZhjb^g| fjZ ZaZhiVbW€b i•b eZaZZhXjgV) 9hh^b' eVgZXZ fjZ hdbdh YdiVYdhXdb ^chi^cidh ^cYji^kdh ZheZX‚[^( XdhZ ZaVWdgVYdh fjZ cdh \j^Vb) ;dcig|g^d { de^c^~d Yd \gVcYZ
= edYZbdh iZgVegZcY^Yd ZggVYd YZcdhhdhVcXZhigV^h) =heZXjadVfj^ fjZ egdkVkZabZciZ]ZgYVbdhdh ^chi^cidhVYZfjVYdheVgVVhdWgZk^k•cX^V cV gZ\^~dYdh?gVcYZhDV\dhYVw[g^XV Gg^ZciVa'YZdcYZ egZhjb^kZabZciZ k^Zbdh' bVh fjZ iV^h^chi^cidhh~dXZgiVbZciZbVa(VYVeiVYdh VdVbW^ZciZ eƒh(Va[VWZid' ^ciZchVbZciZ^c[dgbVX^dcVa ZZhiVi^hi^XVbZciZ XdbeaZmdYd egZhZciZ) FV kZgYVYZ' cdhhd VbW^ZciZ€ jb edjXd bV^hXdbeaZmdYd fjZ cƒh $ZcdhhVh^chi^ij^•…Zh% eVgZXZbdheZgXZWZg) ;dbd8 G bjcYd bdYZgcd' hZcYdd =migZb^hi~d'€ Ydb^cVYdedg ZkZcidhgVgdh( bj^id gVgdh)=aZ edYZVegZhZciVg jb ;^hcZ FZ\gd YZed^hYZb^a]VgZhZb^a]VgZhYZX^hcZh WgVcXdh YZ[dgbV fjZ egZX^hVbdh gZiZgcdhhd_ja\VbZcid edg bV^hiZbed Yd fjZ hdbdh ^cXa^cVYdh V[VoZg);dbd Y^hhZ cd ;Ve‚ijad .' € ^bedhh‚kZa ( W^dad\^XVbZciZ ^bedhh‚kZa( YZeVgVg(hZ Xdb jb ]jbVcd Xdb Va\j( bVh XZciZcVh YZfj^a„bZigdh YZVaijgV'Zci~d cdhhVh^cij^•…ZhZmXajZbZh( hZhZkZcidh)EVh VhkZcYVhYZjb a^kgddj VbV\c^ijYZ YZZkZcidhhdX^V^h
