2- Pal v santos

PHILIPPINE AIRLINES, INC., petitioner, vs. ALBERTO SANTOS, JR., HOUDIEL MAGADIA, GILBERT ANTONIO, REGINO DURAN, PHILIPPINE AIRLINES EMPLOYEES ASSOCIATION, n! THE NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS COMMISSION, respon!ents. G.R. No. ""#"$ %e&r'r( ), *++ %-ts T/is 0s n instnt petition 1or -ertiorri to set si!e t/e !e-ision o1 NLRC settin2 si!e t/e s'spension o1 t/e -o3p4ints n! !ire-tin2 P/i4ippine Air4ine to p( -o3p4innts t/eir s4ries. In!ivi!'4 respon!ents 0ere port ste0r!s o1 -terin2 s'&5!eprt3ent on t/e pssen2er servi-es !eprt3ent o1 petitioner. T/eir s4ries 0ere !e!'-te! !'e to t/e 3is/n!4in2 o1 -o3pn(6s properties 0/i-/ t/e respon!ents resente!. On A'2'st 7", *+#), represente! &( t/e 'nion, in!ivi!'4 respon!ents 3!e  1or34 noti-e re2r!in2 t/e !e!'-tions t/r' Mr. A&!, Mn2er 1or -re t8in2 0/o 0s on v-tion 4eve &'t no -tion 0s t8en. T/e( t/en 94e!  1or34 2rievn-e p'rs'nt to t/e -o44e-tive &r2inin2 2ree3ent. 2ree3ent. On /is ret'rn, Mr. A&! on De-e3&er ", *+#), /e in1or3e! t/e 2rievnts n! s-/e!'4e! 3eetin2. T/ere1ter, t/e in!ivi!'4 respon!ents re1'se! to !o r3p inventor( t/in8in2 t/t sin-e t/ere 0s no -tion t8en &( Mr. A&! 9ve !(s 1ter t/e( 94e! t/e petition, it s/44 &e reso4ve! in t/eir 1vor. B't Mr. A&! !enie! t/e petition n! s'spen!e! in!ivi!'4 respon!ents. respon!ents. He 4so pointe! o't t/t it 0s on4( proper t/t e3p4o(ees 0ere -/r2e! 1or t/e 3is/n!4in2 o1 -o3pn(6s propert(. Privte respon!ents 94e!  -o3p4int 1or i44e24 s'spension to t/e 4&or r&iter. T/e !e-ision 0s r'4e! in 1vor o1 t/e petitioner n! t/e -o3p4int 0s set si!e. T/e 4&or r&iter6s !e-ision 0s ppe4e! to t/e respon!ent -o33ission 0/o ren!ere! !e-ision settin2 si!e t/e 4&or r&iter6s or!er o1 !is3iss4. Petitioner6s 3otion 1or re-onsi!ertion 0s !enie!. Iss'e :/et/er p'&4i- respon!ent NLRC -te! 0it/ 2rve &'se o1 !is-retion 3o'ntin2 to 4-8 o1 ;'ris!i-tion on reso4vin2 in 1vor o1 in!ivi!'4 respon!ents 0/o &e4ieve! t/t in-tion on t/e petition t/e( 94e! 1or 2rievn-e 0o'4! &e reso4ve! in t/eir 1vor in --or!n-e to t/eir -o44e-tive &r2inin2 2ree3ent < He4! T/e petition /in2es on t/e interprettion o1 Se-. 7, Art. I= o1 t/e PAL5PALEA Co44e-tive Br2inin2 A2ree3ent &o't t/e pro-essin2 o1 2rievn-es. Petitioner s'&3its t/t sin-e t/e 2rievn-e 3-/iner( 0s 3!e 1or &ot/ 4&or n! 3n2e3ent, e3p4o(ees re !'t(5&o'n! to t/res/ o't 9rst 44 t/e re3e!ies &e1ore t/e 3n2e3ent n! 2ive t/e3 opport'nit( to -t on it. B't !'e to t/e &sen-e o1 Mr. A&! t/e 2rievn-e 0s not -te! 'pon.

 T/e -o'rt /e4! /e4! t/t t/e e3p4o(ees e3p4o(ees s/o'4! not not &er t/e !ire !ire e>e-ts o1 Mr. Mr. A&!6s &sen-e. T/e 3n2e3ent s/o'4! /! so3eone e4se to 4oo8 1ter t/e 2rievn-e !'rin2 /is &sen-e. Un!er t/e po4i-( o1 so-i4 ;'sti-e, t/e 40 &en!s over &-80r! to --o33o!te t/e interests o1 t/e 0or8in2 -4ss on t/e /'3ne ;'sti9-tion t/t t/ose 0it/ 4ess privi4e2es in 4i1e s/o'4! /ve 3ore privi4e2es in 40. R'4in2 Petition 0s !enie! n! t/e ssi4e! !e-ision o1 NLRC 0s ?r3e!.