REPUBLI COFTHEPHI LI PPI NES REGI ONALTRI ALCOU OURT Ci t yofBac oorCa vi t e Br anch19 Cr uz ,etal . ,
Pl ai nt i ff, v er s us -
CI VI LCASENO.BCV0589
Car monaDel Car men, De f e nd an t . x x ANSWE WERWI THCOUNTERCLAI M
Def endan t ,t hr o ught heunder s i gnedc oun sel ,mo str es pec t f ul l yfi l et hei rAns weri nr e spo ns e t ot heCompl ai ntoft hePl ai nt i ffsandi nt er pos easwel l ast hei rc ount er c l ai m agai ns tt hel at t er ,t owi t : 1 .
Par a gr a ph s1a nd2o ft h eCo mp mp l a i n tar ea dmi t t e d.
2. Par agr aph s2t o6oft heComp l ai n tar edeni edf orl ac kofk no wl edgeori nf or mat i ons uffic i en tt o f or m abel i efast ot hev er ac i t yorf al s i t yt her eof ,t heal l egat i onst her ei nbei ngmat t er sk nownonl yt o, andar ewi t hi nt hec ont r ol onl y ,oft hepl ai nt i ff. 3 . Par a gr a ph s7t o9oft heCo mp mp l ai n ta r ea dmi t t e d. 4 . Par a gr a ph1 0o ft h eCo mp mp l a i n ti sde ni e da st h eal l e gat i o nsar eme me r e l yana c tt op r e e mp mp tt h e def endant ’ se x er c i s eofherr i ghtt opur s uec ol l ec t i onbyc our tac t i onandi si nt endedt oembar r as s h eri no r d ert oc o er c eh eri nt or e t u r n i n gt h et i t l et h atwa st h es u bj e c to ft h e Me mo mo r a ndu m o f Ag r ee me me ntwi t h ou tfi r s tp ay i n gt h el o an so bt ai n edi nt h ea f or e me me nt i o ne da mo mo un t ,t het r ut hb ei ng t hos eal l e gedi nt hespec i al an daffir ma t i v edef ens espar ther ei nbel o w. SPECI ALANDAFFI RMATI VEDEFENSES
5. Thet i t l et ot hesubj ec tpr oper t yi si nt henameoft heEl i s a’ sRi c eMi l l ,r epr es ent edbyMs Ms .Del Ca r me n,i t sr e gi s t e r e do wn er ,a ndn ott h ep l a i n t i ff ,a sp ert h eMemo r a nd um o fAg r e eme ntwi t ht h e Pl ai n t i ff s.( SeeAnne xA) 6. Thepl ai nt i ffi snotent i t l edt ot her et ur noft het i t l eoft hepr oper t y ,t her ebei ngnobr eac hof c ont r ac to nt hepar toft heDef endant ,c ont r ar yt ot heal l egat i onsoft hePl ai nt i ff si nPar .3oft he Co mp mp l a i n t .
7. Theal l ege di nde bt ednes so ft heDe f en da nti su ns ub st a nt i at edb yan ye v i d enc eandi sa nac tt o pr eemptt hedef endant ’ sex er c i s eofherr i ghtt opur s uec ol l ec t i onbycour tac t i on. COMPULS ORYCOUNTE RCLAI M
8 .De f e nd an td ema nd st h ep a y me nto fP1 6,7 00 ,1 41 . 1 5a st h ea mo un to ft h eu np ai dr e i mb ur s e me nt o ft h e Pl a i n t i ff sf ort h ea dv a nc ep ay me nto ft hec ap i t a lg ai n st a x,d oc u me nt ar ys t a mpt a xo ft h e pr oper t yi nques t i on, 9.Byr eas onoft hei ns t antpr ec i pi t at eandunf oundeds ui t ,t hedef endantwascons t r ai nedt ohi r et he s er v i c esofal a wy ert odef endhi sr i ght san di nt er es t sf orapr of es s i on alf e e ofP2 0, 00 0. 00p l us P3 , 0 00 . 0 0p erc o ur ta pp ea r a nc e ; 10.Si mi l a r l y ,t hepl ai nt i ff ’ sunf oundeds ui thasc au sedt hedef endantmen t alangui s hands uff er i ng a nd p u bl i ch umi l i a t i o na n de mb ar r a s s me nt ,f o rwh i c ht h ed ef e n da n tc l a i ms mo r a ld ama ge so f P1 00 , 0 00 . 0 0. WHEREF ORE, p r e mi s e sc o n s i d er e d, i ti sr e s p ec t f u l l yp r a y e dt h at t h ec o mp l a i n tb e di s mi s sedf orl ac kofmer i tandt hedef endant ’ sc ompul s or yc ount er c l ai m begr ant ed,i . e. .at t or ne y’ s f eeso fP20, 000 . 00pl usmor al d ama geso fP1 00, 000. 00,p l usc os t so fs ui t . Th ed ef e nd an tr e s pe c t f u l l yp r a y sf o rs u c ha ndo t h err e l i e f sa sma yb ed ee me dj u s ta n d equi t abl ei nt hepr emi s es . Ci t yofBa co or ,Ca v i t e ,Se pt e mbe r2 2 ,2 00 5. GACUT ANANDSALAZARLAW OFFI CE Co un s el f o rt h eDe f e nd an t Sui t e258TheTower Mal at e,Mani l a By : ARVI NGACUT AN Ro l l No .9 87 65 I BPNo ,1 23 45 / 1 3 2 01 2/ Ma ni l a PTRNo .3 45 67 / 1 3 2 01 2/ Ma ni l a
V ERI F I CA T I ON/ CE RT I F I CA T I ONOFN ONF ORUM S HOP PI NG
Republ i cof t hePhi l i ppi nes Ci t yofBac oor ,Ca vi t e
) )S.S.
I ,Ca r mo na De lCa r me n,o fl e ga la g e,F i l i p i n oc i t i z e n,ma r r i e da nd r e s i d en to f3 45 UN Av e nue ,Ma ni l a ,a f t e rh av i n gd ul ys wo r nt oi na cc or d an cewi t hl a w,d oh er eb yde po s ea nds a y : 1. ThatIam t hedef endant i nt heabo v eent i t l edc as e; 2. ThatIhav er eadandca us edt hepr epar at i onoft hef or egoi ngAnswerandhav er eadt he al l egat i onsc ont ai nedt her ei n; 3. Thatal lal l egat i onsi nsai dAnswerar et r ueandcor r ectofmyownknowl edgeandbasedon aut hent i cr ec or ds ; 4. ThatIher ebycer t i f yt hatIhavenotcommencedanyot heract i onorpr oceedi ngi nvol vi ngt he s amei s s uesi nan yc our t ,t r i bunal o rq uas i j udi c i al ag enc yan d,t ot hebe stofmykno wl edg e,nos uc h ot herac t i onorc l ai mi spendi ngt her ei n; 5. Thati fIshoul dt her eaf t erl ear nt hata si mi l aract i on orpr oceedi ng has been fil ed ori s pendi ng,Iher eb yunder t ak et or epor tt hatf ac twi t hi nfi v e( 5)da yst her ef r om t ot hec our toragenc y wh er et heo r i gi nal p l ea di ngan ds wo r nc er t i fi c at i onc ont empl at edhe r ei nha v ebeenfi l ed; 6 . Tha tIe x ec ut e dt h i sv er i fi c at i o n/ c er t i fi c at i o nt oa t t e s tt ot h et r u t ho ft h ef o r e go i n gf a ct san dt o c ompl ywi t ht h ep r o v i s i o nsofAdm.Ci r c ul a rNo .0 49 4o ft h eHo no r a bl eSu pr e meCo ur t . I NWI TNESSWHEREOF, Ihaveher eunt oaffixedmysi gnat ur et hi s22nddayofSept ember 2005i nt heCi t yofMani l a. Car monaDel Car men SUBSCRI BED AND SWORN TO bef or emet hi s22nddayofSept ember2005,i nt heCi t yof Bac oo rCa vi t e,a ffian te x hi b i t i ngt omehe rGSI SI . D.No.12 345i nt heCi t yofMa ni l a . Co pyf u r n i s he d: ATTY.FRETTILAUREL Couns el f ort hePl ai nt i ff Uni t1234Laur el Bui l di ng Sa mp al o c ,Ma ni l a
