Revista IMPROVISACIÓN. no 1, marzo 2010

   K     Ü    C    L    H    \    C    Y    A    Z    ^    E    C

Zbyc|ph `b hzpb| b|lãkclh| s lrfprzh

   K     Ü    C    L    H    \    C    Y    A    Z    ^    E    C

Eöryhf Laffblpcyb H+L+

CE^ZAYC\HLCÜK+

@CZBLLCÜK‣DBKBZHF‣S‣HZPÅ\PCLH‣

Zbyc|ph‣`b‣hzpb|‣b|lãkclh|‣s‣lrfprzh‣

Fcl+‣Hrzh‣Phkph`bf‣Fü~b‣Lakpzbzh|‣

@CZBLLCÜK‣DBKBZHF

@CZBLLCÜK‣DBKBZHF‣

Eöryhf‣Laffblpcyb‣

Fcl+‣Lhzfa|‣Hfjbzpa‣Lbzyhkpb|‣Jhzzbzh‣

LAZ@CKHLCÜK‣B@CPAZCHF

H\B\AZ‣s‣LAFHJAZH@AZ‣

Fcl+‣_rfhc‣Ehlch|‣A|azka‣

Fcl+‣Izhklc|la‣`b‣Ob|ÿ|‣Fü~b‣Lh|cffh|‣

@C\BØA‣B@CPAZCHF‣

H^ASA‣H@ECKC\PZHPCYA‣

Fcl+‣Hrzh‣Phkph`bf‣Fü~b‣Lakpzbzh|‣

Fcl+‣_rfhc‣Ehlch|‣A|azka‣

Fcl+‣Lhzfa|‣Hfjbzpa‣Lbzyhkpb|‣Jhzzbzh‣

Zbyc|ph `b hzpb| b|lãkclh| s lrfprzh

   K     Ü    C    L    H    \    C    Y    A    Z    ^    E    C

LAKPBKC@A\ B`rlhlcük B}~bzcbklch Bybkpa| Db|pcük ^hpzceakca Zbifb}cük

Zbyc|ph `b hzpb| b|lãkclh| s lrfprzh KAPH @B FH B@CPAZH Fh zbyc|ph Ce~zayc|hlcük  b| rkh ckclchpcyh `b Eöryhf Laffblpcyb& hdzr~hlcük `b hzpc|ph| `b`clh`a| h fh ~zèlpclh b|lãkclh s ~zbalr~h`a| ~az mhlbz `b ã|ph rk b|~hlca hjcbzpa ~hzh fh lzbhlcük& ~bza phejcãk ~hzh fh zbifb}cük+ ^az bffa& h ickhfb| `bf høa :>>3 |b ckclch fh db|phlcük `b b|pb b|~hlca& xrb pcbkb laea ickhfc`h` b|pcerfhz zbifb}cakb|& lzcpclh| s ~za~rb|ph| |ajzb bf hzpb b|lãkcla& bk dbkbzhf& ~bza |ajzb pa`a& hfzb`b`az `b fh `hkh+ Izbkpb h fh laklb~lcük pzh`clcakhf `bf jhcfhzåk& zb`rlc`a h |bz boblrphkpb& cklh~h `b lrb|pcakhz |r ~za~ca xrbmhlbz& ka| ~hzblb irk`hebkphf fh lzbhlcük `b b|pb pc~a `b b|~hlca|& bk `ak`b |b ~rb`h byc`bklchz bf bkazeb ~apbklchf xrb pcbkb krb|pza xrbmhlbz ~hzh b|pcerfhz zbifb}cakb| s& h|å& zbybzpcz& fh b|lbkh kbrpzhfch`h ~az lrbz~a| ajb`cbkpb|+

   K     Ü    C    L    H    \    C    Y    A    Z    ^    E    C

B| h|å xrb& lak bf ~zcebz kÿebza `b fh zbyc|ph Ce~zayc|hlcük & jr|lhea| `hzfb frdhz h fh| yalb| xrb mhlbk s zbmhlbk hf lhe~a `hklå|pcla& yalb| xrb ka |üfa ybkdhk `b pbüzcla| b|~blchfch`a| s zbkaejzh`a|& |cka xrb |rzohk `b fa| mhlb`azb| lapc`chka|& hxrbffa| xrb `åh h `åh |b bkizbkphk h fa| b|lbkhzca|& hf |hfük `b lfh|b|& h fh ihfph `b ~zb|r~rb|pa| s `b frdhzb| ~hzh ~zb|bkphz |r| ~za~ca| pzhjhoa+ H`beè|& ka| ~hzblb xrb ~akbz fh zbyc|ph h `c|~a|clcük bk fh zb`& jzck`h fh a~azprkc`h` `b dbkbzhz rk `cèfada bk `ak`b erlmh eè| dbkpb |b ybh ckyafrlzh`h s b|pcerfh`h h ~hzpclc~hz+ Bkpaklb|& hxrå `hea| ckclca h b|pb ~zasblpa& xrb b|ph yb cklfrsbk `cb lafhjazhlcakb| xrb zbifbohk fh erfpc~fclc`h` `b fh b}~bzcbklch `b fh ~zèlpclh b|lãkclh& bf hzpb s fh lrfprzh bk dbkbzhf+ Lak bf ~za~ü|cpa `b xrb bf hllb|a h fa| hzpålrfa| |bh hllb|cjfb& fa| mbea| `cyc`c`a ~az pbeh|? b`rlhlcük& b}~bzcbklch& `cir|cük& zbifb}cük& ~bz|akhob s& laea rk hdzbdh`a& ~hpzceakca& |ck xrb lak bffa |b ckpbkpb `bfcecphz fh zcxrbh `b lh`h pb}pa h fa| zrjza| hxrå ~za~rb|pa|+ _rfhc Ehlch| A|azka

Zbyc|ph `b hzpb| b|lãkclh| s lrfprzh

LAFHJAZH@AZB\ @B B\PB ^ZCEBZ KßEBZA

_rfhc Ehlch| A|azka+ Fclbklch`h bk ~|clafadåh s ehb|pzh bk icfa|aiåh+ icfa|aiåh+ \b `b`clh h fh ckyb|pcdhlcük bk hzpb| b|lãkclh|+

Ehzdhzcph Pazphoh`h Xrcza+ Ckyb|pcdh`azh `bf LBKC@C @hkh%CKJH+ @alpazh bk Lcbklch| \alchfb|+ Fåkbh| `b ckyb|pcdhlcük? Mc|pazch s pbazåh `b fh `hkh Lhzfa| Lazpã|+ Azcdckhzca `b B|~høh+ Lrz|ü b|pr`ca| `b Icfa|aiåh s Fbpzh| bk fh Rkcybz|c`h` `b _hzhdah+ Ycyb s pzhjhoh bk Fak`zb|& `ak`b laejckh |r hlpcyc`h` bk fh| hzpb| ~fè|pclh| s b|lãkclh|+

   K     Ü Ü|lhz \hfh| Düeb +    C \b alr~h ~bzca`å|pclhebkpb `bf pbhpza s fh `hkh lakpbe~azèkbh    L bk Xrbzãphza h ~hzpcz `b 83=<+ Mh ~zb|bkph`a yhzch|    H b}~a|clcakb| iapadzèiclh| lak fa| ec|ea| pbeh|+    \    C    Y  ]caehzh Zrå+    A Laaz`ckh`azh `bf Ib|pcyhf Cjãzålh& ib|pcyhf `b `hkh    Z lakpbe~azèkbh xrb pcbkb |r |b`b bk Xrbzãphza& Eã}cla+    ^ ^hzpclc~h bk fh ~za`rllcük s eakphob `b b|~blpèlrfa|+    E Hkhjbffh ^hzboh+    C Jhcfhzckh s Lzbh`azh `b @hkh+ Zb|c`b bk fh Lcr`h` `b Eã}cla+ Orkpa lak Fbakhz`a Ehzpck| `b|hzzaffh Izb|la& lafblpcya bkialh`a hf zbdc|pza hr`cayc|rhf& ~zcklc~hfebkpb

B`erk`a Icdrbzah Yczrbdh& Hzxrcpblpa+ Zb|c`b bk fh Lcr`h` `b Eã}cla& bk `ak`b `b|hzzaffh pzhjhoa| `bkpza `bf lhe~a `b zb|phrzhlcük `b eakrebkpa| mc|püzcla|7 fb h~h|cakh fh iapadzhiåh& fa| ychob| s bf ~hpzceakca ckphkdcjfb+ Ibzkhk`a Jr|pa| Drpcãzzb+ Zb|c`b bk \ckhfah& Eã}cla+ @cjrohkpb& ~ckpaz& lazbüdzhia& ehb|pza b ckpãz~zbpb `b `hkh hãzbh s lakpbe~azèkbh7 b}~fazh fh| hzpb| s fh| lcbklch& lak bf ajobpcya `b |bz rk hzpc|ph ckpbdzhf+ ^hrfckh \hjrdhf+ Hlpzc bdzb|h`h bdzb|h`h `bf Lbkpza Khlcakhf `b fh fh Hzpb|& Ckpbzb|h`h bk fh| hzpb| b|lãkclh| s |r ckyb|pcdhlcük+ ^bzfh ^hafh \èklmb Yèxrb+ Dbzbkpb laebzlchf `b Zh`ca Iüzerfh Xrckphkh Zaa s `czblpazh `bf Ib|pcyhf Ckpbzkhlcakhf `b @hkh Lakpbe~azèkbh bk Lhklÿk+ ^zhlpclhkpb `b `hkh lakpbe~azèkbh+ Hrzh Fü~b+ Fclbklch`h bk Hzpb|& lak b|~blchfchlcük bk `hkh Lakpbe~azèkbh& @czblpazh `b Eöryhf Laffblpcyb H+L++ Ckpbzb|h`h bk fh db|pcük s ~zaealcük lrfprzhf+

Iapadzhiåh ~azph`h? Oa|bickh Jhzza|a Iapadzhiåh| |bfbllcakh`h|? Lhzfa| Lazpã| s Izhklc|la Fü~b

B@RLHLCÜK

8

BKLRBKPZA KHLCAKHF @B FH\ B\LRBFH\ @B @HK_H @B B@RLHLCÜK \R^BZCAZ ? MHLCH FH ZBIFB]CÜK S FH PZHK\IAZEHLCÜK Ehzdhzcph Pazphoh`h Xrcza bzecphN~za`cds+kbp+e} @bf :4 hf <> `b alprjzb `b :>>3 |b ffbyü h lhja bk fh lcr`h` `b Lafceh bf Bklrbkpza Khlcakhf `b fh| B|lrbfh| `b @hkh `b B`rlhlcük \r~bzcaz& `ak`b |b pzhphzak pbeh| laea fh b`rlhlcük `hklå|pclh7 fh h~fclhlcük `b c`bh| ~b`hdüdclh| bk fh lak|pzrllcük `b fh lrzzålrfh7 fh ckyb|pcdhlcük s fh ~zèlpclh `albkpb s fa| zbibzbkpb| `b fh iazehlcük hlh`ãeclh7 fh ycklrfhlcük pbazåh% ~zèlpclh7 fh ckyb|pcdhlcük ~hzh fh lzbhlcük lazbadzèiclh7 fh bk|bøhkh `b fh| pãlkclh|+ Hmå |b mca ~hpbkpb xrb b| rkh ~zbalr~hlcük `b fh| b|lrbfh| `b `hkh& h|å laea `b |r| ehb|pza|& hfreka|& `czblpcya| s irklcakhzca|& `bickcz|b& zbifb}cakhz s laerkclhz |r    K xrbmhlbz+     Ü \c mhs hfdrkh laklfr|cük `b b|pb Bklrbkpza& ~hzh ec& b| xrb    C    L fh| b|lrbfh| b|pèk zb`bickcbk`a |r irklcük |alchf+ Bffa b|pè    H ckebz|a bk fa| ~fhkpbhecbkpa| xrb pa`h| mclcbzak |ajzb |r    \ b}~bzcbklch& ~fhkb| `b b|pr`ca& ehb|pza|& fh iazehlcük `b ã|pa|&    C fh yc|cük xrb pcbkbk `b |r hlpcyc`h`& fh| kblb|c`h`b| xrb    Y bklrbkpzhk bk bf eb`ca ~zaib|cakhf s fhjazhf& bplãpbzh+    A Bk Lafceh ~r`a h~zblchz|b xrb fh| b|lrbfh| mhk ea`ciclh`a    Z |r| ~fhkpbhecbkpa| s hflhklb|& ea|pzhk`a rkh ~zbalr~hlcük ~az    ^ ajpbkbz fbdcpcec`h` s zblakalcecbkpa& b|~blchfebkpb b}~zb|h`h    E bk fh| fclbklchprzh|+    C Irb bkièpcla |r |bøhfhecbkpa |ajzb fh kblb|c`h` `b iazehz h b|pr`chkpb| hlpcya|& zbifb}cya|& lzbhpcya| s lzåpcla|& s hf ec|ea  pcbe~a lak rkh |üfc`h pãlkclh -~az bffa p cbkb rk ~b|a lbkpzhf bk fh lhzdh mazhzch#+ B| ajyca xrb bk fh `hkh fh pãlkclh b| irk`hebkphf7 fa| b|pr`chkpb| `bjbk h~zbk`bz& h|cecfhz& cklaz~azhz iazeh| `c|lc~fckhzch| `b lakpzaf s lak|pzrcz|b lak bffh|+ Frbda& r|hzfh|& yhfbz|b `b fh| ec|eh|+

^az bffa& bf jhcfhzåk s bk dbkbzhf bf hzpc|ph `b fh `hkh& ycyb bk lakpzh`cllcük ~bzehkbkpb+ ^az rk fh`a |b mhlb h |å ec|ea lak b|h|  pãlkclh|& s ~az apza `bjb |bz fcjzb ~hzh lzbhz& lzbhz& b}~zb|hz|b s jr|lhz jr|lhz |r lhecka+ B|pa ÿfpcea |üfa fa fadzhzè |c b| lak|lcbkpb& lzåpcla& hjcbzpa& lak lh~hlc`h` `b ckyb|pcdhz& `b lrb|pcakhz& `b `c|lrpcz& `b hzdrebkphz& `b lak|pzrcz |r ~za~ca `c|lrz|a+ B|pa& `clma |bh `b ~h|a& b| fa irk`hebkphf `b fh b`rlhlcük? `bjb jzck`hz fa| bfbebkpa| ~hzh xrb fa| |robpa| |b lae~zbk`hk& |b lrb|pcakbk& |b lak|pzrshk s hzebk rk `c|lrz|a xrb fb| `ã c`bkpc`h`+ Fh| b|lrbfh| xrb ~hzpclc~hzak bk bf bklrbkpza `b Lafceh pcbkbk fh ce~bzca|h kblb|c`h` `b pzhk|ecpcz fa| lakalcecbkpa| s b}~bzcbklch| eè| lbzpbza| ~hzh fa| hfreka|& `èz|bfa| bk irklcük `b fa xrb zbxrcbzbk ~hzh `b|hzzaffhz|b b}cpa|hebkpb bk bf lhe~a `hklå|pcla laea jhcfhzckb|& ehb|pza|& lazbüdzhia|& ckyb|pcdh`azb|& ~zaeapazb|& bpl+ Laea fh `hkh b| rk lhe~a phk he~fca& fh jÿ|xrb`h b| lae~fboh& s pa`h| fh| b|lrbfh| xrcbzbk jzck`hzfb| a~lcakb| h fa| hfreka| ~hzh `b|hzzaffhz|b bk pa`a| fa| èejcpa| xrb zbxrcbzhk bk |r yc`h ~zaib|cakhf+ Hf ec|ea pcbe~a& |hjbk s xrcbzbk ea`ciclhz hf lhe~a& xrcbzbk ~zb~hzhz h rk |robpa xrb |b hor|pb h fh zbhfc`h`& xrb lrbkpb lak fa| bfbebkpa| ~hzh ck|bzphz|b bk bf eb`ca fhjazhf& ~bza xrb fa lhejcb bk irklcük `b fh| `biclcbklch| xrb |b fb m hk `bpblph`a `bkpza `b fh b|lrbfh+ B| `blcz& ka |b pzhph |üfa `b zblr~bzhz `bf lhe~a `hklå|pcla fa xrb |b zbxrcbzb& fh| ea`h|& fh| pãlkclh|& fh| ~za~rb|ph| lzbhpcyh|& fh| iazeh| `b bkpzbkhecbkpa& fh| yc|cakb| ckpbz`c|lc~fckhzch|& bpl+ \hjbea| xrb b| laeÿk xrb pa`h| ã|ph| |rzdbk bk bf lhe~a ~zaib|cakhf s frbda& ~h|h`a bf pcbe~a s rk ~zalb|a `b ‖fbdcpcehlcük―& |b ckpza`rlbk bk fh| b|lrbfh| ~az eb`ca `b fh lrzzålrfh+ ^bza ka |üfa |b pzhph `b b|a& |cka `b cklaz~azhz apza| bfbebkpa| s hfpbzkhpcyh| `b|`b fh b|lrbfh mhlch bf lhe~a ~zaib|cakhf+ Fa yba laea rk ~zalb|a `chfãlpcla `b `hz s zblcjcz& `b ckkayhz& `b ~za~akbz s `c|lrpcz bk heja| b|~hlca|+ H|å fh| b|lrbfh| ka |üfa hlprhzèk laea eb`ca| `b zb~za`rllcük |alchf s `hklå|pclh& |cka phejcãk laea ‖~za`rlpazh|― `b |robpa| lak fh lh~hlc`h` `b ea`ciclhz lak|lcbkpbebkpb bf lhe~a ~zaib|cakhf+ B|b `bjbzåh |bz |r ~zasblpa |alchf s hzpå|pcla irk`hebkphf+

B]^BZCBKLCH

:

ICDRZH S ^HC\HOB Lhzfa| Lazpã| lhzfa|lazpb|Nphfgphfg+kbp

   K     Ü    C    L    H    \    C    Y    A    Z    ^    E    C

Bk høa| zblcbkpb| fa| pãzecka| ckdfb|b| |cpb |~blcicl b cklfr|a |cpb  |bk|cpcyb  a |cpb zbfhpb`  mhk ybkc`a `bickcbk`a krbyh| pbk`bklch| b|lãkclh| xrb ~fhkpbhk rkh zbfhlcük b|~hlca%pbe~azhf `cibzbkpb bkpzb bf b|~blph`az s fa| ckpãz~zbpb|+ Fa| eboazb| bobe~fa| `b b|ph| pbk`bklch| mhk lrb|pcakh`a fh ec|eh b|bklch `bf ehpbzchf `zheèpcla& zb~fhkpbèk`a|b fh iazeh `b lakphz mc|pazch| s `b dbkbzhz eaycecbkpa+ Fh ~za}cec`h` iå|clh& fh bkbzdåh dbkbzh`h ~az b|~hlca| *zbhfb|*& fh lhzbklch& bk alh|cakb|& `b fa| pzh`clcakhfb| zblrz|a| pãlkcla|& laea cfreckhlcük a b|lbkhzca& |ak ~zbec|h| kblb|hzch| ~hzh dbkbzhz krbyh| khzzhpcyh| bk fh| xrb fh ~zb|bklch `bf b|~blph`az ka ~rb`b |bz cdkazh`h s fa| dzhk`b| db|pa| pbhpzhfb| xrb`bk irbzh `b frdhz+ Bk apza| lh|a|& |ck bejhzda& bf krbya ea`bfa mh |bzyc`a |ce~fbebkpb ~hzh lhejchz bf pbfük `b iak`a& lak fa xrb |b dbkbzh rk biblpa la|eãpcla xrb pzh|~fhkph fa| ~hzèebpza| sh b|phjfblc`a| h rk krbya bkpazka& bk `ak`b |b ~za`rlb rk lakifclpa iazehf bkpzb fh| pãlkclh| pzh`clcakhfb| s fa| zblrz|a| kblb|hzca| ~hzh zb|~ak`bz h rk lakpb}pa krbya+ Bf izhlh|a `b erlma| `b b|pa| bobe~fa| mh ffbyh`a h hfdrka| |blpazb| h lrb|pcakhz fh yhfc`b `b b|pb ea`bfa& bk frdhz `b zblakalbz fh| lhzbklch| `b `czblpazb| a lazbüdzhia|& cklh~hlb| `b zb|~ak`bz lak rk fbkdrhob krbya h zbpa| ers `cibzbkpb| `b fa| xrb rka |b bklrbkpzh bk bf pzh`clcakhf pbhpza h fh cphfchkh+ Bk fa| ÿfpcea| høa|& mb lbkpzh`a ec jÿ|xrb`h `b krbya| fbkdrhob| lazbadzèicla| bk b|~hlca| ka pbhpzhfb|& s pzh| yhzca| ~zasblpa| rjclh`a| bk bkpazka| rzjhka|& mb ~a`c`a& ~az ick& bejhzlhzeb bk fh b}~fazhlcük `bf ~hc|hob laea bkpazka ~hzh fh lzbhlcük `b eaycecbkpa+ eaycecbkpa+ B|pa| mhk |c`a ~zasblpa| bk fa| xrb mb lafhjazh`a lak jhcfhzckb| ~zaib|cakhfb| s lak ecbejza| `b fh laerkc`h`& laejckhk`a bf eaycecbkpa lak bfbebkpa| xrb ~a`zåhk `bickcz|b laea ~ckprzh%~hc|hob a b|lrfprzh%~hc|hob+ b|lrfprzh%~hc|hob+

Laea lazzb|~ak`b h pa`a zbpa lzbhpcya& fh jÿ|xrb`h `b rk fbkdrhob xrb zb|~ak`h lak ã}cpa hf r|a `b krbya| ehpbzchfb| b|& h fh yb& irbkpb `b dzhk`b| |hpc|ihllcakb| |hpc|ihllcakb| s `b krebza|h| izr|pzhlcakb|+ Pãzecka| laea b|lhfh& ~bz|~blpcyh s lhfc`h` `b eaycecbkpa& ~fhkpbhk lfhza| zbpa| iazehfb| xrb `bjbk |bz zb|rbfpa|7 pbeh| ~zèlpcla| xrb yhk `b|`b bf lhfh`a s fh za~h h`blrh`a|& mh|ph fh `ciclrfph` ~hzh hllb`bz h lcbzpa| b|~hlca| a fh| fcecphlcakb| xrb bf lfceh   s fh| lak`clcakb| `b fr khprzhfb| ce~akbk& phkpa bk bf ~bzåa`a `b bk|hsa| laea bk fh zb~zb|bkphlcük ickhf& høh`bk `ciclrfph`b| xrb ka b|pèk ~zb|bkpb| bk fa| ~zalb|a| `b lzbhlcük lazbadzèiclh eè| lakybklcakhfb|+ @rzhkpb b|pa| ~zasblpa|& fh lafhjazhlcük lak `cibzbkpb| pc~a| `b ckpãz~zbpb| mh |c`a irbkpb `b krebza|h| |az~zb|h|+ Lak izblrbklch mb lak|phph`a xrb bf jhcfhzåk ~zaib|cakhf& mhjcprh`a h rk |aic|pclh`a |c|pbeh `b *b|lrlmh ckpbzkh*& `b fblprzh `b |r| zbdc|pza| ~za~ca| s `b eaycecbkpa| ~zb%la`ciclh`a|& bklrbkpzh eè| `ciålcf fh zbfhlcük lak b|~hlca| ka `bickc`a| ~az bf lrh`zh`a b|lãkcla+ Xrcè| fh lh~hlc`h` `b *b|lrlmhz* hf bkpazka `bjbzåh |bz eè| ~apbklch`h bk fh iazehlcük `bf jhcfhzåk lakpbe~azèkba+ Bk b|b |bkpc`a& ~hzpclc~hkpb| xrb pbkåhk rkh b`rlhlcük zbfhlcakh`h lak bf b|~hlca -hzxrcpblprzh& `c|bøa#& zb|~ak`åhk lak eè| ã}cpa h fh| yhzchjfb| dbaeãpzclh| dbkbzh`h| ~az lrbz~a| xrb b}~fazhk |r bkpazka fcjzbebkpb fcjzbebkpb %bkizbkpèk`a|b h fa| zbxrbzcecbkpa| zbxrbzcecbkpa| `b rk bkpazka pzc`cebk|cakhf b *cfcecph`a*%& bk yb `b zb~bpcz ~hpzakb| ~zbychebkpb b|phjfblc`a|+ Phejcãk fh dbkpb `b lcr`h` s fh dbkpb `b bkpazka| zrzhfb| zbhllcakh `b iazeh `cibzbkpb h la|h| phk |bklcffh| laea lheckhz |ajzb |r~bziclcb| czzbdrfhzb|& ~c|hz |ajzb fh pcbzzh& fh| ~cb`zh|+ Bf ckpãz~zbpb rzjhka& hla|prejzh`a h |rbfa| hzpciclchfb| s fc|a|& ckpbkph *ce~akbz* |r ~c|h`h& jr|lhz rkh iczebh xrb fb| zbmrsb& ecbkpzh| xrb fa| zrzhfb| b|pèk hla|prejzh`a| h fh ~c|h`h pbkphpcyh& xrb |b h`h~ph h fh pb}przh s hf ehpbzchf hkpb| `b jr|lhz bf h|cbkpa+ @bphffb| phk ce~azphkpb| hf  pzhjhohz bk b|pb lakpb}pa laea fa ~rb`b |bz rk ~cb b|pczh`a bk `hkh lfè|clh a rkh lakpzhllcük lazzblph bk `hkh lakpbe~azèkbh+

B]^BZCBKLCH Bf pcbe~a& b| `blcz& fh `rzhlcük `bf b|~blpèlrfa& b| phejcãk rk ihlpaz xrb ebzblb |bz zbyc|h`a+ Fa| lhejca| xrb bf ~hc|hob b}~bzcebkph |ak fbkpa|& ~bza `b dzhk ce~hlpa+ Xrcè| bf *lakpzhpa* lak bf b|~blph`az `bjb b|phz jh|h`a bk ~hzèebpza| `cibzbkpb| s fh lakycybklch bk bf b|~hlca `bjb ~zafakdhz|b eh| hffè `b fa| pcbe~a| mhjcprhfb| `b lrhfxrcbz b|~blpèlrfa -8%: mazh|#+ Fh ~za}cec`h` `b pa`a| fa| ~hzpclc~hkpb|& fh ihfph `b *izakpbzh|* xrb ce~c`bk fh bkpzh`h a |hfc`h `b hxrbffa| ce~fclh`a| bk b|ph b}~bzcbklch& eb ffbyh h ~bk|hz bk ea`bfa| laea fh| ~zalb|cakb| s lbfbjzhlcakb| zbfcdca|h|& fh| zaebzåh| s ~bzbdzckhlcakb| %phk laerkb| bk fa| ~hå|b| fhpcka|%& `ak`b fa| ~hzpclc~hkpb| bkpzhk s |hfbk fcjzbebkpb bk rk ychob xrb cklfrsb % laea bk pa`a zcprhf%& rkh laejckhlcük `b bfbebkpa| b|~czcprhfb|   s `b `c|izrpb| ehpbzchfb|& laea |ak bf laebz s jbjbz orkpa|& lhkphz b cklfr|a jhcfhz+ B|pb ea`bfa lakphzåh h |r ihyaz lak |r h`h~phjcfc`h` `bea|pzh`h ~hzh mhjcphz b|~hlca| rzjhka| s bf lhe~a hjcbzpa+ Ffbdh`a| h b|pb pãzecka& lhjb ~zbdrkphz|b ~zbdrkphz|b lrèfb| |bzåhk fa| lakpbkc`a| b|~czcprhfb| `b phf b}~b`clcük lrhk`a bf eapcya    K ~zcklc~hf `b fh ec|eh ka b|pè ycklrfh`a h fh| pzh`clcakb|     Ü zbfcdca|h| falhfb|+ Rkh ~zbdrkph xrb fboa| `b |bz zbpüzclh& h~rkph    C h zb~rb|ph| b|bklchfb| ~hzh bf ã}cpa `b b|pb pc~a `b pzhjhoa+    L Bf ck|pckpa eb ffbyh h |rdbzcz xrb bk rkh |alcb`h` eè| s    H eè| lae~fboh& `ak`b lzbbklch| s yhfazb| b|~czcprhfb| `b    \ `cibzbkpb| lrfprzh| |b |ajzb~akbk& fh `hkh bk ~hc|hob ~rb`b |bz    C    Y rkh iazeh `b rkcz h fa| ecbejza| `b laerkc`h`b| lh`h yb eè|    A izhdebkph`h| s `b ~zaybbz rkh ~fhphiazeh hfpbzkhpcyh s mafå|pclh&    Z `ak`b fh b}~bzcbklch lak|lcbkpb `b krb|pzh ~zb|bklch bk bf    ^ bkpazka ka| ffbyb h fh zbifb}cük |ajzb krb|pza frdhz bk bf erk`a s    E |ajzb krb|pzh zbfhlcük lak hxrbffa| xrb ka| za`bhk+    C H pa`h| b|ph| ~zbdrkph| |b rkczåhk apzh| xrb& ka ~az |bz ebka| ~zairk`h|& `bohk `b |bz kblb|hzch|& laea bf ~fhkpbhz|b fh |r|pbkphjcfc`h` blaküeclh `b rk ~zalb|a b|lãkcla bk bf xrb fh zbkphjcfc`h` ickhklcbzh b| ~zèlpclhebkpb ckychjfb -pzhjhoa ~zafakdh`a s lak laerkc`h`b| zbfhpcyhebkpb ~bxrbøh| bk bkpazka| ÿkcla| xrb ce~c`bk xrb |b ~rb`h dczhz rkh ~za`rllcük#+ ±B|pb laklb~pa `b `hkh zbhfebkpb ~rb`b h~azphz hfda h fh| laerkc`h`b|1

< ±\b ~rb`b or|pciclhz fh ckybz|cük ~hzh ~akbz bk ehzlmh rkh ckclchpcyh `b b|pb pc~a %h kcybf ~zaib|cakhf% laea hfda xrb lrjzb kblb|c`h`b| lrfprzhfb| a bealcakhfb| `b hxrbffa| xrb ~rb`bk ~hzpclc~hz bk fh ec|eh1 \bhk lrhf |bhk fh| zb|~rb|ph| h b|ph| ~zbdrkph|& fa xrb ~rb`a hiczehz b| xrb ec| b}~bzcbklch| bk b|pb lhe~a mhk hjcbzpa ~rbzph| h fh| xrb& laea lzbh`az %s |ck |hjbzfa%& mb ffheh`a `rzhkpb erlma| høa|+ Fh bealcük lae~hzpc`h `b ybz lüea rk lae~fboa ph~c `b icdrzh| bk eaycecbkpa |b bkmbjzh |ajzb bf ~hc|hob& fh ffbdh`h `bf hphz`blbz& bf lèfc`a hjzha `bf h|ihfpa |ajzb bf xrb& sh jcbk bkpzh`h fh kalmb& zrb`h ~az fa| lrbz~a| cfreckh`a| ~az fh| frlb| `b ybmålrfa| h~a|ph`a| bk rk lzrlb `b lhecka|+++ Fh ehdch lzbh`h bk ã|pa| s apza| eaebkpa| eb cklfckh h hiczehz xrb |bdrczã& `b rk ea`a r apza& bk fh jÿ|xrb`h `b fh lzbhlcük `b krbya| lrh`za| `hklå|pcla| ck|~czh`a| ck|~czh`a| ~az fh c`bh *icdrzh s ~hc|hob*+

@zhtk pa @hklb Mhsthz` Dhffbzs+ Fak`ak& :>>2+ Dhffbzs ckpbz~zbphpcak+ \cpb%|~blcicl+ Zbjbllh Mazk -Lhzfa| Lazpã|#

BKPZBYC\PH

0

KC JHCFHZCKB\& KC HLPAZB\& KC Eß\CLA\… HZPC\PH\ B\LÃKCLA\ Ü|lhz \hfh| Düeb+ a|dybzNmapehcf+lae Fh| ehb|pzh| Hfeh Za|h Ehzpåk \rèzb s ^hebfh Oceãkb @zhdrclbycl& `b fh Ihlrfph` `b Jbffh| Hzpb| `b fh Rkcybz|c`h` Hrpükaeh `b Xrbzãphza& lakpckrhzak |r h~zbk`chob s hlprhfchlcük bk bf A`ck Pbhpza `b @ckhehzlh bk ehza `b :>>3+ @b |r b}~bzcbklch lak bf ehb|pza cphfchka ~ fhpcxrã lak fh ehb|pzh Hfeh+ ±Xrcãk b| Brdbkca Jhzjh1 

B| rkh ~bz|akh `b ~zairk`h eczh`h& lak rkh bkazeb lbzpbh bk |r| hlpa| s ~hfhjzh|& `b rkh |bklcffb hjzhh`azh& lh|c |hkh`azh& ~bza bf A`ck Pbhpza |ak pa`a|+ B| rkh hpeü|ibzh `b lafhjazhlcük& `b mbzehk`h`& `b lae~zbk|cük& `b `b|hzzaffa lzbhpcya+ Ka phk |üfa dbadzèiclhebkpb rkh c|fh+ Mhk lzbh`a rk ^hfhlca `bf Pbhpza `b rk ckerbjfb hjhk`akh`a xrb fb| `cbzak    K ~hzh ybz xrã mhlåhk+ Mh |c`a rk lh|pcffa lak|pzrc`a s lzbh`a ~az     Ü  pa`a|& xrb lh`h xrcbk pzhb bk |r lhjbh h `ak`b xrcbzh xrb yhsh+    C B| rkh yåh xrb ycbkb `b|`b Obzs Dzapat|gc& xrb Ohceb \azchka    L   pzhoa h Eã}cla& h xrcbk fb b|pas ers hdzh`blc`h xrb eb mhsh    H ckpza`rlc`a bk bffh+ Pb mhjfa `b mhlb eè| `b ybckpclckla høa|&    \ lrhk`a b}c|pcü bf c`bhf `b fh| laerkh|+    C  Ybkda `b fh lafcph `b hxrbffh| laerkh| lhfciazkchkh| `ak`b    Y    A   pb fbyhkphjh| hf hehkblbz ~hzh mhlbz sadh bk laerkcük+ B|pb    Z b|~åzcpr `b lafblpcyc`h` eb mh ihlcfcph`a lakblphzeb lak fh    ^ ~za~rb|ph `b A`ck Pbhpza7 rk c`bhf `b orybkpr` xrb lzbå     E `b|h~hzblc`a s xrb hf ffbdhz h b|h c|fh& h fa| lcklrbkph høa|& fa    C bklakpzã ehpbzchfch`a h pzhyã| `b rk eaycecbkpa lrsa| hkceh`azb|& xrcè eb |bhk `cb høa| ehsazb|+ Mh |c`a laea bklakpzhz krbyhebkpb fh ib+ B}c|pb rk b|~åzcpr `b lae~hzpcz& ka `b lae~bpcz+ ±B| ã|b bf ebaffa `b pr `albklch1 

Mh `h`a bk bf ~rkpa+ B|h b| fh ce~azphklch ycdbkpb `b Brdbkca+

±Mhs bk b|ph ~za~bk|cük& h`cllcük h fh lafblpcyc`h`& rk ~h|hz ~az bklceh  `b fh ck`cyc`rhfc`h`1 

\å& mhjfhea| `b b|pa& ~bza bklrbkpzh| h hzpc|ph| laea Cjbk Khdbf Zh|er||bk `b`clh`h `b`clh`h h pzhjhoa| pzhjhoa| ers ~bz|akhfb|+ ~bz|akhfb|+ Zajbzph Lhzzbzc xrb xrb `b`clü `a| høa| h fh zbhfchlcük `b \hfp bk lakpckrh ckpbzhllcük lak eÿ|cla|& xrb hf høa s eb`ca |b ~zb|bkphzak lak Brdbkca+ Ka b| rkh laerkh `b ycycz orkpa|& |cka `b lae~hzpcz yhfazb| ãpcla| lak rk bxrcfcjzca blaküecla s blreãkcla? pa`a| pcbkbk bf ec|ea |hfhzca `b hlrbz`a lak fh| b|pc~rfhlcakb| |hfhzchfb| `b @ckhehzlh+ Bf `b Brdbkca ka b| ehsaz ~az |bz `czblpaz+ Mhk ckybzpc`a bk lak|pzrcz fa xrb pcbkbk& xrb b| fa ehpbzchfebkpb ck`c|~bk|hjfb+ Bf froa bk b|b frdhz b|pè `h`a ~az fa xrb  yhea| `bohk`a xrcbkb| ~h|hea| ~az hmå+ Mhs pzhjhoa| `b ~ckpazb|& `b  pbob`azb| ph~bpb|+++ Sa `boã bk ec lrhzpa rk jaz`h`a `b Ohf~hk… lzba xrb fb| mhjåh dr|ph`a erlma lrhk`a b|prycbzak hxrå s yc|cphzak b|b frdhz+ Fa ffbyã ffbyã laea rk zbdhfa… zbdhfa… hmå mh xrb`h`a hfda `b Eã}cla+ Bf b|~hlca lak|pzrc`a ~az pa`a| pb ~c`b xrb fb `b|& ~azxrb |r mbzea|rzh  pcbkb fh dzhk`bh `b fa ~bxrbøa& fa lae~fboa `b fh |ce~fclc`h`+ Ã|pb b| bf bklhkpa `b rkh b|phklch!lakycybklch& xrb ka kblb|cph| lakybkcz rkh bkpzbdh+ ±Xrã yh| h mhlbz ~hzh xrb b|b bkzcxrblcecbkpa ka |b xrb`b bk pc1 

Ka b| hfda xrb ~rb`h eazcz ~azxrb |b pzhph `b fa xrb mb b|ph`a mhlcbk`a `b|`b mhlb `cb høa|+ Rkh `b fh| |hpc|ihllcakb| eè| dzhph| xrb mb ycyc`a& irb bklakpzhz xrb ka b|phea| mhlcbk`a irbzh `bf jhlåk bk zbfhlcük h ec| lakycllcakb| bk pazka hf pzhjhoa laz~azhf xrb |b ckclcã lak Ohceb s fh ckpza`rllcük bk Eã}cla `b fh| ~za~rb|ph| `b bkpzbkhecbkpa s `zhehpchlcük `b Dzapat|gc& bk fa xrb `b|~rã| eb xrb`ã |afh+ H b}lb~lcük `b hxrbf ck|phkpb bk xrb pzhoa h Xrbzãphza ‖Lcr`h`b| `b fh ebeazch― -Orfca& -Orfca& hda|pa `b :>>:#& lh`h rka ka| mbea| `b`clh`a `b`clh`a h krb|pzh| la|h|+ Eb `ca erlma dr|pa xrb Brdbkca yckcbzh h Xrbzãphza bf høa ~h|h`a7 eb `boü rkh| phzobph| xrb b|pryb `b|hzzaffhk`a lak ec| hfreka| lak bf ick `b jr|lhz fh ~za~ch azdhkclc`h` h pzhyã| `bf orbda s fh ce~zayc|hlcük+

BKPZBYC\PH Hxrå mhlb| bf `b|lrjzcecbkpa eb`chkpb bf hrpa% `b|lrjzcecbkpa& pÿ pb lak|pzrsb|+ Ka |as ehb|pzh& |as eapcyh`azh& drch`azh& ~azxrb fa ÿkcla h~azpb xrb ~rb`a `bohz b| bf h~zbk`chob `b xrb h~zbk`h| h h~zbk`bz+ Bf ffbyhz hf hlpaz h |bz azdèkcla& ycya& ~zb|bkpb& fb `h b|b yhfaz ÿkcla hf pzhjhoa `b Brdbkca Jhzjh s A`ck Pbhpza+ Rkh lak|blrbklch ckeb`chph `b b|pb lakphlpa |bzè bf dcza  paphf xrb `hzã h ec pb|c| `b ehb|pzåh+ ^bk|hjh hjaz`hz h Ebzlb Lrkkckdmhe s Ghra Aka& laea pzhjhoa| bk fåkbh| a~rb|ph|& ~bza hmazh b|pas lakybklc`h `b mhlbz rk pzhjhoa hlbzlh `b fh b}~zb|cyc`h`& fh azdhkclc`h`& bf hlpaz ycya+ Hxrbf pzhjhoa `b eb|b| ka eb mh mblma `høa& ~bza ~az fa ~zakpa fa `bohzã drhz`h`a+ B|pb krbya pzhjhoa ~rb`b |bz eè| bkzcxrblb`az ~hzh ec| hfreka|+ @b fh ehb|pzåh bk h`bfhkpb& `albklch b ckyb|pcdhlcük |b lae~fbebkphk& b| rkh lak|pzrllcük `b fa ec|ea+ Rkh pb|c| pb   pcbkb xrb ih|lckhz& eb mhk `clma ec| h|b|azb|& laea pzèecpb lhk|h s hjrzzb& ka mhs b|h lmc|~h bkbzdãpclh+ B|lzcjcz eb yh h    K `hz apza kcybf `b lae~zbk|cük `b Brdbkca Jhzjh+ Lh`h kalmb     Ü  ybåhea| rk b|~blpèlrfa s h fh ehøhkh |cdrcbkpb rk hkèfc|c|+ Bzhk    C    L  pzhjhoa| phk mbzea|a|& phk ce~zb|cakhkpb| xrb mhlåhk ers `ciålcf    H laklcfchz bf |rbøa+

2 Ka yba laea rkh ajzh `bf hhz xrb& c`bkpciclh`h| lak Dzapat|gc& mhshea| lacklc`c`a `b|`b mhlb `cb høa|& ^hebfh bk fh ckpbz~zbphlcük&   sa bk fh iazehlcük+ Ircea| fcecph`å|ceh|7 fcecph`å|ceh|7 `b |r ehpbzchf ehpbzchf ce~zb|a |üfa  pzhob fa xrb ka| zbdhfhzak+ Bk |r pcbk`h s jcjfcapblh |r| lakpbkc`a| |ak he~få|cea|& ers b|~blchfch`a|& bk pa`a| fa| c`caeh|+ ^az ec ~zalb|a ebpa`afüdcla eb ~za~r|b b|phz hmå& s fa fadzã+ Ec bkpbk`cecbkpa `bf ~zalb|a `b fh lzbhlcük `bf ~bz|akhob `b|`b fh bkbzdåh xrb bf hlpaz  pzhk|iazeh lzbhpcyhebkpb ka mhjzåh b|ph`a laklfrc`a |ck mhjbz b|ph`a bk @ckhehzlh+ @b hxrå |hla rkh ~zbec|h ehsaz? ka b}c|pb bf jhcfhzåk& ka b}c|pb bf hlpaz& |üfa bf hzpc|ph b|lãkcla+ \c prycbzh fh a~azprkc`h` `b zbb|pzrlprzhz fa| ~fhkb| `b b|pr`ca| xrcphzåh fh `cibzbklchlcük bkpzb jhcfhzckb|& hlpazb| s eÿ|cla|+ ¨Hs& |bzåh ehzhycffa|a hfda h|å(

   \    C ±Lüea |rlb`b bf bklrbkpza `b fa| hzpc|ph| b|lãkcla| `b     Y Xrbzãphza lak A`ck Pbhpza1     A Høa s eb`ca hpzè| hfdrcbk eb mhjåh `clma xrb Brdbkca    Z   ybk`zåh& s `b zb~bkpb b|prya hxrå lak Orfch Yhzfbs+ Mrja rkh    ^ lakyalhpazch ers |bfblpcyh+ @b|~rã| ycka Hrdr|pa Aeafÿ+    E Lrhk`a Brdbkca b|prya hxrå bk :>>= lakalcü krb|pza ckpbzã|    C

hlh`ãecla s ~b`hdüdcla bk fh ~za~rb|ph iazehpcyh s lzbhpcyh `bf A`ck Pbhpza+ Ka| bkycü rkh Ckycphlcük Ckycphlcük s lak ã|ph be~bhea| be~bhea|  pa`a bf ~zalb|a jrzalzèpcla bk bf CXLH s bk fh RHX ~hzh b|phz bk @ckhehzlh+

A`ck Pbhpzbp `b @ckhehzlh ~zb|bkpü Cp|c%jcp|c bk Blhpb~l @czblpaz? Brdbkca Jhzjh Iapa? Yhfbkpckh Yafhkpb

DB\PCÜK

9

@CYBZ\C@H@ B\ ZCXRB_H Eblfh `b |hkdzb s lrfprzh| h pzhyã| `b fh @hkh 

 ]caehzh Zrc  }caehzhN~zahzp+lae+e} Xrbzãphza irb bf ehzla `bf :¾ Ib|pcyhf Ckpbzkhlcakhf `b @hkh CJÃZCLH LAKPBE^AZÈKBH& lbfbjzh`a bk orfca `b :>>3& ce~rf|h`a ~az Lbkpza ^zahzp& ck|pcprlcük xrb `b|`b bf :>>>   pzhjhoh `b iazeh lae~zaebpc`h lak bf |bz mrehka s lak bf hzpb+ H~bfhk`a h fh zcxrbh `bf eb|pchob `b |hkdzb s lrfprzh|& xrb shlb bk krb|pzh| zhålb|& CJÃZCLH LAKPBE^AZÈKBH zbrkcü h eè| `b 4> hzpc|ph| `b B|~høh& Lrjh s B|ph`a| Rkc`a|& bk Xrbzãphza& Drh`hfhohzh& Eakpbzzbs& Drhkhorhpa s Eã}cla @I+ H fa fhzda `b `a| |behkh| |b ~zb|bkphzak? 3 Dhfh| `b @hkh B|~høafh& 8 Dhfh `b @hkh Lfè|clh& < B|~blpèlrfa| `b @hkh Lakpbe~azèkbh& : Laklcbzpa| `b Drcphzzh& : B}~a|clcakb| `b Hzpb| ^fè|pclh| -^ckprzh& B|lrfprzh s Iapadzhiåh#& : ^hkbfb| bk   pazka hf pbeh `b fh @hkh& 8 Erb|pzh Dh|pzaküeclh& 8    K Bklrbkpza `b Hlh`bech| -^hzpclc~hkpb| `b @hkh Iafgfüzclh     Ü Eb}clhkh& @hkh B|~høafh& Phkda& Jhffbp& Lakpbe~azèkba& Oh&    C    L @hkh Hãzbh& bkpzb apza|#+ Ehb|pza| `b dzhk ~zb|pcdca h kcybf ckpbzkhlcakhf |b    H    \ lakdzbdhzak ~hzh aizblbz lrz|a| s ~zb|bkphlcakb|& bkpzb bkpzb    C bffa|? Ehkafa Ehzåk -B|~høh#& Lzc|püjhf Zbsb| -B|~høh#& Afdh    Y Ehzåh Ehlmcakc ‖Fh Lmckh― -B|~høh#& Ehkrbf \bdaych -B|~høh#&    A Ehzåh Orklhf -B|~høh#& C|hjbf Jhsük -B|~høh#& Bf Ihzzr -B|~høh#&    Z bf Jhffbp B|~høaf `b Lrjh& B`r Fahka -B|~høh#& Bf Orkla    ^ -B|~høh#& bf Zbhf Lak|bzyhpazca `b @hkh Ehzcbeeh `b Eh`zc`    E -B|~høh#& Prfca `b fh Za|h -Eã}cla#& Czeh Eazhfb| -Eã}cla#&    C \maga Khgherzh s Tcb|fht @r`bg -`b fh Ü~bzh `b Jbzfåk#& bf Jhffbp Lrjhka `b Echec& Lae~høåh Fhzrejb -B|~høh#& ^b`za \cbzzh -B|~høh#& bkpzb apza|+ Eè| `b :2> hfreka|& jhcfhzckb| s ehb|pza| `b pa`h| ~hzpb| `b Eã}cla ~hzpclc~hzak `bf Lrz|a Ckpbzkhlcakhf `b @hkh+ Eè| `b 8>&>>> b|~blph`azb| h|c|pcbzak h|c|pcbzak h fa| B|~blpèlrfa| s hf Bklrbkpza Ckpbzkhlcakhf `b Dzr~a| s Hlh`bech|+

Fh :¯ b`clcük `bf Ib|pcyhf Ckpbzkhlcakhf `b @hkh CJÃZCLH LAKPBE^AZÈKBH irb rk dzhk fadza& rk b|irbza xrb h~azph hf `b|hzzaffa lrfprzhf& |alchf s blaküecla `b Eã}cla& ea|pzhk`a xrb |aea| rk ~hå| `b dzhk zcxrbh bk krb|pzh `cybz|c`h` lrfprzhf& hjcbzpa h zblcjcz fh| krbyh| pbk`bklch| `b fh `hkh ifhebklh+ Fh <¯ b`clcük |bzè bk :>88+ Fh lakyalhpazch ~hzh hzpc|ph| s lae~høåh| `b @hkh B|~høafh& Lfè|clh s apza| dãkbza| b|pè hjcbzph h ~hzpcz `b Bkbza `b :>8>+

^hzh bf bkyåa `b ~za~rb|ph|  s ehsaz ckiazehlcük `b lakphlpa& ~rb`bk laerkclhz|b lak? Fcl+ ]caehzh Zrc Laaz`ckhlcük Dbkbzhf CJÃZCLH LAKPBE^AZÈKBH  }caehzhN~zahzp+lae+e} -'2:%00:# :82%4>>>

ttt+~zahzp+lae+e}!cjbzclh>3 Mhlcbk`h \hkph Jèzjhzh ,880 Laf+ Bf Ohlhf L^+ 498=> Xrbzãphza& Xza+ EÃ]CLA Iapadzhiåh? Cjãzclh Lakpbe~azèkbh :>>3 % ttt+`hkcbfalmah+kbp

DB\PCÜK

4

^ZA%EAYBZ Hkhjbffh ^hzboh jbffsjappak3Nmapehcf+lae @bjc`a h xrb ycyå hfdrka| høa| bk Hzdbkpckh& h pzhyã| `b Ckpbzkbp |cda fbsbk`a fa| ~bzcü`cla| `b hffè+ ^zajhjfbebkpb ~az ka|phfdch s ~az xrbzbz |bdrcz bkpbzh`h `b fa xrb |rlb`b& ~bza  phejcãk ~azxrb b}c|pb rk |bdrcecbkpa `bf hzpb s lrfprzh `bf ~hå| xrb b| ffhehpcya& ffhehpcya ~azxrb hlè ka fa yba+ Hdbk`h| lrfprzhfb|& lzåpclh| `b ajzh| `b `hkh& pbhpza s lckb bk lhzpbfbzh xrb pb ihlcfcph b|phz bkpbzh`a `b fa xrb b|pè ~h|hk`a& `b xrcãk b|pè mhlcbk`a la|h|& `b xrã b|pèk mhlcbk`a  s `ük`b fa b|pèk mhlcbk`a& bk b|lhfh| xrb yhk eh| hffè `b rk ers ehfa h rk b}lbfbkpb+ S hlfhza xrb ka |üfa h kcybf laebzlchf |cka xrb b|pa| ~bzcü`cla| s lzåpcla| phejcãk fb `hk lhjc`h h fa| xrbmhlbzb| ck`b~bk`cbkpb|+ Mhlb rk høa xrb zbdzb|ã s `ciålcfebkpb fadza bkpbzhzeb `b fa xrb b|pè ~h|hk`a ~az hlè& ~zcklc~hfebkpb bk fh| hzpb| b|lãkclh|& sh xrb fa| laklcbzpa|& bf lckb& fh| hzpb| ~fè|pclh| s fh fcpbzhprzh& eh| a ebka| mhk |hjc`a ~zaeaybz|b7 ~bza `b fh|    K hzpb| b|lãkclh|& |c ka b| ~az rk jalh bk jalh a ~az rkh hz`rh     Ü   phzbh `b jÿ|xrb`h bk Ckpbzkbp s bk hfdrkh| zbyc|ph|& fh    C    L ckiazehlcük& bk lae~hzhlcük h apza| ~hå|b|& b| b|lh|h+ Fh    H hz`rh phzbh `b ckyb|pcdhlcük fh mhda sa& xrb eb ckpbzb|h& s    \ hfdrka| lrhkpa| eh|& ~bza& bk dbkbzhf& b| ce~a|cjfb xrb eè|    C dbkpb hllb`h+    Y Bk fh ÿfpceh kaph xrb fbå bk fh Khlcük& `chzca Hzdbkpcka&    A mhjfhjhk `b fh Ckclchpcyh Zafb} ~hzh Ebkpazb| s ^zapbdc`a|& bk fh    Z lrhf laebkphjhk xrb sh mhjåhk ~hzpclc~h`a 0 hzdbkpcka|& |c ehf    ^ ka zblrbz`a& `a| bk bf :>>3+ B|ph kapclch eb mca zblaz`hz xrb    E `rzhkpb pa`a bf høa eb bkpbzã `b fa| ~zbeca|& jblh| s `b fa|    C ib|pcyhfb| bk fa| xrb ~hzpclc~hzak fa| hzdbkpcka|& lak fa xrb eb  ycka rkh ~zcebz c`bh? fh laklfr|cük `b xrb fa| hzdbkpcka| bzhk eh| lzbhpcya| xrb ka|apza| fa| eb}clhka|+ Bk fh kalmb ~zblc|hebkpb ybåh rkh ~bfålrfh `b rk `czblpaz hzdbkpcka ers zblakalc`a& xrb b|pè jcbk ~bza ka eb ~hzblcü rk  pzhjhoa ehzhycffa|a laea fa xrb mhjåh b|lrlmh`a+

Lrhk`a fh ~bfålrfh pbzeckü ec ~hzboh& rk ~ala eafb|ph& eb laebkpü& % B|ph ~bfålrfh mh b|ph`a b|ph`a bk rk eakpük `b ib|pcyhfb|& ib|pcyhfb|& irb hmå  xrb ec laklfr|cük jè|clh `b xrb fa| hzdbkpcka| bzhk eh| lzbhpcya| xrb ka|apza| fa| eb}clhka| irb ckpbzzadh`h& ¨hiazprkh`hebkpb( Ka fb| xrcphzã |r| lzã`cpa| sh xrb |ak ~bz|akh| ers bkpzbdh`h| h fh yc`h lzbhpcyh s ers ~za~a|cpcya|+ ^bza eb `c lrbkph xrb bk b|h| kapclch|& bk b|h| hdbk`h| lrfprzhfb| xrb mb fbå`a `rzhkpb bf høa& mhs hfdrcbk xrb fh| b|lzcjb `b phf iazeh xrb pb `b|~cbzph lrzca|c`h` s dhkh|+ Lrzca|c`h` ~az lakalbz bf pzhjhoa `bf hzpc|ph h xrcbk |b zbicbzbk s dhkh| `b |bdrcz lzbhk`a s b|pr`chk`a+ Eb `c lrbkph xrb |hjbk ybk`bz ers jcbk bf  pzhjhoa `b |r| hzpc|ph|& s xrb phf yb b|pè hmå fh `cibzbklch lak ka|apza|+ Xrb h|å laea sa eb bkpbzü `b fa xrb ~az hffè ~h|h lak phkph ihlcfc`h` bk  pa`a| fa| lhe~a|& h|å |b bkpbzhk apzh| ~bz|akh| s h|å ~rb`bk mhlbz xrb |r| hzpc|ph| |bhk zblakalc`a| erk`chfebkpb+ Zbcpbza xrb b|ph hr|bklch bk Eã}cla fh yba eè| bk fh| hzpb| b|lãkclh|& sh xrb lzba xrb& ~az bobe~fa& bf lckb eb}clhka bk fa| ÿfpcea| høa| |b mh |hjc`a ~a|clcakhz ~a|clcakhz `b ers jrbka| jrbka| frdhzb|7 h|å xrb xrcbza xrcbza ~bk|hz xrb fh ihfph `b lzåpcla|& `b ~bzcü`cla|& `b zbyc|ph| xrb h~asbk bf  pzhjhoa `b fa| lzbh`azb| |b `ciclrfpb hÿk eh| hf xrbzbz hllb`bz h eh| dbkpb+ A phf yb fa| ~zbeca|& fa| zblakalcecbkpa|& fh ~hzpclc~hlcük bk ib|pcyhfb| b}c|pb& ~bza `b cdrhf iazeh phe~ala eb bkpbza+

CC Ib|pcyhf `b Ckpbzlhejca Ckpbzkhlcakhf Eöryhf+ Iapadzhiåh? Izhklc|la Fü~b

^HPZCEAKCA

=

BF ^HPZCEAKCA LAEA @BPAKH@AZ BLAKÜECLA @B FH\ LAERKC@H@B\ B`erk`a Hzprza Icdrbzah Yczrbdh bhiyNmapehcf+lae @åh h `åh fh lzc|c| blaküeclh |b hlzblcbkph s bf h~asa blaküecla ~az ~hzpb `bf |blpaz ~afåpcla s be~zb|hzchf mhlch fh| laerkc`h`b| b| eè| fcecph`a s lh`h yb yh eè| bkialh`a h èzbh| `b ~zcebzh kblb|c`h`& laea |ak fa| zrjza| `b |hfr`& |bdrzc`h` b ckizhb|pzrlprzh7 |ck bejhzda& fh| laerkc`h`b| `b fa| `cybz|a| ~rkpa| `b fh zb~ÿjfclh ~rb`bk yafybz|b hrpa%|r|pbkphjfb| eb`chkpb fh ~zaealcük s dbkbzhlcük `b z blrz|a|& paehk`a laea ehpbzch ~zceh bf be~fhhecbkpa `ak`b |b mhffhk& b| `blcz& bkpbk`cbk`a& lakalcbk`a s yhfazchk`a bf ~hpzceakca lrfprzhf& ehpbzchf b ckehpbzchf& xrb |b ~a|bb+ Hkpb| xrb kh`h hlfhzbea| xrb ~az ~hpzceakca |b bkpcbk`b  pa`a hxrbffa xrb pcbkb rk yhfaz ~bz |b 7 b| hxrbffa xrb `h hzzhcda s lakiazeh fh mc|pazch& la|prejzb| s pzh`clcakb| `b rk ~rbjfa+ Bf ~hpzceakca& h |r yb& |b `cyc`b bk phkdcjfb b ckphkdcjfb? bf ~zcebza    K fa ckpbdzhk pa`a| hxrbffa| |cpca| `b zcxrbh khprzhf& hzxrbafüdclh&     Ü mc|püzclh s hzpå|pclh7 ecbkpzh| xrb bf ckehpbzchf fa lae~akbk    C   pa`a| h|~blpa| lapc`chka| xrb mhk ~h|h`a `b dbkbzhlcük bk    L dbkbzhlcük& phfb| laea fh fbkdrh& fh| `hkh| pzh`clcakhfb|& fa|    H  pzhob| på~cla|& fh| hzpb|hkåh|& fh dh|pzakaeåh& bkpzb apza|+    \ Lh`h zbdcük a eclzazbdcük `bf ~hå| lrbkph lak |cpca|    C    Y ~hpzceakchfb| -`b ehsaz a ebkaz bkybzdh`rzh#& h`beè| `b    A   pzh`clcakb| mrehkh|& pa`h| bffh| `cdkh| `b |bz b|pr`ch`h|&    Z lakpbe~fh`h| s lae~hzpc`h|+ H ~hzpcz `b bffh|& fh| laerkc`h`b| ~rb`bk ~zaeaybz    ^ `b|`b bf przc|ea fh| akh| |ck kblb|c`h` `b pbkbz zblrz|a|    E blaküecla| hjrk`hkpb|7 ~hzh bffa& fa c`bhf b| zbhfchz rkh    C ~zaealcük h`blrèk`a|b h fa b}c|pbkpb s `b iazeh ~hrfhpckh& s |üfa bk lh|a| kblb|hzca| ~zaeaybz `b|hzzaffa| `b ckizhb|pzrlprzh xrb |afybkpbk fh fh `behk`h& |cbe~zb b|phk`a b|phk`a lak|lcbkpb| `b xrb pa`a `b|hzzaffa b| fh hfpbzhlcük `b rk bkpazka& ~az fa lrhf `bjb |bz eb|rzh`a b ckpbdzèk`a|b fa eboaz ~a|cjfb hf lakpb}pa& bycphk`a lak bffa `biazb|phlcakb|& |ajzb~ajfhlcakb|& lakpheckhlcük& eè| fh `b|lakpb}prhfchlcük s fh `b|ycklrfhlcük `b|ycklrfhlcük bkpzb fa b}c|pbkpb b}c|pbkpb s fa dbkbzh`a+

\ck `r`h hfdrkh& fh fhjaz ~zceaz`chf ~hzh fh| laerkc`h`b| lak|c|pb bk zb|~bphz& lak|bzyhz s ~zb|bzyhz |r ~hpzceakca& phkdcjfb b ckphkdcjfb& b cklrflhz |r c`bkpc`h` lrfprzhf bkpzb fh| krbyh| dbkbzhlcakb|+ B| ce~azphkpb |bøhfhz xrb bf bf mblma `b lak|bzyhzfh| ka |cdkciclh ycycz bk rkh bzh `b zbpzh|a7 bf ~zadzb|a ~rb`b s `bjb cz `b fh ehka& h`h~pèk`a|b h lh`h ~ajfhlcük s ka h fh ckybz|h& ea`ciclhk`a zh`clhfebkpb fh yc`h `b fh| laerkc`h`b| a bkpzhk`a bk rk zae~cecbkpa bkpzb bf ~h|h`a& bf ~zb|bkpb s bf irprza& fa xrb lakffbyh rkh ~bz`c`h xrb ~a`zåh zb|rfphz czzbybz|cjfb `b krb|pza| azådbkb|7 ~az b|a& |b `bjb b|phz lak|lcbkpb| `b xrb bf bkzcxrblcecbkpa lrfprzhf |b mh `h`a bk pa`a| fa| ~rbjfa| h fa fhzda `b fh mc|pazch s xrb b| bf zb|rfph`a `b fh |reh `b ihlpazb| ckpbzka| s b}pbzka| xrb |b ckpbdzhk hf ea`a `b yc`h h|cecfèk`afa| laea ~hzpb `b lh`h ck`cyc`ra& s xrb pcbkbk laea ~za`rlpa ickhf rk ~zalb|a byafrpcya xrb lak`rlb h rkh ehsaz zcxrbh lrfprzhf+ Ck`r`hjfbebkpb bk fh hlprhfc`h` fh iazeh `b yc`h mh lhejch`a ~az `cybz|a| ihlpazb| ea`ciclhk`a& bk hfdrka| lh|a| hjc|ehfebkpb bf lakpb}pa s fh| la|prejzb| la|prejzb| xrb ~bz`rzhzak ~az dbkbzhlcakb|7 dbkbzhlcakb|7 h`beè| fa xrb zb|rfph laea rkh ckyhzchkpb b| xrb& |ck ce~azphz fh hkpcdöb`h` `bf ~ajfh`a& lh`h rka pcbkb bfbebkpa| ~za~ca| xrb fb `hk rk lhzèlpbz ÿkcla& ckifrbklch`a ~az fh| la|prejzb| xrb fa| ~zcebza| eazh`azb| pbkåhk& h|å laea fh zbfhlcük ckmbzbkpb lak bf lakpb}pa `ak`b |b `b|hzzaffhzak+ Mas bk `åh fh dfajhfchlcük& fh ecdzhlcük s apza| h|~blpa| mhk  pzhk|iazeh`a b cklfr|a jazzh`a bf zb|~bpa s fh pzh`clcük `b fa| hlpa| xrb ~az høa| irbzak bf bob zblpaz `b fh| |alcb`h`b|7 b| ~az bffa `b dzhk zbfbyhklch zblr~bzhz s ehkpbkbz krb|pza| azådbkb| s krb|pza bkpazka ~azxrb |ak bf kb}a ycycbkpb bkpzb bf hsbz s bf ehøhkh+

ZBIFB]CÜK

3

±H @ÜK@B YHEA\ YHEA\ LAK FH @HK_H @HK_H1 Ibzkhk`a Jr|pa| Drpcãzzb  }ibkhNmapehcf+lae Bf jhcfhzåk ffbdh hf |cpca `ak`b |b ~zb|bkphzè& aj|bzyh bf b|lbkhzca& h yblb| fa b}~fazh hf ffbdhz s apzh| `b|~rã| `b ~h|hz ~az bf lhebzcka+ Apzh| yblb| sh fa lakalb s |üfa |b ~zb~hzh ~hzh lhfbkphz& ~bzibllcakhz hfdÿk eaycecbkpa& zb~h|hz bf |hfpa a fh lhzdh`h xrb h yblb| ihffh& a b|h rfpceh lazzbllcük xrb `h bf `czblpaz& bf lazbüdzhia a bf lae~høbza `hkhkpb+ ` hkhkpb+ Bf mrehka `boh rkh ~hzpb `b |å bk bf lhebzcka s apzh ~hzpb pzh| fh ~cbzkh `bf iaza& s bk bf b|lbkhzca ybea| rk lrbz~a xrb erph bk lh`h zb|~czhlcük& rk lrbz~a b}lcph`a eaycbk`a bf  pcbe~a s bf b|~hlca h |r hfzb`b`az+ Hf ickhf& bf jhcf hzåk ka |hjb bk xrb ~hzpb `bf fceja b|prya ecbkpzh| |r lrbz~a `hkhjh mc~kapchk`a s mhlcbk`a laerkcük lak |r ~ÿjfcla+ H yblb|& fa| jhcfhzckb|%hlzüjhph|%hlpazb| ka |hjbea| h `ük`b yh krb|pzh zhük ecbkpzh| xrb bf ck|pckpa |b h~a`bzh `bf lrbz~a+ Bkpaklb|& sa lrb|pcaka? ±H `ük`b yhea| lak fh `hkh1 Lzba xrb b|ph ~zbdrkph `bjb mhlãz|bfh lh`h jhcfhzåk s    K     Ü lazbüdzhia hf ckclchz rk ~zalb|a lzbhpcya b ckpbz~zbphpcya& bkpzb    C fh erfpcpr` `b pãlkclh| s b|pcfa| `b eaycecbkpa ~hzh b|ladbz& fh    L   yhzcb`h` `b pbeh| xrb ka| za`bhk s fh ckickc`h` `b b|påerfa|    H lzbhpcya| xrb pbkbea| bk lh`h rkh `b fh| ecfb| `b kapclch|    \ |ajzb krb|pzh lcr`h`& b|ph`a& ~hå| s erk`a+ S |ck bejhzda& fh    C    Y ehsazåh ~cbk|h bk lrèk jakcpa |b yb hkpb bf b|~boa& bk xrb phk    A zè~c`a |b ~rb`b dczhz& bk lrèkph eÿ|clh |b ~rb`b rpcfchz& xrb    Z   phk hfpa mhs xrb |hfphz s bk lh`h rkh `b fh| la|h| xrb    ^ bkyrbfybk hf laeÿk erk`a `hklå|pcla& xrb bk |r ehsazåh& s |ck ebkpcz& b|pè lhzdh`a `b bkyc`ch& lbfa|& mc~alzb|åh s erlmh|    E apzh| bealcakb| xrb lazzae~bk fh b|~czcprhfc`h` xrb ka| `h fh    C `hkh+ Pzhphz `b kbdhz s lhffhz b|ph ybz`h` b| lhbz bk bffh s `hzfb eè| zhük `b b}c|pcz+

Bk fa ~hzpclrfhz& eb dr|ph paehz laea ~zcebz b|pcerfa fa xrb `coa rkh yb rk dzhk maejzb? ‖Bf hzpc|ph pcbkb xrb |bz fh ya s fh laklcbklch `b |r pcbe~a―7 lak b|ph| ~hfhjzh| `b Oa|ã Fceük& lak|c`bza xrb `bjbzåhea| laebkhz laebkhz krb|pza zcprhf `b lzbhlcük b ckpbz~zbphlcük+ ^azxrb krb|pzh khlcük fa ebzblb s fa ~c`b& fa| hzpc|ph| lakpbe~azèkba| `bjbea| |bz fa| krbya| drbzzcffbza|& fbyhkphzka| lak krb|pzh| hzeh| s frlmhz rkh krbyh zbyafrlcük7 |bz oüybkb| xrb bk|bøbk h fa| oüybkb|+ Kblb|cphea| jr|lhz s bklakpzhz bf lhecka mhlch fh zb|~rb|ph h b|h ~zbdrkph+ Ka mhdhea| `hkh lakiazec|ph& `b azkhpa& ffbkh `b mbzea|h| icdrzh| s |ck rk lakpbkc`a xrb `bob mrbffh bk krb|pzh  ybz`h`bzh lapc`chkc`h`+ Kblb|cphea| rkh `hkh xrb ka| zbifbob s xrb`b ~fh|eh`h laea fa| erzhfb|& bk bf zblrbz`a& ka laea rk afyc`a& |cka laea rk ~zb|bkpb+ Kblb|cphea| `b rkh `hkh lak ebph| xrb ka| bkzcxrblhk laea maejzb| s hzpc|ph| lakpbe~azèkba|+ Bkpaklb|& xrcè| laebklbea| h cz ~az bf lhecka mhlch fh zb|~rb|ph& s mhlch rk ~hå| kajfb& lak ybz`h`bzh fcjbzph`& |hjc`rzåh& mrecf`h` s ~a`bz+

Iapadzhiåh? Laaz`ckhlcük Khlcakhf `b @hkh Laerkc`h` `b @hkh `b Eã}cla @bkpza `b fh| hlpcyc`h`b| `b ^ZC\EH Iazre

ZBIFB]CÜK

8>

 SA& B\^BLPH@AZ ^hrfckh \hjrdhf ^hrfckh>8>Nmapehcf+lae Bf ihea|a b|lzcpaz zr|a& C|hhl H|ceay& bk |r ~afãecla pb}pa `b lcbklch icllcük Sa& Zajap& zbfhph& bkpzb apzh| la|h|& xrb bk rkh   pcbzzh `ak`b bf zajap |b mh lakybzpc`a bk rk ajobpa bfblpza`aeã|pcla eè|& b}c|pbk pzb| fbsb|? 8+ Rk zajap ka `bjb `høhz h rk |bz mrehka a& ~az |r ckhllcük& `bohz xrb rk |bz mrehka |rizh `høa+ :+ Rk zajap `bjb ajb`blbz fh| üz`bkb| xrb fb |ak `h`h| ~az rk |bz mrehka& b}lb~pa lrhk`a b|ph| üz`bkb| |b a~akbk h fh ~zcebzh fbs+ <+ Rk zajap `bjb ~zapbdbz |r ~za~ch b}c|pbklch mh|ph `ak`b b|h ~zapbllcük ka bkpzb bk lakifclpa lak fh ~zcebzh a fh |bdrk`h fbs+  S jhoa b|ph ~zbec|h pzhk|lrzzb ã|ph mc|pazch& lakphk`a bf |ck kÿebza `b hkãl`aph| ~az fh| xrb hpzhycb|hk phkpa mrehka|    K laea zajap| bk rkh ã~alh bk xrb bf maejzb s fh eèxrckh     Ü lakycybk bk |alcb`h`+    C H|å laea H|ceay ~fhkpbh fh ckifrbklch xrb fh pblkafadåh mh    L    H  pbkc`a h fa fhzda `bf pcbe~a bk fh mc|pazch `bf |bz mrehka& mh|ph    \ hf ~rkpa `b ffbdhz h rkh paphf `b~bk`bklch `b fh| eèxrckh| bk bf    C irprza& h pzhyã| `b ã|pb pb}pa ~za~akda rkh zbifb}cük |ajzb fh    Y ~zb|bklch xrb pcbkbk fh| hzpb| b|lãkclh| bk bf lapc`chka `b fa|    A ck`cyc`ra| xrb& lh`h yb eè|& zcdbk |r| yc`h| ~az rkh pblkafadåh    Z xrb& bk fh ehsazåh `b fh| alh|cakb|& fa| zbjh|h+    ^ Sa& b|~blph`az& ±xrcãk |as1 \ck `r`h& bf xrb b|~bzh& ~bza    E bk bf ~zalb|a lzbhpcya& pa`a| b|~bzhea|? bf hrpaz& bf `czblpaz&    C fa| boblrphkpb|& fa| ~za`rlpazb|& bf b|lbküdzhia7 |ck bejhzda& bf b|~blph`az ordh& lzcpclh& `b|phh+ Pcbkb ~a`bz& ~bza ~alh|   yblb| |b mhlb zb|~ak|hjfb+ ±Ka `bjbzåh& hf cdrhf xrb bk fh icllcük `b C|hhl H|ceay& zbdcz|b ~az pzb| zbdfh| jè|clh|1 Hfda laea?

8+ Rk b|~blph`az ka `bjb `høhz h rk hzpc|ph a& ~az |r ckhllcük& `bohz xrb rk hzpc|ph |rizh `høa+ :+ Rk b|~blph`az `bjb ajb`blbz fh| üz`bkb| xrb fb |ak `h`h| ~az rk hzpc|ph& b}lb~pa lrhk`a b|ph| üz`bkb| |b a~akbk h fh ~zcebzh fbs+ <+ Rk b|~blph`az `bjb ~zapbdbz |r ~za~ch b}c|pbklch mh|ph `ak`b b|h ~zapbllcük ka bkpzb bk lakifclpa lak fh ~zcebzh a fh |bdrk`h fbs+ Fh ~zcebzh fbs& bkpbk`c`h laea xrb fh ckhllcük `bf b|~blph`az& |b   pzh`rlb laea rkh ckh|c|pbklch `bf ec|ea hf b|~blpèlrfa bk przka7 ±s xrã ~rb`b lhr|hz eè| `høa h rk hzpc|ph xrb ~zb|bkphz|b hkpb rk   pbhpza yhlåa1 Fh |bdrk`h fbs |b zbibzczåh or|pa h lhbz bk fh pbkphlcük ~zayalh`h ~az bf hzpc|ph s h ~hzpclc~hz `bf ibküebka b|lãkcla lak pa`h ~fbkcpr`? zbåz& ffazhz& h~fhr`cz a hjrlmbhz7 `bohz|b drchz ~az bf hzpc|ph& laea |c |b pzhphzh `b rk dzr~a `b lcbda| h ebzlb` `b rk fhhzcffa+ S ~az ÿfpcea& fh pbzlbzh fbs ajb`blbzåh h xrb b| zb|~ak|hjcfc`h` irk`hebkphf `bf b|~blph`az& fh `b b}cdcz bf pc~a `b b|~blpèlrfa xrb xrcbzb ybz7 |ck lhbz& ~az |r~rb|pa& bk xrb ‖hf lfcbkpb mhs xrb `hzfb fa xrb ~c`h― |cka ‖bk|bøhzfa h ~b`cz―+   Sa& b|~blph`az |as bf ÿfpcea b|fhjük xrb lae~fbph bf mblma b|lãkcla+ \as hxrbf aoa xrb eczh b|ph icllcük `b fh xrb `b ~zakpa sh iazea ~hzpb+ Ka jh|ph lak cz h lae~zhz rk jafbpa s |bkphz|b lüea`hebkpb `rzhkpb `a| mazh| bk fh jrphlh b|~bzhk`a h |bz lakybklc`a `b hfda+ \aea| eè|7 |aea| bf xrb ckpbz~zbph& |b lakerbyb  s ~zayalh+ Jh|ph sh `b fa `cdbzc`a s `b mhlbz m hlbz rk hzpb bfcpc|ph& lzbh`a |üfa ~hzh ~ hzh fa| hzpc|ph|+ Paebea| bf zcb|da& bkpaklb|& `b b}cdcz bf hzpb xrb xrbzbea| ybz s fh zb|~ak|hjcfc`h` xrb pbkbea| pa`a| laea b|~blph`azb|7 `b|~rã| `b pa`a& ka |aea| zajap|+

ZBIFB]CÜK

88

¨FA CE^AZPHKPB B\ EAYBZ\B( ^bzfh ^hafh \èklmb Yèxrb ~hafh|hklmbyNshmaa+lae H pzhyã| `b fh mc|pazch& bk fh| lrfprzh|& fa| ~hå|b| b cklfr|cyb fh| laerkc`h`b| hc|fh`h| `b fh xrb ffhehea| lcycfc`h`& bf bklrbkpza lak rka ec|ea |cbe~zb mh |c`a rkh lakyalhpazch mrehkh xrb& hf ickhf& |b lakycbzpb bk hfda xrb azdèkclhebkpb |afclcph lrhfxrcbz lrbz~a lak yc`h+ Bf eaycecbkpa fa pbkbea| bk lh`h lãfrfh xrb `b|hzzaffh |r lclfa7 h|å& |c ~bk|hea| xrb |aea| rk lakorkpa ckebk|a `b bffh|& |b mhlb kblb|hzca |rizcz hlaea`a| s eaybzka| cklb|hkpbebkpb& |bdrcz fh lh`bklch azdèkclh ~hz h b}~bzcebkphz rk jcbkb|phz ic|cafüdclhebkpb lae~zajh`a ~bza& bk `bickcpcyh& ebkphfebkpb kblb|hzca+ Lzba xrb |aea| hzpc|ph| `b jh|b& sh xrb lh`h `åh eakphea| rk b~c|a`ca eè| `b krb|pzh yc`h7 sh b| pzcffh`a `blcz xrb |aea| fa| hzxrcpblpa| `b krb|pza ~za~ca `b|pcka& ~bza fa    K xrb |c b| rkh zbhfc`h` b| xrb |aea| fa| lzbh`azb| `b lh`h     Ü eaebkpa `bf `åh+ H|å& bf eaycecbkpa h~rb|ph h fh b}~bzcbklch `b    C rk zbpa ~bz|akhf? eaybz eaybz bf lrbz~a dbkbzh rkh |cprhlcük    L ~hzpclrfhz `c|pckph bk lh`h eaebkpa+ Bkpaklb|& bf `b|hzzaffa    H laz~azhf dbkbzh rk b|~hlca xrb ybkpcfh bealcakb|& hjzb    \ lhecka| `b izr|pzhlcük s `bzzaph `b~zb|cakb|+    C  Ybea| xrb lh`h yb mhs eè| pãlkclh| hzpå|pclh| xrb |b    Y    A h`h~phk h fa| lrbz~a|& pcbe~a|& bph~h| `b yc`h7 b|ph| pãlkclh|    Z laz~azhfb| ~rb`bk |bz hzpå|pclh|& pbzh~ãrpclh| a |ce~fbebkpb    ^ ckpza|~blpcyh|& h pzhyã| `b `c|lc~fckh| xrb ehkbohk fh    E dbkbzhlcük `b fh bkbzdåh laz~azhf+ Fh `hkh bk |r| `cibzbkpb|    C  ybzpcbkpb|& ~az bobe~fa& h~rb|ph lh`h yb eè| ~az fa azdèkcla& h ka fh|pcehz hzpclrfhlcakb| a& cklfr|cyb& h zbmhjcfcphz pbk`akb|& eÿ|lrfa| a ehfh| ~a|przh| xrb mhk dbkbzh`a `afaz a fb|cakb|+ Bk fa ~bz|akhf zblaecbk`a fh `hkh ~azxrb eb ~hzblb rk ~zalb|a hzpå|pcla hzpå|pcla lae~fbpa& lae~fbpa& bk `ak`b |cbe~zb |b ~rb`bk bklakpzhz krbya| lhecka| s b}~bzcebkphz lak krbyh| pãlkclh|+

Cklfrsb fh eÿ|clh& fh bkbzdåh& bf zcpea& bf hlak`clcakhecbkpa iå|cla s lczphpbzh~ch ebkphf `b hj|pzhllcük bkialh`h ÿkclhebkpb hf eaycecbkpa& `b|`b `ak`b hjzb lhecka| `b zbifb}cük s eb`cphlcük h pzhyã| `b rk `b|hzzaffa laz~azhf+ Bf jhffbp& fh jhzzh hf ~c|a& fh| pãlkclh| lhzcjbøh|& bf mc~ ma~& bf ph~& fh `hkh lakpbe~azèkbh bk |r| `cibzbkpb| pãlkclh|& laea bf zbfbh|b& fh ce~zayc|hlcük& bf bf lakphlp& a fh `hkh lak eblfh| eblfh| `b phkda a ifhebkla& ifhebkla& |ak ~za~rb|ph| xrb mhs xrb lakalbz s& |ck ~bk|hz `a| yblb|& hpzbybz|b h b}~bzcebkphz lak krb|pza ~za~ca lrbz~a& sh xrb pa`h| ã|ph| ~rb`hk |bz zb~zb|bkphlcakb| s pzh`rlczfh| bk c`caeh| laz~azhfb| ~hzh xrb lakphz mc|pazch|& bealcakb| a |ce~fbebkpb bf dr|pa `b eaybz|b+ ^a`bea| be~bhz lak rk jhcfb bk lh|h& eaycbk`a rk `b`a& frbda rkh ehka& `b|~rã| bf jzha s h|c fa xrb yhshk `blc`cbk`a& b|~hf`h bk bf |rbfa& mhlbz rkh b|pzbffh lak bf lrbz~a s frbda b}~bzcebkphz rkh iazeh ibphf& zblakalbz bf lrbz~a s yafybzfa h |bkpcz& zblajzhz b|h b}~bzcbklch `b rk jbjã& palhz rk `b`a `bf ~cb lak fh khzc s fh za`cffh lak fh izbkpb7 |c ~bk|hea|& bf eaycecbpka b| hfda xrb sh ybkch bk bf ~hxrbpb azdèkcla& ~bza xrb |b irã ~az fh |cffh `b fh aiclckh a bf |cffük izbkpb h fh pbfbyc|cük+ Hf b|phz eè| bk lakphlpa lak pr lrbz~a& lak pr| bealcakb| s lak   pr ~bk|hecbkpa |b dbkbzh fa xrb jr|lhea|& lakdzrbklch bkpzb ckpbfcdbklch bealcakhf s laz~azhf+

lfh|b ehdc|pzhf `b `hkh phcfhk`b|h Lae~høåh `b `hkh phcfhk`b|h \AEH^H+ Pbhpza `b fh @hkh& Eã}cla& @I+ Iapadzhiåh? Hzch`kh @aeåkdrb

ZBIFB]CÜK

8:

CE^ZAYC\HLCÜK+ Hrzh Phkph`bf Fü~b Lakpzbzh| ckiaNerryhf+lae Bf ckpbzã| `b b|pb pb}pa ka zh`clh bk b|lzcjcz a zbla~cfhz `bickclcakb| `bf laklb~pa ce~zayc|hlcük7 ~zbicbza hjzcz rkh ~rbzph h ã|ph hlpcyc`h`& iaebkphz bf r|a `b bffh& ~zhlpclhzfh& lae~hzpczfh  s dbkbzhzfh orkpa lak apza|+ Fh ~zcebzh yb xrb |b eb ckpza`roa h fh ce~zayc|hlcük b|pryb bk rk ~zalb|a `ciålcf& ffbka `b pbk|cakb| s lakpzh`cllcakb|& zb|c|pbklch| ~bz|akhfb|& b|pãpclh|& icfa|aiåh| lbzzh`h| s ihfph `b ckiazehlcük xrb& mh|ph mas& lakpckÿa bklakpzhk`a bk bf lhecka `b fh lzbhlcük& fh ce~zayc|hlcük& fh `hkh s fh yc`h+ H|å& `b|~rã| `b erlmh| yrbfph|& pbk|cakb| s `cibzbklch| hkpb bf laklb~pa ce~zayc|hlcük  s fh b}~bzcbklch& ka ckpbkphzã `bickczfh |cka bklrh`zhz hfdrka| h|~blpa| xrb& lak|c`bza& lakpcbkb7 phe~ala ckpbkpa `bea|pzhz lakalcecbkpa& |üfa lae~hzpcz laklfr|cakb| xrb |b yhk lak|pzrsbk`a b ckpbdzhk`a& laea bk lrhfxrcbz ~zalb|a `b ce~zayc|hlcük+ Fh ce~zayc|hlcük b|pè ~zb|bkpb bk krb|pzh yc`h lapc`chkh&    K     Ü bk pa`a hlpa `b lzbhlcük s& hÿk |bh ~zbeb`cph`h& b|pè ~fhdh`h    C `b zb|~rb|ph| ckeb`chph| h b|påerfa| ckpbzka| s b}pbzka|+ @b|`b    L fh yc|cük `b hzpb| b|lãkclh|& hrkxrb lak|c`bza xrb pa`a b|    H h~fclhjfb h lrhfxrcbz la|h& fh ce~zayc|hlcük rpcfch& lak|lcbkpb a    \ cklak|lcbkpbebkpb& hfdrkh| mbzzhecbkph|? cehdckhlcük&    C    Y zhakhecbkpa& zbla~cfhlcük `b lakalcecbkpa|& ebeazch&    A lzbhpcyc`h` s fh ~za~calb~lcük7 ~bza pbkbz `c|~a|clcük& h~bzprzh s    Z  yafrkph` h fa `b|lakalc`a |ak la|h| xrb hsr`hk hf ~zalb|a `b    ^ ce~zayc|hz+ Bf lakorkpa `b pa`h| b|ph| mbzzhecbkph| iazehk ~hzpb `b    E krb|pzh paeh `b `blc|cakb|& `b krb|pza ~zalb|a `b b}~fazhlcük&    C `b|hzzaffa s laklzblcük `b c`bh|7 h|å& fh lzbhlcük b|pè ycklrfh`h lak fh lh~hlc`h` `b ce~zayc|hz s lae~hzpcz lakalcecbkpa| b c`bh| lak bf erk`a+ Lrhk`a cehdckhea| a b}~fazhea| c`bh|& zbhfchea| eÿfpc~fb| hj|pzhllcakb| `b fh zbhfc`h`& zb|~ak`bea| hkpb rkh kblb|c`h`& lczlrk|phklch& eaebkpa& `b|ba a ~zbibzbklch7 fh cehdckhlcük b| rkh zbhllcük ck|phkpèkbh h rk b|pcerfa ckpbzka a b}pbzka& b| bf ckclca `b fh lzbhlcük& `b fh ce~zayc|hlcük+

  Ybea| xrb ‖fh lzbhpcyc`h` b| rkh ihlrfph` ~apbklchf `b pa`a |bz mrehka― & rkh lhzhlpbzå|pclh& kblb|c`h` s mbzzhecbkph `b pa`a ck`cyc`ra s |r |alcb`h`+ Fh ~hfhjzh lzbhpcyc`h` pcbkb |r azcdbk bk bf   pãzecka ‖lzbhzb―& xrb |cdkciclh& bkdbk`zhz& ~za`rlcz& lzbhz+ @b hlrbz`a lak b|ph `bickclcük& fh lzbhpcyc`h` b| rkh `ckèeclh& rk ~zalb|a hjcbzpa xrb lae~azph phejcãk rkh hlpcyc`h` `ckèeclh s xrb cklfrsb fh laklzblcük `b c`bh|+ Fh ~bzlb~lcük `b|`b rka ec|ea s `b rka ec|ea -~za~calb~lcük# b| bf eapaz `b eaycecbkpa `bkpza `b b|pb ~zalb|a `b cehdckhlcük%lzbhlcük7 ã|pb ~zalb|a |b `bfckbh lak fh zbla~cfhlcük `b a~lcakb| xrb ka| jzck`h fh cehdckhlcük& fh ebeazch `b fh| ec|eh| s laea fh| |bfbllcakhea| ~az eb`ca `bf zhlcalckca& ~hzh h|å  lak|pzrcz& lzbhz& ckybkphz& ce~zayc|hz+ Bk fa xrb lazzb|~ak`b hf lhe~a `b fh| hzpb| b|lãkclh| s lrfprzh bk dbkbzhf& fh ce~zayc|hlcük b| yc|cjfb h lh`h ~h|a& |ck bejhzda b| |hjc`a xrb erlmh| yblb| b| ehkc~rfh`h h fh| yc|cakb| `bf lzbh`az& lak|c`bzhk`a h ã|pb laea |r~zbeh hrpazc`h` hkpb rk ~zalb|a lzbhpcya7 bf lrb|pcakhecbkpa xrb ~za~akda h~rkph h fh| |cdrcbkpb ~zbdrkph|? ±~az xrã ka zbhfchz rkh ce~zayc|hlcük lafblpcyh1& ±~az xrã ka ~bzecpcz xrb fh cehdckhlcük s fh lzbhlcük lakffbybk hf ckpbzlhejca& h fh laa~bzhlcük s hf ~za`rlpa bkzcxrblc`a ~az eÿfpc~fb| yc|cakb| `b rk eaebkpa& cehdbk& |bk|hlcük& |bkpcecbkpa a c`bh1 ^az pzhjhoa lakorkpa a lafblpcya ka eb zbicbza h rkh hkhzxråh&   sh xrb |cbe~zb b}c|pb rkh `czbllcük& rk frdhz h `ak`b ffbdhz a rk ~rkpa `b ~hzpc`h xrb& ~zblc|hebkpb& |b bkzcxrblb ~az fa xrb |b yh bklakpzhk`a bk bf lhecka& ~az lüea |b yh ce~zayc|hk`a h ~hzpcz `b fa| b|påerfa| `b apza|+ Laea ~hzpb `b b|ph zbifb}cük& b|ph zbyc|ph b| bk |å rkh ce~zayc|hlcük& xrb pcbkb laea ckclchpcyh ~zaeaybz fh lrfprzh s fh| hzpb| b|lãkclh| h pzhyã| `bf ~zalb|a `b b|lzcprzh& lak|c`bzhk`a h ce~zayc|hlcük laea ~hzpb `b pa`a ~zalb|a lzbh`az xrb yh mhlch fh laklzblcük s laa~bzhlcük `b `cybz|h| c`bh| s b|påerfa| h ~hzpcz `b rk ~rkpa `b ckclca? lrfprzh s hzpb| b|lãkclh|+ 8