Reply to plaintiffs Opposition to defendants’ motion for extension of time to file notice of Appeal

Mdsn 79<2-mv-<6<13-C@F -\ED Comu`nkt 76> #926>7

4 7 = 3 > 8

Hbenc 4
]tnvnk M. ]`bta, ]tdtn Gdr Ko. 448738 ]@BSA MD@\GNEE MEBHHOWC JNDWKNR FOWN 41<< Korta Grodcwdy, ]ubtn 7<< ]dktd Dkd, Mdebhorkbd 276<8 Snenpaokn9 (643) >><-667< Hdmsb`ben9 (643) >><-47>4 N`dbe9 ss`btaLsmmjf.mo` Dttorknys hor Cnhnkcdkts ANDE SAN VOWEC HO^KCDSBOK dkc ^KBSNC HENNS

6

n r o F | y n k r d n J | c r o h h b e M | e e n g p ` d M | a t b ` ]

1

^KBSNC ]SDSN] CB]SWBMS MO^WS

2

MNKSWDE CB]SWBMS OH MDEBHOWKBD

4<

VN]SNWK CBXB]BOK

44 47 4= 43 4> 48 46 41 42 7< 74 77 7=

IOAK IOAK F. GWDK GWDKMD MD,, ]pnm ]pnm d Dc`bkbstrdtor oh tan Nstdtn oh @bmadne I. Idmjsok: IOAK @MMEDBK, ]pnmbde Dc`bkbstrdtor oh tan tan Nstdtn Nstdtn oh @bmadne I. Idmjsok: SWB^@\A BKSNWKDSBOKDE, BKM., d Mdebhorkbd morpordtbok,

) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) \edbktbhhs, ) ) vs. ) ) ANDE SAN VOWEC HO^KCDSBOK, ) d Mdebhorkbd morpordtbok: ^KBSNC ) HENNS, d Mdebhorkbd morpordtbok: dkc ) CON] 4-4<, bkmeusbvn, ) ) Cnhnkcdkts. ) ) ) ) ) )

.

MD]N MD]N KO9 KO9 MX-<2MX-<2-<6< <6<13 13 C@F C@F Z\ED Z\EDxP Aokordgen Coeey @. Fnn Mourtroo` 6 WN\ER SO \EDBKSBHH]‒ O\\O]BSBOK SO CNHNKCDKS]‒ @OSBOK HOW NQSNK]BOK OH SB@N SO HBEN KOSBMN OH D\\NDE

CDSN9 Omtognr 73, 7<44 SB@N9 29=< d.`. MSW@9 6 Aok. Coeey @. Fnn

73 7>

MO@N KOV Cnhnkcdkts Ande tan Vorec Houkcdtbok (―ASVH‐) dkc ^kbtnc

78

Hennt, gy dkc taroufa mouksne, dkc anrngy sug`bt tan hoeeowbkf Wnpey to \edbktbhh‒s

76

Opposbtbok to Cnhnkcdkts‒ @otbok hor Nxtnksbok oh Sb`n to Hben Kotbmn oh Dppnde9

71

4 MD\SBOK

Trusted by over 1 million members

Try Scribd FREE for 30 days to access over 125 million titles without ads or interruptions! Start Free Trial Cancel Anytime.





Mdsn 79<2-mv-<6<13-C@F -\ED Comu`nkt 76> #926>=

Bk tanbr enkftay opposbtbok opposbtbok to Cnhnkcdkts‒ Cnhnkcdkts‒ @otbok hor Nxtnksbok oh Sb`n,

4 7

\edbktbhhs drfun tadt Cnhnkcdkts saouec kot gn deeownc to hben d kotbmn oh dppnde.

=

\edbktbhhs‒ drfu`nkts drn `nrbtenss.

3

B.

San stdkcdrc hor moksbcnrbkf d òtbok hor nxtnksbok bs ukcbsputnc.

Ds \edbktbhhs dc`bt bk tanbr opposbtbok, tan stdkcdrc snt horta bk Cnhnkcdkts‒

>


Hbenc 4
8

òtbok bs tan morrnmt stdkcdrc stdkcdrc hor suma d òtbok. Bk grbnh, d mourt bs to moksbcnr

6

hour hdmtors9 ―(4) tan cdkfnr oh prniucbmn to tan kok-òvbkf pdrty, (7) tan enkfta oh

1

cnedy dkc bts potnktbde b`pdmt ok iucbmbde promnncbkfs, (=) tan rndsok hor tan cnedy,

2

bkmeucbkf wantanr bt wds bk tan rndsokdgen moktroe oh tan òvdkt, dkc (3) wantanr

4<

tan òvbkf pdrty‒s mokcumt mokcumt wds bk fooc hdbta.‐ \bkmdy v. Dkcrnws, =12 H.=c 1>=,

44

1>> (2ta Mbr. 7<<3) (mbtbkf \boknnr Bkv. ]nrvs. ] nrvs. Mo. v. Grukswbmj Dssoms., ><6 ^.].

47

=1<, =2> (4227)). Cnhnkcdkts dccrnss \edbktbhhs‒ drfu`nkts ok ok ndma pobkt bk turk. turk.

4=

BB.

\edbktbhhs advn hdbenc to dccumn dky hdmts saowbkf tadt tanrn bs d cdkfnr

43

oh prniucbmn to tan` bh Cnhnkcdkts drn deeownc to dppnde.

4>

\edbktbhhs‒ drfu`nkts rnfdrcbkf prniucbmn dee rney ok uksupportnc deenfdtboks

48

oh ―prbor dkc ku`nrous nxtnksboks nxtnksboks frdktnc to Cnhnkcdkts.‐ Opposbtbok to @otbok @otbok

46

hor Nxtnksbok, >. Cnspbtn tan medb`, aownvnr, aownvnr, \edbktbhhs advn hdbenc to bcnktbhy bcnktbhy dky

41

spnmbhbms oh suma nxtnksbok. nxtnksbok. Vbtaout mbtbkf to to dky supportbkf supportbkf cnmedrdtboks,

42

\edbktbhhs‒ okey nxd`pens drn tan two yndrs tadt tabs `dttnr wds profrnssbkf bk tan

7<

Mourt, dkc \edbktbhhs deenfnc hdbeurn ―to rnmnbvn tan gnknhbts oh tan Iucf`nkt‐ dhtnr

74

bts bssudkmn. Bc. Knbtanr nxd`pen nxd`pen saows aow \edbktbhhs \edbktbhhs wouec gn prniucbmnc prniucbmnc gy

77

Cnhnkcdkts hbebkf oh dk dppnde.

7= 73

Bk hdmt, \edbktbhhs‒ drfu`nkt, bh gnebnvnc, wouec knfdtn tan hbrst hdmtor oh tan Mourt‒s dkdeysbs dkdeysbs nktbrney. Bt wds wds \edbktbhhs‒ cnmbsbok, kot Cnhnkcdkts‒, to hben tabs






4

Hbenc 4
mokmnbvdgey mokstbtutn mokstbtutn prniucbmn. Ebjnwbsn, hbebkf d mdsn mdsn knmnssdrbey b`pebns tan

dppnde. Dmmorcbkfey, \edbktbhhs mdkkot mdkkot medb` wbta dky sbkmnrbty, sbkmnrbty, 7 possbgbebty oh dk dppnde.


=

wbtaout spnmbhbm nvbcnkmn bk support tanrnoh, tadt tany wbee gn prniucbmnc gy

3

Cnhnkcdkts‒ dppnde.

>

\edbktbhhs co kotn tadt tan Mourt ads kot ruenc ok tanbr pnkcbkf nx pdrtn

8

rnqunst deeowbkf tan` to cbsmeosn d rncdmtnc vnrsbok oh tan Mourt‒s iucf`nkt to tan

6

^]\SO. Sany hdbe to deenfn, aownvnr, aownvnr, aow d hdbeurn to b``ncbdtney b``ncbdtney ogtdbk suma

1

rnebnh–wabma fons dgovn dkc gnyokc tan rnebnh tany soufat dkc rnmnbvnc bk tan

2

Iucf`nkt–wouec mokstbtutn prniucbmn ukcnr tan Mourt‒s dkdeysbs. Hbkdeey, \edbktbhhs medb` tadt tany wnrn kot ok ―dmtude kotbmn‐ oh tan dppnde

4<

kotbmn oh dppnde wds tb`ney tb`ney hbenc. Sany dc`bt, aownvnr, tadt 44 gnmdusn ko cnhbmbnkt kotbmn 47

tany wnrn bkhor`nc tadt Cnhnkcdkts wnrn snnjbkf to rnsnrvn tanbr rbfats ok dppnde,

4=

dkc tadt pdbks wnrn tdjnk bk orcnr to protnmt sdbc rbfats.

43

\edbktbhhs advn mbtnc ko mdsn edw rnqubrbkf ―dmtude‐ kotbmn, dkc tanbr

4>

drfu`nkt bs ukpnrsudsbvn. Nvnk bh tany mouec mbtn mbtn to suma dutaorbty, aownvnr, tan

48

Wuen 3(d)(>) dkdeysbs bs d ―moktnxtude dkdeysbs,‐ dkc d mourt bs to gdedkmn tan hdmtors

46

―dfdbkst tan mrndtbok oh dky rbfbc ruen.‐ \bkmdy, =12 H.=c dt 1>2. Nvnk bh tan tan kotbmn

41

fbvnk cbc kot mokstbtutn ―dmtude‐ kotbmn, \edbktbhhs wnrn ok kotbmn tadt Cnhnkcdkts

42

bktnkcnc to dppnde. Gdsnc ok tan hornfobkf, \edbktbhhs advn hdbenc to deenfn deenfn dky

7<

mofkbzdgen cdkfnr oh prniucbmn ds d rnsuet oh Cnhnkcdkts gnbkf deeownc to hben d

74

kotbmn oh dppnde.

77

BB.

\edbktbhhs advn hdbenc to saow aow tan enkfta oh cnedy wbee b`pdmt iucbmbde

7=

promnncbkfs.

73

\edbktbhhs knxt drfun tadt tan enkfta oh cnedy bs nxmnssbvn, gnmdusn





Mdsn 79<2-mv-<6<13-C@F -\ED Comu`nkt 76> #926>>

4

Hbenc 4
ds to bts ―potnktbde b`pdmt b`pdmt ok iucbmbde promnncbkfs.‐ promnncbkfs.‐ Ds Cnhnkcdkts dc`bt, tan okey

promnncbkf bs tanbr nx pdrtn pdrtn rnqunst rnfdrcbkf tan ^]\SO, wabma wabma 7 pnkcbkf iucbmbde promnncbkf =

rnqunsts rnebnh bk nxmnss oh tadt frdktnc bk tan Iucf`nkt. Dmmorcbkfey, tan enkfta enkfta oh

3

cnedy wbee kot advn dky dpprnmbdgen b`pdmt ok iucbmbde promnncbkfs.

>

BBB.

\edbktbhhs advn hdbenc to provn tadt tan rndsok hor tan cnedy wds

8

bknxmusdgen knfenmt, pdrtbmuedrey fbvnk tan ukbqun mbrmu`stdkmns anrn.

6

\edbktbhhs‒ drfun tadt tan rndsok hor h or cnedy wds kot nxmusdgen, gnmdusn @r.

1

Gdrgdf saouec advn eoojnc up tan ruen, dkc gnmdusn Cnhnkcdkts saouec gn

2 prnsu`nc to jkow tan ruen tan`snevns. Gota drfu`nkts drn ukpnrsudsbvn. n r o F | y n k r d n J | c r o h h b e M | e e n g p ` d M | a t b ` ]

4<

\edbktbhhs hdbe to dpprnmbdtn tan moktnxt oh tabs `dttnr, bkmeucbkf @r. Gdrgdf‒s

44

n`nrfnkmy bktnrvnktbok bk tan mdsn curbkf bts hbkde stdfns, dkc abs mo`pentn

47

bknxpnrbnkmn wbta hncnrde hncnrde ruens. San cntnr`bkbkf hdmtor bk tan tan mdsn mbtnc gy

4=

\edbktbhhs‒ wds tan ―mendr bkhnrnkmn oh Ztan dttorkny‒sP owk `bsfbvbkfs mokmnrkbkf‐

43

tan tb`n hor dppnde, nvbcnkmnc gy abs ndrknstey snnjbkf to moksuet dk dttorkny òrn

4>

nxpnrbnkmnc bk tan hbnec. hbnec. Ojrdy v. Cnkkbs (Bk rn Ojrdy), 7<<2 7<<2 ^.]. Cbst. ENQB]

48

821>=, *1”2 (C. Ded. Ded. Duf. 6, 7<<2). 7<<2). Sanrn bs ko suma nvbcnkmn anrn tadt @r.

46

Gdrgdf adc mendr jkowencfn oh abs owk `bsfbvbkfs mokmnrkbkf tan dppnde cdtn,

41

wabma bs supportnc gy tan hdmt tadt an cbc kot nvnk moksuet tan Wuens oh Dppneedtn

42

\romncurn uktbe Dufust 78, 78, 7<44–wnee dhtnr tan dppnde dppnde pnrboc adc ruk. Vaben tabs

7<

wds mnrtdbkey knfenmthue ok abs pdrt, bt cons kot rbsn to tan envne oh tan dttorkny bk

74

Ojrdy, wao wds mendrey dwdrn tadt an cbc kot jkow tan dppnde cdtn, dkc ynt wbta

77

sdbc `bsfbvbkfs stbee hdbenc to eooj up tan dppebmdgen dppebmdgen ruen. Dccbtbokdeey, bt bs ukmendr

7=

wantanr tan Ojrdy dttorkny, wao wds ―bknxpnrbnkmnc‐ bk gdkjruptmy edw, adc tan

73

sd`n envne oh bknxpnrbnkmn (b.n., kokn) ds @r. Gdrgdf.






4

kotbmn oh dppnde wouec ―turk Wuen 3(d)(>) bkto d cnvbmn to mokvnrt duto`dtbmdeey tan

7

tabrty-cdy dppnde pnrboc bkto d sbxty-cdy pnrboc. Detaoufa bt wds mnrtdbkey

=

knfenmthue, @r. Gdrgdf‒s hdbeurn to rndc tan dppebmdgen ruen wds knbtanr bknxmusdgen

3

kor frossey knfenmthue cun to tan `btbfdtbkf hdmtors oh abs mo`pentn edmj oh hncnrde

>

nxpnrbnkmn dkc abs edtn bktnrvnktbok bk tan mdsn. \edbktbhhs‒ drfu`nkt tadt Cnhnkcdkts‒ saoueck‒t advn rnebnc ok tan dcvbmn oh

8


Hbenc 4 oh 1 \dfn BC

6

tanbr dttorkny bs bs deso ukpnrsudsbvn. ukpnrsudsbvn. Bk su`, \edbktbhhs‒ drfu`nkt bs tadt gnmdusn

1

Cnhnkcdkts ―hbenc coznks oh trdcn`drj dppebmdtboks‐ dkc ukcnrtooj sb`bedr tdsjs,

2

tany saouec gn anec to tan sd`n stdkcdrc ds d pro sn ebtbfdkt. \edbktbhhs advn mbtnc

4<

ko dutaorbty hor suma d posbtbok hor fooc rndsok–tanrn rndsok–tanrn bs kokn. D pdrty

44

rnprnsnktnc gy mouksne bs rndsokdgen rndsokdgen bk rneybkf ok mouksne mouksne hor enfde dcvbmn. San

47

dgbebty to hben d trdcn`drj dppebmdtbok cons kot bkhnr hd`bebdrbty h d`bebdrbty wbta tan Hncnrde

4=

Wuens oh Dppneedtn \rdmtbmn. Dmmorcbkfey, tan hdmt tadt Cnhnkcdkts cbc kot kot

43

bkcnpnkcnktey rnsndrma tan dppebmdgen dppnde pnrboc bs b``dtnrbde to tan bssun–

4>

rnprnsnktnc pdrtbns drn kot anec to suma d stdkcdrc.

48

BX.

\edbktbhhs advn hdbenc to dccumn dky hdmts saowbkf gdc hdbta mokcumt gy

46

Cnhnkcdkts bk snnjbkf dk nxtnksbok to dppnde.

41

San hbkde hdmtor moksbcnrnc ok d òtbok hor h or nxtnksbok ukcnr Wuen 3(d)(>) bs

42

wantanr tan òvbkf pdrty‒s pdrty‒s mokcumt bs bk fooc hdbta. Cnspbtn fbvnk tan opportukbty opportukbty

7<

to dccrnss tabs hdmtor ok bts `nrbts, \edbktbhhs advn rnhusnc to co so, bkstndc cnmbcbkf

74

to mdst dspnrsboks ok ukrnedtnc deenfnc mokcumt.

77

tan mdsn edw tadt tan mokcumt dt bssun bs kot dky dspnmt oh tan pdrty‒s mokcumt nvnr,

4

Bt bs mendr mendr hro` tan edkfudfn oh

7= 73

4

Dccbtbokdeey, bh tanrn bs hduet to gn dssbfknc hor kot mo`peybkf wbta tan Iucf`nkt, \edbktbhhs drn iust ds muepdgen ds Cnhnkcdkts. Cnspbtn mendr edkfudfn bk tan @nòrdkcu` oh ^kcnrstdkcbkf dkc Iucf`nkt spnmbhybkf tadt \edbktbhhs drn to pdy






Hbenc 4
mokcumt rnenvdkt to tan knnc hor dk nxtnksbok. nxtnksbok. 4 gut rdtanr okey tadt mokcumt Anrn, ds prnvbousey stdtnc, Cnhnkcdkts‒ mokcumt bk òvbkf hor dk nxtnksbok

7


=

wds ukcnkbdgey cokn bk fooc hdbta. Cnhnkcdkts rnprnsnktnc to \edbktbhhs hro` prbor

3

to tan bssudkmn oh tan Iucf`nkt tadt tany wnrn bktnrnstbkf bk pursubkf dk dppnde,

>

dkc tanbr prbor dttorkny tooj so`n frndt pdbks to nksurn tadt tanbr dppneedtn rbfats

8

wnrn rnsnrvnc. Dhtnr tan Iucf`nkt, Iucf`nkt, tan ukcbsputnc ukcbsputnc hdmts drn tadt tadt Cnhnkcdkts

6

cbebfnktey soufat hor dppneedtn mouksne, dkc tadt tany rnebnc upok tan dcvbmn oh tanbr

1

dttorkny (to tanbr cntrb`nkt) rnfdrcbkf tan dppnde pnrboc. \edbktbhhs advn kot

2

cbsputnc tansn mrumbde hdmts . Dmmorcbkfey, ds drfunc prnvbousey, prnvbousey, tabs hdmtor wnbfas wnbfas

4<

bk hdvor oh deeowbkf Cnhnkcdkts tan rnqunstnc rnebnh.

44

X.

\edbktbhhs‒ otanr drfu`nkts drn ukpnrsudsbvn dkc brrnenvdkt to tan

47

prnsnkt bssun.

4=

\edbktbhhs deso rdbsn otanr, brrnenvdkt rndsoks hor cnkybkf Cnhnkcdkts‒ òtbok,

43

bkmeucbkf tadt Cnhnkcdkts‒ Cnhnkcdkts‒ madkmns hor summnss ok dppnde dppnde drn deenfncey eow. Ds

4>

\edbktbhhs dc`bt nesnwanrn bk tanbr opposbtbok, aownvnr, tan ebjnebaooc oh summnss ok

48

dppnde bs kot d hdmtor ok wabma wabma d Wuen 3(d)(>) cntnr`bkdtbok cntnr`bkdtbok bs to gn gdsnc. Bt bs

46

nktbrney beeofbmde to deeow d mourt tadt wouec gn suginmt to rnvnrsde bh dppndenc to

41

cnky to deeow dk dppnde ok suma froukcs.

42

Dccbtbokdeey, \edbktbhhs drn hdmtudeey bkmorrnmt. Sanrn bs sugstdktbde sugstdktbde nvbcnkmn,

sugsnqunkt to tan Mourt‒s ruebkf, tadt Cnhnkcdkts‒ tank-dttorkny tank-dttorkny 7< gota prbor to dkc sugsnqunkt 74

adc dgcbmdtnc abs cutbns to abs mebnkt, dkc wds dmtbvney dttn`ptbkf to ukcnr`bkn

77

Cnhnkcdkts‒ mdsn. Dmmorcbkfey, nvnk bh bh bt wds dpproprbdtn to moksbcnr moksbcnr Cnhnkcdkts‒

7=

ebjnebaooc oh summnss ok dppnde (wabma bt bs kot), frdktbkf tan rnqunstnc rnebnh wouec

73

stbee gn dpproprbdtn.








4 7

XB.

Hbenc 4
Mokmeusbok

Gdsnc upok tan hornfobkf, ds wnee ds tan prnvbousey sug`bttnc pdpnrs,

=

Cnhnkcdkts rnspnmthueey rnqunst tadt tan Mourt frdkt d grbnh, hbvn-cdy nxtnksbok bk

3

wabma to hben d kotbmn oh dppnde.

> 8 6 1

Cdtnc9 Omtognr 44, 7<44

]@BSA MD@\GNEE MEBHHOWC JNDWKNR FOWN D \rohnssbokde Edw Morpordtbok

2 n r o F | y n k r d n J | c r o h h b e M | e e n g p ` d M | a t b ` ]

4< 44 47 4= 43 4> 48 46 41 42

Gy9

/s/ ]tnvnk M. ]`bta ]SNXNK M. ]@BSA Dttorknys hor Cnhnkcdkts Ande tan Vorec Houkcdtbok dkc ^kbtnc Hennt






4 7 = 3 > 8 6 1 2 n r o F | y n k r d n J | c r o h h b e M | e e n g p ` d M | a t b ` ]

4< 44 47 4= 43

Hbenc 4
\WOOH OH ]NWXBMN Grdkmd nt de. vs. Ande tan Vorec Vorec Houkcdtbok, nt de.

B cnmedrn tadt B d` n`peoync bk tan Mbty oh ]dktd Dkd, Moukty oh Ordkfn, ]tdtn oh Mdebhorkbd. B d` ovnr tan dfn oh nbfatnnk nbfatnnk yndrs dkc kot d pdrty to tan wbtabk dmtbok: `y gusbknss dccrnss bs9 41<< Korta Grodcwdy, ]ubtn 7<<, ]dktd Dkd, Mdebhorkbd 276<8 Ok Omtognr 44, 7<44, B snrvnc tan hornfobkf comu`nkt(s)9 WN\ER SO \EDBKSBHH]‒ O\\O]BSBOK SO CNHNKCDKS]‒ @OSBOK HOW NQSNK]BOK OH SB@N SO HBEN KOSBMN OH D\\NDE HBEBKF

ok dee bktnrnstnc pdrtbns bk bk tabs dmtbok gy pedmbkf pedmbkf Z P tan orbfbkde Z QP d trun mopy tanrnoh, nkmeosnc bk d sndenc nkvneopn wbta postdfn prn-pdbc, dccrnssnc ds hoeeows9 Xbkmnkt A. Mabnhho, ]tdtn Gdr Ko. 32<82 Kbkd C. Goydibdk, ]tdtn ]tdtn Gdr Ko. 73834> FWNNKGNWF SWD^WBF, EE\ 73>< Moeordco Dvnkun, ]ubtn 3<>73 \aokn9 (=4<) >18-66<< Hdx9 (=4<) >18-61<< MabnhhoXLftedw.mo` GoydibdkKLftedw.mo` GoydibdkKLftedw.mo`

Dttorknys hor \edbktbhhs Ioak F. Grdkmd dkc Ioak @mMedbk, ]pnmbde Dc`bkbstrdtors oh tan Nstdtn oh @bmadne I. Idmjsok, Srbu`pa Bktnrkdtbokde, Bkm.

4>

ZQP Gy NENMSWOKBM HBEN SWDK]HNW SO NMH HBEN & ]NWXN9 Gy trdks`bttbkf d trun mopy oh tan comu`nkt(s) ebstnc dgovn hor snrvbmn ok dee stdtutns, eomde ruens dkc/or orcnr oh tan tan 46 pdrtbns bk tabs mdsn pursudkt to dppebmdgen stdtutns, Mourt. 48

41 42

B cnmedrn tadt B d` n`peoync bk tan ohhbmn oh d `n`gnr oh tan gdr oh tabs mourt dt waosn cbrnmtbok tan snrvbmn wds `dcn.

Reply to plaintiffs Opposition to defendants’ motion for extension of time to file notice of Appeal

Recommend Documents