Curso: DERECHO PROCESAL CONSTITUCIONAL DOCENTE: MAGISTER. MAGISTER . EDWARD VARGAS VARGAS VALDERRAMA VALDERRAMA DATOS DEL TRABAJO ACADEMICO PRESENTADO: TIPO DE TRABAJO ACADÉMICA: Nº fecha TRABAJO MONOGRÁFICO: TEMA: TRABAJO PRACTICO: TEMA: EJERCICIO APLICATIO: !" #! $$ TEMA: EXAMEN DE GRADO
NOMBRE: C&DIGO: A%LA: '!"
DATOS DEL AL%MNA ANCCO PINEDA JACQUELINE 2012-216081 CICLO: (
OBSERACIONES DE DOCENTE:
AGRADECIMIENTO
#!$"
DERECHO PROCESAL CONSTITUCIONAL Ag!"#$%& ! '( )!'(*(! )!'(*(! +& +& , ,&+&# )('# / %&,!# "!# #,# (#'+& (#'+& ! '(, +!"#, (##, '# ("3#& *! 4(%! 4(%! #* !)#%& ! D(&, / #* !'& %& %& #* # 5&/ #%&(#"& +& #,! 5("!. A '(, !'(g&, (##, ,& ! +!# ', "# '( )!'(*(! / ! (##, *#, !g!"#$%& !!, %&,!, # '( 5("! 5!*&& '%7,('& , !+&/& (%&"(%(&!* / #* %!(9& %& #* # ,(#'+# &, 7#'&, ("&. T!'(4 "#,#& "#3! +*!,'!"! ! (# %& ,, %&,#3&, / !'(,!" !'(,!" ,(#'+# ,(#'+# 7! #,!"& !/""&'#.
INDICE 1
;P#"#
#* %&'(4 (4 "# "##%7&, 7'! '!&, "# *! ONU / *! %&'(,(< (<
(#!'#(%!! "# "##%7&, "##%7&, 7'!&, "# *! OEA &"#! !* #,!"& +#!& +#!& *! #3#%%(< "# ,, ()&'#,=..................................................................................6 2
;Q4 ;Q4 (+& (+& "# '#%! '#%!(, (,'&, '&, %## %## ,# ,#" " # # #>(, #>(,# # +!! +!! #,# #)#%& #)#%&=..... =.......10 ..10
?
;Q4 ;Q4 "## "## 7!%# 7!%# #* P#@ P#@ +!! +!! #(! #(!,# ,# "# "# *! %&'+# %&'+## #%(! %(! 3( 3(," ,"(%% (%%(& (&!* !* "#
*! %&# (#!'#(%!! "# "##%7& 7'!&, "# *! OEA= .................................11
PÁGINA #
DERECHO PROCESAL CONSTITUCIONAL
;S( #* P#@ ,# # #(! (! "# *! %&'+##%(! 3(," (,"(%%(& (&!* "# *! %&#
(# (#! !'# '#( (%! %!! ! "# "## "##%7 %7&, &, 7'! 7'!& &,, "# *! OEA OEA !# !# 4 4 &g! &g!( (,' ,'& & (#!%(&!* +&"#'&, %&'& +!(%*!#, !,(,( +!! &## ! #,+#,! ,('(*!=................................................................................................................1B 4.1
R#(& "# *! %&'+##%(! %&#%(&,! "# *! C&# I#!'#(%!! "#
D##%7&, H'!&,........................................................................................16 .2
R#(& R#(& "# *! %&'+# %&'+## #%(! %(! %&# %&#%( %(&,! &,! "# "# *! C&#.... C&#......... ......... ......... ......... ......... .........16 ....16
.?
ORGANO QUE DECIDIR LA VALIDE DEL RETIRO DEL
RECONOCIMIENTO DE LA COMPETENCIA CONTENCIOSA....................18 B
J( J(,+ ,+ "# "#% %(! (!*' *'# ## # ;*!, ;*!, "#%( "#%(,( ,(& &#, #, "# *! %& %&# # (# (#! !'# '#( (%! %!! ! "#
"##%7&, 7'!&, "# *! OEA # %!,&, # & (## !* #,!"& +#!& %&'& +!# +&%#,!* "## ,# &'!"!, "# '!#! &*(g!&(! +& * &, 3#%#, %!"& (#+#! *&, "##%7&, 7'!&, / *! %&,(%(<=........................................1
OBJETIOS
PÁGINA '
DERECHO PROCESAL CONSTITUCIONAL
VER VER %&'& %&'& ,g( ,g("& "& *&,
#,%! "# *! ONU. #,!*#%# %* #! !#! "#* C&'(4 "# D##%7&, H'!&,. #>!'( #>!'(! ! # (+& !%%(< !%%(< (# (#& & #* G&(# G&(#& & P#! P#!& & !*
#%* #%*!' !'&, &, "# !% !%!* !*($ ($!% !%(< (< "# *!
'&'# '&'# & & "# #( #(! ! #* #%& #%&& &%( %('( '(# #& & "# *! %&'+ %&'+# ## #%( %(! ! %&#%(&,! "# *! C&#.
INTROD%CCI&N E* C&'(4 C&'(4 "# D##%7 D##%7&, &, H'! H'!&, &, & "## "## %&) %&)"( "(,# ,# %& *! C&'(,(< "# D##%7&, H'!&, H'!&, &g!(,'& # ,# "#(5! "# *! C!! "# *!, N!%(&#, U("!, ( %& #* C&,#3& "# D##%7&, H'!&, # U("!, H'!&, # *! ,,(/#. M(#!, # *! C&'(,(< / #* C&,#3& "# D##%7&, H'!&, ,& )&&, +&*(%&, "&"# *&, E,!"&, "#!# &"& (+& "# !,&, #*!%(&!"&, #*!%(&!"&, %& *&, "##%7&, 7'!&, 7'!&, #* C&'(4 #, &g!(,'& )&'!"& +& #>+#&, / , %&'+##%(! #, *('(!"! +& #* P!%& I#!%(&!* "# D##%7&, C(5(*#, / P&*(%&,. C&'& ,#g"& +& 5&/ ! #,&*5# *!, B +#g!, # ,& #)##%(! "# %#,(&#, ;P#"# ;P#"# #* %&'(4 "# "##%7&, "##%7&, 7'!&, "# *! *! ONU / *! %&'(,(< (#!'#(%!! "# "##%7&, "##%7&, 7'!&, "# *! OEA &"#! !* #,!"& +#!& +#!& *! #3#%%(< "# ,, ()&'#,=
PÁGINA "
DERECHO PROCESAL CONSTITUCIONAL P& *('& *!, "#%(,(&#, "# *! %&# (#!'#(%!! "# "##%7&, 7'!&, "# *! OEA # %!,&, # & (## !* #,!"& +#!& %&'& +!# +&%#,!* "## ,# &'!"! &'!"!,, "# '!#! '!#! &*(g! &*(g!& &(! (! +& *&, 3#%#, 3#%#, %!"& %!"& (#+ (#+# #! ! *&, "##%7&, 7'!&, / *! %&,(%(<
PÁGINA (
DERECHO PROCESAL CONSTITUCIONAL
PREG%NTAS DE E)AMEN DE GRADO $
*Pue *Pue+e +e e, coco-./ ./0 0 +e +er +erec echo hos s hu-a hu-a1o 1os s +e ,a ,a ON ON% % 2 ,a co-. co-.s. s.31 31 .1/era-er .1/era-er.ca1a .ca1a +e +erecho +erechoss hu-a1os hu-a1os +e ,a OEA or+e1ar or+e1ar a, es/a+o es/a+o 4erua1o ,a e5ecuc.31 +e sus .1for-es6
E*
Comité de Derechos Humanos #,
<g!& %&5#%(&!* )&'!"& +&
#>+#&, ("#+#"(##, # 5(g(*! #* %'+*('(#& "#* P!%& I#!%(&!* "# D##%7&, C(5(*#, / P&*(%&, +& *& *&, E,!"&, E,!"&, # *& 7! !()(%!"&. N&'!*'## ,# #@# # #, +#(&"&, "# ,#,(&#, !* !9& # G(#! & N#5! F& &.. E* C&'(4 #, & "# *&, ,(## &g!(,'&, (,(("&, +& !!"&, ,&# "##%7&, 7'!&, +&'&5("&, +& *! Og!($!%(< "# *!, N!%(&#, U("!,. U("!, . E* C&'(4 C&'(4 "# D##%7 D##%7&, &, H'! H'!&, &, & "## "## %&) %&)"( "(,# ,# %& *! C&'(,(< "# D##%7&, H'!&, H'!&, &g!(,'& # ,# "#(5! "# *! C!! "# *!, N!%(&#, U("!, ( %& #* C&,#3& "# D##%7&, H'!&, # U("!, H'!&, # *! ,,(/#. M(#!, # *! C&'(,(< / #* C&,#3& "# D##%7&, H'!&, ,& )&&, +&*(%&, "&"# *&, E,!"&, "#!# &"& (+& "# !,&, #*!%(&!"&, #*!%(&!"&, %& *&, "##%7&, 7'!&, 7'!&, #* C&'(4 #, &g!(,'& )&'!"& +& #>+#&, / , %&'+##%(! #, *('(!"! +& #* P!%& I#!%(&!* "# D##%7&, C(5(*#, / P&*(%&,.
L&, E,!"&, "#* C&(## A'#(%!& ,# 7!**!! !g+!"&, "#,"# )(#, "#* ,(g*& XIX / ', +#%(,!'## "#,"# 180 # *! U(< P!!'#(%!!. E #* '(& '(& "# "(%7! &g!($!%(< &g!($!%(< **#5!& **#5!& ! %!& !*g!, !*g!, ((%(!(5! ((%(!(5!,, +!*#, +!*#, #*!%( #*!%(&! &!"!, "!, %& *! +&#% +&#%%(< %(< "# *&, "##% "##%7&, 7&, 7'! 7'!&, &, #,+#% #,+#%(!* (!*'# '## # #,+#%& "#* !,(*& +&*(%& (,(%(< "# *!g! !"(%(< # A'4(%! L!(! +#& ,( # #**!, !*%!$!! %!%# ,(,#'(%& ( '#&, # **#g!! ! *! %#!%(< "# !*g@ <g!& "# +&#%%(< "# !*#, "##%7&,. L! ,(!%(< !* #,+#%& +& *& "#', #! !*&g! ! *! "#* #,& "#* '"& # #)#%& # #* '!%& "# *! S&%(#"!" "# *!, N!%(&#, %#!"! !* 4'(& "# *!
PÁGINA 7
DERECHO PROCESAL CONSTITUCIONAL P('# P('#! ! G# G#! ! M" M"(! (!** !'+ !'+&% &%& & ,# #,! #,!* *#% #%(< (< ,(, ,(,#' #'! ! g## g##! !** "# +&#%%(< "# *&, "##%7&, 7'!&, ,( +#3(%(& "# "#,!&**!,# ((%(!(5!, +!! *! +&#%%(< "# *!, '(&!,. S( #'!g& 3& %& *! %#!%(< "# *! OEA # &%# "# 18 *&, E,!"&, # 7!! 7!! %&% %&%(" ("& & +!! +!! , #,!* #,!*#%( #%('(# '(#& & !"&+! !"&+!& & *! D#%*! D#%*!!% !%(< (< A'#(%!! "# D##%7&, D##%7&, / D###, "#* H&'#. 1 E #!*("!" #* # ,# 7!/! !"&+!"& (,'#& "# #5#g!"! !* '(,'& '&'#& "#* #,!*#%('(#& "# ! #5! &g!($!%(< ,<*& ,# #>+*(%! +& #* 7#%7& #%7& "# # 4,! 4,! )# )# +#% +#%# #"("! "("! +& &! &! *! *! /! '#% '#%(& (& !"! !"! U(< (< P!!'#(%!!- # !!3< # *! +#+!!%(< "# "(%7& (,'#&. 2C&'& ,# !+#%(! #,&, !%&#%('(#&, 5(#& *g! #* '(,'& !9& "# *! !"&+%(< "# *! D#%*! D#%*!!%( !%(< < U(5# U(5#,!* ,!* "# D##%7 D##%7&, &, H'!& H'!&,, +& *!, N!%(& N!%(&#, #, U("! U("!,, ONUK? # (g& (g& *! D#% D#%*!! *!!%( %(< < A'#( '#(%! %!! ! +#% +#%#" #"(< (< # "&, "&, '#,# '#,#,, !* (,'#& "# "##%7&, 7'!&, "# *! ONU. L&, %!'(&, +!!*#*&, "# *! OEA / *! ONU # '!#(! "# "##%7&, 7'!&, ,( #'!g& #'(!& !7 +#,& # '(#!, # #,! @*('! ,# %&(<
1 A+&!" A+&!"! ! # *! N&5#! C&)##%( C&)##%(! ! I#!%(&!* I#!%(&!* A'#(% A'#(%!! !! # &g& C&*&'(! 2 "# '!/& "# 18. 2 C&'& C&'& ,#9!*! ,#9!*! G&*"'! G&*"'! *&, *&, E,!"& E,!"&,, !'#(% !'#(%!&, !&, #'+#$! #'+#$!& & ! "(,#9! "(,#9! +&g!'! +&g!'! #g(& #g(&!* !* (%(+( (%(+(# ## # +!! +!! *! +&#%% +&#%%(< (< "# *&, "##%7 "##%7&, &, 7'!&, 7'!&, "! "!# # *! C&)# C&)##%( #%(! ! I# I#! !'# '#(% (%!! !! ,&# ,&# P& P&*# *#'!, '!, "# *! G# G#! ! / "# *! P!$ P!$ *! **!' **!'!" !"! ! C&)# C&)## #% %(! (! "# C7!+*#+#%. E,! %&)##%(! # 5& *g! # 1B 5& #* +&+<,(& "# #)*#>(&! # && "# *! "(#%%(< # 7!! "# &'! #* ,(,#'! (#!'#(%!& !* 4'(& "# *! g#!. R&# . G&*"'! H(,&(! / A%%(<: #* S(,#'! I#!'#(%!& "# D##%7&, H'!&, / #* +!+#* "# *! C&'(,(< I#!'#(%!! "# D##%7&, H'!&, #: A! C&(!, V#*!,%& / D!(#* O#g! N(#& %&'+,.K L! P&#%%(< I#!%(&!* "# *&, D##%7&, H'!&, / #* +!+#* "# *! C&'(,(< I#!'#(%!! "# D##%7&, H'!&,: #& # #* ,(g*& XXI E* C&*#g(& "# M4>(%& C#& "# E,"(&, I#!%(&!*#, M4>(%& 200K ++.10-18 *! #)##%(! #, "# +g(! +g(! 111 111. A"#', A"#', *! C&)## C&)##%( %(! ! "# C7!+* C7!+*#+ #+#% #% *# #%&'# #%&'#"< "< !* C&'(4 C&'(4 J"( J"(%& %& I#!'#(%!& *! #*!&!%(< "# !!"& ,&# "##%7&, / "###, "#* 7&'# # & **#g< ! ,# !"&+ !"&+! !"& "& +#& +#& # # "#' "#'#, #,! ! # # ,# 5#! 5#! #!* #!*($ ($! !"& "& ! !!3 !3& & # '!# '!#( (! ! "# (,'#&,.
? A+&!"! +& *! A,!'*#! G##!* "# *! ONU # N#5! F& #* 10 "# "(%(#'# "# 18.
PÁGINA 8
DERECHO PROCESAL CONSTITUCIONAL !5!$! !5!$!"& "& # *&, !9&, !9&, # ,(g(# ,(g(#& & ! !# # "# "# '!# '!#! ! *# *#! !
# #* #*
#,!*#%('(#& "# #!'!"& (,(%(&!* +!! *! +&#%%(< / +&'&%(< "# !*#, "##%7&, # *! OEA & 7& ,#g('(#& !*g& # *&, &%# !9&, ,(g(##, # &"# ! #,!*#%# '#%!(,'&, (,(%(&!*#, "# +&#%%(<. A* '&'#& "# *! !"&+%(< "# *! D#%*!!%(< A'#(%!! *&, E,!"&, "# *! OEA 7!! !+&!"& !'(4 ! #,&*%(< # *! # ,# #%&&%! *! #%#,("!" "# %&! %& <g!& 3"(%(!* #%!g!"& "# *! +&#%%(< "# *&, "##%7&, 7'!&, #%&'#""&,#*# !* C&'(4 J"(%& I#!'#(%!& *! #*!&!%(< "# P&/#%& "# E,!& # #%7!! *!, !,#, "# ! C&# I#!'#(%!!. L!, (#%(&#, &(g(!*#, "# *! OEA "# !"&+! !!"& g##!* ,&# "##%7&, 7'!&, ,# %&%#!& )(!*'## # 16 %& *! ,,%(+%(< "# *! C&5#%(< A'#(%!! ,&# D##%7&, H'!&, & P!%& "# S! J&,4 "# C&,! R(%!B. S# ,(g(< "# #,! '!#! #* ((#!(& "# *! ONU # #, !9&, !#, - / !'(4 "#,+4, "# %#%! "# "&, "4%!"!, "# +&'#,!,- 7!! !"&+!"& #* P!%& I#!%(&!* "# D##%7&, C(5(*#, / P&*(%&, PIDCPK 6 / #* P!%& I#!%(&!* "# D##%7&, E%&<'(%&, S&%(!*#, / C*!*#, PIDESCK . E #* #3#%(%(& "# , ,#g"! )%(< *! C&# I#!'#(%!! +#"# #'(( O+((&#, C&,*(5!, !%#%! "# *! (#+#!%(< "# *! C&5#%(< A'#(%!! !, %&'& "# &&, !!"&, +#(##, +!! *! +&#%%(< "# *&, "##%7&, S#9!*& S#9!*& # # ,# %&( %&(< < !5!$ !5!$!" !"& & /! # #* !!3& !!3& "# *! ONU # *! '!#(! ,# 7!! ((%(!"& "#,"# !#, "# 18. B A"#', # *! D4%('! C&)##%(! I#!%(&!* I#!'#(%!! #)#%!"! # 1B # C!!%!, ,# !"&+!& #,&*%(&#, ,&# "(,%('(!%(< !%(!* ,)!g(& (5#,!* / )&!*#%('(#& "#* ,(,#'! "# +&#%%(< "# "##%7&, 7'! 7'!& &, , (, (, "& "&,# ,# ! *&, *&, E,! E,!"& "&,, ! "! "! !+*( !+*(%%!%(< !%(< +&g +&g# #,( ,(55! ! *! D#%*! D#%*!!%( !%(< < A'#(%! '#(%!! ! "# D##%7 D##%7&, &, / D## D###, #, "#* H&'# H&'# !, %&'& %&'& ! !"&+! '#"("!, +!! g!!($! !*#, "##%7&,. V4!,# G&*"'! %(. +g(! 11B. 6 A"&+!"& / !(#& ! *! )('! !()(%!%(< / !"7#,(< +& *! A,!'*#! G##!* # *! #,&*%(< 2200 XXIK "# 16 "# "(%(#'# "# 166.
PÁGINA 9
DERECHO PROCESAL CONSTITUCIONAL 7'!&, # *&, E,!"&, "# *! OEA 8. C&)&'# ! *& "(,+#,& # #* !%*& 6.1 (## *! )!%*!" "# )&'*! #,# (+& "# %&,*!, !& "(%7&, E,!"&, %&'& ! ,#(# "# <g!&, "# *! OEA ## #**&, *! C&'(,(< I#!'#(%!! "# D##%7&, H'!&,K. A"#', *&, E,!"&, '(#'&, "# *! OEA +#"# ,&*(%(!*# &+((&#, ! *! C&# # #*!%(< %& *! %&'+!((*("!" ## ,, *#/#, (#!, / *&, !!"&, !#, '#%(&!"&, !%*& 6.2K. L! ONU ,g# # 1B # %&#>& "# +&,g#! '"(!* %& *! )(!*("!" "# )&3! #*!%(&#, (#!%(&!*#, ', 3,!, ## *&, E,!"&, +& '#"(& "# E #)#%& #)#%& # N!%(& N!%(&#, #, U("!, U("!, *! C&'(, C&'(,(< (< "# D##%7 D##%7&, &, H'!& H'!&,, #,!*#%("! # 16- +("!'## ,# +,& ! *! !#! "# **#5! !"#*!# +&% +&%#, #,& & "# #,! #,!* *#% #%(' ('(# (# & & "# #, #," "! !#, #, # *! '!# '!#( (!. !. A, , #*! #*!& &< < +('#!'## *! D#%*!!%(< U(5#,!* "# D##%7&, H'!&, !"&+!"! # 18. E* &3#(5& ,(g(## # ,# !$< *! C&'(,(< "# D##%7&, H'!&, )# *! !"&+%(< "# !!"& g##!* # '!#(! "# "##%7&, 7'!&,. E +&%&, !9&, !9&, ! +( +(%( %(+( +(&, &, "# *! "4%! "4%!"! "! "# *&, *&, %(% %(%# # ! ! *! C&'( C&'(,( ,(< < /! 7! 7!! ! #*!&!"& #>& +!! ,# ,&'#("& ! *! "(,%,(< "# *&, E,!"&,. S( #'!g& #* !,& #,*< '%7& ', %&'+*#3& "# *& !(%(+!"&. S%#"(< # #)#%& # %&'#$< ! "(,+! !%#%! "# ,( "#! !"&+!,# ,&*& !!"& g##!* "# "##%7&, 7'!&, & ,( # %!'(& "##! 7!# "&, !!"&, %& !*#, %!!%#,(%!,: & #)#("& ! *&, "##%7&, %(5(*#, / +&*(%&, / && ! *&, "##%7 "##%7&, &, #%&< #%&<'(% '(%&, &, ,&%(!* ,&%(!*#, #, / %* %*!*# !*#,, DESCK DESCK %& !!' !!'(# (#& & "()##%(!"& +!! !'&, (+&, "# "##%7&, %& g!"&, "(,(&, "# #>(g((*("!" / "# '#%!(,'&, "# ,+#5(,(< "# , %'+*('(#&. E* *&# "# *&, E,!"&, ,&%(!*(,!, #!*#, ,&,5& *! +('#! #,(, / #* "# *&, +!,#, &%%("#!*#, *! ,#g"!. L& !#(& !< #* !,& "!# !9&,. S( +#3(%(& "# #**& # #* (#!& N!%(&#, U("!, !"&+< &&, (,'#&, # '!#(! "# "##%7&, 7'! 7'!& &,, #* #*! !(5 (5&, &, ! !,+# !,+#% %&, &, #,+# #,+#% %)()(%& %&,K ,K # ## # *&, *&, # # #,! #,!**! !& & *! C&5#%(< %&! #* G#&%("(& / *! C&5#%(< +!! *! E*('(!%(< "# T&"!, *!, &'!, "# D(,%('(!%(< R!%(!*. E #* !9& 166 ,# !"&+! )(!*'## "&, ! !!" !"&, &, g## #!*#, !*#, "# "##% ##%7& 7&,, 7'! '!& &, # *! ONU: NU: #* P!% P!%& I# I#!%( !%(&! &!** "# D##%7 D##%7&, &, C(5(*# C(5(*#,, / P&*( P&*(%&, %&, / #* P!%& P!%& I# I#!%( !%(&! &!** "# D##%7&, E%&<'(%&, S&%(!*#, / C*!*#,. P!! ! %!!%#($!%(< "# #,# +#&"& ((%(!* "# *! ONU # '!#(! "# "##%7&, 7'!&,.
PÁGINA
DERECHO PROCESAL CONSTITUCIONAL *! %&&+# %&&+#!% !%(< (< (# (#!%( !%(&! &!** +!! +!! *! +!$ / *! ,#g ,#g("! ("!". ". T!'(4 '(4 7#'&, 7#'&, '#%(&!"& # # *! ,#g"! '(!" "#* ,(g*& XX ,# 7! +&"%("& g!"#, %!'(&, # *!, #*!%(&#, (#!%(&!*#, *& # **#5< ! *! #%#,("!" "# #+*!#!,# *! )%(< "# *!, N!%(&#, U("!, # #* ,(g*& XXI. E #,# #,# %& %&#> #>& & / #( #(# #"& "& # %# %#! ! *! "( "('( '(%! %! "#* "#* #5 #5& & #& #& & & (#!%(&!* ,g# *!, +&+#,!, "# #)&'! "# *! #("!". E #,# ,#("& 7!/ # #%&"! # *!, ((%(!(5!, +!! #)&'! *!, N!%(&#, U("!, & ,& ! &5#"! &5#"!". ". P& P& #* %&!( %&!(& & +#(<"(% +#(<"(%!'# !'## # 7! ,g("& ,g("&
#%*!' #%*!'&, &, "#
!%!*($!%(< "# *! #,%! "# *! ONU # g##!* +& &%!,(< "# *! A, &&, OUTROS-GHALI #* S#%#!(& G##!* "# *! Og!($!%(< "#,"# 12 7!,! 16 /! 7!! +&+#,& ! #)&'! ! *! #,%! "# *! ONU. E #,! 4+&%! #* &3#(5& #! #,!! #* #(*((& ## *&, <g!&, # %&)&'!! *! ONU # %&#>& "# +&, G#! ! # #* %!* %&'& 7#'&, ,#9!*!"& !#(&'## #* +!+#* "# *! Og!($!%(< 7!! #,!"& !& &,%#%("&. E* && &3#(5& "# &&,-G7!*( #! ,('+*()(%! *!, )%(&#, "# %!"! &)(%(! / !g#%(! +& '#"(& "# *! %*!()(%!%(< "# ,, !%(5("!"#, . L! !# !#! ! "#* "#* C&'( C&'(4 4 "# D## D##%%7&, 7&, H'! H'!& &,, #, ,+# +#55(,! (,! / 5(g(* (g(*! ! #* %'+*( %'+*('(# '(#& & "# *!, &*(g!% &*(g!%(& (&#, #, "('!! "('!!#, #, "#* P!%& P!%& +& *&,
E,!"& E,!"&,,
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g7, R(g7, C!'("g# U(5#,(/ P#,, C!'("g# 200? ++.2-80.
S&# *! #)&'! "#,!&**!"! +& &&, &&,-G7!*( SEUERT-ARR !)('! #: E* S#%#!(& G##!* 7! (,(("& #)&'!, !"'((,!(5!, "# *!g& !*%!%# +!! #*('(! *! "+*(%!%(< / %&%#! "# #5& *! *!& "# &"!, *!, +!#, "# *!, N!%(&#, U("!, # , '!"!& ,(%& &(g(!*. E 3(& "# 12 #* S#%#!(& G##!* +*(%< ! #,!#g(! "# *!g& !*%!%# +!! *! *!& )! "# *! Og!($!%(< (*!"! U P&g!'! "# P!$ # # +#,#< +&+#,!, +!! )&!*#%# *! #)(%!%(! "# *!, N!%(&#, U("!, # #* %'+*('(#&.
PÁGINA $!
DERECHO PROCESAL CONSTITUCIONAL '"&. '"&. P& *& !& !& *#3&, *#3&, "# #)*#3 #)*#3! ! ! @(%! +#,+#% +#,+#%(5 (5! ! g#&g g#&g)(% )(%! ! & !%(&!* #* C&'(4 7!*! 7!*! %& ! 5&$ '"(!*. '"(!*. E #* "#,#'+#9& "# "# , *!& "# 5(g(*!%(! 5(g(*!%(! / ,+#5(,(< ,+#5(,(< #* C&'(4 C&'(4 (## %!& )%(&#, )%(&#, +(%(+!* +(%(+!*#,. #,. E +('# *g! #%(# / #>!'(! *&, ()&'#, "#*&, E,!"&, P!#, ,&# *!, "(,+&,(%(&#, # 7! !"&+!"& +!! 7!%# #)#%(5&, * &, "##%7&, #%&&%("&, # #* P!%&. E ,#g"& *g! #*!&! *!, **!'!"!, &,#5!%(&#, g##!*#, ("# ("#!"!, "!, +!! !! !/ !/"! "! ! *&, *&, E,! E,!" "&, P!# !#,, ! "! %'+ %'+*(*('( '(# #& & ! *!, *!, "(,+&,(%( "(,+&,(%(&#, &#, "#* P!%& P!%& !* +& '#'&($! '#'&($! *!, &*(g!%(& &*(g!%(&#, #, ,,!(5! ,,!(5!,, / "# +&%#" +&%#"('(# ('(#& & "# "# *&, E,!" E,!"&, &, P!# P!#,. ,. E #%# #%# *g! *g! #%( #%(# # /
#>!'( #>!'(! !
"#%(!, "# *&, +!(%*!#, !'(4 "#&'(!"!, %&'(%!%(&#, %& !#g*& !* P&&%&*& !%*!(5& +#,#!"!, +& +!(%*!#, # !*#g! # E,!"& P!# 7! 5(&*!"& ,, "##%7&, %&,!g!"&, # #* P!%&. E %!& *g! (## %&'+##%(! +!! #>!'(! "##'(!"!, "#%(!, # E,!"& P!# +#,#! !*#g!"& # && E,!"& P!# & %'+*# *!, &*(g!%(&#, !,'("!, %& !#g*& !* P!%&.
#
*;u0 *;u0 /.4o /.4o +e -eca1 -eca1.s.s-os< os< cre cree e us/e+< us/e+< =ue =ue e>.s/ e>.s/e1 e1 4ara 4ara ese ese efec/o efec/o6 6
A7&! (# &, %&#,+&"# +*!#!&, #* #'! "# *! 3(,"(%%(< (#!%(&!* "# *&, "##%7&, 7'!&, +#, #, #'! # ,# %&'+*#'#! %& *! 3(,"(%%(< (#! & !%(&!*. !%(&!*. E #,# ,#("& ,#("& *&, +!,#, # !,'# !,'# *! )&'! "# E,!"& )#"#!"& (## +&%#,&, %&,(%(&!*#, "# !*%!%# *&%!* & #,!"!* & +&5(%(!* / +&%#,&, %&,(%(&!*#, !%(&!*#,. E #* %!,& %!,& "# P#@ P#@ ,# (g# (g# +& +& E,! E,!"& "& ( (! !(& (& #( #(# #"& "& +&% +&%#, #,&, &, %&,(%(&!*#, !%(&!*#,. !%(&!*#,. S( #'!g& !& # #* E,!"& )#"#!"& %&'& # #* E,!"& (!(& !g&!"! *! 3(,"(%%(< !%(&!* *&, %("!"!&, !)#%!"&, #
,, "##% ##%7 7&, ) )"!'# "!'# !*# !*#,,
+#"# #"#
#% #% ( ( !
*&, *&,
( ( !*# !*#,,
(#!%(&!*#, "# %&'+##%(! #g(&!* & (5#,!* %&,(("&, ,#g@ *&, !!"&, (#!%(&!*#, & %&5#(&, "# *&, # *&, E,!"&, ,& +!# - !* %&'& &%# %& P#@ # 5(,! "# # #* ,(,#'! "# 3,(%(! !%(&!* & *#, ("! *!, g!!!, ,(%!, +!! ! #*! 3"(%(!* #)#%(5! & +&# %&,("#! # ,, "##%7&, 5*#!"&, 5*#!"&, & 7! #("& *! #+!!%(< # *#, %&#,+&"! %&#,+&"! # *!, ,##%(!, # *&, (!*#, #'(#.
PÁGINA $$
DERECHO PROCESAL CONSTITUCIONAL E P#@ !g&!"! *! 5! (#! & !%(&!* *! +#,&! *#,(&!"! # ,, "##%7&, +#"# #%( ! *! C&'(,(< I#!'#(%!& "# D##%7&, H'!&, / ! !54, "# 4,# 4,# ! *! C&# I#!'#(%!! "# D##%7&, H'!&, H'!&, "# *! OEA OEA & !' !'(4 (4 +#" +#"# # #% #% ( ( !# !# #* C&'( C&'(4 4 "# D## D##%7 %7&, &, H'! H'!& &,, "# *!, *!, N!%(&#, U("!, / &&, <g!&,. E* #%&&%('(#&
'
*;u0 +e?e hacer e, Per@ 4ara re/.rarse +e ,a co-4e/e1c.a 5ur.s+.cc.o1a, +e ,a cor/e .1/era-er.ca1a +e +erecho hu-a1os +e ,a OEA6
E* 8 "# "# J*(& J*(& "# 1 #* C&g#,& C&g#,& "#* P#@ !+&< !+&< '#"(! '#"(!# # R#,&*%(< R#,&*%(< L#g(,*!(5! N 21B2 21B2 #* #(& %& #)#%&, ('#"(!&, "#* E,!"& E,!"& +#!& "# *!
%&'+# %&'+##% #%(! (!
%&# %&#%(& %(&,! ,!
"#
*! C&# C&# I#! I#!'# '#(%! (%!! ! "# D##%7 D##%7&, &,
H'!&, *! '(,'! # #* #+#,#!# "#* G&(#& +#!& "#+&,(& !* "! ,(g(## # *! S#%#!(! G##!* "# *! Og!($!%(< "# E,!"&, A'#(%!&, !%(!"& *! "#%(! +!%(!* "# *! C&5#%(< A'#(%!! "# D##%7&, H'!&,. L! "#%(,(< +!*!'#!(! +&'&5("! +& #* P#,("## 3('&( ,# &(g(< # *! ,## ,##%(! %(! "#* ?0 "# '!/& '!/& "# 1 1 "# *! C&# C&# E* g&(# g&(#& & "# 3('& 3('&( ( !+&< #(! !* P#@ ! +!( "#* "# 3*(& "# 1 / %& #)#%&, ('#"(!&, "# *! %(,! )!%*!(5 )!%*!(5! ! "# *! C&5#%(< C&5#%(< A'#(%! A'#(%!! ! "# D##%7&, D##%7&, H'!&, H'!&, "# ,&'#('(#& ! *! %&'+##%(! %&#%(&,! "# *! C&# I#!'#(%!! "# D##%7&, H'!&,. M&(5& +& #* %!* #* #+#,#!# "#* E,!"& +#!& "#5&*5(< ! *! C&# *! &()(%!%(< %&#("! # *! &! CDH-11.60 CDH-11.60 I 002 "# )#%7! 12 "# 3*(& "# 1 #)#("! ! *! +#(%(< "# *! C&'(,(< I#!'#(%!! ,&# *! "#'!"! "# #+&,(%(< "# #, '!g(,!"&, "#* T(!* T(!* C&,(%(&!* "#,(("&, +& #* C&g#,& "# *! R#+*(%! "#* P#@. S( #'!g& *! C&# !,'(< !,'(< %&'+## %&'+##%( %(! ! # #* %!,& %!,& # 5(" 5(" "# # *! C&'(,(< C&'(,(< (#+ (#+,& ,& *! "#'!" "#'!"! ! #*2 "# 3*(& 3*(& "# 1 1 )#%7! )#%7! !#( !#(& & !* ,+# ,+#,& ,& Y#( Y#(&Y &Y "# *! %&'+##%(! %&#%(&,! "# *! C&# #!*($!"& #* "# 3*(& "# 1 10K.
10 Og!($!%(6 "# E,!"&, A'#(%!&, - C&# I#!'#(%!! "# D##%7&, H'!&, S#(# C: R#,&*%(&#, / S##%(!, N&. BB C!,& "#* T(!* C&,(%(&!* C&'+##%(! S##%(! "# 2 "# S#+(#'# "# 1.
PÁGINA $#
DERECHO PROCESAL CONSTITUCIONAL L! !%%(< # # (#! #* G&(#& G&(#& P#!& P#!& "# #(! #* #%&&%('(# #%&&%('(#& & "# *! %&'+##%(! %&#%(&,! "# *! C&# %!#%# "# &"& 5!*& 3"(%& +& & #,! +#5(,& / ,# %&!(& !* &3#& / )( "# *! C&5#%(< A'#(%!! ,&# D##%7&, H'!&,. N(g@ N(g@ !%*& !%*& "# *! C&5#%(< C&5#%(< A'#(%! A'#(%!! ! +#54 *! )(g! "#* #(& "#* #%&&%('(#& "# *! %&'+##%(! %&#%(&,! "# *! C&#. L! C&5#%(< A'#(%!! +#54 ,&*!'## *! !%#+!%(< "# *! %&'+##%(! %&#%(&,! "# *! C&# C&# & *! "#%(! &!* "# *! C&5#%(<. C&5#%(<. N( #>+#,! #>+#,! ( ('+*%(!'## ('+*%(!'## ,# +#54 # *! C&5#%(< C&5#%(< *! +&,((*(" +&,((*("!" !" "# #(! #(! #* #%&&%('(# #%&&%('(#& & "# *! %&'+##%(! %&#%(&,! "# *! C&#. P& #"# *! @(%! !*#!(5! +&,(*# +!! P#@ +!! "#,5(%*!,# "# *! %&'+##%(! %&#%(&,! "# *! C&# #, '#"(!# *! "#%(! &!* "# *! C&5#%(< A'#(%!! ,(g(#"& *&, +!,&, #,!*#%("&, # #* !%*& 8 "#* !!"& # %#,(<. D# !%#"& !* !%*& 62.2 "# *! C&5#%(< E,!"& +#"# #%&&%# %&'& &*(g!&(! &*(g!&(! *! %&'+##% %&'+##%(! (! "# *! C&# "# '!#! '!#! (%&"(%(& (%&"(%(&!* !* & ## &&, ,+#,&, +& +*!$& "##'(!"& & +!! %!,&, #,+#%)(%&,. E,& ,(g()(%! # ,( E,!"& &+! +& !%#+! "# '!#! (%&"(%(&!* !* %&'& *& 7($& P#@ #* 21 "# ##& "# 181 #"! 5(%*!"& ! *! %&'+##%(! %&#%(&,! "# *! C&# '(#!, %&(@# ,(#"& +!# "# *! C&5#%(< A'#(%!!. L! @(%! '!#! +&,(*# "# "#,5(%*!,# "#
*!
%&'+##%(!
%&#%(&,!
"#
*!
C&#
!
5#$
!%#+!"!
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g!*'## *(#, "# 7!%#*& "#
PÁGINA $'
DERECHO PROCESAL CONSTITUCIONAL '!#! (%&"(%(&!* / ,( *('(!%(< #'+&!* & +& #* %&!(& ,3#! !* #%&&%('(#& ! %&"(%(&#, & #,#5!, 11 Z U! 5#$ # ,# +&"% +&"%# # !* "#%*!! "#%*!!%(< %(< (*! (*!#! #!** "# 5&*! 5&*!" " *! '(,'! '(,'! +&"%# #)#%&, *#g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g!%(&#, !%#+!"& (%&"(%(&!*'## *! 3(,"(%%(< "# *! C&# *! @(%! !*#!(5! # *#, "#3! !(#! !(#! *! C&5#%(< #, *! "#%(!. "#%(!. E *! #,%! #,%! %&5#%(&!* *! !%#+!%(< (%&"(%(&!* "# *! 3(,"(%%(< 3 (,"(%%(< #, (#5#,(*#. L! *
PÁGINA $"
DERECHO PROCESAL CONSTITUCIONAL !#**&, E,!"&, # 7! !()(%!"& *! C&5#%(< A'#(%!! +#& # & 7! !%#+!"& *! 3(,"(%%(< "# *! C&#. E* %&&* !'#! +!! !#**&, E,!"&, # 7! !()(%!"& *! C&5#%(< / !%#+!"& *! 3(,"(%%(< "# *! C&# !3& *'(#, #'+&!*#, & +!! %!,&, #,+#%)(%&,. (!*'## #* '!/& '#%!(,'& "# %& %&& &** ,# "! # ! !#**& #**&,, %!,& %!,&,, # # # #* E,! E,!"& "& 7! !%# !%#+!"& !"& (%&"(%(&!*'## *! %&'+##%(! %&#%(&,! "# *! C&# %&'& ,%#"# %& #* P#@. E *! (#*(g#%(! "# *! C&5#%(< A'#(%!! A'#(%!! ! 5#$ # ,# 7! !5!$!"& "# #,! #,!"( "(& & !* ,(g ,(g(# (# # # *! "#%( "#%(,( ,(< < #, (#5 (#5# #,( ,(* *#. #. L&, L&, #"! #"!% %& &#, #, "# *! C&5#%(< +#)((#& # E,!"& # !,'(#! '!/&#, %&'+&'(,&, *& 7(%(#! "# '!#! +#'!##. E* ,+#,& ,+#,& Y#(#Y Y#(#Y "#* P#@ "# *! %&'+##%(! %&'+##%(! %&#% %&#%(&,! (&,! "# *! C&# / *! "#5&*%(6 "# *!, "#'!"!, "# #,4, "&, %!,#, %!,#, & +&"3#& #)#%& !*g& ,&# #* #3#%(%(& #3#%(%(& "# *! %&'+##% %&'+##%(! (! "#* T(! T(!*.*. P& #* %&!(& %&!(& )#& )#& '&(5# +!! # *! C&# I#!'#(%!! #,&*5(#! ! +&+6,(& "# #,4, "&, %!,#, %&%##, !%#%! "# *! (5!*("#$ "#* ,@(& #(# "#* E,!"& +#!& "# *! %&'+##%(! %&#%(&,! "# *! C&# 1?. E %!,& "# # #* E,!"& "#%("(#! #!%!,# "# *! !%#+!%(< "# '!/&#, %&'+&'(,&, *&, #"!%&#, &+!& +& ! "#,5(%*!%(< &!* "#* ,(,#'!. E *! %&% %&%#+ #+%( %(< < C&5# C&5#%( %(< <
"#* "#* ,(, ,(,#' #'! ! (# (#! !'# '#(% (%! !& &
+#)( +#)((# (#& &
#
E,!"& E,!"&
*&, *&,
#"! #"!% %& &#, #,
!,'! !,'! ,
"# *!
#,+& #,+&,! ,!(*(" (*("!" !"
%*!!'## )## ! *! %&'("!" (#!'#(%!! "# #(!,# %&'+*#!'## "#* '!%& %&5#%(& %&5#%(&!* !* !#, !#, "# # #(& +!%(!* +!%(!* "# *! C&#. C&#. E *! *
1? Og!($!%(6 "# E,!"&, A'#(%!&,-C&# I#!'#(%!! "# D##%7&, H'!&, S#(# C: R#,&*%(&#, / S##%(!, N&.BC!,& I5%7# &,#( C&'+##%(! S##%(! "# 2 "# S#+(#'# "# 1.
PÁGINA $(
DERECHO PROCESAL CONSTITUCIONAL
"
*S. *S. e, Per@ Per@ se re re/. /.ra ra +e ,a co-4 co-4e/ e/e1 e1c. c.aa 5ur. 5ur.s+ s+.c .cc. c.o1 o1a, a, +e ,a cor/ cor/ee .1/era-er.ca1a +e +erechos hu-a1os +e ,a OEA a1/e =u0 ora1.s-o .1/er1ac.o1a, 4o+e-os< co-o 4ar/.cu,ares< as.s/.r 4ara o?/e1er u1a res4ues/a s.-.,ar6
A*g&, 7! +##"("& !g'#! # *! !%%(< &'!"! +& #* g&(#& +#!& #, 5*("! "# !%#"& ! *&, 4'(&, "# *! C&5#%(< "# V(#! ,&# #* D##%7& D##%7& "# *&, T!!"& T!!"&,, / "# *! 3(,+"# 3(,+"#%(! %(! "# *! C&# I#!%(& I#!%(&!* !* "# J,(% J,(%(!. (!. E +!(% +!(%*! *! !g'# !g'#! ! # E,!"& E,!"& +#"# +#"# ,&# ,&#!! !!'# '## # "#%("( #(!,# "# !!"& / # *!, "#%*!!%(&#, !%#+!"& *! 3(,"(%%(< "# (!* (!* (#!%(&!* (#!%(&!* ,& !%&, !%&, (*!#!* (*!#!*#, #, # +#"# +#"# "#3!,# ,( #)#%& +& *! +&+(! 5&*!" "#* E,!"&. E* 21 "# ##& "# 181 ,# +#,#< # *! S#%#!! "# *! OEA (,'#& #'!!"& "#* M((,& "# R#*!%(&#, E>#(&#, "# *! R#+@*(%! "#* P#@ %& )#%7! 20 "# &%# "# 180 '!()#,"&,# #: \D# !%#"& %& *& #,(+*!"& # #* +!g!)& 1 "#* A%*& B "# *! C&5#%(< ,&# D##%7&, H'!&, P!%& "# S! J&,4 "# C&,! R(%! !()(%!"& +& #* P#@ #* "# ,#+(#'# "# 180K #* G&(#& "#* P#@ 1 #%&&%# *! %&'+##%(! "# *! C&'(,(< I#!'#(%!! "# D##%7&, H'!&, +!! #%(( / #>!'(! *!, %&'(%!%(&#, # E,!"& P!# !*#g# # && E,!"& P!# 7! (%("& # 5(&*!%(< "# *&, "##%7&, 7'!&, #,!*#%("&, # *! %(!"! C&5#%(< # *&, *&, 4' 4'( (&, &, +#5 +#5(, (,& &,, # #* +! +!g g!) !)& & 2 "# "(% "(%7& A% %* *&. &. E,# E,# #%&&%('(#& "# %&'+##%(! ,# 7!%# +& (#'+& ("#)(("& / !3& %&"(%(< "# #%(+&%("!". D# !%#"& ! %& *& +#,%(+& # #* +!g!)& 1 "#* A%*& 62 "# *! C&5#%(< !#, '#%(&!"! #* G&(#& "#* P#@ "#%*!! # #%&&%# %&'& &*(g!&(! "# +*#& "##%7& / ,( %&5#%(< #,+#%(!* *! C&'+##%(! "# *! C&# I#!'#(%!! "# D##%7&, H'!&, ,&# &"&, *&, %!,&, #*!(5&, ! *! (#+#!%(< & !+*(%!%(< "# *! C&5#%(<. E,# #%&& #%&&%(' %('(# (#& & "# %&'+# %&'+## #%(! %(! ,# 7!%# 7!%# +& +*!$& +*!$& ("## ("##'( '(!"& !"& / !3& !3& %&"(%(< "# #%(+&%("!"\ 1 A(#* D*(,/ YE* #(& "#* #%&&%('(#& "# *! %&'+##%(! %&#%(&,! "# *! C&# I#!'#(%!! "# D##%7&, H'!&, +& +!# "#* P#@Y # #* !!(& P#,!'(#& C&,(%(&!* A)(& VI N& 6 PUCP- MDC L('! 1 ++& 2 ,,&
PÁGINA $7
DERECHO PROCESAL CONSTITUCIONAL 4.1
Re/.ro +e ,a co-4e/e1c.a co1/e1c.osa +e ,a Cor/e I1/era-er.ca1a +e Derechos u-a1os
E* G&(#& "# P#@ %& )#%7! )#%7! "# 8 "# 3*(& "# 1 "#%*!!: D# !%# !%#" "& & %& %& *! C&5 C&5# #%( %(< < A'#( '#(%! %!! ! ,& ,&# # D## D##%7 %7&, &, H'! H'!& &, , *! R#+@*(%! "#* P#@ #(! *! D#%*!!%(< "# #%&&%('(#& "# *! %*,*! )!% )!%*! *!(5 (5! ! "# ,&'# ,&'#(('( '(# #& & ! *! %&'+ %&'+# ## #%( %(! ! %& %&# #%( %(&, &,! ! "# *! C& C&# # I# I#! !'# '#( (%! %!! ! "# D## D##%7 %7&, &, H'! H'!& &, , 7#%7 7#%7! ! # , &+& &+& ( ("! "!" " +& +& #* g&(#& +#!&. E,# E,# #( #(& & #%& #%&& &%( %('(# '(# & & "# *! %&'+ %&'+# ## #%( %(! ! %& %&# #%( %(&, &,! ! "# *! C& C&# # I#!'#(%!! +&"%( #)#%& ('#"(!& / ,# !+*(%! ! &"&, *&, %!,&, # # #* P#@ & 7(#,# %&#,!"& *! "#'!"! (%&!" !# *! C&# 1B.
"# Re Re/.r /.ro o +e ,a ,a co-4e co-4e/e1 /e1c.a c.a co1 co1/e1 /e1c.o c.osa sa +e +e ,a Cor/ Cor/ee
E* G&(#& "# P#@ %& )#%7! "# 2 "# ##& "# 2001 "#%*!!: E* #%&&%('(#& "# *! %&'+##%(! %&#%(&,! "# *! C&# I#!'#(%!! "# D##%7&, H'!&, #)#%!"! +& #* P#@ #* 20 "# &%# "# 180 +&,## +*#! 5(g#%(! / %&'+&'## ! &"&, ,, #)#%&, 3"(%&, !* E,!"& +#!& "#(#"& ##"#,# *! 5(g#%(! / %&'+&'## # &"&, ,, #)#%&, 3"(%&, !* E,!"& +#!& "#(#"& ##"#,# *! 5(g#%(! ((#'+("! "# "(%7! D#%*!!%(< "#,"# , "#+<,(& !# *! S#%#!! G##!* "# *! Og!($!%(< "# *&, E,!"&, A'#(%!&, A'#(%!&, OEAK #* 21 "# ##& "# 181. E* G&( G&(# #& & "# *! R#+@ R#+@* *(% (%! ! "#* "#* P#@ P#@ +&% +&%#" #"# # ! #( #(! ! *! D#%* D#%*! !!% !%(< (< "#+&,(!"! %& )#%7! "# 3*(& "# 1 # 5(" "# *! %!* ,# +##"(< #* #( #(& & "# *! D#%* D#%*! !!% !%(< (< "# #%& #%&& &%( %('( '(# #& & "# *! %* %*, ,*! *! )!% )!%*! *!(5 (5! ! "# ,&'#('(#& ! *! %&'+##%(! %&#%(&,! "# *! C&# I#!'#(%!! "# D##%7&, H'!&, 1B A(#* D*(,/ YE* #(& "#* #%&&%('(#& "# *! %&'+##%(! %&#%(&,! "# *! C&# I#!'#(%!! "# D##%7&, H'!&, +& +!# "#* P#@Y # #* !!(& P#,!'(#& C&,(%(&!* A)(& VI N& 6 PUCP- MDC L('! 1 ++& 2? ,,&
PÁGINA $8
DERECHO PROCESAL CONSTITUCIONAL D(%7!, D(%7!, &+((& &+((&#, #,
#, #,
#!"! #!"!, ,
& ,&*!'# ,&*!'## #
+&# +&# #*
"##%7 "##%7& &
(#!%(&!* %*,(%& & 3,()(%! #* !%%(&! "#* P#@ ,(& !'(4 +& & %&,("#! # *& # #, !3& (#+#!%(< #, !!"& (#!%(&!* +!! *! +&#%%(< "# *&, "##%7&, 7'!&, / & !!"& "#* (+& !"(%(&!* # #* # *&, E,!"&, !,'# %&'+&'(,&, #%+&%&,. E* "##%7& %*,(%& & !"(%(&!* #, (!+*(%!*# # #,# ,+#,&. E *&, !!"&, !"(%(&!*#, ,#! '*(*!#!*#, & (*!#!*#, *&, E,!"&, +!#, +#,(g# (#%!'(& #%+&%& "# ##)(%(&, / 5#!3!,. L! ,(!% ,(!%(< (< #, &!*' &!*'# ## # "()## "()### # # *!, %&5# %&5#%( %(&# &#,, #*!( #*!(5!, 5!, ! *&, "##%7&, 7'!&,. N& +#"# %&,("#!,# # #* &3#& / )( "# *&, !!"&, "# "##%7 "##%7&, &, 7'!& 7'!&,, ,#! #(*( #(*(! ! #%+ #%+&%! &%!'# '## # (## (##,#, ,#, ## ## *&, #,!"&,. #,!"&,. L&, !!"&, !!"&, "# "##%7&, "##%7&, 7'!&, 7'!&, +& #* %&!(& %&!(& +#,(g# +#,(g# #* #,!*#%( #,!*#%('(#& '(#& "# &"# &"# +@*(%& +@*(%& %&'@ %&'@ ! *!, +!#, +!#, # # & (## +& "#,(!!(& ! *&, #,!"&, ,(& *&, ("(5("&,
16
L! C&# I#!'#(%!! "# D##%7&, H'!&, 7! ,#9!*!"& #:
L&, !!"&, %&%#(##, ! #,! '!#(! #, &(#!"&, ', # ! #,!*#%# #(*((& "# (##,#, ## E,!"&, ! g!!($! #*
g&%# "# "##%7&, / *(#!"#, "#* ,# 7'!& 1 L&, L&, ! !!" !"&, &, "# D## D##%7 %7&, &, H'! H'!& &,, (# (## # %&'& %&'& #* &3# &3#((5& 5& #* #,!*#%('(#& "# &"# +@*(%& %&'@ +!! *! +&#%%(< "# *&,
16
V# V#
7+: 7+:
]]]&] ]]]&]%*& %*&!'# !'#(% (%!& !&#" #"+ +7 7' '(g7 (g7R R#+# #+#& &(& (&
!62&7'^62?1 1 V4!, V4!,# # *&, *&, "(5# "(5#, ,&, &, 5&& 5&&,, "(,( "(,("# "# #, #, & !$& !$&! !"& "&,, "#* "#* J#$ J#$ C! C!! !"& "& T("!"# !%#%! "#* %!%# &3#(5& "# *!, &*(g!%(&#, #,!*#%("!, # *&, !!"&, "# "##%7&, 7'!&,. ## &&, %!,& C!!**#& D#*g!"& / S!!! R#+!!%(&#, S##%(! S##%(! "# 2 "# ##& "# 1 5&& "(,("## "#* J#$ J#$ AA AA C!!"& C!!"& T("!" T("!"# # +. 1? / ,,. %!,& *!# E>%#+%(& E>%#+%(&#, #, P#*('(!#, P#*('(!#, ,## ,##%(! %(! "# 2 "# "# 3*( 3*(& & "# "# 16 16 5&& 5&& !$& !$&!" !"& & "#* J#$ J#$ A.A. A.A. C!! C!!"& "& T( T("! "!"# "#
+ +..
1
/
,,. ,,.
%!,& %!,&
E* A'+! '+!& & R#,& R#,&* *%( %(< < "# *! C&# C&#
I#!'#(%!! "# D##%7&, D##%7&, H'!&, H'!&, "#* 16 "# !(* "# 1 5&& "(,("## "(,("## "#* J#$ AA. C&!"& T("!"# T("!"# +. 1 / ,,
PÁGINA $9
DERECHO PROCESAL CONSTITUCIONAL ,##, ,##, 7'!& 7'!&,. ,. E #* %!,& S&#(g S&#(g *! C&# E&+# E&+#! ! "# D##%7 D##%7&, &,
H'!&, "#,!%< #: A* A* (# (#+ +# #! ! #* C&5 C&5# #(& (& E& E&+# +#& & "# D## D##%7 %7&, &, H'! H'!& &,, "## "## ##,# # %#! , %!%# #,+#%)(%& "# !!"& # (,'#! ! g!!! %&*#%(5! +!! #* #,+#& "# *&, "##%7&, 7'!&, /
*(#!"#, )"!'#!*#, 18. E #, #,& & %&( %&(# ## # *! C&# C&# I# I#!'# !'#(% (%!! !! 7! 7! #)!( #)!($!" $!"& & #
"(%7&, (,'#&, 1 N& ,& !!"&, '*(*!#!*#, "#* (+& !"(%(&!* %&%*("&, %&%*("&, # )%(< "# (#%!'(& #%+&%& "# "##%7&, +!! #* ##)(%(& '& "# *&, *&, #,! #,!"& "&,, %& %&! !! ! #, #,.. S &3# &3#& & / )( ,& ,& *! +& +&#% #%%( %(< < "# *&, *&, "##%7&, )"!'#!*#, )"!'#!*#, "# *&, ,##, 7'!&, 7'!&, ("#+#"(##'## ("#+#"(##'## "# , !%(&!*(" !%(&!*("!" !" !& )## ! , +&+(& +&+(& E,!"& E,!"& %&'& )## ! *&, &&, E,!"&, %&!!#,. A* !+&! #,&, !!"&, ,&# "##%7&, 7'!&, *&, E,!"&, ,# ,&'## ! &"# *#g!* "#& "#* %!* #**&, +& #* (# %&'@ !,'# 5!(!, &*(g!%(&#, & # #*!%(< %& &&, E,!"&, ,(& 7!%(! *&, ("(5("&, !3& , 3(,"(%%(< 20 .
18 D(5#,&, &g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
1 C&# E&+#! "# D##%7&, H'!&, C!,& S&#(g "# 3*(& "# 18 +!)& 8. 20 O+((< O+((< C&,*(5 C&,*(5! ! OC-282 OC-282 E* #)#%& #)#%& "# *!, #,#5!, #,#5!, ,&# *! #!"! #!"! # 5(g#%(! 5(g#%(! "# *! C&5#%(< C&5#%(< A'#(%! A'#(%!! ! ,&# D##%7&, D##%7&, H'!&, !,. / BK__ 2 "# ,#(#'# "# 182 +. .
PÁGINA $
DERECHO PROCESAL CONSTITUCIONAL
"' ORGANO
;%E
DECIDIRÁ
LA
ALIDE
DEL
RETIRO
DEL
RECONOCIMIENTO DE LA COMPETENCIA CONTENCIOSA L!, &'!, %&5#%(&!*#, !* (g!* # *! 3(,+"#%(! "# *! C&# I#!'#(%!! / *! "# &&, (!*#, (#!%(&!*#, #,!*#%# # *! +&+(! C&# I#!'#(%!! / & *! S#%#!! G##!* "# *! OEA ,# (# "#%("! !%#%! "# *! 5!*("#$ "#* ,+#,& #(& "#* #%&&%('(#& "# *! %&'+##%(! %&#%(&,! "# *! C&#. L! +&+(! C&5#%(< !(/# ! *! C&# "#%("( &"&, *&, %!,&, #*!(5&, ! *! (# (#+ +# #! !%( %(< < & !+*( !+*(%! %!%( %(< < "# *! C&5 C&5# #%( %(< < ! !% %* *& & 62.1 62.1K. K. E E# # *! (#+#!%(< & !+*(%!%(< "# *! C&5#%(< +& ,+#,& ,# #%#! &"& *& #*!(5& ! *! !%#+!%(< "# *! +&+(! %&'+##%(! %&#%(&,! "# *! C&#. L! 3(,+"#%(! "# *! C&# 7! #,!*#%("& !,('(,'& # #, #**! *! # "#%("( &"& *& #*!(5& !* %&#("& / !*%!%# "# *! 3(,"(%%(< "# *! C&#. A, # #* %!,& G#(# L!%!/& *! C&# ,# +&%(< ,&# #* !*%!%# "# *! "#%*!!%(< "# N(%!!g! #%&&%(#"& *! %&'+##%(! "# *! C&# +!! %!,& #,+#%)(%& 21 E *&, %!,&, *!# *!# / V(**!g V(**!g M&!*#, M&!*#, %&! %&! G!#'!*! G!#'!*! *! C&# 5&*5(< 5&*5(< ! #>+#"(,# # ,+#,&, # *&, %!*#, ,# %#,(&< *! %&'+##%(! "# *! C&# +!! %&&%# "# "(%7&, %!,&, 22 E #* %!,& C!/!! #* G&(#& P#!& +#,#< %&'& #>%#+%(< +#*('(! ! **!'!"! (%&'+##%(! "# *! C&# / ,( #'!g& #'!g& *! C&# #,&*5(< #,&*5(< # #! #**! #* <g!& <g!& %&'+## %&'+### # +!! #,&*5# !* !,& 2? E "#)(((5! "# !%#"& ! *! C&5#%(< A'#(%!! ,# *! C&# *! # "#%("! ,&# #* 5!*& "#* !%%(&! +#!&. A* 7!%#*& #" # %#! #
21 C&# E&+#! "# D##%7&, H'!&, %!,& I*!"! %&! R#(& U("& "# G! #!(! S##%(! "# 18 "# ##& "# 1 +. +. 2?. 22 C&'(4 "# D##%7&, H'!&, O,#5!%(< G##!* 2661K A+&!"! # *! 16?1 ,#,(< %#*#!"! %#*#!"! #* 2 "# "# &%# "# 1. 2? C). C&'(4 "# D##%7&, H'!&,. ("#'.
PÁGINA #!
DERECHO PROCESAL CONSTITUCIONAL %&#,+&"# ! #,! C&# g!!($! *! +&#%%(< (#!%(&!* # #,!*#%# *! C&5#%(< "#& "# *! (#g("!" "#* ,(,#'! +!%!"& +& *&, E,!"&, 2.
(
Jur.s4 Jur.s4ru ru+e1 +e1c.a c.a,-e ,-e1/e 1/e<< *,as +ec.s +ec.s.o1 .o1es es +e ,a cor/e cor/e .1/er .1/era-e a-er.c r.ca1a a1a +e +ere +erech chos os hu-a hu-a1o 1oss +e ,a OEA< OEA< e1 ca caso soss =ue =ue 1o /.e1 /.e1ee a, es es/a /a+o +o 4eru 4erua1 a1o o co-o co-o 4ar/ 4ar/ee 4roc 4roces esa, a,<< +e?e +e?e1 1 se serr /o-a /o-a+a +ass +e -a1e -a1era ra o?,.a/or.a 4or ,os 5ueces cua1+o .1/er4re/a1 ,os +erechos hu-a1os 2 ,a co1s/./uc.316
S( +&# %&'& ,!#'&, *&, 3#%#, ('+!# 3,(%(! "# !%#"& ! *!, *#/#, /! #,!*#%("!,. L! C&,( C&,(% %(6 (6 +#! +#!! ! 7! %&,!g %&,!g!" !"& & # #* !% !%*& *& 1?1?-? ? #* "##%7 "##%7& & )"!'#!* "# *&, %("!"!&, ! *! #*! 3(,"(%%(&!* / # #* !%*& 20B #* "##%7& )"!'#!* ! *! #*! 3(,"(%%(&!* (#!%(&!* !* #,!*#%# #Y !g&!"! *! 3(,"(%%(< (#! (# ,# %&,("## *#,(&!"& # ,, "##%7&, # *! C&,(%(6 #%&&%# +#"# #%( ! *&, (1 '!*#, &g!(,'&, (#!%(&!*#, %&,(("&, ,#g@ !!"&, & %&5#(&, "# *&, # #* P#@ #, +!#Y. +!#Y. L! )(!*("!" )(!*("!" "# #,! "(,+&,(%(6 "(,+&,(%(6 #, !,#g! !,#g! *! 3,(%(! 3,(%(! ! (5#* (5#* (#!%(&!* ,( #, # & ,# 7! &#("& # #* '(& !%(&!* *& # #, *& '(,'& ! ('+#"( *! ('+("!" ! (5#* !%(&!* 2B L!, L!, &' &'!, !, %&5 %&5# #%( %(& &!* !*#, #, !* (g! (g!** # # *! 3( 3(,,+" +"# #%( %(! ! "# *! C& C&# # I#!'#(%!! / *! "# &&, (!*#, (#!%(&!*#, #,!*#%# # *! +&+(! C&# I#!'#(%!! I#!'#(%!! / & & *! S#%#!! S#%#!! G##!* G##!* "# *! OEA OEA ,# (# "#%("! !%#%! "# *! 5!*("#$ "#* #%&&%('(#& "# *! %&'+##%(! %&#%(&,! "# *! C&#. L! +&+(! C&5#%(< !(/# ! *! C&# "#%("( &"&, *&, %!,&, #*!(5&, ! *! (#+#!%(< & !+*(%!%(< "# *! C&5#%(< !%*& 62.1K. 2 C!,& V#*,#$ R&"g#$ E>%#+%(&#, P#*('(!#, S##%(! "# 26 "# 3(& "# 18 +. 6. 2B A*#& &#! E* P&"# 3"(%(!* %&'& %&&* +!! #5(! *! ('+("!" # E,"(&, !,(%&, "# D##%7&, H'!&, II %&'+(*!"&#, A&(& C!%!"& T("!"# / L&#! G&$!*#, V&*(&K V&*(&K IIDH S! J&,4 1B ++. B16 B16 ,,.
PÁGINA #$
DERECHO PROCESAL CONSTITUCIONAL E E# # *! (# (#+ +# #! !%( %(< < & !+*(% !+*(%!% !%(< (< "# *! C&5 C&5# #%( %(< < +& +& ,+ ,+#, #,& & ,# #%#! &"& *& #*!(5& ! *! !%#+!%(< "# *! +&+(! %&'+##%(! %&#%(&,! "# *! C&#. L! 3(,+"#%(! "# *! C&# 7! #,!*#%("& !,('(,'& # #, #**! *! # "#%("( &"& *& #*!(5& !* %&#("& / !*%!%# "# *! 3(,"(%%(< "# *! C&#. A, # #* %!,& G#(# L!%!/& *! C&# ,# +&%(< ,&# #* !*%!%# "# *! "#%*!!%(< "# N(%!!g! #%&&%(#"& *! %&'+##%(! "# *! C&# +!! %!,& #,+#%)(%& 26 E *&, %!,&, *!# *!# / V(**!g V(**!g M&!*#, M&!*#, %&! %&! G!#'!*! G!#'!*! *! C&# 5&*5(< 5&*5(< ! #>+#"(,# # ,+#,&, # *&, %!*#, ,# %#,(&< *! %&'+##%(! "# *! C&# +!! +!! %&&%# %&&%# "# "(%7&, "(%7&, %!,&, %!,&, 2E #* %!,& %!,& C!/! C!/!! ! #* G&(# G&(# & & P# P#! !& & +#,#< %&'& #>%#+%(< +#*('(! ! **!'!"! (%&'+##%(! "# *! C&# / ,( #'!g& #'!g& *! C&# #,&*5(< #,&*5(< # #! #**! #* <g!& <g!& %&'+## %&'+### # +!! #,&*5# !* !,& 28
CONCL%SIONES H!! +&+#,& ! #)&'! ! *! #,%! "# *! ONU. E #,! 4+&%! #* &3#(5& #! #,!! #* #(*((& ## *&, <g!&, # %&)&'!! *! ONU 26 C&# I#!'#(%!! C(#!, A(%(&#, "# *! C&'(,(< I#!'#(%!! "# D##%7&, H'!&, O+((< O+((< C&,*(5! OC-1?? OC-1?? "#* 16 "# 3*(& 3*(& "# 1? +!& B0. 2 C!,& G#(# L!%!/& E>%#+%(&#, P#*('(!#, S##%(! "# 2 "# ##& "# 1B 28 C!,& *!# E>%#+%(&#, P#*('(!#, S##%(! "# 2 "# 3*(& "# 16 / %!,& %!,& V(**!g V(**!g M&!*# M&!*#, , E>%#+ E>%#+%(& %(&#, #, P#* P#*('( ('(! !#, #, S## S##%( %(! ! "# ,#+(#'# "# 1
PÁGINA ##
11
"#
DERECHO PROCESAL CONSTITUCIONAL # %& %&#> #>& & "# +&, +&, G# G#! ! ! ! # #* %!* %!* %&'& %&'& 7#'& 7#'&,, ,#9! ,#9!*! *!"& "& !#(&'## #* +!+#* "# *! Og!($!%(< 7!! #,!"& !& &,%#%("&. E* && &3#(5& "# &&,-G7!*( #! ,('+*()(%! *!, )%(&#, "# %!"! &)(%(! / !g#%(! +& '#"(& "# *! %*!()(%!%(< "# ,, !%(5("!"#, 2. L! !# !#! ! "#* "#* C&'( C&'(4 4 "# D## D##%%7&, 7&, H'! H'!& &,, #, ,+# +#55(,! (,! / 5(g(* (g(*! ! #* %'+*( %'+*('(# '(#& & "# *!, &*(g!% &*(g!%(& (&#, #, "('!! "('!!#, #, "#* P!%& P!%& +& *&,
E,!"& E,!"&,,
P!#,. U& "# *&, +&, +&, ', )##, "#* C&'(4 C&'(4 #, *! !&("!" '&!* # # *# %&)(## #* 7#%7& "# # ,, '(#'&, #+#,#! ! &"!, *!, +!#, "#* '"&. D# !%# !%#" "& & %& %& *! C&5 C&5# #%( %(< < A'#( '#(%! %!! ! ,& ,&# # D## D##%7 %7&, &, H'! H'!& &, , *! R#+@*(%! "#* P#@ #(! *! D#%*!!%(< "# #%&&%('(#& "# *! %*,*! )!% )!%*! *!(5 (5! ! "# ,&'# ,&'#(('( '(# #& & ! *! %&'+ %&'+# ## #%( %(! ! %& %&# #%( %(&, &,! ! "# *! C& C&# # I# I#! !'# '#( (%! %!! ! "# D## D##%7 %7&, &, H'! H'!& &, , 7#%7 7#%7! ! # , &+& &+& ( ("! "!" " +& +& #* g&(#& +#!&. E* #%&&%('(#& "# *! %&'+##%(! %&#%(&,! "# *! C&# I#!'#(%!! "# D##%7&, H'!&, #)#%!"! +& #* P#@ #* 20 "# &%# "# 180 +&,## +*#! 5(g#%(! / %&'+&'## ! &"&, ,, #)#%&, 3"(%&, !* E,!"& +#!& "#(#"& ##"#,# *! 5(g#%(! / %&'+&'## # &"&, ,, #)#%&, 3"(%&, !* E,!"& +#!& "#(#"& ##"#,# *! 5(g#%(! ((# ((# '+( '+("! "! "# "(%7! "(%7! D#%*! D#%*!!%( !%(< < "#,"# "#,"# , "#+<,( "#+<,(& & !# !# *! S#%# S#%#! !! ! G##!* "# *! Og!($!%(< "# *&, E,!"&, A'#(%!&,.
2 S&# *! #)&'! "#,!&**!"! +& &&, &&,-G7!*( SEUERT-ARR !)('! #: E* S#%#!(& G##!* 7! (,(("& #)&'!, !"'((,!(5!, "# *!g& !*%!%# +!! #*('(! *! "+*(%!%(< / %&%#! "# #5& *! *!& "# &"!, *!, +!#, "# *!, N!%(&#, U("!, # , '!"!& ,(%& &(g(!*. E 3(& "# 12 #* S#%#!(& G##!* +*(%< ! #,!#g(! "# *!g& !*%!%# +!! *! *!& )! "# *! Og!($!%(< (*!"! U P&g!'! "# P!$ # # +#,#< +&+#,!, +!! )&!*#%# *! #)(%!%(! "# *!, N!%(&#, U("!, # #* %'+*('(#&.
PÁGINA #'
DERECHO PROCESAL CONSTITUCIONAL
RECOMENDACIONES
E,& &, 7!%# 5# # # *! #!*("!" & ,# "! +& #"# "##'&, +&# # +%(%! %&'& (# *& 7!%# *&, E,!"&, ,(g# ,(g# !+*(%!"& #* 7(& 7(& "# "#%("( "#%("( +#5( +#5(!'# !'## # / +& '#"(& '#"(& "# #g&% #g&%(!% (!%(& (&#, #, +&*( +&*(%!, %!, *&, %!" %!"(" ("! !&, &, # # #, #,*! *! #*#g #*#g(" ("&, &, *& # # ,# %&& %&&%# %# %&'& %&'& *(, *(,!, !, %#!"!, / # ,# (*($!! # *! 4+&%! "# *! C&'(,(< . A,('(,'& #* "#!# ,&# ! ,+#,! "#)(%(#%(! # *&, '(#'&, #*#g("&, +!! #* <g! <g!& & #, # , '(,' '(,'& & )!*! )!*!$$ /! # # %&'& %&'& !g !g'# '# ! !#' #'&, &, ', ', !"#*! !"#*!# #
(#g! (#g! *! !! !!*#$ *#$! ! #,#%( #,#%(!*' !*'# ## # (#g (#g# #! !'# '#!* !* /
+&*(%! "#* <g!& # ,# '!()(#,! # , &+%(< !'(4 +&*(%! +& #,(g( *! +#,#%(! "# #>+#& &, / #* %&%#+& "# +*#! #+#,#!(5("!" # #* ,#& "#* C&,#3& "# D##%7&, H'!&, "# *&, "()###, E,!"&, # %&'+&# *! S&%(#"!" (#!%(&!*.
PÁGINA #"
DERECHO PROCESAL CONSTITUCIONAL
BIBLIOGRAFA
A*(,(, "# *!, "#)((%(&#, %&%#+!*#, ,(%!, +!! *! !+*(%!%(< "# *&, '#%!(,'&, "# "#)#,! %&*#%(5! "# *! "#'&%!%(! +#5(,&, # *!
C!! D#'&%(%! I#!'#(%!! R#5(,! IIDH N`? 2006 ++.1?-B? DOM[NGUE REDONDO E. L&, +&%#"('(#&, +@*(%&, #,+#%(!*#, "# *! C&'(,(< "# D##%7&, H'!&, "# *!, N!%(&#, U("!, T(! *&
*!%7 V!*#%(! 200B. ESCOAR HERNNDE C. L! C&'(,(< "# D##%7&, H'!&, "# *!, N!%(&#, U("!, / *! 5(&*!%(< "# "##%7&, 7'!&, / *(#!"#, )"!' )"!'# #!*# !*#,: ,: #,"( #,"(& & "# *&, +&%#" +&%#"('(# ('(#& &,, +@*(% +@*(%&, &, #,+#% #,+#%(!* (!*#, #, E"(& E"(&(!* (!* "# *! U(5# U(5#,(" ,("!" !" C&'+* C&'+*# #,# ,# "# M!"(" M!"(" %&*#%% %&*#%%(< (< #,(, #,(,
"&%&!*#, M!"(" 188 &'& 1. NIEN P#"& P#)#%%(&! #* S(,#'! I#!'#(%!& "# D##%7&, H'!&, ,( R#)&'! #* P!%& "# S! J&,4 # M4"#$ J! E. / C&> C&> ! !%( %(,% ,%& & #", #",.K .K E* & & "#* "#* S(, S(,#' #'! ! I# I#! !'# '#( (%! %!& & "# P&#% P&#%%(< %(< "# *&, D##%7 D##%7&, &, H'!& H'!&, , I,( I,(& & I#! I#!'# '#(%! (%!& & "#
D##%7&, H'!&, S! J&,4 C&,! R(%! 18 ++. 2B-1. VILLN C!*&,. L! +&#%%(< (#!%(&!* "# *&, "##%7&, 7'!&, # #* ,(,#'! "# *!, N!%(&#, U("!, / "# ,, &g! g!(,'&, #,+#%(!*($!"&,. I,(& I#!%(&!* "# D##%7&, H'!&,. 2 ,#,(< "# #,#9!$!. E,!,g& -2 "# 3*(& "# 2011 +. 8 / .
.
PÁGINA #(
DERECHO PROCESAL CONSTITUCIONAL
ANEXOS
PÁGINA #7
