PLDT vs City of Davao, G.R. No. 143867. August 22, 2001 FACT! CT! P"tit P"titio io#" #"$$ P%i& P%i&i' i''i 'i#" #" Lo# Lo#g g Dist Dista#( a#(" " T" T"&"'% &"'%o# o#" " Co., Co., )#(. )#(. *PL *PLDT DT++ a''& a''&i" i" fo$ fo$ a -ayo$s P"$it to o'"$at" its Davao -"t$o /(%a#g". R"s'o#"#t City of Davao it%%"& a(tio# o# t%" a''&i(atio# '"#i#g 'ay"#t y '"titio#"$ of t%" &o(a& f$a#(%is" ta i# t%" aou#t of P3,681,8.72 fo$ t%" fi$st to t%" fou$t% 5ua$t"$ of 1. P"titio#"$ '$ot"st". P"titio#"$ ustifi"s its (&ai of ta ""'tio# u#"$ R.A. No. 72, ot%"$is" #o# as t%" Pu&i( T"&"(ou#i(atio#s T"&"(ou#i(atio#s Po&i(y A(t of t%" P%i&i''i#"s, 23 of %i(% $"as! /C. 23. 23. Equality of Treatment in the Telecommunications Telecommunications Industry. A#y Industry. A#y ava#tag", favo$, '$ivi&"g", ""'tio#, o$ iu#ity g$a#t" u#"$ "isti#g f$a#(%is"s, o$ ay %"$"aft"$ " g$a#t", s%a&& ipso facto "(o" facto "(o" 'a$t of '$"vious&y g$a#t" t"&"(ou#i(atio#s f$a#(%is"s a# s%a&& " a((o$" i"iat"&y a# u#(o#itio#a&&y to t%" g$a#t""s of su(% f$a#(%is"s! Provided, however, T%at however, T%at t%" fo$"goi#g s%a&& #"it%"$ a''&y to #o$ aff"(t '$ovisio#s of t"&"(ou#i(atio#s f$a#(%is"s (o#("$#i#g t"$$ito$y (ov"$" y t%" f$a#(%is", t%" &if" s'a# of t%" f$a#(%is", o$ t%" ty'" of s"$vi(" aut%o$i" y t%" f$a#(%is".
)9 )9/! /! Davao.
:%"t :%"t%" %"$$ o$ o$ #ot #ot PLDT PLDT is "" ""'t 't" " f$o f$o f$a# f$a#(% (%is is" " ta ta i'o i'os" s" y y Cit City y of of
;/LD ;/LD!!
No. No. PLDT PLDT is #ot #ot "" ""'t 't f$o f$o f$a# f$a#(% (%is is" " ta ta i'o i'os" s" y y City City of Dava Davao. o.
R.A. No. 72 is a &"gis&ativ" "#a(t"#t "sig#" to s"t t%" #atio#a& 'o&i(y o# t"&"(ou#i(atio#s a# '$ovi" t%" st$u(tu$"s to i'&""#t it to ""' u' it% t%" t"(%#o&ogi(a& ava#("s i# t%" i#ust$y a# t%" #""s of t%" 'u&i(. T%" t%$ust of t%" &a is to '$oot" g$aua&&y t%" "$"gu&atio# of t%" "#t$y, "#t$ y, '$i(i#g, a# o'"$atio#s of a&& 'u&i( t"&"(ou#i(atio#s "#titi"s a# t%us '$oot" a &"v"& '&ayi#g fi"& i# t%" t"&"(ou#i(atio#s i#ust$y. T%"$" is #ot%i#g i# t%" &a#guag" of 23 #o$ i# t%" '$o(""i#gs of ot% t%" ;ous" of R"'$"s"#tativ"s a# t%" "#at" i# "#a(ti#g R.A. No. 72 %i(% s%os t%at it (o#t"'&at"s t%" g$a#t of ta ""'tio#s to a&& t"&"(ou#i(atio#s "#titi"s, i#(&ui#g t%os" %os" ""'tio#s %a ""# it%$a# y t%" LGC. T%" ta ""'tio# ust " "'$"ss" i# t%" statut" i# (&"a$ &a#guag" t%at &"av"s #o out of t%" i#t"#tio# of t%" &"gis&atu$" to g$a#t su(% ""'tio#. A#, "v"# if it is g$a#t", t%" ""'tio# ust " i#t"$'$"t" i# strictissimi juris agai#st juris agai#st t%" ta'ay"$ a# &i"$a&&y i# favo$ of t%" tai#g aut%o$ity. )# t%is (as", t%" o$ ""'tio# i# 23 of R.A. No. 72 (ou& (o#t"'&at" ""'tio# f$o ("$tai# $"gu&ato$y o$ $"'o$ti#g $"5ui$""#ts, "a$i#g i# i# t%" 'o&i(y of t%" &a.
