Memorandum on Behalf of Respondent Ilnu



Search



Home



Saved

429 views

1



Sign In

Upload

Join

RELATED TITLES

0

Memorandum on Behalf of Respondent Ilnu



Uploaded by NiteshMaheshwari



Bestsellers



Books



Audiobooks



Magazines



News



Documents



Sheet Music

Memorandum on Behalf of Respondent ILNU









Save

Embed

Share

Print

Memorial for Appellant

1

Download

of 16

 

2011_top10_memorandum10717 Memorandum on Behalf of



 Search document

I.M. N ANAVATI M EMORIAL M OOT C OURT C OMPETITION , 2016

TEAM C

GLS C OLLEGE, AHMEDABAD I.M. N ANAVATI M EMORIAL M OOT C OURT C OMPETITION , 2016

I N THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT

I N THE M ATTER O O F:

AJIT S OLANKI .......................... ....................................... ........................... ............................ ............................ .......................A .........A PPELLANT V.

SHANKAR S S INGH............................ .......................................... .......................... .......................... ............................ ..................R ....R ESPONDEN

IN THE MATTER ARISING OUT OF:

The impugned Judgment and OrderSign dated up 16/08/01! to vote on this title



Useful

 Not useful

"a##ed $% $ % the &'t'r A((ident# Tri$una)* Ahmeda$ad Ahmeda$ad







Home



Saved



Bestsellers



Books



Audiobooks



Magazines



News



Documents



Sheet Music



Upload

Sign In

Join



Search



Home



Saved

429 views

1



Upload

Sign In

Join

RELATED TITLES

0







Bestsellers



Books



Audiobooks



Magazines



News



Documents



Sheet Music










Save

Embed

Share

Print


1

Download

of 16

 


 Search document



I.M. NANAVATI M EMORIAL M OOT C OURT C OMPETITION, 2016

TABLE OF C ONTENTS

Contents

LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

INDEX OF AUTHORITIES +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ STATEMENT OF J URISDICTION +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ +++++++++++++++++++++++

STATEMENT OF F ACTS+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ ++++++++++++++

+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ ++++++++++++++ STATEMENT OF I SSUES++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

SUMMAR OF ARGUMENTS++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ ++++++++++ ARGUMENTS ADVANCED++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ I+

THE TRACTOR   RIER I I 2 NOT G UI3T4 U/2 .* ,,. A N ,,8 O F I"C* 1860++++

II+

THE A""E33ANT 5A2 3 IA3E F OR N N EG3IGENCE +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

I I I+

THE C O&"EN2ATION A5ARE 2 HOU3  E 2ET A2IE+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ +++++++++++++++ PRAER ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

Sign up to vote on this title



Useful

 Not useful







Home



Saved



Bestsellers



Books



Audiobooks



Magazines



News



Documents



Sheet Music



Upload

Sign In

Join



Search



Home



Saved

1

429 views



Upload

Sign In

Join

RELATED TITLES

0







Bestsellers



Books



Audiobooks



Magazines



News



Documents



Sheet Music










Save

Embed

Share

Print

Download


1

of 16

 


 Search document




LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS 7  Anr+ Or#+ A IR Art+ i+e+ p+ 2C 9+

And 2e(ti'n And 'ther# Other# A)) India Rep'rter Arti()e that i# "age 2upreme C'urt er#u#




Useful

 Not useful







Home



Saved



Bestsellers



Books



Audiobooks



Magazines



News



Documents



Sheet Music



Upload

Sign In

Join



Search



Home



Saved

1

429 views



Sign In

Upload

Join

RELATED TITLES

0







Bestsellers



Books



Audiobooks



Magazines



News



Documents



Sheet Music










Save

Embed

Share

Print

Download


1

of 16

 




 Search document


INDEX OF AUTHORITIES CASES C ITED

2+NO 1+ + ,+ -+ !+ 6+ .+ 8+

CA2E NA&E 2tate ': ;arnata 8 2CC -, ? 18 2CC =Cri> 1!08 Tami) Nadu 2tate Tran#p'rt C'rp'rati'n 3td+ 9+ A$du) 2a)am and Or#+ )%th 9+ irmingham 5ater@'r<# C'+* 18!6 =11> E+ .81 GuBarat 2t 2tate R' R'ad Tran#p'rt C'rp'rati'n 9+ 9+ ;am)a$en a)Bi$hai ' 'ra Nati'na) In#uran(e C'+ 3td+ 9+ 9+ 2mt+ Uma Uma e9i Ti@ari Ti@ari and Or#+ =00.> =1> &ANI2A =&+"+> =&+"+> ;anti e9i 2i &"5N88?00.=1> &"H. --. C'mm C'mmi# i##i' #i'ner ner :'r :'r Ee(u Ee(uti ting ng O::i O::i(e (e ': 3'rd 3'rd High High Admir dmira) a) ': Unit United ed ;ingd'm 9+ O@ner# ': 2+2+ ')ute &anBu)a e9i huta 9+ Anr+

9+

&anBu#ri

Raha

and

Or#+

&ANU/&"+/010/16.&ANU/&"/010/16. ? 168 A+C+J+

EFERRED BOOKS C ITED AND R EFERRED

2+N+

OO;2

2+N+

OO;2

1+

HA32UR42 3A52 A52 OF E NG3AN* =-TH E+* 3EDI2NEDI2UTTER5ORTH25AH5

+

01,>+ JU2TICE 4  CHANRACHU 7  R & ANOHAR * THE I NIAN "ENA3 COE  * =,1

,+

E+* R ATAN3A3 ATAN3A3 A N HIRAJ3A3  Useful * 00.>  Not useful 3A5&ANN2 HARGAA2 &OTOR  EHIC3E2 3A52 A52* =; A&A3 A&A3 "U3I2HER2* N


E3HI* 00>





Home



Saved



Bestsellers



Books



Audiobooks



Magazines



News



Documents



Sheet Music



Upload

Sign In

Join



Search



Home



Saved

429 views

1



Upload

Sign In

Join

RELATED TITLES

0







Bestsellers



Books



Audiobooks



Magazines



News



Documents



Sheet Music










Save

Embed

Share

Print


1

Download

of 16

 


 Search document




+ ,+

http?//@@@+@e#t)a@ )a@india+('m http#?//@@@+#(('n)ine+in/de:au)t+a#p

4.

http#?//@@@+B#t'r+('m

DICTIONARIES

Henr% Camp$e)) )a(<*  3AC;  2 3 A5  ICTIONAR4 * =th Ed+* 00!>+ "+ RamnathaAi%er* T HE 3 A5 3 EDICON , =E+ 00>+




Useful

 Not useful







Home



Saved



Bestsellers



Books



Audiobooks



Magazines



News



Documents



Sheet Music



Upload

Sign In

Join



Search



Home



Saved

429 views

1



Upload

Sign In

Join

RELATED TITLES

0







Bestsellers



Books



Audiobooks



Magazines



News



Documents



Sheet Music










Save

Embed

Share

Print

Download


1

of 16

 


 Search document




STATEMENT OF JURISDICTION

The petiti'ner# ha9e :i)ed the (a#e $e:'re the h'n$)e High ('urt ': GuBarat* in the matt

aBit #')an
appea) :i)ed $% an% per#'n aggrie9ed $% the de(i#i'n ': m't'r a((ident ()aim tri$una)+ appe))ant appr'a(he# the h'n'ra$)e ('urt under #e(ti'n 1., 1 ': m't'r m't'r 9ehi()e# a(t 188 The pre#ent mem'randum #et# :'rth the :a(t#* ('ntenti'n# And argument#+




Useful

 Not useful







Home



Saved



Bestsellers



Books



Audiobooks



Magazines



News



Documents



Sheet Music



Upload

Sign In

Join



Search



Home



Saved

1

429 views



Upload

Sign In

Join

RELATED TITLES

0







Bestsellers



Books



Audiobooks



Magazines



News



Documents



Sheet Music










Save

Embed

Share

Print

Download


1

of 16

 


 Search document




STATEMENT OF F ACTS

F'r the #a
&r+ ABit 2')an
$earing num$er GUI 168 a)'ng a )'ng @ith hi# (hi)dren* Anu* aged 1, %ear# and Anand* age

=pi))i'n rider#>+ En r'ute t' Ahmeda$ad* a tra(t'r $earing num$er GJ1; 01, dri9e

2han
A:ter medi(a) eaminati'n it @a# :'und that the appe))ant min'r# ha9e had mu)tip)e inBu 'n their their $'d% $'d% and had t' g' thr'ug thr'ugh h #urger #urgerie# ie#++ Anu* Anu* the appe)) appe))ant ant daught daughter* er* had permanent di#a$i)itie#* and Anand* the appe))ant #'n* had 0 permanent di#a$i)it%+ appe))a appe))ant nt :ather :ather had #e9ere #e9ere head head inBurie# inBurie# and #u#tain #u#tained ed !0 perman permanent ent di#a$i di#a$i)iti )iti eamined $% r+ Hite#h 2hah* an 'rth'paedi( #urge'n+

FIR @a# )'dged again#t the '::ending tru(< at Ha)') "')i(e 2tati'n U/2 .* ,,.* and ,, ()aim petiti'n @a# :i)ed in the &'t'r A((ident# C)aim# Tri$una) Tri$una) #tating hi# in('me ta :'r the pa#t - %ear# in()uding the in('me :'r the (urrent %ear a# R#+ 1 )a(#+

 in#ur A #tud% rendering the re#pe(ti9e e9ent a# a rare '((urren(e* @a# pr'du(ed $% the Sign up to vote on this title

('mpan% ('mpan% #tating that the a((ident# d' '((ur due t' the@hee) it i# $e(au#e ' Useful('ming useful  Not'::

ru#ting ': the $')t* 'r the #tud# ': the t%re ': the m't'r (%()e $eing ')d* ru#ting ': the a





Home



Saved



Bestsellers



Books



Audiobooks



Magazines



News



Documents



Sheet Music



Upload

Sign In

Join



Search



Home



Saved

429 views

1



Upload

Sign In

Join

RELATED TITLES

0







Bestsellers



Books



Audiobooks



Magazines



News



Documents



Sheet Music










Save

Embed

Share

Print


1

Download

of 16

 


 Search document




STATEMENT OF ISSUES

I.

I SSUE 1: WHETHER THE R ESPONDENT ESPONDENT I S GUILT U NDER SECTIONS 2"#, AND $$% O F I NDIAN P ENAL C ODE , 1%60

II.

I SSUE 2: WHETHER THE APPELLANT WAS LIABLE FOR CONTRIBUT NEGLIGENCE

III.

I SSUE $: WHETHER T T HE C OMPENSATION AWARDED B  T HE T RIBUNAL I EASONABLE AND R EASONABLE




Useful

 Not useful







Home



Saved



Bestsellers



Books



Audiobooks



Magazines



News



Documents



Sheet Music



Upload

Sign In

Join



Search



Home



Saved

429 views

1



Sign In

Upload

Join

RELATED TITLES

0







Bestsellers



Books



Audiobooks



Magazines



News



Documents



Sheet Music










Save

Embed

Share

Print

Download


1

of 16

 


 Search document




SUMMARY OF ARGUMENTS I+

THE TRACTOR D D RIVER I I S NOT G UILT U&S 2"#, $$" A ND $$% O F IPC, 1

The The a))eg a))egat ati' i'n# n# agai again# n#tt the the re#p' re#p'nd nden entt 1 are gr'u gr'und nd)e# )e### and and n't n't end' end'r#e r#ed d

e9iden(e+ The re#p'ndent i# :a)#e)% (harged under #e(ti'n .* ,,. a# @e)) a# ,,8+

tra(t'r dri9er @a# n't dri9ing ra#h)% 'r neg)igent)% 'n the ('ntrar%* he @a# (are:u) @

dri9ing the 9ehi()e+ A$#en(e ': an%
neg)igent negate# #e(ti'n . (harged again#t him+ The tra(t'r dri9er did n't d' an%

that (au#ed hurt $% endangering )i:e 'r per#'na) #a:et% ': 'ther#+ The a((ident @a# (a

due t' the neg)igen(e #h'@n $% the appe))ant#+ There:'re* (harged under #e(ti'n .* and ,,8* are a)) :a)#e)% (harged again#t him+ II+

THE APPELLANT I S L IABLE F OR N N EGLIGENCE

It i# #u$mitted t' the H'n'ura$)e C'urt that the appe))ant# are re#p'n#i$)e :'r the a((i 

Sign up to vote on this title a# pi))i'n ri that had ta


Useful

 Not useful

and #' it (an $e #a:e)% a##umed that he did n't ha9e :u)) ('ntr') '9er the 9ehi()e+ du

@hi(h* the ('))i#i'n had ta




Home



Saved



Bestsellers



Books



Audiobooks



Magazines



News



Documents



Sheet Music



Upload

Sign In

Join



Search



Home



Saved

1

429 views



Upload

Sign In

Join

RELATED TITLES

0







Bestsellers



Books



Audiobooks



Magazines



News



Documents



Sheet Music










Save

Embed

Share

Print


1

Download

of 16

 


 Search document




the :uture+ The Tri$una) did n't ta
Tri$una) i# n't enhan(ed $% the H'n'ura$)e High C'urt* then that @'u)d am'unt t' g inBu#ti(e t' appe))ant :ather and appe))ant min'r#+

ARGUMENTS ADVANCED IV.

T HE TRACTOR D D RIVER I I S N OT G UILT U&S 2"#, $$" A ND $$% O F IPC, 1%6

Re#p'ndent 1 i# (harged @ith #e(ti'n . ': the I"C* 1860* @hi(h de:ine# under @

(ir(um#tan(e# (an a per#'n $e )ia$)e :'r ra#h and neg)igent dri9ing + A(('rding t'

de:initi'n* 2han
&ere)% $% 9irtue ': $eing the dri9er ': the hea9% 9ehi()e d'e# n't ma
neg)igen(e+ The m't'r (%()e dri9er @a# (arr%ing  pa##enger# a# pi))i'n rider# @hi(h )e

the a((ident+ A# t' a prudent man* it# rea#'na$)e that it reuire# etra (are 'n the part '

rider @hi(h @a# ()ear)% a$#ent in the pre#ent (a#e+ It i# n't rea#'na$)e :'r the tra(t'r dri9

gr'##)% unBu#t t' the re#p'ndent#+ Thu# the dri9e i# :a)#e)% (harged @ith #e(ti'n . ': I"C* 1860+

2e(ti'n ,,. ': the I"C* 1860 ta)<# ': an a(t d'ne #' ra#h)% 'r neg)igent)% and thu# (au

hurt $% endangering )i:e 'r per#'na) #a:et% ': 'ther#* @hi(h i# n't app)i(a$)e t' the pre

(a#e in hand+ The tra(t'r dri9er @a# n't dri9ing ra#h)% and neg)igent)%* and there i Sign up to vote on this title



e9iden(e t' #upp'rt the #ame+ urden )ie# 'n the appe))ant# t' $ring 'n re('rd materi



Useful

 Not useful

e#ta$ e#ta$)i )i#h #h the the neg) neg)ig igen entt 'r ra#h ra#h dri9 dri9in ing+ g+ in the the a$#en a$#en(e (e ': an% mater materia ia)) 'n re(' re('

pre#umpti'n ': Kra#hne##L 'r Kneg)igen(eL (an $e dra@n $% in9'




Home



Saved



Bestsellers



Books



Audiobooks



Magazines



News



Documents



Sheet Music



Upload

Sign In

Join



Search



Home



Saved

1

429 views



Sign In

Upload

Join

RELATED TITLES

0







Bestsellers



Books



Audiobooks



Magazines



News



Documents



Sheet Music










Save

Embed

Share

Print


1

Download

of 16

 


 Search document




n'ne ': the #e(ti'n# that the re#p'ndent# are (harged @ith* are right)% app)ied and re#p'ndent# #h'u)d $e 9indi(ated ': the #ame+ V.

THE APPELLANT WAS L IABLE F OR N N EGLIGENCE

The ('un#e) hum$)% #u$mit# t' the ('urt that the re#p'ndent# #h'u)d n't ha9e $een

)ia$)e :'r an% neg)igen(e 'n the ('ntrar%* the appe))ant# are )ia$)e :'r the a((ident (au#ed their neg)igen(e+ 2e(ti'n 18 ': the &'t'r ehi()e ehi()e A(t #tate#  K18+ Safety measures for drivers and pillion riders. – (1) No driver of a two-wheeled two-wheeled motor motor cycle shall carry more than one person in addit himself on the motor cycle and no such person shall be carried otherwise than sitting

proper seat securely s ecurely fied to the motor cycle behind the driver!s seat with appropriate appropriate s measures.

(") #n addition to the safety measures mentioned in sub-section (1), the $entral %overnm

may, prescribe other safety measures for the drivers of two-wheeled motor cycles and pi riders thereon&.

The n'n '$edien(e ': thi# a(t ()ear)% mean# that the m't'r (%()e rider @a# neg)igent in ri

hi# $i
:r'm a di#tan(e and then he @'u)d ha9e a9'ided the a((ident+ The re#p'ndent# #h'u)d n'

he)d gui)t% ': neg)igen(e+ In 'amil Nadu State 'ransport $orporation td. v. bdul Sa

and *rs.* *rs.*- the di9i#i'n $en(h ': &adra# High C'urt had he)d that m't'r (%()e and  an% ' Sign up to vote on this title t@' @hee)er i# meant 'n)% :'r t@' per#'n#* the rider andUseful pi))i'n rider and i: m're than Not useful





per#'n# tra9e) 'n a m't'r (%()e* und'u$ted)%* und'u$ted)%* #u(h a(ti'n i: the indi9idua) @'u)d $e(





Home



Saved



Bestsellers



Books



Audiobooks



Magazines



News



Documents



Sheet Music



Upload

Sign In

Join



Search



Home



Saved

1

429 views



Upload

Sign In

Join

RELATED TITLES

0







Bestsellers



Books



Audiobooks



Magazines



News



Documents



Sheet Music










Save

Embed

Share

Print

Download


1

of 16

 


 Search document




Negligence is the omission to do something which a reasonable man, guided upon th

considerations which ordinarily regulate the conduct of human affairs, would do, or do something which a prudent and and reasonable reasonable man would not do.

The ('un#e ('un#e)) #u$mit #u$mit## that that the de(i#i' de(i#i'n n ta
neg)ig neg)igen( en(ee 'n the part part ': the re#p'n re#p'nden dent# t# @a# erred+ erred+ In a %u/arat State 0oad 'rans

$orporation v. amlaben 2al/ibhai 2ora 3 (a#e* the H'n'ura$)e 2upreme C'urt had he)d t

415. Negligence is often used in the sense of careless conduct without reference to any du

tae care. 'he use of the term in this sense has introduced some confusion into the sub

and has tended to obscure the true meaning of negligence as a part of law of tort. hen th

is a duty to tae care, the standard of care is, fre6uently, that of the reasonable man, altho

this is not always so, and conse6uently, failure to tae reasonable care and negligence

sometimes used as synonymous terms regardless regardless of whether or not there there is any duty cast&

Thu#* :'r prudent man* it i# n't p'##i$)e t' predi(t :'r a tra(t'r dri9er t' :'re#ee the a((id

He t''< a)) the rea#'na$)e (are and @a# n't neg)igent @hi)e dri9ing the tra(t'r* a)#' the n' e9iden(e t' ('unter thi#+

Furtherm're* the #tud% ('ndu(ted $% F'ren#i( #(ienti#t# and epert# a)#' #u$#tantiate

p'int that the re#p'ndent @a# n't gui)t% ': neg)igen(e+ neg)igen(e+ A(('rding A(('rding t' the rep'rt* the ('min

': the :r'nt @hee) i# a 9er% rare e9ent t' happen and thu# it @'u)d n't ha9e happened h

 n't $een :'r the a$#en(e ': maintain the m't'r (%()e ( %()e pr'per)%+ Sign up toThe vote@hee) on thishad title ('me ':: du

Not useful  Useful the ru#ting ': the $')t* 'r the #tud# ': the t%re ': the m't'r  (%()e $eing ')d+ Thu#

appe))ant# had :ai)ed t' ta




Home



Saved



Bestsellers



Books



Audiobooks



Magazines



News



Documents



Sheet Music



Upload

Sign In

Join



Search



Home



Saved

1

429 views



Upload

Sign In

Join

RELATED TITLES

0







Bestsellers



Books



Audiobooks



Magazines



News



Documents



Sheet Music










Save

Embed

Share

Print


1

Download

of 16

 


 Search document




'iwari and *rs., 9 the rider @h' @a# dri9ing @ith 'ther pi))i'n rider# @a# he)d )ia$)

neg)igen(e and thu# the ('ntri$ut'r% neg)igen(e #tated $% the Tri$una) @a# redu(ed t' .

:r'm !0?!0 pr'p'rti'n+ In T+O+ Anth'n% 9+ ;ar9a9nan and Or#+ 8* it @a# he)d that @her

inBured inBured i# him#e): part)% )ia$)e* the prin(ip)e ': M('mp'#ite M('mp'#ite neg)igen(e neg)igen(e @i)) @i)) n't app)% 'r

there $e an aut'mati( in:eren(e that neg)igen(e @a# !0?!0+ In the in#tant (a#e* the neg)ige attri$uted $% the Tri$una) @a# !0?!0 'n the pre#umpti'n mere)% that the re#p'ndent

neg)igent @hi)e dri9ing+ There:'re* the ('ntri$ut'r% neg)igen(e attri$uted t' the re#p'nd #h'u)d $e redu(ed* i: n't #et a#ide $% the H'n'ura$)e C'urt+

In ;anti e9i 2i
&adh%a "rade#h that #e(ti'n 18 ': the &'t'r ehi()e A(t $ar# riding ': m're than

pi))i'n rider 'n the m't'r (%()e and in that (a#e the rider @h' @a# dri9ing teh m't'r (%( 9i')a 9i')ati ti'n 'n ': the the pr'9 pr'9i# i#i' i'n# n# ': #e(ti #e(ti'n 'n 18 18 ': the the a(t @a# @a# he)d he)d gui) gui)t% t% ': ('nt ('ntri ri neg)igen(e+ A# pr'p'unded $% i#('unt ir
K7pon the whole # thin the 6uestion of contributory negligence must be dealt with somew

broadly and upon common-sense principles as a /ury would probably deal with it. nd w

no doubt, where a clear line can be drawn, the subse6uent negligence is the only on

looto, there are cases in which the two acts come so closely together, and the second a

negligence is so much mied up with the state of things brought about by the first act, tha

 party secondly negligent, while not held free from blame...might on the other Sign up to vote on this title hand invoe

Useful so Notto useful  as prior negligence as being part of the cause of the  collision mae it a cas

contribution.L contribution.L





Home



Saved



Bestsellers



Books



Audiobooks



Magazines



News



Documents



Sheet Music



Upload

Sign In

Join



Search



Home



Saved

1

429 views



Sign In

Upload

Join

RELATED TITLES

0







Bestsellers



Books



Audiobooks



Magazines



News



Documents



Sheet Music










Save

Embed

Share

Print


1

Download

of 16

 


 Search document




In the in#tant (a#e* e9en i: @e ('n#ider that ('ntri$ut'r% neg)igen(e (an $e attri$uta$)e t'

re#p'ndent#* then the ('mpen#ati'n a@arded $% the tri$una) #h'u)d $e #et a#ide $% H'n'ura$)e High C'urt and the am'unt #h'u)d $e :urther redu(ed+

The prin(ip)e ': ('ntri$ut'r% ('ntri$ut'r% neg)igen(e ha# a)#' $een re('gnied re('gnied $% the C'urt# in Ind

=an/ula 8evi +huta v. nr. v. =an/usri 0aha and *rs +11 A di9i#i'n $en(h ': the &a

"rade#h had he)d that it i# n'@ @e)) #ett)ed that in (a#e ': ('ntri$ut'r% neg)igen(e* ('

ha9e p'@er# t' app'rti'n the )'## $et@een the partie# a# #eem# t' it Bu#t and euita$)e*

app'rti'nment in that ('ntet mean# that damage# are redu(ed t' #u(h an etent a# the C

thin<# Bu#t and euita$)e ha9ing regard t' the ()aim #hared in the re#p'n#i$i)it% :'r damage+ damage+

There: There:'re* 're* in the pre#ent pre#ent (a#e* (a#e* the H'n'ura H'n'ura$)e $)e High C'urt #h'u)d #h'u)d redu(e

('mpen#ati'n a# it deem# :it :'r Bu#ti(e* i: n't den% it+

VI.

T HE C OMPENSATION AWARDED S HOULD B E SET ASIDE

It i# hum$)% put t' the H'n'ura$)e C'urt that the ('mpen#ati'n a@arded $% the tri$una) #h'u)d $e (an(e))ed $% the C'urt due t' it# unBu#t nature+ The ('un#e) had #tated 9ari'u# rea#'n# pr'9ing that there @a# n' neg)igen(e 'n the part ': the re#p'ndent# and 'n the

('ntrar%* the appe))ant# a)'ne are re#p'n#i$)e :'r the a((ident (au#ed+ Thu# there i# n' #up :'r the ('mpen#ati'n t' $e uphe)d $% the C'urt+

Furtherm're* the ('mpen#ati'n a@arded t' the appe))ant daughter and #'n i# n't Bu#ti:ia$)

a))+ The ('un#e) #u$mit# that the parameter# #et $% the tri$una) are n't ()ear* the appe))ant daughter and #'n* aged 1, and a nd 10 re#pe(ti9e)%* are n't earning mem$er#* and thu#the Sign up to vote on this title

('mpen#ati'n a@arded t' them i# 9er% )arge and i# n't pr'p'rti'nate at a))+ The #um ':



Useful

 Not useful

..*6. ('mpen#ated t' the daughter i# n't rea#'na$)e and #h'u)d $e denied upright $% th





Home



Saved



Bestsellers



Books



Audiobooks



Magazines



News



Documents



Sheet Music



Upload

Sign In

Join



Search



Home



Saved

429 views

1



Upload

Sign In

Join

RELATED TITLES

0







Bestsellers



Books



Audiobooks



Magazines



News



Documents



Sheet Music










Save

Embed

Share

Print

Download


1

of 16

 


 Search document







Useful

 Not useful







Home



Saved



Bestsellers



Books



Audiobooks



Magazines



News



Documents



Sheet Music



Upload

Sign In

Join



Search



Home



Saved

1

429 views



Sign In

Upload

Join

RELATED TITLES

0







Bestsellers



Books



Audiobooks



Magazines



News



Documents



Sheet Music










Save

Embed

Share

Print


1

Download

of 16

 


 Search document



PRAYER

herefore, herefore, in light of the facts presented, issues raised, arguments arguments advanced, author

cited, counsels on behalf of 0espondents humbly pray before this ;on!ble $ourt to in declare and ad/udge that : 1

There There had $een $een n' neg) neg)ige igen(e n(e 'n 'n the part part ': ': the Re#p Re#p'nd 'ndent ent**



The tria) tria) ('ur ('urtt erred erred in granti granting ng ('mp ('mpen#a en#ati' ti'n n t' Appe Appe))an ))ant* t*

,

"ut a #ta% #ta% 'n the Budgem Budgement ent ': the the Tri$una ri$una)+ )+

nd pass any other order which this ;on!ble $ourt $ourt may deem fit in the light of /ustice, e6 and good conscience.

nd for this act of indness of your lordship lordship the petitioner shall be duty bound as as ever pra

=C'un#e) :'r the Re#p'nd




Useful

 Not useful







Home



Saved



Bestsellers



Books



Audiobooks



Magazines



News



Documents



Sheet Music



Upload

Sign In

Join

Memorandum on Behalf of Respondent Ilnu

Recommend Documents