Kritik Modern is Me Habernas & Nasr

c c




c c    c   c c

c 
cc

c
c c c
c c c

c c c!c c"
c
#
c $%%&%%&%%'& c 
c(c c c

) c (c *+ c, c- *)c c c

c

.c 
#

c.c/0c-
c1c'%&&2c .c%$$1'$%3324c .c&'41&'0c"
5.c%$$1'$&0&3'c !66
7
.
.
7.cc1cc
c!c
7

8

9
.
7.cc c

c c

p
 


8c c

cSang Illahi Robbic
c

c

c
c
c

1 

c 
c 
c  

c 


c :c 
c 
c 
#
c 
c 

c 

c 
c 
c 7

c 

c )c 
c 
c ;
cNabi Muhammad SAW:c

c


c
c
c
c
c
c<

c
.c

c


ccc 

cc

c :c 

c 
c c

c
c  c c 
.c


c c 


c 

c 8
c c 
c 
c
c 
c 
c 
c 
c 
c

c 

c

c
c c 

c

c 


c #

c 
c 

c 



c
c c 

c 
c
:c


c

c


c

c
cc
cc

cc
c
c=c

:c

c


:c

cc


c
c

c
c 

c 
:c 

c 

c 

c 
c c
c 

c 
c c 
8
:c

c
c


.c c

c
cc7

c

c
c
.c Wasalamua¶laikum wr.bb. c c (
8:ccc$%&&c c c c

c

           

&c c

,

c-

c


c

>c7

cc

c
c

cRositive:c
c

c


c 

c 

c 

c 
c #
c
c 
1
c 8
:c
c 

c 

c 

c 
c 

.c c 
:c

c
c c 

c c 

c 
c

c
c 

c

c c 

c

1

c ?
@:c

c c 
c

c
c 

c 

c c

c 
c 

c c c 
c

c 

.c

c 
c 
c >c 7

c c
c

c
c

c
c

cA7


c

B1 
cc
c

c

c8

c
c
1
c8
.c

c
c 
c:c

c
c
c
8c

c>.c 
c 1&0c 

c

c
c 

c 
c c 

c >:c
c
cc

c

c

cc
cc

.c c 

c:c c 

c8

c

c -

:c 
cc 


c 
#
c

c 1&0c 

c 
c >:c
c

c
c 

c c 

c
c

c 
c 
c 
c
c

c
c c c 

c .c

>c 

c


c 
c 

c 
c 
:c 
c 


c


c
c 
c 
c 

c 

c 
c
c c 
c 
c 

.c >c 8
c 7c 

c 
c

1&0c
c c 
c c c 7
c 

:c 

c 

c
c 
c 
c 

.c 
c c
c 
c 
c >c c 7

c 

c 8
c 
c 

c 
c .c 

c
c 
c 8>
c c c 
c .c >c 8
c 


c 

c 
c 
:c
c 

c 

c c 
c 8

c

c

c

c8c

.c 
c >c 


c 
#
c c 
c 
c 
c 
c ?value free@c

c7
c8>
c
.cccc

c
c  c c 
c c 


c 
c >c:c
c
c 
c c 8c c 

c c 
c c
c 

c 

c c
c 
1
.c

c 



c c 

c 8c

c 
c 

c 
c ?value loaded@:c

cc

c


c
c

c
.c


c


c yc -



c c 
:c 

c 
c c
c 



c 7
c


cc

c
c
c

cCc yc -



c 


c 
c c


c

c 
c 
c 
c Cc

$c c

yc -



c

c
c
ccCc yc -



c
c
c
ccCc



cc
c 

c 

c cc


c
c 8
c c 


c 
c .c
c 
c c >c 

c
c 

c


c 
c
c 
1

11


c 
.c 
c c c 

c 
c 
:c

c c


c 7
7
17
7
c c
c
c
c 

c

1

c
c8
c

c :c 
c 
c c

c 
c  c c 
c 

c 


c
.c


 c  c
 c


c c
 

   c c   c   cc  

c c c
c c
cc)
c &.c >c

c
c


c

7c
c
c 
c 
c 

7c 

c c 
c 

c >
c
c 
c
c 
c 
7

c 

c 


c 
c 

c

c 

c 
c 

.c 

c c 



c 
c c 

c

c 
c 

c
c 

c 
c 8.c 
c 
c

7c c7c
c
c

cc
c
.c 
c 
c 

c 1c 8
c 

c 

7c 
c 

c 8


c ;
c 
c 
#.c c 

7c


c 
ccc
c 

cc

c
1

c

c
c


c 
#c 
c 7c 

c 

c 
c
c 
c 8

:c 

c 

c

c
c

c
c
.c 

7c c c 
c 
c
c 

c c 

c

c;

c
c
1
cc
#:c

c
c c)8
c
c

c
8

c
c
cc
c
cc 
c 
.c >c 
c

c 
c
c c 
c 

c 
c c 8
c c 

c 

c 

:c c 
c c 
c c 
:c 

7c c 

c 
c c 
c
c 




cc

c
c



ccc
.c

3c c

$.c 
c?7

@c 
c


c 8

c 
c 
c 

.c c 
c 

c?
8
@c

c
c
cc-

.c


:c
c
c 

c

c7c

c
c 

c

c
c
c

c

c c

c.cc 

c

c
c7c


c

1&Dc
c

c1&4.c
c 1&Dc 

c 

c c 

c 

c 
c 

c 
c 

c 


c 
#c 
c 
c
c 


c 
c 

:c 
c 
c 
.c
c
c

c1&4c
c

c
c

c
cc c 7

c c ?
c 
c 

1

c
c 
c

@c 

c 

c
c

:c 
c c 

c 

:c 



:c 
c :c 
c :c


:c 
8

c 
c 
c 
c 
c 


.c 
c 
c 
c 
c c 

c 

c 

c c 7

c
c 

c

c 
8
.cc 3.c c

c
c "
c 7

c ?
@c c 
c 
c 
#
c c (
c 
c ?&2//1&D$4@:c ).E.c ,
'c c



c
c:c
c
c8#
.c
c

c
cc 
c
c8

c
c
c

c
cc
c
c
c

c 
c c c 8.c "

c c 
c 
c 
c 

c
c

c 


c 
#
c
c c

c c 

c 

c


c 
c 
:c 

c 
c 



c 
c 

c
c c 8
c 

c

c


ccc
cc

:c.c 
c c 
c 
8
c c 
c
5c
c 
c 
c 
c

c 
c c 
c "
7.c
5c 
c 
c 

c c 
c 

c 

c "
7.c
5c 
c 

c 

c 
c 

c

.c

c
c8
c#
8

c
c
cc 

c 


c 
c 

#c 
c c 

c 

.c 

c
5c 
c 

c
c 

c 

c 
c .c "

c
5c 8

ccc

cc
c
c
c
c
5.c '.c )

c>c>c )

c c 

c c c ,

c E
c ?Wiener Kreis, Vienna Circle@c
c 
8

1
8

c c 
c 
c

c c #
.c )

c c c c >:c>c c

c c .c


c 
c 
c c 
c >:c c c 
c 
c .c


c 
c


c 

c

c 
c c 
8
c
c 


c
c 

c

c
#:c

c
c
c
c
c


c
1
c
c
c


c
c
c

c
c


.c /.c


<
c"
c
c
5c


<
c "
c ?÷ie Frankfurter Schule@c 

c c 8
c c 
8

c
c 8
c 

c Institut fur <
7c ?,

c


c 
@.c 


c

c c c 
c 

c
5c 

c 



c 8
c

c 

c c 
.c 

c 
c


c


cc

cc
c

cc)
7c
c &0$0.c

c 
c 
c 

c c
c 
c 
c 
c
5.cc (c 

c c


c 
#
c 
c 
c 

c 
c 
c c 

c 
c 
c
c 

.c 
c c 
c 



c 
c 
c c 

c c 

c 1c 

c 
c 

.c c c

/c c

c
1 c
c
cc 
c?
@c &.c c
1c 8
c
#
c8

c
:c 
c


c

c
cc:cc 
c
c c 
c :c 
c 
c 
c 
c 
c 
c 

c c 

c 
c
c
c 

.c 
c 
c 



c 
c
c 8c 

c 

c
c 
c c 
c  
.c

c 

c <
c 
c 
c 

c <
c 
c
>c 
c 
1

c

c
c7c
8
:c
c
cc

c:c 

c
c


c
c
c
c

c



cc
c
c 1
c 7
c c 


c 

c 
c
c 
c 


1 .c 
c c 
c 8
c 
#

c
c 
c c c 
c 8
cc 
.c $.c c
c c 
c c 
c 

c 

c .c c 
c

c 1/c 6c &&c c

c 
c 
c 
c 
c 

c

c 1Dc 6c &3c c
c 

c
cc
c 
c 
c

c
.c

c c 
c F
8
c 
c 
c 8
c 
c c 

c 
:c 
c 
c 
c
c
cFc8
c
c
8

c

c
c.c"

c 
c

c
c
c

cc
c
c
c7

c
cc 

1

c 

c
c 
8

c c >
1>
c c 
.c

c 


cc
c 7ccRausyan Fikrc
c7
ccc 
c

c 
.c c c 

c 

c c


c
c >c
c


cAalimcc8
c>c

c
c&0D41 &0D0.c 3.c 
<

c"

c
cc 
c?
@c "

c 
c 

c 

c 

c 


c 

c

c 
1 >
c


cc>
.c '.c c /.c ,

c

c
c
c 
c c c
c  c c 
c 

c c 
c 
c 

c 

c Dc c &033.c 
c 

c 
c 

c 

c 
c 

c 

c 
c  B
c 

:c
c 

c 

c 
c c 
.c 
c 

c 
c c c 
c 
c 

c 

c


c 

c ? 
c
>@c 
c

c

.c

c
cc
c7

c

c 
c c 
c7

c

c
c
.c

2c c


.c



1

c
8
c

cc
cccc
cccc
8
cc
cccccc

cc c c 
:c c 
c c c c 
c c 

c c c c 
.c c 
cc 

cccc7

c
c
c
.c 
c

c
c 

c
c


:c

c
c


.c

c
c

c 

c c c 


c 
.c 
c c c


c 
c 8
c c c 
8
c c 

c

c 


c 
c c c c Fc c
cc 
c c 

c c 



ƒc c 
8
c 

:c c 
c 

#.c c 
cc 8
cccc
8

cc
cc


cc
1F
cc
cc
cc
ccc


c
.c c c +

c c 
c c

c c c c 
c c 8
c c 
c c
cc 8

c 
c 

c 
c 
1
c 
c 
c 
c 

c c 
c c c 7c c #:c #c  c c 

c 
c &0/%.c 
c 
8
c c c

7c c c c cc 7 cc? @.cc cccc
cccc
ccc
cc 
c c 1c c 
c c 
c c 


c c c c c c 
#
c 
cc -
cccc
cc
cc

cc
cccc.cc
cc

c c

c
c

c.cc 
cccc
cc-
cc:cc
cc8
cccc
cc 
c c
c 

c 

c )c c 


.c
c 
c c 
c 

c 

c 
c 
c 

c 
c 

c :c 
c
c 
c 
c 

. 
c c 

c c 
c c 
cc 



cccc:cc

cc
cc .c
cccc
cc8
cc 

c c 
c c 
1
c c 

c c c c :c 



cc
c c 

c c 
c c


c c 
c c "8c c 7c c 
c 
.cc
cccc8
cc

cc
cc
cccc):cc.cc .c(

#
 :cc-7
:c,c
c
c
c,.cc



cc
cc&0/2cc
cc
cc
cc
cc
cccc cc

cc 
c c c
c c c c 

c c 
.c -c c 
c c 
c c 
cc 


:c c 
c c 7


c c c 
c 
c 8

c c 

c
c
8
c
cc
>
c*> .cc

c c  c c 

c c 
c c c c c c )c c 
.cc 
cc
ccc
cccc
cc
:cc)cc
cc
cc 
:c c 
c c 
c 


c c 
c c 
c c c c 
c c 
cc :c c
c c -
c c (:c
c c )c c 
c c
 c c E.cc 
cccc
cc
cc8ccG(7cc
cc
7cHc
c 
c 

c c
>
c *> c c 

c c 
c c &02'cc

Dc c


c c 8c c Gc 7c c 
7c (7
c 7H.c 
cc 

cc 
cc cc 
cc 

cc
cc  cc cc 7cc? . @cc 

c
c
c7c
c
c$/c
c

c

c
c&0/4.cc .c



c
c


c 


c 
8

c c 
c 
:c 
8
c 
c 
8
cc*>
c
c
c8
cc8

c
c
c"

cc >
c .c 
c 8
c 8
c 
c 

c
c 8

c c Iranian Academy of PhylosoRhy.c 
c 8
c
c c Husayniah Irsyadc 
c 

c 



c 
c 
c
c c c 
B
c 

c 
c &02D.c 
c c 
c 
c 8
c 
c 
c c American University of Beirutc 

c &02'1&02/:c 
c ,

c 
c 
c c 
8
c 1 

.c 
c 8
c 

c c 

c 
8
c 

c Pakistan PhilosoRhical Congress.



c 
c &04&c 
c 
c 
c c Gifford Lectures:c 
c

c c 
c 


c :c c 
c 7c 
c 
c 
.c

c 
c c 
c 


c 
c 
c -

c 

c c 


c 
#
c -

c
c 
#
c ?
@c 

c 
c 

c 
c 
c
c .c >c 
c c 

c c 

c 
c c c 
c 
c 
c 8
c c c 
c c George Washington Universityc 
c c c 
c 
c


c c TemRle University c 

.c cc"
cc 

1

c :c c 
c 8c 

c 
1
c
c 8
c 

c 
c

c 
c 
.c

c 
c 
c 

c 
1
c c 

c c 
c 8
c  

c 

:c c 

c c 
c 
c 7
c 
c 
c 
c 
c 
c:cc
c8c

c#
7

cc

.c .c cc c (c 


c 
8
c 



c 

c 
c 
c
c7

c
:c
c>c

c



cc
:c 

c
c

c
c

c

c



c
.cc c ;c 
c 

c c


c 
c
c
Ic 
c 

c c 

c c 7

c 
c 
c 
c 


c 

c 

.c 
c


c 
c >
:c
c 
c 

c 
c 8


c 
c 
c 



c

c

4c c



.c
c
c
#
c
c
c
c
c
c



c

c 

cc
c

c
:c
c:c

c
c1


c 
c 
c c 
c 
c 
c 
c 
c 
c c 
c
c c 

c 
.c 
c c  
c 
c 
c 


c 
:c
c
cc
cc
c

c
.c

c

c c

c

c
c

cc

c
c


c
c8

c 
cc
c .c 
c
c

c
c
c

c
c <

c
:c
c

c
ccc

c

cc#
:c
c :c <

c c
c c 
c <

c c c <

c

c 

.c 
c
c

c

c 

c
c
c 
c 

c
.c

c c 


c 
#
c c 

c c G>
Hc 
c :c
c 



c


c 

c 
c 

c 

c 

c c 

#cc

c


.c .c

c

c c c c
c

-
c

c 7c 

c c #
c 
c 


c 
c :c
cc8c
c
cE
c-8
c
c


c 

c
c
cc
c
c>
.c
c 

c
c GH:c 
c 

c GHc 
c c <

Ic 
c 
c


c
c
c
c
c

c
c
c

c 
.c c 
c 

c 

c GHc
c 
c

c


c

.c -.c c >c

>c c (c 
c
c 
c 
c 

c 
c 


c 
#c

c 

c .c c >c 

c c G>
Hc
c 

c 
#
c 
c 

c 
c 
c 

c 



c
c8c

c


c
c
c.cc 
c >c
c 
c 1c 
c 8
c 

c 

c 8c

.c

c
c


c
c

c

cc
c!c yc ccc

c

c

c

cc
c yc
c 
c 

c 
c
c 
c 8
c c 
c yc 1c
c
c
c.c c &.c >c

c


c

c

0c c



c c >c

c 

c 
8
c c
c 
c c
<
c "
c
c 

c 
.c 
c 
cc >c
c
c

c

c

c

c1c

c

c1 c 
.c 

c 

c c 
c 
c 
c 

c 

c c

c
c .c c c 
c #

c c 

c 
c 
!c &.c #
c 
c c c 

c :c $.c 
c  
c 


c 

c c 
#
c c 
c 
c c 
 

c 
c 
c 
c 8c
c 

.c >c 
c 
c c
c


c

c
c
c
c

.c $.c >c

c


c
c 
c c >c 

c 
c 


c 
c 

:c
c
c

c
c
c

c
c



Ic
#
c

c
c

c
c
.c
c

c>c
c#

c
1
c 

c 
c 

c 
c 

c 
c 

c 
c 

c

c 
8
.c 
c 
c c 
c 

c 
#
c 
c 
c 
c
#
c
cc8
c
cc7

c
.c (.c c8>
c c &.c 8>
c

ccc

c c

c 8>
c 

c c 

c 
c cc

c>c cc

c
c


c
c c
c c

c 
c 

c
c 

c c 
.c 

c 8>c 

c c 

c c

c 


c 

cc
c
5:c

c
c
:cc

c
c 
c 

c 

c 8
c 

c 8c
c 
:c
c 
c 8c
c 

c c c 8c .c

c 
c c c 
c >c 
c 7

c 5c c 
c c c 

cc.c 

c 7c
c c  c

c 7

ccc

cc
cc

.c $.c 8>
c

cc c c
c 8>
c
c 

c 

c 
1
c 
c 
c 
c
c 

c 

c 

c 
c 
c 
c 

c 

c 
c 


c c 
.c 8c 

c 
c 
c 
c 
c c 8c c

c >c ?

c @.c 
c 

c 


c >c


c 
c
c 
c c c 

:c 

c c 
c
c 

c c 

c 
c
c
c

c

cc

c
c
cc7

cc

&%c c

c


:c 
c 7

c G8Hc 


c 
c

.c c 
c 
c 
c c
1
.c .c 
c 

c

c
c
c



c 
c 
c 

c 
#
c c
c 
c 
c 

c c c 7
7
17
7
c
c 

c
c 

c 
:c 

c 
c  
c 

c 7
7
c 

c c 
c 8
:c 
c 
c 
c  

c 1c
c 7c 

c
ccc.c

c
c
c

c
#
cc 
c 

c c 
c >c 
c 


c 

c 
c 

c

c
cc8>
.cc

ccc

cc
c
c 8
#
c c 
c :c 

c 
c c c 8
c 
c
c
c

c.c




c
c

c
c
c

cc:c >:c8>
c


c
!c c 

c 
c c 
c 
:c 
8:c :c 
:c 
c 
c 

:c 

c 
c 

c 8
c 
.c



c 
c c 

c c #
c :c
c


c 

c 
c <

c c c

c 

c 
c

c :c 


c

c 


c 
c 

c 

c 
c 
c 8
c 

c 8
c 

c
c 
.c 

c c

c
cc7

c

c
c
cc
:c

c 7c c 1.c 
c 

c c 

c c
c 

c <

c

c 

c 

c

.c



c 
c 
c 

c c 

c c 
c 

c 

c
c

c

c

c

.c .c >:c 

c 
c (c 
c 
c
c 

:c 
:c 
c 
c .c >c 

c 8>
c 

c 

c 

c 
#.c c

c >c


c


c 

c 

c 1c

c 

c1c
.c
c 
c >c 
c c 

c 

c 
:c >c c c Ac 

c 
c
c


c 
c 
c 
c c 

.c


c
c

c
c

c
c

.c 7.c 8>
:c c >c 8>
c


c 

c 
c 8c ?
c 
c :c @:c 

c 

c 
c 
c 
.c c

c 
c 
c 8>
c
c 

c 

c 
c
c c 
8
c 
c

c 
c
c

c
c 
c 
c 
ccc

c
8
.c


.c

&&c c

c-

c 
cc c

.c



c 

c c c 
c 
8
c 
c 
c 
c c c 
<
c "
:c c c 8
c 
c c 
c
5:c 

c 
c 
:c 
c 8
c 
c
c
.c



c

cc

cc

c
c7

!c 1c 1c 1

.c 
c 1c
c 
#
c 
c 
c
7
c ?


@c c 
c c 

c

1

c
c c
c8c1
.c 1c 1c 1.c 
7c 

c 
c  :c
c c
c 

c 7
c 

c ?Sinneverstehen@c 
c 
c 8

c 

c
c c >
c [email protected] 
c 
c c 7

c c

c 
c 
c 7

c
c 

c c 

c.c 1c 1c .c c 

c c
c c c
<
c "
c
c 

c c c 
c
c 

c 
c 
c
c

c
c?
8@c
c1.c c

cc
c 
c
5c c 

c 

c 8

.c

c 

c 
#
c 8

c 
c 
c ?
@c


c

c 

c 

.c
c c
5c c

c


c 8
c

c c 
c 
c

c 


c c 

c

.c



c 
c 
c 8
c Ec 
#
c c 
1
:c 
c 

c c 


1
c
c 
c c 

#c 

c

c


c
:c
c
c
.c c c

c


c 

c
c 

c 
c c
c
c
c
c  c c
c c
c
c

c


c
c


c
c?
@c
c 
c

c
1
c
c
c
c
c
c
cc
c 
c c

c

c
.cc
c
c
c

c
.
c 

ccc
c7

c
8
c
cc

c
c
c 
c c 
c
c 

c c 
c  
:c 
c 
c 
c c 
c c 
c 
c 

c 
c c 

c 
c 
c 
c 

c 
c 

c 

c

&$c c


7
c
c
cc
c

c

cc?
@.c
c

c c 
c 

c c 
c 


c 
c 
c c 

.c 
c"
c 
cc c

c !c 

.c &.c


c





c 
c 
c c c


c



c
c



c
c

c
8c
c8:c
!c 1c 

c :c
c 

c 8
c c
c

c 7

:c 

cc7

c8
cc
c
.c 1c 

c
>:c
c

c
c


c

c
c
c 
:c
c8
c
c

c
c
c.c 1c 

c 
7:c
c 

c
c 

c 
c 8
c 

cimagecc

c

c


c.c 1c 

c 
:c
c 

c 
c
c 
1 

c 
c 
c 
c
c 
c 

c7
c 
c 
:c
c 

c c 
c

c
c 
c 7

c >
c 
c >
.c 
c


c 
c 

c 7

c 


.c $.c cc 

c c c 

c
c 
c

c 
c 
c 
c c c
c 

c c 

c 
c 

c 
c 

:c 
c 
c 
c 
c 1
c
c 
7
c c 
c 
c
c 
.c



c 

c 
c 7
7
c
c

c 

c c 
c c cc
c
c

.c  c c 
c !c 

c &.c


c



c 
c 
c c c


c

c 
c

c 

c 

c c 
c c 
c


c 

c khalifah ?#
@c 
c c c 
c 

c
1
.c 
c c 

c 

c 

1
c 
c 
:c
c

c #
c
c 
c
c
.c
c


c
#
c

ccc?A
J@c
c

&3c c


c?
6
@.c



c 
c?
c
@c


c



c
c
c
c
c

.c $.c cc

c c c 

c 8
c 8
c c 

c 

c 

c 
c 
c 
c

.c 


c 

c c c 


c 

c 
#
c 

c 

c 

c 
c 

c 
c

c


c
c
c

.c




c

1 

c

c 
c

c 
c 
c 

c 


c
c 
c
:c 

c 

c 

c 

c ?c 

c @c
c c >.c

c c 

c
c 
c

c 

c c

c
c

c#

c
c

c.c c

c

 c c
c

cc

c

cc

c


c 

c 
c 
c 
c 

c 
c ?
c 
c 
@c

c 

c 7

c 
c c
c 

c !c 
1
c


c



c 

c 7

c 
c 

c


c
c
c
1
c



c c
c 

c !c 
1c



c

c 

!c 

c 
c c 

c !c #
 c
c 

c
c
c 


c

cc
c c 

c !c ?1

@c c 

c !c 

c 

c 
c c ?
@c 

c 

c
c

c
c :c.c
c
c
c 
!c 

c 

c 
c !c 

c 

c 
c


c

cc 
cc

c
c 


c 8c 

c 
c 


c c 

c 
c 8

c 8

c 


c 
1
c 

c 
1c

c
c8

c 
c8

c

&'c c




c 

1 

c 

c 8

c 8

c


c 
c
c*>
c
c
c
c

.c

cc
c 7
c c
c 
c >.c 

c c 

c 
c c c 
c 
c 8
c 
c 

c
c 


c

c

c.c c

&/c c