The flm opens to a young woman (Gabriela Oltean) recklessly driving a BMW down a mountain highway highway !"er !"er bei being ng hit by two trucks trucks## she dies (this (this whole whole ordea ordeall is inter interspe spers rsed ed throug throughou houtt the movie) movie) $ohn %uincy !rchibald (&en'el Washington) and his wie &enise (imberly *lise) witness their young son Michael (&aniel * +mith) collapse at his baseball game !"er a series o tests at the hospital# $ohn is ino inormed rmed by &r &r ,aymo ,aymond nd Turner urner ($ames ($ames Woods) oods) and ,ebecca ,ebecca -ayne -ayne (!nne (!nne .eche) .eche)## a hospit hospital al administrator# that Michael has an enlarged heart and will need a transplant .owever because the company he works or dropped $ohn rom ull/0me to part/0me# his health insurance has been changed and the new policy does not cover the surgery# leaving them to raise 123 (456#222) o the 4762#222 in order to get their son8s name on the donor list The amily tries to raise the money but are only able to come up with a third o the necessary payment *ventually the hospital gets 0red o wai0ng and decides to release Michael# leading &enise to tell $ohn to 9do something9 :nwilling to let his child die# $ohn walks into the hospital *, with a handgun# gathers hostages# and sets demands; his son8s name on the recipient list as soon as possible The hostage nego0ator#
let
$ohn
cool
o>
Meanwhile# $ohn and the ?? hostages communicate and learn more about each other They begin to understand $ohn8s situa0on and support him a li@le as he ensures each o them receive the treatment they came to the emergency room or One o them# Miriam (Troy Beyer)# is pregnant# and her husband +teve (Troy Winbush) is hoping that their frst kid is healthy ! young hostage# $ulie (.eather WahlAuist)# has a broken arm# and she and her boyriend Mitch (+hawn .atosy) claim that a car crash caused it# but due to some holes in their story $ohn and another hostage#
the
two
are
lying
and
that
Mitch
had
actually
beat
$ulie
up
!"er a while $ohn agrees to release some hostages in return or his son8s name being on the list an hour a"erward .e releases +teve# Miriam and a hostage named ,osa (Martha Chaves) with her baby The Chicago Chie o -olice# Gus Monroe (,ay
agree
to
his
demand
in
eDchange
or
th e
+W!T
sniper
Once his son arrives# $ohn reveals to the hostages his inten0on to commit suicide so his heart can be used to save his son .e persuades &r Turner to perorm the opera0on# and two o his hostages bear witness to a will sta0ng his last reAuest $ohn goes to say his last good/byes to Michael and goes to the opera0ng room .e loads a single bullet into the gun and pulls the trigger but the saety is on !s he holds the gun to his own head a second 0me and prepares to end his lie# his wie is told about a woman killed in a car crash# the one rom the opening scene# who happens to have the same blood type as Michael# and has been Eown to the hospital or organ recovery +he runs to the emergency room and
stops $ohn rom shoo0ng himsel# and $ohn allows the hostages to go ree Michael is given the lie/ saving opera0on and# a"er watching the procedure with &enise# $ohn is taken into police custody !t his trial# all o the witnesses speak on his behal .e is later acAui@ed o charges o a@empted murder and armed criminal ac0on but is ound guilty o kidnapping Ft is never revealed what his sentence or the crime will be but his lawyer is overheard saying that no udge will give him 9more than three to fve (years)9 and that she will try and get it dropped to two ,eac0on paper The movie 9$ohn %9 was beau0ul H great Ft8s all about the rela0onship o 9ather H son9 or 9parent H child9 This movie shows how important our loved are to us $ohn % did everything H would do anything to save his son# and he did Because o despera0on he decided to hostage a hospital which is illegal in the movie you know that $ohn did8nt know anything about hostaging !nd bacause he8s a kind person# he cared or all the hostages Fn the end# he decided to sacrifce his own lieF can relate to the story# story# because F know my ather will do anything or me Many people do oolish things because o wrong decisions Because people o"en make rush decisions based on the situa0on they are at# but they soon regret that decision
and
fnd
that
what
they
did
was
wrong
Based on what F watched# $ohn % hostaged innocent people because o despera0on .e asked the governmen governmentt to help him save his son# but they didnIt give him any considera considera0on 0on Because i they did# many would imitate $ohn %# H the percentage o crime in their country would increase even though he only wanted to save his son Mickey# it was s0ll against the lawWe know that JmoneyK makes the world go round# but money canIt buy everything Money can even ruin our lives i donIt use or his son because there was no more 0me le" But luck came through H s0ll they ound a donor This shows how a person would do anything or his loved ones i was sad at the end because they ound him guilty i was really hoping that they would be a happy amily again The story was very inspiring F8d salute H admire the man who would do anything to save his loved ones F don8t know i it8s a real story or not but F salute the director or direc0ng such a great movie F would be happy to watch the movie againLF can relate to the story# story# because F know my ather will do anything or me Many people do oolish things because o wrong decisions Because people o"en make rush decisions based on the situa0on they are at# but they soon regret
that
decision
and
fnd
that
what
they
did
was
wrong
Based on what F watched# $ohn % hostaged innocent people because o despera0on .e asked the governmen governmentt to help him save his son# but they didnIt give him any considera considera0on 0on Because i they did# many would imitate $ohn %# H the percentage o crime in their country would increase even though he only
wanted
to
save
his
son
Mickey#
it
was
s0ll
against
th e
law
We know that JmoneyK makes the world go round# but money canIt buy everything Money can even ruin our lives i donIt use correctly
john Q Analysis: Ethical & Moral Moral Dilemmas
Updated on December 26, 2015
John Q shows all sorts of moral questions
Introduction This moie shamelessl! deliers a potent tale of parental loe and sacrifice smothered b! a deafenin" cacophon! of ethical dilemma# $ach ma%or character confronts e&cruciatin" decisions an d must appeal to a code of morals in order to %ustif! his or her actions# 'arel! are these choices clear cut and somethin" precious must be sacrificed in each outcome# The father and prota"onist, John (rchibald )pla!ed b! Den*el +ashin"ton +ashin"ton traerses throu"h the the most e&in" moral quandaries, pittin" his oerwhelmin" dut! as a parent a"ainst the -"reater "ood- for societ!# This moie came out in 2002 and continues to cause us to question what is ri"ht ri "ht and what is wron"# John (rchibald.s e&le ma/es us wonder what we would do in the situation and what is trul! important to us# +e learn how difficult it is to %ud"e the moralit! of the actions of others#
John does whateer it ta/es to sae his son
Role as a father (s a father, father, John has a moral obli"ation to do do all that he can for the welfare welfare of his son# Dut! demands that he proide a better life for i/e than he had for himself# John, a hristian man, understands this and does his best to secure enou"h hours at his plant p lant in order to adequatel! proide for his famil!# e dries i/e to school, isits his little lea"ue baseball "ames, and does his best to support him emotionall! and financiall!# Those needs are drasticall! increased when i/e.s medical condition is discoered3 howeer, John.s deontolo"ical imperatie remains the same4 to loe, support, and ta/e care of his son# n this respect, John responds ethicall! to his moral responsibilities# e ta/es no thou"ht to consequence and proceeds with moties drien purel! b! filial obli"ation# e alues his role as a parent and the sanctit! of human life aboe all else# is selfless decision to donate his heart to his son demonstrates that he een alues this aboe a -ri"ht- to one.s or"ans# This decision is the onl! rational )and subsequentl! condonable action under these circumstances# (s deontolo"! necessitates, actions and laws must be uniersall! applicable# (ll adherents must be willin" to both "ie and receie# John required no less from others than he was willin" to "ie#
Utilitarianism Viewpoin Viewpointt John.s actions affected much more than %ust i/e, howeer# Utilitarianism requires indiiduals to ma/e choices that will proide the "reatest amount of "ood or pleasure for the "reatest number of people# There is no feasible wa! for John (rchibald and his famil! to eer pa! enou"h ta&es on his limited income or enou"h in insurance premiums to close to coerin" the necessar! costs for i/e.s procedure# t would be un%ust for them to receie a treatment that the! had not paid for for## urthermore,
the 7250,000 allocated from the priate health care facilit!.s funds certainl! could be redistributed amon" hundreds or thousands of other patients# This reallocation of limited resources could allow man! other indiiduals to receie minor procedures for free or reduced costs# The! could hire more nurses to shorten wait times or install better b etter medical technolo"!# technolo"!# rom this utilitarian iewpoint, it is un%ust and immoral for i/e.s parents to demand that he be the beneficiar! of such an e&pensie procedure when that mone! could produce more collectie happiness dispersed amon" the other patients that pass throu"h the hospital# rom this ethical standpoint, John acts irrationall! and selfishl! selfishl!## is decisions show a clear inabilit! to see -the "reater "ood-# is choices effectiel! rob the other patients of the abilit! to hae lower l ower costs, better treatment and shorter waits# The borrowed mone! from friends and nei"hbors could hae also proided much "ood in their respectie lies# is cost8benefit anal!sis also seems to ne"lect the distinct possibilit! that his son will neer return to full health#
John Q Buy Now
Conclusion Ultimatel!, John act ethicall! Ultimatel!, ethicall!## orrupt practices within the health care insurance industr! eentuall! led to the iolations of man! indiidual.s inherent ri"hts# These subtle chan"es switched the onus of these companies from beneficence to one of maleficence# This blatant disre"ard of 9ant $thics and dut! naturall! compels other rational and moral indiiduals to ta/e more e&treme measures to uphold their personal beliefs and lie in accordance to their ethical stances#
John Q; From an Ethical Standpoint As human beings, we will all experience some type of ethical dilemma sometime in our lives. Committing an act of “evil” for the sake of someone else’s well being may be one of these dilemmas we face. !he concept of an acceptable or necessary evil is one that is highly debatable. "hen is evil #usti$able% According certain ethical schools, at times the ultimate goal is independent of the means to reach it. &n such ethical schools, the evil act may be #usti$ed if it is the course taken to ultimately do something good for the bene$t of others. !he movie “'ohn “'ohn (” deals deals with the issue issue of “necessa “necessary ry evil”. !his movie )en*el "ashington stars as 'ohn (uincy Archibald, a husband and father whose son is diagnosed with an enlarged heart. !he hospital informs them that his son needs a heart transplant in order to survive. +owever, due to insucient health
insurance, the hospital refuses to put his name on the transplant list or agree to do the surgery. !herefore, he decides to take a hospital full of patients hostage until the hospital puts his son’s name on the recipient’s list. 'ohn also actually considers sacri$cing his own life in order to save is son. -ecessary evil as something that is unpleasant or undesirable but is needed to achieve a result. !his $lm deems 'ohn’s actions necessary to meet his ultimate goal. Although 'ohn’s assault on the hospital and threat to kill hostages would be considered evil, it was done with the intention of saving his son’s life. 'ohn used every other possible option, before he actually considered such an extreme measure. !herefore his choice to assault the hospital was a last resort, and was necessary to meet his goal. !his is what the textbook may consider a necessary evil. !he ethical ethical school of Conseuential Conseuentialism ism determines determines right and and wrong on the the basis of the conseuences. !his school is based on / premises0 ends are independent of the means1 “cost bene$t analysis” and right or wrong determined by conseuences. 2nder this branch of ethical theories, a “necessary evil” may or may not be #usti$ed. 3eing that the term “necessary” implies intent is to reach a commendable goal1 the actual evil act may be taken into account separate from the goal itself. &n addition, in order to look at this dilemma from a conseuential point of view, one would need to take the cost bene$t analysis into consideration. A cost bene$t analysis is done to assess the issue and determine how well, or how poorly, a planned action will turn out. A person must $nd, uantify, and add all the positive and negative factors, and base the decision on the di4erence between the two. &n 'ohn’s case, the positive factor would be saving his son’s life. !he negative factors would be #ail time or being killed in the process. 5ost parents that & know would agree that any of the above would be worth saving their child’s life. &n the movie, 'ohn was willing to give his life and his freedo freedom m in exchange for his son’s. !herefore, in his case, the positive outweighs the negative. -atural 6ights is another theory under the school of conseuentialism that would support 'ohn’s decision in the movie. -aturals rights is the belief that all human beings are endowed by their Creator 78od or nature9 with certain rights. !his is based based on the philosophy philosophy of 'ohn :ocke :ocke,, who said that we we are all all born with with the inalienable rights of life, liberty and property. &n 'ohn (’s case, the hospital had the means to save his son’s life, but chose to deny him that right because of a monetary issue. &n addition, being that this theory is teleological ethical
approach, it determines right and wrong on the basis of a goal. 'ohn (’s goal was honest and admirable, which #usti$ed his “evil act”. Although some ethical conseuentialist theories may support 'ohn (’s actions, 6ule 2tilitarianism does not. !he utilitarian ethical approach determines the action by what can produce the greatest utility. +owever rule utilitarianism maintains that we should look at the conseuences of an action in relation to particularr rules of conduct. &n order to apply this theory to a dilemma, you must particula consider how an action can a4ect the overall rules of society. &n this case, condoning 'ohn’s extremist actions would completely change the rules of society. &f this were to become okay, people would continue to wield guns and threaten hospitals every time they are denied health care. &t is true that everyone has a right to preserve life, if everyone such extreme actions against hospitals and or other medical agencies would create total chaos. &n this movie, 'ohn (’s actions are the “necessary evil” needed to not only save his son’s life, but also expose the in#ustice of this country health system. Although 'ohn’s actions may be considered evil, some would actually consider it evil for him to have done nothing, and allow his son to die. ;o, in retr retrospect, ospect, he committed the lesser of two evils. At the end of the day, sometimes we have to do unfavorable things in order to achieve a favorable. About these ads