Republic of the Philippines SUPREME COURT - En - En Banc Banc - Manila JUDGE FLORENTINO FLORENTINO V. FLORO, JR., Petitioner, Petitioner,
- versus -
G.R. NO. 202465 For: Certiorari
JUDICIAL AND BAR COUNCIL (JBC), Respondent. X------------------------------------------------------------X
VERY URGENT VERIFIED MOTIONS FOR ISSUANCE OF – I.
WRIT OF PRELIMINARY MANDATORY INJUNCTION –
A.) Directing the JBC to include in its Final Short List of Nominees only Antonio T. Carpio Carpio, 2) Maria Lourdes Aranal the following names: 1) Antonio Sereno & 3) Arturo D. Brion; & B.) Directing the JBC to conduct a Panel Inte Interv rvie iew w of Peti Petiti tion oner er [and [and to Admi Admitt the the “ Black Nazarene Nazarene (1606, Acapulco, Acapulco, Mexico)-Holy Mexico)-Holy Eucharist Eucharist (Maundy (Maundy Thursday)-Our Thursday)-Our Lady of Lourdes Lourdes (1858) / Fatima Fatima (1917) / Miraculou Miraculouss Medal (1830) (1830) / Akita (1973) (1973)” July 20, 1999-J 1999-July uly 20, 2012 2012 Dire Dire Messag Messageses-Pro Prophec phecies ies to the Filipi Filipino no Nation Nation /Judiciary-JBC-Supreme Court: “ Ave Maria: Maria: The The Most Most Holy Holy Rosary Rosary” ”], and II.
– TEMPORARY RESTRAINING ORDER –
Nomination Circus” Panel A.) To declare null and void ab initio the “ Nomination Interview conducted by JBC Members Jose V. Mejia, Maria Milagros N. Ferna Fernan-Ca n-Cayo yosa sa & Micha Michael el Freder Frederick ick Musngi Musngi upon upon their their Atene Ateneo o Law School student Cesar L. Villanueva, the 666 alter-ego of the “ David “ Davide, e, Jr., Panganiban Panganiban-Puno -Puno-Coro -Corona na Courts Courts of Moral Farce-Rule Farce-Rule of Law & Hypocrisy Hypocrisy”, ”, B.) To Direct the JBC to Strike-Out the name of Cesar L. Villanueva from the Final Short List of JBC Candidates & C.) To Exclude from the Final Short List of JBC Candidates, all the Non-Insiders, &
VERY URGENT VERIFIED MOTIONS FOR LEAVE OF COURT TO ADMIT SUPPLEMENTAL PETITION / NEW (SUPERVENING) CAUSES OF ACTIONS – To Decla clare Uncon constit stitut utiiona onal, the the Appo ppointm intmen entt and JBC JBC ParticipationsParticip ations-Votings Votings of Michael Frederick Frederic k Musngi , & B.) To Declare Petitioner eligible for future JBC Nominations-Applications (by virtue of the April 12, 2012 Final and Executory SC En Banc GRANT Resolution in A.M. RTJ-99-1460, “OCAD vs. Judge Florentino V. Floro, Jr.” ) and not to Dismiss the instant Petition for being Moot and Academic lest Dire Pains and Horrific Events Unfold upon the JBC Members (loved ones vis-à-vis Conrado J Conrado J Castro+ Castro+ & Lily Victorino+, et al.) A.)
-1-
Petitioner, Judge Florentino V. Floro, Jr. , respectfully petitions for a) Temporary Restraining Order, b) Writ of Preliminary Mandatory Injunction and c) with leave of Court, prays for admission of the following Supplemental Petition /New (Supervening) Causes of Actions.
PREFATORY
Elements 911, Element 112 & Mortis Angelus – the names of LUIS (earth), Larry (Jupiter), Judge Florentino V. Floro, Jr. (Supreme Court) & St. Michael , the the Arch Archan ange gel: l: this this is the the 12:0 12:01 1 a.m. a.m.,, 1 seco second nd afte after r th midnight (high end 2008 SONY DSC T-200 - real, Divine and virtual 7 Dimens Dimension ion)) photo photo of LUIS , the the most most powe powerf rful ul King King of king kingss of all all elementals-spirits on earth, cosmos, galaxies & Heaven, Sole Holder of the Ultimate Pink and Violet Lights “ Lux in Domino” Domino” per “Ave per “Ave Maria”, on June 3, 2012, that is, 29 years from June 3, 1983, when LUIS, Armand and Angel ( St. Michael , St. Raphael & St. Gabriel), appeared to Robert V. Floro, the youngest brother of Judge Floro during the wake of their father, Florentino C. Floro, Sr. LUIS -St. Michael did fulfil His promise:
-2-
“CODED is all caps, for when I write, the Lights of LUIS , the Ultimate Pink and Violet Lux in Domino, Domino, change the
past, present and future, “in state”. In tons of court pleadings I wrote and filed with the Court since 1999 to 2012, I repeatedly prophesied prophesied and alerted the Filipino nation-JBC-the nation-JBC-the Court, per Mind Control (by LUIS ), the destiny of earth people: the cursed July 20, 1999-July 20, 2012 – 12-13+ longest longest preventive preventive suspension suspension in history. On July 18, 2012, 2012, I told the Court that on July 20, the world shall witness the CODED curse of July 20, 1999: I am am 58 years years old; my name name is Element 112 & Elements 911 , inter alia; the Dark Knight tragedy tragedy is composed composed of these
numbers (not numerology), for, by the Light of LUIS , I did tell the world: We implement the mandate mandate of Akita, Lourdes, Lourdes, Fatima Fatima and and Mira Miracul culous ous Me Meda dall - 1973 1973 (Br. (Br. 73, 73, RTC RTC Malab Malabon) on),, 1958 1958 Lourdes, Lourdes, 1917 Fatima and November November 27 Miraculous Miraculous Medal. When Flerida Ruth-Romero wrote my suspension, it was about -3-
12:39 12:39 p.m. of July July 20, 20, 1999 1999,, that that Peter Peter got the the curs cursed ed Pink Pink Resolution Resolution and proceeded proceeded to my Malabon Malabon Sala; the Malabon Malabon Fire on July 22, 2000 vis-a-vis vis-a-vis the Oslo July July 22, 2011 massacre massacre reve reveal alss the the CODE. ODE. I only only reve reveal al this this 1% CODED DED secr secret et (meaning if you touch the Light key, like the ATM machine, the Annihilation Annihilation of the JBC, inter alia is a mystic fiat!) Unlike the Nostradamus Nostradamus quatrain which is outmoded outmoded by our most advanced ET CODED Light, inflicting inflicting of pain and dire illnesses illnesses becomes becomes an impeccable virtual reality that is unfathomable. ”
Elements 911 911 – 2 days after the filing The CODED Prophecy of Elements
of the instant instant Certiorari Petition: Petition: Stern warning upon upon the JBC 20 , 2012, a mass shootin “On July 20 shooting g occurred occurred at a Century Century movie movie theater in Aurora, Colorado , during a midnight midnight screening screening of the film The Dark Knight Knight Rises. A gunman, dressed in tactical clothing, set off tear gas grenades grenades and shot into the audience audience with multiple multiple firearms, killing killing 12 people -4-
and injuring 58 others. The sole suspect is James Eagan Holmes, who was arrested outside the cinema minutes later. The attack occurred in Theater 9 at the Century 16 multiplex.The first phone calls to emergency services via 9-1-1 were made at 12:39 a.m. July 20, 2012 12:38 a.m. (MDT) (UTC–06:00)” http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2012_Aurora_shooting
The Philippines - the JBC-Supreme Court will not be spared!
The 2012 Assam violence refers to a series of on-going violent attacks in the Indian state of Assam, which started on 20 July 2012. The violence arose from ethnic conflict between Bodos, who practice Hinduism, -5-
Bathouism Bathouism and Christi Christianity, anity, and non-Bo non-Bodo do Muslims, Muslims, primarily primarily those those migrate migrated d from Bangladesh Bangladesh in early 19th century. By 27 July 2012, 58 people had died and over 200,000 people have been displaced, from almost 400 villages, taki taking ng shel shelte terr in 150 150 relie relieff camp camps. s. Elev Eleven en perso persons ns have have been been repo report rted ed missing. On July 27, 2012, Assam's Chief Minister Tarun Gogoi blamed the nati nation onal al gove govern rnme ment nt for for "del "delay ay in army army depl deploy oyme ment nt to riotriot-hi hitt area areas". s". http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2012_Assam_violence At least 13 people are killed in clashes in Duékoué Duékoué and a camp for displace displaced d people people in in Ivory Coast. 20 July 2012 (IOL) http://www.iol.co.za/news/africa/13-dead-in-ivory-coast-clashes1.1346196#.UAnKyKO8j_k 21 people were killed and 29 others were injured in bus accident in the Mexican state of Nayarit Nayarit . 20 July 2012 (Fox News) http://latino.foxnews.com/latino/news/2012/07/20/21-dead-in-bus-crash-in-mexico/
Commissioner Vicente de Lima+, age 83, father of Justice Secretary Leila de Lima, lost his battle with colon cancer at about 2:30 p.m. on Monday, July 30, 2012. It is the same dire dreaded disease that Corazon Cojuanco Aquino direly experienced amid the Rising of Benigno Benigno Simeon Simeon Cojuanco Aquino III . At least least 42 people are killed in clashes between rebels and Tajik July 2012 012 Gorn orno government government troops in Gorno-Badak Gorno-Badakhshan hshan.. The 21 July Badakhsh Badakhshan an clashes consisted of fighting between Tajik government forces and an armed group led by Tolib Ayombekov in Tajikistan's semi-autonomous Gorno-Badakhshan province in late July 2012. The Western media described the fighting as the worst in Tajikistan since 2010 or the 1992–1997 civil war. On 21 July July 2012 2012,, Majo Majorr-Ge Gene nera rall Abdu Abdull llo o Naza Nazaro rov, v, head head of the the Tajik Tajik intelligence agency's branch in Gorno-Badakhshan, was fatally stabbed in Ishkashim Ishkashim after being dragged dragged out of his car. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2012_Gorno-Badakhshan_clashes 20 July plot 1944 : Hitler Hitler survives assassination attempt Adolf Hitler escapes escapes death after after a third third attempt attempt on his life when when a bomb explodes explodes in Rastenberg Rastenberg On 20 July 1944, an attempt attempt was made to assassinate assassinate Adolf Hitler, Hitler, Führer of the Third Reich, inside his Wolf's Lair field headquarter headquarterss near Rastenburg, East Prussia. The plot was the culmination of the efforts of several groups in the German Resistance to overthrow overthrow the Nazi-led Nazi-led German German government. government. The The failure failure of both the assassin assassination ation and and the military military coup coup d'état d'état which was planned to follow it led to the arrest of at least 7,000 people by the Gestapo. According to records of the Führer Conferences on Naval Affairs, 4,980 of these were executed, resulting in the destruction of the organised resis resista tanc ncee move moveme ment nt in Germ German anyy for for the the rema remain inde derr of Worl World d War II. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/July_20_Plot 1969 , astronaut Neil Armstrong Armstrong became the first man On July 20, 1969 astronaut Neil to walk on the moon.
-6-
On July 20, 1976 America's America's Viking 1 robot spacecraft spacecraft landed on Mars. On July 20, 1999 years at at the the bottom bottom of the the Atlantic Atlantic,, 1999- After 38 years astronaut Gus Grissom's Liberty Bell 7 Mercury capsule was recovered. Typhoon Saola Saola - On July 22, a tropical disturbance formed eastnortheast of Palau. Gener death toll at 12; 300,000 affected - By Frances Mangosing, Mangosing, INQUIRER.ne INQUIRER.nett Heavy rains brought brought by typhoon typhoon Gener has claimed 12 lives, most of them due to drowning, the National Disaster Risk Reduction Reduction and and Managem Management ent Council Council said Wednesd Wednesday. ay. http://newsinfo.inquirer.net/240625/gener-ups-death-toll-to-12-300000-affected-ndrrmc
13 years Jobless Br. 73, Judge due to Pretend JBC-world, 58 years old, 12th place, 1983 Bar Exams, 87.55%, Full Second Honors Ateneo Law School Sumpa ng 3 Duende Duende :: The The Impr Imprec ecat atio ion n unde underr Psal Psalms ms 109 109 & 73 – Sumpa
Petitioner is now age 58, jobless at 12-13 years since July 20, Colorado, Assam, Assam, p.m. unti untill the the fata fatali list stic ic July 1999, 1999, 12:39 p.m. July 20, 20, 2012 2012 Colorado, Duékoué, Duékoué, Nayarit, Nayarit, Vicente Vicente de Lima, Lima, Gorno-Bad Gorno-Badakhsh akhshan, an, Saola Saola (Gener) (Gener) 7 dire pains-tragedies-mystic Omen upon the JBC members, Judiciary &
Filipino nation . The 7 tragedies vis-à-vis 4 Regular JBC members , vis-à-vis the prior Tupas Congress fire (the Tupas-Escudero alleged JBC boycott), the DOJ sucide by a lesbian, and sealed by the 3rd Vicente dilemma (δί-λημμα) colon cancer demise point to the not uncertain remaining 3 JBC ex-officio votes that will shape the Filipino nations’ crab mentality mortals: # 7. prediction n focuses focuses on Element Element 112 of the Angel Angel of Death’s Death’s predictio Number 9 – the 9 years back wages that Petitioner moved the Court to grant (in the July 1 & October 7, 2011 & February 3, 2012 Motions – all NOTED WITHOUT ACTION ) : : Theater 9 at the Century 16 multiplex, Colorado.
INTRODUCTION
The respondent JBC disregarded Petitioner’s superiority (not only in grades, academic excellence, breed, prophecies, predictions, Lights, inter alia) alia) over most of the 22 candidates: Petitioner submitted to the JBC copies of - his Ateneo Law School School,, 1978-1 1978-198 982 2 Full Full Second Second Honor Honorss cards, cards, 1974 1974 Atene Ateneo o de Manila Manila
-7-
University Pre-Divinity TSN, grades, 1982 Ateneo Law School TSN, grades (91% Criminal Law Review grade, unbroken record for 10 years), May 7, 1984 Daily Express report on his 12th place, 1983 Bar Exams, where only 20% 20% pass passed ed as one one of the the hard hardes estt in hist histor ory, y, his his 87.55% Bar Bar Ratin Rating g Certificate ( 96% in Labor Law) issued by the OBC, SC [Copies of – the docu docume ment ntss were were atta attach ched ed as Anne Annexe xess “A-6 “A-6,, A-7” A-7” of the the Peti Petiti tion on]. ]. GmaNewsTV published the bar ratings of the following 13 candidates, who got lower bar rating grades rating grades vis-a-vis vis-a-vis Petitioner: Roberto Afan Abad Abad 81.70%, 1968 Juan Andres Andres Donato Bautista Bautista 86.90%, 1990 1990 Soledad Manteroso Manteroso Cagampang-De Cagampang-De Castro 85.52%, 1968 1968 Antonio Tirol Tirol Carpio 85.70% (6th (6th Place), 1975 1975 Teresita Leonardo Leonardo De Castro 80.90%, 1972 Leila Norma Eulalia Eulalia Josefa Magistrado De De Lima 87.0150%, 1985 1985 Jose Manuel Icasiano Diokno 1987 (rating not indicated) Maria Carolina Carolina Trinidad Legarda 84.40%, 1980 1980 Raul Cano Cano Pangalangan Pangalangan 83.80%, 1983 Rene Vergara Sarmiento 76.35%, 1978 Manuel De Jesus Siayngco 75.70%, 1986 Amado Domingo Domingo Valdez Valdez 80.65%, 1969 Ronaldo Bayan Bayan Zamora 87.3%, 1st 1st Place, 1969 1969 GROUNDS
The applicant-Petitioner is entitled to the reliefs demanded, and the whole or part of such reliefs consists in restraining the commission or cont contin inua uanc ncee of the the act act or acts acts comp compla lain ined ed of, of, or in requ requir irin ing g the the performan performance ce of an act or acts, acts, either either for for a limited limited period period or perpetu perpetually; ally; that the the comm commis issi sion on,, cont contin inua uanc ncee or nonnon-pe perf rfor orma manc ncee of the the act act or acts acts -8-
complained of during the litigation would probably work injustice to the appl applic ican ant; t; and and that that the the resp respon onde dent nt JBC JBC is doin doing, g, thre threat aten enin ing, g, or is attempting to do, or is procuring or suffering to be done, some act or acts probably probably in violation violation of the rights rights of the applicant applicant respect respecting ing the subject subject of the action or proceeding, and tending to render the judgment ineffectual. The matter is of extreme urgency and the applicant will suffer grave injustice and irreparable injury, hence, he prays that a temporary restraining order be granted and issued forthwith, under Rule 58, in relation to Rule 65 of the Revised Revised Rules of Court, Court, since the instant instant Petition Petition and application in the action or proceeding show facts entitling the Petitioner to the relief demand demanded; ed; it is prayed that that because because Petitioner Petitioner is jobless, jobless, he be exempted by the Court, from paying/filing, a bond executed to the party or person person enjoined, enjoined, the JBC; it clearly clearly appears appears from facts shown shown by the verified application-Petition that great or irreparable injury would result to the applicant before the matter can be heard on notice; hence, Petitioner prays that the court should should issue an ex parte temporary restraining order and preliminary mandatory injunction against the respondent Judicial and Bar Council. Chief Justice Artemio Panganiban, in this regard, wrote: “Criticizing the JBC. Never in its 25-year history has the JBC been more challenged challenged than now to prove that the council council system works, that applicants applicants will be interviewed interviewed assiduously assiduously but not rudely, scrutinized thoroughly but not brusquely, and screened minutely but not abrasively. For too long, critics have attacked the JBC for its alleged leniency in its selection process, allowing some not-too-qualified Palace favorites favorites to be nominated and eventually eventually appointed without without passing the straight straight and narrow gauntlet, gauntlet, thereby thereby contributin contributing g to the supposed deterioration in the dispensation of justice and in the quality of the magistracy itself. Many have gone gone to the the extreme extreme of proposing proposing the abolition abolition of of the JBC and a return to the old way of the President appointing directly the members of the judiciary, and of the Commission on Appointmen Appointments ts (CA) confirming confirming the appointees. appointees. Precisely, Precisely, the JBC was instituted in the new Constitution at the instance of the revered Chief Chief Justice Justice Roberto Roberto Concepcio Concepcion n to elevat elevatee the qualit qualityy of the judiciary, judiciary, to preserve preserve its dignity, dignity, and to shield it from political political shenanigans shenanigans that at times characterize characterize the circus-like circus-like CA confirmation process.” -9-
http://opinion.inquirer.net/33087/transparent-accountable-andhttp://opinion.inquirer.net/33087/transpa rent-accountable-anddignified With Due Respect Transparent, accountable and dignified By: Artemio Artemio V. Panganiba Panganiban n Philippi Philippine ne Daily Daily Inquirer Inquirer Saturday, Saturday, July 21st, 2012
NEW (SUPERVENING) CAUSES OF ACTIONS
I.
It is unthinkable, horrific and ominous, that a St. Peter the Apostle Lay Minister, Regino C. Hermosisima, Jr. (who repeatedly, Sundays, since 1999, would hold, distribute and eat the Body & Blood of Christ in the Holy Eucharist) should, just because of a deleted (by the SC En Banc April 12, 2011 Resolution) Resolution) 2006 P 40,000 40,000 gross ignorance ignorance of law fine throw in the waste can all the a) “on bended knees” knees ” JBC J BC Applications-Nominations Applications-Nominations of Petitioner, including the b) Verified Request to Publish on TV at the Panel Intervie Interview w the Marian-E Marian-Euchar ucharist-B ist-Black lack Nazarene Nazarene dire Messag MessageeProphecy of the Most Holy Rosary to the Filipino nation-Judiciary-JBC. Mark my word, he will regret it!
1. At 3:22 p.m., July 20, 2012, Petitioner filed with the JBC, his Verified Opposition to the Nominations of 1.) Cesar L. Villanueva, 2.) Reti Retire red d Malo Malolo loss City City RTC RTC Judg Judgee Manu Manuel el Siayn Siaynco co (Man (Manue uell de Jesu Jesuss Siayngco), 3.) Amado Amado D. Valdez, 4.) Vicente R. R. Velasquez, Velasquez, and 5.) Maria Carolina T. Legarda. Copy of page 1 of the JBC Opposition is attached at Annex AA hereof.
2. Petitioner informed JBC Executive Executive officer Atty. Atty. Annaliza S. Ty-Capacite of the former’s Decision to file f ile OBC Disbarment cases against her, Atty. Richard O. Pascual , JBC Acting Chief of Office and JBC Member Maria Milagros N. Fernan-Cayosa on legal and Constitutional grounds. Petitioner accused both of gross incompetence, inter alia, alia, specifically, for including in the JBC Long List, an immoral (Lawyer, a philanderer, etc.) candidate for Chief Justice, (adjudged by final Judgment of the Court), Judge Manuel DJ Siaynco, resulting in this sick man’s without shame, facing facing the nation nation (in the televi televised sed Panel Panel Intervi Interview ew). ). Capaci Capacite te told told the Petitioner that she failed to review the candidate’s cases due to tons of papers papers that that she reviews reviews daily. daily. - 10 -
In this regard, Petitioner demanded that Capacite should rese reserv rvee a seat seat for for Peti Petiti tion oner er in the the sche schedu dule led d July July 24-2 24-27, 7, 2012 2012 Pane Panell Interview. Capacite refused, citing 2 JBC media guidelines and public stubs first-come-first basis seating arrangement rules. But Petitioner contradicted her, citing previous seating rules of the JBC in interviews regarding parties, candidates, litigants and oppositors, inter alia. alia . Petitioner informed Capacite that her subordinate Atty. Richard O. Pascual referred Petitioner to her on the matter. Before the interview of Justice Arturo D. Brion (July 25, Wednesday), Petitioner asked the JBC staff, Carolina L. Ramos that, as Petitioner-Oppositor, the latter should be allowed to enter the Interview room room.. But But Atty Atty.. Rich Richar ard d inst instru ruct cted ed her her and and the the guar guards ds not not to allo allow w Petitioner to enter the Interview room upon order of Capacite. Hence, under protest, protest, Petitioner Petitioner was given a blue stub or pass with number number 46. Due to repeated demands, Petitioner waited, waited and waited, until Capacite and her co-conspirator Atty. Richard instructed the security officer to give the stub 41 to Petitioner. But only 1-40 stubs would be allowed to enter the room. Hence, a certain Harold, a security guard gave Petitioner stub 40 and thus allowed the entrance to the room. On July 26, Thursday, despite repeated demands, again, Petitioner was not allowed enter the interview room, since Atty. Richard stated that Capacite instructed him to implement the first-come-first basis rule. The media howerver, allowed Petitioner to speak. Petitioner told the TV reporters that Atty. Capacite, Atty. Richard and Cayosa would face a disbarment case due to gross incompetence, as proved by an evidence: a letter duly signed by her where she wrote: “ xxx “ xxx if they so desires.” desires.” Copy of her JBC letter with the very poor grammar, is attached as Annex BB hereof. Hence, Petitioner was not able to view part of Justice “ Tess” Tess” De Castro Interview and stood still for more than hour, until a lady surrendered her stub 19, and thus, Petitioner got the stub and entered the interview room (in exchange of stub 43). - 11 -
JBC Long List Candidate, Manuel De Jesus Siayngco (75.70%, 1986), with withou outt sham shame, e, spre spread ad lies lies on TV, TV, dece deceiv ived ed the the Filip Filipin ino o nati nation on and and ridiculed the Supreme Court of the Philppines per his supreme act of hypocrisy, even bringing his wife, just to collect his retirement benefits. 3. During the interview, Manuel De Jesus Siayngco, Presiding Judge, Regional Trial Court – Bulacan (June 1, 2001 to December 31, 2011) deceived the JBC-Court, thusly: a) Siayngco stated that he opted to retire since he failed in 6 attempts to be pro promote moted d to the the CA-S CA-San andi diga ganb nbay ayan an;; but but the the fact fact is that that,, this this philandere philandererr Judge Judge was denied denied by the JBC, JBC, for, for, according according to him, he he faced faced 6 administrative charges, hence disqualified under JBC -009; b) He openly openly admitted admitted his marital marital infidelity infidelity and and even even did pressu pressure re his wife to agree upon his immoral relations with a lady Fiscal of Malolos City, to have have a child child,, sinc sincee her her spou spouse se is ster sterile ile;; thus thus,, his his wife wife alle allege gedl dly y threatened to file Rule 140 and disbarment cases against him to prevent him from sharing his retirement benefits to his Kerida, the lady Fiscal. c) After his retirement, he was forced to live li ve with his wife because of the 2004 Justice Nazario SC dismissal of his annulment case; he brought his wife to the JBC interview to prevent her from interfering with Atty. Lilian Co’s processing of his retirement moneys. He has a plan to live with the Kerida after release of the retirement pay and leave his wife forever and ever, as he did before, during the annulment proceedings. proceedings. 4. At the gates of the Court, Atty. Capacite told Petitioner to explain why the latter talked to media about her wrong grammar-letter and to-b to-bee-fil filed ed comp compla lain intt agai agains nstt her. her. Peti Petiti tion oner er told told Capa Capaci cite te that that she she conspired with Atty. Richard to prevent Petitioner from attending the JBC interviews interviews to silence silence Petitioner Petitioner regarding her profession professional al indiscretio indiscretion, n, gross misconduct, gross incompetence and disregard of the Constitution, JBCJBC-00 009 9 and and R.A. R.A. 6713 6713,, incl includ udin ing g the the Code Code of Cond Conduc uctt for for Cour Courtt Personnel vis-à-vis flagrant violation of R.A. 3019, inter alia. - 12 -
II.
3 JBC members conducted a moro-moro (farce so to speak, shameful), nomination circus and unconstitutional Panel Interview of their favorite curs cursed ed Aten Ateneo eo Law Law Scho School ol teac teache herr Cesa Cesarr L. Villa Villanu nuev evaa (Tax (Taxat atio ion n II classmate of Petitioner). Villanueva is the cruelest lawyer that Ateneo ever manufactured. A heartless non-Ignatian Material Material Soprano, Soprano, Cesar is daydreaming to lead the Judiciary per his insane, idealist, perfectionist and most hated mind, corazon and bren-damage. bren-damage . Ano ka sinuswerte. E hindi ka nga nakakuha ni isang perang mutang Boto ng JBC at SC nung nagaply ka sa SC Associate Justice, ngayon, nababaliw kanaba? If Villanueva should receive even 1 JBC vote, does this Court know know that that his audi audien ence ce and and back backer erss (the (the almo almost st disb disbar arre red d Atty Atty.. Pete Pete Princi Principe pe and other other crab crab mental mentality ity Law Law Deans, Deans, whom whom Petitio Petitioner ner faced faced during the Interview) are conduits of Petitioner’s arch enemies VACCDante Jimenez & the insane, demented and cursed Lauro Visconde (who, like Cesar L. Villanueva, did throw in the waste basket Petitioner’s 2000 on bended bended knees pleas for help, job, trabaho trabaho and letter to the most hated Davide, Jr. Court to decide Judge Floro’s duende case)? Does this Court comprehend how Villanueva, who was, is and will be a tool of Corona, the conduit of Jimenez-Visconde, would exact vengeance upon any and all of those Magistrates, lawyers and litigants who were allegedly behind the fall of the Mighty Spinea Corona? The Prophet of prophet, Petitoner Judge Floro cites the dire warning from California, USA: “THE JUDICIAL AND BAR Council’s interview of the 20 nominees to the Chief Justice position was going so well into the fourth and and last day day when suddenly suddenly it it hit a snag that that could trigger trigger a constitutional crisis in the Judiciary. Indeed, in a matter of days, the orderly selection process went into a tailspin when the two
- 13 -
leaders of Congress – Senate President Juan Ponce Enrile and Speaker Feliciano Belmonte Jr. – announced that they’re pulling their representatives out of the Judicial Bar Council (JBC) due to a Supreme Court decision, which ruled that the bicameral legislative body can only have one representative in JBC. As a result, the JBC postponed postponed voting for the final three nominees nominees to August August 7. The postponemen postponementt gave Justice Justice Secretary Secretary Leila Leila de Lima who who is running running against against time to have three disbarment cases against her dismissed dismissed before the JBC votes on the shortlist. But she suffered a major blow last July 28 when the Board of Directors of the Integrated Bar of the Philippines (IBP) rejected her bid to have the cases against her dismissed. De Lima’s Lima’s problem problem As soon as IBP rejected rejected De Lima’s appeal, appeal, Malacañan Malacañang g Palace gave her some encouraging encouraging support. support. During a press briefin briefing, g, preside presidenti ntial al spokes spokesman man Edwin Edwin Lacier Lacierda da said that that De Lima has has “right “right to appeal appeal to the Judicial Judicial and and Bar Council Council should should it exclude her from the chief justice candidate shortlist.” “She is just layi laying ng out out the the basis basis why why this this disb disbar arme ment nt case case shoul should d not not be considered by the JBC considering that they were filed in the light of her opposition to the removed Chief Justice Corona”. Enrile’s dilemma dilemma In another front, front, the Philippine Philippine Senate, Senate, things things are different different over there. Senate President Enrile called for a caucus last July 30 to discuss their position on the JBC composition and other issues relative to the selection process. Ghosts from the past In the 25 years that the present Constitution has been in place, there were two major constitutional constitutional crises. The first was in
- 14 -
2001 when then Vice President Gloria Macapagal Arroyo was sworn in as President President by then Chief Justice Hilario Hilario Davide Davide Jr. while Joseph Estrada was still the sitting President. To fix the loom loomin ing g cons consti titu tuti tion onal al cris crisis is,, the the Supr Suprem emee Cour Courtt issu issued ed its its cont contro rove versi rsial al “cons “constru truct ctiv ivee resig resigna nati tion on” ” rulin ruling g that that deem deemed ed Estrada resigned resigned from office. office. The second second was was in 2010 when when Gloria Gloria appo appoin inte ted d Renat Renato o Coro Corona na as Chie Chieff Justi Justice ce in defi defian ance ce of the the constit constituti utiona onall ban on “midnig “midnight” ht” appoin appointme tments nts during during a short short period of time before and after a presidentia presidentiall election. election. The Supreme Court legitimized Corona’s illegal appointment by ruling that that appo appoin inti tin ng the the Chie Chieff Just Justic icee was was not not cove covere red d by the the constitutional ban. Both crises took a heavy toll on the government and caused political instability for more than a decade, which culminated with the impeachment of Corona last May. Now that the government is recovering from those contentious years, it’s time for our political leaders to do what is right for the country and let the the Supr Suprem emee Cour Courtt perf perfor orm m its cons consti titu tuti tion onal al mand mandat atee to produce the shortlist shortlist in a fashion fashion that is fair, transparent, transparent, and objective. The people deserve no less.(
[email protected]) Constitutional or man-made crisis? By Perry Diaz (California) Wednesday, August 01, 2012 http://www.mindanaoexaminer.com/news.php?news_id=20120801005021
During the Interview of Cesar L. Villanueva, the Filipino nation witnessed as Petitioner did, how JBC Members MMM or Musngi, Mejia and Milagros shamefully acknowledged (and even vigorously smiled before before TV) that Villanuev Villanuevaa was their cutest cutest professor, professor, with a high pitch Soprano golden voice. “ I got 89%, Sir.!”, remarked Mejia to Villanueva, while Musngi giggled and Cayosa almost jumped with laughter. “ Ito “ Ito ang tinatawag na Nomination Circus or moro-moro, farce so to speak, the most corrupt JBC selection process, ever. E, titser pala nila ito, ano ang
- 15 -
laban laban ng mga mga Kand Kandida idato to sa kaniy kaniya, a, dapat dapat,,
nag-d nag-dis isqua qualif lifyy silan silang g
MMM!”, MMM!”, shouted LUIS , the Angel of Death. “Part of the problem may be that the nomination process has been opened and liberally made public. It is enjoying full media coverage, as did Corona’s impeachment and trial (in fact, Corona’s impeachment and trial could have triggered as well the the inte intens nsee publ public ic inte intere rest st in the the proc proces esss of sele select ctin ing g his his repla replacem cemen ent). t). Me Media dia cove coverag ragee has has been been blam blamed ed for for copy copyca cat t crimes, and to some extent, we’re seeing a variation of this in the selecti selection on proces process, s, with crackpo crackpots ts nominat nominating ing themse themselves lves despite their obvious lack of fitness for the job. For example, among the nominees is former Malabon Regional Trial Court Judge Florentino Floro Jr ., ., who was sacked by the Supreme
Cour Courtt in 2006. 006. He had adm admitte itted d to, to, amon among g othe otherr thin things gs,, consu consulti lting ng dwar dwarfs fs in decid decidin ing g case cases. s. Calli Calling ng hims himself elf “Chi “Chief ef Justice of the Universe,” Universe,” Floro personally personally submitted submitted his 45 page application application to the Judicial Judicial and Bar Council Council (JBC), attaching pictures of individuals as well as names of several other other pers persons ons who who have have purpo purporte rtedly dly witne witness ssed ed “the “the mysti mysticc divine lights in Judge Floro’s 2 palm-eyes.” Declared Floro: “The court will never rise again except upon appointment of a chief justice who is anointed by Christ through Ave Maria.” Apparently, the JBC policy is not only full transparency but also “letting a hundred Floros bloom.” It has also released to the the medi media a the the appl applica icatio tion n of one one Anton Antonio io Villa Villamo mor, r, who who reportedly was nominated through an e-mail sent by a certain “Leonardo da Vinci.” The nominations may provide comic relief to otherwise serious business, business, but the search for the top magistrate magistrate of the land is no laughing matter. Back when the list was “just” 50,
- 16 -
3
Sen. Joker Arroyo had observed that “[t]his bid to be chief justice is getting to be ridiculous,” ridiculous,” with “every Tom, Dick and Harry” wanting the position. Quite right. Many of the nominees nominees are ambu ambulan lance-c ce-chas haser ers. s. Some Some of them them have have even even claim claimed ed to reporters reporters that they had “the edge.” Opinion Editorial Nomination circus Philippine Daily Inquirer Monday, July 2nd, 2012
http://opinion.inquirer.net/31 http://opinion.inquirer.net/31877/nomination-circus 877/nomination-circus
CONCLUSION
Petitioner observed the demeanor of Justice “ Tess” who told Justice Peralta, that she prays. LUIS , St. Michael, the Archangel is holding the Kris (flaming sword) in front of her, the 7 JBC members and the 14 other SC Justices, 24/7. Upon appointment and assumption to Office of the next/24 th Chief Justice, Petitioner will formally submit the photos of the 9 Choirs of Angels, the 6 other Archangels and the unnmamed Genesis-Revelation Archangels and Seraphims, inter alia, alia , to the New Court-Chief Justice. Naubos nap o ang luha ng Mahal na Birhen, dahil, bilang Ina ng Awa, Awa, her childr children en are perse persecut cuted ed,, punish punished ed and contin continuou uously sly tempted-mind controlled by the 666 and its instruments who were allowed to rule the Court and the nation for many years. Petitioner was ordered by the Most High to show the Lights in his eyes and palms to Mary’s children and in exchange, they have to pray the Most Holy Rosary lest the gates of Darkness swallow these poor sinners. Since May 4, 2012, Petitioner obeyed the mandate to photograph these Angels, because Our Lady is so desperate. The Serpent at her feet, as
- 17 -
Miraculous Medal is now leading the Court, the respondent JBC and the Filipino nation, including the Filipino journalists, j ournalists, lawyers and Judges. The cursed Davide, Jr., Panganiban, Puno & Corona Courts of Injustice threw in the garbage can Petitioner’s multiple Marian-Eucharist Nazarene Nazarene EnthronementEnthronement-Cons Consecrat ecrationion-Chape Chapell Motions Motions from 2007 to 2012 (the last junked Marian-Eucharist-Nazarene Plea is the 131-page Motion of February 3, 2012, NOTED WITHOUT ACTION ACTION on February 14, 2012, as ruled by the heartless Corona Court). The next Chief Justice must lead in the formal MarianEucharist-Nazarene Consecraton rites which should be officiated by the highest Cardinal or Archbishop inside the new Adoracion Chapel (that must be created, beside the SC Session hall that LUIS , St. Michael did burn on Puno’s 1st conference day as CJ on January 16, 2007); and the Act must be approved approved in Heaven, Heaven, as it was done in Russia’s Russia’s formal formal consecratio consecration: n: nais ni Maria at ng Nazareno na magkaroon ng tahanan sa Puso ng Corte Suprema (the Tabernacle of Filipino Justice), where the Holy Rosary should be prayed daily – the only true, Divine, mystic and just Judicial Reform that none of the 22 candidates ever proposed to most corrupt JBC members, since 1988. Amen+ http://ufojf.blogspot.com// http://ufojf.blogspot.com
27 Jupiter-Venus-Mars Jupiter-Venus-Mars Aliens-
Archangels-Angels & UFOs: LUIS, Armand & Angel http://nazarenejfloro.blogspot.com/ Download: 92 pages - Florentino Floro, Black Nazarene, Virgin Mary, May 21, 2012
http://www.scribd.com/doc/942 http://www.scribd.com/doc/94269779/Ave69779/Ave-Maria Maria http://jfvfhealers.blogspot.com/
Judge Judge Florentin Florentino o V. Floro, Floro, Jr., Petitioner, Cel. # 0915-5330008, c/o Benjamin Benjamin V. Floro Floro, #23 Saluysoy, Meycauayan, 3020 BULACAN, Tel. # (044) 840-817 - 18 -
Relief PREMISES PREMISES CONSIDER CONSIDERED, ED, it is respectfully prayed to this Honorable Court, that the instant –
VERY URGENT PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI & VERY URGENT VERIFIED MOTIONS FOR ISSUANCE OF –
WRIT OF PRELIMINARY MANDATORY INJUNCTION – A.) Directing the JBC to include in its Final Short List of Nominees only the following names: 1) Antonio Antonio T. Carpio Carpio, 2) Maria Lourdes Aranal Sereno & 3) Arturo D. Brion; & B.) Directing the JBC to conduct a Panel Inte Interv rvie iew w of Peti Petiti tion oner er [and [and to Admi Admitt the the “ Black Nazarene Nazarene (1606, Acapulco, Acapulco, Mexico)-Holy Mexico)-Holy Eucharist Eucharist (Maundy (Maundy Thursday)-Our Thursday)-Our Lady of Lourdes Lourdes (1858) / Fatima Fatima (1917) / Miraculou Miraculouss Medal (1830) (1830) / Akita (1973) (1973)” July 20, 1999-J 1999-July uly 20, 2012 2012 Dire Dire Messag Messageses-Pro Prophec phecies ies to the Filipi Filipino no Nation Nation /Judiciary-JBC-Supreme Court: “ Ave Maria: Maria: The The Most Most Holy Holy Rosary Rosary” ”], and
TEMPORARY RESTRAINING ORDER – Nomination Circus” Panel A.) To declare null and void ab initio the “ Nomination Interview conducted by JBC Members Jose V. Mejia, Maria Milagros N. Ferna Fernan-Ca n-Cayo yosa sa & Micha Michael el Freder Frederick ick Musngi Musngi upon upon their their Atene Ateneo o Law School student Cesar L. Villanueva, the 666 alter-ego of the “ David “ Davide, e, Jr., Panganiban Panganiban-Puno -Puno-Coro -Corona na Courts Courts of Moral Farce-Rule Farce-Rule of Law & Hypocrisy Hypocrisy”, ”, B.) To Direct the JBC to Strike-Out the name of Cesar L. Villanueva from the Final Short List of JBC Candidates & C.) To Exclude from the Final Short List of JBC Candidates, all the Non-Insiders, &
VERY URGENT VERIFIED MOTIONS FOR LEAVE OF COURT TO ADMIT SUPPLEMENTAL PETITION / NEW (SUPERVENING) CAUSES OF ACTIONS – To Decla clare Uncon constit stitut utiiona onal, the the Appo ppointm intmen entt and JBC JBC ParticipationsParticip ations-Votings Votings of Michael Frederick Frederic k Musngi , & B.) To Declare Petitioner eligible for future JBC Nominations-Applications (by virtue of the April 12, 2012 Final and Executory SC En Banc GRANT Resolution in A.M. RTJ-99-1460, “OCAD vs. Judge Florentino V. Floro, Jr.” ) and not to Dismiss the instant Petition for being Moot and Academic lest Dire Pains and Horrific Events Unfold upon the JBC Members (loved ones vis-à-vis Conrado J Conrado J Castro+ Castro+ & Lily Victorino+, et al.) B.)
--- be given DUE given DUE COURSE COURSE , duly NOTED and GRANTED. - 19 -
The Clerk of Court should furnish copies of all pleadings, Judgments, Resolutions and papers, etc. to: Judge Judge Florentin Florentino o V. Floro, Floro, Jr., Petitioner, Cel. # 0915-8308816, Benjamin V. V. Floro Floro, #23 Saluysoy, Meycauayan, c/o Benjamin 3020 BULACAN.
Other reliefs and remedies, just and equitable under the circumstances are likewise prayed for, including but not limited to the following: 1) To require JBC Member Maria Milagros N. FernanCayosa & Executive Officer, Annaliza S. Ty-Capacite, to explain, why they included in the JBC Long List of 22 Chief Justice Candidates, a SC adjudged (by final annulment annulment 2004 SC Judgment), Judgment), retired Malolos City
shackled shackled ”-sick man-psychotic and a sex RTC Judge Manuel Siaynco (“ pervert-philanderer “who “who endured and suffered through his turbulent and loveless marriage to his wife for twenty-two (22) years ”, in G.R. NO. 158896
Octob October er 27, 27, 2004 2004 JUANI JUANITA TA CARATI CARATING-S NG-SIAY IAYNGC NGCO, O, petit petition ioner, er, vs. MANUEL SIAYNGCO, respondent. CHICO-NAZARIO, J.).
IN WITNESS WITNESS WHEREOF WHEREOF , I signed this Pleading, this
First
Friday, August 3, 2012, at Malolos City, 3000 Bulacan, Philippines for
Manila, Metro Manila.
Judge Judge Florentin Florentino o V. Floro, Floro, Jr., Petitioner, Cel. # 0915-8308816, Benjamin V. Floro Floro, #23 Saluysoy, Meycauayan, 3020 BULACAN, c/o Benjamin [I.D. Number: RTCJ-317 / EDP Number: 38676300; ROLL OF ATTORNEY’S NO. 32800, Pg. No. 60, Book No. XIV].
- 20 -
Urgent NOTICE (Request for Agendum)
TO: Atty. Enriqueta Enriqueta Esguera Vidal, Clerk Clerk of Court, Court, En Banc, Banc, (Tel. No. 5236558, 524-9560) , 524-9560) , Supreme Court, En Court, En Banc, Banc, Manila: Please AGENDUM forthwith this pleading and submit it immediately to the Supreme Court, En Banc, Banc, upon upon receip receiptt hereof, hereof, for for its deliberation and resolution, since time is of the essence, and considering the urgency, importance and landmark nature of the matter.
JUDGE JUDGE FLORE FLORENTIN NTINO O V. FLORO FLORO,, JR., JR., Petitioner Petitioner
VERIFICATION REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES ) Malolos City, BULACAN ) S.S. I, Judge Florentino V. Floro, Jr., petitioner, under oath, depose/say, that: I am the petitioner-movant in this case. I caused the preparation, signed and read the instant pleading, and all the contents/allegations thereof are true and correct of my own personal knowledge knowledge or based based on authentic authentic records. records.
Judge Judge FLOREN FLORENTINO TINO V. FLORO, FLORO, JR. JR. SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN to before me, on this First Friday the 3rd of August, 2012, here at Malolos City, Bulacan, affiant exhibited to me his CTC NO. CC12005 # 21783592, issued at Malolos, Bulacan, on 2-27, 20011.
BERNAR D. FAJARDO Notary Notary Public, Until Jan.31, 2012, PTR NO. 7960111, 12- 28’11, Atty.’s Roll No. 33633, IBP OR # 852362, 1-2,’12 MCLE COMP. III-0019636, 12- 21-‘10 2nd Floor, or, BPSTA Bldg., dg., Provinc vinciial Compound, Malolos City, Bulacan, (044) 6625335 Celp. # 0906-9669792, Secretary
DOC. NO. BOOK NO.
, PAGE NO. , , SERIES OF 2012.
- 21 -
COPY FURNISHED-SERVED: FURNISHED-SERVED: By Personal Service: Judicial and Bar Council, the Chairman, the Members, Members, and Ex-Offico Ex-Offico Secretary, through the Secretariat, Secretariat, 2nd Floor, Centennial Bldg., Supreme Court, Padre Faura, Manila Philippines 1000 (Email:
[email protected] [email protected] Phone No.: (02) 552-9512 552-9512 / 552-9608 552-9608 Fax No.: No.: (02) 552-9607) 552-9607).. ***The
By Register Registered ed Mail Mail with Return Card: Card: Explana Explanation tion:: Due to lack of messenger, and impracticality, service of copies of this pleading was made by registered mail with return card upon herein parties: ***Office of the Solicitor General Francis Jardaleza, 134 Amorsolo St. Legaspi Village, Makati City Tel. Nos. 818-6381 Fax Nos. 817-6037 Email:
[email protected]
Original of the Registry Receipt is attached above, in the Original of the Petition, while the xerox of the Registry Receipts is attached with the copies of the Petition. REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES ) City of Malolos, Bulacan ) S.S. AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE I, Judge Florentino Floro, Petitioner, with residence, and mailing address at c/o Benjamin V. Floro, #23 Saluysoy, Meycauayan City, 3020 Bulacan, after being duly sworn, depose and say: That on August 3, 2012, I served copies of the petition with annexes of the following pleading/paper by personal personal service in accordance with Rule 13, inter alia, of the Revised Rules of Court, by delivering personally a copy to the party or JBC secretariat, by leaving it in its office with his clerk or with a person having charge thereof, as evidenced by the rubber stamp mark of the office herewith. Nature of Pleading/Paper Certiorari Case, G.R. No. ___________, “ Judge Florent Florentino ino V. Floro, Floro, Jr. Jr. vs. JBC JBC ”. ”.
The addressees are as follows: By Personal Service: The Judicial and Bar Council, the Chairman, the Members, and Ex-Offico Secretary, through the Secretariat, 2nd Floor, Centennial Bldg., Supreme Court, Padre Faura, Manila Philippines 1000 (Email:
[email protected] [email protected] iary.gov.ph ov.ph jbc87supreme jbc87supremecourt court@gmai @gmail.com l.com Phone No.: (02) 5529512 / 552-9608 Fax No.: (02) 552-9607). 552-9607). Chair Justice DIOSDADO M. PERALTA Hon. LEILA M. DE LIMA Hon. FRANCIS JOSEPH G. ESCUDERO Hon. NIEL C. TUPAS JR. Hon. JOSE MIDAS P. MARQUEZ Hon. ENRIQUETA ESGUERRA VIDAL
Hon. REGINO C. HERMOSISIMA JR.
Hon. JOSE V. MEJIA Hon. AURORA SANTIAGO LAGMAN
- 22 -
Hon. MARIA MILAGROS N. FERNAN-CAYOSA FERNAN-CAYOSA
c/o The JBC Secretariat: Atty. ANNALIZA S. TY-CAPACITE, BC Executive Officer
That on August 2, 2012, I served copy of the petition with annexes of the following pleading/paper by depositing the copy of the petition with annexes in the Greenhills, San Sa n Juan, post office, in sealed envelope, plainly addressed to the party or its counsels at its office, with postage fully pre-paid, and with instructions instructions to the postmaster to return the mail to the sender after ten (l0) days if undelivered, as evidenced by the registry receipts attached herewith. Certiorari Case, G.R. No. ___________, “ Judge Florent Florentino ino V. Floro, Floro, Jr. Jr. vs. JBC JBC ”. ”. Due to lack lack of mess messen enge ger, r, and and By Regis Register tered ed Mail Mail with with Return Return Card: Card: Explan Explanati ation: on: Due impracticality, service of copy of this pleading with annexes was made by registered mail with return card upon herein:
Office of the Solicitor General Francis Jardaleza, 134 Amorsolo St. Legaspi Village, 1229 Makati City Tel. Nos. 818-6381 Fax Nos. 817-6037 Email:
[email protected]
Original of the Registry Receipt is attached above, in the Original of the Petition, while the xerox of the Registry Receipts is attached with the copies of the Petition. Judge Judge FLOREN FLORENTINO TINO V. FLORO, FLORO, JR., JR., affiant SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN to before me, on this 3rd, August, 2012, here at Malolos City, Bulacan, affiant exhibited to me his CTC NO. CC12005 # 21783592, issued at Malolos, Bulacan, on 2-27, 2011. BERNAR D. FAJARDO Notary Public, Public, Until Jan.31, 2012, PTR NO. 7960111, 12- 28’11, Atty.’s Roll No. 33633, IBP OR # 852362, 1-2,’12 MCLE COMP. III-0019636, 12- 21-‘10 2nd Floor, BPSTA Bldg., Provincial Compound Compound,, Malolos Malolos City, City, Bulacan, Bulacan, (044) (044) 662-5335 662-5335 Celp. # 0906-9669792, Secretary
DOC. NO. , PAGE NO. , BOOK NO. , SERIES OF 2012.
- 23 -
Download this document: 24 pages Certiorari Motions for TRO, etc.
http://www.scribd.com/doc/101722432/jbcaug3jf ***** Download this document: 68-page - VERY URGENT PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI http://www.scribd.com/doc/100285825 http://www.scribd.com/doc/10028582 http://www.scribd.com/doc/100285825/Certiorari-Petition-Judge-Florentino5/Certiorari-Petition-Judge-FlorentinoFloro-July-18-2012 http://en.calameo.com/books/001207381a92f87f9b70c http://en.calameo.com/read/001207381a92f87f9b70c ***** References Download: 97 pages - Florentino Floro, Black Nazarene, Virgin Mary, June 12, 2012 http://www.scribd.com/doc/96791797 http://en.calameo.com/books/00120 http://en.calameo.com/books/001207381f1c679af6621 7381f1c679af6621 ***** http://www.flickr.com/photos/79584531@N04/ http://www.flickr.com/photos/79262015@N07/ http://www.flickr.com/photos/79442122@N06/ ***** http://ufojf.blogspot.com/ 27 Jupite Jupiter-Ve r-Venus nus-Ma -Mars rs Alien Aliens-A s-Arch rchang angels els & UFOs: UFOs: LUIS, LUIS, Armand Armand & Angel http://nazarenejfloro.blogspot.com/ http://jfvfhealers.blogspot.com/
Attys. Francisco Francisco I. I. Chavez Chavez , Don Carlo R. Ybanez, Neil Jerome A. Rapatan, Carl Jon P. Mucho & Jonas Jonas Julius Caesar N. N. Azura, Chavez Miranda Aseoche Law Offices 8th Floor, One Corporate Plaza 845 Arnaiz Avenue, San Lorenzo Village Makati City
- 24 -
III.
The The pate patent ntly ly unco uncons nsti titu tuti tion onal al Design esignat atio ion n of Usec Usec.. Mich Michae aell Fred Freder eric ick k Musngi, re: Art. VIII, Constitution – converted the JBC selection process into a farce proceeding, tarnished the already wounded image of the JBC and caused irreparable damage and injury to the entire IBP, inter alia. Michael Frederick L. Musngi, Undersecretary of the Office of the Special Concerns, Office of the President, as the representative of the Executive Branch, vice Secretary Leila M. De Lima, for the sole purpose of participating in the deliberations of the CJ JBC selection process, is a virtual mockery of the Rule of Law. His participation in the Constitutional process is a palpable violation of his lawyer’s oath of office, inter alia. Musngi was appointed by President Benigno Aquino III as a replacement for Justice Secretary de Lima, who had to quit the council since she herself is a nominee. But Musngi is not from the justice department but from from the the Offi Office ce of the the Pres Presid iden ent, t, in part partic icul ular ar the the Offi Office ce of Exec Execut utiv ivee Secretary Paquito Ochoa Jr. Musngi and his involvement in the Lenny Villa hazing case here, shocks the conscience of the Court and the IBP, thusly: “Retired Sandiganbayan Justice Raoul Victorino, a former JBC member, member, said it violates violates the Constitution Constitution.. "I believe since DOJ secretary secretary is specificall specificallyy named as representat representative ive to JBC by the Constitution, no replacement is allowed. If at all it has to be with the approval of the SC," he said. Marlon Manuel, a member of the judiciary watchdog Supreme Court Appointments Watch, said Musngi's Musngi's appointmen appointmentt creates a problem. problem. "Based on the wording of the Constitution, the seat is reserved for the DOJ as ex-o ex-ofi fici cio o memb member er," ," he said said.. Musn Musngi gi will will rema remain in in the the JBC member, however, if no one brings the issue to the High Court. Agabin told Rappler Rappler "It's a constitutio constitutional nal issue." But he conceded it might be "too late" to do anything about it, as the JBC will already start the public interviews interviews today. today. But if Musngi's Musngi's appointment appointment is is indeed challenged challenged before before the SC, SC, and if
- 25 -
his appointment is declared illegal, what happens to his vote on the shortlist of nominees to be submitted to the President? "It will will be null nullif ifie ied, d,"" Agab Agabin in said said.. The The JBC JBC curr curren entl tlyy has has 8 members. Musngi is a member of the Aquila Legis fraternity which was involved in the killing of Ateneo Law student Jose Leonardo "Lenny" Villa. According to a Supreme Court ruling on the Villa case promulgated in February 2012, it was in the house of Musngi, Musngi, an Aquilan, Aquilan, that the fraternity fraternity neophytes were brought brought on the night of February 8, 1991. It was Musngi who briefed the neop neophy hyte tes, s, incl includ udin ing g Vill Villa, a, on what what to expe expect ct duri during ng the the initiation rites. http://sc.judiciary.gov.ph/jurisprudence/2012/february2012/1512 58.htm He was among the 19 cleared in the homicide case. Asked why Musngi Musngi was appointed appointed by the President, President, Presidentia Presidentiall Spokesper Spokesperson son Edwin Lacierda Lacierda said, "Underse "Undersecret cretary ary Musngi Musngi is a lawyer...Th lawyer...This is position position is only...tempo only...temporary... rary...and and he being the Undersecr Undersecretary etary for Special Concerns, the OES [Office of the Executive Secretary] felt that he would be able to perform the obligation. This is for a limited role only for selecting the Chief Justice." In his letter to the JBC dated July 19, 2012, President Aquino said: “I hereby designate Atty. Michael Michael Frederi Frederick ck L. Musngi, Musngi, Unders Undersecret ecretary ary of the the Office Office of Special Special Conc Concer erns ns,, Offi Office ce of the the Pres Presid iden ent, t, as the the repr repres esen enta tati tive ve of the the Executive Executive Branch, Branch, vice Secretary Secretary Leila M. De Lima, Lima, for the sole purpose purpose of participat participating ing in the deliberati deliberations ons of the Judicial Judicial and Bar Council for the selection of nominees for the position of Chief Justice. Pangilinan Pangilinan also said Senate Senate President President Juan Ponce Ponce Enrile Enrile also questioned the legality of allowing Justice Undersecretary Michael Frederick Frederick Musngi Musngi to participat participatee in the the JBC proceeding proceedings.” s.” [Sources:
http://www.rappler.com/nation/special-coverage/scwatch/9084-jbc-s-
baptism-ofbaptism-of-fire-an fire-and-lega d-legal-woes l-woes
http://www.rap http://www.rappler.co pler.com/nat m/nation/8 ion/8916-n 916-new-jbcew-jbc-
membe emberr-na name med d
http http:/ ://w /www ww.p .phi hils lsta tar. r.co com m/Art /Artic icle le.a .asp spx? x?
articleId=832859&publicationSubCategoryId=200]
III.a - 26 -
#12. Hazing accused Michael Frederick L. Musngi: “ Silently removed was “Chief Justice of the Universe” Florentino Floro, an ex-judge who claimed to consult dwarves regarding cases.” cases. ” Cursed Ateneo Law School alumni, Efren L. De Leon meets Judge Florentino Florentino Floro – a prelude to Musngi vis-à-vis 3 duende, LUIS , Armand and Angel – the CODED prophecy of death. Commentary Do Filipinos know how to judge ‘Chief Justice Idol’? By: Oscar Franklin Tan Philippine Daily Inquirer Wednesday, August 1st, http://opinion.inquirer.net/33833/do-filipinos-know 833/do-filipinos-know-how-to-judge-chie -how-to-judge-chief-justice-idol f-justice-idol 2012 http://opinion.inquirer.net/33
- 27 -
From June, 1978 to April, 1982, Petitioner sat beside his beloved classmate, Efren L. De Leon, No. 7 in the 1982 Bar Exams (which the former skipped because of the eternal Curse upon Ateneo Law School Class 1982. Petitioner placed 12th in the 1983 Bar Exams, 87.55% wherein 80% of Ateneo, UP & San Beda bar flunkers literally cried. On October 1, 1995, Petitioner and Efren L. De Leon handled the Mariano P. Blanco illegal possession of firearms Criminal Case pending before Judge Candido Belmonte, Br. 22, RTC, Malolos City, Bulacan. Petitioner suggested to De Leon, that Friday the 13 th is a very powerful day, and for this reason, the CA Certiorari-Injunction case must be filed about 1:00 p.m. to 3 p.m. of that fatalistic day. During the discussions, Petitoner suddenly told Efren L. De Leon: “ Efren, “ Efren, terminal terminal cancer cancer !” !” Shocked, De Leon said: “ Jun, wag kang magbibi magbibiro ro!” !” On October 29, 1995, Efren suffered pneumonia and was was diagnosed Stage 4 Metastasis Metastasis of organs, that is, Big C. Mr. Blanco deposited deposited P 800,000 800,000.00 .00 in De Leon’s Leon’s savings savings account (which was shown to Petitioner). De Leon shared only P 100,000.00 to Petitioner since the former said that the balance has yet to be used for CA Justice Corona Ibay Somera, etc. De Leon recovered, but he refused to remit to Petitioner the P300,000 share in that attorney’s fees. Note that Mr. Blanco was charged with P 10 million (search warrant evidence) vote-buying in the Mayorality race against 3 termer, Mayor Eduardo Alarilla who also died of cancer, as Petitioner predicted. Petitioner therefore, decided to annihilate De Leon after his secretary Tomas Carlo Araneta sent the denial letter of De Leon to Petitoner before his last breath. De Leon died in extreme pain on Easter Monday of 1996, when Petitioner paid the Injunction bond in the Court of Appeals. After his death, Petitoner by serendipity met a horse groom who accused de Leon of failing to pay their daily wages. Copy of the Factoran, Tria & De Leon Denial Letter of April 27, 2006 is attached at Annex Annex CC hereof.
- 28 -
In Villa, Justice Lourdes Sereno wrote: “The public outrage over the death of Leonardo “Lenny” Villa – the victim in this case – on 10 February 1991 led to a very strong clamor to put an end to hazing. hazing. On the night of 8 February February 1991, the neophytes were met by some members of the Aquila Fraternity Fraternity (Aquilans) at the lobby of the Ateneo Law School. School. They all proceeded to Rufo’s Restaurant to have dinner. Afterwards, they Michael Musngi Musngi went to the house of Michael , also an Aquilan, Aquilan, who who briefed briefed the neophytes neophytes on what what to expect expect during the the initiation initiation rites. rites. Xxx. Consequently, a criminal case for homicide was filed against the 12. Michael following following 35 Aquilans: #3. Efren de Leon (De Leon) # 12 Musngi (Musngi) (Musngi) On 10 January 2002, the CA in (CA-G.R. No. 15520) set aside the finding of conspiracy by the trial court in Criminal Case No. C-38340(91) C-38340(91) and modified modified the criminal criminal liability of each of the accused according to individual participation. Accused Efren L. De Leon had by then passed away, so the following following Decision Decision applied applied only to the remaining 25 accused: 1. 19 of the accused-appellants – Musngi Victorino, Sabban, Lledo, Guerrero, Musngi , Perez, De Guzman, Guzman, Sant Santos os,, Gene Genera ral, l, Flor Flores es,, Lim, Lim, Mont Montec ecil illo lo,, Ranad Ranada, a, Mendo Mendoza za,, Verdadero, Purisima, Fernandez, Abas, and Brigola (Victorino et al.) – were acquitted, as their individual guilt was not established by proof beyond reasonable doubt.” Responde ndent. nt. G.R. G.R. No. No. 151258 151258 (Villa (Villarea reall v. People People), ), G.R. G.R. No. [Respo 154954 154954 (People (People v. Court of Appeals), Appeals), G.R. G.R. No. 155101 (Dizon v. People), and G.R. Nos. 178057 and 178080 (Villa v. Escalona). http://sc.judiciary.gov.ph/jurisprudence/2012/february2012/151258.htm]
Atty. Marlon Manuel of Alternative Law Group at Supreme Court Appointments Watch in a forum at Manila stated: “MAAARI umanong makwestyon sa Korte Suprema ang resulta ng magiging botohan ng Judicial and Bar Council kaugnay ng isusu isusumi mite teng ng shor shortl tlist ist ng mga mga nomi nomina nado do sa pagk pagkaa-Pun Punon ong g Mahistrado. Mahistrado. Maituturing Maituturing kasing “under trial” ngayon ngayon ang JBC dahil kinukwestyon ang komposisyon nito. Bukod sa kinatawan ng Kongreso, Kongreso, kinukuwestiyo kinukuwestiyon n din ang pag-preside ni Justice Diosdado Diosdado Peralta sa JBC at ang pag-upo pag-upo ni Undersecret Undersecretary ary Michael Michael Frederick Frederick Musngi.” Musngi.” [by Teresa Tavares Aug 2, 2012 6:13am http://www.remate.ph/2012/08/botohan-ng-jbc-kukuwestyunin-sa-sc/]
HKT
Musngi’s Musngi’s Nos. 12 & 19 are defean defeaning ing,, or rather rather CODE CODED D numbers of the Mortis Angelus: 12 died in Colorado & 19 is the JBC Panel Interv Interview iew seat seat of Petiti Petitione onerr (whos (whosee eyes eyes and and palms palms did did emit emit the Lights Lights whic which h are are part part and and parc parcel el of Regi Regino no C. Herm Hermos osis isim ima, a, Jr.’ Jr.’ss dict dictum um – - 29 -
“Vindic Vindicati ation on by the Almigh Almighty ty”” or “ Divine Retribution Retribution”” agai agains nstt “Ungodly Reprisal” Reprisal” verbum verbum of the poor Justice Nazario. Petitioner will not waste time and would rather not lecture to this Court regarding the Argument/Discussion on the unconstitutional JBC participation-voting participation-voting of Musngi. Common sense dictates that even a regular JBC JBC memb member er who who woul would d late laterr on appl apply y for for prom promot otio ion n to a CA or SC position, does not have the power to appoint any JBC staff, SC personnel or even another John or Jane Doe to substitute and vote for him or her. The actu actuat atio ion n of Musn Musngi gi is not not only only a misn misnom omer, er, come comedy dy of erro errors, rs, wron wrong g mistake or moro-moro, but this Aquilian is writing his own death per the Lights of LUIS. LUIS.
The JBC cannot conduct valid proceedings as its composition is illegal and unconstitutional. unconstitutional. Locus Standi Standi
Petitioner possesses a personal stake in the outcome of the controversy (as to assure that there is real, concrete and legal conflict of rights rights and duties duties from the issues issues presented presented before before the Court). Court). In David v. the rules on on locus standi as culled Macapagal Macapagal-Arroyo Arroyo,, the Court summarized the from from jurisp jurisprud rudenc ence. e. There, There, it was was held held that that taxpay taxpayers ers,, voter voters, s, concer concerned ned citizens, citizens, and legislat legislators ors may be accorded accorded standing standing to sue, provided provided that the following requirements are met: (1) cases involve constitutional issues; (2) for taxpayers, there must be a claim of illegal disbursement of public funds or that the tax tax measure is unconstitutional; unconstitutional; (4) for concerned citizens, citizens, there must be a showing that the issues raised are of transcendental importance which must be settled early; In public suits, the plaintiff, representing the gener general al publ public, ic, assert assertss a “ public right ” in assail assailing ing an allege allegedly dly illeg illegal al official action. Petitioner, herein, as taxpayer, is a concerned citizen, Judge and Lawy Lawyer er,, who who is affe affect cted ed no diff differ eren entl tly y from from any any othe otherr perso person. n. Thus, Thus,
- 30 -
taxpayers have been allowed to sue where there is a claim that public funds are are ille illega gall lly y disb disbur urse sed d or that that publ public ic mone money y is bein being g defl deflec ecte ted d to any any improper purpose, or that public funds are wasted through the enforcement of an invalid or unconstitutional law. Of greater import than the damage caus caused ed by the the ille illega gall expe expend ndit iture ure of publ public ic fund fundss is the the mort mortal al woun wound d inflicted upon the fundamental law by the enforcement of an invalid statute.
In this case, petitioner seeks judicial intervention as a taxpayer, a concerned citizen and an applicant-nominee applicant-nominee to the position of Chief Justice of the Supreme Court. Court. As a taxpayer, taxpayer, petitioner invokes invokes his right to demand demand that the taxes he and the rest of the citizenry have been paying to the government are spent for lawful purposes. Since the JBC derives financial supp suppor ortt for for its its func functi tion ons, s, oper operat atio ion n and and proc procee eedi ding ngss from from taxe taxess paid paid,, petitioner possesses as taxpayer both right and legal standing to demand that the JBC’s proceedings are not tainted with illegality and that its composition and actions do not violate the Constitution. (Attribution – Chaves vs. JBC, G.R. No. 202242). The JBC that produced the Long and would submit the short list of nominees had not been validly constituted, and that the President would be selecting from an improperly made short list, making the entire selection process null and void and should be done afresh. This will be the supreme irony in the turn of events that was sparked by the showdown between the President and the Supreme Court on the latter’s ruling removing former President Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo from the travel watch-list orders, and that culminated in the impeachment and subsequent removal of Corona on May 29. The Court must now break the impasse on who gets to vote in the JBC, and resolve the issue categorically and immediately. Petitioner, by these presents, hereby sets forth the following ques questi tion on to Musngi usngi:: “ Do you know how powerful powerful LUIS-Element LUIS-Elementss 911 Element Element 112-Judge 112-Judge Florentino Florentino V. Floro, Jr. is in the entire universeuniverse-
- 31 -
Heavens?” Heavens?” Musngi has no exit. He has to follow the law, if the Court should survive, live and let live.
- 32 -
