HLURB Complaint Revised Updated

Republic of the Philippines Office of the President HOUSING AND LAND USE REGULATORY OARD !ue"on #it$ Araceli Daria Sagario Abad, Luther Bucud Alvarado, Sps. Roel& Thelma Albero, Mary Grace AguasAlcao, Arel Robles Ag, Ma.!ri"elda D. Balta"ar, Rosalida #iloteoBaluti, $ermeo$eroa Bautista, Ruther Du%ue Bautista, vely AlardeBau"o, Rei Ty Belo, #erdiad M. Bolislis, Raymod Reier Salido!adari, 'salyAltare(os!ato(os, Li"abeth $elica !atos, Beedic) Mar) *. !ha, +ohy . !hiu, Staley Sioco!hy, Beradette D. !hua, RomelMagahas !orrea, RochelAaly-ascualDeLa !ru", Marivic!a(umbaDiala, Geesis -ol T. Domigo, Billy +ea *ue"Dugo, vely /. Ga, Maria Lourdes -aredes0Garcia #lordeli"a -. Geslai, *icole Tiu Go, -atric) Bosol Go"ales, -uo Bosalaga Guilig, +R., Melissa A . $ipol, Maria 1ictoria . $ipol, /olada /. $ui, +uliet Macuto -adre +ua, Sps. Arma &Reilda Soriao Layo, Diae Miles #lores Lim, eedy Ta Lim, Sps. Leoides& Geie B. De Lume, Sps. Bobby & +oaa Siues Lope", Reato +estreMaago, !armilu" !arlos Melo, Sps. Ro2ea & Gilbert De Gu"ma Gu "ma Mercado, *eea Aisha a2 Go Del Mudo +oh Meard !ualig *ieto, Sps. #erado & Merly *oble, Grace 3. 4g, Sps. Agelo & +oae -abis, 3edy 3edy Medo"a -etros, melie D. -o5Bria Leemar) -o, Grace #acullo6uioes5Sher2i 6uioes,

P%&e '() #loreda De Mesa Rie"a53i7red +apitaRie"a 5 3edy A De Mesa Rie"a, ditha!laveriaRuallo 5 Romulo Rico Ruallo 5 8arah Ageli%ue Ruallo, Dolores Satos Sagalag 5 Arel!abadigSagalag, Scigate Techology !orp. represeted by9 Richard So 5 Aaly !hua So, Al7oso AgSy +R., Roald Tamayo 5 +ei7er Tamayo, +e77rey Dee Ta 5 #lorice Mae Buecamio Ta, Ale:ader 1e"uela Ta, Mauel Roma Tapoco, Susa Thai, +ohy !hoy Tiu 5 vely Tiu, Tecso;y<=ighua ag>, Deis 1elasco 1illegas, 1ictoria ri%ue" 1illea, Sherly Glipo 1iloria, Audrey Miette Maymay 3og -riscilla -olicarpio /ap, $ery Lim /ap, Barry +ames See /u, +ohso $o /u Rosalie -adilla 8amora, #o*pl%in%nts+ , -ersus ,

HLUR #%se No) ..........   /or0 1iol%tion of Sec) (2 of PD 345+ Unsound usiness Pr%ctices %nd Specific Perfor*%nce 6ith %pplic%tion for #e%se %nd Desist Order)

DM!' ? -ro(ect Developers, 'c., Represeted by Alma A. #loredo, Respondents) 7,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,7 !4M-LA'*T #O8E NO9+ the co*pl%in%nts throu&h counsel %nd unto this Honor%ble Office+ *ost respectfull$ st%te0 The -arties :) All co*pl%in%nts %re residents;purch%sers;bu$ers of residenti%l units %nd;or p%r %t Sorrel Residences? Luther Bucud Alvarado5Ru7ia De(amco Alvarado+ both of le&%l %&e presentl$ % residents of Unit ((:( %t Sorrel Residences? Roel!orbillaAlbero5Thelma SumalisidAlbero+ both of le&%l %&e %nd residents of  Unit '>': %t Sorrel Residences? Mary Grace AguasAlcao5!aliicoAtayAlcao ''+ both of le&%l %&e %nd residents of Unit (=(: %t Sorrel Residences?

P%&e '=) Arel Robles Ag5va SimudacAg, both of le&%l %&e %nd residents of Unit '2(: %t Sorrel Residences? Ma.!ri"elda D. Balta"ar5#rederic) MadariagaBalta"ar+ both of le&%l %&e %nd residents of Unit '3'> %t Sorrel Residences? Rosalida #iloteoBaluta5Arthur Mati"aBaluta+ both of le&%l %&e %nd residents of Unit :5'2 %t Sorrel Residences? vely AlardeBau"o5+oel BuelaBau"o+ both of le&%l %&e %nd residents of Unit '@:' %t Sorrel Residences? $ermeo Geroa Bautista 5 Divia 1illa7lores Bautista+ both of le&%l %&e %nd residents of Unit (>'= %t Sorrel Residences? Ruther Du%ue Bautista5Aaly Saavedra Bautista+ both of le&%l %&e %nd % residents of Unit :3'> %t Sorrel Residences? Rei Ty Belo5Myra Reverete Belo+ both of le&%l %&e %nd % residentsof Unit :((: %t Sorrel Residences? #erdiad M. Bolislis+ of le&%l %&e %nd % resident of Unit :5:3 %t Sorrel Residences? Raymod Reier Salido!adari+ of le&%l %&e %nd % resident of Unit '>:' %t Sorrel Residences? 'salyAltare(os!ato(os+ of le&%l %&e %nd % resident of Unit :3(: %t Sorrel Residences? Li"abeth $elica !atos+ of le&%l %&e %nd % resident of Unit '='2 %t Sorrel Residences? Beedic) Mar) *. !ha5'melda T. !ha+ both of le&%l %&e %nd % residents of Unit '@(: %t Sorrel Residences? +ohy . !hiu5Mary . !hiu, both of le&%l %&e %nd % residents of Unit :2(' %t Sorrel Residences? Staley Sioco!hy, of le&%l %&e %nd % resident of Unit (>'> %t Sorrel Residences? Beradette D. !hua5Bria Leemar) !. -o, both of le&%l %&e %nd % residents of Unit :2'@ %t Sorrel Residences? RomelMagahas !orrea,  of le&%l %&e %nd % resident of Unit '5:5A %t Sorrel Residences? RochelAaly-ascualDeLa !ru"5d2i T. Dela !ru", both of le&%l %&e %nd % residents of Unit :>(' %t Sorrel Residences? Marivic!a(umbaDiala5Agela !a(umbaDiala, both of le&%l %&e %nd % residents of Unit :@:3 %t Sorrel Residences? Geesis -ol T. Domigo5Ria !hristie . Domigo,  both of le&%l %&e %nd % residents Unit '=:@ %t Sorrel Residences? Billy +ea *ue"Dugo,, of le&%l %&e %nd % resident of Unit :':3 %t Sorrel Residences? vely /. Ga5Marti T. Ga,  both of le&%l %&e %nd % residents of Unit '4:( %t Sorrel Residences? +oatha David Teo Go5*icole Tiu Go, both of le&%l %&e %nd % residents Unit (=:: %t Sorrel Residences? #lordeli"a -. Geslai5Ale:ader B. Geslai, both of le&%l %&e %nd % residents of  Unit '=(' %t Sorrel Residences? -atric) Bosol Go"ales5Melaie Delos Satos Go"ales, both of le&%l %&e %nd % residents of Unit '4'2 %t Sorrel Residences? -uo Bosalaga Guilig, +R.5AsiaBasao Guilig,  both of le&%l %&e %nd % residents of Unit '3'4A %t Sorrel Residences? Melissa A . $ipol, of le&%l %&e %nd % resident of Unit '3'3 %t Sorrel Residences?Maria 1ictoria . $ipol, of le&%l %&e %nd % resident of Unit '3'@ %t Sorrel Residences? /omida /. $ui5a ig So $ui, both of le&%l %&e %nd % residents of Unit :@(: %t Sorrel Residences?

P%&e '>) +uliet Macuto -adre +ua5+e77rey avila -adre +ua,  both of le&%l %&e %nd % residents of Unit '2'= %t Sorrel Residences? Reilda Soriao Layo5Arma Reyes Layo, both of le&%l %&e %nd % residents of  Unit :>'4A %t Sorrel Residences? Diae Miles #lores Lim5Alla Dale Magarig $o,  both of le&%l %&e %nd % residents of Unit :>:@ %t Sorrel Residences? eedy Ta Lim, of le&%l %&e %nd % resident of Unit '4:@ %t Sorrel Residences?Geie B. De Lume5LeoidesTeo7ilo !. De Lume '', both of le&%l %&e %nd % residents of Unit '>'5 %t sorrel Residences? +oaa Siues Lope"5Bobby Agaga Lope", both both of le&%l %&e %nd residents Unit '>'3 %t Sorrel Residences? Reato +estreMaago5+eaette RagudoMaago, both of le&%l %&e %nd residents of  Unit ((:3 %t Sorrel Residences? !armilu" !arlos Melo, of le&%l %&e %nd % resident of Unit :4'3 %t Sorrel Residences? Gilbert De Gu"ma Mercado5Ro2ea L. Mercado, both of le&%l %&e %nd residents of Unit '4'5 %t Sorrel Residences? *eea Aisha a2 Go Del Mudo, of le&%l %&e %nd % resident of Unit :5'3 %t Sorrel Residences? +oh Miard!ualig *ieto, of le&%l %&e %nd % resident of Unit :>'2 %t Sorrel Residences? #erado *oble5 Merly *oble, both of le&%l %&e %nd residents of Unit :>:4 %t Sorrel Residences? Grace 3. 4g, of le&%l %&e %nd % resident of Unit :>:( %t Sorrel Residences? Agelo La Torre -abis5 +oae -abis, both of le&%l %&e %nd residents of Unit :''3 %t Sorrel Residences? 3edy Medo"a -etros, of le&%l %&e %nd % resident of Unit :''( %t Sorrel Residences? melie D. -o5Bria Leemar) -o, both of le&%l %&e %nd residents of Unit :2'5 %t Sorrel Residences? Grace #acullo6uioes5Sher2i 6uioes, both of le&%l %&e %nd residents of Unit :3:( %t Sorrel Residences? #loreda De Mesa Rie"a53i7red +apitaRie"a 5 3edy A De Mesa Rie"a,%ll of le&%l %&e %nd residents of Unit '4:: %t Sorrel Residences? ditha!laveriaRuallo 5 Romulo Rico Ruallo 5 8arah Ageli%ue Ruallo,  %ll of  le&%l %&e %nd residents of Unit '3:5 %t Sorrel Residences? Dolores Satos Sagalag 5 Arel!abadigSagalag,  both of le&%l %&e %nd residents of Unit :(:@ %t Sorrel Residences? Scigate Techology !orp., % corpor%tion eistin& under Philippine L%6s6ith %ddress %t Units (::> B (::4 %t Sorrel Residences represented b$ Don%ld de Gu"*%n Ser%fin? Richard So 5 Aaly !hua So,  both of le&%l %&e %nd residents of Unit '4(: %t Sorrel Residences? Al7oso AgSy +R., of le&%l %&e %nd % resident of Unit (4': %t Sorrel Residences?Roald Tamayo 5 +ei7er Tamayo, both of le&%l %&e %nd residents of  Unit '5'> %t Sorrel Residences? +e77rey Dee Ta 5 #lorice Mae Buecamio Ta, both of le&%l %&e %nd residents of  Unit :4:> %t Sorrel Residences? Ale:ader 1e"uela Ta, of le&%l %&e %nd % resident of Unit :':> %t Sorrel Residences? Mauel Roma Tapoco, of le&%l %&e %nd % resident of Unit :(:5+ Sorrel Residences? Susa Thai, of le&%l %&e %nd % resident of Unit :3'3 %nd :3:' %t Sorrel Residences? +ohy !hoy Tiu 5 vely Tiu, both of le&%l %&e %nd residents of Unit (>': %t Sorrel Residences?

-age @. Tecso;y<=ighua ag>, of le&%l %&e %nd % resident Unit (4:: %t Sorrel Residences? Deis 1elasco 1illegas 5 +o A Baligit 1illegas, both of le&%l %&e %nd residents of Unit '4(' %t Sorrel Residences? 1ictoria ri%ue" 1illea 5 +eaette -ere" Mclaie, both of le&%l %&e %nd residents of Unit (>:5 %t Sorrel Residences? Sherly Glipo 1iloria 5 +esperRosete 1iloria+ both of le&%l %&e %nd residents of  Unit :4:' %t Sorrel Residences? Audrey Miette Maymay 3og, of le&%l %&e %nd % resident of Unit :@:2 %t Sorrel Residences? -riscilla -olicarpio /ap, of le&%l %&e %nd % resident of Unit (4:' %t Sorrel Residences? $ery Lim /ap,  of le&%l %&e %nd % resident of Unit (''> %nd (''5 %t Sorrel Residences? Barry +ames See /u, of le&%l %&e %nd % resident of Unit ((:5 %t Sorrel Residences? +ohso $o /u5 1irgiia Tiu /u, both of le&%l %&e %nd residents of Unit (>:@ %t Sorrel Residences? Rosally -adilla 8amora, of le&%l %&e %nd % resident of Unit :(:5A %t Sorrel Residences? () Respondent D8#I C Proect De-elopers+ Inc)+

herein%fter referred

to %s

De-eloperF is % corpor%tion eistin& under the l%6s of the Philippines 6ith princip%l office %t No) :=(: Aplolin%rio St)+ %n&<%l+ 8%<%ti #it$) It is hereto represented b$ its President+ 8r) Alfredo R) Austri%+ It 6%s incorpor%ted %s % re%l est%te de-eloper+ en&%&ed in the de-elop*ent of condo*iniu* proects+ one of 6hich is Sorrel Residences) =) Sorrel Residences 6%s offici%ll$ opened for turn o-er to the unit bu$ers st%rtin& %nu%r$+ (':4 %nd to d%te) >) Thus+ the %bo-e,n%*ed co*pl%in%nts st%rtin& occup$in& their respecti-e units %t Sorrel residences on different d%tes+ -i"0 Araceli Daria Sagario Abad, May , C@ Luther Bucud Alvarado, May E, C@ Sps. Roel& Thelma Albero, May , C@ Mary Grace AguasAlcao, 4ctober F, C@ Arel Robles Ag, +ue C, C@ Ma.!ri"elda D. Balta"ar, +ue H, C@ Rosalida #iloteoBaluta, 4ctober F, C@ $ermeo$eroa Bautista, May CI, C@ Ruther Du%ue Bautista, 4ctober F, C@ vely AlardeBau"o, April H, C@ Rei Ty Belo, +ue C, C@ #erdiad M. Bolislis, May E, C@ Raymod Reier Salido!adari, +ue , C@ 'salyAltare(os!ato(os, April CC, C@ Li"abeth $elica !atos, September C, C@ Beedic) Mar) *. !ha, #ebruary , C@ +ohy . !hiu, #ebruary , C@ Staley Sioco!hy, +ue CE, C@ Beradette D. !hua, May C, C@ RomelMagahas !orrea, April E, C@

P%&e '2) RochelAaly-ascualDeLa !ru", 4ctober F, C@ Marivic!a(umbaDiala, +auary F@, C@ Geesis -ol T. Domigo, +ue , C@, Billy +ea *ue"Dugo,, March C, C@ vely /. Ga, +auary E, C@ Maria Lourdes -aredes0Garcia, August C, C@ #lordeli"a -. Geslai, 4ctober F, C@ +oatha David Teo Go, +uly , C@ -atric) Bosol Go"ales, #ebruary CE, C@ -uo Bosalaga Guilig, +R., May I, C@ Melissa A . $ipol, May F@, C@ Maria 1ictoria . $ipol, May CF, C@ /omida /. $ui, March CE, C@ +uliet Macuto -adre +ua, April CI, C@ Sps. Arma &Reilda Soriao Layo, April F@, C@ Diae Miles #lores Lim, May C, C@ eedy Ta Lim, March C, C@ Sps. Bobby & +oaa Siues Lope", March , C@ Sps. Leoides& Geie B. De Lume, May , C@ Reato +estreMaago, May C, C@ !armilu" !arlos Melo, May , C@ Sps. Ro2ea & Gilbert De Gu"ma Mercado, March F, C@ *eea Aisha a2 Go Del Mudo, #ebruary C, C@ +oh Meard !ualig *ieto, 4ctober F, C@ Sps. #erado & Merly *oble, March C, C@ Grace 3. 4g, #ebruary F, C@ Sps. Agelo & +oae -abis, March CE, C@ 3edy Medo"a -etros, March CH, C@ melie D. -o5Bria Leemar) -o, March F, C@ Grace #acullo6uioes5Sher2i 6uioes, March F, C@ #loreda De Mesa Rie"a53i7red +apitaRie"a 5 3edy A De Mesa Rie"a, May I, C@ ditha!laveriaRuallo 5 Romulo Rico Ruallo 5 8arah Ageli%ue Ruallo, May , C@ Dolores Satos Sagalag 5 Arel!abadigSagalag, April C, C@ Scigate Techology !orp. #ebruary H, C@ Richard So 5 Aaly !hua So, March CF, C@ Al7oso AgSy +R., May CC, C@ Roald Tamayo 5 +ei7er Tamayo, +e77rey Dee Ta 5 #lorice Mae Buecamio Ta, 4ctober F, C@ Ale:ader 1e"uela Ta, +ue , C@ Mauel Roma Tapoco, April F, C@ Susa Thai, September H, C@ +ohy !hoy Tiu 5 vely Tiu, Tecso;y <=ighua ag>, Deis 1elasco 1illegas, April , C@ 1ictoria ri%ue" 1illea, 4ctober F, C@ ShirlyGlipo 1iloria, May , C@ Audrey *ieteMaimai 3og +uly E, C@ -riscilla -olicarpio /ap, #ebruary C, C@ $ery Lim /ap, +ue @, C@ Barry +ames See /u, +ue , C@ +ohso $o /u April C, C@ Rosalie -adilla 8amora, +uly , C@

P%&e '5) #irst !ause o7 Actio 4)

So*eti*e Au&ust ('+ (':4+ the %bo-e,n%*ed co*pl%in%nts 6ere sent out notices b$ the respondent De-eloper to p%$ (':4 Re%l Propert$ T%es in -%r$in& %*ounts 6ith de*%nds to p%$ on or before October =:+ (':4+ but 6hich 6%s l%ter *o-ed to  No-e*ber ='+ (':4+ -i"0 C@ RT

;it -ar)ig Ae:

Araceli Daria Sagario Abad, - F@,.E Abad0A Luther Bucud Alvarado, I,CI.C Alvarado0A Sps. Roel& Thelma Albero, F@,I.IF Albero0A Mary Grace AguasAlcao, JJJJJJJJ  Arel Robles Ag, C,@@.@ -,@EI.I Ag0AK Ag0B Ma.!ri"elda D. Balta"ar, CH,@@. Balta"ar0A Rosalida #iloteoBaluta, F,IC.E Baluta0A $ermeo Geroa Bautista, ,.IF -,E.C Bautista0AK Bautista0B Ruther Du%ue Bautista, JJJJJJJJ -I,EEC. Bautista0AK Bautista0B vely AlardeBau"o, F,I@H. -,F@.@H Bau"o0AK Bau"o 0B Rei Ty Belo, CE,FCH. Belo0A #erdiad M. Bolislis, I,CI.C Bolislis0A Raymod Reier Salido!adari,CE,I. -,IF.I@ !adari0AK!adari0B 'salyAltare(os!ato(os, FF,E.HC -H,EH.E !ato(os0AK!ato(os Li"abeth $elica !atos, C,HH.E !atos0A Beedic) Mar) *. !ha, C,HEE.F -E,[email protected] !ha0AK !ha0B +ohy . !hiu, CH,IFI. !hiu0A Staley Sioco!hy, CF,CHE.@ !hy0A Beradette D. !hua, I,II.@I -H,H@H.F !hua0AK !hua0B RomelMagahas !orrea, CC,H.I !orrea0A RochelAaly-ascualDeLa !ru", JJJJJJJJ  Marivic!a(umbaDiala, C,CI.H -,CI.I Diala0AKDiala0B Geesis -ol T. Domigo, C,I.F Domigo0A CC,E.I Dugo0A Billy +ea *ue"Dugo, vely /. Ga, CI,CC. Ga0A Maria Lourdes -aredes0Garcia @,FH.C Garcia0A #lordeli"a -. Geslai, JJJJJJJJ  *icole Tiu Go, CF,FI.HI Go0A -atric) Bosol Go"ales, F,HF@.H Go"ales0A -uo Bosalaga Guilig, +r. CF,FEE.CC Guilig0A Melissa A . $ipol, ,HFF.CI Melissa $ipol0A Maria 1ictoria . $ipol, E,C@. Maria $ipol0A /omida /. $ui, F,@F.CI -E,CII.EI $ui0AK $ui0B +uliet Macuto -adre +ua, C@,HF.II +ua0A Sps. Arma &Reilda Soriao Layo, C,F.EC Layo0A Diae Miles #lores Lim, CI,H. Diae Lim0A eedy Ta Lim, F,EH. -,C. eedy Lim0AK 0Lim0B Sps. Leoides& Geie B. De Lume,CI,C@.E-H,FHC.H Lume0AKLume0B Sps. Bobby & +oaa Siues Lope", C,HF.I Lope"0A Reato +estreMaago, E,CF.@ -H,@@.I Maago0AKMaago0B !armilu" !arlos Melo, E,IFI.H Melo0A Sps. Ro2ea & Gilbert De Gu"ma Mercado, FH,E.EF -F,@EH. Mercado0AKMercado0B *eea Aisha a2 Go Del Mudo C,HFF.E Mudo0A +oh Meard !ualig *ieto, JJJJJJJ  Sps. #erado & Merly *oble, F,EFI.E -,[email protected]@ *oble0A Grace 3. 4g, CH,CEH.HH 4g0A Sps. Agelo & +oae -abis, CC,H.FF -abis0A 3edy Medo"a -etros, CC,IFI.H@ -etros0A

P%&e @) melie D. -o5Bria Leemar) -o, F,ECH. -E,CF@.I Grace #acullo6uioes5Sher2i 6uioes, CC,F-

-o0AK -o0B 6uioes0A

#loreda De Mesa Rie"a53i7red +apitaRie"a 5 3edy A De Mesa Rie"a, F,.E Rie"a0A ditha!laveriaRuallo 5 Romulo Rico Ruallo 5 8arah Ageli%ue Ruallo, C@,@.I Ruallo0A Dolores Satos Sagalag 5 Arel!abadigSagalag, F,CF.C -H,I.H Sagalag0A Scigate Techology !orp. CH,@.H -C,@I.@ Scigate0AK B Scigate Techology !orp. FI,HIC.F Scigate0! Richard So 5 Aaly !hua So, F,HE.CC So0A Al7oso AgSy +R., CI,EI.@C -H,@H.H Sy0AK Sy0B Roald Tamayo 5 +ei7er Tamayo, C,CI.F Tamayo0A +e77rey Dee Ta 5 #lorice Mae Buecamio Ta,  JJJJJJJJ -I,@. Ta0AK Ta0B Ale:ader 1e"uela Ta, H,HF.HH JJJJJJJJ Ta0AK Ta0B Mauel Roma Tapoco, C,.FI -I,IF. Tapoco AK Tapoco0B Susa Thai, +ohy !hoy Tiu 5 vely Tiu, F,C.E Tiu0A Tecso;y <=ighua ag>, Deis 1elasco 1illegas, C,HFF.F ;y0A 1ictoria ri%ue" 1illea, Sherly Glipo1iloria

-FC,EC.E

-H,.IE

1iloria0AK1iloria0B

Audrey *ieteMaimai 3og F,E.C 3og0A -riscilla -olicarpio /ap, ,CC.EE -riscilla /ap0A $ery Lim /ap, C,@.& C,@. -,@.CF& -,@.CF$ery /ap0AK BK ! Barry +ames See /u, H,F. -,FE.IH /u0AK /u0B +ohso $o /u FC,CCH.E -,@C.C $o /u0AK $o /u0B Rosalie -adilla 8amora, ,[email protected] 8amora0A

2)  Th%t %s % *%tter of f%ct+ on se-er%l occ%sions+ represent%ti-es of the De-eloper c%*e o-er to the condo*iniu* to recei-e the p%$*ents of t%es for (':4 fro* the unit o6ners but the %bo-e,n%*ed co*pl%in%nts refused to p%$ t% rei*burse*ents to the De-eloper for the t%es the l%tter p%id for (':4? 5) Th%t no unit o6ner h%s $et been issued his;her #ondo*iniu* #ertific%te of Title %nd th%t *oreo-er+ the t% li%bilit$ for the $e%r (':4 6%s %ppr%ised b$ the Loc%l Go-ern*ent of 8%nil% to the De-eloper %s it is the re&istered o6ner of the #ondo*iniu*? @) Th%t the %lle&ed b%sis of the De-eloper in de*%ndin& rei*burse*ent for p%$*ent of  t%es for (':4 6%s the ter*s stipul%ted in the #ontr%ct to Sell ? 3) Th%t ho6e-er+ under Section (2 of PD 345+ other6ise
Sectio CH. Realty Tax. Real estate ta: ad assessmet o a lot or uit shall be paid by the o2er or developer 2ithout recourse to the buyer 7or as log as the title has ot passed the buyerK -rovided, ho2ever, that i7 the buyer has actually ta)e possessio o7 ad occupied the lot or uit, he shall be liable to the o2er or developer 7or such ta: ad assessmet e77ective the year 7ollo2ig such ta)ig o7 possessio ad occupacy.

:') Th%t % -iol%tion of the Section (2 of PD 345 not onl$ ent%ils %d*inistr%ti-e s%nction such %s re-oc%tion of its license to sell %nd its certific%te of re&istr%tion but li
::) Th%t the fore&oin& is the pre-%ilin& l%6 on the *%tter %nd therefore the De-eloper is  prohibited to see< rei*burse*ent of the (':4 t% it p%id to the #it$ Go-ern*ent fro* the co*pl%in%nts) :() Th%t 6hile the co*pl%in%nts si&ned %n Undert%
Sectio FF. Nullity of waivers. Ay coditio, stipulatio, or provisio i cotract o7 sale 2hereby ay perso 2aives compliace 2ith ay provisio o7 this Decree or o7 ay rule or regulatio issued thereuder shall be void. Underscorin&+ oursJ Cd !ause o7 Actio :>) Th%t %side fro* Notice to P%$ (':4 t%+ the %bo-e,n%*ed co*pl%in%nts 6ere li
Anne Abad0B Alvarado0B Albero0B Alcao0! Ag0! Balta"ar0B Baluti0B Bautista0! Ruther Bautista0! Bau"o0! Belo0B Bolislis0B !adari0! !ato(os0! !atos0B !ha0! !hiu0B !hy0B !hua0!

RomelMagahas !orrea, JJJJJJJJ !orrea0B RochelAaly-ascualDeLa !ru", CI,I.@@ Dela !ru"0B Marivic!a(umbaDiala, CI,I.@@ Diala0! Geesis -ol T. Domigo, ,FH.CC Domigo0B CI,I.@@ Dugo0B Billy +ea *ue"Dugo,, vely /. Ga, CI,I.@@ Ga0B Maria Lourdes -aredes0Garcia CI,I.@@ Garcia0B #lordeli"a -. Geslai, CI,I.@@ Geslai0B *icole Tiu Go, E,@. Go0B -age @. -atric) Bosol Go"ales, F,[email protected] Go"ales0B -uo Bosalaga Guilig, +r. F,[email protected] Guilig0B Melissa A . $ipol, CF,EH.C Melissa $ipol0B Maria 1ictoria . $ipol, CI,I.@@ Maria $ipol0B /omida /. $ui, E,@. $ui0! +uliet Macuto -adre +ua, CI,I.@@ +ua0B Sps. Arma &Reilda Soriao Layo, F,[email protected] Layo0B Diae Miles #lores Lim, JJJJJJJJ Diae Lim0B eedy Ta Lim, ,H.CC eedy Lim0! Sps. Leoides& Geie B. De Lume, ,H.CC Lume0! Sps. Bobby & +oaa Siues Lope", CI,I.@@ Lope"0B Reato +estreMaago, CI,I.@@ Maago0! !armilu" !arlos Melo, CI,I.@@ Melo0B Sps. Ro2ea & Gilbert De Gu"ma Mercado, ,H.CC Mercado0! *eea Aisha a2 Go Del Mudo JJJJJJJJ Mudo0B +oh Meard !ualig *ieto, F,[email protected] Sps. #erado & Merly *oble, FH,FHI.@ *oble0! Grace 3. 4g, CI,I.@@ 4g0B Sps. Agelo & +oae -abis, CI,I.@@ -abis0B 3edy Medo"a -etros, JJJJJJJJ -etros0B melie D. -o5Bria Leemar) -o, FH,FHI.@ -o0! Grace #aculla6uioes5Sher2i 6uioes, CI,I.@@ 6uioes0B #loreda De Mesa Rie"a53i7red +apitaRie"a 5 3edy A De Mesa Rie"a,   JJJJJJJJ Rie"a0B ditha!laveriaRuallo 5 Romulo Rico Ruallo 5 8arah Ageli%ue Ruallo,   JJJJJJJJJ Ruallo0B Dolores Satos Sagalag 5 Arel!abadigSagalag, ,H.CC Sagalag0B Scigate Techology !orp. CI,I.@@ & ,H.CC Scigate0B Richard So 5 Aaly !hua So, E,@. So0B Al7oso AgSy +r., E,@. Sy0B Roald Tamayo 5 +ei7er Tamayo, JJJJJJJJ Tamayo0B +e77rey Dee Ta 5 #lorice Mae Buecamio Ta, CI,I.@@ Ta0B Ale:ader 1e"uela Ta, CI,I.@@ Ta0B Mauel Roma Tapoco, F@,E.F@ Tapoco0B Susa Thai, CF,EH.C & FE,E@.C +ohy !hoy Tiu 5 vely Tiu, E,@. Tiu0B Tecso;y <=ighua ag>, JJJJJJJJ Tecso0B Deis 1elasco 1illegas, CI,I.@@ 1illegas0B 1ictoria ri%ue" 1illea, F@,E.F@ 1illea0B ShirlyGlipo 1iloria, E,@ 1iloria0! Audrey *ieteMaimai 3og JJJJJJJJ 3og0B -riscilla -olicarpio /ap, JJJJJJJJ -riscilla /ap0B $ery Lim /ap, ,H.CC & ,H.CC $ery /ap0!K/ap0D Barry +ames See /u, F@,E.F@ /u0! +ohso $o /u ,H.CC $o /u0! Rosalie -adilla 8amora, JJJJJJJJ 8amora0B

:4) There is no cle%r b%sis for the s%id t% %ssess*ent on the e%ch of the unit o6ners+ 6hich le%d the* to belie-e th%t the t% %ssess*ents 6ere *erel$ b%sed on the tot%l

t% li%bilit$ of the De-eloper di-ided b$ %ll the unit o6ners+ 6ithout re&%rd to the condo*iniu* dues bein& %ssessed the indi-idu%l co*pl%in%nts) :2) Th%t the De-eloper should be directed to co*e up 6ith % definite %nd cle%r  co*put%tion on ho6 the t%es 6ere %rri-ed %tso th%t the %bo-e,n%*ed co*pl%in%nts *%$ be cl%rified on their respecti-e t% li%bilit$? :5) Th%t in the *e%nti*e+ the De-eloper thre%tens to i*pose pen%lties %nd surch%r&es on the %bo-e co*put%tions should the indi-idu%l unit o6ners f%il to p%$ 6ithin the de%dline i*posed b$ the de-eloper on Dece*ber ='+ (':4) P%&e ::) Third !ause o7 Actio ) Th%t *oreo-er+ the De-eloper is thre%tenin& or is %bout to i*pose pen%lties %nd surch%r&es to the co*pl%in%nts+ if %nd 6hen+ the$ f%il to p%$ the (':4 t%es+ tendin& to r ender the ud&*ent ineffectu%l? (4) Th%t 6hile co*pl%in%nts %re %lre%d$ obli&%ted to p%$ their (':2 t%es+ the De-eloper is %lre%d$ thre%tenin& %&%in to i*pose pen%lties %nd surch%r&es+ 6ithout cl%rif$in& ho6 the fi&ures 6ere %rri-ed %t+ to the &r%-e %nd irrep%r%ble inur$ of the %pplic%nts? (2) Th%t the co*pl%in%nts %re 6illin& to file % bond to %ns6er for 6h%te-er d%*%&es th%t the %d-erse p%rt$ *%$ sust%in b$ re%son of the order+ if it should be l%ter decided th%t the %pplic%nt is not entitled thereto) #ourth !ause o7 Actio Sub,St%nd%rd /%cilities %nd /%ult$ Structures (5) Th%t this e%rl$ since the De-eloper turned o-er the possession of the units to the respecti-e unit bu$ers+ so*e of the %*enities %nd f%cilities of the condo*iniu* h%-e either been inst%lled or constructed belo6 p%rF the st%nd%rds reKuired under the N%tion%l uildin& #ode?

(@) Th%t the ele-%tors of Sorrel Residences h%-e+ on countless occ%sions+ *%lfunctioned %nd this e%rl$ under6ent se-er%l rep%irs? (3) Th%t to %-oid tr%&ic %ccidents+ there is % need to ch%n&e the ele-%tor cubicle fro* %n un) Orderin& the De-eloper to i**edi%tel$ conduct rep%irs %nd inst%ll%tions of f%cilities up p%r 6ith the st%nd%rds reKuired for hi&h rise condo*iniu* li
No-e*ber 2+ (':4

The L%6 /ir* of  -AD'LLA 1'LLA*;1A AB;*D4 1'R*S GAR!'A #ST'* & ASS4!'ATS 8e""%nine /loor 9est %nd E%st 9in&s 9heels uildin&  No) ((( E) Rodri&ue" Sr)+ A-enue !ue"on #it$ Tel) Nos) >:2=3':? >544@=5

Atty. MAR'# S. TA8A Roll No) 4(5=' IP No) 32545' %nu%r$ 4+ (':4+ !)#) PTR No) '4235>5 %nu%r$ 4+ (':4+ !)#) 8#LE #o*pli%nce I1,''::443, %nu%r$ (:+ (':= 8obile No) '3:42>:@235

Atty. **T$ !. SAGA;'*'T Roll No) 42332 IP No) 3>4=33 ':;'5;:4 8%nil% PTR No) =@2='=( ':;'5;:4 8%nil% 8#LE #o*pli%nce No) I1,''((==' 8obil No) '3=33:'=25:

Atty. +;D #RA*!'S 1. 8AMBRA*4 Roll No) 4@'3: IP No) '3@(@:4 !# ':;:';:4 PTR No) '2>>23( !# ':;:(;:4 8#LE #o*pli%nce No) I1,'':2='= '>,:',:= Tel No) 5(52==3

P%&e :=)

1R'#'!AT'4* A*D !RT'#'!AT'4* 4# *4*0#4R;M S$4--'*G

9E+ unit o6ners,bu$ers %nd residents of Sorrel Residences+ 6hose n%*es %re 6ritten hereunder decl%re under o%th th%t :)

9e %re the co*pl%in%ntsin the %bo-e,entitled c%se %nd 6e c%used the prep%r%tion of the fore&oin& #o*pl%int?

()

9e re%d %nd understood the content thereof %nd th%t the %lle&%tions therein %re true %nd correct of our o6n person%l
=)

Th%t 6e h%-e not co**enced %n$ %ction or proceedin& before %n$ court+ tribun%l or %n$ other %&enc$ in-ol-in& the s%*e p%rties %nd c%use of %ction+ %nd th%t to the  best of our
IN 9ITNESS 9HEREO/+ 6e h%-e hereunto set our h%nd this .... d%$ of No-e*ber+ (':4 %t !ue"on #it$+ Philippines)

Araceli Daria Sagario Abad

Raymod Reier Salido!adari,

Unified 8ulti,Purpose ID No) #RN,''2''@=:=:@@

Luther Bucud Alvarado,

Sps. Roel& Thelma Albero,

Dri-ers License ID No) N'(,:=,':54(5

Mary Grace AguasAlcao,

Arel Robles Ag,

Dri-ers License ID No) N':,::,':@553

Ma.!ri"elda D. Balta"ar, P%ssport ID No) E2@5>533

$ermeo$eroa Bautista, Dri-ers License No) #'5,'4':(==( @>42(:=,4

vely AlardeBau"o, SSS ID No) ==,=4@(43(,@ ''>',('4@,4

Rosalida #iloteoBaluta, PR# ID No) ':45>2'

Ruther Du%ue Bautista, Unified 8uti,Porpose ID #RN,''==,

Rei Ty Belo, Unified 8uti,Purpose ID No) #RN,''2,

#erdiad M. Bolislis,

'salyAltare(os!ato(os

Li"abeth $elica !atos, P%ssport ID No) E (5:'452

P%&e :>)

Beedic) Mar) *. !ha

+ohy . !hiu, P%ssport ID No) 4'''5'2(

Staley Sioco!hy

Beradette D. !hua,

 Non,Profl Dri-ers license N,'( '5':(=:3

IR ID  :'55>>3(@'''

RomelMagahas !orrea

RochelAaly-ascualDeLa !ru",

PR# ID '''55=3

Profl Dri-ers License N'> ,32=@:535

Marivic!a(umbaDiala,

Geesis -ol T. Domigo,

 Non,Profl Dri-ers License N'(,:4''5553

PR# ID No) ''>=@>(

Billy +ea *ue"Dugo,,

vely /. Ga,

%r%n&%$ ID  :>''3'

U8Purpose ID No) #RN '''=4452>>2

Maria Lourdes -aredes0Garcia

#lordeli"a -. Geslai,

PR# ID  '''>554

Non,Profl Dri-ers License  N'>,'(''>4((

+oatha David Teo Go,

-atric) Bosol Go"ales,

-uo Bosalaga Guilig, +R.,

SSS ID ==3'24(532

#OA ID No) '(4=>>@

Melissa A . $ipol,

Maria 1ictoria . $ipol,

/omida /. $ui, SSS ID  '=,5@24==4,>

+uliet Macuto -adre +ua,

Sps. Arma &Reilda Soriao Layo,

Diae Miles #lores Lim,

PR# ID '@5=2'2

eedy Ta Lim,

Leoides& Geie B. De Lume,

 Non Profl Dri-ers Licence N'>,33>4'((3

PR# ID  ''35=@@

Sps. Bobby & +oaa Siues Lope",

Reato +estreMaago,

PR# ID No) ':'':=4

U8P ID No) ':::('2>@@>2

P%&e :4)

!armilu" !arlos Melo,

Ro2ea & Gilbert De Gu"ma Mercado,

PR# ID  ''''4=@

P%ssport ID No) E 4>>354=

*eea Aisha a2 Go Del Mudo

+oh Meard !ualig *ieto,

P%ssport ID No) E 4'3'34@

SSS ID  ==@@>5=@>@

Sps. #erado & Merly *oble,

Grace 3. 4g,

SSS ID  '=5(@>>(4=

SSS ID  ==:>3'3=33

Sps. Agelo & +oae -abis,

3edy Medo"a -etros,

P%ssport ID  E(:2>5>'

P%ssport ID  E @53'@>2

melie D. -o5Bria Leemar) -o,

Grace #acullo6uioes5Sher2i 6uioes,

P%ssport ID  E>4(4:(>

SSS  ==@@>='2(3

#loreda De Mesa Rie"a53i7red +apitaRie"a 5 3edy A De Mesa Rie"a,

ditha!laveriaRuallo 5 Romulo Rico Ruallo 5 8arah Ageli%ue Ruallo, Unified 8ulti,Purpose ID  #RN,':::,(3:=:5(,=

Dolores Satos Sagalag 5 Arel!abadigSagalag,

Scigate Techology !orp. represeted by Doald DG Sera7i  Non Profl Dri-ers License  N':,:(,':'':2

Richard So 5 Aaly !hua So,

Al7oso AgSy +R.,

U8P ID  #RN,':::,(44@''3,'

Non Profs Dri-ers License  N'>,3(,(=@3(>

Roald Tamayo 5 +ei7er Tamayo,

+e77rey Dee Ta 5 #lorice Mae Buecamio Ta,

Ale:ader 1e"uela Ta,

Mauel Roma Tapoco,

 Non,Profl Dri-ers License No N'>,@>,'4:2@5

PR# ID  '3:45''

P%&e :2)

Susa Thai,

+ohy !hoy Tiu 5 vely Tiu,

 Non,Profl Dri-ers License No) N'5,@>,':2334PR# ID ''==>2:

Tecso;y <=ighua ag>, SSS ID No) ==,4(('@23,2

Deis 1elasco 1illegas, Non,Profl Dri-ers License No) #:',3>,:::((3

1ictoria ri%ue" 1illea,

Sherly Glipo 1iloria, Non,Profl Dri-ers License No) N'>,:=,':5>5'

Audrey Miette Maymay 3og Unified 8ulti,Purpose ID No) #RN,':::,'455''@,4

$ery Lim /ap,

-riscilla -olicarpio /ap, Post%l Identit$ #%rd ID No) '3>:4'(3@=>>

Barry +ames See /u,

#o**ission On Elections ID No) 1IN,=3'2,:(@2'HLY,:''':,@

NI ID No) Y34(5YU'ES''''

+ohso $o /u

Rosalie -adilla 8amora,

 Non,Profl Dri-ers License No) N'>,@(,'':=(>

PhilHe%lth ID No) :('(,:((4254,:

Affi%nts

Affi%nts

SUS#RIED %nd S9ORN to before *e this .... d%$ of No-e*ber + (':4+ %ffi%nts ehibited to *e their &o-ern*ent issued identific%tion c%rd described %bo-e)

Doc) No) ........  P%&e No) ........  oo< No) .......  Series of (':4)