!"#$"%&'( !*++,!"#$% '#%#()*)%+ !"# %&#'" ()**#(+,)* -./# .*.01','
"#$%&''# ()*+,*- . /0123045
!"#$%&'(# *%++,-.
78, 9:,;8 +<**,+-)<* =>?, -8>- @>; ->A)*= BC>+, >- -8, D*)E,:;)-F <9 %/GG,:;9),CG =)E,; -< -8, $<=);-)+; ;-/G,*- > :,>C E);)<* <9 @8>- C<=);-)+;
-)<* +>* H, )* > ;)?/C>-)<* =>?,I J; ">E)G $,>+8 ;->-,GK L78, M:,;8 N<**,+-)<* 8>; H,,* > :,>CCF E>C/>HC, >GG)-)<* -< C F,>: B:<=:>??,O ,*>HC)*= ;-/G,*-; -< ,PB,:)?,*- @)-8 ;/BBCF +8>)* -8,<:F >*G -,+8*)Q/,; G,E,C* >*>CF;); <9 -8, ;-:>-,=)+ ?>*>=,?,*- /*G,:->A, HF -8, L8/GG S 7,>? T3R -8>- 8>; H,,* B>:-)+)B>-)*= -8, =>?,I 78, B>:-)+)B>*-; <9 -8, =>?, @,:, -< ,*G<:;, -8, 9
U/:+8>;)*= "):,+-<:O )* +8>:=, <9 -8, ;/BBC),: ;,C,+-)<* :,=>:G)*= -< C,>G -)?, >*G V/BBCF +8>)* :,Q/):,?,*-
!
V/BBCF N8>)* "):,+-<:O )* +8>:=, <9 BC>**)*= >*G C<=);-)+; G,+);)<* :,=>:G)*= 9<:,+>;-)*=
!
&B,:>-)<* "):,+-<:O )* +8>:=, <9 @>:,8*>=,?,*- >*G H<--C)*= >*G ?)P)*= C)*, <9 B:
!
V>C,; "):,+-<:O )* +8>:=, 9<: +/;-+- >*G G,?>*G 9<:,+>;-)*=
78, ;,C,+-)<* <9 ;-:>-,=F @>; -8, :,;B<*;)H)C)-F <9 -8, N#& )* +8>:=, <9 -8, +<<:G)*>-)<* H,-@,,* -8, G)99,:,*- ;,:E)+,; )* <:G,: -< >+8),E, > B<;)-)E, :,-/:* <* W*E,;-?,*-I
78, :,B<:- @)CC :,E),@ -8, ;-:>-,=F <9 -8, -,>? >*G -8, )?BC)+>-)<* @)-8 -8, +C;< G,>C @)-8 > 9)*>*+)>C >*>CF;); H>;,G <* -8,<:F >*G ,99,+-)E, +8<)+, ->A,* HF -8, -,>?O ,PBC>)*)*= -8, :,>;<* >*G -8, B<;;)HC, )?B:- C,>G -< -8, 9)*>C :*G 9)*>CCF ,PBC>)* )* @8)+8 ,P-,*- -8, 9)*>C :)* >*G >+8),E, > 8)=8,: B,:9<:?>*+, :>-)
6
/01&* #P,+/-)E, ;/??>:F IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII 6 W*-:
7,>? ;-:>-,=F >C)=*?,*-; @)-8 +-,=F IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII 5 >Y
'>)* ;-:>-,=F IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII 5 6Y
#99)+),*- ;-:>-,=)+ ?>*>=,?,*- B:<+,;; IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII 5
TY Z,;B<*;)E, ;-:>-,=)+ ?>*>=,?,*- B:<+,;; IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII 4 HY \Y
V/BBCF +8>)* V-:>-,=F @)-8)* -8, [>?, IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII 4 M)*>C Z*>CF;);K ,99,+- <9 ;/BBCF +8>)* ;-:>-,=F <* 9)*>*+)>C B,:9<:?>*+, IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII ]
>Y
J*>CF;, <9 -8, 9)*>*+)>C ;->-,?,*- IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII ]
HY
#99,+- <* -8, 9)*>*+)>C ;->-,?,*- IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII 1
NY
V/;->)*>HC, )?B:*G :,+-)<* IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII 6X >Y
%<@ -< ;/;->)* > 8)=8 C,E,C <9 ,99)+),*+F^ IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII 65
HY
$<*= -,:? ;-:>-,=F -< >+8),E, H,;- )* +C>;; B,:9<:?>*+, IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII 62
N<*+C/;)<* IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII 6] \)HC)<=:>B8F IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII 63
T
21&-03%$&'01 V-:>-,=)+ ?>*>=,?,*- @)-8)* > C<=);-)+; >*G ;/BBCF +8>)* ?>*>=,?,*- +*F 8>; -< G,>C @)-8 ;,E,:>C +)*I V/BBCF +8>)* ?>*>=,?,*- ); -8, ?>*>=,?,*-8>- ->A,; BC>+, @)-8)* -8, ;/BBCF +8>)* @)-8 -8, >)? -< C)*A >CC <9 -8, +8>)* C)*A -8>- +)*I M:;)*= >+-)E)-),; -< -8, ;>C,; =<)*= -8:-)<*; >*G -8, ;/BBCF +8>)*O ;,E,:>C ;-:>-,=),; +E, H,,* /*G,:->A,*I 78, N#& <9 -8, +*F 8>; -< ->A, G,+);)<* :,=>:G)*= @8>- -< 9<+/; <* _H>;,G <* 9<:,+>;-)*= >*G G,?>*GY >*G -< @8*)`,G -< ,E,:F +/;-*F :,=>:G; -< -8,): G,?>*GY >*G >C;< -8:F)*= >--,*-)<* -< B/-<=,-8,: >CC -8, )*9<:?>-)<* =)E,* HF -8, G)99,:,*- G,B>:-?,*-;I
U/:+8>;)*=
V/BBCF +8>)*
&B,:>b<*;
V>C,;
78, >H:-?,*-; @)-8)* -8, ;/BBCF +8>)*I 78, +-)<* B:<+,;; H,-@,,* -8, G)99,:,*- ,*-)-),; ); <*, <9 -8, +>B)->C );;/,; -8>- +*F 8>E, -< 9>+,;I a)-8)* -8, 9:,;8 +<**,+-)<* =>?,;O -8, >)? <9 -8, ;-:>-,=F @>; -< )?B:*F HF >BBCF)*= -@< -FB,; <9 ;-:>-,=F H>;,G <* -@< -FB,; <9 +8>:>+-,:);-)+K ,99)+),*+FO 9C,P)H)C)-FI J++<:G)*= -< M);8,:O -8, -@< -FB,; <9 ;-:>-,=F -8>- >:, /;,G @)-8)* -8, ;/BBCF +8>)* ?>*>=,?,*- 8>E, G)99,:,*- /;,; -8>- +>* +<::,;B<*G -< G)99,:,*- -FB,; <9 B: G)99,:,*+, )* -,:?; <9 B:C >*G -8, )**-)E, B: F,>: 9<: -8, )**-)E, B:* T F,>:; 9<: -8, 9/*+-)<*>C B:?,O -8, B:HC, ;< )G,*-)9F )*-< -8, )**-)E, B:
X
45 6#,+ *&-,. ,8'71+#1&* 9'&: $0+;#&'&'(# *&-,. ,5 <,'1 *&-,.
J++<:G)*= -< \>CC)* ;-:>-,=F 8>; -8:,, C);, 9:B)->C :,G/+-)<* -8:CC?,O -@< -FB, <9 ;-:>-,=F +A,* -< :,>+8 -8,;, *G ;+)* +>* H, G:)E, -8: +<;- <: -)?, <:),*-,G ;-:>-,=FI J++<:G)*= -< U<:-,:O +GE>*->=, ); > +<:, B<)*- <9 +-,=F _U<:-,:O 6113YO @8,:, )- ++8 -8:G,:;8)B B<;)-)<* <: G)99,:,*-)>-)<* B<;)-)<* @)-8)* -8, ?>:A,-I
=5 !>>'$'#1& *&-,'$ +,1,7#+#1& ;-0$#**
78, ;-:>-,=F H>;,G <* ,99)+),*+F @>; C)*A,G -< -8, G):,+- +<;-; _B/:+8>;)*= >*G B:- +99,+- -8, ?>:A,-I L78, C<@,: -8, G):,+- +<;-;O -8, 8)=8,: -8, ,99)+),*+F ;+<:,;R _78, 9:,;8 +<**,+-)<* =>?,O T06TYI J++<:G)*= -< M);8,:O -8, ,99)+),*+F ;-:>-,=F +>* >C;< H, +>CC,G -8, C,>* ;/BBCF ;-:>-,=F @8,:, -8, :,G/+-)<* <9 @>;-, C,>G -< -8, :,G/+-)<* <9 +<;-;I 78, >)? <9 -8); ;-:>-,=F ); -< ?>A, ;/:, -8>- -8, E>C/, +:,>-,G >*G -8, +<;- >:, ?)*)?);,G E)> -8, ,C)?)*>-)<* <9 @>;-, _d<*;;<*O T003YI 23* #44,(,#*+ '56601 (".,* ,' 7,'+,*-5,'"#7 81 0)*-#& 6&)75(+,)* 0#.79+,/#': ",-" '#+956 ()'+': .*7 0.&-#& 8.+(" ',;#' +".+ .00)< +"# #44,(,#*+ 4,&/ +) 6&)75(# .+ . 0)< 5*,+ ()'+=> _7>FC<: ZI Z>*G>CCO T00XY
78, ,99)+),*+FO )9 )- ); -8, ->:=,-O -8>- -8, +*F -:F -< :,>+8 8>; -< )?BC,?,*- ;,E,:>C C,E,:>=, -< )*9C/,*+, -8, G)99,:,*- G,B>:-?,*- <9 -8, ;/BBCF +8>)* -< =,- )* -+8 <-8,: )* <:G,: -< +:,>-, ;,E,:>C +<**,+-)<* -8>- @)CC ,*>HC, -8, +*F -< ?>A, +<;- :,G/+-)<*I 78); +<;:,G/+-)<* +E, ;,E,:>C 9>+,;O 9:*,*,?BC > H,--,: ;,C,+-)<* <9 -8, ;/BBC),: >*G C,>G -< )?BC,?,*- >* ,99)+),*- ;/BBCF +8>)* ;-:>-,=FI 78, B:)*+)B>C >)? <9 >* ,99)+),*- ;/BBCF +8>)* ?>*>=,?,*- 8>E, >C;< -< G,>C @)-8 +<*-)*/A, ;/:, -8>- -8, <:G,: +CC)*= )*-< ;-<:>=, G);:/B-)<* _N8:);-;, <9 ,99)+),*- ;/BBCF +8>)* ?>*>=,?,*- -8, +GE>*->=, +>* <*CF H, -:>*;C>-,G >; > E>C/, >GE>*->=, @8,:, -8, +*F ); *<- *,+,;;>:F ;,,A)*= 9<: > 8)=8 B:GE>*->=, H/- 9<, > 8)=8 C,E,C <9 ;,:E)+, -8>- @)CC 8,CB -< ,>:* -8, +/;-C-FO >*G -8,* ;,- /B > C<*=S-,:? B>:-*,:;8)BI
5
J++<:G)*= -< M);8,:O -8, -@< -FB,; <9 ;-:>-,=F -8>- >:, /;,G @)-8)* -8, ;/BBCF +8>)* ?>*>=,?,*- 8>E, G)99,:,*- /;,; -8>- +>* +<::,;B<*G -< G)99,:,*- -FB,; <9 B:
(Fisher, 1997) 78, B:E, >* )?B>+- <* -8, G,?>*G -8>- +/;-A,;I 7< >*;@,: -8); G,?>*G -8, ,99)+),*- ;/BBCF +8>)* ?>*>=,?,*- ;-:>-,=F G<,; >*F-8)*= -< ?>P)?);, -8, :,C)>H)C)-F <9 -8, G,C)E,:F -< ,*;/:, > C<*= -,:? B>:-*,:;8)BI a8)C, <* -8, <-8,: ;)G, -8, :,;B<*;)E, ;-:>-,=)+ ?>*>=,?,*- ); -:F)*= -< >+8),E, > 8)=8 C,E,C <9 :,C)>H)C)-F -8:* >G>B->HC, ;/BBCF +8>)* >*G -8, :,G/+-)<* <9 ;-<+A
?5 @#*;01*'(# *&-,'$ +,1,7#+#1& ;-0$#**
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`>-)<* <9 )*E,;-?,*- >C<*= -8, ;/BBCF +8>)* >*G <*CF ;,,A)*= 9<: -8, :,G/+-)<* <9 ;-<+A +<;-I 78, :,;B<*;)E, ;-:>-,=F ); H>;,G <* -8, d/;- )* -)?, +<*+,B- @8,:, -8, +/;-*G >:, C,>G)*= -8, @8*G 8,CB -< >E<)G *G -8, :,;B<*;)E,*,;; <9 -8, +*F -8,* C,>G -< ;,:E)+, C,E,C )?B:- 8>; 9<: ,99,+- > 8)=8,: +/;-C-F _N8:);-
A5 B%;;8. $:,'1 B&-,. 9'&:'1 &:# C,+#
4
78, >)? <9 )* ;-:>-,=F @>; -< :,>+8 -8, ;->=, <9 -8, )*-,=:>-,G ;/BBCF +8>)* @)-8 -8, ?>)* =<>C <9 >+8),E)*= > 8)=8 C,E,C <9 ,99)+),*+F -8:?,O -8, L%/GG 7,>? T3R 8>G 9<: =<>C -< >+8),E, >* ,99)+),*- ;/BBCF +8>)* ;-:>-,=F )* <:G,: -< )?BC,?,*- > C<*= -,:? B>:-*,:;8)B @)-8 -8,): +/;--,=F 8>; H,,* )?BC,?,*-,G >C<*= ;,E,:>C G,+);)<*; ->A,* HF -8, N#& <9 -8, +*F -8:)* ;)G,O -8, ?>)* =<>C @>; -< :,>+8 -8, C<@,: C,E,C <9 ; @,CC <9 -8, 9)*);8,G B:C );;/,; :<;, 9:-)<* H,-@,,* -8, G)99,:,*- 9),CG; <9 -)<* G/:)*= -8, ,>:CF :C G)99,:,*+, H,-@,,* -8, -@< C>;- :E, ;8<@* -8>- >* ,99)+),*;-:>-,=F +A, +8>*=,; <* -8, C<*= -,:? H>;); O @)-8 > G)99,:,*+, <9 g63OX]h )* -8, Z&WI 78>>CC<@; -8, -,>? -< ,*G /B @)-8 > B<;)-)E, :,;/C-I 78::-?,*- -8, -,>? 8>; ?>*>=,G -< :,G/+, ;-<+A +<;- >*G 8>*GC)*= +<;-I ' +<;:,G/+-)<* -< +>B)->C :,G/+-)<* >C;< >+- <* 9C,P)HC, ?>*B<@,: >*G ,*>HC,; -8, +*F -< 9)*);8 -8, + B<;)-)E, -)*= B:<9)-I a)-8)* -8, ;/BBCF +8>)* G,B>:-?,*-O -8, :,G/+-)<* <9 -8, ;-<+A +<;- >*G 8>*GC)*= +<;- 8>; -< H, 8>*GC,G HF -8, ;>9,-F ;-<+A ?>*>=,?,*-I 78, :,C>-)<*;8)B H,-@,,* +/;-*>=,?,*/*G,:->A,* HF -8, ;>C,; G,B>:-?,*- >*G -8, ;/BBCF +8>)* ?>*>=,?,*- >99,+- -8, G,+);)<* -8>- 8>; -< H, ->A,* )* <:G,: -< ?>P)?);, -8, ,99)+),*+F <9 -8, +*FI
2
D5 E'1,8 @0%13 ,1,8.*'*F #>>#$& 0> *%;;8. $:,'1 *&-,. 01 >'1,1$',8 ;#->0-+,1$#
,5 41,8.*# 0> &:# >'1,1$',8 *&,&#+#1&
J 9)*>*+)>C >*>CF;); ); ?>G, :,> @8,:, > +*F ); ,)-8,: B:<9)->HC, <: ,99)+),*-I 78, 9)*>*+)>C >*>CF;); ); =,*,:>CCF /;,G -< G,-,:?)*, )9 -8, +*F ); ;/;->)*)*= 9<: )*E,;-?,*-;I ',>;/:)*= B:<9)->H)C)-F >*G ,99)+),*+F +>* H, G<*, -8::)-)<; +>C+/C>-)<* _ZF>*O T003YI BA
#(%*%&(*+ C'*'0=0%' *+)%: '90 D E)$%. )2 '90 #-0/9 F)%%0&'()% :*=0G
HA
E*'()/ *%*+8/(/G
]
78, 9:- ); ;8<@)*= -8, Z&W _:,-/:* <* )*E,;-?,*-Y <9 -8, %/GG . -,>? T3 >C<*= -8, 2 Z?,K
"#$ 4O00h
0O00h 6
T
X
5
4
2
S4O00h Z&W S60O00h
S64O00h
ST0O00h
W* <:G,: -< )?BC,?,*- >* ,99,+-)E, ;-:>-,=)+ ?>*>=,?,*- >C<*= -8, ;/BBCF +8>)* -8, +*F 8>; -< /;, C,E,:>=, -< >+- <* -8,): Z&WO -8); G)99,:,*- C,E,:>=, 8>; H,,* ,E>C/>-,G -8:-)<; -8>- ,*>HC, -8, +*F -< ?<*)-<: >*G +<*-:?, B,:);- :F,G HF -8, 7,>? T3 8>; H,,* -8, ?<;- B:<9)->HC,I 78); +--:)H/-)*= -< > H,--,: ?>*>=,?,*- <9 -8, G)99,:,*- G,B>:-?,*- >*G >* )*+:,>;, )* +-)<* H,-@,,* -8, ;,:E)+,;I
3
A5 !>>#$& 01 &:# >'1,1$',8 *&,&#+#1&
78, :>-)<* >*>CF;); -8>- 8>; H,,* /*G,:->A,* /;)*= -8, 9)*>*+)>C ;->-,?,*- 8>; H,,* ;,B>:>-,G H,-@,,* -@< G)99,:,*- >:,>;K -8, B:<9)->H)C)-F :>-)<; >*G -8, ,99)+),*+F :>-)<;I BA
I-)2('*;(+('8 E*'()/G
Round
!
"
#
$
%
&
Profitability Ratios Operation margin / net profit ratio (%) Grossprofit ratio (%) Operating ratio (%) ROI(%)
' () **+
' "&) #(+
' "") %,+
' *) "!+
' "") ("+
$-)#%+
#&) &!+
#()#!+
#,)%,+
#!)$#+
$-)#"+
%*)&%+
&#) #*+
&!)&*+
&")$#+
&()%,+
%*)&(+
' &) (&+
' !%) *"+
' !%) #$+
' ,) ##+
' !() -#+
-)#$+
-)#&+
M)*>*+)>C :>-)< -8>- 8>; -< H, +>C+/C>-,G ); C)*A,G -< -8, ,99)+),*+F <9 ,E,:F G,B>:-?,*- -8>+)*O >++<:G)*= -< -8, :,E,*/, -8,F =,*,:>-,G >*G -8, +<;- -8,F 8>G B/- )* BC>+, -< ?>P)?);, -8, :,E,*/, _J-:)CC f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
1
78, *,- B:<9)- :>-)< >*G -8, Z&W ;8<@; > /-)C)`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h
%&'()*+,-,). "*/'
20O00h
&B,:>b<* ?>:=)* i *,B:b< _hY
50O00h [:<;;B:b< _hY T0O00h &B,:>b*= :>b< _hY 0O00h 6
T
X
5
4
2
Z&W _hY
ST0O00h
S50O00h
HA
J22(&(0%&8 E*'()/G
78, ,99)+),*+F :>-)< ;8<@ -8>- -8, ,>:*)*= <9 -8, +*F +:,G -< -8, +>B)->C -8>- 8>; H,,* ,?BC; H,,* 9<: ,*8>*+)*= -8, /-)C);>-)<* <9 -8, ;/BBCF +8>)*I
J* ,*8>*+,G
,99,+-)E,*,;; HF >G>B-)*= -8, ?,>*; <9 B:*GO >*G > H,--,: ?>*>=,?,*- <9 ;-<:>=, +<;-O H/- >C;< > H,--,: ?>*>=,?,*- <9 ;>C,; >*G B/:+8>;,;I #>+8 G,B>:-?,*- @)-8)* -8, +*F +>* ?>*>=, 8); <@* ,99)+),*+F :,C>-,G -< -8, :,E,*/, _J-:)CC f '+$>*,FO T003YI 78, B:-)< ;8<@ -8>- B:E, H,,* ,*8>*+,G -8:=)*= <* -8, ,?BC-)<; ); ;8<@)*= >* +<*;)G,:>HC, )?B:C<*= -8, =>?, B,:):G)*= >- -8, G)99,:,*+, H,-@,,* :*G 2I
60
78, +<;- :,G/+-)<* 8>; H,,* ,99,+-)E, :,=>:G)*= -8, L&E,:9C<@ :>@ ?>-,:)>C; @>:,8*G L&E,:9C<@ 9)*);8,G =<:,8- 8>; H,,* :,G/+, HF T3h >*G XXhI 78, +<;- <9 ;+:>B B:; >C;< H,,* )?B: :,G/+-)<* <9 63hI 78, ;-<+A :>-)< -8>- +>C+/C>-, -8, :,C>-)<* H,-@,,* ;-<+A +<;- >*G :,E,*/,; ;8<@ -8>- -8, +<*-:)* ?>*>=,?,*- @)CC ?>G, -8, +*F ?<:, ,99,+-)*= HF )*9C/,*+)*= > :,G/+-)<* <9 +<;- >*G =,*,:>-)*= -)<*>C )*+:G)*= -8, +<*-:>+- +<;- -8>- 8>; H,,* :/* ?, B,:); H,,* -<->C @)-8 > B,:9,+- ?>*>=,?,*- -8>- C,G -< > 0I00h
X0O00h
0(1,231. &*/'
T4O00h
U:
");-:)H/b<* _hY JG?)*);-:b<* _hY
64O00h
V-<+A_hY 60O00h
%>*GC)*=_hY N<*-:>+-_hY
4O00h 0O00h 6
T
X
5
4
2
78, B:)<:)-);>-)<* <9 +/;-; >C;< 8,CB -< -8, :,G/+-)<* <9 +<;- >*G ->A)*= ?<:, G,->)C <* Q/>C)-F B:-)<*;I
66
78, ;/BBCF +8>)* ?>*>=,?,*- -8>- 8>; H,,* /*G,:->A,* HF -8, -,>? T3 8>; ;8<@* -8>- >* ,99)+),*- ;-:>-,=F ); H>;,G <* > C<*= -,:? B,:;B,+-)E,O ,E,* )9 -8, B:?, >:, ;8<:C)9, +F+C, >*G > :,;B<*;)E, ;-:>-,=F @)CC H, ?<:, >++/:>-, _\:,>C,FO ,- >CIO T001YI 78, 9HC, ); =)E)*= -8, B<;)-)<* -8>- 7,>? T3 8>; -:F)*= -< :,>+8 >*G )- >+-/>C B<;)-)<*K
Functional Products Efficient Supply Chain
Responsive Supply Chain
Match
Mismatch
Innovative Products
Mismatch
Match
Fig. 2. Matching supply chains with product characteristics (Source: Fisher, 1997).
6T
/5 B%*&,'1,A8# '+;-0(#+#1& ,13 -#$0++#13,&'01 J++<:G)*= -< 7>FC<: ZI Z>*G>CCO Z/;A)* 'I '<:=>*O >*G JCF;;, ZI '<:-<* @)-8)* > dC <9 B:-)<* ?>*>=,?,*-O -8, ;/BBCF +8>)* ;-:>-,=F -8>- >:, ;,,A)*= 9<: +GE>*->=, >:, ?<:, C)A,CF ,*-,:)*= -8, ?>:A,- @)-8)* >* :,;B<*;)E, H>;,G ;-:>-,=F -< -8,* +<*-)*/, <* -8, ,99)+),*- ?:>*-,, > +GE>*->=, >*G -< ;,- /B > CC-F :,=>:G)*= +/;--,=F _7>FC<: ZI Z>*G>CCO T00XYI 78, 9-)<* H,-@,,* -8, ;/BBCF +8>)* C,E,:>=, >*G -8,): )?B>+- <* -8, Z&W <9 > +*FK
"#$%&'()*$+%, -../0
6X
,5 G09 &0 *%*&,'1 , :'7: 8#(#8 0> #>>'$'#1$.H
V/BBCF +8>)* 8>; -< H, ;,,* >; > @8; ?/C-)BC, B>:- -8>- )*-,:>+- <*+, )* > @8)C,I a)-8)* -8, ;/BBCF +8>)* ?>*>=,?,*- -8, G)99,:,*- ;,:E)+,; 8>; -< ?<*)-<: -8,): >+-)E)-),; -< G,-,:?)*, )9 -8,): ;,+-<: ); G<)*= =<-)<; -8>- 8>E, H,,* +>C+/C>-,G )* -8, B:,E))* ;-:>-,=F B:<9)->H)C)-F >*G ,99)+),*+F -8>- C,G -< ?>P)?);, -8, Z&WI 78, 9B8 ); ;8<@)*= -8, ,E
(Christopher, 2004) 78C ;-:>-,=),; > +*F +>* >BB:>);, >*G ?>)*->)* > 8)=8 C,E,C <9 +GE>*->=, >?<*=;- -8,): +:A)*= @8)+8 +; +<*-)*/*G ?,>;/:,?,*- <9 -8, B:*G B:<+,;; >C<*= -8, ;/BBCF +8>)* ); <*, <9 -8, ,P>?BC,; <9 -8, ;/BBCF +8>)* ?>*>=,?,*-I k,-O -< ?>*>=, @)-8 >* ,99)+),*- ;/BBCF +8>)* -8, +*F 8>; -< ?<*)-<: -8,): B:)+, >GE>*->=,O B:-)<* >*G B:)+, +-)<* <9 :>-)<; ;/+8 >; :>-)<; C)*A,G -< -8, +<;- +)* >*G ,*8>*+, H/;)*,;; )* > @>F -8>- -8,F >:, >HC, -< +>C+/C>-, -8, B>:- <9 -8, +<;-; -8>- ); +*+)>C >*>CF;); 8>; C)?)- >*G +- -8, +*F ); G<)*= @,CC <: *<-O V/BBCF +8>)* G):,+-<:; >*G <-8,: ?,?H,: <9 -8, +*F 8>E, -< 9)*G - -8, :>-)<; >:, ;>F)*=O -8,F >:, <*CF +<*;,Q/,*+,; 8,CB)*= -< 9)*G -8, +>/;,I
65
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
64
A5 I017 &#-+ *&-,. &0 ,$:'#(# A#*& '1 $8,** ;#->0-+,1$#
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attorna, 2006) I &* -8, ;>C,; G,B>:-?,*- B,:;B,+-)E, )- @)CC H, >BB:-, -< ?<:, -< 9<+/; <* +/;--)<*O -8:; J\N ?,-8*G -< )?BC,?,*- >++/:>-, 9<:,+>;-)*= -< :,G/+, -8, ?>:=)* <9 ,::<: -8>- -8, B:E, -< G,>C @)-8I 78, ;/BBCF +8>)* G,B>:-?,*- @)CC 8>E, -< :,CF <* 9<:,+>;-)*= >*G B/:+8>;)*= -< )?BC,?,*>* >++/:>-, :,BC,*);8?,*- <9 -8, ;-<+A HF @<:A)*= +C<;,: @)-8 -8, -)<*; )* +8>:=, <9 @>:,8+,; >*G +;-, -8>- +E, H,,* ?>G, )* <:G,: -< )*+:,>;, -8, 6
C,>* ?>*>=,?,*- >++/:>+FI 78, )?BC,?,*->-)<* <9 ;)P ;)=?> ;-:>-,=F <:),*-,G @)CC >C;< C,>G -< > :,G/+-)<* <9 +<;- -8:;-, ,C)?)*>-)<* @)-8 > +<*-)*/
78, )?BC,?,*->-)<* <9 ;F;-,? ;/+8 >; +<*-)*/C+/C>-)<* <9 :,<:G,: B<)*-O #&l _#+<**-)-FYO @E, > =:,>-,: )?B>+- <* -8, ?>*>=,?,*- <9 -8, ;/BBCF +8>)* ,99)+),*+F HF >E<)G)*= ;-<+A *G
6
LV)P ;)=?> ); > B8)C<; 9<+/; <* ,C)?)*>-)*= G,9,+-; -8:?,*->C B:<+,;; A*<@C,G=,I V)P ;)=?> ?,-8-, B:)*+)BC,; <9 H/;)*,;;O ;->-);-)+; >*G ,*=)*,,:)*= -< >+8),E, ->*=)HC, :,;/C-;IR _V)P ;)=?> ;F;-,?O T06TY
62
/01$8%*'01 78, 9:,;8 +<**,+-)<* =>?, @>; >* )*-,:,;-)*= >*G ;-)?/C>-)*= ++8 <*, <9 -8, B>:-)+)B>*-; +C @)-8 -8, G)99,:,*- B<;)-)<* @)-8)* > 9:,;8 9:/)- +*FI V/+8 ;)?/C>-)<* <9 ?>*>=,?,*- >CC<@; ;-/G,*- -< H, >HC, -< ;,, 8<@ > +*F ); @<:A)*= )* -)?, +<*;/?)*= ,*E):<*?,*- >*G @8,:, >HC, -< <:=>*);, -8,?;,CE,; >:*F *G B<;)-)<*;I V-:>-,=)+ ;/BBCF +8>)* ?>*>=,?,*- ,*+C<;, > @)G, :>*=, <9 ;-:>-,=)+ );;/,;O >H H/;)*,;; )* >G ,Q/>-)<* -< @8)+8 B:*G >*G -< -8, )*-,:*>Ci,P-,:*>C 9>+-<:;I \/;)*,;;,; >:, :,;-:>)*- -< -@< ?>)* Q/>C)-),;K -)?, >*G +<;-;m >*G ;-:>-,=F >:, )* C)*, @)-8 -8,? HF -:F)*= -< ,*8>*+,G <: :,G/+, -8,? -< ?>A, +*F B:<;B,:*G +?<*=;- <-8,:;I J; ;->-,G )* V-:>-,=F >*>CF;); >*G B:>+-)+, H<?BC, <9 a>8>8> +*F ;8<@ -8>-8, ?>*>=,?,*- ;-:>-,=F @)-8)* > ;?>CC ;<9- G:)*A +*F +>* >+-/>CCF +*- <9 -8, )*G/;-:F ;/+8 >; N<+>SN +*F >*G U,B;)N< (John, et al., 2005) I
78, ;-:>-,=F ); -8, >:- <9 ->A)*= >GE>*->=, <9 <:=>*);>-)<* <9 -8, ;-:/+-/:, >*G >+-)*= <* -8, ,P-,:*>C 9>+-<:; -< E>C/>-, -8, +*F >;;,-; >- -8,): H,;-I
6]
D'A8'07-,;:. J-:)CCO UI f '+$>*,FO #IO T003I 7&&)$%'(%: *%. 2(%*%&0 2)- %)%:;<* #G/+-)<* $)?)-,GI \>CC:;<* #G/+>-)<* W*-,:*>-)<*>CI \:,>C,FO ZIO 'F,:;O VI f '>:+/;O JIO T001I M/*G>?,*->C <9 +<:B<:>-, 9)*>*+,I W*K ;ICIK'+[:>@S %)CCiW:E)*O BBI U>:- 5 S M)*>*+)*=iU>:- 2 S M)*>*+)>C >*>CF;); >*G BC>**)*=I N8>*=:/) Z,*O dI "I %I "I >I aI aIO T002I 7 CFOE)-@ 2)- C$,,+8 F9*(%A n&*C)*,o JE>)C>HC, >-K 8--B;Kii/*)C,>:*I8/GI>+I/Ai@,H>BB;iB<:->Ci9:>?,;,-Ic;B^->Hp->Hp=:BB; hTMHC>+AH<>:GhTM,P,+/-,hTMC>/*+8,:hXM-FB,hX"N:+8 T06ToI N8:);-:;<* ,G/+>-)<* $)?)-,GI N8:);-**I M);8,:O 'I $IO 611]I P9*' (/ '90 -(:9' /$,,+8 &9*(% 2)- 8)$- ,-).$&'Q5 ;ICIK ;I*I [>--<:*>O dIO T002I L(4(%: C$,,+8 &9*(%/G 9)> ') =);(+(?0 '90 0%'-0,-(/0 *-)$%. .0+(40-(%: >9*' 8)$&$')=0-/ >*%'A ;ICIKU>,:;<* ,G/+>-)<* C)?)-,GI d<8*O 'IO %<@>:GO 7I f ">E)G O aIO T004I C'-*'0:8G 7%*+8/(/ R I-*&'(&0A ;ICIK'+[:>@S%)CC #G/+>-)<*I d<*;;<*O UIO T003I L):(/'(&/ *%. /$,,+8 &9*(% =*%*:0=0%'A ;ICIK'+[:>@S%)C #G/+>-)<*CI $F*+8O ZIO T001I C'-*'0:(& =*%*:0=0%'A %>:C<@K U,>:;<* #G/+>-)<* $)?)-,GI U,::,-O MISCIO d>99,/PO NIO M,*G,:O 'I f a),;,:O UIO T00]I J//0%'(*+/ )2 +):(/'(&/ *%. =*%*:0=0%'A ;ICIKNZN U:,;;I U<:-,:O 'I #IO 6113I S90 F)=,0'('(40 7.4*%'*:0A n&*C)*,o JE>)C>HC, >-K 8--BKiiH<=,fQf9q9>C;, nJ++,;;,G T4 M,H:/>:F T06ToI ZF>*O \IO T003I #(%*%&0 *%. *&&)$%'(%: 2)- ;$/(%0//A ;ICIKN,*=>=, $,>:*)*=I V)P ;)=?> ;F;-,?O T06TI P9*' (/ /(:=*QA n&*C)*,o JE>)C>HC, >-K 8--BKii@@@I;)P;)=?>;F;-,?;I+-IB8B nJ++,;;,G T '>:+8 T06ToI 7>FC<: ZI Z>*G>CCO ZI 'I 'I >I JI ZI 'IO T00XI #99)+),*- E,:;/; Z,;B<*;)E, V/BBCF N8>)* N8<)+,K J* #?B):)+>C #P>?)*>-)<* <9 W*9C/,*-)>C M>+-<:;I T)$-%*+ )2 ,-).$&' (%%)4*'()% =*%*:0=0%'A 7>FC<: ZI Z>*G>CCO ZI 'I 'I >I JI ZI 'IO T00XI #99)+),*- E,:;/; Z,;B<*;)E, V/BBCF N8>)* N8<)+,K J* #?B):)+>C #P>?)*>-)<* <9 W*9C/,*-)>C M>+-<:;I S90 T)$-%*+ )2 I-).$&' (%%)4*'()% =*%*:0=0%'A
63
78, 9:,;8 +<**,+-)<* =>?,O T06TI U%2)&0%'0- < S90 #-0/9 F)%%0&'()%A n&*C)*,o JE>)C>HC, >-K 8--BKii=>?,I-8,9:,;8+<**,+-)<*I,/iT066iW*9;BP^)-,?A,Fq)*;-:/+-),p;+<:,3 nJ++,;;,G 64 d>**/>:F T06ToI
61
