REPUBLI C OFTHEPHI LI PPI NES THI RD JUDI CI ALREGI ON REGI ONALTRI ALCOURT BRANCH 69 ANGELESCI TY
MARTI N DESI ERTO, ALAN DESI ERTO, and FRANCI S DESI ERTO, Pl ai nt i ffs ,
Ci vi lCaseNo.RANG150 0 5 7 4CV F o r :Annul me nto fSa l ea nd
Rec onv ey anceofReal P r o p e r t y
v e r s us -
RODRI GO DESI ERTO RAMON DOE OE, x -
and
Def endant s. x
COM OMMENTS/OBJECTI ONS TO THE FORMALOFFER OFEXHI BI TS Tot hi sHonor abl eCour t ,t hePl ai nt i ffmos tr es pe ct f ul l y s t at e st hat1.
The Plaintiffs object to the admissibility of “Exhibit 1”, “Exhibit 2” and “Exhibit 3” which were the alleged Identifications of artin, !lan and "rancis #esierto on the the gro$ gro$nd nd that that they they were were not not form formal ally ly offe offere red d d$ri d$ring ng tria triall and and that that the the Identi Identifi ficati cations ons s$bmitt s$bmitted ed by herein herein #efenda #efendant nt were were false false and do not clearl clearly y establish and show to the co$rt, the identity of the herein Plaintiffs artin, !lan and "rancis all s$rnamed #esierto%
2.
The Plaintiffs object to the admissibility of Exhibit & on the gro$nd that the #efense failed to 'ro(e its gen$iness and d$e exec$tion and its legal existence in the records of the )egistry of #eeds%
3.
The Plaintiffs object to the a$thenticity of “Exhibit &*+”, “Exhibit &*” and “Exhibit &*#” on the gro$nd that the #efense failed to offer
4.
The 'laintiffs
PRAYERS:
WHEREFORE,i ti s mostr espect f ul l y pr ayed
t hatt he f or eg oi ng co mment s be consi der ed i nr es ol vi ng t he For mal OfferofExhi bi t sfil edbyt hePr osecut i on. Ange l esCi t y ,Pampanga,Febr uar y15,2016. Mani qui s, Sabado, Sant os& Vi l l ar osaLaw Offices XXX Angel e sCi t y Couns e lf ort hePl ai nt i f
By
xxx ATTY .Kur tEi yanG.Mani q ui s MCLE. XXXXX,PTR XXXX,I BPXXX At t or ne yRol lXXX Mar c h2014
Copyf ur ni shedbyper sonalser vi ce:
CHAN_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
Re g i s t r yRe c e i p tNo .
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
AUF ASSOCI ATESLAW OFFI CES Counse lf ort heDe Def endant XXX
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ _ _ ,2015
REPUBLI C OFTHE PHI LI PPI NES) )S. S. ANGELESCI TY,PAMPANGA VERI FI CATI ON AND CERTI FI CATI ON OFNONFORUM SHOPPI NG
N,ALAN,FRANCI S al lsur name med DESI ERTO, We We MARTI ,
o fl e g alag e ,Fi l i pi noandr e s i de nto A f ngel e sCi t y ,af t erhav i ngbeen dul y swornt oi naccor dancewi t hl aw,doher ebydeposeandst at eTHA HAT: Wear eoneoft hedef endant si nt hei ns t antci vi lcas e; 1. We 2. We We caused t he pr epar at i on and fil i ng oft he sai d Answerwi t h
Affir mat i v eDef ens ewi t hCount er cl ai m; We Wehav er ead and under st ood t hesameand al lt heal l egat i ons 3. t her ei n ar et r ue and cor r ect ,i n good f ai t h,based on ourown per sonalknowl edgeandema manat edf r om aut hent i cr ecor ds; We We 4.
hav e not t her e t of or e commenced any ot her act i on or pr oceedi ngi nvol vi ngt hesame mei ssuesi nt heSupr eme meCour t ,t he Cour tofAppeal s,oranyot hert r i bunaloragency;t ot hebestof ourknowl edge,nosuch act i on orpr oceedi ngi spendi ngi nt he Supr eme meCour t ,t heCour tofAppeal s,oranyot hert r i bunalor agency;i ft her ei sanysuchact i on orpr oceedi ngwh whi chi sei t her pendi ngorma mayhavebeen t er mi nat ed,wewi wi l lst at et hest at us t he r e o f ;andi fwes ho ul dt he r e a f t e rl e ar ne dt hatas i mi l arac t i on orpr oce edi nghasbee n fil ed ori spendi ngbef or et heSupr eme me Cour t ,t heCour tofAppeal s,oranyot hert r i bunaloragency ,We s hal lunde r t aket or e po r tt hef a ctwi t hi n fiv e( 5)da y st he r e f r o m t ot hecour toragencywher ei nt heori gi nalpl eadi ngand sworn
cer t i ficat i oncont emp mpl at edher ei nhavebeenfil ed.
MARTI N DESI ERTO Affiant
ALAN DESI ERTO Affiant
FRANCI SDESI ERTO Affiant
TH
SUBSCRI BED AND SWO WORN TO bef or e me t hi s 10 day of Febr uary2015i nt heAnge l esCi t y ,Pampanga,byher ei naffi ffia ant swhoar e per sonal l y known t o me t o be t he s am me e per s ons who e xe cut ed t he f or egoi ngandunder st oodt hesame me.
