Corpus vs Grospe

CORPUS VS GROSPE GR NO 135297 PANGANIBAN, J.

FACTS: Petitione G!"ino Co#$% &!' ! (!)e*+ene-i! $n/e t0e O#e!tion !n/  T!n'(e  T!n'(e OT OT Po4!) Po4!) o( t0e e#!t)ent o( A4!i!n Re(o) Re(o) AR. P$'$!nt P$'$!nt to Pe'i/enti!6 e-ee P No. 27, 0e &!' i''$e/ ! Ceti-!te o( !n/ T!n'(e CT o"e t&o #!-e6' o( !4i-$6t$!6 6!n/. T0e 6ot' &ee (o)e6 o&ne/ + ! -et!in F6oentino C0io-o !n/ e4i'tee/ $n/e Tit6e No. 1238.  To  To #! (o 0i' &i(e' 0o'#it!6i%!tion, 0o'#it!6i%!tion, #etitione )ot4!4e/ t0e '$+e-t 6!n/ on in (!"o o( Vi4ini! /e eon. 0en t0e -ont!-t #eio/ e;#ie/, 0e !4!in )ot4!4e/ it to Re'#on/ent Re'#on/ent ?!'$n/$!n S! P!4#!#!0i!) N4 $#!n4 S!@!0!n,>&0i-0 !66o&e/ t0e e'#on/ent' to $'e o -$6ti"!te t0e 6!n/ /$in4 t0e /$!tion o( t0e )ot4!4e. Be(o Be(oe t0e t0e e#! e#!t t)e )ent nt o( A4 A4! !i i!n !n Re(o e(o) ) A/ A/$ $/i /i-! -!ti tion on Bo! Bo!/ / AR ARAB AB in C!+!n!t$!n Cit Re4ion III, #etitione in'tit$te/ !4!in't t0e e'#on/ent' !n !-tion (o e-o"e o( #o''e''ion /$e to t0e (!-t t0!t t0e 6!tte 0!/ entee/ t0e /i'#$te/ 6!n/ + (o-e !n/ inti)i/!tion on !n/ /e'toe/ t0e #!6! t0!t 0e 0!/ #6!nte/ on t0e 6!n/. A' #e t0e e'#on/ent', e'#on/ent', #etitione !66o&e/ !66o&e/ t0e (o)e to t!@e t!@e o"e t0e #o''e''ion #o''e''ion !n/ -$6ti"!tion o( t0e #o#et $nti6 t0e 6!tte #!i/ 0i' 6o!n. In'te!/ o( #!in4 0i' 6o!n, #etitione !66e4e/6 e;e-$te/! >!i"e >!i"e o( Ri40t'> o"e t0e 6!n/0o6/in4 in (!"o o( e'#on/ent' in -on'i/e!tion o( P5,39. Petitione /enie/ t0i'. ISSUE: 1. ON t0e &!i"e o( 6!n/ e(o) i40t' in (!"o o( t0e S!)!0!n4 N!on i' "!6i/. NO 2. ON t0ee &!' "o6$nt! '$en/e on t0e #!t o( t0e #etitione. ES RUING: 1. NO. T0e Co$t 0!' !6e!/ $6e/ t0!t t0e '!6e o t!n'(e o( i40t' o"e ! #o#et -o"ee/ + ! Ceti-!te o( !n/ T!n'(e i' "oi/ e;-e#t &0en t0e !6ien!tion i' )!/e in (!"o o( t0e 4o"en)ent o t0o$40 0ee/it! '$--e''ion. T0i' $6in4 i' inten/e/ to #e"ent ! e"e'ion to t0e o6/ (e$/!6 ''te) in &0i-0 t0e 6!n/o&ne' e!-$ie/ "!'t t!-t' o( 6!n/, t0$' ne4!tin4 t0e 4o"en)ent' #o4!) o( (eein4 t0e ten!nt (o) t0e +on/!4e o( t0e 'oi6. 2. ES. T0e n$66it o( t0e !i"e /oe' not '!"e t0e -!'e (o 0i) +e-!$'e t0ee i' ! -6e! -6e! '0o&in4 '0o&in4 t0!t 0e "o6$nt! "o6$nt!i6 i6 '$en '$en/e /ee/ e/ 0i' 6!n/0o6/i 6!n/0o6/in4 n4 to t0e S!)!0!n4 S!)!0!n4

N!on &0i-0 )! $!6i( !' ! '$en/e o t!n'(e, to t0e 4o"en)ent, o( 0i' i40t' $n/e t0e !4!i!n 6!&'. A' #e P 27, tit6e to 6!n/ !-$ie/ #$'$!nt to t0e 6!n/ e(o) #o4!) '0!66 not +e t!n'(e!+6e e;-e#t t0o$40 0ee/it! '$--e''ion o to t0e 4o"en)ent, in !--o/!n-e &it0 t0e #o"i'ion' o( e;i'tin4 6!&' !n/ e4$6!tion'. Se-tion 8 o( RA 38 !6'o #o"i/e' t0!t >Dt0e !4i-$6t$!6 6e!'e0o6/ e6!tion ;;; '0!66 +e e;tin4$i'0e/ +: ;;; 2 D"o6$nt! '$en/e o( t0e 6!n/0o6/in4 + t0e !4i-$6t$!6 6e''ee, ;;;.> In t0i' -!'e, #etitione' intention to '$en/e t0e 6!n/0o6/in4 &!' -6e! !n/ $ne$i"o-!6.