NXPAEIK [B@KX XKSAKT - @G BGP EAPK GX EAXE[INPK TAPFG[P ZKXMAUUAGB
U[HMAUUAGB PG INBEKP Z[HIAE FKNIPF
Efnbdks ab tfk prkvnikbek gc vnpabd nb` smglabd nmgbd ygutf ab Enbn`n, Kbdinb` nb` tfk [batk` Utntks. @nva` Fnmmgb`, Zf@ >*< Okssaen I. Xka`, MUe >< Saela I. Xybnr`, MUe >< Dkgccrky P. Cgbd, 5
0
0
Zf@>,8
< L. Maefnki
;
Eummabds, Zf@ < Nbb MeBkaii, Zf@ < Unrn Fatefmnb, Zf@ < Onmks C. Pfrnsfkr, Zf@ < Mneako Dgbakwaez, Zf@3, Mnnbsa Hnbsni-Prnvkrs, Zf@ 3< Xaefnr` G'Egbbgr, Zf@ 3< @nva` Ikvy, Zf@ 4< Xgb Hgrinb`, Zf@ 6< Efrastabk M. Tfatk, MUe > *Egrrkspgb`abd nutfgr N``rkss? 8:: [bavkrsaty Nvk T, Tntkrigg, GB, Enbn`n B8I 5D> Kmnai? `fnmmgb`Juwntkrigg.en `fnmmgb`Juwntkrigg.en<< Pki? +>-;>1-666-0;34 x 53038 Nccaiantagb(s)? >
Uefggi gc Zuhiae Fknitf & Fknitf Uystkms, [bavkrsaty gc Tntkrigg, Tntkrigg, Gbtnrag, Enbn`n<
8
@kpnrtmkbt gc Zsyefgigdy, [bavkrsaty gc Tntkrigg, Tntkrigg, Gbtnrag, Enbn`n nb` Gbtnrag Abstatutk cgr Enbekr Xksknref, Pgrgbtg, Gbtnrag, Enbn`n
5
Mk`aeni [bavkrsaty gc Ugutf Enrgiabn, Efnrikstgb, Ugutf Enrgiabn, [UN<
0
Labd‑s Egiikdk Igb`gb, Igb`gb, [b atk` Labd`gm<
;
@kpnrtmkbt gc Fknitf Zrgmgtagb, K`uentagb, nb` Hkfnvagr, [bavkrsaty gc Ugutf Enrgiabn, Egiumhan, Ugutf Enrgiabn, [UN<
3
Xgswkii Znrl Egmprkfkbsavk Enbekr Ekbtkr, Huccnig, Bkw Qgrl, [UN<
NXPAEIK [B@KX XKSAKT - @G BGP EAPK GX EAXE[INPK TAPFG[P ZKXMAUUAGB
NHUPXNEP
HNELDXG[B@? Ab Mny 8:>6, Enbn`n n`gptk` mgrk pkrmassavk vnpabd rkduintagbs. N bkw dkbkrntagb gc
baegtabk snit-hnsk` k-eadnrkttks, suef ns O[[I, wfaef `kiavkr fadfkr egbekbtrntagbs gc baegtabk nisg kmkrdk` ab 8:>6. Pfkrk as iattik ergss-egubtry kva`kbek kxnmababd tfk ampnet gc `acckrkbt rkduintgry crnmkwgrls nb` mnrlkt efnbdks gb vnpabd nmgbd ygutf, pnrtaeuinriy ab tfk egbtkxt gc smglabd rntks. MKPFG@U? Xkpknt ergss-sketagbni survkys wkrk egb`uetk` gbiabk watf bntagbni snmpiks gc >3- tg >1-yknr-gi`s
ab 8:>4 nb` 8:>6, rkeruatk` crgm egmmkreani pnbkis ab Enbn`n (b=4,61>), Kbdinb` (b=4,654), nb` tfk [U (b=6,>0:). Pfk prkvnikbek gc vnpabd nb` smglabd wns nsskssk` cgr ‖kvkr usk‑, pnst 5: -`nys, pnst wkkl, nb` >;+ `nys pkr mgbtf. Igdastae rkdrkssagb mg`kis kxnmabk` efnbdks ab vnpabd nb` smglabd hktwkkb egubtraks nb` gvkr tamk. CAB@ABDU? Pfk prkvnikbek gc vnpabd ab tfk pnst 5: `nys, vnpabd ab tfk pnst wkkl, nb` vnpabd >;+ `nys pkr
mgbtf aberknsk` ab Enbn`n nb` tfk [U hktwkkb 8:>4 nb` 8:>6 (p9.:::> cgr nii), abeiu`abd nmgbd bgb-smglkrs nb` kxpkramkbtni smglkrs, watf bg efnbdks ab Kbdinb`. Umglabd prkvnikbek aberknsk` ab Enbn`n (p9.::> cgr nii), watf mg`kst aberknsks ab Kbdinb`, nb` bg efnbdks ab tfk [U. Pfk pkrekbtndk gc ‖kvkr vnpkrs‑ wfg rkpgrtk` mgrk crkqukbt vnpabd aberknsk` ab Enbn`n nb` tfk [U, rkintavk tg Kbdinb` (Z9.:> cgr nii). ABPKXZXKPNPAGB? Pfk prkvnikbek gc vnpabd aberknsk` nmgbd Enbn`anb nb` [U ygutf, nigbd watf
suhstnbtani aberknsks ab smglabd nmgbd Enbn`anb ygutf, watf ckw efnbdks ab Kbdinb`. Pfk ampnet gc rkduintgry efnbdks nb` kmkrdkbek gc baegtabk snit-hnsk` k-eadnrkttks gb vnpabd nb` smglabd wnrrnbts skragus egbsa`krntagb. Nhstrnet wgr` egubt? 8;:
NXPAEIK [B@KX XKSAKT - @G BGP EAPK GX EAXE[INPK TAPFG[P ZKXMAUUAGB
ABPXG@[EPAGB Snpabd rkprkskbts n ikss fnrmcui mg`k gc baegtabk `kiavkry tfnb abfniabd smglk crgm egmhustahik eadnrkttks. > Kstnhiasfk` smglkrs wfg swatef tg vnpabd fnvk tfk pgtkbtani tg rk`uek tfkar fknitf rasls< fgwkvkr, tfkrk nrk wa`ksprkn` egbekrbs tfnt vnpabd mny ub`krmabk tfk rk`uetagbs ab ygutf smglabd ghskrvk` ab mgst Tkstkrb mnrlkts. mnrlkts.>
Xkduintgry crnmkwgrls cgr vnpabd prg`uets egbtabuk tg kvgivk ns egubtraks skkl n hninbek hktwkkb `asegurndabd vnpabd nmgbd bgb-smglkrs watfgut `asegurndabd eurrkbt smglkrs crgm swatefabd tg vnpabd. 8 Ab Mny 8:>6, Enbn`n ampikmkbtk` mgrk pkrmassavk vnpabd pgiaeaks ns pnrt gc tfk Pghneeg nb` Snpabd Zrg`uets Net .5 Zrkvagusiy, baegtabk-egbtnababd baegtabk-egbtnababd k-eadnrkttks egui` bgt hk sgi` ab Enbn`n watfgut prk-mnrlkt npprgvni cgr snik gr mnrlktabd. Nitfgudf bg prg`uets fn` hkkb npprgvk` cgr ikdni snik, k -eadnrkttks wkrk wa`kiy nvnainhik ab vnpk sfgps nb` gbiabk, ab n``atagb tg bgb-baegtabk k-eadnrkttks crgm trn`atagbni rktnai gutikts. 0 Ab Mny 8:>6, baegtabkegbtnababd k-eadnrkttks hkenmk ikdniiy nvnainhik cgr snik, watf nb ammk`antk aberknsk ab tfkar nvnainhaiaty ab egbvkbtagbni rktnai gutikts, ns wkii ns tfk abtrg`uetagb gc mnogr abtkrbntagbni hrnb`s, suef ns O[[I nb` Sypk. Pfk bkw Net nisg pkrmats drkntkr n`vkrtasabd nb` prgmgtagb gc vnpabd prg`uets, abeiu`abd mnss mk`an n`vkrtaskmkbts nb` pgabt-gc-snik `aspinys, ubikss prgfahatk` prgfahatk` nt tfk prgvabeani ikvki. Gvkrnii, tfk vnpabd mnrlkt ab Enbn`n kxpkrakbek` rnpa` efnbdk, hrabdabd at eigskr tg mgrk pkrmassavk rkduintgry skttabds ab egubtraks suef ns Kbdinb` nb` tfk [U, watf wa`ksprkn` rktnai nvnainhaiaty gc vnpabd prg`uets. Hgtf egubtraks pkrmat mnrlktabd gc vnpabd prg`uets, nitfgudf tg n muef iksskr kxtkbt ab tfk Kbdinb` egmpnrk` tg tfk [U, wfaik k-eadnrkttks fnvk nisg hkkb abtkdrntk` ab smglabd ekssntagb skrvaeks ab Kbdinb`. ; Pfkrk as rkintavkiy iattik kva`kbek gc tfk ampnet gc `acckrkbt rkduintgry npprgnefks gb tfk prkvnikbek gc vnpabd. Nmgbd n`uits, prkiamabnry kva`kbek suddksts tfnt mgrk rkstraetavk mknsurks mny hk nssgeantk` watf igwkr prkvnikbek gc vnpabd, nitfgudf nitfgudf tfkrk nrk bgtnhik kxekptagbs, kxekptagbs, pgssahiy `uk tg igw igw egmpianbek watf rkduintagbs rkduintagbs ab 3,4 mnby ‖rkstraetavk‑ mnrlkts. Gbk stu`y gc ma``ik nb` fadf sefggi stu`kbts kxnmabk` `acckrkbeks hktwkkb tfk Xkpuhiae gc Lgrkn nb` tfk [batk` Utntks, cab`abd igwkr rntks gc hgtf vnpabd nb` smglabd ab Lgrkn, wfkrk vnpabd rkduintagbs nrk strgbdkr. 6 Pg `ntk, fgwkvkr, tfkrk as nimgst bg kva`kbek egmpnrabd ygutf vnpabd nergss egubtraks watf `acckrkbt rkduintgry crnmkwgrls.
NXPAEIK [B@KX XKSAKT - @G BGP EAPK GX EAXE[INPK TAPFG[P ZKXMAUUAGB
Pfkrk as nb urdkbt bkk` tg kxnmabk wfktfkr ygutf vnpabd mny hk sfactabd ab rkspgbsk tg efnbdks ab tfk `ksadb gc vnpabd prg`uets nb` tfk kmkrdkbek gc baegtabk snit-hnsk` tkefbgigdy. Gvkr tfk pnst yknr, O[[I fns kmkrdk` ns tfk `gmabnbt vnpabd hrnb` ab tfk [U mnrlkt. >6 O[[I usks hkbzgae nea` nb` baegtabk snit tkefbgigdy tg `kiavkr vkry fadf egbekbtrntagbs gc baegtabk. >1 Nitfgudf O[[I eurrkbtiy neegubts cgr tfk mnograty gc tfk vnpabd mnrlkt ab tfk [U, gtfkr ikn`abd hrnb`s fnvk nisg abegrpgrntk` baegtabk snit-hnsk` tkefbgigdy. Kmkrdabd rksknref suddksts tfnt tfksk vnpabd prg`uets mny hk nssgeantk` watf drkntkr crkqukbey nb` abtkbsaty gc vnpabd, nb` nrk >1,8:,8> pnrtaeuinriy pgpuinr nmgbd nmgbd ygubd pkgpik. pkgpik .>1,8:,8> Pfk eurrkbt stu`y egmpnrk` efnbdks hktwkkb 8:>4 nb` 8:>6 ab tfk prkvnikbek gc vnpabd nb` eadnrkttk smglabd nmgbd >3 - >1 yknr-gi`s ab Enbn`n, Kbdinb`, nb` tfk [U. Pfas ndk drgup enpturks n suhstnbtani prgpgrtagb gc hgtf vnpabd nb` smglabd smglabd abatantagb abatantagb ab nii tfrkk egubtraks .;,1 Ab pnrtaeuinr, tfk stu`y kxnmabk` wfktfkr tfk rkduintgry efnbdks ampikmkbtk` ab Enbn`n ab 8:>6 wkrk nssgeantk` watf efnbdks ab smglabd gr vnpabd. Nitfgudf bg mnogr rkduintgry efnbdks wkrk ampikmkbtk` ab Kbdinb` gr tfk [U gvkr tfk snmk pkrag`, tfk inrdkst aberknsks ab sniks gc O[[I geeurrk` hktwkkb 8:>4 nb` 8:>6. O[[I hkenmk nvnainhik cgr snik ab tfk Kbdinb` mnrlkt ab Ouiy 8:>6, nb` Ukptkmhkr 8:>6 ab Enbn`n, nitfgudf tfk uptnlk gc O[[I nmgbd ygutf fns hkkb igwkr ab Kbdinb` tfnb Enbn`n. Enbn`n .8> @uk tg tfk egmhabntagb gc rkduintgry efnbdks nb` O[[I abtrg`uetagb ab Enbn`n, wk fypgtfksazk` tfnt tfk drkntkst aberknsks ab vnpabd wgui` geeur ab Enbn`n, cgiigwk` hy tfk [U watf tfk fadfkst pkbktrntagb gc O[[I, O[[I, watf tfk iknst efnbdk ab Kbdinb`. Kbdinb`. MKPFG@U @ntn sgurek @ntn nrk crgm Tnvk > nb` Tnvk 8 gc tfk Abtkrbntagbni Pghneeg Egbtrgi Zgiaey Kvniuntagb Zrgoket (APE) Qgutf Pghneeg nb` Snpabd Uurvky, egb`uetk` ab Enbn`n, Kbdinb`, nb` tfk [batk` Utntks. Gbiabk survkys wkrk egb`uetk` ab Ouiy/Nudust 8:>4 (Tnvk >) nb` Nudust/Ukptkmhkr 8:>6 (Tnvk 8). Xkspgb`kbts ndk` >3 tg >1 wkrk rkeruatk` tfrgudf Bakiskb Egbsumkr Absadfts Dighni Znbki nb` tfkar pnrtbkrs‑ pnbkis, katfkr `arketiy gr tfrgudf tfkar pnrkbts. N cuii `kseraptagb gc tfk stu`y mktfg`s enb hk cgub` ab tfk Pkefbaeni Xkpgrt. 88 Mknsurks Xkspgb`kbts wkrk nslk` ac tfky fn` ’kvkr trak`” nb k-eadnrkttk/vnpk`, tfk bumhkr gc `nys tfky fn` usk` nb keadnrkttk/vnpk` ab tfkar iacktamk, nb` tfk inst tamk tfky usk` nb k-eadnrkttk/vnpk (nbniyzk` ns pnst 5: `nys nb` pnst wkkl). Znrniiki Znrniiki qukstagbs wkrk nslk` cgr ‖eadnrkttk smglabd‑, nb` wkrk usk` tg `kravk ‖kvkr‑, pnst 5: -`ny, pnst wkkl uskrs. Ab n``atagb, n``atagb, rkspgb`kbts wkrk einssacak` einssacak` ns bkvkr smglkrs, kxpkramkbtni smglkrs (smglk` 9>::
NXPAEIK [B@KX XKSAKT - @G BGP EAPK GX EAXE[INPK TAPFG[P ZKXMAUUAGB
Pnhik > sfgw prkskbts tfk snmpik efnrnetkrastaes gc rkspgb`kbts ab knef egubtry. Bg `acckrkbeks wkrk ghskrvk` watfab egubtraks hktwkkb 8:>4 nb` 8:>6, watf tfk kxekptagb tfnt, ab Enbn`n, ckwkr rkspgb`kbts a`kbtacak` ns ‖wfatk gbiy‑ (NGX=:.35, ( NGX=:.35, :.;3-:.48< p9:.:::>), nb` pnst >8-mgbtf enbbnhas usk aberknsk` (NGX=>.55, >.>;>.;0< p9:.:::>). Zrkvnikbek gc vnpabd nb` smglabd Pnhik 8 prkskbts efnbdks ab tfk prkvnikbek gc vnpabd nb` smglabd nergss tfk tfrkk egubtraks. Zrkvnikbek gc nii vnpabd nb` smglabd gutegmks aberknsk` hktwkkb 8:>4 nb` 8:>6 ab Enbn`n. Bg efnbdks wkrk ghskrvk` cgr vnpabd ab Kbdinb`, watf mg`kst aberknsks ab smglabd ab tfk pnst wkkl nb` >;+ `nys pkr mgbtf. Ab tfk [U, tfk prkvnikbek gc vnpabd aberknsk`, aberknsk`, watf bg efnbdks ab smglabd smglabd hkfnvagr. Cgr ‖kvkr ‑, pnst 5: `ny nb` pnst wkkl smglabd nb` vnpabd, efnbdks hktwkkb 8:>4 nb` 8:>6 wkrk sadbacaenbtiy drkntkr ab Enbn`n egmpnrk` tg tfk gtfkr egubtraks (p9.:> cgr nii). Efnbdks ab vnpabd prkvnikbek hy smglabd stntus Pnhik 5 sfgws efnbdks ab vnpabd hy smglabd stntus. Ab Enbn`n, vnpabd aberknsk` crgm 8:>4 tg 8:>6 nmgbd bkvkr smglkrs nb` kxpkramkbtni smglkrs. Ab tfk [U, vnpabd aberknsk` nmgbd bkvkr smglkrs nb` kxpkramkbtni smglkrs, watf tfk kxekptagb gc ‖kvkr vnpabd‑. Bg efnbdks hktwkkb 8:>4 nb` 8:>6 wkrk ghskrvk` hy smglabd stntus ab Kbdinb`, gr nmgbd eurrkbt smglkrs ab nby egubtry. Xntag gc kvkr tg mgrk crkqukbt usk Pnhik 0 sfgws tfk pkrekbtndk gc ‖kvkr‑ vnpkrs wfg rkpgrtk` rkpgrt k` mgrk rkekbt vnpabd. Ab Enbn`n nb` tfk [U, tfk pkrekbtndk gc kvkr vnpkrs wfg rkpgrtk` rkpgrtk` vnpabd ab tfk pnst 5: `nys, tfk pnst wkkl, nb` vnpabd >;+ >;+ `nys ab tfk pnst mgbtf aberknsk` ab 8:>6 8:>6 egmpnrk` tg 8:>4. Bg efnbdks efnbdks wkrk ghskrvk` ab Kbdinb`. Ab 8:>6, 8:>6, ‖kvkr‑ smglkrs ab Enbn`n wkrk nisg mgrk ialkiy tg rkpgrt smglabd ab tfk pnst 5: `nys, wkkl, nb` >;+ `nys ab tfk pnst mgbtf egmpnrk` tg 8:>4, 8:>4 , ‖kvkr‑ smglkrs ab Kbdinb` wkrk mgrk ialkiy tg rkpgrt >;+ `nys ab tfk pnst mgbtf egmpnrk` tg 8:>4, watf bg efnbdks ab tfk [U.
Egmpnrabd `acckrkbeks hktwkkb egubtraks ab 8:>6, kvkr vnpkrs ab tfk [U wkrk mgst ialkiy, nb` kvkr vnpkrs ab tfk [L iknst ialkiy, tg rkpgrt vnpabd ab tfk pnst 5: `nys, wkkl nb` >; gr mgrk `nys ab tfk pnst mgbtf (p9.:> cgr nii) kxekpt tfk [U wns bgt sadbacaenbtiy `acckrkbt crgm Enbn`n (p=:.:>53) cgr vnpabd ab tfk pnst wkkl. Cgr kxnmpik, npprgxamntkiy >;.0% gc nii kvkr vnpkrs ab tfk [U nisg rkpgrtk` vnpabd mgrk tfnb >; `nys ab tfk pnst mgbtf,
NXPAEIK [B@KX XKSAKT - @G BGP EAPK GX EAXE[INPK TAPFG[P ZKXMAUUAGB
usk, watf wkkliy vnpabd nimgst kbtarkiy egbekbtrntk` nmgbd ygutf smglkrs .;,>>,>8 Tfaik vnpabd >; `nys gr mgrk ab tfk pnst mgbtf rkmnabs igw nmgbd bkvkr smglkrs, tfkrk wns nb gvkrnii aberknsk ab rkduinr vnpabd rkdnr`ikss gc smglabd stntus ab Enbn`n nb` tfk [U. Pfk aberknsks ab vnpabd geeurrk` ab pnrniiki watf tfk rask gc O[[I nb` gtfkr baegtabk snit pg`-hnsk` prg`uets. Pfas bkw dkbkrntagb gc vnpabd prg`uets typaeniiy fnvk drkntkr baegtabk `kiavkry nb` mgrk rkduinr pnttkrbs gc usk nmgbd ygubd pkgpik .>1,8:,8> Ab 8:>6, O[[I kmkrdk` ns tfk ikn`abd vnpabd hrnb` nmgbd [U ygutf .8> O[[I wns abtrg`uek` ab Enbn`n ab Ukptkmhkr 8:>6, ma`wny tfrgudf tfk eurrkbt survky, watf bgtnhik aberknsks ab tfk carst cgur wkkls gc sniks, hy wfaef pgabt at wns nirkn`y tfk skegb` mgst pgpuinr hrnb` nmgbd Enbn`anb ygutf .8> O[[I wns usk` hy egbsa`krnhiy ckwkr ygutf ab Kbdinb` nt tfk tamk gc tfk survky .8> Xknsgbs cgr igwkr ikvkis gc usk nmgbd Kbdinb` ygutf nrk ubeiknr< fgwkvkr, O[[I prg`uets ab Kbdinb` egbtnab ikss tfnb fnic tfk baegtabk egbekbtrntagb egmpnrk` tg [U nb` Enbn`anb `kvaeks, ab egmpianbek watf Kurgpknb iamats gb baegtabk egbtkbt (>.4% ab tfk [L vkrsus ;% ab Enbn`n nb` tfk [U). 80 At sfgui` hk bgtk` tfnt, nitfgudf O[[I as tfk `gmabnbt hrnb` tg usk baegtabk-snit baegtabk-snit tkefbgigdy ab tfas tfas entkdgry, gtfkr vnpabd hrnb`s hrnb`s fnvk n`gptk` samainr baegtabk-snit baegtabk-snit hnsk` tkefbgigdy, abeiu`abd abeiu`abd gtfkr ikn`abd hrnb`s hrnb`s tfnt nrk pgpuinr nmgbd [U nb` nb` Enbn`anb ygutf .8> Ab rkspgbsk tg drgwabd egbekrb gvkr tfk aberknsabd pgpuinraty gc tfksk hrnb`s nmgbd ygubd pkgpik, tfk [U Cgg` nb` @rud N`mabastrntagb (C@N) fns prgpgsk` rkduintgry efnbdks tg tfk rktnai nvnainhaiaty gc k-eadnrkttks, wfaik mnbucneturkrs fnvk ub`krtnlkb vgiubtnry mknsurks ab rkspgbsk tg egbekrbs nhgut aberknsk` vnpabd nmgbd ygutf.8; Pfk aberknsk ab smglabd nmgbd Enbn`anb ygutf rkprkskbts tfk mgst bgtnhik stu`y cab`abd. Pfas aberknsk stnb`s ab egbtrnst tg n trkb` gc `keiababd ygutf smglabd ab Enbn`n gvkr tfk inst skvkrni `ken`ks .>: Davkb tfk mndbatu`k gc tfas cab`abd, at waii hk ampgrtnbt tg rkpiaentk tfk rksuits ab gbk gc Enbn`n‑s bntagbniiy rk prkskbtntavk rk prkskbtntavk hkbefmnrl survkys. At as ubeiknr ubeiknr tg wfnt kxtkbt tfk aberknsks aberknsks ab vnpabd nb` smglabd smglabd nmgbd Enbn`anb ygutf nrk enusniiy iablk`, gr tfk kxtkbt tg wfaef tfksk aberknsks nrk tfk rksuit gc tfk 8:>6 Net tfnt pkrmattk` tfk snik nb` mnrlktabd baegtabk-egbtnababd k-eadnrkttks, abeiu`abd abtkrbntagbni hrnb`s suef ns O[[I. At sfgui` nisg hk bgtk` tfnt tfk tamabd gc tfk 8:>6 survky wns sfgrtiy hkcgrk ikdniazntagb gc bgb-mk`aeni enbbnhas ab Enbn`n. Enbbnhas rntks nmgbd Enbn`anb ygutf fnvk hkkb stnhik cgr tfk pnst `ken`k, 83 nitfgudf `ntn crgm bntagbni survkys suddkst tfnt tfk prkvnikbek gc enbbnhas nmgbd ygubd pkgpik mny fnvk aberknsk` ab tfk mgbtfs pragr tg ikdniazntagb. 84
NXPAEIK [B@KX XKSAKT - @G BGP EAPK GX EAXE[INPK TAPFG[P ZKXMAUUAGB
bntagbni hkbefmnrl survkys ab knef egubtry. Pfk prkvnikbek gc vnpabd nb` smglabd ab tfk stu`y snmpik nrk 88,81,5: watfab > tg 5 pkrekbtndk pgabts gc 8:>4 bntagbni kstamntks ab nii tfrkk egubtraks .88,81,5: Pg `ntk, tfkrk nrk bg 8:>6 kstamntks nvnainhik ab Enbn`n gr Kbdinb` tg egmpnrk watf tfk 8:>6 stu`y kstamntks. Ab tfk [U, tfk BQPU cgub` n 46% aberknsk ab pnst 5:-`ny vnpabd hktwkkb 8:>4 nb` 8:>6, fadfiy egbsastkbt watf +40% aberknsk ghskrvk` ab tfk eurrkbt stu`y. stu`y .86 Pg curtfkr abvkstadntk pgtkbtani `acckrkbeks ab tfk 8:>6 snmpik, wk kxnmabk` niegfgi nb` enbbnhas usk. Bg `acckrkbeks wkrk ghskrvk` nergss nby egubtraks, watf tfk kxekptagb tfnt enbbnhas usk aberknsk` nmgbd Enbn`anb ygutf. Fgwkvkr, tfas aberknsk as tfk egbsastkbt watf bntagbni `ntn, suddkstabd tfnt tfas as n ‖rkni‑ aberknsk, rntfkr tfnb n prg`uet gc n ‖raslakr‑ snmpik gc ygutf .84 Ab n``atagb, suppikmkbtni tksts ab`aentk` tfnt tfk aberknsk ab smglabd nb` vnpabd ab Enbn`n rkmnabk` sadbacaenbt nctkr n`oustabd cgr enbbnhas usk, ns bgtk` nhgvk. Pfkrkcgrk, wfaik wk nelbgwik`dk tfk iamatntagb gc bgb-prghnhaiaty snmpiks, kstamntks crgm tfk eurrkbt stu`y `kmgbstrntk n fadf ikvki gc egbsastkbey watf bntagbni hkbefmnrls nb` nrk rghust nctkr neegubtabd cgr gtfkr rasl hkfnvagurs tfnt nrk fadfiy fadfiy egrrkintk` watf smglabd smglabd nb` vnpabd. Utrkbdtfs gc tfk tfk stu`y abeiu`k stnb`nr` stnb`nr` mktfg`gigdy nergss egubtraks nb` gvkr muitapik yknrs, nb` tfk abeiusagb gc `ktnaik` mknsurks gc vnpabd nb` smglabd tg kxnmabk mgrk crkqukbt pnttkrbs gc usk. Egbeiusagbs Znttkrbs gc ygutf vnpabd ab Enbn`n nb` tfk [U nrk efnbdabd ab rkspgbsk tg n rnpa`iy kvgivabd baegtabk mnrlkt. Ab egbtrnst, ckw `acckrkbeks wkrk ghskrvk` nmgbd ygutf ab Kbdinb`, davkb tfk nhskbek gc mnogr rkduintgry gr mnrlkt efnbdks. Pfk eurrkbt cab`abds sfgui` hk abtkrprktk` watfab tfk hrgn`kr egbtkxt gc gvkrnii trkb`s ab smglabd nb` vnpabd, ab wfaef tfk prkvnikbek gc n`uit tghneeg usk egbtabuks tg `kerknsk ab nii tfrkk egubtraks. Tfaik tfk ampnet gc vnpabd prg`uets gb smglabd rntks rkmnabs fadfiy egbtkbtagus, at as nb ubcgrtubntk pnrn`gx tfnt tfk efnrnetkrastaes gc vnpabd prg`uets tfnt kbfnbek tfkar kccketavkbkss ns smglabd ekssntagb na`s ‐ na`s ‐ kccaeakbt kccaeakbt baegtabk `kiavkry ‐ `kiavkry ‐ nisg nisg aberknsk tfkar pgtkbtani tg prgmgtk n``aetagb nmgbd ygubd pkgpik. Zragr tg 8:>6, tfkrk wns rkintavkiy iattik kva`kbek gc rkduinr vnpabd nmgbd ygutf tfnt madft hk ab`aentavk gc baegtabk n``aetagb< fgwkvkr, tfk kmkrdkbek gc O[[I nb` baegtabk snit-hnsk` prg`uets mny sadbni n efnbdk. Xntfkr tfnb cuki tfk `khntk gvkr trn`k-gccs hktwkkb ikss fnrmcui baegtabk nitkrbntavks cgr n`uit smglkrs vkrsus aberknsk` ygutf abatantagb, tfk cab`abds sfgui` `arket nttkbtagb tg rkduintgry mknsurks tfnt mgrk skiketavkiy tnrdkt tfksk vnpabd prg`uets tg n`uit smglkrs. smglkrs. Pfas `aseussagb fns fns egmk tg tfk cgrk ab tfk [U, ns tfk C@N egbtkmpintks drkntkr rkstraetagbs gb n`vkrtasabd nb` prgmgtagb, cinvgurs, nb` rktnai neekss .8; Cab`abd tfk gptamni rkduintgry hninbek
NXPAEIK [B@KX XKSAKT - @G BGP EAPK GX EAXE[INPK TAPFG[P ZKXMAUUAGB
PNHIKU & CAD[XKU
Pnhik >. Unmpik efnrnetkrastaes, hy survky wnvk nb` egubtry (wkadftk`) ENBN@N
KBDINB@
[U
8:>4 b=0:56
8:>6 b=56;5
8:>4 b=515;
8:>6 b=51:8
8:>4 b=0:1;
8:>6 b=0:0;
>4´3 (>´:;)
>4´; (>´:6)
>4´; (>´:8)
>4´3 (>´:;)
>4´; (>´:6)
>4´; (>´:4)
Mnik
;>´0
;>´;
;>´5
;>´5
;>´>
;>´>
‖Tfatk gbiy‑ gbiy ‑ rnek/ktfbaeaty
;6´0
04´>
41´0
44´:
45´0
45´0
Znst >8-mgbtf niegfgi usk (nby)
3>´3
;1´1
43´>
40´6
0>´;
56´6
Znst >8-mgbtf enbbnhas usk (nby)
88.;
83.6
>6.>
>4.;
8>.8
88.;
Ndk (mknb< U@)
NXPAEIK [B@KX XKSAKT - @G BGP EAPK GX EAXE[INPK TAPFG[P ZKXMAUUAGB
Pnhik 8? Efnbdks ab prkvnikbek gc smglabd nb` vnpabd hktwkkb 8:>4 nb` 8:>6 nmgbd ygutf ndk` >3->1 yknrs, hy egubtry
8:>4
b=0:56
Snpabd Kvkr
ENBN@N 8:>6 Efnbdk crgm 8:>4 tg 8:>6 b=56;5
NGX (11%EA) p-vniuk
8:>4
b=515;
KBDINB@ 8:>6 Efnbdk crgm 8:>4 tg 8:>6 b=51:8
NGX (11%EA) p-vniuk
8:>4
b=0:1;
[U 8:>6
b=0:0;
Efnbdk crgm 8:>4 tg 8:>6 NGX (11%EA) p-vniuk
81´5% (>>68)
54´:% (>08;)
>´;: (>´ 5>->´4>) 5>->´4>) p9:´:::>
55´4 (>506)
58´4% (>843)
:´13 (:´ 60->´:1) 60->´:1) 5>´5% p=:´5656 (>865)
55´3% (>53:)
>´>> (>´::->´80) p=:´:064
Znst 5: `nys
6´0% (50:)
>0´3 (;38)
>´1; (>´ ;6-8´0:) ;6-8´0:) p9:´:::>
6´4% (504)
6´1% (503)
>´:5 (:´ 68->´81) 68->´81) >>´>% p=:´44:: (0;0)
>3´8 (3;;)
>´;; (>´50->´6:) p9:´:::>
Znst wkkl
;´8% (8:6)
1´5 (5;4)
>´11 (>´ ;5-8´3:) ;5-8´3:) p9:´:::>
0´3% (>60)
0´3% (>46)
:´11 (:´ 45->´53) 45->´53) 3´0% p=:´138> (838)
>:´3 (081)
>´40 (>´0;-8´>:) p9:´:::>
>;+ `nys pkr mgbtf
8´>% (6;)
5´3 (>51)
>´63 (>´ 85-8´41) 85-8´41) p9:´:::>
8´:% (6:)
8´8% (64)
>´>5 (:´ 4>->´41) 4>->´41) 5´:% p=:´01:6 (>80)
;´8 (8>:) (8>:)
>´4; (>´50, 8´81) p9:´:::>
5>´1% (>866)
53´3% (>0>8)
>´5> (>´ >;->´03) p9:´:::>
0:´0% (>3>;)
51´6% (>;;;)
:´16 (:´ 63->´>8) 63->´>8) 58´5% p=:´40;3 (>588)
55´>% (>554)
>´:0 (:´15->´>;) p=:´;>56
Znst 5: `nys
>:´4% (05>)
>;´; (;11)
>´3: (>´ 58->´10) p9:´:::>
>;´3% (388)
>3´0% (30>)
>´:6 (:´ 1>->´81) 1>->´81) >>´:% p=:´8556 (0;>)
>8´8% (010)
>´>8 (:´13->´5>) p=:´>063
Znst wkkl
4´3% (5:6)
>>´1 (03:)
>´4> (>´ 54-8´>0) 54-8´>0) p9:´:::>
1´6% (51>)
>>´5% (00>)
>´>1 (:´ 14->´04) 14->´04) 6´;% p=:´:830 (504)
6´6% (5;3)
>´:0 (:´64->´8;) p=:´3345
>;+ `nys pkr mgbtf
0´6% (>13)
4´0 (863)
>´30 (>´ 80-8´>;) p9:´:::>
;´:% (8::)
3´0% (806)
>´5> (:´ 11->´48) 11->´48) 0´3% p=:´:>>; (>61)
;´>% (8:;)
>´>: (:´64->´51) p=:´08>5
Umglabd Kvkr
NXPAEIK [B@KX XKSAKT - @G BGP EAPK GX EAXE[INPK TAPFG[P ZKXMAUUAGB
Pnhik 5? Efnbdks ab prkvnikbek gc vnpabd hktwkkb 8:>4 nb` 8:>6 nmgbd ygutf ndk` >3->1 yknrs, hy egubtry nb` smglabd stntus BKSKX UMGLKX 8:>4
8:>6
Efnbdk
KVZKXAMKBP NI UMGLKX 8:>4
8:>6
NGX (11%EA) p-vniuk
Efnbdk
E[XXKBP UMGLKX 8:>4
8:>6
NGX (11%EA) p-vniuk
b=84;:
b=800>
b=>13
b=851
>5´;% (545)
>1´8% (065)
>´3> (>´5:->´11) p9:´:::>
;6´4% (;10)
30´5% (485)
>´5: (>´ ::->´34), ::->´34), p=:´::66
41´6% (>;3)
43´4% (>65)
:´16 (:´ 04-8´:3), 04-8´:3), p=:´1085
Znst 5: `ny vnpabd
8´5% (35)
;´:% (>88)
8´5; (>´;>-5´3;) p9:´:::>
>6´8% (>60)
86´4% (585)
>´6; (>´ 54-8´;:), 54-8´;:), p9:´:::>
50´6% (36)
05´;% (>:0)
>´;3 (:´6;, 8´64), p=:´:;41
Znst wkkl vnpabd
:´6% (88)
8´4% (33)
5´36 (>´63-4´86) p9:´:::>
>>´:% (>>>)
>6´>% (8:5)
>´63 (>´ 84-8´48), 84-8´48), p9:´:::>
86´6% (;3)
55´:% (41)
>´81 (:´ 36-8´00), 36-8´00), p=:´8145
Snpabd >;+ `nys pkr mgbtf
:´8% (;)
:´3% (>0)
5´63 (:´ 66->3´16) 66->3´16) p=:´:>61
0´;% (0;)
3´3% (40)
>´;1 (:´ 1:-8´6>), 1:-8´6>), p=:´:540
>;´>% (81)
>6´:% (05)
>´84 (:´ ;6-8´6>), ;6-8´6>), p=:´0586
KBDINB@
b=856:
b=8504
b=>864
b=>8;:
b=856
b=833
Kvkr vnpabd
>>´1% (860)
>>´6% (843)
:´14 (:´43->´83) p=:´4108
3>´8% (464)
;1´4% (403)
:´15 (:´ 4;->´>4) p=:´0538
63´4% (8:3)
60´>% (885)
:´64 (:´08->´46) p=:´3>6:
Znst 5: `ny vnpabd
>´3% (51)
>´4% (51)
>´:5 (:´;5-8´:>) p=:´1>56
>;´8% (>1;)
>;´6% (>14)
>´:0 (:´ 43->´08) p=:´43;0
5;´4% (6;)
56´4% (>:5)
>´:6 (:´3;->´6>) p=:´31;1
Znst wkkl vnpabd
:´;% (>8)
:´0% (1)
:´44 (:´8:-8´10) p=:´3>0:
4´;% (14)
6´8% (>:8)
>´:6 (:´ 4>->´33) p=:´3883
88´8% (;5)
88´1% (3>)
>´:> (:´;;->´63) p=:´130:
Snpabd >;+ `nys pkr mgbtf
:´8% (0)
:´>% (>)
:´5> (:´:8-;´;5) p=:´8131
5´>% (0>)
5´4% (04)
>´>6 (:´ 3>-8´8;) :´;8>5
>:´6% (83)
>5´0% (53)
>´84 (:´;1-8´43) p=:´080>
[U
b=8445
b=84:6
b=>68
b=>45
Kvkr vnpabd
>5´>% (535)
>3´:% (058)
Znst 5: `ny vnpabd
8´0% (33)
Znst wkkl vnpabd Snpabd >;+ `nys pkr mgbtf
ENBN@N Kvkr vnpabd
b=>:>>
b=>>85
Efnbdk NGX (11%EA) p-vniuk
b=>:68
b=>>8>
>´80 (:´11->´06) p=:´:>8>
3;´;% (4:6)
34´>% (4;8)
>´>: (:´ 60->´05) 60->´05) p=:´5466
6;´0% (>;;)
6>´0% (>0>)
;´1% (>3:)
8´;3 (>´31-5´66) p9:´:::>
80´0% (830)
55´3% (544)
>´;4 (>´ >1-8´:4) >1-8´:4) p9:´:::>
;;´8% (>::)
;;´4% (13)
>´:5 (:´ ;5->´11) ;5->´11) p=:´1:66
>´>% (5>)
5´:% (68)
8´48 (>´06-0´16) p9:´:::>
>5´;% (>03)
88´4% (8;;)
>´61 (>´ 5;-8´3;) 5;-8´3;) p9:´:::>
53´5% (33)
00´6% (46)
>´06 (:´ 4;-8´1>) 4;-8´1>) p=:´>501
:´;% (>0)
>´;% (0:)
5´:; (>´>4-4´15) p=:´::84
3´:% (30)
>:´;% (>>6)
>´6; (>´ >0-5´::) >0-5´::) p=:´::>>
>1´6% (53)
85´0% (0>)
>´84 (:´ ;4-8´6:) ;4-8´6:) p=:´0050
:´4; (:´ 5:->´66) 5:->´66) p=:´0801
NXPAEIK [B@KX XKSAKT - @G BGP EAPK GX EAXE[INPK TAPFG[P ZKXMAUUAGB
Pnhik 0? Xkekbey nb` crkqukbey gc k- eadnrkttk usk nb` smglabd nmgbd ‖kvkr‑ uskrs , hy egubtry
8:>4
ENBN@N 8:>6 Efnbdk
8:>4
KBDINB@ 8:>6 Efnbdk
NGX (11%EA) p-vniuk K-EADNXKPPKU K-EADNXKPPKU
b=>>68
b=>08;
[U 8:>4
8:>6
NGX (11%EA) p-vniuk b=>506
b=>843
Efnbdk NGX (11%EA) p-vniuk
b=>865
b=>53:
Znst 5:-`ny vnpabd nmgbd kvkr-vnpkrs
86´6% (50:)
51´;% (;38)
>´31 (>´0>-8´:0) p9:´:::>
8;´6% (504)
84´>% (503)
>´:6 (:´ 61->´5>) 61->´5>) p=:´008:
5;´0% (0;0)
06´>% (3;;)
>´31 (>´0>-8´:8) p9:´:::>
Znst-wkkl vnpabd nmgbd kvkrvnpkrs
>4´3% (8:6)
8;´:% (5;4)
>´31 (>´5;-8´>>) p9:.:::>
>5´4% (>60)
>5´1% (>46)
>´:5 (:´ 6:->´58) 6:->´58) p=:.65:4
8:´0% (838)
5>´3% (081)
>´41 (>´03-8´8:) p9:.:::>
4.8% (6;)
1.4% (>51)
>.;5 (>.>>-8.>>) p=:.::1;
;.1% (6:)
3.6% (64)
>.>4 (:.68->.34) p=:.5151
1.4% (>80)
>;.0% (8>:)
>.31 (>.86-8.80) p=:.:::8
EADNXKPPK UMGLABD
b=>866
b=>0>8
b=>3>;
b=>;;;
b=>588
b=>554
Znst 5:-`ny smglabd nmgbd kvkr-smglkrs
55´0% (05>)
08´0% (;11)
>´03 (>´88->´45) p9:.:::>
56´;% (388)
0>´5% (30>)
>´>5 (:´ 14->´58) 14->´58) p=:.>8>1
50´>% (0;>)
53´1% (010)
>´>8 (:´15->´50) p=:.88;:
Znst-wkkl smglabd nmgbd kvkr-smglkrs
85´1% (5:6)
58´3% (03:)
>´;; (>´86->´64) p9:.:::>
80´8% (51>)
86´0% (00>)
>´8; (>´ :;->´06) :;->´06) p=:.:>>5
83´5% (504)
83´3% (5;3)
>´:: (:´68->´85) p=:.14>5
Znst->; `nys/mgbtf smglabd nmgbd kvkr smglkrs
>;.8% (>13)
8:.8% (863)
>.08 (>.>0->.46) p=:.::8:
>8.0% (8::)
>3.:% (806)
>.5; (>.:1->.36) p=:.::31
>0.5% (>61)
>;.5% (8:;)
>.:3 (:.65->.53) p=:.30>>
>;+ `nys/mgbtf nmgbd kvkr vnpkrs
NXPAEIK [B@KX XKSAKT - @G BGP EAPK GX EAXE[INPK TAPFG[P ZKXMAUUAGB
XKCKXKBEKU >
8
Bntagbni Nen`kmaks gc Ueakbeks, Kbdabkkrabd, nb` Mk`aeabk. Zuhiae Fknitf Egbskqukbeks gc K-Eadnrkttks. Utrnttgb L, Lwnb IQ, Kntgb @I, K`s. Tnsfabdtgb, @E? Pfk Bntagbni Nen`kmaks Zrkss, 8:>6. fttp?//bntagbninen`kmaks.grd/fm`/rkpgrts/8:>6/puhiae-fknitf-egbskqukbeks-gc-k-eadnrkttks.nspx (Neekssk` @ke 5, 8:>6). Lkbbk`y X@, Nwgpkdhn N, @k Ikõb K, Egfkb OK. Dighni npprgnefks tg rkduintabd kiketrgbae eadnrkttks. Pgh Egbtrgi 8:>4< 83? 0;. 83? 00: ― 0;.
5 Fknitf Enbn`n. Snpabd prg`uets, Mny 8:>6. fttps?//www.enbn`n.en/kb/fknitf-enbn`n/bkws/8:>6/:;/hneldrgub`kr-vnpabd-prg`uets.ftmi (Neekssk` @ke 5, 8:>6). 0 Fnmmgb` @, Tfatk EM, Ezgia E@, Mnrtab EI, Mndkbbas Z, Ufapig U. Xktnai nvnainhaiaty nb` nb` mnrlktabd gc k-eadnrkttks ab Enbn`n. Enb O Zuhiae Fknitf 8:>;< >:3? >:3? k0:6->8. ; MeBkaii N, Hrgsk IU, Eni`kr X, Hnui` I & Xghsgb @. Kva`kbek rkvakw gc k-eadnrkttks nb` fkntk` tghneeg prg`uets, 8:>6. N rkpgrt egmmassagbk` hy Zuhiae Fknitf Kbdinb`. Igb`gb? Zuhiae Fknitf Kbdinb`. fttps?//www.dgv.ul/dgvkrbmkbt/puhiaentagbs/k-eadnrkttks-nb`-fkntk`-tghneeg-prg`uetskva`kbek-rkvakw/kva`kbek-rkvakw-gc-k-eadnrkttks-nb`-fkntk`-tghneeg-prg`uets-8:>6-kxkeutavk-summnry (Neekssk` @ke 5, 8:>6). 3 Fnmmgb` @, Tfatk EM, Ezgia E@, Mnrtab EI, Mndkbbas Z, Ufapig U. Xktnai nvnainhaiaty nb` mnrlktabd gc k-eadnrkttks ab Enbn`n. Enb O Zuh Fknitf 8:>;< >:3 (3)? >:3 (3)? k0:6-k0>8. 4 Drnvkiy U, Cgbd DP, Eummabd LM, kt ni. Nwnrkbkss, kvkr-trani, nb` usk gc kiketrgbae eadnrkttks nmgbd >: egubtraks? Cab`abds crgm tfk APE Zrgoket. 4:0. >>? >>31> ― 4:0. Abt O Kbvargb Xks Zuhiae Fknitf 8:>0< >>? 6 Efg FO, @utrn IM, Dinbtz UN. @acckrkbeks ab n`giksekbt k-eadnrkttk nb` eadnrkttk prkvnikbek ab twg pgiaey kbvargbmkbts? Ugutf Lgrkn nb` tfk [batk` Utntks. Baegtabk Pgh Xks 8:>6< 8:? ;5. 8:? 101 ― ;5. 1 Dgvkrbmkbt gc Enbn`n. @ktnaik` tnhiks cgr tfk Enbn`anb Utu`kbt Pghneeg, Niegfgi nb` @ruds Uurvky 8:>3->4. fttps?//www.enbn`n.en/kb/fknitfenbn`n/skrvaeks/enbn`anb-stu`kbt-tghneeg-niegfgi-`ruds-survky/8:>3-8:>4-suppikmkbtnry-tnhiks.ftmi#t> (Neekssk` @ke 5, 8:>6). >: Xka` OI, Fnmmgb` @, Xybnr` SI, Mn`aii EI, Hurlfnitkr X. Pghneeg [sk ab Enbn`n? Znttkrbs nb` Prkb`s, 8:>4 K`atagb. Tntkrigg, GB? Zrgpki Ekbtrk cgr Zgpuintagb Fknitf Ampnet, [bavkrsaty gc Tntkrigg, 8:>4. www.tghneegrkpgrt.en (Neekssk` @ke 5, 8:>6). >> Onmni N, Dkbtzlk N, Fu UU, kt ni. Pghneeg usk nmgbd ma``ik nb` fadf sefggi stu`kbts - [batk` Utntks, 8:>>-8:>3. MMTX Mgrh Mgrtni Tliy Xkp 8:>4< 33? 3:5. 33? ;14 ― 3:5. >8 Tnbd PT, Dkbtzlk N, Ufnrnpgvn U, Euiikb LN, Nmhrgsk HL, Onmni N. Pghneeg prg`uet usk nmgbd ma``ik nb` fadf sefggi stu`kbts - [batk` Utntks, 8:>>-8:>4. MMTX Mgrh Mgrtni Tliy Xkp 8:>6< 34? 55. 34? 381 ― 55.
NXPAEIK [B@KX XKSAKT - @G BGP EAPK GX EAXE[INPK TAPFG[P ZKXMAUUAGB
>5 Gccaek cgr Bntagbni Utntastaes. Ugeani Uurvky @avasagb. Gpabagbs nb` Iackstyik Uurvky, Pghneeg Egbsumptagb nb` K-Eadnrkttks Mg`uiks, Onbunry Ckhrunry, Nprai - Mny, Ouiy - Nudust nb` Getghkr - Bgvkmhkr, 8:>3 \`ntn egiiketagb]. 8b` K`atagb. [L @ntn Ukrvaek, 8:>4. UB? 6868. fttp?//`ga.grd/>:.;8;;/[L@N-UB-6868-8 (Neekssk` @ke 5, 8:>6). >0 Fnmmgb` @, Xka` OI, Egik ND, Ikntfkr`nik UP. Kiketrgbae eadnrkttk usk nb` smglabd abatantagb nmgbd ygutf? n igbdatu`abni egfgrt stu`y. Enb Mk` 8:>4< >61? 53. >61? K>586 ― 53. Nssge O 8:>4< >; Ikvkbtfni NM, Utgbk M@, Nb`rnha B, kt ni. Nssgeantagb gc k-Eadnrkttk Snpabd nb` Zrgdrkssagb tg Fknvakr Znttkrbs gc Eadnrkttk Umglabd. ONMN 8:>3< 5>3? 8:. 5>3? >1>6 ― 8:. >3 Knst L, Fatefmnb UE, Hnlgias A, kt ni. Pfk Nssgeantagb Hktwkkb Umglabd nb` Kiketrgbae Eadnrkttk [sk ab n Egfgrt gc Qgubd Zkgpik. O N`gikse 04. Fknitf 8:>6< 38? 38? ;51 ― 04. >4 Ikvy @P, Tnrbkr LK, Eummabds LM, kt ni. Kxnmababd tfk rkintagbsfap gc vnpabd tg smglabd abatantagb nmgbd [U ygutf nb` ygubd n`uits? n rkniaty efkel. Pgh Egbtrgi< 8:>6< paa? tghneegegbtrgi-8:>6-:;0003. \Kpuh nfkn` gc prabt] >6. Funbd O, @unb _, Lwgl O, kt ni. Snpabd vkrsus O[[Iabd? fgw tfk kxtrngr`abnry drgwtf nb` mnrlktabd gc O[[I trnbscgrmk` tfk [U rktnai k-eadnrkttk mnrlkt. Pgh Egbtrgi 8:>6< \Kpuh nfkn` gc prabt 5> Mny 8:>6]. >1 Dgbakwaez MI, Hgylnb X, Mkssabn EX, Kiaseu N, Pgikbtabg O. Fadf kxpgsurk tg baegtabk nmgbd n`giksekbts wfg usk Ouui nb` gtfkr vnpk pg` systkms ('pg`s'). Pgh Egbtrgi 8:>6< paa? tghneegegbtrgi-8:>6-:;0;3;.\Kpuh nfkn` gc prabt] 8: Dgi`kbsgb BA, Ikvkbtfni NM, Utgbk M@, MeEgbbkii XU, Hnrrabdtgb-Pramas OI. Nssgeantagbs gc K-Eadnrkttk Baegtabk Egbekbtrntagb nb` Uuhskqukbt Eadnrkttk Umglabd nb` Snpabd Ikvkis ab N`giksekbts. ONMN Zk`antr 8:>4< 8:>4< >4>(>8)? >>18 ― >>11. >>11. 8> Fnmmgb` @, Xka` OX, Dgbakwaez M, G‑Egbbgr XO, Pfrnsfkr OC, Tnelgwsla G. Pfk rask gc O[[I vnpabd nmgbd ygutf ab Enbn`n, Kbdinb` nb` tfk [U. Uuhmattk`. 88. Fnmmgb` @, Xka` OI, Tfatk EM, Hgu`rknu E. APE Qgutf Pghneeg nb` K-Eadnrkttk Uurvky? Pkefbaeni Xkpgrt ― Tnvk Tnvk > (8:>4). Tntkrigg, GB? [bavkrsaty gc Tntkrigg. Mnref 8:>6. fttp?//`nva`fnmmgb`.en/prgokets/tghneeg-egbtrgi/ate-ygutf-tghneeg-kead/ (Neekssk` @ke 5, 8:>6). 85 [U @kpnrtmkbt gc Fknitf nb` Fumnb Ukrvaeks. Zrkvkbtabd tghneeg usk nmgbd ygutf nb` ygubd n`uits? N rkpgrt gc tfk Uurdkgb Dkbkrni. Ntinbtn, DN? [U @kpnrtmkbt gc Fknitf nb` Fumnb Ukrvaeks, Ekbtkrs cgr @asknsk Egbtrgi nb` Zrkvkbtagb, Bntagbni Ekbtkr cgr Efrgbae @asknsk Zrkvkbtagb nb` Fknitf Zrgmgtagb, Gccaek gb Umglabd nb` F knitf, 8:>8. 80 Dkiikr M. Cnst-drgwabd k-eadnrkttk mnlkr O[[I tg inubef ab [L. Xkutkrs, >3 Oui, 8:>6. fttps?//www.rkutkrs.egm/nrtaeik/us-ouui-hratnab/cnst-drgwabdk-eadnrkttk-mnlkr-ouui-tg-inubef-ab-ul-a`[ULHB>L38TE (Neekssk` @ke 5, 8:>6).
NXPAEIK [B@KX XKSAKT - @G BGP EAPK GX EAXE[INPK TAPFG[P ZKXMAUUAGB
8; [U Cgg` nb` @rud N`mabastrntagb. Utntkmkbt crgm C@N Egmmassagbkr Uegtt Dgttiakh, M.@., gb prgpgsk` bkw stkps tg prgtket ygutf hy prkvkbtabd neekss tg cinvgrk` tghneeg prg`uets nb` hnbbabd mkbtfgi ab eadnrkttks. >; Bgvkmhkr 8:>6. fttps?//www.c`n.dgv/BkwsKvkbts/Bkwsrggm/ZrkssNbbgubekmkbts/[EM38;660.ftm7utmWenmpnadb=>>>;>6WUtntkmkbtWC@N%8:Egmmassagbkr%8: stntkmkbt%8:gb%8:prgpgsnis%8:tg%8:n``rkss%8:ygutf%8:tghneeg%8:usk&utmWmk`aum=kmnai&utmWsgurek=Kigqun (Neekssk` @ke 5, 8:>6). 83 Ikgs-Pgrg E, Xybnr` S, Murbndfnb @, Mne@gbni` ON, Fnmmgb` @. Prkb`s ab enbbnhas usk gvkr tamk nmgbd Enbn`anb ygutf? 8::0-8:>0. Zrkv Mk` 8:>6< >>6 ?5:-54. >>6 ?5:-54. 84 Utntastaes Enbn`n. Bntagbni Enbbnhas Uurvky? 5r` ^unrtkr, 8:>6. fttps?//www>;:.stntenb.de.en/b>/`naiy-qugta`akb/>6>:>>/t::>h-kbd.ftm (Neekssk` @ke 5, 8:>6). 86 Euiikb LN, Nmhrgsk HL, Dkbtzlk NU, Npkihkrd HO, Onmni N, Labd HN. [sk gc Kiketrgbae Eadnrkttks nb` Nby Pghneeg Zrg`uet Nmgbd Ma``ik nb` Fadf Uefggi Utu`kbts ‐ Utu`kbts ‐ [batk` [batk` Utntks, 8:>> ― 8:>6. 8:>6. MMTX Mgrh Mgrtni Tliy Xkp. 8:>6< 34(0;)?>843->844. 34(0;)?>843->844. 81 Utntastaes Enbn`n. Enbn`anb Egmmubaty Fknitf Uurvky. Fknitf Cnet Ufkkts< Umglabd 8:>4. fttps?//www>;:.stntenb.de.en/b>/puh/68-38;x/8:>6::>/nrtaeik/;0140-kbd.ftm (Neekssk` @ke 5, 8:>6). 5: Gccaek cgr Bntagbni Utntastaes. Ugeani Uurvky @avasagb. (8:>4). Gpabagbs nb` Iackstyik Uurvky, Pghneeg Egbsumptagb nb` K-Eadnrkttks Mg`uiks, Onbunry - Ckhrunry, Nprai - Mny, Ouiy - Nudust nb` Getghkr - Bgvkmhkr, 8:>3. \`ntn egiiketagb]. 8b` K`atagb. [L @ntn Ukrvaek. UB? 6868, fttp?//`ga.grd/>:.;8;;/[L@N-UB-6868-8 \Pnhiks dkbkrntk` cgr @ME hy [L Gccaek gc Bntagbni Utntastaes] (Neekssk` @ke 5, 8:>6).