A Beginners Guide to Flux Cored Arc Welding When it comes to Flux cored arc welding or "FCAW" many people think it is a different welding “process” when in reality it is not! Even though there are books, classes and equipment specifically specifically labeled for flux cored arc welding only, the reality of FCAW is that the process is nothing more than a different type of filler wire used in a MIG welding machine. That is it! Flux Cored Arc Welding Power Supplies
The power supplies used for this welding process are typically MIG welders without any modifications. In some cases you might need to change out the rollers that feed the wire, as well as the contact tip to accommodate for a larger size wire. This is no different than changing to a different size MIG wire! When it comes to power supplies, there are some specifically made for FCAW, but this equipment is only used in heavy industrial applications. The main difference between a FCAW power supply and a MIG machine is how much voltage and amperage the machine is able to produce. In most cases (this includes welding shops and schools) there is no need for theses massive power supplies that are for welding extremely heavy plate. If you have a MIG power supply and a wire feed then you are ready to set it up to start st art flux cored arc welding. Flux Cored Arc Welding Electrodes
The electrodes, or filler wire, used in FCAW is completely different then MIG welding. The main difference is that the electrodes have a hollow center filled with flux. The flux is what shields the weld area from the air and is the main reason this process works better outdoors. Think of this electrode as an inside-out stick welding electrode. This gives this process some real advantages over MIG w elding electrodes. There are four main benefits to FCAW: 1.
Deposit rate per hour.
2.
Welding dirty and rusted metals as thick as ½ of an inch in a single pass.
3.
Perfect for welding outdoors, as well as for hobby welding.
4.
Low skill level needed.
Deposit Rate per Hour
The deposit rate blows away all other manual welding processes. A MIG welder could deposit up to eight pounds of wire per hour compared to a flux cored arc welder packing in up to twenty-five pounds per hour . This is a big advantage for companies that weld heavy p late. When it comes to weld deposit rate, FCAW can’t be beat! That is why shipyards are always using this process. Firsthand experience; I worked on a project that required installing two wave deflectors one of the world’s largest cruise ships while it was in port for 18 hours. The catch was, we needed to install the deflector and weld at least 100 feet of it in that time frame on steel plate that was almost one inch thick. This was a “never done before” ship modification that had over 5,000 people waiting on us so the ship could depart. The only way to get the welds done in this time frame was with flux cored arc welding. If any other process had been used, the ship would have been docked for at least a week, while millions of dollars a day were lost. FCAW got the job done on time, and most importantly, the job was done right the first time! Welding Dirty and Rusted Metals
This is one of the few electrodes, or processes, that do not need a clean joint. Unlike MIG, Stick and TIG welding, this process can burn through rust, mill scale, and just about anything except for paint, water or oils. This process is so good at burning through mill scale and rust that in a single pass it can weld a 1/2 inch plate with groove joint and achieve full penetration on both sides. FCAW runs hot and fast in all positions, and that makes it perfect for both industrial and shipyard applications. Welding Outdoors and Hobbyist Welders
If you have a MIG welder, you know that welding outdoors has some real troubles. Fortunately, if you swap out your MIG wire for FCAW wire, most of those problems go away. What happens while welding is that the flux inside the electrode helps shield the weld from wind just like a stick welding electrode. When it comes to people who weld as a hobby or for general repairs around the home or farm, the flux cored wire, in some cases, does not need shielding gas. This gives the user more flexibility with less equipment. Low Skill Level Needed
Unlike many other welding processes, this electrode requires very little skill. I t is just like MIG welding but much easier. The catch is, you need to how to set-up the welder properly! Once the welder is set-up properly it is a "point-and-shoot" operation with very little welding skill needed. This process, just like MIG welding, requires a precisely set-up machine for it to work well.
Flux Cored Arc Welding Electrodes Types and Designations
Flux core arc welding electrodes come in two types: 1.
Self-Shielding
2.
Dual-Shielding
Self-Shielding is exactly what it states. The filler wire does not require any shielding gasses to weld. This wire works well outdoors and is one of the best choices for general repairs. It keeps the process simple and cuts back on additional costs. Dual-Shielding wire requires additional shielding gasses. In most cases it is a mixture called C25 or 75% Aragon Gas and 25% Carbon Dioxide Gas. The only way to know what shielding gas to use with Dual-Shield electrodes is to contact your welding supply store, electrode manufacture or a welding instructor. It is not worth guessing because you will waste your money and most likely need to remove the weld afterwards. FCAW Electrode Designation
The electrodes for this process come in a variety of sizes. For most welding applications you will likely use one of the following:
•
.023
•
.030
•
.035
The electrodes have a designation system that identifies the type of electrode. As an example we will use an "E71T-1"and explain what the coding system means.
•
E- Stands for electrode.
7 – Identifies the minimum tensile strength of the weld per square inch, and in • this case, you need to add four zeros (70,000). What this means is the filler metal has a minimum of 70,000 pounds of tensile per square inch of weld.
• 1 – Identifies what position the electrode is designed to weld in. There are only two designations and they are zero and one. Zero means the electrode can only weld in the flat and horizontal positions. One means it can weld in any position.
T – Stands for Tubular and this will be how you know it is a flux cored • electrode. If this were a MIG electrode, it would have an "S", which stands for Solid.
•
1 – Identifies the type of flux that is inside of the electrode.
Flux Cored Arc Welding Machine Set-Up
Machine set-up is a critical component of the FCAW welding process. Before setting up the machine, the tension on the rollers needs to be set. The tension should be just enough to feed the wire without slipping. If you tighten up the rollers too much, the wire will get crushed and then you will need to re- feed the wire. The heat settings are done with voltage and wire feed speed. In some cases involving Dual-Shield electrodes there will be the additional task of setting the gas flow rate for the shielding gas. The voltage controls the heat setting, while the wire feed speed controls how much wire will flow in to the joint in "IPM" or Inches Per Minute. Since this process uses a constant voltage power supply, the amperage is regulated with the wire feed speed. The faster and harder the wire contacts the weld joint the higher the amperage. When it comes to the settings, there is typically a chart inside the welder containing a clear guideline on voltage and wire feed speed for the thickness of the metal that will be welded. These recommended settings are not very important with FCAW. If the puddle flows and the weld washes in then the weld is strong. If these were MIG welding machine settings, this would be very important because MIG welding requires a minimum voltage and wire feed speed for different thicknesses of metal. When setting your machine there are two types of transfers that can be used and they are: 1.
Globular Transfer
2.
Spray Transfer
Globular transfercan be used on thinner metals and it is a setting where the voltage and wire feed speed produce a weld that sounds like it is popping. You typically hear a few pops per second and can see globs forming on the wire then dropping into the weld joint. To use globular you need to have a Dual-Shielding electrode. What makes this transfer possible is a high percentage of Argon gas that creates a fluid arc. Spray transferfor FCAW has a deep, fast, crackling sound to it. Don’t confuse this transfer with true spray transfer because the voltage and amperage that are used actually spray the metal into the joint even though it crackles like a short circuit. Spray transfer is what is typically used to weld with.
Setting up your welder is best done on a piece of scrap metal close to the thickness that you are planning to weld. This is true of any other welding process and this is where you need to spend your time making sure it welds properly. The down side of flux cored arc welding is that thin metals don’t always weld well, and it is limite d on the types of metal that can be welded. Very limited! Flux Cored Arc Welding Techniques
The techniques used for this process are very basic and don’t require much skill besides machine setup. The first thing you need to know about is forehand vs. backhand welding. Forehand is where you push the puddle in the direction of the weld. Forehand welding produces a shallow but wide, penetrating weld that has a low profile. This is most suitable for thinner metals or on the cap of a weld for the sake of esthetics or appearance. Backhand welding produces a narrow, deep, penetrating weld that has a high profile and is best used on thick metals. The techniques used are similar to Stick and MIG welding. There are the whipping, circles and weave techniques/patterns. In most cases you can use a steady travel speed with a slight side-to-side shake of the handle to spread the weld. This is the best technique and works well in any position either forehand or backhand. The flat, horizontal and overhead positions can be welded forehand or backhand. More often than not, it is just a side-to-side shake of the handle to spread the weld. The vertical position can be welded by pointing the electrode starting at 90 degrees square to the metal that is to be welded all the way up to 45 degrees on an upward angle. Vertical welding is typically done traveling uphill. I personally don’t know if anyone welds downhill with FCAW unless it is an open root weld on pipe. When it comes to welding techniques, always remember that it is mainly all about machine set-up. The vertical and overhead positions require a precisely set-up machine without any exceptions. That is what separates the pros from the amateurs. As for vertical and overhead welding, be certain that the filler wire is designed for all positions, and has the designation of “1” on the last digit of the label. Stick-Out – Self-Shielding vs. Dual-Shielding Stick-out for self-shielding wire, in some cases, should be more than 3/4 of an inch.The reason for this is to preheat the wire to burn off any moisture that it may contain. If you are using Dual-Shielding wire, then your stick-out should be 3/4 of an inch or less because you want the shielding gas to properly shield the weld.
In the event you are getting porosity in the weld, chances are you need to throw out the first few feet of wire because it has moisture in it from storage. For more detailed information see: Flux cored arc welding or "FCAW". A Beginner’s Guide to Flux Cored Arc Welding was written exclusively for Metal Web News and their readers by Go Welding.Org.
The above article is available for download in PDF and Microsoft Word format.
Posted: 12/06/2010 Revised: 12/08/2010
Advanced Search
o o o o o o o o o o
Home Tech Cells
o o o o o o o o o o
Article Archive Industry Directory
o o o o o o
Subscriptions
o
o
o
o
o
o o o
FAB 40 Media Center
o o o o
Login/Register
Arc Welding Article Order Reprint
Print Friendly
Published in...
Practical Welding Today®
Subscribe to PWT
View This Issue
Related TechCells
Tube and Pipe Production
Consumables
Cutting and Weld Prep
Automation and Robotics
Welding Inspection
Art and Sculpture
Aluminum Welding
Home \ Arc Welding \ Articles \ GMAW vs. FCAW for beginners: Choose the best process for your small...
GMAW vs. FCAW for beginners: Choose the best process for your small operation By Lincoln Electric Weld Technology Center Staff August 16, 2001
There are several pros and cons to using the gas metal arc welding process versus the flux cored arc welding process in compact applications. When you prepare to buy your first wire-feed welding machine, you don't want to waste your money on a toy that goes out with the trash in a few weeks. You probably want to use 115-V input for portability, but might want to step up to a 230-V-input machine to weld thicker material. After you've made this decision, one more question will remain: Which welding process will I use metal arc (GMAW) or flux cored arc welding (FCAW)?
—
gas
If you are like many beginning welding operators, you may be confused about which process to choose. The choice depends on three variables: 1. What you are welding 2. Where you are welding 3. The surface finish requirements of what you are welding
Defining GMAW GMAW uses a continuous solid wire electrode for filler metal and an externally supplied gas, typically from a high-pressure cylinder, for shielding. The wire usually is mild steel, which typically is copper -colored because it's electroplated with a thin layer of copper to protect it from rusting, improve electrical conductivity, increase contact tip life, and improve arc performance. The shielding gas, usually carbon dioxide or a mixture of carbon dioxide and argon, protects the molten metal from reacting with the atmosphere. Shielding gas flows through the gun and cable assembly and out the gun nozzle with the welding wire to shield and protect the molten weld pool. If exposed, molten metal reacts with oxygen, nitrogen, and hydrogen in the atmosphere. The inert gas usually continues to flow for some time after welding to protect the metal as it cools. A slight breeze can blow the shielding away and cause porosity in the weld, so you should avoid welding outdoors unless you erect special windscreens. If done properly, GMAW can yield excellent results. The finished weld has no slag and almost no spatter. If the material you're welding is dirty, rusty, or painted, you must clean it by grinding until you see shiny, bare metal. A novice can use GMAW successfully with common commercial metals — low-carbon steel, low-alloy steel, stainless steel, and aluminum.
Defining FCAW FCAW uses a wire that contains materials in its core that, when burned by the heat of the arc, produces shielding gases and fluxing agents to help produce a sound weld without the need for external shielding gas. The shielding can endure a strong breeze. The arc is forceful but creates spatter. When finished, the weld is covered with slag that usually must be removed. The settings on the wire feeder and power source are more critical for this process. An improper technique can magnify poor results. You can use this type of welding primarily on mild steel in outdoor applications.
General Usage Rules GMAW. Experts recommend you use a compact 115-V or 230-V-input GMAW wire feeder and welding machine indoors on new, clean steel from 24- to 12-ga. Twelve gauge material is a little less than 1/8 in. thick, while 24-ga. is less than 1/16 in. thick. The smallest wire (0.025 in.) can make it easier to weld thinner material. If you need to weld 1/8- to 1/4-in.-thick material with GMAW, you will need a higher-capacity, compact machine, which requires 230-V input. The higher amperage range of this machine can handle your welding needs in a single pass, so you may not have to waste time with second or third passes. The 230 V machine also can run 0.035-in.-dia. wire. To weld material thicker than 1/4 in., you need a higher-capacity industrial machine. If you perform most of your welding indoors on clean material 1/8 in. thick or less, a GMAW machine that operates on 115 V probably is more economical than a 230-V-input machine. FCAW. Experts recommend that FCAW be used only on materials no thinner than 20-ga., a bit thicker than the 24-ga. for GMAW. In general, this process is best for welding thicker m aterials with a single pass, especially when welding outdoors. With the proper electrode and the right machine, you can weld steel up to 1/2 in. thick.
Choosing Wire One concern with FCAW is how to choose the best wire. Proper electrode diameter is related to metal plate thickness and the welding machine you use. A smaller wire makes it easier to weld thinner metal. Small machines cannot do everything. Electrodes for production welding, hard facing to resist wear, and most specialty electrodes will exceed the capacity of these machines. You must be careful to match the output voltage of your machine with the voltage of the electrode and the appropriate wire diameter and wire-feed speeds to make sure you have a compatible system.
Tips for Both Processes For both processes, welders need to follow certain tips. For instance, you should clean or grind the surface of the metal thoroughly before tightly attaching the work clamp to get a solid work connection. Some other tips to consider include the following: 1. Put the welding machine on a separate circuit breaker that is fused properly, as stated in its operator's manual. You can't melt steel at about 5,000 degrees F without adequate input power. 2. Strive for good fit-up. Avoid gaps whenever possible to minimize burn-through. This is critical, especially on thin sheet metal. 3. Keep the gun cable as straight as possible for smooth wire feeding. Don't bend it sharply. 4. Make sure the contact tip is not elongated or melted and is tightened in place. 5. Cut the wire at an angle to form a point for better starts. 6. Use and maintain correct electrode stickout and proper welding procedures. 7. Make sure the drive rolls feed smoothly with proper tension. 8. Try to hold the gun steadily and smoothly.
9. Observe and follow all welding safety precautions as specified in your operator's manual. Pay special attention to the potential for electric shock, arc rays that can burn skin and eyes, fire and explosion, and proper ventilation. For more details, consult ANSI Z 49.1. Related Company Showrooms : Lincoln Electric Co., The
Additional Information
Author
Lincoln Electric Weld Technology Center Staff
Disqus
Like
Dislike
o
2 people liked this. Showing 0 comments
M Subscribe by email S RSS
Login Add New Comment
Post as …
Image
Trackback URL blog comments powered by DISQUS
Sponsors
Advertising Information
Tools and Resources
Supplier Search Article Archive Buyer's Guides SuperDeck Subscriptions Media Center Useful Links Advertise With Us My Account Login/Register
Contact Us Learn and Connect Industry Tradeshows Educational Events FMA Store Job Board Podcasts Affiliations FMA TPA FABTECH Nuts & Bolts Foundation Policies Privacy Copyright Legal
Follow us on:
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn FMA Communications, Inc. 833 Featherstone Road Rockford, IL 61107 815-399-8700 E-mail:
[email protected] Thefabricator.com provides metal fabrication professionals with market news, the industry's best articles, product news, and conference information from the Fabricators & Manufacturers Association, Intl.
Thefabricator.com covers technologies in the following areas: Fab Stories Back Page Plasma Cutting Automation and Robotics Metals/Materials Tool and Die Resistance Welding Machining Cutting Bending Press Technology Art and Sculpture Materials Handling Arc Welding Folding Hydroforming Welding Punching Industry Trends and Analysis Assembly Shop Management For CEOs Training and Retention Finishing Power Tools Shearing Shop Strategies Safety Tube and Pipe Production For Engineers Cutting and Weld Prep Laser Welding Aluminum Welding Consumables Blanking, Drawing, and Deep Drawing Oxyfuel Cutting Sawing Repair and Field Welding Coil Processing Laser Cutting Welding Inspection Press Feeding Testing and Measuring Roll Forming Waterjet Cutting Tube and Pipe Fabrication Stamping CAD/CAM Software
