6. Jose Espinelli vs PP

6. JOSE ESPINELI ESPINELI vs. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES PHILIPPINES G.R. No.179535

June 9, 2014

F!"s#

− Es$%ne&&% 's (u)*e) 's +&e* e-o)e "e RT/ − RT/ -oun* $e"%"%one) u%&". )(e* (e* '%" '%" (o*% (o*%+! +!" "%o %on n "e "e +n*% +n*%n ns s o- "e "e ")% ")%&& !ou) !ou)". ". I" − / ) )"%o!%n"e* "" s%n!e none o- "e $)ose!u"%on '%"nesses s' o' "e %&&%n o- "e v%!"%( 's $e)$e")"e*, "e u&%-%n !%)!u(s"n!e o-  us use e o- su su$e $e)% )%o) o) s") s")en" en"  !nn !nno" o" e $$) $$)e! e!% %"e "e*. *. Ne%" Ne%"e e)) !n !n n%""%(e se)ve s n )v"%n !%)!u(s"n!e s "e "%(e o- "e !o((%ss%on o- "e !)%(e 's no" even &&ee* %n "e In-o)("%on. In v%e' "e)eo-, "e / -oun* $e"%"%one) u%&" on& o- o(%!%*e %ns"e* o-  (u)*e). (u)*e). Te *e!)e"& $o)"%on o- "e $$e&&"e !ou)"s e!%s%on )e*s# Issue# !%)!u(s" s"n"% n"%& & ev%*en ev%*en!e !e enou enou "o )u&e )u&e -o) "e !onv%!"% !onv%!"%on on o- "e − Is !%)!u( !!use*8 Ru&%n#  es. T)u&, T)u&, :*%)e!" :*%)e!" ev%*en!e o- "e !o((%ss%on o-  !)%(e %s no" "e on& −  es. s%s -)o( '%!  !ou)" ( *)' %"s +n*%n o- u%&".: Te )u&es o-  ev%* ev%*en en!e !e &&o &&o' '  ")% ")%&& !ou) !ou)"" "o )e& e& on !%) !%)!u(s !u(s" "n" n"% %&& ev%* ev%*en en!e !e "o su$$o)" %"s !on!&us%on o- u%&". /%)!u(s"n"%& ev%*en!e ev%*en!e %s "" ev%*en!e :'%! %n*%)e!"& $)oves  -!" %n %ssue ")ou n %n-e)en!e '%! "e -!";+n*e) *)'s -)o( "e ev%*en!e es"&%se*.:"e)e %s (o)e "n one !%)!u(s"n!e? %%> "e -!"s -!"s -)o( -)o( '%! '%!  "e "e %n-e %n-e))en!e en!e %s *e)% *e)%ve ve* * )e )e $)ov $)oven en?? n* %%%> %%%> "e "e

!o(%n"%on o- && !%)!u(s"n!es %s su! s "o $)o*u!e  !onv%!"%on eon* )eson&e *ou".: && "e !%)!u(s"n!es (us" e !ons%s"en" '%" one no"e), !ons%s"en" '%" "e $o"es%s "" "e !!use* %s u%&" n* " "e s(e "%(e %n!ons%s"en" '%" "e $o"es%s "" e %s %nno!en". Tus, !onv%!"%on se* on !%)!u(s"n"%& ev%*en!e !n e u$e&* $)ov%*e* "" "e !%)!u(s"n!es $)ove* !ons"%"u"e n un)oen !%n '%! &e*s "o one -%) n* )eson&e !on!&us%on "" $o%n"s "o "e !!use*, "o "e e@!&us%on o- && o"e)s s "e u%&" $e)son. In "%s !se, "e !%)!u(s"n!es -oun*  "e / s -o)(%n n un)oen !%n &e*%n "o one -%) n* )eson&e !on!&us%on "" $e"%"%one), "o "e e@!&us%on o- && o"e)s, %s "e u%&" $e)son.  Te )e!o)*s )eve& "" "e)e 's no ee'%"ness "o "e !"u& %&&%n o-  &e)"o. Tus "e !ou)"s e&o' 'e)e -o)!e* "o )en*e) "e%) ve)*%!" o-  !onv%!"%on on !%)!u(s"n"%& ev%*en!e s sn!"%one* un*e) Se!"%on 4, Ru&e 133 o- "e Ru&es o- /ou)". Te !en")& %ssue no' !on-)on"%n "%s /ou)" %s 'e"e) "e $)ose!u"%on s ($& $)ove*  !%)!u(s"n"%& ev%*en!e $e"%"%one)s u%&" eon* )eson&e *ou".  Te !%)!u(s"n"%& ev%*en!e )e&%e* u$on  "e /ou)" o- $$e&s su!%en"& su$$o)" $e"%"%one)s !onv%!"%on.