Search
Home
Saved
0
7 views
Sign In
Upload
RELATED TITLES
0
1 Uploaded by karl
Books
Audiobooks
Magazines
ty
Save
Embed
Share
Print
Yamane vs. BA Lepanto
1
Download
News
Documents
Sheet Music
Join
of 5
United States v. Leonard Paulk,
Banda vs Ermita GR NO. 166620;
Search document
REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT MALACAÑANG, MALACAÑANG, MANILA TOURISM INFRASTRUCTURE AND ENTERPRISE ZONE AUTHORITY, AUTHORITY, REPRESENTED BY ITS ITS CHIEF OPERATING OPERATING OFFICER, THE HONORABLE MARK T. LAPID,
Petitioner-Appellee,
O.P. _____________ OSJ Case N. !"##$-$$
-versus-
NATIONAL %ATER RESOURCES BOARD, Respondent-Appellant, x-----------------------------------------------------------x
COMMENT & OPPOSITION 'T( 'T( A))ea* Me+a/+ a0e 1 O203e 4!$4 56*e 37 08e Na06a* %a0e Res/2es Ba9
Appellee Appellee TOURISM TOURISM INFRASTRUCT INFRASTRUCTURE URE AND ENTERPRISE ENTERPRISE ONE
AUT!ORIT" AUT!ORIT" #TIEA$, represented represented %& its C'ie( Operatin) O((i*er, Mar+ T T apid respe*t(ull& states.
/
On /0 /0 Nove Nove1% 1%er er 23/ 23/2, 2, itit re*e re*eiv ived ed a *op *op& & o( t'e t'e 4 O*t O*to% o%er er 23/ 23/
Appeal Me1orandu1 Me1orandu1 (iled %& t'e appellant appellant assailin) assailin) t'e Ma& 25, 23/
Resolution and Au)ust /6, 23/2 Order respe*tivel& rendered %& t'e !onora%le
Se*retar& o( 7usti*e in t'e a%ove-entitled *ase rulin) t'at PETITIONER TIEA
'as t'e sole and ex*lusive ri)'t to re)ulate all utilities, in*ludin) 8ater8or+s and Sign up to vote on this title
se8era) se8era)e e s&ste1s, s&ste1s, in 9ora*a 9ora*a& & and ot'er ot'er tourist tou ristUseful :ones; :ones;and 9ora*a& Island Not useful
Home
Saved
Books
Audiobooks
Magazines
News
Documents
Sheet Music
Upload
Sign In
Join
Search
Home
Saved
0
7 views
Sign In
Upload
RELATED TITLES
0
1 Uploaded by karl
Books
Audiobooks
Magazines
ty
Save
Embed
Share
Print
News
Documents
Yamane vs. BA Lepanto
1
Download
Join
of 5
United States v. Leonard Paulk,
Banda vs Ermita GR NO. 166620;
Search document
2
Sheet Music
2
Appellee su%1its t'at t'e said Noti*e o( Appeal (iled %& respond
appellant s'ould %e denied (or t'e (ollo8in) reasons, to 8it.
I.
Res)e0 N%RB:s ;/6s6206 0 e62e A20 =8628 6s +ee*7 a
5 T'e Pu%li* Servi*e A*t is a )eneral la8 8'i*' deals 8it' 8at utilities in )eneral On t'e ot'er 'and, t'e Touris1 A*t deals 8it' utilities in in tourist :ones onl&, and t'us, *an %e *onsidered
You're Reading a Preview Unlock full access with a free trial.
Download With Free Trial
Sign up to vote on this title
Useful
Not useful
Home
Saved
Books
Audiobooks
Magazines
News
Documents
Sheet Music
Upload
Sign In
Join
Search
Home
Saved
0
7 views
Sign In
Upload
RELATED TITLES
0
1 Uploaded by karl
Books
Audiobooks
Magazines
ty
Save
Embed
Share
Print
News
Documents
Yamane vs. BA Lepanto
1
Download
Join
of 5
United States v. Leonard Paulk,
Banda vs Ermita GR NO. 166620;
Search document
3
Sheet Music
08e Se2e0a7 5 J/s062e, as Attorne& ?eneral and ex o((i*io le)al adviser o( all )overn1ent-o8ned or *ontrolled *orporations and entities, in *onsonan*e 8it' se*tion 45 o( t'e Revised Ad1inistrative Code !is rulin) or deter1ination o( t'e @uestion in ea*' *ase s'all %e *on*lusive and %indin) upon all t'e parties *on*erned #Unders*orin) supplied$
Se*tion 6 o( Presidential De*ree No 2=2 provides. >Se*tion 6 T8e e26s6s 5 08e Se2e0a7 5 J/s062e , as 8ell as t'ose o( t'e Soli*itor ?eneral or t'e ?overn1ent Corporate Counsel, 8'en approved %& t'e Se*retar& o( 7usti*e, s8a** 3e 56a* a 366< /) 08e )a06es
6>*>e. A))ea*s +a7 3e 0ae 0 a e0e0a6e 37 08e O5562e 5 08e Pes6e0 *7 6 2ases =8ee6 08e a+/0 5 08e 2*a6+ >a*/e 5 08e ))e07 e2ees P$ +6**6. T'e de*isions o( t'e O((i*e o( t'e President on appeal *ases s'all %e (inal #E1p'asis supplied$
Se*tion 0 o( Presidential De*ree No 2=2 provides. >Se*tion 0 T8e 56a* e26s6s eee 6 08e se00*e+e0
a;/62a06 5 a** s/28 6s)/0es, 2*a6+s 20>es6es s8a** 8a>e 08e sa+e 52e a e55e20 as 56a* e26s6s 5 08e 2/0s 5 ;/s062e. #E1p'asis supplied$ You're Reading a Preview
5
It is *learl& stated under 6 o( PD No 2=2 t'at Unlock full access se*tion with a free trial.
appeals 1a& %e ta+en to and entertained %& t'e O((i*e o( t'e President Download With Free Trial onl& in *ases 8'erein t'e a1ount o( t'e *lai1 or value o( t'e propert& ex*eeds P/ 1illion In t'e *ase at %ar, t'e issue neit'er involves a 1one& *lai1 nor a propert& T'e issue 1erel& involves a @uestion o( Burisdi*tion !en*e, no appeal 1a& %e ta+en %& N
=
In United CMC Textile
up to vote on this title 'eld t'at >t'e ri)'t to appeal is not a naturalSign ri)'t nor a part o( due
Useful
Not useful
pro*ess; it is 1erel& a statutor& privile)e, and 1a& %e exer*ised onl& in t'e
Home
Saved
Books
Audiobooks
Magazines
News
Documents
Sheet Music
Upload
Sign In
Join
Search
Home
Saved
0
7 views
Sign In
Upload
RELATED TITLES
0
1 Uploaded by karl
Books
Audiobooks
Magazines
ty
Save
Embed
Share
Print
News
Documents
Yamane vs. BA Lepanto
1
Download
Join
of 5
United States v. Leonard Paulk,
Banda vs Ermita GR NO. 166620;
Search document
4
Sheet Music
as lon) as t'e la8 provides (or an appeal, t'e ri)'t to appeal is part o( due pro*ess
6
Furt'er1ore, in UP v CSC 2, t'e Supre1e Court ruled t'at
>a a))ea* 6s 0 )a0 5 /e )2ess, 3/0 a s0a0/07 )6>6*e
+a7 3e ee26se *7 6 08e +ae a =6086 08e )e6 )es263e 37 *a=. A =8ee 08e *a= es 0 <a0 a 6<80 0 a))ea*, s/28 e+e7 2a0 3e 6>e. #E1p'asis supplied$ 0
Sin*e t'e ri)'t to appeal (ro1 t'e de*ision o( t'e Se*retar&
o( 7usti*e to t'e O((i*e o( t'e President is neit'er provided in Presidential De*ree No 2=2, its I1ple1entin) Rules nor in t'e /4 Ad1inistrative Code, t'e said re1ed& *annot %e invo+ed %& 'erein appellant
II.
Res)e0 N%RB:s ;/6s6206 0 e62e A20 =8628 6s +ee*7 a
RELIEF
%HEREFORE, )e+6ses 2s6ee, it is respe*t(ull& pra&ed t'at t'i
!onora%le O((i*e issue an order den&in) said Noti*e o( Appeal (or utter la*+ o 1erit
Ot'er relie(s, Bust and e@uita%le under t'e pre1ises, are li+e8ise pra&ed (or Cit& o( Manila, 23 Nove1%er 23/2
Sign up to vote on this title
Useful
Not useful
Home
Saved
Books
Audiobooks
Magazines
News
Documents
Sheet Music
Upload
Sign In
Join
Search
Home
Saved
0
7 views
Sign In
Upload
RELATED TITLES
0
1 Uploaded by karl
Books
Audiobooks
Magazines
ty
Save
Embed
Share
Print
Download
News
Documents
Join
Yamane vs. BA Lepanto
1
of 5
United States v. Leonard Paulk,
Banda vs Ermita GR NO. 166620;
Search document
5
Sheet Music
C86e5 O)ea06< O5562e
C)7 F/6s8e '37 )esa* se>62e9( THE EECUTI?E DIRECTOR T!E NATIONA
108 F*, NIA B/6*6< EDSA D6*6+a, /e C607
FRANCIS H. JARDELEZA SOICITOR ?ENERA T'e O((i*e o( t'e Soli*itor ?eneral /5= A1orsolo Street, e)aspi Illa)e Ma+ati Cit&
JOHN EMMANUEL F. MADAMBA ASSISTANT SOICITOR ?ENERA T'e O((i*e o( t'e Soli*itor ?eneral /5= A1orsolo Street, e)aspi Illa)e Ma+ati Cit& You're Reading a Preview MAISARA C. DANDAMUN-LATIPH
STATE SOICITOR II Unlock full access with a free trial. T'e O((i*e o( t'e Soli*itor ?eneral /5= A1orsolo Street, e)aspi Illa)e Download With Free Trial Ma+ati Cit&
Sign up to vote on this title
Useful
Not useful
Home
Saved
Books
Audiobooks
Magazines
News
Documents
Sheet Music
Upload
Sign In
Join
