IN THE COURT OF SH.NOROTTAM KAUSHAL, PRINCIPAL JUDGE DISTT.FAMILY COURT, NORTH-WEST, ROHINI COURTS, DELHI MAINTENANCE PETITION NO.______/2016 IN THE MATTER OF SMT.SHAHEEN PARVEEN
…PETITIONER
VERSUS SHAKEEL @ GAURAV
…RESPONDENT
REPLY !Y AND ON !EHALF OF THE RESPONDENT TO THE PETITION UNDER SECTION 12" C#.P.C. MOST RESPECTFULLY SHOWETH PRELIMINARY O!JECTIONS 1. That the petition is not aintaina!"e a"so in #ie$ o% the %a&ts that the petitione' is (ain (ain%) %)"" ""* * ep" ep"o* o*e+ e+ an+ an+ the the 'esp 'espon on+e +ent nt is tota""* )nep"o*e+ an+ "ea+in( han+ to o)th "i%e. ,. That That the the peti petiti tion on +ese +ese'# '#es es +is +isis issa sa" " as the petitione' has &on&ea"e+ the 'ea" %a&ts$hi&h a"a%i+e"* oti#es. . That the petition petition is +e!a''e+ +e!a''e+ an* &a)se o% a&ti a&tion on an+ an+ has has !een een %i" %i"e+ $it $ith a"a a"a% %i+e i+e oti#e an+ on the !asis o% &on&o&te+ %a&ts an+ sto'*. /. That the petition o% the petitione' is !ase !ase+ +
on
a"to a"to(e (eth the' e'
%a"s %a"see-
!ase !ase" "ess ess
an+ an+
&on&o&te+ a""e(ations an+ the petitione' has &oe
%o'$a'+
&on& &on&o& o&t te+
$ith
sto' sto'ie ies s
a"to(ethe' an+ an+
the the
%a"se
peti petiti tion one' e'
an+ is
()i"t* o% is'ep'esentation an+ s)pp'ession o% t')e %a&ts an+ as s)&h the petition is "ia!"e to !e +isisse+.
0.
That
the
petitione'
he'se"%
is
()i"t*
an+ t'eate+ the 'espon+ent $ith &')e"t* an+ &a)se+
enta"
tension
an+
to't)'e
to
the
ans$e'in( 'espon+ent +is&"osin( he' &hi"+'en an+ p'e#io)s a''ia(e a%te' to / onths o% (ettin( . The &')e" t'eatent ete+ o)t to the
'espon+ent
a+#e'se
ipa&t
!*
the
on
petitione'
'espon+ents
!'o)(ht
hea"th
an+
the 'espon+ent "ost his $o'2in( st'en(th an+ positi#e
thin2in(
petitione'
is
+)e
to
t'*in(
+ep'ession. to
ta2e
The
)n+)e
a+#anta(es o% he' o$n $'on(s an+ as s)&h the petition is "ia!"e to !e +isisse+.
3.That the petition %i"e+ !* the petitione' in
the
p'esent
%o'
is
"e(a""*
not
aintaina!"e in as )&h as the sae is not in
a&&o'+an&e
$ith
pe'sona"
"a$
as
s)&h
the petition is "ia!"e to !e +isisse+.
4.
That
petition
is
a!so")te"*
#a()e
an+
a!i()o)s an+ "a&2s pa'ti&)"a's an+ e#ents. The
petition
%a"se
an+
has
!een
%'i#o"o)s
+'a%te+
p"eas
an+
!*
ta2in(
as s)&h
the
petition is "ia!"e to !e +isisse+.
5. That the petition is an a!)se o% p'o&ess o% "a$. The oti#e !ehin+ the %i"in( o% the petition
is
'e"ati#es
that
$ant
to
the
petitione'
p)t
)n+)e
an+
p'ess)'e
he' )pon
the 'espon+ent to e6to't one* %'o hi an+ as
s)&h
+isisse+.
the
petition
is
"ia!"e
to
!e
7.That
the
ans$e'in(
'espon+ent
has
ne#e'
t)'ne+ o)t he' %'o the ho)se. The petitione' has
he'se"%
"e%t
the
&opan*
o%
the
'espon+ent- in %a&t she $as so hosti"e an+ a!)si#e
in
nat)'e
that
no
p')+ent
an
&an
e6pe&t s)&h !eha#io' %'o his $i%e. 18.That it is pe'tinent to ention he'e that the
petitione'
ans$e'in(
has
sta'te+
'espon+ent
in
ha'assin(
#a'io)s
the
$a*s
!*
a!)sin( in %i"th* "an()a(e- an+ !* othe' $a*s o%
to't)'e
$hen
the
petitione'
a+e
%a"se
&op"aints $ith 9A: &e"" ;No'th<. 11.That the petitione' has not &oe to the &o)'t
$ith
&"ean
han+s
an+
s)pp'esse+
the
t')e %a&ts !e%o'e this Hon!"e 9o)'t- hen&e the
p'esent
petition=app"i&ation
is
"ia!"e
to !e +isisse+. 1,.That the petitione' has !een a >)a"i%ie+ !ea)tition- ea'nin( a han+soe ao)nt has no "o&)s
stan+i
to
%i"e
!e&a)se she $as ha#in(
the
p'esent
petition
animus dessrendi
sin&e
the +a* $hen he' t')th o% p'e#io)s a''ia(e an+ ha#in( &hi"+'en %'o sai+ a''ia(e &ae to
2no$"e+(e
&on&ea"ent
o% o%
ans$e'in( he'
'espon+ent-
p'e#io)s
a''ia(e
th)s an+
&hi"+'en the'e %'o a2es he' "ia!"e to !e p'ose&)te+ in &'iina" &o)'t o% "a$. She a"so &oitte+
se'ies
o%
&')e"ties
to$a'+s
the
'espon+ents $itho)t an* "e(a" ?)sti%i&ation.
1,. That no &a)se o% a&tion e#e' a&&')e+ in the %a#o' o% the petitione' an+ a(ainst the Respon+ent-
hen&e
the
p'esent
petition=app"i&ation is not aintaina!"e an+ is "ia!"e to !e +isisse+ $ith &ost. 1. That the petitione' has
"e%t the &opan*
o%
o$n
the
'espon+ent
at
he'
%o'
$'on(s
&oitte+ !* he' to$a'+s 'espon+ent. 1/.
The
&ontents
o%
ea&h
an+
e#e'*
p'e"iina'* o!?e&tion a* 2in+"* !e 'ea+ as 'ep"* to ea&h o% the pa'a on e'its- $ho so e#e'- it is 'e"e#ant.
REPLY ON MERITS CUM FACTUAL SU!MISSIONS That the ans$e'in( 'espon+ent &'a#es the "ea#e o% this &o)'t that the &ontents o% the
a++itiona"
p"eas
an+
s)!issions
entione+ )n+e' sepa'ate hea+in( a"so !e 'ea+ as pa't an+ pa'&e" to this 'ep"* on e'its
&)
%a&t)a"
s)!issions
as
the
sae a'e not !ein( 'epeate+ %o' sa2e o% !'e#it*.
REPLY ON MERITS 1.
That
the
&ontents
o%
pa'a
1
o%
the
petition a'e not a+itte+ to the e6tent that a''ia(e
$as
so"enie+
a&&o'+in(
to
M)s"i
'ites an+ &e'eonies at Tis Haa'i 9o)'ts. It is
s)!itte+
petitione'
an+
that
a''ia(e
'espon+ent
$as
!et$een pe'%o'e+
Masi+ ateh P)'i-9han+ni 9ho$2 - Ne$
the at
De"hiB
11883.
Sin&e-
+i%%e'ent
the
'espon+ent
'e"i(ion
!e"on(e+
i.e.CHin+)C
to
an+
a
the
petitione' &ae to &onta&t o% 'espon+ent in the *ea'
-,81/
$hen
she
opene+
a
!ea)t*
pa'"o)'
nea' in the #i&init* o% 'espon+ent an+ a%te' (ettin(
inte'a&tion
at
se#e'a"
o&&asions
+e&i+e+ to a''* $ith ea&h othe' she o%%e'e+ a p'oposa"
%o'
+is&"osin(
a''ia(e
the
#e'*
to
'espon+ent
%a&t
o%
he'
$itho)t p'e#io)s
a''ia(e an+ th'ee &hi"+'en %'o sai+ $e+"o&2 th)s-
&on&ea"in(
the
%a&ts
o%
a''ia(e an+ &hi"+'en a'e a+e
p'e#io)s
an+ !oth the
pa'ties !e"on( to "o$ st'ata o% so&iet* $he'e the &on&ept o% e6&han(e o% +o$'* a'ti&"es a'e #e'* !i( thin(.
,.
That
the
&ontents
o%
pa'a
petition a'e $'on( an+ +enie+.
,
o%
the
It is +enie+
that the a''ia(e $as so"enie+ $ith +i(nit* an+
(oo+
+o$'*
$as
p'esente+.
It
is
+enie+
that a''ia(e pa't* $as a"so (i#en (oo+ %east. It
is
s)!itte+
so"enie+
in
a
that #e'*
the sip"e
a''ia(e $a*
$as
$itho)t
e6&han(e o% an* (i%ts an+ +o$'* a'ti&"es.
.
That
the
&ontents
o%
pa'a
petition a'e $'on( an+ +enie+. that
$hen
the
at'ionia"
&op"ainant
hoe
a%te'
o%
the
It is +enie+
'ea&he+
a''ia(e-
at
the
the
h)s!an+
Ha'in+e' Sin(h- othe'BinB"a$ O!i'i an+ Ra?pa" Sin(h
an+
Ra?)-
$ho
is
the
!'othe'
o%
the
%athe'BinB"a$ o% the &op"ainant $e'e not happ* $ith
the
sta'te+
+o$'*
sa*in(
(i#en that
in
the
the
+o$'*
a''ia(e
an+
(i#en
the
in
a''ia(e is not a&&o'+in( to thei' stat)s an+ thei' p'esti(e has !een "o$e'e+ in the so&iet* %'o this a''ia(e.
/.
That
the
&ontents
o%
pa'a
petition a'e $'on( an+ +enie+. that
the
othe'
in
"a$
o%
/
o%
the
It is +enie+
the
&op"ainant
sta'te+ sa*in( that (oo+ p'oposa" o% a''ia(e $e'e &oin( %o' an* p"a&es %o' he' son the* $o)"+
ha#e
a''ia(e thei'
(i#en
(oo+
the* ha#e not
e6pe&tations
an+
+o$'*(ot
the
sta'te+
!)t
in
+o$'*
this
as pe'
+ean+in(
an+
p'ess)'isn( the &op"ainant to !'in( one "a& o% ')pees +o$'*.
an+
one
A"to
9a'
%o'
he'
pa'ent
in
0.
That
the
&ontents
o%
pa'a
petition a'e $'on( an+ +enie+.
0
o%
the
It is +enie+
that Sh'i Ra?pa" Sin(h- $ho is the !'othe' o% the
%athe'BinB"a$
o%
the
&op"ainant
is
a"so
)na''ie+ an+ 'esi+in( ?oint"* $ith the %ai"* o%
he'
h)s!an+
a"so
sta'te+
sa*in(
that
the
%ai"* o% the &op"ainant is not a&&o'+in( to thei'
stat)s
an+
the
&op"ainant
sho)"+
ie+iate"* !'in( at "east ')pees o% one "a& an+
one
A"to
&op"ainant
3.
That
9a'
in
+o$'*
othe'$ise
the
$i"" not 'eain in thei' ho)se.
the
&ontents
o%
pa'a
petition a'e $'on( an+ +enie+.
3
o%
the
It is +enie+
that a"" the %ai"* e!e's o% the h)s!an+ o% the
&op"ainant
sta'te+
+is&a'+in(
an+
ins)"tin( the &op"ainant an+ e#en +i+ not (i#e s)%%i&ient %oo+ to he' an+ $as not (i#en "o#e an+ a%%e&tion to the &op"ainant as is 'e>)i'e+ %o' a ne$"* $e++e+ !'i+e.
4.
That
the
&ontents
o%
pa'a
petition a'e $'on( an+ +enie+. that
$hen
!eha#io)'
the to$a'+s
&op"ainant he'
an+
4
o%
the
It is +enie+ oppose+
+o$'*
thei'
+ean+
the
h)s!an+
o%
the
&op"ainant
(a#e
he'
se#e'e
!eatin(s $ith %ist an+ "e(s an+ the othe' in "a$ O!i'i an+ Ra?pa" Sin(h $e'e a"so stan+in( !esi+es an+ this !eatin(s !* he' h)s!an+ $as (on( on at the instan&e o% the.
5.
That
the
&ontents
o%
pa'a
petition a'e $'on( an+ +enie+.
5
o%
the
It is +enie+ in
%e$ +a*s in the at'ionia" hoe the* a"" a+e he' "i%e a he"".
7.
That
the
&ontents
o%
pa'a
petition a'e $'on( an+ +enie+. that
on
10.1,.,885-
&op"ainant !'in( a%te'
the
a"on(
$hen
$ith
&op"ainant
a''ia(e.
&op"ainant
to"+
%e$ to
It he'
the
is
7
o%
It is +enie+ %athe'
pe'sons
he'
o%
the
&ae
pa'enta"
+enie+
%athe'
the
that
'e(a'+in(
to
hoe the this
+o$'* +ean+ o% Rs.1-88-888=B an+ one A"to 9a'. It
is
atte'
+enie+ $ith
that Ra?pa"
the an+
%athe' the
+is&)sse+
h)s!an+
o%
the the
&op"ainant an+ to"+ the that he has a"'ea+* (i#en )&h in +o$'* an+ no$ he &annot (i#e this a++itiona" +o$'* as +ean+e+ !* the.
18. That
the
&ontents
o%
pa'a
petition a'e $'on( an+ +enie+.
18
o%
the
It is +enie+
that on hea'in( this the h)s!an+ an+ his a!o#e %ai"* e!e's "ost thei' tepe' an+ ins)"te+ $ith
hi &"ea'"* to"+ that *o) a* &a''* *o)'
+a)(hte' ie+iate"* an+ she &an sta* in he' at'ionia" hoe on"* i% Rs.1-88-888=B an+ one A"to 9a' is (i#en to the.
It is +enie+ that
the* +i+ not p'o#i+e %oo+ to he' %athe' an+ the peop"e- $ho ha+ &oe $ith hi.
11. That
the
&ontents
o%
pa'a
petition a'e $'on( an+ +enie+.
11
o%
the
It is +enie+
that the &op"ainant $as th'o$n o)t %'o he' at'ionia" hoe in th'ee $ea'in( &"othes an+ 'etaine+ a"" the +o$'* a'ti&"es an+ ist'i+han.
1,. That
the
&ontents
o%
pa'a
petition a'e $'on( an+ +enie+. that !ein(
the the
&op"ainant "ite'ate
is
"a+*
a
1,
the
It is s)!itte+
(ain%)""*
an+
o%
is
ep"o*e+
"ea+in(
#e'*
+e&ent "i%e at De"hi as she has no "ia!i"it* to &a''* on.
1. That
the
&ontents
o%
pa'a
petition a'e $'on( an+ +enie+.
1
o%
the
It is $'on( an+
+enie+ that the 'espon+ent is a an o% eans an+ he o$ns 8 !i(has o% "an+ in his nati#e #i""a(e an+ ea'n Rs.,8-888=B pe' onth. It is s)!itte+ that the 'espon+ent is "ea+in( han+ to o)th "i%e as he +oes not ha#e an* p'ope't* in
his
nae
an+
he
is
not
in
ep"o*ent
on
'e()"a' !asis an+ is a"so not &apa!"e o% +oin( the an)a" $o'2 on +ai"* $a(es.
He soe ho$
ana(es to e2e o)t his "i#e"ihoo+ an+ o)t o% that has to aintain an+ to "oo2 his o"+ a(e+ pa'ents.
1/. That
the
&ontents
o%
pa'a
petition a'e $'on( an+ +enie+.
1/
o%
the
It is +enie+
that the 'espon+ent has +ese'te+ an+ ne("e&te+ the &op"ainant an+ has 'e%)se+ to aintain the &op"ainant.
It
is
s)!itte+
that
the
&op"ainant- $ho is t)ne+ to the &osopo"itan aenities is not a!"e to a+?)st to the nati#e #i""a(e o% the 'espon+ent an+ %o' the sae the 'espon+ent is not at a"" 'esponsi!"e as he is &oope'atin( )&h $ith he'- !)t +espite that the &op"ainant +i+ not a2e e%%o't to a+?)st %o'
"ea+in(
he'
"i%e
in
a&&o'+an&e
$ith
the
p'e#ai"in( so&ia" &)sto an+ o'es.
10. That
the
&ontents
o%
pa'a
petition a'e $'on( an+ +enie+. that
the
'espon+ent
has
no
10
o%
the
It is +enie+
othe'
"ia!i"it*
e6&ept to aintain the &op"ainant.
13. That
the
&ontents
o%
pa'a
13
o%
the
petition a'e "e(a".
The p'a*e' &"a)se o% the petition is $'on( an+
+enie+
in
toto.
The
petitione's
a'e
"ia!"e
to
petition !e
o%
+isisse+
the $ith
e6ep"a'* &osts.
DELHI DATED1$.0$.2010
RESPONDENT THROUGH JAYKANT PRASAD AD%OCATE SEAT NO.$0, CI%IL WING, TIS HA&ARI COURTS, DELHI-1100"'
IN THE COURT OF MS. SUNAINA SHARMA, M.M., DISTT. EAST, KARKARDOOMA COURTS, DELHI MAINTENANCE PETITION NO.______/200( IN THE MATTER OF SMT.
NEHA
…PETITIONER VERSUS
SH. HARINDER SINGH
…RESPONDENT
REPLY ON AND !EHALF OF RESPONDENT TO THE APPLICATION FOR AD-INTERIM ON !EHALF OF THE PETITIONER. MOST RESPECTFULLY SHOWETH
1.
That
the
app"i&ation $'on(
an+
a'e
pa't"*
+enie+.
petitione' )na!"e
&ontents
has
to
ea'n
aintaina!"e petitione'
no
It
he'
no
pa'a
a+itte+ is
so)'&e
he'se"%. has
o%
1 an+
+enie+ o%
o%
in&oe
o#ea!"e
is an+
pa't"*
that
"i#e"ihoo+ It
the
the
an+ an+
+enie+
is to
that
io#ea!"e
p'ope't* o' in&oe to aintain he'se"%.
,.
That
the
app"i&ation
.
That
&ontents
o%
pa'a
,
o%
the
o%
pa'a
o%
the
a'e a+itte+.
the
&ontents
app"i&ation a'e $'on( an+ +enie+.
It is +enie+
that the app"i&ant 'e>)i'e a s) o% Rs.0-888=B p.. %o' he' inte'i aintenan&e a""o$an&e %o' he' aintenan&e an+ hen&e see2s an o'+e' %'o this Hon!"e 9o)'t as p'a*e+ %o' in the ain petition.
/.
The &ontents o% pa'a / o% the app"i&ation
a'e atte' o% 'e&o'+ an+ the &ontents o% the 'ep"* to the sai+ petition a* 2in+"* !e 'ea+ as pa't an+ pa'&e" o% this app"i&ation- $hi&h a'e
not
'ep'o+)&e+
he'ein
%o'
the
sa2e
o%
app"i&ation
is
!'e#it*.
The
p'a*e'
&"a)se
o%
the
$'on( an+ +enie+ in toto. The app"i&ation o% the petitione's a'e "ia!"e to !e +isisse+ $ith e6ep"a'* &osts.
DELHI DATED1$.0$.2010
RESPONDENT THROUGH JAYKANT PRASAD AD%OCATE SEAT NO.$0, CI%IL WING, TIS HA&ARI COURTS, DELHI-1100"'
IN THE COURT OF MS. SUNAINA SHARMA, M.M., DISTT. EAST, KARKARDOOMA COURTS, DELHI MAINTENANCE PETITION NO.______/200( IN THE MATTER OF SMT.
NEHA
…PETITIONER VERSUS
SH. HARINDER SINGH
…RESPONDENT
AFFIDA%IT I- Ha'in+e' Sin(h- S=o R=o
Vi""a(e
Distt.
Fha!hisha-
M)a%%a'
Na(a'
Sh.
en+e' Sin(h-
Tehsi"
;U.P.<
F)+hana-
p'esent"*
at
De"hi- +o he'e!* so"en"* a%%i' an+ +e&"a'e as )n+e'B 1.
That the +eponent is the 'espon+ent in the
a!o#e note+ &ase an+ is $e"" &on#e'sant $ith the %a&ts o% the &ase an+ is &opetent to s$ea' this a%%i+a#it. ,.
That
the
&ontents
o%
the
a&&opan*in(
'ep"* to the petition )n+e' Se&tion 1,0 9'.P.9. has
!een
+'a%te+
!*
*
&o)nse"
)n+e'
*
inst')&tions an+ the &ontents o% the sae ha#e !een 'ea+ o#e' an+ e6p"aine+ to e an+ I ha#e )n+e'stoo+ the sae an+ a'e not 'epeate+ he'ein %o' the sa2e o% !'e#it*.
DEPONENT %ERIFICATION Ve'i%ie+ at De"hi on this 15th +a* o% the A)()st- ,818 that the &ontents o% the a!o#e a%%i+a#it a'e t')e to * 2no$"e+(e an+ no pa't o% it is %a"se an+ nothin( ate'ia" has !een &on&ea"e+ the'e%'o.
DEPONENT
