Royal Plant Workers Union vs. Coca Cola Bottlers Philippines, Inc.. –Cebu Plant

!"#$% '%$() *"!+,!- .(/"( 0-1 2"2$ 2"%$ 3"))%,!- '4/%/''/(,-5 /(211 62,3. '%$() 7$2)-8

"#$%$%&'#( )&*+,)&-+ .&$$-#(/ "0%-%11%'#/2 3'*4 5))."36 %/ + 7&8#/$%* *&(1(+$%' #'9+9#7 %' $0# 8+':;+*$:(#2 /+-#2 +'7 7%/$(%<:$%&' &; /&;$7(%'= 1(&7:*$/4 >0# <&$$-%'9 &1#(+$&(/ ?#(# 1(&@%7#7 ?%$0 *0+%(/ :1&' $0#%( (#A:#/$/4 .:$ $0#/# ?#(# (#8&@#7 1:(/:+'$ $& + '+$%&'+- 7%(#*$%@# &; 1#$%$%&'#( B3 &1#(+$#2 3 8+%'$+%'2 3 *-#+'B 1(&9(+84 >0# (#/1&'7#'$/ C:/$%;%#7 $0%/
I&' $0# (#8&@+- &; $0# <&$$-%'9 &1#(+$&(/J *0+%(/ ;(&8 ))."3J/ 1(&7:*$%&'K8+':;+*$:(%'9 -%'#/ + @+-%7 #F#(*%/# &; + 8+'+9#8#'$ 1(#(&9+$%@#L 4,%98

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` 8%':$#/ <#$?##' (&$+$%&'/4 >0# <&$$-%'9 &1#(+$&(/_ '#? ?&(= /*0#7:-# %/ *#($+%'-D +7@+'$+9#&:/ $& $0#8 <#*+:/# %$ 9(#+$-D %'*(#+/#/ $0#%( (#/$ 1#(%&7 +'7 /%9'%;%*+'$-D 7#*(#+/#/ $0#%( ?&(=%'9 $%8#4 G <(#+= $%8# &; $0%($D 5Z`6 8%':$#/ +;$#( ?&(=%'9 ;&( &'-D &'# +'7 + 0+-; 5Y ]6 0&:(/ %/ + C:/$ +'7 ;+%( ?&(= /*0#7:-#4 >0# &1#(+$&(/_ *0+%(/ *+''&$ <# *&'/%7#(#7 +/ &'# &; $0# #81-&D## <#'#;%$/ *&@#(#7 %' G($%*-# Y`` &; $0# T+<&( )&7#4 3' $0# )&:($_/ @%#?2 $0# $#(8 a<#'#;%$/b 8#'$%&'#7 %' $0# '&',7%8%':$%&' (:-# (#;#(/ $& 8&'#$+(D <#'#;%$/ &( 1(%@%-#9#/ 9%@#' $& $0# #81-&D## ?%$0 8&'#$+(D #A:%@+-#'$/4 O:*0 <#'#;%$/ &( 1(%@%-#9#/ ;&(8 1+($ &; $0# #81-&D##/_ ?+9#2 /+-+(D &( *&81#'/+$%&' 8+=%'9 $0#8 #';&(*#+<-# &<-%9+$%&'/4