Professional Video, Inc. vs. Tesda

PROFESSIONAL VIDEO, INC. vs. TESDA G.R. No. 155504 June 26, 200 S!""AR# OF FACTS$ PROVI %&s &n en'(') en*&*e+ (n 'e s&-e o (* 'e/no-o*) eu(en', (no3&'(on 'e/no-o*) 3o+u/'s &n+ 3o&+/&s' +ev(/es, (n/-u+(n* 'e su-) o -&s'(/ /&3+ 3(n'(n* &n+ se/u3(') &/(-('(es.  TESDA (s & sus(+(&3) sus(+(&3) 3&n/ o 'e De&3'en' o o L&o3 &n+ E-o)en' E-o)en' DOLE es'&-(se+ un+e3 Reu-(/ A/' R.A. No. 776 'e TESDA A/' o 14 'o 8+eve-o &n+ es'&-(s & n&'(on&- s)s'e o s9(--s s'&n+&3+(:&'(on, s'&n+&3+(:&'(on, 'es'(n*, &n+ /e3'(;/&'(on (n 'e /oun'3).< To u-;- '(s &n+&'e, (' sou*' 'o (ssue se/u3(')=3(n'e+ /e3'(;/&'(on &n+>o3 (+en'(;/&'(on o-)v(n)- PVC /&3+s 'o '3&(nees %o &ve &sse+ 'e /e3'(;/&'(on 3o/ess. 3o/ess.  TESDA?s P3e=@u&-(;/&'(on P3e=@u&-(;/&'(on (+s A%&3+ A%&3+ Co(''ee Co(''ee PAC /on+u/'e+ /on+u/'e+ '%o 2 2 u-(/ (++(n*s on June 25, 1 &n+ Ju-) 22, 1 o3 'e 3(n'(n* &n+ en/o+(n* o PVC /&3+s. Due 'o 'e &(-e+ (++(n*, 'e PAC 3e/oen+e+ '&' TESDA en'e3 (n'o & ne*o'(&'e+ /on'3&/' %(' PROVI. On De/ee3 2, 1, TESDA &n+ PROVI s(*ne+ &n+ eBe/u'e+ 'e(3 8Con'3&/' A*3eeen'< o3 'e 3ov(s(on o *oo+s &n+ se3v(/es (n 'e 3(n'(n* &n+ en/o+(n* o PVC /&3+s. !n+e3 'e Con'3&/' A*3eeen', PROVI %(-- su-) TESDA %(' 'e /on'3&/'e+ *oo+s &n+ se3v(/es '&' %ou-+ /o-) %(' 'e se/(;/&'(ons +e;ne+ (n 'e Te/n(/&P3oos&- &n+ (n 'u3n, TESDA %ou-+ &) PROVI 'e &oun' o T(3')=N(ne "(--(on Fou3 un+3e+ &n+ Seven')=F(ve Tous&n+ Pesos P,475,000 %('(n ;'een 15 +&)s &'e3 TESDA?s &//e'&n/e o 'e /on'3&/'e+ *oo+s &n+ se3v(/es. In & -&'e3 +&'e, TESDA &n+ PROVI eBe/u'e+ &n 8A++en+u 'o 'e Con'3&/' A*3eeen'< %ose 'e3s oun+ PROVI 'o +e-(ve3 one un+3e+ e3/en' 100 o 'e enue3&'e+ su-(es 'o TESDA /ons(s'(n* o ;ve un+3e+ 'ous&n+ 500,000 (e/es o se/u3(') o(- ;ve 5 (e/es o se/u3(') +(e %(' TESDA se&- ;ve un+3e+ 'ous&n+ 500,000 (e/es o 3e=3(n'e+ &n+ /us'o(:e+ (+en'(;/&'(on /&3+s one un+3e+ 'ous&n+ 100,000 (e/es o s/&nn&-e &ns%e3 see's &n+ ;ve un+3e+ 'ous&n+ 500,000 /us'o(:e+ TESDA o-o*3&(/ -&(n&'e. In &++('(on, PROVI %ou-+ (ns'&-- &n+ &(n'&(n 'e o--o%(n* eu(en'$ one 1 un(' o "(/3oo(se, "(/3oo(se, '%o 2 un('s o /&3+ 3(n'e3, '3ee  un('s o &'e+ s/&nne3, one 1 un(' o O"R s/&nne3, one 1 un(' o Se3ve3, &n+ seven 7 un('s o e3son&- /ou'e3.

STATE"ENT OF RELEVANT ISS!E$ He'e3 TESDA, &s &n &*en/) o 'e S'&'e, /&n e o3 /&nno' e sue+ %('ou' ('s /onsen'. CO!RT?S R!LING ON TE ISS!E$  Te Su3ee Cou3' &3e+ 'e +e/(s(on o 'e Cou3' o Ae&-s '&' 'e3e %&s *3oss (s3e&+(n* o 'e -&% &n+ u3(s3u+en/e &oun'(n* 'o &/'(on (n eB/ess o 'e Re*(on&- T3(&- Cou3'?s u3(s+(/'(on.  TESDA (s &n (ns'3uen'&-(') o 'e *ove3nen' un+e3'&9(n* *ove3nen'&- un/'(ons.  TESDA, &s &n &*en/) o 'e S'&'e, /&nno' e sue+ %('ou' ('s /onsen'.  TESDA?s un+s &3e u-(/ (n /&3&/'e3, en/e eBe' 3o &''&/en' o3 *&3n(sen'.

PROVI &s no' so%n '&' (' (s en'('-e+ 'o 'e %3(' o &''&/en'. I' &(-e+ 'o /o-) %(' 'e '%o *3oun+s enue3&'e+ (n Se/'(on 1, Ru-e 57 o 'e Ru-es o Cou3' 'o %(/ &''&/en' &) (ssue$  In &n &/'(on o3 one) o3 3oe3') ee::-e+ o3 3&u+u-en'-) (s&-(e+ o3 /onve3'e+ 'o (s use ) & u-(/ o/e3, o3 &n o/e3 o & /o3o3&'(on, o3 &n &''o3ne), &/'o3, 3o9e3, &*en' o3 /-e39, (n 'e /ou3se o (s e-o)en' &s su/, o3 ) &n) o'e3 e3son (n & ;+u/(&3) /&&/('), o3 o3 & %(--u- v(o-&'(on o +u') + In &n &/'(on &*&(ns' & &3') %o &s een *u(-') o 3&u+ (n /on'3&/'(n* 'e +e' o3 (n/u33(n* 'e o-(*&'(on uon %(/ 'e &/'(on (s 3ou*', o3 (n /on/e&-(n* o3 +(sos(n* o 'e 3oe3') o3 'e '&9(n*, +e'en'(on o3 /onve3s(on o %(/ 'e &/'(on (s 3ou*'