Republ i coft hePhi l i ppi nes Nati onalCapi t alJudi ci alRegi on Muni ci palTr i alCour t Angono,Ri zal
RI ZALPROV OVI NCI AL GOV OVERNMENT, Pl ai nti ff, ver sus-
SCA CaseNo.__ __ __ _ For :Unl awf wf ulDet ai ner
For t unat oAndaya,NoelVal eri ano, Br andoAbocat al ,Toma m asAbocat al , RoqueEst or ni no,Mi chel l eGa Gal i si ng, Evel ynOňot ,Vi r gi l i oPascua, NormaPensocas,Cor azon SanAnt oni o, JoseRi ver a,Joj oRi ver a, Manuel Ri ver a, Def endant s.
PRE RETRI ALBRI EF
Pl ai nt i ff, Ri zal Pr ovi nci al Gover nment ( her ei naf t er r ef er r ed t o as “ RPG” f or br evi t y) ,t hr ough t he under si gned co unse l and unt ot hi s Honor abl e Cour t mos tr e spec t f ul l y s ubmi t st hi sPr e Tr i alBr i e f ,t owi t :
AMI CABLE SETTLEMENT
Pl ai nt i ffi swi wi l l i ngt os e t t l et hec as eami c abl yasl ong ast het er mst her eofar er easonabl e.
FACTS FOR STI PULATI ON
Pl ai nt i ff,i no r de rt oe xpe di t et hepr oc e e di ng so ft hi s case, pr oposes t he f ol l owi ng f act s f or st i pul at i on and/or submi ss i on:
1.Pl ai nt i ffi st her e g i s t e r e do wne ro ft hel o ts ubj e c tmat t e ro f t hi scas e ; 2.Def endant sar epr esent l yoccupyi ngt hel otsubj ectmat t er oft hi sc as e ; 3.De f e ndant s ,wi t ho utj us t i fiabl er e a s on,c o nt i nuo us l yf ai l e d and r ef use dt o vac at e sai d pr emi se s des pi t e not i ce t o v acat es entt ot hem;
I SSUES
1.Whe t herornotdef endant s’occ upancyon t hel otsubj ec t mat t e roft hi sc as e be c ome si l l e g alaf t e rt he i rf ai l ur et o v acat et he s ame wi t houtj us t i fiabl er eas on and despi t e no t i c et ov ac at e ? 2.Whe t her or not def endant s ar el i abl ef or t he cos t s of l i t i gat i on.
DOCUMENTSFOR MARKI NG
Pl ai nt i ff woul dl i ke t o pr opose t he mar ki ngs oft he f o l l o wi ngdo c ume nt s ,t owi t :
Ex hi bi t“ A” -Re s ol ut i o nNo .083,s .3012 Exhi bi t“ B” -TaxDecl arat i onNo.01000509999 Exhi bi t “ C” - Tr ansf er Cer t i ficat e of Ti t l e No. 0682011007648 Exhi bi t“ D” -SPResol ut i onNo.142,s.2012 Exhi bi t“ E” -DemandLe t t erdat edJune28,2012f or TomasAbocat al Exhi bi t“ E1” -Si gnat ur eappeari ngatt hebot t om oft he demandl e t t erf orTomasAbocat al Exhi bi t“ F” -DemandLet t erdat edJune28,2012f or Ev el ynOnot Exhi bi t“ F1” -Si gnat ur eanddat eappeari ngatt hebot t om oft hedemandl et t erf orEvel ynOnot Exhi bi t“ G” -DemandLet t erdat edJune28,2012f or Mi c he l l eGal i s i ng Exhi bi t“ G1” -Si gnat ur eanddat eappear i ngatt hebot t om oft hede mandl e t t e rf orMi c he l l eGal i s i ng Exhi bi t“ H” -DemandLet t erdat edJune28,2012f or Joj oRi v er a Exhi bi t“ H1” -Si gnat ur eappeari ngatt hebot t om oft he de mandl e t t e rf o rJo j oRi v e r a Exhi bi t“ I ” -DemandLet t erdat edJune28,2012f or Vi r gi l i oPascua Ex hi bi t“ I 1” -Si g nat ur eanddat eappe ar i ngatt hebo t t o m o ft hede mandl e t t e rf o rVi r g i l i oPas c ua Exhi bi t“ J” -DemandLet t erdat edJune28,2012f or Br andoAbocat al
Exhi bi t“ J1” -Si gnat ur eappeari ngatt hebot t om oft he demandl et t erf orBr andoAbocat al Exhi bi t“ K” -DemandLe t t erdat edJune28,2012f or Cor az onSanAnt oni o Exhi bi t“ K1” -Si gnat ur eappeari ngatt hebot t om oft he demandl et t erf orCor azonSanAnt oni o Exhi bi t“ L” -DemandLet t erdat edJune28,2012f or RoqueEs t or ni no Exhi bi t“ L1” -Si gnat ur eappear i ngatt hebot t om oft he demandl et t erf orRoqueEst orni no Exhi bi t“ M” -DemandLet t erdat edJune28,2012f or Jos eRi v er a Exhi bi t“ M1” -Si gnat ur eanddat eappeari ngatt hebot t om o ft hede mandl e t t e rf o rJo s eRi v e r a Exhi bi t“ N” -DemandLet t erdat edJune28,2012f or ManuelRi v er a Exhi bi t“ N1” -Si gnat ur eappeari ngatt hebot t om oft he demandl et t erf orManuelRi ver a Exhi bi t“ O” -DemandLet t erdat edJune28,2012f or No e lVal e r i ano Ex hi bi t“ O1” -No t at i o n“ Re f us et oSi g n”appe ar i ngatt he bot t om oft hedemandl et t erf orNoelVal er i ano Exhi bi t“ P” -DemandLet t erdat edJune28,2012f or For t unat oAnday a Exhi bi t“ P1” -Not at i ons appear i ng att he l ef tport i on of t he demandl et t erf orFort unat oAndaya
Exhi bi t“ E1” -
Pl ai nt i ffr eser vedt heri ghtt omar kot herdocument s dur i ngt hecour s eoft r i al ,i fne ce ss i t at e d.
WI TNESSES/AFFI DAVI TS
Pl ai nt i ff wi l l pr es ent /submi tt he affidavi t s of t he f ol l owi ng: 1.Affidavi tofSant i agoM.Abr er a,Pr es i dentKapi sanan ng Maybahay ansaPur ok6& 7I nc . 2.Affidavi tof___ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___ __ ofRi zalProvi nci al Gov er nment ,Ser ve rofDemandLe t t er s
Pl ai nt i ffr eserv ed t he r i ghtt o pr esent /submi tot her wi t nes ses /affidavi t s dur i ng t he cour se of t he t r i al /posi t i on pape r ,i fne ce ss i t at e d.
RESPECTFULLY SUBMI TTED.
Ant i pol oCi t yf orAngonoRi z al ,June10,2013
OFFI CE OF THE PROVI NCI AL LEGAL OFFI CER Counself ort hePl ai nt i ff Ri z alPr o v i nc i alCapi t olBl dg. , Ci r c umf e r e nt i alRo adCo r ne rP .Ol i v e r o sSt . , Br gy .SanRoque,Ant i pol oCi t y1870 By: ATTY.ROSELLE ANDALLO RAMI LO OI C-Pr ovi nci alLegalOfficer PTR No.9611411/010113/Ri z al I BPNo.882447/010413/Ri z al Rol lNo.43742 MCLECompl i anceNo.1110020170 By: ATTY.MARI VI C MORGI A FERUELO Rol lofAt t orneyNo.61649 I BPNo.907512/011613/Ri z al PTR No.9739131/013013/Ri z al MCLE Compl i ance :I V0013224
CopyFur ni s hed:
At t y.Fr ancoFer nandezdeGuzman Cer ez oandDeGuz manLa w Offic e Counself orJoseRi ver a,Joj oRi ver aandManuelRi ve r a No.4C K9th St r e e tc or ne rCo l .Sal g adoSt r e e t Wes tKami as,Que z onCi t y
For t unat oAndaya NoelVal eri ano Br andoAbocat al TomasAbocat al RoqueEst orni no Mi chel l eGal i si ng Evel yn Oňot Vi r gi l i oPascua Nor maPensocas CorazonSanAnt oni o, Br gy .MahabangPar ang, AngonoRi z al
