Petitioner P2 Memorial

- P R E L I M I N A R I E S A DV A N C E D -

Page | i

TA B L E O F C O N T E N T S INDEX OF AUTHORITIES........................................... .......... II ................. ..................... ..................... ............. .. V LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS............................ ........ ............... ................ ............ ........ ...... VII STA STATEMENT OF JURISDICTION............... ........ ............... ............... ................ ............... .............. ........... .... VIII SYNOPSIS OF FACTS................ ....... ................ ............... ............... ................ ............ ........ .... IX STATEMENT OF ISSUES............... ....... ................ ............... .............. ........... ........ ...... .. X SUMMARY OF ARGUMENTS............... ....................................... ........................ ............. .. 1 ARGUMENTS ADVANCED..........................

I. WHETH HETHER ER THE THE DIV DIVORCE ORCE NOT NOT BEIN BEING G IN CONF CONFOR ORMI MITY TY WITH ISLAMIC LAW BE DECLARED AS A NULLITY?...........1

A. That Tr Triple-talaq is talaq is not recognized under the Holy Quran, under any source of Shia Law and that the requisite procedure for talaq under talaq under the Quran was not followed......................................1 II. II. WHETH HETHER ER DOME DOMES STIC TIC VIOL VIOLEN ENCE CE ACT, 2005 2005 TO THE THE EXTENT THAT IT GIVES RIGHTS TO WOMEN BEYOND THE PERIOD OF IDDAT IS AGAINST ARTICLE 25 OF THE CONSTITUTION?............................................................2

A. That That igh ightt to el elig igio ion n is su!" su!"ec ectt to pu!l pu!lic ic ord order, er, #ora #orali lity ty and health and su!"ect to the other pro$isions pro$isions of %art &&& of the 'onstitution of &ndia...................................................................................( ). That the *o#e o#estic +iolence nce Act, ( is applica!le to usli# wo#en............................................................................................../ III. III. WHET WHETHE HER R THE THE COUR COURT T SHOU SHOULD LD REJE REJECT CT SHAH SHAHEE EEN NS S APPLICATION APPLICATION UNDER THE DOMESTIC VIOLENCE ACT AND WHETH WHETHER ER AFREEN AFREEN CAN BE MADE MADE RESPON RESPONDEN DENT T UNDER UNDER THE SAME ACT?............................................................!

A. The court should grant relief to Shaheen under the *o#estic +iolence Act, (. .................................................................0 -W SUBMISSION ON & OTHERS RITTEN S UBMISSION ON BEHALF OF BEHALF OF THE THE S HAHEEN &

- P REL IMI NA RIES A DV AN CED -

Page | ii

). That the cousin can !e #ade a respondent under the Act.0 '. That the apart#ent in reater %alash co#es under the de2nition of 3shared household4 under section (5s6 of the Act. 0 *. That the court should pass a protection order under Section 17 and residence order under Section 18 of the Act .....

PRAYER................................................................................... XI

-W RITTEN SUBMISSION ON BEHALF OF THE S HAHEEN & OTHERS-


Page | iii

INDEX OF AUTHORITIES A. INDIAN CASES

1. Ajay Kumar Madanlal Bajla v. Mrs. Neha Vishal Bajla 2011(3)ALLMR303..........................5 2. Ali Nawaz v. Mohd. Yusuf P.L.D. 1963 S.C. 51.........................................................................2 3. Aziz Bano v. Muhammad (1925) 47 All. 823; 89 I.C. 690; (’25) A.A. 720...............................1 4. Danial Latifi and anr. v. Union of ndia! AIR2001SC3958.......................................................4 5. "veneet #in$h v %rashant &haudhri 177(2011)DLT124...........................................................5 6. 'ajendra #in$h v. Mina(shi Yadav MANU/RH/0338/2011......................................................5 7. )*al Bano v. #tate of U.%. and Anr  (2007) 6 SCC 785............................................................4 8. sh+al #in$h Kahai v. ,amanjeet Kahai !P 576 "# 2011 $"%&' H*+ C",-.......................5 9. -aved  /rs. v. #tate of 0aryana AIR 2003 SC 3057...............................................................3 10. -ohn Vallamattom v. Union of ndia (2003) 6 SCC 611............................................................3 11. Khushi Mohd. and /rs. v. #mt. Aneesha 2011 (3) C-% 7; MANU/RH/0485/2011...............4 12. Kunimohammed v. Ayisha(utty 2010 (2) HC 63.....................................................................2 13. Mohd. Ahmed Khan v. #hah Bano Be$um and /rs (1985) 2 SCC 556.....................................4 14. N. Adithyan v. 1ravan2ore Devaswom Board  /rs (2002 8 SCC 106)...................................3 15. Nur Ali 3Md4 v. 1ham*al #ana Bi*i 2007 (1) LT 508.............................................................2 16. %. Ba*u Ven(atesh  /rs. v. ,ani 20082L!(C-l)451............................................................6 17. ,amesh Da$a v ,ameshwari Bai(2005) 4 SCC 772................................................................6 18. ,iaz 5atma v. Mohammed #harif I (2007) DMC 26; 135 (2006) DLT 205..............................2 19. ,u(ia Khatun v. A*dul Khali)ue Las(ar (1981) 1 ',. L.R. 375;............................................2 20. #.,. Batra v. 1aruna Batra (2007) 3 S.C.C. 169........................................................................6 21. #amar 'hosh v. -aya 'hosh (2007) 4 SCC 511........................................................................6 22. #andhya Manoj 6an(hade v. Manoj Bhimrao 6an(hade And /thers (2011) 3 SCC 650........5 23. #arat2handra Mishra v #tate of /rissa(2006) 1 SCC 638........................................................6 24. #atya v. #iri ,am AIR 1983 P H 252.........................................................................................6 25. #ha*ana Bano v. mran Khan AIR2010SC305.........................................................................3 26. #hamim Ara v. #tate of U.%. and Anr (2002) 7 SCC 513...........................................................2



Page | iv

27. #mt. #arita v. #mt. Umrao 2008 (1) R. C-. D 97........................................................................5 28. #ri -iauddin Ahmed v. Mrs. Anwara Be$um (1981) 1 LR 358...............................................2 29. #uman Ka+oor v. #udhir Ka+oor AIR 2009 SC 589.................................................................6 30. #yed Md. Nadeem 7 Mohsin and /rs. v. #tate and Anr MANU/D/2460/2011......................4 31. Ummer 5aroo)ue v. Naseema 2005 (4) LT 565......................................................................2

B. BOOKS 1. $ASU DD CNSTITUTINAL LA!  I NDIA’ (!ADH!A A ND CMPAN 7TH DITIN  NAPUR ) (R P. 2003) 2. MULLA PRINCIPLS  MAHMDAN LA! (LIS NIS $UTTR!RTHS  I NDIA 19+ DN. 16+ R PRINT  N! DLHI) (2007) 3. NARAANA P. S. LA!  DI:RC IN I NDIA (IA LA! ANC  I NDIA HDRA$AD ) (2007) 4. $ASHI P.M. TH CNSTITUTIN  I NDIA (U NI:RSAL LA! PU$LISHIN C. I NDIA 8 TH DN N! DLHI ) (2007) C. DICTIONARIES

1. AIAR  R AMANATHA P. 810" LA6 L"9&/N: !ADH!A < CMPAN 2 ND DN. NAPUR (2002). 2. $LAC  HNR CAMP$LL  BLA&K# LA6 D&1/NA,Y ’ 6TH DN. CNTNNIAL D. (18911991). 3. CUR=N. L. $ 8D&1/NA,Y /5 LA6: PITMAN PU$LISHIN  4TH DN. N! DLHI (1994). 4. ARNR  $RAN A. 8A D&1/NA,Y /5 M/D",N L"'AL U#A'": RD U NI:RSIT PRSS 2 ND DN. RD (1995). 5. RN$R  DANIL AND ALANDRA 

MILL$R 

8#1,/UD;#

-UD&AL

D&1/NA,Y /5 6/,D#  %0,A#"#: :L. 2 6TH  DN. L NDN S !T < MA!LL (2000). 6. >USTIC D SAI M.C. AND AIAR  SU$RAMANAM  ? LA6 L"9&/N  L"'AL MA9M# @ 2 ND DN. DLHI DLHI LA! HUS (1980). 7. MITRA $.C. < MITRA A.C. 8L"'AL 10"#A,U#: U NI:RSIT $  ALLAHA$AD (1997). 8. MS LI=A$TH M. ?&LA##5&A1/N  10"#AU,U# 5/, L"'AL MA1",AL@ 3RD DN. LNDN $!R SAUR (1992).



Page | v

9. PP. A.S. ?60A,1/N;# LA6 L"9&/N @ 14TH DN. N! DLHI S!T < MA!LL (1997). 10. PRM DAULATRAM ? -UD&AL D&1/NA,Y @ 1ST DN. >AIPUR  $HARAT LA! PU$LICATIN (1992).

D. STATUTORY COMPILATIONS 1. I NDIAN CNTRACT ACT 1872 2. AR$ITRATIN AND CNCILIATIN ACT 1996 3. TH CNSTITUTIN  I NDIA 1950

E. INTERNET SITES 1. +//BBB.#l'B.E"% 2. +//BBB.'F'"".E"% 3. +//BBB.l'B#"."-*/ 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9.

+//BBB.G"-."-*. +//BBB.G,.E. +//BBB.l'B"#'."-* +//BBB.%','-'.E"% +//BBB.EE"l.E"% +//BBB.,-%E",-E'l'B.E"%



Page | vi

LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS A.I.R. All All E.R. AP Bom C.L.R. Cal Co. Comm. CWN Del Edn. e.g. K.B. Lah LR Mad MANU M.P. Pat PC p. Para. Pn !C !CC !CN U.P. W.L.R.

A LL  NDA , "%/,1", A LLA0ABAD A LL " N'LAND , "%/,1", A ND0,A % ,AD"#0 B/MBAY & /MM/N6"AL10 L A6 , "%/,1", & AL&U11A & /M%ANY & /MM##/N", & AL&U11A 6 ""KLY N /1"# D "L0 " D1/N "9"M%LUM ',A1A 3 5/, "9AM%L" 4 K N'# B"N&0 L A0/," L A6 , "%/,1", M AD,A# MANU%A1,A

M AD0YA % ,AD"#0 % A1NA % ,VY & /UN&L % A'" % A,A',A%0 % UN-AB AND 0 A,YANA # U%,"M" &/U,1 # U%,"M" &/U,1 &A#"# # 0/6 & AU#" N /1&" U 11A, % ,AD"#0 6 ""KLY L A6 , "%/,1#



Page | vii

S TAT E M E N T O F J U R I S D I C T I O N SHAHN HAS APPRACHD TH HN’$L HIH CURT  N NA: DALL UNDR ARTICL 226  TH CNSTITUTIN  I NDIA. TH MATTR HAS $N CNNCTD !ITH ANTHR RLATD !RIT PTITIN AND HAS $N LISTD R INAL DISPSAL.

ARTICL 226  TH CNSTITUTIN  I NDIA RADS AS

HRUNDR 

 226. P"WER "# $ $I%$ C C"UR&! &" I!!UE CER&AIN WRI&!.' 3<4 N /1610#1ANDN' ANY10N' N A,1&L" =>! "V",Y 0 '0 & /U,1 #0ALL 0AV" %/6", ! 10,/U'0/U1 10" ! 1/ ##U" 1/ ANY %",#/N /, AU10/,1Y ! 1",,1/,"# N ,"LA1/N 1/ 60&0 1 "9",&#"# -U,#D&1/N ! ANY ' /V",NM"N1 ! 610N 10/#" 1",,1/,"# D,"&1/N# ! /,D",# /, N&LUDN' N A%%,/%,A1" &A#"# ! N&LUDN' 6,1# N 10" NA1U," /5 0AB"A# &/,%U# ! MANDAMU# ! %,/0B1/N ! ?U/ 6A,,AN1/ AND 6,1# ! /, ANY /5 10"M ! 5/, 10" "N5/,&"M"N1 /5 ANY /5 10" ,'01# &/N5",,"D BY % A,1  AND &",1/,A, 5/, ANY /10", %U,%/#" .

3>4 1 ! /,D",# /, 6,1# 1/ ANY '/V",NM"N1 ! 0" %/6", &/N5",,"D BY &LAU#" 3<4 1/ ##U" D,"&1/N# AU10/,1Y /, %",#/N MAY AL#/ B" "9",&#"D BY ANY 0 '0 & /U,1 "9",&#N' -U,#D&1/N N ,"LA1/N

! 60/LLY /, N %A,1 ! A,#"# 5/, 10" "9",&#" 1/ 10" 1",,1/,"# 610N 60&0 10" &AU#" /5 A&1/N /5 #U&0 %/6", ! N/1610#1ANDN' 10A1 10" #"A1 /5 #U&0

'/V",NM"N1 /, AU10/,1Y /, 10"

,"#D"N&" /5 #U&0 %",#/N # N/1 610N 10/#" 1",,1/,"# .

3=4... 3@4...





Page | viii

S Y N O P S I S O F FA C T S 

!haheen and !oha(l  S+'+ ' +' M,l% %'-- S"+'l ' , M,l%. S+'+ 

E", - "# A#- B+"  S"+'l’ E", - " %'-'l . 

Relo)at(on to Na*( Dall+  T+ E",l -l"E' " N' D'll ' '- l*  ' 1 $H

''-%  -'- P'l'+ "B & A%- S"+'l’ &-"+- ' -%' EJ "# U &, + %''E E+'-* "# + #l' B- ' & S"+'l. T+ +' *" ' #l'  l"-  :'- :+'- K" P+' 3. S"+'l  , ' -*- '--+ -- S"+'l < S'+l A"E' B+ S"+'l’ E"ll* #- S'+l. 

&he D(,pte  A#- -l"E'" " N' D'll S+'+ B' " +' ' E+l ' ' ' +"%

B+l S"+'l +",*+  B' "" '-l l'* " %' +' '-*,%. A#- B' ,,EE#,l  -* &B B".  N"%&- 10 2010 S"+'l ' S+'+ +' ' +' '-*,% "- + '% ,. A#- + '-*,% S"+'l -,- '#- 2 +",- #-"% ' B'lF ' "-E S+'+ B+ +- -"",E% "# ?tala)@. A#- B' ' B " + ' E", " l  + ' ''-%. S"+'l %" ", "# + +", ' '- l* ' ' - *, +", #-"% + '--+ #-%. 

#(l(ng o- the ,(t  S+'+ #l ' 'lE'" ,- D"%E :"lE AE 2005 &#"-

M'*-'  N' D'll " -#-' S"+'l ' A#- #-"% "* +- #-"% +- ''-% ' '-"'E+ El E",- " * ' El'-'" +' + "-E  ' ,ll B+E+ B' # & S"+'l. S"+'l '-*, +' D"%E :"lE AE 2005 " + K +'  * -*+ " B"% &" + -" "# iddat  '*' + #,'%'l -*+ " -'E + -l*" B+l A#- '-*, +' + E'’ & %' -" ,- D"%E :"lE AE. 

Wr(t pet(t(on, S+'+ #l ' B- " E+'ll** + "-- "# + Cl >,* D-E

C",- "# N' D'll. S"+'l #l ' B- " E+'ll** + D"%E :"lE AE 2005. $"+ %'- +' & E"E & ' "-- "# + N' D'll H*+ C",- ' '- l "*+- #"- #'l "'l. 



Page | ix

STATEMENT OF ISSUES TH APPLLANTS RSPCTULL ASS TH HN’$L SUPRM CURT  I NDIA TH LL!IN USTINS 

  I!!UE / I W$E&$ER &$E DI0"RCE N"& BEIN% IN C"N#"RMI&1 WI&$ I!LAMIC LAW BE DECLARED A! A NULLI&1

ISSUE – 2 WHETHER DOMESTIC VIOLENCE ACT, 200 TO THE EXTENT THAT IT GIVES RIGHTS TO WOMEN BEYOND THE PERIOD OF IDDAT IS AGAINST ARTICLE 2 OF THE CONSTITUTION!

ISSUE – " WHETHER THE COURT SHOULD REJECT SHAHEEN#S APPLICATION UNDER THE DOMESTIC VIOLENCE ACT AND WHETHER AFREEN CAN BE MADE RESPONDENT UNDER THE SAME ACT!

 



Page | x

SUMMARY OF ARGUMENTS NULLITY OF D DIVORCE I  +,%&l ,&% +' %' E+"l'- "# M'+"%' l'B +' +l +' -ltala) +' " ,-'E &'  #'E "-E +' & E+'-'E-J ' - &'l ' %'--'* +' & E-& ' ' #unnat. T-ltala)  K-l &'-- ,- S+' l'B. ,-+- + ?uran -E-& ' E-' -"E,- " & #"ll"B &#"- "-E* + B# B+E+ +' & ,+l & %' E",-  + E",- ' B+E+ B' " #"ll"B & S"+'l.

DOMESTIC V VIOLENCE A ACT

BEING A AGAINST A ARTICLE 2 2 OF THE

CONSTITUTION. I  ,&% +' A-El 25 " " E"#- ' '&"l, -*+ '  ,&GE " "E'l -#"-% '%"* "+- +* ' Bll +-#"- & ,&GE " &#E'l l*l'". T+-  ' E" &B -l*", -'EE ' -l*", &l# ' A-El 25 '##"- -"E" "l " -l*", &l#. REJECTION OF S SHAHEEN#S APPLICATION UNDER THE D DOMESTIC

VIOLENCE A ACT

AND A AFREEN#S STATUS OF R RESPONDENT. I  +,%&l ,&% +' S+'+  ' E% "# "%E "lE. ,-+- + -'-

P'l'+ ''-% E"% B+ + #" "# ?+'- +",+"l@ ,- + D"%E :"lE AE 2005. L'l A#- E' & %' ' -" ,- + AE.


- A RGUMENTS A DVANCED-

 Page 1 o 5-

ARGUMENTS ADVANCED I.

WHETHER THE DIVORCE NOT BEING IN

CONFORMITY WITH ISLAMIC LAW BE DECLARED AS A NULLITY! A.

THAT TRIPLE-TALAQ IS NOT RECOGNIZED UNDER THE HOLY QURAN,

SHIA L AW AND THAT THE REQUISITE PROCEDURE FOR UNDER ANY SOURCE OF S QURAN WAS NOT FOLLOWED. TALAQ UNDER THE UNDER THE Q 1. I  %" +,%&l ,&% +' ' - SE" 2 "# + M,l% P-"'l L'B (S+'-') AlE'" AE 1937 NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT  M,l% -"'l l'B Bll & 'lE'&l " + ' ,. I  #,-+- ,&% +' ' 'l %'--'* +' & "l%J &B ' S, %'l ' ' S+' #%'l. NTR R#318563612 +

O MRRMAT

I Aziz Bano v. Muhammad +

E",- E B+ '-"'l A%- Al’ E"%%'- " + M,+'%%'' L'B B+E+ ' +' S+'

'

S,

%'

-%'--

B+",

'

E+'*

"#

E

"-

E"%%,". NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT 2. I  ,&% +' M,l% l'B - " + #",-#"l ll'- "# + fi)h '%l1 + ?uran 3(ita*4!

+

#unna

jma N/1","5 ,ef=<C=<> Eh

3hadith4

EF M",'"5/,MA1

N/1","5

,ef=<C=<>

Eh

' ?iyas N/1","5 ,ef=<C=<> Eh

EF

M",'"5/,MA1

EF M",'"5/,MA1

!

+

. I# + "l," "# '

-"&l%  *  + ?uran +   + #'l -,l* "# sharia. I# +-  " El'- K"" NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT #ee alsoG MULLA %rin2i+les of Mahomedan Law (LK NK$,-B"-+ 19+  15+ -- NB Dl+ 2007) SE" 2 ' . 1. NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT *id.! SE" 258 ' . 226; #ee alsoG Aziz Bano v. Muhammad (1925) 47 All. 823; 89 I.C. 690; (’25) A.A. 720  %'--'* " El'- ' ,ll ' "+* '*'   + ?uran. NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT DE," " * "# -,l  Aziz Bano *id.! #-"%  912. 1 #u+ra " 1 SE" 33 ' . 22. NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT M'* + -E 'E" ' '* "# + P-"+ M'+"% " B- "B ,-* + l#% &, -- & -'" ' +' "B & *-'". NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT M'* + E"E,--E "# "" "# + E"%'" "# M'+"% ' + El. NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT $* ''l"*E'l ,E" - #-"% E"%'-" "# + #- +- ",-E



 Page 2 o 5-

 + ?uran B l""F ' + -'" "# + P-"+ (hadith4 ' # + -"&l% +' " "l,"  +- "# + B" + l  -"- 'F " jma. NTR

R#318563612 +


I 

,&% +' +-  " ?urani2 &' " '&l+ +' +- "-E " ' *l "EE'" +",l

'%",

"

'

--"E'&l

"-E;



#'E

+

P-"+

l"-

"-E NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT ' E-& %'--'* NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT ' + #unnat . 3. I  &E+ +' ' - + ?uran! +- %, & ##"- "B'- -E"El'" &B + "-E. NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT T+ B +' & ,+l & + E",-  #hamim Ara v. #tate of U.%. and Anr N/1","5 ,ef=<C=<> Eh

EF M",'"5/,MA1

+' () ' -'" #"- + "-E %, &

* ' () +- %, & ' '% " -E"El. T+ E' +' #,-+- & ,+l & + %' H*+ C",- NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT El,* + -l' HC  Kunimohammed v. Ayisha(utty. N/1","5

,ef=<C=<> Eh

EF M",'"5/,MA1

T+ E",- +l +' 81o us! it a++ears that this

de2laration of law rhymes well with modern notions of marria$e and the true slami2 2on2e+ts of marria$e and divor2eH 1hat de2laration of law is 2onsistent with modern notions of marria$e and rhymes *etter with the human ri$ht to life re2o$nized under Art.><. t rhymes well with the 2on2e+ts of e)uality under Art.<@ of the &onstitution. Any 2ontra inter+retation a++ears to us to *e not valid! just or ri$htI *ut ar*itrary! unjust fan2iful and o+ +ressive...:

NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT URAN AHMD1ri+le 1ala)G An Analyti2al #tudy with "m+hasis on #o2ioJLe$al As+e2t (R*E P,&lE'" NB Dl+ 1994) ' . 41 NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT ? Divor2e is most detesta*le in the si$ht of 'odI a*stain from it:; 8Divor2e sha(es the throne of 'od: E"% #-"% + 0adith 8AlJtala)u indallahJi a*$had al mu*ahat: #",  %' ',+E E"llE" "# -'". NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT T'+- M'+%"" Muslim Law of ndia (LKNK$,-B"-+ NB Dl+ 3- . 2002) ' . 48. NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT :- (434 35) ' E & AI=UR RAHMAN 8nstant Divor2e is alien to slam;s s+irit: I' K- "E+ . >, 17+ 2008; An "nli$htenment &ommentary into the Li$ht of the 0oly ?uran (T+ SE#E ' Rl*", C- I-' 2 . 1995) NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT (2002) 7 SCC 513; E B+ '-"'l #ri -iauddin Ahmed v. Mrs. Anwara Be$um (1981) 1 LR 358; ,u(ia Khatun v. A*dul Khali)ue Las(ar (1981) 1 ',. L.R. 375; NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT ,iaz 5atma v. Mohammed #harif I (2007) DMC 26; 135 (2006) DLT 205; Ummer 5aroo)ue v. Naseema 2005 (4) LT 565; Nur Ali 3Md4 v. 1ham*al #ana Bi*i 2007 (1) LT 508 NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT 2010 (2) HC 63



 Page 3 o 5-

4. I  ,&% +'  + ' E' S+'+ &* ' S+' + #"-% "# tala) Bll & 'l E   " -E"*J ,- S+' l'B. NTR R#318563612 +


,-+- + "-E

%, & -' ' ' ,ll E +- B' +- ' '% " -E"El'" "- B' ' -'" '* #"- + "-E. NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT

II.

WHETHER DOMESTIC DOMESTI C VIOLENCE VIOLENC E ACT, ACT, 200 TO THE EXTENT THAT IT GIVES RIGHTS TO WOMEN BEYOND THE PERIOD OF IDDAT IS AGAINST ARTICLE ARTICLE 2 2 OF THE CONSTITUTION!

A THAT R IGHT IGHT TO R ELIGION ELIGION IS SUBJECT TO PUBLIC ORDER , MORALITY AND MORALITY AND HEALTH AND SUBJECT TO THE OTHER PROVISIONS OF

P ART III OF THE

CONSTITUTION OF I INDIA . 5. I  +,%&l ,&% +' A-El 25(1) *,'-' " - -" ?+ #-"% "# E"EE@ ' ?+ -*+ #-l " -"# -'EE ' -"'*' -l*".@ I -aved  /rs. v. #tate of 0aryana N/1","5 ,ef=<C=<> Eh

EF M",'"5/,MA1

 + E",- ''lJ A-El 25(2)(&) ' +l

B+l *,+* &B ?-l*", -'EE@ ' ?-l*", &l#@ +' # -l*", -'EE -, E",- " ,&lE "-- %"-'l "- +'l+ "- ' "lE "# "E'l Bl#'- + + l'- -'l "- -l*", -'EE. NTR R#318563612 + 1ravan2ore Devaswom Board  /rs. N/1","5


,ef=<C=<> Eh

. ,-+-  N. Adithyan v.

EF M",'"5/,MA1

+ E",- +l +' '

E,"% "- ,'* "##* +,%' -*+ * ' "E'l Q,'l E'" & ,+l & + E",- "# + E",-. ,-+- , " A-El 44 NTR

R#318563612 +


"# +

NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT #u+ra " 1 SE" 311 ' . 262; #ee alsoG Ali Nawaz v. Mohd. Yusuf P.L.D. 1963 S.C. 51 NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT R#- &om+romis  4. NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT AIR 2003 SC 3057 NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT Al" ,+l #rinivasa Aiyar v. #araswathi Ammal AIR 1952 M' 193; #tate of Bom*ay v. Narasu A++a Mali AIR 1952 $"% 84 ('l "# + M'-' H, ($*'% P-" ' D"-E) AE 1949 ' + '% AE "# $"%&' -El.) NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT (2002 8 SCC 106) NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT Un(-orm )(*(l )ode -or the )(t(3en, . T+ S' +'ll '",- " E,- #"- + EJ ' ,#"-% El E" +-",*+",  + --"- "# I'.



 Page 4 o 5-

E"," E",- %, #'",- --'" "# ', " ' " #"- ,#"-%  -"'l l'B. I -ohn Vallamattom v. Union of ndia N/1","5 ,ef=<C=<> Eh

EF M",'"5/,MA1

! + E",- E"%'-

A-El 25 ' 44 ' +l +' %'--'* ,EE" ' lF %'- "# ' E,l'- E+'-'E- E'" & &-",*+ B+ + *,'-' +- ,- A-El 25 ' 26. I #,-+- "&- B+l -*-* +' A-El 44 +' " & * ##E " +' l*l'" B+E+ &-* ,E+ %'- B+ + '%& "# A-El 25 ' 26 '- ,E l*l'". 6. I #ha*ana Bano v. mran Khan N/1","5 ,ef=<C=<> Eh EF M",'"5/,MA1 ! + E",- -' -l' "-" #-"% #hah Bano N/1","5 ,ef=<C=<> Eh ' )*al Bano N/1","5 ,ef=<C=<> Eh

EF M",'"5/,MA1

 Danial Latifi N/1","5 ,ef=<C=<> Eh

EF M",'"5/,MA1

EF M",'"5/,MA1

! +l +'   E-'l El'- +' + SE" 125 "#

C-.PC &* ' &#E'l E "# l*l'" &# ,-  %, 'EE-, " + "-E M,l% B"%' E"El,* +' +  l " %''E &" + iddat -". T+ '% -'"* E' & ,l' #"- 'lE'" "# &# ,- + D"%E :"lE AE 2005 &" iddat .

B.

THAT THE D DOMESTIC V IOLENCE MUSLIM IOLENCE A CT CT, 2005 IS APPLICABLE TO M

WOMEN.

7. I  +,%&l ,&% +'  #yed Md. Nadeem 7 Mohsin and /rs. v. #tate and Anr. N/1","5 ,ef=<C=<> Eh

EF M",'"5/,MA1

  ''- +' , " + -"" "# + M,l% !"%

AE "% "# + -"" "# + D"%E :"lE AE Bll " 'l " M,l% &, "B* " %l'- -""  + H, M'--'* AE 1955 &, + '% B",l & ' l- l". ,-+- "B* " SE" 36 NTR R#318563612 +


"# + AE &# ,- "+-

-"" "# + AE Bll &  '" " K* ". NTR R#318563612 +


Al" +

NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT (2003) 6 SCC 611 NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT AIR2010SC305 NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT Mohd. Ahmed Khan v. #hah Bano Be$um and /rs (1985) 2 SCC 556 NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT Danial Latifi and anr. v. Union of ndia! AIR2001SC3958 NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT )*al Bano v. #tate of U.%. and Anr  (2007) 6 SCC 785 NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT MANU/D/2460/2011 NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT 46. A)t not (n derogat(on o- an+ other la5.T+ -"" "# + AE +'ll &  '" " ' "  -"*' " "# + -"" "# ' "+- l'B #"- + % &*  #"-E. NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT Khushi Mohd. and /rs. v. #mt. Aneesha 2011 (3) C-% 7; MANU/RH/0485/2011



 Page 5 o 5-

AE , + B"- ?'**- -"@ 'll"B* ' B %"- "# + -% +, E"-* ' #%'l.

III.

WHETHER THE COURT SHOULD RE JECT REJECT

SHAHEEN#S APPLICATION UNDER THE DOMESTIC VIOLENCE ACT AND WHETHER AFREEN CAN BE MADE RESPONDENT UNDER THE SAME ACT! A THE COURT SHOULD GRANT RELIEF TO SHAHEEN UNDER THE DOMESTIC V IOLENCE IOLENCE A CT CT, 2005. 8. I  +,%&l ,&% +' S+'+  ' E% "# "%E "lE B+E+ +' & #lE ," +- & S"+'l ' A#-. T+-  ' -'"'&l '-+" +' + Bll & " #-"% +- +'- +",+"l & + -". ,-+- ,- + D"%E :"lE AE 2005 + E", E' & %' ' -".

C.

THAT THE COUSIN CAN BE MADE A RESPONDENT UNDER THE UNDER THE A CT CT

9. U- E" 2 + AE ' E"%l' E' & #l '*' ' -l' "# + +,&' B+" +' --' + "lE. NTR R#318563612 +


T+ H"&l AK C",-  #andhya

Manoj 6an(hade v. Manoj Bhimrao 6an(hade And /thers N/1","5 ,ef=<C=<> Eh

EF M",'"5/,MA1

 +l

+' " --E %'* +' & * " + K-" ?-l'@ "- +' + ' K-" & E#E'll #  + AE. I ,E+ E-E,%'E   El'- +' + l*l',- -  " ' KEl, #%'l -l' "# + +,&' #-"% + '%& "# ' E"%l' +' E' & %' ,- + -"" "# + AE.

D.

THAT THE APARTMENT IN GREATER P ALASH COMES UNDER THE

SHARED HOUSEHOLD! UNDER SECTION 2"S# OF THE A CT DEFINITION OF  UNDER SECTION 2" CT. 10. I  '-' +' + AE K-l KEl, + E"-'" "# "B-+ -*+ ' ' E""

#"-

-%*

+",+"l NTR R#318563612 +

B++-


"-

"

'

'-E,l'-

-"-



'

+'-

. H,%' -*+ "# + -" "# + B# +' ll "

" B+ +- "B-+ -*+  -"-. NTR R#318563612 +


T+ +' & '##-%

NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT #mt. #arita v. #mt. Umrao 2008 (1) R. C-. D 97 NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT (2011) 3 SCC 650 NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT S E" 2() ' 17 "# + AE NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT sh+al #in$h Kahai v. ,amanjeet Kahai !P 576 "# 2011 $"%&' H*+ C",-



 Page 6 o 5-

 + &GE ' R'" "# + AE. SE" 17 'E ' -*+ " -E  #'",- "# B"%. T+ 'E% &* ' &#E'l " + C",- +",l F " ,+"l + '-l'%'- "

-'+-

+'

E"#*

l'*

"

#'*

+

"&GE

"#

+

l'B. NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT 11. I  ,&% +' S"+'l  + deJfa2to "B- "# + -'- P'l'+ ''-%. H ' + lE-E E+'-* B'- 'K +", 'K ' %''E. NTR R#318563612 +


A%-

 ' -%' - "# U *"% ' +' " l  + ' #l'. I  ' '&l+ -El "# l'B +' B+' E'" & " -El E'" & 'E+ -El +-",*+ -''*%. I# + C",- E' l""F &" + #'E '  ' * E' E"El, +' + "-'ll E"E, "# E-E,%'E ,** %',l'" & + +,&' "- + -l' " #' ' -*+ +-  + B# " ' "-- ,- SE" 19 ,E+ ?l#* "# + l@ +",l & -"- ". NTR R#318563612 +


I  El'- +' + S"+'l -'#-- + +", ,-

+ &-"+-’ '% * " #' S+'+’ -*+ " - +- ' -"- " S+'+’ "" &"+ '- - G"l  + +",+"l. NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT 12. !+", -G,E " + '&" Q,'* ?G" #'%l@  + AE " ' ?H, U '%l@ B",l E+'* + E,l'- ',- "# + AE. I  " '" + '"%'l +' P'-l'% El'-# +' --E "# l "# + ?-"@ " + ?+'- +",+"l@ ' -"E" "-- E' & %' ,- SE" 19(1)('). NTR R#318563612 +


I +' & -,l &

+ S,-% C",-  -'l G,*% +' ' G,*%  " " & -' ' ' ', E + #'E,'l %'-K  'l" %"-'. NTR

R#318563612 +


I  %"-' +-#"- "

*,+ + - E' #-"% + #.,. Batra v. 1aruna Batra N/1","5 ,ef=<C=<> Eh

EF M",'"5/,MA1

" &' "# ' %'-'l ##-E  #'E.

NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT "veneet #in$h v %rashant &haudhri 177(2011)DLT124; 'ajendra #in$h v. Mina(shi Yadav MANU/RH/0338/2011 NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT R#- " 3 "# + #'E+; Ajay Kumar Madanlal Bajla v. Mrs. Neha Vishal Bajla 2011(3)ALLMR303 NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT #u+ra " 35 NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT %. Ba*u Ven(atesh  /rs. v. ,ani 20082 L!(C-l)451 NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT #u+ra " 35 NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT #arat2handra Mishra v #tate of /rissa(2006) 1 SCC 638 ,amesh Da$a v ,ameshwari Bai(2005) 4 SCC 772 NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT (2007) 3 S.C.C. 169


- A RGUMENTS A DVANCEDE.

 Page 7 o 5-

THAT THE COURT SHOULD PASS A PROTECTION ORDER UNDER SECTION

$% AND RESIDENCE ORDER UNDER $& OF THE A CT ORDER UNDER SECTION $& CT 13. S+'+ +' &  ' ?"%E -l'"+@ NTR R#318563612 +


B+ + +,&'

'  ' E% "# "%E "lE ' +' ,##- ?-&'l ' %""'l '&,@ ' ?%'l +'-%@. NTR R#318563612 +


Ul'-'l E" "# + +,&' "- B# " -#, "

+' E+l- %' '%", " %'l E-,l. NTR

R#318563612 +


I# +,&'

l&-'l ' E"l -#, " '# B# ',-'l ' l*%' E-'* " +' ' E+l + -'" -,E +- " '- '  %',-l '##E +- %'l +'l+. NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT 14. I  +,%&l ,&% +' + C",- %' ' ' -"E" "-- ,- E" 18 " -"E 'EE " + E%’ '. ,-+- + C",- %' ' ' -E "-- ,- E" 19 -"E +- #-"% &* ". A - "vneet #in$h! + B#  l " -E  ' -"- E"%%,-' B+ +- l#l ' +- E,-- -E. T+, ll 'l-' 'EE"%%"'"  ''l'&l B# +",l & l " -  + +'- +",+"l.

NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT S E" 2(') ' 2(#) "# + AE NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT S E" 3() ' Kl''" I "# E" 3 "# + AE NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT #amar 'hosh v. -aya 'hosh (2007) 4 SCC 511; #uman Ka+oor v. #udhir Ka+oor AIR 2009 SC 589 NTR R#318563612 + O MRRMAT #atya v. #iri ,am AIR 1983 P H 252


RA!ER-P

-Page | xi-

PRAYER

9

HEREFORE

ADVANCED,

IN THE LIGHT OF THE ISSUES RAISED, ARGUMENT REASONS

HON’BLE COURT

GIVEN AND AUTHORITIES

CITED,

THIS

MAY BE PLEASED TO

&" $"LD  

THAT THAT

THE DIVORCE IS A NULLITY .

DDAT ARE NOT AVERSE BENEFITS CONFERRED BEYOND THE PERIOD OF I

TO A RTICLE 25. 

THAT A FREEN

CAN BE MADE A RESPONDENT UNDER THE DOMESTIC VIOLENCE

ACT.

&" PA!! 

A

PROTECTION ORDER UNDER SECTION 18 OF THE DOMESTIC V IOLENCE A CT,



2005. A RESIDENCE

ORDER UNDER SECTION 19 OF THE DOMESTIC V IOLENCE A CT,

2005. &" !E& A!IDE

THE

ORDER PASSED BY THE LD.

CIVIL JUDGE, DISTRICT COURT

OF N AVY D ALLY .

MI!CELLANE"U!

A ND ANY OTHER RELIEF

THAT THIS HON’BLE COURT MAY BE PLEASED TO GRANT IN

THE INTERESTS OF JUSTICE, EUITY AND GOOD CONSCIENCE

A LL

OF WHICH IS RESPECTFULL! SUBMITTED.

COUNSELS FOR THE S SHAHEEN ' ' OTHERS


Petitioner P2 Memorial

Recommend Documents